BOOK CLUB GROUP SCORING GUIDE Name ______________________ Date of Meeting __________________ Write the name of the member

after each role and then circle the number of their score. Score 1 2 3 Discussion Director2= You didnt always guide the discussion. You added few thoughts or questions to the discussion. You did not try to keep the group on task. 3= You guided discussion, but didnt always keep it going. You added some thoughts and questions. You tried to keep the group on task

4
4= You guided discussion and kept it going. You added thought and questions when appropriate. You made sure the group stayed on task.

1= You did not try to guide the discussion and/or contributed very little. You did not try to keep the group on task.

Masterpiece Maker1= Illustration is either of poor quality or does not relate to the story. 2= Illustration does not relate to the story. 3= Illustration is of adequate quality and somewhat relates to the story. 4= Illustration is of good quality and relates well to the story.

Passage Personifier Passage is irrelevant and the speaker offers little explanation. 2= Passage is of some relevance and the speaker offers a bit of explanation. 3= Passage is of adequate relevance and the speaker offers some explanation. 4= Passage is relevant and the speaker offers good insight.

Paraphrasing Perfectionist1= Outline is incomplete and/or missing important events. 2= Outline is general and is missing important events. Main idea is weak. 3= Outline is complete, but is missing important events. Main idea is vague. 4= Outline is complete and well done. Main idea is insightful.

Connection Creator1= Connections are not strong and are nonsensical. 2= Connections make sense, but the speaker offers little explanation. 3= Connections make sense and the speaker offers some explanation. 4= Connections are relevant and the speaker offers a good deal of explanation.

Worldly Wordsmith1= Words are not defined or are not of appropriate difficulty. 2= Some words are defined incorrectly and are not of appropriate difficulty. 3= Words are defined and are of adequate difficulty. 4= Words are defined and the speaker explains them well.

Literary Luminator1= Literary device is incorrect or not identified. 2= Literary device identified is incorrect or does not illuminate the chapter in any way. Speaker does not explain its significance. 3= Literary devices identified are general and speaker does not explain their significance. 4= Literary devices identified are strong and add something to the understanding of the story. Speaker explains their significance.

What was your most important contribution to the discussion?

What is your plan for improvement?

What did your group do well today?