Professional Documents
Culture Documents
92 6
OF I
FEDERAL
NVESTIGATIDN
RELEASE "
BUREAU
SUBJECT :,
FILE
Z15/j@g iga
.
>I: _@; -
~;;%
OPENING STATEMENT OF
_ BEFORE
THE
SUBCOMMITTEE on
TERRORISM, TECHNOLOGY
COMMITTEE on UNITED STATES
AND GOVERNMENT
INFORMATION
WASHINGTON, n.c.
OCTOBER 19,
1995
FBI/DOJ
VJ
Introduction
Good morning,
Mr. Chairman
and distinguished
Members of
the
Subcommittee. I
role of the Federal
am pleased
Bureau of
to testify
Investigation
before you
in the
concerning the
events at Ruby
Ridge and
the substantial
reforms
Ihave
made as
a result
of the
serious deficiencies
Iwelcome
in the
crisis.
the opportunity
Subcommittee
Ruby Ridge
deaths there
has become
synonymous with
Deputy United
tragedy,
States Marshal,
given the
a young
ofta decorated
boy,
and the
boy's mother.
It has of federal
also
exaggerated application
conclusions seem justified.
at the FBI.
the the
Ridge was
a series of
terribly flawed
operations with
Ruby Ridge.
reasonably
promulgated rules
of engagement
subject
policy and
to
interpretation
the Constitution
that would
- rules
permit
that could occurred. Rules
a violation
have caused
of FBI
even
of engagement
use
again. mistakes
FBI Headquarters
serious operational
Northern Idaho to
that
and back
went
mountains of
' G
out to
a federal
courtroom in
Boise, Idaho.
Today, there
are
a coverup
occurred of integrity
if proven, is built.
very foundation
Although I
occurred, I during the have only
learned from
was not
FBI Director
when the
Ruby Ridge
crisis
disappointed with
its mistakes
almost every
aspect of
promulgated new
procedures to
the tragedies
of Ruby
the to Idaho
happen again.
%$ %%
As you to the
are aware,
the FBI
responded to
Ruby Ridge
subsequent
Bureau of
Randy Weaver.
Marshals Service surveillance of
response came
to Ruby
Ridge on
August
21, 1992,
after the
tragic murder
of Deputy
United States
Marshal
William Degan.
It is
important to
facts in
mind. Deputy
Marshal by other
agencies -
which other
described
in August,
--
formed the
1992.
basis upon
which the
FBI responded
threat that
benefits of
required
a prompt
response. Now,
FBI s response
with all
clearly was
of the
an
hindsight, the
overreaction. In
assessment of
Rules of The Death
future situations,
such threats before the
I will
FBI acts.
!8 N" ?:?.&
As I have stated
many times
before, Vicki
tragic but
occurred at
accidental. I
been left Ruby Ridge.
fully appreciate
without their On behalf of the
the fact
FBI, I
that three
of what
children have
mother as a result
wishtx>expressn
regret and sorrow for Mrs. Weaver's Moreover, the FBI fully death.
supports the settlement with the Weaver family that the Department
of Justice negotiated. For the FBI, the settlement does not bring
I also
want to
express my
heartfelt condolences
to Mrs.
Degan.
price paid
should never
line of duty.
by this
dedicated public
left behind
servant. We,
when an officer
_
as a
Nation,
the
forget those
dies in
to interpretation
the Constitution.
that would
permit
a violation
said that,
of FBI
policy and
Those rules
under certain
persons "can
and should"
be the
Those rules
of engagement
were contrary
FBI policy.
the rules
interpreted
was
they knew
inconsistent with
entirely unacceptable.
policy. Such
confusion
is
According to
Special Agent
Lon Horiuchi,
the HRT
sniper who
accidentally shot
1992, both_pursuant
testified that he did
two shots on
the rules of
August 22,
has
engagement
policy. He
that I
just mentioned.
The shot that killed Mrs. Weaver was the second that Special
Agent Horiuchi
Mrs. Weaver
fired. He
and was not fired
testified that
at her.
it was
not intended
for
In discussing
Special Agent
am not
saying that
I approve
of it.
