page 1 of 20

Article : Art. 10 (1) Freedom of expression

Libert d'expression
Article : Art. 6 (1) Reasonable time (criminal proceedings)
Dlai raisonnable (pnal)
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Case name / NISKASAARI and OTAVAMEDIA OY v. Finland Date of Decision to Communicate /
Intitul de l'affaire NISKASAARI et OTAVAMEDIA OY c. Finlande Date de dcision de la communication
Appno / No de requte 32297/10 10/02/2012
Torture
Article : Art. 3 Torture
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Appno / No de requte 30953/11 10/02/2012
Intitul de l'affaire A.E. c. Finlande Date de dcision de la communication
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Case name / A.E. v. Finland Date of Decision to Communicate /
State / Etat Finland / Finlande
Traitements inhumains ou dgradants
Article : Art. 3 Inhuman or degrading treatment
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Appno / No de requte 6198/12 10/02/2012
Intitul de l'affaire DAYTBEGOVA ET MAGOMEDOVA c. Autriche Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / DAYTBEGOVA AND MAGOMEDOVA v. Austria Date of Decision to Communicate /
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
State / Etat Austria / Autriche
Communicated cases - European Court of Human Rights
for the period 06/02/2012 to 12/02/2012
This list is not exhaustive; it includes only cases deemed to be of more significant jurisprudential interest. Cases may have been communicated only
with regard to some of the Convention provisions listed below. Please refer to the questions put to the parties.
Affaires communiques - Cour europenne des Droits de l'Homme
pour la priode du 06/02/2012 au 12/02/2012
Cette liste n'est pas exhaustive ; n'y figurent que les affaires prsentant un intrt jurisprudentiel certain. Pour chaque requte, la communication peut
porter uniquement sur certaines des dispositions de la Convention numres ci-dessous. Pour plus de prcisions, consulter les questions qui ont t
poses aux parties
page 2 of 20
Interdiction discrimination
Article : Prot. 1 Art. 1 Peaceful enjoyment of possessions
Article : Art. 14 Prohibition of discrimination
Appno / No de requte 49570/11 08/02/2012
Intitul de l'affaire GALL c. Hongrie Date de dcision de la communication
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Case name / GALL v. Hungary Date of Decision to Communicate /
State / Etat Hungary / Hongrie
Contestations de droit/obligations civiles
Article : Art. 6 (1) Determination of civil rights and obligations
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Case name / GARBO v. France Date of Decision to Communicate /
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Intitul de l'affaire GARBO c. France Date de dcision de la communication
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Appno / No de requte 53362/10 06/02/2012
Article : Art. 8 (2) Necessary in a democratic society
Droit de se marier
Article : Art. 12 Right to marry
Ncessit dans une socit dmocratique
Article : Art. 14 Prohibition of discrimination
Article : Art. 6 (1) Determination of civil rights and obligations
Contestations de droit/obligations civiles
Interdiction discrimination
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Appno / No de requte 65192/11 12/02/2012
Intitul de l'affaire MENNESSON c. France Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / MENNESSON v. France Date of Decision to Communicate /
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Ncessit dans une socit dmocratique
Article : Art. 8 (2) Necessary in a democratic society
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Appno / No de requte 65941/11 12/02/2012
Intitul de l'affaire LABASSEE c. France Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / LABASSEE v. France Date of Decision to Communicate /
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
State / Etat France / France
page 3 of 20
Vie prive
Article : Art. 8 (1) Private life
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Appno / No de requte 64753/11 06/02/2012
Intitul de l'affaire MITKA-MASLOWSKA c. Pologne Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / MITKA-MASLOWSKA v. Poland Date of Decision to Communicate /
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
State / Etat Poland / Pologne
Domicile
Article : Art. 13 Effective remedy/national authority
Droit de recours effectif/instance nationale
Article : Art. 8 (1) Home
Vie prive
Article : Art. 8 (1) Private life
Vie familiale
Article : Art. 8 (1) Family life
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
A partial decision on admissibility was adopted in this case / Une dcision partielle sur la recevabilit a t adopte dans cette affaire
Appno / No de requte 28926/10 07/02/2012
Intitul de l'affaire VINKS et RIBICKA c. Lettonie Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / VINKS and RIBICKA v. Latvia Date of Decision to Communicate /
