Professional Documents
Culture Documents
��������������������������������������
����������������������������������
���������������������������������
���������������������������������������
����
������������������������������������������������������
Rally to welcome members of the Lincoln Brigade returning to New York. This photograph is one of the many images in
“Facing Fascism: New York and the Spanish Civil War,” at the Museum of the City of New York. See page 3. (Photograph
from the Columbia University Rare Book & Manuscript Library, New York. )
Letter From the Editor
The 70th anniversary of the Lincoln Brigade provides a The Volunteer
backdrop for one of the most ambitious projects in ALBA’s Journal of the
history. Veterans of the
The national monument, soon to be unveiled in San Abraham Lincoln Brigade
Francisco, is a dream literally being made. The lawyers are an ALBA publication
fine tuning the contracts, craftspeople are designing the 799 Broadway, Rm. 227
words and images for the onyx, the steel is in transit. Your New York, NY 10003
generous response to our November appeal is heartening. (212) 674-5398
We have raised about $200,000, but we are still only two- Editorial Board
thirds of the way to the necessary target. If you’ve already Peter N. Carroll • Gina Herrmann
given, as Moe Fishman says, give again. We’re serious! Fraser Ottanelli • Abe Smorodin
Meanwhile, in New York, the opening of the exhibition Book Review Editor
“Facing Fascism” demonstrates the importance of building Shirley Mangini
something else: bridges to kindred groups, beginning with
Art Director-Graphic Designer
the Puffin Foundation and extending to the Instituto Richard Bermack
Cervantes, which are sponsoring this incredible project.
Editorial Assistance
New York University’s Tamiment Library, home to the
Nancy Van Zwalenburg
ALBA collection, opened its shelves to the curators of the
Museum of the City of New York; the King Juan Carlos I Submission of Manuscripts
Please send manuscripts by E-mail or on disk.
Center, led by James Fernandez, provides the setting for
E-mail: volunteer@rb68.com
numerous collateral programs that will go on all spring.
New York University Press is publishing the companion
volume of essays/catalogue for the show, edited by Peter N. political cartoons, photographs, works of literature and art.
Carroll and James Fernandez. You will also see the exciting exchanges between those
Just as important as this institutional collaboration is who went to Spain and those who stayed at home. There is
the fresh conceptual framework that distinguishes this ex- a freshness about this project: a dialogue between past and
hibition. During the 1930s, the public perceived the Spanish present that is the hallmark of ALBA’s mission.
Civil War through two competing dichotomies: democracy —Peter N. Carroll
vs fascism or radicalism vs order.
It would be difficult to identify another historical epi-
sode that has been more distorted by the lens of subsequent
events. The long decades of the Cold War produced a
Letters to the Editor
Dear Editor,
wholesale rewriting of history, in which domestic fascists Enclosed you will find a modest contribution for the
disappeared and those who defended the Spanish Republic proposed VALB monument in memory of my father, who,
were dismissed as un-American. Even after the Cold War as a member of El Club Obrero, contributed what he could
has ended, this view prevails in the mainstream media. to the cause of the Republic and brought me as an infant to
The new exhibition—and the published catalogue—at- events sponsored by that organization of which I have a
tempt to restore the original terms of debate. Here we find very distant and hazy memory.
the United States of the 1930s, much like the country today, He was a working man but learned his history and got
bitterly divided about the international situation. German- his political acumen as a result of that organization’s semi-
American bundists, pro-Mussolini Italian-Americans, nars and lectures.
leaders of the Roman Catholic hierarchy fought strenuously He was nicknamed “El Comandante” by his aunts and
for their versions of a better world, while other constituen- village crones as an infant because of his serious demeanor
cies adopted an agenda based on anti-racism, social justice, and studious gaze as he stared at the older ladies while in
an interventionist foreign policy. his mother’s arms. The nickname stuck and that is what he
You will see all this on the walls of the Museum of the was called by my uncles and their friends, all immigrants
City of New York: the struggles as they were fought in the from the fishing village of Sada, near La Coruna.
hearts and minds of ordinary New Yorkers, in newspapers, Continued on page 1
of those placed on the children’s refu-
gee ships which slipped out of Bilbao
Bay Area Reunion Honors Activist Legacy while that city was undergoing its
blitz. Her ship was the one diverted to
W
ith expectations of ment in downtown Madison, Leningrad. After the war, in 1948, the
unveiling the new monu- Wisconsin; and a granite stone at Soviets managed to repatriate her to
ment to the Abraham the Centro Asturiana in Tampa, Mexico, which her ever resourceful fa-
Lincoln Brigade later this year, Florida—the new monument is dra- ther had managed to reach, again,
friends, family, and vets will cel- matic in scale and presentation and thanks to help arranged by my father
ebrate the 70th anniversary of will be located at a major intersec- to get him on one of the last ships to
the Spanish Civil War on March tion of pedestrian traffic near San make it out of LeHavre. The Nazis
3 at a Saturday afternoon gath- Francisco’s historic Ferry Building. were already overrunning France.