I am not trying
4 o
to justify
it. I
am
that I what he
I am
not saying
similar set
should take
of circumstances
such a shot.
FBI Agents
The FBI will strive
or law
enforcement officers
and train to avoid
such tragic
results, whenever
humanly possible.
Special Agent very difficult "black and or with question. It white" terms. a high degree
'
Horiuchi's is not It of
can be
addressed in
answered categorically
on August believe
evidence, I
unlawful in
that time
and place
Horiuchi testified
for him
to take
he took
the second
the first
shot.
Special Agent
shot when
Horiuchi perceived
law enforcement Horiuchi said
that Weaver
helicopter that was the first
"was trying
to get
a shot off"
at a
he took
believed he
in the
was protecting
fellow law
enforcement officers
who were
helicopter.
Special
he observed
Agent Horiuchi
Randy Weaver
said he
raise his
took the
rifle in sniper positions
first shot
the direction
only when
of the had observed
helicopter. Although
FBI Agents in
5
from the
cabin and
were not
scene.
-- because
safety of
the agents
The bullet
that struck
Mrs. Weaver
was fired
seconds after
the
first shot.
It was
intended for
a man
who Special
Agent Horiuchi
vicinity of
Tragically, Mrs.
stood behind the open
by that
cabin.
shot while
she
at or
into
the cabin;
Randy Weaver
Special Agent
target
and KevinHarris: he
the cabin door when Horiuchi has
Kevin Harris
second shot.
testified
- at that
Pt is
important to
remember that
two different
components of
of those
components --
the Office
Division -
of Professional
Responsibility and
that there
the Civil
was no
Rights
basis upon
independently determined
which to
was not
conclude that
unlawfully. Both
unconstitutional.
determined by their
Special Agent
I believe would find evidence, I that a
not criminal.
immunity principles based on all of
Nor do
-the
was unconstitutional.
Employees
Punishment Administered
In January
of this
year, I
disciplined or
proposed discipline
for twelve
at Ruby
related to
the incident
and
prosecution of
action followed
Randy Weaver
an FBI
those employees.
My action
also followed
reviews by
the Department
of Justice
Office of
and the
Civil Rights
that criminal
actions, including
prosecution was
my own, relied upon
was directly
that was
Special Agents.
supervised
written by
by the
Justice and
a report
not FBI
Department
the twelve
FBI employees
did not
commit
improper judgment,
neglect of
duty, and
7
failure to
exert proper
with suspension
believed the
the factual
discipline imposed
basis for
The discipline
discipline was
imposed on is a
the basis
process. The
precedent is a
reliance ensures
basic matter
that" people
of due
who commit
@$$@ %
of
obviously cannot
I had
complete as
believed.
If this,
in fact,
occurred, then
it is
- if the judge does not have allof the facts, or does not have
facts that have an impact upon credibility or honesty, the judge's
findings will
an incorrect
scrutiny. That
that he
judge will
must readdress.
make
invalid decision
I intend
to be
fair about
this matter,
but any
final action
must be
based upon
a full
of Larry
and accurate
Potts
reporting of
the facts.
"
ghe Promotion
Larry Potts
twelve FBI
in my of
to the
disciplinary decisions
censure for failure to
January. He
provide proper
oversight with
rules of
that the Potts nor
engagement employed
Administrative Summary Mr. Coulson
upon the
at Ruby
Ridge. It
should be
that neither with
noted
Mr: that
report recommended
be disciplined.
facts as I found
I disagreed
them.
conclusion based
ex
At the
time I
disciplined Larry
Potts, he
was the
Acting
Deputy Director.
Deputy Director
Shortly thereafter,
of the FBI.
-.921Z:;.* mares
punishment that I
Deputy Director
In determining
I did
not appoint
him
he is a friend.
appoint Larry Potts to be the Deputy
Director, I
Nation and
service to
esteem in
the
which
subordinates, superiors,
considered his
counterparts, and
in the
colleagues hold
FBI, including
him. I
our work
vast accomplishments
together during
which President
Bush
and outside
of federal,
their consensus
enforcement associations.
Larry Potts
was an
excellent and
progressive leader,
highly
qualified to
and confidence
be Deputy
in Mr.
