Professional Documents
Culture Documents
GEOGRAPHICALDEFINITIONSOFZONES
Thi sdocument cont ai nsaw r i t t endescr i pt i onof t heboundar i esof t hepr oposedzonesf or t heEconomi c
LossCl ass.Thedescr i pt i onsf or t hezonesar eor gani zedt omover oughl yf r om w est er nmost
geogr aphi cal ar eaw i t hi nt hecl assdef i ni t i onf or w hi cht her ei sazonet ot heeast er nmost geogr aphi cal
ar eaw i t hi nt hecl assdef i ni t i onf or w hi cht her ei sazone,begi nni ngw i t hZoneA,f ol l ow edbyZoneB,and
concl udi ngw i t hZoneC.Eachzonei sgi venanamew hi chcor r espondst ot hegener al geogr aphi cal ar ea
or ar easi t cover s;t hesenamesar ei nt endedf or r ef er encepur posesonl y.Eachzonei sal sogi vena
number w hi chi ndi cat est het ypeof zoneandt heor der i nw hi chi t appear si nt hi sdocument .Thenames
of st r eet sandhi ghw aysar ew r i t t ent ocor r espondascl osel yaspossi bl ew i t ht hosew hi chappear ont he
basemap onw hi cht hesezonesw er edr aw n.Thebasemapusedi nt hecr eat i onof t hezonesi st he
M i cr osof t Bi ngHybr i dmap.
ZONEADEFINITIONS
A1,Sout hLoui si ana,Zone1:Thi szoneconsi st sof t w osect i onsdi vi dedr oughl yi nt hemi ddl ebyt he
Ver mi l i onBay/ At chaf al ayaBay.Thew est er nzonei sboundedbyt heTexas/ Loui si anast at el i ne(Sabi ne
Pass)t ot hew est ,t heGul f of M exi cot ot hesout h,andt heeast er nshor eof M ar shIsl andt ot heeast .
Thenor t her nboundar yof t hi szonei sasf ol l ow s:
x Hi ghw ay82f r omt heeast er nshor eof Sabi nePasst oBayouRoad
x BayouRoadf r omHi ghw ay82t oPar i shRoad548
x Par i shRoad548f r omBayouRoadt oi t st er mi nus
x Thel i neconnect i ngt het er mi nusof Par i shRoad548t ot henor t her nshor eof M udLake
x Thel i neconnect i ngt henor t her nshor eof M udLaket ot hei nt er sect i onof Hi ghw ay82andt he
Cal casi euRi ver
x Hi ghw ay82t ot hei nt er sect i onof Schooner BayouCanal
x Sout her nbankof Schooner BayouCanal f r omHi ghw ay82t oVer mi l i onBay
x Thesout her nshor el i neof Ver mi l i onBayandW est Cot eBl ancheBayf r omSchooner BayouCanal
t ot heendof M ar shIsl and
Theeast er nsect i onof t hi szonei sboundedbyt heeast er nshor eof East Cot eBl ancheBayt ot hew est
andt henor t her nshor eof t heGul f of M exi cot ot hesout h.Thenor t her nboundar yi sdef i nedast hel i ne
connect i ngt hef ol l ow i ngpoi nt s:
x Thesout her nt er mi nusof Hi ghw ay317(St .M ar yPar i sh)
x Thesout her nt er mi nusof LeveeRoad(Ter r ebonnePar i sh)
x Thesout her nt er mi nusof BayouDul ar geRoad(Ter r ebonnePar i sh)
x Thesout her nt er mi nusof Four Poi nt Road(Ter r ebonnePar i sh)
x Thei nt er sect i onof t heHoumaNavi gat i onCanal andBayouPet i t (Ter r ebonnePar i sh)
x Thesout her nt er mi nusof Isl andRoad(Ter r ebonnePar i sh)
x Thesout her nt er mi nusof Low er Hi ghw ay665(Ter r ebonnePar i sh)
x Theeast er nt er mi nusof t heJeanPl ai sanceCanal (Laf our chePar i sh)
028269
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-4 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 23
2
A4,Dow nt ow nNew Or l eans:Thi szonei sboundedbyCal l i opeSt r eet (w hi chr unsunder neat ht he
Pont char t r ai nExpr essw ay)i nt hesout handext endst oEl ysi anFi el dsAvenuei nt henor t h.Theeast er n
boundar yi st heM i ssi ssi ppi Ri ver .Thew est er nboundar yconsi st sof t hef ol l ow i ngst r eet s:
x St .Char l esAvenuef r omCal l i opeSt r eet t oSt .JosephSt r eet
x St .JosephSt r eet f r om St .Char l esAvenuet oS.Pet er sSt r eet
x S.Pet er sSt r eet f r omSt .JosephSt r eet t oNot r eDam eSt r eet
x Not r eDameSt r eet f r omS.Pet er sSt r eet t oConvent i onCent er Boul evar d
x Convent i onCent er Boul evar df r omNot r eDameSt r eet t oPoydr asSt r eet
x Poydr asSt r eet f r omConvent i onCent er Boul evar dt oS.Pet er sSt r eet
x S.Pet er sSt r eet f r omPoydr asSt r eet t oCanal St r eet
x Canal St r eet f r omS.Pet er sSt r eet t oN.Rampar t St r eet
x Rampar t St r eet (w hi chbecomesSt .Cl audeAvenue)f r omCanal St r eet t oEl ysi anFi el dsAvenue.
A5,Sl i del l Ar ea:Thi szonebegi nsat t hei nt er sect i onof Hi ghw ay90(Chef M ent eur Boul evar d)at
Int er st at e510andi ncl udesal l pr oper t i esf r ont i ngHi ghw ay90unt i l t henor t hsi deof t heRi gol et sPass.
Thezonet henbr oadenst oi ncl udear easbet w eenFr ont St r eet (andt her ai l r oadt r acks)i nt hew est ,t he
Loui si ana/ M i ssi ssi ppi st at el i ne(t hePear l Ri ver )i nt heeast ,andt hecont i nuousshor el i neof Lake
Pont char t r ai n,t heRi gol et sPass,andLakeBor gnei nt hesout h.Thenor t her nboundar yconsi st sof t he
f ol l ow i ngr oads:
x Ol dSpani shTr ai l t oInt er st at e10
x Int er st at e10f r omOl dSpani shTr ai l t oHi ghw ay190East
x Hi ghw ay190East f r omInt er st at e10t oHi ghw ay90
x Hi ghw ay90f r omHi ghw ay190t ot heLoui si ana/ M i ssi ssi ppi st at el i ne(t hePear l Ri ver )
Thi szoneal soi ncl udest hew et l andssout hof t heRi gol et sPasst ot heM i ssi ssi ppi Ri ver Gul f Out l et and
al l w et l ands.
A6,BaySt .Loui s:Thi szonei sboundedi nt hesout hbyt heM i ssi ssi ppi Sound/ LakeBor gneshor el i ne.It s
nor t her nboundar ybegi nsat t hecr ossi ngof Int er st at e10over t hePear l Ri ver andcont i nuesal ong
Int er st at e10unt i l Hi ghw ay607.It r unsal ongHi ghw ay607unt i l t hei nt er sect i onw i t hHi ghw ay90,and
cont i nuesal ongHi ghw ay90andt er mi nat esat t hebegi nni ngof t hebr i dgeover BaySt .Loui s,w her ei t
meet st hezone ssout her nboundar y.Thew est er nboundar yof t hezonei sconf i gur edasf ol l ow s:
x ThePear l Ri ver f r omInt er st at e10t oHi ghw ay90
x Hi ghw ay90f r omPear l Ri ver t ot oLow er BayRoad
x Low er BayRoadt o(30.236N,89.52W ),at w hi chpoi nt t heboundar ycut sduesout ht o
i nt er sect w i t hJohn sBayou
x John sBayouf r ompoi nt descr i bedabovet oGr andPl ai nsBayou
x Gr andPl ai nsBayouf r omJohn sBayout ot hePear l Ri ver
028272
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-4 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 23
5
A7,Gul f por t / Bi l oxi / OceanSpr i ngs:Thi szonebegi nsat t heHi ghw ay90br i dgeont heeast si deof BaySt .
Loui s.It sw est er nboundar yi st heshor el i neof BaySt .Loui ssout hof t hebr i dgeandi t ssout her n
boundar yi st heshor el i neof t heM i ssi ssi ppi Soundbut i ncl udesCat Isl and,Shi pIsl and,Hor nIsl and,and
Deer Isl and.It seast er nboundar yi sHal st eadRoadi nOceanSpr i ngs.Thenor t her nboundar yi sas
f ol l ow s:
x W .BeachBoul evar d(Hi ghw ay90)t oCSXRai l r oad
x CSXRai l r oadf r omBeachBoul evar dt oTegar denRoad
x Tegar denRoadf r omCSXRai l r oadt oE.PassRoad
x E.PassRoadf r omTegar denRoadt oLor r ai neRoad
x Lor r ai neRoadf r omE.PassRoadt oBer nar dBayou
x Sout her nbankof Ber nar dBayouf r omLor r ai neRoadt oBi gLake/ BackBayof Bi l oxi
x Sout her nshor eof BackBayof Bi l oxi f r omBer nar dBayout oHi ghw ay90
x Hi ghw ay90f r omw est er nshor eof BackBayof Bi l oxi t oeast er nshor eof BackBayof Bi l oxi
x East er nshor eof BackBayof Bi l oxi f r om Hi ghw ay90t oOl dFor t Bayou
x Sout her nshor eof Ol dFor t Bayouf r omBackBayof Bi l oxi t oW ashi ngt onAvenue
x W ashi ngt onAvenuef r om Ol dFor t Bayout oHi ghw ay90
x Hi ghw ay90f r omW ashi ngt onAvenuet oHal st eadRoad
A8:Int er st at e110t oBi l oxi :Thi szoneconsi st sof Int er st at e110sout hof Int er st at e10andw i t hi none
quar t er mi l eof t heexi t r amponRodr i guezSt r eet .
A9,BayouLaBat r e:Thi szonei st r i angul ar i nshapeandcont ai nst hear eabet w eenBayouLaBat r et o
Hi ghw ay188(Al abamaCoast al Connect i on).It cont i nuesonHi ghw ay188t ot hebayousout hw est of
Coden.It ssout her nboundar yi st heGul f of M exi co.
A10,Dauphi nIsl and:Thi szoneconsi st sexcl usi vel yandent i r el yof Dauphi nIsl and.
A11,Gul f Shor es/ Or angeBeach:Thi szonei sboundedbyt heGul f of M exi cot ot hesout h,f r omt he
w est er nt i pof For t M or ganSt at ePar kt ot heAl abama/ Fl or i dast at el i ne.It al soi ncl udest heent i r et yof
OnoIsl and.It snor t her nboundar ybegi nsat t hecanal connect i ngM obi l eBayandW ol f Bayand
cont i nuest oBayoul aLaunch,Ar ni caBay,BayouSt .John,andOl dRi ver .
A12,Hi ghw ay59t oGul f Shor es:Thi szoneconsi st sof pr oper t i esf r ont i ngHi ghw ay59f r omInt er st at e10
t ot hecanal connect i onBonSecour BayandW ol f Bay
A13,Per di doKey:Thi szonei sboundedbyt heGul f of M exi coi nt hesout h,begi nni ngat t he
Al abama/ Fl or i dast at el i ne.Thew est er nboundar yi st hest at el i nesi t uat edi nt heOl dRi ver andPer di do
Bay.Thenor t her nboundar yi sasf ol l ow s:
x BayouGar cont ot hepoi nt duenor t hof t heendof Cor i nnaSt r eet
x Cor i nnaSt r eet f r omt er mi nust oHi ghw ay292A(Gul f BeachHi ghw ay)
x Hi ghw ay292Af r omCor i nnaSt r eet t oRadf or dBoul evar d
x Radf or dBoul evar df r omHi ghw ay292At oFuel Far m Road
028273
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-4 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 23
6
A28:Fl or i daKeys:Thi szoneconsi st sof t heent i r et yof t heser i esof i sl andsof f t hesout hcoast of Fl or i da
st r et chi ngf r omKeyW est i nt hesout h/ w est t oKeyLar goi nt henor t h/ east .
ZONEBDEFINITIONS
B1,Sout hLoui si ana1:Thi szoneconsi st sof anar eaof sout her nLoui si anaspanni ngf r om t he
Loui si ana/ Texasst at el i net oCami nadaBay.Al t hought hezonei sonecont i guouspol ygon,t hi s
descr i pt i ondi vi desi t i nt ot w opar t s.Thef i r st of t hesepar t si ncl udest hel ar ger ar easmovi ngasf ar east
andsout hasGol denM eadow ,andt hesecondi ncl udest henar r ow er por t i onof t hezonesout hof
Gol denM eadow / BayouLaf our che.It sw est er nboundar yi st heTexas/ Loui si anast at el i ne.
Thezone snor t her n/ east er nboundar yi sasf ol l ow s:
x Thesout her nboundar yof Cal casi euPar i shf r omt heTexas/ Loui si anast at el i neunt i l t heeast er n
boundar yof Cal casi euPar i shi nt er sect sInt er st at e10
x Int er st at e10f r omt heCal casi euPar i shl i net ot heLaf ayet t ePar i shl i ne
x TheLaf ayet t ePar i shl i nesout hof Int er st at e10unt i l i t i nt er sect sagai nw i t hInt er st at e10ont he
east si deof Laf ayet t ePar i sh
x Int er st at e10f r omt heLaf ayet t ePar i shl i net oHi ghw ay1w est of Bat onRouge
x Hi ghw ay1f r omInt er st at e10t ot heInt r acoast al W at er w ayi nLar ose
x Int r acoast al W at er w ayf r omHi ghw ay1t oSt at i onNo.7Road/ Canal andl eveesyst em
x St at i onNo.7Road/ canal andl eveesyst emf r om Int r acoast al W at er w ayt oBayouLaf our che
It ssout her nboundar yi sasf ol l ow s:
x Hi ghw ay82f r omSabi nePasst oBayouRoad
x BayouRoadf r omHi ghw ay82t oPar i shRoad548
x Par i shRoad548f r omBayouRoadt oi t st er mi nus
x Thel i neconnect i ngt het er mi nusof Par i shRoad548t ot henor t her nshor eof M udLake
x Thel i neconnect i ngt henor t her nshor eof M udLaket ot hei nt er sect i onof Hi ghw ay82andt he
Cal casi euRi ver
x Hi ghw ay82t oSchooner BayouCanal
x Thenor t her nbankof Schooner BayouCanal f r omHi ghw ay82t oVer mi l i onBay
x Thenor t her nshor el i neof Ver mi l i onBayandW est Cot eBl ancheBayf r omSchooner BayouCanal
t osout her nt er mi nusof Hi ghw ay317
x Theboundar ycont i nuest hr oughout sout her nLoui si anaeast of Ver mi l i onBayi nal i ne
connect i ngt heendof t hef ol l ow i ngr oads:
o Hi ghw ay317(St .M ar yPar i sh)
o LeveeRoad(Ter r ebonnePar i sh)
o BayouDul ar geRoad(Ter r ebonnePar i sh)
o Four Poi nt Road(Ter r ebonnePar i sh)
o M out hof HoumaNavi gat i onCanal (Ter r ebonnePar i sh)
o Isl andRoad(Ter r ebonnePar i sh)
028276
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-4 Filed 04/18/12 Page 9 of 23
9
x Nor t her nbankof BayouLamoquef r om w est er nshor eof Cal i f or ni aBayt oBayouTor t i l l en
x Sout her nbankof BayouTor t i l l enf r omBayouLamoquet oOst r i caLocks
x Ost r i caLocksf r omBayouTor t i l l ent oeast er nshor eof M i ssi ssi ppi Ri ver
x East er nshor eof M i ssi ssi ppi Ri ver f r omOst r i caLockst oPassaLout r e
B3,Dow nt ow nNew Or l eans:Thi szonei sboundedbyCal l i opeSt r eet (w hi chr unsunder neat ht he
Pont char t r ai nExpr essw ay)t ot hew est ,Cl ai bor neAvenue(w hi chr unsunder neat hInt er st at e10)t ot he
nor t h,andEspl anadeAvenuet ot heeast .Thesout her nboundar yi sasf ol l ow s:
x St .Char l esAvenuef r omCal l i opeSt r eet t oSt .JosephSt r eet
x St .JosephSt r eet f r om St .Char l esAvenuet oS.Pet er sSt r eet
x S.Pet er sSt r eet f r omSt .JosephSt r eet t oNot r eDam eSt r eet
x Not r eDameSt r eet f r omS.Pet er sSt r eet t oConvent i onCent er Boul evar d
x Convent i onCent er Boul evar df r omNot r eDameSt r eet t oPoydr asSt r eet
x Poydr asSt r eet f r omConvent i onCent er Boul evar dt oS.Pet er sSt r eet
x S.Pet er sSt r eet f r omPoydr asSt r eet t oCanal St r eet
x Canal St r eet f r omS.Pet er sSt r eet t oN.Rampar t St r eet
x Rampar t St r eet f r omCanal St r eet t oEspl anadeAvenue
B4,Upt ow nNew Or l eans:Thi szonei sboundedbyCal l i opeSt r eet (w hi chr unsunder neat ht he
Pont char t r ai nExpr essw ay)t ot heeast ,St .Char l esAvenuet ot henor t h,andW al nut St r eet (at t heedge
of AudubonPar k)t ot hew est .Thesout her nboundar yi sasf ol l ow s:
x Rai l r oadt r acksf r omFr ont St r eet / W al nut St r eet t oRi ver Dr i ve
x TheM i ssi ssi ppi Ri ver f r omRi ver Dr i vet oRi ver Dr i ve/ East Dr i ve
x East Dr i vef r omRi ver Dr i vet oTchoupi t oul asSt r eet
x Tchoupi t oul asSt r eet f r omEast Dr i vet oCal l i opeSt r eet
B5,Buckt ow n/ Lakeshor e,New Or l eans:Thi szonei sboundedbyLakePont char t ai nt ot henor t hand
Bonnabel Boul evar dt ot hew est .Thesout her nboundar yi sasf ol l ow s:
x W est Espl anadeAvenuef r omBonnabel Boul evar dt ot he17
t h
St r eet Canal (Jef f er son/ Or l eans
Par i shl i ne)
x 17
t h
St r eet Canal f r omW .Espl anadeAvenuet o38
t h
St r eet
x 38
t h
St r eet f r omt he17
t h
St r eet Canal t oPont char t r ai nBoul evar d/ W est EndBoul evar d
Theeast er nboundar yi sasf ol l ow s:
x Pont char t r ai nBoul evar d/ W est EndBoul evar df r om38
t h
St r eet t oHammondHi ghw ay/ Rober t E.
LeeBoul evar d
x Lakeshor eDr i vef r omHammondHi ghw ay/ Rober t E.LeeBoul evar dt obegi nni ngof har bor / boat
sl i ps
x Har bor / boat sl i pst oLakePont char t r ai n
028278
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-4 Filed 04/18/12 Page 11 of 23
11
B6,St .TammanyPar i sh:Thi szonei sboundedbyt henor t hshor eof LakePont char t r ai nt ot hesout h,
Causew ayBoul evar dt ot hew est ,andt heHi ghw ay11r ai l r oadt ot heeast .Thenor t her nboundar yi sas
f ol l ow s:
x M onr oeSt r eet f r omCausew ayBoul evar dt oGi r odSt r eet
x Gi r odSt r eet f r omM onr oeSt r eet t oHi ghw ay190
x Hi ghw ay190f r omGi r odSt r eet t oThom psonRoad
x ThompsonRoadf r omHi ghw ay190t oBayouLi ber t yRoad
x BayouLi ber t yRoadt oHi ghw ay11r ai l r oadt r acks
B5,Bat t l eshi pPar kw ay:Thi szoneconsi st sof t hef ol l ow i ngr oads:
x Bat t l eshi pPar kw ay(U.S.Hi ghw ay90)f r omInt er st at e10near Pol ecat Bayt oSpani shFor t
Boul evar d(U.S.Hi ghw ay31)
x Spani shFor t Boul evar d(U.S.Hi ghw ay31)f r omBat t l eshi pPar kw ayt oM obi l ePl ant at i onPar kw ay
(Hi ghw ay181)
x M obi l ePl ant at i onPar kw ay(Hi ghw ay181)f r omSpani shFor t Boul evar dt oInt er st at e10
B7,Daphne/ Fai r hope:Thi szonei sboundedbyM obi l eBayt ot hew est ,Spani shFor t Boul evar dt ot he
nor t h,Hi ghw ay98t ot heeast ,andHi ghw ay98t ot hesout h.
B8,Gul f Br eeze:Thi szonei sboundedbyt heSant aRosaSoundt ot henor t handHi ghw ay98t osout h
andw est .Theeast er nboundar yi st hel i nebet w eenBal t ar Dr i veandHi ckor yShor esDr i ve,i ncl udi ngt he
east er nt er mi nusof SandyBl uf f Dr i ve.
B9,Fol eyAr ea:Thi szonei sboundedont henor t hbyHi ghw ay98f r omt heeast er nshor eof M obi l eBay
t ot heFol eyBeachExpr essw ay.It ssout her nboundar yi st henor t her nbankof t heInt r acoast al
W at er w ayf r omM obi l eBayt ot heFol eyBeachExpr essw ay.It sw est er nboundar yi sM obi l eBayf r om
t hei nt er sect i onof Al abama sCoast al Connect i onandU.SHi ghw ay98t ot henor t her nbankof t he
Int r acoast al W at er w ay.It seast er nboundar yi st heFol eyBeachExpr essw ayf r omHi ghw ay98t ot he
nor t her nbankof t heInt r acoast al W at er w ay.Thi szoneexcl udest hepor t i onsof ZoneA12w hi chr un
t hr oughi t .
B10,Fol eyBeachExpr essw ay:Thi szoneconsi st sof Fol eyBeachExpr essw ayf r omHi ghw ay59t o
Hi ghw ay98.
B11,Dow nt ow nPensacol a:Thi szonei sboundedi nt hesout hbyt henor t her nbankof BayouGr ande
f r omS.NavyBoul evar dt ot henor t her nshor eof Pensacol aBay,andbyt henor t her nshor eof Pensacol a
Bayf r omBayouGr andet ot hePensacol aBayBr i dge(Hi ghw ay98).It sw est er nboundar yi sS.Navy
Boul evar df r omBar r ancasAvenuet ot henor t her nbankof BayouGr ande.It snor t her nboundar yi sas
f ol l ow s:
x Bar r ancasAvenuef r omS.NavyRoadt oW .Gar denSt r eet
x W .Gar denSt r eet f r om Bar r ancasAvenuet oN.Al cani zSt r eet
028279
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-4 Filed 04/18/12 Page 12 of 23
12
x N.Al cani zSt r eet f r om E.Gar denSt r eet t oE.Gr egor ySt r eet
x E.Gr egor ySt r eet f r om N.Al cani zAvenuet ot hePensacol aBayBr i dge
B12,Hi ghw ay98f r omGul f Br eezet oFor t W al t onBeach:Thi szoneconsi st sof U.S.Hi ghw ay98(Gul f
Br eezePar kw ay,Navar r ePar kw ay,or M i r acl eSt r i pPar kw ay)f r om t heeast er nedgeof ZoneA14(edge
of t heTi ger Poi nt Gol f Cour sedevel opment )t ot henor t her nshor eof Sant aRosaSound.
B13,Hi ghw ay293i nDest i n:Thi szoneconsi st sof Hi ghw ay293f r omt henor t her nshor eof
Choct aw hat cheeBayt oHi ghw ay98(Emer al dCoast Par kw ay).
B14,PanamaCi t yBeach:Thi szonei sboundedont henor t hbyHi ghw ay98(BackBeachRoad)f r om
Cl ar aAvenuet oFr ont BeachRoad.It sw est er nboundar yi sCl ar aAvenuef r om Hi ghw ay98t o
Hut chi nsonBoul evar d.It ssout her nboundar yi sasf ol l ow s:
x Hut chi nsonBoul evar df r omCl ar aAvenuet oFr ont BeachRoad
x Fr ont BeachRoadf r omHut chi nsonAvenuet oHi ghw ay98
B15,PanamaCi t y:Thi szoneconsi st sof t w or oads,asdescr i bedbel ow :
x W .Hi ghw ay98/ W .18
t h
St r eet f r om t hew est er nshor eof t heUpper Gr andLagoont oBeck
Avenue
x W .23
r d
St r eet / E.23
r d
St r eet f r omHi ghw ay98t oN.CoveBoul evar d/ M ar t i nLut her Ki ng,Jr .
Boul evar d
B16,Por t St .Joe:Thi szonei sboundedont hew est byM onument Avenuef r om 1
st
St r eet t oCeci l G.
Cost i nBoul evar d.It snor t her nboundar yi s1
st
St r eet f r omM onum ent Avenuet oW oodw ar dAvenue.It s
east er nboundar yi sW oodw ar dAvenuef r om1
st
St r eet t oCeci l G.Cost i nBoul evar d.It sout her n
boundar yi sCeci l G.Cost i nBoul evar df r omM onum ent Avenuet oW oodw ar dAvenue.
B17,Apal achi col a:Thi szonei sboundedont heeast byt hew est er nbankof Sci pi oCr eek/ Apal achi col a
Ri ver .It snor t her nboundar yi sasf ol l ow s:
x AvenueM f r om12
t h
St r eet t oM ar ket St r eet
x M ar ket st r eet f r omAvenueM t omar i na/ i nl et at Sci pi oCr eek
x Nor t her nbankof i nl et / mar i nat oSci pi oCr eek
It sw est er nboundar yi sasf ol l ow s:
x 12
t h
St r eet f r omAvenueM t oAvenueL
x AvenueLf r om12
t h
St r eet t o14
t h
St r eet
x 14
t h
St r eet f r omAvenueLt oAvenueE
It ssout her nboundar yi sasf ol l ow s:
x AvenueEf r om14
t h
St r eet t oM ar ket St r eet
x M ar ket St r eet f r omAvenueEt ot heeast er nshor eof t heApal achi col aRi ver
028280
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-4 Filed 04/18/12 Page 13 of 23
13
ZONECDEFINITIONS
C1,Gal vest on:Thi szonescont ai nst heent i r et yof Gal vest onIsl andandt heBol i var Peni nsul a/ Cr yst al
Beach.Thezone seast er nboundar yi st hew at er passagew ayf r omt heGul f of M exi cot oRol l over Bay,
l ocat edj ust east of N.Bauer St r eet .
C2,Por t Ar t hur :Thi szoneconsi st sof t hef ol l ow i ngboundar i es,movi ngcl ockw i sebegi nni ngat i t s
nor t her nmost t i pat t hei nt er sect i onof Hi ghw ay82andTayl or Bayou.
x Hi ghw ay82f r omt heeast er nbankof Tayl or Bayout ot heSabi neNechesCanal
x Sout her nbankof Sabi neNechesCanal f r omHi ghw ay82t onor t her nt er mi nusof S.LeveeRoad
x S.LeveeRoadf r omsout her nbankof Sabi neNechesCanal t ot hesout her nshor eof Sabi neLake
x Sout her nshor eof Sabi neLake/ Sabi nePassf r omS.LeveeRoadt oeast er nt er mi nusof Jet t yRoad
x Jet t yRoad/ 1
st
St r eet f r om east er nt er mi nust oQui nnSt r eet
x Qui nnSt r eet f r omJet t yRoadt oS.8
t h
Avenue(Rout e3322)
x S.8
t h
Avenue(Rout e3322/ Hi ghw ay87)f r omQui nnSt r eet t onor t her nbankof Int r acoast al
W at er w ay
x Nor t her nbankof Int r acoast al W at er w ayf r omS.8
t h
Avenuet oeast er nbankof Tayl or Bayou
x East er nbankof Tayl or Bayouf r omnor t her nbankof Int r acoast al W at er w ayt oHi ghw ay82
C3,Sout hLoui si ana:Thi szoneconsi st sof t hr eepar t sspanni ngacr osssout her nLoui si ana.Thef i r st
por t i onconsi st sof Cal casi euPar i shsout hof Int er st at e10.Thesecondpor t i onconsi st sof Laf ayet t e
Par i shsout hof Int er st at e10.
Thet hi r dandl ar gest por t i oni sboundedont hesout h/ w est byHi ghw ay1f r om Int er st at e10t ot he
Int r acoast al W at er w ayi nLar ose.It seast er nboundar yi sasf ol l ow s:
x W est er n/ nor t her nbankof Int r acoast al W at er w ayf r omHi ghw ay1t ot hew est er nbankof Bayou
Bar at ar i a
x W est er n/ nor t her nbankof BayouBar at ar i af r omnor t her nbankof Int r acoast al W at er w ayt o
Hi ghw ay3134
x Hi ghw ay3134f r omnor t her nbankof BayouBar at ar i at oBar at ar i aBoul evar d(Hi ghw ay45)
x Bar at ar i aBoul evar df r omHi ghw ay3134t oW est bankExpr essw ay(Hi ghw ay90)
x W est bankExpr essw ayf r omBar at ar i aBoul evar dt oInt er st at e310
x Int er st at e310f r omW est bankExpr essw ayt oInt er st at e10
x Int er st at e10f r omInt er st at e310t oendof Bonnet Car r et Spi l l w ay,w her ei t meet st heshor eof
LakePont char t r ai n
x Sout her n/ w est er n/ nor t her nshor eof LakePont char t r ai nf r omBonnet Car r et Spi l l w ayt oN.
Causew ayBoul evar dont henor t hshor e
x N.Causew ayBoul evar df r omnor t her nshor eof LakePont char t r ai nt oM onr oeSt r eet
x M onr oeSt r eet f r omN.Causew ayBoul evar dt oGi r odSt r eet
x Gi r odSt r eet f r omM onr oeSt r eet t oFl or i daSt r eet (Hi ghw ay190)
028281
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-4 Filed 04/18/12 Page 14 of 23
14
C6,BaySt .Loui s:Thi szonei sboundedbyInt er st at e10f r omHi ghw ay607t oInt er st at e110i nt he
nor t handHi ghw ay607f r omInt er st at e10t oHi ghw ay90i nt hew est .It seast er nboundar yi st he
w est er nboundar yof t heInt er st at e110ZoneA.It ssout her nboundar yi sasf ol l ow s:
x Hi ghw ay607f r omInt er st at e10t oi t smer ger w i t hHi ghw ay90
x Hi ghw ay90f r omHi ghw ay607t oEver et t St r eet / Rai l r oadAvenuei nPassChr i st i anRai l r oad
Avenuef r om Hi ghw ay90t oTegar denRoad
x Tegar denRoadf r omRai l r oadAvenuet oE.PassRoad
x E.PassRoadf r omTegar denRoadt oLor r ai neRoad
x Lor r ai neRoadf r omPassRoadt ot henor t her nshor eof Bi gLake/ BackBayof Bi l oxi
x BackBayof Bi l oxi f r omLor r ai neRoadt ot hebegi nni ngof t heInt er st at e110ZoneA
C7,Bi l oxi / Pascagoul a/ M obi l e:Thi szonespanst hr eeci t i esf r omInt er st at e110t oM obi l eBay.It s
w est er nboundar yi st heeast er nboundar yof t heInt er st at e110ZoneA.It snor t her nboundar yi sas
f ol l ow s:
x Int er st at e10f r omt heInt er st at e110ZoneA1zonet oInt er st at e65
x Int er st at e65f r omInt er st at e10t osout her nbankof Chi ckasaw Cr eek
x Sout her nbankof Chi ckasaw Cr eekf r om Int er st at e65t ow est er nbankof Bl ackBayou
x W est er nbankof Bl ackBayouf r omsout her nbankof Chi ckasaw Cr eekt ot heeast er nbankof t he
M obi l eRi ver
x East er nbankof M obi l eRi ver t ot hew est er nbankof t heSpani shRi ver
It ssout her nboundar yi sasf ol l ow s:
x Thenor t her nshor eof BackBayof Bi l oxi f r omt heInt er st at e110ZoneAt oW ashi ngt onAvenue
x W ashi ngt onAvenuef r om t henor t her nshor eof t heBackBayof Bi l oxi t oHi ghw ay90
x Hi ghw ay90f r omW ashi ngt onAvenuet oHal st eadRoad
x Hal st eadRoadf r om Hi ghw ay90t ot henor t her nshor eof Davi sBayou/ M i ssi ssi ppi Sound
x Nor t her nshor eof Davi sBayou/ M i ssi ssi ppi Soundf r omHal st eadRoadt ot hew est er nbankof
BayouLaBat r e
x W est er nbankof BayouLaBat r ef r omt heGul f of M exi cot oHi ghw ay188
x Hi ghw ay188f r omBayouLaBat r et ot heeast er nbankof BayouCoden
x East er nbankof BayouCodent ot henor t her nshor eof t heGul f of M exi co
x Nor t her nshor eof t heGul f of M exi cof r omBayouCodent ot hew est er nshor eof M obi l eBay
It seast er nboundar yi sasf ol l ow s:
x Thew est er nbankof t heSpani shRi ver f r omt heM obi l eRi ver t ot hew est er nshor eof M obi l e
Bay
x Thew est er nshor eof M obi l eBayf r omt heSpani shRi ver t ot heGul f of M exi co
C8,Or angeBeach/ Pensacol a:Thi szonespansf r omt heZoneB7andB8i nt hew est t ot heeast er n
shor esof Pensacol aBayandEscambi aBaysout hof Int er st at e10t ot heeast .It i sbi sect edbyt he
028283
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-4 Filed 04/18/12 Page 16 of 23
16
Hi ghw ay59t oGul f Shor es(ZoneA12)andbyt heFol eyBeachExpr essw aynor t hof Hi ghw ay98(ZoneB
10).It snor t her nboundar yi sInt er st at e10f r omHi ghw ay98t oEscambi aBay.It sw est er nboundar yi s
asf ol l ow s:
x U.S.Hi ghw ay98/ 42f r omInt er st at e10t oHi ghw ay98(Al abama sCoast al Connect i on)
x Hi ghw ay98(Al abama sCoast al Connect i on)f r om U.S.Hi ghw ay98t ot heFol eyBeach
Expr essw ay
x Fol eyBeachExpr essw ayf r omHi ghw ay98t ot henor t her nbankof t heInt r acoast al W at er w ay
It ssout her nboundar yi sasf ol l ow s:
x Thenor t her nshor eof t heInt r acoast al W at er w ayf r omM obi l eBayt oW ol f Bay
x Thenor t her nshor esof W ol f Bay,BayouLaLaunch,Ami caBay,andPer di doBayf r omt he
Int r acoast al W at er w ayt ot henor t her nbankof BayouGar con
x Thenor t her nbankof BayouGar conf r omPer di doBayt o(30.323N,87.425W ),apoi nt due
nor t hof t heendof Cor i nnaSt r eet
x Cor i nnaSt r eet f r omt hel i neduesout hof (30.323N,87.425W )t oHi ghw ay292A
x Hi ghw ay292Af r omCor i nnaSt r eet t oHi ghw ay173
x Hi ghw ay173f r omHi ghw ay292At oFuel Far mRoad
x Fuel Far mRoadf r omHi ghw ay173t ot henor t her nshor eof Bi gLagoon
x Nor t her nshor eof Bi gLagoonf r omFuel Far mRoadt ot hew est shor eof Pensacol aBay
It seast er nboundar yi sasf ol l ow s:
x W est er nshor eof Escambi aBay/ Pensacol aBayf r omInt er st at e10t oHi ghw ay98(Pensacol aBay
Br i dge).
x Hi ghw ay98(E.Gr egor ySt r eet )f r omPensacol aBayt oS.Al cani zSt r eet
x S.Al cani zSt r eet f r om E.Gr egor ySt r eet t oE.Gar denSt r eet .
x E.Gar denSt r eet / W .Gar denSt r eet f r om E.Gr egor ySt r eet t oBar r ancasAvenue
x Bar r ancasAvenuef r omW .Gar denSt r eet t oS.NavyBoul evar d
x S.NavyBoul evar df r omBar r ancasAvenuet ot henor t her nbankof BayouGr ande
x Nor t her nbankof BayouGr andef r om S.NavyBoul evar dt ot hew est er nshor eof Pensacol aBay
x W est er nshor eof Pensacol aBayf r omBayouGr andet ot henor t her nshor eof Bi gLagoon
C9,Gul f Br eeze/ For t W al t on/ Ni cevi l l e:Thi szonei sboundedont hesout hbyt henor t her nshor esof t he
Sant aRosaSoundandChoct aw hat cheeBay.It sw est er nboundar yi sasf ol l ow s:
x Thegr eenspacebet w eenBal t ar Dr i veandHi ckor yShor esBoul evar df r omt hesout her nshor eof
East Bayt oHi ghw ay98
x Hi ghw ay98(Gul f Br eezePar kw ay)f r om t hegr eenspacet ot heeast er nedgeof t heTi ger Poi nt
Gol f Cour sedevel opment .
x Theeast er nedgeof t heTi ger Poi nt Gol f Cour sedevel opment f r om Hi ghw ay98t ot henor t her n
shor eof Sant aRosaSound
028284
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-4 Filed 04/18/12 Page 17 of 23
17
x NW 102
nd
Pl acef r om NW 107
t h
Ter r acet oNW 128
t h
Cour t
x NW 128
t h
Cour t f r om NW 102
nd
Pl acet oNW 90
t h
St r eet
x NW 90
t h
St r eet f r omNW 128
t h
Cour t t oNW CampAzal eaRoad
x NW CampAzal eaRoadf r omNW 90
t h
St r eet t oNW Count yRoad347
x NW Count yRoad347f r omNW Cam pAzal eaRoadPl acet oSR24
x SR24f r om Count yRoad347t oSW SW 95
t h
Avenue
x SW 95
t h
Avenuef r omSR24t oSW 94
t h
Ter r ace
x SW 94
t h
Ter r acef r om SR24t oSW HodgeRoad/ SW M ai nLi neRoad
x SW M ai nLi neRoadf r om SW 94
t h
Ter r acet oFi ber Fact or yRoad
x Fi ber Fact or yRoadf r omSW M ai nLi neRoadt oSE80
t h
St r eet
x SE80
t h
St r eet f r omFi ber Fact or yRoadt oSE25
t h
Avenue
x SE25
t h
Avenuef r omSE80
t h
St r eet t oSE76
t h
Lane
x SE76
t h
Lanef r omSE25
t h
St r eet t oHi ghw ay19/ 98
x Hi ghw ay19/ 98f r omSE76
t h
Lanet oPasco/ Pi nel l asCount yl i ne
C17,Tampat oM ar coIsl and:Thi szonei sboundedbyt heeast er nshor esof t heGul f of M exi co
(excl udi ngt hei sl andsi ncl udedi nZoneA),Tampa/ Hi l l sbor oughBay,andChar l ot t eHar bor Bayt ot he
w est .It snor t her nboundar yi st hePasco/ Pi nel l asCount yl i ne,andi t ssout her nboundar yi st heedgeof
M ar coIsl and.It seast er nboundar yi sasf ol l ow s:
x Hi ghw ay19f r omt hePasco/ Pi nel l asCount yl i net oUl mer t onRoad
x Ul mer t onRoadf r omHi ghw ay18t oInt er st at e275
x Int er st at e275f r omUl mer t onRoadt oInt er st at e4
x Int er st at e4f r omInt er st at e275t oHi ghw ay41
x Hi ghw ay41f r omInt er st at e4t oHi ghw ay951
x Hi ghw ay951t oM ar coIsl and/ Bi gM ar coRi ver
FEEDERROUTES
Thef ol l ow i ngr oadsegment sar ei ncl udedi nZoneC.Thezonesar edescr i bedi nor der f r om w est t o
east ,gr oupedi nt hest at esi nw hi cht heyt er mi nat e.
Texas
x Hi ghw ay124f r omInt er st at e10t oHi ghw ay87,andHi ghw ay87f r omHi ghw ay124t ot he
begi nni ngof t heBol i var Peni nsul a
Loui si ana
x Canal St r eet f r omCl ai bor neAvenuet oCi t yPar kAvenue
x Bar at ar i aBoul evar df r omt heW est bankExpr essw ay(Hi ghw ay90)t oHi ghw ay3134,and
Hi ghw ay3134f r omBar at ar i aBoul evar dt oi nt er sect i onw i t hBar at ar i aBoul evar dnear est t he
Int er coast al W at er w ay
028289
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-4 Filed 04/18/12 Page 22 of 23
22
x Pet er sRoadf r omW est bankExpr essw ayt oEngi neer sRoad,andEngi neer sRoadf r omPet er s
Roadt oBel l eChasseHi ghw ay
x Bel l eChasseHi ghw ay(Hi ghw ay23)f r omW est bankExpr essw ay(Hi ghw ay90)t obegi nni ngof
t heSout hLoui si anaZoneBzone
x Gener al deGaul l eDr i vef r omW est bankExpr essw ay(Hi ghw ay90)t oBehr manHi ghw ay,and
Behr manHi ghw ayf r omGener al deGaul l eDr i vet oHi ghw ay23
x W est bankExpr essw ay(Hi ghw ay90)f r omBar at ar i aBoul evar dt ot hew est bankof t he
M i ssi ssi ppi Ri ver
x Int er st at e59f r omHi ghw ay98sout hof Hat t i esbur gt oInt er st at e12i nSl i del l
M i ssi ssi ppi
x Hi ghw ay49f r omHi ghw ay98sout hof Hat t i esbur gt oInt er st at e10nor t hof Gul f por t
Al abama
x Hi ghw ay98f r omInt er st at e59sout hof Hat t i esbur gt oInt er st at e65i nM obi l e
x Int er st at e65f r omEast Ol dFor t Roadeast of For t Deposi t t oInt er st at e165i nM obi l e
x Int er st at e10acr ossM obi l eBay
x Hi ghw ay98acr ossM obi l eBay
x Hi ghw ay59f r omInt er st at e65t oInt er st at e10
x Hi ghw ay287(RabunRoad)f r omInt er st at e65t oHi ghw ay59
Fl or i da
x Int er st at e10f r omw est shor eof Escambi aBayt oHi ghw ay231
x Hi ghw ay331f r omInt er st at e10t osout hshor eof Choct aw hat cheeBay
x Hi ghw ay331f r omInt er st at e10t oHi ghw ay54
x Hi ghw ay79f r omFl or i da/ Al abamast at el i net oHi ghw ay30A
x Hi ghw ay109/ 77f r omHi ghw ay231sout hof Dot hant osout hshor eof Nor t hBay
x Hi ghw ay231f r om231/ 431l oopsout hof Dot hant oPanamaCi t ybuf f er zone
x Hi ghw ay319f r omspl i t f r omHi ghw ay61t oHi ghw ay98
028290
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-4 Filed 04/18/12 Page 23 of 23
EXHIBIT 1C
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-5 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-5 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 2
EXHIBIT 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-6 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 17
1
Tour i sm
Tour i sm means busi nesses w hi ch pr ovi de ser vices such as at t r act i ng, t r anspor t i ng, accommodat i ng or
cat er i ng t o t he needs or want s of per sons t r avel i ng t o, or st ayi ng i n, pl aces out si de t hei r home
communi t y. Ther ef or e, i f you ar e i n one of t he f ol l ow i ng busi nesses or wor k f or such a busi ness, you ar e
i n t he Tour i sm Indust r y.
1
447110 - Gasol i ne St at i ons wi t h Conveni ence St or es
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s engaged i n r et ai l i ng aut omot i ve f uel s (e.g., di esel f uel ,
gasohol , gasol i ne) i n combi nat i on w i t h conveni ence st or e or f ood mar t i t ems. These
est abl i shment s can ei t her be i n a conveni ence st or e (i .e., f ood mar t ) set t i ng or a gasol i ne st at i on
set t i ng. These est abl i shment s may al so pr ovi de aut omot i ve r epai r ser vi ces.
Conveni ence f ood w i t h gasol i ne st at i ons
Gasol i ne st at i ons w i t h conveni ence st or es
Gasol i ne w i t h conveni ence st or es
447190 - Ot her Gasol i ne St at i ons
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s know n as gasol i ne st at i ons (except t hose w i t h
conveni ence st or es) pr i mar i l y engaged i n one of t he f ol l ow i ng: (1) r et ai l i ng aut omot i ve f uel s
(e.g., di esel f uel , gasohol , gasol i ne) or (2) r et ai l i ng t hese f uel s i n combi nat i on w i t h act i vi t i es, such
as pr ovi di ng r epai r ser vi ces; sel l i ng aut omot i ve oi l s, r epl acement par t s, and accesso r i es; and/ or
pr ovi di ng f ood ser vi ces.
Gasol i ne st at i ons w i t hout conveni ence st or es
M ar i ne ser vi ce st at i ons
Ser vi ce st at i ons, gasol i ne
Tr uck st ops
448110 - Men' s Cl ot hi ng St or es
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n r et ai l i ng a gener al l i ne of new men' s
and boys' cl ot hi ng. These est abl i shment s may pr ovi de basi c al t er at i ons, such as hemmi ng, t aki ng
i n or l et t i ng out seams, or l engt heni ng or shor t eni ng sl eeves.
Appar el st or es, men' s and boys' cl ot hi ng
Cl ot hi ng st or es, men' s and boys'
448120 - Women' s Cl ot hi ng St or es
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n r et ai l i ng a gener al l i ne of new
women' s, mi sses' ; and j uni or s' cl ot hi ng, i ncl udi ng mat er ni t y w ear . These est abl i shment s may
pr ovi de basi c al t er at i ons, such as hemmi ng, t aki ng i n or l et t i ng out seams, or l engt heni ng or
shor t eni ng sl eeves.
Appar el st or es, w omen' s and gi r l s' cl ot hi ng
Cl ot hi ng st or es, w omen' s and gi r l s'
M at er ni t y shops
448130 - Chi l dr en' s and Inf ant s' Cl ot hi ng St or es
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n r et ai l i ng a gener al l i ne of new
chi l dr en' s and i nf ant s' cl ot hi ng. These est abl i shment s may pr ovi de basi c al t er at i ons, such as
hemmi ng, t aki ng i n or l et t i ng out seams, or l engt heni ng or shor t eni ng sl eeves.
Appar el st or es, chi l dr en' s and i nf ant s' cl ot hi ng
Baby cl ot hi ng shops
Cl ot hi ng st or es, chi l dr en' s and i nf ant s'
1
Thi s Tour i sm Def i ni t i on subst i t ut es f or t he Tour i sm Def i ni t i on pr evi ousl y at Bat es 026632 - 026646.
028973
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-6 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 17
2
448140 - Fami l y Cl ot hi ng St or es
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n r et ai l i ng a gener al l i ne of new
cl ot hi ng f or men, w omen, and chi l dr en, w i t hout speci al i zi ng i n sal es f or an i ndi vi dual gender or
age gr oup. These est abl i shment s may pr ovi de basi c al t er at i ons, such as hemmi ng, t aki ng i n or
l et t i ng out seams, or l engt heni ng or shor t eni ng sl eeves.
Cl ot hi ng st or es, f ami l y
Fami l y cl ot hi ng st or es
Uni sex cl ot hi ng st or es
West er n w ear st or es
448150 - Cl ot hi ng Accessor i es St or es
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n r et ai l i ng si ngl e or combi nat i on l i nes
of new cl ot hi ng accessor i es, such as hat s and caps, cost ume j ew el r y, gl oves, handbags, t i es, w i gs,
t oupees, and bel t s.
Appar el accessor y st or es
Cl ot hi ng accessor i es st or es
Cost ume j ew el r y st or es
Fur ni shi ngs st or es, men' s and boys'
Fur ni shi ngs st or es, w omen' s and gi r l s'
Handbag st or es
Hat and cap st or es
Jewel r y st or es, cost ume
Neckw ear st or es
Ti e shops
Wi g and hai r pi ece st or es
448190 - Ot her Cl ot hi ng St or es
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n r et ai l i ng speci al i zed l i nes of new
cl ot hi ng (except gener al l i nes of men' s, w omen' s, chi l dr en' s, i nf ant s' , and f ami l y cl ot hi ng). These
est abl i shment s may pr ovi de basi c al t er at i ons, such as hemmi ng, t aki ng i n or l et t i ng out seams,
or l engt heni ng or shor t eni ng sl eeves.
Br i dal gow n shops (except cust om)
Coat st or es
Cost ume st or es (i ncl udi ng t heat r i cal )
Dr ess shops
Fur appar el st or es
Fur r i er s
Hosi er y st or es
Leat her coat st or es
Li nger i e st or es
School uni f or m st or es
Sw i mw ear st or es
T-shi r t shops, cust om pr i nt ed
Uni f or m st or es (except at hl et i c)
451110 - Spor t i ng Goods St or es
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n r et ai l i ng new spor t i ng goods, such
as bi cycl es and bi cycl e par t s; campi ng equi pment ; exer ci se and f i t ness equi pment ; at hl et i c
uni f or ms; speci al t y spor t s f oot w ear ; and spor t i ng goods, equi pment , and accessor i es.
At hl et i c equi pment and suppl y st or es (i ncl udi ng uni f or ms)
Bi cycl e (except mot or i zed) shops
Bow l i ng equi pment and suppl y st or es
028974
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-6 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 17
3
Di vi ng equi pment st or es
Exer ci se equi pment st or es
Fi shi ng suppl y st or es (e.g., bai t )
Foot w ear (e.g., bow l i ng, gol f , spi ked), speci al t y spor t s, st or es
Gol f pr o shops
Gun shops
Out door spor t i ng equi pment st or es
Pr o shops (e.g., gol f , ski i ng, t enni s)
Saddl er y st or es
Shoe st or es, speci al t y spor t s f oot w ear (e.g., bow l i ng, gol f , spi ked)
Spor t i ng goods st or es
Spor t s gear st or es (e.g., out door s, scuba, ski i ng)
Tack shops
Tackl e shops (i .e., f i shi ng)
Uni f or m st or es, at hl et i c
452111 - Depar t ment St or es (except Di scount Depar t ment St or es)
Thi s U.S. i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s know n as depar t ment st or es t hat have separ at e
depar t ment s f or var i ous mer chandi se l i nes, such as appar el , j ewel r y, home f ur ni shi ngs, and
l i nens, each w i t h separ at e cash r egi st er s and sal es associ at es. Depar t ment st or es i n t hi s i ndust r y
gener al l y do not have cent r al cust omer checkout and cash r egi st er f aci l i t i es.
Depar t ment st or es (except di scount depar t ment st or es)
452990 - Al l Ot her Gener al Mer chandi se St or es
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n r et ai l i ng new goods i n gener al
mer chandi se st or es (except depar t ment st or es, war ehouse cl ubs, super st or es, and
super cent er s). These est abl i shment s r et ai l a gener al l i ne of new mer chandi se, such as appar el ,
aut omot i ve par t s, dr y goods, har dw ar e, gr ocer i es, housewar es or home f ur ni shi ngs, and ot her
l i nes i n l i mi t ed amount s, w i t h none of t he l i nes pr edomi nat i ng.
Cat al og show r ooms, gener al mer chandi se (except cat al og mai l -or der )
Dol l ar st or es
Gener al st or es
Home and aut o suppl y st or es
Li mi t ed pr i ce var i et y st or es
Tr adi ng post s, gener al mer chandi se
Var i et y st or es
453220 - Gi f t , Novel t y, and Souveni r St or es
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n r et ai l i ng new gi f t s, novel t y
mer chandi se, souveni r s, gr eet i ng car ds, seasonal and hol i day decor at i ons, and cur i os.
Bal l oon shops
Car d shops, gr eet i ng
Chr i st mas st or es
Col l ect i bl e gi f t shops (e.g., cr yst al , pew t er , por cel ai n)
Cr af t (except cr af t suppl y) st or es
Cur i o shops
Gi f t shops
Gi f t st ands, per manent l ocat i on
Gr eet i ng car d shops
Novel t y shops
Par t y goods (e.g., paper suppl i es, decor at i ons, novel t i es) st o r es
Seasonal and hol i day decor at i on st or es
028975
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-6 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 17
4
Souveni r shops
481111 - Schedul ed Passenger Ai r Tr anspor t at i on
Thi s U.S. i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n pr ovi di ng ai r t r anspor t at i on of
passenger s or passenger s and f r ei ght over r egul ar r out es and on r egul ar schedul es.
Est abl i shment s i n t hi s i ndust r y oper at e f l i ght s even i f par t i al l y l oaded. Schedul ed ai r passenger
car r i er s i ncl udi ng commut er and hel i copt er car r i er s (except sceni c and si ght seei ng) ar e i ncl uded
i n t hi s i ndust r y.
Ai r commut er car r i er s, schedul ed
Ai r passenger car r i er s, schedul ed
Commut er ai r car r i er s, schedul ed
Hel i copt er passenger car r i er s, schedul ed
Passenger ai r t r anspor t at i on, schedul ed
Passenger car r i er s, ai r , schedul ed
Schedul ed ai r passenger car r i er s
Schedul ed ai r passenger t r anspor t at i on
485310 - Taxi Ser vi ce
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n pr ovi di ng passenger t r anspor t at i on
by aut omobi l e or van, not oper at ed over r egul ar r out es and on r egul ar schedul es.
Est abl i shment s of t axi cab ow ner / oper at or s, t axi cab f l eet oper at or s, or t axi cab or gani zat i ons ar e
i ncl uded i n t hi s i ndust r y.
Cab (i .e., t axi ) ser vi ces
Taxi cab di spat ch ser vi ces
Taxi cab f l eet oper at or s
Taxi cab or gani zat i ons
Taxi cab owner -oper at or s
Taxi cab ser vi ces
487110 - Sceni c and Si ght seei ng Tr anspor t at i on, Land
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n pr ovi di ng sceni c and si ght seei ng
t r anspor t at i on on l and, such as si ght seei ng buses and t r ol l eys, st eam t r ai n excur si ons, and hor se-
dr aw n si ght seei ng r i des. The ser vi ces pr ovi ded ar e usual l y l ocal and i nvol ve same-day r et ur n t o
pl ace of or i gi n.
Buses, sceni c and si ght seei ng oper at i on
Cabl e car , l and, sceni c and si ght seei ng oper at i on
Car r i age, hor se-dr awn, oper at i on
Cog r ai l way, sceni c and si ght seei ng, oper at i on
Hor se-dr aw n car r i age oper at i on
M onor ai l , sceni c and si ght seei ng, oper at i on
Rai l r oad t r anspor t at i on, sceni c and si ght seei ng
Rai l r oad, sceni c and si ght seei ng, oper at i on
Rai l w ay t r anspor t at i on, sceni c and si ght seei ng
Sceni c and si ght seei ng excur si ons, l and
Si ght seei ng bus oper at i on
Si ght seei ng oper at i on, human-dr awn vehi cl e
St eam t r ai n excur si ons
Tour bus, sceni c and si ght seei ng, oper at i on
Tr acked vehi cl e si ght seei ng oper at i on
Tr ol l ey, sceni c and si ght seei ng, oper at i on
028976
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-6 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 17
5
487210 - Sceni c and Si ght seei ng Tr anspor t at i on, Wat er
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n pr ovi di ng sceni c and si ght seei ng
t r anspor t at i on on w at er , w i t h t he except i on t hat Char t er Fi shi ng, as def i ned i n t he Set t l ement
Agr eement , i s excl uded f r om t hi s Tour i sm def i ni t i on . The ser vi ces pr ovi ded ar e usual l y l ocal and
i nvol ve same-day r et ur n t o place of or i gi n.
Ai r boat (i .e., swamp buggy) oper at i on
Di nner cr ui ses
Excur si on boat oper at i on
Har bor si ght seei ng t our s
Hover cr af t si ght seei ng oper at i on
Sceni c and si ght seei ng excur si ons, w at er
Si ght seei ng boat oper at i on
Swamp buggy oper at i on
Whal e w at chi ng excur si ons
487990 - Sceni c and Si ght seei ng Tr anspor t at i on, Ot her
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n pr ovi di ng sceni c and si ght seei ng
t r anspor t at i on (except on l and and w at er ). The ser vi ces pr ovi ded ar e usual l y l ocal and i nvol ve
same-day r et ur n t o pl ace of depar t ur e.
Aer i al cabl e car , sceni c and si ght seei ng, oper at i on
Aer i al t r amw ay, sceni c and si ght seei ng, oper at i on
Gl i der excur si ons
Hel i copt er r i de, sceni c and si ght seei ng, oper at i on
Hot ai r bal l oon r i de, sceni c and si ght seei ng, oper at i on
Sceni c and si ght seei ng excur si ons, aer i al
Tr amw ay, aer i al , sceni c and si ght seei ng oper at i on
532111 - Passenger Car Rent al
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n r ent i ng passenger car s w i t hout
dr i ver s, gener al l y f or shor t per i ods of t i me.
Aut omobi l e r ent al
Car r ent al
Car r ent al agenci es
Hear se r ent al
Li mousi ne r ent al w i t hout dr i ver
Luxur y aut omobi l e r ent al
Passenger car r ent al
Passenger van r ent al
Passenger van r ent al agenci es
Spor t ut i l i t y vehi cl e r ent al
Van (passenger ) r ent al
532292 - Recr eat i onal Goods Rent al
Thi s U.S. i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n r ent i ng r ecr eat i onal goods,
such as bi cycl es, canoes, mot or cycl es, ski s, sai l boat s, beach chai r s, and beach umbr el l as.
Beach chai r r ent al
Beach umbr el l a r ent al
Bi cycl e r ent al
Boat r ent al , pl easur e
Canoe r ent al
028977
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-6 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 17
6
Exer ci se equi pment r ent al
Gol f car t r ent al
Houseboat r ent al
M oped r ent al
M ot or cycl e r ent al
Per sonal w at er cr af t r ent al
Pl easur e boat r ent al
Recr eat i onal goods r ent al
Row boat r ent al
Sai l boat r ent al
Ski equi pment r ent al
Snow ski equi pment r ent al
Spor t i ng goods r ent al
Spor t s equi pment r ent al
Sur f boar d r ent al
Tent , campi ng, r ent al
Wat er ski r ent al
Yacht r ent al w i t hout cr ew
561520 - Tour Oper at or s
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n ar r angi ng and assembl i ng t our s. The
t our s ar e sol d t hr ough t r avel agenci es or t our oper at or s. Tr avel or whol esal e t our oper at or s ar e
i ncl uded i n t hi s i ndust r y.
Tour oper at or s (i .e., ar r angi ng and assembl i ng t our s)
Tr avel t our oper at or s
Whol esal e t our oper at or s
561599 - Al l Ot her Tr avel Ar r angement and Reser vat i on Ser vi ces
Thi s U.S. i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s (except t r avel agenci es, t our oper at or s, and
convent i on and vi si t or s bur eaus) pr i mar i l y engaged i n pr ovi di ng t r avel ar r angement and
r eser vat i on ser vi ces. Il l ust r at i ve Exampl es: Condomi ni um t i me-shar e exchange ser vi ces Ti cket
(e.g., ai r l i ne, bus, cr ui se shi p, spor t s, t heat r i cal ) of f i ces Reser vat i on (e.g., ai r l i ne, car r ent al , hot el ,
r est aur ant ) ser vi ces Ti cket (e.g., amusement , spor t s, t heat r i cal ) agenci es Road and t r avel
ser vi ces aut omobi l e cl ubs.
Ai r l i ne r eser vat i on ser vi ces
Ai r l i ne t i cket of f i ces
Aut omobi l e cl ubs, r oad and t r avel ser vi ces
Bus t i cket of f i ces
Car r ent al r eser vat i on ser vi ces
Condomi ni um t i me shar e exchange ser vi ces
Cr ui se shi p t i cket of f i ces
Hot el r eser vat i on ser vi ces
M ot or t r avel cl ubs
Rai l r oad t i cket of f i ces
Reser vat i on (e.g., ai r l i ne, car r ent al , hot el , r est aur ant ) ser vi ces
Spor t s t i cket of f i ces
Theat r i cal t i cket of f i ces
Ti cket (e.g., ai r l i ne, bus, cr ui se shi p, spor t s, t heat r i cal ) of f i ces
Ti cket (e.g., ai r l i ne, bus, cr ui se shi p, spor t s, t heat r i cal ) sal es of f i ces
Ti cket (e.g., amusement , spor t s, t heat r i cal ) agenci es
Ti cket (e.g., amusement , spor t s, t heat r i cal ) sal es agenci es
028978
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-6 Filed 04/18/12 Page 7 of 17
7
Ti cket agenci es, amusement
Ti cket agenci es, spor t s
Ti cket agenci es, t heat r i cal
Ti cket of f i ces f or f or ei gn cr ui se shi p compani es
Ti me shar e exchange ser vi ces, condomi ni um
711211 - Spor t s Teams and Cl ubs
Thi s U.S. i ndust r y compr i ses pr of essi onal or semi pr of essi onal spor t s t eams or cl ubs pr i mar i l y
engaged i n par t i ci pat i ng i n l i ve spor t i ng event s, such as basebal l , basket bal l , f oot bal l , hockey,
soccer , and j ai al ai games, bef or e a payi ng audi ence. These est abl i shment s may or may not
oper at e t hei r ow n ar ena, st adi um, or ot her f aci l i t y f or pr esent i ng t h ese event s.
Basebal l cl ubs, pr of essi onal or semi pr of essi onal
Basebal l t eams, pr of essi onal or semi pr of essi onal
Basket bal l cl ubs, pr of essi onal or semi pr of essi onal
Basket bal l t eams, pr of essi onal or semi pr of essi onal
Boxi ng cl ubs, pr of essi onal or semi pr of essi onal
Foot bal l cl ubs, pr of essi onal or semi pr of essi onal
Foot bal l t eams, pr of essi onal or semi pr of essi onal
Hockey cl ubs, pr of essi onal or semi pr of essi onal
Hockey t eams, pr of essi onal or semi pr of essi onal
Ice hockey cl ubs, pr of essi onal or semi pr of essi onal
Jai al ai t eams, pr of essi onal or semi pr of essi onal
M aj or l eague basebal l cl ubs
M i nor l eague basebal l cl ubs
Pr of essi onal basebal l cl ubs
Pr of essi onal f oot bal l cl ubs
Pr of essi onal spor t s cl ubs
Rol l er hockey cl ubs, pr of essi onal or semi pr of essi onal
Semi pr of essi onal basebal l cl ubs
Semi pr of essi onal f oot bal l cl ubs
Semi pr of essi onal spor t s cl ubs
Soccer cl ubs, pr of essi onal or semi pr of essi onal
Soccer t eams, pr of essi onal or semi pr of essi onal
Spor t s cl ubs, pr of essi onal or semi pr of essi onal
Spor t s t eams, pr of essi onal or semi pr of essi onal
712110 - Museums
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n t he pr eser vat i on and exhi bi t i on of
obj ect s of hi st or i cal , cul t ur al , and/ or ed ucat i onal val ue.
Ar t gal l er i es (except r et ai l )
Ar t museums
Communi t y museums
Cont empor ar y ar t museums
Decor at i ve ar t museums
Fi ne ar t s museums
Gal l er i es, ar t (except r et ai l )
Hal l s of f ame
Her bar i ums
Hi st or i cal museums
Human hi st or y museums
Int er act i ve museums
028979
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-6 Filed 04/18/12 Page 8 of 17
8
M ar i ne museums
M i l i t ar y museums
M obi l e museums
M ul t i di sci pl i nar y museums
M useums
Nat ur al hi st or y museums
Nat ur al sci ence museums
Obser vat or i es (except r esear ch i nst i t ut i ons)
Pl anet ar i ums
Sci ence and t echnol ogy museums
Spor t s hal l s of f ame
Tr avel i ng museum exhi bi t s
War museums
Wax museums
712120 - Hi st or i cal Si t es
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n t he pr eser vat i on and exh i bi t i on of
si t es, bui l di ngs, f or t s, or communi t i es t hat descr i be event s or per sons of par t i cul ar hi st or i cal
i nt er est . Ar cheol ogi cal si t es, bat t l ef i el ds, hi st or i cal shi ps, and pi oneer vi l l ages ar e i ncl uded i n t hi s
i ndust r y.
Ar cheol ogi cal si t es (i .e., publ i c di spl ay)
Bat t l ef i el ds
Her i t age vi l l ages
Hi st or i cal f or t s
Hi st or i cal shi ps
Hi st or i cal si t es
Pi oneer vi l l ages
712130 - Zoos and Bot ani cal Gar dens
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n t he pr eser vat i on and exhi bi t i on of
l i ve pl ant and ani mal l i f e di spl ays.
Ani mal exhi bi t s, l i ve
Ani mal saf ar i par ks
Aquar i ums
Ar bor et a
Ar bor et ums
Avi ar i es
Bot ani cal gar dens
Conser vat or i es, bot ani cal
Gar dens, zool ogi cal or bot ani cal
M enager i es
Par ks, w i l d ani mal
Pet t i ng zoos
Rept i l e exhi bi t s, l i ve
Wi l d ani mal par ks
Zool ogi cal gar dens
Zoos
712190 - Nat ur e Par ks and Ot her Si mi l ar Inst i t ut i ons
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n t he pr eser vat i on and exhi bi t i on of
nat ur al ar eas or set t i ngs.
Bi r d sanct uar i es
028980
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-6 Filed 04/18/12 Page 9 of 17
9
Caver ns (i .e., nat ur al w onder t our i st at t r act i ons)
Conser vat i on ar eas
Int er pr et i ve cent er s, nat ur e
Nat i onal par ks
Nat ur al w onder t our i st at t r act i ons (e.g., caver ns, w at er f al l s)
Nat ur e cent er s
Nat ur e par ks
Nat ur e pr eser ves
Nat ur e r eser ves
Par ks, nat i onal
Par ks, nat ur e
Pr ovi nci al par ks
Wat er f al l s (i .e., nat ur al w onder t our i st at t r act i ons)
Wi l dl i f e sanct uar i es
713110 - Amusement and Theme Par ks
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s, know n as amusement or t heme par ks, pr i mar i l y
engaged i n oper at i ng a var i et y of at t r act i ons, such as mechani cal r i des, w at er r i des, games,
show s, t heme exhi bi t s, r ef r eshment st ands, and pi cni c gr ounds. These est abl i shment s may l ease
space t o ot her s on a concessi on basi s.
Amusement par ks (e.g., t heme, w at er )
Par ks (e.g., t heme, w at er ), amusement
Pi er s, amusement
Theme par ks, amusement
Wat er par ks, amusement
713120 - Amusement Ar cades
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n oper at i ng amusement (except
gambl i ng, bi l l i ar d, or pool ) ar cades and par l or s.
Amusement ar cades
Amusement devi ce (except gambl i ng) par l or s, coi n -oper at ed
Amusement devi ces (except gambl i ng) oper at ed i n ow n f aci l i t i es
Ar cades, amusement
El ect r oni c game ar cades
Fami l y f un cent er s
Indoor pl ay ar eas
Pi nbal l ar cades
Vi deo game ar cades (except gambl i ng)
713910 - Gol f Cour ses and Count r y Cl ubs
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses (1) est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n oper at i ng gol f cour ses (except
mi ni at ur e) and (2) est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n oper at i ng gol f cour ses, al ong w i t h di ni ng
f aci l i t i es and ot her r ecr eat i onal f aci l i t i es t hat ar e know n as count r y cl ubs. These est abl i shment s
of t en pr ovi de f ood and bever age ser vi ces, equi pment r ent al ser vi ces, and gol f i nst r uct i on
ser vi ces.
Count r y cl ubs
Gol f and count r y cl ubs
Gol f cour ses (except mi ni at ur e, pi t ch-n-put t )
028981
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-6 Filed 04/18/12 Page 10 of 17
10
713990 - Al l Ot her Amusement and Recr eat i on Indust r i es
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s (except amusement par ks and ar cades; gambl i ng
i ndust r i es; gol f cour ses and count r y cl ubs; ski i ng f aci l i t i es; mar i nas; f i t ness and r ecr eat i onal
spor t s cent er s; and bow l i ng cent er s) pr i mar i l y engaged i n pr ovi di ng r ecr eat i onal and amusement
ser vi ces.
Amat eur spor t s t eams, r ecr eat i onal
Amusement devi ce (except gambl i ng) concessi on oper at or s (i .e., suppl yi ng and
ser vi ci ng i n ot her s' f aci l i t i es)
Amusement r i de concessi on oper at or s (i .e., supp l yi ng and ser vi ci ng i n ot her s'
f aci l i t i es)
Ar cher y r anges
At hl et i c cl ubs (i .e., spor t s t eams) not oper at i ng spor t s f aci l i t i es, r ecr eat i onal
Avi at i on cl ubs, r ecr eat i onal
Bal l r ooms
Basebal l cl ubs, r ecr eat i onal
Basket bal l cl ubs, r ecr eat i onal
Bat hi ng beaches
Beach cl ubs, r ecr eat i onal
Beaches, bat hi ng
Bi l l i ar d par l or s
Bi l l i ar d r ooms
Boat i ng cl ubs w i t hout mar i nas
Bocci e bal l cour t s
Bow l i ng l eagues or t eams, r ecr eat i onal
Boxi ng cl ubs, r ecr eat i onal
Boys' day camps (except i nst r uct i onal )
Br i dge cl ubs, r ecr eat i onal
Camps (except i nst r uct i onal ), day
Canoei ng, r ecr eat i onal
Car ni val r i de concessi on oper at or s (i .e., suppl yi ng and ser vi ci ng i n ot her s' f aci l i t i es)
Coi n-oper at ed nongambl i ng amusement devi ce concessi on oper at or s (i .e., suppl yi ng
and ser vi ci ng i n ot her s' f aci l i t i es)
Concessi on oper at or s, amusement devi ce (except gambl i ng) and r i de
Cur l i ng f aci l i t i es
Dance hal l s
Di scot heques (except t hose ser vi ng al cohol i c bever ages)
Dr i vi ng r anges, gol f
Fi r ew or ks di spl ay ser vi ces
Fi shi ng cl ubs, r ecr eat i onal
Fi shi ng gui de ser vi ces
Fi shi ng pi er s
Fl yi ng cl ubs, r ecr eat i onal
Foot bal l cl ubs, r ecr eat i onal
Gal l er i es, shoot i ng
Gi r l s' day camps (except i n st r uct i onal )
Gocar t r acew ays (i .e., amusement r i des)
028982
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-6 Filed 04/18/12 Page 11 of 17
11
Gocar t t r acks (i .e., amusement r i des)
Gol f cour ses, mi ni at ur e
Gol f cour ses, pi t ch-n-put t
Gol f dr i vi ng r anges
Gol f pr act i ce r anges
Gui de ser vi ces (i .e., f i shi ng, hunt i ng, t our i st )
Gui de ser vi ces, f i shi ng
Gui de ser vi ces, hunt i ng
Gui de ser vi ces, t our i st
Gun cl ubs, r ecr eat i onal
Hockey cl ubs, r ecr eat i onal
Hockey t eams, r ecr eat i onal
Hor se r ent al ser vi ces, r ecr eat i onal saddl e
Hor seback r i di ng, r ecr eat i onal
Hunt i ng cl ubs, r ecr eat i onal
Hunt i ng gui de ser vi ces
Ice hockey cl ubs, r ecr eat i onal
Jukebox concessi on oper at or s (i .e., suppl yi ng and ser vi ci ng i n ot her s' f aci l i t i es)
Kayaki ng, r ecr eat i onal
Law n bow l i ng cl ubs
M i ni at ur e gol f cour ses
M ount ai n hi ki ng, r ecr eat i onal
Ni ght cl ubs w i t hout al cohol i c bever ages
Nudi st camps w i t hout accommodat i ons
Obser vat i on t ower s
Out door advent ur e oper at i ons (e.g., w hi t e w at er r af t i ng) w i t hout accommodat i ons
Pack t r ai ns (i .e., t r ai l r i di ng), r ecr eat i onal
Par a sai l i ng, r ecr eat i onal
Pi cni c gr ounds
Pi nbal l machi ne concessi on oper at or s (i .e., suppl yi ng and ser vi ci ng i n ot her s' f aci l i t i es)
Pi ng pong par l or s
Pool hal l s
Pool par l or s
Pool r ooms
Racet r acks, sl ot car (i .e., amusement devi ces)
Racew ays, gocar t (i .e., amusement r i des)
Recr eat i onal camps w i t hout accommodat i ons
Recr eat i onal day camps (except i nst r uct i onal )
Recr eat i onal spor t s cl ubs (i .e., spor t s t eams) not oper at i ng spor t s f aci l i t i es
Recr eat i onal spor t s t eams and l eagues
Ri di ng cl ubs, r ecr eat i onal
Ri di ng st abl es
Ri f l e cl ubs, r ecr eat i onal
Ri ver r af t i ng, r ecr eat i onal
Row i ng cl ubs, r ecr eat i onal
Saddl e hor se r ent al ser vi ces, r ecr eat i onal
Sai l i ng cl ubs w i t hout mar i nas
Sea kayaki ng, r ecr eat i onal
028983
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-6 Filed 04/18/12 Page 12 of 17
12
Shoot i ng cl ubs, r ecr eat i onal
Shoot i ng gal l er i es
Shoot i ng r anges
Skeet shoot i ng f aci l i t i es
Sl ot car r acet r acks (i .e., amusement devi ces)
Snow mobi l i ng, r ecr eat i onal
Soccer cl ubs, r ecr eat i onal
Spor t s cl ubs (i .e., spor t s t eams) not oper at i ng spor t s f aci l i t i es, r ecr eat i onal
Spor t s t eams and l eagues, r ecr eat i onal or yout h
St abl es, r i di ng
Summer day camps (except i nst r uct i onal )
Tour i st gui de ser vi ces
Tr ai l r i di ng, r ecr eat i onal
Tr ampol i ne f aci l i t i es, r ecr eat i onal
Tr apshoot i ng f aci l i t i es, r ecr eat i onal
Wat er sl i des (i .e., amusement r i des)
Whi t e w at er r af t i ng, r ecr eat i onal
Yacht cl ubs w i t hout mar i nas
Yout h spor t s l eagues or t eams
721110 - Hot el s (except Casi no Hot el s) and Mot el s
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n pr ovi di ng shor t -t er m l odgi ng i n
f aci l i t i es know n as hot el s, mot or hot el s, r esor t hot el s, and mot el s. The est abl i shment s i n t hi s
i ndust r y may of f er f ood and bever age ser vi ces, r ecr eat i onal ser vi ces, conf er ence r ooms and
convent i on ser vi ces, l aundr y ser vi ces, par ki ng, and ot her ser vi ces.
Al pi ne ski i ng f aci l i t i es w i t h accommodat i ons (i .e., ski r esor t )
Aut o cour t s, l odgi ng
Aut omobi l e cour t s, l odgi ng
Heal t h spas (i .e., physi cal f i t ness f aci l i t i es) w i t h accommodat i ons
Hot el management ser vi ces (i .e., pr ovi di ng management and oper at i ng st af f t o r un
hot el )
Hot el s (except casi no hot el s)
Hot el s (except casi no hot el s) w i t h gol f cour ses, t enni s cour t s, and/ or ot her heal t h spa
f aci l i t i es (i .e., r esor t s)
Hot el s, member shi p
Hot el s, r esor t , w i t hout casi nos
Hot el s, seasonal , w i t hout casi nos
M ember shi p hot el s
M ot el s
M ot or cour t s
M ot or hot el s w i t hout casi nos
M ot or i nns
M ot or l odges
Resor t hot el s w i t hout casi nos
Seasonal hot el s w i t hout casi nos
Ski l odges and r esor t s w i t h accommodat i ons
Summer r esor t hot el s w i t hout casi nos
Tour i st l odges
028984
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-6 Filed 04/18/12 Page 13 of 17
13
721191 - Bed-and-Br eakf ast Inns
Thi s U.S. i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n pr ovi di ng shor t -t er m l odgi ng i n
f aci l i t i es know n as bed -and-br eakf ast i nns. These est abl i shment s pr ovi de shor t -t er m l odgi ng i n
pr i vat e homes or smal l bui l di ngs conver t ed f or t hi s pur pose. Bed -and-br eakf ast i nns ar e
char act er i zed by a hi ghl y per sonal i zed ser vi ce and i ncl usi on of a f ul l br eakf ast i n a r oom r at e.
Bed and br eakf ast i nns
Inns, bed and br eakf ast
721199 - Al l Ot her Tr avel er Accommodat i on
Thi s U.S. i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n pr ovi di ng shor t -t er m l odgi ng
(except hot el s, mot el s, casi no hot el s, and bed -and-br eakf ast i nns).
Cabi ns, housekeepi ng
Cot t ages, housekeepi ng
Guest houses
Host el s
Housekeepi ng cabi ns
Housekeepi ng cot t ages
Tour i st homes
Yout h host el s
721211 - RV (Recr eat i onal Vehi cl e) Par ks and Campgr ounds
Thi s U.S. i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n oper at i ng si t es t o
accommodat e camper s and t hei r equi pment , i ncl udi ng t ent s, t ent t r ai l er s, t r avel t r ai l er s, and RVs
(r ecr eat i onal vehi cl es). These est abl i shment s may pr ovi de access t o f aci l i t i es, such as
washr ooms, l aundr y r ooms, r ecr eat i on hal l s and pl aygr ounds, st or es, and snack bar s.
Campgr ounds
Recr eat i onal vehi cl e par ks
RV (r ecr eat i onal vehi cl e) par ks
Tr avel t r ai l er campsi t es
721214 - Recr eat i onal and Vacat i on Camps (except Campgr ounds)
Thi s U.S. i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n oper at i ng over ni ght
r ecr eat i onal camps, such as chi l dr en' s camps, f ami l y vacat i on camps, hunt i ng and f i shi ng camps,
and out door advent ur e r et r eat s t hat of f er t r ai l r i di ng, w hi t e-wat er r af t i ng, hi ki ng, and si mi l ar
act i vi t i es. These est abl i shment s pr ovi de accommodat i on f aci l i t i es, such as cabi ns and f i xed
campsi t es, and ot her ameni t i es, such as f ood ser vi ces, r ecr eat i onal f aci l i t i es and equi pment , and
or gani zed r ecr eat i onal act i vi t i es.
Boys' camps (except day, i nst r uct i onal )
Camps (except day, i nst r uct i onal )
Chi l dr en' s camps (except day, i nst r uct i onal )
Dude r anches
Fi shi ng camps w i t h accommodat i on f aci l i t i es
Gi r l s' camps (except day, i nst r uct i onal )
Guest r anches w i t h accommodat i on f aci l i t i es
Hunt i ng camps w i t h accommodat i on f aci l i t i es
Nudi st camps w i t h accommodat i on f aci l i t i es
Out door advent ur e r et r eat s w i t h accommodat i on f aci l i t i es
Recr eat i onal camps w i t h accommodat i on f aci l i t i es (except campgr ounds)
Summer camps (except day, i nst r uct i onal )
Tr ai l r i di ng camps w i t h accommodat i on f aci l i t i es
028985
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-6 Filed 04/18/12 Page 14 of 17
14
Vacat i on camps (except campgr ounds, day i nst r uct i onal )
Wi l der ness camps
721310 - Roomi ng and Boar ding Houses
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n oper at i ng r oomi ng and boar di ng
houses and si mi l ar f aci l i t i es, such as f r at er ni t y houses, sor or i t y houses, of f -campus dor mi t or i es,
r esi dent i al cl ubs, and w or ker s' camps. These est abl i shment s pr ovi de t empor ar y or l onger -t er m
accommodat i ons w hi ch, f or t he per i od of occupancy, may ser ve as a pr i nci pal r esi dence. These
est abl i shment s al so may pr ovi de compl ement ar y ser vi ces, such as housekeepi ng, meal s, and
l aundr y ser vi ces.
Boar di ng houses
Cl ubs, r esi dent i al
Dor mi t or i es, of f campus
Fr at er ni t y houses
M i gr ant w or ker s' camps
Of f campus dor mi t or i es
Resi dence cl ubs, or gani zat i onal
Resi dent i al cl ubs
Roomi ng and boar di ng houses
Sor or i t y houses
Wor ker s' camps
Wor ker s' dor mi t or i es
722110 - Ful l -Ser vi ce Rest aur ant s
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n pr ovi di ng f ood ser vi ces t o pat r ons
w ho or der and ar e ser ved w hi l e seat ed (i .e. w ai t er / wai t r ess ser vi ce) and pay af t er eat i ng. These
est abl i shment s may pr ovi de t hi s t ype of f ood ser vi ces t o pat r ons i n combi nat i on w i t h sel l i ng
al cohol i c bever ages, pr ovi di ng car r y out ser vi ces, or pr esent i ng l i ve nont heat r i cal ent er t ai nment .
Bagel shops, f ul l ser vi ce
Di ner s, f ul l ser vi ce
Doughnut shops, f ul l ser vi ce
Fami l y r est aur ant s, f ul l ser vi ce
Fi ne di ni ng r est aur ant s, f ul l ser vi ce
Ful l ser vi ce r est aur ant s
Pi zza par l or s, f ul l ser vi ce
Pi zzer i as, f ul l ser vi ce
Rest aur ant s, f ul l ser vi ce
St eak houses, f ul l ser vi ce
722211 - Li mi t ed-Ser vi ce Rest aur ant s
Thi s U.S. i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n pr ovi di ng f ood ser vi ces (except
snack and nonal cohol i c bever age bar s) w her e pat r ons gener al l y or der or sel ect i t ems and pay
bef or e eat i ng. Food and dr i nk may be consumed on pr emi ses, t aken out , or del i ver ed t o t he
cust omer ' s l ocat i on. Some est abl i shment s i n t hi s i ndust r y may pr ovi de t hese f ood ser vi ces i n
combi nat i on w i t h sel l i ng al cohol i c bever ages.
Car r yout r est aur ant s
Del i cat essen r est aur ant s
Dr i ve-i n r est aur ant s
Fami l y r est aur ant s, l i mi t ed-ser vi ce
Fast -f ood r est aur ant s
Pi zza del i ver y shops
Pi zza par l or s, l i mi t ed-ser vi ce
028986
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-6 Filed 04/18/12 Page 15 of 17
15
Pi zzer i as, l i mi t ed-ser vi ce (e.g., t ake-out )
Rest aur ant s, car r yout
Rest aur ant s, f ast f ood
Sandwi ch shops, l i mi t ed-ser vi ce
St eak houses, l i mi t ed-ser vi ce
Take out eat i ng pl aces
722213 - Snack and Nonal cohol i c Bever age Bar s
Thi s U.S. i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n (1) pr epar i ng and/ or ser vi ng a
speci al t y snack, such as i ce cr eam, f r ozen yogur t , cooki es, or popcor n or (2) ser vi ng nonal cohol i c
bever ages, such as cof f ee, j ui ces, or sodas f or consumpt i on on or near t he pr emi ses. These
est abl i shment s may car r y and sel l a combi nat i on of snack, nonal cohol i c bever age, and ot her
r el at ed pr oduct s (e.g., cof f ee beans, mugs, cof f ee maker s) but gener al l y pr omot e and sel l a
uni que snack or nonal cohol i c bever age.
Bagel shops, on pr emi se baki ng and car r yout ser vi ce
Bever age (e.g., cof f ee, j ui ce, sof t dr i nk) bar s, nonal cohol i c, f i xed l ocat i on
Cant eens, f i xed l ocat i on
Cof f ee shops, on pr emi se br ewi ng
Conf ect i oner y snack shops, made on pr emi ses w i t h car r yout ser vi ces
Cooki e shops, on pr emi se baki ng and car r yout ser vi ce
Doughnut shops, on pr emi se baki ng and car r yout ser vi ce
Fi xed l ocat i on r ef r eshment st ands
Fr ozen cust ar d st ands, f i xed l ocat i on
Ice cr eam par l or s
Pr et zel shops, on pr emi se baki ng and car r yout ser vi ce
Snack bar s (e.g., cooki es, popcor n, pr et zel s), f i xed l ocat i on
Sof t dr i nk bever age bar s, nonal cohol i c, f i xed l ocat i on
722310 - Food Ser vi ce Cont r act or s
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n pr ovi di ng f ood ser vi ces at
i nst i t ut i onal , gover nment al , commer ci al , or i ndust r i al l ocat i ons of ot her s based on cont r act ual
ar r angement s w i t h t hese t ype of or gani zat i ons f or a speci f i ed per i od of t i me. The est abl i shment s
of t hi s i ndust r y pr ovi de f ood ser vi ces f or t he conveni ence of t he cont r act i ng or gani zat i on or t he
cont r act i ng or gani zat i on' s cust omer s. The cont r act ual ar r angement of t hese est abl i shment s w i t h
cont r act i ng or gani zat i ons may var y f r om t ype of f aci l i t y oper at ed (e.g., caf et er i a, r est aur ant ,
f ast -f ood eat i ng pl ace), r evenue shar i ng, cost st r uct ur e, t o pr ovi di n g per sonnel . M anagement
st af f i s al w ays pr ovi ded by t he f ood ser vi ce cont r act or s.
Ai r l i ne f ood ser vi ces cont r act or s
Caf et er i a f ood ser vi ces cont r act or s (e.g., gover nment of f i ce caf et er i as, hospi t al
caf et er i as, school caf et er i as)
Food concessi on cont r act or s (e.g., convent i on f aci l i t i es, ent er t ai nment f aci l i t i es,
spor t i ng f aci l i t i es)
Food ser vi ce cont r act or s, ai r l i ne
Food ser vi ce cont r act or s, caf et er i a
Food ser vi ce cont r act or s, concessi on oper at or (e.g., convent i on f aci l i t i es,
ent er t ai nment f aci l i t i es, spor t i ng f aci l i t i es)
Indust r i al cat er er s (i .e., pr ovi di ng f ood ser vi ces on a cont r act ur al ar r angement (except
si ngl e-event basi s))
028987
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-6 Filed 04/18/12 Page 16 of 17
16
722410 - Dr i nki ng Pl aces (Al cohol i c Bever ages)
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s known as b ar s, t aver ns, ni ght cl ubs, or dr i nki ng pl aces
pr i mar i l y engaged i n pr epar i ng and ser vi ng al cohol i c bever ages f or i mmedi at e consumpt i on.
These est abl i shment s may al so pr ovi de l i mi t ed f ood ser vi ces.
Al cohol i c bever age dr i nki ng pl aces
Bar s (i .e., dr i nki ng pl aces), al cohol i c bever age
Cockt ai l l ounges
Dr i nki ng pl aces (i .e., bar s, l ounges, t aver ns), al cohol i c
Lounges, cockt ai l
Ni ght cl ubs, al cohol i c bever age
Taver ns (i .e., dr i nki ng pl aces)
028988
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-6 Filed 04/18/12 Page 17 of 17
EXHIBIT 3
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-7 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 6
ATTACHMENT A - SEAFOOD DISTRIBUTION CHAIN DEFINITIONS
Seafood shall be defined as fish and shellfish, including shrimp, oysters, crab, and finfish, caught in the
Specified Waters of the Gulf of Mexico. Seafood shall exclude menhaden.
This document shall establish Seafood distribution chain definitions, as set forth below:
1. Commercial Fishermen, Seafood Crew, Oyster Leaseholders and Seafood Vessel Owners
Economic loss claims by Commercial Fishermen, Seafood Crew, Oyster Leaseholders and
Seafood Vessel Owners shall be governed by the Seafood Program.
Definitions for Commercial Fisherman, Seafood Crew, Oyster Leaseholder and Seafood Vessel
Owner are set forth below:
a. Commercial Fisherman shall be defined as a Natural Person or entity that holds a
commercial fishing license issued by the United States and/or the State(s) of Alabama,
Florida, Louisiana, Mississippi and/or Texas and derives income from catching and selling
Seafood that he caught. The following additional definitions are relevant with regard to the
Commercial Fisherman definition:
i. Shrimp Fisherman shall be defined as a Commercial Fisherman that catches shrimp.
ii. Oyster Harvester shall be defined as a Commercial Fisherman that harvests oysters.
iii. Crab Fisherman shall be defined as a Commercial Fisherman that catches crab.
iv. Finfish Fisherman shall be defined as a Commercial Fisherman that catches finfish.
b. Seafood Crew shall be defined as the Seafood Boat Captain, Seafood First Mate,
Seafood Second Mate, Seafood Boatswain, Seafood Deckhand, working for a
Commercial Fisherman.
i. Seafood Boat Captain shall be defined as a Natural Person who owns or operates a
Commercial Fishing vessel. In addition, the Seafood Boat Captain may plan and
oversee the fishing operation, the fish to be sought, the location of the best fishing
grounds, the method of capture, the duration of the trip, and the sale of the catch. A
person with the job of skipper will be considered to satisfy this definition.
ii. Seafood First Mate shall be defined as a Natural Person who assists a Seafood Boat
Captain and assumes control of the Commercial Fishing vessel when the Seafood
Boat Captain is off duty, and who assists in directing the fishing operations and sailing
responsibilities of the Seafood Deckhands, including the operation, maintenance, and
repair of the vessel and the gathering, preservation, stowing, and unloading of the catch.
iii. Seafood Second Mate shall be defined as a Natural Person who assists in performing
the duties of a Seafood First Mate.
028950
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-7 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 6
iv. Seafood Boatswain shall be defined as a Natural Person who is a highly skilled
Seafood Deckhand with supervisory responsibilities on a Commercial Fishing vessel,
and who directs the Seafood Deckhands as they carry out sailing and fishing
operations.
v. Seafood Deckhand shall be defined as a Natural Person who provides services on
marine vessels (not personally owned or leased) to any type of Commercial Fisherman,
including, but not limited to, the following:
1. Operating fishing gear;
2. Letting out and pulling in nets and lines;
3. Extracting the catch;
4. Washing, salting, icing and stowing the catch;
5. Ensuring the decks are clear and clean at all times;
6. Loading equipment and supplies prior to departure; and/or
7. Unloading the catch.
c. An Oyster Leaseholder shall be defined as a Natural Person or entity that is a lessee
holding one or more private oyster leases.
d. Seafood Vessel Owner shall be defined as a Natural Person or entity that owns a vessel
and earns income from leasing or renting that vessel to a Commercial Fisherman and/or
Oyster Leaseholder. A Seafood Vessel Owner may also be a Commercial Fisherman
and/or an Oyster Leaseholder.
2. Primary Seafood Industry
The Primary Seafood Industry shall be comprised of entities and Natural Persons that satisfy the
definitions of Landing Site, Commercial Wholesale or Retail Dealer A, and Primary Seafood
Processor, and Natural Persons employed by a Landing Site, Commercial Wholesale or Retail
Dealer A, or Primary Seafood Processor, including Seafood Dockside Workers.
Economic loss claims by entities and Natural Persons claiming losses related to business income
required to be reported on Internal Revenue Service Form 1040 Schedules C, E or F, and that satisfy
the Primary Seafood Industry definition above shall be compensated pursuant to the
Compensation Framework for Business Economic Loss Claims.
Economic loss claims by Individuals satisfying the Primary Seafood Industry definition above shall
be compensated pursuant to the Framework for Individual Economic Loss Claims.
Definitions of Landing Site, Commercial Wholesale or Retail Dealer A, Primary Seafood
Processor, and Seafood Dockside Worker are set forth below:
a. Landing Site shall be defined as a business at which boats first land their catch, including
facilities for unloading and handling Seafood. A landing site may also include the provision
of ice, fresh water fuel and boat repair or service in connection with the landing of Seafood.
The following additional definition is relevant with regard to Landing Site:
i. Seafood Dockside Worker shall be a Natural Person performing services for a Landing
028951
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-7 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 6
Site.
b. Commercial Wholesale or Retail Dealer A shall be defined as an entity or Natural Person
that holds a commercial wholesale or retail dealer license issued by the State(s) of Alabama,
Florida, Louisiana, Mississippi and/or Texas for which 75% or more of the 2009 cost or weight
in pounds of the product it purchases constitutes Seafood purchased directly from
Commercial Fisherman or Landing Site and re-sells to Primary Seafood Processors,
Seafood Distributors, Seafood Wholesalers and Seafood Retailers.
c. Primary Seafood Processor shall be defined as an entity or Natural Person that receives
and prepares Seafood purchased from a Commercial Fisherman, Landing Site, or
Commercial Wholesale or Retail Dealer including, but not limited to, cleaning, cooking,
canning, smoking, salting, drying or freezing, grading by size, packing storing Seafood for
shipment.
3. Secondary Seafood Industry
The Secondary Seafood Industry shall be comprised of entities that satisfy the definitions of
Commercial Wholesale or Retail Dealer B, Secondary Seafood Processor, Seafood Wholesaler
or Distributor, and Seafood Retailer, and Natural Persons employed by a Commercial Wholesale
or Retail Dealer B, Secondary Seafood Processor, Seafood Wholesaler or Distributor, or
Seafood Retailer.
Economic loss claims by entities and Natural Persons claiming losses related to business income
required to be reported on Internal Revenue Service Form 1040 Schedules C, E or F, and that satisfy
the Secondary Seafood Industry definition above shall be compensated pursuant to the
Compensation Framework for Business Economic Loss Claims.
Economic loss claims by Individuals satisfying the Secondary Seafood Industry definition above
shall be compensated pursuant to the Framework for Individual Economic Loss Claims.
Definitions of Commercial Wholesale or Retail Dealer B, Secondary Seafood Processor,
Seafood Wholesaler or Distributor, and Seafood Retailer are set forth below:
a. Commercial Wholesale or Retail Dealer B shall be defined as an entity or Natural Person
that holds a commercial wholesale or retail dealer license issued by the State(s) of Alabama,
Florida, Louisiana, Mississippi and/or Texas for which less than 75% of the cost or weight in
pounds of the product it purchases constitutes Seafood purchased directly from a
Commercial Fisherman or Landing Site, and re-sells to Primary Seafood Processors,
Seafood Distributors, Seafood Wholesalers and Seafood Retailers.
b. Secondary Seafood Processor shall be defined as an entity or Natural Person that
purchases Seafood from a Primary Seafood Processor in order to add further value
including, but not limited to, cleaning, cooking, canning, smoking, salting, drying or freezing,
grading by size packing and storing Seafood for shipment.
c. Seafood Wholesaler or Distributor shall be defined as an entity or Natural Person that
purchases Seafood in bulk quantities and sells to retailers such as restaurants, fish shop and
supermarkets.
