Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2011
2. HISTORY
Prior to 1990, Federal and Provincial Governments used to borrow on tap instruments with predetermined rates. The main thrust of Federal Government borrowing was through captive funding. Large statutory preemptions and borrowing from SBP at highly concessionary rates enabled the Government to finance its large fiscal deficits. In such an environment the only tool available to counteract was to makes successive increases in Statutory Liquidity Requirement (SLR) and Cash Reserve Requirement (CRR). There was very little scope for development of Government Securities Market in Pakistan that could provide benchmarks for private sector to play their role in development of Capital Market in the country. To cover non-banking segment,
1|Page
2011
Prize Bonds were introduced in1960 followed by various NSS schemes. However 1990 onward, market based Government Securities came in to existence. With the introduction of long term paper in1992 (FIB), long term yield curve emerged that gave opportunity to the Corporate to come up with their instruments that became reality in 1995. Long-term instruments gained momentum after the introduction of Pakistan Investment Bonds (PIBs) in 2000, to stream line the auction of Government Securities and to develop secondary market for the Government paper. SBP introduced selective Primary Dealer System (PD) in 2000. In 2001 KIBOR/KIBID rates were introduced to provide inter-bank call money curve. With the development of Fixed Income Securities Market in Pakistan, SBP allowed Commercial banks to make available Derivative products to their clients. In this regard SBP issued guidelines on Forward Rate Agreements (FRA), Interest Rate Swaps (IRS) and Currency Options in 2005. Foundation of the corporate bond market was laid in 1995 with the first issue of Term Finance Certificates (TFC). Since then, issuance of listed TFCs has totaled approximately PKR 67 billion. The Corporate Bond market in Pakistan has been much more vibrant over the 2001-05 periods, adding approximately PKR 65 billion in issuance or 98% of total issuance to-date. Pace of development of Islamic Money and Sukuk market is a new phenomenon that gained importance with the induction of 6 full-fledged Islamic Banks and 16 conventional banks to conduct Islamic banking business in Pakistan; however the size of Sukuk Market is very small at the moment. To facilitate Corporates to raise short term funding i.e. up to 9 months, Commercial Papers have recently been allowed but the market has yet to take its roots.
2|Page
2011
y y y y y y y
Bonds are issued in 3, 5, 10, 15, 20, and 30 years tenors. Bonds are issued through auction system in which only Primary Dealers (PDs) can participate. Issued at Par. Coupon payments are made semi annually. Bonds are issued in the form of un-certificated bonds and are maintained in SGLA maintained by the SBP. Bonds are SLR eligible securities and individuals, institutions and corporate bodies including banks can purchase, irrespective of their residential status. Bonds are tradable in secondary market.
Pakistan Investment Bonds (PIBs) as fixed rate government securities provide a benchmark for debt capital market. The government is committed to provide sufficient supply of long term papers in the market to develop the longer end of the government debt yield curve. The government is educating the investor base especially the institutional investors to manage their balance sheets in a more innovative way by diverting resources from working capital needs towards investment. PIBs together with the NSS (National Saving Schemes) instruments primarily hold a larger portion of local fixed-income market. They provide the government with long-term maturity debt. SBP held seven auctions in 2007-08, four in 2008-09, fourteen in 200910 and seven in 2010-11. Government amassed Rs. 64.7 billion through PIB auctions in 2009-10 and Rs. 83.4 billion in 2010-11. The government showed greater craving for borrowing through long term securities, and set the target of Rs 60 billion against a maturity of Rs 6.9 billion during 2010-11. Keeping in view the widening deficit gap of the government, from the demand side, market players offered Rs 134.4 billion and Rs 83.4 billion net of maturities was accepted as long term financing during 2010-11 as against Rs 51 billion net of maturities accepted in 2009-10 in the same corresponding period. Government generated resources from 10-years PIBs, and accepted 69 percent of the amount through this single maturity. This was followed by 3, 5-year PIBs with a share of 22.4 and 8 percent, respectively of the amount accepted in 2010-11. PIBs with 20 -year maturity accounted
3|Page
2011
for a share of 0.6 percent and 10-year PIB has shown a huge increase as compared to previous fiscal year as its percentage share in 2009-10 was 60.9 percent and 3-years PIB has also witnessed an increase from 18 percent in 2009-10 to 22.4 percent in 2010-11. On the other side shares of 5 and 20years PIBs declined shares to 8 and 0.6 percent, respectively in 2011. The share of 10 year PIB is amount to Rs. 57.5 billion in the 2010-11 as compared to Rs.39.4 billion in previous fiscal year. Amount received by 3-years PIB is Rs.18.7 billion in 2011 as compared Rs. 11.7 billion in 2009-10. The share of 7, 15 and 30-year PIB has declined in the current financial year as shown in Table 6.7.