Director. Like
Potts. -
them, I
placed great
trust
I recognize
that I created by
I made
held accountable
for it.
relating to
One is in
Ruby Ridge
Boundary County,
and its
aftermath are
currently pending.
Day is
Idaho, where
prosecutor Randall
and Deputy in
allegedly taken
by FBI
during and
not wish to prejudge
I also of those
do
anyone who
investigations. I
allegations are
must stress,
quite serious and go
however, that
to the very heart
the coverup
of what FBI
Special Agents
do -
seek the
truth. There
is nothing' more
10
iii
I92
grievous and
committed perjury
shocking than
or obstruction
an allegation
of justice.
that an
FBI Agent
has
The Subcommittee and the American people that Iwill swiftly and decisively address In that
L F r a
committed by any
consistent with
Iestablished
FBI employees.
the "bright
for FBI
be
that
line ethical
standard"
employees on
January 3,
cannot occur
the facts
until the
all of
are known.
Management Reforms
Subsequent to
The FBI
at Ruby Ridqg
the lessons of Ruby Ridge. As the
Subcommittee has
already heard,
we have
changed policies
and
procedures to
have prepared it be
prevent similar,
a handout record.
tragic mistakes
Iwould like to
_
in the
future.
of the
I
that
@ %$
describing these
reforms.
Irequest
review four
First,
Ihave
ended forever
the use
of rules
of engagement
by
the FBI.
deadly force
Department of
injury to
or another in greater
person. In
a moment,
Iwill
describe this
detail.
of engagement be open to an
Never again
will rules
deadly force as
policy. In
future
about the
interplay' between deadly force standard deadly on-scene commanders will as necessary.
of sole if it
engagement. The standard, although restrict the is necessary risk, that In the
force policy
to further heightened
In addition, advisories.
to communicate to agents
an especially
shooting Incident
aftermath of
Ruby Ridge, there were problems relating review conducted by the FBI in 1992. That
analyzed the accidental
and incompletely
shooting death of
of that Ruby
Headquarters oversight
of the
Ridge response
shootings
..-.,,~::. .
that occurred
fair. They
must be a
persons who do
even the
appearance of
1995, I
announced revisions to
the FBI's
shooting incidents.
the executive
*,established new
shooting inquiries; and,
protocols governing
12
* included, representation on
Critical Incident
for the
first time,
the Shooting
Response Group
The third
creation of
and most
the Critical
significant major
Incident Response
change I
Group "CIRG"!,
made is
the
which I
established in
1994. I
have provided
to the
Subcommittee
a handout
describing CIRG
made part of
and its
responsibilities. I
request that
it be
the record.
the FBI's
terribly flawed.
leadership's
responsibility and
individuals, including
directly establishes
myself, for
accountability on
crisis management.
specific
CIRG fully
m
integrates crisis
same level under
negotiators and
a unified
them at
the
I have
command. The
an equal with a
overseeing the
process. As
a part
of that
integration, I
have
the FBI.
Their goal
has always
Like
Special Agent,
the members
of the
badges and
handcuffs. Their
objective is
identical to
law enforcement
officers around
the country
-~ to
arrest safely
those responsible
13
for crimes
and assist
in their
members of
HRT,
capability. Nevertheless,
mean that
it must
be used,
especially if
we do not have to
use it.
and seek
I cannot
independent FBI
its
am
and appropriate
Through the
integrated response
that CIRG
provides, I
am
been
provided to
cadre of will help Department of
Crisis Management
other senior
and a
effort
commanders. I
peaceful resolution
Reforms
Justice management reforms Department of Agency Policies, Justice. In I have have been my capacity issued Resolutions
recommendations of
Some crisis
1
which resulted
from consensus
14
investigative agencies
resolutions were and she has approved created at
of the
Department of
of Attorney
Ju--ice. These
General Reno _ _.
the request
them.