ering in Oakland, California. According to Linda Lustig, trea- I share these tidbits for whatever
Russ Ellis, emeritus vice chan- surer of the Bay Area Friends and they may be worth. I know you proba-
cellor of the University of Veterans of the Abraham Lincoln bly have access to many more
California/Berkeley, will give the Brigade, which initiated the project, dramatic and important stories, but
keynote talk, “A Monument to the the current campaign to fund the often not about the “little people”
Activism of the Lincoln Brigade.” monument has reached $200,000, caught in the maelstrom of power pol-
Five years ago, Ellis was instrumen- about two-thirds of the anticipated itics and international intrigues, who
tal in launching the campaign for cost. “It’s important for our donors are often mute and inarticulate about
the monument and shaping its mes- to realize that we still have a way to their travails.
sage of the vets’ lifelong activism. go to complete the fund drive for Guillermo’s story is actually lon-
Constructed of open steelwork and this terrific monument,” she says. ger and more dramatic than what I’ve
onyx, the planned monument will The monument will not be the been able to just hint at. I learned
be 39 feet long and 8 feet high. The only cause for cheer at the gathering. about his adventures crossing the
translucent design allows visitors to There will also be a musical perfor- mountains in Spain to avoid main
see photographic images of the mance by Barbara Dane, Bruce roads, and subsequently what he and
Lincoln volunteers in Spain, as well Barthol, and Barrett Nelson, bringing his mates did in France prior to its fall,
as inscribed texts of poetry and up memories of the good fight and when I visited Mexico many years ago
prose that depict their experiences the feeling that younger generations when he was still alive. He always at-
as activists. will continue the struggle. tributed his luck and means to get
Although several smaller away to my father.
plaques commemorate the Lincoln Tax-deductible contributions for the Incidently, tired of WW II conven-
Brigade at various sites—the monument should be made out to tional wisdom stuff and its ignoring of
University of Washington campus ALBA and mailed to ALBA, 799 the implications of Spain’s Civil War
in Seattle; a wall plaque at City Broadway—Room 227, New York, NY or even mentioning it, I have been
College in New York; a stone monu- 10003. badgering PBS and William Baker to
produce or finance the production of
documentaries about the Spanish
Requetes. He was a block captain and Civil War, the American volunteers,
Letters
Continued from page 2
would have been murdered by the
Fascists. The funds arrived on
and the real position of the U.S. and
the Western Powers and their surrep-
I know he managed to get funds Christmas day in 1938 and shortly, he titious support of the Fascists. At least
to my uncle Guillermo Lecuona and two others broke out of the camp run the movie “To Die In Madrid” oc-
(mother’s side), who had been dis- in the dead of winter and made it to casionally. I never even get an
armed and placed in one of those Paris. He always remained amazed acknowledgment of my letters.
French concentration camps after he that French authorities actually deliv- Best of luck on the monument proj-
walked the distance to the border ered the wired funds. ect and my humble thanks for your
from Bilbao after its fall to the My cousin, his daughter, was one
Continued on page 2
THE VOLUNTEER March 2007 1
Dispatch from Madrid
The Re turn of E TA
By Miguel Ángel Nieto
There are more than 3,000 ETA the opposite. Both discourses are part
W
hen the president of the militants in Spanish prisons, and ETA of the game, and neither of them is rel-
Spanish government, José believed—Zapatero led ETA to be- evant to the kind of negotiation that
Luis Rodríguez Zapatero, lieve—that the negotiations would took the British government more
announced in mid-2006 that he had begin with full pardons for all those than 10 years, and which has scarcely
initiated contact with the Basque ter- convicts. This was the President’s first begun in Spain.
rorist organization, ETA, seeking error. Zapatero has heard the wake-up
a negotiated settlement, his British Second error: ETA considers inde- call. He is aware that to make any new
counterpart, Tony Blair, warned him pendence for the Basque country attempt at dialogue with ETA he must
that peace doesn’t win votes, point- non-negotiable (though a majority of achieve political consensus and have
ing to his own experience in Ulster. Basques do not want it), and in their the support of the opposition. The pity
But Zapatero is a bit dense at negotiations with the government, ap- is that the shift from peace process as
times, delighted with himself and parently it was not made clear that the the President’s personal goal to a state
thrilled with his own confabulations. constitutional principle of Spain as a campaign cost two lives in a country
So he spent the final months of last national unity is, as things now stand, that had gone three years without a
year patting himself on the back for non-negotiable. single victim of ETA terror.
the success of his negotiations with And the third error: Zapatero’s de- Translated by Tony Geist
the band of murderers and scorning termination to finish off ETA as a
those in the opposition who cautioned personal mission, not a State mission. Miguel Ángel Nieto is a prominent
him about playing with fire. In this context, the ETA bombing journalist in Madrid and director of the
Zapatero is also a bit perverse. He that took place on December 30, 2006, documentary film, Souls Without Borders.