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Article : Art. 3 Conditions of detention
Conditions de dtention
Article : Art. 3 Inhuman or degrading treatment
Traitements inhumains ou dgradants
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Appno / No de requte 26544/10 08/02/2012
Intitul de l'affaire BERNOTS c. Lettonie Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / BERNOTS v. Latvia Date of Decision to Communicate /
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
State / Etat Latvia / Lettonie
Respect des biens
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
page 4 of 20
Article : Art. 6 (1) Determination of civil rights and obligations
Contestations de droit/obligations civiles
Article : Art. 3 Conditions of detention
Conditions de dtention
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Intitul de l'affaire TORAN et SCHYMIK c. Roumanie Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / TORAN and SCHYMIK v. Romania Date of Decision to Communicate /
Appno / No de requte 43873/10 08/02/2012
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Procs quitable/Prononc
Article : Art. 6 (1) Fair hearing/Pronouncement
Respect des biens
Article : Prot. 1 Art. 1 Peaceful enjoyment of possessions
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Appno / No de requte 31203/04 08/02/2012
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Case name / FUNDATIA UNIVERSITARA 'UNITEH' v. Romania Date of Decision to Communicate /
Intitul de l'affaire FUNDATIA UNIVERSITARA 'UNITEH' c. Roumanie Date de dcision de la communication
Torture
Article : Art. 3 Torture
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Intitul de l'affaire DONOS c. Roumanie Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / DONOS v. Romania Date of Decision to Communicate /
Appno / No de requte 30647/07 08/02/2012
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Contestations de droit/obligations civiles
Article : Art. 6 (1) Determination of civil rights and obligations
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Intitul de l'affaire DAN c. Roumanie Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / DAN v. Romania Date of Decision to Communicate /
Appno / No de requte 60276/08 08/02/2012
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
State / Etat Romania / Roumanie
page 5 of 20
Article : Art. 5 (4) Decision on lawfulness/review of detention
Dcision sur la lgalit/Rvision de la dtention
Article : Art. 5 (3) Trial within reasonable time after arrest
Jugement aprs arrestation/dlai raisonnable
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
A partial decision on admissibility was adopted in this case / Une dcision partielle sur la recevabilit a t adopte dans cette affaire
Intitul de l'affaire GABREA et autres c. Roumanie Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / GABREA and others v. Romania Date of Decision to Communicate /
Appno / No de requte 51157/10 07/02/2012
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Article : Art. 14 Prohibition of discrimination
Contestations de droit/obligations civiles
Article : Art. 6 (1) Determination of civil rights and obligations
Respect des biens
Article : Prot. 1 Art. 1 Peaceful enjoyment of possessions
Interdiction discrimination
A partial decision on admissibility was adopted in this case / Une dcision partielle sur la recevabilit a t adopte dans cette affaire
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Appno / No de requte 45312/11 07/02/2012
Intitul de l'affaire FRIMU c. Roumanie Date de dcision de la communication
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Case name / FRIMU v. Romania Date of Decision to Communicate /
Traitements inhumains ou dgradants
Article : Art. 3 Inhuman or degrading treatment
Article : Art. 5 (3) Trial within reasonable time after arrest
Jugement aprs arrestation/dlai raisonnable
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
A partial decision on admissibility was adopted in this case / Une dcision partielle sur la recevabilit a t adopte dans cette affaire
Intitul de l'affaire BUCURESTEANU c. Roumanie Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / BUCURESTEANU v. Romania Date of Decision to Communicate /
Appno / No de requte 20558/04 07/02/2012
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Dtermination d'une accusation pnale
Article : Art. 6 (1) Determination of a criminal charge
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
A partial decision on admissibility was adopted in this case / Une dcision partielle sur la recevabilit a t adopte dans cette affaire
Intitul de l'affaire ANTOHE c. Roumanie Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / ANTOHE v. Romania Date of Decision to Communicate /
Appno / No de requte 55857/07 07/02/2012
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
page 6 of 20
Article : Prot. 1 Art. 1 Peaceful enjoyment of possessions
Interdiction discrimination
Article : Art. 14 Prohibition of discrimination