Resolution 12
to govern
of as
CIRG. I lines of
avert
occurs. Additionally,
Resolution 12
requires other
consult and
Department of
coordinate with
Justice investigative
the FBI when the degree of
agencies to
threat in
one of
conduct of
changes to
that Department
FBI policy
governing this
matter. Resolution
13 ensures
and are
of Justice
agencies will
objective shooting
reviewed further in order
incident reviews,
to ensure fairness
and accuracy.
ago, the
Policies to
policy for
and analysis
her consideration.
between the
After months
of research,
discussion
of of the
agencies comprising
the Office
Investigative Agency
Policies and
various components
Department of
Resolution 14, issued and
Justice -
especially the
a uniform
Office of
deadly force
Legal Counsel
policy, was
--
General has
approved it.
15
The Treasury
leading to
Department also
participated in
th. negotiations
efforts of
the deadly
force policy.
Through the
and Justice
permits deadly
belief that death or
person." The FBI
Department law
force to
the subject serious physical
enforcement officers.
officer has
an imminent
That policy
a reasonable
danger of or to another
injury to
the officer
Investigating Itself
during these
issue of In assessing
investigate itself
should consider
the Subcommittee
FBI's history
in this
Unlike most
the FBI
two,
independent watchdogs
and activities.
with the
of and
distinguished record
misconduct by
of successfully
This record
investigating alleged
of success includes
FBI employees.
matters of
For example:
great significance
to the
*In
1976, the
of led
against numerous
others. One
FBI employee
16
who was
fired as
result of Callahan. A
was then-Deputy
Dire ;or
this investigation
was publicly
investigated allegations
Special Agent Joseph Stabile who, on September 15, 1978, became the
first Special Agent indicted in the FBI s history.
* The
property.
assisted in
the stolen
~
prosecution of
*The
transportation of
assisted in
investigated and
the
prosecution of
was later convicted
the first
for the
* The
FBI investigated
my predecessor
for misuse
of his
position, which
investigation was The Attorney
resulted
in his
dismissal. A
an order
report of
this
$%%%%
which makes
Office of
clear
that, in
addition to
the Department
the Office of the
of Justice
Inspector
Professional Responsibility,
General also
internal security
performs oversight
of the
FBI. That
oversight is
Ames
of the
Inspector General
General to
take responsibility
for investigating
allegation under
17
The success
of the
s is
due,
in
to the
investigations require
familiar with
the expertise
internal policing
successfully, to
and to
and ethical
priorities,
demonstrate to
the Congress,
with
of Justice
Office of
Office of effective
of
Professional Responsibility
the Inspector
twenty years
reached two
and second, the FBI has enjoyed extraordinary success with independent
major police
dependent on
States. is
hard experience
police being
accountable to
with independent
chart which
prepared a
18
pOliCe forces
made part of
that investigate
the record.
themselves. I
requ
L that
it be
_ occurred with
mistakes should
regard to
have been
the Ruby
avoided and
Ridge
were
those, the
FBI offers
not excuses,
but rather
the facts
Intentional misconduct
I stated
that I
before, I
will swiftly
assure the
and decisively
misconduct.
Subcommittee and
deal with
the American
anyone who
people
the facts
show committed
With the
arsenals at
the disposal
of criminals
in our
Nation
that law
have in
dangerous job
Since becoming
the FBI
Special
September, 1993,
I have
attended the
funerals of
Agents and
were murdered
numerous state
in the line of
enforcement officers
criminals with guns. Again,
who
I attended
the funeral
for a
Department officer
killed without
in the
and loved
line of
duty. I
inflict upon
these weapons
and officers,
their families,
Police and in their
speak with
Chiefs of
Sheriffs from
country who
suffer casualties
ranks
at the
We take
hands of
criminals with
guns.
seriously when we ask the men and
women of
law enforcement
themselves in
19
like Deputy
leaders and
United States
managers, we
Marshal Bill
owe them
Degan. As
our complete
J enforcement
must
support and
strive to
give them
upon the under very
the
best guidance
women of
possible. _
law enforcement to do In return
,
their for
men and
difficult circumstances.
protecting us,
them to use their
and ask
tells
families in
and compassion
human
fallibility. This
well lighted knowledge
Court calls "split-second
is particularly
of hindsight,
true as
we judge
far from
in circumstances
judgments -
tense, uncertain
and rapidly
evolving."
Graham v.
Connor, 490
U.S. 386,
20
397 989!.