insinuates that he can offer more than in Madrid’s Barajas airport must be
he can legally deliver. In this way he understood as a corrective to
led ETA to believe that the political
concessions he was willing to make to
Zapatero’s enthusiasm, but also as a
warning that the killers are in a hurry
Letters
Continued from page 1
the terrorist group were as great as the to leave 40 years of terrorism behind
murderers’ commitment to stop kill- them, and as a consequence, want im- work to keep the memory of these
ing. And the murderers, whose mediate results. brave and dedicated Americans alive.
numbers are dwindling as the police They are in a hurry because elec- Yours, sincerely,
close in on them, believed him. tions are just around the corner (in Edward Garcia
Zapatero is a bit ingenuous, and May) and their political arm, Herri
this is dangerous, for he believes that Batasuna, has been declared illegal Dear Editor,
the country’s legal framework is as and cannot run candidates. If its can- I was delighted to read the 2-page
flexible as his dreams of it. didates can’t run for office, ETA’s article in The Volunteer concerning vet
Fortunately, the Spanish legal frame- friends will be excluded from local artist Irving Norman of San Francisco.
work concerning terrorism is inflexible government, and consequently ETA One of his very large paintings was
and does not depend on presidential will have no legal source of funding. bought by the Museum of Modern Art
whims, as it did under Franco, but on And without funding they have no in San Francisco and now hangs in the
the Parliament. tools to maintain their dwindling sup- main gallery. It is an art work that I
In other words: when it came time port from the Basque people. hope many of the Bay Area residents
to set the terms for the concessions Zapatero’s socialist government and visitors will have a chance to view.
ETA could receive in exchange for lay- now says that, after the airport bomb- Sincerely,
ing down its arms, Zapatero in fact ing, the peace process has been Dave Smith
had nothing to offer. “liquidated.” And ETA maintains just Oakland, CA
O
n Friday April 27, in conjunc- Library, from 4:00 to 9:00 P.M. This Michael Nash (Tamiment Library),
tion with ALBA’s annual program is being organized to raise and Andrew Lee (NYU). Each will
spring meeting, New York public awareness about the extraordi- discuss the recent literature about the
University and the Spanish Civil War and the
Abraham Lincoln Brigade International Brigades
Archives will celebrate within the context of the
the official opening of the Lincoln Brigade archive.
archive of the Abraham Our symposium is de-
Lincoln Brigade at the signed to raise the profile
Tamiment Library. After of the Lincoln Brigade col-
a three-year preserva- lection, encourage use, and
tion and cataloging provide a framework for
project supported by the discussion about needs
National Endowment and opportunities for re-
for the Humanities, the search. A number of our
ALBA collection is now speakers will explore the
fully accessible and relationship between the
available for research. increasingly tense political
To bring public atten- situation in Spain and the
tion to this extremely rich contested memory of the
collection, NYU is organiz- Spanish Civil War. During
ing a major exhibit of the symposium we will
Spanish Civil War poster view a new documentary
art in the Elmer Homes film on the Lincoln
Bobst Library’s first floor Brigade, Souls Without
gallery. The title of the Borders (2006), made by
show is “Art and Politics: Spanish journalist Miguel
Posters from the Spanish Angel Nieto and ALBA’s
Civil War, 1936-1939.” The Tony Geist. The sympo-
exhibition will illustrate sium will be at the Elmer
how public art became a Bobst Library on the New
crucial element of the York University campus, 70
Republican government’s Washington Square South
efforts to rally support for (West 4th Street between
its cause, impart political lessons, and nary value of the Lincoln Brigade Mercer and LaGuardia).
convey a vision of a better world and a archive— the most significant collec- For more information about these
more egalitarian society. This exhibi- tion of historical materials in the events, please email Michael.Nash@
tion, drawn from the Lincoln Brigade world documenting American partici- nyu.edu or call (212) 998-2428.
collection at the Tamiment Library, pation in the Spanish Civil War.
will be on view from April 25 through Speakers will include Noel Valis (Yale Michael Nash is the director of the
August 15, 2007. University), Gabriel Jackson, Judy Tamiment Library and an ALBA board
The second part of our celebration Montell (ALBA), Fraser Ottanelli member.
will be a half-day symposium at the (University of South Florida), Jo
letters, diaries, and hundreds of photo- and a handwritten list of union mem- being challenged to evaluate their re-
graphs, each of which speaks volumes bers and their donation amounts, lationship to the rest the world,
about the personal and political com- ranging from 25 cents to a dollar, writ- particularly in terms of responsibility,
mitments and choices made by ten on letterhead bearing the influence, and action. Second, as the
individual New Yorkers in confronting following name and address: Spanish Civil War progressed, the
the issues of the Spanish Civil War. Dressmakers Union, 2189-232 West stances of the American government
TM: Among the items in the exhi- 40th Street, NY, NY. and the majority of the American peo-
bition I find most compelling are the • A collection can marked “Save a ple seemed to grow increasingly
following: Spanish Republican Child” that was divergent. Some museum-goers may
• A photograph of wounded introduced as evidence in the draw parallels to our own time and
James Lardner, son of Ring Lardner, Rosenbergs’ trial. The can is the same the war in Iraq in this regard.
and his letter to his mother, written in as countless others, long forgotten and What are the main ideas
Barcelona and dated May 3, 1938, ex- discarded, but of course is redolent you hope each visitor takes away
plaining his reasons for joining the with associations, given its use in the from “Facing Fascism”?