Contestations de droit/obligations civiles
Article : Art. 6 (1) Determination of civil rights and obligations
Intitul de l'affaire TANKO c. Roumanie Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / TANKO v. Romania Date of Decision to Communicate /
Appno / No de requte 45583/11 07/02/2012
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Vie prive
Article : Art. 8 (1) Private life
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Appno / No de requte 38566/04 07/02/2012
Case name / NICOLESCU v. Romania Date of Decision to Communicate /
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Intitul de l'affaire NICOLESCU c. Roumanie Date de dcision de la communication
Contestations de droit/obligations civiles
Article : Art. 6 (1) Determination of civil rights and obligations
Article : Prot. 1 Art. 1 Peaceful enjoyment of possessions
Respect des biens
Interdiction discrimination
Article : Art. 14 Prohibition of discrimination
A partial decision on admissibility was adopted in this case / Une dcision partielle sur la recevabilit a t adopte dans cette affaire
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Intitul de l'affaire MOLNAR c. Roumanie Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / MOLNAR v. Romania Date of Decision to Communicate /
Appno / No de requte 45587/11 07/02/2012
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Interdiction discrimination
Respect des biens
Article : Prot. 1 Art. 1 Peaceful enjoyment of possessions
Article : Art. 6 (1) Determination of civil rights and obligations
Contestations de droit/obligations civiles
Article : Art. 14 Prohibition of discrimination
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
A partial decision on admissibility was adopted in this case / Une dcision partielle sur la recevabilit a t adopte dans cette affaire
Intitul de l'affaire GHETU c. Roumanie Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / GHETU v. Romania Date of Decision to Communicate /
Appno / No de requte 45588/11 07/02/2012
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
page 7 of 20
Article : Art. 5 (3) Arrestee/brought before judge/other authorised officer
Personne arrte/
prsentation/juge/magistrat habilit
Article : Art. 5 (1) (c) Lawful arrest or detention/reasonable suspicion of having committed an offence
Arrestation/dtention rgulire/raisons plausibles de souponner une infraction
Intitul de l'affaire ALEKSEYEV c. Russie Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / ALEKSEYEV v. Russia Date of Decision to Communicate /
Appno / No de requte 16242/08 08/02/2012
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Procs quitable/Prononc
Article : Art. 6 (3) (c) Free legal assistance
Assistance gratuite/avocat d'office/assistance judiciaire
Article : Art. 3 Conditions of detention
Conditions de dtention
Article : Art. 6 (1) Fair hearing/Pronouncement
Correspondance
Article : Art. 34 Right of individual petition without hindrance
Droit de recours individuel sans entrave
Article : Art. 6 (3) (d) Examination/attendance of witnesses
Interrogation/convocation tmoins
Article : Art. 8 (1) Correspondence
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Appno / No de requte 36814/06 10/02/2012
Intitul de l'affaire CHUKAYEV c. Russie Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / CHUKAYEV v. Russia Date of Decision to Communicate /
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
State / Etat Russia / Russie
Interdiction discrimination
Article : Art. 14 Prohibition of discrimination
Contestations de droit/obligations civiles
Respect des biens
Article : Art. 6 (1) Determination of civil rights and obligations
Article : Prot. 1 Art. 1 Peaceful enjoyment of possessions
A partial decision on admissibility was adopted in this case / Une dcision partielle sur la recevabilit a t adopte dans cette affaire
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Case name / TIMAR v. Romania Date of Decision to Communicate /
Intitul de l'affaire TIMAR c. Roumanie Date de dcision de la communication
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Appno / No de requte 45581/11 07/02/2012
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Respect des biens
A partial decision on admissibility was adopted in this case / Une dcision partielle sur la recevabilit a t adopte dans cette affaire
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
page 8 of 20
Droit la libert/privation de libert
Article : Art. 6 (3) (d) Examination/attendance of witnesses
Article : Art. 10 (1) Freedom of expression
Article : Art. 10 (2) Prescribed by law
Libert d'expression
Propre dfense
Procs quitable/Prononc
Article : Art. 6 (1) Fair hearing/Pronouncement
Article : Art. 6 (3) (b) Adequate time/facilities for preparation of defence
Article : Art. 6 (3) (c) Defence in person
Temps/facilits/dfense
Article : Art. 5 (1) Right to liberty/deprivation of liberty
Conditions de dtention