OO
O CRISIS
MANAGEMENT TRAINING
U SHOOTING
O SWATTRAINING
O FBI
U OUTSIDE
CRISIS MANAGEMENT
NETWORK ESTABLISHED.
' NEW
RISlS
RII=O%$
MANAGEMENT -
. ~15
I F Q
force policy, which permits use deadly the of force only the in face of imminent deat
or serious physical injurythe to Agent or another person, be will used in future crisis
Situations. .
accountability have been ixed specific to individuals, including FBI the Director.
negotiators will with HostageTeam. Leadership always deploy the Rescue and
HOSTAGE TEAM DEPLOYMENT Rescue be RESCUE --- The Hostag Teamnot will deployedan independentthe FBIe without assessment by oft threatneed. The and FBI
Director must persona satisfied it is be ly that necessary and appropriate. to tactical personnel and negotiators will a ways deploy with Hostage the Rescue Team. The number FBI of hostage negotiators been has increased.
CRISIS MANAGEMENT TRAINING ---
crisis management. Negotiators and tactical personnel on are equal footing thei and
been created a as single entity under the leadership of FBI an executive experienced i_n
HOSTAGE NEGOTIATORS have given a equal --- FBI hostage negotiatorsstatus been
of cesinhave beplaced in dcommand crisis. Only trained received specialized speciaily crisis management training. Special Agents Charge will fie o a
SHOOTING INCIDENT--REVIEW Responsibility for investigating all shooting incidents involving Agents been FBI has removed from FBI's Investigative the Criminal Division and placed with FBl's the Inspection Division. results theinvestigation The of will bereviewed by a newly reconstituted group includes that Department of justice
representation.
General, the Deputy Attorney General and FBI 42 Special AgentsChare FBI field in of
training and equipment has enhanced, all FBI been so that SWAT Teams compatible are
FBI LABORATORY Specialized --teams have been created are that experts in the
identification, recovery preservation evidence. and of
OUTSIDE EXPERTS ON CRISIS MANAGEMENT --Through universities andother
FBI SWAT Teams has been placed under the Critical Incident Response Group their and
sources, anetwork ofoutside experts crisis on management and otherdisciplines has been established aid the FBIin understanding responding uniquecrisis and to and to hostage situations.
'23 -rg,
~31" I-iI=T1 ~51; 11'-K-'-'_:* ,;;,;.{.,.~'~_7_ :15if v;'.- .;.,:= -.'-3;-~_-'41 -:-. 'I_-; '@_BF; ; ?'92l_ ,, 1<;-3'-_:5-'.-"_-._. : 1 -is -4; 1. _;92:; _-. 5 ..1 =-. 1,"11*:-5 ~:~'-;'. :~.v- =1--,_ G
s5. ' ~- La 4 hp" '4 n L51'2 ~.: 'Z 1 ':" >I I'_- 3 4;" ' ' I.-E5 ..~ _;., ___-_ _;__-i _~, =2- _,_= ;.; _ 5; _; -2; ~_ , ;_ ;;._,.:L
4*
D DIRECTOR
ASSISTANT DIRECTOR 7
Criminal Investigative Division
RESPONSEGROUP _
CRISIS MANAGERS
I r
IN
_ TACTICAL
SUPPORT
Child Abduction
&
Serial ltiller
Unit ~
SWAT Training
Unit
Special Detail
Unit
Investigative Support
Unit
I
ml
Aviation & Special
Operations Unit
Undercover Safeguard
Unit
.-'r'I.!,_.. V _r . . ._~.uJ_,_ _.i. 'i~'- f~ .:1'.-< ' ~ ,_ j-_~r -r;-..92_.: < i-Anilo slim J1 Trooper:
K1IlI.EtIlP#l_'itE_1*;$
'9292-..@,n,I Q 0
A I /I "
VerrriontStnto dice H _V,r---.~v;-la!" 5 ?,92-;-____- -, TY =-neat ; .l.~ EH;-__ I ;A' r Ii~;~2 ..;_w'- .ii.U9-_'';..,',.'1-:-v'92'. .'-:=?i r.-.Q _ _,_,':v:" ' .Bolee:' " 1' '-'W92Ww Patrcl .1.,. _t::'-'.V i Bvlholw P0 PorllnIPD ._, .7}! .-i{ ;:'_f.-;_ig';?I7_i!;.;-l7:5r,-,;_ A-$5}.-__:.-j 'I_._'~ - 7YI7T WyerrttriqslatoPa -=.'-||-., .l~i--iii.~r!.-.+.. -.1*rI''~i,- _ .,. --r_;'.,; y 1;-"". ___,__ _'r--" _92,. _--L--.., -:_: I. , '4 :-.v-. - ii :::r;-_:_ 1"-A .,. --~'-~~i-r<;:=a-'_..:__.:_? -' ' '.'$"i'f:I7 Stale Poke I-"f92 92 --= r-. -.1-'.'r.- . -I ;--'92y.. .n. H , ;;3rsorthoi<otn '__l:M,".m " we i - -1 i r ,Q;-_ vii it "7 y.I Eetr"3- _i ~0 tmt{'_ raw ma 0 " '" ell "_>sIlPBU'a;d cliilm i.-i .. r. ' ',' t' ; ,3; , -*.-"-l~';- :56-=~*'~.ir';.!;.-__:t_~ ._;.i..;-I,--;~ i __PD :-" " -"i'7"'Ii5"'f-*?.*r.-.'~' - .,r|.~i. .~- , I Y:-.1 Sedstldrto - .92lI.' ..*..'-" " -.= ' 1. I. .i Y ' V. l?' T:iii"i. r" l:"l'."l" '=';92""i1i Uh .., .: _ "__>. V:;W I_.>:;'__4'_;.~;.. l :'_:-;-'_='_ 5, ,. _, .t '2-' 4 1T7"1 .. Iii "i '.-I4- ;l _ _.,_I . Rochester -R'/. .=- =;:':-. -I" 1 "":Y. -37}-"= 4 ' ;.' " B""" om" "1 .-*1 vi __._"1'Prrrwienon PD - """" '-:'t= '.. lIMOiedcr'- Pdice '--1' :.92r, ._ ' ~..v-we -.., _. 1 ' State _Z t,T , 1,, Cd: tie I-' 'y - rlirtt-iiavo ";'.irtgol.l;l.=_:;o--eel, $m:_92f |_Dqln -:;~- --=1 t i~- .1r" ' ,Nassau PD oiil<tirili1v,.i_=i" ggi _i.!.- -i_-=.-;"=._"'_ Cr: Ath lrc on 'r; -.~ i.-'-'1: ~'-.~ t<i lI"lIlI'- F ' , s -'1r;~ " " _ '" Lee ':,-g:~;;ii HI ?! SOUTH CAROLINA ' .-r ';1"~' Mir Ie -.--~: i.",. 4. ,.__ /{-I Mlrylond .' I _;r;il_;< . t'~ Columbia PD ' g4 _ i'!_t. 92=t*&,ii"~&>; $""i%'-'lg-3i ." 5I ~ .1'"B'N3- Mntro l!ii'F ' I " ' p9 l ." '"- i. 3. - m:_=,rm-Louie Fr-iii-i .--'-..i i . Charleston City N"Iw~v|}92 92 Q}} f PD SOUTH DAKOTA Mngtori " riereq> g!'! i[ i,ii..ir_i.i1/-i.?8'p"">. l!-.'-." Sioux Falls _."'i"*'i-"111 -tt "' .-w ' .rift Hawaii g Ric "i 9'1 -3' i ..a' ~ ,. .. South Dakota Stare Tio TENNESSEE l~.i {92-iIi l*l':thI ,, ALABAMA .a... ,4 KnoxvilleSO Co Mobile PD -. .,I _ .-92. ;_ Tennessee But-.-nti ol Monlgonterg PD Alabama D S InvestigationPD Mettopoitan Nashville 1 92 ..~l__g |92 Orly oI MQI9292|!I92| PL ALASKA FLORIDA TEXAS Alaska State Trootieis ~ ;.:~ -. ~ it/<! .;,~i 92! ~i'> - ; T'TK'r_1:'?" "n i4vs'.Y v ~I:i%&?-.3 I. ",Ei;";ill->>" i -- 4 - _. , r-"rJ 6 '=i-4<"*"" .at. Artcliorage PD Jacksonville SheriIf's Olfica Harris CO SIt.irrIl'5 Dnpl. Houston Police Dent Dept ol Enlotcenient Law ARIZONA Metro-Dade PD Irving PD KANSAS -- _'> erson Je Arizona Dept Salely of Public Miami PD Dallas PD Jacksorwile H tw r-1 5 " Id"' U pm so DoIofLaw l. _ Phoenix PD Fort Worth PD Kansas Slate av Pat ol igl GEORGIA orcerrvnt l92i92.<, H , Harrie Co El Paso PD Mancopa County SO Kansas City .' Slterilfa Dept NS Bureau Florida El Pnso Sheriff's Dqttl Atlanta PD ARKANSAS KENTUCKY cl Nrilcotica Odessa PD GA Bureau ol Investigation En? _ I' ' A Texas DPS Arkansas State Police Kentucky State Police Jackson PD HAWAII PD Uttle Rock PD -:?