Abraham Lincoln Brigade. I find the trial, and suggests volumes about how SH: Exhibitions are designed to
mix of reasons, from the lofty to the the war and American support of the have many layers so that they can be
mundane, expressed in the alternately Spanish Republic was viewed by accessible to a wide variety of visitors,
sincere, ironic, playful, and profound some. We have requested this object; approaching the subject matter from
tone that seems to be a hallmark of we do not yet know if we will be able different levels of interest, knowledge,
young adulthood, very moving, par- to borrow it. and points of view. We would like
ticularly in light of fact that he How is this exhibition relevant for even the novice visitor to leave the ex-
ultimately sacrificed his life for a today’s New Yorkers? Why should we hibition understanding three central
cause in which he believed. care today about how New Yorkers reacted points: 1) the significance of the strug-
• A letter from Secretary of State 70 years ago to a faraway foreign conflict? gle in Spain in the context of the
Cordell Hull to Episcopal Bishop SH: The story of New Yorkers’ en- world-wide events triggered by the
Francis J. McConnell in New York, in gagement in the Spanish Civil War Depression and the rise of fascism; 2)
which Hull contrasts his personal feel- resonates today as a reminder that be- the intense engagement of New
ings and official government policy. ing a global city doesn’t just mean Yorkers from across the political spec-
He states, “The heavy loss of life diversity in population—it puts New trum in the unfolding international
among non-combatants resulting from York in a special and complex relation- events of the 1930s; and 3) the extraor-
the bitter struggle now raging in Spain ship to the rest of the world. In fact, dinary accomplishments of ordinary
has caused me the deepest distress many New Yorkers of the 1930s saw people acting in extraordinary cir-
and you may be sure that I have given themselves as citizens of the world, as cumstances.
and shall continue to give all possible engaged and moved by events an TM: The main ideas Sarah men-
consideration to any suggested practi- ocean away as they were by the press- tioned have guided us throughout the
cable means of alleviating the present ing issues at home. Their level of preparation of the exhibition. I would
deplorable situation consistent with personal, passionate, political engage- just add that in terms of the last point,
the American Government’s funda- ment serves as a sounding board for I hope people will come away from
mental policy of non-interference in today’s New Yorkers as they consider the exhibition understanding that
internal affairs of other nations.” their relationship to the global events many of the people that they have just
• Two items reflecting New York- of our own time. learned about were very much like
based labor union support of aid to TM: The exhibition seems to me to their neighbors, doctors, nurses, the
Spain: a photograph of a group of be especially relevant to New Yorkers students now at City College and else-
women sewing beneath a sign stating today for two (among many) reasons. where—that the people in the
“Volunteer workers making garments First, it documents a moment, much exhibition are much like the New
for Spain; Trade Union Committee”; like our own, when Americans were Yorkers that they know.
How has the experience been of col- ion volume. Public programs and Calendar of Events
laborating with ALBA, the Instituto prior exhibitions at the Tamiment Continued from page 6
Cervantes, and NYU (Tamiment, Library and the King Juan Carlos I of
ALBA, KJC) throughout the process? Spain Center have provided an intel- the Prado Museum) and Romances
SH: One of the most exciting lectual foundation for planning our de la Guerra de España (Romances
things about this project is its collab- exhibition. And most important has of the War in Spain). A panel dis-
orative nature. We’ve had the great been the collaborative nature of the cussion will follow. Martin E.
good fortune to have partners in sev- development of the exhibition itself, Segal Theatre, CUNY Graduate
eral extraordinary institutions—the drawing on the tremendous expertise Center, 365 Fifth Avenue/34th
Instituto Cervantes, ALBA, and of our team members as well as an ex- Street. For information call (212)
NYU—and all of the expertise and re- ceptionally generous and 817-1860 or go to http://web.gc.
sources that they bring to bear. knowledgeable scholarly advisory cuny.edu/mestc/.
Through the ALBA collection at the panel. May 2 – August 12, 2007
Tamiment Library, we have access to TM: My experience of collaborat- Exhibition: “They Still Draw
an astonishing array of material—far ing with ALBA, the Instituto Pictures: Children’s Art in
more than we could ever hope to in- Cervantes, and NYU has been excel- Wartime.” A new version of
clude. Instituto Cervantes has lent, with everyone involved showing ALBA’s traveling exhibition. (See
provided intellectual and practical ac- enormous support for our efforts, as article page 7.) Cervantes Institute,
cess to the Spanish side of the story. well as providing insightful commen- 211 East 49th Street (near Third
NYU Press is publishing the compan- tary and very helpful suggestions. Ave.).