Interrogation/convocation tmoins
Article : Art. 3 Conditions of detention
Article : Art. 11 (1) Freedom of peaceful assembly
Prvue par la loi
Libert de runion pacifique
Article : Art. 11 (2) Prescribed by law
Appno / No de requte 76204/11 08/02/2012
Intitul de l'affaire NAVALNYY ET YASHIN c. Russie Date de dcision de la communication
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Case name / NAVALNYY AND YASHIN v. Russia Date of Decision to Communicate /
Dcision sur la lgalit/Rvision de la dtention
Article : Art. 5 (5) Compensation for unlawful arrest or detention
Article : Art. 5 (4) Decision on lawfulness/review of detention
Article : Art. 5 (1) (c) Lawful arrest or detention/bring before legal authority
Arrestation/dtention rgulire/comparution devant autorit judiciaire
Rparation pour arrestation ou dtention irregulire
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Intitul de l'affaire FORTALNOV c. Russie Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / FORTALNOV v. Russia Date of Decision to Communicate /
Appno / No de requte 7077/06 08/02/2012
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Article : Art. 6 (1) Fair hearing/Pronouncement
Procs quitable/Prononc
Article : Art. 6 (3) (c) Own choice of legal assistance
Dcision sur la lgalit/Rvision de la dtention
Article : Art. 5 (3) Trial within reasonable time after arrest
Jugement aprs arrestation/dlai raisonnable
Article : Art. 5 (4) Decision on lawfulness/review of detention
Assistance gratuite/avocat d'office/assistance judiciaire
Article : Art. 6 (3) (c) Free legal assistance
Assistance d'un dfenseur de son choix
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
page 9 of 20
Traitements inhumains ou dgradants
Article : Art. 13 Effective remedy/national authority
Article : Art. 3 Inhuman or degrading treatment
Article : Art. 3 Torture
Torture
Droit de recours effectif/instance nationale
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Intitul de l'affaire O.G.S. c. Espagne Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / O.G.S. v. Spain Date of Decision to Communicate /
Appno / No de requte 62799/11 08/02/2012
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Article : Art. 3 Torture
Droit la vie
Torture
Peines/traitements dgradants
Article : Art. 3 Degrading treatment/punishment
Article : Art. 2 (1) Right to life
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Case name / D.M.L. v. Spain Date of Decision to Communicate /
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Intitul de l'affaire D.M.L. c. Espagne Date de dcision de la communication
Appno / No de requte 62808/11 08/02/2012
State / Etat Spain / Espagne
Article : Art. 17 Prohibition on destruction Convention rights and freedoms
Interdiction/destruction droits ou liberts conventionnelles
Article : Art. 10 (1) Freedom of expression
Libert d'expression
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Intitul de l'affaire PUTINTSEV c. Russie Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / PUTINTSEV v. Russia Date of Decision to Communicate /
Appno / No de requte 44900/06 08/02/2012
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Application des restrictions dans le but prvu
Article : Art. 18 Application of restrictions only for prescribed purposes
Prvues par la loi
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
page 10 of 20
Jugement aprs arrestation/dlai raisonnable
Article : Art. 5 (4) Decision on lawfulness/review of detention
Dcision sur la lgalit/Rvision de la dtention
Article : Art. 5 (1) (c) Lawful arrest or detention/reasonable suspicion of having committed an offence
Arrestation/dtention rgulire/raisons plausibles de souponner une infraction
Article : Art. 5 (3) Trial within reasonable time after arrest
Vie prive
Article : Art. 8 (1) Private life
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
A partial decision on admissibility was adopted in this case / Une dcision partielle sur la recevabilit a t adopte dans cette affaire
Intitul de l'affaire BEKTAS c. Turquie Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / BEKTAS v. Turkey Date of Decision to Communicate /
Appno / No de requte 70026/10 07/02/2012
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
State / Etat Turkey / Turquie
Traitements inhumains ou dgradants
Article : Art. 3 Inhuman or degrading treatment
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Appno / No de requte 6071/12 06/02/2012
Intitul de l'affaire Y.I. c. Royaume-Uni Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / Y.I. v. the United Kingdom Date of Decision to Communicate /
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
State / Etat the United Kingdom / Royaume-Uni
Procs quitable/Prononc
Article : Art. 6 (3) (c) Own choice of legal assistance
Assistance d'un dfenseur de son choix
Article : Art. 6 (1) Determination of civil rights and obligations
Contestations de droit/obligations civiles
Article : Art. 6 (1) Fair hearing/Pronouncement