028952
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-7 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 6
d. Seafood Retailer shall be defined as an entity that is an end user of Seafood such as a
restaurant, fish market or super market for which 25% or more of total food costs for 2009
constitute Seafood.
028953
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-7 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 6
028954
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-7 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 6
EXHIBIT 4A
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-8 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 5
Document at i on Requi r ement s f or Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms
1
The f r amew or k det ai l ed bel ow descr i bes t he document at i on r equi r ement s f or busi ness
economi c l oss cl ai ms.
In or der t o be el i gi bl e f or compensat i on, a busi ness cl ai mant must pr ovi de t he f ol l ow i ng:
1. A Cl ai m For m w hi ch t he cl ai mant (or cl ai mant s r epr esent at i ve) shal l ver i f y under
penal t i es of per j ur y. The Cl ai m For m shal l di r ect t he cl ai mant t o pr ovi de i nf or mat i on,
i ncl udi ng t he cl ai mant s chosen Compensat i on Per i od and cor r espondi ng Benchmar k
Per i od
2
i n t he year (s) sel ect ed by t he cl ai mant . The cl ai mant shal l at t ach r equi r ed
document s suppor t i ng t he cl ai m. Al l st at ement s made i n and document s submi t t ed
w i t h t he Cl ai m For m may be ver i f i ed as j udged necessar y by t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or .
2. Document s r ef l ect i ng t he busi ness st r uct ur e and ow ner shi p of t he cl ai mant , i ncl udi ng
but not l i mi t ed t o ar t i cl es of i ncor por at i on, shar ehol der l i st (s), and par t ner shi p or
l i mi t ed par t ner shi p agr eement s.
3. Feder al t ax r et ur ns (i ncl udi ng al l schedul es and at t achment s) f or t he year s i ncl uded i n
t he cl ai mant -sel ect ed Benchmar k Per i od, 2010, and, i f appl i cabl e, 2011.
3
a) Pr ovi de t he compl et e f eder al t ax r et ur n and t he appl i cabl e suppor t i ng
document at i on.
b) For sel f empl oyed i ndi vi dual s, pr ovi de For m 1040, pages 1 and 2, al ong w i t h
Schedul es C, D, E, and F and For m 1099 i f appl i cabl e.
4. M ont hl y and annual pr of i t and l oss st at ement s (w hi ch i dent i f y i ndi vi dual expense l i ne
i t ems and r evenue cat egor i es), or al t er nat e sour ce document s est abl i shi ng mont hl y
r evenues and expenses f or t he cl ai med Benchmar k Per i od,
4
2010 and, i f appl i cabl e,
1
These Document at i on Requi r ement s al so appl y gener al l y t o (i ) st ar t -up busi nesses and (i i ) busi nesses cl ai mi ng t o
have ceased oper at i ons due t o and r esul t i ng f r om t he DWH Spi l l , subj ect t o such excl usi ons as may be not ed i n t he
f r amew or ks gover ni ng compensat i on f or such busi nesses. Ot her pr ovi si ons of t he set t l ement agr eement mi ght
r equi r e addi t i onal document at i on f or speci f i c busi ness t ypes.
2
As used her ei n, Benchmar k Per i od w i l l have t he meani ng set f or t h i n t he Compensat i on Fr amew or k f or Busi ness
Economi c Loss Cl ai ms), and may i ncl ude (i ) 2009, (i i ) 2008 and 2009, or (i i i ) 2007-2009. If t he cl ai mant sel ect s a
Benchmar k Per i od i ncl udi ng dat es i n year s pr i or t o 2009, t he cl ai mant shal l pr ovi de t he r el evant document s f or
each of t hose year s.
3
Cl ai mant s w ho must sat i sf y t he r equi r ement s of Sect i ons II and III of t he Causat i on Requi r ement s f or Busi ness
Economi c Loss Cl ai ms ar e r equi r ed t o submi t 2011 f eder al t ax r et ur ns.
4
If t he cl ai mant s Benchmar k Per i od i ncl udes dat es i n year s pr i or t o 2009, t he cl ai mant shal l pr ovi de t he r el evant
document s f or t he appl i cabl e year s.
02539
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-8 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 5
2
2011.
5
Pr of i t and l oss st at ement s shal l i dent i f y t he dat es on w hi ch t hey w er e cr eat ed.
The Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or may, i n hi s di scr et i on, r equest sour ce document s f or pr of i t
and l oss st at ement s. If t her e i s a di scr epancy bet w een amount s r ef l ect ed i n a t ax r et ur n
and compar abl e i t ems r ef l ect ed i n a pr of i t and l oss st at ement f or t he same per i od, t he
Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or may r equest t he cl ai mant t o pr ovi de addi t i onal i nf or mat i on or
document at i on.
5. If t he cl ai mant f al l s w i t hi n any of t he speci f i c busi ness t ypes l i st ed bel ow , t he f ol l ow i ng
addi t i onal document s ar e r equi r ed f or t he year s i ncl uded i n t he Benchmar k Per i od,
2010, and, i f appl i cabl e, 2011:
a) Ret ai l
i . M ont hl y sal es and use t ax r et ur ns.
b) Lodgi ng (i ncl udi ng hot el s, mot el s, and vacat i on r ent al pr oper t i es):
i . Lodgi ng t ax r et ur ns;
i i . Occupancy r epor t s or hi st or i cal r ent al r ecor ds, on a per uni t basi s i f avai l abl e;
i i i . Document at i on t o i dent i f y how t he r ent al pr oper t y i s managed, such as (i ) a
management cont r act f r om a t hi r d-par t y management company or (i i ) a
Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement f r om an ow ner t hat manages i t s ow n pr oper t y.
6. Addi t i onal document s may be r equi r ed dependi ng on t he causat i on pr ovi si ons t he
cl ai mant i s seeki ng t o sat i sf y, as r ef l ect ed i n Causat i on Requi r ement s f or Busi ness
Economi c Loss Cl ai ms . These document s i ncl ude, w her e appl i cabl e:
a) Document s used t o sat i sf y t he Cust omer M i x Test s accompanyi ng t he M odi f i ed V-
Test and/ or Dow n Onl y Revenue Pat t er n Test :
i . Cr edi t car d r ecei pt s, or ot her cont empor aneousl y-mai nt ai ned r ecor ds of
payment f r om cust omer s;
i i . Cust omer r egi st r at i on l ogs, such as hot el r egi st r i es;
i i i . Document at i on mai nt ai ned i n t he or di nar y cour se of busi ness t hat l i st s
cust omer s by l ocat i on and mont hl y sal es associ at ed w i t h t hose cust omer s;
i v. Busi ness document s r ef l ect i ng cont empor aneous r ecor di ng of r ecei pt s or
i nvoi ces l i st i ng cust omer s by l ocat i on.
b) Document s pr ovi di ng cont empor aneous w r i t t en evi dence of t he cancel l at i on of a
cont r act as t he di r ect r esul t of t he DWH Spi l l , w hi ch t he cl ai mant w as not abl e t o
r epl ace, under t he same t er ms, or a Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement f r om an i ndi vi dual
t hi r d par t y af f i r mi ng t hat t he cancel l at i on w as Spi l l -r el at ed. A copy of al l
cor r espondi ng cont r act s shal l al so be pr ovi ded.
5
Cl ai mant s i ncl uded i n Sect i ons II or III of t he Causat i on Requi r ement s f or Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms ar e
r equi r ed t o submi t 2011 mont hl y pr of i t and l oss st at ement s or al t er nat e sour ce document s.
02540
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-8 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 5
3
c) Speci f i c document at i on i dent i f yi ng f act or s out si de t he cont r ol of t he cl ai mant t hat
pr event ed t he r ecover y of r evenues i n 2011, such as:
i . The ent r y of a compet i t or i n 2011;
i i . Bankr upt cy of a si gni f i cant cust omer ;
i i i . Near by r oad cl osur es af f ect i ng t he busi ness;
i v. Unant i ci pat ed i nt er r upt i on r esul t i ng i n t he cl osur e of t he busi ness;
v. Pr oduct / ser vi ce r epl acement by cust omer ; or
vi . Loss of f i nanci ng and/ or r easonabl e t er ms of r enew al .
d) Document s cr eat ed dur i ng t he per i od Apr i l 21, 2010 - December 31, 2010, t hat
evi dence spi l l -r el at ed r eser vat i on cancel l at i ons dur i ng t hat per i od t hat t he cl ai mant
w as not abl e t o r ebook under t he same t er ms, such as l et t er s, emai l s, hot el l ogs f or
t he r el evant t i me, or a Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement f r om an i ndependent t hi r d par t y
ci t i ng t he DWH Spi l l as t he r eason f or t he cancel l at i on. Wr i t t en evi dence of t he
or i gi nal r eser vat i on shal l al so be pr ovi ded.
e) Document s demonst r at i ng expenses associ at ed w i t h pur chases of seaf ood
har vest ed i n t he Gul f of M exi co dur i ng 2009, such as hi st or i cal pur chase or der s or
i nvoi ces.
f ) Ot her busi ness document s t he cl ai mant bel i eves est abl i sh causat i on pur suant t o t he
t er ms of t he Economi c and Pr oper t y Damages Set t l ement Agr eement . Pur chase
or der s or i nvoi ces document i ng seaf ood pur chase cost s f or t he compensat i on
per i od, and f or t he year 2010 or 2011 i f appl i cabl e.
7. Cl ai mant must pr ovi de a copy of any appl i cabl e f eder al , st at e, or l ocal gover nment al
l i cense r equi r ed t o oper at e i t s busi ness. For exampl e, cl ai mant s shal l pr oduce t he
f ol l ow i ng f or t he Benchmar k Per i od, 2010 and, i f appl i cabl e, 2011:
a) Real est at e sal es l i censes
b) Occupancy l i censes (l odgi ng busi nesses, i ncl udi ng hot el s, mot el s, and vacat i on r ent al
pr oper t i es)
c) Busi ness or occupat i onal l i censes
i . Rest aur ant l i censes
i i . Bar s (l i quor ) l i censes
i i i . Taxi / l i ver y l i censes
i v. Ser vi ce l i censes or per mi t s
8. Cl ai mant s w ho have r ecei ved any of t he payment s l i st ed bel ow must pr ovi de
document at i on of t he amount of payment s r ecei ved:
a) VoO payment s
b) Payment s f r om GCCF
c) Payment s f r om BP as par t of i t s OPA cl ai ms pr ocess.
02541
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-8 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 5
4
9. Addi t i onal document at i on f or cl ai mant s w i t h annual r evenue of $75,000 or l ess w hi ch
seek t o est abl i sh causat i on on t he basi s of a Causat i on Pr oxy Cl ai mant :
a) Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement f r om Cl ai mant document i ng t he f ol l ow i ng:
i . Cont act i nf or mat i on and ver i f i cat i on of st at us i n M DL 2179 Set t l ement of t he
Causat i on Pr oxy Cl ai mant t o be used by t he cl ai mant t o sat i sf y causat i on;
i i . Busi ness l i nkage bet w een t he cl ai mant and t he Causat i on Pr oxy Cl ai mant ;
and
i i i . Pr oxi mi t y of t he cl ai mant t o t he Causat i on Pr oxy Cl ai mant (must be w i t hi n
100 yar ds f or ur ban cl ai mant s and w i t hi n one-quar t er mi l e f or r ur al
cl ai mant s).
b) Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement f r om Causat i on Pr oxy Cl ai mant aut hor i zi ng cl ai mant s use
of t he Causat i on Pr oxy Cl ai mant s document at i on t o sat i sf y causat i on.
10. For m af f i r mi ng t hat t he i ndi vi dual f i l i ng t he cl ai m on behal f of t he busi ness i s an
aut hor i zed r epr esent at i ve of t he cl ai mant .
02542
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-8 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 5
EXHIBIT 4B
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-9 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 17
1
CAUSATION REQUIREM ENTS FOR BUSINESSES ECONOM IC LOSS CLAIM S
1
I. Busi ness Cl ai mant s f or Whi ch Ther e i s No Causat i on Requi r ement
1) If you ar e a busi ness i n Zone A, you ar e not r equi r ed t o pr ovi de any evi dence of causat i on
unl ess you f al l i nt o one of t he except ions agr eed t o by t he par t ies, and l i st ed i n f oot not e (1).
2) If you ar e a Landi ng Si t e, or Commerci al Whol esale or Ret ai l Dealer A, or Pr imar y
Seaf ood Processor , as set f or t h i n Seaf ood Di st r i but ion Chai n Def i ni t ions, you ar e not
r equi r ed t o pr ovi de any evidence of causat i on.
3) If you ar e i n Zone A, B or C and you are a Commer ci al or Wholesal e or Ret ai l Deal er B, or a
Secondar y Seaf ood Processor , or a Seaf ood Whol esal er or Di st r i but or, or a Seaf ood
Ret ai l er , as set f or t h i n Seaf ood Di st r i but ion Chai n Def i ni t ion, you ar e not r equi r ed t o
pr ovi de any evi dence of causat i on.
4) If you ar e i n Zone A or Zone B, and you meet t he Tour i sm Def i ni t ion, you ar e not r equi r ed
t o pr ovi de any evi dence of causat i on.
5) If you ar e i n Zone A, B or C, and you meet t he Char t er Fi shi ng Def i ni t ion you ar e not
r equi r ed t o pr ovi de any evidence of causat i on.
II. Causat i on Requi r ement s f or Zone B and Zone C
If you ar e not ent i t l ed t o a pr esumpt ion as set f or t h i n (I) above and you ar e l ocat ed i n Zone B
or Zone C t hen you must sat i sf y t he r equi r ement s of one of t he f ol low i ng sect i ons A-E below:
A. V-Shaped Revenue Pat t er n:
Tot al business r evenue show s t he f ol l ow i ng pat t er n:
1. DOWNTURN: a decl i ne of an aggr egat e of 8.5% or mor e i n t ot al r evenues
over a per i od of t hr ee consecut i ve mont hs bet ween M ay-December 2010
compar ed t o t he same mont hs i n t he Benchmar k Per i od sel ect ed by t he
cl ai mant ;
2
AND
2. LATER UPTURN: an i ncr ease of an aggr egat e of 5% or mor e i n t ot al r evenues
over t he same per i od of t hr ee consecut i ve mont hs i n 2011 compar ed t o
2010.
3
OR
1
Thi s Causat i on Requi r ement s f or Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms does not appl y t o (i ) St ar t -up Busi nesses;
(i i ) Fai l ed Busi nesses; (i i i ) Ent i t i es, Indi vi dual s or Cl ai ms not i ncl uded w i t hi n t he Economi c Cl ass def i ni t i on ; and (i v)
Cl ai ms cover ed under t he Seaf ood Pr ogr am.
2
See Compensat i on Fr amewor k f or Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms.
3
See Exhi bi t A at t ached her et o f or an exampl e of how t hi s cal cul at i on i s per f or med.
028725
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-9 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 17
2
B. M odi f i ed V-Shaped Revenue Pat t er n:
Tot al business r evenue show s t he f ol l ow i ng pat t er n:
1. DOWNTURN: a decl i ne of an aggr egat e of 5% or mor e i n t ot al r evenues over
a per i od of t hr ee consecut i ve mont hs bet ween M ay-December 2010
compar ed t o t he same mont hs i n t he Benchmar k Per i od sel ect ed by t he
cl ai mant ;
4
AND
2. LATER UPTURN: an i ncr ease of an aggr egat e of 5% or mor e i n t ot al r evenues
over t he same per i od of t hr ee consecut i ve mont hs i n 2011 compar ed t o
2010;
AND ONE OR M ORE OF THE FOLLOWING:
a. The cl ai mant demonst r at es a decl i ne of 10% i n t he shar e of t ot al r evenue
gener at ed by non-l ocal cust omer s over t he same per i od of t hr ee consecut i ve
mont hs f r om M ay-December 2010 as sel ect ed by cl ai mant f or t he M odi f i ed
V-Shaped Revenue Pat t er n as i dent i f i ed i n (II.B.1) compar ed t o t he same
t hr ee consecut i ve mont h per i od i n 2009, as r ef l ect ed i n:
5
x cust omer cr edi t car d r ecei pt s or ot her cont empor aneousl y mai nt ai ned
r ecor ds of payment ; or
x cust omer r egi st r at i on l ogs (e.g., hot el r egi st r i es); or
x document at i on mai nt ai ned i n t he or di nar y cour se of business t hat l i st s
cust omer s by l ocat i on and mont hl y sal es associ at ed w i t h t hose
cust omer s; or
x busi ness document s r ef l ect i ng cont empor aneous r ecor di ng of r ecei pt s or
i nvoi ces l i st i ng cust omer s by l ocat i on.
6
OR
b. For busi ness cl ai mant s t hat have cust omer s i n Zones A-C, t he cl ai mant
demonst r at es a decl ine of 10% i n t he shar e of t ot al r evenue gener at ed by
cust omer s l ocat ed i n Zones A-C over t he same per i od of t he t hr ee
consecut i ve mont hs f r om M ay-December 2010 as sel ect ed by cl ai mant f or
t he M odi f i ed V-Shaped Revenue Pat t er n as i dent i f i ed i n (II.B.1) compar ed t o
t he same t hr ee consecut i ve mont h per i od i n 2009, as r ef l ect ed i n:
4
See Compensat i on Fr amewor k f or Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms.
5
A Cust omer shall be consider ed a non-l ocal cust omer i f t hey r esi de mor e t han 60 mi l es f r om a cl ai mant
busi ness l ocat i on.
6
See Exhi bi t B at t ached her et o f or an exampl e of how t hi s cal cul at i on i s per f or med.
028726
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-9 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 17
3
x cust omer cr edi t car d r ecei pt s or ot her cont empor aneousl y mai nt ai ned
r ecor ds of payment ; or
x cust omer r egi st r at i on l ogs (e.g., hot el r egi st r i es); or
x document at i on mai nt ai ned i n t he or di nar y cour se of business t hat l i st s
cust omer s by l ocat i on and mont hl y sal es associ at ed w i t h t hose
cust omer s; or
x busi ness document s r ef l ect i ng cont empor aneous r ecor di ng of r ecei pt s or
i nvoi ces l i st i ng cust omer s by l ocat i on.
7
OR
c. The cl ai mant pr ovi des cont empor aneous wr i t t en evi dence of t he cancel l at i on
of a cont r act as t he di r ect r esul t of t he spi l l t hat cl ai mant was not abl e t o
r epl ace. Pr oof of a spi l l -r el at ed cont r act cancel l at i on onl y est abl i shes
causat i on f or t he specif i c cont r act subst ant i at ed by t he cl ai mant and may
r esul t i n r ecover y onl y of damages sol el y associ at ed wi t h such cont r act .
OR
C. Decl i ne-Onl y Revenue Pat t er n:
1. DOWNTURN: a decl i ne of an aggr egat e of 8.5% or mor e i n r evenues over
a per i od of t hr ee consecut i ve mont hs bet ween M ay-December 2010
compar ed t o t he same mont hs i n t he Benchmar k Per i od sel ect ed by t he
cl ai mant ;
8
AND
2. Speci f i c document at i on i dent i f yi ng f act or s out side t he cont r ol of t he
cl ai mant t hat pr event ed t he r ecover y of r evenues i n 2011, such as:
x The ent r y of a compet i t or i n 2011
x Bankr upt cy of a si gni f i cant cust omer i n 2011
x Near by r oad cl osur es af f ect i ng t he busi ness
x Unant i ci pat ed i nt er r upt i on r esul t i ng i n cl osur e of t he busi ness
x Pr oduct / Ser vi ce r epl acement by Cust omer
x Loss of f i nanci ng and/ or r easonabl e t er ms of r enew al ;
AND
3. ONE OF THE FOLLOWING:
7
See Exhi bi t C at t ached her et o f or an exampl e of how t hi s cal cul at i on i s per f or med.
8
See Compensat i on Fr amewor k f or Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms.
028727
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-9 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 17
4
x The cl ai mant demonst r at es pr oof of a decl i ne of 10% i n t he shar e of t ot al
r evenue gener at ed by non-l ocal cust omer s over t he same per i od of t hr ee
consecut i ve mont hs f r om M ay-December 2010 as sel ect ed by t he
cl ai mant f or t he Decl i ne-Onl y Revenue Pat t er n as i dent i f i ed i n (II.C.1)
compar ed t o t he same t hr ee consecut i ve mont h per i od i n 2009, as
r ef l ect ed i n:
9
o cust omer cr edi t car d r ecei pt s or ot her cont empor aneousl y
mai nt ai ned r ecor ds of payment ; or
o cust omer r egi st r at i on l ogs (e.g., hot el r egi st r i es); or
o document at i on mai nt ai ned i n t he or di nar y cour se of business t hat
l i st s cust omer s by l ocat i on and mont hl y sal es associ at ed w i t h
t hose cust omer s; or
o busi ness document s r ef l ect i ng cont empor aneous r ecor di ng of
r ecei pt s or i nvoi ces l i st i ng cust omer s by l ocat i on.
10
x For busi ness cl ai mant s t hat have cust omer s i n Zones A-C, t he cl ai mant
demonst r at es pr oof of a decl i ne of 10% i n t he shar e of t ot al r evenue
gener at ed by cust omer s l ocat ed i n Zones A-C over t he same per i od of
t hr ee consecut i ve mont hs f r om M ay-December 2010 as sel ect ed by t he
cl ai mant f or t he Decl i ne-Onl y Revenue Pat t er n as i dent i f i ed i n (II.C.1)
compar ed t o t he same t hr ee consecut i ve mont h per i od i n 2009, as
r ef l ect ed i n:
o cust omer cr edi t car d r ecei pt s or ot her cont empor aneousl y
mai nt ai ned r ecor ds of payment ; or
o cust omer r egi st r at i on l ogs (e.g., hot el r egi st r i es); or
o document at i on mai nt ai ned i n t he or di nar y cour se of business t hat
l i st s cust omer s by l ocat i on and mont hl y sal es associ at ed w i t h
t hose cust omer s; or
o busi ness document s r ef l ect i ng cont empor aneous r ecor di ng of
r ecei pt s or i nvoi ces l i st i ng cust omer s by l ocat i on.
11
OR
D. Pr oof of Spi l l -Rel at ed Cancel l at i ons
x Cl ai mant may est abl i sh causat i on by pr ovi di ng cont empor aneous wr i t t en
evi dence of spi l l -r el at ed r eser vat i on cancel l at i ons (i .e., l et t er s, emai l s, hot el l ogs
f or t he r el evant t i me, or an af f i davi t f r om an i ndependent t hi r d par t y ci t i ng t he
9
A Cust omer shall be consider ed a non-l ocal cust omer i f t hey r esi de mor e t han 60 mi l es f r om a cl ai mant
busi ness l ocat i on.
10
See Exhi bi t B at t ached her et o f or an exampl e of how t hi s cal cul at i on i s per f or med.
11
See Exhi bi t C at t ached her et o f or an exampl e of how t hi s cal cul at i on i s per f or med.
028728
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-9 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 17
5
spi l l as t he r eason f or cancel l at i on) t hat t he cl ai mant was unabl e t o r ebook.
Pr oof of spi l l -r el at ed r eser vat i on cancel l at i ons onl y est abl i shes causat i on f or t he
speci f i c cancel l at i ons subst ant i at ed by t he cl ai mant and may r esul t i n r ecover y
onl y of damages sol el y associ at ed wi t h such cancel l at i ons est abl i shed as causal l y
r esul t i ng f r om t he spi l l . However , i f t he l odgi ng f aci l i t y has f ood and/ or bever age
ser vi ces on sit e, t he evi dence of cancel l at i on shal l sat i sf y causat i on f or t he
speci f i c l osses cor r espondi ng t o such cancel l at i on i n t hose ser vi ce ar eas as wel l .
x The cl ai mant pr ovi des cont empor aneous wr i t t en evi dence of t he cancel l at i on of
a cont r act as t he di r ect r esul t of t he spi l l t hat cl ai mant was not abl e t o r epl ace.
In t he absence of cont empor aneous wr i t t en evi dence, t he cl ai mant must pr esent
an af f i davi t f r om an i ndependent t hi r d par t y af f i r mi ng t hat t he cancel l at i on was
spi l l -r el at ed. Pr oof of a spi l l -r el at ed cont r act cancel l at i on onl y est abl i shes
causat i on f or t he specif i c cont r act subst ant i at ed by t he cl ai mant and may r esul t
i n r ecover y onl y of damages sol el y associ at ed w i t h such cont r act .
OR
E. A non-r ur al business cl ai mant on a pr oper t y t hat i s i n cl ose pr oxi mi t y (wi t hi n 100
yar ds) t o t he pr oper t y of a separ at e M DL 2179 busi ness cl ai mant t hat has
est abl i shed causat i on ( Causat i on Pr oxy Cl ai mant ) may r el y on t he document at i on
submi t t ed by such Causat i on Pr oxy Cl ai mant t o sat i sf y t hese Causat i on
Requi r ement s f or Business Economi c Loss Cl ai ms. A Rur al Business cl aimant
l ocat ed wi t hi n one quar t er -mi l e of t he pr oper t y of t he Causat i on Pr oxy Cl ai mant
may r el y on t he document at i on submi t t ed by t he Causat i on Pr oxy Cl ai mant t o sat i sf y
t hese causat i on r equi r ement onl y i f t he cl ai mant pr ovides i nf or mat i on suf f i ci ent f or
t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or t o det er mi ne t hat a causal r el at i onshi p exi st s bet ween t he
cl ai mant s f i nanci al per f or mance and t he f i nanci al per f or mance of t he Causat i on
Pr oxy Cl ai mant . A Rur al Busi ness shal l be def i ned as one i s l ocat ed i n ar ea out side an
Ur ban Ar ea or Ur ban Cl ust er , as def i ned by t he US Census Bur eau s cl assi f i cat i on.
Onl y business cl ai mant s wi t h annual r evenue of $75,000 or bel ow ar e el i gi bl e t o
est abl i sh causat i on under t hi s Subpar t IIE.
III. Causat i on Requi r ement s f or Zone D
If you ar e not ent i t l ed t o a pr esumpt ion as set f or t h i n (I) above and you ar e l ocat ed out si de of
Zones A, B or C, t hen you must sat i sf y t he r equi r ement s of one of t he f ol low i ng sect ions A-F
bel ow:
A. V-Shaped Revenue Pat t er n:
Busi ness r evenue show s t he f ol l ow i ng pat t er n:
028729
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-9 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 17
6
1. DOWNTURN: a decl i ne of an aggr egat e of 15% or mor e i n t ot al r evenues
over a per i od of t hr ee consecut i ve mont hs bet ween M ay-December 2010
compar ed t o t he same mont hs i n t he Benchmar k Per i od sel ect ed by t he
cl ai mant ;
12
AND
2. LATER UPTURN: an i ncr ease of an aggr egat e of 10% or mor e i n t ot al
r evenues over t he same per i od of t hr ee consecut i ve mont hs i n 2011
compar ed t o 2010.
13
OR
B. M odi f i ed V-Shaped Revenue Pat t er n:
Tot al business r evenue show s t he f ol l ow i ng pat t er n:
1. DOWNTURN: a decl i ne of an aggr egat e of 10% or mor e i n t ot al r evenues
over t he same per i od of t hr ee consecut i ve mont hs bet ween M ay-December
2010 compar ed t o t he same mont hs i n t he Benchmar k Per i od sel ect ed by t he
cl ai mant ;
14
AND
2. LATER UPTURN: an i ncr ease of an aggr egat e of 7% or mor e i n t ot al r evenues
over t he same per i od of t hr ee consecut i ve mont hs i n 2011 compar ed t o
2010;
AND
3. ONE OF THE FOLLOWING:
x The cl ai mant demonst r at es pr oof of a decl i ne of 10% i n t he shar e of t ot al
r evenue gener at ed by non-l ocal cust omer s over t he same per i od of t hr ee
consecut i ve mont hs f r om M ay-December 2010 as sel ect ed by t he
cl ai mant f or t he M odi f i ed V-Shaped Revenue Pat t er n i dent i f i ed i n (III.B.1)
compar ed t o t he same t hr ee consecut i ve mont h per i od i n 2009, as
r ef l ect ed i n:
15
12
See Compensat i on Fr amewor k f or Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms.
13
See Exhi bi t A at t ached her et o f or an exampl e of how t hi s cal cul at i on i s per f or med.
14
See Compensat i on Fr amewor k f or Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms.
15
A Cust omer shall be consider ed a non-l ocal cust omer i f t hey r esi de mor e t han 60 mi l es f r om a cl ai mant
busi ness l ocat i on.
028730
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-9 Filed 04/18/12 Page 7 of 17
7
o cust omer cr edi t car d r ecei pt s or ot her cont empor aneousl y
mai nt ai ned r ecor ds of payment ; or
o cust omer r egi st r at i on l ogs (e.g., hot el r egi st r i es); or
o document at i on mai nt ai ned i n t he or di nar y cour se of business t hat
l i st s cust omer s by l ocat i on and mont hl y sal es associ at ed w i t h
t hose cust omer s; or
o busi ness document s r ef l ect i ng cont empor aneous r ecor di ng of
r ecei pt s or i nvoi ces l i st i ng cust omer s by l ocat i on.
16
x For busi ness cl ai mant s t hat have cust omer s i n Zones A-C, t he cl ai mant
demonst r at es pr oof of a decl i ne of 10% i n t he shar e of t ot al r evenue
gener at ed by cust omer s l ocat ed i n Zones A-C over t he same per i od of t he
t hr ee consecut i ve mont hs f r om M ay-December 2010 as sel ect ed by t he
cl ai mant f or t he M odi f i ed V-Shaped Revenue Pat t er n i dent i f i ed i n (III.B.1)
compar ed t o t he same t hr ee consecut i ve mont h per i od i n 2009, as
r ef l ect ed i n:
o cust omer cr edi t car d r ecei pt s or ot her cont empor aneousl y
mai nt ai ned r ecor ds of payment ; or
o cust omer r egi st r at i on l ogs (e.g., hot el r egi st r i es); or
o document at i on mai nt ai ned i n t he or di nar y cour se of business t hat
l i st s cust omer s by l ocat i on and mont hl y sal es associ at ed w i t h
t hose cust omer s; or
o busi ness document s r ef l ect i ng cont empor aneous r ecor di ng of
r ecei pt s or i nvoi ces l i st i ng cust omer s by l ocat i on.
17
x The cl ai mant pr ovi des cont empor aneous wr i t t en evi dence of t he
cancel l at i on of a cont r act as t he di r ect r esul t of t he spi l l t hat cl ai mant
was not abl e t o r epl ace. Pr oof of a spi l l -r el at ed cont r act cancel l at i on onl y
est abl i shes causat i on f or t he speci f i c cont r act subst ant i at ed by t he
cl ai mant and may r esul t i n r ecover y onl y of damages sol el y associ at ed
w i t h such cont r act .
OR
C. Decl i ne-Onl y Revenue Pat t er n:
1. DOWNTURN: a decl i ne of an aggr egat e of 15% or mor e i n t ot al r evenues
over a per i od of t hr ee consecut i ve mont hs bet ween M ay-December 2010
compar ed t o t he same mont hs i n t he Benchmar k Per i od sel ect ed by t he
cl ai mant wi t hout a r ecover y i n t he cor r espondi ng mont hs of 2011;
18
16
See Exhi bi t B at t ached her et o f or an exampl e of how t hi s cal cul at i on i s per f or med.
17
See Exhi bi t C at t ached her et o f or an exampl e of how t hi s cal cul at i on i s per f or med.
18
See Compensat i on Fr amewor k f or Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms.
028731
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-9 Filed 04/18/12 Page 8 of 17
8
AND
2. Speci f i c document at i on i dent i f yi ng f act or s out side t he cont r ol of t he
cl ai mant t hat pr event ed t he r ecover y of r evenues i n 2011:
x The ent r y of a compet i t or i n 2011
x Bankr upt cy of a si gni f i cant cust omer i n 2011
x Near by r oad cl osur es af f ect i ng t he busi ness
x Unant i ci pat ed i nt er r upt i on r esul t i ng i n cl osur e of t he busi ness
x Pr oduce/ Sour ce r epl acement by Cust omer ,
x Loss of f i nanci ng and/ or r easonabl e t er ms of r enew al ;
AND
3. ONE OR M ORE OF THE FOLLOWING:
x The cl ai mant demonst r at es pr oof of a decl i ne of 10% i n t he shar e of t ot al
r evenue gener at ed by non-l ocal cust omer s over t he same per i od of t hr ee
consecut i ve mont hs f r om M ay-December 2010 as sel ect ed by t he
cl ai mant f or t he Decl i ne-Onl y Revenue Pat t er as i dent i f i ed i n (III.C.1)
compar ed t o t he same t hr ee consecut i ve mont h per i od i n 2009, as
r ef l ect ed i n:
19
o cust omer cr edi t car d r ecei pt s or ot her cont empor aneousl y
mai nt ai ned r ecor ds of payment ; or
o cust omer r egi st r at i on l ogs (e.g., hot el r egi st r i es); or
o document at i on mai nt ai ned i n t he or di nar y cour se of business t hat
l i st s cust omer s by l ocat i on and mont hl y sal es associ at ed w i t h
t hose cust omer s; or
o busi ness document s r ef l ect i ng cont empor aneous r ecor di ng of
r ecei pt s or i nvoi ces l i st i ng cust omer s by l ocat i on.
20
x For busi ness cl ai mant s t hat have cust omer s i n Zones A-C, t he cl ai mant
demonst r at es pr oof of a decl i ne of a 10% i n t he shar e of t ot al r evenue
gener at ed by cust omer s l ocat ed i n Zone A, Zone B, or Zone C over t he
same per i od of t hr ee consecut i ve mont hs f r om M ay-December 2010 as
sel ect ed by t he cl ai mant f or t he Decl i ne-Onl y Revenue Pat t er n as
i dent i f i ed i n (III.C.1) compar ed t o t he same t hr ee consecut i ve mont h
per i od i n 2009, as r ef l ect ed i n:
o cust omer cr edi t car d r ecei pt s or ot her cont empor aneousl y
mai nt ai ned r ecor ds of payment ; or
o cust omer r egi st r at i on l ogs (e.g., hot el r egi st r i es); or
19
A Cust omer shal l be consi der ed a non-l ocal cust omer i f t hey r esi de mor e t han 60 mi l es f r om a cl ai mant
busi ness l ocat i on.
20
See Exhi bi t B at t ached her et o f or an exampl e of how t hi s cal cul at i on i s per f or med.
028732
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-9 Filed 04/18/12 Page 9 of 17
9
o document at i on mai nt ai ned i n t he or di nar y cour se of business t hat
l i st s cust omer s by l ocat i on and mont hl y sal es associ at ed w i t h
t hose cust omer s; or
o busi ness document s r ef l ect i ng cont empor aneous r ecor di ng of
r ecei pt s or i nvoi ces l i st i ng cust omer s by l ocat i on.
21
OR
D. Pr oof of Spi l l -Rel at ed Reser vat i on Cancel l at i ons
x Cl ai mant may est abl i sh causat i on by pr ovi di ng cont empor aneous wr i t t en
evi dence of spi l l -r el at ed r eser vat i on cancel l at i ons (i .e., l et t er s, emai l s, hot el l ogs
f or t he r el evant t i me) t hat t he cl ai mant was unabl e t o r ebook. Pr oof of spi l l -
r el at ed r eser vat i on cancel l at i ons onl y est abl i shes causat i on f or t he speci f i c
cancel l at i ons subst ant i at ed by t he cl ai mant and may r esul t i n r ecover y onl y of
damages sol el y associ at ed wi t h such cancel l at i ons est abl i shed as causal l y
r esul t i ng f r om t he spi l l . However , i f t he l odgi ng f aci l i t y has f ood and/ or bever age
ser vi ces on sit e, t he evi dence of cancel l at i on shal l sat i sf y causat i on f or t he l osses
i n t hose ser vi ce ar eas as wel l .
x The cl ai mant pr ovi des cont empor aneous wr i t t en evi dence of t he cancel l at i on of
a cont r act as t he di r ect r esul t of t he spi l l t hat cl ai mant was not abl e t o r epl ace.
In t he absence of cont empor aneous wr i t t en evi dence, t he cl ai mant must pr esent
an af f i davi t f r om an i ndependent t hi r d par t y af f i r mi ng t hat t he cancel l at i on was
spi l l -r el at ed. Pr oof of a spi l l -r el at ed cont r act cancel l at i on onl y est abl i shes
causat i on f or t he specif i c cont r act subst ant i at ed by t he cl ai mant and may r esul t
i n r ecover y of damages sol el y associ at ed wi t h such cont r act .
OR
E. For cl ai mant s def i ned as Seaf ood Ret ai l er s (i ncl udi ng r est aur ant s):
o Cl ai mant demonst r at es pur chases of Gul f of M exi co har vest ed seaf ood
f r om Zone A, Zone B or Zone C vendor s r epr esent ed at l east 10% of f ood
cost s dur i ng 2009, as r ef l ect ed i n hi st or i cal pur chase or der s and/ or
i nvoi ces.
AND
21
See Exhi bi t C at t ached her et o f or an exampl e of how t hi s cal cul at i on i s per f or med.
028733
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-9 Filed 04/18/12 Page 10 of 17
10
o Cl ai mant demonst r at es a decl i ne of 7.5% i n gr oss pr of i t (gr oss sal es l ess
cost of goods sol d) over a per i od of t hr ee consecut i ve mont hs bet ween
M ay-December 2010 compar ed t o t he same mont hs i n 2009.
OR
F. A non-r ur al business cl ai mant on a pr oper t y t hat i s i n cl ose pr oxi mi t y (wi t hi n 100
yar ds) t o t he pr oper t y of a separ at e M DL 2179 busi ness cl ai mant t hat has
est abl i shed causat i on ( Causat i on Pr oxy Cl ai mant ) may r el y on t he document at i on
submi t t ed by such Causat i on Pr oxy Cl ai mant t o sat i sf y t hese Causat i on
Requi r ement s f or Business Economi c Loss Cl ai ms. A Rur al Business cl ai mant
l ocat ed wi t hi n one quar t er -mi l e of t he pr oper t y of t he Causat i on Pr oxy Cl ai mant
may r el y on t he document at i on submi t t ed by t he Causat i on Pr o xy Cl ai mant t o sat i sf y
t hese causat i on r equi r ement onl y i f t he cl ai mant pr ovides i nf or mat i on suf f i ci ent f or
t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or t o det er mi ne t hat a causal r el at i onshi p exi st s bet ween t he
cl ai mant s f i nanci al per f or mance and t he f i nanci al per f or mance of t he Causat i on
Pr oxy Cl ai mant . A Rur al Busi ness shal l be def i ned as one i s l ocat ed i n ar ea out side an
ur ban ar ea or urban cl ust er , as def i ned by t he US Census Bur eau s cl assi f i cat i on.
Onl y business cl ai mant s wi t h annual r evenue of $75,000 or bel ow ar e el i gi bl e t o
est abl i sh causat i on under t hi s Subpar t IIIF.
Exhi bi t A
Test
Dow n Up Dow n Up Dow n Up Dow n Up
V-Test -8.5% 5% -8.5% 5% -15% 10%
M odi f i ed V-Test * -5% 5% -5% 5% -10% 7%
Dow n Onl y Test * -8.50% N/ A -8.50% N/ A -15% N/ A
Summar y of Revenue Pat t er n Requi r ement s f or Causat i on Test s
Zone A
Zone B
(Non-Tour i sm and
Non-Seaf ood)
* = For t he M odi f i ed V-Test and t he Dow n Onl y Test , addi t i onal r equi r ement s appl y, as descr i bed i n Sect i ons
IIB, IIC, IIIB, and IIIC above.
Zone C
(Non-Seaf ood) Zone D
N/ A
N/ A
N/ A
028734
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-9 Filed 04/18/12 Page 11 of 17
11
Exampl e 1:
M ont h 2008 2009
Aver age of
2008-2009 2010 2011
June 325,000 300,000 312,500 285,000 305,000
Jul y 360,000 350,000 355,000 330,000 345,000
August 340,000 325,000 332,500 295,000 330,000
3-M ont h Aggr egat e: 1,025,000 975,000 1,000,000 910,000 980,000
[ Sum of June, Jul y, August ]
Dow n Per cent age: -9.0% =(910,000 - 1,000,000)/ 1,000,000
Up Per cent age: 7.7% =(980,000 - 910,000)/ 910,000
Exampl e 2:
M ont h 2008 2009
Aver age of
2008-2009 2010 2011
June 325,000 300,000 312,500 295,000 320,000
Jul y 360,000 350,000 355,000 335,000 355,000
August 340,000 325,000 332,500 315,000 340,000
3-M ont h Aggr egat e: 1,025,000 975,000 1,000,000 945,000 1,015,000
[ Sum of June, Jul y, August ]
Dow n Per cent age: -5.5% =(945,000 - 1,000,000)/ 1,000,000
Up Per cent age: 7.4% =(1,015,000 - 945,000)/ 945,000
Exampl e 3:
M ont h 2008 2009
Aver age of
2008-2009 2010 2011
June 325,000 300,000 312,500 285,000 300,000
Jul y 360,000 350,000 355,000 330,000 325,000
August 340,000 325,000 332,500 295,000 310,000
3-M ont h Aggr egat e: 1,025,000 975,000 1,000,000 910,000 935,000
[ Sum of June, Jul y, August ]
Dow n Per cent age: -9.0% =(910,000 - 1,000,000)/ 1,000,000
Up Per cent age: 2.7% =(935,000 - 910,000)/ 910,000
Not es:
In t hese exampl es, t he cl ai mant i s l ocat ed i n Zone B or C, uses 2008-2009 average as Benchmark
Peri od, and has sel ect ed June, Jul y and August as i t s t hree consecut i ve mont hs.
Exampl es of Revenue Pat t er n Requi r ement s f or Causat i on Test s
The causat i on t est s woul d wor k i n t he same way f or cl ai mant s i n Zone D wi t h hi gher t hr eshol ds f or t he t est s. I n
Zone D, t he V-Test t hr eshol ds ar e -15% decl i ne, 10% upt ur n; t he M odi f i ed V-Test t hr eshol ds ar e -10% decl i ne, 7%
upt ur n; t he Down-Onl y Test t hr eshol d i s -15%.
Cl ai mant passes V-Test . Not e: A cl ai mant t hat sat i sf i es t he revenue pat t ern
requi rement s f or t he V-Test will al ways al so sat i sf y t he requirement s f or t he
Modi f i ed V-Test and Down Onl y Test .
Cl ai mant f ai l s V Test and t he Down Onl y Test .
Cl ai mant has sat i sf i ed t he revenue pat t ern requi rement f or t he Modi f i ed V-Test and
can est abl i sh causat i on i f abl e t o sat i sf y t he addi t i onal requi rement s descri bed i n
Sect i on IIB above.
Cl ai mant f ai l s V Test and t he Modi f i ed V-Test .
Cl ai mant has sat i sf i ed t he revenue pat t ern requi rement f or t he Down Onl y Test and
can est abl i sh causat i on i f abl e t o sat i sf y t he addi t i onal requi rement s descri bed i n
Sect i on IIC above.
Revenue by Year
Revenue by Year
Revenue by Year
028735
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-9 Filed 04/18/12 Page 12 of 17
12
Exampl e 4A:
M ont h 2008 2009
Aver age of
2008-2009 2010 2011
June 325,000 300,000 312,500 285,000 305,000
Jul y 360,000 350,000 355,000 330,000 345,000
August 340,000 325,000 332,500 295,000 330,000
3-M ont h Aggr egat e: 1,025,000 975,000 1,000,000 910,000 980,000
[ Sum of June, Jul y, August ]
Dow n Per cent age: -9.0% =(910,000 - 1,000,000)/ 1,000,000
Up Per cent age: 7.7% =(980,000 - 910,000)/ 910,000
Exampl e 4B:
M ont h 2008 2009
Aver age of
2008-2009 2010 2011
June 325,000 300,000 312,500 385,000 305,000
Jul y 360,000 350,000 355,000 230,000 345,000
August 340,000 325,000 332,500 295,000 330,000
3-M ont h Aggr egat e: 1,025,000 975,000 1,000,000 910,000 980,000
[ Sum of June, Jul y, August ]
Dow n Per cent age: -9.0% =(910,000 - 1,000,000)/ 1,000,000
Up Per cent age: 7.7% =(980,000 - 910,000)/ 910,000
Exampl e 4C:
M ont h 2008 2009
Aver age of
2008-2009 2010 2011
June 325,000 300,000 312,500 385,000 305,000
Jul y 360,000 350,000 355,000 430,000 345,000
August 340,000 325,000 332,500 95,000 330,000
3-M ont h Aggr egat e: 1,025,000 975,000 1,000,000 910,000 980,000
[ Sum of June, Jul y, August ]
Dow n Per cent age: -9.0% =(910,000 - 1,000,000)/ 1,000,000
Up Per cent age: 7.7% =(980,000 - 910,000)/ 910,000
Not es:
Revenue by Year
Cl ai mant passes V-Test . Not e: A cl ai mant t hat sat i sf i es t he revenue pat t ern
requi rement s f or t he V-Test will al ways al so sat i sf y t he requi rement s f or t he
Modi f i ed V-Test and Down Onl y Test .
Exampl es of Revenue Pat t er n Requi r ement s f or Causat i on Test s
In t hese exampl es, t he cl ai mant i s l ocat ed i n Zone B or C, uses 2008-2009 average as Benchmark
Peri od, and has sel ect ed June, Jul y and August as i t s t hree consecut i ve mont hs.
Exampl e 4 demonst rat es t hat under an aggregat e t est , t hree mont hs of revenues are summed.
The i ndi vi dual mont hs may be up or down, as l ong as t he t hree mont h aggregat e peri od passes
t he t est .
Cl ai mant passes V-Test .
Revenue by Year
Cl ai mant passes V-Test .
Revenue by Year
The causat i on t est s woul d wor k i n t he same way f or cl ai mant s i n Zone D wi t h hi gher t hr eshol ds f or t he t est s. I n
Zone D, t he V-Test t hr eshol ds ar e -15% decl i ne, 10% upt ur n; t he M odi f i ed V-Test t hr eshol ds ar e -10% decl i ne, 7%
upt ur n; t he Down-Onl y Test t hr eshol d i s -15%.
028736
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-9 Filed 04/18/12 Page 13 of 17
13
Exhi bi t B
Exampl e 1: LT= Less t han GE=Gr eat er t han or equal t o
Cust omer Resi dence June-August ' 09 June-August ' 10
LT 60 mi l es f r om cl ai mant $80,000 $66,000
GE 60 mi l es f r om cl ai mant $20,000 $14,000
Tot al $100,000 $80,000
% GE 60 mi l es 20% 17.5%
Exampl e 2:
Cust omer Resi dence June-August ' 09 June-August ' 10
LT 60 mi l es f r om cl ai mant $50,000 $40,000
GE 60 mi l es f r om cl ai mant $50,000 $40,000
Tot al $100,000 $80,000
% GE 60 mi l es 50% 50%
Exampl e 3:
Cust omer Resi dence June-August ' 09 June-August ' 10
LT 60 mi l es f r om cl ai mant $50,000 $48,000
GE 60 mi l es f r om cl ai mant $50,000 $40,000
Tot al $100,000 $88,000
% GE 60 mi l es 50% 45.5%
Exampl e of Cust omer M i x Test (Non-Local Cust omers)
The cl ai mant i n t hi s Exhi bi t B uses t he same t hree-mont h t i me peri od as t he
cl ai mant i n Exhi bi t A (June-Jul y-August ).
Cl ai mant passes Cust omer Mi x Test : Claimant has a 12.5
percent decline in share of t ot al revenue f rom non-local
cust omers [ 12.5%= .125 = (20-17.5)/ 20] .
Cl ai mant f ai l s Cust omer Mi x Test : No change in share of
t ot al revenue f rom non-local cust omers. [ 0% = 0 = (50-
50)/ 50] .
Cl ai mant f ai l s Cust omer Mi x Test : Claimant has a 9%
decline in share of t ot al revenue f rom non-local cust omers
[ 9% = .09 = (50-45.5)/ 50] .
To pass t he t est , cl ai mant s must demonst rat e proof of a decl i ne of 10% or more
i n t he share of t ot al revenue generat ed by non-l ocal cust omers over t he same
peri od of t hree consecut i ve mont hs f rom May-December 2010 as sel ect ed by t he
cl ai mant f or t he Modi f i ed V-Test or Down Onl y Test s compared t o t he same
t hree consecut i ve mont hs i n 2009.
028737
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-9 Filed 04/18/12 Page 14 of 17
14
Exhi bi t C
Exampl e 1:
Cust omer Resi dence June-August ' 09 June-August ' 10
Zone D $80,000 $66,000
Zones A- C $20,000 $14,000
Tot al $100,000 $80,000
% Zones A- C 20% 17.5%
Exampl e 2:
Cust omer Resi dence June-August ' 09 June-August ' 10
Zone D $50,000 $40,000
Zones A- C $50,000 $40,000
Tot al $100,000 $80,000
% Zones A- C 50% 50%
Exampl e 3:
Cust omer Resi dence June-August ' 09 June-August ' 10
Zone D $50,000 $48,000
Zones A- C $50,000 $40,000
Tot al $100,000 $88,000
% Zones A- C 50% 45.5%
Exampl e of Cust omer M i x Test (Cust omers i n Zones A-C)
To pass t he t est , cl ai mant s must demonst rat e proof of a decl i ne of 10% or more
i n t he share of t ot al revenue generat ed by cust omers i n Zones A-C over t he
same peri od of t hree consecut i ve mont hs f rom May-December 2010 as sel ect ed
by t he cl ai mant f or t he Modi f i ed V-Test or Down Onl y Test s compared t o t he
same t hree consecut i ve mont hs i n 2009.
Cl ai mant f ai l s Cust omer Mi x Test : Claimant has a 9%
decline in share of t ot al revenue f rom cust omers in Zones A-
C [ 9% = .09 = (50-45.5)/ 50]
Cl ai mant passes Cust omer Mi x Test : Claimant has a 12.5
percent decline in share of t ot al revenue f rom cust omers in
Zones A-C [ 12.5%= .125 = (20-17.5)/ 20]
Cl ai mant f ai l s Cust omer Mi x Test : No change in share of
t ot al revenue f rom cust omers in Zones A-C. [ 0% = 0 = (50-
50)/ 50]
The cl ai mant i n t hi s Exhi bi t B uses t he same t hree-mont h t i me peri od as t he
cl ai mant i n Exhi bi t A (June-Jul y-August ).
028738
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-9 Filed 04/18/12 Page 15 of 17
Addendum To
Causat i on Requi rement s For Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms and
Compensat i on Framework f or Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms
The t erm Benchmark Period is defined at pp. 1-2 i n t he Compensat i on Framework f or
Busi ness Economi c Loss Clai ms (Ex. 4C). That def i ni t ion pr ovi des:
The Benchmar k Per i od i s t he pr e-DWH Spi l l t ime per i od whi ch cl aimant
chooses as t he basel i ne f or measur i ng i t s hi st or i cal f i nanci al
per f or mance. The cl aimant can sel ect among t he f ol lowi ng Benchmar k
Per iods: 2009; t he aver age of 2008-2009; or t he aver age of 2007-2009,
pr ovi ded t hat t he r ange of year s sel ect ed by t he cl aimant wi l l be ut i l i zed
f or al l Benchmar k Per iod pur poses.
Foot not e 2 of t he Causat i on Requi rement s For Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms (Ex. 4B) speci f ical l y
i ncor por at es t hat def i nit i on of Benchmar k Per iod by r ef er ence.
Accor di ngl y, once t he cl aimant sel ect s t he Benchmar k Per iod year (s) (2009, t he aver age of 2008-
2009, or t he aver age of 2007-2009), t he same Benchmar k Per i od year (s) are used for all Benchmark
Period purposes -- speci f ical l y, t he same Benchmar k Per iod year (s) ar e used f or pur poses of
det er mi ni ng bot h causat ion and compensat ion.
In cont r ast , a cl ai mant i s not r equi r ed t o use t he same mont hs i n t he Benchmar k Per i od f or
pur poses of est abl i shi ng causat i on pur suant t o Ex. 4B and det er mi ni ng compensat i on pur suant t o Ex. 4C.
For example, when eval uat i ng whet her a cl aimant can sat isfy causat ion using t he V Test , t he
cl ai mant may sel ect any consecut i ve 3-mont h per iod bet ween M ay and December 2010 f or compar i son
t o a compar abl e per iod i n t he Benchmar k Per iod (i .e., 2009, t he aver age of 2008-2009, or t he aver age of
2007-2009). Af t er est abl i shi ng causat i on, however , t he cl aimant may select a di f f er ent 3 or mor e
consecut i ve mont hs bet ween M ay and December 2010 i n det er mi ni ng compensat i on i n accor dance wit h
t he Compensat i on Framework f or Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms, so l ong as t he cl aimant uses t he
same Benchmar k Per i od year s as t he basi s f or compar ison. Thus, i f t he cl aimant sel ect ed f or causat ion
t he t hr ee mont hs of M ay - Jul y i n t he Benchmar k Per iod year s of t he aver age of 2008-2009, t he cl ai mant
can sel ect f or compensat ion di f f er ent mont hs -- e.g., August - Oct ober -- but must use t he same aver age
of 2008-2009 Benchmar k Per i od. The same Benchmar k Per i od year (s) t hus must be used bot h f or
causat i on (Ex. 4B) and compensat i on (Ex. 4C).
The addi t i onal exampl es on t he next page i l l ust r at e t hese r ul es:
028779
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-9 Filed 04/18/12 Page 16 of 17
Scenar i o 1:
1) Cl ai mant sel ect ed t he mont hs of M ay-Jul y 2010 f or t he pur pose of det er mi ni ng causat i on, and
t he cl aimant , usi ng t hese mont hs, meet s t he causat ion t est f or t he Benchmar k per i od year s of
2009, 2008-2009 and 2007-2009;
2) In det er mi ni ng Compensat ion, Cl aimant woul d be al l owed t o sel ect t he mont hs of August
t hr ough November 2010 as compar ed t o t he mont hs of August t hr ough November i n ei t her
2009, 2008-2009 or 2007-2009 as t he Benchmar k year s whi chever pr ovi des t he hi ghest
compensat ion.
Scenar i o 2:
1) Cl ai mant sel ect ed t he mont hs of Oct ober December 2010 f or t he pur pose of det er mi ni ng
causat i on and t he clai mant , usi ng t hese mont hs, meet s t he causat ion t est f or t he
Benchmar k per iod year s of 2009, 2008-2009;
2) In det er mi ni ng compensat ion, Cl aimant coul d sel ect t he mont hs of M ay-Sept ember 2010 as
compar ed t o t he mont hs of M ay-Sept ember i n ei t her 2009 or 2008-2009 whi chever
pr ovi des t he hi ghest compensat i on.
Scenar i o 3:
1) Cl ai mant sel ect ed t he mont hs of June August 2010 f or t he pur pose of det er mi ni ng
causat i on and t he clai mant , usi ng t hese mont hs, meet s t he causat ion t est f or t he
Benchmar k per iod year of 2009. In addi t i on, Cl ai mant sel ect ed t he mont hs of August
Oct ober 2010 f or t he pur pose of det er mi ni ng causat i on, and t he cl aimant , usi ng t hese
mont hs, meet s t he causat ion t est f or t he Benchmar k per i od year s of 2007-2009;
2) In det er mi ni ng compensat ion, Cl aimant coul d sel ect t he mont hs of M ay-December 2010 as
compar ed t o t he mont hs of M ay-December i n ei t her 2009 or 2007-2009 whi chever
pr ovi des t he hi ghest compensat i on.
028780
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-9 Filed 04/18/12 Page 17 of 17
EXHIBIT 4C
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-10 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 8
1
Compensat i on Fr amew or k f or Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms
The compensat i on f r amew or k f or busi ness cl ai mant s compar es t he act ual pr of i t of a busi ness dur i ng a
def i ned post -spi l l per i od i n 2010 t o t he pr of i t t hat t he cl ai mant mi ght have expect ed t o ear n i n t he
compar abl e post -spi l l per i od of 2010.
1
The cal cul at i on i s di vi ded i nt o t w o st eps:
St ep 1 Compensat es cl ai mant s f or any r educt i on i n pr of i t bet w een t he 2010 Compensat i on
Per i od sel ect ed by t he cl ai mant and t he compar abl e mont hs of t he Benchmar k Per i od. St ep 1
compensat i on r ef l ect s t he r educt i on i n Var i abl e Pr of i t (w hi ch r ef l ect s t he cl ai mant s r evenue
l ess i t s var i abl e cost s) over t hi s per i od.
St ep 2 Compensat es cl ai mant s f or i ncr ement al pr of i t s or l osses t he cl ai mant mi ght have been
expect ed t o gener at e i n t he absence of t he spi l l r el at i ve t o sal es f r om t he Benchmar k Per i od.
Thi s cal cul at i on r ef l ect s a Cl ai mant -Speci f i c Fact or t hat capt ur es gr ow t h or decl i ne i n t he pr e-
spi l l mont hs of 2010 compar ed t o t he compar abl e mont hs of t he Benchmar k Per i od and a
Gener al Adj ust ment Fact or .
For pur poses of t he t w o st ep cal cul at i on, t he par t i es have agr eed t o a def i ned l i st of f i xed and var i abl e
expenses as r ef l ect ed i n At t achment A.
In or der t o al l ocat e payr ol l expenses (i ncl udi ng Sal ar i es and Wages, Empl oyee Benef i t s, and, w her e
appl i cabl e, 401K Payment s, but excl udi ng Ow ner / Of f i cer Compensat i on) i nt o f i xed and var i abl e
component s, a mi ni mum l evel of f i xed payr ol l cost s w i l l be measur ed based on t he aver age of t he t w o
mont hs bet w een M ay 2010 and December 2010 i n w hi ch t he cl ai mant had i t s l ow est payr ol l cost s.
Cer t ai n except i ons ar e i dent i f i ed bel ow f or i dent i f yi ng mont hs w i t h t he cl ai mant s l ow est payr ol l cost s.
For cl ai mant s t hat i ncl ude Cost of Goods Sol d (COGS) i n t hei r f i nanci al st at ement s, COGS w i l l be t r eat ed
as a var i abl e expense af t er excl udi ng, t o t he ext ent possi bl e, t he f ol l ow i ng cost i t ems w hi ch may be
embedded i n COGS and ar e l i kel y t o be f i xed i n nat ur e: Fi xed COGS Payr ol l , Amor t i zat i on, Depr eci at i on,
Insur ance Expense, Int er est Expense, and Cont r act Ser vi ces.
Based on t hese consi der at i ons, t he r esul t i ng cal cul at i ons ar e per f or med t o det er mi ne compensat i on f or
cl ai mant s.
I. Def i ni t i ons
For t he pur poses of t hi s cal cul at i on, t he f ol l ow i ng ar e def i ned t er ms:
Compensat i on Per i od: The Compensat i on Per i od i s sel ect ed by t he Cl ai mant t o i ncl ude t hr ee or mor e
consecut i ve mont hs bet w een M ay and December 2010.
Benchmar k Per i od: The Benchmar k Per i od i s t he pr e-DWH Spi l l t i me per i od w hi ch cl ai mant chooses as
t he basel i ne f or measur i ng i t s hi st or i cal f i nanci al per f or mance. The cl ai mant can sel ect among t he
1
Thi s Compensat i on Fr amewor k f or Busi ness Cl ai ms does not appl y t o (i ) st ar t -up busi nesses and (i i ) f ai l ed
busi nesses. Compensat i on f r amew or ks f or t hese t ypes of busi nesses w i l l be pr esent ed separ at el y.
02294
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-10 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 8
2
f ol l ow i ng Benchmar k Per i ods: 2009; t he aver age of 2008-2009; or t he aver age of 2007-2009, pr ovi ded
t hat t he r ange of year s sel ect ed by t he cl ai mant w i l l be ut i l i zed f or al l Benchmar k Per i od pur poses.
Cl ai mant -Speci f i c Fact or : In or der t o capt ur e t he i mpact of pr e-DWH Spi l l t r ends i n t he cl ai mant s
r evenue per f or mance t hat mi ght have been expect ed i n t he post -DWH Spi l l Benchmar k Per i od, r evenue
w i l l be adj ust ed by a Cl ai mant -Speci f i c Fact or . The f ol l ow i ng st eps w i l l be used t o comput e t he
Cl ai mant -Speci f i c Fact or :
A. Cal cul at e t he di f f er ence bet w een cl ai mant s t ot al r evenue f or Januar y t hr ough Apr i l
2010 and t ot al r evenue i n Januar y t hr ough Apr i l of t he cor r espondi ng cl ai mant
sel ect ed Benchmar k Per i od.
B. Di vi de t he r evenue change cal cul at ed i n St ep A by t ot al r evenue i n Januar y t hr ough Apr i l
of t he Benchmar k Per i od t o der i ve t he Cl ai mant -Speci f i c Fact or . If t he cal cul at ed
Cl ai mant -Speci f i c Fact or f al l s bel ow -2% or exceeds +10%, t hen i t w i l l be set at -2% or
+10%, r espect i vel y.
Gener al Adj ust ment Fact or : In addi t i on t o t he Cl ai mant -Speci f i c f act or , al l Cl ai mant s shal l be ent i t l ed t o
a 2.0% Gener al Adj ust ment Fact or .
Var i abl e Pr of i t : Thi s i s cal cul at ed f or bot h t he Benchmar k Per i od and t he Compensat i on Per i od as
f ol l ow s:
1. Sum t he mont hl y r evenue over t he per i od.
2. Subt r act t he cor r espondi ng var i abl e expenses f r om r evenue over t he same t i me per i od.
Var i abl e expenses i ncl ude:
a. Var i abl e Cost s as i dent i f i ed i n At t achment A.
b. Var i abl e por t i on of sal ar i es, cal cul at ed as descr i bed bel ow i n t he def i ni t i on of Fi xed and
Var i abl e Payr ol l Expenses.
c. Var i abl e por t i on of COGS, cal cul at ed by excl udi ng sal ar y cost s (w hi ch ar e di scussed bel ow i n
t he def i ni t i on of Fi xed and Var i abl e Payr ol l Expenses) and f i xed expenses i ncl uded w i t hi n
COGS, i ncl udi ng Amor t i zat i on, Depr eci at i on, Insur ance Expense, and Int er est Expense and
Cont r act Ser vi ces.
Var i abl e M ar gi n: Thi s i s cal cul at ed onl y f or t he Benchmar k Per i od and i s cal cul at ed as f ol l ow s:
1. Sum Var i abl e Pr of i t f r om M ay t hr ough December of t he year s sel ect ed by t he cl ai mant t o be
used f or t he Benchmar k Per i od.
2. Sum t ot al r evenue f r om M ay t hr ough December of t he year s sel ect ed by t he cl ai mant t o be
used f or t he Benchmar k Per i od.
3. Cal cul at e Var i abl e M ar gi n per cent as Var i abl e Pr of i t cal cul at ed i n (1) di vi ded by t ot al
r evenue cal cul at ed i n (2).
02295
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-10 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 8
3
Fi xed and Var i abl e Payr ol l Expenses: Fi xed and Var i abl e Payr ol l Expenses ar e cal cul at ed based on t he
under st andi ng t hat ever y busi ness must oper at e w i t h a mi ni mum cor e st af f and ar e def i ned usi ng
mont hl y pr of i t and l oss st at ement s and/ or t hose document s l i st ed i n t he Document at i on Requi r ement s
f or Busi ness Cl ai ms, f or M ay t hr ough December 2010. Fi xed and Var i abl e Payr ol l expenses ar e
cal cul at ed as f ol l ow s:
1. Obt ai n mont hl y amount s f or t he f ol l ow i ng payr ol l expenses (excl udi ng Ow ner / Of f i cer
Compensat i on): (a) Sal ar i es & w ages; (b) Payr ol l t axes (i ncl udi ng FICA, w or ker s compensat i on
i nsur ance, unempl oyment t ax); (c) Empl oyer cost s f or empl oyee benef i t s. Cal cul at i ons i ncl ude
component s of sal ar i es and r el at ed expenses i ncl uded i n bot h Sel l i ng, Gener al & Admi ni st r at i ve
Expenses ( SG& A ) and COGS.
2. Sum t hese payr ol l expenses on a mont hl y basi s t o det er mi ne t he Tot al Payr ol l Expense f or each
mont h.
3. Ident i f y t he t w o mont hs bet w een M ay and December 2010 w i t h t he l ow est Tot al Payr ol l
Expense.
M ont hs i n w hi ch t he cl ai mant has zer o r evenue, zer o non-of f i cer payr ol l expenses, or
t he busi ness i s cl osed, w i l l be excl uded f r om t hi s cal cul at i on.
4. Def i ne Fi xed Payr ol l Expenses as t he aver age payr ol l expense over t he t w o mont hs w i t h t he
l ow est Tot al Payr ol l Expense.
5. For any mont h w i t h Tot al Payr ol l Expenses l ess t han Fi xed Payr ol l Expenses, al l payr ol l cost s w i l l
be consi der ed f i xed expenses.
6. For any mont h w i t h Tot al Payr ol l Expenses gr eat er t han Fi xed Payr ol l Expenses, t he excess
amount of Tot al Payr ol l Expenses w i l l be consi der ed var i abl e expenses.
Incr ement al Revenue: Incr ement al r evenue shal l be cal cul at ed as (i ) t he cl ai mant s r evenue i n a
cl ai mant -sel ect ed per i od of si x, seven or ei ght consecut i ve mont hs (as set f or t h i n St ep 2 bel ow )
bet w een M ay and December of t he year s sel ect ed by t he cl ai mant t o be i ncl uded i n t he Benchmar k
Per i od, mul t i pl i ed by (i i ) t he Cl ai mant -Speci f i c Fact or and t he Gener al Adj ust ment Fact or .
II. Descr i pt i on of Compensat i on Cal cul at i on
St ep 1 Compensat i on
St ep 1 of t he compensat i on cal cul at i on i s det er mi ned as t he di f f er ence i n Var i abl e Pr of i t bet w een t he
2010 Compensat i on Per i od sel ect ed by t he cl ai mant and t he Var i abl e Pr of i t over t he compar abl e
mont hs of t he Benchmar k Per i od.
As not ed above, t he Compensat i on Per i od i s sel ect ed by t he Cl ai mant t o i ncl ude t hr ee or mor e
consecut i ve mont hs bet w een M ay and December 2010.
0229
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-10 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 8
4
For cl ai mant s t hat par t i ci pat ed i n t he VoO pr ogr am, Var i abl e Pr of i t i n t he Compensat i on Per i od w i l l
excl ude r evenue gener at ed by or cost s i ncur r ed i n connect i on w i t h VoO.
2
St ep 2 Compensat i on
St ep 2 of t he Compensat i on Cal cul at i on f or Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms i s i nt ended t o compensat e
cl ai mant s f or i ncr ement al pr of i t s t he cl ai mant mi ght have been expect ed t o gener at e i n 2010 i n t he
absence of t he spi l l , based on t he cl ai mant s gr ow t h i n r evenue i n Januar y-Apr i l of 2010 r el at i ve t o t he
cl ai mant -sel ect ed Benchmar k Per i od (2009 or (aver age of 2008 and 2009) or (aver age of 2007, 2008 and
2009)).
Cal cul at i on:
Usi ng mont hl y pr of i t and l oss st at ement s and/ or t hose document s l i st ed i n t he Document at i on
Requi r ement s f or Busi ness Cl ai ms:
1. Cl ai mant may sel ect f r om t he f ol l ow i ng si x-consecut i ve mont h per i ods f or cal cul at i ng
St ep 2 Compensat i on:
a. M ay-Oct ober
b. June-November
c. Jul y-December
Unl ess cl ai mant chose a seven-consecut i ve-mont h or ei ght -consecut i ve-mont h per i od i n
St ep 1, i n w hi ch case t hat same per i od of i dent i cal consecut i ve mont hs i n 2010 shal l be
used f or St ep 2.
2. Cal cul at e t he Cl ai mant -Speci f i c Fact or :
a. Cal cul at e t he di f f er ence bet w een cl ai mant s t ot al r evenue f or Januar y t hr ough Apr i l
2010 and t ot al r evenue i n Januar y t hr ough Apr i l of t he Benchmar k Per i od.
b. Di vi de t he r evenue change cal cul at ed i n [ 2.a] by t ot al r evenue i n Januar y t hr ough Apr i l
of t he Benchmar k Per i od t o der i ve t he Cl ai mant -Speci f i c Fact or . If t he cal cul at ed
Cl ai mant -Speci f i c Fact or f al l s bel ow -2% or exceeds +10%, t hen i t w i l l be set at -2% or
+10%, r espect i vel y.
3. Cal cul at e Incr ement al Revenue:
a. Cal cul at e t ot al r evenue i n t he consecut i ve mont hs of t he Benchmar k Per i od sel ect ed i n
[ 1] above.
b. M ul t i pl y t ot al r evenue by t he sum of t he Cl ai mant -Speci f i c Fact or and t he Gener al
Adj ust ment Fact or of 2% t o cal cul at e Incr ement al Revenue.
4. M ul t i pl y Incr ement al Revenue by t he Var i abl e M ar gi n i n t he Benchmar k Per i od t o cal cul at e St ep
2 Compensat i on.
2
Cl ai mant s ar e r equi r ed t o r epor t payment s r ecei ved under t he VoO pr ogr am. If cl ai mant s t hat r ecei ved VoO
payment s f ai l separ at el y t o r epor t cost s i ncur r ed i n VoO and non-VoO act i vi t i es, t hen St ep 1 Compensat i on f or
non-VoO act i vi t y al one can be det er mi ned t hr ough a pr o-r at a r evenue based al l ocat i on of var i abl e cost s bet w een
VoO and non-VoO r el at ed act i vi t i es.
02297
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-10 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 8
5
Exampl e 1:
In t hi s exampl e, t he cl ai mant sel ect s June-November as t he si x-consecut i ve mont h per i od i n t he
Benchmar k Per i od t o cal cul at e St ep 2 Compensat i on:
June-November Revenue i n t he Benchmar k Per i od [ a] $200,000
Cl ai mant -Speci f i c Fact or [ b] 8%
Gener al Adj ust ment Fact or [ c] 2%
Incr ement al Revenue [ d] = [ a] * ([ b] +[ c] ) $20,000
Var i abl e M ar gi n Per cent age [ e] 50%
St ep 2 Compensat i on [ f ] = [ d] * [ e] $10,000
Exampl e 2:
In t hi s exampl e, t he cl ai mant sel ect ed June-December as t he seven-consecut i ve mont h Compensat i on
Per i od i n St ep 1 and t her ef or e must use t he same per i od of i dent i cal consecut i ve mont hs i n t he
Benchmar k Per i od t o cal cul at e St ep 2 Compensat i on:
June-December Revenue i n t he Benchmar k Per i od [ a] $220,000
Cl ai mant -Speci f i c Fact or [ b] 8%
Gener al Adj ust ment Fact or [ c] 2%
Incr ement al Revenue [ d] = [ a] * ([ b] +[ c] ) $22,000
Var i abl e M ar gi n Per cent age [ e] 50%
St ep 2 Compensat i on [ f ] = [ d] * [ e] $11,000
Tot al Compensat i on
Tot al Compensat i on i s cal cul at ed as f ol l ow s:
(1) Add St ep 1 Compensat i on t o St ep 2 Compensat i on.
(2) Appl y t he agr eed-upon Ri sk Tr ansf er Pr emi um (RTP).
(3) Wher e appl i cabl e, subt r act f r om t he sum of St ep 1 Compensat i on and St ep 2 Compensat i on any
payment s r ecei ved by t he cl ai mant f r om BP or t he GCCF pur suant t o BP s OPA cl ai ms pr ocess, as
w el l as any VoO Set t l ement Payment Of f set and VoO Ear ned Income Of f set .
02298
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-10 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 8
Addendum To
Causat i on Requi rement s For Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms and
Compensat i on Framework f or Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms
The t erm Benchmark Period is defined at pp. 1-2 i n t he Compensat i on Framework f or
Busi ness Economi c Loss Clai ms (Ex. 4C). That def i ni t ion pr ovi des:
The Benchmar k Per i od i s t he pr e-DWH Spi l l t ime per i od whi ch cl aimant
chooses as t he basel i ne f or measur i ng i t s hi st or i cal f i nanci al
per f or mance. The cl aimant can sel ect among t he f ol lowi ng Benchmar k
Per iods: 2009; t he aver age of 2008-2009; or t he aver age of 2007-2009,
pr ovi ded t hat t he r ange of year s sel ect ed by t he cl aimant wi l l be ut i l i zed
f or al l Benchmar k Per iod pur poses.
Foot not e 2 of t he Causat i on Requi rement s For Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms (Ex. 4B) speci f ical l y
i ncor por at es t hat def i nit i on of Benchmar k Per iod by r ef er ence.
Accor di ngl y, once t he cl aimant sel ect s t he Benchmar k Per iod year (s) (2009, t he aver age of 2008-
2009, or t he aver age of 2007-2009), t he same Benchmar k Per i od year (s) are used for all Benchmark
Period purposes -- speci f ical l y, t he same Benchmar k Per iod year (s) ar e used f or pur poses of
det er mi ni ng bot h causat ion and compensat ion.
In cont r ast , a cl ai mant i s not r equi r ed t o use t he same mont hs i n t he Benchmar k Per i od f or
pur poses of est abl i shi ng causat i on pur suant t o Ex. 4B and det er mi ni ng compensat i on pur suant t o Ex. 4C.
For example, when eval uat i ng whet her a cl aimant can sat isfy causat ion using t he V Test , t he
cl ai mant may sel ect any consecut i ve 3-mont h per iod bet ween M ay and December 2010 f or compar i son
t o a compar abl e per iod i n t he Benchmar k Per iod (i .e., 2009, t he aver age of 2008-2009, or t he aver age of
2007-2009). Af t er est abl i shi ng causat i on, however , t he cl aimant may select a di f f er ent 3 or mor e
consecut i ve mont hs bet ween M ay and December 2010 i n det er mi ni ng compensat i on i n accor dance wit h
t he Compensat i on Framework f or Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms, so l ong as t he cl aimant uses t he
same Benchmar k Per i od year s as t he basi s f or compar ison. Thus, i f t he cl aimant sel ect ed f or causat ion
t he t hr ee mont hs of M ay - Jul y i n t he Benchmar k Per iod year s of t he aver age of 2008-2009, t he cl ai mant
can sel ect f or compensat ion di f f er ent mont hs -- e.g., August - Oct ober -- but must use t he same aver age
of 2008-2009 Benchmar k Per i od. The same Benchmar k Per i od year (s) t hus must be used bot h f or
causat i on (Ex. 4B) and compensat i on (Ex. 4C).
The addi t i onal exampl es on t he next page i l l ust r at e t hese r ul es:
028779
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-10 Filed 04/18/12 Page 7 of 8
Scenar i o 1:
1) Cl ai mant sel ect ed t he mont hs of M ay-Jul y 2010 f or t he pur pose of det er mi ni ng causat i on, and
t he cl aimant , usi ng t hese mont hs, meet s t he causat ion t est f or t he Benchmar k per i od year s of
2009, 2008-2009 and 2007-2009;
2) In det er mi ni ng Compensat ion, Cl aimant woul d be al l owed t o sel ect t he mont hs of August
t hr ough November 2010 as compar ed t o t he mont hs of August t hr ough November i n ei t her
2009, 2008-2009 or 2007-2009 as t he Benchmar k year s whi chever pr ovi des t he hi ghest
compensat ion.
Scenar i o 2:
1) Cl ai mant sel ect ed t he mont hs of Oct ober December 2010 f or t he pur pose of det er mi ni ng
causat i on and t he clai mant , usi ng t hese mont hs, meet s t he causat ion t est f or t he
Benchmar k per iod year s of 2009, 2008-2009;
2) In det er mi ni ng compensat ion, Cl aimant coul d sel ect t he mont hs of M ay-Sept ember 2010 as
compar ed t o t he mont hs of M ay-Sept ember i n ei t her 2009 or 2008-2009 whi chever
pr ovi des t he hi ghest compensat i on.
Scenar i o 3:
1) Cl ai mant sel ect ed t he mont hs of June August 2010 f or t he pur pose of det er mi ni ng
causat i on and t he clai mant , usi ng t hese mont hs, meet s t he causat ion t est f or t he
Benchmar k per iod year of 2009. In addi t i on, Cl ai mant sel ect ed t he mont hs of August
Oct ober 2010 f or t he pur pose of det er mi ni ng causat i on, and t he cl aimant , usi ng t hese
mont hs, meet s t he causat ion t est f or t he Benchmar k per i od year s of 2007-2009;
2) In det er mi ni ng compensat ion, Cl aimant coul d sel ect t he mont hs of M ay-December 2010 as
compar ed t o t he mont hs of M ay-December i n ei t her 2009 or 2007-2009 whi chever
pr ovi des t he hi ghest compensat i on.
028780
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-10 Filed 04/18/12 Page 8 of 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-11 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 2
Attachment A
Not e: Payr ol l expenses (i ncl udi ng Sal ar i es and Wages, Empl oyee Benef it s, Over t ime Wages, and, wher e applicable,
401K Payment s, but excl udi ng Owner / Of f i cer Compensat i on) wi l l be al l ocat ed bet ween f i xed and var i abl e
component s based on t he agr eed-upon payr ol l met hodol ogy.
* If claimant s financial st at ement s, books and/ or r ecor ds do not separ at el y i dent i f y Mai nt enance cost s and Repai r
cost s, cl ai mant shal l al l ocat e cost s associ at ed wi t h Repai r s and Mai nt enance 50% t o Fi xed Cost s and 50% t o
Var iable Cost s.
Fixed Costs
Variable Costs
Bad Debt Expense Variable
COGS - Variable Variable
Commissions Variable
Consumable Goods Variable
Contract Labor Variable
Credit Card Fees Variable
Discounts & Rebates Variable
Donations / Contributions Variable
Drug Testing Variable
Franchise Fees - Variable Variable
Freight Variable
Fuel Expense Variable
Inventory Adjustment Variable
*Repairs (excluding Maintenance) Variable
Sales/Lodging Tax Variable
Training & Education Variable
Travel & Entertainment Variable
Advertising Expense Fixed
Auto Expense Fixed
Bank Charges Fixed
Cleaning and Housekeeping Costs Fixed
COGS - Fixed Fixed
Computer and Internet Expenses Fixed
Contract Services Fixed
Dues and Subscriptions Fixed
Fees Fixed
Franchise Fees - Fixed Fixed
Insurance Fixed
Interest Expense Fixed
Lease Expense Fixed
Licenses And Taxes Fixed
*Maintenance Fixed
Misc Expense Fixed
Overhead Fixed
Postage Fixed
Professional Services Fixed
Property Taxes Fixed
Renovation Expense Fixed
Rental Expense Fixed
Retirement Expense Fixed
Security Services Fixed
Storage Expense Fixed
Supplies Fixed
Unemployment Tax Fixed
Uniforms Fixed
Utilities Fixed
028778
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-11 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-12 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 7
Addendum t o Compensat i on f or Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms:
Compensat i on f or Spi l l -Rel at ed Cancel l at i ons
A. El i gi bi l i t y
Thi s addendum set s f or t h t he excl usive compensat i on met hodology f or busi ness cl ai mant s t hat
pr ovi de appr opr i at e document at i on and whi ch est abl i sh causat i on by demonst r at i ng (a) a Spi l l -
Rel at ed Cancel l at ion pur suant t o Causat ion f or Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl aims Sect i on II.D or Sect i on
III.D, or (b) t he M odi f i ed V-Shaped Revenue Pat t er n and a cont r act cancel l at ion pur suant t o
Causat i on f or Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms Sect i on II.B or Sect ion III.B.
B. Def i ni t i ons
1. A Cancel ed Cont r act shal l be a cont r act (i ) whi ch was i n pl ace as of Apr i l 20, 2010, (i i ) t o be
per f or med bet ween Apr i l 21, 2010 and December 31, 2010, (i i i ) whi ch was canceled bet ween
Apr i l 21, 2010 and December 31, 2010, (i v) whi ch t he cl ai mant was unabl e t o r epl ace on t he
same or simi l ar t er ms bet ween Apr i l 21, 2010 and t he dat e t he cl aimant s cl ai m i s f i l ed, and
(v) f or whi ch causat i on was est abl i shed pur suant t o t he pr ovi sions of Causat ion f or Busi ness
Economic Loss Cl ai ms specif i ed i n Addendum Sect ion A above.
1
2. A Cancel ed Reservat ion shal l be a r eservat ion (i ) which was i n pl ace as of Apr i l 20, 2010,
(i i ) whi ch was t o occur bet ween Apr i l 21, 2010 and December 31, 2010, (i i i ) which was cancel ed
bet ween Apr i l 21, 2010 and December 31, 2010, (iv) whi ch t he cl ai mant was unabl e t o r ebook
on t he same or simi l ar t er ms, and (v) f or whi ch causat i on was est abl i shed pur suant t o t he
pr ovi sions of Causat i on f or Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms speci f i ed i n Addendum Sect ion A
above.
3. A Repl acement Cont ract shal l be a cont r act (i ) whi ch t he cl aimant ent er ed af t er Apr i l 21, 2010
and af t er t he Cancel ed Cont r act was cancel ed, but bef or e December 31, 2010, (i i) whi ch
pr ovi ded compl et e or par t ial r epl acement of pr of it expect ed f r om t he Canceled Cont r act , and
(i i i ) f or whi ch ser vices wer e per f or med bet ween Apr i l 21, 2010 and December 31, 2010.
4. A Repl acement Reser vat i on shal l be a r eser vat i on (i ) whi ch t he cl ai mant booked bet ween Apr i l
21, 2010 and December 31, 2010, and af t er t he Cancel ed Reser vat i on was canceled, (i i ) whi ch
pr ovi ded par t i al r epl acement of pr of i t expect ed f r om t he Canceled Reser vat i on, and (i i i ) whi ch
was compl et ed bet ween Apr i l 21, 2010 and December 31, 2010.
C. Compensat i on:
Compensat ion f or t he cl aimant s l i st ed i n Addendum Sect i on A above shal l be cal cul at ed as f ol lows:
1
As used i n t hi s Addendum, cont r act s shal l r ef er t o agr eement s ent er ed i n t he nor mal cour se of busi ness and
shal l speci f i cal l y excl ude cont r act s f or t he sal e of r eal pr oper t y, f i xed asset s, non-oper at i ng asset s, or f or al l or a
por t i on of t he busi ness i t sel f .
02878
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-12 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 7
2
1. Det er mi ne l ost r evenue f rom t he Cancel ed Cont r act or Cancel ed Reservat i on
a. Lost Cont r act Revenue shal l be t he amount t hat a cl ai mant woul d have been paid by a
cust omer bet ween Apr i l 21, 2010 and December 31, 2010 i n connect ion wi t h a Cancel ed
Cont r act , had t hat cont r act not been cancel ed as a r esul t of t he DWH Spi l l .
Lost Cont r act Revenue shall be det er mi ned based on inf or mat i on set f or t h i n t he Cancel ed
Cont r act , and, i f necessar y, ot her cont empor aneous document at ion pr ovi ded by t he
cl ai mant , such as pur chase or der s or shi ppi ng schedules. Lost Cont r act Revenue may
i ncl ude any f ood, bever age, or ot her anci l l ar y r evenue t hat t he cl aimant can demonst r at e
woul d have been expect ed i n connect i on wi t h t he Cancel ed Cont r act .
b. Lost Reser vat i on Revenue shal l be t he amount t hat a cl ai mant woul d have been pai d by a
cust omer (or cust omer s) bet ween Apr i l 21, 2010 and December 31, 2010 i n connect ion wi t h
a Cancel ed Reser vat i on, had t hat r eser vat i on not been cancel ed as a r esul t of t he DWH Spi l l .
Lost Reser vat ion Revenue shal l be det er mi ned based on i nf or mat i on set f or t h i n t he
document at ion r ef lect i ng t he t er ms of t he Cancel ed Reser vat ion, and/ or ot her
cont empor aneous document at i on pr ovi ded by t he cl ai mant . Lost Reser vat ion Revenue may
i ncl ude f ood and bever age sal es t hat t he cl aimant can demonst r at e woul d have been
expect ed i n connect ion wi t h t he Cancel ed Reser vat ion.
2. Det er mi ne l ost pr of i t associ at ed wi t h t he Cancel ed Cont r act or Cancel ed Reservat i on
Lost Cont r act Pr of i t shall be t he amount of var i abl e pr of i t t hat a clai mant would have ear ned
bet ween Apr i l 21, 2010 and December 31, 2010 i n connect i on wi t h a Canceled Cont r act , had
t hat cont r act not been cancel ed as a r esul t of t he DWH Spi l l .
Lost Reser vat i on Pr of i t shal l be t he amount of var i abl e pr of i t t hat a cl aimant woul d have
ear ned bet ween Apr i l 21, 2010 and December 31, 2010 i n connect ion wi t h a Cancel ed
Reser vat ion, had t hat r eser vat ion not been canceled as a r esul t of t he DWH Spi l l .
If (i ) t he Canceled Cont r act or Cancel ed Reser vat ion document at i on ei t her speci f ies cost s t o be
i ncur r ed by t he cl aimant , or speci f i es a pr of i t mar gi n in connect i on wi t h t he Cancel ed Cont r act
or Cancel ed Reser vat ion, or (i i ) t he cl aimant i s ot her wi se abl e t o pr ovi de a speci f ic est imat e of
t he pr of it expect ed f r om t he Canceled Cont r act or Cancel ed Reser vat ion based on speci f i c
account i ng f or pr ior event s t hat t ook pl ace af t er Januar y 1, 2007 and wer e compar abl e i n t er ms
of t ype, si ze and r evenue, t he cl aimant s lost pr of i t s associ at ed wit h t he Canceled Cont r act or
Cancel ed Reser vat ion shal l be det er mi ned accor di ng t o (a) below . Ot herwi se t he cl ai mant s lost
pr of i t s associat ed wi t h t he Cancel ed Cont r act or Cancel ed Reser vat ion shal l be det er mi ned
accor di ng t o (b) below.
a. Cancel ed Cont r act s or Cancel ed Reser vat i ons wi t h Expl i ci t Cost Inf or mat i on
For Cancel ed Cont r act s and/ or Canceled Reser vat i ons wi t h expl i ci t cost i nf or mat ion, Lost
Cont r act Pr of i t and Lost Reser vat i on Pr of i t shal l be det er mi ned as f ol lows:
028782
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-12 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 7
3
i . Ident i f y t he var i abl e expenses t hat woul d have been incur r ed (but wer e not act ual l y
i ncur r ed) by t he cl aimant in car r yi ng out t he Canceled Cont r act or Cancel ed
Reser vat ion accor di ng t o ei t her (i ) t he i nf or mat ion set f or t h i n t he Cancel ed
Cont r act or Canceled Reser vat ion document at ion, or (ii ) document at i on pr ovi ded by
t he cl aimant r egar di ng var iabl e expenses i ncur r ed i n connect ion wit h pr i or event s
whi ch wer e compar abl e i n t er ms of t ype, si ze and r evenue and t ook pl ace af t er
Januar y 1, 2007. The t ot al var i abl e expenses shal l al so i ncl ude any commi ssions or
bonuses t hat woul d have been pai d t o sales or ot her st af f had t he Canceled
Cont r act or Canceled Reser vat ion not been canceled.
i i . Sum (a) t ot al var i abl e expenses associ at ed wit h t he Cancel ed Cont r act or Canceled
Reser vat ion and (b) any cancel l at i on f ees, non-r ef undabl e deposit s or ot her
amount s r eceived by t he clai mant i n connect i on wi t h t he Canceled Cont r act or
Cancel ed Reser vat ion and (c) t he l i qui dat i on or salvage val ue of any pr oduct which
r emai ns unsol d as of t he cl ai m f i l i ng dat e.
i i i . Subt r act t he sum of (i i ) f r om t he Lost Cont r act Revenue or Lost Reser vat ion Revenue
as appl i cabl e.
b. Cancel ed Cont r act s or Cancel ed Reser vat i ons wi t hout Expl i ci t Cost Inf or mat i on
For Cancel ed Cont r act s and/ or Canceled Reser vat i ons wi t hout expl i cit cost i nf or mat ion, Lost
Cont r act Pr of i t and Lost Reser vat i on Pr of i t shal l be det er mi ned as f ol lows:
i . Det er mi ne t he var i able mar gi n f or t he cl aimant s busi ness f or t he per i od M ay
t hr ough December 2009 by di vi di ng:
1. The cl aimant s t ot al var i able expenses f rom May t hr ough December 2009
(wher e var i able expenses i ncl ude t hose i dent i f ied i n At t achment A t o t he
Compensat ion Fr amewor k f or Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms) by
2. The cl aimant s t ot al revenues f rom May t hrough December 2009.
i i . Mul t i pl y t he cl aimant s var iabl e mar gi n cal cul at ed i n A.2.b.i by t he cl aimant s Lost
Cont r act Revenue or Lost Reser vat ion Revenue, as appr opr i at e.
i i i . Fr om t he r esul t of (i i ), subt r act any non-r ef undabl e deposi t s or ot her amount s
r eceived by t he cl aimant i n connect i on wi t h t he Cancel ed Cont r act or Cancel ed
Reser vat ion and t he l i qui dat i on or salvage val ue of any pr oduct whi ch r emai ns
unsol d as of t he cl aim f i l i ng dat e.
3. Det er mi ne r evenue f r om t he Repl acement Cont r act or Repl acement Reser vat i on
a. Repl acement Cont r act Revenue shal l be t he amount t hat a cl aimant was pai d by a
cust omer bet ween Apr i l 21, 2010 and December 31, 2010 i n connect ion wi t h a Repl acement
Cont r act .
02878
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-12 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 7
4
Repl acement Cont r act Revenue shal l be det er mi ned based on document at i on est abl i shi ng
act ual r evenue r ecei ved (such as, f or example, pur chase or der s and/ or shi ppi ng schedul es)
i ncl udi ng, i f r el evant , i nf or mat ion set f or t h i n t he Repl acement Cont r act , pr ovi ded t hat
act ual cash r ecei pt s or ot her act ivi t y shal l be used i f conf l i ct i ng i nf or mat i on i s pr ovi ded.
Repl acement Cont r act Revenue must i ncl ude any f ood, bever age, or ot her anci l lar y r evenue
t hat t he cl aimant ear ned i n connect i on wi t h t he Repl acement Cont r act , i f r el evant .
b. Repl acement Reservat ion Revenue shal l be t he amount t hat a cl ai mant was paid by a
cust omer (or cust omer s) bet ween Apr i l 21, 2010 and December 31, 2010 i n connect ion wi t h
a Repl acement Reser vat ion.
Repl acement Reser vat i on Revenue shal l be det er mi ned based on document at ion
est abl i shi ng act ual r evenue r eceived, i ncl udi ng, i f r el evant , i nf or mat ion set f or t h in t he
document at ion r ef lect i ng t he t er ms of t he Repl acement Reser vat i on, pr ovi ded t hat act ual
cash r ecei pt s or ot her act ivi t y shal l be used i f conf l i ct ing i nf or mat i on i s pr ovi ded.
Repl acement Reser vat i on Revenue must i ncl ude f ood and bever age sales t hat t he cl aimant
made i n connect ion wi t h t he Repl acement Reser vat ion, i f r el evant .
4. Det er mi ne pr of i t associ at ed wi t h t he Repl acement Cont r act or Repl acement Reser vat i on
Repl acement Cont r act Pr of it shall be t he amount of var i abl e pr of i t t hat a cl ai mant ear ned
bet ween Apr i l 21, 2010 and December 31, 2010 i n connect i on wi t h a Repl acement Cont r act .
Repl acement Reservat ion Pr of it shal l be t he amount of prof i t t hat a cl ai mant ear ned bet ween
Apr i l 21, 2010 and December 31, 2010 i n connect ion wi t h a Repl acement Reser vat i on.
If cont empor aneous document at i on r egar di ng t he Repl acement Cont r act or Repl acement
Reser vat ion est abl i shes t he act ual cost s i ncur r ed by t he cl aimant i n car r yi ng out t he
Repl acement Cont r act or Repl acement Reser vat i on, t he cl aimant s var i abl e pr of it s associ at ed
wi t h t he Repl acement Cont r act or Repl acement Reser vat ion shal l be det er mi ned accor di ng t o
(a) below. Ot herwi se t he cl ai mant s var i abl e pr of it associ at ed wit h t he Repl acement Cont r act or
Repl acement Reser vat i on shal l be det er mi ned accor ding t o (b) below.
a. Repl acement Cont r act s or Repl acement Reservat i ons wi t h Act ual Cost Inf or mat i on
i . Ident i f y t he var i abl e expenses t hat wer e act ual l y i ncur r ed by t he cl aimant i n
car r yi ng out t he Repl acement Cont r act or Repl acement Reser vat i on accor di ng t o
document at ion pr ovi ded by t he cl aimant and/ or i nf or mat ion set f or t h i n t he
Repl acement Cont r act or Repl acement Reser vat i on document at i on, pr ovi ded t hat
i nf or mat i on r egar di ng act ual cost s shal l be used wher e conf l i ct i ng sour ces of cost
i nf or mat i on exi st . The t ot al var i abl e expenses shal l al so i ncl ude any commi ssi ons or
bonuses t hat wer e pai d t o sal es or ot her st af f had t he Repl acement Cont r act or
Repl acement Reser vat i on not been cancel ed.
i i . Subt r act t he t ot al var i abl e expenses associ at ed wit h t he Repl acement Cont r act or
Repl acement Reser vat i on f r om t he Repl acement Cont r act Revenue or Repl acement
Reser vat ion Revenue, r espect i vel y.