That was your lunch. What about Valencia. To Gandía, really. To be ex- the 20 of us, eight parents said yes,
dinner? act, to a town called Palma de Gandía. mine among them. My father didn’t
Oh, dinner! My mother sent us to We moved into a country house aban- belong to any political party, but he
the “white sheet cinema,” that is, to doned by fascist sympathizers. A big was close to the PSOE [Socialist
bed, with no dinner. This was our rou- house with lots of plants, in the mid- Party]. I remember the demonstrations
tine. So food became an obsession. I dle of an orange grove. There were in the 30s. When the Popular Front
remember my mother saying, “Don’t about 20 of us. won the election we shouted PSOE slo-
go outside, the tomato and cucumber Do you remember your teachers? gans. The PSOE of that day, naturally.
kids are out now.” Of course, two school marms: OK, back to my father and Moscow, he
Who were the “tomato and cucumber Conchita the Fair and Conchita the said yes, that I should go, that it was
kids”? Dark. I remember their enthusiasm for the paradise of the proletariat. And it
In those days tomatoes and cu- the cause of the Republic and for the was paradise until 1941, when the war
cumbers were totally beyond our future of a new Spain. I remember began. Then things became quite diffi-
means. In that context, if a kid could how they took us to the beach and to cult. And by the time we were adults,
eat a tomato or a cucumber with a lit- see some caves that had paintings in forget it. Anyway…
tle salt on it, this meant he was rich. them. And I remember how we used Was it difficult to adapt to Russia?
Did they do this to make you jealous? to throw oranges at each other. As for The Russians decided we should
No, but you know what people are food, need I say that we ate three continue our education in Spanish
like. They wanted everyone to see how squares a day? rather than in Russian, so our integra-
rich they were. So their mothers sent Did you draw pictures like these in tion into Russian society was quite
them to eat the famous cucumbers the exhibit? difficult. Even today I can’t say the
outside. Well, I always liked to draw and word for “onion”–luk. I have to point at
Then the war came. to make wall newspapers. Sure we it in the market. You can imagine the
Franco led the rebellion and the drew. We also wrote. I remember writ- Russian we learned in the streets. We
Republican government established ing poems. The idea was to keep us said things you weren’t supposed to
Colonies in Madrid. My mother took busy so we wouldn’t get up to mis- say. Curse words, of course. Naturally,
all five of us kids. That was too much chief. we heard Russians speaking Russian
so they gave each of us a physical to What do you feel when you see these all around us every day. And since we
see who needed the most help. The drawings? learned very little Russian in school,
doctors picked the weakest of us, and Sometimes I think I could have we repeated what we heard. I still re-
that was me. I was sent to the Colonia drawn them myself. Of course, that member the trouble I got in at school
Puerta de Hierro, in a wealthy neigh- was a long time ago. Who knows? I one day when I said that someone
borhood. I wore pajamas there for the don’t see sadness in them, though of “cunted” my towel from me! I didn’t
first time in my life and had three course they show sad things, bomb- know the word for “steal.”
meals a day. I’ll never forget my first ings and evacuation…but you know What hopes do you have for this
breakfast. Hot chocolate as thick as ce- what kids are like. Their vision is not exhibit?
ment, and wonderful toast with butter usually melancholy. They remind me That it will keep us alive. There
and marmalade. It was incredible. But of Picasso. I think Picasso was in- were 3,000 of us. Now there are 199.
even more incredible was then we had spired by kids in his painting. (Translated by Tony Geist)
lunch and then we had dinner. We When did your experience in the
lacked nothing. Steaks, ham, sausages. Colonias end?
The government of the Republic took In March of ’37. The possibility of
care of the kids. evacuation to Moscow came up and See Calendar for listing of
Then came the evacuation from they asked our parents. You know, exhibit events, page 6.
Madrid and we were taken to since we were minors they had to. Of
“T
he elections held last rapid seizure of power. But by under- murdered during the Civil War. Over
Sunday clearly show me mining the Republican government’s 60,000 people were murdered on the
that I do not have the power to keep order, this coup d’état other side. And 50,000 people were
love of my people today,” wrote King transformed into open violence, such killed in the uncivil peace that followed
Alfonso XIII in a farewell note to the as never seen before, by the groups the Civil War. At the end of the war, in
Spanish people, before leaving the that supported and those that opposed 1939, half a million people languished
Royal Palace on the night of Tuesday it. It was July 1936 and thus began the in prisons and concentration camps.
