Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ORIGINAL PAPER
M. Pilar Cano
Begon a de Ancos
M. Gloria Lobo
Mariana Santos
Improvement of f rozen banana (Musa cavendi shi i , cv. Enana)
col our by bl anchi ng: rel at i onshi p bet ween browni ng, phenol s
and pol yphenol oxi dase and peroxi dase act i vi t i es
Received: 22 February 1996
Abstract Browning in banana (Musa cavendishii, cv.
Enana) processed products is a result of phenol oxida-
tion catalysed by polyphenol oxidase (PPO) and per-
oxidase (POD) or of other non-enzymatic reactions
(Maillard and Strecker mechanisms). Microwave and
steam blanching signicantly reduced PPO and POD
activities and phenol levels in banana esh, steam
blanching being the most eective method for enzyme
inactivation. Freezing/thawing processes produced
a signicant increase in phenol levels in all samples,
due to cellular breakdown. After microwave heating
browning processes occurred while steam-treated
samples did not exhibit a signicant colour change.
Extractable PPO and POD activities in all banana
samples increased as a consequence of freezing/thaw-
ing: steam-blanched slices exhibited lower residual ac-
tivities. High correlations occurred between phenols
and browning (r"0.86) in control samples. Blanched
samples (microwave or steam) only exhibited correla-
tions between PPO (r"0.80) and POD (r"0.80) ac-
tivities and browning.
Key words Browning reactions Banana processed
products Blanching Polyphenol oxidase Peroxidase
Int roduct i on
Enzymatic browning in fruit and vegetables can cause
undesirable quality changes during handling, process-
ing and storage. This reaction results mostly from poly-
phenol oxidase (PPO, EC 1.10.3.1) and peroxidase
(POD, EC 1.11.1.7) [14]. Both enzymes catalyse more
than one reaction and act on a number of substrates;
M.P. Cano ( ) B. de Ancos M.G. Lobo M. Santos
Plant Food Science and Technology Department, Instituto
del Frio (C.S.I.C.), Ciudad Universitaria, E-28040 Madrid, Spain
browning or darkening is the principal and more mani-
fest consequence, but discoloration, o-avours and
nutritional damage also occur [3, 5, 6]. However, the
browning potential of some plant products has been
reported to be also directly related to the phenol levels
[7], or a combination of both enzymatic activities
(PPO and POD) and phenols [8].
Bananas undergo rapid browning as a result of tissue
disruption and exposure to oxygen during the peeling
and slicing operations that take place prior to further
processing. The successful prevention of banana
browning by addition of sodium bisulphite has been
widely discussed [911], but blanching to inactivate
enzymes in whole peeled fruits has also been reported
[12, 13]. A process for banana puree preservation was
described by Garcia et al. [14], which required a mild
heat treatment plus addition of sodium bisulphite, cit-
ric acid and potassium sorbate. Other authors have
described the eect of some heat and chemical treat-
ments on the quality of banana puree stored at 30C
[15] or on intermediate-moisture banana products
[16].
To optimize the freezing process of banana slices, it is
necessary to study the eects of some mild heat treat-
ments and freezing on the enzymatic activities in the
fruit at dierent maturity levels. Cano et al. [12] de-
scribed the eects of some heat treatments on PPO and
POD enzymes, including a single experiment that in-
volved blanching the fruit in a microwave. Most re-
cently, Cano [ 17] reported the importance of selecting
the banana fruit to be frozen at the optimal level of
ripeness, using microwave treatment to obtain an
optimal quality in the nal product. Bananas with
a greenyellow peel colour were used to improve pro-
cessed fruit colour in terms of enzymatic browning in
frozen banana slices.
In this work an investigation was carried out into the
eects of microwave and steam blanching, at previously
selected conditions, on browning, phenol concentra-
tion, and PPO and POD activities in banana slices
(Musa cavendishii, var. Enana) during frozen storage.
The individual roles of these factors involved in the
biochemical processes of darkening have been tenta-
tively dened.
Mat eri al s and met hods
Plant material. Air-freight shipments of green bananas (M. caven-
dishii L. var. Enana), produced in the Canary Islands (Spain), were
obtained from a commercial source in Madrid. Undamaged fruits
free from infection were selected and stored at 14C and 8590%
relative humidity [18]. At the right stage of maturity for processing,
after 15 days of storage under the previously mentioned conditions,
fruits exhibiting a greenyellow peel colour [12] were removed from
storage and processed as follows.