~'. *.Pi Metro-Dntle Son Antonio . LOUISIANA UTAH Honolulu PD CALIFORNIA MISSISSIPPI . Maui County PD New Orleans PD Utnh Dot f'iN.-ilrity it cit -i-i-. it Cal ornia Highway Patrol Mississippi Bureau ol Narcotics Jetlerson Parish SO 92' Miami Utalt State p !'Il:'.' Sacramento Co SO NEW JERSEY Louisiana Stale Police Mississipgiol-lighway Salety Jersey Police Patrol San Diego PD VERMONT New State Jackson MAINE San Diego SO Coung Atlantic City PD Vermont Stole Police San Francisco P Portland PD Burlington PD Oakland PD MISSOURI NEW MEXICO OHIO Los Angeles PD VIRGINIAI DISTRICT Idaho Dept. of MARYLAND Los Angeles Sheriffs Dept. Albuquerque PD Hamilton Sherill s Office OF COLUMBIA O0 Law Enforcement Kansas City PD New Mexico Police State Columbus P0 COLORADO Baltimore PD Missouri Slate Petrol Hi%hway ILLINOIS Metropolitan PD Toledo PD Maryland State Police NEWYORK SpfingIl6|d cit; P Arlington PD Co Denver PD Cleveland PD St. Louis D Co Illinois State Polioe Fairfax P O0 Aurora PD MASSACHUSETTS Rochester PD St. Louis Metro PD Springfield Police Dept, OKLAHOMA Virginia Stat P JeffersonSharill s Dept Co Buffalo PD Chicago PD Boston PD Henrico F-I, O0 MONTANA Tulsa PD West ChesterDPS Co CONNECTICUT Massachusetts Police Stale INDIANA Oklahoma Highway Patrol New York PD WASHINGTON Flathead SherilfOffice Co s Hartford PD Oklahoma PD City MICHIGAN New York Police State Montana Highway Patrol Marlort Co Sheriffs Dept. Connecticut State Police Tacoma PD Nassau PD Co OREGON Indianapolis PD NEBRASKA Michigan State Police Seattle PD DE LAWARE Lansing PD NORTH CAROLINA Portland POIOO Bureau Omaha PD IOWA _ Detroit PD Wilmington PD Oregon Stats Police Charlotte Mecklenburg PD NEVADA Iowa DPS MINNESOTA PENNSYLVANIA Des Moines PD Raleigh PD F Las Vegas PD Metro Greensborough PD Cedar Rapids PD Minnesota State Patrol Nevada Highway Patrol ;:{92nsylvaritaieP%ate Police Davenport PD Minneapolis PD North Las Vegas PD NORTH DAKOTA Green Bay PD AlleghenyPD Oo St. Paul PD Eau Claire PD NEW HAMPSHIRE Nonh Dakota I-fighway Patrol Pittsburgh PD DivisionCriminal OI Fargo PD New Hampshire Police Stale PUERTO RICO Investigation Police Puerto Rico ol WEST VIRGINIA RHODE ISLAND Charleston PD Providence PD WYOMING Cheyenne PD Wyoming State Patrol
_ .y_v;;_;: 0 P-id , ., __:5;QT "",,><r=u.a1&i1l ,ir*r_1#$ ="'l=~; T ._...U3 .,.-~"-' _. ~. 1* ti;I-:1l1.24; ;'; ->1-'r,!,ii;-tlI_. M _"-'-1- 92- .-."i._--"-"-'-Division l I@II"!l"IM@ ol Crirrind gag i, .;{-" I "t".""t" """l'~ zr--1' " It Il-_ ' *9 'l'r~~'1'2 : ~;Z '- r--Invesligrilnri '-Llrili ' " stnrpols :.~_FIT; ;'~'i"-$r_ >a'-li- tt ,~/. -I5 :-- '1 _ ;_:' '. 1 __ 2_;lf'1, ._~" ._92 i _ "'3; :51 ? ~,_.-.~I 5 71"-'9? ,;.,__ ".-<~-
INN .I J
LPIIIJILIIIJIJLE llJElt%l1l.iil'"m'"tttll
.-i'rEi"iiiiLI'iia'r2i"-"1-l"
V Mil Slate Pobco -'" . Fm 1-Ir "0 .1! .1 .:-t,-.i _- I. -.~..-.'.-.=_;-'-". m;,!-u,' e 1-92 ,. "
I-we-i..