14th April 1931. So began the Second civil war. There were various conflicts in-
Spanish Republic, with street cel- The Spanish Civil War is notorious volved in the Spanish Civil War. It was
ebrations and a festive atmosphere for the dehumanization of the adver- a war of classes, between different
in which revolutionary hopes were sary, for the terrible violence it conceptions of the social order, be-
combined with hunger for reform. generated. Lawless, arbitrary shootings tween Catholicism and
The Republic had vast problems in and massacres eliminated enemies, anti-clericalism, about the idea of na-
consolidating itself and had to con- real or presumed, on both sides. The tion and about ideas and creeds that
front firm challenges from above and Francoist policy of extermination of the then dominated the international
below. It went through two years of left was fervently approved by a large scene. The Civil War crystallized
relative stability, followed by another number of conservative people. world-wide battles between landown-
two years of political uncertainty and Meanwhile, where the army coup ers and workers, Church and State,
a final few months of disturbance and failed, many of the left saw this as the obscurantism and modernization,
insurrection. The first firm challenges, hour of revolution and of final judg- which were also being fought out else-
which were the most visible as they ment against the rich, and class hatred where between communism and
usually ended up as confrontations and vengeance spread like wild fire. fascism, while the debilitated democ-
with the police, came from below, first The Church suffered a cruel and vio- racies looked on.
as social protests and later as insurrec- lent persecution: almost 7,000 members From the outset, the Church and
tions from anarchists and socialists. of the clergy were murdered. most Catholics placed all their resourc-
However, the coup de grâce, the chal- The military created, from the first es, and there were a good many of
lenge that finally overthrew the moment of the coup, a climate of terror Continued on page 12
them, at the disposal of the insurgent this agreement was conducted by a fact hit Spain through an open mili-
military. The military did not have to Non-Intervention Committee, set up in tary intervention was fascism.
ask the Church for its support, which London on September 9, under the In the closing years of Franco’s
it offered gladly, nor did the Church chairmanship of the Conservative Lord dictatorship, certain pro-Franco mili-
have to take its time in deciding. Both Plymouth, the parliamentary under- tary historians, such as Ramón and
parties were aware of the benefit of the secretary to the Foreign Office, and a Jesús Salas Larrazábal and Ricardo de
role played by the religious element, Non-Intervention Subcommittee made la Cierva, attempted to show that the
the military because they wanted or- up of representatives from the states Republicans and the military rebels
der, the Church because it was bordering Spain and the major arms had received the same amount of ma-
defending the faith. producers, including Germany, France, terial, that foreign participation was
The international situation was Great Britain, and the Soviet Union. not enough to tip the balance in favor
not conducive to peace and this affect- In practice, non-intervention was a of Franco, and that the idea that non-
ed the war, in its origin an internal complete “farce,” as it was termed by intervention had harmed the
conflict. International support on both people at the time, who saw that it put Republicans was made up by the
sides was vital in keeping the war go- the Republic at a disadvantage with Communists and the International
ing in the first few months. the military rebels. This policy put a Left who sympathised with the
When the war began, the demo- legal government and a group of mili- Republic.
cratic powers were attempting to tary rebels on the same footing. However, the foremost experts on
“appease” the fascists, especially the The war was not a Spanish domes- the financing of the war and its inter-
German Nazis. So the Spanish tic matter. It became internationalized, national dimension, from Viñas to
Republic had to wage war against an thereby increasing the brutality and Martín Aceña, and including Howson
army favored by the international situ- destruction. This was because Spanish and Moradiellos, have pointed out the
ation. Dictatorships under the rule of a territory became a testing ground for imbalance in favor of the Nationalist
single man and a single party had new weaponry that was being devel- cause not only in terms of war materi-
been substituted for democracy in oped during those rearmament years als but also in terms of logistic,
many countries; and, except in Russia, prior to a great war that was on the diplomatic and financial aid. The
all these parties were of the right. Six horizon. Republic had money from the sale of
of the continent’s democracies were in- Tens of thousands of foreigners gold reserves at its disposal, an amount
vaded by the Nazis the year after the fought in the Spanish Civil War. It very similar to that provided to Franco
Civil War ended. Spain, then, was no was, in fact, a European civil war, in foreign aid, but the problem lay in
exception in a continent ruled by the with the tacit sanction of the British the difficulties it had in legally pur-
authoritarian right. But this cannot ex- and French governments. A little over chasing arms from democratic
cuse a wide sector of Spanish society, 100,000 fought on Franco’s side: countries. As Howson has pointed out,
the political and union leaders, sol- 78,000 Italians, 19,000 Germans, gold and foreign currency were not
diers and churchmen, who did 10,000 Portuguese, plus over 1,000 enough because the embargo and re-
nothing to develop a civil culture of volunteers from other countries, not strictions imposed by the
respect for the law, for electoral re- counting the 70,000 Moroccans who Non-Intervention Agreement forced
sults, for freedom of expression and made up the Native Regulars. On the successive governments under Giral,
association and for civil rights. Republican side, the figures given by Caballero, and Negrín to fall into the
At the end of August 1936, the 27 Rémi Skoutelsky show nearly 35,000 clutches of arms dealers who demand-
European states, all except volunteers in the International ed exorbitant prices and commissions
Switzerland, whose constitution de- Brigades and 2,000 Soviets, of whom and blackmailed politicians and civil
creed its neutrality, had officially 600 were non-combatant advisors. servants. As a result, the Republic often
subscribed to the Non-Intervention in Contrary to the myth of the commu- had to buy overpriced and obsolete
Spain Agreement. The monitoring of nist and revolutionary threat, what in equipment, disarmed planes or bomb-
T
he first-ever seminar on New Medical Aid Committee. ting in discussing an event that
Zealand and the Spanish Other highlights included author generated so much art and literature, a
Civil War, organized by the James McNeish telling the story of number of cultural events were held in
Trade Union History Project, took New Zealand war correspondent association with the seminar. The New
place last November at Turnbull Geoffrey Cox; literary expert Zealand Film Archive ran a short festi-
House in Wellington. Coinciding Lawrence Jones outlining the reactions val of films relating to the Spanish
with the 70th anniversary of the ar- of New Zealand writers to Spain; an- Civil War; Diana Burns organized an
rival of the International Brigade in archist poet Farrell Cleary speaking evening of music, poetry, and drama
Madrid, the conference was well at- on New Zealand connections to the based around the same theme, includ-
tended, with 95 participants from Spanish anarchists; and Rosamund ing an extract from the Hemingway
a wide variety of backgrounds, in- play Fifth Column; and a new edition of
cluding trade unionists, historians, Geoffrey Cox’s 1937 book, Defence of
anarchists, and interested members Madrid, was launched by Otago
of the public, including several from University Press.