02878
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-12 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 7
5
b. Repl acement Cont r act s or Repl acement Reservat i ons wi t hout Act ual Cost Inf ormat i on
i . Det er mi ne t he var i able mar gi n f or t he cl aimant s busi ness f or t he per i od M ay
t hr ough December 2009 by di vi di ng:
1. The cl aimant s t ot al var i able expenses f rom May t hr ough December 2009
(wher e var i able expenses i ncl ude t hose i dent i f ied i n At t achment A t o t he
Compensat ion Fr amewor k f or Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms) by
2. The cl aimant s t ot al revenues f rom May t hrough December 2009.
i i . Mul t i pl y t he cl aimant s var iabl e mar gi n cal cul at ed i n A.2.b.i by t he cl aimant s Lost
Cont r act Revenue or Lost Reser vat ion Revenue, as appr opr i at e.
5. Cal cul at e Tot al Compensat i on Rel at ed t o t he Cancel ed Cont r act or Cancel ed Reser vat i on
Spi ll -Rel at ed Cancel l at i on Compensat ion shal l be compensat ion f or t he Cancel ed Cont r act or
Cancel ed Reser vat ion, net of amount s r ecei ved i n connect i on wi t h any Repl acement Cont r act (s)
or Repl acement Reser vat i on(s), as appl i cabl e, and shall be cal cul at ed as f ol lows:
a. The cl aimant s Lost Cont r act Prof i t / Lost Reservat ion Pr of i t (cal cul at ed i n St ep 2), l ess
b. Any Repl acement Cont r act Pr of it or Repl acement Reser vat ion Pr of i t (cal cul at ed i n St ep
4), l ess
c. Any payment s r ecei ved by t he cl aimant f rom BP or t he GCCF pur suant t o BP s OPA
cl ai ms pr ocess compensat ing f or t he l oss, as wel l as VoO Set t l ement Payment Of f set and
VoO Ear ned Income Of f set r el at ed t o t he Cancel ed Cont r act or Cancel ed Reser vat i on.
An RTP shal l appl y t o cl aimant s Spi l l -Rel at ed Cancel l at i on Compensat ion consi st ent wit h t he
cl ai mant s i ndust r y and/ or zone.
D. Document at i on
A cl ai mant shal l al so pr ovi de document at ion est abl i shi ng any Repl acement Cont r act or Repl acement
Reser vat ion, i ncl udi ng t he f ol l owi ng:
1. Document at ion r egar di ng any Canceled Cont r act (s) or Cancel ed Reser vat i on(s), incl udi ng t he
f ol l owi ng:
a. A copy of each Canceled Cont r act and document at ion est abl i shi ng t he t er ms of each
Cancel ed Reser vat ion.
b. Document at ion pr ovi di ng cont empor aneous wr i t t en evi dence t hat each Cancel ed
Cont r act and each Canceled Reser vat ion was cancel ed as t he di r ect r esul t of t he DWH
Spi l l , and/ or a Swor n Wr it t en St at ement f r om an i ndi vi dual t hi r d par t y af f i r mi ng t hat
each cancel l at ion was due t o or r esul t i ng f r om t he DWH Spi l l .
02878
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-12 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 7
6
c. Document at ion pr ovi di ng cont empor aneous w r i t t en evi dence t hat t he cl aimant was not
abl e t o r epl ace each Canceled Cont r act or Cancel ed Reser vat i on on t he same or simi l ar
t er ms, provided, t hat i f no such document at i on exi st s, t he cl aimant may pr ovi de a
Swor n Wr i t t en St at ement (1) st at i ng t hat no such cont empor aneous wr it t en evi dence
exi st s, (2) descr i bi ng t he clai mant s ef f or t s t o r epl ace t he Canceled Cont r act or Cancel ed
Reser vat ion, and (3) descr ibi ng t he ext ent t o whi ch t he cl aimant was not abl e t o r epl ace
t he Canceled Cont r act or Cancel ed Reser vat ion.
d. If not pr ovi ded i n a Cancel ed Cont r act or t he Canceled Reser vat ion document at ion, t he
cl ai mant shal l pr ovi de document at i on est abl i shi ng r evenue (i ncl udi ng any f ood,
bever age or ot her anci l l ar y r evenue) expect ed i n connect ion wi t h t hat Cancel ed
Cont r act and/ or Cancel ed Reser vat ion and one of t he f ol lowi ng:
i . Document at ion est abl i shi ng var i abl e expenses (i ncl uding any var i able expenses
r el at ed t o any f ood, bever age or ot her anci l l ar y r evenues) i ncur r ed i n connect i on
wi t h pr i or event s whi ch wer e compar able i n t er ms of t ype, si ze and r evenue and
t ook pl ace af t er Januar y 1, 2007
OR
i i . Document at ion est abl i shi ng t he t ot al r evenue and t ot al var i abl e expenses f or t he
cl ai mant s busi ness f or t he per i od May 1 t hr ough December 31, 2009.
Var i abl e expenses i ncl ude t hose i dent i f i ed i n At t achment A t o t he Compensat ion
Fr amewor k f or Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl aims.
e. Document at ion est abl i shi ng any cancel l at i on f ees, non-r ef undabl e deposi t s or ot her
amount s r eceived by t he clai mant i n connect i on wi t h t he Canceled Cont r act or Cancel ed
Reser vat ion.
f . Document at ion r ef lect i ng t he l i qui dat i on or salvage val ue of any pr oduct whi ch r emai ns
unsol d as of t he cl aim f i l i ng dat e.
2. Document at ion r egar di ng any Repl acement Cont r act (s) or Repl acement Reser vat i on(s), i f
r el evant , i ncl udi ng t he f ol lowi ng:
a. A copy of each Repl acement Cont r act and document at i on est abl i shi ng t he t er ms of each
Repl acement Reser vat i on.
b. Document at ion est abl i shi ng pr oj ect ed and act ual r evenues and var i abl e expenses
r el at ed t o each Repl acement Cont r act and each Repl acement Reser vat ion, i ncl udi ng any
f ood, bever age or ot her anci l l ar y r evenue and/ or expenses r ecogni zed i n connect ion
wi t h each Repl acement Cont r act and each Repl acement Reser vat i on. The clai mant
must also pr ovi de t he basi s f or such amount s and any cor r espondi ng suppor t i ng
document at ion. Var i abl e expenses i ncl ude t hose i dent i f i ed i n At t achment A t o t he
Compensat ion Fr amewor k f or Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms.
02878
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-12 Filed 04/18/12 Page 7 of 7
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-13 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 5
Compensat i on f or Mul t i -Faci l i t y Busi nesses
Thi s document i s i nt ended t o provi de opt i ons, or ot her gui dance, t o a Mul t i -Faci l it y Busi ness maki ng a
Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai m. Each Mul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness must sat i sf y al l document at i on
r equi r ement s set f or t h i n Document at ion Requi r ement s f or Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl aims and i n II
bel ow.
The choi ces avai l able t o Mul t i -Faci l i t y Busi nesses ar e di ct at ed by: (i) wher e t he business Headquar t er s
ar e l ocat ed; (i i ) whet her t he busi ness mai nt ai ned separ at e cont empor aneous prof i t and loss st at ement s
f or each Faci l i t y; and (iii) whet her all of t he business Facilit ies are locat ed wit hin t he Gulf Coast Areas.
A Mul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness wit h i t s Headquar t er s and al l Faci l it i es locat ed wit hin t he Gul f Coast Ar eas t hat
mai nt ai ned separ at e cont empor aneous pr of i t and l oss st at ement s f or each Faci l i t y dur i ng t he
Benchmark Per iod and 2010, may, at it s opt i on, el ect t o f i l e cl aims i n one of t wo ways: 1) A cl ai m f or
each i ndi vi dual Faci l i t y t hat t he Mul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness chooses t o i ncl ude i n t he clai m, or 2) a
consol i dat ed cl aim. If t he M ul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness chooses t o f i l e separ at e cl aims f or one, some, or al l of
i t s Faci l i t i es, t he appl i cabl e Causat i on st andar d and RTP shal l be appl i ed separ at ely t o each cl aimi ng
Faci l i t y based on it s locat ion and i ndust r y. If t he M ul t i-Faci l i t y Busi ness chooses t o f i l e a consol i dat ed
f acilit y claim, t he Causat ion st andar d and RTP appl i cabl e t o t he Headquar t er s shall be appl i ed t o t he
ent i r e consol i dat ed cl ai m.
A Mul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness wit h i t s Headquar t er s and al l Faci l it i es locat ed wit hin t he Gulf Coast Ar eas t hat
di d not mai nt ai n separ at e cont emporaneous pr of it and l oss st at ement s f or each Faci l i t y dur i ng t he
Benchmark Per iod and 2010, may, at it s opt i on, el ect t o f i l e cl aims i n one of t wo ways: 1) A cl ai m f or
each i ndi vi dual Faci l i t y t hat t he Mul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness chooses t o i ncl ude i n t he clai m, or 2) a
consol i dat ed cl aim. If t he Mul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness chooses t o f i l e separ at e cl aims f or one, some, or al l of
i t s Faci l i t i es, t he Addi t i onal M ul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness Document at ion must be provi ded, and t he Set t lement
Pr ogr am shal l appl y t he r elevant Causat ion st andar d and RTP separ at el y t o each cl ai mi ng Faci l i t y based
on i t s locat i on and i ndust ry. If t he M ul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness chooses t o f i l e a consol idat ed cl aim, t he
Causat i on st andar d and RTP appl i cabl e t o t he Headquar t er s shal l be appl i ed t o t he ent i re consol i dat ed
cl ai m.
A M ul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness wit h i t s Headquar t er s locat ed wi t hi n t he Gul f Coast Ar eas t hat has one or more
Faci l i t i es locat ed out si de of t he Gul f Coast Ar eas and mai nt ai ned separ at e cont empor aneous pr of i t and
l oss st at ement s f or each Faci l i t y dur i ng t he Benchmar k Per iod and 2010, may, at it s opt ion, el ect t o f i l e
cl ai ms i n one of t wo ways: 1) A clai m f or each i ndivi dual Faci l i t y locat ed i n t he Gul f Coast Ar eas t hat t he
Mul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness chooses t o i ncl ude i n t he cl aim, or 2) a consol i dat ed cl aim on behal f of al l
Faci l i t i es locat ed i n t he Gulf Coast Ar eas. If t he M ul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness chooses t o f i l e separ at e cl aims f or
one, some, or al l of i t s Faci li t i es locat ed i n t he Gul f Coast Ar eas, t he r el evant Causat i on st andar d and RTP
f or each cl aimi ng Faci l i t y based on it s locat ion and i ndust r y shal l apply. If t he M ul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness
chooses t o f i l e a consol i dat ed cl aim, t he Addi t i onal Mul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness Document at i on must be
0280 9
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-13 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 5
2
pr ovi ded, and t he Set t lement Progr am shal l ut i l i ze t he Causat i on st andar d and RTP appl i cabl e t o t he
Headquar t er s t o det ermi ne t he Set t l ement Payment t hat i s owed wi t h respect t o t he losses suf f ered by
al l Faci l i t i es locat ed wi t hi n t he Gul f Coast Ar eas.
A M ul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness wit h i t s Headquar t er s locat ed wi t hi n t he Gul f Coast Ar eas t hat has one or more
Faci l i t i es locat ed out si de of t he Gul f Coast Ar eas and di d not mai nt ai n separ at e cont empor aneous prof i t
and l oss st at ement s f or each Faci l i t y dur i ng t he Benchmar k Per i od and 2010, may, at i t s opt ion, elect t o
f i l e cl aims i n one of t wo ways: 1) A cl aim f or each i ndivi dual Faci l i t y l ocat ed i n t he Gul f Coast Ar eas t hat
t he M ult i -Faci l i t y Busi ness chooses t o i ncl ude i n t he clai m, or 2) a consol i dat ed clai m on behal f of al l
Faci l i t i es locat ed i n t he Gulf Coast Ar eas. If t he M ul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness chooses t o f i l e separ at e cl aims f or
one, some, or al l of i t s Faci li t i es locat ed i n t he Gul f Coast Ar eas, t he Addi t i onal Mul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness
Document at ion must be pr ovi ded and t he rel evant Causat i on st andar d and RTP f or each cl aimi ng Faci l i t y
based on it s locat ion and i ndust r y shal l appl y. If t he Mul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness chooses t o f i l e a
consol i dat ed cl aim, t he Addi t i onal Mult i -Faci l i t y Busi ness Document at ion must be pr ovi ded, and t he
Set t l ement Progr am shal l ut i l i ze t he Causat ion st andard and RTP appl i cabl e t o t he Headquar t er s t o
det ermi ne t he Set t l ement Payment t hat i s owed wi t h r espect t o t he l osses suf f ered by al l Faci l i t i es
l ocat ed wi t hi n t he Gul f Coast Ar eas.
A M ul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness wit h i t s Headquar t er s locat ed out si de of t he Gul f Coast Ar eas t hat mai nt ai ned
separ at e cont empor aneous pr of i t and l oss st at ement s f or each Faci l it y i n t he Gul f Coast Ar eas dur i ng
t he Benchmar k Per i od and 2010, may submi t separ at e cl ai ms f or one, some or al l Faci l i t i es locat ed
wi t hi n t he Gul f Coast Areas. The appl i cabl e Causat ion st andar d and RTP shal l be appl i ed separ at ely t o
each cl aimi ng Faci l i t y based on i t s l ocat i on and i ndust r y.
A M ul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness wit h i t s Headquar t er s locat ed out si de of t he Gul f Coast Ar eas t hat di d not
mai nt ai n separ at e cont empor aneous pr of it and l oss st at ement s f or each Faci l i t y i n t he Gul f Coast Ar eas
dur i ng t he Benchmar k Per iod and 2010, may submi t a consol i dat ed cl ai m f or al l Faci l i t i es locat ed wit hi n
t he Gul f Coast Ar eas. The Addi t i onal M ul t i -Faci l it y Busi ness Document at ion must be provi ded, and t he
Set t l ement Progr am shal l appl y t he rel evant Causat i on st andar d and RTP separ at el y t o each Faci l i t y
l ocat ed wi t hi n t he Gul f Coast Ar eas.
I. Def i ni t i ons
Mul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness: A business ent it y t hat , dur ing t he per iod Apr i l 1, 2010 t hr ough December 31,
2010, mai nt ai ned Faci l i t i es i n mor e t han one locat ion and had at l east one Faci l i t y wit hi n t he Gul f Coast
Ar eas.
Faci l i t y: A separ at e and di st i nct physi cal l ocat ion of a Mul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness at whi ch i t per f orms or
manages it s oper at ions.
028020
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-13 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 5
3
II. Mul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness Document at i on
1. Separ at e prof i t and loss (P&L) st at ement s f or each i ndi vi dual Faci l i t y t hat wer e pr epar ed and
mai nt ai ned i n t he nor mal cour se of busi ness must be pr ovi ded.
2. Organi zat i onal Descr i pt i on: A chart or descr i pt i on det ai l i ng al l Faci l i t i es i ncl uded i n t he Mul t i -
Faci l i t y Busi ness.
III. Addi t i onal Mul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness Document at i on
1. Consol i dat i ng Fi nanci al St at ement s: Consol i dat i ng f i nanci al st at ement s are requi r ed f or t he
Mul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness speci f yi ng pr of i t and l oss f or all Faci l i t i es and det ai l i ng el imi nat i ng
ent r i es requi r ed. In addi t ion, t he Mul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness wi l l complet e a Swor n Wr i t t en
St at ement t hat separ at e pr of i t and loss st at ement s f or each of t he cl aimi ng Faci l i t i es do not
exi st , and i ndi vi dual Faci l i t y P&L st at ement s pr epar ed f or t he pur pose of f i l i ng a cl ai m are based
on t he business s books and records.
2. Int ercompany Tr ansact i on Repor t s: Li st i ng of al l i nt ercompany t r ansact ions bet ween Faci l i t i es
i ncl uded i n t he Mul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness.
3. Al l ocat ed Cost Schedul e: Li st i ng of al l shar ed cost s bet ween Faci l i t i es of t he Mul t i -Faci l i t y
Busi ness and t he cal cul at i ons used t o al locat e t hose expenses bet ween Faci l i t i es. Where a
Mul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness pr epar es i ndi vi dual Faci l i t y P&L st at ement s based on i t s books and
r ecor ds t o suppor t a cl aim, al l shar ed cost s shal l be al locat ed among al l Faci l i t i es based on t hei r
shar e of t he t ot al revenue of t he Mul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness.
IV. Cost Al l ocat i on
1. Wher e a M ul t i -Faci l i t y business mai nt ai ned separ at e cont emporaneous pr of it and l oss
st at ement s f or each Faci l i t y dur i ng t he Benchmar k Per i od and 2010, and f i les a clai m f or one,
some, or al l f aci l i t i es wit hi n t he Gul f Coast Ar eas, al l dir ect expenses associ at ed wi t h each
cl ai mi ng Faci l i t y in t he Facilit y s cont emporaneously-pr epar ed P&L st at ement s, and onl y such
expenses, wi l l be i ncl uded in t he cal cul at i on.
2. Wher e a Mul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness pr epar es i ndi vi dual Faci l i t y P&L st at ement s based on i t s books
and r ecor ds t o support a clai m, al l shar ed cost s shal l be al l ocat ed among al l Faci l i t i es based on
t hei r shar e of t he t ot al r evenue of t he Mul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness.
V. Compensat i on
1. For a Mul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness whi ch has al l Faci l i t i es (i ncl udi ng Headquar t er s) i n t he Gul f Coast
Ar eas and f i l es a consol i dat ed cl aim on behal f of t he ent i r e busi ness, compensat ion shal l be
det ermi ned as set f ort h i n t he Busi ness Compensat ion Fr amework.
2. For any ot her Mul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness, compensat ion shal l be cal cul at ed usi ng t he Busi ness
Compensat ion Fr amework modi f ied as f ol l ows:
a. Sum l ost prof i t s and RTP(s) f or al l Faci l i t i es i n cl ai m.
028021
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-13 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 5
4
b. Subt r act any spi l l -r el at ed Payment s f rom t he i ni t i al BP cl ai ms pr ocess and/ or t he GCCF t o
t he Mul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness cl ai mant .
c. Subt r act any appl i cabl e VoO Set t lement Payment Of f set and/ or any appl i cabl e VoO Ear ned
Income Of f set .
028022
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-13 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 5
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-14 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 16
1
Fai l ed Busi ness Compensat i on Fr amew or k
1
I. Def i ni t i ons
A Fai l ed Busi ness shall be an ent it y t hat commenced oper at i ons pr i or t o November 1, 2008,
and t hat , subsequent t o M ay 1, 2010 but pr i or t o December 31, 2011, ei t her (i ) ceased
oper at i ons and wound down, or (i i ) ent er ed bankr upt cy (t hr ough t he f i l i ng of a pet it i on f or
bankr upt cy pr ot ect i on i n a cour t of compet ent j ur i sdi ct i on), or (i i i ) ot her w i se i nit i at ed or
compl et ed a l i qui dat i on of subst ant ial l y al l of i t s asset s.
A Fai l ed St ar t -Up Business shal l be an ent i t y t hat commenced oper at ions on or af t er
November 1, 2008, and, subsequent t o M ay 1, 2010 but pr i or t o December 31, 2011, ei t her (i )
ceased oper at i ons and wound down, or (i i ) ent er ed bankr upt cy (t hr ough t he f i l ing of a pet i t ion
f or bankr upt cy pr ot ect i on i n a cour t of compet ent j ur i sdi ct ion), or (i i i ) ot her w i se i nit i at ed or
compl et ed a l i qui dat i on of subst ant ial l y al l of i t s asset s.
II. Causat i on Requi r ement s
If t he cl ai m i s not excl uded by t he appl i cat i on of III bel ow, a cl ai mant may est abl i sh causat i on as
f ol l ows:
1. If t he cl ai mant i s a Fai l ed Busi ness or a Fai l ed St ar t -Up Busi ness in Zone A, t he
cl ai mant i s not r equi r ed t o pr ovi de any evi dence of causat i on unl ess you f al l i nt o
t he except ion agr eed t o by t he par t ies, and l i st ed i n f oot not e (1).
2. If t he cl ai mant i s a Fai l ed Busi ness or a Fai l ed St ar t -Up Busi ness meet i ng t he
def ini t ion of a Commer ci al Fi sher man, or Landi ng Si t e, or Commer ci al
Whol esal e or Ret ai l Dealer A, or Pr i mar y Seaf ood Pr ocessor , as set f or t h i n
Seaf ood Di st r ibut i on Chai n Def ini t ions, t he cl ai mant i s not r equi r ed t o pr ovi de
any evi dence of causat i on.
3. If t he cl ai mant i s a Fai l ed Busi ness or a Fai l ed St ar t -Up Busi ness in Zone A, B or C
and t he cl ai mant i s al so a Commer ci al or Whol esal e or Ret ai l Dealer B, or a
Secondar y Seaf ood Pr ocessor , or a Seaf ood Whol esal er or Di st r i but or, or a
Seaf ood Ret ai l er , as set f or t h in Seaf ood Di st r ibut ion Chai n Def i nit i on, t he
cl ai mant i s not r equi r ed t o pr ovi de any evi dence of causat i on.
4. If t he cl ai mant i s a Fai l ed Busi ness or a Fai l ed St ar t -Up Busi ness in Zone A or Zone
B, and t he cl ai mant al so meet s t he Tour i sm Def ini t i on, t he cl ai mant i s not
r equi r ed t o pr ovi de any evi dence of causat i on.
1
Thi s Fai l ed Busi ness Compensat i on Fr amewor k does not appl y t o (i ) St ar t -Up busi nesses (except Fai l ed St ar t -
Ups), (i i ) Ent i t i es, Indi vi dual s or Cl ai ms not i ncl uded w i t hi n t he Economi c Cl ass def i ni t i on; or (i i i ) Cl ai ms
cover ed under t he Seaf ood Pr ogr am.
028 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-14 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 16
2
5. If you ar e in Zone A, B or C, and you meet t he Char t er Fi shi ng Def i ni t i on you
ar e not r equi r ed t o pr ovide any evi dence of causat i on.
6. If t he cl ai mant i s a Fai l ed Busi ness in Zone B not r ecei vi ng a pr esumpt i on,
causat i on may be est abl ished by demonst r at i ng t he f ol l owi ng:
a. A 8.5% decl i ne in r evenues dur i ng t he mont hs f or whi ch it oper at ed
bet ween M ay 2010 and it s l ast f ul l mont h of oper at i ons (not t o ext end
beyond Apr i l 2011) as compar ed t o t he compar abl e mont hs dur i ng t he
per i od of M ay 2009 t hr ough Apr i l 2010.
AND
b. The Admi ni st r at or i s pr ovi ded evi dence t hr ough document at i on and/ or
af f idavi t s t hat pr ovi de a r easonabl e basi s t o concl ude t hat t he DWH Spi l l
was a subst ant i al cause of t he r evenue decl ine. For example, t he
cl ai mant pr ovides evidence of cust omer cancel l at ions or l ost cont r act s
r el at ed t o t he DWH Spi l l .
7. If t he cl ai mant i s a Fai l ed Busi ness t hat meet s t he def ini t ion of Seaf ood
Ret ai l er oper at ing out side of Zone A, B, or C, t he cl ai mant may al t er nat i vel y
est abl i sh causat i on by showi ng t hat i t exper i enced a 15% i ncr ease in cost s dur i ng
t he mont hs f or whi ch i t oper at ed bet ween M ay 2010 and it s l ast f ul l mont h of
oper at i ons (not t o ext end beyond Apr i l 2011) as compar ed t o t he compar abl e
mont hs dur ing t he per i od f r om M ay 2009 t hr ough Apr i l 2010. The cl ai mant must
al so est abl i sh t he speci f ic basi s f or t he cost i ncr ease and t hat , absent t he DWH
Spi l l , t he i ncr ease i n cost s woul d not have occur r ed.
8. If t he cl ai mant i s a Fai l ed St ar t -Up Busi ness i n Zone B not r ecei vi ng a
pr esumpt ion, causat ion may be est abl i shed by demonst r at ing t he f ol lowi ng:
a. A 8.5% decl i ne in r evenues dur i ng t he mont hs f or whi ch it oper at ed
bet ween M ay 2010 and it s l ast f ul l mont h of oper at i ons (not t o ext end
beyond Apr i l 2011) r el at ive t o expect ed r evenue in t he same t i me per i od
as demonst r at ed by cont empor aneous f i nanci al pr oj ect i ons (t o t he
ext ent avai l abl e) and expr essed as a per cent age of expect ed r evenue;
2
AND
b. The Admi ni st r at or i s pr ovi ded evi dence t hr ough document at i on and/ or
af f idavi t s t hat pr ovi de a r easonabl e basi s t o concl ude t hat t he DWH Spi l l
was a subst ant i al cause of t he r evenue decl ine. For example, t he
2
See Exhi bi t A at t ached her et o f or an exampl e of how t hi s cal cul at i on i s per f or med.
028 1
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-14 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 16
3
cl ai mant pr ovides evidence of cust omer cancel l at ions or l ost cont r act s
r el at ed t o t he DWH Spi l l .
9. If t he cl ai mant i s a Fai l ed Busi ness or Fai l ed St ar t -Up Busi ness i n Zone C, t hen
par agr aphs 6 and 8 appl y wi t h t he per cent age of decl i ne changing t o 10%.
10. If t he cl ai mant i s a Fai l ed Busi ness or Fai l ed St ar t -Up Busi ness i n Zone D, t hen
par agr aphs 6 and 8 appl y wi t h t he per cent age of decl i ne changing t o 15%.
III. Excl uded Busi ness Fai l ur e
Any Fai l ed Busi ness sat i sf yi ng subpar t s (a), (b), or (c), bel ow shal l not be ent i t l ed t o
compensat i on pur suant t o sect i on IV.
a. The Fai l ed Busi ness or Fai l ed St ar t -Up Busi ness r epor t ed negat i ve
EBITDA
3
f or t he t wel ve mont h per i od pr i or t o M ay 1, 2010 (or , in t he
event t hat t he cl ai mant i s a Fai l ed St ar t -Up Business w i t h less t han t w el ve
mont hs of oper at i ng hi st or y, negat i ve EBITDA f or t he mont hs dur i ng
whi ch t he busi ness oper at ed pr i or t o M ay 1, 2010).
b. The Fai l ed Busi ness or Fai l ed St ar t -Up Busi ness was i n def ault pr i or t o
M ay 1, 2010 under any exi st i ng f inancing agr eement .
c. The Fai l ed Busi ness or Fai l ed St ar t -Up Busi ness i s locat ed i n Zone D and
does not sat i sf y t he Tour i sm or Seaf ood Di st r i but i on Chain
def ini t ions.
IV. Document at i on Requi r ement s
1. Cl ai mant shal l pr ovide t he f ol lowi ng document at ion:
a. An af f idavi t f r om an aut hor i zed r epr esent at i ve of t he cl ai mant cer t i f yi ng
t he f ol lowi ng:
b. The posit i on of t he af f iant , hi s or her r el at i onshi p t o t he cl ai mant , and
cer t i f i cat i on t hat t he af f iant i s aut hor i zed t o act on behal f of t he cl ai mant .
c. The dat e on whi ch t he ent it y was i ncor por at ed and t he dat e on whi ch it
began oper at ions.
d. Cer t i f i cat ion t hat , as of M ay 1, 2010:
3
EBITDA i s def i ned as ear ni ngs bef or e i nt er est , i ncome t axes, depr eci at i on, amor t i zat i on and owner s
compensat i on.
028 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-14 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 16
4
i . No bankr upt cy f i l i ng, asset l iquidat ion, or debt r est r uct ur i ng had
been i nit i at ed; (A r enewal of a busi ness l oan wi l l not be deemed
r est r uct ur i ng.)
i i . The business was i n f ul l compl i ance wi t h al l covenant s as t o
f i nanci al condi t ion gover ni ng out st andi ng bor r owi ng or cr edit
agr eement s pr i or t o t he DWH Spi l l ; and
i i i . Al l document at ion submit t ed consi st s of or was der i ved f r om
document s mai nt ai ned in t he or dinar y cour se of busi ness.
2. Document s r ef lect i ng cor por at e or par t ner ship or gani zat i on (e.g., ar t i cl es of
i ncor por at i on or par t ner shi p agr eement s).
3. Act ual annual and mont hl y f inanci al st at ement s (i ncl uding income st at ement s
and bal ance sheet s) f or at l east al l of 2009 and Januar y-Apr i l of 2010 or if t he
cl ai mant i s a Fai l ed St ar t -Up Busi ness, f or al l mont hs of oper at i on pr i or t o M ay 1,
2010. Cl ai mant may pr epar e f i nanci al st at ement s f r om cont empor aneous
busi ness r ecor ds cur r ent ly mai nt ai ned, as long as t he cl ai mant pr ovi des t he
document s or inf or mat ion upon whi ch any subsequent l y-pr epar ed f inancial
st at ement s ar e based.
4. Act ual annual and mont hl y f inanci al st at ement s (i ncl uding income st at ement s
and bal ance sheet s) f or M ay 2010 t hr ough pr esent , or t hr ough t he l iquidat i on of
t he company, or cessat i on of oper at i on, whi chever occur s f i r st . Cl ai mant may
pr epar e f i nanci al st at ement s f r om cont empor aneous busi ness r ecor ds cur r ent l y
mai nt ai ned, as long as t he cl ai mant pr ovi des t he document s or inf or mat ion upon
whi ch any subsequent l y-pr epar ed f inanci al st at ement s ar e based.
5. Any and al l cr edit agr eement s, pr omi ssor y not es, l ease agr eement s, l et t er s of
cr edi t and ot her l oan document at i on, incl udi ng any not i ces of def aul t , i n
exi st ence as of Apr i l 20, 2010 or ent er ed int o t her eaf t er incl uding amendment s
r el at ed t her et o.
6. Any and al l pr oj ect i ons, f or ecast s or budget s pr epar ed pr i or t o Apr i l 20, 2010
pr oj ect ing, pr edi ct i ng or f or ecast ing t he f inanci al per f or mance of t he business
f or any per i od af t er Apr i l 20, 2010.
7. To t he ext ent appl i cabl e, any and al l bankr upt cy schedules, i ncluding t he or i gi nal
pet it i on, any conf i r med pl ans of l i qui dat i on or r eor gani zat i on, and any
document at i on evidencing st anding t o pur sue cl ai ms i f vest ed wi t h any ent i t y or
ot her par t y ot her t han t he debt or f i l ing bankr upt cy. To t he ext ent t he cl ai mant
has not f i l ed f or bankr upt cy pr ot ect i on, (a) document at i on r ef l ect ing t he
company s ent r y i nt o t he l i quidat i on process, (b) any and al l document at ion
r ef l ect ing t he st anding or aut hor i t y of t he cl ai mant t o pur sue any cl ai ms of t he
028
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-14 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 16
5
busi ness, and (c) any document at ion evi denci ng st andi ng t o pur sue cl ai ms i f
vest ed wi t h any ent it y or ot her par t y ot her t han t he cl ai mant pur sui ng t he
l i quidat i on of it s asset s.
8. Evi dence of any asset sales, i ncl udi ng a descr i pt i on of each asset and t he
cor r esponding sal es pr i ces, and evidence of any payment s of l iquidat i on
pr oceeds i n sat i sf act i on of debt and/ or ot her cr edi t or obl i gat i ons.
9. A l i st ing of any asset s whi ch have not been l iquidat ed at t he t i me of t he cl ai m
submi ssi on, i ncluding a descr i pt i on of each asset , t he r ecor ded net book val ue of
each asset , and, if avai labl e, al l cer t if i ed appr ai sal s of t he val ue of each asset .
10. A l i st ing of any debt and/ or t r ade cr edit or obl i gat ions out st andi ng at t he t ime of
t he cl ai m submi ssi on.
V. Compensat i on
1. For Fai l ed Businesses t hat meet one of t he causat ion r equir ement s set f or t h
above, cl ai mant compensat i on shal l be det er mined as f ol lows:
a. Sum t he l at est t wel ve mont hs EBITDA of t he business f or t he t wel ve
mont h per i od pr i or t o M ay 1, 2010.
b. Ident i f y t he gener al indust r y i n whi ch cl ai mant oper at es and l ocat e t he
cor r esponding medi an Mar ket Value of Invest ed Capi t al ( M VIC ) t o
EBITDA mult i pl e f r om Tabl e 1 bel ow. If an appr opr i at e i ndust r y and
mul t ipl e cannot be f ound i n t he Tabl e 1, use t he Al l Deal s medi an MVIC
t o EBITDA mul t ipl e at t he bot t om of t he t abl e.
c. M ult i pl y t he EBITDA by t he M VIC t o EBITDA mult ipl e t o cal cul at e t he Pr e-
DWH Spi l l t ot al ent er pr i se val ue ( TEV ).
d. Det er mi ne t he Liquidat ion Val ue of asset s as ei t her (i ) t he cour t -appr oved
r eor ganizat ion val ue, t o t he ext ent r eor ganized under bankr upt cy l aw
pr ocess or (i i ) sal es pr oceeds f r om asset s l i qui dat ed pl us cer t i f ied
appr ai sal val ues of asset s yet t o be l iquidat ed under a pl an of l iquidat ion,
net of act ual or ant i ci pat ed l iquidat ion cost s (i ncludi ng out -of -pocket
cost s t o t he cl ai mant f or t he l i qui dat i on or wi nd down pr ocess), as
r el evant . If no cer t i f i ed appr ai sal exi st s f or un-l i qui dat ed asset s, net book
val ues wi l l be used. The t ot al l i qui dat i on value (i ncl udi ng bot h r eal i zed
and unr eal i zed amount s) shal l be incr eased f or any cr edi t or cl ai ms
exi st i ng pr e-DWH Spi l l and di schar ged dur i ng bankr upt cy, and any
amount s recei ved by t he cl ai mant f rom BP or t he GCCF pur suant t o BP s
OPA Cl ai ms pr ocess, or pr of i t s ear ned by t he cl ai mant by par t i cipat ing in
any BP-sponsor ed spi l l r emedi at i on pr ogr am t o det er mi ne t he Net
028
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-14 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 16
6
Li qui dat i on Val ue. However , no cr edit wi l l be t aken f or unl iquidat ed
asset s t hat t he cl ai mant t ender s t o BP.
e. Cal cul at e cl ai mant compensat i on by subt r act i ng t he Net Li qui dat i on
Val ue f r om t he Pr e-DWH Spi l l TEV.
f . A Ri sk Tr ansf er Pr emi um ( RTP ) wi l l not be appl i ed t o cl ai mant
compensat i on f or Fai l ed Busi nesses because t he measur ement of TEV
i ncor por at es t he f ut ur e lost pr of it s of t he busi ness.
2. For Fai l ed St ar t -Up Busi nesses t hat meet one of t he causat i on r equi r ement s set
f or t h above, cl ai mant compensat i on shal l be cal cul at ed as f ol low s:
a. Cal cul at e book val ue of equi t y as of M ay 1, 2010.
b. Subt r act amount s di st r i but ed t o equit y hol der s subsequent t o t he DWH
Spi l l .
c. Add t he t ot al cur r ent amount of unpai d obl i gat i ons of cl ai mant t o i t s
cr edi t or s.
d. Subt r act t he book val ue of asset s r emai ning t o be l i quidat ed unl ess such
asset s ar e t ender ed t o BP t hen t he value shal l not be subt r act ed.
e. Subt r act any ot her pr oceeds r ecei ved by t he cl ai mant f r om BP or t he
GCCF pur suant t o BP s OPA Cl ai ms pr ocess, or prof i t s ear ned by t he
cl ai mant by par t i ci pat ing i n any BP-sponsor ed spi ll r emedi at ion pr ogr am.
f . Wher e a Fai l ed St ar t -Up Busi ness r ecei ves compensat i on under t hi s
f r amew or k, compensat i on shal l be pr ovi ded t o t he cl ai mant f or an
owner s sweat equi t y if t he owner s submi t af f idavi t s set t ing f or t h f or
each owner (i ) t he nat ur e of ser vi ces pr ovi ded by t hat owner t o t he
cl ai mant f or whi ch t he owner r ecei ved no compensat i on or l ess t han f ai r
mar ket compensat i on, (i i) t he t i me per i od over whi ch t he ser vi ces wer e
r ender ed, (i i i ) t he aver age amount of t i me per week devot ed t o t he
Fai l ed St ar t -Up Busi ness, and, (i v) i f empl oyed out si de t he Fai l ed St ar t -Up
Busi ness dur i ng t he t i me t he busi ness oper at ed, a descr i pt i on of t hat
empl oyment .
Wher e t hese cr i t er i a ar e sat i sf i ed, cl ai mant shal l be ent i t led t o sweat
equit y compensat i on as set f or t h bel ow . In addit i on, t wo exampl e
cal cul at i ons ar e at t ached her et o as Exhibi t B.
1. St ep 1: Cal cul at e t he M ont hl y Sweat Equi t y Benchmar k Income
pur suant t o St ep 1 subpar t s (a) t hr ough (d).
028
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-14 Filed 04/18/12 Page 7 of 16
7
St ep 1a: Ident i f y t he Commencement Dat e : t he day t hat t he
Fai l ed St ar t -Up Busi ness commenced oper at ions.
St ep 1b: Ident i f y t he Sweat Equi t y Cont r i but i on St ar t Dat e : t he
dat e when t he owner f i r st began per f or mi ng sweat equit y wor k or
t he dat e si x mont hs pr i or t o t he Commencement Dat e, whi chever
yi el ds t he shor t er t i me per i od.
St ep 1c: Est abl i sh t he Sweat Equi t y Benchmar k Per i od: The
Sw eat Equi t y Benchmar k Per i od shal l consi st of t he t i me per i od
f r om t he Sweat Equit y Benchmar k Per iod St ar t Dat e t hr ough t he
Sweat Equit y Benchmark Per i od End Dat e.
The Sweat Equit y Benchmar k Per i od St ar t Dat e wi l l be ei t her :
a) Januar y 1 of t he cal endar year pr eceding t he year
i n whi ch t he Sweat Equi t y Cont r i but i on St ar t Dat e
occur r ed, or
b) Januar y 1 of any year pr i or t o t he year ident i f ied in
(a) above, but not pr ecedi ng Januar y 1, 2007.
For example, f or a busi ness wi t h a Commencement Dat e of
Januar y 1, 2010, and a Sweat Equi t y Cont r i but i on St ar t Dat e of
August 10, 2009, t he cl ai mant may choose as t he Sw eat Equi t y
Benchmar k Per i od St ar t Dat e ei t her Januar y 1, 2008 or Januar y 1,
2007.
The Sweat Equit y Benchmar k Per i od End Dat e shal l be def ined
as t he end of t he l ast f ul l mont h pr ecedi ng t he Sweat Equit y
Cont r i but i on St ar t Dat e. For example, if t he Sw eat Equit y
Cont r i but i on St ar t Dat e was August 10, 2009, t he Sweat Equit y
Benchmar k Per i od End Dat e wi l l be Jul y 31, 2009.
St ep 1d: Cal culat e t he M ont hl y Sweat Equit y Benchmar k
Income. The owner shal l pr ovide document at i on of i ncome
ear ned f or t he Sw eat Equi t y Benchmar k Per i od, incl uding t ax
r et ur ns, W-2s, year -end pay st ub inf or mat i on and, i f avai l abl e,
mont hl y or ot her per i odic pay st ubs or ot her r ecor ds r ef l ect ing
mont hl y earned i ncome ( Ear ned Income Document at i on ).
M ont hl y Sweat Equit y Benchmar k Income shal l be det er mined by
di vi di ng:
(i ) Tot al i ncome ear ned f r om al l empl oyer s and/ or
act i vi t i es (i ncluding sel f -empl oyment ) dur i ng t he
028
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-14 Filed 04/18/12 Page 8 of 16
8
Sw eat Equi t y Benchmar k Per i od, as r ef l ect ed in
Ear ned Income Document at i on
by
(i i ) The t ot al number of mont hs in t he Sweat Equi t y
Benchmar k Per i od, adj ust ed, i f r el evant , t o
excl ude mont hs wher e t he owner pr ovi des
document s evi denci ng t hat
a. No i ncome was ear ned, and
b. The owner was not employed, f unct i oni ng as
an i ndependent cont r act or , or ot her w i se
engaged i n i ncome-gener at i ng act i vi t ies
unr el at ed t o t he Fai l ed St ar t -Up Business. For
exampl e, if t he owner was a r eal est at e agent
oper at i ng as an i ndependent cont r act or , t he
owner must incl ude al l mont hs f or whi ch he or
she f unct i oned as a r eal est at e agent , even i f
no income was ear ned in a par t i cul ar mont h.
2. St ep 2: For each owner , det er mi ne t he Sweat Equi t y
Compensat i on Per i od as t he per i od f r om hi s or her Sw eat Equit y
Cont r i but i on St ar t Dat e t o t he dat e t he Fai l ed St ar t -Up Busi ness (i )
ceased oper at i ons and wound down, or (i i ) ent er ed bankr upt cy
(t hr ough t he f i l ing of a pet i t ion f or bankr upt cy pr ot ect ion in a
cour t of compet ent j ur i sdi ct i on), or (i i i ) ot her w i se i nit i at ed or
compl et ed a l i qui dat i on of subst ant ial l y al l of i t s asset s ( Fai l ur e
Dat e ). Tot al M ont hl y Sweat Equi t y acr oss al l owner s in a gi ven
mont h i s cal cul at ed by summi ng t he mont hl y Sweat Equit y
Benchmar k Income f or each owner wi t h sweat equi t y i n t he
r el evant mont h f or al l mont hs i n t he Sweat Equit y Compensat i on
Per i od. The maxi mum amount of Tot al M ont hl y Sw eat Equi t y i n
any mont h i s $12,500. Tot al Sw eat Equit y r epr esent s t he sum of
t he Tot al M ont hl y Sweat Equi t y f or al l owner s and cannot exceed
$150,000.
3. St ep 3: To det er mi ne Net Sw eat Equi t y f or each owner , f r om t he
Tot al Sweat Equit y in St ep 2, subt r act (i ) any f unds (i ncl uding
payr ol l ear nings, dr aws, cancel l ed loans or ot her di st r i but i ons)
act ual l y pai d t o an owner by t he Fai l ed St ar t -Up dur i ng it s
028
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-14 Filed 04/18/12 Page 9 of 16
9
oper at i on and (i i ) any i ncome ear ned by t he owner f r om
empl oyment out si de t he Fai l ed St ar t -Up. These amount s shal l be
est abl i shed by t he owner pr ovidi ng document at ion in t he f or m of
t ax r et ur ns, W-2s, year -end pay st ub i nf or mat i on or t he Fai l ed
St ar t -Up s cont emporaneousl y maint ained payrol l r ecor ds.
g. An RTP wi l l not be appli ed t o cl ai mant compensat i on f or Fai l ed St ar t -Up
Busi nesses.
028 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-14 Filed 04/18/12 Page 10 of 16
10
Table 1: Indust ry Mult iples
Sour ce: Pr at t ' s St at s - Pr i vat e Company M er ger and Acqui sit i on Tr ansact ion Dat abase. Dat a
r ef l ect s al l deal s in t he dat abase w i t h a di scl osed M VIC t o EBITDA mult i ple and a r epor t dat e of
Januar y 1, 2008 or l at er .
41 Local And Suburban Transit And Interurban Highway Passenger Transportation 3.1x
42 Motor Freight Transportation And Warehousing 2.9x
44 Water Transportation 7.1x
45 Transportation By Air 4.6x
47 Transportation Services 3.6x
48 Communications 5.5x
50 Wholesale Trade-durable Goods 5.0x
51 Wholesale Trade-non-durable Goods 3.9x
52 Building Materials, Hardware, Garden Supply, And Mobile Home Dealers 3.4x
53 General Merchandise Stores 1.5x
54 Food Stores 2.4x
55 Automotive Dealers And Gasoline Service Stations 1.8x
56 Apparel And Accessory Stores 2.6x
57 Home Furniture, Furnishings, And Equipment Stores 3.5x
58 Eating And Drinking Places 1.9x
59 Miscellaneous Retail 3.2x
65 Real Estate 2.8x
70 Hotels, Rooming Houses, Camps, And Other Lodging Places 1.8x
72 Personal Services 2.3x
73 Business Services 4.4x
75 Automotive Repair, Services, And Parking 3.3x
76 Miscellaneous Repair Services 4.0x
79 Amusement And Recreation Services 2.1x
81 Legal Services 3.2x
82 Educational Services 4.6x
83 Social Services 4.1x
87 Engineering, Accounting, Research, Management, And Related Services 5.0x
2
028
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-14 Filed 04/18/12 Page 11 of 16
11
Exhi bi t A
Zone A
Zone B
(Non-Tour i sm and
Non-Seaf ood)
Zone C
(Non-Seaf ood) Zone D
Decl i ne
Thr eshol d Decl i ne Thr eshol d
Decl i ne
Thr eshol d
Decl i ne
Thr eshol d
Revenue Decl i ne Test N/ A -8.5% -10.0% -15%
Summar y of Revenue Decl i ne Causat i on Test s f or Fai l ed Busi nesses
028 00
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-14 Filed 04/18/12 Page 12 of 16
12
Exhi bi t A (cont i nued)
Exampl e 1:
M ont h 2009 2010
M ay 300,000 250,000
June 350,000 275,000
Jul y 325,000 225,000
3-M ont h Aggr egat e: 975,000 750,000
[ Sum of June, Jul y, August ]
Revenue Decl i ne Per cent age: -23.1% =(750,000 - 975,000)/ 975,000
Exampl e 2:
M ont h 2009 2010
M ay 300,000 295,000
June 350,000 335,000
Jul y 325,000 315,000
3-M ont h Aggr egat e: 975,000 945,000
[ Sum of June, Jul y, August ]
Revenue Decl i ne Per cent age: -3.1% =(945,000 - 975,000)/ 975,000
Not es:
Claimant Fails Revenue Decline Test
Revenue Decl i ne Causat i on Test wor ks i n t he same way f or cl ai mant s i n Zones C or D, wi t h hi gher t hr eshol ds
f or t he r evenue decl i ne. I n Zone C t he r evenue decl i ne per cent age must be 10%. I n Zone D t he r evenue decl i ne
per cent age must be 15%.
Exampl e of Revenue Decl i ne Causat i on Test s f or Fai l ed Busi ness Cl ai ms
I n Exampl es 1 and 2, t he cl ai mant i s assumed t o be i n Zone B and t he cl ai mant ' s l ast f ul l mont h of
oper at i ons i s Jul y 2010. These exampl es demonst r at e a cl ai mant t hat passes and a cl ai mant t hat f ai l s t he
Revenue Decl i ne Causat i on Test .
Revenue by Year
Claimant Passes Revenue Decline Test
Revenue by Year
028 01
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-14 Filed 04/18/12 Page 13 of 16
13
Exhi bi t A (cont i nued)
Exampl e 3A:
M ont h 2009 2010
M ay 300,000 250,000
June 350,000 275,000
Jul y 325,000 225,000
3-M ont h Aggr egat e: 975,000 750,000
[ Sum of June, Jul y, August ]
Revenue Decl i ne Per cent age: -23.1% =(750,000 - 975,000)/ 975,000
Exampl e 3B:
M ont h 2009 2010
M ay 300,000 350,000
June 350,000 175,000
Jul y 325,000 225,000
3-M ont h Aggr egat e: 975,000 750,000
[ Sum of June, Jul y, August ]
Revenue Decl i ne Per cent age: -23.1% =(750,000 - 975,000)/ 975,000
Exampl e 3C:
M ont h 2009 2010
M ay 300,000 350,000
June 350,000 375,000
Jul y 325,000 25,000
3-M ont h Aggr egat e: 975,000 750,000
[ Sum of June, Jul y, August ]
Revenue Decl i ne Per cent age: -23.1% =(750,000 - 975,000)/ 975,000
Not es:
Claimant Passes Revenue Decline Test
Revenue by Year
Claimant Passes Revenue Decline Test
Revenue Decl i ne Causat i on Test wor ks i n t he same way f or cl ai mant s i n Zones C or D, wi t h hi gher
t hr eshol ds f or t he r evenue decl i ne. I n Zone C t he r evenue decl i ne per cent age must be 10%. I n Zone D t he
r evenue decl i ne per cent age must be 15%.
Revenue by Year
Exampl e of Revenue Decl i ne Causat i on Test s f or Fai l ed Busi ness Cl ai ms
Cl ai mant i n Zone B (8.5% Revenue Decl i ne Test )
I n Exampl es 3A-C t he cl ai mant i s assumed t o be i n Zone B and t he cl ai mant ' s l ast f ul l mont h of oper at i ons
i s Jul y 2010. Exampl es 3A-C demonst r at e t hat under an aggr egat e t est , t hr ee mont hs of r evenues ar e
summed. The i ndi vi dual mont hs may be up or down, as l ong as t he t hr ee mont h aggr egat e per i od passes
t he t est .
Revenue by Year
Claimant Passes Revenue Decline Test
028 02
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-14 Filed 04/18/12 Page 14 of 16
14
Exhi bi t B
Exampl e 1:
St ep 1: Cal cul at e M ont hl y Sw eat Equi t y Benchmar k Income
St ep 1a: Ident i f y t he Commencement Dat e of Oper at i ons January 1, 2010 [ a]
St ep 1b: Ident i f y t he Sw eat Equi t y Cont r i but i on St ar t Dat e August 10, 2009 [ b]
(6 mont hs or l ess pri or t o t he Commencement Dat e)
St ep 1c: Est abl i sh t he Sw eat Equi t y Benchmar k Per i od
Sw eat Equi t y Bencmar k Per i od St ar t Dat e Opt i on 1: January 1, 2008 [ c]
- or -
Opt i on 2: January 1, 2007 [ d]
Sw eat Equi t y Benchmar k Per i od End Dat e Jul y 31, 2009 [ e]
(Last f ul l mont h pri or t o t he Sweat Equi t y Cont ri but i on St art Dat e)
St ep 1d: Cal cul at e M ont hl y Sw eat Equi t y Benchmar k Income
Hi st or i cal Ear ned Income
January - December 2007 Earned Income $50,000 [ f ]
January - December 2008 Earned Income $55,000 [ g]
January - Jul y 2009 Earned Income $35,000 [ h]
Sw eat Equi t y Benchmar k Per i od Opt i ons
Opt i on 1: Januar y 1, 2008 - Jul y 30, 2009
[ 1]
Tot al Compensat i on $90,000 [ i ] =[ g] +[ h]
Number of Mont hs i n Peri od wi t h Earned Income 19 [ j ] =count of mont hs f rom [ c] t o [ e]
Average Mont hl y Compensat i on $4,737 [ k] =[ i ] / [ j ]
Opt i on 2: Januar y 1, 2007 - Jul y 30, 2009
[ 2]
Tot al Compensat i on $140,000 [ l ] =[ f ] +[ g] +[ h]
Number of Mont hs i n Peri od wi t h Earned Income 31 [ m] =count of mont hs f rom [ d] t o [ e]
Average Mont hl y Compensat i on $4,516 [ n] =[ l ] / [ m]
Ow ner Sel ect s Opt i on 1 f or M ont hl y Benchmar k Per i od Income $4,737 [ o] =maxi mum of [ k] and [ n]
(Maxi mum of $12,500)
St ep 2: Cal cul at e Tot al Sw eat Equi t y
Fai l ur e Dat e December 31, 2010 [ p]
(Dat e t he Fai l ed St art -Up ei t her (i ) ceased operat i ons and wound down,
(i i ) f i l ed f or bankrupt cy prot ect i on, or (i i i ) ot herwi se i ni t i at ed or
compl et ed a l i qui dat i on of subst ant i al l y al l of i t s asset s)
Sel ect ed Aver age M ont hl y Benchmar k Per i od Income $4,737 =[ o]
Number of M ont hs Sw eat Equi t y Pr ovi ded 17 [ q] =count of mont hs f rom [ b] t o [ p]
(Number of mont hs bet ween t he Sweat Equi t y Cont ri but i on St art Dat e
and t he Fai l ure Dat e)
Tot al Gr oss Sw eat Equi t y $80,526.32 [ r] =[ o] * [ q]
(Maxi mum of $150,000)
St ep 3: Cal cul at e Net Sw eat Equi t y Compensat i on by Subt r act i ng Act ual Ear ned Income
Act ual Ear ned Income af t er t he Sw eat Equi t y Cont r i but i on St ar t Dat e $0 [ s]
Net Sw eat Equi t y Compensat i on $80,526 [ t ] =[ r] -[ s]
Not es:
[ 1] Cl ai mant uses onl y t he mi ni mum t i me t o cal cul at e t he Sweat Equi t y Benchmark Peri od, whi ch provi des a l arger mont hl y amount here.
[ 2] Cl ai mant uses t he f ul l mont hs avai l abl e t o cal cul at e t he Sweat Equi t y Benchmark Peri od.
Exampl es of Sweat Equi t y Cal cul at i on
(Must begi n no l at er t han January 1 of t he cal endar year precedi ng t he
year i n whi ch t he Sweat Equi t y Cont ri but i on St art Dat e occurred.
However, t he Cl ai mant may, i f rel evant , el ect a l onger peri od and add
t he t wel ve mont hs of 2008 or t he 24 mont hs of 2007 and 2008. Peri od
ends wi t h t he l ast f ul l mont h precedi ng t he Sweat Equi t y Cont ri but i on
St art Dat e.)
028 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-14 Filed 04/18/12 Page 15 of 16
15
Exhi bi t B (cont i nued)
Exampl e 2:
St ep 1: Cal cul at e M ont hl y Sw eat Equi t y Benchmar k Income
St ep 1a: Ident i f y t he Commencement Dat e of Oper at i ons December 10, 2008 [ a]
St ep 1b: Ident i f y t he Sw eat Equi t y Cont r i but i on St ar t Dat e August 10, 2008 [ b]
(6 mont hs or l ess pri or t o t he Commencement Dat e)
St ep 1c: Est abl i sh t he Sw eat Equi t y Benchmar k Per i od
Sw eat Equi t y Bencmar k Per i od St ar t Dat e January 1, 2007 [ c]
Sw eat Equi t y Benchmar k Per i od End Dat e Jul y 30, 2008 [ d]
(Last f ul l mont h pri or t o t he Sweat Equi t y Cont ri but i on St art Dat e)
St ep 1d: Cal cul at e M ont hl y Sw eat Equi t y Benchmar k Income
Hi st or i cal Ear ned Income
January - December 2007 Earned Income $50,000 [ e]
January - Jul y 2008 Earned Income $30,000 [ f ]
Sw eat Equi t y Benchmar k Per i od (One Opt i on)
Januar y 1, 2007 - Jul y 30, 2008
Tot al Compensat i on $80,000 [ g] =[ e] +[ f ]
Number of Mont hs i n Peri od wi t h Earned Income 19 [ h] =count of mont hs f rom [ c] t o [ d]
Average Mont hl y Compensat i on $4,211 [ i ] =[ g] / [ h]
M ont hl y Benchmar k Per i od Income $4,211 [ j ] =[ i ]
(Maxi mum of $12,500)
St ep 2: Cal cul at e Tot al Sw eat Equi t y
Fai l ur e Dat e December 31, 2010 [ k]
(Dat e t he Fai l ed St art -Up ei t her (i ) ceased operat i ons and wound down,
(i i ) f i l ed f or bankrupt cy prot ect i on, or (i i i ) ot herwi se i ni t i at ed or
compl et ed a l i qui dat i on of subst ant i al l y al l of i t s asset s)
Sel ect ed Aver age M ont hl y Benchmar k Per i od Income $4,211 =[ j ]
Number of M ont hs Sw eat Equi t y Pr ovi ded 29 [ l ] =count of mont hs f rom [ b] t o [ k]
(Number of mont hs bet ween t he Sweat Equi t y Cont ri but i on St art Dat e
and t he Fai l ure Dat e)
Tot al Gr oss Sw eat Equi t y $122,105 [ m] =[ j ] * [ l ]
(Maxi mum of $150,000)
St ep 3: Cal cul at e Net Sw eat Equi t y Compensat i on by Subt r act i ng Act ual Ear ned Income
Act ual Ear ned Income af t er t he Sw eat Equi t y Cont r i but i on St ar t Dat e $0 [ n]
Net Sw eat Equi t y Compensat i on $122,105 [ o] =[ m] -[ n]
(Must begi n no l at er t han January 1 of t he cal endar year precedi ng t he
year i n whi ch t he Sweat Equi t y Cont ri but i on St art Dat e occurred.
However, t he Cl ai mant may, i f rel evant , el ect a l onger peri od and add
t he t wel ve mont hs of 2008 or t he 24 mont hs of 2007 and 2008. Peri od
ends wi t h t he l ast f ul l mont h precedi ng t he Sweat Equi t y Cont ri but i on
St art Dat e.)
028 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-14 Filed 04/18/12 Page 16 of 16
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-15 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 15
Fr amew or k f or St ar t -up Busi ness Cl ai ms
The f r amew or k out l i ned bel ow appl i es t o cl ai ms f or st ar t -up busi nesses. For pur poses of t hi s
Fr amew or k, a St ar t -up Busi ness i s consi der ed t o be a cl ai mant wi t h l ess t han ei ght een
mont hs of oper at i ng hi st or y at t he t i me of t he DWH Spi l l .
1
I. DEFINITIONS
2
Busi ness Compensat i on Fr amew or k: Busi ness Compensat i on Fr amew or k i s t he
Compensat i on Fr amew or k f or Business Economi c Loss Cl ai ms.
Compensat i on Per i od: The Compensat i on Per i od i s sel ect ed by t he cl ai mant t o i ncl ude
t hr ee or mor e consecut ive mont hs bet ween M ay 2010 and Apr i l 2011.
Benchmar k Per i od: The Benchmar k Per i od i s t he post -spi l l t i me per i od bet ween M ay
2011 and Apr i l 2012 cor r espondi ng t o t he mont hs of t he Compensat i on Per i od t hat
ser ves as t he basi s f or est i mat ing t he cl ai mant s Expect ed Pr of i t dur i ng 2010.
Fi xed and var i abl e payr ol l expenses shal l be cal cul at ed i n t he same manner as i n t he
Busi ness Compensat i on Fr amew or k, pr ovided t hat subpar t 3 of t he Fi xed & Var i abl e
Payr ol l Expenses (SG&A and COGS) Def ini t ion shal l be modi f i ed t o i dent if y t he t wo
mont hs bet ween M ay and December 2010 wit h t he l ow est Tot al Payr ol l Expense.
Var i abl e Cost s shal l be det er mined i n accor dance wi t h Business Compensat i on
Fr amew or k At t achment A.
II. OVERVIEW
As set f or t h mor e f ul l y i n t he Compensat i on Cal cul at i on sect i on bel ow, 2010 cl ai mant
compensat i on (bef or e any adj ust ment s) wi l l be cal cul at ed accor ding t o t he f o l lowi ng
met hodology:
A. Est abl i sh (i ) t he r evenue t he cl ai mant woul d have expect ed t o ear n dur i ng t he
Compensat i on Per i od i n t he absence of t he DWH Spi l l ( Expect ed Revenue ), and
(i i ) t he var i abl e cost s t he cl ai mant woul d have expect ed t o i ncur dur i ng t he
Compensat i on Per i od ( Expect ed Cost s ) t o gener at e t he Expect ed Revenue.
1
Thi s Fr amewor k f or St ar t -up Busi ness Cl ai ms does not apply t o (i ) Fai l ed Busi nesses; (i i ) Ent i t i es, Indi vi dual s or
Cl ai ms not i ncl uded w i t hi n t he Economi c Cl ass def i ni t i on; or (i i i ) Cl ai ms cover ed under t he Seaf ood Pr ogr am.
2
In addi t i on t o t he f ol l ow i ng, ot her t er ms ar e def i ned i n t hi s document and i ndi cat ed by i ni t i al capi t al s.
028 1
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-15 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 15
2
The di f f er ence bet ween Expect ed Revenue and Expect ed Cost s i s Expect ed
Pr of it .
B. Cal cul at e act ual pr of i t / l oss r eal i zed by t he cl ai mant dur i ng t he Compensat i on
Per i od based on t he di f f er ence bet ween (i ) act ual r evenue, and (i i ) act ual
var i abl e cost s.
C. Deduct act ual pr of i t / l oss f r om Expect ed Pr of i t over t he Compensat i on Per i od t o
det er mi ne t he Base Compensat i on Loss.
III. CAUSATION REQUIREM ENTS
A. St ar t -Up Busi nesses i n Zones A, B and C For Whi ch Causat i on Shal l Be
Pr esumed
1) If t he cl ai mant i s a St ar t -up Business in Zone A t hat i s not excl uded pur suant t o t he
except i on agr eed t o by t he par t ies, and l i st ed i n f oot not e (1), t he cl ai mant i s not
r equi r ed t o pr ovi de any evi dence of causat i on.
2) If t he cl ai mant i s a St ar t -up Business meet ing t he def ini t ion of a Commer ci al
Fi sher man, or Landi ng Si t e, or Commer ci al Whol esal e or Ret ai l Dealer A, or
Pr i mar y Seaf ood Pr ocessor , as set f ort h i n Seaf ood Di st r ibut i on Chain
Def ini t ions, t he cl ai mant i s not r equi r ed t o pr ovide any evi dence of causat i on.
3) If t he cl ai mant i s a St ar t -up Business in Zone A, B or C and t he cl ai mant i s al so a
Commer ci al or Whol esal e or Ret ai l Dealer B, or a Secondar y Seaf ood Pr ocessor ,
or a Seaf ood Wholesal er or Di st r ibut or , or a Seaf ood Ret ai l er , as set f or t h i n
Seaf ood Di st r ibut i on Chai n Def ini t ion, t he cl ai mant i s not r equi r ed t o pr ovi de any
evi dence of causat i on.
4) If t he cl ai mant i s a St ar t -up business in Zone B, and t he cl ai mant al so meet s t he
Tour i sm Def i nit i on, t he cl ai mant i s not r equi r ed t o pr ovi de any evi dence of
causat i on.
5) If you ar e in Zone A, B or C, and you meet t he Char t er Fi shi ng Def i ni t i on you ar e
not r equi r ed t o pr ovide any evi dence of causat i on.
B. Causat i on Requi r ement s For St ar t -Up Busi nesses In Zones B and C
If t he cl ai mant i s l ocat ed wi t hi n Zones B or C and not ent i t led t o a pr esumpt i on, it must
est abl i sh:
028 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-15 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 15
3
1. UPTURN REVENUE PATTERN PLUS
a. Cl ai mant must demonst r at e:
1. If i n Zone B, an incr ease of an aggr egat e of 8.5% or mor e i n
t ot al r evenues over a per i od of t hr ee consecut i ve mont hs
f r om M ay 2011 t o Apr i l 2012 compar ed t o t he same
mont hs f r om M ay 2010 t o Apr i l 2011 as sel ect ed by t h e
cl ai mant ;
3
2. If i n Zone C, an incr ease of an aggr egat e of 10% or mor e i n
t ot al r evenues over a per i od of t hr ee consecut i ve mont hs
f r om M ay 2011 t o Apr i l 2012 compar ed t o t he same
mont hs f r om M ay 2010 t o Apr i l 2011 as sel ect ed by t he
cl ai mant ;
4
AND
b. one or mor e of t he f ol l owi ng:
1. For busi ness cl ai mant s t hat have cust omer s in Zones A-C,
t he cl ai mant demonst r at es pr oof of an aggr egat e of 10%
i ncr ease in t he shar e of t ot al r evenue gener at ed by
cust omer s l ocat ed in Zones A-C over t he same per i od of
t hr ee consecut i ve mont hs f r om M ay 2011 t o Apr i l 2012 as
sel ect ed by t he cl ai mant f or t he upt ur n r evenue pat t er n as
i dent i f ied in III.B.1.a compar ed t o t he same t hr ee
consecut i ve mont h per i od f r om M ay 2010 t o Apr i l 2011,
5
as r ef lect ed i n:
(a) cust omer cr edit car d r ecei pt s or ot her
cont empor aneousl y mai nt ai ned r ecor ds of
payment ; or
(b) cust omer r egi st r at i on logs (e.g., hot el r egi st r i es); or
(c) document at i on mai nt ai ned in t he or dinar y cour se
of busi ness t hat l i st s cust omer s by l ocat ion and
mont hl y sal es associ at ed w i t h t hose cust omer s; or
3
See Exhi bi t A at t ached her et o f or an exampl e of how t hi s cal cul at i on i s per f or med .
4
See Exhi bi t A at t ached her et o f or an exampl e of how t hi s cal cul at i on i s per f or med .
5
See Exhi bi t B at t ached her et o f or an exampl e of how t hi s cal cul at i on i s per f or med.
028
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-15 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 15
4
(d) busi ness document s r ef lect i ng cont empor aneous
r ecor di ng of r ecei pt s or invoi ces l i st ing cust omer s
by l ocat i on; or
(e) Any ot her document at i on pr ovi ding evi dence of
t he port i on of t he cl ai mant s r evenue pr oj ect ed t o
be gener at ed by cust omer s i n Zones A-C ver sus
out side of Zones A-C dur i ng t he Compensat i on
Per i od. The cl ai mant must be able t o demonst r at e
t hat t he pr oj ect i ons wer e pr epar ed pr i or t o t he
DWH Spi l l and pr ovi ded t o and ut i l ized by a
f i nanci al i nst i t ut ion ext endi ng cr edit t o t he St ar t -up
Busi ness.
OR
2. For busi nesses meet i ng t he Tour i sm Def i nit i on or t he
Seaf ood Di st r i but i on Chai n Def ini t i on, t he cl ai mant
demonst r at es pr oof of an aggr egat e of 10% i ncr ease i n t he
shar e of t ot al r evenue gener at ed by non-l ocal cust omer s
6
over t he same per i od of t hr ee consecut i ve mont hs f r om
M ay 2011 t o Apr i l 2012 as sel ect ed by cl ai mant f or t he
upt ur n r evenue pat t er n as i dent if i ed i n III.B.1.a
compar ed t o t he same t hr ee consecut i ve mont h per i od
f r om M ay 2010 t o Apr i l 2011,
7
as r ef l ect ed in:
(a) cust omer cr edit car d r ecei pt s or ot her
cont empor aneousl y mai nt ai ned r ecor ds of
payment ; or
(b) document at i on mai nt ai ned in t he or dinar y cour se
of busi ness t hat l i st s cust omer s by l ocat ion and
mont hl y sal es associ at ed w i t h t hose cust omer s; or
(c) busi ness document s r ef lect i ng cont empor aneous
r ecor di ng of r ecei pt s or invoi ces l i st ing cust omer s
by l ocat ion; or
(d) cust omer r egi st r at i on logs (e.g., hot el r egi st r i es); or
6
A Cust omer shal l be consi der ed a non-l ocal cust omer i f t hey r esi de mor e t han 60 mi l es f r om a cl ai mant
busi ness l ocat i on.
7
See Exhi bi t C at t ached her et o f or an exampl e of how t hi s cal cul at i on i s per f or med .
028
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-15 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 15
5
(e) Any ot her document at i on pr ovi ding evi dence of
t he port i on of cl ai mant s r evenue pr oj ect ed t o be
gener at ed by l ocal ver sus non-l ocal cust omer s
dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od. The cl ai mant
must be abl e t o demonst r at e t hat t he pr oj ect ions
wer e pr epar ed pr i or t o t he DWH Spi l l and pr ovi ded
t o and ut i l i zed by a f i nanci al i nst it ut i on ext ending
cr edi t t o t he St ar t -up Busi ness.
OR
2. Pr oof of Spi l l -Rel at ed Cancel l at i ons
a. Cl ai mant may est abl i sh causat i on by pr ovi di ng cont empor aneous
wr i t t en evi dence of spi l l -r el at ed r eser vat i on cancel l at i ons (i.e.,
l et t er s, emai l s, hot el l ogs f or t he r el evant t i me, or an af f idavi t
f r om an independent t hir d par t y cit i ng t he DWH Spi l l as t he
r eason f or cancel l at i on) t hat t he cl ai mant was unabl e t o r ebook
( Un-r epl aced Cancel l at ions ). Pr oof of Un-r epl aced Cancel l at i ons
onl y est abl i shes causat i on f or t hose specif i c Un-r epl aced
Cancel l at i ons subst ant i at ed by t he cl ai mant and may r esult i n
r ecover y onl y wi t h r espect t o such Un-r epl aced Cancel l at i ons.
However , i f t he l odgi ng f aci l i t y has f ood and/ or bever age ser vi ces
on sit e, t he evi dence of Un-r epl aced Cancel l at i ons shal l sat i sf y
causat i on f or t he specif i c l osses cor r espondi ng t o such Un-
r epl aced Cancel l at i ons i n t hose ser vi ce ar eas as wel l .
OR
b. The cl ai mant pr ovi des cont empor aneous wr i t t en evi dence of t he
cancel l at i on of a cont r act , or l oss of pr evi ousl y-commi t t ed capi t al
i nvest ment s f r om i nvest or s and/ or busi ness l oans ar i si ng f r om t he
DWH Spi l l t hat t he cl ai mant was not abl e t o r epl ace. In t he
absence of cont empor aneous wr i t t en evidence, t he cl ai mant must
pr esent an af f idavi t f r om an independent t hi r d par t y af f i r mi ng
t hat t he cancel l at ion or loss w as spi l l -r el at ed. Pr oof of any spi l l -
r el at ed cont r act cancel l at i ons or losses di scussed above onl y
est abl i shes causat i on f or t he speci f i c l oss subst ant i at ed by t he
cl ai mant and may r esul t in r ecover y of amount s sol el y associ at ed
w i t h such l oss.
028
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-15 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 15
6
C. Causat i on Requi r ement s f or St ar t -Up Busi nesses i n Zone D
If t he cl ai mant i s l ocat ed wi t hi n Zone D, i t must est abl i sh one or mor e of t he
f ol l owi ng:
1. UPTURN REVENUE PATTERN PLUS
a. an i ncr ease of an aggr egat e of 15% or mor e i n t ot al r evenues over
a per i od of t hr ee consecut i ve mont hs f r om M ay 2011 t o Apr i l
2012 compar ed t o t he same mont hs f r om M ay 2010 t o Apr i l 2011
as sel ect ed by t he cl ai mant ;
8
AND
b. one of t he f ol l owi ng:
1. For busi ness cl ai mant s t hat have cust omer s in Zones A-C,
t he cl ai mant demonst r at es pr oof of an aggr egat e of 10%
i ncr ease in t he shar e of t ot al r evenue gener at ed by
cust omer s l ocat ed in Zones A-C over t he same per i od of
t hr ee consecut i ve mont hs f r om M ay 2011 t o Apr i l 2012 as
sel ect ed by t he cl ai mant f or t he upt ur n r evenue pat t er n as
i dent i f ied in III.C.1.a compar ed t o t he same t hr ee
consecut i ve mont h per i od f r om M ay 2010 t o Apr i l 2011,
9
as r ef lect ed i n:
(a) cust omer cr edit car d r ecei pt s or ot her
cont empor aneousl y mai nt ai ned r ecor ds of
payment ;
(b) cust omer r egi st r at i on logs (e.g., hot el r egi st r i es);
(c) document at i on mai nt ai ned in t he or dinar y cour se
of busi ness t hat l i st s cust omer s by l ocat ion and
mont hl y sal es associ at ed w i t h t hose cust omer s; or
(d) busi ness document s r ef lect i ng cont empor aneous
r ecor di ng of r ecei pt s or invoi ces l i st ing cust omer s
by l ocat ion.
8
See Exhi bi t A at t ached her et o f or an exampl e of how t hi s cal cul at i on i s per f or med.
9
See Exhi bi t B at t ached her et o f or an exampl e of how t hi s cal cul at i on i s per f or med.
028
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-15 Filed 04/18/12 Page 7 of 15
7
OR
2. For busi nesses meet i ng t he Tour i sm Def i nit i on or t he
Seaf ood Di st r i but i on Chai n Def ini t i on, t he cl ai mant
demonst r at es pr oof of an aggr egat e of 10% i ncr ease i n t he
shar e of t ot al r evenue gener at ed by non-l ocal cust omer s
over t he same per i od of t hr ee consecut i ve mont hs f r om
M ay 2011 t o Apr i l 2012 as sel ect ed by cl ai mant f or t he
upt ur n r evenue pat t er n as i dent if i ed i n III.C.1.a
compar ed t o t he same t hr ee consecut i ve mont h per i od
f r om M ay 2010 t o Apr i l 2011,
10
as r ef l ect ed in:
(a) cust omer cr edit car d r ecei pt s or ot her
cont empor aneousl y mai nt ai ned r ecor ds of
payment ; or
(b) cust omer r egi st r at i on logs (e.g., hot el r egi st r i es).
(c) document at i on mai nt ai ned in t he or dinar y cour se
of busi ness t hat l i st s cust omer s by l ocat ion and
mont hl y sal es associ at ed w i t h t hose cust omer s; or
(d) busi ness document s r ef lect i ng cont empor aneous
r ecor di ng of r ecei pt s or invoi ces l i st ing cust omer s
by l ocat ion.
2. PROOF OF SPILL-RELATED CANCELLATIONS
a. Cl ai mant may est abl i sh causat i on by pr ovi di ng cont empor aneous
wr i t t en evi dence of spi l l -r el at ed r eser vat i on cancel l at i ons (i .e.,
l et t er s, emai l s, hot el l ogs f or t he r el evant t i me, or an af f idavi t
f r om an independent t hir d par t y cit i ng t he DWH Spi l l as t he
r eason f or cancel l at i on) t hat t he cl ai mant was unabl e t o r ebook
( Un-r epl aced Cancel l at ions ). Pr oof of Un-r epl aced Cancel l at i ons
onl y est abl i shes causat i on f or t hose specif i c Un-r epl aced
Cancel l at i ons subst ant i at ed by t he cl ai mant and may r esult i n
r ecover y onl y wi t h r espect t o such Un-r epl aced Cancel l at i ons.
However , i f t he l odgi ng f aci l i t y has f ood and/ or bever age ser vi ces
on sit e, t he evi dence of Un-r epl aced Cancel l at ions shal l sat i sf y
causat i on f or t he specif i c l osses cor r espondi ng t o such Un-
r epl aced Cancel l at i ons i n t hose ser vi ce ar eas as wel l .
10
See Exhi bi t C at t ached her et o f or an exampl e of how t hi s cal cul at i on i s per f or med.
028
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-15 Filed 04/18/12 Page 8 of 15
8
OR
b. The cl ai mant pr ovi des cont empor aneous wr i t t en evi dence of t he
cancel l at i on of a cont r act , or l oss of pr evi ousl y-commi t t ed capi t al
i nvest ment s f r om i nvest or s and/ or busi ness l oans ar i si ng f r om t he
DWH Spi l l t hat t he cl ai mant was not abl e t o r epl ace. In t he
absence of cont empor aneous wr i t t en evidence, t he cl ai mant must
pr esent an af f idavi t f r om an independent t hi r d par t y af f i r mi ng
t hat t he cancel l at ion or loss w as spi l l -r el at ed. Pr oof of any spi l l -
r el at ed cont r act cancel l at i ons or losses di scussed above onl y
est abl i shes causat i on f or t he speci f i c l oss subst ant i at ed by t he
cl ai mant and may r esul t in r ecover y of amount s sol el y associ at ed
w i t h such l oss.
IV. COM PENSATION CALCULATION
A. Det er mi nat i on of Cl ai mant s Expect ed Pr of i t / Loss
1. Cl ai mant s Expect ed Revenue and Expect ed Cost s shal l equal ,
r espect i vel y:
a. Act ual r evenue ear ned and act ual var i able cost s incur r ed by
cl ai mant s business dur i ng t he Benchmar k Per i od; or
b. Cl ai mant s can al t er nat i vel y el ect t o est abl i sh Expect ed Revenue
and Expect ed Cost s based on f inanci al pr oj ect i ons f or t he St ar t -up
Busi ness. Pr oj ect ions must be pr epar ed pr i or t o t he DWH Spi l l
and pr ovided t o and ut i l ized by a f inanci al i nst it ut i on, ot her ent it y
i n t he pr i mar y busi ness of l ending or i nvest i ng money (ex.- pr i vat e
equit y f i r ms, i nvest ment banks, et c.), or non-f ami l y pr i vat e
i nvest or s wi t h business l endi ng exper i ence (her eaf t er r ef er r ed t o
as Lender ) who conf i r m t hei r use of such pr oj ect i ons in
ext endi ng cr edi t t o t he St ar t -up Cl ai mant .
c. Regar dl ess of t he basi s upon w hi ch Expect ed Revenue and
Expect ed Cost s ar e est abl i shed, t he det er mi nat i on wi l l excl ude
any one-t i me non-oper at i ng i ncome/ expenses (i ncl udi ng, but not
l i mi t ed t o, any busi ness int er r upt i on insur ance pr oceeds r ecei ved
by t he cl ai mant dur i ng t he r el evant per i od), any payment s
r ecei ved by t he cl ai mant f r om BP or t he GCCF pur suant t o BP s
OPA Cl ai ms pr ocess f or t he same busi ness cl ai m.
028 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-15 Filed 04/18/12 Page 9 of 15
9
2. Cl ai mant s Expect ed Pr of i t / Loss f or t he Compensat i on Per i od wi l l be
cal cul at ed as t he dif f er ence bet ween t he cl ai mant s Expect ed Revenue
and Expect ed Cost s, pr ovi ded t hat Expect ed Revenue and Expect ed
Cost s must bot h be based on act ual r esult s f r om t he Benchmar k Per i od,
or , i f al t er nat i vel y sel ect ed by cl ai mant s in Zones B and C, bot h Expect ed
Revenue and Expect ed Cost s must bot h be based on qual i f yi ng
pr oj ect ions as descr ibed her ein.
B. Det er mi nat i on of Cl ai mant s Act ual Pr of i t / Loss
1. Act ual Pr of i t / Loss gener at ed over t he Compensat ion Per i od wi l l be
cal cul at ed as t he di f f er ence bet ween (i ) t he cl ai mant s act ual r evenues
and (i i ) t he cl ai mant s act ual var i abl e cost s, bot h f or t he Compensat i on
Per i od.
2. Act ual r evenue and act ual Var i abl e Cost s wi l l exclude any one-t i me non-
oper at i ng i ncome/ expenses (i ncl uding any busi ness i nt er r upt i on
i nsur ance pr oceeds r ecei ved by t he cl ai mant dur i ng t he r el evant per i od) ,
any payment s r ecei ved by t he cl ai mant f r om BP or t he GCCF pur suant t o
BP s OPA Cl ai ms pr ocess. Fur t her , f or cl ai mant s t hat par t i ci pat ed i n t he
VoO pr ogr am, Act ual Pr of i t / Loss wi l l excl ude r evenue gener at ed by or
cost s i ncur r ed i n connect i on wi t h VoO.
11
C. Cal cul at i on of Cl ai mant Compensat i on
1. Cal cul at e t he cl ai mant s Base Compensat i on Loss as t he dif f er ence
bet ween (i ) cl ai mant s Expect ed Pr of it / Loss and (i i) t he cl ai mant s Act ual
Pr of it / Loss gener at ed over t he Compensat i on Per i od.
2. Appl y t he agr eed-upon RTP.
3. Deduct any payment s r ecei ved by t he cl ai mant f r om BP or t he GCCF
pur suant t o BP s OPA cl ai ms pr ocess, any VoO Set t l ement Payment
Of f set and VoO Ear ned Income Of f set , wher e appl i cabl e.
D. DOCUM ENTATION REQUIREM ENTS
In addi t ion t o t he r el evant inf or mat ion r equi r ement s set f or t h i n t he
Document at i on Requi r ement s f or Busi ness Cl ai ms, t he f ol l owi ng suppl ement al
i nf or mat i on may be r equi r ed:
11
Cl ai mant s ar e r equi r ed t o r epor t payment s r ecei ved under t he VoO pr ogr am. If cl ai mant s t hat r ecei ved VoO
payment s f ai l separ at el y t o r epor t cost s i ncur r ed i n VoO and non-VoO act i vi t i es, t hen Act ual Pr of i t / Loss f or non-
VoO act i vi t y al one can be det er mi ned t hr ough a pr o-r at a r evenue based al l ocat i on of var i abl e cost s bet w een VoO
and non-VoO r el at ed act i vi t i es.
028
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-15 Filed 04/18/12 Page 10 of 15
10
1. Cont empor aneousl y pr epar ed mont hl y f inanci al st at ement s f r om t he
i ncept ion of t he st ar t -up busi ness t hr ough 2011.
2. Document s evi denci ng loss of pr evi ousl y-commi t t ed capit al invest ment s
f r om invest or s and/ or busi ness l oans due, and t he i nabil i t y t o pr ocur e
r epl acement f inanci ng, as r el evant . Accept abl e document at ion i ncl udes
a l et t er wi t hdr aw i ng capit al , or ot her cont empor aneous document at i on
evi denci ng t he invest ment wi t hdr awal .
3. Evi dence of any payment s r ecei ved by t he cl ai mant f r om BP or t he GCCF
pur suant t o BP s OPA cl ai ms pr ocess.
4. Al l f inanci al pr oj ect i ons (or busi ness pl ans cont ai ni ng f inanci al
pr oj ect ions) pr epar ed f or t he St ar t -up Business pr i or t o t he DWH Spi l l ,
and cont empor aneous document at ion and/ or wr i t t en conf i r mat i on f r om
t he Lender est abl i shing t hat such pr oj ect i ons wer e submi t t ed t o and
ut i l ized by t he Lender pr i or t o ext endi ng cr edi t t o t he St ar t -up Busi ness.
a. Addit i onal document at i on as necessar y t o pr ovi de t he
backgr ound and exper i ence of any Lender s not r egul at ed by a
gover nment agency (ex.- FDIC, SEC, et c.).
b. Wr i t t en conf i r mat i on f r om Lender t hat pr oj ect i ons submi t t ed as
par t of t he cl ai m wer e ut i l i zed by t he Lender i n gr ant ing cr edit
pr i or t o t he DWH Spi l l .
5. Cl ai mant s shal l pr ovi de an execut ed subr ogat i on wai ver or indemni t y i n
t he r el ease.
028 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-15 Filed 04/18/12 Page 11 of 15
11
Exhi bi t A
Exampl e 1:
M ont h 2010 2011
June 285,000 320,000
Jul y 330,000 350,000
August 295,000 335,000
3-M ont h Aggr egat e: 910,000 1,005,000
[ Sum of June, Jul y, August ]
Upt ur n Revenue Per cent age: 10.4% =(1,005,000 - 910,000)/ 910,000
Exampl e 2:
M ont h 2010 2011
June 285,000 290,000
Jul y 330,000 330,000
August 295,000 315,000
3-M ont h Aggr egat e: 910,000 935,000
[ Sum of June, Jul y, August ]
Upt ur n Revenue Per cent age: 2.7% =(935,000 - 910,000)/ 910,000
Not es:
Exampl es 1 and 2 demonst r at e a cl ai mant t hat passes or f ai l s t he Upt ur n Revenue Causat i on Test .
Exampl e of Upt ur n Revenue Causat i on Test s f or St ar t -Up Busi ness Cl ai ms
Cl ai mant i n Zone B (8.5% Upt ur n Revenue Test )
Upt ur n Revenue Causat i on Test wor ks i n t he same way f or cl ai mant s i n Zones C or D, wi t h hi gher t hr eshol ds
f or t he r evenue upt ur n. I n Zone C t he upt ur n r evenue per cent age must be 10%. I n Zone D t he upt ur n r evenue
per cent age must be 15%.
I n t hese exampl es t he St ar t -Up busi ness cl ai mant has sel ect ed June, Jul y, and August as t he t hr ee consecut i ve
mont hs t o use.
Revenue by Year
Claimant Passes Upt urn Revenue Test
Revenue by Year
Claimant Fails Upt urn Revenue Test
028 1
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-15 Filed 04/18/12 Page 12 of 15
12
Exampl e 3A:
M ont h 2010 2011
June 285,000 320,000
Jul y 330,000 350,000
August 295,000 335,000
3-M ont h Aggr egat e: 910,000 1,005,000
[ Sum of June, Jul y, August ]
Upt ur n Revenue Per cent age: 10.4% =(1,005,000 - 910,000)/ 910,000
Exampl e 3B:
M ont h 2010 2011
June 285,000 220,000
Jul y 330,000 450,000
August 295,000 335,000
3-M ont h Aggr egat e: 910,000 1,005,000
[ Sum of June, Jul y, August ]
Upt ur n Revenue Per cent age: 10.4% =(1,005,000 - 910,000)/ 910,000
Exampl e 3C:
M ont h 2010 2011
June 285,000 220,000
Jul y 330,000 250,000
August 295,000 535,000
3-M ont h Aggr egat e: 910,000 1,005,000
[ Sum of June, Jul y, August ]
Upt ur n Revenue Per cent age: 10.4% =(1,005,000 - 910,000)/ 910,000
Not es:
Claimant Passes Upt urn Revenue Test
Upt ur n Revenue Causat i on Test wor ks i n t he same way f or cl ai mant s i n Zones C or D, wi t h hi gher t hr eshol ds f or
t he r evenue upt ur n. I n Zone C t he upt ur n r evenue per cent age must be 10%. I n Zone D t he upt ur n r evenue
per cent age must be 15%.
I n t hese exampl es t he St ar t -Up busi ness cl ai mant has sel ect ed June, Jul y, and August as t he t hr ee consecut i ve
mont hs t o use.
Claimant Passes Upt urn Revenue Test
Revenue by Year
Claimant Passes Upt urn Revenue Test
Exampl e of Upt ur n Revenue Causat i on Test s f or St ar t -Up Busi ness Cl ai ms
Cl ai mant i n Zone B (8.5% Upt ur n Revenue Test )
Revenue by Year
Exampl e 3 demonst r at es t hat under an aggr egat e t est , t hr ee mont hs of r evenues ar e summed. The i ndi vi dual
mont hs may be up or down, as l ong as t he t hr ee mont h aggr egat e per i od passes t he t est .
Revenue by Year
028 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-15 Filed 04/18/12 Page 13 of 15
13
Exhi bi t B
Exampl e 1: LT= Less t han GE=Gr eat er t han or equal t o
Cust omer Resi dence Aggregat e of June-August ' 10 Aggregat e of June-August ' 11
Zone D $80,000 $85,000
Zones A- C $20,000 $25,000
Tot al $100,000 $110,000
% Zones A- C 20% 23%
Exampl e 2:
Cust omer Resi dence Aggregat e of June-August ' 10 Aggregat e of June-August ' 11
Zone D $50,000 $55,000
Zones A- C $50,000 $55,000
Tot al $100,000 $110,000
% Zones A- C 50% 50%
Exampl e 3:
Cust omer Resi dence Aggregat e of June-August ' 10 Aggregat e of June-August ' 11
Zone D $50,000 $55,000
Zones A- C $50,000 $65,000
Tot al $100,000 $120,000
% Zones A- C 50% 54%
Exampl e of Cust omer M i x Test f or St art Up Busi ness Cl ai mant s
(Cust omers i n Zones A-C)
Based on 3-mont h t i me peri od sel ect ed f or Modi f i ed V or Down-Onl y t est
Cl ai mant passes Cust omer Mi x Test : Claimant has a 15 percent
increase in share of revenue f rom cust omers in Zones A-C [ 15%=
.15 = (23-20)/ 20]
Cl ai mant f ai l s Cust omer Mi x Test : No change in share of revenue
f rom cust omers in Zones A-C.
Cl ai mant f ai l s Cust omer Mi x Test : Claimant has an 8% increase
in share of revenue f rom cust omers in Zones A-C [ 8% = .08 = (54-
50)/ 50]
028
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-15 Filed 04/18/12 Page 14 of 15
14
Exhi bi t C
Exampl e 1: LT= Less t han GE=Gr eat er t han or equal t o
Cust omer Resi dence Aggregat e of June-August ' 10 Aggregat e of June-August ' 11
LT 60 mi l es f r om cl ai man $80,000 $85,000
GE 60 mi l es f r om cl ai man $20,000 $25,000
Tot al $100,000 $110,000
% GE 60 mi l es 20% 23%
Exampl e 2:
Cust omer Resi dence Aggregat e of June-August ' 10 Aggregat e of June-August ' 11
LT 60 mi l es f r om cl ai man $50,000 $55,000
GE 60 mi l es f r om cl ai man $50,000 $55,000
Tot al $100,000 $110,000
% GE 60 mi l es 50% 50%
Exampl e 3:
Cust omer Resi dence Aggregat e of June-August ' 10 Aggregat e of June-August ' 11
LT 60 mi l es f r om cl ai man $50,000 $55,000
GE 60 mi l es f r om cl ai man $50,000 $65,000
Tot al $100,000 $120,000
% GE 60 mi l es 50% 54%
Exampl e of Cust omer M i x Test f or St art Up Busi ness Cl ai mant s
(Non-Local Cust omers)
Based on 3-mont h t i me peri od sel ect ed f or Modi f i ed V or Down-Onl y t est
Cl ai mant passes Cust omer Mi x Test : Cl ai mant has a 15 percent
i ncrease i n share of revenue f rom non-l ocal cust omers [ 15%= .15
= (23-20)/ 20]
Cl ai mant f ai l s Cust omer Mi x Test : No change in share of revenue
f rom non-local cust omers.
Cl ai mant f ai l s Cust omer Mi x Test : Claimant has an 8% increase
in share of revenue f rom non-local cust omers [ 8% = .08 = (54-
50)/ 50]
028
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-15 Filed 04/18/12 Page 15 of 15
8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 53
Fr amew or k f or Indi vi dual Economi c Loss Cl ai ms
Over vi ew
Indi vi dual economi c loss cl ai ms ar e cl aims by Indi vi dual s, w ho shal l be def i ned as (i ) Nat ur al Per sons
w ho (a) sat i sf y (or w hose empl oyer s sat i sf y) t he Cl ass Def i ni t ion and (b) w hose losses ar e not
excl uded f r om t he Cl ass and (i i ) w ho seek compensat ion f or l ost ear ni ngs f r om empl oyment due t o
or r esul t i ng f r om t he DWH Spi l l f or cl aims t hat ar e not excl uded f r om t he Cl ass, w i t h t he f ol l ow i ng
except ions:
1. Al l Nat ur al Per sons (ot her t han Nat ur al Per sons addr essed i n 2, 3 and 4 bel ow ) clai mi ng
l osses r el at ed t o busi ness i ncome r equi r ed t o be r epor t ed on Int er nal Revenue Ser vi ce For m
1040 Schedul es C, E or F ar e gover ned by t he Document at i on Requi r ement s f or Busi ness
Economi c Loss Cl ai ms, Causat i on Requi r ement s f or Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms, and
Compensat i on Fr amew or k f or Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms, or , i f appr opr i at e, t he Fai l ed
Busi ness Fr amew or k or t he St ar t -up Busi ness Fr amew or k, r at her t han t hi s Fr amew or k f or
Indi vi dual Economi c Loss Cl ai ms.
1
2. Al l Nat ur al Per sons cl aimi ng l osses as an Indi vi dual Peri odi c Vendor ( IPV ) or a Fest i val
Vendor ar e gover ned by t he Addendum t o Indi vi dual s Fr amew or k IPVs and Fest i val
Vendor s.
2
3. Cl ai ms f or lost ear ni ngs f r om employment as a Commer ci al Fi sher man, Seaf ood Cr ew ,
Oyst er Leasehol der , or Seaf ood Vessel Ow ner , al l as def i ned i n t he Seaf ood Di st r i but i on
Chai n Def i ni t i ons, shal l be compensat ed t hr ough t he Seaf ood Pr ogr am, r at her t han t hi s
Fr amew or k f or Indi vi dual Economi c Loss Cl ai ms.
4. Cl ai ms by sel f -empl oyed Nat ur al Per sons w ho sat isf y t he def i ni t ion of a Commer ci al
Fi sher man, Seaf ood Cr ew , Oyst er Leasehol der , or Seaf ood Vessel Ow ner , al l as def i ned i n
t he Seaf ood Di st r i but i on Chai n Def i ni t i ons, shal l be compensat ed t hr ough t he Seaf ood
Pr ogr am, r at her t han t hi s Fr amew or k f or Indi vi dual Economi c Loss Cl ai ms.
As det ai l ed bel ow , Indi vi dual compensat i on f or lost ear ni ngs i s cal cul at ed as t he di f f er ence bet w een
(i ) a cl aimant s Expect ed Ear ni ngs f or a speci f i ed per iod of t ime af t er t he DWH Spi l l and (i i ) a
cl ai mant s Act ual Ear ni ngs over t he same speci f i ed per i od.
3
Each cl aimant must submi t pr oof of
ear ni ngs dur i ng t he r elevant t ime per i ods, as wel l as speci f i ed addi t ional document at i on t o est abl i sh
t hat t he DWH Spi l l caused a l oss of ear ni ngs.
Under t hi s Fr amew or k f or Indi vi dual Economi c Loss Cl ai ms, a cl aimant may r ecover f or l ost
ear ni ngs by submi t t i ng a sw or n Cl aim For m and suppor t i ng document at ion (w hen r equi r ed)
est abl i shi ng t hat t he cl aimant sat i sf i es t he document at i on and causat i on r equi r ement s of one of
1
Wor ds or phr ases i n Capi t al i zed Bol d-f ace Type ar e def i ned t er ms wi t h t he meani ng set f or t h i n t he Def i ni t i ons
sect i on of t hi s Indi vi dual Economi c Loss Cl ai m Fr amew or k.
