Professional Documents
Culture Documents
www.peacefultomorrows.org
Contributions by: Alexandra Cooper, Jesse Laird, Kelly Campbell, Madelyn Hoffman.
Special thanks to the United for Peace and Justice Afghanistan Working group for
input.
November 2008
Cover photo: Kabul home destroyed by US bomb, killing nine civilians. Photo by Kelly Campbell
Afghanistan Resources................................................16
Notes..............................................................................19
Introduction
Following the tragic events of September 11, Today, as calls grow louder for the US military to
2001, many in the US initially supported the war in send more troops to Afghanistan, it is up to the US
Afghanistan because they believed that it would reduce peace movement to address the realities and counter the
the threat of another attack on US soil, and that it would misconceptions surrounding the war and occupation.
enable the US to bring to justice Osama bin Laden and We must educate our own communities about the true
others responsible for the attacks. Once the Taliban consequences of US foreign policy in Afghanistan,
fell, the war was touted as a success. However, while connect with Afghan peacemakers and grassroots
public attention shifted to the war in Iraq, the conflict movements that are calling for alternatives to military
in Afghanistan entered a new phase of violence and action, and devise strategies for joining together to
decay. build a lasting peace.
Concerns about the increased violence and lack of This primer outlines ten reasons the US should end
stability in Afghanistan have led many – including the occupation in Afghanistan. We call instead for a
President-elect Obama – to call for an increased drastically revamped US policy focused on diplomacy,
presence of US and NATO forces in Afghanistan. negotiation, aid, reconstruction and international
However, the idea that more US troops are the answer cooperation. We hope that this information will help
to Afghanistan’s woes is misguided. Rather than a our colleagues in the US peace movement unite to call
military escalation, what is needed is a shift away from for a new strategy in Afghanistan.
militarism, toward diplomacy, aid and reconstruction.
1
US And NATO Occupation Creates Civilian
Casualties, Angering Afghans
Due to heightened insurgent attacks since 2005, approximately 3,200 Afghan civilians have
and foreign air strikes in Afghanistan, been killed by US/NATO attacks.6
civilian casualties increased 40 percent Attacks on civilians have caused controversy
in the first nine months of 2008 from for the US military. In July 2008, 47 members of
last year. Of the 1,445 recorded civilian deaths so far a wedding party – 38 of whom were women and
this year, 55 percent were caused by the Taliban and children – were killed by an air strike in Nangarhar
other insurgent groups and 40 percent are credited Province.7 Controversy surrounded another US/NATO
to US, NATO and Afghan forces.1 In August 2008, attack on the village of Azizabad on August 22, 2008.
the Agency Coordinating Body for Afghan Relief Originally, the military announced six civilian deaths.
(ACBAR), reported that an estimated 260 civilians It soon became clear that this was an outrageous
were killed in July alone, a higher number than any underestimate, and the Afghan government called for
other month in the last six years. The number of air a reinvestigation. The US Central Command reported
strikes by international military forces was up 40 in October that the death toll was in fact higher than
percent over last year since the beginning of 2008. By originally reported. It now appears that 35 civilians
September 2007, there were more than two times as were killed in the attack,
many air strikes in Afghanistan as in Iraq.2 twelve of whom were
Shootings, ambushes, kidnappings, suicide attacks children. Despite these
By September
and roadside bombings are now more common than findings, US military 2007, there were
ever. In 2006, there were 123 such attacks and, in officials maintained that
2007, that number rose more than 25 percent, to 160 the site in Azizabad was
more than two
attacks.3 Security in Afghanistan has gotten worse. In a “legitimate target” and times as many
2005, there were an estimated 1,000 violent deaths and that the attack was a
injuries. In 2006, that number surged to 4,000. The “valid military action.”8
air strikes in
United Nations has reported that 2007 was the worst on Afghan President Afghanistan as
record: casualties in Afghanistan soared above 8,000, Hamid Karzai and other
with at least 1,500 innocent men, women and children government officials have
in Iraq
killed in acts of violence.4 repeatedly expressed
Although no comprehensive figures exist, incidents anger over attacks on civilians. Responding to incidents
of NATO and US air strikes killing innocent civilians of civilian casualties, Karzai said, “Civilian deaths
in Afghanistan have been documented every year and arbitrary decisions to search people’s houses have
since the invasion. According to University of reached an unacceptable level.”9 Mere hours after
New Hampshire Economics Professor Marc W. Barack Obama was elected President, Karzai called on
Herold’s Dossier on Civilian Victims of United him to make it a top priority of the new administration
States’ Aerial Bombing, as many as 3,600 civilians to stop the killing of Afghan civilians.10 Students,
were killed as a result of US bombing from 2001 tribal elders and grassroots groups have organized
to June 2003.5 Herold’s latest research, released in demonstrations in different parts of the country in
October 2008, on the seventh anniversary of the response to civilian casualties, but US media rarely
first US bombing attacks on Afghanistan, shows that covers these acts of protest.11
3
Afghan Women Continue To Face Violence And
Oppression Under The Occupation
Women in Afghanistan Have Against Women, yet widespread inequality continues,
Not Been Granted Full Rights as especially regarding access to public health resources
Citizens and Continue to Face and protection from spousal abuse.27 The new Afghan
Violence and Oppression. Constitution recognizes men and women as equal
citizens under the law – yet women have no redress for
The crimes against women committed by the
domestic violence or rape.28
Taliban are among the worst on record, and the Bush
In August 2008, President Karzai pardoned three
Administration justified the invasion of Afghanistan in
men associated with a warlord who pled guilty to the
part as a feminist mission to relieve their suffering. In
public and brutal gang rape of a woman in the northern
November 2001, Laura Bush delivered the President’s
weekly radio address, decrying the “poverty, poor province of Samangan.29 There are also no protections
health, and illiteracy that the terrorists and the Taliban for people who speak out on behalf of women in
Afghan society. Recently, a twenty-three year old
have imposed on women in Afghanistan.”26 Yet, seven
Afghan journalism student, Sayed Perves Kambaksh
years later, conditions for women and children have
was sentenced to death by a local Islamic court for
not significantly improved.