Australia. The presentations exam- A memorial ceremony was held at
ined New Zealand’s foreign policy the Wellington Cenotaph for the New
in the late 1930s; the work of aid or- Zealand International Brigade and all
ganizations; the reaction to the war those who died fighting fascism in
of the Labour Party, the Communist Spain. Green Party MP Keith Locke
Party, and the trade unions; the addressed the crowd, followed by a
pro-Franco activities of the Catholic wreath laying and the singing of The
Church; New Zealand literary re- Internationale.
sponses to the war; and the stories Canterbury University Press is
of individual New Zealanders who now planning to publish the seminar
served as combatants, medical staff, presentations in edited and revised
and war correspondents in Spain. Droescher, daughter of civil war veter- form.
Two Australian keynote speakers ans Werner Droescher and Greville For further information, contact
addressed the seminar. Judith Keene Texidor, telling the story of her re- <markderby@paradise.net.nz>.
of the University of Sydney spoke on markable family and their
the Spanish Civil War and historical involvements in Spain and New
memory; Amirah Inglis, author of a Zealand. Dark Metropolis
number of books on the Australian A particular feature of this semi-
An exhibit of the paintings of
connection with the civil war, covered nar was the high level of audience
Lincoln vet Irving Norman, “Dark
the topic of Australians in the Spanish participation. This was evident at a
Metropolis: Irving Norman’s Social
Civil War. The two leading New panel discussion on New Zealanders
Surrealism,” is on display at the
Zealand researchers on the Spanish who had served in Spain, with audi-
Pasadena Museum of California
conflict also spoke. Michael ence members adding their own
Art from January 21 to April 15.
O’Shaughnessy gave a paper on New knowledge to the information present-
According to the museum flyer,
Zealanders in the International ed by the panel. This session
“Norman’s monumental paintings
Brigade, based on research he is cur- complemented talks already given on
reflect a troubled turbulent
rently undertaking for his thesis. individuals such as New Zealand
world.” For more information, see
Susan Skudder, whose 1986 thesis re- International Brigaders Tom Spiller
www.pmcaonline.org or call (626)
mains the definitive work on New and surgeon Doug Jolly, as well as
568-3665.
Zealand and the Spanish Civil War, Anna Rogers’ paper on the New
O
n November 17 and 18, the Underground, Spanish republican unfortunate turn of events was that
historic Hôtel de Ville of prisoners in German concentration most of the surviving French
Paris was host to an interna- camps, IBers in the Cold War, and the International Brigade veterans were so
tional conference on the Spanish Civil issue of historic memory in Spain to- exhausted from the week-long anni-
War and the International Brigades. day. The presentations often led to versary commemorations in Spain a
The third conference of its type this lively question and answer periods. few weeks earlier that they were un-
year, following Bristol in July and Several Spanish Civil War activists able to attend the proceedings.
Salamanca in October, was initiated also participated, including Lise The papers are expected to be
by ACER, an association of veterans, London, former secretary to André published next year as a lasting record
family members and friends of the Marty; Cecile Rol-Tanguy, widow of of the memorable occasion.