2
The t er ms IPV and Fest i val Vendor ar e def i ned i n t he Addendum t o Indi vi dual s Fr amew or k IPVs and Fest i val
Vendor s.
3
Al l damages pai d shal l be pai d on a pr e-t ax basi s w i t h pr oper For m 1099 or ot her r epor t i ng as r equi r ed by t he IRS.
0288
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 53
2
f our al t er nat i ve met hodologi cal cat egor i es. These cat egor i es, w hi ch ar e set f or t h f ul l y i n Sect i ons I-
IV of t hi s Fr amew or k f or Indi vi dual Economi c Loss Cl ai ms, ar e summar i zed bel ow .
4
I. INDIVIDUAL CLAIM ANTS WITH CONTEM PORANEOUS TAX DOCUM ENTS FOR 2010 AND
BENCHM ARK PERIOD: Appl i es t o Indi vi dual s pr ovi di ng Tax Inf or mat i on Document s f or
2010 and t he clai mant select ed Base Year (s). Requi r ement s det ai led i n Sect i on I must
be f ul f i l l ed (Cat egor y I, begi nni ng at page 10).
II. INDIVIDUAL CLAIM ANTS WITH PAY PERIOD OR OTHER EARNINGS DOCUM ENTATION
FOR 2010 AND BENCHM ARK PERIOD: Appl i es t o Indi vi dual s w i t hout Tax Inf or mat i on
Document s but w i t h ot her cont empor aneous document s pr esent i ng empl oyment and
compensat i on i nf or mat i on f or 2010 and t he Benchmar k Per i od. Requi r ement s det ai l ed
i n Sect i on II must be f ul f i l l ed (Cat egor y II, begi nni ng at page 19).
III. INDIVIDUAL CLAIM ANTS WITH EARNINGS DOCUM ENTATION FOR 2010 BUT WITHOUT
COM PARABLE BENCHM ARK PERIOD EARNINGS: Appl i es t o Indi vi dual s w i t h Tax
Inf or mat i on Document s or ot her cont empor aneous document s pr esent i ng employment
and compensat ion i nf or mat i on f or 2010 but w i t hout a compar abl e Benchmar k Per i od.
Requi r ement s det ai l ed i n Sect ion III must be f ul f i l led (Cat egor y III, begi nni ng at page
28).
IV. INDIVIDUAL CLAIM ANTS WITHOUT EARNINGS DOCUM ENTATION WHO SUBM IT
INDIVIDUAL AND EM PLOYER SWORN WRITTEN STATEM ENTS TO ESTABLISH EARNINGS:
Appl i es t o Indi vi dual s w i t hout any document ar y pr oof but pr ovi di ng Sw or n Wr i t t en
St at ement s (f r om bot h t he cl ai mant and t he empl oyer ) pr esent i ng empl oyment and
compensat ion i nf or mat i on f or 2010. Requi r ement s det ai l ed i n Sect i on IV must be
f ul f i l l ed (Cat egor y IV, begi nni ng at page 44).
Def i ni t i ons
The f ol l ow i ng def i ned t er ms used i n t hi s Fr amew or k f or Indi vi dual Economi c Loss Cl ai ms shal l
have t he meani ngs set f or t h bel ow and be pr esent ed in bol d-f aced t ype t hr oughout t hi s
Fr amew or k.
A. Act ual Ear ni ngs: Clai mant s i ncome act ual ly ear ned f r om t he Cl ai mi ng Job(s) dur i ng t he
Compensat i on Per i od excludi ng Spi l l -Rel at ed Payment s and empl oyment ear nings f r om t he
VoO pr ogr am (i f any). For pur poses of calcul at i ng Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs, t her e may be
4
For pur poses of t hi s Fr amew or k f or Indi vi dual Economi c Loss Cl ai ms, t he pr esumpt i on shal l be t hat t he l ocat i on
of economi c l oss f or t he Cl ai mi ng Job i s t he l ocat i on of t he cl ai mant s empl oyer wi t hi n t he Cl ass Def i ni t i on
geogr aphi c ar ea, not t he cl ai mant s r esi dence. Cl ai mant s may est abl i sh an al t er nat i ve l ocat i on of economi c l oss f or
t he Cl ai mi ng Job ot her t han t hei r empl oyer s l ocat i on by pr ovi di ng evi dence t hat t hei r pr i mar y empl oyment
act i vi t i es and r esponsi bi l i t i es occur i n a l ocat i on di f f er ent f r om t hei r empl oyer s busi ness addr ess, and t hat t he
cl ai med DWH Spi l l -r el at ed economi c l oss occur r ed at such l ocat i on. For exampl e, t he cl ai mant w or ks f or a
housekeepi ng company l ocat ed i n Zone C t hat ser vi ces househol ds i n Zones A, B and C, i ncl udi ng vacat i on
condomi ni ums l ocat ed i n Zone A, and t he cl ai mant est abl i shes t hat she w or ks pr i mar i l y i n Zone A.
0288 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 53
3
adj ust ment s t o Act ual Ear ni ngs pur suant t o St ep 5 of t he Compensat i on Cal cul at ions set f or t h
i n Cat egor i es I, II and III.
B. Base Year (s): A cl aimant sel ect ed per i od used f or hi st or i cal compar i son and def ined as one of
t he f ol low i ng opt ions, pr ovi ded t hat once sel ect ed, t he same Base Year (s) shal l be used i n t hi s
Fr amew or k f or Indi vi dual Economi c Loss Cl ai ms f or al l pur poses f or w hi ch a Base Year (s) i s
r equi r ed:
1. 2009; or
2. The aver age of 2008 and 2009; or
3. The aver age of 2007, 2008 and 2009.
C. Benchmar k Per i od: A t i me per i od f or w hi ch a clai mant w as engaged i n a Cl ai mi ng Job or a
compar abl e j ob (w her e compar abl e shal l mean a j ob w i t h t he same empl oyer , or a j ob w i t h
a new employer wher e t he cl ai mant s ear ned i ncome changed by l ess t han 20% bet w een
Januar y 1 Apr i l 30 of t he Base Year (s) and Januar y 1 Apr i l 30, 2010), and w hi ch a cl ai mant
chooses f or t he f ol l ow i ng:
1. To est abl i sh basel i ne ear ni ngs t o be used i n cal cul at i ng t he cl aimant s Expect ed
Ear ni ngs.
i . For Cat egor ies I and II, t he Benchmar k Per i od i s t he t ime per i od of at l east 90
consecut i ve days w i t hi n t he cl aimant -sel ect ed Base Year (s) t hat cor r esponds
t o t he same cal endar mont hs and days sel ect ed by t he cl ai mant as t he
Compensat i on Per i od. In ci r cumst ances w her e t he cl ai mant chooses mul t i ple
Base Year s, t he Benchmar k Per i od shal l be cal cul at ed as t he aver age of t he
t i me per iods (of at l east 90 consecut i ve days) f r om each Base Year t hat
cor r espond t o t he same calendar mont hs and days select ed by t he cl aimant as
t he Compensat i on Per i od.
i i . For a cl aimant i n Cat egor y III, 2011 Benchmar k Per i od shal l be def i ned as a
2011 t i me per iod of at l east 90 consecut i ve days t hat cor r esponds t o t he same
cal endar mont hs and days as t he cl ai mant s sel ect ed Compensat i on Per i od.
i i i . If t he pay per iods f al l on di f f er ent dat es i n t he Benchmar k Per i od or t he 2011
Benchmar k Per i od, ear ni ngs shal l be al locat ed pr o-r at a t o cor r espond t o t he
dat es of t he Compensat i on Per i od.
i v. Examples of Benchmar k Per i od and 2011 Benchmar k Per i od can be seen i n
Appendi ces A t hr ough F at t ached her et o.
AND
2. If appl i cabl e, t o est abl i sh t he basel i ne hi st or ical ear nings t o be used i n cal cul at i ng t he
Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or . For t hi s pur pose, t he Benchmar k Per i od i s t he
consecut i ve pay per i ods w hi ch cover Januar y t hr ough Apr i l of t he cl aimant -sel ect ed
Base Year (s). In ci r cumst ances w her e t he cl aimant chooses mul t i pl e Base Year s, t he
Benchmar k Per i od shal l be cal cul at ed as t he aver age of t he cor r espondi ng per i ods
f r om each Base Year . Exampl es can be seen i n Appendi ces A t hr ough F at t ached
her et o.
0288 1
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 53
4
D. Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs: The cl aimant s Expect ed Ear ni ngs f r om al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs mi nus t he
cl ai mant s Act ual Ear ni ngs f r om al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od, mi nus any
Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs.
E. Cl ai mant s Wi t hout Compar abl e Benchmar k Ear ni ngs: Indi vi dual s w i t hout hi st or i cal ear ni ngs
compar abl e t o t he Compensat i on Per i od employment shal l use 2011 Benchmar k Per i od
ear ni ngs (i f any) t o est abl i sh Expect ed Ear ni ngs (as descr i bed i n Cat egor y III). Those cl ai mant s
ar e:
1. New Ent r ant To Empl oyment : An Indi vi dual (i) w ho was not empl oyed bet ween
Januar y 1, 2007 and Apr i l 20, 2010, and (i i ) w ho accept ed an of f er of f i r st -t ime
employment i n a new j ob, f ul l or par t -t ime (i ncl udi ng but not l imi t ed t o seasonal
employment ), pr i or t o Apr il 20, 2010, t o st ar t wor ki ng dur i ng t he per i od Apr i l 21, 2010
t o December 31, 2010, and (i i i ) w hose of f er was w it hdr aw n or amended dur i ng 2010
af t er t he DWH Spi l l .
For example, i f as of Apr i l 20, 2010, an Indi vi dual w ho had never been employed had
r eceived and accept ed an of f er of empl oyment t o begin w or ki ng bet w een Apr i l 21 and
December 31, 2010, t he Indi vi dual shal l be consi der ed a New Ent r ant t o
Empl oyment . Simi l ar l y, i f an Indi vi dual had pr eviously engaged i n par t -t ime w or k, but
as of Apr i l 20, 2010 had accept ed an of f er f or hi s or her f i r st f ul l -t ime posi t ion (or f or
hi s or her f i r st seasonal empl oyment posi t ion) t o begin w or ki ng bet w een Apr i l 21 and
December 31, 2010, t he Indi vi dual shal l al so be consider ed a New Ent r ant t o
Empl oyment . And, i f an Indi vi dual had wor ked pr i or t o 2007, but not bet w een
Januar y 1, 2007 and Apr i l 20, 2010, and had accept ed an of f er of empl oyment t o
begi n w or ki ng bet w een Apr i l 21 and December 31, 2010, t he Indi vi dual shal l be
consi der ed a New Ent r ant t o Empl oyment .
2. Cl ai mant Who Had Less Than Tw el ve M ont hs Of Ear ni ngs Hi st or y But Was Empl oyed
On Apr i l 20, 2010: An Indi vi dual w i t h 2010 ear ni ngs i nf or mat i on w ho w as employed
on Apr i l 20, 2010 but w ho di d not become empl oyed unt i l af t er Apr i l 20, 2009.
3. Car eer Changer : An Indi vi dual w ho (i ) changed employer (s) and l i ne of wor k bet w een
t he Benchmar k Per i od and t he Compensat i on Per i od and (i i ) w hose ear ni ngs dur i ng
t he per iod Januar y 1 - Apr i l 30, 2010 changed by mor e t han pl us or mi nus 20%
compar ed t o t hei r ear ni ngs dur i ng t he per iod Januar y 1 - Apr i l 30 of t he Base Year (s).
F. Cl ai mi ng Job(s): The j ob hel d or secur ed by t he cl aimant as of Apr i l 20, 2010 f or w hi ch t he
cl ai mant seeks compensat ion and f or w hi ch causat ion r equi r ement s under t hi s Fr amew or k f or
Indi vi dual Economi c Loss ar e sat i sf ied. Any j ob f r om w hi ch t he cl ai mant gener at ed ear ni ngs
dur i ng t he Benchmar k Per i od and/ or t he Compensat i on Per i od (i ncl udi ng Schedul e C or F
act i vi t ies) and f or w hi ch t he cl aimant does not seek compensat ion shal l be a Non-Cl ai mi ng
Job.
G. Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or : The Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or and r el at ed st af f appoi nt ed pur suant t o t he
Economic And Pr oper t y Damages Set t lement Agr eement and any Cl ai ms Admi nist r at i on
Vendor oper at i ng i n t he Class Act ion Set t l ement Of f i ce.
028842
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 53
5
H. Compensat i on Per i od: The Compensat i on Per i od i s sel ect ed by t he cl aimant . It must i ncl ude
90 or mor e consecut ive days bet w een Apr i l 21, 2010 and December 31, 2010, except f or
cl ai mant s w ho ar e i n t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Indust r y
5
f or w hi ch t he t ime per i od i s 90 or mor e
consecut i ve days bet w een Apr i l 21, 2010 and Apr i l 30, 2011. Cl aimant can select onl y one
Compensat i on Per i od, and t he Compensat i on Per i od must cor r espond w i t h t he pay per iods
used by t he empl oyer (i.e., st ar t and end w i t h t he st andar d dai l y, weekly, or mont hl y pay
per i od used by t he empl oyer ).
6
I. El i gi bl e Empl oyer : An empl oyer t hat (a) f i led a cl aim i n t he M DL 2179 set t lement pr ocess and
est abl i shed causat i on accor di ng t o r ul es descr i bed i n Causat i on Requi r ement s For Busi ness
Economi c Loss Cl ai ms or (b) r ecei ved a compensat ion of f er f r om t he GCCF.
J. Empl oyment -Rel at ed Benef i t s Losses: Losses def i ned i n t he Addendum Regar di ng
Compensat i on Rel at ed t o a Cl ai mant s Loss of Empl oyment -Rel at ed Benef i t s Income as a
Resul t of t he DWH Spi l l .
K. Expect ed Ear ni ngs: Cl aimant s ear ni ngs i n t he Compensat i on Per i od i n t he Cl ai mi ng Job t hat
w oul d have been expect ed i n t he absence of t he DWH Spi l l .
L. Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on: The Fi nal Compensat i on Amount shal l be t he amount ow ed t o
t he cl aimant . For Cat egor ies I, II, and III, t he Fi nal Compensat i on Amount shal l equal t he sum
of t he Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs, any appl i cabl e RTP, any Empl oyment -Rel at ed Benef i t s Losses,
any Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng Cost s, and any Rei mbur sabl e Sear ch Cost s, l ess any Spi l l -Rel at ed
Payment s. For Cat egor y IV, t he Fi nal Compensat i on Amount shal l be t he sum of t he Cl ai mant
Lost Ear ni ngs and any appl icabl e RTP, l ess any Spi l l -Rel at ed Payment s.
M . Fr amew or k f or Indi vi dual Economi c Loss Cl ai ms: Thi s Fr amew or k f or Indi vi dual Economi c
Loss Cl ai ms.
N. Gr ow t h Fact or : For cl ai mant s i n Cat egor i es I III only, Gr ow t h Fact or shal l be def i ned as any
of t he gr ow t h-r el at ed f act or s descr i bed bel ow t hat may be appl i ed i n t he cal cul at i on of a
cl ai mant s Expect ed Ear ni ngs, w her e t he cl aimant i s eli gi bl e, i ncl udi ng t he Cl ai mant Speci f i c
Gr ow t h Fact or or t he Gener al Gr ow t h Fact or , and, i f appl i cabl e, t he Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or .
Onl y cer t ai n cl aimant s w ho qual i f y f or compensat ion pur suant t o Cat egor i es I, II and III bel ow
ar e el i gi bl e t o r ecei ve any appl i cabl e f act or s. Gr ow t h Fact or s ar e not appl i cabl e i n Cat egor y
IV.
1. Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or : Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or shal l be def i ned as
an i ndi vi dual i zed Gr ow t h Fact or f or each Cl ai mi ng Job f or w hi ch t he cl aimant pr ovi des
5
As used her ei n, t he def i ni t i ons of Pr i mar y Seaf ood Indust r y and Secondar y Seaf ood Indust r y ar e set f or t h i n t he
Seaf ood Di st r i but i on Chai n Def i ni t i ons.
6
If t he cl ai mant has mul t i pl e Cl ai mi ng Jobs w hi ch ut i l i ze di f f er ent pay per i ods, t he Compensat i on Per i od dat es
shal l be sel ect ed t o cor r espond t o pay per i ods f r om t he posi t i on pr oduci ng gr eat est ear ni ngs. Ot her w ages
(ut i l i zi ng di f f er ent pay per i od schedul es), i ncl udi ng w ages f r om j obs w or ked i n t he Compensat i on Per i od f or w hi ch
l ost ear ni ngs ar e not sought (wher e r el evant ), shal l be al l ocat ed pr o -r at a t o t he days cor r espondi ng t o t he
Compensat i on Per i od. See exampl es at Appendi x C.
02884
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 53
6
Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on. The Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or shal l be
cal cul at ed as t he r at io of t he cl aimant s act ual Januar y-Apr i l 2010 base ear ni ngs
(i ncl udi ng commi ssions but excl udi ng bonuses) i n t he Cl ai mi ng Job di vi ded by act ual
Januar y-Apr i l base ear ni ngs i n t he Base Year (s) (i ncl uding commi ssi ons but excl udi ng
bonuses), pr ovi ded t hat i f t he cal cul at ed r at e i s gr eat er t han +10%, t he Cl ai mant
Speci f i c Gr ow t h Rat e shal l be +10%, and i f t he cal cul at ed r at e i s less t han -1.5%, t he
Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Rat e shal l be -1.5%. If t he Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or
r ef l ect s a change of pl us or mi nus 20% and t he Indi vi dual w as employed i n a new l i ne
of wor k w i t h a new empl oyer , cl aimant shal l be consi der ed a Car eer Changer and be
subj ect t o t he r equi r ement s of Cat egor y III: INDIVIDUAL CLAIM ANTS WITH EARNINGS
DOCUM ENTATION FOR 2010 BUT WITHOUT COM PARABLE BENCHM ARK PERIOD
EARNINGS.
2. Gener al Gr ow t h Fact or : Gener al Gr ow t h Fact or shal l be def i ned as a Gr ow t h Fact or
of 2.0% t hat shal l be assumed and appl i ed f or a cl aimant i n Cat egor y I or Cat egor y II
w ho does not pr ovi de Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on or w ho i s a Seasonal
Empl oyee (and t her ef or e has no Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or because he or she
has pr ovi ded no basi s f or cal cul at i ng i t ). For a cl ai mant i n Cat egor y III w ho has 2011
Benchmar k Per i od ear ni ngs, t hose ear ni ngs shal l be decr eased by t he Gener al
Gr ow t h Fact or t o cal cul at e Expect ed Ear ni ngs. For a Car eer Changer w ho does not
have 2011 ear ni ngs i nf or mat i on f or t he 2011 Benchmar k Per i od, t he Gener al Gr ow t h
Fact or may appl y i n est abl ishi ng Expect ed Ear ni ngs pur suant t o Cat egor y III.
3. Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or : Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or shal l be def i ned as a Gr ow t h Fact or
of 1.5% and may be appl i ed t o cl ai mant s i n Cat egor ies I, II and III i n cer t ai n
ci r cumst ances w her e t he Cl ai mi ng Job i s a non-sal ar i ed, hour l y w age j ob i n bot h
(i ) t he Compensat i on Per i od and (i i ) t he Benchmar k Per i od or 2011, as r el evant .
O. Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs: Ear nings f r om any Non-Cl ai mi ng Job(s) dur i ng t he cl ai mant s
Compensat i on Per i od i n excess of ear ni ngs f r om any Non-Cl ai mi ng Job(s) dur i ng t he
cl ai mant s Benchmar k Per i od, i f any, shal l of f set Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs unl ess:
1. If t he cl aimant pr ovi des document at i on (as descr i bed i n O.3) est abl i shi ng t hat he or
she wor ked t he same or mor e t ot al hour s at al l Cl ai mi ng Job(s) dur i ng t he
Compensat i on Per i od (as compar ed t o t he Benchmar k Per i od), t hen (a) no Of f set t i ng
Ear ni ngs shal l appl y, and (b) t o t he ext ent t he cl aimant w or ked mor e t ot al hour s i n al l
Cl ai mi ng Jobs i n t he Compensat i on Per i od (r el at ive t o t he Benchmar k Per i od), Act ual
Ear ni ngs shal l be l i mi t ed as set f or t h i n St ep 5 of t he Compensat ion Cal cul at ions set
f or t h i n Cat egor i es I, II and III.
OR
2. If t he cl aimant (i ) pr ovi des document at ion (as descr i bed i n O.3) est abl i shi ng t hat he or
she wor ked f ew er t ot al hour s at al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs dur ing t he Compensat i on Per i od (as
compar ed t o t he Benchmar k Per i od), and (i i ) pr ovi des evi dence as t o t he number of
hour s w or ked i n a Non-Cl ai mi ng Job(s) dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od and t he
Benchmar k Per i od, t hen Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs shal l be cal cul at ed f ol l ow s:
028844
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 7 of 53
7
i . The aver age hour l y r at e f or t he Non-Cl ai mi ng Job(s) dur i ng t he Compensat i on
Per i od, mul t i pl i ed by t he lesser of t he f ol low i ng:
a. The t ot al number of i ncr eased hour s wor ked i n t he Non-Cl ai mi ng
Job(s) dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od above t he hour s (i f any)
w or ked at t hat j ob or act i vit y dur i ng t he cl aimant s Benchmar k Per i od
(w hi ch may be zer o); or
b. The sum of t he t ot al number of hour s lost i n t he Cl ai mi ng Job(s).
3. Document at ion suf f i ci ent t o sat isf y O.1 and O.2 by est abl i shi ng t he number of hour s
w or ked (and, i f r el evant , wage r at e) i n (a) t he Cl ai mi ng Job(s) and (b) t he Non-
Cl ai mi ng Job(s) dur i ng bot h (c) t he Compensat i on Per i od and (d) t he Benchmar k
Per i od (as r el evant ), i ncl udes t he f ol low i ng:
i . For any Cl ai mi ng Job or Non-Cl ai mi ng Job w hi ch i s paid on an hour l y basi s,
t he cl aimant must pr ovi de document at ion est abl i shi ng t he number of hour s
w or ked f or each hour ly posi t i on and f or t he r elevant per i od(s).
Document at ion coul d i ncl ude, f or exampl e, pay st ubs.
i i . For non-hour l y j obs, t he cl ai mant must pr ovi de an Empl oyer Sw or n Wr i t t en
St at ement and any ot her document at ion est abl i shi ng t he number of hour s
w or ked f or each r elevant posi t ion and per iod, i ncl udi ng, but not l i mi t ed t o
document at ion r ef lect i ng over t i me wor ked.
i i i . For any Schedul e C or F act i vi t y, t he cl aimant must pr ovi de a Cl ai mant Sw or n
Wr i t t en St at ement and al l avai l abl e suppor t i ng document at i on di scl osi ng t he
number of hour s wor ked i n connect i on w i t h t he i dent if i ed act ivi t y f or each of
t he r elevant per iods.
P. One Ti me, Non-Recur r i ng Event Compensat i on: If a cl ai mant can est abl i sh l ost ear ni ngs
i ncome or pr of i t f r om a Cl ai mi ng Job due t o t he cancel l at i on of a cont r act f or a One Ti me,
Non-Recur r i ng Event as set f or t h i n t he One Ti me Loss Addendum, t he clai mant may r ecei ve
addi t i onal compensat ion i n accor d w i t h One Ti me Loss Addendum.
Q. Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on: Document at i on suf f i ci ent t o est abl i sh a clai mant s
ear ni ngs f r om employment and hour s w or ked dur i ng t he appl i cabl e per iod(s), i ncludi ng (i ) t he
Benchmar k Per i od (r el evant f or Cat egor i es I and II), (ii ) Januar y t hr ough Apr i l of 2010 and t he
Base Year (s), (i i i ) t he Compensat i on Per i od (r el evant f or Cat egor ies I t hr ough III), and (i v) t he
2011 Benchmar k Per i od (r el evant f or Cat egor y III). Document at ion may i ncl ude:
x Paycheck st ubs; and/ or
x Ot her employer r ecor ds document i ng act ual amount s pai d, i f appl i cabl e; and/ or
x Bank r ecor ds show i ng i ncome deposit s and suppor t i ng document at ion i ndi cat i ng
t he sour ce of t hose deposi t s; and/ or
02884
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 8 of 53
8
x A bank st at ement or ot her cont empor aneous document at i on ver i f yi ng t he absence
of i ncome f or al l or par t of t he Compensat i on Per i od; and/ or
x Recei pt s or r ecor ds f r om check cashi ng and payday loan ser vices; and/ or
x Cont r act s f or employment accompani ed by document at i on est abl i shi ng t hat w ages
or ot her amount s t o be paid pur suant t o t he cont r act , i f appl i cabl e, w er e i n f act
pai d; and/ or
x Pay per i od ear ni ngs det ai l submi t t ed under oat h and i ncl uded i n cour t f i l i ngs (f or
exampl e, document at ion pr ovi ded i n connect i on w it h di vor ce, chi l d suppor t , or
w age gar ni shment pr oceedi ngs).
R. Rei mbur sabl e Sear ch Cost s: Document ed t r avel and j ob sear ch cost s act ual ly i ncur r ed af t er
Apr i l 20, 2010 i n sear chi ng f or al t er nat ive employment due t o j ob l oss or w or k r educt i on af t er
t he DWH Spi l l .
S. Rei mbur sabl e Sear ch Cost Document at i on: Document s r ef lect i ng al l amount s i ncur r ed f or
Rei mbur sabl e Sear ch Cost s sought by t he cl aimant .
T. Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng Cost s: Tr ai ni ng, l i censi ng and educat i onal t ui t i on, f ees, and si mi l ar
expenses f or cour ses or pr ogr ams r el at ed t o i mpr ovi ng j ob ski l l s or secur i ng alt er nat e
employment (i.e., educat i on not i n pur sui t of a t w o- or f our -year degr ee) i n w hi ch cl ai mant
enr ol l ed and par t i ci pat ed commenci ng on or af t er Apr i l 21, 2010 t hr ough December 31, 2010
due t o j ob l oss or wor k r educt i on af t er t he DWH Spi l l .
U. Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng Cost Document at i on: Document s r ef lect i ng al l amount s pai d f or
Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng Cost s sought by t he clai mant , and al l cer t i f i cat es, cour se cr edi t s,
di pl omas, or l i censes obt ained by t he cl aimant based upon t he clai mant s compl et i on of such
t r ai ni ng.
V. Ri sk Tr ansf er Pr emi um ( RTP ): A f act or by w hi ch Cl ai mant Lost Income may be mul t i pl i ed as
def i ned and agr eed t o i n t he Economi c And Pr oper t y Damages Set t l ement Agr eement .
W. Seasonal Empl oyee: An Indi vi dual w i t h ear ni ngs dur i ng 6 or f ew er consecut i ve mont hs dur i ng
t he Base Year (s) but w ho w as not employed as of Apr i l 20, 2010, and w ho as of t hat dat e had
accept ed an of f er of employment f or a l at er per i od i n 2010 w hi ch subsequent l y w as
w i t hdr aw n or amended dur i ng 2010 af t er t he DWH Spi l l .
X. Spi l l -Rel at ed Payment s: Compensat ion pai d t o a cl aimant by BP or GCCF r el at ed t o t he DWH
Spi l l f or l oss of ear ni ngs f or t he Cl ai mi ng Job, i ncl udi ng (but not l i mit ed t o) payment s made
pur suant t o t he BP/ GCCF Oi l Pol l ut i on Act of 1990 ( OPA ) cl aims f aci l it i es.
Y. Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement : A w r it t en st at ement submi t t ed under penalt i es of per j ur y, w hi ch
may be submi t t ed el ect r oni cal l y, along w i t h any at t achment s, but w hi ch must be manual l y
si gned by t he per son making t he st at ement and r ef l ect such manual si gnat ur e. In addi t i on,
02884
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 9 of 53
9
t he st at ement may have a second, el ect r oni c si gnat ur e usi ng an appr oved t echnol ogy such as
(but not l i mi t ed t o) Adobe Echosi gn.
7
A Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement submi t t ed by a cl ai mant i s
a Cl ai mant Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement and a Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement submi t t ed by a
cl ai mant s empl oyer i s an Empl oyer Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement .
Z. Tax Inf or mat i on Document s: Tax Ret ur ns and For ms W-2 and/ or 1099.
AA. Tax Ret ur ns: Feder al or st at e i ncome t ax r et ur ns, i ncludi ng any r el evant suppor t i ng
schedul es.
Sw or n Cl ai m For m Requi r ement
Each cl aimant must compl et e and submi t a Cl ai m For m w hi ch t he cl ai mant shal l ver i f y under
penal t i es of per j ur y. The Clai m For m shal l di r ect t he clai mant t o pr ovi de i nf or mat i on, i ncl udi ng t he
cl ai mant s chosen Base Year (s) and Compensat i on Per i od. The cl aimant shal l at t ach r equi r ed
document s suppor t i ng t he cl ai m. Al l st at ement s made i n, and document s submit t ed w i t h, t he Cl aim
For m may be ver i f i ed as j udged necessar y by t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or . The cl aimant shal l pr ovi de
f or ms i n w hi ch t he cl ai mant shal l aut hor i ze t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or t o: (1) ver i f y empl oyment and
obt ai n copi es of w age r ecor ds, (2) obt ai n Tax Inf or mat i on Document s f r om t he Int er nal Revenue
Ser vi ce and/ or Soci al Secur i t y Admi ni st r at ion, and (3) conf i r m any bank account inf or mat i on used i n
suppor t of a clai m, but t he aut hor i zat i on f or bank r ecor ds shal l be l imi t ed t o t he Benchmar k Per i od
(or t he 2011 Benchmar k Per i od, w her e r elevant ) and Compensat i on Per i od. The Cl aim For m may
be submi t t ed i n el ect r oni c f ashi on, i ncl udi ng scanni ng of document s or copi es of ver i f i cat i on f r om
publ i c dat abases pr ovi di ng t he same i nf or mat ion as woul d be pr ovi ded by t he or igi nal document .
The Cl aim For m and any Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement s must be manual l y si gned and r ef l ect such
manual si gnat ur e. In addi t ion, t he Cl aim For m and any Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement may have a
second, el ect r oni c si gnat ur e usi ng an appr oved t echnol ogy such as (but not l imi t ed t o) Adobe
Echosi gn.
8
7
The par t i es agr ee t hat t he si gned st at ement must be as f ul l y enf or ceabl e agai nst t he maker as a hand -si gned
st at ement . If and t o t he ext ent i t i s det er mi ned t hat an e-si gned st at ement w i l l be so enf or ceabl e, t hen an e-
si gned st at ement al one w i l l suf f i ce.
8
The par t i es agr ee t hat t he si gned st at ement must be as f ul l y enf or ceabl e agai nst t he maker as a hand -si gned
st at ement . If and t o t he ext ent i t i s det er mi ned t hat an e-si gned st at ement w i l l be so enf or ceabl e, t hen an e-
si gned st at ement al one w i l l suf f i ce.
02884
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 10 of 53
10
I. CATEGORY I: INDIVIDUAL CLAIM ANTS WITH CONTEM PORANEOUS TAX INFORM ATION
DOCUM ENTS FOR 2010 AND BENCHM ARK PERIOD
If avai l abl e, t he Indi vi dual cl ai mant must pr ovi de clai mant s f eder al or st at e Tax Ret ur ns or
For ms W-2 and/ or 1099 f or t he Compensat i on Per i od and f or t he Base Year (s).
9
In such cases,
t he Indi vi dual cl ai mant s compensat ion shal l be cal cul at ed accor di ng t o t hi s Cat egor y I. If Tax
Ret ur ns or For ms W-2 and/ or 1099 ar e not avai l abl e, t he cl aimant must pr ovi de a w r i t t en
st at ement under oat h at t est i ng t hat no Tax Ret ur ns ar e avai l able and at t est i ng t hat t he cl aimant
made di l i gent ef f or t s t o obt ai n For ms W-2 f r om hi s or her employer . An Indi vi dual cl aimant
w ho i s a Car eer Changer shoul d pr oceed t o Cat egor y III. A cl ai mant w ho l acks Tax Inf or mat i on
Document s and/ or dat a f or a Benchmar k Per i od cannot pr oceed under t hi s Cat egor y I and
shoul d pr oceed t o Cat egor y II, III or IV, as r elevant .
A. Document at i on Requi r ement s
1. Document at i on Est abl i shi ng Empl oyment Ear ni ngs: For each year i ncl uded i n t he Base
Year (s), and f or 2010, Indi vi dual cl aimant s must pr ovide at least one of t he f ol l ow i ng Tax
Inf or mat i on Document s:
x Feder al t ax For m 1040 pages 1 and 2, al l pages of Schedul es C, E, and F, and any
suppor t i ng st at ement s at t ached t o t he For m 1040 f i l i ng (i ncl udi ng For m W-2s f or
j oi nt r et ur ns); or
x St at e t ax r et ur n, i ncl udi ng any suppor t i ng schedul es or st at ement s; or
x For ms W-2 document i ng ear ni ngs; and/ or
x For ms 1099 document i ng ear ni ngs.
2. Document at i on Est abl i shi ng Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs: To t he ext ent avai l abl e, a clai mant must
pr ovi de Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on f or t he Benchmar k Per i od and f or 2010. A
cl ai mant al so must pr ovi de document at ion t o est abl i sh any bonuses and/ or commi ssions
r eceived dur i ng t he Benchmar k Per i od and t he Compensat i on Per i od, as wel l as bonuses
and/ or commissi ons r eceived dur i ng Januar y or Febr uar y of t he Base Year (s), 2010 and 2011
f or al l j obs w or ked.
To t he ext ent Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on i s unavai l abl e, t he cl aimant shal l so
i ndi cat e i n t he swor n Cl aim For m, and ear ni ngs shal l be t r eat ed as ear ned evenl y t hr oughout
each year .
3. Document at i on Of Ear ni ngs Fr om Ot her Sour ces Dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od:
Cl ai mant s must al so submi t document s suf f i ci ent t o est abl i sh t he sour ce(s) and amount s of
ear ni ngs, i f any, f r om ot her post -DWH Spi l l sour ces of i ncome i ncl udi ng: (1) Spi l l -Rel at ed
9
If an Indi vi dual cl ai mant has not mai nt ai ned copi es of hi s or her f eder al i ncome t ax r et ur ns, he or she shal l
r equest a copy or t r anscr i pt di r ect l y f r om t he IRS. If a cl ai mant has not mai nt ai ned copi es of hi s or her For ms W-2,
he or she shal l r equest copi es di r ect l y f r om t he IRS or each empl oyer he or she w or ked f or dur i ng t he
Compensat i on Per i od and t he Benchmar k Per i od. A f eder al Tax Inf or mat i on Document shal l be consi der ed
avai l abl e i f i t exi st s and i s i n t he cl ai mant s possessi on or has not been r equest ed f r om t he IRS and/ or empl oyer .
028848
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 11 of 53
11
Payment s, and (2) compensat i on r eceived f r om and hour s wor ked i n each empl oyment
posi t ion ot her t han t he Cl ai mi ng Job(s). The t ypes of document s suf f i cient t o sat i sf y t hi s
r equi r ement ar e as f ol low s:
x For ms W-2, paycheck st ubs or ot her empl oyer -pr ovi ded payr ol l i nf or mat ion; and/ or
x Bank r ecor ds show i ng i ncome deposit s and suppor t i ng document at ion i ndi cat i ng
t he sour ce of t hose deposi t s; and/ or
x Document s f r om BP/ GCCF show i ng payment and BP/ GCCF Cl ai m Number ; and/ or
x For ms 1099; and/ or
x Recei pt s f r om check cashi ng ser vi ces; and/ or
x Ot her document s pr ovi ded by an employer set t i ng f or t h f or such ot her employment
posi t ion(s) (i) r equi r ed hour s of wor k, (i i ) act ual hour s w or ked by cl aimant , and (i ii )
compensat ion r at e.
4. Document at i on Est abl i shi ng Ot her Cost s/ Losses: The cl aimant may al so submi t
Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng Cost Document at i on, Rei mbur sabl e Sear ch Cost Document at i on,
and/ or document at i on r egar di ng Empl oyment -Rel at ed Benef i t s Losses.
5. Addi t i onal Cl ai mant Document at i on:
a. Cl ai mant Empl oyabi l i t y Document at i on: Consist s of bot h:
i . A copy of a Soci al Secur i t y car d, gover nment -i ssued i dent i f i cat i on (f or
exampl e, a val i d dr iver s l i cense), t empor ar y w or ker visa, or gr een car d t hat
w as val i d as of Apr i l 20, 2010 f or t he cl aimant , or a pr int out f r om a publ i c
dat abase pr ovi di ng t he same i nf or mat ion as w oul d be pr ovi ded by t he or i gi nal
document ;
AND
i i . Evi dence t he cl aimant w as at l east 16 year s of age as of Apr i l 20, 2010.
Accept abl e evi dence i ncl udes a copy of a val i d dr i ver s l i cense, a val i d
passpor t , a cer t i f i ed copy of t he cl aimant s bi r t h cer t i f icat e, or a pr i nt out f r om
a publ i c dat abase pr ovi di ng t he same i nf or mat ion as woul d be pr ovi ded by
t he or i gi nal document .
b. Li censi ng Document at i on: If cl ai mant s employment r equi r es a gover nment -i ssued
l i cense/ per mi t , a copy of val i d 2010 and 2011 l i censes, i f appr opr i at e, or a pr i nt out
f r om a publ i c dat abase pr ovi di ng t he same i nf or mat ion as woul d be pr ovi ded by t he
or i gi nal document . Licenses coul d i ncl ude, but ar e not l i mi t ed t o:
i . Taxi / l iver y l i censes.
i i . Real Est at e Sal es l icenses.
i i i . Ot her l i censes and per mi t s r el at ed t o i ncome sour ces.
02884
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 12 of 53
12
c. If t he cl aimant s empl oyment i n t he Cl ai mi ng Job w as t er mi nat ed bet ween Apr i l 20,
2010 and December 31, 2010, t he clai mant shal l have t he bur den of pr oof t o
est abl i sh t he t er mi nat ion w as not f or cause. The t er mi nat ion shal l be deemed not
f or cause i f :
i . The cl aimant est abl i shes t hat he or she f i l ed f or and r ecei ved unempl oyment ,
i ncl udi ng, f or exampl e, as evi denced by For m 1099 G.
OR
i i . Cl ai mant pr ovi des a let t er f r om t he f or mer empl oyer or an Empl oyer Sw or n
Wr i t t en St at ement conf i r mi ng t er mi nat ion w as not f or cause. Any such l et t er
must i ncl ude cont act i nf or mat ion f or an aut hor i zed r epr esent at i ve of t he
employer .
OR
i i i . Ot her document at ion accept abl e t o t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or t hat est abl i shes
t hat t he cl aimant w as not t er mi nat ed f or cause.
6. Addi t i onal Document at i on t o Est abl i sh Causat i on Pr esumpt i ons:
If t he cl aimant seeks t o qual i f y f or a causat i on pr esumpt ion as set f or t h i n Sect ions I.B.1 and
I.B.2.a, t he cl ai mant must pr ovi de document at ion f or 2010 t o est abl i sh t hat t he cl ai mant or
t he cl aimant s empl oyer sat i sf i es (or sat i sf i ed) t he geogr aphi c r equi r ement s and/ or t he
def i ni t i on of an ent i t y or Nat ur al Per son i ncl uded i n t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Indust r y,
Secondar y Seaf ood Indust r y, Tour i sm,
10
or Char t er Fi shi ng
11
as appl i cabl e. To sat i sf y t hi s
r equi r ement , t he cl aimant must demonst r at e t he empl oyer s locat ion and t he f ol l ow i ng:
a. That t he cl aimant w or ks or w or ked f or an employer t hat f i l ed a cl ai m i n t he M DL
No. 2179 set t lement pr ocess and w as det er mi ned by t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or t o
sat i sf y one of t he above-l i st ed def i ni t ions;
OR
b. That t he cl aimant s Tax Inf or mat i on Document s, Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs
Document at i on, or ot her document at ion est abl i shes t hat t he cl ai mant s employer
sat i sf i es one of t he above-l ist ed def i ni t ions.
B. Causat i on Requi r ement s
In or der t o est abl i sh causat i on under t hi s Cat egor y I, a cl ai mant must sat i sf y t he f ol l ow i ng:
1. The cl aimant must have been empl oyed i n t he Cl ai mi ng Job on Apr i l 20, 2010, unl ess t he
cl ai mant i s a Seasonal Empl oyee w ho can pr ovi de evidence of hi st or i cal seasonal
employment begi nni ng af t er Apr i l 20 i n t he Base Year (s).
10
The def i ni t i on of Tour i sm i s set f or t h i n t he Tour i sm Def i ni t i on, Bat es 026632 - 026646.
11
The def i ni t i on of Char t er Fi shi ng i s set f or t h i n Def i ni t i ons Sect i on 38 of t he Deepwat er Hori zon Economi c and
Pr oper t y Damages Set t l ement Agr eement .
0288 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 13 of 53
13
2. The cl aimant must sat i sf y one of t he f ol low i ng:
a. Indi vi dual Cl ai mant s Wi t h Pr esumed Causat i on: The DWH Spi l l shal l be pr esumed
t o be t he cause of lost ear ni ngs f or a Cl ai mi ng Job dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od
f or t he f ol low i ng cat egor i es of cl ai mant s w ho submi t t he r equi r ed document at ion,
pr ovi ded t hat t he cl aimant can demonst r at e t hat any l oss of i ncome or employment
r el at ed t o t he Cl ai mi ng Job was not a f unct ion of t he cl ai mant s t er mi nat ion f or
cause pur suant t o t he Document at ion Requi r ement s set f or t h i n Sect ion I.A.5.c:
i . If a cl aimant i s an Indi vi dual seeki ng compensat ion f or an economi c loss
r el at i ng t o employment w i t hi n Zone A,
12
t he cl ai mant i s not r equi r ed t o
pr ovi de any evi dence of causat i on r el at i ng t o t hat Cl ai mi ng Job.
i i . If a cl aimant i s an i ndi vi dual seeki ng compensat i on f or an economi c loss f or a
j ob i n w hi ch he or she w as employed by, or excl usively ser vi ced, an ent it y or
Nat ur al Per son t hat sat i sf i es t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Indust r y def i ni t ion as set
f or t h i n t he Seaf ood Di st r i but i on Chai n Def i ni t i ons, t he cl aimant i s not
r equi r ed t o pr ovi de any evidence of causat i on r el at i ng t o t hat Cl ai mi ng Job.
i i i . If a cl aimant i s an i ndi vi dual seeki ng compensat i on f or an economi c loss f or a
j ob i n w hi ch he or she w as employed by an ent i t y or Nat ur al Per son t hat
sat i sf i es t he Secondar y Seaf ood Indust r y def i ni t i on as set f or t h i n t he Seaf ood
Di st r i but i on Chai n Def i ni t i ons, and t he ent i t y or Nat ur al Per son w as locat ed
i n Zones B or C, t he cl aimant i s not r equi r ed t o pr ovi de any evi dence of
causat i on r el at i ng t o t hat Cl ai mi ng Job.
i v. If t he cl aimant is an Indi vi dual seeki ng compensat i on f or an economi c loss f or
a j ob i n w hi ch he or she was empl oyed by a busi ness l ocat ed i n Zone B t hat
meet s t he def i ni t ion of Tour i sm, t he cl aimant is not r equi r ed t o pr ovi de any
evi dence of causat i on r el at i ng t o t hat Cl ai mi ng Job.
v. If t he cl aimant is an Indi vi dual seeki ng compensat i on f or an economi c loss f or
a j ob i n w hi ch he or she was empl oyed by an ent it y or Nat ur al Per son t hat
sat i sf i es t he def i nit i on of Char t er Fi shi ng, and t he Char t er Fi shi ng busi ness
w as locat ed i n Zones A, B or C, t he cl aimant i s not r equi r ed t o pr ovi de any
evi dence of causat i on r el at i ng t o t hat Cl ai mi ng Job.
12
For pur poses of t hi s Fr amew or k f or Indi vi dual Economi c Loss Cl ai ms, t he pr esumpt i on shal l be t hat t he l ocat i on
of economi c l oss f or t he Cl ai mi ng Job i s t he l ocat i on of t he cl ai mant s empl oyer w i t hi n t he Cl ass Def i ni t i on
geogr aphi c ar ea, not t he cl ai mant s r esi dence. Cl ai mant s may est abl i sh an al t er nat i ve l ocat i on of economi c l oss f or
t he Cl ai mi ng Job ot her t han t hei r empl oyer s l ocat i on by pr ovi di ng evi dence t hat t hei r pr i mar y empl oyment
act i vi t i es and r esponsi bi l i t i es occur i n a l ocat i on di f f er ent f r om t hei r empl oyer s busi ness addr ess, and t hat t he
cl ai med DWH Spi l l -r el at ed economi c l oss occur r ed at such l ocat i on. For exampl e, t he cl ai mant w or ks f or a
housekeepi ng company l ocat ed i n Zone C t hat ser vi ces househol ds i n Zones A, B and C, i ncl udi ng vacat i on
condomi ni ums l ocat ed i n Zone A, and t he cl ai mant est abl i shes t hat she w or ks pr i mar i l y i n Zone A.
0288
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 14 of 53
14
OR
b. Indi vi dual Cl ai mant s Wi t hout Pr esumed Causat i on: If a cl aimant i s not ent i t l ed t o a
causat i on pr esumpt i on as set f or t h i n Sect i on I.B.2.a, t he cl aimant can est abl i sh
causat i on f or a Cl ai mi ng Job dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od only by sat i sf yi ng t he
r equi r ement s of one of t he f ol low i ng sub-sect i ons:
i . Causat i on i s est abl i shed i f t he Cl ai mi ng Job i s w i t h an El i gi bl e Empl oyer . The
Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l ver i f y t hat t he empl oyer i s an El i gi bl e Empl oyer .
i i . Causat i on f or a Cl ai mi ng Job i s est abl i shed i f t he cl aimant pr ovi des an
Empl oyer Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement at t r i but i ng t he clai mant s l oss of i ncome
dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od t o t he DWH Spi l l . The Empl oyer Sw or n
Wr i t t en St at ement must ar t i cul at e i n det ai l how t he clai mant s l osses at t he
Cl ai mi ng Job ar e causal ly r el at ed t o t he DWH Spi l l . Such Empl oyer Sw or n
Wr i t t en St at ement must also i ncl ude cont act i nf or mat i on f or an aut hor i zed
r epr esent at i ve of t he employer .
i i i . The Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l eval uat e t he cr edi bi l i t y and r el i abi l i t y of t he
i nf or mat i on pr ovi ded by t he empl oyer and t he cl ai mant , i ncl udi ng any Sw or n
Wr i t t en St at ement s, and have t he r i ght t o r equest suppl ement al
document at ion and/ or t o i nt er vi ew t he employer i n accor dance w i t h t he
Addendum Regar di ng Int er vi ew s of Cl ai mant Al l egi ng Economi c Loss.
C. Compensat i on Cal cul at i on
The Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l use Tax Inf or mat i on Document s and ot her suppor t i ng
document at ion pr ovi ded by t he cl aimant t o cal cul at e t he Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs. As set f or t h i n
t he st eps below , Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs i ncl udes: (1) any r educt i on i n ear ni ngs bet ween t he
Compensat i on Per i od and t he Benchmar k Per i od f or each Cl ai mi ng Job, pl us (2) any l ost
pot ent i al ear ni ngs gr ow t h expect ed f or each Cl ai mi ng Job i n t he absence of t he DWH Spi l l ,
mi nus (3) any Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs. Lost pot ent i al ear nings gr ow t h expect ed f or each Cl ai mi ng
Job shal l be det er mi ned t hr ough appl i cat i on of (a) a Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or , or (b) a
Gener al Gr ow t h Fact or ; i n addi t i on, f or cl aims based on non-sal ar ied, hour ly-w age j obs, an
Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or i s appl i ed.
The cl aimant shal l r ecei ve a l ump-sum f i nal payment t hat i ncl udes compensat ion f or Cl ai mant
Lost Ear ni ngs, pl us any appl i cabl e RTP agr eed upon by t he par t ies, pl us compensat i on f or
pr oper l y document ed Empl oyment -Rel at ed Benef i t s Losses, Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng Cost s and
Rei mbur sabl e Sear ch Cost s, or One Ti me, Non-Recur r i ng Event Commi ssi on Compensat i on, i f
any, l ess any Spi l l -Rel at ed Payment s.
Example compensat ion calcul at i ons ar e set f or t h i n Appendi ces A t hr ough F at t ached her et o.
St ep 1: Cl ai mant Sel ect s Compensat i on Per i od and Benchmar k Per i od
1. Cl ai mant sel ect s a Compensat i on Per i od. For a cl aimant w ho (i ) w as t er mi nat ed f or
cause i n 2010 f r om t he Cl ai mi ng Job(s), or (i i ) ot her w i se ended employment at t he
0288 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 15 of 53
15
Cl ai mi ng Job(s) i n 2010 f or r easons unr el at ed t o t he DWH Spi l l , t he Compensat i on
Per i od may not ext end beyond t he t er mi nat ion dat e.
2. Cl ai mant sel ect s a Base Year (s).
St ep 2: Det er mi ne Benchmar k Per i od Ear ni ngs f or t he M ont hs Cor r espondi ng t o t he
Compensat i on Per i od
Ear ni ngs dur i ng t he Benchmar k Per i od mont hs (as evi denced by Tax Inf or mat i on Document s)
shal l i ncl ude ear ned i ncome f r om each Cl ai mi ng Job (or compar abl e j ob) and shal l be assumed
t o have been ear ned evenly t hr oughout t he year unl ess t he cl ai mant pr ovi des Pay Per i od
Ear ni ngs Document at i on suf f i ci ent t o est abl i sh act ual ear ni ngs di st r i but ion t hr oughout t he year .
Al l bonuses and/ or commi ssi ons shal l be al l ocat ed pr o r at a acr oss t he per i od f or w hi ch t hey
w er e aw ar ded, and annual per f or mance bonuses pai d i n Januar y and Febr uar y shal l be assumed
t o r el at e t o t he pr i or cal endar year , unl ess t he document s est abl i sh t hat t he bonus r el at ed t o a
speci f i c per iod of t ime.
St ep 3: Det er mi ne Ear ni ngs Gr ow t h Fact or (s)
1. Cl ai mant Speci f i c Growt h Fact or : For cl ai mant s w ho pr ovi de Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs
Document at i on suf f i ci ent t o cal cul at e a Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or , t he f oll ow i ng
Gr ow t h Fact or s may appl y:
a. Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or i s def i ned, and t he cal cul at i on i s expl ai ned, i n
Def i ni t ions Sect i on N.1.
b. Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or i s def i ned i n Def i ni t i ons Sect i on N.3.
2. Cl ai mant s f or Whom Cl ai mant Speci f i c Growt h Fact or Is Not Appl i cabl e: For cl aimant s
unabl e t o pr ovi de Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on suf f i ci ent t o cal cul at e a Cl ai mant
Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or and f or Seasonal Empl oyees, no Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h
Fact or shal l appl y. Inst ead, t he f ol l ow i ng Gr ow t h Fact or s may appl y:
a. Gener al Gr ow t h Fact or i s def i ned i n Def i ni t i ons Sect i on N.2 and i s 2.0%.
b. Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or i s def i ned i n Def i ni t i ons Sect i on N.3: For cl aims based on
non-sal ar i ed, hour l y-w age j obs, an Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or of 1.5% shal l be appl i ed.
St ep 4: Cal cul at e Expect ed Ear ni ngs
Expect ed Ear ni ngs equal t he Benchmar k Per i od ear nings cal cul at ed i n St ep 2 i ncr eased by
t he appl i cabl e Gr ow t h Fact or s (f r om St ep 3).
Expect ed Ear ni ngs = Benchmar k Per i od Earnings f rom St ep 2 x (1 + applicable St ep 3 Growt h
Fact or (s))
St ep 5: Det er mi ne Act ual Ear ni ngs and Any Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs In The Compensat i on Per i od
Act ual Ear ni ngs f or al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs and any appl i cabl e Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs dur i ng t he
Compensat i on Per i od shal l be det er mi ned based on Tax Inf or mat i on Document s and Pay
0288
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 16 of 53
16
Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on pr ovi ded by t he cl aimant and ot her document at i on
r el evant t o det er mi ni ng Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs.
To t he ext ent t he cl aimant does not have Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on f or a
Cl ai mi ng Job, Act ual Ear ni ngs dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od shal l be est imat ed f or t hat
Cl ai mi ng Job by di vi di ng t he cl aimant s t ot al 2010 Cl ai mi ng Job ear ni ngs by 12 and
mul t i pl yi ng t hat amount by t he number of mont hs i n t he Compensat i on Per i od. Al l bonuses
and/ or commi ssions shal l be al l ocat ed pr o r at a acr oss t he per iods f or w hi ch t hey w er e
aw ar ded, and annual per f or mance bonuses pai d i n Januar y and Febr uar y shal l be assumed
t o r el at e t o t he pr i or cal endar year , unl ess t he document s est abl i sh t hat t he bonus r el at ed
t o a speci f i c per iod of t ime.
Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs and Act ual Ear ni ngs f r om al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs shal l be calcul at ed gi vi ng
consi der at ion t o al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs, pr ovi ded t hat :
1. If t he cl aimant has only one Cl ai mi ng Job, t hen:
i . If Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on (or ot her document at i on r el evant t o
cal cul at i ng Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs) r ef l ect s t he same or an i ncr eased number of
hour s wor ked at t he Cl ai mi ng Job i n t he Compensat i on Per i od r el at i ve t o t he
Cl ai mi ng Job (or compar abl e j ob) i n t he Benchmar k Per i od, Act ual Ear ni ngs
shal l be l i mit ed t o ear ni ngs f r om t he Cl ai mi ng Job (or compar abl e j ob) over t he
same t ot al number of hour s wor ked i n t he Benchmar k Per i od, and no
Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs shal l appl y.
OR
i i . If Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on (or ot her document at i on) (i ) r ef l ect s a
decr ease i n hour s wor ked at t he Cl ai mi ng Job dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od,
and (i i ) t he cl ai mant s Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on r ef l ect s addi t ional
hour s wor ked at a Non-Cl ai mi ng Job (w het her such Non-Cl ai mi ng Job w as hel d
i n t he Benchmar k Per i od or i s a new posi t ion), Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs shal l be
cal cul at ed and f act or ed i nt o t he det er mi nat i on of Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs.
2. If t he cl aimant has mor e t han one Cl ai mi ng Job, t hen:
i . If Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on (or ot her document at i on r el evant t o
cal cul at i ng Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs) f or al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs r ef l ect s t he same or an
i ncr eased number of t ot al hour s wor ked acr oss al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs dur i ng t he
Compensat i on Per i od (r el at i ve t o al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs (or compar abl e j obs) i n t he
Benchmar k Per i od), aggr egat e Act ual Ear ni ngs i n t he Compensat i on Per i od
shal l be l i mit ed t o t ot al ear ni ngs f r om al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs (or compar abl e j obs)
over t he same number of t ot al hour s w or ked i n t he Benchmar k Per i od,
pr ovi ded t hat ear ni ngs f r om hour s l ost i n one Cl ai mi ng Job shal l be r epl aced by
ear ni ngs f r om t he same number of hour s w or ked i n a di f f er ent Cl ai mi ng Job
dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od. No Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs shal l appl y.
0288 4
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 17 of 53
17
OR
i i . If Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on (or ot her document at i on r el evant t o
cal cul at i ng Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs) f or al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs r ef l ect s (i ) f ewer t ot al
hour s wor ked acr oss al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od (r el at i ve
t o al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs (or compar abl e j obs) i n t he Benchmar k Per i od), but (i i )
mor e hour s wor ked i n one (or mor e) Cl ai mi ng Job(s) in t he Compensat i on
Per i od (r el at i ve t o t he same Cl ai mi ng Job(s) i n t he Benchmar k Per i od),
aggr egat e Act ual Ear ni ngs in t he Compensat i on Per i od shal l i ncl ude t ot al
ear ni ngs f r om al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs (or compar abl e j obs) in t he Compensat i on
Per i od. If t he cl aimant s Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on al so r ef l ect s
addi t i onal hour s wor ked at a di f f er ent (Non-Cl ai mi ng Job) posi t i on (w het her
such posi t ion was hel d i n t he Benchmar k Per i od or i s a new posi t ion), Of f set t i ng
Ear ni ngs shal l be cal cul at ed and f act or ed i nt o t he det er mi nat ion of Cl ai mant
Lost Ear ni ngs f or t he number of hour s r epr esent i ng t he di f f er ence bet w een (a)
t ot al hour s w or ked i n al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs i n t he Compensat i on Per i od, and (b)
t ot al hour s w or ked i n al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs i n t he Benchmar k Per i od.
OR
i i i . If Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on (or ot her document at i on) f or al l Cl ai mi ng
Jobs (i ) r ef l ect s a decr ease i n hour s wor ked at each Cl ai mi ng Job dur i ng t he
Compensat i on Per i od, and (i i ) t he cl aimant s Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs
Document at i on r ef lect s addi t i onal hour s wor ked at a di f f er ent posi t ion
(w het her such posi t ion w as hel d i n t he Benchmar k Per i od or i s a new posi t ion),
Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs shal l be cal cul at ed and f act or ed int o t he det er mi nat i on of
Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs f or t he t ot al lost hour s.
OR
i v. If t he cl aimant does not have Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on (or ot her
document at ion est abl i shi ng hour s wor ked) f or al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs, t hen Act ual
Ear ni ngs shal l i ncl ude al l ear ni ngs f r om al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs and Of f set t i ng
Ear ni ngs shal l appl y.
St ep 6: Det er mi ne Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs
Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs shal l be cal cul at ed as (a) t he dif f er ence bet w een (i ) t he clai mant s
Expect ed Ear ni ngs dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od (St ep 4) f r om al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs and
(i i ) t he cl ai mant s Act ual Ear ni ngs dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od, as adj ust ed, i f r el evant ,
(St ep 5) f r om al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs, r educed by (b) any appl i cabl e Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs.
St ep 7: Cal cul at e Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on
Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on shal l be Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs (St ep 6) adj ust ed as f ol low s:
1. Add any appl i cabl e RTP agr eed t o by t he par t i es. For an employee t er mi nat ed f or cause
f r om a Cl ai mi ng Job, no RTP shal l appl y.
0288
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 18 of 53
18
- For cl aimant s w hose Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs r esul t f r om mor e t han one Cl ai mi ng
Job, t he cl ai mant s appl i cabl e RTP shal l be cal cul at ed based on (i ) t he per cent age of
t ot al Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs r el at ed t o each Cl ai mi ng Job, mul t i pl i ed by (i i ) t he RTP
appl i cabl e t o each Cl ai mi ng Job, w hi ch i s det er mi ned by t he j ob t ype
(Tour i sm/ Ot her Indust r i es) and zone (Zone A, B, C or D). For exampl e, a cl aimant
w i t h 50% of t hei r lost ear nings f r om a j ob Zone A hot el , and 50% of t hei r lost
ear ni ngs f r om a j ob i n a Zone C r est aur ant shal l r ecei ve an RTP t hat i s cal cul at ed as
f ol l ow s:
Appl i cabl e RTP = .5* RTP
Zone A Tour i sm (hot el )
+ .5* RTP
Zone C Tour i sm (r est aur ant )
2. Add any Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng Cost s. Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng Cost s shal l be f ul ly
r ei mbur sed i f t he t r ai ni ng led di r ect ly t o ear ned i ncome i n 2010. If no cor r espondi ng
i ncome w as ear ned i n 2010, t hen Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng Cost s shal l be r eimbur sed up
t o $2,000.
For example: A cl aimant who pai d $3,000 af t er Apr i l 20, 2010 t o secur e a
commer ci al t r ucki ng l i cense and w ho ear ned i ncome as a commer ci al t r ucker i n
2010 shal l r ecei ve $3,000 i n r ei mbur sement . If t he clai mant ear ned no i ncome f r om
commer ci al t r ucki ng dur i ng 2010, t he cl aimant w oul d r eceive a $2,000
r ei mbur sement .
3. Add any Rei mbur sabl e Sear ch Cost s.
4. Add any appl i cabl e Empl oyment -Rel at ed Benef i t s Losses.
5. Add any One Ti me, Non-Recur r i ng Event Compensat i on.
6. Subt r act any Spi l l -Rel at ed Payment s.
7. The f or mul a f or Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on i s:
Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs
+ (Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs x any appl i cabl e RTP)
+ Empl oyment -Rel at ed Benef i t s Losses (i f appl i cabl e)
+ Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng Cost s (f ul l i f led t o ear ned i ncome i n 2010 f r om
ar ea of t r ai ni ng, ot her w i se $2,000) (i f appl i cabl e)
+ Rei mbur sabl e Sear ch Cost s (i f appl i cabl e)
+ One Ti me, Non-Recur r i ng Event Compensat i on (i f appl i cabl e)
- Spi l l -Rel at ed Payment s (i f appl i cabl e)
- VoO Set t l ement Of f set and/ or VoO Ear ned Income Of f set (i f any)
0288
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 19 of 53
19
II. CATEGORY II: INDIVIDUAL CLAIM ANTS WITH PAY PERIOD OR OTHER EARNINGS
DOCUM ENTATION FOR 2010 AND BENCHM ARK PERIOD
13
Indi vi dual cl aimant s w ho do not have Tax Inf or mat i on Document s avai l abl e f or ei t her 2010 or
t he Base Year (s) may i nst ead pr ovi de Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on suf f i cient t o est abl i sh
ear ni ngs dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od and t he Benchmar k Per i od. Such Indi vi dual
cl ai mant s must pr ovi de a w r i t t en st at ement under oat h at t est i ng t hat no Tax Ret ur ns ar e
avai l abl e and at t est i ng t hat t he cl aimant made di l i gent ef f or t s t o obt ai n For ms W-2 f r om hi s or
her empl oyer and st at i ng t hat t hey ar e not avai l able. An Indi vi dual cl aimant w ho i s a Car eer
Changer shoul d pr oceed t o Cat egor y III. An Indi vi dual cl ai mant w ho l acks Tax Inf or mat i on
Document s and Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on f or t he Benchmar k Per i od and/ or 2010
must so st at e i n t he swor n Cl ai m For m. In such ci r cumst ances, cl ai mant cannot pr oceed under
t hi s Cat egor y II and shoul d pr oceed t o Cat egor y III or IV t o t he ext ent t he cl aimant qual i f i es
under any such Cat egor y.
A. Document at i on Requi r ement s
1. Document at i on Est abl i shi ng Empl oyment Ear ni ngs: To t he ext ent avai l abl e, t he cl ai mant
must pr ovi de Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on f or t he Benchmar k Per i od and f or 2010.
Wher e i ncompl et e Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on i s pr ovi ded, Expect ed Ear ni ngs and
Act ual Ear ni ngs shal l be calcul at ed based onl y on t he act ual document at ion pr ovi ded. A
cl ai mant al so must pr ovi de document at i on t o est abl i sh any bonuses and/ or commi ssions
r eceived dur i ng t he Benchmar k Per i od and t he Compensat i on Per i od, as wel l as bonuses
and/ or commi ssions r ecei ved dur i ng Januar y or Febr uar y of t he Base Year (s), 2010 and 2011
f or al l j obs w or ked.
2. Document at i on Of Ear ni ngs Fr om Ot her Sour ces Dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od:
Cl ai mant s must al so submi t document s suf f i ci ent t o est abl i sh t he sour ce(s) and amount s of
ear ni ngs, i f any, f r om ot her post -DWH Spi l l sour ces of i ncome i ncl udi ng: (1) Spi l l -Rel at ed
Payment s, and (2) compensat i on r eceived f r om and hour s w or ked i n each empl oyment
posi t ion ot her t han t he Cl ai mi ng Job(s). The t ypes of document s suf f i cient t o sat i sf y t hi s
r equi r ement ar e as f ol low s:
x For ms W-2, paycheck st ubs or ot her empl oyer -pr ovi ded payr ol l i nf or mat ion; and/ or
x Bank r ecor ds show i ng i ncome deposit s and suppor t i ng document at ion i ndi cat i ng
t he sour ce of t hose deposi t s; and/ or
x Document f r om BP/ GCCF show i ng payment and BP/ GCCF Cl ai m Number ; and/ or
x For ms 1099; and/ or
x Recei pt s f r om check cashi ng ser vi ces; and/ or
x Ot her document s pr ovi ded by an employer set t i ng f or t h f or such ot her employment
posi t ion(s) (i) r equi r ed hour s of wor k, (i i ) act ual hour s w or ked by cl aimant , and
13
A cl ai mant w ho has no j ob ear ni ngs f r om any Benchmar k Per i od may not pr oceed under Cat egor y II but shoul d
pr oceed t o Cat egor y III as a pot ent i al New Ent r ant To Empl oyment or Cl ai mant Who Had Less Than Tw el ve
M ont hs Of Ear ni ngs Hi st or y But Was Empl oyed On Apr i l 20, 2010, or t o Cat egor y IV, as r el evant .
0288
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 20 of 53
20
(i i i ) compensat i on r at e.
3. Document at i on Est abl i shi ng Ot her Cost s/ Losses: The cl aimant may al so submi t
Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng Cost Document at i on, Rei mbur sabl e Sear ch Cost Document at i on,
and/ or document at i on r egar di ng Empl oyment -Rel at ed Benef i t s Losses.
4. Addi t i onal Cl ai mant Document at i on
a. Cl ai mant Empl oyabi l i t y Document at i on: Consi st s of bot h:
i . A copy of a Soci al Secur i t y car d, gover nment -i ssued i dent i f i cat i on (f or exampl e,
a val i d dr iver s l icense), t empor ar y w or ker vi sa, or gr een car d t hat w as val i d as
of Apr i l 20, 2010 f or t he cl ai mant , or a pr i nt out f r om a publ i c dat abase
pr ovi di ng t he same i nf or mat i on as woul d be pr ovi ded by t he or i gi nal document ;
AND
i i . Evi dence t he cl aimant w as at l east 16 year s of age as of Apr i l 20, 2010.
Accept abl e evi dence i ncl udes a copy of a val i d dr i ver s l i cense, a val i d passpor t ,
a cer t i f ied copy of t he cl aimant s bi r t h cer t i f i cat e, or a pr i nt out f r om a publ i c
dat abase pr ovi di ng t he same i nf or mat ion as w oul d be pr ovi ded by t he or i gi nal
document .
b. Li censi ng Document at i on: If cl ai mant s employment r equi r es a gover nment -i ssued
l i cense/ per mi t , a copy of val i d 2010 and 2011 l i censes, i f appr opr i at e, or a pr i nt out
f r om a publ i c dat abase pr ovi di ng t he same i nf or mat ion as w oul d be pr ovi ded by t he
or i gi nal document . Licenses coul d i ncl ude, but ar e not l i mi t ed t o:
i . Taxi / l iver y l i censes.
i i . Real Est at e Sal es l icenses.
i i i . Ot her l i censes and per mi t s r el at ed t o i ncome sour ces.
c. If t he cl aimant s empl oyment i n t he Cl ai mi ng Job w as t er mi nat ed bet ween Apr i l 20,
2010 and December 31, 2010, t he clai mant shal l have t he bur den of pr oof t o est abl i sh
t he t er mi nat ion w as not f or cause. The t er mi nat ion shal l be deemed not f or cause i f :
i . The cl aimant est abl i shes t hat he or she f i l ed f or and r ecei ved unempl oyment ,
i ncl udi ng, f or exampl e, as evi denced by For m 1099 G.
OR
i i . Cl ai mant pr ovi des a let t er f r om t he f or mer empl oyer or an Empl oyer Sw or n
Wr i t t en St at ement conf i r mi ng t er mi nat ion w as not f or cause. Any such l et t er
must i ncl ude cont act i nf or mat ion f or an aut hor i zed r epr esent at i ve of t he
employer .
OR
i i i . Ot her document at ion accept abl e t o t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or t hat est abl i shes
t hat t he cl aimant w as not t er mi nat ed f or cause.
0288 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 21 of 53
21
5. Addi t i onal Document at i on t o Est abl i sh Causat i on Pr esumpt i ons:
If t he cl aimant seeks t o qual i f y f or a causat i on pr esumpt ion as set f or t h i n Sect ions II.B.1 and
II.B.2.a, t he cl ai mant must pr ovi de document at i on f or 2010 t o est abl i sh t hat t he cl ai mant or
t he cl aimant s empl oyer sat i sf i es (or sat i sf i ed) t he geogr aphi c r equi r ement s and/ or t he
def i ni t i on of an ent i t y or Nat ur al Per son i ncl uded i n t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Indust r y,
Secondar y Seaf ood Indust r y, Tour i sm,
14
or Char t er Fi shi ng
15
as appl i cabl e. To sat i sf y t hi s
r equi r ement , t he cl aimant must demonst r at e t he empl oyer s locat ion and t he f ol l ow i ng:
a. That t he cl aimant w or ks or w or ked f or an employer t hat f i l ed a cl ai m i n t he M DL
No. 2179 set t lement pr ocess and w as det er mi ned by t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or t o
sat i sf y one of t he above-l i st ed def i ni t ions;
OR
b. That t he cl aimant s Tax Inf or mat i on Document s, Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs
Document at i on, or ot her document at ion est abl i shes t hat t he cl ai mant s employer
sat i sf i es one of t he above-l ist ed def i ni t ions.
B. Causat i on Requi r ement s
In or der t o est abl i sh causat i on under t hi s Cat egor y II, a cl ai mant must sat i sf y t he f ol l ow i ng:
1. The cl aimant must have been empl oyed i n t he Cl ai mi ng Job on Apr i l 20, 2010, unl ess t he
cl ai mant i s a Seasonal Empl oyee w ho can pr ovi de evidence of hi st or i cal seasonal
employment begi nni ng af t er Apr i l 20 i n t he Base Year (s).
2. The cl aimant must sat i sf y one of t he f ol low i ng:
a. Indi vi dual Cl ai mant s Wi t h Pr esumed Causat i on: The DWH Spi l l shal l be pr esumed
t o be t he cause of lost ear ni ngs f or a Cl ai mi ng Job dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od
f or t he f ol low i ng cat egor i es of cl ai mant s w ho submi t t he r equi r ed document at ion,
pr ovi ded t hat t he cl aimant can demonst r at e t hat any l oss of i ncome or employment
r el at ed t o t he Cl ai mi ng Job w as not a f unct ion of t he cl ai mant s t er mi nat ion f or
cause pur suant t o t he Document at ion Requi r ement s set f or t h i n Sect ion II.A.4.c:
i . If a cl aimant i s an Indi vi dual seeki ng compensat ion f or an economi c loss
r el at i ng t o employment w i t hi n Zone A,
16
t he cl ai mant i s not r equi r ed t o
pr ovi de any evi dence of causat i on r el at i ng t o t hat Cl ai mi ng Job.
14
The def i ni t i on of Tour i sm i s set f or t h i n t he Tour i sm Def i ni t i on, Bat es 026632 - 026646.
15
The def i ni t i on of Char t er Fi shi ng i s set f or t h i n Def i ni t i ons Sect i on 38 of t he Deepwat er Hori zon Economi c and
Pr oper t y Damages Set t l ement Agr eement .
16
For pur poses of t hi s Fr amew or k f or Indi vi dual Economi c Loss Cl ai ms, t he pr esumpt i on shal l be t hat t he l ocat i on
of economi c l oss f or t he Cl ai mi ng Job i s t he l ocat i on of t he cl ai mant s empl oyer wi t hi n t he Cl ass Def i ni t i on
geogr aphi c ar ea, not t he cl ai mant s r esi dence. Cl ai mant s may est abl i sh an al t er nat i ve l ocat i on of economi c l oss f or
t he Cl ai mi ng Job ot her t han t hei r empl oyer s l ocat i on by pr ovi di ng evi dence t hat t hei r pr i mar y empl oyment
act i vi t i es and r esponsi bi l i t i es occur i n a l ocat i on di f f er ent f r om t hei r empl oyer s busi ness addr ess, and t hat t he
cl ai med DWH Spi l l -r el at ed economi c l oss occur r ed at such l ocat i on. For exampl e, t he cl ai mant w or ks f or a
0288
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 22 of 53
22
i i . If a cl aimant i s an i ndi vi dual seeki ng compensat i on f or an economi c loss f or a
j ob i n w hi ch he or she w as employed by, or excl usively ser vi ced, an ent it y or
Nat ur al Per son t hat sat i sf i es t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Indust r y def i ni t ion as set
f or t h i n t he Seaf ood Di st r i but i on Chai n Def i ni t i ons, t he cl aimant i s not
r equi r ed t o pr ovi de any evidence of causat i on r el at i ng t o t hat Cl ai mi ng Job.
i i i . If a cl aimant i s an i ndi vi dual seeki ng compensat i on f or an economi c loss f or a
j ob i n w hi ch he or she w as employed by an ent i t y or Nat ur al Per son t hat
sat i sf i es t he Secondar y Seaf ood Indust r y def i ni t i on as set f or t h i n t he Seaf ood
Di st r i but i on Chai n Def i ni t i ons, and t he ent i t y or Nat ur al Per son w as locat ed
i n Zones B or C, t he cl aimant i s not r equi r ed t o pr ovi de any evi dence of
causat i on r el at i ng t o t hat Cl ai mi ng Job.
i v. If t he cl aimant is an Indi vi dual seeki ng compensat i on f or an economi c loss f or
a j ob i n w hi ch he or she was empl oyed by a busi ness l ocat ed i n Zone B t hat
meet s t he def i ni t ion of Tour i sm, t he cl aimant is not r equi r ed t o pr ovi de any
evi dence of causat i on r el at i ng t o t hat Cl ai mi ng Job.
v. If t he cl aimant is an Indi vi dual seeki ng compensat i on f or an economi c loss f or
a j ob i n w hi ch he or she was empl oyed by an ent it y or Nat ur al Per son t hat
sat i sf i es t he def i nit i on of Char t er Fi shi ng, and t he Char t er Fi shi ng busi ness
w as locat ed i n Zones A, B or C, t he cl aimant i s not r equi r ed t o pr ovi de any
evi dence of causat i on r el at i ng t o t hat Cl ai mi ng Job.
OR
b. Indi vi dual Cl ai mant s Wi t hout Pr esumed Causat i on: If a cl aimant i s not ent i t l ed t o a
causat i on pr esumpt i on as set f or t h i n Sect i on II.B.2.a, t he cl aimant can est abl i sh
causat i on f or a Cl ai mi ng Job dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od only by sat i sf yi ng t he
r equi r ement s of one of t he f ol low i ng sub-sect i ons:
i . Causat i on i s est abl i shed i f t he Cl ai mi ng Job i s w i t h an El i gi bl e Empl oyer . The
Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l ver i f y t hat t he empl oyer i s an El i gi bl e Empl oyer .
i i . Causat i on f or a Cl ai mi ng Job i s est abl i shed i f t he cl aimant pr ovi des an
Empl oyer Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement at t r i but i ng t he clai mant s l oss of i ncome
dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od t o t he DWH Spi l l . The Empl oyer Sw or n
Wr i t t en St at ement must ar t i cul at e i n det ai l how t he clai mant s l osses at t he
Cl ai mi ng Job ar e causal ly r el at ed t o t he DWH Spi l l . Such Empl oyer Sw or n
Wr i t t en St at ement must also i ncl ude cont act i nf or mat i on f or an aut hor i zed
r epr esent at i ve of t he employer .
i i i . The Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l eval uat e t he cr edi bi l i t y and r el i abi l i t y of t he
i nf or mat i on pr ovi ded by t he empl oyer and t he cl ai mant , i ncl udi ng any Sw or n
Wr i t t en St at ement s, and have t he r i ght t o r equest suppl ement al
housekeepi ng company l ocat ed i n Zone C t hat ser vi ces househol ds i n Zones A, B and C, i ncl udi ng vacat i on
condomi ni ums l ocat ed i n Zone A, and t he cl ai mant est abl i shes t hat she w or ks pr i mar i l y i n Zone A.
0288 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 23 of 53
23
document at ion and/ or t o i nt er vi ew t he employer i n accor dance w i t h t he
Addendum Regar di ng Int er vi ew s of Cl ai mant Al l egi ng Economi c Loss.
C. Compensat i on Cal cul at i on
The Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l use Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on or annual employer -
pr ovi ded payr ol l i nf or mat ion submit t ed by t he cl aimant pur suant t o Sect i on II.A, and ot her
suppor t i ng document at i on pr ovi ded by t he cl aimant , t o cal cul at e t he Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs.
As set f or t h i n t he st eps below , Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs i ncl udes: (1) any r educt i on i n ear ni ngs
bet w een t he Compensat i on Per i od and t he Benchmar k Per i od f or each Cl ai mi ng Job, pl us
(2) any l ost pot ent i al ear nings gr ow t h expect ed f or each Cl ai mi ng Job i n t he absence of t he
DWH Spi l l , mi nus (3) any Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs. Lost pot ent i al ear ni ngs gr ow t h expect ed f or each
Cl ai mi ng Job shal l be det er mi ned t hr ough appl i cat i on of (a) a Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or ,
or (b) a Gener al Gr ow t h Fact or ; i n addi t i on, f or cl aims based on non-sal ar ied, hour l y-w age j obs,
an Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or i s appl i ed.
The cl aimant shal l r ecei ve a l ump-sum f i nal payment t hat i ncl udes compensat ion f or Cl ai mant
Lost Ear ni ngs, pl us any appl i cabl e RTP agr eed upon by t he par t ies, pl us compensat i on f or
pr oper l y document ed Empl oyment -Rel at ed Benef i t s Losses, Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng Cost s and
Rei mbur sabl e Sear ch Cost s, or One Ti me, Non-Recur r i ng Event Commi ssi on Compensat i on, i f
any, l ess any Spi l l -Rel at ed Payment s.
Example compensat ion calcul at i ons ar e set f or t h i n Appendi ces A t hr ough F at t ached her et o.
St ep 1: Cl ai mant Sel ect s Compensat i on Per i od and Benchmar k Per i od
1. Cl ai mant sel ect s a Compensat i on Per i od. For a cl aimant w ho (i ) w as t er mi nat ed f or
cause i n 2010 f r om t he Cl ai mi ng Job(s), or (i i ) ot her w i se ended employment at t he
Cl ai mi ng Job(s) i n 2010 f or r easons unr el at ed t o t he DWH Spi l l , t he Compensat i on
Per i od may not ext end beyond t he t er mi nat ion dat e.
2. Cl ai mant sel ect s a Base Year (s).
St ep 2: Det er mi ne Benchmar k Per i od Ear ni ngs f or t he M ont hs Cor r espondi ng t o t he
Compensat i on Per i od
Ear ni ngs dur i ng t he Benchmar k Per i od shal l be est abli shed on t he basi s of Pay Per i od
Ear ni ngs Document at i on and shal l i ncl ude ear ned i ncome f r om each Cl ai mi ng Job (or
compar abl e j ob). The speci f i c det er mi nat ion of ear ni ngs f or t he Benchmar k Per i od shal l
depend on t he nat ur e and ext ent of t he Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on pr ovi ded. For
exampl e, i f t he cl aimant submi t s Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on t hat cover s onl y
di scr et e por t ions of a gi ven cal endar year (e.g., empl oyee commi ssion st at ement s f r om M ay
2009 and December 2009), t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l base t he Benchmar k Per i od
ear ni ngs onl y on t he act ual document at i on pr ovi ded ( i.e., dat a shal l not be ext r apol at ed t o
per i ods f or w hi ch Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on w as not pr ovi ded).
If t he cl aimant submi t s Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on t hat pr ovi des dat a as t o f ul l
year ear ni ngs but not t he al l ocat i on of t hose ear ni ngs (i.e., a year -end payst ub), and i f t he
0288
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 24 of 53
24
cl ai mant al so pr ovi des addit i onal Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on deemed by t he
Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or t o be suf f i ci ent f or pur poses of al l ocat i ng t hose ear ni ngs acr oss t he
r el evant per iod, ear ni ngs shal l be al l ocat ed accor di ngl y. If no addi t ional i nf or mat i on i s
pr ovi ded r egar di ng t he al locat i on of t hose ear ni ngs, t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l assume
a pr o r at a di st r i but ion over t he r elevant per iod.
Al l bonuses and/ or commi ssi ons shal l be al l ocat ed pr o r at a acr oss t he per i od f or w hi ch t hey
w er e aw ar ded, and annual per f or mance bonuses pai d i n Januar y and Febr uar y shal l be
assumed t o r el at e t o t he pr i or calendar year , unl ess t he document s est abl i sh t hat t he bonus
r el at ed t o a speci f ic per iod of t ime.
St ep 3: Det er mi ne Ear ni ngs Gr ow t h Fact or (s)
1. Cl ai mant Speci f i c Growt h Fact or : For cl ai mant s w ho pr ovi de Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs
Document at i on suf f i ci ent t o cal cul at e a Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or , t he f oll ow i ng
Gr ow t h Fact or s may appl y:
a. Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or i s def i ned, and t he cal cul at i on i s expl ai ned, i n
Def i ni t ions Sect i on N.1).
b. Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or i s def i ned i n Def i ni t i ons Sect i on N.3.
2. Cl ai mant s f or Whom Cl ai mant Speci f i c Growt h Fact or Is Not Appl i cabl e: For cl aimant s
unabl e t o pr ovi de Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on suf f i ci ent t o cal cul at e a Cl ai mant
Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or and f or Seasonal Empl oyees, no Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h
Fact or shal l appl y. Inst ead, t he f ol l ow i ng Gr ow t h Fact or s may appl y:
a. Gener al Gr ow t h Fact or i s def i ned i n Def i ni t i ons Sect i on N.2 and i s 2.0%.
b. Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or i s def i ned i n Def i ni t i ons Sect i on N.3: For cl aims based on
non-sal ar i ed, hour l y-w age j obs, an Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or of 1.5% shal l be appl i ed.
St ep 4: Cal cul at e Expect ed Ear ni ngs
Expect ed Ear ni ngs equal t he Benchmar k Per i od ear nings cal cul at ed i n St ep 2 i ncr eased by
t he appl i cabl e Gr ow t h Fact or s (f r om St ep 3).
Expect ed Ear ni ngs = Benchmar k Per i od Earnings f rom St ep 2 x (1 + applicable St ep 3 Growt h
Fact or (s))
St ep 5: Det er mi ne Act ual Ear ni ngs and Any Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs In The Compensat i on Per i od
Act ual Ear ni ngs f or al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs and any appl i cabl e Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs dur i ng t he
Compensat i on Per i od shal l be det er mi ned based on Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on
pr ovi ded by t he cl aimant and ot her document at i on r el evant t o det er mi ni ng Of f set t i ng
Ear ni ngs. Al l bonuses and/ or commissi ons shal l be al locat ed pr o r at a acr oss t he per i od f or
w hi ch t hey wer e aw ar ded, and annual per f or mance bonuses pai d i n Januar y and Febr uar y
shal l be assumed t o r el at e t o t he pr ior cal endar year , unl ess t he document s est abl i sh t hat
t he bonus r el at ed t o a speci f i c per i od of t i me.
0288 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 25 of 53
25
Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs and Act ual Ear ni ngs f r om al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs shal l be calcul at ed gi vi ng
consi der at ion t o al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs, pr ovi ded t hat :
1. If t he cl aimant has only one Cl ai mi ng Job, t hen:
i . If Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on (or ot her document at i on r el evant t o
cal cul at i ng Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs) r ef l ect s t he same or an i ncr eased number of
hour s wor ked at t he Cl ai mi ng Job i n t he Compensat i on Per i od r el at i ve t o t he
Cl ai mi ng Job (or compar abl e j ob) i n t he Benchmar k Per i od, Act ual Ear ni ngs
shal l be l i mit ed t o ear ni ngs f r om t he Cl ai mi ng Job (or compar abl e j ob) over t he
same t ot al number of hour s wor ked i n t he Benchmar k Per i od, and no
Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs shal l appl y.
OR
i i . If Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on (or ot her document at i on) (i ) r ef l ect s a
decr ease i n hour s wor ked at t he Cl ai mi ng Job dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od,
and (i i ) t he cl ai mant s Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on r ef l ect s addi t ional
hour s wor ked at a Non-Cl ai mi ng Job (w het her such Non-Cl ai mi ng Job w as hel d
i n t he Benchmar k Per i od or i s a new posi t ion), Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs shal l be
cal cul at ed and f act or ed i nt o t he det er mi nat i on of Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs.
2. If t he cl aimant has mor e t han one Cl ai mi ng Job, t hen:
i . If Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on (or ot her document at i on r el evant t o
cal cul at i ng Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs) f or al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs r ef l ect s t he same or an
i ncr eased number of t ot al hour s wor ked acr oss al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs dur i ng t he
Compensat i on Per i od (r el at i ve t o al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs (or compar abl e j obs) i n t he
Benchmar k Per i od), aggr egat e Act ual Ear ni ngs i n t he Compensat i on Per i od
shal l be l i mit ed t o t ot al ear ni ngs f r om al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs (or compar abl e j obs)
over t he same number of t ot al hour s w or ked i n t he Benchmar k Per i od,
pr ovi ded t hat ear ni ngs f r om hour s l ost i n one Cl ai mi ng Job shal l be r epl aced by
ear ni ngs f r om t he same number of hour s w or ked i n a di f f er ent Cl ai mi ng Job
dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od. No Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs shal l appl y.
OR
i i . If Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on (or ot her document at i on r el evant t o
cal cul at i ng Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs) f or al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs r ef l ect s (i ) f ewer t ot al
hour s wor ked acr oss al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od (r el at i ve
t o al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs (or compar abl e j obs) i n t he Benchmar k Per i od), but (i i )
mor e hour s wor ked i n one (or mor e) Cl ai mi ng Job(s) in t he Compensat i on
Per i od (r el at i ve t o t he same Cl ai mi ng Job(s) i n t he Benchmar k Per i od),
aggr egat e Act ual Ear ni ngs in t he Compensat i on Per i od shal l i ncl ude t ot al
ear ni ngs f r om al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs (or compar abl e j obs) in t he Compensat i on
Per i od. If t he cl aimant s Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on al so r ef l ect s
addi t i onal hour s wor ked at a di f f er ent (Non-Cl ai mi ng Job) posi t i on (w het her
0288
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 26 of 53
26
such posi t ion was hel d i n t he Benchmar k Per i od or i s a new posi t ion), Of f set t i ng
Ear ni ngs shal l be cal cul at ed and f act or ed i nt o t he det er mi nat ion of Cl ai mant
Lost Ear ni ngs f or t he number of hour s r epr esent i ng t he di f f er ence bet w een (a)
t ot al hour s w or ked i n al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs i n t he Compensat i on Per i od, and (b)
t ot al hour s w or ked i n al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs i n t he Benchmar k Per i od.
OR
i i i . If Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on (or ot her document at i on) f or al l Cl ai mi ng
Jobs (i ) r ef l ect s a decr ease i n hour s wor ked at each Cl ai mi ng Job dur i ng t he
Compensat i on Per i od, and (i i ) t he cl aimant s Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs
Document at i on r ef lect s addi t i onal hour s wor ked at a di f f er ent posi t ion
(w het her such posi t ion w as hel d i n t he Benchmar k Per i od or i s a new posi t ion),
Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs shal l be cal cul at ed and f act or ed int o t he det er mi nat i on of
Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs f or t he t ot al lost hour s.
OR
i v. If t he cl aimant does not have Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on (or ot her
document at ion est abl i shi ng hour s wor ked) f or al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs, t hen Act ual
Ear ni ngs shal l i ncl ude al l ear ni ngs f r om al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs and Of f set t i ng
Ear ni ngs shal l appl y.
St ep 6: Det er mi ne Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs
Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs shal l be cal cul at ed as (a) t he dif f er ence bet w een (i ) t he clai mant s
Expect ed Ear ni ngs dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od (St ep 4) f r om al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs and
(i i ) t he cl ai mant s Act ual Ear ni ngs dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od, as adj ust ed, i f r el evant
(St ep 5) f r om al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs, r educed by (b) any appl i cabl e Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs.
St ep 7: Cal cul at e Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on
Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on shal l be Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs (St ep 6) adj ust ed as f ol low s:
1. Add any appl i cabl e RTP agr eed t o by t he par t i es. For an employee t er mi nat ed f or cause
f r om a Cl ai mi ng Job, no RTP shal l appl y.
- For cl aimant s w hose Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs r esul t f r om mor e t han one Cl ai mi ng
Job, t he cl ai mant s appl i cabl e RTP shal l be cal cul at ed based on (i ) t he per cent age of
t ot al Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs r el at ed t o each Cl ai mi ng Job, mul t i pl i ed by (i i ) t he RTP
appl i cabl e t o each Cl ai mi ng Job, w hi ch i s det er mi ned by t he j ob t ype
(Tour i sm/ Ot her Indust r i es) and zone (Zone A, B, C or D). For exampl e, a cl aimant
w i t h 50% of t hei r lost ear nings f r om a j ob Zone A hot el , and 50% of t hei r lost
ear ni ngs f r om a j ob i n a Zone C r est aur ant shal l r ecei ve an RTP t hat i s cal cul at ed as
f ol l ow s:
Appl i cabl e RTP = .5* RTP
Zone A Tour i sm (hot el )
+ .5* RTP
Zone C Tour i sm (r est aur ant )
2. Add any Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng Cost s. Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng Cost s shal l be f ul ly
r ei mbur sed i f t he t r ai ni ng l ed di r ect ly t o ear ned i ncome i n 2010. If no cor r espondi ng
0288 4
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 27 of 53
27
i ncome w as ear ned i n 2010, t hen Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng Cost s shal l be r eimbur sed up
t o $2,000.
For example: A cl aimant who pai d $3,000 af t er Apr i l 20, 2010 t o secur e a
commer ci al t r ucki ng l i cense and w ho ear ned i ncome as a commer ci al t r ucker i n
2010 shal l r ecei ve $3,000 i n r ei mbur sement . If t he clai mant ear ned no i ncome f r om
commer ci al t r ucki ng dur i ng 2010, t he cl aimant w oul d r eceive a $2,000
r ei mbur sement .
3. Add any Rei mbur sabl e Sear ch Cost s.
4. Add any appl i cabl e Empl oyment -Rel at ed Benef i t s Losses.
5. Add any One Ti me, Non-Recur r i ng Event Compensat i on.
6. Subt r act any Spi l l -Rel at ed Payment s.
7. The f or mul a f or Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on i s:
Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs
+ (Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs x any appl i cabl e RTP)
+ Empl oyment -Rel at ed Benef i t s Losses (i f appl i cabl e)
+ Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng Cost s (f ul l i f led t o ear ned i ncome i n 2010 f r om
ar ea of t r ai ni ng, ot her w i se $2,000) (i f appl i cabl e)
+ Rei mbur sabl e Sear ch Cost s (i f appl i cabl e)
+ One Ti me, Non-Recur r i ng Event Compensat i on (i f appl i cabl e)
- Spi l l -Rel at ed Payment s (i f appl i cabl e)
- VoO Set t l ement Of f set and/ or VoO Ear ned Income Of f set (i f any)
0288
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 28 of 53
28
III. CATEGORY III: CLAIM ANTS WITH EARNINGS DOCUM ENTATION FOR 2010 BUT WITHOUT
COM PARABLE BENCHM ARK PERIOD EARNINGS
For Indi vi dual Cl ai mant s Wi t hout Compar abl e Benchmar k Ear ni ngs w ho meet t he def i ni t i on of a
New Ent r ant To Empl oyment , a Cl ai mant Who Had Less Than Tw el ve M ont hs Of Ear ni ngs Hi st or y
But Was Empl oyed On Apr i l 20, 2010 or a Car eer Changer , 2011 Benchmar k Per i od ear ni ngs shal l
be used t o est abl i sh Expect ed Ear ni ngs, pr ovi ded t hat i f no such ear ni ngs exist , t he cl aimant s
Expect ed Ear ni ngs w i l l be based on t he appl i cabl e al t er nat i ve i dent i f ied i n t hi s Cat egor y III, St ep 2.
If avai l abl e, t he Cat egor y III cl ai mant must pr ovi de f eder al or st at e Tax Ret ur ns or For ms W-2 f or
2010 and 2011 (and f or 2009 i f t he cl ai mant i s a Car eer Changer w ho di d not wor k i n t he r el evant
2011 t i me per iod).
17
If Tax Ret ur ns or For ms W-2 and/ or 1099 ar e not avai l able, t he cl aimant must
pr ovi de a w r it t en st at ement under oat h at t est i ng t hat no Tax Ret ur ns ar e avai l able and at t est i ng
t hat t he cl aimant made di l igent ef f or t s t o obt ai n For ms W-2 f r om hi s or her employer .
Cat egor y III cl aimant s w ho do not have Tax Inf or mat i on Document s avai l abl e may i nst ead pr ovi de
Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on suf f i ci ent t o est abl i sh ear ni ngs dur i ng t he Compensat i on
Per i od and 2011 (and f or 2009 i f t he cl aimant is a Car eer Changer w ho di d not wor k i n t he r el evant
2011 t i me per iod). If no Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on or ot her annual empl oyer -pr ovi ded
payr ol l document at i on i s avai l abl e f or 2010 and 2011 (and f or 2009 i f t he cl aimant i s a Car eer
Changer w ho di d not w or k i n t he r elevant 2011 t ime per i od), cl ai mant shal l so st at e i n t he swor n
Cl ai m For m.
In t he event a cl aimant cannot pr ovi de Tax Inf or mat i on Document s or Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs
Document at i on or , f or cl aimant s w ho w er e not employed i n 2011, ot her document at ion r equi r ed i n
III.B.1.b or III.B.2.b, clai mant may not pr oceed under t hi s Cat egor y III and shoul d pr oceed t o
Cat egor y IV t o t he ext ent t he cl aimant qual i f i es f or compensat ion under t hat Cat egor y.