distributing a critique of those who misrepresent the
Since the US invaded Afghanistan and ousted the
Taliban from power, the new government has initiated Koran to justify the oppression of women.30 In October
significant – even revolutionary – reforms for women. 2008, his sentence was commuted to 20 years.31
Many of these reforms, however, have yet to be realized. The inability of the Karzai administration to stand
In 2003, the Afghan government signed the Convention up to tribal leaders and thus implement one law
on the Elimination of All forms of Discrimination for all its citizens has resulted in the continuation
5
The Occupation Contributes To Violence And
Destabilization For Ordinary Afghans, Including
Refugees
The Afghan People’s Needs are percent of the population is just above the poverty line.
Vast and Critical at this Moment The country is suffering not only from the effects of
war, but also from the volatility of the world economy,
Afghanistan is rated the fourth poorest
which has caused food prices to rise significantly. 70
country in the world today. According to
percent of Afghans face food insecurity, 20 percent of
the UN Development Programme (UNDP), the country
rural households are chronically food insecure and 18
has a poverty rate of 42 percent, and an additional 20
6
NATO Allies Are Expressing Doubts About The
Occupation
US allies are coming under increasing ten months of 2008.72 Citing increasing costs,
fire. Since 2001, 379 non-US NATO deteriorating security conditions and public outrage,
troops have lost their lives in Afghanistan. NATO allies have threatened to reduce their role in
105 of these deaths occurred in the first Afghanistan in the near future.73
7
US Troop Casualties In Afghanistan Are On The Rise
Numbers of US and NATO The Military is Being Stretched Beyond its
Forces Killed in Afghanistan on Means
Are Increasing Many servicemen and women are forced to serve
More US soldiers die in Afghanistan multiple tours in Iraq and Afghanistan due to limited
each year the occupation continues. The enlistment. The RAND Corporation released a study in
military reports that more than 600 US troops have April 2008 asserting that 20 percent of military service
been killed in Operation Enduring Freedom, and more members returning from Iraq and Afghanistan have
than 1,200 have been seriously wounded, impacting symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) or
communities throughout the US. The number of US major depression. They also discovered that 19 percent
casualties in Afghanistan nearly equaled those in Iraq of returning service members had a possible traumatic
since May 2008 and exceeded numbers in Iraq in brain injury while deployed. The study predicts that
September and October.84 The number of US contractors PTSD and depression alone will cost the US $6.2 billion
killed in Afghanistan is unknown. Other NATO deaths in direct medical care costs as well as lost productivity
are on the rise as well, making the total troop casualties and suicide.86
over 1,000 since 2001.85 Even top officials admit that it is becoming
8
Afghans Are Calling For A Negotiated End To
The War
In recent months, several governments The Christian Science Monitor reports that the
have begun coordinating talks with majority of Afghans favor some sort of negotiated
factions of the Taliban. Just before the settlement, however, many peace activists are critical
US presidential election, Pakistani of the Saudi talks because they only included members
and Afghan leaders held a two-day jirga, or council of the Afghan government and former Taliban officials.
of tribal leaders. At the end of the meeting, they “We want reconciliation with the Taliban through a loya
issued a decision to hold talks with resistance groups, jirga,” or grand assembly of Afghans, says Fatana Gilani,
including the Taliban.89 The Saudi head of the prominent NGO
government also hosted a meeting “We don’t want Afghanistan Women’s Council (AWC).