French volunteers in the International Henri Rol-Tanguy, hero of the French ALBA board member Robert Coale
Brigades. Other national organiza- Resistance and former 14th IB political teaches Spanish literature at the
tions joined the project, providing commissar; and Ramón Santisteban, University of Paris.
a broad cross section of official par-
ticipation. The City of Paris, the Catalonia Honors 70th Anniversary
National Museum of the Resistance,
and the Museum of the Liberation By Angela Jackson war, the lectures concentrated on the
L
of Paris-Leclerc-Jean Moulin all par- ast November the associa- reasons for the conflict and the tragic
ticipated directly in the conference. tion ‘No Jubilem La Memòria’ events that took place in some parts of
This wide support is proof of the (NJLM) sponsored the fourth this region during the summer of
evolution of thought on the Spanish annual commemorative weekend
Civil War and the International focusing on the Spanish Civil War
Brigades over the last decade in in Catalonia. The program began in
France. In 1996, following the massive Marçà with a tribute to the Welsh
“homenaje” in Spain, the French gov- Brigader, Alun Menai Williams. A
ernment officially granted former moving BBC documentary was shown,
IBers the status of “veterans.” Then in presented by Anna Martí, telling the
2004, during the ceremonies to com- story of his return visit to this area in
memorate the 60th anniversary of the 2005 for the first time since the war.
Liberation of Paris, the city govern- The film was followed by the first
ment paid special tribute to the public viewing of extracts from inter- 1936. The subject of the anarchist as-
Spanish Republican volunteers who views recorded for the next NJLM sassinations in the town of Falset
fought in the Leclerc Division and documentary. Joan Maria Thomàs, during the first weeks of the war had
were the first to enter the occupied Professor of Contemporary History been shrouded in darkness until now.
capital. Now, two years later, Paris, from the University of Rovira I Virgili The talk given by Toni Orensanz on
whose lieutenant mayor is of Spanish (Tarragona), took the chair for a round his research into the killings carried
origin, played a key role in holding table discussion. It was a memorable out by the “Brigade of Death” was fol-
this international conference by mak- occasion; for the first time, local peo- lowed by a lively debate.
ing generous resources available to the ple, many of whom were women, NJLM collaborated with ADAR
organizers. spoke of their wartime experiences. (The Association of Aviators of the
The conference itself was varied To commemorate the start of the Republic) for the commemoration
and the papers presented covered held in El Molar the following day.
many aspects. In addition to the dif- Angela Jackson is the president of No After a tribute to the pilots who per-
ferent perspectives on the war, Jubilem La Memòria and author of British ished nearby and to the soldiers and
participants discussed such subjects Women and the Spanish Civil War.
Continued on page 20
www.alba-valb.org
Books about the LINCOLN BRIGADE Poems about the Spanish Civil War
The Spanish Civil War by Cary Nelson
By Francisco J. Romero Salvadó. Passing the Torch: The Abraham
Ghosts of Spain: Travels through a Country’s Hidden Lincoln Brigade and its Legacy of Hope
Past by Anthony Geist and Jose Moreno
by Giles Tremlett Another Hill
Dark Metropolis: Irving Norman’s Social Surrealism by Milton Wolff
edited by Ray Day and Scott A. Shields Our Fight—Writings by Veterans of the
The Good Fight Continues: World War II Letters from Abraham Lincoln Brigade: Spain 1936-1939
the Abraham Lincoln Brigade edited by Alvah Bessie & Albert Prago
edited by Peter N. Carroll, Michael Nash & Melvin Small Spain’s Cause Was Mine
The Spanish Civil War: A Very Short Introduction by Hank Rubin
by Helen Graham Comrades
Member of the Working Class by Harry Fisher
by Milton Wolff The Odyssey of the Abraham
Fighting Fascism in Europe. The World War II Letters of Lincoln Brigade
an American Veteran of the Spanish Civil War by Peter Carroll
by Lawrence Cane, edited by David E. Cane, Judy The Lincoln Brigade, a Picture History
Barrett Litoff, and David C. Smith by William Katz and Marc Crawford
The Front Lines of Social Change: Veterans of the
Abraham Lincoln Brigade EXHIBIT CATALOGS
by Richard Bermack They Still Draw Pictures: Children’s Art in Wartime
by Anthony Geist and Peter Carroll
The Wound and the Dream: Sixty Years of American
The Aura of the Cause, a photo album
edited by Cary Nelson
❑ Yes, I wish to become an ALBA
Associate, and I enclose a check for VIDEOS
Into the Fire: American Women in the Spanish Civil War
$30 made out to ALBA (includes a one Julia Newman
year subscription to The Volunteer).
Art in the Struggle for Freedom
Name ____________________________________ Abe Osheroff
Dreams and Nightmares
Address__________________________________ Abe Osheroff
The Good Fight
City________________ State ___Zip_________ Sills/Dore/Bruckner
❑ I’ve enclosed an additional donation of Forever Activists
_________. I wish ❑ do not wish ❑ to have this Judith Montell
donation acknowledged in The Volunteer. You Are History, You Are Legend
Judith Montell
Please mail to: ALBA, 799 Broadway, Room 227,
Professional Revolutionary: Life of Saul Wellman
New York, NY 10003
Judith Montell
Name _ ______________________________
Address ____________________________
March 23
New York
Exhibition Opens
Facing Fascism: NY & The Spanish Civil War
April 29
New York
70th Anniversary Reunion of the Lincoln Brigade
Scheduled Guest: Harry Belafonte