A. Document at i on Requi r ement s
1. Document at i on Est abl i shi ng Empl oyment Ear ni ngs: Cl ai mant s under t hi s Cat egor y w ho
have Tax Inf or mat i on Document s f or 2010 and 2011 must pr ovi de at l east one of t he
f ol l ow i ng Tax Inf or mat i on Document s f or 2010 and 2011 and, i f a Car eer Changer , f or 2009:
x Feder al t ax For m 1040 pages 1 and 2, al l pages of Schedul es C, E, and F, and any
suppor t i ng st at ement s at t ached t o t he For m 1040 f i l i ng (i ncl udi ng For m W-2s f or
j oi nt r et ur ns); or
x St at e t ax r et ur n, i ncl udi ng any suppor t i ng schedul es or st at ement s; or
x For ms W-2 document i ng ear ni ngs; or
x For ms 1099 document i ng ear ni ngs.
17
If a cl ai mant has not mai nt ained copi es of hi s or her f eder al i ncome t ax r et ur ns, he or she shal l r equest a copy or
t r anscr i pt di r ect l y f r om t he IRS. If a cl ai mant has not mai nt ai ned copi es of hi s or her For ms W-2, he or she shal l
r equest copi es di r ect l y f r om t he IRS f or each empl oyer t hey w or ked f or dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od and 2011
(and, i f t he cl ai mant i s a Car eer Changer , f or 2009). A f eder al Tax Inf or mat i on Document shal l be consi der ed
avai l abl e i f i t exi st s and i s i n t he cl ai mant s possessi on or has not been r equest ed f r om t he IRS and/ or empl oyer .
0288
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 29 of 53
29
2. Document at i on Est abl i shi ng Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs: To t he ext ent i t i s avai l abl e, or i f Tax
Inf or mat i on Document s f or 2010 and 2011 ar e not avai l abl e, a cl aimant must pr ovi de Pay
Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on f or 2010 and t he 2011 Benchmar k Per i od. A cl ai mant al so
must pr ovi de document at ion t o est abl i sh any bonuses and/ or commi ssions r eceived dur i ng
t he 2011 Benchmar k Per i od and t he Compensat i on Per i od, as w el l as bonuses and/ or
commissi ons r ecei ved dur i ng Januar y or Febr uar y of t he 2010 and 2011 f or al l j obs w or ked.
A Car eer Changer must al so pr ovi de such i nf or mat i on f or 2009. To t he ext ent Pay Per i od
Ear ni ngs Document at i on i s unavai l abl e, t he cl aimant shal l so i ndi cat e i n t he sw or n Cl ai m
For m, and ear ni ngs shal l be t r eat ed as ear ned evenl y t hr oughout each year .
3. Document at i on Of Ear ni ngs Fr om Ot her Sour ces Dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od:
Cl ai mant s must al so submi t document s suf f i ci ent t o est abl i sh t he sour ce(s) and amount s of
ear ni ngs, i f any, f r om ot her post -DWH Spi l l sour ces of i ncome (and, i f a Car eer Changer , f or
2009) i ncl udi ng: (1) Spi l l -Rel at ed Payment s, and (2) compensat ion r ecei ved f r om and hour s
w or ked i n each empl oyment posi t ion ot her t han t he Cl ai mi ng Job(s). The t ypes of
document s suf f i cient t o sat i sf y t hi s r equi r ement ar e as f ol low s:
x For ms W-2, paycheck st ubs or ot her empl oyer -pr ovi ded payr ol l i nf or mat ion; and/ or
x Bank r ecor ds show i ng i ncome deposit s and suppor t i ng document at ion i ndi cat i ng
t he sour ce of t hose deposi t s; and/ or
x Document s f r om BP/ GCCF show i ng payment and BP/ GCCF Cl ai m Number ; and/ or
x For ms 1099; and/ or
x Recei pt s f r om check cashi ng ser vi ces; and/ or
x Ot her document s pr ovi ded by an employer set t i ng f or t h f or such ot her employment
posi t ion(s) (i) r equi r ed hour s of wor k, (i i ) act ual hour s w or ked by cl aimant , and
(i i i ) compensat i on r at e.
4. Document at i on Est abl i shi ng Ot her Cost s/ Losses: The cl aimant may al so submi t
Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng Cost Document at i on, Rei mbur sabl e Sear ch Cost Document at i on,
and/ or document at i on r egar di ng Empl oyment -Rel at ed Benef i t s Losses.
5. Addi t i onal Cl ai mant Document at i on:
a. Cl ai mant Empl oyabi l i t y Document at i on: Consi st s of bot h:
i . A copy of a Soci al Secur i t y car d, gover nment -i ssued i dent i f i cat i on (f or exampl e,
a val i d dr iver s l icense), t empor ar y w or ker vi sa, or gr een car d t hat w as val i d as
of Apr i l 20, 2010 f or t he cl ai mant , or a pr i nt out f r om a publ i c dat abase
pr ovi di ng t he same i nf or mat i on as woul d be pr ovi ded by t he or i gi nal document ;
AND
i i . Evi dence t he cl aimant w as at l east 16 year s of age as of Apr i l 20, 2010.
Accept abl e evi dence i ncl udes a copy of a val i d dr i ver s l i cense, a val i d passpor t ,
a cer t i f ied copy of t he cl aimant s bi r t h cer t i f i cat e, or a pr i nt out f r om a publ i c
0288
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 30 of 53
30
dat abase pr ovi di ng t he same i nf or mat ion as w oul d be pr ovi ded by t he or i gi nal
document .
b. Li censi ng Document at i on: If cl ai mant s employment r equi r es a gover nment -i ssued
l i cense/ per mi t , a copy of val i d 2010 and 2011 l i censes, i f appr opr i at e, or a pr i nt out
f r om a publ i c dat abase pr ovi di ng t he same i nf or mat ion as woul d be pr ovi ded by t he
or i gi nal document . Licenses coul d i ncl ude, but ar e not l i mi t ed t o:
i . Taxi / l iver y l i censes.
i i . Real Est at e Sal es l icenses.
i i i . Ot her l i censes and per mi t s r el at ed t o i ncome sour ces.
c. If t he cl aimant s empl oyment i n t he Cl ai mi ng Job w as t er mi nat ed bet ween Apr i l 20,
2010 and December 31, 2010, t he clai mant shal l have t he bur den of pr oof t o est abl i sh
t he t er mi nat ion w as not f or cause. The t er mi nat ion shal l be deemed not f or cause i f :
i . The cl aimant est abl i shes t hat he or she f i l ed f or and r ecei ved unempl oyment ,
i ncl udi ng, f or exampl e, as evi denced by For m 1099 G.
OR
i i . Cl ai mant pr ovi des a let t er f r om t he f or mer empl oyer or an Empl oyer Sw or n
Wr i t t en St at ement conf i r mi ng t er mi nat ion w as not f or cause. Any such l et t er
must i ncl ude cont act i nf or mat ion f or an aut hor i zed r epr esent at i ve of t he
employer .
OR
i i i . Ot her document at ion accept abl e t o t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or t hat est abl i shes
t hat t he cl aimant w as not t er mi nat ed f or cause.
6. Addi t i onal Document at i on t o Est abl i sh Causat i on Pr esumpt i ons:
If t he cl aimant is (i ) a Car eer Changer or a Cl ai mant Who Had Less Than Tw el ve M ont hs of
Ear ni ngs Hi st or y But Was Empl oyed On Apr i l 20, 2010 w ho seeks t o qual i f y f or a causat i on
pr esumpt ion as set f or t h i n Sect i ons III.B.1.a, III.B.1.b and III.B.1.c.i , or (i i i ) a New Ent r ant t o
Empl oyment w ho seeks t o qual i f y f or a causat i on pr esumpt i on as set f or t h i n Sect i ons
III.B.2.a, III.B.2.b and III.B.2.c.i , t he clai mant must pr ovide document at i on 2010 and 2011
(and, i f t he cl ai mant i s a Car eer Changer , f or 2009) t o est abl i sh t hat t he cl aimant or t he
cl ai mant s empl oyer sat i sf ies (or sat i sf i ed) t he geogr aphi c r equi r ement s and/ or t he
def i ni t i on of an ent i t y or Nat ur al Per son i ncl uded i n t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Indust r y,
Secondar y Seaf ood Indust r y, Tour i sm,
18
or Char t er Fi shi ng
19
as appl i cabl e. To sat i sf y t hi s
r equi r ement , t he cl aimant must demonst r at e t he empl oyer s locat ion and t he f ol l ow i ng:
18
The def i ni t i on of Tour i sm i s set f or t h i n t he Tour i sm Def i ni t i on, Bat es 026632 - 026646.
19
The def i ni t i on of Char t er Fi shi ng i s set f or t h i n Def i ni t i ons Sect i on 38 of t he Deepwat er Hori zon Economi c and
Pr oper t y Damages Set t l ement Agr eement .
0288 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 31 of 53
31
a. That t he cl aimant w or ks or w or ked f or an employer t hat f i l ed a cl ai m i n t he M DL
No. 2179 set t lement pr ocess and w as det er mi ned by t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or t o
sat i sf y one of t he above-l i st ed def i ni t ions;
OR
b. That t he cl aimant s Tax Inf or mat i on Document s, Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs
Document at i on, or ot her document at ion est abl i shes t hat t he cl ai mant s employer
sat i sf i es one of t he above-l ist ed def i ni t ions.
7. The Causat ion Requi r ement s set f or t h i n Sect i on III.B bel ow may r equi r e addi t ional
document at ion.
B. Causat i on Requi r ement s
1. Causat i on f or a Car eer Changer and a Cl ai mant Who Had Less Than Tw el ve M ont hs of
Ear ni ngs Hi st or y But Was Empl oyed On Apr i l 20, 2010: In or der f or a Car eer Changer or a
Cl ai mant Who Had Less Than Tw el ve M ont hs of Ear ni ngs Hi st or y But Was Empl oyed On
Apr i l 20, 2010 t o est abl i sh causat i on under t hi s Cat egor y III, t he cl ai mant must sat i sf y t he
f ol l ow i ng:
a. The cl aimant must have been empl oyed i n t he Cl ai mi ng Job on Apr i l 20, 2010.
AND
b. Dur i ng t he 2011 Benchmar k Per i od (even i f 2011 i s not used t o cal cul at e Expect ed
Ear ni ngs), t he cl aimant w as ei t her (i ) employed, (i i ) t empor ar i ly medi cal ly
i ncapaci t at ed such t hat t he cl ai mant w as unabl e t o w or k but expect ed t o r et ur n t o
t he wor kf or ce shor t l y t her eaf t er , (i i i ) engaged i n act ivi t i es or i n a condi t ion ent it l ing
an employee t o l eave under Sect ion 102 of The Fami ly M edi cal Leave Act , of 1993,
as amended, 29 U.S.C. 2601, 2612, but di d not r ecei ve compensat ion,
20
(i v)
i nvol unt ar i ly unempl oyed and can appr opr i at ely document j ob sear ch act i vi t i es,
pr ovi ded t hat t he cl aimant can demonst r at e t hat any i nvol unt ar y unempl oyment
was not a f unct i on of t he clai mant s t er mi nat ion f or cause, (v) a f ul l t i me st udent ,
(vi ) medi cal l y i ncapacit at ed such t hat t he cl aimant w as unabl e t o wor k and w as
expect ed t o be unabl e t o r et ur n t o t he wor kf or ce, or (vi i ) was engaged i n f ul l -t i me
vol unt eer or mi ssionar y wor k or had chosen t o l eave t he wor kf or ce t o ser ve as a
f ul l -t i me par ent or l egal guar di an. Document at ion sat i sf yi ng t hi s r equi r ement
i ncl udes one of t he f ol low i ng:
i . For a cl aimant empl oyed dur i ng 2011, Tax Inf or mat i on Document s, Pay
Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on, or ot her annual empl oyer -pr ovi ded payr ol l
20
If t he cl ai mant i s (i ) a Car eer Changer or a Cl ai mant Who Had Less Than Tw el ve M ont hs Of Ear ni ngs Hi st or y But
Was Empl oyed On Apr i l 20, 2010, and (i i ) w as on t empor ar y medi cal l eave f r om hi s or her empl oyer pur suant t o
t he Fami l y M edi cal Leave Act , and (i i i ) r ecei ved compensat i on dur i ng t he t i me per i od of 2011 Benchmar k Per i od,
t he cl ai mant shal l be consi der ed t o have been empl oyed dur i ng t he t i me he or she w as r ecei vi ng compensat i on.
0288
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 32 of 53
32
i nf or mat i on or ot her document ar y evi dence accept abl e t o t he Cl ai ms
Admi ni st r at or .
i i . For a t empor ar i ly medi cal ly-i ncapaci t at ed Indi vi dual , document at ion
est abl i shi ng t hat cl ai mant exper i enced t he t empor ar y di sabi l i t y, such as
hospi t al or medi cal r ecor ds or r ecor ds r ef lect i ng r eceipt of shor t -t er m
di sabi l i t y or simi l ar benef it s.
i i i . For an Indi vi dual engaged in act i vi t i es or a condi t i on ent i t l i ng an empl oyee t o
l eave under Sect i on 102 of The Fami l y M edi cal Leave Act , of 1993, as
amended, 29 U.S.C. 2601, 2612, w ho di d not r ecei ve compensat ion dur i ng
t he 2011 Benchmar k Per i od, document at ion est abl i shi ng t he act i vi t i es or
condi t i on, t he dur at i on of such act i vi t i es or condi t ion, any compensat ion
r eceived dur i ng such per iods, and/ or communi cat ions w i t h t he employer
r egar di ng t he same.
i v. For an i nvol unt ar i ly unempl oyed Indi vi dual , cont empor aneous
document at ion evi denci ng a j ob sear ch and di l i gent ef f or t s t o secur e
employment , as w el l as t he document at i on set f or t h in Sect ion III.A.5
demonst r at i ng t hat t he i nvol unt ar y unemployment was not a f unct i on of t he
cl ai mant s t er mi nat ion f or cause.
v. For a f ul l -t ime st udent , document at ion r ef l ect i ng f ul l -t i me mat r i cul at ion or
enr ol lment at a col lege or uni ver si t y, such as a mat r icul at i on cer t i f i cat e,
t ui t i on bi l l and evi dence of payment , a t r anscr i pt , a degr ee, cer t i f i cat e, or
di pl oma i ndi cat i ng compl et i on of a cour se of st udy, or a l et t er f r om t he
col l ege or uni ver sit y r egi st r ar ver i f yi ng t he mat r i cul at ion.
vi . For a medi cal ly-i ncapaci t at ed Indi vi dual not expect ed t o r et ur n t o t he
w or kf or ce, document at ion est abl i shi ng t he cl ai mant exper i enced such
di sabi l i t y, such as hospit al or medi cal r ecor ds or r ecor ds r ef l ect i ng r ecei pt of
Soci al Secur i t y or ot her di sabi l i t y benef it s.
vi i . For an Indi vi dual w ho w as engaged i n f ul l -t i me vol unt eer or mi ssionar y wor k
or w ho had chosen t o l eave t he wor kf or ce t o ser ve as a f ul l -t i me par ent or
l egal guar di an, document at i on evi denci ng t he r eason t hat t he Indi vi dual w as
not engaged i n wor k f or monet ar y compensat ion.
AND
c. The cl aimant must sat i sf y one of t he f ol low i ng:
i . Pr esumed Causat i on: The DWH Spi l l shal l be pr esumed t o be t he cause of
l ost ear ni ngs f or a Cl ai mi ng Job dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od f or t he
f ol l ow i ng cat egor ies of cl aimant s w ho submi t t he r equi r ed document at i on,
pr ovi ded t hat t he cl aimant can demonst r at e t hat any l oss of i ncome or
employment r el at ed t o t he Cl ai mi ng Job was not a f unct i on of t he cl aimant s
t er mi nat i on f or cause pur suant t o t he Document at ion Requi r ement s set f or t h
i n Sect i on III.A.5.c:
0288 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 33 of 53
33
1) If a cl aimant i s an Indi vi dual seeki ng compensat ion f or an economi c
l oss r el at i ng t o employment w i t hi n Zone A,
21
t he cl aimant i s not
r equi r ed t o pr ovi de any evidence of causat i on r el at i ng t o t hat
Cl ai mi ng Job.
2) If a cl aimant i s an i ndi vi dual seeki ng compensat i on f or an economi c
l oss f or a j ob i n w hi ch he or she w as employed by, or excl usi vely
ser vi ced, an ent i t y or Nat ur al Per son t hat sat i sf i es t he Pr i mar y
Seaf ood Indust r y def i ni t ion as set f or t h i n t he Seaf ood Di st r i but i on
Chai n Def i ni t i ons, t he cl aimant i s not r equi r ed t o pr ovi de any
evi dence of causat i on r el at i ng t o t hat Cl ai mi ng Job.
3) If a cl aimant i s an i ndi vi dual seeki ng compensat i on f or an economi c
l oss f or a j ob i n w hi ch he or she w as employed by an ent i t y or
Nat ur al Per son t hat sat i sf i es t he Secondar y Seaf ood Indust r y
def i ni t i on as set f or t h i n t he Seaf ood Di st r i but i on Chai n Def i ni t i ons,
and t he ent it y or Nat ur al Per son w as locat ed i n Zones B or C, t he
cl ai mant i s not r equi r ed t o pr ovi de any evi dence of causat i on
r el at i ng t o t hat Cl ai mi ng Job.
4) If t he cl aimant is an Indi vi dual seeki ng compensat i on f or an
economi c loss f or a j ob i n w hi ch he or she w as empl oyed by a
busi ness l ocat ed i n Zone B t hat meet s t he def i ni t ion of Tour i sm, t he
cl ai mant i s not r equi r ed t o pr ovi de any evi dence of causat i on
r el at i ng t o t hat Cl ai mi ng Job.
5) If t he cl aimant is an Indi vi dual seeki ng compensat i on f or an
economi c loss f or a j ob i n w hi ch he or she w as empl oyed by an
ent i t y or Nat ur al Per son t hat sat i sf ies t he def i ni t ion of Char t er
Fi shi ng, and t he Char t er Fi shi ng busi ness w as locat ed i n Zones A, B
or C, t he cl ai mant i s not r equi r ed t o pr ovi de any evi dence of
causat i on r el at i ng t o t hat Cl ai mi ng Job.
OR
i i . Indi vi dual Cl ai mant Wi t hout Pr esumed Causat i on: If a cl ai mant i s not
ent i t l ed t o a causat i on pr esumpt i on as set f or t h i n Sect i on III.B.1.c.i , t he
cl ai mant can est abl i sh causat i on f or a Cl ai mi ng Job dur i ng t he Compensat i on
21
For pur poses of t hi s Fr amew or k f or Indi vi dual Economi c Loss Cl ai ms, t he pr esumpt i on shal l be t hat t he l ocat i on
of economi c l oss f or t he Cl ai mi ng Job i s t he l ocat i on of t he cl ai mant s empl oyer wi t hi n t he Cl ass Def i ni t i on
geogr aphi c ar ea, not t he cl ai mant s r esi dence. Cl ai mant s may est abl i sh an al t er nat i ve l ocat i on of economi c l oss f or
t he Cl ai mi ng Job ot her t han t hei r empl oyer s l ocat i on by pr ovi di ng evi dence t hat t hei r pr i mar y empl oyment
act i vi t i es and r esponsi bi l i t i es occur i n a l ocat i on di f f er ent f r om t hei r empl oyer s busi ness addr ess, and t hat t he
cl ai med DWH Spi l l -r el at ed economi c l oss occur r ed at such l ocat i on. For exampl e, t he cl ai mant w or ks f or a
housekeepi ng company l ocat ed i n Zone C t hat ser vi ces househol ds i n Zones A, B and C, i ncl udi ng vacat i on
condomi ni ums l ocat ed i n Zone A, and t he cl ai mant est abl i shes t hat she w or ks pr i mar i l y i n Zone A.
0288
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 34 of 53
34
Per i od only by sat i sf yi ng t he r equi r ement s of one of t he f ol low i ng sub-
sect ions:
1) Causat i on i s est abl i shed i f t he Cl ai mi ng Job i s w i t h an El i gi bl e
Empl oyer . The Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l ver i f y t hat t he empl oyer
i s an El i gi bl e Empl oyer .
2) Causat i on f or a Cl ai mi ng Job i s est abl i shed i f t he cl aimant pr ovi des
an Empl oyer Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement at t r i but i ng t he cl aimant s
l oss of i ncome dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od t o t he DWH Spi l l .
The Empl oyer Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement must ar t i culat e i n det ai l
how t he cl aimant s l osses at t he Cl ai mi ng Job ar e causal l y r el at ed t o
t he DWH Spi l l . Such Empl oyer Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement must al so
i ncl ude cont act i nf or mat ion f or an aut hor i zed r epr esent at i ve of t he
employer .
i i i . The Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l eval uat e t he cr edi bi l i t y and r el i abi l i t y of t he
i nf or mat i on pr ovi ded by t he empl oyer and t he cl ai mant , i ncl udi ng any Sw or n
Wr i t t en St at ement s, and have t he r i ght t o r equest suppl ement al
document at ion and/ or t o i nt er vi ew t he employer i n accor dance w i t h t he
Addendum Regar di ng Int er vi ew s of Cl ai mant Al l egi ng Economi c Loss.
2. Causat i on f or a New Ent r ant t o Empl oyment : In or der f or a New Ent r ant t o Empl oyment
t o est abl i sh causat i on under t hi s Cat egor y III, t he cl aimant must sat i sf y t he f ol l ow i ng:
a. The cl aimant must sat i sf y t he def i ni t i on of a New Ent r ant t o Empl oyment and shal l
pr ovi de document at i on show i ng r esi dency, or t hat t he cl aimant t ook si gni f i cant
af f i r mat ive st eps t o est abl i sh r esi dency, w it hi n cl ose enough pr oximi t y t o t he
ant i ci pat ed l ocat i on of empl oyment t o t r avel t o t he j ob as f r equent l y as r equi r ed by
t he empl oyer , f or a per iod of at l east 60 days af t er Apr i l 20, 2010 but bef or e
December 31, 2010 (or bef or e Apr i l 30, 2011 f or cl ai mant s w hose empl oyer or
expect ed employer sat i sf ied t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Indust r y def i ni t ion).
Document at ion meet i ng t hi s r equi r ement i ncl udes:
i . A l ease or r ent al agr eement ; or
i i . A subl ease agr eement ; or
i i i . Cont empor aneous ut i l i t y bil l s.
AND
b. Dur i ng t he 2011 Benchmar k Per i od, t he cl aimant w as ei t her (i) empl oyed, (i i )
t empor ar i ly medi cal ly i ncapaci t at ed such t hat t he cl aimant w as unabl e t o wor k but
expect ed t o r et ur n t o t he w or kf or ce shor t ly t her eaf t er , (i i i ) engaged i n act i vi t ies or
i n a condi t ion ent it l i ng an empl oyee t o l eave under Sect i on 102 of The Fami l y
M edi cal Leave Act , of 1993, as amended, 29 U.S.C. 2601, 2612, but di d not
0288 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 35 of 53
35
r eceive compensat i on,
22
(i v) i nvol unt ar i ly unempl oyed and can appr opr i at ely
document j ob sear ch act i vit i es, pr ovi ded t hat t he cl aimant can demonst r at e t hat
any i nvol unt ar y unemployment was not a f unct ion of t he cl aimant s t er mi nat i on f o r
cause, (v) a f ul l t i me st udent , (vi ) medi cal l y i ncapaci t at ed such t hat t he cl aimant w as
unabl e t o wor k and w as expect ed t o be unabl e t o r et ur n t o t he wor kf or ce, or (vii )
w as engaged i n f ul l -t i me vol unt eer or mi ssionar y w or k or had chosen t o l eave t he
w or kf or ce t o ser ve as a f ul l -t i me par ent or legal guar di an. Document at ion sat i sf ying
t hi s r equi r ement i ncl udes one of t he f ol low i ng:
i . For a cl aimant empl oyed dur i ng 2011, Tax Inf or mat i on Document s, Pay
Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on, or ot her annual empl oyer -pr ovi ded payr ol l
i nf or mat i on or ot her document ar y evi dence accept abl e t o t he Cl ai ms
Admi ni st r at or .
i i . For a t empor ar i ly medi cal ly-i ncapaci t at ed Indi vi dual , document at ion
est abl i shi ng t hat cl ai mant exper i enced t he t empor ar y di sabi l i t y, such as
hospi t al or medi cal r ecor ds or r ecor ds r ef lect i ng r eceipt of shor t -t er m
di sabi l i t y or simi l ar benef it s.
i i i . For an Indi vi dual engaged in act i vi t i es or a condi t i on ent i t l i ng an empl oyee t o
l eave under Sect i on 102 of The Fami l y M edi cal Leave Act , of 1993, as
amended, 29 U.S.C. 2601, 2612, w ho di d not r ecei ve compensat ion dur i ng
t he 2011 Benchmar k Per i od, document at ion est abl i shi ng t he act i vi t i es or
condi t i on, t he dur at i on of such act i vi t i es or condi t ion, any compensat ion
r eceived dur i ng such per iods, and/ or communi cat ions w i t h t he employer
r egar di ng t he same.
i v. For an i nvol unt ar i ly unempl oyed Indi vi dual , cont empor aneous
document at ion evi denci ng a j ob sear ch and di l i gent ef f or t s t o secur e
employment , as w el l as t he document at i on set f or t h in Sect ion III.A.5
demonst r at i ng t hat t he i nvol unt ar y unemployment was not a f unct i on of t he
cl ai mant s t er mi nat ion f or cause.
v. For a f ul l -t ime st udent , document at ion r ef l ect i ng f ul l -t i me mat r i cul at ion or
enr ol lment at a col lege or uni ver si t y, such as a mat r icul at i on cer t i f i cat e,
t ui t i on bi l l and evi dence of payment , a t r anscr i pt , a degr ee, cer t i f i cat e, or
di pl oma i ndi cat i ng compl et i on of a cour se of st udy, or a l et t er f r om t he
col l ege or uni ver sit y r egi st r ar ver i f yi ng t he mat r i cul at ion.
vi . For a medi cal ly-i ncapaci t at ed Indi vi dual not expect ed t o r et ur n t o t he
w or kf or ce, document at ion est abl i shi ng t he cl ai mant exper i enced such
di sabi l i t y, such as hospit al or medi cal r ecor ds or r ecor ds r ef l ect i ng r ecei pt of
Soci al Secur i t y or ot her di sabi l i t y benef it s.
22
If t he cl ai mant i s (i ) a Car eer Changer or a Cl ai mant Who Had Less Than Tw el ve M ont hs Of Ear ni ngs Hi st or y But
Was Empl oyed On Apr i l 20, 2010, and (i i ) w as on t empor ar y medi cal l eave f r om hi s or her empl oyer pur suant t o
t he Fami l y M edi cal Leave Act , and (i i i ) r ecei ved compensat i on dur i ng t he t i me per i od of 2011 Benchmar k Per i od,
t he cl ai mant shal l be consi der ed t o have been empl oyed dur i ng t he t i me he or she w as r ecei vi ng compensat i on.
0288
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 36 of 53
36
vi i . For an Indi vi dual w ho w as engaged i n f ul l -t i me vol unt eer or mi ssionar y wor k
or w ho had chosen t o l eave t he wor kf or ce t o ser ve as a f ul l -t i me par ent or
l egal guar di an, cont empor aneous document at ion evidenci ng t he r eason t hat
t he Indi vi dual w as not engaged i n wor k f or monet ar y compensat ion.
AND
c. The cl aimant must sat i sf y one of t he f ol low i ng:
i . Pr esumed Causat i on: The DWH Spi l l shal l be pr esumed t o be t he cause of
l ost ear ni ngs f or a Cl ai mi ng Job dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od f or New
Ent r ant s t o Empl oyment who pr ovi de document at i on show i ng pr oof of an
of f er of empl oyment made and accept ed pr i or t o Apr i l 20, 2010 f or
employment t o begi n bet ween Apr i l 21 and December 31, 2010 (or f or
employment t o begi n bet ween Apr i l 21, 2010 and Apr il 30, 2011 f or cl aimant s
i n t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Indust r y), pr ovi ded t hat t he f ol l ow i ng condi t i ons ar e
al so met :
1) The of f er document at ion evi dences expect ed empl oyment :
a) Wi t hi n Zone A;
23
or ,
b) In w hi ch t he of f er i ng empl oyer w as an ent i t y or Nat ur al
Per son t hat sat i sf ies t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Indust r y
def i ni t i on as set f or t h i n t he Seaf ood Di st r i but i on Chai n
Def i ni t i ons; or ,
c) In w hi ch t he of f er i ng empl oyer w as an ent i t y or Nat ur al
Per son t hat sat i sf ies t he Secondar y Seaf ood Indust r y
def i ni t i on as set f or t h i n t he Seaf ood Di st r i but i on Chai n
Def i ni t i ons, and t he ent i t y or Nat ur al Per son w as locat ed
i n Zones B or C; or
d) In w hi ch t he of f er i ng empl oyer w as a busi ness l ocat ed i n
Zone B t hat meet s t he def ini t i on of Tour i sm; or
e) In w hi ch t he of f er i ng empl oyer w as a busi ness l ocat ed i n
Zones A, B or C t hat sat i sf i es t he def i nit i on of Char t er
Fi shi ng.
23
For pur poses of t hi s Fr amew or k f or Indi vi dual Economi c Loss Cl ai ms, t he pr esumpt i on shal l be t hat t he l ocat i on
of economi c l oss f or t he Cl ai mi ng Job i s t he l ocat i on of t he cl ai mant s empl oyer w i t hi n t he Cl ass Def i ni t i on
geogr aphi c ar ea, not t he cl ai mant s r esi dence. Cl ai mant s may est abl i sh an al t er nat i ve l ocat i on of economi c l oss f or
t he Cl ai mi ng Job ot her t han t hei r empl oyer s l ocat i on by pr ovi di ng evi dence t hat t hei r pr i mar y empl oymen t
act i vi t i es and r esponsi bi l i t i es occur i n a l ocat i on di f f er ent f r om t hei r empl oyer s busi ness addr ess, and t hat t he
cl ai med DWH Spi l l -r el at ed economi c l oss occur r ed at such l ocat i on. For exampl e, t he cl ai mant w or ks f or a
housekeepi ng company l ocat ed i n Zone C t hat ser vi ces househol ds i n Zones A, B and C, i ncl udi ng vacat i on
condomi ni ums l ocat ed i n Zone A, and t he cl ai mant est abl i shes t hat she w or ks pr i mar i l y i n Zone A.
0288 4
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 37 of 53
37
2) The document at ion pr ovi ded must i ncl ude i nf or mat i on suf f i ci ent t o
est abl i sh pr oposed st ar t and end dat es, w age r at e and pr oj ect ed
hour s, and w it hdr aw al of t he of f er dur i ng t he per i od Apr i l 21
t hr ough December 31, 2010.
OR
i i . Indi vi dual Cl ai mant Wi t hout Pr esumed Causat i on: If t he New Ent r ant t o
Empl oyment i s not ent i t l ed t o a causat i on pr esumpt ion as set f or t h i n Sect i on
III.B.2.c.i , t he cl aimant can est abl i sh causat i on f or a Cl ai mi ng Job dur i ng t he
Compensat i on Per i od onl y by pr ovi di ng an Empl oyer Sw or n Wr i t t en
St at ement at t r i but i ng t he cl ai mant s l oss of i ncome dur i ng t he Compensat i on
Per i od t o t he DWH Spi l l . The st at ement must ar t i cul at e i n det ai l how t he
cl ai mant s l osses ar e causall y r el at ed t o t he DWH Spi l l , and must speci f i cal ly
(i ) at t est t o t he cl ai mant s accept ed empl oyment of f er (i ncl udi ng st ar t and end
dat es, w age r at e and pr oj ect ed hour s), and (i i) ver i f y t hat t he empl oyer s
deci si on not t o empl oy t he cl ai mant , or t o empl oy t he cl ai mant i n a r educed
capaci t y, w as due t o or r esul t i ng f r om t he DWH Spi l l . Such l et t er must al so
i ncl ude cont act i nf or mat ion f or an aut hor i zed r epr esent at i ve of t he empl oyer .
i i i . The Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l eval uat e t he cr edi bi l i t y and r el i abi l i t y of t he
i nf or mat i on pr ovi ded by t he empl oyer and t he cl ai mant , i ncl udi ng any Sw or n
Wr i t t en St at ement (s), and have t he r i ght t o r equest suppl ement al
document at ion and/ or i nt er vi ew t he empl oyer i n accor dance w i t h t he
Addendum Regar di ng Int er vi ew s of Cl ai mant Al l egi ng Economi c Loss.
C. Compensat i on Cal cul at i on
For cl aimant s w ho wer e empl oyed i n 2011 i n t he same j ob or simi l ar j ob as t hat per f or med or
of f er ed and w i t hdr aw n i n t he Compensat i on Per i od sel ect ed by t he cl aimant , t he Cl ai ms
Admi ni st r at or shal l use ei t her Tax Inf or mat i on Document s and/ or Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs
Document at i on, t o cal cul at e t he Cl ai mant s Lost Ear ni ngs. As set f or t h i n t he st eps bel ow ,
Cl ai mant s Lost Ear ni ngs i ncl udes any lower amount of ear ni ngs i n t he Compensat i on Per i od as
compar ed t o t he 2011 Benchmar k Per i od, af t er t hose 2011 ear ni ngs have been decr eased by
t he Gener al Gr ow t h Fact or , l ess any Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs. In addi t ion, f or clai ms based on non-
sal ar i ed, hour ly-w age j obs, t he cl aimant s 2011 ear ni ngs shal l al so be decr eased by t he Indust r y
Gr ow t h Fact or .
For any Cat egor y III cl aimant not empl oyed i n 2011 i n t he same j ob or si mi l ar j ob as t hat
per f or med or of f er ed and w i t hdr aw n i n t he Compensat i on Per i od sel ect ed by t he cl aimant and
sat i sf yi ng a r equi r ement of Sect i on III.B.1.b or III.B.2.b above, Expect ed Ear ni ngs f or each t ype of
Cat egor y III cl aimant shal l be based on al t er nat i ve dat a, as descr i bed i n det ai l i n It em 2 of St ep 2
bel ow .
The cl aimant shal l r ecei ve a l ump-sum f i nal payment t hat i ncl udes compensat ion f or Cl ai mant s
Lost Ear ni ngs, pl us any appl i cabl e RTP agr eed upon by t he par t ies, pl us compensat i on f or
pr oper l y document ed Empl oyment -Rel at ed Benef i t s Losses, Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng Cost s and
0288
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 38 of 53
38
Rei mbur sabl e Sear ch Cost s, i f any, l ess t he amount s of any Spi l l -Rel at ed Payment s.
Example compensat ion calcul at i ons ar e set f or t h i n Appendi ces A t hr ough F at t ached her et o.
St ep 1: Cl ai mant Sel ect s Compensat i on Per i od
1. Cl ai mant sel ect s a Compensat i on Per i od. For a cl aimant w ho (i ) w as t er mi nat ed f or
cause i n 2010 f r om t he Cl ai mi ng Job(s), or (i i ) ot her w i se ended employment at t he
Cl ai mi ng Job(s) i n 2010 f or r easons unr el at ed t o t he DWH Spi l l , t he Compensat i on
Per i od may not ext end beyond t he t er mi nat i on dat e.
St ep 2: Ident i f y 2011 Benchmar k Per i od Ear ni ngs t o Be Used i n Cal cul at i ng Expect ed Ear ni ngs
The pur pose of t hi s St ep 2 i s t o i dent i f y ear ni ngs t o be used i n cal cul at i ng Expect ed
Ear ni ngs.
1. For cl aimant s empl oyed dur i ng a 2011 Benchmar k Per i od, t he cl aimant s ear ni ngs used
i n cal cul at i ng Expect ed Ear ni ngs shal l be t he cl aimant s ear ni ngs f r om such 2011 per i od.
a. Cl ai mant s w i t h Tax Inf or mat i on Document s: Ear ni ngs dur i ng t he 2011 Benchmar k
Per i od as evi denced by Tax Inf or mat i on Document s shal l i ncl ude ear ned i ncome
f r om t he Cl ai mi ng Job (or compar able j ob) and shal l be assumed t o have been
ear ned evenly t hr oughout 2011 unl ess t he cl aimant pr ovi des Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs
Document at i on suf f i ci ent t o est abl i sh act ual ear ni ngs di st r i but i on. Al l bonuses
and/ or commi ssions shal l be al l ocat ed pr o r at a acr oss t he per iod f or w hi ch t hey
w er e aw ar ded, and annual per f or mance bonuses pai d i n Januar y and Febr uar y shal l
be assumed t o r el at e t o t he pr i or cal endar year , unl ess t he document s est abl i sh t hat
t he bonus r el at ed t o a speci f i c per i od of t i me.
b. Cl ai mant s w i t h onl y Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on: Ear ni ngs dur i ng t he 2011
Benchmar k Per i od as evi denced by Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on f or each
Cl ai mi ng Job shal l be det er mi ned based upon t he nat ur e and ext ent of t he
document at ion pr ovi ded.
i . If t he cl aimant submi t s Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on t hat cover s
onl y di scr et e por t i ons of 2011, t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l base t he
2011 Benchmar k Per i od ear ni ngs f or t hat j ob only on t he act ual
document at ion pr ovi ded (i .e., dat a shal l not be ext r apol at ed t o per iods
f or w hi ch Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on was not pr ovi ded).
0288
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 39 of 53
39
i i . If t he cl aimant submi t s Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on f or a j ob
t hat pr ovi des dat a as t o f ul l year ear ni ngs but not t he al l ocat i on of t hose
ear ni ngs (i.e., a year -end payst ub), t hen i f t he cl aimant al so pr ovi des
addi t i onal Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on deemed by t he Cl ai ms
Admi ni st r at or t o be suf f i cient f or pur poses of al locat i ng t hose ear ni ngs
acr oss t he r el evant per iod, ear ni ngs f or t hat j ob shal l be al l ocat ed
consi st ent w i t h t hat Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on.
i i i . If no addi t ional i nf or mat ion i s pr ovi ded r egar di ng t he al l ocat i on of t hose
ear ni ngs, t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l assume a pr o r at a di st r i but ion
over t he r elevant per i od.
i v. Al l bonuses and/ or commi ssi ons shal l be al l ocat ed pr o r at a acr oss t he
per i od f or w hi ch t he cl ai mant i ndi cat es t hey wer e aw ar ded, and annual
per f or mance bonuses pai d i n Januar y and Febr uar y shal l be assumed t o
r el at e t o t he pr ior cal endar year , unl ess t he document s est abl i sh t hat
t he bonus r el at ed t o a speci f i c per i od of t i me.
OR
2. For cl aimant s not empl oyed dur i ng t he 2011 Benchmar k Per i od, but w ho sat i sf ied t he
causat i on r equi r ement i n Sect i on III.B.3, t he cl aimant s ear ni ngs used i n cal cul at ing
Expect ed Ear ni ngs shal l be one of t he f ol l ow i ng:
a. New Ent r ant To Empl oyment : The cl aimant s Expect ed Ear ni ngs dur i ng t he
Compensat i on Per i od shal l be based on t he r esci nded or r educed of f er of
employment or Empl oyer Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement used t o est abl i sh causat ion.
b. Cl ai mant Who Had Less Than Tw el ve M ont hs Of Ear ni ngs Hi st or y But Was
Empl oyed On Apr i l 20, 2010: The cl aimant s Expect ed Ear ni ngs shal l be based on
t he cl aimant s aver age mont hl y pr e-DWH Spi l l ear ni ngs i n t he Cl ai mi ng Job,
r ecogni zi ng t hat t hi s cal culat i on shal l be based on l ess t han t wel ve mont hs of
ear ni ngs dat a and shal l be subj ect t o an Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or onl y, i f r el evant , as
descr i bed below .
c. Car eer Changer : The cl aimant s Expect ed Ear ni ngs shal l be based on ear ni ngs i n t he
2009 t i me per iod of at l east 90 consecut i ve days cor r espondi ng t o t he t i me per iod
of at l east 90 consecut i ve days w it hi n t he same mont hs sel ect ed by t he cl aimant as
t he Compensat i on Per i od.
St ep 3: Det er mi ne Ear ni ngs Gr ow t h Fact or (s)
1. The f ol l ow i ng Gr ow t h Fact or s may appl y f or pur poses of cal cul at i ng Expect ed Ear ni ngs:
a. Gener al Gr ow t h Fact or i s def i ned i n Def i ni t i ons Sect i on N.2 and i s 2.0%.
b. Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or i s def i ned i n Def i ni t i ons Sect i on N.3. For clai mant s i n
non-sal ar i ed, hour l y w age j obs, t he Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or of 1.5% shal l be
0288
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 40 of 53
40
appl i ed.
c. Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or i s def i ned, and t he cal cul at i on i s expl ai ned i n
Def i ni t ions Sect i on N.1. For pur poses of t hi s Sect i on III, a Cl ai mant Speci f i c
Gr ow t h Fact or may appl y onl y i n t he l imi t ed ci r cumst ance of a Car eer Changer
w ho does not have ear ni ngs dur i ng t he 2011 Benchmar k Per i od f or one of t he
r easons set f or t h i n Sect i on III.B.3.
St ep 4: Cal cul at e Expect ed Ear ni ngs
Expect ed Ear ni ngs w i l l be cal cul at ed as f ol low s:
1. For cl aimant s cover ed by St ep 2.a, Expect ed Ear ni ngs equal t he ear ni ngs over t he 2011
Benchmar k Per i od, decr eased by t he appl i cabl e Gr ow t h Fact or s (f r om St ep 3).
Expect ed Ear ni ngs = 2011 Benchmark Peri od Ear nings f r om St ep 2 x (1 - applicable St ep 3
Gr owt h Fact or(s))
2. For cl aimant s cover ed by St ep 2.b, Expect ed Ear ni ngs ar e cal cul at ed accor di ng t o one of
t he f ol low i ng:
a. New Ent r ant To Empl oyment : The cl aimant s Expect ed Ear ni ngs dur i ng t he
Compensat i on Per i od shal l be based on t he r esci nded or r educed of f er of
employment or Empl oyer Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement used t o est abl i sh
causat i on. No Gr ow t h Fact or s appl y.
b. Cl ai mant Who Had Less Than Tw el ve M ont hs Of Ear ni ngs Hi st or y But Was
Empl oyed On Apr i l 20, 2010: The cl aimant s Expect ed Ear ni ngs shal l be based
on t he cl aimant s aver age mont hl y pr e-DWH Spi l l ear ni ngs i n t he Cl ai mi ng Job,
r ecogni zi ng t hat t hi s cal culat i on shal l be based on l ess t han t wel ve mont hs of
ear ni ngs dat a and shal l be incr eased by t he Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or , i f r el evant .
No ot her Gr ow t h Fact or s shal l appl y.
c. Car eer Changer : The cl aimant s Expect ed Ear ni ngs shal l be based on ear ni ngs i n
t he 2009 t i me per iod of at least 90 consecut ive days cor r espondi ng t o t he t i me
per i od of at l east 90 consecut i ve days w i t hi n t he same mont hs select ed by t he
cl ai mant as t he Compensat i on Per i od, i ncr eased by t he Cl ai mant Speci f i c
Gr ow t h Fact or or t he Gener al Gr ow t h Fact or , as appl icabl e, and by an Indust r y
Gr ow t h Fact or , i f appl i cable.
St ep 5: Det er mi ne Act ual Ear ni ngs and Any Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs In The Compensat i on Per i od
Act ual Ear ni ngs f or al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs and any appl i cabl e Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs dur i ng t he
Compensat i on Per i od shal l be det er mi ned based on Tax Inf or mat i on Document at i on or
Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on pr ovi ded by t he cl ai mant and ot her document at ion
r el evant t o det er mi ni ng Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs.
To t he ext ent t he cl aimant does not have Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on f or a
Cl ai mi ng Job, Act ual Ear ni ngs dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od shal l be est imat ed f or t hat
Cl ai mi ng Job by di vi di ng t he cl aimant s t ot al 2010 Cl ai mi ng Job ear ni ngs by 12 and
0288 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 41 of 53
41
mul t i pl yi ng t hat amount by t he number of mont hs i n t he Compensat i on Per i od. Al l bonuses
and/ or commi ssions shal l be al l ocat ed pr o r at a acr oss t he per iods f or w hi ch t hey w er e
aw ar ded, and annual per f or mance bonuses pai d i n Januar y and Febr uar y shal l be assumed
t o r el at e t o t he pr i or cal endar year , unl ess t he document s est abl i sh t hat t he bonus r el at ed
t o a speci f i c per iod of t ime.
Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs and Act ual Ear ni ngs f r om al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs shal l be calcul at ed gi vi ng
consi der at ion t o al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs, pr ovi ded t hat :
1. If t he cl aimant has only one Cl ai mi ng Job, t hen:
i . If Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on (or ot her document at i on r el evant t o
cal cul at i ng Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs) r ef l ect s t he same or an i ncr eased number of
hour s wor ked at t he Cl ai mi ng Job i n t he Compensat i on Per i od r el at i ve t o t he
Cl ai mi ng Job (or compar abl e j ob) i n t he Benchmar k Per i od, Act ual Ear ni ngs
shal l be l i mit ed t o ear ni ngs f r om t he Cl ai mi ng Job (or compar abl e j ob) over t he
same t ot al number of hour s wor ked i n t he Benchmar k Per i od, and no
Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs shal l appl y.
OR
i i . If Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on (or ot her document at i on) (i ) r ef l ect s a
decr ease i n hour s wor ked at t he Cl ai mi ng Job dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od,
and (i i ) t he cl ai mant s Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on r ef l ect s addi t ional
hour s wor ked at a Non-Cl ai mi ng Job (w het her such Non-Cl ai mi ng Job w as hel d
i n t he Benchmar k Per i od or i s a new posi t ion), Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs shal l be
cal cul at ed and f act or ed i nt o t he det er mi nat i on of Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs.
2. If t he cl aimant has mor e t han one Cl ai mi ng Job, t hen:
i . If Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on (or ot her document at i on r el evant t o
cal cul at i ng Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs) f or al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs r ef l ect s t he same or an
i ncr eased number of t ot al hour s wor ked acr oss al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs dur i ng t he
Compensat i on Per i od (r el at i ve t o al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs (or compar abl e j obs) i n t he
Benchmar k Per i od), aggr egat e Act ual Ear ni ngs i n t he Compensat i on Per i od
shal l be l i mit ed t o t ot al ear ni ngs f r om al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs (or compar abl e j obs)
over t he same number of t ot al hour s w or ked i n t he Benchmar k Per i od,
pr ovi ded t hat ear ni ngs f r om hour s l ost i n one Cl ai mi ng Job shal l be r epl aced by
ear ni ngs f r om t he same number of hour s w or ked i n a di f f er ent Cl ai mi ng Job
dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od. No Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs shal l appl y.
OR
i i . If Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on (or ot her document at i on r el evant t o
cal cul at i ng Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs) f or al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs r ef l ect s (i ) f ewer t ot al
hour s wor ked acr oss al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od (r el at i ve
t o al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs (or compar abl e j obs) i n t he Benchmar k Per i od), but (i i )
0288
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 42 of 53
42
mor e hour s wor ked i n one (or mor e) Cl ai mi ng Job(s) in t he Compensat i on
Per i od (r el at i ve t o t he same Cl ai mi ng Job(s) i n t he Benchmar k Per i od),
aggr egat e Act ual Ear ni ngs in t he Compensat i on Per i od shal l i ncl ude t ot al
ear ni ngs f r om al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs (or compar abl e j obs) in t he Compensat i on
Per i od. If t he cl aimant s Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on al so r ef l ect s
addi t i onal hour s wor ked at a di f f er ent (Non-Cl ai mi ng Job) posi t i on (w het her
such posi t ion was hel d i n t he Benchmar k Per i od or i s a new posi t ion), Of f set t i ng
Ear ni ngs shal l be cal cul at ed and f act or ed i nt o t he det er mi nat ion of Cl ai mant
Lost Ear ni ngs f or t he number of hour s r epr esent i ng t he di f f er ence bet w een (a)
t ot al hour s w or ked i n al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs i n t he Compensat i on Per i od, and (b)
t ot al hour s w or ked i n al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs i n t he Benchmar k Per i od.
OR
i i i . If Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on (or ot her document at i on) f or al l Cl ai mi ng
Jobs (i ) r ef l ect s a decr ease i n hour s wor ked at each Cl ai mi ng Job dur i ng t he
Compensat i on Per i od, and (i i ) t he cl aimant s Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs
Document at i on r ef lect s addi t i onal hour s wor ked at a di f f er ent posi t ion
(w het her such posi t ion w as hel d i n t he Benchmar k Per i od or i s a new posi t ion),
Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs shal l be cal cul at ed and f act or ed i nt o t he det er mi nat i on of
Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs f or t he t ot al lost hour s.
OR
i v. If t he cl aimant does not have Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on (or ot her
document at ion est abl i shi ng hour s wor ked) f or al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs, t hen Act ual
Ear ni ngs shal l i ncl ude al l ear ni ngs f r om al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs and Of f set t i ng
Ear ni ngs shal l appl y.
St ep 6: Det er mi ne Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs
Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs shal l be cal cul at ed as (a) t he dif f er ence bet w een (i ) t he clai mant s
Expect ed Ear ni ngs dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od (St ep 4) f r om al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs and
(i i ) t he cl ai mant s Act ual Ear ni ngs dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od, as adj ust ed, i f r el evant ,
(St ep 5) f r om al l Cl ai mi ng Jobs, r educed by (b) any appl i cabl e Of f set t i ng Ear ni ngs.
St ep 7: Cal cul at e Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on
Fi nal cl ai mant compensat i on shal l be Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs (St ep 6) adj ust ed as f ol l ow s:
1. Add any appl i cabl e RTP agr eed t o by t he par t i es, pr ovided t hat :
- For cl aimant s w hose Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs r esul t f r om mor e t han one
Cl ai mi ng Job, t he cl aimant s appl i cabl e RTP shal l be cal cul at ed based on
(i ) t he per cent age of t ot al Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs r elat ed t o each Cl ai mi ng
Job, mul t i pl i ed by (i i) t he RTP appl i cabl e t o each Cl ai mi ng Job, w hi ch i s
det er mi ned by t he j ob t ype (Tour i sm/ Ot her Indust r i es) and zone (Zone A, B,
C or D). For exampl e, a cl aimant w i t h 50% of t hei r l ost ear ni ngs f r om a j ob
028880
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 43 of 53
43
Zone A hot el , and 50% of t hei r l ost ear ni ngs f r om a j ob i n a Zone C
r est aur ant shal l r ecei ve an RTP t hat i s cal cul at ed as f oll ow s:
Appl i cabl e RTP = .5* RTP
Zone A Tour i sm (hot el )
+ .5* RTP
Zone C Tour i sm (r est aur ant )
- For cl aimant s unabl e t o wor k i n 2011 because t hey w er e (i ) a f ul l t i me
st udent , (i i ) medi cal l y i ncapaci t at ed such t hat t he cl aimant w as unabl e t o
w or k and w as expect ed t o be unabl e t o r et ur n t o t he w or kf or ce, or
(i i i ) engaged i n f ul l -t ime volunt eer or mi ssionar y wor k or had chosen t o
l eave t he wor kf or ce t o ser ve as a f ul l -t i me par ent or l egal guar di an (as set
f or t h i n Sect i on III.B.3), no RTP shal l be appl i ed.
- For an employee t er mi nat ed f or cause i n 2010 f r om a Cl ai mi ng Job, no RTP
shal l appl y.
2. Add any Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng Cost s. Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng Cost s shal l be f ul ly
r ei mbur sed i f t he t r ai ni ng l ed di r ect ly t o ear ned i ncome i n 2010. If not , t hen
Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng Cost s shal l be r eimbur sed up t o $2,000.
For example: A cl aimant who pai d $3,000 af t er Apr i l 20, 2010 t o secur e a
commer ci al t r ucki ng l i cense and w ho ear ned i ncome as a commer ci al t r ucker i n
2010 shal l r ecei ve $3,000 i n r ei mbur sement . If t he clai mant ear ned no i ncome f r om
commer ci al t r ucki ng dur i ng 2010, t he cl aimant w oul d r eceive a $2,000
r ei mbur sement .
3. Add any Rei mbur sabl e Sear ch Cost s.
4. Add any appl i cabl e Empl oyment -Rel at ed Benef i t s Losses.
5. Add any One Ti me, Non-Recur r i ng Event Compensat i on.
6. Subt r act any Spi l l -Rel at ed Payment s.
7. The f or mul a f or Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on i s:
Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs
+ (Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs x appl i cabl e RTP (i f any))
+ Empl oyment -Rel at ed Benef i t s Losses (i f appl i cabl e)
+ Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng Cost s (f ul l i f led t o ear ned i ncome i n 2010 f r om
ar ea of t r ai ni ng, ot her w i se $2,000) (i f appl i cabl e)
+ Rei mbur sabl e Sear ch Cost s (i f appl i cabl e)
+ One Ti me, Non-Recur r i ng Event Compensat i on (i f appl i cabl e)
- Spi l l -Rel at ed Payment s (i f appl i cabl e)
- VoO Set t l ement Of f set and/ or VoO Ear ned Income Of f set (i f any)
02888
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 44 of 53
44
IV. CATEGORY IV: CLAIM ANTS WITHOUT EARNINGS DOCUM ENTATION WHO SUBM IT CLAIM ANT
AND EM PLOYER SWORN WRITTEN STATEM ENTS TO ESTABLISH EARNINGS
Any cl aimant w ho sat i sf i es al l of t he f ol l ow i ng cr i t er i a may be el i gi bl e f or compensat i on pur suant t o
t hi s Cat egor y IV:
1. The cl aimant s empl oyer or employment i s locat ed i n Zones A, B or C.
24
2. The cl aimant does not have Tax Inf or mat i on Document s or Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs
Document at i on f or t he Cl ai mi ng Job evi denci ng hi s or her ear ni ngs dur i ng t he r elevant t i me
per i od. For clai mant s w hose empl oyer (s) i s an ent it y or Nat ur al Per son sat i sf yi ng t he
Pr i mar y Seaf ood Indust r y def i ni t i on, t he r elevant per i ods shal l be (i ) Apr i l 21, 2009 t hr ough
Apr i l 20, 2010, and (i i ) Apr i l 21, 2010 t hr ough Apr i l 30, 2011. For al l ot her cl aimant s, t he
r equi si t e per iods shal l be (i) Apr i l 21 t hr ough December 31, 2009 and (i i ) Apr i l 21 t hr ough
December 31, 2010.
3. The cl aimant i s not a New Ent r ant t o Empl oyment .
Cl ai mant s w ho meet t he cr it er i a above may i nst ead est abl i sh l ost ear ni ngs and causat i on by
submi t t i ng, i n addi t ion t o a swor n Cl aim For m, (a) a Cl ai mant Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement w i t h
speci f i ed cont ent s, (b) one or mor e Empl oyer Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement (s) pr ovidi ng i nf or mat ion
f or at l east t he per i ods Apr il 21 t hr ough December 31, 2009, and Apr i l 21 t hr ough December 31,
2010,
25,26
and, at t he cl aimant s opt ion, f or addi t ional per iods as descr i bed bel ow, (c) any ot her
speci f i ed document at ion. In addi t i on, t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or may i nt er vi ew t he cl aimant and/ or
t he empl oyer consist ent w it h t he Addendum Regar di ng Int er vi ew s of Cl ai mant Al l egi ng Economi c
Loss and Sect i on IV.B, below .
A. Document at i on And Causat i on Requi r ement s:
A Cat egor y IV cl aimant must pr ovi de a swor n Cl aim For m and al l of t he document s i dent i f i ed
bel ow . The Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l r evi ew and assess t he document at ion pr ovi ded by t he
cl ai mant , i ncl udi ng i nf or mat i on f r om t he cl ai mant s empl oyer (s), and any ot her inf or mat i on
deemed r elevant by t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or , f or pur poses of det er mi ni ng w het her t he
24
For pur poses of t hi s Fr amew or k f or Indi vi dual Economi c Loss Cl ai ms, t he pr esumpt i on shal l be t hat t he l ocat i on
of economi c l oss f or t he Cl ai mi ng Job i s t he l ocat i on of t he cl ai mant s empl oyer wi t hi n t he Cl ass Def i ni t i on
geogr aphi c ar ea, not t he cl ai mant s r esi dence. Cl ai mant s may est abl i sh an al t er nat i ve l ocat i on of economi c l oss f or
t he Cl ai mi ng Job ot her t han t hei r empl oyer s l ocat i on by pr ovi di ng evi dence t hat t hei r pr i mar y empl oyment
act i vi t i es and r esponsi bi l i t i es occur i n a l ocat i on di f f er ent f r om t hei r empl oyer s busi ness addr ess, and t hat t he
cl ai med DWH Spi l l -r el at ed economi c l oss uni quel y occur r ed at such l ocat i on. For exampl e, t he cl ai mant w or ks f or
a housekeepi ng company l ocat ed i n Zone C t hat ser vi ces househol ds i n Zones A, B and C, i ncl udi ng vacat i on
condomi ni ums l ocat ed i n Zone A, and t he cl ai mant est abl i shes t hat she w or ks p r i mar i l y i n Zone A.
25
For cl ai mant s w hose empl oyer (s) i s an ent i t y or Nat ur al Per son sat i sf yi ng t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Indust r y
def i ni t i on, t he cl ai mant shoul d i nst ead pr ovi de one or mor e Empl oyer Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement (s) f or t he per i ods
(i ) Apr i l 21, 2009 t hr ough Apr i l 20, 2010 and (i i ) Apr i l 21, 2010 t hr ough Apr i l 20, 2011.
26
If t he i nf or mat i on f or bot h r equi r ed per i ods can be sat i sf i ed w i t h an Empl oyer Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement f r om
one empl oyer , onl y one Empl oyer Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement i s r equi r ed. If a si ngl e empl oyer i s not abl e t o pr ovi de
t he necessar y i nf or mat i on f or bot h r equi r ed per i ods set f or t h above, t he cl ai mant must submi t at l east one
Empl oyer Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement f or each per i od.
028882
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 45 of 53
45
cl ai mant exper ienced a l oss of ear ni ngs dur i ng Apr i l 21 t hr ough December 31, 2010,
27
and, i f so,
w het her t he loss w as due t o or r esul t i ng f r om t he DWH Spi l l . The Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l
r el y on hi s assessment of t he cr edi bi l i t y and r el i abi l i t y of t he i nf or mat i on submi t t ed i n
det er mi ni ng i f t hi s causat ion r equi r ement i s sat i sf ied.
1. Cl ai mant Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement : The cl aimant shall submi t a Cl ai mant Sw or n Wr i t t en
St at ement w hi ch set s f or t h t he f ol low i ng i nf or mat i on and shal l at t ach any r el evant
document s i n cl ai mant s possessi on:
a. No Tax Ret ur ns ar e avai l abl e f or 2009 and 2010.
b. No Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on i s avai l abl e f or t he Cl ai mi ng Job(s) f or
t he per iod Apr i l 21 t hr ough December 31 of 2009 and 2010.
28
c. The cl aimant made di l i gent ef f or t s t o obt ai n For m W-2s f or 2009 and 2010 f r om
hi s or her empl oyer (s) and t hey ar e not avai l abl e.
d. The cl aimant s empl oyment hi st or y wi t h each employer , i ncl udi ng, f or exampl e,
t he nat ur e of t he w or k per f or med, number of year s wor ked, w het her t he
employment i s st eady or seasonal , year -r ound or i nt er mi t t ent , and t he
ci r cumst ances of t he clai mant s depar t ur e and/ or t er mi nat ion, i f appl i cabl e. At
a mi nimum, t he cl ai mant shal l i ncl ude t he f ol l ow i ng:
i . The busi ness name, l ast know n addr ess, t el ephone number and, i f
avai l abl e, w ebsi t e of each of cl aimant s empl oyer s f or t he per iod Apr i l
21 t hr ough December 31 of 2009 and 2010.
29
i i . To be pot ent i al ly el i gi bl e f or an RTP, t he cl aimant must al so pr ovi de t he
above i nf or mat i on f or t he per i od Apr i l 21 t hr ough December 31, 2011.
30
e. The cl aimant s act ual ear ned i ncome f r om al l sour ces in 2009 and 2010, and any
ot her ear ni ngs hi st or y t hat t he cl aimant bel i eves i s r elevant t o suppor t t he
cl ai m, i ncl udi ng any suppor t f or t he cl ai mant s bel ief t hat t hese act ual ear ned
amount s ar e accur at e.
f . If appl i cabl e, t he cl aimant s BP/ GCCF Cl aim Number , and a l i st i ng of any Spi l l -
Rel at ed Payment s r eceived by t he cl aimant .
g. An expl anat i on of how t he r educt i on of cl ai mant s hour s of w or k, t er mi nat i on of
t he cl aimant s empl oyment , and/ or w i t hdr aw al of an of f er of empl oyment
27
For cl ai mant s w hose empl oyer (s) i s an ent i t y or Nat ur al Per son sat i sf yi ng t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Indust r y
def i ni t i on, t he pot ent i al l oss per i od shal l be Apr i l 21, 2010 t hr ough Apr i l 20, 2011.
28
For cl ai mant s w hose empl oyer (s) i s an ent i t y or Nat ur al Per son sat i sf yi ng t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Indust r y
def i ni t i on, t he cl ai mant shoul d i nst ead ver i f y t hat no Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on f or t he Cl ai mi ng Job i s
avai l abl e f or t he per i ods (i ) Apr i l 21, 2009 t hr ough Apr i l 20, 2010 and (i i ) Apr i l 21, 2010 t hr ough Apr i l 20, 2011.
29
For cl ai mant s w hose empl oyer (s) i s an ent i t y or Nat ur al Per son sat i sf yi ng t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Indust r y
def i ni t i on, t he cl ai mant shoul d i nst ead pr ovi de t he busi ness name and l ast known addr ess of each of cl ai mant s
empl oyer s f or t he per i ods (i ) Apr i l 21, 2009 t hr ough Apr i l 20, 2010 and (i i ) Apr i l 21, 2010 t hr ough Apr i l 20, 2011.
30
For cl ai mant s w hose empl oyer (s) i s an ent i t y or Nat ur al Per son sat i sf yi ng t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Indust r y
def i ni t i on, t he cl ai mant shoul d i nst ead pr ovi de t he busi ness name and l ast known addr ess of each of cl ai mant s
empl oyer s f or t he per i od Apr i l 21, 2011 t hr ough Apr i l 20, 2012 t o be pot ent i al l y el i gi bl e f or an RTP.
02888
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 46 of 53
46
r el at ed t o t he Cl ai mi ng Job(s) dur i ng t he per iod f r om Apr i l 21, 2010 - December
31, 2010 w as due t o or r esul t i ng f r om t he DWH Spi l l .
31
h. A st at ement and any avai l abl e document at i on est abl i shi ng t hat t he cl ai mant
w as pr esent and avai l abl e t o wor k i n Zones A, B or C i n cl ose enough pr oximi t y
t o t he ant i ci pat ed l ocat i on of employment t o t r avel t o t he j ob as f r equent ly as
r equi r ed by t he employer dur i ng t he per i od f r om Apr i l 21, 2010 t o December
31, 2010.
32
i . To be pot ent i al ly el i gi bl e f or an RTP, t he cl aimant must sat i sf y t he above
r equi r ement f or t he per iod Apr i l 21 t hr ough December 31, 2011.
33
i i . Document at ion t hat coul d demonst r at e pr esence and avai l abi l i t y
i ncl udes, but i s not l imi t ed t o, t he f ol l ow i ng:
1) A l ease or r ent al agr eement ; or
2) A subl ease agr eement ; or
3) Cont empor aneous ut i l i t y bil l s.
2. Cl ai mant Empl oyabi l i t y Document at i on:
Consi st s of bot h:
a. A copy of a Soci al Secur i t y car d, gover nment -i ssued i dent i f i cat i on (f or exampl e,
a val i d dr iver s l icense), t empor ar y w or ker vi sa, or gr een car d t hat w as val i d as
of Apr i l 20, 2010, or a pr i nt out f r om a publ i c dat abase pr ovi di ng t he same
i nf or mat i on as w oul d be pr ovi ded by t he or i gi nal document .
AND
b. Evi dence t hat t he cl ai mant w as at l east 16 year s of age as of Apr i l 20, 2010.
Accept abl e evi dence i ncl udes a val i d dr i ver s l i cense, a val i d passpor t , or a copy
of t he cl aimant s bi r t h cer t if i cat e, or a pr i nt out f r om a publ i c dat abase
pr ovi di ng t he same i nf or mat i on as woul d be pr ovi ded by t he or i gi nal document .
3. Li censi ng Document at i on: If t he cl ai mant s employment i n t he Cl ai mi ng Job r equi r es a
gover nment -i ssued l i cense/ per mi t , t he cl aimant shal l pr ovi de a copy of val i d 2009, 2010
and, i f appl i cabl e, 2011 l icenses, or a pr i nt out f r om a publ i c dat abase pr ovi di ng t he same
i nf or mat i on as w oul d be pr ovi ded by t he or i gi nal document , such as:
31
For cl ai mant s w hose empl oyer (s) i s an ent i t y or Nat ur al Per son sat i sf yi ng t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Indust r y
def i ni t i on, t he cl ai mant shoul d i nst ead pr ovi de an expl anat i on of how t he r educt i on of cl ai mant s hour s of wor k,
t er mi nat i on of t he cl ai mant s empl oyment , and/ or wi t hdr awal of an of f er of empl oyment f or t he per i ods (i ) Apr i l
21, 2009 t hr ough Apr i l 20, 2010 and (i i ) Apr i l 21, 2010 t hr ough Apr i l 20, 2011 w as due t o or r esul t i ng f r om t he
DWH Spi l l .
32
For cl ai mant s w hose empl oyer (s) i s an ent i t y or Nat ur al Per son sat i sf yi ng t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Indust r y
def i ni t i on, t he cl ai mant shoul d i nst ead pr ovi de i nf or mat i on r egar di ng hi s or her pr esence and avai l abi l i t y f or w or k
i n Zones A, B or C f or t he per i od Apr i l 21, 2010 t hr ough Apr i l 20, 2011.
33
For cl ai mant s w hose empl oyer (s) i s an ent i t y or Nat ur al Per son sat i sf yi ng t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Indust r y
def i ni t i on, t he cl ai mant shoul d i nst ead pr ovi de i nf or mat i on r egar di ng hi s or her pr esence and avai l abi l i t y f or wor k
i n Zones A, B or C f or t he per i od Apr i l 21, 2011 t hr ough Apr i l 20, 2012 t o be pot ent i al l y el i gi bl e f or an RTP.
028884
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 47 of 53
47
a. Taxi / l iver y l i censes.
b. Real Est at e Sal es l icenses.
c. Ot her l i censes and per mi t s r el at ed t o i ncome sour ces.
4. Empl oyer Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement : The cl ai mant shal l submi t an Empl oyer Sw or n
Wr i t t en St at ement f r om at l east one of hi s or her empl oyer s dur i ng each of t he per i ods
Apr i l 21 t hr ough December 31 of 2009 and 2010, w hi ch set s f or t h t he f ol low i ng i nf or mat i on
w i t h any r el evant document s at t ached.
34
If t he i nf or mat i on f or bot h r equi r ed per iods can
be sat i sf ied w i t h an Empl oyer Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement f r om one employer , onl y one
Empl oyer Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement i s r equi r ed. If a si ngl e employer i s not abl e t o pr ovi de
t he necessar y i nf or mat ion f or bot h r equi r ed per i ods, t he cl aimant must submi t at l east one
Empl oyer Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement s f or each per iod.
a. Empl oyer Inf or mat i on
i . Empl oyer s busi ness name
i i . Addr ess(es)
i i i . Tel ephone number (s)
i v. Websi t e(s), i f avai l able
v. A descr i pt ion of t he nat ur e of t he busi ness
vi . Compensat ion pr act ices (f or exampl e, w eekl y or bi -w eekl y pay per iods),
w age r at es, and t ypi cal hour s wor ked f or empl oyees hol di ng j obs
compar abl e t o t he Cl ai mi ng Job.
vi i . If t he employer i s not an El i gi bl e Empl oyer , i nf or mat ion suf f i ci ent t o
est abl i sh t he f ol low i ng:
1) The si ze and scal e of t he empl oyer s busi ness, such as:
a) Si ze of physi cal pl ant ;
b) Best est imat e of t he number of cust omer s;
c) Best est imat e of t he vol ume of pr oduct pr oduced;
d) Best est imat e of t he number of f ul l -t i me and par t -t i me
employees;
e) Fi nanci al i nf or mat i on; and/ or
f ) To t he ext ent t he busi ness i s a seasonal busi ness, t hi s
i nf or mat i on shoul d be pr ovi ded t o r ef l ect busi ness si ze dur i ng
di f f er ent seasons.
34
For cl ai mant s w hose empl oyer (s) i s an ent i t y or Nat ur al Per son sat i sf yi ng t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Indust r y
def i ni t i on, t he Empl oyer Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement shal l be pr ovi ded f r om each of t he cl ai mant s empl oyer s f or
t he per i ods (i ) Apr i l 21, 2009 t hr ough Apr i l 20, 2010 and (i i ) Apr i l 21, 2010 t hr ough Apr i l 20, 2011.
02888
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 48 of 53
48
2) Copi es of any appl i cabl e r equi r ed l i censes possessed by t he
employer dur i ng t he per iod Apr i l 21 t hr ough December 31 of 2009
and 2010,
35
or a pr i nt out f r om a publ i c dat abase pr ovi di ng t he
same i nf or mat ion as woul d be pr ovi ded by t he or i gi nal document .
b. Empl oyee Inf or mat i on
i . The cl aimant s empl oyment hi st or y wi t h employer , i ncl udi ng, f or
exampl e, t he nat ur e of t he w or k per f or med, number of year s wor ked,
w het her t he employment i s st eady or seasonal , year -r ound or
i nt er mit t ent , and t he ci r cumst ances of t he cl aimant s depar t ur e and/ or
t er mi nat i on, i f appl i cabl e.
i i . The cl aimant s wage r at e and t ot al compensat i on f or t he f ol low i ng
per i ods, i f appl i cabl e:
1) Apr i l 21 t hr ough December 31, 2009;
36
2) Apr i l 21 t hr ough December 31, 2010;
37
3) Apr i l 21 t hr ough December 31, 2011;
38
and
4) Any ot her t ime per iod f or w hi ch t he empl oyer i s abl e and el ect s t o
pr ovi de t he r equest ed i nf or mat ion.
If t he employer cannot pr ovi de pr eci se act ual dat es and t i mes, i t shal l
be suf f i ci ent f or t he employer t o pr ovi de mor e gener al i nf or mat ion
sat i sf yi ng t hi s st andar d f or exampl e, Cl aimant was empl oyed f or 30
days at a r at e of $100 per day f or 12 w eeks dur i ng t he mont hs of [ June -
August 2009] .
i i i . If t he employer (i ) empl oyed t he cl aimant and/ or (i i ) of f er ed t he
cl ai mant empl oyment dur ing t he per i od f r om Apr i l 21, 2010 - December
31, 2010,
39
t he empl oyer shal l pr ovi de t he f ol low i ng:
1) How t he employer (a) t er mi nat ed t he cl ai mant s employment ,
(b) r educed t he cl aimant s hour s of wor k, (c) w i t hdr ew an of f er of
employment , (d) di d not ext end an of f er of seasonal (par t i al year )
employment t o t he cl aimant , or (e) ot her wi se r educed employee s
compensat ion due t o or r esul t i ng f r om t he DWH Spi l l w i t h suf f i ci ent
35
For cl ai mant s w hose empl oyer (s) i s an ent i t y or Nat ur al Per son sat i sf yi ng t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Indust r y
def i ni t i on, t he empl oyer shoul d i nst ead pr ovi de copi es of any appl i cabl e r equi r ed l i censes f or t he per i ods (i ) Apr i l
21, 2009 t hr ough Apr i l 20, 2010 and (i i ) Apr i l 21, 2010 t hr ough Apr i l 20, 2011.
36
For cl ai mant s w hose empl oyer (s) i s an ent i t y or Nat ur al Per son sat i sf yi ng t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Indust r y
def i ni t i on, t he appr opr i at e per i od i s f r om Apr i l 21, 2009 t hr ough Apr i l 20, 2010.
37
For cl ai mant s w hose empl oyer (s) i s an ent i t y or Nat ur al Per son sat i sf yi ng t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Indust r y
def i ni t i on, t he appr opr i at e per i od i s f r om Apr i l 21, 2010 t hr ough Apr i l 20, 2011.
38
For cl ai mant s w hose empl oyer (s) i s an ent i t y or Nat ur al Per son sat i sf yi ng t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Indust r y
def i ni t i on, t he appr opr i at e per i od i s f r om Apr i l 21, 2011 t hr ough Apr i l 20, 2012.
39
For cl ai mant s w hose empl oyer (s) i s an ent i t y or Nat ur al Per son sat i sf yi ng t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Indust r y
def i ni t i on, t he appr opr i at e per i od i s f r om Apr i l 21, 2010 t hr ough Apr i l 20, 2011.
02888
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 49 of 53
49
det ai l t o per mi t t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or t o calcul at e t he cl aimant s
l ost hour s of w or k and l ost ear ni ngs f r om such empl oyment dur i ng
such per i od.
2) A speci f i c expl anat ion of how (i ) t he r educt ion of cl aimant s hour s of
w or k i dent i f i ed, or (i i ) t he w i t hdr aw al of , or (i i i ) t he f ai l ur e t o
ext end, an of f er of employment w as due t o or r esul t ing f r om t he
DWH Spi l l .
The number of af f i davit s submi t t ed by an empl oyer on behal f of t he cl ai mant and any
ot her cl aimant s shal l be moni t or ed by t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or f or r easonabl eness i n
l i ght of t he employer s oper at i ons. For exampl e, i t woul d be ant i ci pat ed t hat a 10-r oom
mot el w oul d have appr oximat el y f ive f ul l -t i me equival ent empl oyees, or t hat a 50-seat
di ner -st yl e r est aur ant would have appr oximat el y f ive f ul l -t i me equi val ent ser ver s.
B. Int er vi ew s
1. The Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l have t he r i ght t o i nt er vi ew al l cl ai mant s and r elat ed
employer (s) i n t hi s Cat egor y IV cl aimi ng l ost ear ni ngs of $7,500 or mor e and up t o 25%
of al l ot her cl aimant s w i t hin t hi s Cat egor y IV and t hei r suppor t i ng empl oyer (s), i n
accor dance w i t h t he pr ovi si ons of t he Addendum Regar di ng Int er vi ew s of Cl ai mant
Al l egi ng Economi c Loss.
40
2. In addi t i on, and not w i t hst andi ng t he pr ovi si ons of Sect i on IV.B.1, t he Cl ai ms
Admi ni st r at or shal l have t he r i ght t o i nt er vi ew any empl oyer w ho submit s an Empl oyer
Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement on behal f of mor e clai mant s t han t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or
det er mi nes i s r easonabl e f or t he posit i on f or w hi ch t he empl oyer is pr ovi di ng t he
Empl oyer Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement , i n accor dance wi t h t he pr ovi sions of t he
Addendum Regar di ng Int er vi ew s of Cl ai mant Al l egi ng Economi c Loss.
C. Descr i pt i on Of Compensat i on Cal cul at i on
The Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l det er mi ne t he Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on amount based on
t he t ot al i t y of t he i nf or mat i on pr ovi ded by t he cl aimant and hi s or her employer (s), i ncl udi ng t he
sw or n Cl ai m For m, Cl ai mant Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement , Empl oyer Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement (s),
i nt er vi ew s (i f any), and/ or any suppl ement al i nf or mat i on t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or may r equi r e
t he cl aimant t o pr ovi de t o suppor t t he cl aim, and/ or any ot her i nf or mat i on t he Cl ai ms
Admi ni st r at or may det er mi ne t o be r el evant and r el i abl e (col l ect ively, t he Cl ai m Fi l e ). The
Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l r el y on hi s assessment of t he r el i abi l i t y and cr edi bi l i t y of t he Cl ai m
Fi l e i nf or mat i on and t he speci f i cs of any cl aimed economic loss i n det er mi ni ng t he cl aimant s
compensat ion, i f any, t o be pr ovi ded t o t he cl aimant .
40
In addi t i on, not hi ng i n t hi s Fr amew or k f or Indi vi dual Economi c Loss Cl ai ms shal l i n any w ay l i mi t t he r i ght and
obl i gat i on of t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or t o i nvest i gat e f ul l y al l suspi ci ons of f r audul ent conduct by or on behal f of
any cl ai mant , i ncl udi ng but not l i mi t ed t o conduct i ng any i nt er vi ew s and obt ai ni ng any document s t he Cl ai ms
Admi ni st r at or deems necessar y. Any such i nt er vi ew s w i l l not be i ncl uded i n t he 25% l i mi t set f or t h above.
02888
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 50 of 53
50
St ep 1: Cal cul at e Cl ai mant s Lost Ear ni ngs
In det er mi ni ng t he clai mant s l ost ear ni ngs f or t he Cl ai mi ng Job, t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or
shal l consi der t he f ol low i ng f act or s:
1. Pr i or Empl oyment Hi st or y: The ext ent t o w hi ch t he Cl ai m Fi l e est abl i shes t he
cl ai mant s pr e-DWH Spi l l empl oyment i n t he Cl ai mi ng Job, i ncl udi ng t he t ype of w or k
per f or med, w age r at e, and amount of t ime spent w or ki ng i n t he Cl ai mi ng Job.
2. Post -DWH Spi l l Ant i ci pat ed Empl oyment : The ext ent t o w hi ch t he Cl ai m Fi l e est abl i shes
t he cl aimant s post -DWH Spi l l expect ed employment i n t he Cl ai mi ng Job, i ncl udi ng t he
j ob descr i pt i on, w age r at e, and amount of t i me cl ai mant w as expect ed t o be empl oyed
i n t he Cl ai mi ng Job dur i ng t he per iod f r om Apr i l 21 t hr ough December 31, 2010,
41
and
w ages expect ed t o be ear ned i n t he Cl ai mi ng Job.
3. Post -DWH Spi l l Act ual Empl oyment : The ext ent t o whi ch t he Cl ai m Fi l e est abl i shes t he
cl ai mant s act ual post -DWH Spi l l employment i n t he Cl ai mi ng Job, i ncl udi ng t he j ob
descr i pt i on, w age r at e, amount of t ime cl aimant act ual l y w as empl oyed i n t he Cl ai mi ng
Job dur i ng t he per i od f r om Apr i l 21 t hr ough December 31, 2010,
42
and act ual ear ni ngs i n
t he Cl ai mi ng Job and any ot her empl oyment dur i ng t hat per iod.
4. Lost Ear ni ngs And Causat i on: The ext ent t o w hi ch t he Cl ai m Fi l e est abl i shes (a) a
r educt i on i n ant i ci pat ed empl oyment and ear ni ngs i n t he Cl ai mi ng Job dur i ng t he per iod
f r om Apr i l 21 t hr ough December 31, 2010,
43
and (b) t he ext ent t o w hi ch any such
r educt i on i n ant i ci pat ed empl oyment and ear ni ngs was due t o or r esul t i ng f r om t he
DWH Spi l l .
5. Cont i nued Empl oyment i n 2011: The ext ent t o w hi ch t he Cl ai m Fi l e est abl i shes t hat t he
cl ai mant w as empl oyed i n t he Cl ai mi ng Job or a simi l ar j ob i n 2011 and l i ved w i t hi n 60
mi l es of hi s pl ace of empl oyment .
Based on t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or s consi der at ion of t he t ot al it y of t he i nf or mat i on above, t he
Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l det er mi ne t he cl aimant s lost ear ni ngs f or t he per i od Apr i l 21
t hr ough December 31, 2010
44
up t o a cap of $20,000.
41
For cl ai mant s w hose empl oyer (s) i s an ent i t y or Nat ur al Per son sat i sf yi ng t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Indust r y
def i ni t i on, t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l consi der t he ext ent t o w hi ch t he cl ai mant has est abl i shed hi s or her
expect ed post -DWH Spi l l empl oyment i n t he Cl ai mi ng Job f or t he per i od Apr i l 21, 2010 t hr ough Apr i l 20, 2011.
42
For cl ai mant s w hose empl oyer (s) i s an ent i t y or Nat ur al Per son sat i sf yi ng t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Indust r y
def i ni t i on, t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l consi der t he ext ent t o w hi ch t he cl ai mant has est abl i shed hi s or h er
act ual post -DWH Spi l l empl oyment i n t he Cl ai mi ng Job f or t he per i od Apr i l 21, 2010 t hr ough Apr i l 20, 2011.
43
For cl ai mant s w hose empl oyer (s) i s an ent i t y or Nat ur al Per son sat i sf yi ng t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Indust r y
def i ni t i on, t he cl ai mant shal l est abl i sh t he cl ai mant s l ost ear ni ngs f or t he per i od Apr i l 21, 2010 t hr ough Apr i l 20,
2011.
44
For cl ai mant s w hose empl oyer (s) i s an ent i t y or Nat ur al Per son sat i sf yi ng t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Indust r y
def i ni t i on, t he cl ai mant shal l est abl i sh t he cl ai mant s expect ed post -DWH Spi l l empl oyment f or t he per i od Apr i l 21,
2010 t hr ough Apr i l 20, 2011.
028888
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 51 of 53
51
St ep 2: Appl y RTP, If Appl i cabl e
Onl y cl aimant s w ho, i n 2011, (1) cont i nued t o be employed i n a posi t ion t he same as, or
si mi l ar t o, t he Cl ai mi ng Job, and (2) st i l l l ived w i t hi n 60 mi l es of t hei r pl ace of empl oyment ,
shal l be el i gi bl e f or an RTP of 1.
If el i gi bl e, t he cl aimant s lost ear ni ngs shal l be mul t i pl i ed by t he RTP.
St ep 3: Det ermi ne Cl ai mant s Compensat i on
Deduct any Spi l l -Rel at ed Payment s f r om t he sum of St eps 1 and 2 t o det er mi ne cl ai mant s
compensat ion amount .
Cl ai mant s under t hi s Cat egor y IV shal l not be el i gi bl e t o r ecover Rei mbur sabl e Sear ch Cost s,
Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng Cost s or Empl oyment -Rel at ed Benef i t s Losses.
The f or mul a f or t he clai mant s compensat ion i s:
Cl ai mant s l ost ear ni ngs (not t o exceed $20,000) (f r om St ep 1)
+ (Cl ai mant s l ost ear ni ngs (not t o exceed $20,000) x RTP (i f any)) (f r om St ep 2)
+ One Ti me, Non-Recur r i ng Event Compensat i on: i f appl i cabl e, pr ovi ded,
how ever , t hat i n no event shal l t hi s amount exceed: ($20,000 l ess Cl ai mant s
l ost ear ni ngs f r om St ep 1)
- Spi l l -Rel at ed Payment s (i f appl i cabl e) (f r om St ep 3)
- VoO Set t l ement Of f set and/ or VoO Ear ned Income Of f set (i f any)
02888
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 52 of 53
52
One Ti me Loss Addendum
A One Ti me, Non-Recur r i ng Event shal l be def i ned as an event or sale t hat (i ) w oul d have occur r ed i n
t he Cl ai mi ng Job bet w een Apr i l 21, 2010 and December 31, 2010, and (i i ) had not been i ncl uded i n t he
Indi vi dual s i ncome f r om t he Cl ai mi ng Job i n 2007, 2008 or 2009, and (i i i ) was cancel ed due t o or
r esul t i ng f r om DWH Spi l l .
An Indi vi dual asser t i ng l ost ear ni ngs due t o cancel l at ion of a One Ti me, Non-Recur r i ng Event must
pr ovi de document at i on and est abl i sh causat i on as f ol low s:
Document at i on and Causat i on
The cl aimant shal l pr ovi de al l of t he f ol l ow i ng:
1. Copy of cont r act f or t he One Ti me, Non-Recur r i ng Event schedul ed t o occur dur i ng t he per iod
Apr i l 21, 2010 and December 31, 2010, and cancel ed subsequent t o Apr i l 21, 2010. The cont r act
must i ndi cat e t he dat e, t ime and det ai l s of t he event .
2. Document at ion suf f i ci ent t o est abl i sh t he l ost ear ni ngs, i ncome or pr of i t , t o t he cl ai mant i n
r espect of t he One Ti me, Non-Recur r i ng Event , i ncl uding but not l imi t ed t o a Sw or n Wr i t t en
St at ement by t he par t y r esponsi bl e f or cancel i ng t he cont r act f or t he One Ti me, Non-Recur r i ng
Event .
3. Document at ion est abl i shi ng t hat t he l ost ear ni ngs, i ncome or pr of i t , i dent i f i ed i n 2 i s (a) f or
cl ai mant s w i t h mor e t han t en sal es per year i n t he Base Year (s), equal t o or gr eat er t han 10% of
t he cl aimant s ear ni ngs i n t he Base Year (s) f r om t he Cl ai mi ng Job, or (b) f or cl aimant s w i t h
f ew er t han t en sal es per year i n t he Base Year (s), gr eat er t han t wo t imes t he cl aimant s aver age
commissi on on al l t r ansact i ons i n t he Base Year (s) f r om t he Cl ai mi ng Job.
4. Document at ion suf f i ci ent t o est abl i sh t hat (a) t he cancel l at ion of t he One Ti me, Non-Recur r i ng
Event w as due t o or r esul t ing f r om t he DWH Spi l l , i ncludi ng but not l imi t ed t o a Sw or n Wr i t t en
St at ement by t he par t y r esponsi bl e f or cancel i ng t he cont r act f or t he One Ti me, Non-Recur r i ng
Event , and (b) t he cancel l at i on w as a loss t o cl ai mant .
5. Document at ion est abl i shi ng t hat t he l ost ear ni ngs, i ncome or pr of i t , ar e not dupl icat i ve of
amount s quant i f i ed as Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs i n St ep 6 of t he Compensat i on Cal cul at i on f or
Cat egor ies I, II or III.
6. It emi zed commi ssion st at ement s f or 2007, 2008 and 2009, i f appl i cabl e.
Compensat i on f or t he One Ti me, Non-Recur r i ng Event
Compensat ion f or t he One Ti me, Non-Recur r i ng Event shal l equal t he l ost ear ni ngs f or t he One Ti me,
Non-Recur r i ng Event , and no RTP shal l be appl i cabl e t o t he cor r espondi ng l oss.
0288 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-16 Filed 04/18/12 Page 53 of 53
8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-17 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 27
INDIVIDUAL ECONOM IC LOSS CLAIM S: EXAM PLES
1.
2.
3.
The f ol l ow i ng Appendi ces gi ve exampl es of Indi vi dual Economi c Loss Cat egor i es I-III . In each
exampl e, t he Compensat i on Per i od sel ect ed i s t he per i od bet w een Apr i l 21, 2010 and December
31, 2010 t hat pr oduces maxi mum Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs f or t hat exampl e. In each exampl e,
Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on f or cl ai mai nt s w ho est abl i sh causat i on depends pr i mar i l y on t he
f ol l ow i ng f act or s:
Component s of Lost Ear ni ngs: Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs i s cal cul at ed as t he sum of t w o
f act or s: (i ) any decr ease i n ear ni ngs dur i ng t he cl ai mant sel ect ed Compensat i on Per i od
compar ed t o t he same per i od(s) i n t he Base Year (s), and (i i ) any expect ed gr ow t h i n ear ni ngs
dur i ng t he same Compensat i on Per i od r el at i ve t o t he Base Year (s). Thus, t he cl ai mant
sel ect ed Compensat i on Per i od i s r el evant f or bot h f act or s, and cl ai mant s w i l l w ant t o
consi der bot h f act or s i n sel ect i ng t hei r Compensat i on Per i od.
Lengt h and Dur at i on Of Economi c Loss (Compensat i on Per i od): Each cl ai mant sel ect s a
per i od of l oss (or Compensat i on Per i od) r ef l ect i ng t he per i od i n w hi ch t he cl ai mant ' s Act ual
Ear ni ngs w er e l ess t han Expect ed Ear ni ngs due t o or r esul t i ng f r om t he DWH Spi l l . The
Compensat i on Per i od must consi st of at l east 90 consecut i ve days bet w een Apr i l 21, 2010
and December 31, 2010, and may ext end f or t he ent i r e per i od, at t he cl ai mant ' s el ect i on. In
sel ect i ng a Compensat i on Per i od, cl ai mant shoul d be aw ar e t hat any per i od w hen i ncome
(i ) f el l , (i i ) st ayed t he same, or (i i i ) demonst r at ed a per cent age i ncr ease l ow er t han t he
appl i cabl e Gr ow t h Fact or (s) (per cent ages), w i l l r esul t i n Act ual Ear ni ngs bei ng l ess t han
Expect ed Ear ni ngs, and t her ef or e a hi gher l evel of l oss and compensat i on.
Locat i on and Indust r y Of Economi c Loss: Cl ai mant s i ncur r i ng economi c l oss due t o or
r esul t i ng f r om t he DWH Spi l l may al so r ecei ve Ri sk Tr ansf er Pr emi um (RTP) compensat i on
based upon t he i ndust r y and l ocat i on of t hei r l oss. The RTP i s cal cul at ed as a mul t i pl e of t he
cl ai mant ' s l oss dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od.
Int r oduct i on t o Exampl e Appendi ces A t hr ough F
028 82
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-17 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 27
Dat aSubmi t t edbyCl ai mant
2009 2010
Annual Ear ni ngsper TaxInf or mat i onDocument s 61,500 $ 47,250 $
PayPer i odEar ni ngs
Januar y 5,000 $ 5,250 $
Febr uar y 5,000 $ 5,250 $
M ar ch 5,000 $ 5,250 $
Apr i l 5,000 $ 5,250 $
M ay 5,000 $ 5,250 $
June 5,000 $ 5,250 $
Jul y 5,250 $ 5,250 $
August 5,250 $ 5,250 $
Sept ember 5,250 $ 5,250 $
Oct ober 5,250 $ $
November 5,250 $ $
December 5,250 $ $
Tot al Ear ni ngs 61,500 $ 47,250 $
St ep1:Cl ai mant Sel ect sCompensat i onPer i od& BaseYear
St ep2:Det er mi neBenchmar kPer i odEar ni ngsCor r espondi ngt ot heCompensat i onPer i od
Benchmar kPer i odEar ni ngs(Jul y1Dec31,2009) 31,500 $
Cl ai mant hassel ect edJul y1,2010t hr oughDecember 31,2010ast heCompensat i onPer i od,andchosen
2009ast heBaseYear .
Exampl eof Compensat i onCal cul at i on:Cat egor yIIndi vi dual
Cat egor yIIndi vi dual w i t hPayPer i odEar ni ngsDocument at i on:Int hi sexampl e,t hecl ai mant haspassedt he
causat i onr equi r ement sandpr ovi desTaxInf or mat i onDocument sdemonst r at i ngannual ear ni ngs,andal so
pr ovi desPayPer i odEar ni ngsDocument at i onsuf f i ci ent t oest abl i shmont hl y/ payper i odear ni ngs,al l ow i ngf or
t hecal cul at i onof aCl ai mant Speci f i cGr ow t hFact or .Thi scl ai mant w asasal ar i edw or ker at ar esor t i nZoneA
w hol ost hi sj obat t heendof Sept ember 2010.Becauset hecl ai mant i sasal ar i edw or ker ,noIndust r yGr ow t h
Fact or i sappl i cabl e.
Appendi xA1
B
e
n
c
h
m
a
r
k
P
e
r
i
o
d
C
o
m
p
e
n
s
a
t
i
o
n
P
e
r
i
o
d
Benchmar kPer i odear ni ngsar et heact ual ear ni ngsdur i ngt heper i odof t heBaseYear of t hesamel engt h
anddat escor r espondi ngt ot heCompensat i onPer i od.Gi vent hesel ect i oni nSt ep1,t heBenchmar kPer i od
ear ni ngsequal t heear ni ngsbet w eenJul y1,2009andDecember 31,2009,andar ecal cul at edasf ol l ow s:
028 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-17 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 27
Exampl eof Compensat i onCal cul at i on:Cat egor yIIndi vi dual
Appendi xA1
St ep3:Det er mi neEar ni ngsGr ow t hFact or (s)
2009 2010
Januar yApr i l Ear ni ngs 20,000 $ [ a] 21,000 $ [ b]
Cal cul at edCl ai mant Speci f i cGr ow t hFact or 5.0% [ c] =([ b] [ a] )/ [ a]
5.0%=($21,000$20,000)/ $20,000
[ c] =([ b] [ a] )/ [ a]
Cl ai mant Speci f i cGr ow t hFact or (maxof +10%,mi nof 1.5%) 5.0% [ d]
St ep4:Cal cul at eExpect edEar ni ngs
Benchmar kPer i odEar ni ngs(f r omSt ep2) 31,500 $ [ e]
Cl ai mant Speci f i cGr ow t hRat e(i f appl i cabl ef r omSt ep3) 5.0% =[ d]
Indust r yGr ow t hFact or(i f hour l y,seeSt ep3) n/ a [ f ]
Expect edEar ni ngsf or t heCompensat i onPer i od 33,075 $ [ g] =[ e] * (1+[ d] +[ f ] )
$33,075=$31,500x(1+0.05+0)
[ g] =[ e] x(1+[ d] +[ f ] )
St ep5:Det er mi neAct ual Ear ni ngsi nt heCompensat i onPer i od
Act ual Ear ni ngs(Jul y1December 31,2010) 15,750 $ [ h]
St ep6:Det er mi neCl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs
Lost Ear ni ngs 17,325 $ [ i ] =[ g] [ h]
Expect edEar ni ngsequal sBenchmar kPer i odear ni ngs(cal cul at edi nSt ep2)i ncr easedbyt heappl i cabl e
Gr ow t hFact or s(f r omSt ep3).