Article : Art. 6 (3) (d) Examination/attendance of witnesses
Interrogation/convocation tmoins
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Appno / No de requte 3519/08 10/02/2012
Intitul de l'affaire ARSOV c. ex-Republique yougoslave de Macedoine Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / ARSOV v. the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia Date of Decision to Communicate /
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
State / Etat the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia / ex-Rpublique yougoslave de Macdoine
page 11 of 20
Article : Art. 5 (4) Decision on lawfulness/review of detention
Dcision sur la lgalit/Rvision de la dtention
Jugement aprs arrestation/dlai raisonnable
Information arrestation/accusation
Article : Art. 5 (3) Trial within reasonable time after arrest
Article : Art. 5 (5) Compensation for unlawful arrest or detention
Arrestation/dtention rgulire/raisons plausibles de souponner une infraction
Article : Art. 5 (1) (c) Lawful arrest or detention/reasonable suspicion of having committed an offence
Article : Art. 5 (2) Information on arrest/charge
Intitul de l'affaire KIRECTEPE et AUTRES c. Turquie Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / KIRECTEPE and OTHERS v. Turkey Date of Decision to Communicate /
Appno / No de requte 59194/10 07/02/2012
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Dcision sur la lgalit/Rvision de la dtention
Article : Art. 5 (4) Decision on lawfulness/review of detention
Droit la libert/privation de libert
Article : Art. 6 (1) Fair hearing/Pronouncement
Domicile
Article : Art. 8 (1) Home
Procs quitable/Prononc
Article : Art. 5 (1) Right to liberty/deprivation of liberty
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
A partial decision on admissibility was adopted in this case / Une dcision partielle sur la recevabilit a t adopte dans cette affaire
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Intitul de l'affaire IKE c. Turquie Date de dcision de la communication
Appno / No de requte 10108/10 07/02/2012
Case name / IKE v. Turkey Date of Decision to Communicate /
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Dcision sur la lgalit/Rvision de la dtention
Article : Art. 5 (4) Decision on lawfulness/review of detention
Rparation pour arrestation ou dtention irregulire
Article : Art. 5 (5) Compensation for unlawful arrest or detention
Article : Art. 5 (3) Arrestee/brought before judge/other authorised officer
Personne arrte/
prsentation/juge/magistrat habilit
Jugement aprs arrestation/dlai raisonnable
Article : Art. 5 (3) Trial within reasonable time after arrest
Article : Art. 13 Effective remedy/national authority
Droit de recours effectif/instance nationale
Article : Art. 6 (1) Reasonable time (criminal proceedings)
Dlai raisonnable (pnal)
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
A partial decision on admissibility was adopted in this case / Une dcision partielle sur la recevabilit a t adopte dans cette affaire
Intitul de l'affaire ERGEZEN c. Turquie Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / ERGEZEN v. Turkey Date of Decision to Communicate /
Appno / No de requte 73359/10 07/02/2012
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
page 12 of 20
Peines/traitements dgradants
Article : Art. 3 Degrading treatment/punishment
Arrest./dtention rg/procdure d'expulsion/d'extradition
Article : Art. 5 (1) (f) Lawful arrest/detention/for deportation/expulsion
Droit la vie
Article : Art. 2 (1) Right to life
Traitements inhumains ou dgradants
Article : Art. 3 Inhuman or degrading treatment
Information/accusation
Article : Art. 6 (3) (a) Charges/information about charges
Information arrestation/accusation
Article : Art. 5 (2) Information on arrest/charge
Procs quitable/Prononc
Article : Art. 6 (1) Fair hearing/Pronouncement
Intitul de l'affaire ALEKSANDR SMIRNOV c. Ukraine Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / ALEKSANDR SMIRNOV v. Ukraine Date of Decision to Communicate /
Appno / No de requte 69250/11 09/02/2012
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
State / Etat Ukraine / Ukraine
Article : Art. 8 (1) Correspondence
Correspondance
Information/accusation
Article : Art. 5 (4) Decision on lawfulness/review of detention
Jugement aprs arrestation/dlai raisonnable
Dcision sur la lgalit/Rvision de la dtention
Rparation pour arrestation ou dtention irregulire
Article : Art. 5 (5) Compensation for unlawful arrest or detention
Droit la libert/privation de libert
Article : Art. 5 (1) Right to liberty/deprivation of liberty
Article : Art. 5 (2) Information on arrest/charge
Article : Art. 5 (3) Trial within reasonable time after arrest
Information arrestation/accusation
Prsomption d'innocence
Article : Art. 6 (3) (a) Charges/information about charges
Article : Art. 6 (2) Presumption of innocence
Article : Art. 6 (1) Fair hearing/Pronouncement
Procs quitable/Prononc
