You are on page 1of 8

Monday, February 20, 2012 THE LIGHT OF ANDAMANS | ISSUE 27 | 17 FEB 2012

Writer Zubair Ahmed


COVER STORY:

ROHINGYAS: ENDLESS WAIT FOR REPATRIATION


About 400 desperate souls rescued from the seas and detained in a distress camp for almost three years at Port Blair dream for a free life and a reunion with their families. Abandoned by both Myanmar and Bangladesh, their fate hangs in balance, with an indecisive government policy and the sluggish pace of repatriation.

By Zubair Ahmed

Since December 2008, about 702 boat people with Bangladesh-Myanmar nationality were rescued from various parts of the Islands. After a slow moving process, about 270 of them were repatriated. The remaining 422 are languishing in the Distress Camp set up at Brookshabad by the ANI Admn. Another 54 were to be deported this week to Bangladesh. "Its three years now, and we have not done anything wrong. We were first persecuted by the Burmese Junta, pushed by the Thais into the face of death. Indian government has been very sympathetic to us, but how can we continue to remain in a detention camp like this?" asks Ghulam Kadir, who is just 25 years old. The 400 persons have been lodged in the Open Distress Camp, where they live in three dormitories. The Admn spends about Rs 75 per diem. They all look well-fed and clothed. However, they are unable to accept their fate, of living as prisoners without any hope. 1

Mohammed Zameer: Optimistic


"It is very unfortunate that poachers and Illegal fishermen from Myanmar, Bangladesh or Thailand, who are apprehended gets repatriated after they serve their sentences, whereas these boatpeople does not have the right to even get out of their camp," says a senior police officer. Mohammed Zameer, 23 years, born in Arakan has six members in his family. Faced with desperation and pain in managing a family in a hostile country, where its own citizens are persecuted by the Myanmar government, he crossed to Bothi Gaon in Bangladesh, just 20 kms away. One of the 2 lakh stateless and worst discriminated Rohingyas and Arakanese who had crossed the border looking for a safe haven from the clutches of Myanmar, he too dreamed of a better world. The border towns of Myanmar-Bangladesh are home to many such unfortunate souls. However life was not that easy in Bangladesh. He remained 8 months in Chittagong and thought of moving to Malaysia. When he heard that Captain Rafeeque, would take him to Malaysia for an amount of 15-20 thousand takas, he too joined the 102 member group. Rafeeque, known as Captain promised them a safe landing in Malaysia. It took about 8 days to reach Phuket on their way, where they were intercepted by Thai Navy. They could see around 120 such Arakanese/Bangladeshi economic migrants already detained by the Thai Navy. Lately, the Thai authorities had picked Red Sand Island for 'processing' the Rohingyas before pushing them into the sea. They are subjected to inhuman torture and humiliation in the process. They are detained on the beach with guntrotting guards abusing and torturing them. About 413 of these boat people were loaded into a dead engineless incapacitated wooden boat and towed deep into the sea for 24 hours and left to drift. Two bags of boiled rice and two jars of water were provided on each boat. There was no provision to cook the rice. They soaked it in water and chewed raw. But that too did not last more than two days. 412 persons tossed in a boat with no space to even move, they drifted in the sea for more than 15 days and they even lost the count of days after a certain period. Hunger and thirst drove them mad. Everyday, they were throwing dead bodies into the sea. When after a long period, the boat drifted towards Little Andaman Islands, where they were spotted and rescued by the A&N police and ANC, out of 413, only 107 survived.

Ghulam Kadir: Its a Long Wait!

Mukhtar: Engine Betrayed!

UNENDING WAIT: At the Distress Camp at Brookshabad


They arrived at Port Blair famished and totally dehydrated. They were shifted to hospital. After they recovered from the trauma, they were jointly interrogated by police and defence personnel. 2

Although there is no lack of facilities, what they rue is detention without any crime. When asked SBS Deol, DGP told LOA, "They are not criminals and there is no justification in holding them in a detention camp, and I think they should be given Refugee status by Government of India." When asked about the delay in repatriation, Naushad, Dy SP Emigration told LOA, "We have already forwarded all the details of the boatpeople to BSF as well as to the concerned High Commission; however, its time consuming and the response is very slow from Dhaka as well as from BSF."