4|Page
2011
Government and the central bank worked together to launch the GoP Ijara Sukuk in order to support efforts to diversify the borrowings mix to ensure financial stability. Islamic Banks have been aggressively mobilizing deposits, and play a significant role particularly after the introduction of the minimum deposit rate and easing of reserve ratios. To cope with the liquidity requirements of Shariah compliant banking institutions, the target or the auction of fourth GoP Ijara Sukuk is set at Rs 40 billion during Fiscal Year 2010-11 while it was 20.4 billion in revised budget in FY 2010. Increasing zeal for investment in these instruments was observed. Three auctions were held in July-March 2010-11 and targets for these were set at Rs.40, 40 and 45 billion, respectively. Total amount offered for the said bids was Rs.179.3 billion against target of Rs.125 billion while Rs.136.5 billion were accepted which reflects strong liquidity position of Islamic banks and their investment appetite for this asset class. The maturity of the Sukuk will be of one, two and three years. Table-16.11 depicts that SBP has increased the interest rates for 3, 5 and 10 years PIBs in 201011. For three years PIB interest rate is increased to 14.05 percent in March 2011 up from 12.66 in July 2010. Similarly interest rate for 5 and 10 years are 14.08 percent at the end of third quarter of the ongoing fiscal year as compared to 12.75 and 12.93 in July 2010.
5|Page
2011
Certificates attracted Rs 45.3 billion, followed by Special Saving Scheme and Regular Income Certificate. Defense saving certificate attracted net investment of Rs 6.6 billion against the target of retirement of 2.6 billion. The NSS contains a number of instruments with significant concentration on individual investment, NSS scheme are available with the maturity period of 3 years, 5 years, and ten years. It is also worth mentioning that segment of subsidized scheme i.e. Pensioner Benefit Account and Behbood Saving Certificate, contribute Rs. 58.8 billion in the total net investment of Rs. 168.7 billion till March 2011.
6|Page
2011
because it was specifically designed to comply with Shariah law. The key difference is that the TFC substitutes the words expected profit rates for interest rate. 3. TFC issuers include both NBFIs as well as public and private firms. 4. The coupon rates on the TFCs display a wide variety with different fixed coupons as well as floating coupons linked to various interest rates including the discount rates, PIB rates and the KIBOR. A well functioning corporate bond market provides an additional avenue to corporate sector for raising funds for meeting their financial requirements. During the period July-March 2010-11 one listed debt instrument was offered to the general public i.e. offering of Rs 4 billion Term Finance Certificate (TFC) by Engro Corporation Ltd. The TFC was offered only to retail investors and was fully subscribed. Out of the said Rs.4 billion, 74 percent were subscribed by the individuals, 20% by employees fund and balance by the others.
During the period a total of 07 debt securities issued through private placement. The break-up of these privately placed corporate debt issues are as follows.
As on December 31, 2010 a total of 142 corporate debt securities were issued with an outstanding amount of Rs 379.4 billion as follows.
7|Page
2011
2011
measures, this statute was also administered by the CLA. The abolition of the Capital Issues Act transferred the regulation of public issues (both debt and equity) to the Companies Ordinance of 1984, which also provides the legal framework for the corporate sector. The Companies Ordinance of 1984 gives the name term finance certificates to what are essentially debt securities, whose important feature is that the return promised by the issuer to the investor is built into the repurchase price at maturity. The difference between the original price and the repurchase price is not referred to as a fixed return but as expected profit. The labels, particularly expected profit, are chosen to confer an Islamic character on the instrument, since interest in the form of a fixed return (riba) on capital is deemed un-Islamic by most religious scholars. Thus, while both the issuer and the potential investor share the perception that the return on a TFC, in purely legal terms, is a fixed return, there is no certainty of a fixed obligation on the part of the issuer. This appears to be an unavoidable and unrectifiable anomaly which casts doubt on the character of the TFC as a fixed-income security. Interestingly enough, the government itself promises a fixed and specified return to investors in its federal investment bonds.
9|Page
2011
The bonds were issued in Rs 5,000500,000 denominations with returns payable every six months, and are discountable after six months from the date of sale (except for the sixth issue). They are quoted on the Karachi and Lahore Stock Exchanges. The Civil Aviation Authority (CAA) is another public-sector organization that has relied on bond financing for its capital expenditures. It has issued one series, valued at Rs 900 million and
10 | P a g e
2011
with an annual return of 12.5 percent, in 1991. These government-guaranteed bonds were redeemable after five years.
MTBs
Market Treasury Bills are the short term securities for government borrowing. They have the following Characteristics; y Issued in three tenors of 3-month, 6-month and 12-months maturity y Zero Coupon bonds sold at a discount to their face values
11 | P a g e
2011
Purchased by individuals, institutions and corporate bodies including banks irrespective of their residential status. y Primary Dealer maintains a Subsidiary General Ledger Account (SGLA) with SBP for the settlement purpose. The outstanding amount of MTBs as of March 2007 is Rs. 1086.25 billion (43.25% of total Domestic Debt) y
12 | P a g e
2011
The PIBs represent 63% of total permanent debt while 13.23% of the total domestic debt by March 2007.