Microwave treatment. Samples of peeled banana fruits were sliced
into 1.0-cm-thick pieces, selecting only the slices with homogeneous
diameters (3.03.2cm). Microwave treatment was carried out at
650 W for 30 s [ 17]. After blanching, the slices were packaged in
plastic bags and cooled at 8C with owing cold water (fruit slices
did not make contact with the cold water). Chilled microwave-
treated slices were vacuum-packed in plastic bags (PolyskinX12,
Cryovac) and frozen in an air-blast freezer at !40C for 30 min.
Steam blanching treatment. Samples of the peeled whole banana
fruits were steam blanched for 5 min in a conventional oven
(Rational, Combi-Master CM). Treated fruits were chilled and
frozen as stated in the previous section.
Control samples. Untreated banana slices were packed and frozen
under the same conditions as the treated samples. All frozen samples
were stored at !24C for a 12-month period.
Determination of browning. Browning of banana slices were deter-
mined by the procedure reported by Chan and Cavaletto [19]. Fruit
slices from each treatment and each storage period were freeze-dried
and then made into a homogeneous lyophilized powder for deter-
mination of darkening. Banana powder (2.5 g) was homogenized
with 15 ml of methanol for 3 min using external cooling. The mixture
was centrifuged at 6500 g at 5C for 10 min. The supernatant was
decanted into a 25-ml volumetric ask and made up to the correct
volume with additional methanol. The degree of browning was
determined by measuring the absorbance at 400 nm using a spectro-
photometer (Perkin-Elmer mod. Lambda 15). All analyses were
carried out in triplicate.
Determination of phenol concentration. One gram of lyophilized
powder of banana ( obtained as previously described) from each
treatment and storage period was extracted with 50 ml of deionized
water in an Omni-mixer, externally cooled and set at 4500 rpm for
3 min [17]. The homogenate was centrifuged at 12,000 g for 10 min
at 4C. The supernatant was vacuum ltered through a Whatman
no. 4 lter. The solid residue obtained by centrifugation was hom-
ogenized again with 25 ml of deionized water and centrifuged as
above. The second supernatant was also ltered and the two ltrates
were combined in a 100-ml volumetric ask. The combined ltrates
were made up to 100 ml with deionized water. Of this aqueous
extract, 1 ml was added to 7.5 ml deionized water, and 0.5 ml Folin
and Ciocalteau Phenol Reagent (Sigma) was added. The sample was
then mixed and, after 5 min, 1 ml of saturated sodium carbonate
(Merck) solution was added and then the mixture was shaken. The
optical density of the solution at 670 nm was measured after 1 h. The
amount of total phenols was calculated from a standard curve of
dopamine prepared at the same time.
Preparation of enzyme extract. A crude enzyme extract was pre-
pared by taking 10 g of raw or thawed (at 4C for 2 h) banana
samples and homogenizing then in an Omni-mixer at 16,000 g with
50 ml of phosphate buer (pH 7.0) containing 10 g l of insoluble
polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVPP). Homogenization was carried out
with external cooling for 3 min at 30-s intervals. The homogenate
was centrifuged at 16,000 g at 4C for 15 min. The supernatant was
ltered through a nylon cloth and the volume obtained was meas-
ured carefully.
Polyphenoloxidase (PPO) assay. The enzyme activity was deter-
mined by measuring the rate of increase in absorbance at 420 nm
(A
"`"
) and 25C using a Lambda 15 double beam spectro-
photometer (Perkin-Elmer). The reaction mixture contained 2.9 ml
of 0.07 M of catechol solution in 0.05 M phosphate buer (pH 7.0)
and 100 l of diluted [1: 1, v: v, 0.2 M phosphate buer (pH 7.0)] or
undiluted enzyme extract. The activity was calculated on the basis of
the slope of the linear portion of the curve of A
"`"
plotted against
time (up to 3 min). Enzyme activity was expressed as A
"`"
min mg protein. Residual PPO activity was expressed as a ra-
tio of values measured for the treated or/and frozen sample versus its
control.