;'.--...-- -I .. i:~l~_;
~-i~*3
* ii Ill l .., tr . or
o or
:iIiY,~I r__ .;'ii'tt3 ,..i,i<;;_;e _5_i;l~ ~';;;;-_';5:lA.-_,-f '{ ""i '1-rail .~]:.Ls"_m _.}__:-.. lu:iM;WFd$t;ittn.-. -" .t "<1".'~ feL. _ M;_ ': Z'-ti, =:ete.i--;.-ir_,; >_ ,5 r*lr,t _4$'a ma ,,;,tr..,.,,__,., _,__.,i .,,._,= j- ~l_rg,sI.,-;_ _,.-5.; ~*:-;.~ i!._1_~;92_q_~_!__l. ,*- Ir '_ ,}._,im92,;,_Ii@_i; .- _cg3_W5,_v~'*" hI f_--' ;D _,i._.,.,_._. * 5rIg,__,.I _ pw, _. W38, _ -*<.'._, -" A4.i-r..<i..ii ;gvI}oJ, _: Wm, -=~ - ~fl Q 1- ii-ii i~,@_-_-,~l:=92.7=?7'tF5"L.-." .i_t,;,-. "~ "'. hr "Ill I .i-I; ~ .'kI1>r.4="i*-*3 te ?I" ?* > i:I'-1:-, -->.<!,-;ii._~.i ."'"-ii I:""'.- r ~ ~,}i~ ii; ~92". ?j-'-"'.;;5:;;-.~7'1,,k'r ,' -~ ii-, egg 5 -00. -;i. $' 3" A-I rt :-< I -"' Nam ,i-1 riL_bP~ Plierto Flico
.7 ff i; W PD '1-..r'-3% W.gt,-!"DI'*'Y_'? I;92"-l EhQ0-rirt 9292 t3i1tirr i'i:?i"P0 , t M, , ,DI !" _.!I[';r :! . 1-=> ~='<.92 -*"'~i@ e': -Ii
Horiolulus -0
I / . ;isi~M *""i" ?-i_~v- lit-:_.~.",F. -rm;;,.p| pc~fogPA ' .I W J EQLIQTi.l-~;;_ ' _:31 - L~'--I"'"""p ,i tit --. iq_v _ Q '%I.r..!.;n ;.x Q; ~ . i2' .'-;_ . ' 1+"-, 1 - ~'"2M~"
~-.~fi.1.';.~:=r.I~?- %:~?- I3 i52Mo&l~:" " ""~" > 1-'1:-..-iii '35it ; :zI'.-L~'_:! .'?|~--.-w ~ iii~rj-.92~ rt.-.l-. "'?gf?=i&tlgetImu -*1-ta},-_ -Q ,,i'?:~q.'!LiE";bI:. ir.1- A"'-PSI ? iiiiii-~ -. "mi Lt?-*;%_E~
W-'<
E 2:.
IDAHO Boise PD
WISCONSIN Milwaukee PD