between Afghan government officials “We don’t want interference from
and the Taliban.90 interference foreign countries or negotiations
These kind of talks can be seen as from foreign behind closed doors.” Gilani explains
encouraging developments, since that Afghans are against Western
negotiations are a necessary countries or policy. “They should bury their guns
component to ending war. Many negotiations in a grave and focus on diplomacy
Afghan NGOs are calling for and economic development.”92
negotiations. “People are growing behind closed Some Afghan women leaders,
tired of the fighting,” says Bakhtar doors” however, have cautioned about the
Aminzai of the National Peace Jirga danger of compromising with the
of Afghanistan, an association of Taliban on women’s rights. According
students, professors, lawyers, clerics, and others. “We to the BBC, the Afghan Minister for Women’s
need to pressure the Afghan government and the Affairs, Hasan Bano Ghazanfar, said that women
international community to find a solution without were against “any political compromises” that did
9
using guns.”91 not guarantee their constitutional and human rights.93
Afghanistan Resources
United for Peace and Justice, a national US coalition, has formed an Afghanistan working group and added
an Afghanistan resource section to its website. Go to www.unitedforpeace.org for a continually updated
resource list, or to get involved.
Books
Non-Fiction
Afzal-Khan, Fawzia. Shattering the Stereotypes: Muslim Women Speak Out. Fowlerville, MI: Olive Branch Press, 2004.
[no page from the publisher available] http://www.powells.com/biblio/72-9781566565691-0
Benard, Cheryl. Veiled Courage: Inside Afghan Women’s Resistance. New York: Random House, 2002.
http://www.randomhouse.com/catalog/display.pperl/9780767913065.html
Novels
Hosseini, Khaled. The Kite Runner. New York: Riverhead, 2003. [This book is particularly good at depicting life in
Afghanistan BEFORE the Soviets, the civil war and the Taliban, a period of time most Western media completely ignores.]
http://us.penguingroup.com/nf/Book/BookDisplay/0,,9781573222457,00.html
Hosseini, Khaled. A Thousand Splendid Suns. New York: Riverhead, 2007.
http://us.penguingroup.com/nf/Book/BookDisplay/0,,9781594489501,00.html?A_Thousand_Splendid_Suns_Khaled_
Hosseini
Khadra, Yasmina. The Swallows of Kabul. New York: Anchor Books, 2005.
[Puts a human face on the suffering inflicted by the Taliban]
http://www.randomhouse.com/catalog/display.pperl?isbn=9781400033768
Pazira, Nelofer. A Bed of Red Flowers: In Search of My Afghanistan. New York: Free Press, 2005.
http://www.simonsays.com/content/book.cfm?tab=1&pid=511796
Seierstad, Asne. The Booksellers of Kabul. New York: Back Bay Books, 2003.
http://www.hachettebookgroup.com/books_9780316734509.htm
Films
Afghanistan: From Ground Zero to Ground Zero, directed by Jon Alpert and Masuda Sultan (2003).
Information at http://www.brooklynfilmfestival.org/films/detail.asp?fid=278
Beyond Belief, directed by Beth Murphy (Alive Mind Media, 2006).
http://www.alivemindmedia.com/films/beyond-belief/
Civilian Casualties: Fragments From the War on Terror, directed by Frances Anderson (Pomegranate Films, 2003).
For information, email office@peacefultomorrows.org
Osama, directed by Siddiq Barmak (MGM Entertainment, 2003). http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0368913/
View from a Grain of Sand, directed by Meena Nanji (Ecesis Films Inc., 2004). http://www.viewgrainofsand.com
Organizations
Based in Afghanistan
Afghan Women’s Network, http://www.afghanwomensnetwork.org/
Afghanistan Independent Human Rights Commission, http://www.aihrc.org.af/mon_inv.htm
Afghanistan Justice Project, http://www.afghanistanjusticeproject.org/
Agency Coordinating Body for Afghan Relief, http://www.acbar.org/
Revolutionary Association of the Women of Afghanistan (RAWA), http://www.rawa.org/index.php
Based in US with work in Afghanistan
Afghan Women’s Mission, http://www.afghanwomensmission.org/
Afghans 4 Tomorrow, http://www.afghans4tomorrow.com/
Afghans for Afghans, http://www.afghansforafghans.org/blanket.html
American Friends Service Committee, http://www.afsc.org/middleeast/ht/display/ContentDetails/i/17601/pid/673
Beyond the 11th, http://www.beyondthe11th.org/
Defense Committee for Malalai Joya, http://www.malalaijoya.com/index1024.htm
Human Rights Watch Afghanistan, http://www.hrw.org/en/asia/afghanistan
Women for Afghan Women, http://www.womenforafghanwomen.org/
Women for Women, Afghanistan Work, http://www.womenforwomen.org/afghanistan.htm
Peace Movements in Other NATO countries that are working on Afghanistan
Canadian Peace Alliance, Afghanistan Campaign, http://www.acp-cpa.ca/en/AfghanistanResources.htm
European Social Forum, http://www.esf2008.org/
Stop the War UK, Afghanistan Briefing Paper, http://www.stopwar.org.uk/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=244&I
temid=194