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Appno / No de requte 32009/11 06/02/2012
Intitul de l'affaire UNLU c. Turquie Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / UNLU v. Turkey Date of Decision to Communicate /
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Rparation pour arrestation ou dtention irregulire
A partial decision on admissibility was adopted in this case / Une dcision partielle sur la recevabilit a t adopte dans cette affaire
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
page 13 of 20
Dtermination d'une accusation pnale
Article : Art. 6 (1) Determination of a criminal charge
Information arrestation/accusation
Article : Art. 6 (1) Independent and impartial tribunal
Dlai raisonnable (pnal)
Article : Art. 6 (1) Reasonable time (criminal proceedings)
Article : Art. 5 (2) Information on arrest/charge
Article : Art. 3 Conditions of detention
Traitements inhumains ou dgradants
Droit la libert/privation de libert
Article : Art. 5 (1) Right to liberty/deprivation of liberty
Conditions de dtention
Tribunal indpendant/impartial
Interprtation gratuite
Article : Art. 6 (3) (e) Free assistance of an interpreter
Interrogation/convocation tmoins
Vie familiale
Article : Art. 8 (1) Family life
Article : Art. 6 (3) (d) Examination/attendance of witnesses
Article : Art. 6 (3) (b) Adequate time/facilities for preparation of defence
Prsomption d'innocence
Article : Art. 6 (2) Presumption of innocence
Assistance gratuite/avocat d'office/assistance judiciaire
Article : Art. 6 (3) (c) Free legal assistance
Temps/facilits/dfense
Article : Art. 2 (1) Right to life
Article : Art. 3 Inhuman or degrading treatment
Droit la vie
Torture
Article : Art. 3 Torture
Intitul de l'affaire ROMANOV c. Ukraine Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / ROMANOV v. Ukraine Date of Decision to Communicate /
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Appno / No de requte 63782/11 09/02/2012
Interprtation gratuite
Article : Art. 6 (3) (e) Free assistance of an interpreter
Correspondance
Article : Art. 8 (1) Correspondence
Temps/facilits/dfense
Article : Art. 6 (3) (b) Adequate time/facilities for preparation of defence
Assistance d'un dfenseur de son choix
Article : Art. 6 (3) (c) Own choice of legal assistance
Article : Art. 9 (1) Freedom of thought/conscience
Article : Art. 14 Prohibition of discrimination
Interdiction discrimination
Droit de recours effectif/instance nationale
Libert de pense/conscience
Article : Art. 13 Effective remedy/national authority
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
page 14 of 20
Temps/facilits/dfense
Article : Art. 6 (3) (b) Adequate time/facilities for preparation of defence
Assistance gratuite/avocat d'office/assistance judiciaire
Article : Art. 6 (3) (c) Free legal assistance
Contestations de droit/obligations civiles
Article : Art. 5 (5) Compensation for unlawful arrest or detention
Arrestation/dtention rgulire/comparution devant autorit judiciaire
Article : Art. 6 (1) Determination of civil rights and obligations
Rparation pour arrestation ou dtention irregulire
Article : Art. 6 (3) (d) Examination/attendance of witnesses
Droit de recours effectif/instance nationale
Article : Art. 13 Effective remedy/national authority
Application des restrictions dans le but prvu
Article : Art. 18 Application of restrictions only for prescribed purposes
Libert de runion pacifique
Article : Art. 7 (1) Retroactivity/criminal offence/ penalty
Interrogation/convocation tmoins
Article : Art. 11 (1) Freedom of peaceful assembly
Rtroactivit/infraction/peine
Article : Art. 5 (1) Prescribed by law
Selon les voies lgales
Article : Art. 5 (1) (c) Lawful arrest or detention/bring before legal authority
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Appno / No de requte 20372/11 09/02/2012
Case name / VYERENTSOV v. Ukraine Date of Decision to Communicate /
Intitul de l'affaire VYERENTSOV c. Ukraine Date de dcision de la communication
Article : Art. 13 Effective remedy/national authority
Correspondance
Article : Art. 9 (1) Freedom of thought/conscience
Article : Art. 8 (1) Correspondence
Libert de pense/conscience
Libert d'opinion
Article : Art. 10 (1) Freedom of opinion
Droit de recours individuel sans entrave
Article : Prot. 12 Art. 1 General prohibition of discrimination
Interdiction gnrale de la discrimination
Article : Art. 34 Right of individual petition without hindrance
Droit de recours effectif/instance nationale
Article : Art. 14 Prohibition of discrimination
Interdiction discrimination
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
page 15 of 20
Article : Art. 2 (1) Right to life
Intitul de l'affaire ZINCHENKO c. Ukraine Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / ZINCHENKO v. Ukraine Date of Decision to Communicate /
Appno / No de requte 63763/11 09/02/2012
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Article : Art. 8 (1) Correspondence
Vie familiale