Peroxidase (POD) assay. The enzyme activity was determined by
measuring the rate of increase in absorbance at 485 nm (A
"``
) and
25C of a mixture containing 2.7 ml of 0.05 M phosphate buer
(pH 7.0), 200 l of 10 g l p-phenylenediamine in distilled water (H>
donor), 100 l of 15 ml l of hydrogen peroxide (oxidant) and 25 l
of diluted or non-diluted enzyme extract (total reaction volume
"3.0 ml). The enzyme activity was calculated on the basis of the
slope of the linear portion of a plot of A
"``
against time (up to
3 min). Enzyme activity was expressed as A
"``
min mg pro-
tein. Residual POD activity was expressed as a ratio of measure-
ments from treated and/or frozen sample versus an untreated
sample.
Protein content. Protein concentration in all extracts was deter-
mined using a Bio-Rad kit for the Bradford reaction [20].
Objective colour measurement. Triplicate samples (one slice each)
were placed in a 5-cm-diameter covered plastic dish. The sample
dish was placed on the light port of a Hunter Lab Model M25-9
colorimeter. Standard colour plate no. c2-19952 , with reectance
values of "77.65, a"!1.51 and b"21.41, was used as
reference. The sample dish was covered to avoid stray light. The ,
a and b values were recorded, and the derived functions for hue
(h), saturation (C), and total colour dierence (E) were calculated:
h"arctan (b/a); C"(a`#b`)`; E"[(
!
`
)`#(a
!a
`
)`
#(b
!b
`
)`]`, where
, a
and b
!
`
)`#(a
!a
`
)`#(b
!b
`
)`]` (Hunter
Lab values).
, a
and b
!
`
)`#
(a
!a
`
)`#(b
!b
`
)`]` (Hunter Lab values)
Non-enzymatic browning index analysed as described in Materials and methods
* Signicant correlation at P40.05
investigated, the substrate level was the major factor
contributing to darkening. However, when the slices
were steam blanched, the browning index was negative-
ly correlated with this parameter. No correlation was
found to occur between browning and phenol levels
in microwave-treated slices. Enzymatic activities, i.e.
those of PPO and POD, only exhibited a signicant
correlation ( P40.05) with browning (r"0.79 and
r"0.80, respectively) in steam-blanched samples,
showing that the PPO and POD deactivation obtained
by steam treatment signicantly inhibited the brown-
ing process.
Relationships between total colour dierence,
phenolic levels and PPO and POD activities
In control samples the most signicant ( P40.05) cor-
relation (r"0.81) was found to occur between total
colour dierence and POD activity. The correlation
between POD activity and the phenol level or PPO
activity decreased such that r"0.74 and r"0.70,
respectively. There was no correlation between any of
the parameters studied for the microwave-treated sam-
ples, indicating that, in addition to the enzymatic
browning, other non-enzymatic reactions could take
place in the product as a consequence of the blanching
and freezing process. Steam-blanched banana slices
only showed a low level of correlation (r"0.73 and
0.72) between enzymatic activities of PPO and POD
and the total colour dierence calculated by Hunter
Lab parameters.
Enzymatic browning in bananas has been studied
extensively [15, 14, 22, 23]. However, the relationships
between phenol levels PPO and POD activities and
browning and the total colour dierence in blanched
bananas prior to freezing have not been elucidated.
Also, there are no published reports available that
describe the use of microwave or steam blanching to
prevent enzymatic browning in order to produce com-
mercially acceptable frozen banana slices. Blanching
partially inactivates PPO and POD activities to certain
low levels, depending on the treatment, and it provides
a new approach to study the individual roles of phenol,
PPO and POD in enzymatic browning and the pro-
duction of colour dierences. This approach had been
employed by Ma et al. [24] in an investigation of this
relationship in frozen sweet potatoes.
64
Results show that, in the main, the phenol level is
critical in the browning process. In unblanched con-
trols, browning is more dependent on the original
amount of PPO and POD activities in the substrate,
because these enzymes are present in such high
amounts relative to substrate levels so that, at equilib-
rium, most of the substrate has been oxidized to brown
pigments [7].