Act ual Ear ni ngsi nt hecl ai mant sel ect edCompensat i onPer i odi nt hi sexampl ei ncl udesal l ear ni ngsbet w een
t heper i odsel ect edbyt heCl ai mant i nSt ep1,Jul y1,2010t hr oughDecember 31,2010.
Lost Ear ni ngsi st hedi f f er encebet w eent heExpect edEar ni ngs(St ep4)andt heAct ual Ear ni ngs(St ep5)over
t heCompensat i onPer i od.
TheCl ai mant haspr ovi dedpayper i oddet ai l ,andaCl ai mant Speci f i cGr ow t hFact or canbecal cul at edusi ng
Januar yt hr oughApr i l ear ni ngsi n2010andt heBaseYear .Indust r yGr ow t hFact or doesnot appl y
(Benchmar kPer i odear ni ngsar esal ar i ed).
$17,325=$33,075$15,750
[ i ] =[ g] [ h]
028 84
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-17 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 27
Exampl eof Compensat i onCal cul at i on:Cat egor yIIndi vi dual
Appendi xA1
St ep7:Cal cul at eFi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on
Lost Ear ni ngs(St ep6) 17,325 $ =[ i ]
+ Lost Ear ni ngsM ul t i pl i edbyOt her Indust r i esRTP(2.5i nZoneA) 43,313 $ [ j ] =[ i ] xRTP
=$17,325x2.5
+ Empl oyment Rel at edBenef i t sLosses 2,000 $ Gi venabove.
+ Rei mbur sabl eTr ai ni ngCost s 500 $ Gi venabove.
+ Rei mbur sabl eSear chCost s 500 $ Gi venabove.
Spi l l Rel at edPayment s (3,000) $ Gi venabove.
Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on 60,638 $
Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i oni ncl udesLost Ear ni ngsi ncr easedbyt heagr eeduponRi skTr ansf er Pr emi um
(ZoneATour i sm=2.5),t henadj ust edf or anyEmpl oyeeRel at edBenef i t sLoss(assume$2,000),any
Rei mbur sabl eTr ai ni ng& Sear chCost s(assume$500eachf or t r ai ni ngandsear ch)andanySpi l l Rel at ed
Payment s(assume$3,000).
028 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-17 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 27
Dat aSubmi t t edbyCl ai mant andReal l ocat i onof BonusEar ni ngs
2009Bonus
Incl udedi n
Year Pai d
2010Bonus
Incl udedi n
Year Pai d
2009No
Bonus
2010No
Bonus
2009Bonus
Al l ocat edt o
Year Ear ned*
2010Bonus
Al l ocat edt o
Year Ear ned* *
Regul ar Pay 61,500 $ 47,250 $ 61,500 $ 47,250 $ 61,500 $ 47,250 $
Tot al BonusesPai d 5,000 $ 6,000 $ 6,000 $ $
Tot al Annual Ear ni ngs 66,500 $ 53,250 $ 61,500 $ 47,250 $ 67,500 $ 47,250 $
PayPer i odEar ni ngs
Januar y 5,000 $ 5,250 $ 5,000 $ 5,250 $ 5,500 $ 5,250 $
Febr uar y 5,000 $ 5,250 $ 5,000 $ 5,250 $ 5,500 $ 5,250 $
M ar ch 10,000 $ 11,250 $ 5,000 $ 5,250 $ 5,500 $ 5,250 $
Apr i l 5,000 $ 5,250 $ 5,000 $ 5,250 $ 5,500 $ 5,250 $
M ay 5,000 $ 5,250 $ 5,000 $ 5,250 $ 5,500 $ 5,250 $
June 5,000 $ 5,250 $ 5,000 $ 5,250 $ 5,500 $ 5,250 $
Jul y 5,250 $ 5,250 $ 5,250 $ 5,250 $ 5,750 $ 5,250 $
August 5,250 $ 5,250 $ 5,250 $ 5,250 $ 5,750 $ 5,250 $
Sept ember 5,250 $ 5,250 $ 5,250 $ 5,250 $ 5,750 $ 5,250 $
Oct ober 5,250 $ $ 5,250 $ $ 5,750 $ $
November 5,250 $ $ 5,250 $ $ 5,750 $ $
December 5,250 $ $ 5,250 $ $ 5,750 $ $
Tot al Ear ni ngs 66,500 $ 53,250 $ 61,500 $ 47,250 $ 67,500 $ 47,250 $
* $6,000bonusr ecei vedi n2010r el at est o2009per f or manceandi st her ef or eal l ocat edevenl yacr osst hemont hsof 2009.
* * Nobonusw asr ecei vedf or cal endar year 2010,sonobonusear ni ngsar eal l ocat edt o2010.
St ep1:Cl ai mant Sel ect sCompensat i onPer i od& BaseYear
St ep2:Det er mi neBenchmar kPer i odEar ni ngsCor r espondi ngt ot heCompensat i onPer i od
Benchmar kPer i odEar ni ngs(Jul y1Dec31,2009) 34,500 $
St ep3:Det er mi neEar ni ngsGr ow t hFact or (s)
2009No
Bonus
2010No
Bonus
Januar yApr i l Ear ni ngs 20,000 $ [ a] 21,000 $ [ b]
Cal cul at edCl ai mant Speci f i cGr ow t hFact or 5.0% [ c] =([ b] [ a] )/ [ a]
Cl ai mant Speci f i cGr ow t hFact or (maxof +10%,mi nof 1.5%) 5.0% [ d]
5.0%=($21,000$20,000)/ $20,000
[ c] =([ b] [ a] )/ [ a]
Cat egor yIIndi vi dual w i t hPayPer i odEar ni ngsDocument at i on:Int hi sexampl e,t hecl ai mant haspassedt hecausat i onr equi r ement sandpr ovi desTaxInf or mat i on
Document sdemonst r at i ngannual ear ni ngs,andal sopr ovi desPayPer i odEar ni ngsDocument at i onsuf f i ci ent t oest abl i shmont hl y/ payper i odear ni ngs,al l ow i ngf or t he
cal cul at i onof aCl ai mant Speci f i cGr ow t hFact or .Thi scl ai mant w asasal ar i edw or ker at ar esor t i nZoneAw hol ost hi sj obat t heendof Sept ember 2010.Becauset he
cl ai mant i sasal ar i edw or ker ,noIndust r yGr ow t hFact or i sappl i cabl e.Thecl ai mant ' sdocument at i oni ndi cat edt hat t hecl ai mant r ecei vedabonusi nM ar ch2009r el at ed
t ocal endar year 2008,andabonusi nM ar ch2010r el at edt ocal endar year 2009.Becauset hecl ai mant l ost hi sj ob,nobonusw asr ecei vedf or cal endar year 2010.
G
r
o
w
t
h
R
a
t
e
G
r
o
w
t
h
R
a
t
e
Cl ai mant hassel ect edJul y1,2010t hr oughDecember 31,2010ast heCompensat i onPer i od,andchosen2009ast heBaseYear .
Benchmar kPer i odear ni ngsar et heact ual ear ni ngsdur i ngt heper i odof t heBaseYear of t hesamel engt handdat escor r espondi ngt ot heCompensat i onPer i od.
Gi vent hesel ect i oni nSt ep1,t heBenchmar kPer i odear ni ngsequal t heear ni ngsbet w eenJul y1,2009andDecember 31,2009,andar ecal cul at edasf ol l ow s(i ncl usi ve
of t heal l ocat edbonus):
TheCl ai mant haspr ovi dedpayper i oddet ai l ,andaCl ai mant Speci f i cGr ow t hFact or canbecal cul at edusi ngJanuar yt hr oughApr i l ear ni ngsi n2010andt heBaseYear
(excl udi nganybonusamount s).Indust r yGr ow t hFact or doesnot appl y(Benchmar kPer i odear ni ngsar esal ar i ed).
Appendi xA2
B
e
n
c
h
m
a
r
k
P
e
r
i
o
d
C
o
m
p
e
n
s
a
t
i
o
n
P
e
r
i
o
d
Exampl eof Compensat i onCal cul at i on:Cat egor yIIndi vi dual w i t hBonus
028 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-17 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 27
Appendi xA2
Exampl eof Compensat i onCal cul at i on:Cat egor yIIndi vi dual w i t hBonus
St ep4:Cal cul at eExpect edEar ni ngs
Benchmar kPer i odEar ni ngs(f r omSt ep2) 34,500 $ [ e]
Cl ai mant Speci f i cGr ow t hRat e(i f appl i cabl ef r omSt ep3) 5.0% =[ d]
Indust r yGr ow t hFact or (i f hour l y,seeSt ep3) n/ a [ f ]
Expect edEar ni ngsf or t heCompensat i onPer i od 36,225 $ [ g] =[ e] * (1+[ d] +[ f ] )
St ep5:Det er mi neAct ual Ear ni ngsi nt heCompensat i onPer i od
Act ual Ear ni ngs(Jul y1December 31,2010) 15,750 $ [ h]
St ep6:Det er mi neCl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs
Lost Ear ni ngs 20,475 $ [ i ] =[ g] [ h]
St ep7:Cal cul at eFi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on
Lost Ear ni ngs(St ep6) 20,475 $ =[ i ]
+ Lost Ear ni ngsM ul t i pl i edbyOt her Indust r i esRTP(2.5i nZoneA) 51,188 $ [ j ] =[ i ] xRTP
=$20,475x2 5
+ Empl oyment Rel at edBenef i t sLosses 2,000 $ Gi venabove.
+ Rei mbur sabl eTr ai ni ngCost s 500 $ Gi venabove.
+ Rei mbur sabl eSear chCost s 500 $ Gi venabove.
Spi l l Rel at edPayment s (3,000) $ Gi venabove.
Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on 71,663 $
Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i oni ncl udesLost Ear ni ngsi ncr easedbyt heagr eeduponRi skTr ansf er Pr emi um(ZoneATour i sm=2.5),t henadj ust edf or anyEmpl oyee
Rel at edBenef i t sLoss(assume$2,000),anyRei mbur sabl eTr ai ni ng& Sear chCost s(assume$500eachf or t r ai ni ngandsear ch)andanySpi l l Rel at edPayment s
(assume$3,000).
$36,225=$34,500x(1+0.05+0)
[ g] =[ e] x(1+[ d] +[ f ] )
$20,475=$36,225$15,750
[ i ] =[ g] [ h]
Expect edEar ni ngsequal sBenchmar kPer i odear ni ngs(cal cul at edi nSt ep2)i ncr easedbyt heappl i cabl eGr ow t hFact or s(f r omSt ep3).
Act ual Ear ni ngsi nt hecl ai mant sel ect edCompensat i onPer i odi nt hi sexampl ei ncl udesal l ear ni ngsbet w eent heper i odsel ect edbyt heCl ai mant i nSt ep1,Jul y1,2010
t hr oughDecember 31,2010.
Lost Ear ni ngsi st hedi f f er encebet w eent heExpect edEar ni ngs(St ep4)andt heAct ual Ear ni ngs(St ep5)over t heCompensat i onPer i od.
028 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-17 Filed 04/18/12 Page 7 of 27
Dat aSubmi t t edbyCl ai mant andReal l ocat i onof Commi ssi onEar ni ngs
2009
Commi ssi on
Incl udedasPai d
2010
Commi ssi on
Incl udedas
Pai d
2009
Commi ssi on
Al l ocat edt o
Per i odEar ned*
2010
Commi ssi on
Al l ocat edt o
Per i odEar ned*
Regul ar Pay 61,500 $ 47,250 $ Regul ar Pay 61,500 $ 47,250 $
Commi ssi onPai di n: Commi ssi onRel at edt o:
Januar y 1,000 $ 1,250 $ Januar yM ar ch 1,250 $ 1,500 $
Apr i l 1,250 $ 1,500 $ Apr i l June 1,250 $ 1,500 $
Jul y 1,250 $ 1,500 $ Jul yOct ober 1,250 $ $
Oct ober 1,250 $ $ Oct ober December 1,250 $ $
Tot al Commi ssi ons* 4,750 $ 4,250 $ Tot al Commi ssi ons* 5,000 $ 3,000 $
Tot al Annual Ear ni ngs 66,250 $ 51,500 $ 66,500 $ 50,250 $
PayPer i odEar ni ngs
Januar y 6,000 $ 6,500 $ 5,417 $ 5,750 $
Febr uar y 5,000 $ 5,250 $ 5,417 $ 5,750 $
M ar ch 5,000 $ 5,250 $ 5,417 $ 5,750 $
Apr i l 6,250 $ 6,750 $ 5,417 $ 5,750 $
M ay 5,000 $ 5,250 $ 5,417 $ 5,750 $
June 5,000 $ 5,250 $ 5,417 $ 5,750 $
Jul y 6,500 $ 6,750 $ 5,667 $ 5,250 $
August 5,250 $ 5,250 $ 5,667 $ 5,250 $
Sept ember 5,250 $ 5,250 $ 5,667 $ 5,250 $
Oct ober 6,500 $ $ 5,667 $ $
November 5,250 $ $ 5,667 $ $
December 5,250 $ $ 5,667 $ $
Tot al Ear ni ngs 66,250 $ 51,500 $ 66,500 $ 50,250 $
*
St ep1:Cl ai mant Sel ect sCompensat i onPer i od& BaseYear
St ep2:Det er mi neBenchmar kPer i odEar ni ngsCor r espondi ngt ot heCompensat i onPer i od
Benchmar kPer i odEar ni ngs(Jul y1Dec31,2009) 34,000 $
Commi ssi onsw er epai dquar t er l y.Commi ssi onspai di n2009w er e$1,250each.Thecommi ssi onpai di nJanuar yr el at edt oOct ober December 2008,t he
commi ssi onpai di nApr i l 2009r el at edt oJanuar yM ar ch2009,t hecommi ssi onpai di nJul y2009r el at edt oApr i l June2009,andt hecommi ssi onpai di nOct ober
2009r el at edt oJul yt hr oughSept ember 2009.Commi ssi onspai di n2010w er eal so$1,500each.Thecom m i ssi onpai di nJanuar y2010r el at edt oOct ober
December 2009,t hecommi ssi onpai di nApr i l 2010r el at edt oJanuar yM ar ch2010,andt hecommi ssi onpai di nJul y2010r el at edt oApr i l June2010.The
cl ai mant w ast er mi nat edi nSept ember 2010anddi dnot r ecei veanyaddi t i onal commi ssi ons.
Cl ai mant hassel ect edJul y1,2010t hr oughDecember 31,2010ast heCompensat i onPer i od,andchosen2009ast heBaseYear .
Benchmar kPer i odear ni ngsar et heact ual ear ni ngsdur i ngt heper i odof t heBaseYear of t hesamel engt handdat escor r espondi ngt ot heCompensat i on
Per i od.Gi vent hesel ect i oni nSt ep1,t heBenchmar kPer i odear ni ngsequal t heear ni ngsbet w eenJul y1,2009andDecember 31,2009,andar ecal cul at edas
f ol l ow s(i ncl usi veof t heal l ocat edcommi ssi ons):
Appendi xA3
Exampl eof Compensat i onCal cul at i on:Cat egor yIIndi vi dual w i t hCommi ssi ons
Cat egor yIIndi vi dual w i t hPayPer i odEar ni ngsDocument at i on:Int hi sexampl e,t hecl ai mant haspassedt hecausat i onr equi r ement sandpr ovi desTaxInf or mat i on
Document sdemonst r at i ngannual ear ni ngs,andal sopr ovi desPayPer i odEar ni ngsDocument at i onsuf f i ci ent t oest abl i shmont hl y/ payper i odear ni ngs,al l ow i ngf or
t hecal cul at i onof aCl ai mant Speci f i cGr ow t hFact or .Thi scl ai mant w asaw or ker at ar esor t i nZoneAw hor ecei vedasal ar ypl usquar t er l ycommi ssi ons,andw ho
l ost hi sj obat t heendof Sept ember 2010.Becauset hecl ai mant i sasal ar i edw or ker ,noIndust r yGr ow t hFact or i sappl i cabl e.
G
r
o
w
t
h
R
a
t
e
G
r
o
w
t
h
R
a
t
e
B
e
n
c
h
m
a
r
k
P
e
r
i
o
d
C
o
m
p
e
n
s
a
t
i
o
n
P
e
r
i
o
d
028 88
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-17 Filed 04/18/12 Page 8 of 27
Appendi xA3
Exampl eof Compensat i onCal cul at i on:Cat egor yIIndi vi dual w i t hCommi ssi ons
St ep3:Det er mi neEar ni ngsGr ow t hFact or (s)
2009Commi ssi on
Al l ocat edt oPer i od
Ear ned*
2010
Commi ssi on
Al l ocat edt o
Per i odEar ned*
Januar yApr i l Ear ni ngs 21,667 $ [ a] 23,000 $ [ b]
Cal cul at edCl ai mant Speci f i cGr ow t hFact or 6.2% [ c] =([ b] [ a] )/ [ a]
Cl ai mant Speci f i cGr ow t hFact or (maxof +10%,mi nof 1.5%) 6.2% [ d]
St ep4:Cal cul at eExpect edEar ni ngs
Benchmar kPer i odEar ni ngs(f r omSt ep2) 34,000 $ [ e]
Cl ai mant Speci f i cGr ow t hRat e(i f appl i cabl ef r omSt ep3) 6.2% =[ d]
Indust r yGr ow t hFact or (i f hour l y,seeSt ep3) n/ a [ f ]
Expect edEar ni ngsf or t heCompensat i onPer i od 36,108 $ [ g] =[ e] * (1+[ d] +[ f ] )
St ep5:Det er mi neAct ual Ear ni ngsi nt heCompensat i onPer i od
Act ual Ear ni ngs(Jul y1December 31,2010) 15,750 $ [ h]
St ep6:Det er mi neCl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs
Lost Ear ni ngs 20,358 $ [ i ] =[ g] [ h]
St ep7:Cal cul at eFi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on
Lost Ear ni ngs(St ep6) 20,358 $ =[ i ]
+ Lost Ear ni ngsM ul t i pl i edbyOt her Indust r i esRTP(2.5i nZoneA) 50,895 $ [ j ] =[ i ] xRTP
=$20,342x2 5
+ Empl oyment Rel at edBenef i t sLosses 2,000 $ Gi venabove.
+ Rei mbur sabl eTr ai ni ngCost s 500 $ Gi venabove.
+ Rei mbur sabl eSear chCost s 500 $ Gi venabove.
Spi l l Rel at edPayment s (3,000) $ Gi venabove.
Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on 71,253 $
Act ual Ear ni ngsi nt hecl ai mant sel ect edCompensat i onPer i odi nt hi sexampl ei ncl udesal l ear ni ngsbet w eent heper i odsel ect edbyt heCl ai mant i nSt ep1,Jul y
1,2010t hr oughDecember 31,2010.
Lost Ear ni ngsi st hedi f f er encebet w eent heExpect edEar ni ngs(St ep4)andt heAct ual Ear ni ngs(St ep5)over t heCompensat i onPer i od.
$20,342=$36,092$15,750
[ i ] =[ g] [ h]
Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i oni ncl udesLost Ear ni ngsi ncr easedbyt heagr eeduponRi skTr ansf er Pr emi um(ZoneATour i sm=2.5),t henadj ust edf or any
Empl oyeeRel at edBenef i t sLoss(assume$2,000),anyRei mbur sabl eTr ai ni ng& Sear chCost s(assume$500eachf or t r ai ni ngandsear ch)andanySpi l l Rel at ed
Payment s(assume$3,000).
TheCl ai mant haspr ovi dedpayper i oddet ai l ,andaCl ai mant Speci f i cGr ow t hFact or canbecal cul at edusi ngJanuar yt hr oughApr i l ear ni ngsi n2010andt heBase
Year (i ncl udi ngcommi ssi ons).Indust r yGr ow t hFact or doesnot appl y(Benchmar kPer i odear ni ngsar esal ar i ed).
6.2%=($23,000$21,667)/ $23,000
[ c] =([ b] [ a] )/ [ a]
Expect edEar ni ngsequal sBenchmar kPer i odear ni ngs(cal cul at edi nSt ep2)i ncr easedbyt heappl i cabl eGr ow t hFact or s(f r omSt ep3).
$36,092=$34,000x(1+0 062+0)
[ g] =[ e] x(1+[ d] +[ f ] )
028 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-17 Filed 04/18/12 Page 9 of 27
Dat a Submi t t ed by Cl ai mant
2009 2010
Annual Ear ni ngs per Tax Inf or mat i on Document s 61,500 $ 45,950 $
Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs (Per i od Endi ng...)
Januar y 15 - 2,600 $
Januar y 31 5,000 $ 2,650 $
Febr uar y 15 - 2,550 $
Febr uar y 28 5,000 $ 2,300 $
M ar ch 15 - 2,350 $
M ar ch 31 5,000 $ 2,550 $
Apr i l 15 - 2,600 $
Apr i l 30 5,000 $ 2,700 $
M ay 15 - 2,800 $
M ay 31 5,000 $ 2,850 $
June 15 - 2,900 $
June 30 5,000 $ 1,750 $
Jul y 15 - $ 1,400 $
Jul y 31 5,250 $ 1,300 $
August 15 - $ 1,200 $
August 31 5,250 $ 1,100 $
Sept ember 15 - $ 1,200 $
Sept ember 30 5,250 $ 1,240 $
Oct ober 15 - $ 1,320 $
Oct ober 31 5,250 $ 1,340 $
November 15 - $ 1,250 $
November 30 5,250 $ 1,200 $
December 15 - $ 1,300 $
December 31 5,250 $ 1,500 $
Tot al Ear ni ngs 61,500 $ 45,950 $
St ep 1: Cl ai mant Sel ect s Compensat i on Per i od & Base Year
St ep 2: Det er mi ne Benchmar k Per i od Ear ni ngs Cor r espondi ng t o t he Compensat i on Per i od
Ear ni ngs June 15-Jul y 1, 2009 2,500 $ (=$5,000 x 0.5 mont hs)
Ear ni ngs Jul y 1-December 31, 2009 31,500 $ (=$5,250 x 6 mont hs)
Tot al Benchmar k Per i od Ear ni ngs 34,000 $
St ep 3: Det er mi ne Ear ni ngs Gr ow t h Fact or (s)
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
C
o
m
p
e
n
s
a
t
i
o
n
P
e
r
i
o
d
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Benchmar k Per i od ear ni ngs ar e t he act ual ear ni ngs dur i ng t he per i od of t he Base Year of t he same l engt h and dat es as i n t he
Compensat i on Per i od. Gi ven t he sel ect i on i n St ep 1, t he Benchmar k Per i od ear ni ngs equal t he ear ni ngs bet w een June 15, 2009
and December 31, 2009, and ar e cal cul at ed as f ol l ow s:
Exampl e of Compensat i on Cal cul at i on: Cat egor y I Indi vi dual (Sal ar i ed)
Cat egor y I Indi vi dual w i t h Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on : In t hi s exampl e, t he cl ai mant has passed t he causat i on r equi r ement s
and pr ovi des Tax Inf or mat i on Document s demonst r at i ng annual ear ni ngs, and al so pr ovi des Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on
suf f i ci ent t o est abl i sh pay per i od ear ni ngs, al l ow i ng f or t he cal cul at i on of a Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or . Thi s cl ai mant w as a
sal ar i ed w or ker at a manuf act ur i ng f aci l i t y i n Zone A pai d mont hl y i n 2009 w ho changed j obs and began bei ng compensat ed usi ng an
hour l y w age f or w hi ch he w as pai d t w i ce mont hl y. Because t he cl ai mant w as a sal ar i ed w or ker i n t he Benchmar k Per i od , no Indust r y
Gr ow t h Fact or i s appl i cabl e.
Appendi x B
Cl ai mant has sel ect ed June 15, 2010 t hr ough December 31, 2010 as t he Compensat i on Per i od, and chosen 2009 as t he Base Year .
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
B
e
n
c
h
m
a
r
k
P
e
r
i
o
d
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
028 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-17 Filed 04/18/12 Page 10 of 27
Exampl e of Compensat i on Cal cul at i on: Cat egor y I Indi vi dual (Sal ar i ed)
Appendi x B
2009 2010
Januar y - Apr i l Ear ni ngs 20,000 $ [ a] 20,300 $ [ b]
Cal cul at ed Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or 1.5% [ c] =([ b] -[ a] )/ [ a]
1.5% = ($20,300 - $20,000)/ $20,000
[ c] = ([ b] - [ a] ) / [ a]
Sel ect ed Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or (max of +10%, mi n of -1.5%) 1.5% [ d]
St ep 4: Cal cul at e Expect ed Ear ni ngs
Benchmar k Per i od Ear ni ngs (f r om St ep 2) 34,000 $ [ e]
Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Rat e (i f appl i cabl e f r om St ep 3) 1.5% = [ d]
Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or (i f hour l y, see St ep 3) n/ a [ f ]
Expect ed Ear ni ngs f or t he Compensat i on Per i od 34,510 $ [ g] =[ e] * (1+[ d] +[ f ] )
$34,510 = $34,000 x (1 + 0.015 + 0)
[ g] = [ e] x (1 + [ d] + [ f ] )
St ep 5: Det er mi ne Act ual Ear ni ngs i n t he Compensat i on Per i od
Act ual Ear ni ngs (June 15-December 31, 2010) 17,100 $ [ h]
St ep 6: Det er mi ne Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs
Lost Ear ni ngs (St ep 4: Expect ed Ear ni ngs - St ep 5: Act ual Ear ni ngs) 17,410 $ [ i ] =[ g] -[ h]
$17,410 = $34,510 - $17,100
[ i ] = [ g] - [ h]
The Cl ai mant has pr ovi ded pay per i od det ai l , and a Cl ai mant Speci f i c Fact or can be cal cul at ed usi ng Januar y t hr ough Apr i l ear ni ngs
i n 2010 and t he Base Year . Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or does not appl y as Benchmar k Per i od ear ni ngs ar e sal ar i ed.
Expect ed Ear ni ngs equal s Benchmar k Per i od ear ni ngs (cal cul at ed i n St ep 2) i ncr eased by t he appl i cabl e Gr ow t h Fact or s (f r om St ep
3).
Act ual Ear ni ngs i n t he cl ai mant sel ect ed Compensat i on Per i od i n t hi s exampl e i ncl udes al l ear ni ngs i n t he 2010 per i od sel ect ed by
t he Cl ai mant i n St ep 1, June 15, 2010 t hr ough December 31, 2010.
Lost Ear ni ngs i s t he di f f er ence bet w een t he Expect ed Ear ni ngs (St ep 4) and t he Act ual Ear ni ngs (St ep 5) over t he Compensat i on
Per i od.
028
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-17 Filed 04/18/12 Page 11 of 27
Exampl e of Compensat i on Cal cul at i on: Cat egor y I Indi vi dual (Sal ar i ed)
Appendi x B
St ep 7: Cal cul at e Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on
Lost Ear ni ngs (St ep 6) 17,410 $ [ i ]
+ Lost Ear ni ngs M ul t i pl i ed by Ot her Indust r i es RTP (1.5 i n Zone A) 26,115 $ [ j ] =[ i ] x RTP
+ Empl oyment Rel at ed Benef i t s Losses 2,000 $ Gi ven above.
+ Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng Cost s - $ Gi ven above.
+ Rei mbur sabl e Sear ch Cost s - $ Gi ven above.
- Spi l l Rel at ed Payment s (3,000) $ Gi ven above.
Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on 42,525 $
Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on i ncl udes Lost Ear ni ngs i ncr eased by t he agr eed upon Ri sk Tr ansf er Pr emi um (Zone A Ot her
Indust r i es= 1.5), t hen adj ust ed f or any Empl oyment -Rel at ed Benef i t s Losses (assume $2,000), any Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng & Sear ch
Cost s (assume none) and any Spi l l Rel at ed Payment s (assume $3,000).
028 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-17 Filed 04/18/12 Page 12 of 27
Dat a Submi t t ed by Cl ai mant
2009-Job 1 2009-Job 2 2010-Job 1 2010-Job 2
Annual Ear ni ngs per Tax Inf o Docs 28,800 $ 17,720 $ 24,600 $ 15,320 $
Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs (Per i od Endi ng...)
Januar y 15 - 800 $ - 820 $
Januar y 31 2,300 $ 760 $ 2,400 $ 780 $
Febr uar y 15 - 680 $ - 660 $
Febr uar y 28 2,350 $ 660 $ 2,450 $ 700 $
M ar ch 15 - 640 $ - 740 $
M ar ch 31 2,130 $ 700 $ 2,600 $ 800 $
Apr i l 15 - 710 $ - 860 $
Apr i l 30 2,220 $ 730 $ 2,300 $ 860 $
M ay 15 - 720 $ - 740 $
M ay 31 2,450 $ 800 $ 2,200 $ 640 $
June 15 - 820 $ - 600 $
June 30 2,500 $ 800 $ 1,950 $ 540 $
Jul y 15 - 840 $ - 560 $
Jul y 31 2,650 $ 880 $ 1,800 $ 600 $
August 15 - 780 $ - 560 $
August 31 2,700 $ 770 $ 1,800 $ 600 $
Sept ember 15 - 810 $ - 620 $
Sept ember 30 2,250 $ 680 $ 1,740 $ 540 $
Oct ober 15 - 660 $ - 520 $
Oct ober 31 2,350 $ 640 $ 1,660 $ 480 $
November 15 - 660 $ - 400 $
November 30 2,400 $ 700 $ 1,800 $ 560 $
December 15 - 680 $ - 500 $
December 31 2,500 $ 800 $ 1,900 $ 640 $
Tot al Ear ni ngs 28,800 $ 17,720 $ 24,600 $ 15,320 $
St ep 1: Cl ai mant Sel ect s Compensat i on Per i od & Base Year
Appendi x C1
Cat egor y I Indi vi dual w i t h Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on: In t hi s exampl e, t he cl ai mant has passed t he causat i on
r equi r ement s and pr ovi des Tax Inf or mat i on Document s demonst r at i ng annual ear ni ngs, and al so pr ovi des Pay Per i od
Ear ni ngs Document at i on suf f i ci ent t o est abl i sh pay per i od ear ni ngs, al l ow i ng f or t he cal cul at i on of a Cl ai mant Speci f i c
Gr ow t h Fact or . Thi s cl ai mant w as an hour l y w or ker w i t h t w o Cl ai mi ng Jobs: one Zone B const r uct i on j ob (Job 1) w hi ch pai d
mont hl y and one Zone B r est aur ant j ob w hi ch pai d t w i ce mont hl y (Job 2). Because t he cl ai mant i s an hour l y w age w or ker , an
Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or i s appl i cabl e.
Exampl e of Compensat i on Cal cul at i on:
Cat egor y I Indi vi dual (M ul t i pl e Hour l y Cl ai mi ng Jobs)
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
C
o
m
p
e
n
s
a
t
i
o
n
P
e
r
i
o
d
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Cl ai mant has sel ect ed M ay 15, 2010 t hr ough December 31, 2010 as t he Compensat i on Per i od, and
chosen 2009 as t he Base Year .
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
B
e
n
c
h
m
a
r
k
P
e
r
i
o
d
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
028
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-17 Filed 04/18/12 Page 13 of 27
Appendi x C1
Exampl e of Compensat i on Cal cul at i on:
Cat egor y I Indi vi dual (M ul t i pl e Hour l y Cl ai mi ng Jobs)
St ep 2: Det er mi ne Benchmar k Per i od Ear ni ngs Cor r espondi ng t o t he Compensat i on Per i od
Job 1 Job 2
Ear ni ngs M ay 15-June 1, 2009 1,225 $ 800 $ (Job 1=$2,450 x 50%)
Ear ni ngs June 1-December 31, 2009 17,350 $ 10,520 $
Tot al Benchmar k Per i od Ear ni ngs 18,575 $ 11,320 $
St ep 3: Det er mi ne Ear ni ngs Gr ow t h Fact or (s)
2009-Job 1 2009-Job 2 2010-Job 1 2010-Job 2
Januar y - Apr i l Ear ni ngs 9,000 $ 5,680 $ [ a] 9,750 $ 6,220 $ [ b]
Cal cul at ed Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or 8.3% 9.5% [ c] =([ b] -[ a] )/ [ a]
Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or (max of +10%, mi n of -1.5%) 8.3% 9.5% [ d]
St ep 4: Cal cul at e Expect ed Ear ni ngs
2010-Job 1 2010-Job 2
Benchmar k Per i od Ear ni ngs (f r om St ep 2) 18,575 $ 11,320 $ [ e]
Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Rat e (i f appl i cabl e f r om St ep 3) 8.3% 9.5% = [ d]
Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or (i f hour l y, see St ep 3) 1.5% 1.5% [ f ]
Expect ed Ear ni ngs f or t he Compensat i on Per i od 20,402 $ 12,566 $ [ g] =[ e] * (1+[ d] +[ f ] )
The Cl ai mant has pr ovi ded Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on, and a Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or
can be cal cul at ed usi ng Januar y t hr ough Apr i l ear ni ngs i n 2010 and t he Base Year . Indust r y Gr ow t h
Fact or (1.5%) appl i es as Benchmar k Per i od ear ni ngs ar e pai d hour l y.
Expect ed Ear ni ngs equal s Benchmar k Per i od ear ni ngs (cal cul at ed i n St ep 2) i ncr eased by t he appl i cabl e Gr ow t h Fact or s
(f r om St ep 3).
8.3% = ($9,750 - $9,000)/ $9,000
9.5% = ($6,220 - $5,680)/ $5,680
[ c] = ([ b] - [ a] ) / [ a]
$20,402 = $18,575 x (1 + 0.083 + 0.015)
$12,566 = $11,320 x (1 + 0.095 + 0.015)
[ g] = [ e] x (1 + [ d] + [ f ] )
Benchmar k Per i od ear ni ngs ar e t he act ual ear ni ngs dur i ng t he per i od of t he Base Year of t he same l engt h
and dat es cor r espondi ng t o t he Compensat i on Per i od. Gi ven t he sel ect i on i n St ep 1, t he Benchmar k
Per i od ear ni ngs equal t he ear ni ngs bet w een M ay 15, 2009 and December 31, 2009, and ar e cal cul at ed as
f ol l ow s:
028 4
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-17 Filed 04/18/12 Page 14 of 27
Appendi x C1
Exampl e of Compensat i on Cal cul at i on:
Cat egor y I Indi vi dual (M ul t i pl e Hour l y Cl ai mi ng Jobs)
St ep 5: Det er mi ne Act ual Ear ni ngs i n t he Compensat i on Per i od
Act ual Ear ni ngs (M ay 15-December 31, 2010) 13,750 $ 8,360 $ [ h]
St ep 6: Det er mi ne Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs
Job 1 Job 2
Lost Ear ni ngs 6,652 $ 4,206 $ [ i ] =[ g] -[ h]
St ep 7: Cal cul at e Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on
Job 1 Job 2
Lost Ear ni ngs (St ep 6) 6,652 $ 4,206 $ [ i ]
+ Lost Ear ni ngs M ul t i pl i ed by RTP (Job 1= 1.25; Job 2= 2.5) 8,314 $ 10,515 $ [ j ] =[ i ] x RTP
+ Empl oyment Rel at ed Benef i t s Losses 2,000 $ - $ [ k]
16,966 $ 14,721 $ [ l ] =[ i ] +[ j ] +[ k]
Tot al Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs 31,687 $ Tot al of [ l ]
+ Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng Cost s 500 $ Gi ven above.
+ Rei mbur sabl e Sear ch Cost s 500 $ Gi ven above.
- Spi l l Rel at ed Payment s (3,000) $ Gi ven above.
Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on 29,687 $
Act ual Ear ni ngs i n t he cl ai mant sel ect ed Compensat i on Per i od i n t hi s exampl e i ncl udes al l ear ni ngs
bet w een t he per i od sel ect ed by t he Cl ai mant i n St ep 1, M ay 15, 2010 t hr ough December 31, 2010.
Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on i ncl udes Lost Ear ni ngs i ncr eased by t he agr eed upon Ri sk Tr ansf er
Pr emi um (RTP Job 1= 1.25; Job 2= 2.5), t hen adj ust ed f or any Empl oyee-Rel at ed Benef i t s Loss (assume
$2,000 f or Job 1), any Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng & Sear ch Cost s (assume $500 f or each t r ai ni ng and sear ch)
and any Spi l l Rel at ed Payment s (assume $3,000).
Lost Ear ni ngs i s t he di f f er ence bet w een t he Expect ed Ear ni ngs (St ep 4) and t he Act ual
Ear ni ngs (St ep 5) over t he Compensat i on Per i od.
$6,652 = $20,402 - $13,750
$4,206 = $12,566 - $8,360
[ i ] = [ g] - [ h]
028
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-17 Filed 04/18/12 Page 15 of 27
Dat a Submi t t ed by Cl ai mant
Annual Ear ni ngs per Tax Inf o Docs 8,920 $ 8,370 $ 525 $
Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs (Per i od Endi ng...)
Hrs
Hourl y
Rat e
Tot al
Pay Hrs
Hourl y
Rat e
Tot al
Pay Hrs
Hourl y
Rat e
Tot al
Pay
Januar y 31 76 10 $ 760 $ 80 10 $ 800 $ - - $
Febr uar y 28 66 10 $ 660 $ 72 10 $ 720 $ - - $
M ar ch 31 70 10 $ 700 $ 74 10 $ 740 $ - - $
Apr i l 30 73 10 $ 730 $ 76 10 $ 760 $ - - $
M ay 31 80 10 $ 800 $ 70 10 $ 700 $ 10 5 $ 50 $
June 30 80 10 $ 800 $ 60 10 $ 600 $ 25 5 $ 125 $
Jul y 31 88 10 $ 880 $ 75 10 $ 750 $ 20 5 $ 100 $
August 31 77 10 $ 770 $ 66 10 $ 660 $ 15 5 $ 75 $
Sept ember 30 68 10 $ 680 $ 54 10 $ 540 $ 15 5 $ 75 $
Oct ober 31 64 10 $ 640 $ 60 10 $ 600 $ 20 5 $ 100 $
November 30 70 10 $ 700 $ 70 10 $ 700 $ - - $
December 31 80 10 $ 800 $ 80 10 $ 800 $ - - $
Tot al Ear ni ngs & Hour s 892 8,920 $ 837 8,370 $ 105 525 $
St ep 1: Cl ai mant Sel ect s Compensat i on Per i od & Base Year
St ep 2: Det er mi ne Benchmar k Per i od Ear ni ngs and Hour s Cor r espondi ng t o t he Compensat i on Per i od
Hr s Ear ni ngs
Benchmar k Per i od Ear ni ngs (M ay 1 - Dec. 31, 2009) 607 [ a] 6,070 $ [ b]
Appendi x C2
Exampl e of Compensat i on Cal cul at i on:
Cat egor y I Indi vi dual (Hour l y Cl ai mi ng Job and M ul t i pl e Sour ces of Compensat i on Per i od Income)
Cat egor y I Indi vi dual w i t h Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on: In t hi s exampl e, t he cl ai mant has passed t he causat i on r equi r ement s, pr ovi ded Tax
Inf or mat i on Document s demonst r at i ng annual ear ni ngs, and al so pr ovi ded Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on suf f i ci ent t o est abl i sh pay per i od
ear ni ngs (al l ow i ng f or t he cal cul at i on of a Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or ). Thi s cl ai mant i s an hour l y w or ker w i t h one j ob meet i ng causat i on, a
Zone B const r uct i on j ob (Job 1) w hi ch pai d mont hl y. Af t er t he DWH Spi l l , t he cl ai mant f ound a second hour l y j ob at a r est aur an t i n Zone C w hi ch al so
pays mont hl y (Job 2). Because t he cl ai mant i s an hour l y w age w or ker , an Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or i s appl i cabl e. To t he ext ent t he cl ai mant f ound
new w or k t o r epl ace any hour s l ost due t o or r esul t i ng f r om t he DWH Spi l l , compensat i on f or t hose r epl aced hour s ar e i ncl uded i n Act ual Ear ni ngs.
2009 - Job 1 2010 - Job 1 2010 - Job 2
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
B
e
n
c
h
m
a
r
k
P
e
r
i
o
d
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
C
o
m
p
e
n
s
a
t
i
o
n
P
e
r
i
o
d
-
-
-
-
-
-
Cl ai mant has sel ect ed M ay 1, 2010 t hr ough December 31, 2010 as t he Compensat i on Per i od, and chosen 2009 as t he Base Year .
Benchmar k Per i od ear ni ngs ar e t he act ual ear ni ngs dur i ng t he per i od of t he Base Year of t he same l engt h and dat es cor r espondi ng t o t he
Compensat i on Per i od. Gi ven t he sel ect i on i n St ep 1, t he Benchmar k Per i od ear ni ngs equal t he ear ni ngs bet w een M ay 1, 2009 and December 31,
2009, and ar e cal cul at ed as f ol l ow s:
Job 1
028
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-17 Filed 04/18/12 Page 16 of 27
St ep 3: Det er mi ne Ear ni ngs Gr ow t h Fact or (s)
2009 - Job 1 2010 - Job 1
Januar y - Apr i l Ear ni ngs 2,850 $ [ c] 3,020 $ [ d]
Cal cul at ed Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or 6.0% [ e] ([ d] -[ c] )/ [ c]
Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or (max of +10%, mi n of -1.5%) 6.0% [ f ]
St ep 4: Cal cul at e Expect ed Ear ni ngs
Job 1
Benchmar k Per i od Ear ni ngs (see St ep 2) 6,070 $ [ b]
Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Rat e (i f appl i cabl e f r om St ep 3) 6.0% [ f ]
Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or (i f hour l y, see St ep 3) 1.5% [ g]
Expect ed Ear ni ngs f or t he Compensat i on Per i od 6,523 $ [ h] [ b] * (1+[ f ] +[ g] )
St ep 5: Det er mi ne Act ual Ear ni ngs i n t he Compensat i on Per i od
Act ual Ear ni ngs - Job 1 (M ay 1 - December 31, 2010) 5,350 $ [ i ]
Act ual Ear ni ngs - Job 2 (M ay 1 - Oct ober 31, 2010)
Hour s Wor ked i n Benchmar k Per i od - Job 1 (M ay 1-Dec. 31, 2009)
Hour s Wor ked i n Compensat i on Per i od - Job 1 (M ay 1-Dec. 31, 2010)
Decr eased Hour s In Cl ai mi ng Job [ j ]
Hour s Wor ked i n Compensat i on Per i od - Job 2 (M ay 1-Dec. 31, 2010)
Hour s Wor ked i n Benchmar k Per i od - Job 2 (M ay 1-Dec. 31, 2009)
Incr eased Hour s Wor ked [ k]
Redi r ect ed Hour s (l esser of [ j ] and [ k] ) [ l ]
Aver age Compensat i on Per i od Wage Rat e i n t he non- Cl ai mi ng Job [ m]
(= Tot al Compensat i on Peri od Earnings/ Tot al Compensat i on Peri od Hours= $525/ 105)
Job 2 Act ual Ear ni ngs t o Incl ude 360 $ [ n] [ l ] x [ m]
Tot al Act ual Ear ni ngs 5,710 $ [ o] [ i ] + [ n]
105
72
5.00 $
6.0% = ($3,020 - $2,850)/ $2,850
[ e] = ([ d] - [ c] ) / [ c]
Expect ed Ear ni ngs equal s Benchmar k Per i od ear ni ngs (cal cul at ed i n St ep 2) i ncr eased by t he appl i cabl e Gr ow t h Fact or s (f r om St ep 3).
$6,523 = $6,070 x (1 + 0.06 + 0 015)
[ h] = [ b] x (1 + [ f ] + [ g] )
Act ual Ear ni ngs i n t he cl ai mant sel ect ed Compensat i on Per i od i n t hi s exampl e i ncl udes al l ear ni ngs bet w een t he per i od sel ect ed by t he Cl ai mant
i n St ep 1, M ay 1, 2010 t hr ough December 31, 2010. Ear ni ngs f r om Job 2 ar e onl y i ncl uded t o t he ext ent t hey r epl ace hour s f r om Job 1.
607
535
72
105
-
The Cl ai mant has pr ovi ded Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on, and a Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or can be cal cul at ed usi ng Januar y t hr ough
Apr i l ear ni ngs i n 2010 and t he Base Year . Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or (1.5%) appl i es as Benchmar k Per i od ear ni ngs ar e pai d hour l y.
$360 = 72 x $5 00
[ n] = [ l ] x [ m]
$5,710 = $5,350 + $360
[ o] = [ i ] + [ n]
028
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-17 Filed 04/18/12 Page 17 of 27
St ep 6: Det er mi ne Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs
Lost Ear ni ngs 813 $ [ p] [ h] -[ o]
St ep 7: Cal cul at e Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on
Lost Ear ni ngs (St ep 6) 813 $ [ i ]
+ Lost Ear ni ngs M ul t i pl i ed by RTP (Job 1= 1.25) 1,016 $ [ j ] [ i ] x RTP
+ Empl oyment Rel at ed Benef i t s Losses 2,000 $ [ k]
3,830 $ [ l ] [ i ] +[ j ] +[ k]
Tot al Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs 3,830 $ Tot al of [ l ]
+ Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng Cost s 500 $ Gi ven above.
+ Rei mbur sabl e Sear ch Cost s 500 $ Gi ven above.
- Spi l l Rel at ed Payment s (1,000) $ Gi ven above.
Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on 3,830 $
Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs i s t he di f f er ence bet w een t he Expect ed Ear ni ngs (St ep 4) and t he Act ual Ear ni ngs (St ep 5) over t he Compensat i on Per i od.
$813 = $6,523 - $5,710
[ p] = [ h] - [ o]
Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on i ncl udes Lost Ear ni ngs i ncr eased by t he agr eed upon Ri sk Tr ansf er Pr emi um (RTP Job 1= 1.25), t hen adj ust ed f or
any Empl oyee-Rel at ed Benef i t s Loss (assume $2,000 f or Job 1), any Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng & Sear ch Cost s (assume $500 f or each t r ai ni ng and
sear ch) and any Spi l l Rel at ed Payment s (assume $1,000).
028 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-17 Filed 04/18/12 Page 18 of 27
Appendi x D
Dat a Submi t t ed by Cl ai mant
2009 2010
Annual Ear ni ngs per Tax Inf or mat i on Document s Not Gi ven Not Gi ven
Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs (Per i od Endi ng...)
Januar y 15 2,200 $ 2,250 $
Januar y 31 2,250 $ 2,300 $
Febr uar y 15 2,200 $ 2,200 $
Febr uar y 28 2,100 $ 2,150 $
M ar ch 15 2,200 $ 2,200 $
M ar ch 31 2,300 $ 2,400 $
Apr i l 15 2,300 $ 2,250 $
Apr i l 30 Not Gi ven 2,500 $
M ay 15 2,500 $ 1,750 $
M ay 31 2,525 $ 1,400 $
June 15 2,600 $ 1,300 $
June 30 2,500 $ 1,200 $
Jul y 15 2,650 $ 1,100 $
Jul y 31 2,725 $ 1,200 $
August 15 Not Gi ven 1,240 $
August 31 2,550 $ 1,320 $
Sept ember 15 2,500 $ 1,340 $
Sept ember 30 2,400 $ 1,250 $
Oct ober 15 2,300 $ 1,200 $
Oct ober 31 2,325 $ 1,300 $
Tot al Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Pr ovi ded 43,125 $ 33,850 $
Exampl e of Compensat i on Cal cul at i on: Cat egor y II Indi vi dual
-
-
-
-
B
e
n
c
h
m
a
r
k
P
e
r
i
o
d
-
-
-
-
Cat egor y II Indi vi dual w i t h det ai l ed Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on: In t hi s exampl e, t he cl ai mant has
passed t he causat i on r equi r ement s but pr ovi ded i ncompl et e Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on i nsuf f i ci ent
t o cal cul at e a Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or . Thi s cl ai mant i s an hour l y w or ker at a f act or y i n Zone C i n
bot h per i ods, and an Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or i s t her ef or e appl i cabl e. Because t he Cl ai mant i s mi ssi ng
i nf or mat i on f or cer t ai n pay per i ods i n t he Base Year and has not pr ovi ded t ot al annual ear ni ngs f or t he Base
Year , t he Compensat i on Per i od and Benchmar k Per i od may not i ncl ude t hose pay per i ods. If t he cl ai mant
pr ovi ded t ot al annual ear ni ngs f or t he Base Year (2009), t he ear ni ngs f or Apr i l 30t h and August 15t h coul d be
der i ved f r om t he annual dat a by subt r act i ng t he sum of t he Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on dat a
pr ovi ded f r om t ot al annual ear ni ngs. If appr opr i at e, t he cl ai mant coul d t hen have consi der ed al t er nat i ve
Compensat i on Per i ods t hat i ncl uded t he Apr i l 30t h and August 15t h pay per i ods.
-
-
C
o
m
p
e
n
s
a
t
i
o
n
P
e
r
i
o
d
-
-
028
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-17 Filed 04/18/12 Page 19 of 27
Appendi x D
Exampl e of Compensat i on Cal cul at i on: Cat egor y II Indi vi dual
St ep 1: Cl ai mant Sel ect s Compensat i on Per i od & Base Year
St ep 2: Det er mi ne Benchmar k Per i od Ear ni ngs Cor r espondi ng t o t he Compensat i on Per i od
Ear ni ngs M ay 1-Jul y 31, 2009 15,500 $
St ep 3: Det er mi ne Ear ni ngs Gr ow t h Fact or (s)
2009 2010
Januar y - Apr i l Ear ni ngs N/ A [ a] N/ A [ b]
Cal cul at ed Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or N/ A [ c] =([ b] -[ a] )/ [ a]
Gener al Gr ow t h Fact or 2.0% [ d]
St ep 4: Cal cul at e Expect ed Ear ni ngs
Benchmar k Per i od Ear ni ngs (f r om St ep 2) 15,500 $ [ e]
Gener al Gr ow t h Rat e (i f appl i cabl e f r om St ep 3) 2.0% [ d]
Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or (i f hour l y, see St ep 3) 1.5% [ f ]
Expect ed Ear ni ngs f or t he Compensat i on Per i od 16,043 $ [ g] =[ e] * (1+[ d] +[ f ] )
Cl ai mant has sel ect ed M ay 1, 2010 t hr ough Jul y 31, 2010 as t he Compensat i on Per i od, and
has chosen 2009 as t he Base Year .
Benchmar k Per i od ear ni ngs ar e t he act ual ear ni ngs dur i ng t he per i od of t he Base Year of t he same l engt h
and dat es cor r espondi ng t o t he Compensat i on Per i od. Gi ven t he sel ect i on i n St ep 1, t he Benchmar k Per i od
ear ni ngs equal t he ear ni ngs bet w een M ay 1, 2009 and Jul y 31, 2009, and ar e cal cul at ed as f ol l ow s:
The cl ai mant has pr ovi ded pay per i od det ai l , but i nsuf f i ci ent t o cal cul at e a Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or
due t o t he mi ssi ng per i ods and t he absence of annual ear ni ngs document at i on. The Gener al Gr ow t h Fact or
(2%) w i l l t her ef or e appl y, and an Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or (1.5%) w i l l appl y because t he cl ai mant i s an hour l y
w or ker .
Expect ed Ear ni ngs equal s Benchmar k Per i od ear ni ngs (cal cul at ed i n St ep 2) i ncr eased by t he appl i cabl e
Gr ow t h Fact or s (f r om St ep 3).
$16,043 = $15,500 x (1 + 0.02 + 0.015)
[ g] = [ e] x (1+ [ d] + [ f ] )
028 00
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-17 Filed 04/18/12 Page 20 of 27
Appendi x D
Exampl e of Compensat i on Cal cul at i on: Cat egor y II Indi vi dual
St ep 5: Det er mi ne Act ual Ear ni ngs i n t he Compensat i on Per i od
Act ual Ear ni ngs (M ay 1-Jul y 31, 2010) 7,950 $ [ h]
St ep 6: Det er mi ne Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs
Lost Ear ni ngs 8,093 $ [ i ] =[ g] -[ h]
St ep 7: Cal cul at e Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on
Lost Ear ni ngs (St ep 6) 8,093 $ [ i ]
+ Lost Ear ni ngs M ul t i pl i ed by Ot her Indust r i es RTP (0.25 i n Zone C) 2,023 $ [ j ] =[ i ] x RTP
+ Empl oyment Rel at ed Benef i t s Losses 2,000 $ Gi ven above.
+ Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng Cost s 500 $ Gi ven above.
+ Rei mbur sabl e Sear ch Cost s 500 $ Gi ven above.
- Spi l l Rel at ed Payment s (3,000) $ Gi ven above.
Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on 10,116 $
Lost Ear ni ngs i s t he di f f er ence bet w een t he Expect ed Ear ni ngs (St ep 4) and t he Act ual Ear ni ngs (St ep 5)
over t he Compensat i on Per i od.
Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on i ncl udes Lost Ear ni ngs i ncr eased by t he agr eed upon Ri sk Tr ansf er Pr emi um
(Zone C Ot her Indust r i es= 0.25), t hen adj ust ed f or any Empl oyee-Rel at ed Benef i t s Loss (assume $2,000),
any Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng & Sear ch Cost s (assume $500 each f or t r ai ni ng and sear ch) and any Spi l l Rel at ed
Payment s (assume $3,000).
Act ual Ear ni ngs i n t he cl ai mant sel ect ed Compensat i on Per i od i n t hi s exampl e i ncl udes al l ear ni ngs
bet w een t he Compensat i on Per i od sel ect ed by t he cl ai mant i n St ep 1, M ay 1, 2010 t hr ough Jul y 31, 2010.
$8,093 = $16,043 - $7,950
[ i ] = [ g] - [ h]
028 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-17 Filed 04/18/12 Page 21 of 27
Dat a Submi t t ed by Cl ai mant
2010 2011
Annual Ear ni ngs per Tax Inf or mat i on Document s - $ 55,200 $
Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs
Januar y - $ 4,600 $
Febr uar y - $ 4,600 $
M ar ch - $ 4,600 $
Apr i l - $ 4,600 $
M ay - $ 4,600 $
June - $ 4,600 $
Jul y - $ 4,600 $
August - $ 4,600 $
Sept ember - $ 4,600 $
Oct ober - $ 4,600 $
November - $ 4,600 $
December - $ 4,600 $
Tot al Ear ni ngs - $ 55,200 $
St ep 1: Cl ai mant Sel ect s Compensat i on Per i od & Base Year
St ep 2: Det er mi ne Benchmar k Per i od Ear ni ngs Cor r espondi ng t o t he Compensat i on Per i od
Ear ni ngs M ay 1-December 31, 2011 36,800 $ [ a]
Appendi x E
Exampl e of Compensat i on Cal cul at i on:
Cat egor y III Indi vi dual - New Ent r ant t o Empl oyment
Cat egor y III Indi vi dual - New Ent r ant t o Empl oyment : In t hi s exampl e, t he cl ai mant has passed t he causat i on
r equi r ement s and accept ed, as of Apr i l 20, 2010, a f i r st -t i me of f er of empl oyment i n Zone A i n t he Tour i sm cat egor y
t hat w as r esci nded due t o or r esul t i ng f r om t he DWH Spi l l . The cl ai mant pr ocur es empl oyment i n Januar y 2011 and
pr ovi des i nf or mat i on suf f i ci ent t o est abl i sh mont hl y pay per i od ear ni ngs. Thi s cl ai mant i s consi der ed a New Ent r ant t o
Empl oyment and 2011 ear ni ngs adj ust ed dow nw ar d by t he Gener al Gr ow t h Fact or w i l l be used i n l i eu of Benchmar k
Per i od ear ni ngs. Because t he cl ai mant i s a sal ar i ed w or ker , no Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or i s appl i cabl e.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
B
e
n
c
h
m
a
r
k
P
e
r
i
o
d
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
C
o
m
p
e
n
s
a
t
i
o
n
P
e
r
i
o
d
-
-
-
-
-
Cl ai mant has sel ect ed M ay 1, 2010 t hr ough December 31, 2010 as t he Compensat i on Per i od, and 2011 i s t he Base
Year as cl ai mant i s a New Ent r ant t o Empl oyment .
Benchmar k Per i od ear ni ngs ar e t he act ual ear ni ngs dur i ng t he per i od of t he Base Year of t he same l engt h and
dat es cor r espondi ng t o t he Compensat i on Per i od. Gi ven t he sel ect i on i n St ep 1, t he Benchmar k Per i od ear ni ngs
equal t he ear ni ngs bet w een M ay 1, 2011 and December 31, 2011, and i s cal cul at ed as f ol l ow s:
028 02
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-17 Filed 04/18/12 Page 22 of 27
Appendi x E
Exampl e of Compensat i on Cal cul at i on:
Cat egor y III Indi vi dual - New Ent r ant t o Empl oyment
St ep 3: Det er mi ne Ear ni ngs Gr ow t h Fact or (s)
St ep 4: Cal cul at e Expect ed Ear ni ngs
Benchmar k Per i od Ear ni ngs (f r om St ep 2) 36,800 $ = [ a]
Reduce 2011 Ear ni ngs by Gener al Gr ow t h Fact or (f r om St ep 3) -2.0% [ b]
Reduce 2011 Ear ni ngs by Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or (f r om St ep 3) n/ a [ c]
Expect ed Ear ni ngs f or t he Compensat i on Per i od 36,064 $ [ d] =[ a] * (1+[ b] +[ c] )
St ep 5: Det er mi ne Act ual Ear ni ngs i n t he Compensat i on Per i od
Act ual Ear ni ngs (M ay 1 -December 31, 2010) - $ [ e]
St ep 6: Det er mi ne Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs
Lost Ear ni ngs 36,064 $ [ f ] =[ d] -[ e]
$36,064 = $36,064 - 0
[ f ] = [ d] - [ e]
Lost Ear ni ngs i s t he di f f er ence bet w een t he Expect ed Ear ni ngs (St ep 4) and t he Act ual Ear ni ngs (St ep 5) over t he
Compensat i on Per i od.
Expect ed Ear ni ngs equal s Benchmar k Per i od ear ni ngs (cal cul at ed i n St ep 2) decr eased back t o 2010 l evel s usi ng t he
appl i cabl e Gr ow t h Fact or s (f r om St ep 3).
Because t he cl ai mant i s a New Ent r ant t o Empl oyment , Benchmar k Per i od ear ni ngs ar e di scount ed back t o 2010
usi ng agr eed upon Gr ow t h Fact or s. The Gener al Gr ow t h Rat e of 2.0% i s appl i ed, but si nce cl ai mant i s a sal ar i ed
w or ker no Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or i s appl i ed.
Act ual Ear ni ngs i n t he cl ai mant sel ect ed Compensat i on Per i od i n t hi s exampl e i ncl udes al l ear ni ngs bet w een t he
per i od sel ect ed by t he cl ai mant i n St ep 1, M ay 1, 2010 t hr ough December 31, 2010.
$36,064 = $36,800 x (1 - 0.02 + 0)
[ d] = [ a] x (1 + [ b] + [ c] )
028 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-17 Filed 04/18/12 Page 23 of 27
Appendi x E
Exampl e of Compensat i on Cal cul at i on:
Cat egor y III Indi vi dual - New Ent r ant t o Empl oyment
St ep 7: Cal cul at e Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on
Lost Ear ni ngs (St ep 6) 36,064 $ =[ f ]
+ Lost Ear ni ngs M ul t i pl i ed by Tour i sm RTP (2.5 i n Zone A) 90,160 $ [ g] =[ f ] x RTP
+ Empl oyment Rel at ed Benef i t s Losses 2,000 $ Gi ven above.
+ Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng Cost s 500 $ Gi ven above.
+ Rei mbur sabl e Sear ch Cost s 500 $ Gi ven above.
- Spi l l Rel at ed Payment s (3,000) $ Gi ven above.
Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on 126,224 $
Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on i ncl udes Lost Ear ni ngs i ncr eased by t he agr eed upon Ri sk Tr ansf er Pr emi um (Zone A
Tour i sm= 2.5 RTP), t hen adj ust ed f or any Empl oyee-Rel at ed Benef i t s Loss (assume $2,000), any Rei mbur sabl e
Tr ai ni ng & Sear ch Cost s (assume $500 each f or t r ai ni ng and sear ch) and any Spi l l Rel at ed Payment s (assume
$3,000).
028 04
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-17 Filed 04/18/12 Page 24 of 27
Dat a Submi t t ed by Cl ai m
2009 2010 2011
Annual Ear ni ngs per Tax Inf or mat i on Document s 36,000 $ 22,500 $ 55,200 $
Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs
Januar y 3,000 $ 4,500 $ 4,600 $
Febr uar y 3,000 $ 4,500 $ 4,600 $
M ar ch 3,000 $ 4,500 $ 4,600 $
Apr i l 3,000 $ 4,500 $ 4,600 $
M ay 3,000 $ 4,500 $ 4,600 $
June 3,000 $ - $ 4,600 $
Jul y 3,000 $ - $ 4,600 $
August 3,000 $ - $ 4,600 $
Sept ember 3,000 $ - $ 4,600 $
Oct ober 3,000 $ - $ 4,600 $
November 3,000 $ - $ 4,600 $
December 3,000 $ - $ 4,600 $
Tot al Ear ni ngs 36,000 $ 22,500 $ 55,200 $
St ep 1: Cl ai mant Sel ect s Compensat i on Per i od & Base Year
St ep 2: Det er mi ne Benchmar k Per i od Ear ni ngs Cor r espondi ng t o t he Compensat i on Per i od
Ear ni ngs June 1-December 31, 2011 32,200 $
St ep 3: Det er mi ne Ear ni ngs Gr ow t h Fact or (s)
-
-
-
-
B
e
n
c
h
m
a
r
k
P
e
r
i
o
d
-
-
-
-
Cl ai mant sel ect s June 1, 2010 t hr ough December 31, 2010 as t he Compensat i on Per i od, and 2011 i s t he
Base Year f or cal cul at i ng Expect ed Ear ni ngs because cl ai mant i s a Car eer Changer .
Benchmar k Per i od ear ni ngs ar e t he act ual ear ni ngs dur i ng t he per i od of t he Base Year of t he same l engt h
and dat es cor r espondi ng t o t he Compensat i on Per i od. Gi ven t he sel ect i on i n St ep 1, t he Benchmar k
Per i od ear ni ngs equal t he ear ni ngs bet w een June 1, 2011 and December 31, 2011:
Appendi x F
Exampl e of Compensat i on Cal cul at i on:
Cat egor y III Indi vi dual - Car eer Changer
Cat egor y III Indi vi dual - Car eer Changer : In t hi s exampl e, t he cl ai mant has passed t he causat i on
r equi r ement s and pr ovi des Tax Inf or mat i on Document s demonst r at i ng annual ear ni ngs, and al so pr ovi des
Pay Per i od Ear ni ngs Document at i on suf f i ci ent t o est abl i sh mont hl y/ pay per i od ear ni ngs. The Indi vi dual
sw i t ched j obs at t he end of 2009 and w as empl oyed i n Zone B Tour i sm i n 2010, and t he Cl ai mant Speci f i c
Gr ow t h Fact or exceeded 20%, so t hi s cl ai mant i s consi der ed a Car eer Changer and 2011 ear ni ngs adj ust ed
dow nw ar d by t he Gener al Gr ow t h Fact or w i l l be used i n l i eu of a Benchmar k Per i od. Because t he cl ai mant i s
a sal ar i ed w or ker , no Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or i s appl i cabl e.
-
-
C
o
m
p
e
n
s
a
t
i
o
n
P
e
r
i
o
d
-
-
028 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-17 Filed 04/18/12 Page 25 of 27
Appendi x F
Exampl e of Compensat i on Cal cul at i on:
Cat egor y III Indi vi dual - Car eer Changer
Det er mi nat i on of Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or
2009 2010
Januar y - Apr i l Ear ni ngs 12,000 $ [ a] 18,000 $ [ b]
Cal cul at ed Cl ai mant Speci f i c Gr ow t h Fact or 50.0% [ c] =([ b] -[ a] )/ [ a]
Gener al Gr ow t h Fact or 2.0% [ d]
St ep 4: Cal cul at e Expect ed Ear ni ngs
2011 Benchmar k Per i od Ear ni ngs 32,200 $ [ e]
Reduce 2011 Ear ni ngs by Gener al Gr ow t h Fact or (f r om St ep 3) -2.0% [ d]
Reduce 2011 Ear ni ngs by Indust r y Gr ow t h Fact or (f r om St ep 3) n/ a [ f ]
Expect ed Ear ni ngs f or t he Compensat i on Per i od 31,556 $ [ g] =[ e] * (1+[ d] +[ f ] )
St ep 5: Det er mi ne Act ual Ear ni ngs i n t he Compensat i on Per i od
Act ual Ear ni ngs (June-December 2010) - $ [ h]
Expect ed Ear ni ngs equal s Benchmar k Per i od ear ni ngs (cal cul at ed i n St ep 2) decr eased back t o 2010 l evel s
usi ng t he appl i cabl e Gr ow t h Fact or s (f r om St ep 3).
Act ual Ear ni ngs i n t he cl ai mant sel ect ed Compensat i on Per i od i n t hi s exampl e i ncl udes al l ear ni ngs bet w een
t he per i od sel ect ed by t he cl ai mant i n St ep 1, June 1, 2010 t hr ough December 31, 2010.
As i l l ust r at ed bel ow , t he cl ai mant ' s i ncome changed by mor e t han 20%, and, t her ef or e, t he cl ai mant i s a
Car eer Changer , and t he Gener al Gr ow t h Fact or (2%) appl i es. Si nce cl ai mant i s a sal ar i ed w or ker no Indust r y
Gr ow t h Fact or i s appl i ed.
(Claimant earnings changed by more t han 20%, t heref ore, 2011 becomes Base Year and growt h rat e def ault s t o
General Growt h Fact or of 2%.)
50.0% = ($18,000 - $12,000) / $12,000
[ c] = ( [ b] - [ a] ) / [ a]
$31,556 = $32,200 x (1 - 0.02 + 0)
[ g] = [ e] x (1 - [ d] + [ f ] )
028 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-17 Filed 04/18/12 Page 26 of 27
Appendi x F
Exampl e of Compensat i on Cal cul at i on:
Cat egor y III Indi vi dual - Car eer Changer
St ep 6: Det er mi ne Cl ai mant Lost Ear ni ngs
Lost Ear ni ngs 31,556 $ [ i ] =[ g] -[ h]
$31,556 = $31,556 - 0
[ i ] = [ g] - [ h]
St ep 7: Cal cul at e Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on
Lost Ear ni ngs (St ep 6) 31,556 $ =[ i ]
+ Lost Ear ni ngs M ul t i pl i ed by Tour i sm RTP (2.0 i n Zone B) 63,112 $ [ j ] =[ i ] x RTP
+ Empl oyment Rel at ed Benef i t s Losses 2,000 $ Gi ven above.
+ Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng Cost s 500 $ Gi ven above.
+ Rei mbur sabl e Sear ch Cost s 500 $ Gi ven above.
- Spi l l Rel at ed Payment s (3,000) $ Gi ven above.
Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on 94,668 $
Lost Ear ni ngs i s t he di f f er ence bet w een t he Expect ed Ear ni ngs (St ep 4) and t he Act ual Ear ni ngs (St ep 5) over
t he Compensat i on Per i od.
Fi nal Cl ai mant Compensat i on i ncl udes Lost Ear ni ngs i ncr eased by t he agr eed upon Ri sk Tr ansf er Pr emi um
(Zone B Tour i sm= 2.0 RTP), t hen adj ust ed f or any Empl oyee-Rel at ed Benef i t s Loss (assume $2,000), any
Rei mbur sabl e Tr ai ni ng & Sear ch Cost s (assume $500 each f or t r ai ni ng and sear ch) and any Spi l l Rel at ed
Payment s (assume $3,000).
028 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-17 Filed 04/18/12 Page 27 of 27
8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-18 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 11
1
AddendumRegar di ngCompensat i onRel at edt oaCl ai mant sLossof Empl oyment Rel at edBenef i t s
IncomeasaResul t of t heDWHSpi l l
I. El i gi bi l i t y:
Onl yEl i gi bl eCl ai mant sshal l qual i f yf or compensat i onpur suant t ot hi sAddendum.TobeanEl i gi bl e
Cl ai mant ,acl ai mant must sat i sf yal l of t hef ol l ow i ngEl i gi bi l i t yCr i t er i a:
1. Thecl ai mant must qual i f yf or compensat i onpur suant t oSect i onI,Sect i onIIor Sect i onIIIof t he
Fr amewor kf or Indi vi dual Economi cLossCl ai ms.
2. Unl esst hecl ai mant i saNewEnt r ant t oEmpl oyment ,t hecl ai mant must havebeencover edby
aheal t hi nsur anceand/ or r et i r ement pl anpr ovi dedbyt hecl ai mant sempl oyer asof Apr i l 20,
2010( Pr eSpi l l Benef i t Pr ovi di ngEmpl oyer ).
3. If t hecl ai m ant i saNewEnt r ant t oEmpl oyment ,t henasof Apr i l 20,2010t hecl ai mant must
havehadandaccept edanof f er f r omaPr eSpi l l Benef i t Pr ovi di ngEmpl oyer w hi chi ncl uded
heal t hcar ei nsur ancecover ageand/ or r et i r ement benef i t scommenci ngw i t hi nt heper i odM ay
1,2010t hr oughDecember 31,2011.
4. Thecl ai mant must demonst r at e Empl oyment Rel at edBenef i t Losses .Empl oyment Rel at ed
Benef i t sLossesshal l consi st of (i )Heal t hInsur anceCover ageLossesand/ or (b)Ret i r ement
Benef i t Losses(bot hof w hi char edef i nedbel ow )duet o:
a. Thet er mi nat i onof t hecl ai mant sempl oyment byt hePr eSpi l l Benef i t Pr ovi di ng
Empl oyer ;or
b. Ot her t er mi nat i onof cl ai mant sbenef i t s(e.g.,achangei nempl oyee sel i gi bi l i t y);or
c. Ar educt i oni ncl ai mant scompensat i onr el at edt ot heDW HSpi l l ;or
d. For NewEnt r ant st oEmpl oyment ,t hat t heheal t hcar ei nsur anceand/ or r et i r ement
benef i t sbecameunavai l abl easar esul t of t heof f er bei ngw i t hdr aw nor amendedasa
r esul t of t heDW HSpi l l .
Heal t hInsur anceCover ageLosses and Ret i r ement Benef i t Losses shal l bedef i nedas
f ol l ow s:
a. Heal t hInsur anceCover ageLosses:Thecl ai mant spost DW HSpi l l l ossof i ncomer el at ed
t ot hel ossof cover ageunder aheal t hi nsur ancepl anf r omaPr eSpi l l Benef i t Pr ovi di ng
Empl oyer i nw hi cht hecl ai mant w asenr ol l edasof Apr i l 20,2010(or w hi chw aspar t of
t hebenef i t spackageaNewEnt r ant t oEmpl oyment w oul dhaver ecei vedf r omhi sor
her Pr eSpi l l Benef i t Pr ovi di ngEmpl oyer ),i ncl udi nganymedi cal ,pr escr i pt i ondr ug,
dent al and/ or vi si oni nsur ancepl ancover ages( Pr eSpi l l Insur ancePl anCover ages );
1
AND/ OR
1
For pur posesof t hi saddendum,eachi ndi vi dual heal t hi nsur ancepol i cycover age(i .e.,medi cal ,pr escr i pt i ondr ug,
dent al ,and/ or vi si on)w i l l beeval uat edsepar at el y.
025226
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-18 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 11
2
b. Ret i r ement Benef i t Losses:Thecl ai mant spost DW HSpi l l l ossof i ncomer el at edt ot he
l ossof or r educt i oni nr et i r ement or pensi onbenef i t spr ovi dedbyhi sor her Pr eSpi l l
Benef i t Pr ovi di ngEmpl oyer ,i ncl udi ngempl oyer pensi onpayment s,and/ or ot her
empl oyer cont r i but i onsr el at edt oacl ai mant s401(k)or 403(b)account ,pr of i t shar i ng
pl anor ot her t ypeof r et i r ement account ( Pr eSpi l l Ret i r ement Benef i t s ).
a. That t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant sof f er i ncl udedPr eSpi l l Insur ancePl anCover age(s).
b. That asof Apr i l 20,2010,t heNewEnt r ant t oEmpl oyment pl annedt opar t i ci pat ei n
oneor mor eof t hosePr eSpi l l Insur ancePl anCover age(s),i ncl udi ng(i )speci f i c
i dent i f i cat i onof al l r el evant Pr eSpi l l Insur ancePl anCover age(s),(i i )w het her t he
El i gi bl eCl ai mant i nt endedt oenr ol l asani ndi vi dual or f ami l y,and(i i i )t hedat eon
w hi cht hecover agew oul dhavebegun,asr el evant .
c. Theamount of per i odi c(annual ,mont hl y,et c.)pr em i umcost sf or w hi cht he
cl ai mant w oul dhavebeenr esponsi bl e,i f any,f or eachPr eSpi l l Insur ancePl an
Cover age.
d. If t heNewEnt r ant t oEmpl oyment sof f er w asamendedr at her t hanw i t hdr aw n,
t hat t hei nabi l i t yt opar t i ci pat ei nt hePr eSpi l l Insur ancePl anCover age(s)w asdue
t ot heDW HSpi l l ,i ncl udi ngt hespeci f i cbasi s.
e. TheNewEnt r ant t oEmpl oyment shal l pr ovi deaSwor nWr i t t enSt at ement f r oman
aut hor i zedr epr esent at i veof t hePr eSpi l l Benef i t Pr ovi di ngEmpl oyer i ndi cat i ngt he
amount of per i odi cpr emi ums(payper i od,mont hl y,annual ,et c.)t hat w oul dhave
beenpai df or t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant sPr eSpi l l Insur ancePl anCover age(s)byt he
Pr eSpi l l Benef i t Pr ovi di ngEmpl oyer absent t heDW HSpi l l i f t hef ol l ow i ngappl y:
i . If t heNewEnt r ant t oEmpl oyment sof f er w asw i t hdr aw n,or i f t heNew
Ent r ant t oEmpl oyment sof f er w asonl yamended,but heor shew asno
l onger el i gi bl ef or Pr eSpi l l Insur ancePl anCover age;and
i i . If t heNewEnt r ant t oEmpl oyment di dnot obt ai nRepl acement Heal t h
Insur anceCover ageor aNewEmpl oyer Insur ancePl an(asdef i nedher ei n)
pr i or t oDecember 31,2011.
Document at i onmayi ncl ude,f or exam pl e,t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant sr el evant of f er l et t er ,
i nsur ancepl ani nf or mat i onr ecei vedf r omt hePr eSpi l l Benef i t Pr ovi di ngEmpl oyer ,and/ or
aSwor nWr i t t enSt at ement f r om anaut hor i zedr epr esent at i veof t hef r om t hePr eSpi l l
Benef i t Pr ovi di ngEmpl oyer w i t hr el evant i nf or mat i onr egar di ngt hePr eSpi l l Insur ance
Pl anCover age(s),suchaspr emi umi nf or mat i on,t hecl ai mant sel i gi bi l i t y,et c.,asappl i cabl e.
3. If ,af t er t het er mi nat i onof anyPr eSpi l l Insur ancePl anCover age,t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant
obt ai nedheal t hi nsur ancecover aget hr oughCOBRA,t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant shal l pr ovi deal l
of t hef ol l ow i ng:
a. Document sevi denci ngt heper i odf or w hi cht heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant w ascover edby
COBRA,i ncl udi ngt hef i r st andl ast ef f ect i vedat esof cover age.
b. Document sevi denci ngt heCOBRApr emi ums(andt heper i odt ow hi cheach
pr emi umr el at es)t hr ought heear l i er of (i )t het er mi nat i onof COBRA,or
(i i )December 31,2011.
c. Document sevi denci ngt hecl ai mant spayment of anyCOBRApr emi umsf or w hi ch
t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant seeksr ei mbur sement .
4. If ,af t er t het er mi nat i onof anyPr eSpi l l Insur ancePl anCover age,t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant
obt ai nedandpai df or r epl acement heal t hi nsur anceot her t hani nconnect i onw i t hCOBRA,
02522
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-18 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 11
4
new empl oyment or anal t er nat i veheal t hcar ei nsur ancepl anf or w hi cht hecl ai mant w as
el i gi bl e(asdi scussedbel ow )( Repl acement Heal t hInsur anceCover age ),t heEl i gi bl e
Cl ai mant shal l pr ovi deal l of t hef ol l ow i ng:
a. Document sevi denci ngt heper i odf or w hi cht heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant pr ocur edany
Repl acement Heal t hInsur anceCover age,i ncl udi ngt hef i r st andl ast ef f ect i vedat es
of cover age,pr ovi dedt hat evi denceof cover agebeyondDecember 31,2011need
not bepr ovi ded.
b. Document sevi denci ngt hepr emi um amount s(andt heper i odt ow hi cheach
pr emi umr el at es),asw el l ascl ai mant spayment of t hosepr emi ums,f or eachpol i cy
pr ovi di ngRepl acement Heal t hInsur anceCover aget hr ought heear l i er of (i )t he
t er mi nat i onof t hepol i cypr ovi di ngRepl acement Heal t hInsur anceCover age,or
(i i )December 31,2011.
5. If ,af t er t het er mi nat i onof anyPr eSpi l l Insur ancePl anCover ages,t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant
w asof f er edbut di dnot accept heal t hi nsur ancecover agepur suant t oCOBRAor apol i cy
pr ovi di ngRepl acement Heal t hInsur anceCover age,t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant shal l pr ovi de
cont empor aneousdocument sevi denci ngt het er msof anyof f er of COBRAcover age,
i ncl udi ngt hecor r espondi ngpr emi um .If t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant w asnot el i gi bl ef or COBRA
becauset hePr eSpi l l Benef i t Pr ovi di ngEmpl oyer nol onger pr ovi dedheal t hi nsur ancet oi t s
exi st i ngempl oyees,or becausei t w asnot r equi r edbyl aw t opr ovi desuchcover age,t he
cl ai mant shoul dcer t i f yi nw r i t i ngt hat noCOBRAcover agew asof f er ed.
6. If t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant obt ai nedor w ascover edbyheal t hi nsur ancef r om anew or f or mer
empl oyer ,or byanal t er nat i veheal t hcar ei nsur ancepl anf or w hi cht hecl ai mant w asel i gi bl e
(t hr ough,f or exampl e,aspouse,domest i cpar t ner ,par ent ,l egal guar di an,vet er an sor ot her
pl an,asappl i cabl e)af t er t het er mi nat i onof t hePr eSpi l l Insur ancePl ans,but pr i or t o
December 31,2011( Post Spi l l Empl oyer Insur ancePl anCover age ),t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant
shal l pr ovi dedocument sset t i ngf or t ht het ypeandef f ect i vedat e(s)of anyPost Spi l l
Empl oyer Insur ancePl anCover ages.
02522
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-18 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 11
5
2. Document at i onest abl i shi ngt hat t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant sPr eSpi l l Ret i r ement Benef i t sw er e
t er mi nat edaf t er Apr i l 20,2010asar esul t of ei t her (i )t hepost Spi l l t er mi nat i onof t he
El i gi bl eCl ai mant sempl oyment byt hePr eSpi l l Benef i t Pr ovi di ngEmpl oyer ,or (i i )apost
Spi l l changei nt heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant sempl oyment st at usw i t ht hePr eSpi l l Benef i t
Pr ovi di ngEmpl oyer .
3. Document at i onevi denci ngt heamount of vest edPr eSpi l l Ret i r ement Benef i t scont r i but ed
onbehal f of t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant byt hePr eSpi l l Benef i t Pr ovi di ngEmpl oyer bet w eenM ay
1,2009andt hedocument edt er mi nat i ondat eof t hePr eSpi l l Ret i r ement Benef i t s.Tot he
ext ent t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant hadbeenempl oyedw i t ht hePr eSpi l l Benef i t Pr ovi di ng
Empl oyer f or l esst hant w el vemont hs,heor sheshoul dpr ovi det her equest edi nf or mat i on
f r omhi sor her st ar t dat ew i t ht hePr eSpi l l Benef i t Pr ovi di ngEmpl oyer t hr ought hedat e
Pr eSpi l l Ret i r ement Benef i t sceased.
4. If t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant sPr eSpi l l Ret i r ement Benef i t sw er et er mi nat ed,t hecl ai mant shal l
pr ovi dedocument at i onevi denci ngt het er mi nat i onof t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant sPr eSpi l l
Ret i r ement Benef i t s,i ncl udi ngt heef f ect i vedat eof t er mi nat i on.
5. If t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant exper i encedapost DW HSpi l l r educt i oni nPr eSpi l l Ret i r ement
Benef i t s,t hecl ai mant shal l pr ovi det hef ol l ow i ng:
a. Document sr egar di nganyr et i r ement benef i t spr ovi dedbyt hePr eSpi l l Benef i t
Pr ovi di ngEmpl oyer af t er t heDW HSpi l l ( Act ual Post Spi l l Ret i r ement Benef i t s );
and
b. If appl i cabl e,anydocument sevi denci ngachangei nt het er msbyw hi cht hePr eSpi l l
Benef i t Pr ovi di ngEmpl oyer pr ovi dedt hePr eSpi l l Ret i r ement Benef i t s(e.g.,such
asanel i mi nat i onof empl oyer mat chi ng)or achangei nvest i ngschedul et er ms
unr el at edt ot heDW HSpi l l ( Unr el at edPl anChange ).It w i l l beassumedt hat any
pl anchangei sunr el at edt ot heDW HSpi l l f or pur posesof t hi saddendum,unl esst he
cl ai mant pr ovi desdocument at i onest abl i shi ngt hat t hepl anchangew asduet oor
r esul t i ngf r omt heDW HSpi l l ( Spi l l Rel at edPl anChange ).Document at i oncoul d
i ncl ude,f or exampl e,cont empor aneousnot i f i cat i onr ecei vedf r om,or aSwor n
Wr i t t enSt at ement pr ovi dedbyanaut hor i zedr epr esent at i veof ,t hePr eSpi l l
Benef i t Pr ovi di ngEmpl oyer .
7. For NewEnt r ant st oEmpl oyment ,document at i onest abl i shi ngal l of t hef ol l ow i ng:
a. That t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant sof f er i ncl udedPr eSpi l l Ret i r ement Benef i t s.
b. That asof Apr i l 20,2010,t heNewEnt r ant t oEmpl oyment pl annedt opar t i ci pat ei n
t heof f er edPr eSpi l l Ret i r ement Benef i t s.
c. Theamount of Pr eSpi l l Ret i rement Benef i t sf or w hi cht heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant w oul d
havebeenel i gi bl e,t hevest i ngschedul ef or suchbenef i t s,and,i f t heamount or
0252 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-18 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 11
6
vest i ngof Pr eSpi l l Ret i r ement Benef i t sw ascont i ngent upont heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant s
cont r i but i ons,t hepl annedcont r i but i onsof t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant .
d. If t heNewEnt r ant t oEmpl oyment sof f er w asamendedr at her t hanw i t hdr aw n,t he
El i gi bl eCl ai mant sandhi sor her Pr eSpi l l Benef i t Pr ovi di ngEmpl oyer sact ual post
DW HSpi l l cont r i but i onst ot hePr eSpi l l Ret i r ement Pl an.
Document at i onmayi ncl ude,f or exam pl e,t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant sr el evant of f er l et t er ,
r et i r ement pl ani nf or mat i onr ecei vedf r omt hePr eSpi l l Benef i t Pr ovi di ngEmpl oyer ,and/ or
aSwor nWr i t t enSt at ement f r om anaut hor i zedr epr esent at i veof t hePr eSpi l l Benef i t
Pr ovi di ngEmpl oyer w i t hr el evant i nf or mat i onr egar di ngt hePr eSpi l l Ret i r ement Benef i t s,
suchascont r i but i ont er msandcondi t i ons,t hecl ai mant sel i gi bi l i t y,et c.
6. If t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant obt ai nedr et i r ement benef i t sf r omanew empl oyer af t er t he
t er mi nat i onof t hePr eSpi l l Ret i r ement Benef i t s,but pr i or t oDecember 31,2011( New
Empl oyer Ret i r ement Benef i t s ),t hecl ai mant shal l pr ovi dedocument sset t i ngf or t ht he
ef f ect i vedat e(s)of anyNewEmpl oyer Ret i r ement Benef i t s.
a. Thet er mi nat i onof t hePr eSpi l l Insur ancePl anCover ageor ,f or NewEnt r ant st o
Empl oyment ,t hedat eonw hi cht hePr eSpi l l Insur ancePl anCover agew oul dhave
begunabsent t heDW HSpi l l ,unt i l
b. Theear l i er of (i )t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant senr ol l ment i naNewEmpl oyer Insur ancePl an,
or (i i )December 31,2011.
OR
2
El i gi bl eCl ai mant swhoqual i f yf or compensat i onpur suant t oOpt i on1mayal t er nat i vel ybecompensat edont he
basi sof Opt i on2(i f t heappr opr i at ei nf or mat i oni spr ovi ded).
0252
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-18 Filed 04/18/12 Page 7 of 11
7
2. Compensat i onBasedonDocument at i onRegar di ngPr emi umsPai dbyt hePr eSpi l l Benef i t
Pr ovi di ngEmpl oyer
3
:If t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant pr ovi desaSwor nWr i t t enSt at ement f r oman
aut hor i zedr epr esent at i veof t hePr eSpi l l Benef i t Pr ovi di ngEmpl oyer ,t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant
mayber ei mbur sedbasedont hepr emi um(s)pai df or t hePr eSpi l l Insur ancePl anCover age(s)
byt hePr eSpi l l Benef i t Pr ovi di ngEmpl oyer .Thet ot al l ossof i ncomew i l l equal (i )t hedai l yr at e
f undedbyt hePr eSpi l l Benef i t Pr ovi di ngEmpl oyer mul t i pl i edby(i i )t het ot al number of daysi n
t heper i odf or w hi cht heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant qual i f i esf or Heal t hInsur anceCover ageLosses.
Heal t hInsur anceCover ageLossesw i l l becal cul at edover t heper i odext endi ngf r om:
a. Thet er mi nat i onof t hePr eSpi l l Insur ancePl anCover ageor ,f or NewEnt r ant st o
Empl oyment ,t hedat eonw hi cht hePr eSpi l l Insur ancePl anCover agew oul dhave
begunabsent t heDW HSpi l l ,unt i l
b. Theear l i er of (i )t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant senr ol l ment i naNewEmpl oyer Insur ancePl an,
or (i i )December 31,2011.
OR
3. Compensat i onBasedonEst i mat edPr emi umsPai dbyt hePr eSpi l l Benef i t Pr ovi di ng
Empl oyer
4
:AnEl i gi bl eCl ai mant w hodi dnot r epl acecover aget hr oughCOBRAor Repl acement
Heal t hInsur anceCover age,t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant sHeal t hInsur anceCover ageLossesw i l l be
cal cul at edasf ol l ow s:
3
El i gi bl eCl ai mant swhoqual i f yf or compensat i onpur suant t oOpt i on2mayal t er nat i vel ybecompensat edont he
basi sof Opt i on1(i f t heappr opr i at ei nf or mat i oni spr ovi ded).
4
Opt i on3w i l l onl ybeusedi nci r cumst ancesw her et heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant i sunabl et opr ovi det hei nf or mat i on
necessar yt oper f or mt hecal cul at i onsset f or t hi nOpt i ons1or 2.
5
Thesef act or sr epr esent t heappr oxi mat epor t i onof heal t hcar ei nsur ancepr emi umsf undedbyempl oyeesbased
ondat af r omt heBur eauof Labor St at i st i csEmpl oyeeBenef i t sSur vey.
0252 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-18 Filed 04/18/12 Page 8 of 11
8
6
Thesef act or sr epr esent t heappr oxi mat epor t i onof heal t hcar ei nsur ancepr emi umsf undedbyempl oyeesbased
ondat af r omt heBur eauof Labor St at i st i csEmpl oyeeBenef i t sSur vey.
7
For exampl e,i f t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant r ecei vedcover agef r omPost Spi l l Empl oyerInsurancePl anCover ageasof
t hedat eof t het er mi nat i onof t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant sPr eSpi l l Insur ancePl anCover age,t hecl ai mant w i l l not have
suf f er edacompensabl el ossandw i l l t her ef or enot r ecei vecompensat i on.
0252
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-18 Filed 04/18/12 Page 9 of 11
9
b. Theear l i er of (i )t heef f ect i vedat eof anyNewEmpl oyer Ret i r ement Benef i t s,or (i i )
December 31,2011.
TheEl i gi bl eCl ai mant sRet i r ement Benef i t Lossesshal l bedet er mi nedasf ol l ow s:
1. St ep1:Est abl i shDai l yRet i r ement Benef i t sRat e(s)
a. If t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant sPr eSpi l l Ret i r ement Benef i t sw er eel i mi nat edasdescr i bed
above,cal cul at et he Pr eSpi l l Dai l yRet i r ement Benef i t sRat e bydi vi di ng(i )by(i i ),as
descr i bedbel ow :
i . Thet ot al vest edpor t i onof t hePr eSpi l l Ret i r ement Benef i t scont r i but edon
behal f of t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant byt hePr eSpi l l Benef i t Pr ovi di ngEmpl oyer
bet w eent hel at er of M ay1,2009or t hecommencement dat eof t heEl i gi bl e
Cl ai mant sempl oyment w i t ht hePr eSpi l l Benef i t Pr ovi di ngEmpl oyer ,andt he
document eddat eonw hi cht hePr eSpi l l Ret i r ement Benef i t sw er er educedor
t er mi nat ed,by
i i . Thet ot al number of daysi nt hat per i od.
b. If t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant sPr eSpi l l Ret i r ement Benef i t sw er er educed,t hen:
i . If t her ew asnopost DW HSpi l l Pl anChange,t hePr eSpi l l Ret i r ement Benef i t s
Rat ecal cul at edi n(a)abovew i l l appl yf or al l r el evant per i ods;or
i i . If t her ew asapost DW HSpi l l Pl anChange,t hen:
1. ThePr eSpi l l Dai l yRet i r ement Benef i t sRat ecal cul at edasi n(a)above
w i l l appl yf or t her el evant per i odpr i or t ot hePl anChange,and
2. For t her el evant per i odaf t er t hePl anChange,t he Revi sedDai l y
Ret i r ement Benef i t sRat e w i l l bet heexpect eddai l yr at ebasedont he
Pr eSpi l l Benef i t Pr ovi di ngEmpl oyer sr evi sedcont r i but i ont er ms
r el at i vet ot heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant spr eDW HSpi l l ear ni ngs.
c. If t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant w asaNewEnt r ant t oEmpl oyment ,t he NewEnt r ant
Ret i r ement Benef i t sRat e w i l l becal cul at edast hePr eSpi l l Benef i t Pr ovi di ng
Empl oyer sexpect edaver agedai l ycont r i but i ononbehal f of t heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant based
ondocument spr ovi dedbyt heEl i gi bl eCl ai mant .
0252 5
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-18 Filed 04/18/12 Page 11 of 11
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-19 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 19
Addendum t o Indi vi dual Fr amew or k
I. Indi vi dual Per i odi c Vendor s ( IPV )
1
A. El i gi bi l i t y
An IPV i s a Nat ur al Per son cl ai mi ng economi c l oss dur i ng a per i od i n M ay t hr ough
December 2010 w ho sat i sf i es al l of t he f ol l ow i ng cr i t er i a:
1. Regul ar l y sol d at r et ai l dur i ng 2009 and 2010 any of t he l egal f ood, souveni r , ar t ,
t our i st -r el at ed or w at er -r el at ed goods or ser vi ces l i st ed i n At t achment A or
subst ant i al l y equi val ent i t ems ( Cover ed Sal es ) t o CONSUM ERS i n Zones A, B or
C dur i ng M ay t hr ough December 2009 and/ or M ay t hr ough December 2010.
2. M ade such Cover ed Sal es, pr i mar i l y t o non-l ocal CONSUM ERS,
2
except t hat
w at er -r el at ed Cover ed Sal es, need not be pr i mar i l y made t o non-l ocal
CONSUM ERS.
3. Di d not mai nt ai n a per manent busi ness l ocat i on i n a bui l di ng at w hi ch t he
cl ai mant made Cover ed Sal es.
4. Hel d any l i censes r equi r ed by l aw .
5. Was not empl oyed by an empl oyer i n connect i on w i t h such Cover ed Sal es.
6. Does not have Tax Inf or mat i on Document s suf f i ci ent t o suppor t a cl ai m under
t he Busi ness Compensat i on Fr amew or k f or t hi s cl ai med l oss.
B. Causat i on
1. Causat i on shal l be pr esumed f or cl ai med l osses associ at ed w i t h l ost Cover ed
Sal es i n Zones A and B. If t he cl ai mant al l eges l ost Cover ed Sal es i n Zone C, t he
cl ai mant must pr ovi de ei t her :
a. Document s est abl i shi ng a decl i ne of 5% or mor e i n net ear ni ngs f r om
t he cl ai mant s Cover ed Sal es i n Zone C dur i ng t he cl ai mant -sel ect ed
per i od of 3 consecut i ve mont hs or mor e dur i ng M ay t hr ough December
2010 ( Compensat i on Per i od ), compar ed t o t he same 3 or mor e
consecut i ve mont h per i od i n 2009; OR
1
Thi s sect i on i s not i nt ended t o compensat e l osses associ at ed w i t h vendor s w ho do not qual i f y f or
compensat i on pur suant t o Sect i ons I V and w hose cl ai med l osses r el at e t o i ncome f r om Fest i val s (as def i ned
her ei n). Fest i val -r el at ed l osses ar e addr essed i n a separ at e sect i on of t hi s document . Cl ai mant s may,
how ever , f i l e separ at e cl ai ms f or compensat i on associ at ed w i t h Fest i val -r el at ed l osses and IPV-r el at ed l osses,
as appl i cabl e.