13 | P a g e
2011
Instruments issued by the corporate and financial sectors Certificates of investment (COIs)
COIs are issued by DFIs, investment banks, leasing companies, and housing finance companies to raise deposits from the general public. Their tenor varies from three months to five years, and determines their rates, which also vary depending on market conditions, the credit of the borrowing institution, and deposit size. COIs cannot be recalled at the option of the issuer, and the investor is penalized for cashing them in early. There is no secondary market in COIs.
14 | P a g e
2011
The auction of MTBs is done on a fixed schedule on fortnightly basis while the auction of PIBs is done under Jumbo issuance mechanism under which the previous issues are reopened in order to enhance their liquidity in the secondary market.
15 | P a g e
2011
Both theoretical and empirical literature has extensively debated the virtues of the development of the corporate bond market. Some view it is an alternate or a substitute to the banking system and a spare tyre as referred to by Alan Greenspan, while others have contested that bond markets cannot serve as substitutes to bank debt as the performance of bonds is often impacted when there is an overall decline in economic and banking sector confidence. Growth in debt markets is a positive development for the financial system and the economy at large. It helps to diversify the financial system, reducing excessive dependence on banks and vulnerabilities within the banking system, while providing funding to large corporations looking for long term financing options. Financial engineering of different types has facilitated the development of innovate debt products which have supplemented and complemented bank financing. A viable fixed-income market provides an alternative source of finance to firms that exclusively rely on the banking sector in emerging economies, like Pakistan. Indeed, the monopoly of the banking sector is an impediment to the fundamental principles of a market economy based on perfect competition; it leads to inefficiency and therefore to sub-optimal outcomes in the loan market; and jeopardizes the stability of the financial system. A well-developed fixed income market helps expose banks to competition which in turn helps improve their efficiency. Indeed, extraordinary banking spreads in Pakistan in recent years is an evidence of lack of competition and efficiency in Pakistans financial markets. The short tenor of bank loans, itself a consequence of the nature of banks deposits, leads to maturity mismatch issues in the banks asset and liability portfolios. Long-term funding needs hence are financed by a consistent roll-over of short-term loans, and in times of tight liquidity, borrowers often face credit crunch and difficulties in rolling over their maturing obligations. A developed fixed income market would help mitigate these difficulties and also facilitate better risk diversification as debt is spread across a large number of individuals as opposed to bank lending, and the corporate sector is able to raise longer term debt. With the development of the fixed-income market, banks can focus more on those enterprises of the economy that typically
16 | P a g e
2011
face credit constraints due to their small size, relatively new stage of development, or simply asymmetrical information.
2011
Provincial Governments on their transactions and certain fees to be paid on their issuances and time taking procedures for their approval.
y y
Non issuance of Sovereign Sukuk Transaction cost as Stamps duties on Commercial Paper making them non cost effective.
shares/Corporate Bonds. y Introduced PIBs of 15 and 20-year tenors in Jan 2004 that has now been extended up to 30 years.
18 | P a g e
2011
Recent initiatives that are yet to materialize include allowing bond strips against PIBs, listing of Government Securities on Stock Exchanges, calendar for Government Securities issuances.
11.2. Roadmap (Plan/Strategy) for the Development of Bond Market (Financial Sector):
There cannot be any doubt that financial system of Pakistan has a lot of potential, however, it is to be searched and put in place. Another angle, which needs to be brought into the system, is to integrate it with global financial system. The vision, which anybody can have in the market for the future financial system of Pakistan, can be briefed as under: y y y y It has to be market based The market should have its own policing system in addition to Regulatory framework. Development of new hedging products like derivates. Updating of accounting/auditing and reporting system in line with the international standards. y y y y Fully automated financial system. New Government Securities Act to replace out dated Public Debt Act 1944. Listing of Government Securities on Stock Exchange to widen investor base. Implementation of Real Time Gross Settlement System to mitigate systemic risk in fund settlement. y Bond Stripping to create liquidity in the bond market and to induct zero coupon yield curve. y y To foster growth of corporate Bond market in Pakistan by making it cost effective. To develop Trading/Risk Management/price dissemination mechanism for Corporate Bond Market. y Financial Institutions to have controls i.e. Clear Strategies of duties at all levels, Dual Controls, Rotation of assignment of duties, Internal auditing of all operations, Audit programs for external auditing, Operational reviews. y y y Development of newly inducted Islamic Finance Development of Investor base specifically Mutual Funds Development of Sub National Bond Market in Pakistan
19 | P a g e
2011
20 | P a g e