In contrast, in steam-blanched samples, PPO and
POD activities decreased dramatically and the amount
of substrate diminished (31%). In this situation, enzy-
matic activities became the limiting factors together
with the phenol level. Also, we can observe that, in all
frozen samples, the phenol level increased as a conse-
quence of the cellular disruption produced by freezing.
However, in microwave-blanched samples the only lim-
iting factors were the residual enzymatic activities pres-
ent in the tissue. It can also be expected that when PPO
and POD are completely inactivated, no enzymatic
browning can occur. However, this fact could only be
true for microwave-treated samples, because steam-
blanched samples showed relatively high browning
values indicating a near-complete inactivation of these
oxidative enzymes.
The total colour dierence, as calculated using
Hunter Lab colour parameters, only partially reects
the enzymatic browning of banana samples. Other
mechanisms of darkening occurred in banana pro-
cessed products which also aect the sample colour.
Microwave-treated samples with partially inactivated
PPO and POD showed large total colour dierence
values. In these samples, there were no correlations
between phenol level, PPO or POD activities and
total colour dierence, indicating the presence of other
non-enzymatic mechanisms which aected the sample
colour.
In summary, prevention of enzymatic browning in
frozen banana products (without the addition of chem-
icals) by blanching is the result of the dramatic of PPO
and POD activities and, depending on the type of
blanching, a reduction in phenol levels. The browning
potential was correlated with phenol levels in control
samples, but with residual PPO and POD activities in
blanched and frozen samples. Microwave blanching
aects the colour of the banana samples, not only in
terms of enzymatic browning, since other non-enzy-
matic mechanisms contribute to the colour dierence
of these samples as compared with control.
Acknowledgement This research was supported by the Comisio n
Interministerial de ciencia y Tecnolog a through the project no.
ALI95-0105
Ref erences
1. Mathew AM, Parpia HB (1971) Adv Food Res 19: 75137
2. Mayer MA, Harel E (1979) Phytochemistry 18: 193215
3. Vamos-Vygazo L (1981) Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr 15: 49127
4. Mayer AM, Harel E (1987) Phytochemistry 26: 1120
5. Burnette FS (1977) J Food Sci 42: 16
6. Haard NS, Tobin CL (1971) J Food Sci 36: 854857
7. Walter WM Jr, Purcell AE (1980) J Agric Food Chem 28:
941944
8. Walter WM Jr, Schadel WE (1981) J Agric Food Chem 29:
904906
9. Guyer RS, Erickson FR (1954) Food Technol 8: 165167
10. Tonaki KI, Brekke JE, Frank HA, Cavaletto CG (1973) Banana
puree processing research. Report 202, Hawaii Agricultural Ex-
perimental Station, College of Tropical Agriculture, University
of Hawaii, Hawaii
11. Garcia R, Menchu JF, Rolz C (1974) Proc Int Congr Food Sci
Technol 4: 3240
12. Cano MP, Marin MA, Fuster C (1990) J Sci Food Agric 51:
223231
13. Giami SY (1991) J Sci Food Agric 55: 661666
14. Garcia R, Arriola MC, Porres E, Rolz C (1985) Lebensm Wiss
Technol 18: 211215
15. Mowlah G, Takano K, Kamoi Y, Obara T (1982) Lebensm Wiss
Technol 15: 211215
16. Ramirez-Martinez JR, Levi A, Padua H, Bakil A (1977) J Food
Sci 5: 12011205
17. Cano MP (1994) Combined microwave/freezing methods to
improve preserved fruit quality. In: Singh RP, Oliveira MAF
(eds) Process optimization and minimal processing of foods.
CRC, Boca Raton, Fla., pp 135141
18. Salunke DK (1984) Banana. In: Postharvest biotechnology of
fruits, vol 1. CRC, Boca Raton, Fla., pp 4357
19. Chan HT Jr, Cavaletto CG (1982) J Food Sci 47: 11641169
20. Bradford H (1976) Anal Biochem 72: 248254
21. Steel RGD, Torrie JM (1980) Principles and procedures of
statistics. McGraw-Hill, New York
22. Galeazzi MAM, Sgarbieri V, Constantinides SM (1981) J Food
Sci 46: 150155
23. Weaver C, Charley H (1974) J Food Sci 39: 12001202
24. Ma S, Silva JL, James JO, Garner JO Jr (1992) J Agric Food
Chem 40: 864867
.
65