Article : Art. 9 (2) Necessary in a democratic society
Correspondance
Article : Art. 6 (3) (e) Free assistance of an interpreter
Interrogation/convocation tmoins
Article : Art. 8 (1) Family life
Interprtation gratuite
Ncessaire dans une socit dmocratique
Interdiction discrimination
Article : Art. 14 Prohibition of discrimination
Droit de recours individuel sans entrave
Article : Art. 34 Right of individual petition without hindrance
Ncessit dans une socit dmocratique
Article : Art. 10 (2) Necessary in a democratic society
Droit de recours effectif/instance nationale
Article : Art. 13 Effective remedy/national authority
Article : Art. 5 (1) Right to liberty/deprivation of liberty
Conditions de dtention
Droit la libert/privation de libert
Dtermination d'une accusation pnale
Article : Art. 6 (1) Determination of a criminal charge
Droit la vie
Article : Art. 2 (1) Right to life
Article : Art. 3 Torture
Article : Art. 3 Conditions of detention
Torture
Article : Art. 6 (1) Reasonable time (criminal proceedings)
Article : Art. 6 (3) (d) Examination/attendance of witnesses
Article : Art. 6 (3) (b) Adequate time/facilities for preparation of defence
Assistance gratuite/avocat d'office/assistance judiciaire
Temps/facilits/dfense
Article : Art. 6 (3) (c) Free legal assistance
Article : Art. 6 (1) Independent and impartial tribunal
Dlai raisonnable (pnal)
Tribunal indpendant/impartial
Prsomption d'innocence
Article : Art. 6 (2) Presumption of innocence
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Intitul de l'affaire YAKOVENKO c. Ukraine Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / YAKOVENKO v. Ukraine Date of Decision to Communicate /
Appno / No de requte 63727/11 09/02/2012
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
page 16 of 20
Article : Art. 8 (1) Correspondence
Vie familiale
Article : Art. 9 (1) Freedom of thought/conscience
Correspondance
Article : Art. 8 (1) Family life
Interprtation gratuite
Article : Art. 6 (3) (e) Free assistance of an interpreter
Vie prive
Article : Art. 8 (1) Private life
Libert de pense/conscience
Article : Art. 34 Right of individual petition without hindrance
Interdiction discrimination
Droit la vie
Droit de recours individuel sans entrave
Article : Art. 14 Prohibition of discrimination
Libert d'opinion
Article : Art. 10 (1) Freedom of opinion
Droit de recours effectif/instance nationale
Article : Art. 13 Effective remedy/national authority
Interrogation/convocation tmoins
Article : Art. 5 (2) Information on arrest/charge
Droit la libert/privation de libert
Article : Art. 5 (1) Right to liberty/deprivation of liberty
Dtermination d'une accusation pnale
Article : Art. 6 (1) Determination of a criminal charge
Information arrestation/accusation
Article : Art. 3 Inhuman or degrading treatment
Torture
Article : Art. 3 Torture
Conditions de dtention
Article : Art. 3 Conditions of detention
Traitements inhumains ou dgradants
Article : Art. 6 (1) Reasonable time (criminal proceedings)
Propre dfense
Article : Art. 6 (3) (c) Defence in person
Article : Art. 6 (3) (d) Examination/attendance of witnesses
Article : Art. 6 (3) (c) Own choice of legal assistance
Assistance gratuite/avocat d'office/assistance judiciaire
Article : Art. 6 (3) (c) Free legal assistance
Assistance d'un dfenseur de son choix
Temps/facilits/dfense
Article : Art. 6 (2) Presumption of innocence
Prsomption d'innocence
Article : Art. 6 (3) (b) Adequate time/facilities for preparation of defence
Dlai raisonnable (pnal)
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
page 17 of 20
Tribunal indpendant/impartial
Article : Art. 6 (1) Independent and impartial tribunal
Dlai raisonnable (pnal)
Article : Art. 6 (3) (b) Adequate time/facilities for preparation of defence
Prsomption d'innocence
Article : Art. 6 (2) Presumption of innocence
Article : Art. 6 (1) Reasonable time (criminal proceedings)
Article : Art. 5 (1) Right to liberty/deprivation of liberty
Conditions de dtention
Article : Art. 3 Conditions of detention
Dtermination d'une accusation pnale
Article : Art. 6 (1) Determination of a criminal charge
Droit la libert/privation de libert
Temps/facilits/dfense
Correspondance
Article : Art. 8 (1) Correspondence
Interprtation gratuite
Article : Art. 9 (1) Freedom of thought/conscience
Article : Art. 6 (3) (e) Free assistance of an interpreter
Article : Art. 6 (3) (c) Free legal assistance
Propre dfense
Article : Art. 6 (3) (c) Defence in person
Interrogation/convocation tmoins
Article : Art. 6 (3) (d) Examination/attendance of witnesses
Assistance gratuite/avocat d'office/assistance judiciaire
Article : Art. 2 (1) Right to life
Torture
Article : Art. 3 Torture
Droit la vie
Intitul de l'affaire DANILOV c. Ukraine Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / DANILOV v. Ukraine Date of Decision to Communicate /
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Appno / No de requte 2585/06 06/02/2012
Traitements inhumains ou dgradants