2
CONSUM ER shal l have t he meani ng i n t he Economi c and Pr oper t y Damages Set t l ement Agr eement . A
CONSUM ER shal l be consi der ed a non-l ocal CONSUM ER i f t hey r esi de mor e t han 60 mi l es f r om t he l ocat i on
at w hi ch cl ai mant made t he Cover ed Sal e.
027375
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-19 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 19
2
b. A st at ement f r om an Adj acent Busi ness as def i ned i n Sect i on I(C)4(e)
bel ow , t hat t he Adj acent Busi ness exper i enced a decl i ne i n sal es t o non-
l ocal CONSUM ERS dur i ng M ay t hr ough December 2010 compar ed t o
M ay t hr ough December 2009 due t o or r esul t i ng f r om t he DWH Spi l l .
C. Document at i on Requi r ement s
An IPV under t hi s Sect i on must pr ovi de t he document s i ndi cat ed bel ow :
1. Recor ds Regar di ng Cover ed Sal es
a. Document s r egar di ng t he IPV s Cover ed Sal es i n Zones A, B or C t o
CONSUM ERS, i ncl udi ng non-l ocal CONSUM ERS, f r om M ay t hr ough
December 2009 and M ay t hr ough December 2010. The i nf or mat i on
must be suf f i ci ent f or t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or t o det er mi ne t hat t he
IPV w as i n t he busi ness of r egul ar l y maki ng such Cover ed Sal es pr i or t o
Apr i l 20, 2010, and i ncl udes al l i nf or mat i on r egar di ng t he IPV s r evenues
f r om Cover ed Sal es f r om M ay t hr ough December 2009 and M ay
t hr ough December 2010, as w el l as cor r espondi ng expenses. Such
document at i on coul d i ncl ude, but i s not l i mi t ed t o, t he f ol l ow i ng:
i . Sal es l ogs, sal es t ax r ecei pt s, cash r ecei pt s r egi st er s, cr edi t car d
r egi st er s, bank st at ement s or ot her cont empor aneous r ecor ds;
and/ or
i i . Recei pt s f r om t hi r d-par t y vendor s or ot her sour ces r el at ed t o
t he pur chase of mat er i al s or equi pment r el at ed t o t he Cover ed
Sal es; and/ or
i i i . Document s est abl i shi ng any w ages pai d t o empl oyees or
amount s pai d t o ot her i ndi vi dual s w ho assi st ed i n maki ng t he
Cover ed Sal es, or any ot her expenses i ncur r ed i n connect i on
w i t h t he Cover ed Sal es.
b. Phot ogr aphs and ot her document at i on (i ncl udi ng but not l i mi t ed t o
new s ar t i cl es, sal es f l yer s or adver t i sement s) r ef l ect i ng (i ) t he goods or
ser vi ces sol d i n Cover ed Sal es by t he IPV, (i i ) t he l ocat i on(s) at w hi ch t he
IPV sol d t he goods or ser vi ces (i ncl udi ng any document s pr ovi di ng
i nf or mat i on r egar di ng an Adj acent Busi ness), (i i i ) t he pr i ces char ged f or
Cover ed Sal es of goods or ser vi ces, and/ or ot her pr oduct i nf or mat i on,
and (i v) any bi ogr aphi cal or ot her backgr ound i nf or mat i on on t he IPV
sel l i ng t he goods or ser vi ces. The IPV shal l al so pr ovi de t he dat e(s) of
any phot ogr aphs and t he l ocat i ons depi ct ed. If t he exact dat e i s not
avai l abl e, t he IPV may pr ovi de t he mont h, or r ange of mont hs, and year .
c. Document s est abl i shi ng t he IPV s t ot al ear ned i ncome f r om Cover ed
Sal es (net of al l var i abl e expenses) f or M ay t hr ough December 2009 and
M ay t hr ough December 2010.
02737
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-19 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 19
3
d. Any avai l abl e document s show i ng t hat t he IPV made Cover ed Sal es t o
non-l ocal CONSUM ERS i n each per i od, w i t h suppor t i ng i nf or mat i on
and/ or document at i on suf f i ci ent t o per mi t t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or t o
r easonabl y concl ude t hat t he IPV made sal es t o non-l ocal CONSUM ERS
i n each per i od.
i . For IPVs sel l i ng i n Zones A and B, sal es t o non-l ocal CONSUM ERS
shal l be pr esumed.
i i . For Cover ed Sal es i n Zone C, t he IPV may pr ovi de IPV s r ecei pt s
r ef l ect i ng pur chaser s addr esses, and/ or document at i on
est abl i shi ng t hat t he Cover ed Sal es w er e made on an i nt er st at e
hi ghw ay or ot her hi ghw ay i n Zone C or i n an ar ea gener al l y
vi si t ed by Tour i st such as a museum, zoo, or hi st or i c si t e.
e. Document s i dent i f yi ng by name, addr ess and t el ephone number any
empl oyee i n connect i on w i t h t he Cover ed Sal es of cl ai mant dur i ng 2009
or 2010.
2. Li censi ng Document at i on: If a gover nment -i ssued l i cense/ per mi t w as r equi r ed
t o make any Cover ed Sal es, IPV shal l pr ovi de a copy of val i d 2009 and 2010
l i censes,
3
or evi dence such exi st ed, such as:
Busi ness l i cense.
Vendor s l i cense.
Peddl er s l i cense.
It i ner ant Vendor l i cense.
Commer ci al / r ecr eat i onal f i shi ng l i cense.
Occupat i onal l i cense.
Sal es t ax l i cense.
Ot her l i censes & per mi t s r el at ed t o i ncome sour ces.
Cancel ed check f or l i cense or af f i davi t f r om i ssui ng gover nment body.
3. IPV Empl oyabi l i t y Document at i on
4
: The IPV must pr ovi de bot h:
3
To t he ext ent a st at e or muni ci pal i t y or ot her gover nment al agency agr ees t o pr ovi de t he Cl ai ms
Admi ni st r at or w i t h access t o any of f i ci al dat abase suf f i ci ent f or t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or t o conf i r m t he
cl ai mant possessed a val i d 2009 and 2010 l i cense, t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or need not r equi r e f r om t he
cl ai mant a copy of t he val i d l i cense. Rat her , t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or i s aut hor i zed t o accept f r om t he
cl ai mant t he l i cense number as suf f i ci ent t o sat i sf y t hi s subpar t , and t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or w i l l use t he
dat abase t o conf i r m cl ai mant s l i cense i s val i d.
027377
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-19 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 19
4
a. A copy of a Soci al Secur i t y car d, gover nment i ssued i dent i f i cat i on,
t empor ar y w or ker vi sa, or gr een car d t hat w as val i d as of Apr i l 20, 2010
or ver i f i cat i on of exi st ence of at l east one such document f r om a publ i c
dat abase pr ovi di ng t he same i nf or mat i on as w oul d be pr ovi ded f r om
t he or i gi nal document ;
AND
b. Evi dence t hat t he IPV w as at l east 16 year s of age as of Apr i l 20, 2010.
Accept abl e evi dence i ncl udes a copy of a val i d dr i ver s l i cense, a val i d
passpor t , or t he IPV s bi r t h cer t i f i cat e, ot her gover nment i ssued
i dent i f i cat i on i ndi cat i ng dat e of bi r t h, or ver i f i cat i on of exi st ence of at
l east one such document f r om a publ i c dat abase pr ovi di ng t he same
i nf or mat i on as w oul d be pr ovi ded f r om t he or i gi nal document .
4. IPV Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement : The IPV must submi t a Sw or n Wr i t t en
St at ement t hat set s f or t h al l of t he f ol l ow i ng:
a. Ver i f i cat i on t hat t he IPV does not have avai l abl e, and i s not abl e t o
pr ovi de, Tax Inf or mat i on Document s suf f i ci ent t o suppor t a cl ai m as a
busi ness under t he Busi ness Compensat i on Fr amew or k f or t he cl ai mant
Cover ed Sal es.
b. A descr i pt i on of t he Cover ed Sal es made by t he IPV, i ncl udi ng a
descr i pt i on of t he r el evant goods or ser vi ces sol d by t he IPV.
c. A st at ement t hat (i ) t he IPV possessed and has at t ached copi es of al l
r equi r ed l i censes as set f or t h i n sect i on IC.2., or (i i ) t he r eason no such
l i cense(s) w er e r equi r ed.
d. A st at ement t hat al l avai l abl e document at i on r egar di ng r evenue and
expenses r el at ed t o Cover ed Sal es dur i ng t he per i ods (i ) M ay t hr ough
December 2009 and (i i ) M ay t hr ough December 2010 t hat t he IPV
possesses or has access t o has been pr ovi ded i n suppor t of t he cl ai m.
e. The name, addr ess, t el ephone number and a br i ef descr i pt i on of at l east
one busi ness sat i sf yi ng t he Tour i sm def i ni t i on and l ocat ed on a par cel of
pr oper t y w i t h a boundar y w i t hi n 100 yar ds of any l ocat i on at w hi ch t he
IPV made or ar r anged f or Cover ed Sal es ( Adj acent Busi ness ), and a
Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement f r om an ow ner or empl oyee of such busi ness
4
To t he ext ent t he st at e or f eder al gover nment agr ees t o pr ovi de t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or w i t h access t o any
of f i ci al dat abase suf f i ci ent f or t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or t o conf i r m t hat a cl ai mant possessed val i d
document at i on of t he t ype r equi r ed i n subpar t s 3(a) and 3(b). The Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or may not r equi r e
f r om t he cl ai mant a copy of t he r equest ed document . Rat her , t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or i s aut hor i zed t o
accept f r om t he cl ai mant t he r el evant gover nment i ssued number as suf f i ci ent t o sat i sf y t hi s subpar t 3, and
t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l ut i l i ze t he dat abase t o conf i r m t he cl ai mant s gover nment i ssued number ed i s
val i d.
027378
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-19 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 19
5
i n suppor t of t he cl ai m. If no such Adj acent Busi ness exi st s, t he IPV
shal l so st at e.
f . To t he ext ent t he IPV i s not abl e t o pr ovi de document s demonst r at i ng
t he r evenue associ at ed w i t h Cover ed Sal es, t he IPV shoul d est i mat e t he
Cover ed Sal es r evenues i n each of Zone A, B or C f or bot h M ay t hr ough
December 2009 and M ay t hr ough December 2010, and expl ai n t he basi s
f or t he est i mat es pr ovi ded (e.g., Sol d __ bags of peanut s at ___ per
uni t ). To t he ext ent document at i on exi st s i n suppor t of t he ear ned
i ncome est i mat e (or component s t her eof ), copi es of such
document at i on must be pr ovi ded.
g. To t he ext ent t he IPV i s not abl e t o pr ovi de document s demonst r at i ng
t he expenses associ at ed w i t h t he Cover ed Sal es, t he IPV shoul d pr ovi de
(i ) a descr i pt i on of any mat er i al s pur chased by t he IPV i n connect i on
w i t h maki ng t he Cover ed Sal es, i ncl udi ng t he name and addr ess of t he
pr ovi der of t he mat er i al s, and t he est i mat ed cost s of such mat er i al s i n
t ot al and/ or f or each good or ser vi ce sol d i n Cover ed Sal es, (i i ) an
est i mat e of any w ages pai d t o empl oyees or amount s pai d t o ot her
i ndi vi dual s w ho assi st ed i n maki ng t he Cover ed Sal es and an
i dent i f i cat i on of t he per i od t o w hi ch such payment s r el at e, and (i i i ) a
descr i pt i on and est i mat e of any ot her expenses i ncur r ed i n connect i on
w i t h t he Cover ed Sal es.
h. A descr i pt i on of any cash or i n-ki nd payment s made by t he IPV i n 2009,
2010 and/ or 2011 t o an Adj acent Busi ness i n consi der at i on of such
Adj acent Busi ness per mi t t i ng or f aci l i t at i ng IPV s Cover ed Sal es.
i . An expl anat i on suf f i ci ent t o per mi t t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or t o
det er mi ne t hat any r educt i on of IPV s net ear ni ngs f r om Cover ed Sal es
f r om M ay t hr ough December 2010 compar ed t o pr i or per i ods w as due
t o or r esul t i ng f r om t he DWH Spi l l .
5. Adj acent Busi ness Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement :
The IPV must pr ocur e and submi t a Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement f r om an ow ner or
empl oyee of an Adj acent Busi ness(es) ( Adj acent Busi ness Af f i ant ), set t i ng
f or t h t he f ol l ow i ng:
a. The name, addr ess, t el ephone number of t he Adj acent Busi ness Af f i ant
and r el at i onshi p t o t he Adj acent Busi ness; and
b. The busi ness name, addr ess(es), t el ephone number (s), and w ebsi t e(s) of
t he Adj acent Busi ness, and a descr i pt i on of t he nat ur e of t he busi ness;
and
c. A descr i pt i on of any cash or ot her payment s made by t he IPV i n 2009,
2010 and/ or 2011 t o t he Adj acent Busi ness i n consi der at i on of such
Adj acent Busi ness per mi t t i ng or f aci l i t at i ng t he IPV s sal es; and
027379
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-19 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 19
6
d. A st at ement set t i ng f or t h t he dat es and ot her i nf or mat i on r egar di ng t he
IPV s Cover ed Sal es w i t nessed by t he Adj acent Busi ness Af f i ant e.g.,
I obser ved IPV sel l i ng _____ [ TYPE OF GOODS OR SERVICES] at
[ LOCATION] dur i ng appr oxi mat el y [ DAYS OR WEEKS] dur i ng [ PRE-SPILL
PERIOD] and I obser ved t he IPV sel l i ng _____ [ TYPE OF GOODS OR
SERVICES at [ LOCATION] dur i ng appr oxi mat el y [ DAYS OR WEEKS] dur i ng
[ t he Compensat i on Per i od] . If t he IPV made Cover ed Sal es i n mul t i pl e
l ocat i ons dur i ng t he pr e-DWH Spi l l per i od, and w i shes t o r el y upon al l of
t hose sal es, t he IPV shoul d submi t an Adj acent Busi ness Sw or n Wr i t t en
St at ement w i t h r espect t o each such l ocat i on; and
e. For an IPV al l egi ng l osses i n Zone C w ho does not submi t
document at i on est abl i shi ng a decl i ne of 5% or mor e i n net ear ni ngs
f r om Cover ed Sal es i n Zone C dur i ng t he Compensat i on Per i od,
compar ed t o t he same 3 or mor e consecut i ve mont h per i od i n 2009,
t hen t he Adj acent Busi ness Af f i ant must set f or t h t he f ol l ow i ng
addi t i onal i nf or mat i on:
i . A st at ement f r om t he Adj acent Busi ness Af f i ant t hat t he
Adj acent Busi ness exper i enced a decl i ne i n sal es t o non-l ocal
CONSUM ERS dur i ng t he same t hr ee or mor e consecut i ve
mont hs i n M ay t hr ough December 2010 compar ed t o t he same
t hr ee or mor e consecut i ve mont hs i n M ay t hr ough December
2009;
i i . A descr i pt i on of t he amount and t i me per i od of such decl i ne,
t he Adj acent Busi ness Af f i ant s basi s f or such st at ement s; and
i i i . An expl anat i on of how t he decl i ne w as due t o or r esul t i ng f r om
t he DWH Spi l l .
D. Compensat i on Cal cul at i on
Consi st ent w i t h t he Causat i on pr ovi si ons of Sect i on B.1., t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l
eval uat e t he suf f i ci ency and r el i abi l i t y of i nf or mat i on pr ovi ded by IPV and t he
suppor t i ng Adj acent Busi ness Af f i ant (s), i ncl udi ng t he sw or n cl ai m f or m, Sw or n Wr i t t en
st at ement s, i nt er vi ew s (i f any) and/ or any suppl ement al i nf or mat i on t he Cl ai ms
Admi ni st r at or may r equi r e, t o det er mi ne w het her (i ) t he IPV engaged i n Cover ed Sal es
t o non-l ocal CONSUM ERS and such non-l ocal Cover ed Sal es decl i ned i n t he
Compensat i on Per i od and/ or (i i ) t he IPV exper i enced any ot her decl i ne i n Cover ed Sal es
due t o or r esul t i ng f r om t he DWH Spi l l . Compensat i on may be aw ar ded w her e t he
Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or det er mi nes t hat causat i on has been est abl i shed based upon t he
above-descr i bed i nf or mat i on as w el l as suf f i ci ent document at i on f or t he Cl ai ms
Admi ni st r at or t o det er mi ne t hat t he Cover ed Sal es i dent i f i ed by t he cl ai mant occur r ed
dur i ng t he per i ods i ndi cat ed ( Suf f i ci ent Document at i on ). Exampl es of such Suf f i ci ent
Document at i on i ncl ude:
1. A summar y spr eadsheet w i t h accompanyi ng suppor t i ng schedul es r ef l ect i ng t he
t ot al r evenues and t ot al expenses associ at ed w i t h Cover ed Sal es; or
027380
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-19 Filed 04/18/12 Page 7 of 19
7
2. Document s f r om per sons or ent i t i es unr el at ed t o t he cl ai mant t hat r ef l ect t he
t ot al r evenues and t ot al expenses associ at ed w i t h Cover ed Sal es.
The IPV Ear ni ngs f r om Cover ed Sal es shal l be cal cul at ed as t he di f f er ence bet w een a)
t he IPV s t ot al r evenues l ess cor r espondi ng t ot al expenses r el at ed t o Cover ed Sal es f or
any cl ai mant sel ect ed Compensat i on Per i od of t hr ee or mor e consecut i ve mont hs
bet w een M ay 1 and December 31, 2010, and b) t he same mont hs i n 2009.
The IPV s Lost Ear ni ngs shal l be cal cul at ed as t he IPV Ear ni ngs f r om Cover ed Sal es f or
t he Base Per i od mi nus t he IPV Ear ni ngs f r om Cover ed Sal es f or t he Compensat i on
Per i od.
The IPV s Compensat i on Amount shal l be equal t o t he l esser of t he IPV s Lost Ear ni ngs
or $12,000. An RTP of 1 shal l be appl i cabl e.
If t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or has r eason t o quest i on t he r el i abi l i t y of t he i nf or mat i on
pr ovi ded or i f t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or f eel s t hat t he i nf or mat i on suppl i ed i s i nsuf f i ci ent f or a
det er mi nat i on of t he IPV s l oss t o be made under t hi s Sect i on I, t hen t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or
may r equest an i nt er vi ew of t he IPV and/ or t he Adj acent Busi ness Af f i ant (s) consi st ent w i t h t he
Int er vi ew Pr ocedur es set f or t h i n t he Addendum Regar di ng Int er vi ew s of Cl ai mant s Al l egi ng
Indi vi dual Economi c Loss.
5
The Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l det er mi ne t he Fi nal Compensat i on Amount based on t he
i nf or mat i on pr ovi ded by t he IPV and t he suppor t i ng Adj acent Busi ness Af f i ant (s), i ncl udi ng t he
sw or n cl ai m f or m, af f i davi t s, i nt er vi ew s, any suppl ement al i nf or mat i on t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or
may r equi r e t he IPV t o pr ovi de t o suppor t t he cl ai m, and/ or any ot her i nf or mat i on t he Cl ai ms
Admi ni st r at or may det er mi ne t o be r el evant and r el i abl e. The Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or may r el y on
hi s cr edi bi l i t y and r el i abi l i t y det er mi nat i ons i n det er mi ni ng t he Fi nal Compensat i on amount , i f
any, t o be pr ovi ded t o t he IPV.
II. FESTIVAL VENDORS
6
A. El i gi bi l i t y
A Cancel ed Fest i val i s a Fest i val t hat occur r ed at any t i me f r om M ay t hr ough
December 2009 and w as or i gi nal l y schedul ed t o occur at any t i me bet w een M ay
t hr ough December 2010, but w as cancel ed af t er Apr i l 20, 2010 as a r esul t of t he DWH
Spi l l .
5
Not hi ng i n t hi s Indi vi dual Economi c Loss Fr amew or k shal l i n any w ay l i mi t t he r ight and obl i gat i on of t he
Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or t o i nvest i gat e f ul l y al l suspi ci ons of f r audul ent conduct by or on behal f of any cl ai mant ,
i ncl udi ng but not l i mi t ed t o conduct i ng any i nt er vi ew s and obt ai ni ng any document s t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or
deems necessar y.
6
For pur poses of t hi s document , IPVs and Fest i val Vendor s ar e consi der ed t o be separ at e cl ai mant s, but
not hi ng pr ecl udes a cl ai mant f r om maki ng a cl ai m bot h as a IPV and as a Fest i val Vendor .
6
The Par t i es shal l seek a Cour t Or der aut hor i zi ng t hem t o obt ai n f r om r el evant st at e and l ocal aut hor i t i es
i nf or mat i on r egar di ng exampl es of Fest i val s t hat may be pr esent ed at t he Fai r ness Hear i ng.
027381
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-19 Filed 04/18/12 Page 8 of 19
8
A Fest i val i ncl udes or gani zed st r eet f est i val s, t our nament s or maj or spor t i ng event s,
out door ar t exhi bi t i ons, car ni val s or ot her si mi l ar event s of t he t ype set f or t h i n
At t achment B hel d i n Zone A, B or C at any t i me dur i ng M ay t hr ough December 2009
and/ or M ay t hr ough December 2010.
Fest i val Sal es ar e l egal sal es of i t ems def i ned as Cover ed Sal es made at r et ai l at
Fest i val s.
A Repl acement Fest i val i ncl udes any or gani zed st r eet f est i val , t our nament or maj or
spor t i ng event , out door ar t exhi bi t i on, car ni val or ot her si mi l ar event of t he t ype set
f or t h i n At t achment B, r egar dl ess of w her e t hat event w as hel d, i n w hi ch t he cl ai mant
par t i ci pat ed bet w een M ay and December 2010 i n l i eu of a Cancel ed Fest i val .
Repl acement Fest i val Sal es ar e l egal sal es of i t ems def i ned as Cover ed Sal es made at
r et ai l at Repl acement Fest i val s.
A cl ai mant must be an el i gi bl e Fest i val Vendor t o qual i f y f or compensat i on pur suant t o
t hi s Sect i on II. A Fest i val Vendor (al so r ef er r ed t o her ei n as cl ai mant ) i s a Nat ur al
Per son cl ai mi ng economi c l oss f or a per i od i n M ay t hr ough December 2010 w ho
sat i sf i ed al l of t he f ol l ow i ng cr i t er i a bel ow :
1. Regul ar l y made Fest i val Sal es pr i or t o Apr i l 20, 2010; and
2. Hel d any and al l l i censes and/ or per mi t s r equi r ed by l aw ; and
3. Was not empl oyed by an empl oyer i n connect i on w i t h such sal es; and
4. Does not have Tax Inf or mat i on Document s suf f i ci ent t o suppor t a cl ai m under
t he Busi ness Compensat i on Fr amew or k; and
5. Cl ai ms a l oss of r evenue and ear ni ngs r el at ed t o a Fest i val i n w hi ch t he Fest i val
Vendor par t i ci pat ed or w oul d have par t i ci pat ed absent t he DWH Spi l l .
B. Causat i on
1. Causat i on shal l be pr esumed f or cl ai med l osses associ at ed w i t h Fest i val Sal es i n
Zones A and B.
2. If t he cl ai mant al l eges l ost el i gi bl e Fest i val Sal es i n Zone C, t he cl ai mant must
pr ovi de al l of t he f ol l ow i ng:
a. A Fest i val Vendor Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement t hat i ncl udes t he
i nf or mat i on r equi r ed i n Sect i on I(C)5(g); and
b. Cer t ai n r el evant document at i on speci f i ed her ei n; and
c. A Fest i val Coor di nat or Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement by a Fest i val
Coor di nat or of each Fest i val at w hi ch t he Fest i val Vendor pl anned t o,
or di d, make Fest i val Sal es. The t er ms Fest i val Coor di nat or Sw or n
027382
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-19 Filed 04/18/12 Page 9 of 19
9
Wr i t t en St at ement and Fest i val Coor di nat or ar e def i ned i n Sect i ons
II(C)5 bel ow .
C. Document at i on Requi r ement s
A Fest i val Vendor under t hi s Sect i on must pr ovi de t he document s i ndi cat ed bel ow :
1. Recor ds Regar di ng Fest i val Sal es
a. Document s r egar di ng t he Fest i val Vendor s Fest i val Sal es, f r om bot h
M ay t hr ough December 2009 and M ay t hr ough December 2010, and f or
any Repl acement Fest i val Sal es f r om M ay t hr ough December 2010.
The i nf or mat i on must be suf f i ci ent f or t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or t o
det er mi ne t hat t he Fest i val Vendor w as i n t he busi ness of r egul ar l y
maki ng Fest i val Sal es pr i or t o Apr i l 20, 2010, and i ncl udes al l
i nf or mat i on r egar di ng t he Fest i val Vendor s r evenues and expenses
f r om Fest i val Sal es f r om M ay t hr ough December 2009 and M ay t hr ough
December 2010, and f or Repl acement Fest i val Sal es f r om M ay t hr ough
December 2010. Such document at i on coul d i ncl ude, but i s not l i mi t ed
t o, t he f ol l ow i ng:
i . Sal es l ogs, sal es t ax r ecei pt s, cash r ecei pt s r egi st er s, cr edi t car d
r egi st er s, bank st at ement s or ot her cont empor aneous r ecor ds;
and/ or
i i . Recei pt s f r om vendor s or ot her sour ces r el at ed t o pr oduct
cost s, mat er i al pur chases, and/ or equi pment pur chases r el at ed
t o t he Fest i val Sal es and Repl acement Fest i val Sal es; and/ or
i i i . Document s est abl i shi ng any w ages pai d t o empl oyees or
amount s pai d t o ot her i ndi vi dual s w ho assi st ed i n maki ng t he
Fest i val Sal es or Repl acement Fest i val Sal es, or any ot her
expenses i ncur r ed i n connect i on w i t h t he Fest i val Sal es or
Repl acement Fest i val Sal es.
b. Document s evi denci ng par t i ci pat i on i n any and al l Fest i val s dur i ng t he
per i od M ay t hr ough December 2009 and M ay t hr ough December 2010,
and al l Repl acement Fest i val s f r om M ay t hr ough December 2010,
i ncl udi ng but not l i mi t ed t o (i ) r ecor ds of payment made by Fest i val
Vendor t o par t i ci pat e i n each Fest i val or Repl acement Fest i val , i f
appl i cabl e, and (i i ) ent r y or r egi st r at i on f or ms, or ot her document s
show i ng al l boot h or st al l assi gnment s, i f appl i cabl e.
c. If appl i cabl e, document s evi denci ng Fest i val Vendor s i nt ended
par t i ci pat i on i n a Cancel ed Fest i val , i ncl udi ng but not l i mi t ed t o (i )
r ecor ds of payment made by Fest i val Vendor t o par t i ci pat e i n each
Fest i val and r et ur ned due t o t he Cancel ed Fest i val bei ng cancel ed, and
(i i ) ent r y or r egi st r at i on f or ms, or ot her document s show i ng al l boot h or
st al l assi gnment s, and (i i i ) any document s not i f yi ng t he Fest i val Vendor
t hat t he Cancel ed Fest i val w as cancel ed. The Fest i val Vendor shal l al so
027383
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-19 Filed 04/18/12 Page 10 of 19
10
i dent i f y any Repl acement Fest i val i n w hi ch t he Fest i val Vendor
par t i ci pat ed and t he cor r espondi ng Cancel ed Fest i val . If t he Fest i val
Vendor di d not par t i ci pat e i n any Repl acement Fest i val s, t he Fest i val
Vendor shoul d so st at e.
d. Document s i dent i f yi ng by name, addr ess and t el ephone number any
empl oyee i n connect i on w i t h t he Fest i val Sal es or Repl acement Fest i val
Sal es of cl ai mant dur i ng 2009 or 2010.
2. Li censi ng Document at i on
7
: If a gover nment -i ssued l i cense/ per mi t w as r equi r ed
t o make any Fest i val Sal es or Repl acement Fest i val Sal es, Fest i val Vendor shal l
pr ovi de a copy of val i d 2009 and 2010 l i censes, such as:
Busi ness l i cense.
Vendor s l i cense.
Commer ci al / r ecr eat i onal f i shi ng l i cense.
Occupat i onal l i cense.
Peddl er s l i cense.
It i ner ant Vendor l i cense.
Sal es t ax l i cense.
Ot her l i censes & per mi t s r el at ed t o i ncome sour ces.
3. Fest i val Vendor s Empl oyabi l i t y Document at i on
8
: The Fest i val Vendor must
pr ovi de bot h:
a. A copy of a Soci al Secur i t y car d, gover nment i ssued i dent i f i cat i on or
car d, t empor ar y w or ker vi sa, or gr een car d t hat w as val i d as of Apr i l 20,
2010 or a ver i f i cat i on of exi st ence of at l east one such document f r om a
publ i c dat abase pr ovi di ng t he same i nf or mat i on as w oul d be pr ovi ded
f r om t he or i gi nal document ;
7
To t he ext ent a st at e or muni ci pal i t y or ot her gover nment al agency agr ees t o pr ovi de t he Cl ai ms
Admi ni st r at or w i t h access t o any of f i ci al dat abase suf f i ci ent f or t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or t o conf i r m t he
cl ai mant possessed a val i d 2009 and 2010 l i cense, t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or need not r equi r e f r om t he
cl ai mant a copy of t he val i d l i cense. Rat her , t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or i s aut hor i zed t o accept f r om t he
cl ai mant t he l i cense number as suf f i ci ent t o sat i sf y t hi s subpar t , and t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or w i l l use t he
dat abase t o conf i r m cl ai mant s l i cense i s val i d.
8
To t he ext ent t he st at e or f eder al gover nment agr ees t o pr ovi de t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or w i t h access t o any
of f i ci al dat abase suf f i ci ent f or t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or t o conf i r m t hat a cl ai mant possessed val i d
document at i on of t he t ype r equi r ed i n subpar t s 3(a) and 3(b). The Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or may not r equi r e
f r om t he cl ai mant a copy of t he r equest ed document . Rat her , t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or i s aut hor i zed t o
accept f r om t he cl ai mant t he r el evant gover nment i ssued number as suf f i ci ent t o sat i sf y t hi s subpar t 3, and
t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l ut i l i ze t he dat abase t o conf i r m t he cl ai mant s gover nment i ssued number ed i s
val i d.
027384
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-19 Filed 04/18/12 Page 11 of 19
11
AND
b. Evi dence t hat t he Fest i val Vendor w as at l east 16 year s of age as of
Apr i l 20, 2010. Accept abl e evi dence i ncl udes a copy of a val i d dr i ver s
l i cense, a val i d passpor t , or a copy of t he Fest i val Vendor s bi r t h
cer t i f i cat e or ver i f i cat i on of exi st ence of at l east one such document
f r om a publ i c dat abase pr ovi di ng t he same i nf or mat i on as w oul d be
pr ovi ded f r om t he or i gi nal document .
4. Fest i val Vendor Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement : The Fest i val Vendor must submi t a
Fest i val Vendor Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement set t i ng f or t h al l of t he i t ems bel ow :
a. Ver i f i cat i on t hat t he Fest i val Vendor does not have avai l abl e, and i s not
abl e t o pr ovi de, Tax Inf or mat i on Document s suf f i ci ent t o suppor t a
cl ai m as a busi ness under t he Busi ness Compensat i on Fr amew or k.
b. A descr i pt i on of t he Fest i val Sal es and Repl acement Fest i val Sal es,
made by t he Fest i val Vendor , i ncl udi ng a descr i pt i on of t he r el evant
goods or ser vi ces sol d by t he Fest i val Vendor .
c. A st at ement t hat (i ) t he Fest i val Vendor possessed and has at t ached
copi es of al l r equi r ed l i censes and/ or per mi t s as set f or t h i n Sect i on
II(C)2, or (i i ) t hat no such l i cense(s) w er e r equi r ed.
d. A st at ement t hat al l avai l abl e r ecei pt s or r ecor ds of Fest i val Sal es
and/ or Repl acement Fest i val Sal es f r om (i ) M ay t hr ough December
2009 and (i i ) M ay t hr ough December 2010 t hat Fest i val Vendor
possesses or has access t o have been pr ovi ded i n suppor t of t he cl ai m.
e. A l i st of each Fest i val and Repl acement Fest i val i n w hi ch t he Fest i val
Vendor par t i ci pat ed as a vendor i n 2009 and 2010, and each Cancel ed
Fest i val . The Fest i val Vendor must al so pr ovi de t he f ol l ow i ng i n w r i t i ng,
as w el l as t he suppor t i ng document at i on i dent i f i ed above:
i . t he name, dat e(s) and l ocat i on(s) of each Fest i val , or
Repl acement Fest i val , and, f or Cancel ed Fest i val s, t he name
and or i gi nal l y pl anned dat e(s) and l ocat i on(s);
i i . t he name, addr ess, busi ness t el ephone number , and a br i ef
descr i pt i on of any sponsor or or gani zer of each Fest i val ,
Cancel ed Fest i val and Repl acement Fest i val ;
i i i . a descr i pt i on of al l f ees pai d i n connect i on w i t h par t i ci pat i on or
exhi bi t i on i n each Fest i val , Cancel ed Fest i val or Repl acement
Fest i val ; and
i v. f or each Fest i val or Repl acement Fest i val , a st at ement t hat
pr ovi des al l boot h or st al l assi gnment s, r ecor ds of payment
made by Fest i val Vendor t o par t i ci pat e i n each Fest i val or
027385
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-19 Filed 04/18/12 Page 12 of 19
12
Repl acement Fest i val , and sal es t ax r ecei pt s obt ai ned by t he
Fest i val Vendor i n connect i on w i t h t hei r par t i ci pat i on.
f . To t he ext ent t he Fest i val Vendor i s unabl e t o pr ovi de document s
demonst r at i ng t he r evenue associ at ed w i t h Fest i val Sal es and/ or
Repl acement Fest i val Sal es, t he Fest i val Vendor shoul d est i mat e t he
r evenue f r om Fest i val Sal es f or bot h M ay t hr ough December 2009 and
M ay t hr ough December 2010 and f or Repl acement Fest i val Sal es f r om
M ay t hr ough December 2010, and expl ai n t he basi s f or t he est i mat es
pr ovi ded (e.g., Sol d __ bags of peanut s at ___ per uni t ). To t he ext ent
document at i on exi st s i n suppor t of t he ear ned i ncome est i mat e (or
component s t her eof ), pr ovi de copi es of such document at i on.
g. To t he ext ent t he Fest i val Vendor i s not abl e t o pr ovi de document s
demonst r at i ng al l expenses associ at ed w i t h t he Fest i val Sal es or
Repl acement Fest i val Sal es, t he Fest i val Vendor shoul d pr ovi de a
descr i pt i on of any mat er i al s pur chased by Fest i val Vendor i n connect i on
w i t h maki ng t he Fest i val Sal es or Repl acement Fest i val Sal es, i ncl udi ng
t he name and addr ess of t he pr ovi der of t he mat er i al s, t he act ual or
est i mat ed cost s of such mat er i al s i n t ot al and/ or f or each good or
ser vi ce i t em sol d.
h. An expl anat i on suf f i ci ent t o per mi t t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or t o
det er mi ne t hat any r educt i on of Fest i val Vendor Ear ni ngs f r om Fest i val
Sal es or Repl acement Fest i val Sal es i n M ay t hr ough December 2010
compar ed t o Fest i val Vendor Ear ni ngs f r om t he same Fest i val s (and any
Fest i val s cancel ed i n 2010 due t o t he DWH Spi l l ) w as due t o or r esul t i ng
f r om t he DWH Spi l l , w her e Fest i val Vendor Ear ni ngs shal l be
cal cul at ed as t he Fest i val Vendor s t ot al r evenues l ess t ot al expenses
associ at ed w i t h Fest i val Sal es.
5. Fest i val Coor di nat or Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement (s): A Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement
f r om an i ndi vi dual r epr esent i ng t he ent i t y or commi t t ee r esponsi bl e f or
or gani zi ng t he Fest i val ( Fest i val Coor di nat or ) f or each Fest i val , Cancel ed
Fest i val or Repl acement Fest i val f or w hi ch l oss i s cl ai med set t i ng f or t h al l of t he
f ol l ow i ng:
9
a. The name, addr ess, t el ephone number of t he Fest i val Coor di nat or
af f i ant .
b. The name, dat e and l ocat i on of each Fest i val or Repl acement Fest i val
f or w hi ch t he af f i ant ser ved as a Fest i val Coor di nat or and i n w hi ch t he
Fest i val Vendor appl i ed t o par t i ci pat e, and t he name, addr ess and
9
If t he Fest i val Coor di nat or i s w i l l i ng t o pr ovi de at one t i me i nf or mat i on i dent i f i ed i n subpar t s 5(c), 5(d) and
5(e) f or al l Fest i val Vendor s at one t i me, t hen a si ngl e Fest i val Coor di nat or Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement shal l be
suf f i ci ent f or al l cl ai ms by Fest i val Vendor s. Al t er nat i vel y, t he Fest i val Coor di nat or may pr ef er t o pr ovi de
separ at e Fest i val Coor di nat or Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement s f or each Fest i val Vendor cont ai ni ng t he i nf or mat i on
r equi r ed i n subpar t s 5(c), 5(d) and 5(e), and t hi s shal l l i kew i se be accept abl e.
02738
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-19 Filed 04/18/12 Page 13 of 19
13
busi ness t el ephone number of any sponsor or or gani zer of each such
Fest i val , Cancel ed Fest i val or Repl acement Fest i val .
c. Ident i f i cat i on of each Fest i val or Repl acement Fest i val i n w hi ch t he
Fest i val Vendor (i ) submi t t ed an appl i cat i on, and (i i ) pai d a deposi t or
f ee, and (i i i ) ei t her (a) par t i ci pat ed, or (b) di d not par t i ci pat e because i t
w as a Cancel ed Fest i val . If t he Fest i val Coor di nat or i s pr ovi di ng
i nf or mat i on r egar di ng a Cancel ed Fest i val t hat w as cancel ed af t er Apr i l
20, 2010, and t her ef or e (i ) no appl i cat i on w as submi t t ed by t he Fest i val
Vendor , and/ or (i i ) no deposi t or f ee w as pai d by t he Fest i val Vendor
f or t he Cancel ed Fest i val , t he Fest i val Coor di nat or need onl y pr ovi de
t he r equest ed i nf or mat i on r egar di ng t he Fest i val Vendor s par t i ci pat i on
i n t he same Fest i val i n pr i or per i ods, as w el l as any i nf or mat i on
avai l abl e t o t he Fest i val Coor di nat or r egar di ng t he Fest i val Vendor s
expect ed par t i ci pat i on i n t he Cancel ed Fest i val .
d. Copi es of any appl i cat i on, or r ecor d of deposi t or f ee or not i ce of
cancel l at i on i dent i f i ed i n (c) above.
e. Any appl i cabl e per mi t r equi r ed t o hol d any Fest i val or Repl acement
Fest i val , and, i f avai l abl e, any Cancel ed Fest i val , i n w hi ch t he Fest i val
Vendor appl i ed t o par t i ci pat e.
f . At t endance dat a (or an est i mat e) f or each Fest i val i n w hi ch t he Fest i val
Vendor par t i ci pat ed and, i f t he same Fest i val w as hel d i n a pr i or year ,
at t endance dat a (or an est i mat e) f or t he near est pr i or year or per i od
pr i or t o t he DWH Spi l l .
g. Onl y i f t he Fest i val i s l ocat ed i n Zone C, t he Fest i val Coor di nat or must
al so set f or t h t hat t he Fest i val w as a Cancel ed Fest i val or exper i enced a
decl i ne i n at t endance, compar ed t o ei t her t he pr i or year or pr oj ect ed
at t endance, due t o or r esul t i ng f r om t he DWH Spi l l . The Fest i val
Coor di nat or must i ncl ude (i ) a st at ement descr i bi ng t he r easons f or t he
cancel l at i on or t he amount of decl i ne, and t he af f i ant s basi s f or such
st at ement s, and (i i ) a st at ement t hat t he Fest i val Coor di nat or af f i ant
bel i eves t hat t he cancel l at i on of a Cancel ed Fest i val , or t he decl i ne i n
at t endance at a Fest i val dur i ng t he per i od M ay 1 t hr ough December 31,
2010 w as due t o or r esul t i ng f r om t he DWH Spi l l .
6. Sponsor Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement : If no Fest i val Coor di nat or af f i ant i s
avai l abl e, submi t a Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement f r om anot her per son ot her t han a
r el at i ve w ho has per sonal know l edge of t he Fest i val Vendor s par t i ci pat i on i n a
Fest i val or non-par t i ci pat i on i n a Cancel ed Fest i val (i ncl udi ng but not l i mi t ed t o
a cust omer , f el l ow Fest i val Vendor , or oper at or of a busi ness l ocat ed w i t hi n 100
f eet of t he Fest i val Vendor s sal es l ocat i on at t he Fest i val ), pr ovi di ng det ai l s
r egar di ng t he Fest i val or Cancel ed Fest i val and t he Fest i val Vendor s
r el at i onshi p t o such Sponsor t hat shal l set f or t h al l of t he f ol l ow i ng:
a. Name, addr ess, phone and e-mai l of t he Sponsor .
027387
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-19 Filed 04/18/12 Page 14 of 19
14
b. Basi s f or t he per sonal know l edge.
c. Descr i pt i on of t he Fest i val or Cancel ed Fest i val .
d. Inf or mat i on r egar di ng t he Fest i val Vendor s par t i ci pat i on i n t he Fest i val
(i ncl udi ng dat e(s), l ocat i on(s) and t he descr i pt i on of t he Fest i val Sal es, i f
appl i cabl e).
e. Inf or mat i on r egar di ng Cancel ed Fest i val i n w hi ch t he Fest i val Vendor
w as schedul ed and r egi st er ed t o par t i ci pat e (i ncl udi ng dat e(s),
l ocat i on(s) and t he descr i pt i on of t he Fest i val Sal es, i f appl i cabl e) but
di d not par t i ci pat e because i t w as a Cancel ed Fest i val , and how t he
cancel l at i on w as due t o or r esul t i ng f r om t he DWH Spi l l .
7. The Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l eval uat e t he suf f i ci ency and r el i abi l i t y of
i nf or mat i on pr ovi ded by Fest i val Vendor and t he suppor t i ng Fest i val
Coor di nat or af f i ant (s), i ncl udi ng t he sw or n cl ai m f or m, t he Fest i val Vendor
Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement , t he Fest i val Coor di nat or Sw or n Wr i t t en
St at ement (s), t he Sponsor Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement (s) and/ or any
suppl ement al i nf or mat i on t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or may r equi r e, t o det er mi ne
w het her (i ) Fest i val Vendor engaged i n Fest i val Sal es and (i i ) such sal es decl i ned
i n t he per i od M ay t hr ough December 2010.
D. Compensat i on Cal cul at i on
Wher e t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or det er mi nes t hat causat i on has been est abl i shed based
upon (i ) t he Zone, or (i i ) t he Fest i val Vendor Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement and ei t her (a)
Fest i val Coor di nat or Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement (s) or (b) Sponsor Sw or n Wr i t t en
St at ement (s), as w el l as ot her document at i on, a Fest i val Vendor r el yi ng on t hi s Sect i on
II may r ecei ve compensat i on as f ol l ow s:
1. Fest i val Vendor s w i t h Document at i on Est abl i shi ng Loss of Ear ni ngs f r om
Fest i val s
a. St ep 1: Speci f y Fest i val s or Cancel ed Fest i val s f or w hi ch cl ai mant
i ncur r ed economi c l oss r el at ed t o t he DWH Spi l l .
The Fest i val Vendor w i l l be el i gi bl e f or compensat i on f or l osses
associ at ed w i t h each El i gi bl e Fest i val . An El i gi bl e Fest i val shal l be
def i ned as a Fest i val or Cancel ed Fest i val t hat sat i sf i es al l of t he
f ol l ow i ng cr i t er i a:
i . The Fest i val Vendor must demonst r at e l osses associ at ed w i t h
t he Fest i val .
i i . The Fest i val must have t aken pl ace (or f or a Cancel ed Fest i val ,
must have been or i gi nal l y schedul ed t o t ake pl ace) bet w een
M ay 1, 2010 and December 31, 2010.
027388
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-19 Filed 04/18/12 Page 15 of 19
15
i i i . Cl ai mant must have par t i ci pat ed i n t he Fest i val i n 2010, or , f or
Cancel ed Fest i val s, t he cl ai mant must pr ovi de document s
est abl i shi ng t he cancel l at i on, and t hat t he cl ai mant par t i ci pat ed
i n same Fest i val i n 2009.
i v. Document at i on (i ncl udi ng Fest i val Coor di nat or Sw or n Wr i t t en
St at ement (s)) must be suf f i ci ent t o est abl i sh l oss.
b. St ep 2: Det er mi ne Fest i val Vendor Ear ni ngs i n M ay t hr ough December
2009 f r om El i gi bl e Fest i val s i dent i f i ed i n St ep 1.
c. St ep 3: Det er mi ne Fest i val Vendor Ear ni ngs f r om El i gi bl e Fest i val (s) or
Repl acement Fest i val (s) i n M ay t hr ough December 2010.
d. St ep 4: Cal cul at e Fest i val Vendor Lost Ear ni ngs
Fest i val Vendor Lost Ear ni ngs w i l l be cal cul at ed as t he di f f er ence
bet w een Fest i val Vendor Ear ni ngs f r om El i gi bl e Fest i val (s) f r om M ay
t hr ough December 2009 (det er mi ned i n St ep 2) l ess Fest i val Vendor
Ear ni ngs f r om El i gi bl e Fest i val (s) or Repl acement Fest i val (s) f r om M ay
t hr ough December 2010 (det er mi ned i n St ep 3).
Tot al Fest i val Vendor Lost Ear ni ngs may not exceed $12,000. An RTP of
an amount agr eed upon by t he ar t i es not t o exceed 1 shal l be
appl i cabl e.
2. Fest i val Vendor Wi t hout Suf f i ci ent Document at i on Of Ear ni ngs Fr om Fest i val
Sal es Who Rel i es On Fest i val Coor di nat or Sw or n St at ement s.
For a Fest i val Vendor w i t hout document at i on suf f i ci ent t o demonst r at e and
cal cul at e Fest i val Vendor Ear ni ngs f r om El i gi bl e Fest i val (s), and w ho r el i es on a
Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement (s) by a Fest i val Coor di nat or , such Fest i val Vendor
w i l l be compensat ed up t o $10,000, based upon t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or s
assessment of t he cr edi bi l i t y and r el i abi l i t y of t he i nf or mat i on pr ovi ded by t he
Fest i val Vendor i n suppor t of t he cl ai m (i ncl udi ng f i nanci al per f or mance,
compl et eness and accur acy of document at i on, i nt er vi ew r esul t s, and any ot her
r el evant i nf or mat i on). No RTP shal l be appl i cabl e.
If t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or has r eason t o quest i on t he r el i abi l i t y of t he i nf or mat i on
pr ovi ded or i f t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or f eel s t hat t he i nf or mat i on suppl i ed i n i nsuf f i ci ent f or a
det er mi nat i on of t he Fest i val Vendor s l oss under t hi s Sect i on II. Then t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or
may r equest an i nt er vi ew of t he Fest i val Vendor and/ or t he Fest i val Coor di nat or , consi st ent
w i t h t he Int er vi ew Pr ocedur es set f or t h i n t he Addendum Regar di ng Int er vi ew s of Cl ai mant s
Al l egi ng Economi c Loss.
The Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l det er mi ne t he Fi nal Compensat i on Amount based on t he
i nf or mat i on pr ovi ded by t he Fest i val Vendor and t he suppor t i ng Fest i val Coor di nat or af f i ant (s),
i ncl udi ng t he sw or n cl ai m f or m, t he Fest i val Vendor Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement , t he Fest i val
Coor di nat or Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement (s), t he Sponsor Sw or n Wr i t t en St at ement (s), i nt er vi ew s
and/ or any suppl ement al i nf or mat i on t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or may r equi r e t he Fest i val
027389
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-19 Filed 04/18/12 Page 16 of 19
16
Vendor t o pr ovi de t o suppor t t he cl ai m. The Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or may r el y on hi s cr edi bi l i t y
and r el i abi l i t y det er mi nat i ons i n det er mi ni ng t he Fi nal Compensat i on Amount , i f any, t o be
pr ovi ded t o t he Fest i val Vendor .
027390
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-19 Filed 04/18/12 Page 17 of 19
17
At t achment A
COVERED SALES
1. Peanut s (boi l ed or r oast ed) or popcor n
2. Hot dogs
3. Ice Cr eam
4. Snow Cones
5. Tat t oos
6. Snakes
7. Beads
8. Fr esh f i sh or shel l f i sh
9. Jams, j el l i es and pr eser ves, and ot her canned f r ui t and veget abl es
10. Fr ui t
11. Smal l w ood car vi ngs such as w ood cl ocks, st at ues or w al l hangi ngs
12. Shel l j ew el r y
13. St r eet ar t i st s, car i cat ur i st s, or f acepai nt er s
14. St r eet per f or mer s, mi mes and magi ci ans
15. Sel l er s of cl ot hi ng speci f i cal l y pr omot i ng t he ci t y, beaches or ot her t our i sm act i vi t i es
(spor t s t eams, f i shi ng, et c.)
16. Hai r -w eavi ng and br ai di ng (not i ncl udi ng cut t i ng and hai r dr essi ng)
17. Shal l ow Wat er Di ver s i n por t i ons of t he Gul f cont ai ned i n t he Cl ass Def i ni t i on
18. Boat Repai r Di ver s i n por t i ons of t he Gul f cont ai ned i n t he Cl ass Def i ni t i on
19. Sw amp Boat and Ai r Boat Oper at or s i n por t i ons of t he Gul f cont ai ned i n t he Cl ass
Def i ni t i on
20. Par asai l , scuba and snor kel t eacher s/ oper at or s i n por t i ons of t he Gul f cont ai ned i n t he
Cl ass Def i ni t i on
Expr essl y excl uded f r om t hi s Fr amew or k ar e Deepw at er Di ver s and any i ndi vi dual s w or ki ng on an Oi l Ri g.
027391
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-19 Filed 04/18/12 Page 18 of 19
18
At t achment B
INCLUDED IN FESTIVALS
1. St r eet f est i val s or f ai r s (excl udi ng nei ghbor hood bl ock par t i es or gar age sal es or f l ea
mar ket s)
2. Out door ar t exhi bi t i ons (same excl usi ons)
3. Fi shi ng t our nament s
4. Gol f t our nament s
5. Boat i ng t our nament s
6. Rodeos
7. 4-H compet i t i ons
8. M aj or col l ege or pr of essi onal spor t s event s (not i ncl udi ng r egul ar season games, l ocal
cl ub or K-12 school event s)
9. Car ni val s
027392
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-19 Filed 04/18/12 Page 19 of 19
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-20 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 3
Addendum Regar di ng Int er vi ews Of Cl ai mant s Al l egi ng Indi vi dual Economi c Loss
And Ot her Indi vi dual s Pr ovi di ng Swor n St at ement s In Suppor t Of Such A Cl ai m
The Part ies agree t o t he f ollowing proposed Addendum, which applies where it is ref erenced in
t he Framework f or Individual Economic Loss Claims, subj ect t o t he underst anding t hat it is cont ingent on
t he concurrence of t he select ed Claims Administ rat or
1
t hat t he t erms, condit ions and deadlines set f ort h
in t he addendum are realist ic and achievable.
If , af t er reviewi ng t he Cl aim For m, and ot her i nf ormat i on submi t t ed by or on behal f of t he cl aimant
(collect ively, t he Cl ai m Submi ssi on ), t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or bel i eves t here is a r easonabl e basi s t o
quest i on t he credi bi l i t y and r el i abi l i t y of i nf ormat ion i n t he Cl ai m Submi ssi on, t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or
may i nt ervi ew t he cl aimant and/ or any ot her i ndi vi dual pr ovi di ng a swor n st at ement i n support of t he
claimant s cl aim, i n or der t o r esolve any such quest ion r egar di ng r el i abi l i t y. Such i nt er views may, at t he
Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or s opt ion, be conduct ed in-per son, by t elephone or el ect roni cal l y (e.g., vi a Skype).
1. Deadline To Conduct Int erviews. The Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l use t hei r best ef f or t s t o
conduct any int erview of a cl aimant , and/ or any ot her i ndi vi dual pr ovi di ng a sworn st at ement in
suppor t of t he claimant s claim, wi t hi n 45 (f or t y-f i ve) days of t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st rat or s
acknowl edgment of a compl et e Cl ai m Submi ssi on, pr ovi ded t hat such 45-day l imi t cannot st ar t
t o r un unt i l af t er t he announced openi ng of t he Cl ass Act i on Set t l ement Faci l i t y.
2
At t he
Claimant s opt ion, t he int erview period can be ext ended furt her; any such ext ension r equest by
t he cl aimant and agreed-upon ext ension shal l be document ed by t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or . If
at any t ime t he Cl aims Facil i t y r eceives and/ or has pendi ng a number of cl aims wi t hi n Cat egory
IV of t he Indi vi dual Compensat i on Framewor k such t hat t he above deadl i ne cannot be met
despi t e t he Cl aims Admini st rat or s good f ai t h compl i ance wi t h al l of t he ot her provi sions of t hi s
Addendum , t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or wi l l prompt l y so advise Lead Cl ass Counsel and BP
Counsel so t hat t he par t i es can seek r esol ut ion of t he issue t hrough t he Cl aims Admi ni st r at ion
Panel .
2. Ti mi ng And Locat i on Of Int er vi ews. The Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l use t hei r best ef f or t s t o
ar r ange t o conduct int er views at a t ime and locat ion convenient t o t he cl aimant and/ or ot her
i nt er vi ewee. The cl aimant may pr ovi de t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or wi t h reasonabl e advance
not i ce of conveni ent t imes and l ocat ions and t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l seek i n good f ai t h
t o honor such schedul i ng and locat ion r equest s.
3. Int er vi ewi ng St af f . The Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l use t hei r best ef f or t s t o r ecr ui t and t r ai n a
cl ai ms st af f t hat i s of diver se r aces, et hni ci t i es, and gender s mat chi ng t he communi t i es served
by t he Cl ai ms Faci l i t y and i t s of f i ces, and who have t he cult ur al background, t r aining and
l anguage ski l l s r equi r ed t o int er vi ew clai mant s or ot her i ndi vi dual s i n t hei r nat i ve l anguages,
i ncl udi ng but not l imi t ed t o Vi et namese, Khmer , and Nat ive Amer ican languages and cult ur es.
To t he ext ent cl aimant s, or ot her i ndivi dual s pr ovi di ng a swor n st at ement i n suppor t of clai ms,
1
As expl ai ned i n Economi c and Pr oper t y Damages Set t l ement Agr eement 3.3.3 and 3.3.6, t he Cl aims
Admi ni st r at or i s r esponsi bl e f or over seei ng t he Cl aims Admi ni st r at ion Vendor s who pr ocess cl aims.
2
The Cl aims Admi ni st r at or wi l l det er mi ne t he openi ng dat e of t he Cl aims Faci l it y.
02 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-20 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 3
2
and t hey or t hei r repr esent at i ves r equest t hat any int er view be conduct ed by an individual of
t he same et hni c backgr ound, t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l endeavor i n good f ai t h t o comply
wi t h t hat r equest . If and t o t he ext ent t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or concl udes compl i ance wit h
t hi s pr ovi si on ar e causi ng signi f i cant del ay i n cl ai ms processi ng, t hey shal l br i ng t he i ssue t o t he
at t ent ion of Lead Cl ass Counsel and BP Counsel so t hat t he part i es can seek resol ut i on of t he
i ssue t hrough t he Cl aims Admi ni st r at ion Panel .
4. Li mi t at i ons on i nt ervi ews. To t he ext ent pr ovisions of t he Indi vi dual Compensat i on Fr amewor k
i mpose l imi t at ions on t he number of i nt er views t hat may be conduct ed of cl aimant s i n cert ai n
cat egor ies, or indivi duals suppor t ing t heir claims, f or pur poses of resolving quest ions of
r el i abi l i t y, t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l compl y wi t h such l i mi t at i ons.
5. The Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l mai nt ai n recor ds document i ng t hei r compl i ance wi t h t he
r equi r ement s of t hi s Addendum.
6. Not hi ng i n t hi s par agr aph or i n t he Indi vi dual Compensat i on Fr amewor k i s i nt ended, nor shal l i t
be const r ued, t o limi t in any way t he r i ght and obl i gat ion of t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st rat or and/ or
Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or t o i nvest i gat e f ul ly al l suspi cions of f raudulent conduct by or on behalf of
any cl aimant , including but not limi t ed t o conduct ing any int erviews and obt aining any
document s t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or deems necessar y.
02
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-20 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 3
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-21 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 5
Framework For Subsistence Claims
A. Eligibility
1. Only claimants who satisfy the Subsistence Claimant definition shall be
eligible for compensation pursuant to this Framework for Subsistence Claims.
2. Subsistence Claimant shall be defined as follows: (i) a Natural Person who
satisfies the Class Definition, (ii) who fishes or hunts to harvest, catch, barter,
consume or trade Gulf of Mexico natural resources (including Seafood and
Game
1
), in a traditional or customary manner, to sustain his or her basic personal
or family dietary, economic security, shelter, tool, or clothing needs
2
, and (iii)who
relied upon subsistence resources that were diminished or restricted in the
geographic region used by the claimant due to or resulting from the DWH Spill.
3. The Subsistence Claimant definition includes claimants who satisfy the
definitions of a Commercial Fisherman and Seafood Crew, provided such
claimants satisfy the other elements of the Subsistence Claimant definition and
provide the documentation listed below.
3
4. The Subsistence Claimant definition does not include Recreational Fishermen
or Recreational Hunters. Recreational Fishermen shall be defined as
Natural Persons who fish for pleasure or sport. Recreational Hunters shall be
defined as Natural Persons who hunt for pleasure or sport. The Subsistence
Claimant definition does include claimants who hold a Recreational Fishing
license, provided such claimants satisfy the other elements of the Subsistence
Claimant definition and provide the documentation listed below.
B. Compensation
1. Identify the time period of loss of subsistence use consistent with the closure or
impairment of geographic areas relied upon by the Claimant between April 20,
2010 and December 31, 2011.
2. Identify the quantity of lost natural resources, including Seafood and Game. This
will include quantity of natural resources given to members of Claimants
extended family unit for their personal consumption or for the purposes of barter.
In making the determination, the Claims Administrator must evaluate any lost
1
Game is defined as nutria, mink, otters, raccoons, muskrats, alligators, and other wetlands and coastal
wildlife.
2
This definition is derived from various statutory and regulatory sources (e.g., ANILCA, Coast Guard) revised to
reflect the socio-economic realities of the Gulf Coast ethnic, traditional, and customary subsistence
communities and individuals.
3
The definitions of Seafood, Commercial Fisherman and Seafood Crew from the Seafood Distribution Chain
Definitions document shall apply herein.
028015
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-21 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 5
2
earnings claim also submitted by the claimant for compensation under the
Seafood Program to ensure that any in-kind Seafood compensation received by
the claimant is appropriately allocated between the claimants lost earnings and
subsistence claims. For example, Seafood sold by the claimant, rather than used
for barter should be allocated toward lost earnings which shall be compensated
through the Seafood Program.
a. Quantity of lost natural resources will be determined based on information
provided by the claimant in intake forms and interviews with the Claims
Administrator.
b. Quantity of lost natural resources will be calculated in, or converted to,
measures of consumable retail product by the Claims Administrator.
c. Quantities of lost natural resources shall not exceed reasonable
consumption rates as determined by the Claims Administrator.
3. Calculate the Total Value of Loss of Subsistence Use of Natural Resources by
multiplying the quantity in pounds by average post-spill retail price or, if
unavailable, an estimated retail price based on a reasonable proxy. Average post-
spill retail prices, and any proxies there for, will be determined the Parties based
on, where available, data on retail prices for Gulf of Mexico natural resources,
and be subject to approval by the Claims Administration Panel. The Parties shall
provide a chart of the approved, mutually agreed-upon prices to the Claims
Administrator for use in calculation of Subsistence claims.
4. Claimant will receive a Risk Transfer Premium (RTP) of 2.25, in order to
compensate for factors including value of Subsistence use, including damage to
subsistence family and community customs and culture.
5. Claimants compensation pursuant to this Framework For Subsistence Claims
shall be equal to the sum of (i) the Claimants Total Value of Lost Natural
Resources calculated in B(3) plus (ii) the Claimants Total Value of Lost
Natural Resources multiplied by 2.25.
C. Documentation Requirements
The Claimant must provide sufficient information for the Claims Administrator to
determine (1) that the claimant satisfies the Subsistence Claimant definition and, (2) the
quantity of Gulf of Mexico natural resources from within the Class Definition
geographic area lost by the Subsistence Claimant during the time period April 20, 2010
to December 31, 2011. The required documents shall include:
1. The Gulf of Mexico location(s) within the Class Definition geographic area
where claimant fished or hunted or utilized Gulf of Mexico natural resources
immediately prior to the oil spill.
028016
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-21 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 5
3
a. Type of documentation: (1) Identification on map and narrative
description on claims form; (2) narrative description on claims form of
equipment used to fish or hunt; and (3) affidavit verifying location of
claimants fishing or hunting grounds.
2. The location where the claimant fished or hunted or utilized Gulf of Mexico
natural resources between April 20, 2010 and December 31, 2011.
a. Type of documentation: Information provided by claimant on claims
form.
3. Length of time that fishing or hunting areas were closed or impaired as a result of
the spill.
a. Type of documentation: Information provided by claimant on claims
form, to be confirmed by claims facility by reference to closure maps and
other relevant reports.
4. Prior to spill, claimant relied upon the fishing or hunting area at issue for
subsistence purposes as defined above.
a. Type of documentation: (1) Claimant to specify on claims form number
of people in the extended family unit who rely on natural resources caught
by the Subsistence Claimant, the specific species and amounts of natural
resources relied upon, the percentage of subsistence source that natural
resources from closed or impaired areas provided prior to the spill, and (2)
a supporting affidavit.
4
Following an interview with the claimant,
members of the claims administration staff may, at their discretion, require
an additional affidavit from a third party or other appropriate supporting
information.
5. Copy of state and/or federal commercial or recreational fishing and/or hunting
license. Deckhands or others that are not required to possess a fishing license are
excused from this requirement.
D. Court-Appointed Distribution Agents Audit Process
BP, the PSC and the Claims Administrator shall jointly propose a Court-Appointed
Distribution Agent (CADA). Upon approval, the CADA shall work under the direction
and supervision of the Claims Administrator. The CADA shall establish a dedicated
team to assist Subsistence claimants in completing the claim form and collecting
supporting documentation, and will also confirm the eligibility status of the claimants.
The CADA will conduct subsistence interviews with claimants and apply the
4
The Parties shall collaborate on a form affidavit for Subsistance Claimants, which shall be subject to approval by
the Claims Administrator Panel.
028017
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-21 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 5
4
compensation formula. The CADA team shall establish a physical presence and a
reasonable operating schedule to allow claimants to be interviewed in their geographical
area including at Landing Dock locations.
E. Field Visits
There is no pre-set cap on payment amounts for Subsistence claims. However, the
CADA will not pay Subsistence claims with a base amount greater than $10,000 per
extended family unit without conducting a field visit and investigation as to the accuracy
of the claim prior to the payment.
F. RTP
An RTP of 2.25 shall be applied to the base compensation amount.
028018
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-21 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 5
0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 96
SEAFOOD COMPENSATION PROGRAM
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
GENERAL FRAMEWORK AND OVERVIEW OF SEAFOOD COMPENSATION
PROGRAM DISTRIBUTION
3
SHRIMP COMPENSATION PLAN 4
I. Expedited Compensation Method 8
II. Reduced Expedited Method 13
III. New Entrant Compensation Method 15
IV. Historical Revenue Method 18
V. Vessel Lease Compensation Allocation 24
OYSTER COMPENSATION PLAN 25
1. Oyster Leaseholder Interest Compensation 28
2. Oyster Leaseholder Lost Income Compensation 29
3. Oyster Harvester Lost Income Compensation 30
4. Vessel Lease Compensation Allocation 40
FINFISH COMPENSATION PLAN 41
I. Historical Revenue Method 44
II. Compensation for IFQ Quota Holders 49
III. Vessel Lease Compensation Allocation 50
BLUE CRAB/OTHER SEAFOOD COMPENSATION PLAN 52
I. Historical Revenue Method 55
II. Vessel Lease Compensation Allocation 63
SEAFOOD CREW COMPENSATION PLAN 65
I. Category I Crew Compensation 68
II. Category II Crew Compensation 70
III. Category III Crew Compensation 78
SEAFOOD SPILL-PAYMENT REDUCTION PROCEDURES 85
02 5
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 96
SEAFOOD COMPENSATION PROGRAM
OVERVIEW
The Seafood Compensation Program shall cover and compensate Commercial Fishermen,
Seafood Boat Captains, all other Seafood Crew, Oyster Leaseholders, and Seafood Vessel
Owners for economic loss claims relating to Seafood.
1
All economic loss claims by Commercial
Fishermen, Seafood Boat Captains, all other Seafood Crew, Oyster Leaseholders, and Seafood
Vessel Owners relating to Seafood will be part of and must be brought under the Seafood
Compensation Program.
2
The Seafood Compensation Program is divided into the following compensation categories and
claim types:
TABLE 1
CATEGORY COMPENSABLE CLAIMS
Shrimp Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman
Vessel Lessee claims
Boat Captain claims
Oyster Leaseholder Interest claims
Leaseholder Lost Income claims
Vessel Owner/Oyster Harvester Vessel
Lessee claims
Boat Captain claims
Finfish Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman
Vessel Lessee claims
Boat Captain claims
Individual Fishing Quota holder claims
Blue Crab/Other Seafood Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman
Vessel Lessee claims (including crab
trap damage)
Boat Captain claims
1
The terms Commercial Fisherman, Seafood Boat Captains, Seafood Crew, Oyster Leaseholders and Seafood
Vessel Owners as defined in the Seafood Distribution Chain Definitions (Exhibit 3 to the Deepwater Horizon
Economic and Property Damages Settlement Agreement) shall apply in this Seafood Compensation Program.
2
To the extent terms herein are defined in the Deepwater Horizon Economic And Property Damages Settlement
Agreement, those definitions shall apply in the Seafood Compensation Program. Nevertheless, any term
specifically defined within the Seafood Compensation Program, shall be interpreted as set forth in this Seafood
Compensation Program, notwithstanding any contrary definition in the Deepwater Horizon Economic And
Property Damages Settlement Agreement.
02 6
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 96
2
CATEGORY COMPENSABLE CLAIMS
Seafood Crew (excluding Boat Captains) for
all Seafood industries
Crew claimants with standard
documentation
Crew claimants with documentation
supplied by employer
Crew claimants with documentation
supplied by non-employers
For each category and compensable claim type, a Claimant will have to establish that the
Claimant is a Class Member and meets the separate eligibility requirements defined below. In
addition, Claimants are subject to the requirements of the Deepwater Horizon Economic And
Property Damages Settlement Agreement and any applicable Court order, except as otherwise
modified or provided by the Seafood Compensation Program.
Claimants are able to file a single Seafood Compensation Program Sworn Claim Form seeking
compensation for multiple compensable claims. A Claimant filing a claim under the different
plan in the Seafood Compensation Program, may be required to use different historical
information for the Benchmark Period and must review the definition of Benchmark Period in
each plan. For example, the Claimant may use a different Benchmark Period for the Claimants
claim under the Shrimp Compensation Plan and the Claimants claim under the Oyster
Compensation Plan. The following provides a non-exhaustive list of examples in which a single
claimant might be eligible to receive compensation for multiple compensable claims:
A shrimp Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee who is also a shrimp Boat
Captain may be eligible to receive compensation both as a shrimp Vessel
Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee and shrimp Boat Captain.
An oyster leaseholder may be eligible to receive compensation for both Leaseholder
Interest and Leaseholder Lost Income claims. If the oyster leaseholder claimant is also a
Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee and a Boat Captain, that claimant
may be eligible to receive compensation as both an oyster Vessel Owner/Commercial
Fisherman Vessel Lessee and an oyster Boat Captain.
A claimant who is a Boat Captain for vessel(s) in both the blue crab industry and shrimp
industry may be eligible to receive compensation under applicable blue crab and shrimp
categories.
Claimants filing multiple claims under the Seafood Compensation Program are required to
submit all claims at the same time on a single Seafood Compensation Program Sworn Claim
Form. The single Seafood Compensation Program Sworn Claim Form may be submitted at any
time after entry of the Preliminary Approval Order, but no later than thirty (30) days from the
date of entry of the Final Order and Judgment of the District Court ruling upon final approval of
the Settlement (Bar Date). Claims will be processed and paid as expeditiously as possible by
the Claims Administrator.
It is expressly acknowledged that the fact that a Claimant has made a claim and/or received
compensation under the Seafood Compensation Program, does not preclude that claimant from
029147
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 96
3
making an independent claim and/or receiving compensation under the Deepwater Horizon
Economic And Property Damages Settlement Agreement.
Compensation received by an eligible Claimant under the Seafood Compensation Program will
be reduced by the amount of prior Seafood Spill-Related Payments as described in the Seafood
Spill Related Payment Reduction Procedures in this document.
3
No other reductions to the
compensation amount under the Seafood Compensation Program will be taken, including
compensation received for work in the VoO Program or compensation for VoO Damages under
the Settlement.
Compensation under the Seafood Compensation Program provides compensation for economic
loss claims of Commercial Fishermen, Seafood Crew, Oyster Leaseholders, Seafood Vessel
Owners, and Individual Fishing Quota holders including all lost in-kind payments of Seafood
and all lost sales of Seafood, including undocumented sales. To the extent Commercial
Fishermen, Seafood Crew, Vessel Owners and Seafood Boat Captains engage in subsistence
activities unrelated to their commercial fishing for Seafood activities and have valid subsistence
loss claims other than the losses compensated in the Seafood Compensation Program, such
claims do not fall within the scope of this Seafood Compensation Program and recovery, if any,
would be under the Subsistence Claim Framework.
General Framework and Overview of Seafood Compensation Program Distribution
The Seafood Compensation Program is estimated to result in prompt claims payments totaling
more than $1.9 billion representing approximately 83% of the $2.3 billion Seafood
Compensation Program Amount. After applying the terms of the Deepwater Horizon Economic
And Property Damages Settlement Agreement (including determining the Seafood
Compensation Program Amount) and paying the eligible Seafood Compensation Program
claims, the Claims Administrator shall determine the amount of funds, if any, constituting the
remaining Seafood Compensation Program Amount. In the event there are Seafood
Compensation Program Amount funds remaining, such funds will be distributed to claimants that
received compensation from the Seafood Compensation Program. The balance will be
distributed to each Claimant in proportion to the Claimants gross compensation expressed as a
share of the gross compensation paid by the Claims Administrator to all claimants under the
Seafood Compensation Program.
4
Gross compensation reflects compensation paid by the Claims
Administrator prior to deduction for Seafood Spill-Related Payments.
3
Seafood Spill-Related Payments are defined as compensation paid to a claimant through the OPA Process, by
BP, the GCCF, or through the Transition Facility for economic loss claims relating to Seafood.
4
All claimants who receive compensation under the Seafood Compensation Program are entitled to a share of the
distribution of the balance whether or not their individual claims have been characterized as lump sum or a
similar term, and whether or not they are members of Categories II and III of the Seafood Crew Compensation
Plan (each of which provides for an Aggregate Compensation Amount, which shall not apply as a limitation to a
Claimants entitlement to a share of the balance to be distributed).
02914
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 96
4
SHRIMP COMPENSATION PLAN
Generally Applicable Provisions of the Shrimp Compensation Plan:
1. Eligible Claimants shall be comprised of Class Members (i) who do not fall within the
exclusions to the Economic Loss and Property Class Definition, (ii) who are Vessel
Owners, Commercial Fishermen who lease Seafood Vessels (Commercial Fisherman
Vessel Lessee), and/or Seafood Boat Captains that derive earnings from commercial
shrimping and (iii) who meet the additional criteria listed in this Shrimp Compensation
Plan.
2. It is understood that in some instances, the Vessel Owner is also the Commercial
Fisherman; however, it may be the case that the Vessel Owner leased the vessel to a
Commercial Fisherman. In those instances where the vessel was leased during the time
period of April 20, 2010 to December 31, 2010, the Vessel Owner and Commercial
Fisherman Vessel Lessee must file the vessel claim jointly in order to receive
compensation prior to the Bar Date, and they shall share any Vessel Owner/Commercial
Fisherman Vessel Lessee compensation provided for in this Shrimp Compensation Plan.
If at the time of the Bar Date either the Vessel Owner or the Commercial Fisherman
Vessel Lessee has not filed a claim, the one that has filed the claim shall receive the full
Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee compensation for the vessel. The
allocation of compensation between Vessel Owner and Commercial Fisherman Vessel
Lessee shall be determined as provided in Section V. If the vessel was not leased to a
Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee during the time period of April 20, 2010 to
December 31, 2010, the Vessel Owner is entitled to the full Vessel Owner/Commercial
Fisherman Vessel Lessee compensation for the vessel.
3. It is understood that in some instances, the Vessel Owner and/or the Commercial
Fisherman Vessel Lessee is also the Boat Captain. In those instances where the Vessel
Owner and/or the Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee were also the Boat Captain, they
shall be eligible to receive the Boat Captain compensation portion for the vessel under the
Shrimp Compensation Plan as set forth below. If the Vessel Owner and/or Commercial
Fisherman Vessel Lessee employed a Boat Captain on the vessel and did not serve as a
Boat Captain on that vessel, the hired Boat Captain is eligible for the Boat Captain
compensation, not the Vessel Owner or Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee.
4. To establish eligibility to participate in the Shrimp Compensation Plan, a Vessel Owner
Claimant must provide for each vessel(s) for which the Claimant is seeking
compensation:
A. Proof of ownership of the vessel during the time period of April 20, 2010 to
December 31, 2010.
B. Proof that as of April 20, 2010 there was a government license (even if it had
expired before that date) that authorized that vessel to commercially fish for
shrimp in the Specified Gulf Waters for the 2009 season or the 2010 season.
However, a Vessel Owner who did not have such a license for the vessel can
029149
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 96
5
participate in the Shrimp Compensation Plan for that vessel if the Claimant can
establish the criteria for the New Entrant Compensation Method as described in
Section III below.
C. The vessel name and any applicable federal and/or state vessel registration
numbers.
D. Proof that either:
1. the vessel was home ported in the Gulf Coast Areas at any time from
April 20, 2010 to April 16, 2012; or,
2. the vessel landed shrimp in the Gulf Coast Areas at any time from
April 20, 2009 to April 16, 2012.
E. A sworn statement attesting as to whether or not the vessel was leased during the
time period April 20, 2010 to December 31, 2010. If the vessel was leased during
this time period, the Vessel Owner must provide a copy of the lease agreement.
F. A sworn statement attesting as to whether or not the Vessel Owner was the Boat
Captain for that vessel during January 1, 2007 through December 31, 2009. If the
Vessel Owner was not the sole Boat Captain for that vessel for some portion of
January 1, 2007 through December 31, 2009, to the extent possible, the Claimant
shall identify all other Boat Captains employed on the vessel and the time periods
for which the Boat Captains were employed.
5. To establish eligibility to participate in the Shrimp Compensation Plan, a Commercial
Fisherman Vessel Lessee must provide for each vessel for which the claimant seeks
compensation:
A. Proof that during the period of April 20, 2010 through December 30, 2010 the
Claimant leased the vessel to be used for commercial shrimping.
B. Proof that as of April 20, 2010 there was a government license (even if it had
expired before that date) that authorized that vessel to commercially fish for
shrimp in the Specified Gulf Waters for the 2009 season or the 2010 season.
However, a Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee who did not have such a
license for the vessel can participate in the Shrimp Compensation Plan for that
vessel if the Claimant can establish the criteria for the New Entrant Compensation
Method as described in Section III below.
C. The vessel name and any applicable federal and/or state vessel registration
identification numbers.
D. Proof that either:
1. the vessel was home ported in the Gulf Coast Areas at any time from
April 20, 2010 to April 16, 2012; or,
0291 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 7 of 96
6
2. the vessel landed shrimp in the Gulf Coast Areas at any time from
April 20, 2009 to April 16, 2012.
E. A sworn statement, attesting that the Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee leased
the vessel during the time period of April 20, 2010 to December 31, 2010. The
Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee must also provide a copy of the lease
agreement for the vessel.
F. A sworn statement attesting as to whether or not the Commercial Fisherman
Vessel Lessee was the Boat Captain for that vessel during January 1, 2007
through December 31, 2009. If the Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee was not
the sole Boat Captain for that vessel for some portion of January 1, 2007 through
December 31, 2009, to the extent possible, the Claimant shall identify all other
Boat Captains employed on the vessel and the time periods for which the Boat
Captains were employed.
6. To establish eligibility to participate in the Shrimp Compensation Plan a Boat Captain
must provide:
A. Proof that as of April 20, 2010 the Boat Captain held a governmental license
(even if it had expired before that date) authorizing the Claimant to operate as a
Boat Captain and/or to commercially fish for shrimp in the Specified Gulf Waters
for the 2009 season or the 2010 season.
B. Proof that either the Boat Captain worked:
1. on one or more commercial shrimping vessels home ported in the Gulf
Coast Areas at any time from April 20, 2010 to April 16, 2012; or,
2. on one or more commercial shrimping vessels that landed shrimp in the
Gulf Coast Areas at any time from April 20, 2009 to April 16, 2012.
7. A Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee who does not have either a 2009
or 2010 fishing license or proof of shrimp landings in 2009, 2010 or 2011 can participate
in the Shrimp Compensation Program if that Vessel Owner can establish the criteria for
the New Entrant Compensation Method as defined in Section III below. Additionally, a
Boat Captain who had not previously worked as a Boat Captain for a commercial
shrimping vessel in the Gulf Coast Areas and who prior to April 20, 2010 had a written
job offer for employment as a Boat Captain on a vessel home ported in the Gulf Coast
Areas for the 2010 shrimping season may be able to establish the criteria for the New
Entrant Compensation Method as defined in Section III below.
8. A Sworn Statement attesting whether or not the Claimant received any Seafood Spill-
Related Payments. If the Claimant received Seafood Spill-Related Payments, the
Claimant shall provide documents
5
sufficient to establish the timing, amount and source
5
When documents are requested in the Seafood Compensation Program, Claimant may provide either legible
copies or originals of the documents.
0291 1
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 8 of 96
7
of Seafood Spill-Related Payments, including documents providing the claimants
BP/GCCF/Transition Facility Claim Number, if applicable, and any corresponding
payments.
Shrimp Compensation Plan Definitions:
Benchmark Period
6
is selected by the Claimant and can be (i) 2009, (ii) 2008 and 2009, or (iii)
2007, 2008 and 2009. If the Claimant elects to use years 2008 and 2009 or 2007, 2008, and
2009, the annual revenue amounts shall be averaged.
A Vessel Owner or Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee must submit separate Vessel
Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee claims for each vessel they owned or leased and
may select different Benchmark Periods for different vessels.
A Boat Captains claim reflects the Claimants activities on all vessels, and the Boat Captain
must select a single Benchmark Period for the Claimants claim.
A Vessel Owner or Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee who also submits a Boat Captain
claim may select different Benchmark Periods for the Claimants Vessel Owner/Commercial
Fisherman Vessel Lessee claim and the Claimants Boat Captain claim.
Compensation Plan Methods:
There are four methods for a Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee and/or Boat
Captain to be compensated under the Shrimp Compensation Plan. The options are:
Expedited Compensation Method
Reduced Expedited Compensation Method
New Entrant Compensation Method
Historical Revenue Method
A Vessel Owner or Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee may select different Compensation
Plan Methods for different vessels. There is no qualifying revenue level required for the
Historical Revenue Method. The qualifying vessel revenue for the Expedited Compensation
Method and Reduced Expedited Compensation Method is summarized in the second column of
Table 2 and the compensation amount is summarized in the third column. The eligibility,
documentation and details of each method are described more fully in Sections I and II below.
A Boat Captain must select a single Compensation Method for his claim. There is no qualifying
revenue for the Historical Revenue Method. The qualifying vessel revenue for the Expedited
Compensation Method and Reduced Expedited Compensation Method must be made based on
revenue for a single vessel size and type category (but not necessarily for a single vessel). The
6
For the Seafood Compensation Program, the Benchmark Period is defined independently for each Seafood
Compensation Program Plan and is set forth within the specific Plan. Definitions of Benchmark Period in any
other frameworks in the Deepwater Horizon Economic And Property Damages Settlement Agreement do not
apply in the Seafood Compensation Program.
0291 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 9 of 96
8
qualifying revenue for the Expedited Compensation Method and Reduced Expedited
Compensation Method is summarized in the second column of Table 2 and the compensation
amount is summarized in the third and fourth columns. The eligibility, documentation and
details of each method are described more fully in Sections I and II below.
TABLE 2
Qualifying Vessel Revenue and Compensation for Expedited
and Reduced Expedited Methods
Vessel Size
Qualifying
Vessel
Revenue
Vessel
Owner/Commercial
Fisherman Vessel
Lessee
Compensation
Boat Captain
Compensation
Expedited Method:
< 30 feet $32,500 $104,063 $92,813
30 - 44 feet $40,000 $135,281 $107,250
45 - 74 feet (Ice) $90,000 $270,563 $160,875
45 - 74 feet (Freezer) $275,000 $478,688 $284,625
75+ feet (Ice) $225,000 $416,250 $206,250
75+ feet (Freezer) $400,000 $582,750 $288,750
Reduced Expedited Method:
< 30 feet N/A N/A N/A
30 - 44 feet $25,000 $62,438 $49,500
45 - 74 feet (Ice) $50,000 $145,688 $86,625
45 - 74 feet (Freezer) $200,000 $333,000 $198,000
75+ feet (Ice) $150,000 $291,375 $144,375
75+ feet (Freezer) $290,000 $457,875 $226,875
I. Expedited Compensation Method
A. Eligibility Requirements
1. Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee
In order to qualify for compensation under the Expedited Compensation Method, the Vessel
Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee must provide for each vessel:
a. A copy of the 2009 or 2010 governmental issued vessel
registration for each of Claimants vessel(s) establishing the home
port of the vessel was within the states of Louisiana, Mississippi
and Alabama or a Florida registered vessel with its home port in
0291
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 10 of 96
9
the counties of Escambia, Santa Rosa, Okaloosa, Walton, Holmes,
Washington, Bay, Jackson, Calhoun, Gulf, Liberty, Franklin,
Gadsden, Leon, Wakulla in the State of Florida; and,
b. Proof of revenue from commercial shrimping equal to or greater
than the Qualifying Revenue in Table 3 based on vessel size and
type for the Benchmark Period.
2. Boat Captains
In order to qualify for compensation under the Expedited Compensation Method, the Boat
Captain must provide for each vessel:
a. Proof that during the Benchmark Period:
i. the Claimant was a Boat Captain on a commercial
shrimping vessel with the home port of the vessel that was
within the states of Louisiana, Mississippi and Alabama or
a Florida registered vessel with its home port in the
counties of Escambia, Santa Rosa, Okaloosa, Walton,
Holmes, Washington, Bay, Jackson, Calhoun, Gulf,
Liberty, Franklin, Gadsden, Leon, Wakulla in the State of
Florida; and,
ii. the vessel had revenue from commercial shrimping equal to
or greater than the Qualifying Revenue in Table 3 based on
vessel size and type for the Benchmark Period. A Boat
Captain may combine vessel revenue from multiple vessels
of the same size and type for the Benchmark Period; and,
iii. the Claimant was the Boat Captain of the vessel during the
time period for which the vessel generated the revenue on
which the Claimant relies to establish the Qualifying
Revenue for the Benchmark Period reported in Table 3.
TABLE 3
VESSEL SIZE QUALIFYING VESSEL REVENUE
<30 feet $32,500
30-44 feet $40,000
45-74 feet Ice $90,000
45-74 feet Freezer $275,000
75+ feet Ice $225,000
75+ feet Freezer $400,000
0291 4
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 11 of 96
10
B. Documentation Required
1. Vessel Owners/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessees
Vessel Owners/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessees seeking compensation under the
Expedited Compensation Method must provide documents sufficient to prove eligibility pursuant
to the applicable paragraphs of the Generally Applicable Provisions of the Shrimp
Compensation Plan and the requirements in Section I.A.1, and to determine compensation
pursuant to Section I.C below, including the following:
a. Trip Tickets or their equivalents such as dealer forms, which show
the volume of shrimp harvested and the sales price as shown on the
trip tickets or their equivalents for the Benchmark Period. The total
volume multiplied by the price will be the applicable gross
revenue.
OR
b. Federal or state tax and financial information as follows:
i. If Claimant is an entity, federal or state tax returns and
sufficient documentation to identify those components of
gross revenue derived from commercial shrimp harvesting
by vessel for the Benchmark Period for each vessel for
which the Claimant submits a Vessel Owner/Commercial
Fisherman Vessel Lessee claim.
ii. If Claimant is an individual, federal form 1040 including
Schedules C, E and F or state tax forms with supporting
documents, as well as sufficient documentation to identify
those components of earnings derived from commercial
shrimp harvesting by vessel for the Benchmark Period.
iii. In addition, the Claimant must provide sufficient
documentation for the Claims Administrator to be able to
identify (i) Claimants revenue from shrimping as
compared to other sources, (ii) Claimants revenue from
landings in the Gulf Coast Areas. If necessary, the Claims
Administrator may require supplemental information from
the Claimant in order to make these determinations.
c. Also, the Claimant must provide documentation sufficient to
establish the vessel size and type for each vessel for which the
Claimant seeks compensation.
d. In addition, if available, it is requested that the Claimant also
provide the following documents, to assist the Claims
Administrator:
0291
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 12 of 96
11
i. Vessel log book
ii. Share sheets
iii. Sales or other production reports maintained in the normal
course of business.
2. Boat Captains
Boat Captains seeking compensation under the Expedited Compensation Method must provide
documents sufficient to prove eligibility pursuant to the applicable paragraphs of the Generally
Applicable Provisions of the Shrimp Compensation Plan and the eligibility requirements in
Section I.A.2, and to determine compensation pursuant to Section I.C below, including the
following:
a. Trip Tickets or their equivalents for each vessel, which show the
volume of shrimp harvested and the sales price as shown on the
trip tickets or their equivalents for the Benchmark Period. The
total volume multiplied by the price will be the applicable gross
revenue.
OR
b. Federal tax returns, including Schedules C, E and F, W-2s, and
1099s or state tax returns and supporting documents for the
Benchmark Period and sufficient documentation to identify those
components of earnings derived from commercial shrimp
harvesting for the Benchmark Period for the vessel(s) selected by
the Claimant. In addition, the Claimant must provide sufficient
documentation for the Claims Administrator to be able to identify
revenue from shrimp landings in the Gulf Coast Areas for each
vessel while the Claimant was Boat Captain. If necessary, the
Claims Administrator may require supplemental information from
the Claimant in order to make these determinations.
c. Also, the Claimant must provide documentation sufficient to
establish the vessel size and type for the vessel(s) for which the
Claimant seeks compensation.
d. In addition, if available, it is requested that the Claimant also
provide the following documents, to assist the Claims
Administrator:
i. Captains log book
ii. Vessel log book
iii. Share sheets
0291
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 13 of 96
12
iv. Sales or other production reports maintained in the normal
course of business.
C. Compensation Amounts
1. Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee Compensation
If the Claims Administrator determines that the Vessel Owner or Commercial Fisherman Vessel
Lessee has provided necessary proof of eligibility and the required documentation, the Claimant
shall receive the Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee Compensation for the
vessel set forth in Table 4. The Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee
Compensation includes an RTP of 8.25. A Claimant may have more than one vessel and is
eligible for compensation for each vessel for which the Claimant independently satisfies the
eligibility and documentation requirements.
TABLE 4
VESSEL SIZE VESSEL OWNER/COMMERCIAL
FISHERMAN VESSEL LESSEE
COMPENSATION
<30 feet $104,063
30-44 feet $135,281
45-74 feet Ice $270,563
45-74 feet Freezer $478,688
75+ feet Ice $416,250
75+ feet Freezer $582,750
2. Boat Captain Compensation
If the Claims Administrator determines that the Boat Captain has provided necessary proof of
eligibility and the required documentation for a vessel, the Claimant shall receive the Boat
Captain Compensation set forth in Table 5. The Boat Captain Compensation includes an RTP of
7.25.
TABLE 5
VESSEL SIZE BOAT CAPTAIN COMPENSATION
<30 feet $92,813
30-44 feet $107,250
45-74 feet Ice $160,875
45-74 feet Freezer $284,625
75+ feet Ice $206,250
75+ feet Freezer $288,750
0291 7
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 14 of 96
13
II. Reduced Expedited Compensation Method
If a Claimant does not qualify for the Expedited Compensation Method, the Claimant may
qualify for the Reduced Expedited Compensation Method for each vessel.
A. Eligibility Requirements
1. Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee
In order to qualify for compensation under the Reduced Expedited Compensation Method, the
Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee must provide for each vessel:
a. A copy of the 2009 or 2010 governmental issued vessel
registration for each of Claimants vessel(s) establishing the home
port of the vessel was within the states of Louisiana, Mississippi
and Alabama or a Florida registered vessel with its home port in
the counties of Escambia, Santa Rosa, Okaloosa, Walton, Holmes,
Washington, Bay, Jackson, Calhoun, Gulf, Liberty, Franklin,
Gadsden, Leon, Wakulla in the State of Florida; and,
b. Proof of revenue from commercial shrimping equal to or greater
than the Qualifying Revenue in Table 6 based on vessel size and
type for the Benchmark Period.
2. Boat Captains
In order to qualify for compensation under the Reduced Expedited Compensation Method, the
Boat Captain must provide for each vessel:
a. Proof that during the Benchmark Period:
i. the Claimant was a Boat Captain on a commercial
shrimping vessel with the home port of the vessel that was
within the states of Louisiana, Mississippi and Alabama or
a Florida registered vessel with its home port in the
counties of Escambia, Santa Rosa, Okaloosa, Walton,
Holmes, Washington, Bay, Jackson, Calhoun, Gulf,
Liberty, Franklin, Gadsden, Leon, Wakulla in the State of
Florida; and,
ii. the vessel had revenue from commercial shrimping equal to
or greater than the Qualifying Revenue in Table 6 based on
vessel size and type for the Benchmark Period, a Boat
Captain may combine vessel revenue from multiple vessels
of the same size and type for the Benchmark Period; and,
iii. the Claimant was the Boat Captain of the vessel during the
time period for which the vessel generated the revenue on
0291
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 15 of 96
14
which the Claimant relies to establish the Qualifying
Revenue for the Benchmark Period reported in Table 6.
TABLE 6
VESSEL SIZE QUALIFYING VESSEL REVENUE
<30 feet n/a
30-44 feet $25,000
45-74 feet Ice $50,000
45-74 feet Freezer $200,000
75+ feet Ice $150,000
75+ feet Freezer $290,000
B. Documentation Required
1. Vessel Owners/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessees
See documentation requirements for Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee
Claimants under Expedited Compensation Method in Section I above.
2. Boat Captains
See documentation requirements for Boat Captain Claimants under Expedited Compensation
Method in Section I above.
C. Compensation Amounts
1. Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee Compensation
If the Claims Administrator determines that the Vessel Owner or Commercial Fisherman Vessel
Lessee has provided necessary proof of eligibility and the required documentation for a vessel,
the Claimant shall receive the Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee
Compensation set forth in Table 7. The Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee
Compensation includes an RTP of 8.25. A Claimant may have more than one vessel and is
eligible for compensation for each vessel for which the Claimant independently satisfies the
eligibility and documentation requirements.
TABLE 7
VESSEL SIZE VESSEL OWNER/COMMERCIAL
FISHERMAN VESSEL LESSEE
COMPENSATION
<30 feet n/a
30-44 feet $62,438
45-74 feet Ice $145,688
0291 9
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 16 of 96
15
VESSEL SIZE VESSEL OWNER/COMMERCIAL
FISHERMAN VESSEL LESSEE
COMPENSATION
45-74 feet Freezer $333,000
75+ feet Ice $291,375
> 75 feet Freezer $457,875
2. Boat Captain Compensation
If the Claims Administrator determines that the Boat Captain has provided necessary proof of
eligibility and the required documentation, the Claimant shall receive the Boat Captain
Compensation set forth in Table 8. The Boat Captain Compensation includes an RTP of 7.25.
TABLE 8
VESSEL SIZE BOAT CAPTAIN COMPENSATION
<30 feet n/a
30-44 feet $49,500
45-74 feet Ice $86.625
45-74 feet Freezer $198,000
75+ feet Ice $144,375
75+ feet Freezer $226,875
III. New Entrant Compensation Method
A. Eligibility Requirements
1. Vessel Owner
In order to qualify for the New Entrant Compensation Method, the Vessel Owner/Commercial
Fisherman Vessel Lessee must establish for each vessel that as of April 20, 2010:
a. If the vessel is over 30 feet:
i. the Claimant owned or leased the vessel and the vessel was
specifically designed for commercial shrimping, such as a
trawler, freezer boat, or ice boat, and
ii. the Claimant had expenditures in excess of $25,000 within
12 months prior to April 20, 2010 for purchase or repair of
the vessel.
b. If the vessel is less than or equal to 30 feet:
0291 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 17 of 96
16
i. the Claimant owned or leased a vessel and intended to use
the vessel predominantly as a shrimping boat, and
ii. the Claimant had expenditures for the vessel on shrimping
gear, such as trawls, nets, iceboxes, or winches, in excess
of $6,000 within 12 months prior to April 20, 2010.