Andaman Islands The Cellular Jail, Port Blair

"We are doing our best in addressing their requirements. "There is cellphone facility provided to them and they speak to their family members and relatives," he said. The Administration is spending about Rs 12 Lakhs per month for the detainees. "The desperation among the detainees has increased a lot. They had gone on hunger strike four or five times demanding quick repatriation, which is not a good sign," said DGP. A few of them in fact had tried to escape from the camp. About ten of them are undergoing prison sentence.

"In 2005-07, many Rohingyas had trespassed Thailand to enter Malaysia. Although they were detained by Thai authorities for 10-15 days, as soon as their relatives in Malaysia intervened and paid an amount of 3000 Malaysian Ringgit, they were released. In Malaysia, the government accepted them and would provide them Refugee Card for labourers," said Mohd Zameer.

Indian coastguards rescued more than 700 Rohingya Boat people from near death from a deadly sea route near the Andaman Islands. On August 24,2011 after languishing in Andaman jail for about eight months, 175 boat-people were handed over to Bangladesh Red Crescent Society.

Rohingya Boat People in Thai Security Forces Custody: Are They Not Human Beings?
Mukhtar (35) belonged to a group of 61 persons, which landed in Twin Islands on 08 Jan 2009. Their boat had developed an engine snag, and drifting in open sea for about eight days. 3

In another incident, about 150 persons landed near Tillangchaung Island on 10 Jan 2009. Ghulam Kadir (25) who is still in the camp says that they were about 110 and 41 more people were tossed into an incapacitated boat by Thai authorities and pushed into the sea. About 113 persons have been repatriated. Another 36 persons are still in the Distress Camp waiting repatriation to Bangladesh. One more incapacitated boat carrying 133 Rohingyas reached Pillow Millow village in Great Nicobar on 15th January 2009. The boat caught the attention of the residents of the village that had just 5-6 families living there after tsunami devastated it in 2004. Rest of the 41 families of the village were still living in temporary shelters in Campbell Bay. However, the villagers took out their boats and with great difficulties towed the drifting boat to the village in a very rough weather. The Rohingyas were famished and dehydrated as was the case with earlier arrivals in the Islands. There was not much in the village to offer over 130 hungry people, said Paul Jura, the tribal chief of the village from Campbell Bay. However, the villagers offered them banana and whatever else they could. The police in Campbell Bay was alerted though even that in itself was a monumental task. The issue is very serious for those of Burmese origin. There were about 107 of them, out of which 38 of them were rescued in 2008 and only one of them was repatriated. Another group of 37 were found on Barren Island in December 2011. 34 more of Burmese origin was rescued near Goal Tikrey, Kalighat on 23 December 2011. "Even Rohingyas living legally on Phuket have been refused passports by the ''new'' Burmese government. Those who do land in Thailand are ''helped on'' to Malaysia or into the arms of brokers," said Alan Morison, Editor, Phuketwan to LOA. "Myanmar is not going to take them back as they are outcasts there and Bangladesh would do the same as they are Rohingyas. It would be inhumane to keep them in detention. Either United Nations or Government of India would have to pitch in and confer Refugee status to them," said a Police Officer. It is human right issue of monumental proportion rather than stray incidents of desperate people drifting in with the trade winds as the A&N Administration treats it. A proper policy needs to be devised in consultation with the Government of India to handle the migrant Rohingyas problem. ## THE LIGHT OF ANDAMANS | ISSUE 27 | 17 FEB 2012