Article : Art. 6 (1) Fair hearing/Pronouncement
Procs quitable/Prononc
Article : Art. 2 (1) Right to life
Droit la vie
Article : Art. 3 Inhuman or degrading treatment
Article : Art. 13 Effective remedy/national authority
Interdiction discrimination
Article : Art. 14 Prohibition of discrimination
Droit de recours effectif/instance nationale
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Intitul de l'affaire BUCHYNSKA c. Ukraine Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / BUCHYNSKA v. Ukraine Date of Decision to Communicate /
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Appno / No de requte 35493/10 06/02/2012
page 18 of 20
Article : Art. 8 (1) Family life
Vie familiale
Article : Art. 8 (1) Private life
Vie prive
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Intitul de l'affaire GARNAGA c. Ukraine Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / GARNAGA v. Ukraine Date of Decision to Communicate /
Appno / No de requte 20390/07 06/02/2012
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Droit de recours effectif/instance nationale
Article : Art. 13 Effective remedy/national authority
Traitements inhumains ou dgradants
Article : Art. 3 Inhuman or degrading treatment
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Intitul de l'affaire FESIK c. Ukraine Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / FESIK v. Ukraine Date of Decision to Communicate /
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Appno / No de requte 2704/11 06/02/2012
Contestations de droit/obligations civiles
Article : Art. 6 (1) Determination of civil rights and obligations
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Intitul de l'affaire DOVGOPOL c. Ukraine Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / DOVGOPOL v. Ukraine Date of Decision to Communicate /
Appno / No de requte 27317/08 06/02/2012
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Article : Art. 13 Effective remedy/national authority
Droit de recours effectif/instance nationale
Article : Art. 14 Prohibition of discrimination
Libert de pense/conscience
Article : Art. 10 (1) Freedom of opinion
Libert d'opinion
Interdiction discrimination
Droit de recours individuel sans entrave
Article : Art. 34 Right of individual petition without hindrance
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
page 19 of 20
Article : Art. 1 (1) General undertaking/HPC
Intitul de l'affaire SERIKOV c. Ukraine Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / SERIKOV v. Ukraine Date of Decision to Communicate /
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Appno / No de requte 42164/09 06/02/2012
Prsomption d'innocence
Dtermination d'une accusation pnale
Article : Art. 6 (2) Presumption of innocence
Article : Art. 6 (1) Determination of a criminal charge
Article : Art. 3 Torture
Torture
Article : Art. 6 (3) (a) Charges/information about charges
Interrogation/convocation tmoins
Article : Art. 8 (1) Private life
Vie prive
Article : Art. 6 (3) (d) Examination/attendance of witnesses
Information/accusation
Article : Art. 6 (3) (b) Adequate time/facilities for preparation of defence
Temps/facilits/dfense
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Intitul de l'affaire SALYUK c. Ukraine Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / SALYUK v. Ukraine Date of Decision to Communicate /
Appno / No de requte 273/06 06/02/2012
Article : Art. 6 (1) Determination of civil rights and obligations
Contestations de droit/obligations civiles
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
Intitul de l'affaire POPOVYCH c. Ukraine Date de dcision de la communication
Case name / POPOVYCH v. Ukraine Date of Decision to Communicate /
Appno / No de requte 44704/11 06/02/2012
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Propre dfense
Rtroactivit/infraction/peine
Article : Art. 6 (3) (c) Defence in person
Article : Art. 7 (1) Retroactivity/criminal offence/ penalty
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
Appno / No de requte 65078/10 06/02/2012
Intitul de l'affaire GRYB c. Ukraine Date de dcision de la communication
Reason / Raison Communicated to the Government for observations
Case name / GRYB v. Ukraine Date of Decision to Communicate /
Communique au Gouvernement pour observations
page 20 of 20
Torture
Article : Art. 3 Torture
Engagement gnral/HPC
Statement of facts, complaints and questions put by the Court / Expos des faits, griefs et questions poses par la Cour
[The statements of facts and complaints have been prepared by the Registry (solely in one of the official languages) on the basis of the applicant's
submissions. The Court cannot be held responsible for the veracity of the information contained therein.]
[L'expos des faits et des griefs a t labor par le greffe (dans l'une des langues officielles seulement) sur la base des observations du requrant. La
responsabilit de la Cour ne saurait tre engage quant la vracit des informations qu'il contient.]