Please Unite Us with Our Families: Mohd Muslim


Mohammed Muslim (47) is one of the most vocal among the detainees at the Distress Camp. He does not like to be addressed as Rohingya or Arakani. He says that he is from Teknaf, a sub-district of Cox Bazar, a division of Chittagong in Bangladesh. "The officials from Bangladesh High Commission comes here every 5-6 months. They take all our addresses and details. But, nothing is happening in our case," he said. 'We are 265 persons and detained in this camp for last three years. Only 11 persons from our group 4

have left. Out of 265, more than 100 persons will never get to go back as Bangladeshi official suspects us to be Arakanese," he worriedly said. "About 40 persons in our group have their own residence in Bangladesh, but the land is not in their name. The local police officials in our village demand huge amount of bribe in Bangladesh to respond to the identification letters." "Some of us even have Identity Cards, but our papers are not processed," "We are away from our families and they are in deep trouble as the earning members of the families are held up here. We speak to our family members over phone from here, but the authorities seem to be unaware of their whereabouts," Mohd told LOA. "Even UN is not taking up our issue with Indian Government. Give us the freedom every human being aspires for, he pleads. THE LIGHT OF ANDAMANS | ISSUE 27 | 17 FEB 2012

Persecution of Rohingyas
According to Amnesty International, the Rohingya people have continued to suffer from human rights violations under the Myanmar junta since 1978, and many have fled to neighbouring Bangladesh as a result:

Recently the Rohingya boat-people dead body was seen floating in the Naf River
"The Rohingyas' freedom of movement is severely restricted and the vast majority of them have effectively been denied Myanmar citizenship. They are also subjected to various forms of extortion and arbitrary taxation; land confiscation; forced eviction and house destruction; and financial restrictions on marriage. Rohingyas continue to be used as forced labourers on roads and at military camps, although the amount of forced labour in northern Rakhine (Arakan) State has decreased over the last decade." "In 1978 over estimated number of 300,000 Rohingyas fled to Bangladesh, following the 'Nagamin' ('Dragon King') operation of the Myanmar army. Officially this campaign aimed at "scrutinising each individual living in the state, designating citizens and foreigners in accordance with the law and taking actions against foreigners who have filtered into the country illegally". This military campaign directly targeted civilians, and resulted in widespread killings, rape and destruction." "During 1991-92 a new wave of the estimated number of a quarter of a million Rohingyas fled to Bangladesh. They reported widespread forced labour, as well as summary executions, torture, and rape. Rohingyas were forced to work without pay by the Myanmar army on infrastructure and economic projects, often under harsh conditions. Many other human rights violations occurred in the context of forced labour of Rohingya civilians by the security forces."

Rohingyas or Bangladeshis?
The boatpeople pushed deep into the sea to drift by Thai authorities and reached the Andaman shores facing hardships and ordeals now face a major crisis - Burmese does not recognize Rohingyas/Arakanese as their citizens, and many of them living in Bangladesh does not possess any paper from Bangladesh government. Most of these state-less people were living in the border towns of Bangladesh. Two-third of us is from Cox Bazar in Bangladesh. 5

Under Burmese law, the Rohingyas are de jure stateless, but they fare little better in Bangladesh. Most Rohingyas in Bangladesh have no legal rights and few employment opportunities. Hence, they try to move to Thailand and Malaysia. "As we are landless, our families live in rented houses there," said Abdul Rehman, who had crossed from Myanmar and living with his family in Cox Bazar. "We would like to go back to our families in Bangladesh," he said. ##

News Analysis

Friday, February 24, 2012, PHUKET WAN, Thailand

ROHINGYA REMAIN UNWANTED AS SECRECY COVERS TREATMENT OF BOATPEOPLE


By Alan Morison and Chutima Sidasathian
PHUKET: A compact between Thailand and neighboring countries is keeping treatment of Rohingya boatpeople secret as details are emerging of their continued imprisonment in India, on the Andaman and Nicobar Islands. About 400 boatpeople remain in detention on the isolated islands in the middle of the Indian Ocean more than three years on from Thailand's notorious ''pushbacks,'' says a new investigation. ''Abandoned by both Burma (Myanmar) and Bangladesh, their fate hangs in balance, with an indecisive government policy and the sluggish pace of repatriation,'' writes journalist Zubair Ahmed in the 'Light of Andamans' online magazine.

Rohingya who landed on Phuket last year await their fate Photo by phuketwan.com/file
Fishermen from Thailand, Burma and Bangladesh caught off the Andaman and Nicobar islands will be repatriated, a local police officer said. But the Rohingya are stateless so nobody wants them back, and there is nowhere for them to go. Phuketwan has recently confirmed that Burma's policy of the slow but steady ethnic cleansing of the Rohingya remains in place despite hope in the West that repression in the dictatorship will cease as it embraces democracy. A small number of Rohingya who have been granted the right to live and work on Phuket have recently been denied passports by the new ''democratic'' government of Burma despite their birth there, and in some cases despite having parents and grandparents who were raised as Burmese. Around the region, a blanket of secrecy has been thrown over the apprehension of Rohingya boatpeople, obscuring both their treatment in captivity and their future. Vice Admiral Thavatorn Thinsuwan, Commander of Royal Thai Navy 3, which patrols Thailand's Andaman coast from bases on Phuket and Phang Nga, acknowledged this week that Thailand was working with Singapore, Malaysia and Indonesia to ward 6

off piracy with regular air patrols. But he was less ready to say what the compact between the countries meant for the Rohingya boatpeople, whose vessels would be more easily spotted in aerial surveys than by navy patrols in the Andaman Sea.

Rohingya Boat-people before releasing secretly into international water by Thaiforces


While Burma is becoming more open and seemingly democratic, its most abhorrent policy - the denial of citizenship and rights to the Rohingya - remains in place and is being given tacit support by a conspiracy of silence among the governments of the region. When Phuketwan journalists, working with the South China Morning Post newspaper, in January 2009 exposed the covert ''pushbacks'' that were the then Thai government's response to growing numbers of Rohingya boatpeople, we thought the secrecy would come to an end. After a period of openness during which Rohingya boatpeople in Thailand were treated as other illegal detainees are treated, the policy surrounding the would-be refugees - among the world's most oppressed people - has become secret again.

The rescue Rohingya Boat People by the Indian Coastguards in the Andaman Islands.
Because Burma point-blank refuses to grant citizenship to the Muslim Rohingya - despite their centuries of history there - those who flee can never go home. Neighboring countries are adopting the only practical solution left to them: a covert back-door policy that basically involves tacitly supporting the handling of boatpeople by people traffickers. Vice Admiral Taratorn was reticent to go into details when he talked to journalists on Phuket this week but he did say that the Navy and Thailand upheld UN principles of human rights. That wasn't the case in 2009, when the reprensible ''pushbacks'' by other branches of the Thai military led to the deaths of hundreds of boatpeople and aroused concern around the region and the world. Now for the first time, Zubair Ahmed has reported on the fate of the survivors, who remain trapped in the Andaman and Nicobar islands with no obvious hope of being returned to their homes in Burma or Bangladesh. One survivor, Ghulam Kadir, 25, told Ahmed: ''Its three years now, and we have not done anything wrong. We were first persecuted by the Burmese Junta, pushed by the Thais into the face of death. ''The Indian government has been very sympathetic to us, but how can we continue to remain in a detention camp like this?'' Indian Navy senior officers have been engaged in talks with their peers in Thailand but when it comes to the Rohingya, no questions are being answered. 7

Ahmed says 422 boatpeople continue to ''languish'' in three dormitories in a centre known as the Distress Camp. About 270 have been repatriated - but not those who are bold enough to declare they are Rohingya. Of the detainees, Ahmed writes: ''They all look well-fed and clothed. However, they are unable to accept their fate, of living as prisoners without any hope.'' Boatpeople who have been apprehended in Thailand in recent times - including the occupants of a ricketty vessel that landed on the international holiday island of Phuket last year - have simply vanished. The suspicion is that they have been passed on to smugglers.

Rohingya from Burma landed on the Southern Thailand in last December


Non-government organisations say that despite the covert nature of the process, their sense is that the Rohingya who come ashore in Thailand are not being mistreated and are simply being ''helped on,'' often to Muslim-majority Malaysia. Efforts have been made, though, to stop the boats leaving northern Burma or neighboring Bangladesh, where many Rohingya live unsettled lives in refugee camps. Aid workers say that although there was once intense interest, especially among European Governments, in the fate of the Rohingya, that interest has tapered off with the apparent ''Burma spring'' of voluntary reforms. Yet while the world openly embraces the new Burma, the policy of ethnically cleansing the country of its resident Muslims remain unchanged. So does the abject hopelessness of the Rohingya people. ##

====== END ====== 8

You might also like