2. Boat Captains
A Claimant may receive Boat Captain compensation under the New Entrant Compensation
Method if the Claimant: (i) qualifies for compensation as a Vessel Owner/Commercial
Fisherman Vessel Lessee under the New Entrant Compensation Method for the same vessel and
(ii) has not submitted a separate claim for compensation as a Boat Captain under any Shrimp
Compensation Plan. Such Claimant cannot qualify as a Boat Captain for more than one vessel
under the New Entrant Compensation Method.
Additionally, a Claimant who had not previously worked as a Boat Captain for a commercial
shrimping vessel home ported in the Gulf Coast Areas may receive Boat Captain compensation
under the New Entrant Compensation Method if the Claimant provides proof:
a. of an agreement entered prior to April 20, 2010 with a Vessel
Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee for employment as a
Boat Captain on a commercial shrimping vessel home ported in the
Gulf Coast Areas during April 20, 2010 to December 31, 2010 that
is supported by some written documentation that pre-dates April
20, 2010.
b. information sufficient to establish the proposed compensation,
such as proposed start and end dates, wage rates, projected hours
or Boat Captains share of the shrimping vessel revenue, and
c. that offer for employment as a Boat Captain on a commercial
shrimping vessel home ported in the Gulf Coast Areas was
rescinded or withdrawn as a result of the Deepwater Horizon Oil
Spill.
d. Information regarding the employer, including: (i) employers
business name, address(es), telephone number(s), website(s) (if
available), and a description of the nature of the business.
The Claims Administrator shall have the right to interview the Claimant and potential employer
if the Claims Administrator determines an interview is appropriate.
0291 1
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 18 of 96
17
B. Documentation Required
1. Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee
Vessel Owners and Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessees seeking compensation under the New
Entrant Compensation Method must provide documents sufficient to prove eligibility pursuant to
the applicable paragraphs of the Generally Applicable Provisions of the Shrimp Compensation
Plan and the eligibility requirements in Section III.A.1, and to determine compensation pursuant
to Section III.C below, including proof of (i) vessel size and type, (ii) expenditures for purchase
and/or repair of the vessel, or (iii) purchases of shrimping gear.
2. Boat Captains
Boat Captains seeking compensation under the New Entrant Compensation Method must provide
documents sufficient to prove eligibility pursuant to the applicable paragraphs of the Generally
Applicable Provisions of the Shrimp Compensation Plan and the eligibility requirements in
Section III.A.2, and to determine compensation pursuant to Section III.C below.
C. Compensation Amount
1. Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee
If the Claims Administrator determines that the Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel
Lessee has provided necessary proof of eligibility and the required documentation for a vessel,
the Claimant shall receive the Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee
Compensation set forth in Table 9. The Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee
Compensation includes an RTP of 8.25.
TABLE 9
VESSEL SIZE VESSEL OWNER/COMMERCIAL
FISHERMAN VESSEL LESSEE
COMPENSATION
<30 feet $26,016
30-44 feet $33,820
45-74 feet Ice $67,641
45-74 feet Freezer $119,672
75+ feet Ice $104,063
> 75 feet Freezer $145,688
2. Boat Captains
If the Claims Administrator determines that a Claimant seeking compensation as a Boat Captain
has provided necessary proof of eligibility and the required documentation, the Claimant shall
receive the Boat Captain Compensation set forth in Table 10. The Boat Captain Compensation
includes an RTP of 7.25.
0291 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 19 of 96
18
TABLE 10
VESSEL SIZE BOAT CAPTAIN COMPENSATION
<30 feet $23,203
30-44 feet $26,813
45-74 feet Ice $40,219
45-74 feet Freezer $71,156
75+ feet Ice $51,563
75+ feet Freezer $72,188
IV. Historical Revenue Method
A. Eligibility Requirements
1. Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee
To be eligible under the Historical Revenue Method, a Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman
Vessel Lessee must meet the eligibility requirements of the applicable paragraphs of the
Generally Applicable Provisions of the Shrimp Compensation Plan and provide evidence to
demonstrate the Claimants commercial shrimping revenue during the selected Benchmark
Period.
2. Boat Captains
To be eligible under the Historical Revenue Method, a Boat Captain must meet the eligibility
requirements of the applicable paragraphs of the Generally Applicable Provisions of the Shrimp
Compensation Plan and provide evidence to demonstrate the Claimants earnings from
commercial shrimping on vessels for which the Claimant served as Boat Captain during the
selected Benchmark Period.
B. Documentation Required
1. Vessel Owners/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessees
Vessel Owners/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessees seeking compensation under the
Historical Revenue Method must provide documents sufficient to prove the eligibility
requirements in Section IV.A and to determine compensation pursuant to Section IV.C below,
including the following:
a. Trip Tickets or their equivalents for each vessel for which
Claimant seeks compensation, which show the volume of shrimp
harvested and the sales price as shown on the trip tickets or their
equivalents for the Benchmark Period for shrimp landed in the
Gulf Coast Areas. The Claimant must provide sufficient
documentation for the Claims Administrator to be able to identify
gross revenue derived for each vessel solely for shrimp catch
0291
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 20 of 96
19
landed in the Gulf Coast Areas during the Benchmark Period. The
total volume multiplied by price will be the applicable gross
revenue.
OR
b. Federal or state tax and financial information as follows:
i. If Claimant is an entity, federal or state tax returns, and
sufficient documentation to identify those components of
gross revenue derived from commercial shrimp harvesting
by vessel for the Benchmark Period for each vessel for
which the Claimant submits a Vessel Owner/Commercial
Fisherman Vessel Lessee claim.
ii. If Claimant is an individual, federal form 1040 including
Schedules C, E and F or state tax forms and supporting
documents, as well as sufficient documentation to identify
those components of earnings derived from commercial
shrimp harvesting by vessel for the Benchmark Period.
iii. In addition, the Claimant must provide sufficient
documentation for the Claims Administrator to be able to
identify (i) Claimants revenue from shrimping as
compared to other sources, (ii) Claimants revenue from
landings in the Gulf Coast Areas. If necessary, the Claims
Administrator may require supplemental information from
the Claimant in order to make these determinations.
c. Also, the Claimant must provide documentation sufficient to
establish the vessel size and type for each vessel for which the
Claimant seeks compensation.
d. In addition, if available, it is requested that the Claimant also
provide the following documents, to assist the Claims
Administrator:
i. Vessel log book
ii. Share sheets
iii. Sales or other production reports maintained in the normal
course of business.
0291 4
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 21 of 96
20
2. Boat Captains
Boat Captains seeking compensation under the Historical Revenue Method must provide
documents sufficient to prove the eligibility requirements in section IV.A.2 and to determine
compensation pursuant to Section IV.C below, including the following:
a. Trip tickets or their equivalents for each vessel for which Claimant
seeks compensation which show the volume of shrimp harvested
and the sales price as shown on the trip tickets or their equivalents
for the Benchmark Period for shrimp landed in the Gulf Coast
Areas. The total volume multiplied by price will be the applicable
gross revenue.
OR
b. Federal tax returns, including Schedules C, E and F, W-2s, and
1099s or state tax returns with supporting documents for the
Benchmark Period and sufficient documentation to identify those
components of earnings derived from commercial shrimp
harvesting for the Benchmark Period for the vessel(s) selected by
the Claimant. In addition, the Claimant must provide sufficient
documentation for the Claims Administrator to be able to identify
revenue from shrimp landings in the Gulf Coast Areas for each
vessel while the Claimant was Boat Captain. If necessary, the
Claims Administrator may require supplemental information from
the Claimant in order to make these determinations.
c. Also, the Claimant must provide documentation sufficient to
establish the vessel size and type for each vessel for which the
Claimant seeks compensation.
d. In addition, if available, it is requested that the Claimant also
provide the following documents, to assist the Claims
Administrator:
i. Captains log book
ii. Vessel log book
iii. Share sheets
iv. Sales or other production reports maintained in the normal
course of business
C. Compensation Calculations
1. Calculate Benchmark Shrimp Revenue
0291
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 22 of 96
21
a. If trip tickets or their equivalents are used, the volume and price of
shrimp on the trip tickets or their equivalents are used to calculate
gross revenue from shrimp landed in the Gulf Coast Areas. If the
Claimant is a Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee,
the Claimant may provide trip tickets for the Benchmark Period for
each vessel for which compensation is being sought. If the
Claimant is a Boat Captain, the Claimant may provide trip tickets
or their equivalents for all vessels the Claimant served as a Captain
during the Benchmark Period.
OR
b. The Claims Administrator may determine the gross vessel revenue
or Boat Captain earnings from shrimp landings in the Gulf Coast
Areas based on the Claimants tax returns, monthly profit and loss
statements, or financial information if the Claims Administrator
has sufficient information to determine: (i) Claimants revenue
from shrimping as compared to other sources, and (ii) Claimants
revenue from shrimp landings in the Gulf Coast Areas. If
necessary, the Claims Administrator may require supplemental
information from the Claimant in order to make these
determinations.
2. Calculate Additional Catch Adjusted Benchmark Shrimp Revenue by
multiplying Benchmark Shrimp Revenue by the Additional Catch Factor.
The Additional Catch Factor is presented in Table 11 and is intended to
compensate for lost undocumented catch and in-kind payments.
Additional Catch Adjusted Benchmark Shrimp Revenue = (Benchmark Shrimp Revenue *
Additional Catch Factor)
TABLE 11
VESSEL SIZE ADDITIONAL CATCH
FACTOR
<30 feet 1.25
30-44 feet 1.20
45-74 feet Ice 1.15
45-74 feet Freezer 1.05
75+ feet Ice 1.05
75+ feet Freezer 1.05
3. Calculate Total Adjusted Benchmark Shrimp Revenue by multiplying the
Additional Catch Adjusted Benchmark Shrimp Revenue by 1.2, the
Adjustment for Changes in 2010-11 Prices.
0291
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 23 of 96
22
Total Adjusted Benchmark Shrimp Revenue = (Additional Catch Adjusted Benchmark Shrimp
Revenue * Adjustment for Changes in 2010-11 Prices).
4. If (i) the Claimant is a Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel
Lessee or (ii) the Claimant is a Boat Captain and Benchmark Revenue was
calculated using trip tickets or their equivalents, calculate Benchmark
Shrimp Cost. Benchmark Shrimp Cost is calculated by multiplying
Benchmark Shrimp Revenue by the Shrimp Cost Percentage. The Shrimp
Cost Percentage, presented in Table 12, is expressed as a percentage of
revenue and reflects standard industry non-labor variable costs. If the
Claimant is a Boat Captain and Benchmark Revenue was calculated based
upon his earnings, such as from tax return or financial information, then
no Shrimp Cost Percentage is applied, skip to step 5.
Benchmark Shrimp Cost = (Benchmark Shrimp Revenue * Shrimp Cost Percentage)
TABLE 12
VESSEL SIZE SHRIMP COST
PERCENTAGE
<30 feet 42%
30-44 feet 39%
45-74 feet Ice 39%
45-74 feet Freezer 42%
75+ feet Ice 54%
75+ feet Freezer 52%
5. Calculate the Base Shrimp Loss using the Shrimp Loss Percentage of
35%.
a. If (i) the Claimant is a Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman
Vessel Lessee or (ii) the Claimant is a Boat Captain and Total
Adjusted Benchmark Shrimp Revenue was calculated using trip
tickets or their equivalents, the Base Loss is calculated as follows:
Base Shrimp Loss = (Total Adjusted Benchmark Shrimp Revenue Benchmark Shrimp
Cost) * 35%
b. If the Claimant is a Boat Captain and Total Adjusted Benchmark
Shrimp Revenue was calculated using a different source than trip
tickets or their equivalents, the Base Loss is calculated as follows:
Base Shrimp Loss = Total Adjusted Benchmark Shrimp Revenue * 35%
0291 7
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 24 of 96
23
6. Determine Base Compensation by multiplying Base Shrimp Loss by the
appropriate Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee or Boat
Captain share. Vessel Owner and Boat Captain shares differ by boat size
and type and are presented in Table 13.
a. Base Compensation for Vessel Owners/Commercial Fisherman
Vessel Lessees is calculated as:
Base Compensation = Base Shrimp Loss * Shrimp Vessel Share
b. Base Compensation for Shrimp Boat Captains is calculated as:
i. If Shrimp Boat Captain Compensation is calculated based
on trip tickets then the Base Compensation for Shrimp Boat
Captains is calculated as:
Base Compensation = Base Shrimp Loss * Shrimp Boat Captain Share
ii. If Shrimp Boat Captain Compensation is calculated based
on tax returns and financial records, then the Base
Compensation for Shrimp Boat Captains is calculated as:
Base Compensation = Base Shrimp Loss
TABLE 13
VESSEL TYPE AND SIZE SHRIMP VESSEL
OWNER/COMMERCIAL
FISHERMAN VESSEL
LESSEE SHARE
SHRIMP BOAT CAPTAIN
SHARE
<30 feet 45% 45%
30-44 feet 45% 40%
45-74 feet Ice 45% 30%
45-74 feet Freezer 45% 30%
75+ feet Ice 45% 25%
75+ feet Freezer 45% 25%
7. Apply the RTP to Base Compensation in order to determine Final
Compensation. Base Compensation is specific to Claimant type and is
found in Table 14.
Final Compensation = Base Compensation + (Base Compensation * RTP)
0291
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 25 of 96
24
TABLE 14
VESSEL
OWNERS/COMMERCIAL
FISHERMAN VESSEL
LESSEES
BOAT CAPTAINS
RTP 8.25 7.25
V. Vessel Lease Compensation Allocation
To the extent the vessel was leased by the Vessel Owner to the Commercial Fisherman Vessel
Lessee as of April 20, 2010, compensation will be allocated between the parties based upon
Benchmark Revenue, as calculated above and Annual Lease Payment. The Annual Lease
Payment shall be calculated as the annual payment to the Vessel Owner by the Commercial
Fisherman Vessel Lessee for the lease in effect as of April 20, 2010. The ratio of the Annual
Lease Payment to Benchmark Revenue multiplied by the Final Compensation determines the
Vessel Owner Share of Final Compensation. The Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessees Share
of Compensation is Final Compensation less the Vessel Owners Share of Final Compensation.
Vessel Owner Share of Final Compensation = Final Compensation * (Annual Lease Payment /
Benchmark Revenue)
Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessees Share of Final Share of Compensation = Final
Compensation - Vessel Owner Share of Final Compensation.
0291 9
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 26 of 96
25
OYSTER COMPENSATION PLAN
The Oyster Compensation Plan provides compensation to Oyster Leaseholders and Oyster
Harvester Claimants. Oyster Harvesters eligible under the Oyster Compensation Plan are (i)
Seafood Vessel Owners, (ii) Oyster Harvester lessees of Seafood Vessels, and (iii) Seafood Boat
Captains. Oyster Leaseholders can submit Leaseholder Property Claims and/or Leaseholder Lost
Income Claims. Oyster Harvesters can submit Harvester Lost Income Claims. A single
Claimant can qualify as both an Oyster Leaseholder and an Oyster Harvester. Compensation
plans for each of these claim types are set forth below.
In some instances, Oyster Leaseholders earn income solely from allowing another natural person
or entity to harvest oysters from their oyster leaseholds. In other instances, Oyster Leaseholders
may be combined such that they both own oyster leaseholds and harvest from those and other
leaseholds. For purposes of the Oyster Compensation Plan, Claimants should submit claims
reflecting both their harvesting and leaseholder claims together. A combined Oyster
Leaseholder/Oyster Harvester is eligible for compensation as both an Oyster Leaseholder and an
Oyster Harvester.
Generally Applicable Provisions of the Oyster Compensation Plan:
1. Eligible Claimants shall be comprised of Class Members (i) who do not fall within the
exclusions to the Economic Loss and Property Class Definitions; (ii) who are Oyster
Leaseholders or Oyster Harvesters; and (iii) who meet the following additional criteria.
2. An Oyster Leaseholder Claimants shall be an entity or individual with an oyster leasehold
interest.
3. Oyster Leaseholder Claimants are eligible to receive compensation for leaseholds that are
located within Zone A, B or C as reflected on the Oyster Leasehold Compensation Zone
Map attached hereto, as Exhibit 1. Oyster Harvesters are eligible to receive
compensation for oysters landed in the Gulf Coast Areas.
4. It is understood that in some instances, the Vessel Owner is also the Oyster Harvester;
however, it may be the case that the Vessel Owner leased the vessel to an Oyster
Harvester Vessel Lessee. In those instances where the vessel was leased during the time
period of April 20, 2010 to December 31, 2010, the Vessel Owner and Oyster Harvester
Vessel Lessee must file the vessel claim jointly in order to receive compensation prior to
the Bar Date, and they shall share any Vessel Owner/Oyster Harvester Vessel Lessee
compensation provided for in this Oyster Compensation Plan. If at the time of the Bar
Date either the Vessel Owner or the Oyster Harvester Vessel Lessee has not filed a claim,
the one that has filed the claim shall receive the full Vessel Owner/Oyster Harvester
Vessel Lessee compensation for the vessel. The allocation of compensation between
Vessel Owner and Oyster Harvester Vessel Lessee shall be determined as provided in
Section 4. If the vessel was not leased to an Oyster Harvester Vessel Lessee during the
time period of April 20, 2010 to December 31, 2010, the Vessel Owner is entitled to the
full share of the Vessel Owner/ Oyster Harvester Vessel Lessee compensation.
029170
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 27 of 96
26
5. It is understood that in some instances, the Vessel Owner or the Oyster Harvester Vessel
Lessee is also the Boat Captain. In those instances where the Vessel Owner and/or the
Oyster Harvester Vessel Lessee were also the Boat Captain, the Claimant shall be eligible
to receive the Boat Captain compensation under the Oyster Compensation Plan as set
forth below. If the Vessel Owner and/or Oyster Harvester Vessel Lessee employed a
Boat Captain on the vessel and did not serve as a Boat Captain on that vessel, the hired
Boat Captain is eligible for the Boat Captain compensation, not the Vessel Owner or
Oyster Harvester Vessel Lessee.
6. To establish eligibility to participate in the Oyster Compensation Plan, an Oyster
Leaseholder Claimant must provide:
A. Valid oyster lease entered into by Claimant that establishes, as of April 20, 2010,
the Claimant as the lessee of the oyster leasehold, or a copy of the actual title for
the leasehold. Claimants are required to provide documentation that their
leasehold interest is in good standing, such as proof of renewal.
B. Information sufficient to ascertain the geographic boundaries of the oyster
leasehold, including the oyster lease ID number.
7. To establish eligibility to participate in the Oyster Compensation Plan, a Vessel Owner
Claimant must provide for each vessel for which the Claimant is seeking compensation:
A. Proof of ownership of the vessel during the time period of April 20, 2010 to
December 31, 2010.
B. Proof that as of April 20, 2010 there was a government license (even if it had
expired as of that date) that authorized that vessel to harvest and land oysters in
the Gulf Coast Areas for the 2009 season or the 2010 season.
C. The vessel name and any applicable federal and/or state vessel registration
identification numbers.
D. Proof that the vessel landed oysters in the Gulf Coast Areas in 2009 or 2010. For
example, this can be demonstrated using trip tickets (or equivalent documents
such as dealer forms) or Federal or state tax returns.
E. A sworn statement attesting as to whether or not the vessel was leased during the
time period April 20, 2010 to December 31, 2010. If the vessel was leased during
this time period, the Vessel Owner must provide a copy of the lease agreement.
8. To establish eligibility to participate in the Oyster Compensation Plan, an Oyster
Harvester who leases a Seafood Vessel (Oyster Harvester Vessel Lessee) must provide
for each vessel for which the Claimant is seeking compensation:
A. Proof that during the time period of April 20, 2010 to December 31, 2010 the
Claimant leased a vessel to be used for oyster harvesting.
029171
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 28 of 96
27
B. Proof that as of April 20, 2010 there was a government license (even if it had
expired as of that date) that authorized the vessel to harvest and land oysters in the
Gulf Coast Areas for the 2009 season or the 2010 season.
C. Proof that the vessel landed oysters in the Gulf Coast Areas in 2009 or 2010. For
example, this can be demonstrated using trip tickets (or equivalent documents
such as dealer forms) or Federal or State tax returns.
D. A sworn statement attesting that the Claimant leased the vessel from the Vessel
Owner during the time period of April 20, 2010 to December 31, 2010. The
Oyster Harvester Vessel Lessee must also provide a copy of the lease agreement.
9. Oyster Boat Captain Claimants must provide:
A. Proof that as of April 20, 2010 the Boat Captain held a governmental license
(even if it had expired before that date) authorizing the Claimant to operate as a
Boat Captain and/or to commercially harvest and land oysters in the Gulf Coast
Areas.
B. Proof that Claimant landed oysters in the Gulf Coast Areas in 2009 or 2010. This
can be demonstrated using trip tickets (or equivalent documents such as dealer
forms) or federal or state tax returns.
10. A Sworn Statement attesting whether or not the Claimant received any Seafood Spill-
Related Payments. If the Claimant received Seafood Spill-Related Payments, the
Claimant shall provide documents
7
sufficient to establish the timing, amount and source
of Seafood Spill-Related Payments, including documents providing the claimants
BP/GCCF/Transition Facility Claim Number, if applicable, and any corresponding
payments:
Oyster Compensation Plan Methods Available:
There are two types of claims available to Oyster Leaseholders:
Leaseholder Interest Compensation
Leaseholder Lost Income Compensation
There is one type of claim available to Oyster Harvesters:
Historical Revenue Compensation
7
When documents are requested in the Seafood Compensation Program, Claimant may provide either legible
copies or originals of the documents.
029172
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 29 of 96
28
A given Claimant may submit claims for more than one form of compensation, for example a
combined Oyster Leaseholder/Oyster Harvester may submit claims for all three forms of
compensation.
Oyster Compensation Plan Definition:
The Benchmark Period for the Claimant is the combination of 2007, 2008 and 2009. All
calculations of Benchmark Period revenues, costs or payments use the average of annual figures
across 2007, 2008 and 2009. In the event that a Claimant entered the oyster industry after 2007,
then the Benchmark Period will include all full years since the Claimant entered the oyster
harvesting industry, so 2008-2009 or 2009. In the event the Claims Administrator determines
that the Claimant (individual or vessel) did not participate at the same level of effort in oyster
harvesting due to circumstances beyond the Claimants control (such as illness, disability or
major mechanical failure), the Claims Administrator may at his discretion allow the Claimant to
exclude one or more years of the Benchmark Period.
1. Oyster Leaseholder Interest Compensation
Oyster Leaseholder Interest Compensation provides all eligible Oyster Leaseholders with
compensation on a per acre basis for their leaseholds. Compensation shall be determined by the
geographic location of the oyster leasehold as set forth below.
1.1 Eligibility for Oyster Leaseholder Property Claim
Eligible leaseholds are those located within Zone A, B or C as reflected on the Oyster Leasehold
Compensation Zone Map.
1.2 Documentation Requirement for Oyster Leaseholder Interest Compensation
The Oyster Leaseholder must provide the documentation required under the Generally
Applicable Provisions of the Oyster Compensation Plan.
1.3 Calculation of Oyster Leaseholder Interest Compensation
The Oyster Leaseholder Claimant shall receive compensation on a per acre basis based upon
where the lease is located on the Oyster Leaseholder Compensation Zone Map. The per acre
compensation amounts for each zone are as follows:
Zone A: $2,000
Zone B: $1,000
Zone C: $400
If a lease crosses two zones, compensation will be determined based on the number of acres of
the lease in each zone. For example, if a lease covers 20 acres in Zone A and 30 acres in
Zone B, then compensation will be calculated as: (20 acres * $2,000) + (30 acres * $1,000) =
$70,000.
02917
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 30 of 96
29
The per acre payment is not subject to any RTP.
2. Oyster Leaseholder Lost Income Compensation
The Oyster Leaseholder Lost Income Compensation provides eligible Oyster Leaseholders with
compensation for income earned through payments from another natural person or entity that
harvests oysters on their leases. This Section 2 describes compensation for an Oyster
Leaseholder that is not also an Oyster Vessel Owner/Oyster Harvester Vessel Lessee. If the
Oyster Leaseholder is also a Vessel Owner/Oyster Harvester Vessel Lessee, the Oyster
Leaseholder shall receive compensation for a combined Oyster Leaseholder and Vessel
Owner/Oyster Harvester Vessel Lessee, as described in Section 3.5.
2.1 Eligibility Requirements for Oyster Leaseholder Lost Income Claims
Oyster Leaseholder Claimants who meet the eligibility requirements set forth in the applicable
paragraphs of the Generally Applicable Provisions of the Oyster Compensation Plan and
Section 1.1 above are eligible to receive Oyster Leaseholder Lost Income Claims Compensation.
2.2 Documentation Requirements for Oyster Leaseholder Lost Income Claims
To receive Oyster Leaseholder Lost Income Compensation, a Claimant must provide:
A. Tax returns, financial statements or business documents establishing revenue
earned by the Claimant during the Benchmark Period from another natural person
or entity that harvests oysters on their leaseholds located in Zones A, B or C, as
reflected on the Oyster Leasehold Compensation Zone Map.
B. Contracts or agreements between the Oyster Leaseholder and another natural
person or entity that harvests oysters from their leaseholds located in Zones A, B
or C, as reflected on the Oyster Leasehold Compensation Zone Map.
In addition, if available, it is requested that the Claimant also provide the following documents,
to assist the Claims Administrator:
A. A list of all Oyster Harvesters who harvested oysters on Claimants leasehold(s)
during 2007 through 2009.
2.3 Calculation of Oyster Leaseholder Lost Income Compensation
For all Oyster Leaseholder Claimants, the Oyster Leaseholder Lost Income Compensation is
calculated as follows:
A. Calculate Benchmark Revenue as the average annual revenue earned by the
Claimant during the Benchmark Period from other natural people or entities that
harvest oysters on the Claimants leaseholds that are located in Zones A, B or C,
as reflected on the Oyster Leasehold Compensation Zone Map.
029174
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 31 of 96
30
B. Calculate Total Adjusted Benchmark Revenue by multiplying Benchmark
Revenue by 1.1, the Adjustment For Changes in 2010-11 Prices.
Total Adjusted Benchmark Revenue = Benchmark Revenue * 1.1
C. Calculate Base Compensation as Total Adjusted Benchmark Revenue multiplied
by the Oyster Loss Percentage of 40%.
Base Compensation = Total Adjusted Benchmark Revenue * 40%
D. Apply an RTP of 8.75 to Base Compensation in order to determine Final
Compensation.
Final Compensation = Base Compensation + (Base Compensation * 8.75)
TABLE 1
Example of Compensation Calculation for Hypothetical Oyster
Leaseholder Lost Income Claimant
Inputs
Benchmark Revenue [A] $20,000
Adjustment for Changes in 2010-2011
Prices [B] 1.10
Oyster Loss Percentage [C] 40%
RTP [D] 8.75
Calculation
Total Adjusted Benchmark Revenue [E] = [A] * [B] $22,000
Base Compensation [F] = [E] * [C] $8,800
Final Compensation [G] = [F] + [F] * [D] $85,800
3. Oyster Harvester Lost Income Compensation
An Oyster Harvester Claimant may seek compensation for the Claimants economic loss from
oyster harvesting by establishing historical revenue generated by Oyster Harvesting. Section 3.3
describes calculation of compensation for an oyster Boat Captain, Section 3.4 describes
calculation of compensation for a Vessel Owner/Oyster Harvester Vessel Lessee that is not also
an Oyster Leaseholder. If a Vessel Owner/Oyster Harvester Vessel Lessee is also an Oyster
Leaseholder, Section 3.5 describes the calculation of both Oyster Leaseholder Lost Income and
Oyster Harvester Lost Income for that Claimant.
02917
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 32 of 96
31
3.1 Eligibility and Documentation Boat Captain
To be eligible to receive compensation for lost oyster harvesting earnings, a Boat Captain
Claimant (i) must meet the applicable paragraphs of the Generally Applicable Provisions of the
Oyster Compensation Plan and (ii) provide evidence to document the oyster harvesting revenue
earned by vessels on which the Claimant served as Boat Captain, or the earnings the Claimant
earned as Boat Captain of oyster harvesting vessels, during the Benchmark Period. This revenue
must be established using:
A. Trip tickets (or equivalent documents such as dealer forms) for each vessel for
which Claimant seeks compensation which show the volume of oysters harvested
and the sales price for the Benchmark Period for oysters landed in the Gulf Coast
Areas. The total volume multiplied by the price will be the applicable gross
revenue.
-OR-
B. Federal or state tax returns, including Schedules C, E and F, W-2s, and 1099s for
the Benchmark Period and sufficient documentation to identify those components
of earnings derived from oyster harvesting for the Benchmark Period for the
vessel(s) selected by the Claimant. In addition, the Claimant must provide
sufficient documentation for the Claims Administrator to be able to identify
revenue from oyster landings in the Gulf Coast Areas for each vessel while the
Claimant was Boat Captain. If necessary, the Claims Administrator may require
supplemental information from the Claimant in order to make these
determinations.
In addition, if available, it is requested that the Claimant also provide the following documents to
assist the Claims Administrator:
A. Captains Log Book
B. Share Sheets
C. Vessel name and any applicable federal and/or state vessel registration
identification numbers for any vessels the Claimant captained during the
Benchmark Period
3.2 Eligibility and Documentation: Seafood Vessel Owner Oyster Harvester Vessel
Lessee
To be eligible to receive compensation for lost harvesting income, a Vessel Owner/Oyster
Harvester Vessel Lessee must meet the eligibility requirements set forth in the applicable
paragraphs of the Generally Applicable Provisions of the Oyster Compensation Plan and
provide evidence to document harvesting revenue and certain costs associated with oyster
harvesting during their Benchmark Period for landings in the Gulf Coast Areas. Oyster
02917
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 33 of 96
32
harvesting gross revenue earned by Claimants during their Benchmark Period must be
established using:
A. Trip tickets (or equivalent documents such as dealer forms) for each vessel for
which Claimant seeks compensation which show the volume of oysters harvested
and the sales price for the Benchmark Period for oysters landed in the Gulf Coast
Areas. The total volume multiplied by the price will be the applicable gross
revenue.
-OR-
B. Federal or state tax forms and financial information as follows:
1. If a Claimant is an entity, federal or state tax returns, and sufficient
documentation to identify those components of gross revenue derived
from oyster harvesting by vessel for the Benchmark Period for landings in
the Gulf Coast Areas for each vessel for which the Claimant submits a
Vessel Owner/Oyster Harvester Vessel Lessee claim.
2. If the Claimant is an individual, federal form 1040 including Schedules C,
E and F or state tax forms with supporting documents as well as sufficient
documentation to identify components of earnings derived from oysters
landed in the Gulf Coast Areas by vessel for the Benchmark Period.
3. In addition, the Claimant must provide sufficient documentation for the
Claims Administrator to be able to identify Claimants revenue from
oyster harvesting in the Gulf Coast Areas as compared to other sources of
revenue. If necessary, the Claims Administrator may require
supplemental information from the Claimant in order to make these
determinations.
In addition, if available, it is requested that the Claimant also provide, for each vessel for which
the Claimant is seeking compensation, the following documents to assist the Claims
Administrator:
1. Vessel Log Book
2. Share Sheets
3. Names and periods of employment of Boat Captains employed on the
vessel during 2007, 2008 and 2009
3.3.1 Calculation of Harvester Lost Income Compensation for Boat Captains for Captains
Using Trip Tickets to Document Claims
A. Calculate average annual revenue in Benchmark Period for (i) oysters harvested
from public grounds (Public Benchmark Harvest Revenue) and (ii) oysters
harvested from private leaseholds (Private Benchmark Harvest Revenue). Public
029177
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 34 of 96
33
Benchmark Harvest Revenue and Private Benchmark Harvest Revenue shall be
separately calculated as described above in 3.1. If the Claimant does not have
information sufficient to establish the split between revenue from oysters
harvested on public grounds and oysters harvested on private leaseholds, all
oyster harvesting revenue shall be assumed to have come from private leaseholds.
B. Calculate Total Adjusted Benchmark Revenue by multiplying the sum of Public
Benchmark Harvest Revenue and Private Benchmark Harvest Revenue by 1.1, the
Adjustment For Changes in 2010-11 Prices.
Total Adjusted Benchmark Revenue = (Public Benchmark Harvest Revenue + Private
Benchmark Harvest Revenue) * 1.1
C. Determine Variable Harvest Cost by multiplying the sum of Public Benchmark
Revenue and Private Benchmark Revenue by 12%. If the Claimant establishes
Benchmark Revenue through individual income tax forms, Variable Harvest Cost
shall be zero ($0).
Variable Harvest Cost = (Public Benchmark Revenue + Private Benchmark Revenue) * 12%
D. Calculate Leaseholder Payment Cost by multiplying Private Benchmark Revenue
by Leaseholder Payment Percentage of 33%. If the Claimant establishes
Benchmark Revenue through individual income tax forms, Variable Harvest Cost
shall be zero ($0).
Leaseholder Payment Cost = Private Benchmark Revenue * 33%
E. Calculate Base Harvest Margin as Total Adjusted Benchmark Oyster Revenue
less Variable Harvest Cost and Leaseholder Payment Cost.
Base Harvest Margin = Total Adjusted Benchmark Oyster Revenue Variable Harvest Cost
Leaseholder Payment Cost
F. Determine Base Harvest Loss by multiplying Base Harvest Margin by Oyster
Loss Percentage of 40%.
Base Harvest Loss = Base Harvest Margin * 40%
G. Multiply Base Harvest Loss by Boat Captain Share of 40% to determine Base
Compensation.
Base Compensation = Base Harvest Loss * 40%
H. Apply an RTP of 7.75 to Base Compensation in order to determine Final
Compensation.
Final Compensation = Base Compensation + (Base Compensation * 7.75)
02917
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 35 of 96
34
TABLE 2
Example of Compensation Calculation for Hypothetical Boat Captain Harvester Lost
Income Claimant Who Uses Trip Tickets
Inputs
Public Benchmark Harvest Revenue [A] $50,000
Private Benchmark Harvest Revenue [B] $100,000
Adjustment for Changes in 2010-2011 Prices [C] 1.10
Variable Harvest Cost Percentage [D] 12%
Leaseholder Payment Percentage [E] 33%
Oyster Loss Percentage [F] 40%
Boat Captain Share [G] 40%
RTP [H] 7.75
Calculation
Total Adjusted Benchmark Revenue [I] = ([A] + [B]) * [C] $165,000
Variable Harvest Cost [J] = ([A] + [B]) * [D] $18,000
Leaseholder Payment Cost [K] = [B] * [E] $33,000
Base Harvest Margin [L] = [I] - [J] - [K] $114,000
Base Harvest Loss [M] = [L] * [F] $45,600
Base Compensation [N] = [M] * [G] $18,240
Final Compensation [O] = [N] + [N] * [G] $159,600
3.3.2 Calculation of Harvester Lost Income Compensation for Boat Captains for Captains
Using Tax Returns and/or Financial Records to Document Claims.
A. Calculate Average Earnings in Benchmark Period for oysters landed in the Gulf
Coast Areas.
B. Calculate Total Adjusted Earnings in Benchmark Period by multiplying Average
Earnings in Benchmark Period by 1.1, the Adjustment For changes in 2010-11
Prices.
C. Determine Base Earnings Loss by multiplying total Adjusted Earnings in
Benchmark Period by Oyster Loss Percentage of 40%.
Base Earnings Loss = Total Adjusted Earnings in Benchmark Period * 40%
D. Apply at RTP of 7.75 to Base Earnings Loss to determine Final Compensation
Final Compensation = Base Earnings Loss + (Base Earnings Loss * 7.75)
029179
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 36 of 96
35
3.4 Calculation of Harvester Lost Income Compensation for Oyster Vessel
Owners/Oyster Harvester Vessel Lessees that Are Not Oyster Leaseholders
This Section 3.4 describes compensation for an Oyster Vessel Owner/Oyster Harvester Vessel
Lessee that is not also an Oyster Leaseholder.
A. Calculate average annual revenue in Benchmark Period for (i) oysters harvested
from public grounds (Public Benchmark Harvest Revenue) and (ii) oysters
harvested from private leaseholds (Private Benchmark Harvest Revenue). Public
Benchmark Harvest Revenue and Private Benchmark Harvest Revenue shall be
separately calculated as described above in 3.2. If the Claimant does not have
information sufficient to establish the split between revenue from public grounds
and private leaseholds, all oyster harvesting revenue shall be assumed to have
come from private leaseholds.
B. Calculate Total Adjusted Benchmark Revenue by multiplying the sum of Public
Benchmark Harvest Revenue and Private Benchmark Harvest Revenue by 1.1, the
Adjustment For Changes in 2010-11 Prices.
Total Adjusted Benchmark Revenue = (Public Benchmark Harvest Revenue + Private
Benchmark Harvest Revenue) * 1.1
C. Determine Variable Harvest Cost by multiplying the sum of Public Benchmark
Revenue and Private Benchmark Revenue by 12%.
Variable Harvest Cost = (Public Benchmark Revenue + Private Benchmark Revenue) * 12%
D. Determine Leaseholder Payment Cost by multiplying Private Benchmark
Revenue by Leaseholder Payment Percentage of 33%.
Leaseholder Payment Cost = Private Benchmark Revenue * 33%
E. Calculate Base Margin as Total Adjusted Benchmark Revenue less Variable
Harvest Cost and Leaseholder Payment Cost.
Base Harvest Margin = Total Adjusted Benchmark Revenue Variable Harvest Cost
Leaseholder Payment Cost
F. Determine Base Harvest Loss by multiplying Base Harvest Margin by Oyster
Loss Percentage of 40%.
Base Harvest Loss = Base Harvest Margin * 40%
G. Multiply Base Harvest Loss by Vessel Owner Share of 40% to determine Base
Compensation.
Base Compensation = Base Harvest Loss * 40%
0291 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 37 of 96
36
H. Apply an RTP of 8.75 to Base Compensation in order to determine Final
Compensation.
Final Compensation = Base Compensation + (Base Compensation * 8.75)
TABLE 3
Example of Compensation Calculation for Hypothetical Vessel Owner / Oyster
Harvester Vessel Lessee
Harvester Lost Income Claimant
Inputs
Public Benchmark Harvest Revenue
[A]
$50,000
Private Benchmark Harvest Revenue
[B]
$100,000
Adjustment for Changes in 2010-2011 Prices
[C]
1.10
Variable Harvest Cost Percentage
[D]
12%
Leaseholder Payment Percentage
[E]
33%
Oyster Loss Percentage
[F]
40%
Vessel Owner Share
[G]
40%
RTP
[H]
8.75
Calculation
Total Adjusted Benchmark Revenue [I] = ([A] + [B]) *[C] $165,000
Variable Harvest Cost [J] = ([A] + [B]) * [D] $18,000
Leaseholder Payment Cost [K] = [B] * [E] $33,000
Base Harvest Margin [L] = [I] - [J] - [K] $114,000
Base Harvest Loss [M] = [L] * [F] $45,600
Base Compensation [N] = [M] * [G] $18,240
Final Compensation [O] = [N] + [N] * [H] $177,840
3.5 Calculation of Harvester Lost Income Compensation for Oyster Vessel
Owners/Oyster Harvester Vessel Lessees that are also Oyster Leaseholders
This section explains compensation for the Oyster Harvester that is also an Oyster Leaseholder
and includes compensation for a Claimants role as an Oyster Leaseholder and a Vessel
Owner/Oyster Harvester Vessel Lessee. If the Claimant is also a Boat Captain, the Claimant can
receive compensation based on the Boat Captain Compensation framework described in Section
3.3 above.
Compensation for an Oyster Leaseholder/Vessel Owner/Oyster Harvester Vessel Lessees role as
an Oyster Leaseholder and Vessel Owner/Oyster Harvester Vessel Lessee depends on Claimants
Total Benchmark Revenue less Total Benchmark Costs.
0291 1
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 38 of 96
37
Total Benchmark Revenue includes four types of revenues received by Claimant:
Oyster Leaseholder Revenue, which reflects revenue received from another natural
person or entity that harvests oysters on the Claimants leaseholds;
Own Lease Harvest Revenue, which reflects revenue received from oysters harvested by
Claimant on the Claimants leaseholds;
Harvest Revenue from other private leaseholds, which reflects revenue received from
oysters harvested from private leaseholds owned by others; and
Public Harvest Revenue, which reflects revenue received from harvests from public
oyster grounds.
Total Benchmark Cost includes three types of costs incurred by Claimant:
Variable Harvest Cost
Payments to Other Leaseholders as compensation for oysters harvested from their leases
Payments to Boat Captains and Seafood Crew
The following steps describe calculation of compensation for Oyster Vessel Owners/Oyster
Harvester Vessel Lessees that are also Oyster Leaseholders. The calculation is summarized in
Table 4 below. Exhibit 2 presents a table summarizing the approach in additional detail and
includes a further example summarizing compensation for Lost Leaseholder Income and Lost
Harvester income when the claimant also acts as the sole Boat Captain.
Calculate Revenue:
1. Calculate Oyster Leaseholder Benchmark Revenue which reflects revenue received from
other harvesters as payment for oysters harvested from the claimants lease. Calculate
Adjusted Oyster Leaseholder Benchmark Revenue as 1.1*Oyster Leaseholder
Benchmark Revenue
2. Calculate harvest revenues:
A. Calculate Private Benchmark Harvest Revenue, which reflects revenue generated
from oysters harvested on private leaseholds, including leaseholds owned by the
Claimant and leaseholds owned by others. Calculate Adjusted Private Benchmark
Harvest Revenue as 1.1*Private Benchmark Harvest Revenue
B. Calculate Public Benchmark Harvest Revenue, which reflects revenue generated
from oysters harvested on public grounds and Adjusted Public Benchmark
Harvest Revenue as 1.1*Public Benchmark Harvest Revenue
C. Calculate Adjusted Total Harvest Benchmark Revenue as the sum of Adjusted
Private Benchmark Harvest Revenue and Adjusted Public Benchmark Harvest
Revenue.
0291 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 39 of 96
38
3. Calculate Adjusted Total Benchmark Revenue as the sum of Adjusted Total Benchmark
Harvest Revenue and Adjusted Oyster Benchmark Leaseholder Income.
Calculate Costs:
1. Calculate Variable Harvest Cost as 12% multiplied by the sum of (i) Public Benchmark
Harvest Revenue and (ii) Private Benchmark Harvest Revenue.
2. Calculate Estimated Total Leaseholder Costs as Adjusted Benchmark Private Harvest
Revenue *33%
3. Calculate or estimate Claimants Lease Payments to Other Leaseholders based on tax
returns, financial statements and business records provided by Claimant.
4. Calculate Payments to Boat Captains and Seafood Crew
A. Calculate Claimants Adjusted Total Benchmark Harvest Revenue, minus
Variable Harvest Cost, minus Estimated Total Leaseholder Costs
B. Multiply by 60% to determine Payments to Boat Captains and Seafood Crew
5. Calculate Total Cost as Variable Harvest Cost plus Claimants Lease Payments to Other
Leaseholders plus Payments to Boat Captains and Seafood Crew
Calculate Final Compensation:
1. Calculate Total Margin as Adjusted Total Benchmark Revenue minus Total Cost
2. Calculate Base Compensation as Total Margin multiplied by Oyster Loss Percentage of
40%.
3. Apply an RTP of 8.75 to Base Compensation in order to determine Final Compensation.
Final Compensation = Base Compensation + (Base Compensation * 8.75)
0291
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 40 of 96
39
TABLE 4
Example of Compensation Calculation for Hypothetical Oyster Leaseholder / Oyster
Harvester Claimant
Calculation Determines Compensation for Lost Leaseholder Income
and Lost Harvester Income
Oyster Leaseholder Benchmark Revenue [A] $10,000
Adjusted Oyster Leaseholder Benchmark
Revenue
[B]=[A]*1.1 $11,000
Private Benchmark Harvest Revenue [C] $75,000
Adjusted Private Benchmark Harvest Revenue [D]=[C]*1.1 $82,500
Public Benchmark Harvest Revenue [E] $25,000
Adjusted Public Benchmark Harvest Revenue [F]=[E]*1.1 $27,500
Adjusted Total Benchmark Harvest Revenue [G]=[D]+[F] $110,000
Adjusted Total Benchmark Revenue [H]=[B]+[G] $121,000
Variable Harvest Cost [I]=([C]+[E])*12% $12,000
Estimated Total Leaseholder Cost [J]=[D]*33% $27,225
Claimants Lease Payments to Other Leaseholders [K]=[based on claimant
records]
$10,000
Payments to Boat Captains and Seafood Crew [L]=([G]-[I]-[J])*60% $42,465
Total Cost [M]=[I]+[K]+[L] $64,465
Total Margin [N]=[H]-[M] $56,535
Base Compensation [O]=[N]*40% $22,614
Final Compensation [P]=[O]+[O]*8.75 $220,487
0291 4
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 41 of 96
40
4. Vessel Lease Compensation Allocation
To the extent the vessel was leased by the Vessel Owner to the Oyster Harvester Vessel Lessee
as of April 20, 2010, compensation will be allocated between the parties based upon Benchmark
Revenue, as calculated above at Section 3.4 or 3.5, and Annual Lease Payment. The Annual
Lease Payment shall be calculated as the annual payment to the Vessel Owner by the Oyster
Harvester Vessel Lessee for the lease in effect as of April 20, 2010. The ratio of the Annual
Lease Payment to Benchmark Revenue multiplied by the Final Compensation determines the
Vessel Owner Share of Final Compensation. The Oyster Harvester Vessel Lessees Share of
Compensation is Final Compensation less the Vessel Owners Share of Final Compensation.
Vessel Owner Share of Final Compensation = Final Compensation * (Annual Lease Payment /
Benchmark Revenue)
Oyster Harvester Vessel Lessees Share of Final Share of Compensation = Final Compensation -
Vessel Owner Share of Final Compensation.
TABLE 5
Example of Vessel Lease Compensation Allocation Between
Vessel Owner Claimant and Oyster Harvester Vessel Lessee Claimant
Inputs (Based on Table 3)
Benchmark Revenue [A] $165,000
Annual Lease Payment [B] $55,000
Final Compensation [C] $177,840
Calculation
Annual Lease Payment / Benchmark Revenue [D] = [B] / [A] 33%
Vessel Owner's Share of Final Compensation [E] = [C] * [D] $59,280
Oyster Harvester Vessel Lessee's Share of Final
Compensation
[F] = [C] - [E] $118,560
0291
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 42 of 96
O t C t i Pl Oyst er Compensat i on Pl an
Exhi bi t 1
O L h l d C i Oyst er Leasehol d Compensat i on
Zone M app
0291
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 43 of 96
Al l St at es
LEGEND
Zone A
Zone B
Zone C
LEGEND
0291 7
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 44 of 96
Texas
LEGEND
Zone A
Zone B
Zone C
LEGEND
0291
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 45 of 96
Sout hwest Loui si ana
LEGEND
Zone A
Zone B
Zone C
LEGEND
0291 9
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 46 of 96
Sout heast Loui si ana
LEGEND
Zone A
Zone B
Zone C
029190
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 47 of 96
M i ssi ssi ppi & Al abama
Zone A
Zone B
LEGEND
Zone B
Zone C
029191
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 48 of 96
Fl or i da
Z A
LEGEND
Zone A
Zone B
Zone C
029192
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 49 of 96
Oyster Compensation Plan
Exhibit 2
02919
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 50 of 96
Leasehol di ng
Oper at i ons
2
Combi ned
Oper at i ons
3
Combi ned
Oper at i ons
3
Fr om Publ i c
Gr ounds
Fr om Pr i vat e
Leasehol ds
Payment s Fr om
Ot her Har vest er s
Cl ai mant
Empl oys Hi r ed
Capt ai n
Cl ai mant Is Al so
Sol e Capt ai n
COLUM N NUM BER: [ 1] [ 2] [ 4] [ 5] [ 6]
Benchmar k Revenue [ A] 25,000 75,000 10,000 110,000 110,000
Benchmar k Har vest Revenue [ B]
Var i abl e Har vest Cost Per cent age [ C]
Var i abl e Har vest Cost [ D] =[ B] * [ C] 12,000 12,000
Adj ust ment t o Revenue f or
Changes i n 2010-2011 Pr i ces
[ E] 1.1
Adj ust ed Benchmar k Revenue [ F] =[ A] * [ E] 27,500 82,500 11,000 121,000 121,000
Adj ust ed Tot al Benchmar k Har vest Revenue [ G]
Adj ust ed Pr i vat e Benchmar k Har vest Revenue [ H] =[ F] 82,500
Leasehol der Payment Per cent age [ I] 33%
Est i mat ed Tot al Leasehol der Cost [ J] =H] * [ I] 27,225 *
Cl ai mant ' s Lease Payment s t o Ot her Leasehol der s [ K] =[ based on cl ai mant r ecor ds] 10,000 10,000 10,000
* Used t o Cal cul at e Capt ai n/ Cr ew Cost s
Adj ust ed Benchmar k Har vest M ar gi n [ L] =[ G] -[ D] -[ J]
Boat Capt ai n Shar e [ M ]
Payment s t o Boat Capt ai ns [ N] =[ L] * [ M ] 28,310
Adj ust ed Benchmar k Har vest M ar gi n [ O] =[ G] -[ D] -[ J]
Seaf ood Cr ew Shar e [ P]
Payment s t o Seaf ood Cr ew [ Q] =[ O] * [ P] 14,155 14,155
Tot al Cost [ R] =[ D] +[ K] +[ N] +[ Q] 64,465 36,155
M ar gi n Recei ved by t he Cl ai mant [ S] =[ F] -[ R] 56,535 84,845
As Ow ner / Leasehol der [ T] =COLUM N [ 5] , ROW [ S] 56,535
As Capt ai n [ U] =COLUM N [ 5] , ROW [ N] 28,310
Oyst er Loss Per cent age [ V] 40% 40%
Ri sk Tr ansf er Pr emi um - Ow ner / Leasehol der [ W] 8.75 8.75
Ri sk Tr ansf er Pr emi um - Capt ai n [ X] 7.75
Compensat i on - Ow ner / Leasehol der [ Y] =[ S] * [ V] * (1+[ W] ) 220,487
Compensat i on - Ow ner / Leasehol der [ Z] =[ T] * [ V] * (1+[ W] ) 220,487
Compensat i on - Capt ai n [ AA] =[ U] * [ V] * (1+[ X] ) 99,085
Fi nal Compensat i on [ AB] =[ Y] +[ Z] +[ AA] 220,487 319,572
1. Ref l ect s r evenues and cost s associ at ed w i t h t he Cl ai mant ' s oyst er har vest i ng oper at i ons.
2. Ref l ect s r evenues ear ned by t he Cl ai mant f r om ot her har vest er s f or use of t he Cl ai mant ' s l easehol d(s).
3. Ref l ect s r evenues and cost s associ at ed w i t h t he Cl ai mant ' s oyst er har vest i ng and l easehol di ng oper at i ons.
12%
Exhi bi t 2
Exampl e of Compensat i on Cal cul at i on f or Hypot het i cal Oyst er Leasehol der / Oyst er Har vest er Cl ai mant
Cal cul at i on Det er mi nes Compensat i on f or Lost Leasehol der Income and Lost Har vest er Income
Har vest i ng Oper at i ons
1
100,000
28,310
70,775
20%
14,155
12,000
1.1
110,000
70,775
40%
029194
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 51 of 96
41
FINFISH COMPENSATION PLAN
Generally Applicable Provisions of the Finfish Compensation Plan:
1. Eligible Claimants shall be comprised of Class Members (i) who do not fall within the
exclusions to the Economic Loss and Property Class Definition, (ii) who are Vessel
Owners, Commercial Fishermen who lease Seafood Vessels (Commercial Fisherman
Vessel Lessee), and/or Seafood Boat Captains that derive income from commercial
finfishing, and (iii) who meet the additional criteria listed in this Finfish Compensation
Plan.
2. It is understood that in some instances, the Vessel Owner is also the Commercial
Fisherman; however, it may be the case that the Vessel Owner leased the vessel to a
Commercial Fisherman. In those instances where the vessel was leased during the time
period of April 20, 2010 to December 31, 2010, the Vessel Owner and Commercial
Fisherman Vessel Lessee must file the vessel claim jointly in order to receive
compensation prior to the Bar Date, and they shall share any Vessel Owner/Commercial
Fisherman Vessel Lessee compensation provided for in this Finfish Compensation Plan.
If at the time of the Bar Date either the Vessel Owner or the Commercial Fisherman
Vessel Lessee has not filed a claim, the one that has filed the claim shall receive the full
Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee compensation for the vessel. The
allocation of compensation between Vessel Owner and Commercial Fisherman Vessel
Lessee shall be determined as provided in Section III. If the vessel was not leased to a
Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee during the time period of April 20, 2010 to
December 31, 2010, the Vessel Owner is entitled to the full Vessel Owner/Commercial
Fisherman Vessel Lessee compensation for the vessel.
3. It is understood that in some instances, the Vessel Owner and/or the Commercial
Fisherman Vessel Lessee is also the Boat Captain. In those instances where the Vessel
Owner and/or the Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee were also the Boat Captain, they
shall be eligible to receive the Boat Captain compensation portion for the vessel under the
Finfish Compensation Plan as set forth below. If the Vessel Owner and/or Commercial
Fisherman Vessel Lessee employed a Boat Captain on the vessel and did not serve as a
Boat Captain on that vessel, the hired Boat Captain is eligible for the Boat Captain
compensation, not the Vessel Owner or Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee.
4. To establish eligibility to participate in the Finfish Compensation Plan, a Vessel Owner
Claimant must provide for each vessel(s) for which the Claimant is seeking
compensation:
A. Proof of ownership of the vessel during the time period of April 20, 2010 to
December 31, 2010.
B. Proof that as of April 20, 2010 there was a government license (even if it had
expired before that date) that authorized that vessel to commercially fish for
finfish in the Specified Gulf Waters for the 2009 season or the 2010 season.
02919
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 52 of 96
42
C. The vessel name and any applicable federal and/or state vessel registration
identification numbers.
D. Proof that either:
1. the vessel was home ported in the Gulf Coast Areas at any time from
April 20, 2010 to April 16, 2012; or,
2. the vessel landed finfish in the Gulf Coast Areas at any time from
April 20, 2009 to April 16, 2012.
E. A sworn statement attesting as to whether or not the vessel was leased during the
time period April 20, 2010 to December 31, 2010. If the vessel was leased during
this time period, the Vessel Owner must provide a copy of the lease agreement.
F. A sworn statement attesting as to whether or not the Vessel Owner was the Boat
Captain for that vessel during January 1, 2007 through December 31, 2009. If the
Vessel Owner was not the sole Boat Captain for that vessel for some portion of
January 1, 2007 through December 31, 2009, to the extent possible, the Claimant
shall identify all other Boat Captains employed on the vessel and the time periods
for which the Boat Captains were employed.
5. To establish eligibility to participate in the Finfish Compensation Plan, a Commercial
Fisherman Vessel Lessee must provide for each vessel for which he or she seeks
compensation:
A. Proof that during the period of April 20, 2010 through December 31, 2010 he or
she leased the vessel to be used for commercial finfishing.
B. Proof that as of April 20, 2010 there was a government license (even if it had
expired before that date) that authorized that vessel to commercially fish for
finfish in the Specified Gulf Waters for the 2009 season or the 2010 season.
C. The vessel name and any applicable federal and/or state vessel registration
identification numbers.
D. Proof that either:
1. the vessel was home ported in the Gulf Coast Areas at any time from
April 20, 2010 to April 16, 2012; or,
2. the vessel landed finfish in the Gulf Coast Areas at any time from
April 20, 2009 to April 16, 2012.
E. A sworn statement, attesting that the Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee leased
the vessel during the time period of April 20, 2010 to December 31, 2010. The
Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee must also provide a copy of the lease
agreement for the vessel.
02919
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 53 of 96
43
F. A sworn statement attesting as to whether or not the Commercial Fisherman
Vessel Lessee was the Boat Captain for that vessel during January 1, 2007
through December 31, 2009. If the Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee was not
the sole Boat Captain for that vessel for some portion of January 1, 2007 through
December 31, 2009, to the extent possible, the Claimant shall identify all other
Boat Captains employed on the vessel and the time periods for which the Boat
Captains were employed.
6. To establish eligibility to participate in the Finfish Compensation Plan a Boat Captain
must provide:
A. Proof that as of April 20, 2010 the Boat Captain held a governmental license
(even if it had expired before that date) authorizing the Claimant to operate as a
Boat Captain and/or to commercially fish for finfish in the Specified Gulf Waters
for the 2009 season or the 2010 season.
B. Proof that either the Boat Captain worked:
1. on one or more commercial finfishing vessels that were home ported in the
Gulf Coast Areas from April 20, 2010 through the date of execution of the
Settlement Agreement; or,
2. one or more commercial finfishing vessels that landed finfish in the Gulf
Coast Areas from April 20, 2009 through the date of execution of the
Settlement Agreement.
7. A Sworn Statement attesting whether or not the Claimant received any Seafood Spill-
Related Payments. If the Claimant received Seafood Spill-Related Payments, the
Claimant shall provide documents
8
sufficient to establish the timing, amount and source
of Seafood Spill-Related Payments, including documents providing the claimants
BP/GCCF/Transition Facility Claim Number, if applicable, and any corresponding
payments.
Finfish Compensation Plan Definition:
Benchmark Period
9
is selected by the Claimant and can be (i) 2009, (ii) 2008 and 2009, or
(iii) 2007, 2008 and 2009. If the Claimant elects to use years 2008 and 2009 or 2007, 2008, and
2009, the annual revenue amounts shall be averaged.
8
When documents are requested in the Seafood Compensation Program, Claimant may provide either legible
copies or originals of the documents.
9
For the Seafood Compensation Program, the Benchmark Period is defined independently for each Seafood
Compensation Program Plan and is set forth within the specific Plan. Definitions of Benchmark Period in any
other frameworks in the Deepwater Horizon Economic And Property Damages Settlement Agreement do not
apply in the Seafood Compensation Program.
029197
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 54 of 96
44
A Vessel Owner or Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee must submit separate Vessel
Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee claims for each vessel they owned or leased and
may select different Benchmark Periods for different vessels.
A Boat Captains claim reflects the Claimants activities on all vessels, and the Claimant must
select a single Benchmark Period for the Boat Captains claim.
A Vessel Owner or Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee who also submits a Boat Captain
claim may select different Benchmark Periods for the Claimants Vessel Owner/Commercial
Fisherman Vessel Lessee claim and the Claimants Boat Captain claim.
Compensation Plan Method:
Vessel Owners/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessees and Boat Captains will be compensated
through the Historical Revenue Method. A Vessel Owner or Commercial Fisherman Vessel
Lessee must submit separate Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee claims for
each vessel they owned or leased.
Additionally, owners of Individual Fishing Quota (IFQ) shares may be eligible to receive
compensation for their IFQ shares under the IFQ Share Compensation Method.
I. Historical Revenue Method
A. Eligibility Requirements
1. Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee
To be eligible under the Historical Revenue Method, a Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman
Vessel Lessee must meet the eligibility requirements of the applicable paragraphs of the
Generally Applicable Provisions of the Finfish Compensation Plan above and provide
evidence to demonstrate his or her commercial finfishing revenue during the selected Benchmark
Period.
2. Boat Captains
To be eligible under the Historical Revenue Method, a Boat Captain must meet the eligibility
requirements of the applicable paragraphs of the Generally Applicable Provisions of the Finfish
Compensation Plan above and provide evidence to demonstrate his or her commercial gross
earnings from commercial finfishing on vessels for which he or she served as Boat Captain
during the selected Benchmark Period.
B. Documentation Required
1. Vessel Owners/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessees
Vessel Owners/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessees seeking compensation under the
Historical Revenue Method must provide documents sufficient to prove the eligibility
02919
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 55 of 96
45
requirements in Section I.A.1 above and to determine compensation pursuant to Section I.C
below, including the following:
a. Trip ticket or their equivalents, such as dealer forms, for each
vessel for which Claimant seeks compensation, which show the
volume of finfish harvested and the sales price as shown on the trip
tickets or their equivalents for the Benchmark Period for finfish
landed in the Gulf Coast Areas. The Claimant must provide
sufficient documentation for the Claims Administrator to be able to
identify gross revenue derived for each vessel solely for finfish
landed in the Gulf Coast Areas during the Benchmark Period. The
total volume multiplied by price will be the applicable gross
revenue.
OR
b. Federal or state tax and financial information as follows:
i. If Claimant is an entity, federal tax returns or state tax
returns, and sufficient documentation to identify
components of gross revenue derived from commercial
finfish harvesting by vessel for the Benchmark Period for
each vessel for which the Claimant submits a Vessel
Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee claim.
ii. If Claimant is an individual, federal form 1040 including
Schedules C, E and F or state tax forms as well as sufficient
documentation to identify those components of earnings
derived from commercial finfish harvesting by vessel for
the Benchmark Period.
iii. In addition, the Claimant must provide sufficient
documentation for the Claims Administrator to be able to
identify (i) the Claimants revenue from finfishing as
compared to other sources and (ii) Claimants revenue from
landings in the Gulf Coast Areas. If necessary, the Claims
Administrator may require supplemental information from
the Claimant in order to make these determinations.
c. In addition, if available, it is requested that the Claimant also
provide the following documents, to assist the Claims
Administrator:
i. Vessel log book
ii. Share sheets
iii. Proof of vessel size and type
029199
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 56 of 96
46
iv. Sales or other production reports maintained in the normal
course of business
2. Boat Captains
Boat Captains seeking compensation under the Historical Revenue Method must provide
documents sufficient to prove the eligibility requirements in Section I.A.2 and to determine
compensation pursuant to Section I.C below, including the following:
a. Trip tickets or their equivalents for each vessel for which the
Claimant seeks compensation, which show the volume of finfish
harvested and the sales price as shown on the trip tickets or their
equivalents for the Benchmark Period for finfish landed in the Gulf
Coast Areas. The total volume multiplied by price will be the
applicable gross revenue.
OR
b. Federal tax returns, including Schedules C, E and F, W-2s, and
1099s or state tax returns with supporting documents for the
Benchmark Period and sufficient documentation to identify those
components of earnings derived from commercial finfish
harvesting for the Benchmark Period for the vessel(s) selected by
the Claimant. In addition, the Claimant must provide sufficient
documentation for the Claims Administrator to be able to identify
revenue from finfish landings in the Gulf Coast Areas for each
vessel while the Claimant was Boat Captain. If necessary, the
Claims Administrator may require supplemental information from
the Claimant in order to make these determinations.
c. In addition, if available, it is requested that the Claimant also
provide the following documents, to assist the Claims
Administrator:
i. Captains log book
ii. Vessel log book
iii. Share sheets
iv. Proof of vessel size and type for Captained vessels
v. Sales or other production reports maintained in the normal
course of business
C. Compensation Calculations
1. Calculate Benchmark Finfish Revenue.
029200
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 57 of 96
47
a. If trip tickets or their equivalents are used, the volume and price of
finfish on the trip tickets or their equivalents are used to calculate
gross revenue from finfish landed in the Gulf Coast Areas. If the
Claimant is a Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee,
the Claimant may provide trip tickets or their equivalents for the
Benchmark Period for each vessel for which compensation is being
sought. If the Claimant is a Boat Captain, the Claimant may
provide trip tickets or their equivalents for all vessels he or she
served as a Captain during the Benchmark Period.
OR
b. The Claims Administrator may determine the gross vessel revenue
for Boat Captain earnings from finfish landings in the Gulf Coast
Areas based on the Claimants tax returns, or financial information
if the Claims Administrator has sufficient information to
determine: (i) Claimants revenue from finfish harvesting as
compared to other sources, (ii) Claimants revenue from finfish
landings in the Gulf Coast Areas. If necessary, the Claims
Administrator may require supplemental information from the
Claimant in order to make these determinations.
2. If (i) the Claimant is a Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel
Lessee or (ii) the Claimant is a Boat Captain and Benchmark Revenue
was calculated using trip tickets or their equivalents, calculate
Benchmark Finfish Cost. Benchmark Finfish Cost is calculated by
multiplying Benchmark Finfish Revenue by the Finfish Cost Percentage.
The Finfish Cost Percentage, 27%, is expressed as a percentage of
revenue and reflects standard industry non-labor variable costs. If the
Claimant is a Boat Captain and Benchmark Revenue was calculated
based upon his earnings, such as from tax returns or financial
information, then no Finfish Cost Percentage is applied, skip to step 3.
Benchmark Finfish Cost = (Benchmark Finfish Revenue * Finfish Cost Percentage)
3. Calculate the Base Finfish Loss using the Finfish Loss Percentage of 25%.
a. If (i) the Claimant is a Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman
Vessel Lessee or (ii) the Claimant is a Boat Captain and
Benchmark Revenue was calculated using trip tickets or their
equivalents, the Base Loss is calculated as follows:
Base Finfish Loss = (Benchmark Finfish Revenue Benchmark Finfish Cost) * 25%
b. If the Claimant is a Boat Captain and Benchmark Revenue was
calculated using a different source than trip tickets or their
equivalents, the Base Loss is calculated as follows:
029201
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 58 of 96
48
Base Finfish Loss = Benchmark Finfish Revenue * 25%
4. Determine Base Compensation by multiplying Base Finfish Loss by the
appropriate Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee or Boat
Captain share. Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman and Boat Captain
shares are: 45% for the Vessel/Owner Commercial Fisherman and 35%
for the Finfish Boat Captain.
a. Base Compensation for Vessel Owners/Commercial Fisherman
Vessel Lessees is calculated as below and found in Table 1:
Base Compensation = Base Finfish Loss * Finfish Vessel Share
TABLE 1
FINFISH VESSEL
OWNERS/COMMERCIAL
FISHERMAN VESSEL
LESSEE SHARE
FINFISH BOAT
CAPTAIN SHARE
45% 35%
b. Base Compensation for Finfish Boat Captains is calculated as:
i. If Finfish Boat Captain Compensation is calculated based
on trip tickets, then the Base Compensation for the Finfish
Boat Captain is calculated as:
Base Compensation = Base Finfish Loss * Finfish Boat Captain Share
ii. If Finfish Boat Captain Compensation is calculated based
on tax returns and financial records, then the Base
Compensation for the Finfish Boat Captain is calculated as:
Base Compensation = Base Finfish Loss
5. Apply the RTP to Base Compensation in order to determine Final
Compensation. Base Compensation is specific to Claimant type and is
found in Table 2.
Final Compensation = Base Compensation + (Base Compensation * RTP)
029202
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 59 of 96
49
TABLE 2
FINFISH VESSEL
OWNERS/COMMERCIAL
FISHERMAN VESSEL
LESSEES
FINFISH BOAT
CAPTAINS
RTP 6.0 5.0
II. Compensation for IFQ Quota Holders
The Finfish Quota Allocation Method provides a fixed compensation amount to Claimants that
meet certain requirements and are Individual Fishing Quota (IFQ) shareholders.
A. Eligibility and Documentation Requirements
In order to be eligible to qualify for compensation under the Individual Fishing Quota
Shareholder Method, the Claimant must provide:
1. Proof of ownership as of April 20, 2010 of the Individual Fishing Quota
share for all species identified by IFQs, including Red Snapper, Gag
Grouper Red Grouper, Deep Water Grouper Shallow Water Grouper and
Tilefish.
B. Compensation Calculations
1. Individual Fishing Quota Shareholders that have provided the proof of
eligibility and the required documentation set forth in section II.A. above
shall receive the compensation based on the value of Individual Fishing
Quota shares held. IFQ shares are defined as the right to catch 0.0001% of
the pounds of the catch the relevant species that can be caught by
commercial fishermen under the relevant quota.
2. In the aggregate, IFQ holders will receive compensation of $50 million. If
the $50 million is not exhausted in payment of IFQ Shareholder claimants,
then any remaining amount shall be distributed as part of the balance
described in the General Framework and Overview of Seafood
Compensation Program Distribution section of this Seafood
Compensation Program.
3. IFQ Shareholder Claimants will be compensated in proportion to the
percentage of the total value of IFQ shares, calculated across all species.
The relevant prices and aggregate value of IFQ shares is summarized in
Table 2. The table reports NOAA 2010 IFQ data on the prices at which
IFQ shares were sold, with a share defined as 0.0001% of pounds of
catch allowed under the species-specific IFQ program.
02920
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 60 of 96
50
TABLE 2
Species Price per .0001% Share Total Value ($Million)
Red Snapper $44.90 $44.9
Gag Grouper $6.75 $6.8
Red Grouper $20.67 $20.7
Deep Water Grouper $4.99 $5.0
Shallow Water Grouper $1.64 $1.6
Tilefish $1.08 $1.1
Total $80.0
4. Compensation for IFQ share holders is calculated as follows:
a. The value of a Claimants IFQ shares is calculated as the product
of the species-specific number of quota shares held and the
species-specific value per quota share, as reflected in Table 3.
b. The compensation received by a Claimant is calculated by
multiplying the value of the Claimants share multiplied by 0.625.
For example, a Claimant with 1,000 shares of Red Grouper would have a IFQ
share value of $20,670 (1,000 shares * $20.67). The Claimant would then receive
compensation of $12,918.75 ($20,670 * 0.625).
III. Vessel Lease Compensation Allocation
To the extent the Vessel was leased by the Vessel Owner to the Commercial Fisherman Vessel
Lessee as of April 20, 2010, compensation will be allocated between the parties based upon
Benchmark Revenue, as calculated above and Annual Lease Payment. The Annual Lease
Payment shall be calculated as the annual payment to the Vessel Owner by the Commercial
Fisherman Vessel Lessee for the lease in effect as of April 20, 2010. The ratio of the Annual
Lease Payment to Benchmark Revenue multiplied by the Final Compensation determines the
Vessel Owner Share of Final Compensation. The Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessees Share
of Compensation is Final Compensation less the Vessel Owners Share of Final Compensation.
Vessel Owner Share of Final Compensation = Final Compensation * (Annual Lease Payment /
Benchmark Revenue)
029204
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 61 of 96
51
Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessees Share of Final Share of Compensation = Final
Compensation - Vessel Owner Share of Final Compensation.
02920
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 62 of 96
52
BLUE CRAB/OTHER SEAFOOD COMPENSATION PLAN
Generally Applicable Provisions of the Blue Crab/Other Seafood Compensation Plan:
1. Eligible Claimants shall be comprised of Class Members (i) who do not fall within the
exclusions to the Economic Loss and Property Class Definition, (ii) who are Vessel
Owners, Commercial Fishermen who lease Seafood Vessels (Commercial Fisherman
Vessel Lessee), and/or Seafood Boat Captains that derive income from commercial
fishing for blue crab and/or Other Seafood,
10
and (iii) who meet the additional criteria
listed in this Blue Crab/Other Seafood Compensation Plan.
2. It is understood that in some instances, the Vessel Owner is also the Commercial
Fisherman; however, it may be the case that the Vessel Owner leased the vessel to a
Commercial Fisherman. In those instances where the vessel was leased during the time
period of April 20, 2010 to December 31, 2010, the Vessel Owner and Commercial
Fisherman Vessel Lessee must file the vessel claim jointly in order to receive
compensation prior to the Bar Date, and they shall share any Vessel Owner/Commercial
Fisherman Vessel Lessee compensation provided for in this Blue Crab/Other Seafood
Compensation Plan. If at the time of the Bar Date either the Vessel Owner or the
Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee has not filed a claim, the one that has filed the
claim shall receive the full Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee
compensation for the vessel. The allocation of compensation between Vessel Owner and
Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee shall be determined as provided in Section II. If
the vessel was not leased to a Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee during the time
period of April 20, 2010 to December 31, 2010, the Vessel Owner is entitled to the full
Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee compensation for the vessel.
3. It is understood that in some instances, the Vessel Owner and/or the Commercial
Fisherman Vessel Lessee is also the Boat Captain. In those instances where the Vessel
Owner and/or the Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee were also the Boat Captain, they
shall be eligible to receive the Boat Captain compensation portion for the vessel under the
Blue Crab/Other Seafood Compensation Plan as set forth below. If the Vessel Owner
and/or Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee employed a Boat Captain on the vessel and
did not serve as a Boat Captain on that vessel, the hired Boat Captain is eligible for the
Boat Captain compensation, not the Vessel Owner or Commercial Fisherman Vessel
Lessee.
4. To establish eligibility to participate in the Blue Crab/Other Seafood Compensation Plan,
a Vessel Owner Claimant must provide for each vessel(s) for which the Claimant is
seeking compensation:
A. Proof of ownership of the vessel during the time period of April 20, 2010 to
December 31, 2010.
10
Other Seafood shall be defined to mean all forms of seafood included in the Exhibit 3 of the Deepwater Horizon
Economic And Property Damages Settlement Agreement (Seafood Distribution Chain Definitions) including
stone crab and spiny lobster, but excluding shrimp, oysters, finfish and blue crab.
02920
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 63 of 96
53
B. Proof that as of April 20, 2010 there was a government license (even if it had
expired before that date) that authorized that vessel to commercially fish for blue
crab or Other Seafood in the Specified Gulf Waters for the 2009 season or the
2010 season.
C. The vessel name and any applicable federal and/or state vessel registration
identification numbers.
D. Proof that either:
1. the vessel was home ported in the Gulf Coast Areas at any time from
April 20, 2010 to April 16, 2012; or,
2. the vessel landed blue crab and/or Other Seafood in the Gulf Coast Areas
at any time from April 20, 2009 to April 16, 2012.
E. A sworn statement attesting as to whether or not the vessel was leased during the
time period April 20, 2010 to December 31, 2010. If the vessel was leased during
this time period, the Vessel Owner must provide a copy of the lease agreement.
F. A sworn statement attesting as to whether or not the Vessel Owner was the Boat
Captain for that vessel during January 1, 2007 through December 31, 2009. If the
Vessel Owner was not the sole Boat Captain for that vessel for some portion of
January 1, 2007 through December 31, 2009, to the extent possible, the Claimant
shall identify all other Boat Captains employed on the vessel and the time periods
for which the Boat Captains were employed.
5. To establish eligibility to participate in the Blue Crab/Other Seafood Compensation Plan,
a Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee must provide for each vessel for which the
Claimant seeks compensation:
A. Proof that during the period of April 20, 2010 through December 31, 2010 the
Claimant leased the vessel to be used for commercial blue crab and/or Other
Seafood harvesting.
B. Proof that as of April 20, 2010 there was a government license (even if it had
expired before that date) that authorized that vessel to commercially fish for blue
crab and/or Other Seafood in the Specified Gulf Waters for the 2009 season or the
2010 season.
C. The vessel name and any applicable federal and/or state vessel registration
identification numbers.
D. Proof that either:
1. the vessel was home ported in the Gulf Coast Areas at any time from
April 20, 2010 to April 16, 2012; or,
029207
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 64 of 96
54
2. the vessel landed blue crab and/or Other Seafood in the Gulf Coast Areas
at any time from April 20, 2009 to April 16, 2012.
E. A sworn statement, attesting that the Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee leased
the vessel during the time period of April 20, 2010 to December 31, 2010. The
Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee must also provide a copy of the lease
agreement for the vessel.
F. A sworn statement attesting as to whether or not the Commercial Fisherman
Vessel Lessee was the Boat Captain for that vessel during January 1, 2007
through December 31, 2009. If the Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee was not
the sole Boat Captain for that vessel for some portion of January 1, 2007 through
December 31, 2009, to the extent possible, the Claimant shall identify all other
Boat Captains employed on the vessel and the time periods for which the Boat
Captains were employed.
6. To establish eligibility to participate in the Blue Crab/Other Seafood Compensation Plan
a Boat Captain must provide:
A. Proof that as of April 20, 2010 the Boat Captain held a governmental license
(even if it had expired before that date) authorizing the Claimant to operate as a
Boat Captain and/or to commercially fish for blue crab and/or Other Seafood in
the Specified Gulf Waters for the 2009 season or the 2010 season.
B. Proof that either the Boat Captain worked:
1. on one or more commercial blue crab or Other Seafood vessels that were
home ported in the Gulf Coast Areas at any time from April 20, 2010 to
April 16, 2012; or,
2. on one or more commercial blue crab or Other Seafood vessels that landed
blue crab or Other Seafood in the Gulf Coast Areas at any time from
April 20, 2009 to April 16, 2012.
7. A Sworn Statement attesting whether or not the Claimant received any Seafood Spill-
Related Payments. If the Claimant received Seafood Spill-Related Payments, the
Claimant shall provide documents
11
sufficient to establish the timing, amount and source
of Seafood Spill-Related Payments, including documents providing the claimants
BP/GCCF/Transition Facility Claim Number, if applicable, and any corresponding
payments.
11
When documents are requested in the Seafood Compensation Program, Claimant may provide either legible
copies or originals of the documents.
02920
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 65 of 96
55
Blue Crab/Other Seafood Compensation Plan Definition:
Benchmark Period
12
is selected by the Claimant and can be (i) 2009, (ii) 2008 and 2009, or
(iii) 2007, 2008 and 2009. If the Claimant elects to use years 2008 and 2009 or 2007, 2008, and
2009, the annual revenue amounts shall be averaged.
A Vessel Owner or Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee must submit separate Vessel
Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee claims for each vessel they owned or leased and
may select different Benchmark Periods for different vessels.
A Boat Captains claim reflects the Claimants activities on all vessels, and the Boat Captain
must select a single Benchmark Period for the Claimants claim.
A Vessel Owner or Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee who also submits a Boat Captain
claim may select different Benchmark Periods for the Claimants Vessel Owner/Commercial
Fisherman Vessel Lessee claim and the Claimants Boat Captain claim.
Compensation Plan Method:
Vessel Owners/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessees and Boat Captains will be separately
compensated for blue crab claims and Other Seafood claims through the Historical Revenue
Method. Claimants may submit a claim for either or both blue crab or Other Seafood categories.
Compensation for blue crab claims is set forth in Section I.C and compensation for Other
Seafood claims is set forth in Section I.D. A Vessel Owner or Commercial Fisherman Vessel
Lessee must submit separate Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee claims for
each vessel they owned or leased.
Additionally, Vessel Owners and Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessees that establish they
commercially fished for blue crab in the Benchmark Period and who satisfy the applicable
paragraphs of the Generally applicable Provisions of the Blue Crab/Other Seafood Compensation
Plan above and in Section I.A. below will receive a lump sum payment as set forth in Section I.
I. Historical Revenue Method
A. Eligibility Requirements
1. Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee
To be eligible under the Historical Revenue Method, a Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman
Vessel Lessee must meet the eligibility requirements of the applicable paragraphs of the
Generally Applicable Provisions of the Blue Crab/Other Seafood Compensation Plan and
provide evidence to demonstrate the Claimants commercial blue crab and/or Other Seafood
revenue during the selected Benchmark Period.
12
For the Seafood Compensation Program, the Benchmark Period is defined independently for each Seafood
Compensation Program Plan and is set forth within the specific Plan. Definitions of Benchmark Period in any
other frameworks in the Deepwater Horizon Economic And Property Damages Settlement Agreement do not
apply in the Seafood Compensation Program.
029209
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 66 of 96
56
2. Boat Captains
To be eligible under the Historical Revenue Method, a Boat Captain must meet eligibility
requirements of the applicable paragraphs of the Generally Applicable Provisions of the Blue
Crab/Other Seafood Compensation Plan requirements of the Blue Crab/Other Seafood
Compensation Plan and provide evidence to demonstrate the Claimants gross earnings from
commercial blue crab and/or Other Seafood harvesting on vessels for which the Claimant served
as Boat Captain during the selected Benchmark Period.
B. Documentation Required
1. Vessel Owners/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessees
Vessel Owners/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessees seeking compensation under the
Historical Revenue Method must provide documents sufficient to prove the eligibility
requirements in Section I.A.1 above and to determine compensation pursuant to Section I.C or
I.D below, including the following:
a. Trip ticket or their equivalents, such as dealer forms, for each
vessel for which Claimant seeks compensation, which show the
volume of blue crab and/or Other Seafood harvested and the sales
price as shown on the trip tickets or their equivalents for the
Benchmark Period for blue crab and/or Other Seafood landed in
the Gulf Coast Areas. The Claimant must provide sufficient
documentation for the Claims Administrator to be able to identify
gross revenue derived for each vessel solely for blue crab and/or
Other Seafood landed in the Gulf Coast Areas during the
Benchmark Period. The total volume multiplied by price will be
the applicable gross revenue.
OR
b. Federal or state tax returns and financial information as follows:
i. If Claimant is an entity, federal tax returns, state tax returns
and sufficient documentation to identify components of
gross revenue derived from commercial blue crab and/or
Other Seafood harvesting by vessel for the Benchmark
Period for each vessel for which the Claimant submits a
Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee claim.
ii. If Claimant is an individual, federal form 1040 including
Schedules C, E and F or state tax forms and supporting
documents as well as sufficient documentation to identify
by vessel components of gross earnings derived from
commercial blue crab and/or Other Seafood harvesting for
the Benchmark Period for each vessel for which the
029210
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 67 of 96
57
Claimant submits a Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman
Vessel Lessee claim.
iii. In addition, the Claimant must provide sufficient
documentation for the Claims Administrator to be able to
identify (i) the Claimants revenue from blue crab and/or
Other Seafood as compared to other sources and
(ii) Claimants revenue from landings in the Gulf Coast
Areas. If necessary, the Claims Administrator may require
supplemental information from the Claimant in order to
make these determinations.
c. In addition, if available, it is requested that the Claimant also
provide the following documents, to assist the Claims
Administrator:
i. Vessel log book
ii. Share sheets
iii. Proof of vessel size and type
iv. Sales or other production reports maintained in the normal
course of business
2. Boat Captains
Boat Captains seeking compensation under the Historical Revenue Method must provide
documents sufficient to prove the eligibility requirements in Section I.A.2 above and to
determine compensation pursuant to Section I.C. or I.D. below, including the following:
a. Trip tickets or their equivalents for each vessel for which the
Claimant seeks compensation, which show the volume of blue crab
and/or Other Seafood harvested and the sales price as shown on the
trip tickets or their equivalents for the Benchmark Period for blue
crab and/or Other Seafood landed in the Gulf Coast Areas. The
total volume multiplied by price will be the applicable gross
revenue.
OR
b. Federal tax returns, including Schedules C, E and F, W-2s, and
1099s or state tax returns with supporting documents for the
Benchmark Period and sufficient documentation to identify those
components of gross earnings derived from commercial blue crab
and/or Other Seafood harvesting for the Benchmark Period for the
vessel(s) selected by the Claimant. In addition, the Claimant must
provide sufficient documentation for the Claims Administrator to
029211
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 68 of 96
58
be able to identify revenue from blue crab and/or Other Seafood
landings in the Gulf Coast Areas for each vessel while the
Claimant was Boat Captain. If necessary, the Claims
Administrator may require supplemental information from the
Claimant in order to make these determinations.
c. In addition, if available, it is requested that the Claimant also
provide the following documents, to assist the Claims
Administrator:
i. Captains log book
ii. Vessel log book
iii. Share sheets
iv. Proof of vessel size and type for Captained vessels
v. Sales or other production reports maintained in the normal
course of business
C. Compensation Calculations for Blue Crab
The Claims Administrator shall determine compensation separately for blue crab and for Other
Seafood. The compensation for gross revenue or earnings attributable to blue crab is determined
as set forth in Section I.C. The separate and independent compensation for gross revenue or
earnings attributable to Other Seafood is determined as set forth in Section I.D.
1. Calculate Benchmark Blue Crab Revenue.
a. If trip tickets or their equivalents are used, the volume and price of
blue crab on the trip tickets or their equivalents are used to
calculate gross revenue from blue crab landed in the Gulf Coast
Areas. If the Claimant is a Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman
Vessel Lessee, the Claimant may provide trip tickets for the
Benchmark Period for each Vessel for which compensation is
being sought. If the Claimant is a Boat Captain, the Claimant may
provide trip tickets or their equivalents for all vessels the Claimant
served as a Captain during the Benchmark Period.
OR
b. The Claims Administrator may determine the gross vessel revenue
or Boat Captain earnings from blue crab landings in the Gulf Coast
Areas based on the Claimants tax returns or financial information
if the Claims Administrator has sufficient information to
determine: (i) Claimants revenue from blue crab as compared to
other sources and (ii) Claimants revenue from blue crab landings
029212
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 69 of 96
59
in the Gulf Coast Areas. If necessary, the Claims Administrator
may require supplemental information from the Claimant in order
to make these determinations.
2. Calculate Total Adjusted Benchmark Blue Crab Revenue by multiplying
the Adjusted Benchmark Blue Crab Revenue by 1.2, the Adjustment for
Changes in 2010-11 Prices.
Total Adjusted Benchmark Blue Crab Revenue =
(Benchmark Blue Crab Revenue * Adjustment for Changes in 2010-11 Prices).
3. If (i) the Claimant is a Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel
Lessee or (ii) the Claimant is a Boat Captain and Benchmark Revenue was
calculated using trip tickets or their equivalents, calculate Benchmark Blue
Crab Cost. Benchmark Blue Crab Cost is calculated by multiplying
Benchmark Blue Crab Revenue by the Blue Crab Cost Percentage of 35%.
The Blue Crab Cost Percentage is expressed as a percentage of revenue
and reflects standard industry non-labor variable costs. If the Claimant is
a Boat Captain and Benchmark Revenue was calculated based upon his
earnings, such as from tax returns or financial information, then no Blue
Crab Cost Percentage is applied, skip to step 4.
Benchmark Blue Crab Cost = (Benchmark Blue Crab Revenue * Blue Crab Cost Percentage)
4. Calculate the Base Blue Crab Loss using the Blue Crab Loss Percentage of
35%.
a. If (i) the Claimant is a Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman
Vessel Lessee or (ii) the Claimant is a Boat Captain and
Benchmark Revenue was calculated using trip tickets or their
equivalents, the Base Loss is calculated as follows:
Base Blue Crab Loss =
(Total Adjusted Benchmark Blue Crab Revenue Benchmark Blue Crab Cost) * 35%
b. If the Claimant is a Boat Captain and Total Adjusted Benchmark
Revenue was calculated using a different source than trip tickets or
their equivalents, the Base Loss is calculated as follows:
Base Blue Crab Loss = Adjusted Benchmark Blue Crab Revenue * 35%
5. Determine Base Compensation by multiplying Base Blue Crab Loss by the
appropriate Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee share.
Vessel Owner and Boat Captain shares are presented in Table 1.
a. Base Compensation for Vessel Owners/Commercial Fisherman
Vessel Lessees is calculated as:
02921
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 70 of 96
60
Base Compensation = Base Blue Crab Loss * 50%
b. Base Compensation for Blue Crab Boat Captains is calculated as:
i. if Blue Crab Boat Captain Compensation is calculated
based on trip tickets, then the Base Compensation for Blue
Crab Boat Captain is calculated as:
Base Compensation = Base Blue Crab Loss * 30%
ii. If Blue Crab Boat Captain Compensation is calculated
based on tax returns and financial records, Compensation
for Blue Crab Boat Captain is calculated as:
Base Compensation = Base Blue Crab Loss
TABLE 1
BLUE CRAB VESSEL
OWNER/COMMERCIAL
FISHERMAN VESSEL
LESSEE SHARE
BLUE CRAB BOAT
CAPTAIN SHARE
50% 30%
6. Apply the RTP to Base Compensation in order to determine Final
Compensation. Base Compensation is specific to Claimant type and is
found in Table 2.
Final Blue Crab Compensation = Base Compensation + (Base Compensation * RTP)
029214
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 71 of 96
61
TABLE 2
BLUE CRAB VESSEL
OWNERS/COMMERCIAL
FISHERMAN VESSEL
LESSEES
BLUE CRAB BOAT
CAPTAINS
RTP 6.0 5.0
In addition, Vessel Owners/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessees who receive Final Blue Crab
Compensation shall also receive a lump sum payment of $7,500 per vessel.
A. Compensation Calculations for Other Seafood
1. Calculate Benchmark Other Seafood Revenue
a. If trip tickets or their equivalents are used, the volume and price of
Other Seafood on the trip tickets or their equivalents are used to
calculate gross revenue from Other Seafood landed in the Gulf
Coast Areas. If the Claimant is a Vessel Owner/Commercial
Fisherman Vessel Lessee, the Claimant may provide trip tickets or
their equivalents for the Benchmark Period for each Vessel for
which compensation is being sought. If the Claimant is a Boat
Captain, the Claimant may provide trip tickets for all vessels the
Claimant served as a Captain during the Benchmark Period.
OR
b. The Claims Administrator may determine the gross vessel revenue
or Boat Captain earnings from Other Seafood landings in the Gulf
Coast Areas based on the Claimants tax returns, monthly profit
and loss statements, or financial information if the Claims
Administrator has sufficient information to determine:
(i) Claimants revenue from Other Seafood as compared to other
sources and (ii) Claimants revenue from Other Seafood landings
in the Gulf Coast Areas. If necessary, the Claims Administrator
may require supplemental information from the Claimant in order
to make these determinations.
2. Calculate Total Adjusted Benchmark Other Seafood Revenue by
multiplying the Additional Catch Adjusted Benchmark Other Seafood
Revenue by 1.1, the Adjustment for Changes in 2010-11 Prices.
Total Adjusted Benchmark Other Seafood Revenue =
(Benchmark Other Seafood Revenue * Adjustment for Changes in 2010-11 Prices).
02921
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 72 of 96
62
3. If (i) the Claimant is a Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel
Lessee or (ii) the Claimant is a Boat Captain and Benchmark Revenue was
calculated using trip tickets or their equivalents, calculate Benchmark
Other Seafood Cost. Benchmark Other Seafood Cost is calculated by
multiplying Benchmark Other Seafood Revenue by the Other Seafood
Cost Percentage of 35%. The Other Seafood Cost Percentage is expressed
as a percentage of revenue and reflects standard industry non-labor
variable costs. If the Claimant is a Boat Captain and Benchmark Revenue
was calculated based upon his earnings, such as from tax returns or
financial information, then no Other Seafood Cost Percentage is applied,
skip to step 5.
Benchmark Other Seafood Cost =
(Benchmark Other Seafood Revenue * Other Seafood Cost Percentage)
4. Calculate the Base Other Seafood Loss using the Other Seafood Loss
Percentage of 10%.
a. If (i) the Claimant is a Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman
Vessel Lessee or (ii) the Claimant is a Boat Captain and
Benchmark Revenue was calculated using trip tickets or their
equivalents, the Base Loss is calculated as follows
Base Other Seafood Loss =
(Total Adjusted Benchmark Other Seafood Revenue Benchmark Other Seafood Cost) * 10%
b. If the Claimant is a Boat Captain and Benchmark Revenue was
calculated using a different source than trip tickets or their
equivalents, the Base Loss is calculated as follows
Base Other Seafood Loss = Total Adjusted Benchmark Other Seafood Revenue * 10%
5. Determine Base Compensation by multiplying Base Other Seafood Loss
by the appropriate Vessel Owner/Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessee or
Boat Captain share. Vessel Owner and Boat Captain shares are presented
in Table 3.
a. Base Compensation for Vessel Owners/Commercial Fisherman
Vessel Lessees is calculated as:
Base Compensation = Base Other Seafood Loss * 50%
b. Base Compensation for Other Seafood Boat Captains is calculated
as:
02921
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 73 of 96
63
i. If Other Seafood Boat Captain Compensation is calculated
based on trip tickets, then Other Seafood Boat Captain Base
Compensation is calculated as:
Base Compensation = Base Other Seafood Loss * 30%
ii. If Other Seafood Boat Captain Compensation is calculated
based on tax returns and financial records, then Other
Seafood Boat Captain Base Compensation is calculated as:
Base Compensation = Base Other Seafood Loss
TABLE 3
OTHER SEAFOOD
VESSEL
OWNER/COMMERCIAL
FISHERMAN VESSEL
LESSEE SHARE
OTHER SEAFOOD
BOAT CAPTAIN
SHARE
50% 30%
6. Apply the RTP to Base Compensation in order to determine Final Compensation.
Base Compensation is specific to Claimant type and is found in Table 1.
Final Compensation = Base Compensation + (Base Compensation * RTP)
TABLE 4
OTHER SEAFOOD
VESSEL
OWNERS/COMMERCIAL
FISHERMAN VESSEL
LESSEES
OTHER SEAFOOD BOAT
CAPTAINS
RTP 5.5 4.5
II. Vessel Lease Compensation Allocation
To the extent the Vessel was leased by the Vessel Owner to the Commercial Fisherman Vessel
Lessee as of April 20, 2010, compensation will be allocated between the parties based upon
Benchmark Revenue, as calculated above and Annual Lease Payment. The Annual Lease
Payment shall be calculated as the annual payment to the Vessel Owner by the Commercial
Fisherman Vessel Lessee for the lease in effect as of April 20, 2010. The ratio of the Annual
Lease Payment to Benchmark Revenue multiplied by the Final Compensation determines the
029217
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 74 of 96
64
Vessel Owner Share of Final Compensation. The Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessees Share
of Compensation is Final Compensation less the Vessel Owners Share of Final Compensation.
Vessel Owner Share of Final Compensation = Final Compensation * (Annual Lease Payment /
Benchmark Revenue)
Commercial Fisherman Vessel Lessees Share of Final Share of Compensation = Final
Compensation - Vessel Owner Share of Final Compensation.
02921
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 75 of 96
65
Seafood Crew Compensation Plan for Individuals Who Are Seafood First Mates, Seafood
Second Mates, Seafood Boatswains, and Seafood Deckhands
Overview
This Seafood Crew Compensation Plan is for Class Members who are Seafood First Mates,
Seafood Second Mates, Seafood Boatswains and Seafood Deckhands claiming economic loss
from employment by a Commercial Fisherman due to or resulting from the Deepwater Horizon
oil spill. Claimants seeking compensation under Category I or III must show they were
employed by a Commercial Fisherman in 2009, and Claimants seeking compensation under
Category II must show that they were employed by a Commercial Fisherman in 2009 or that
they had accepted a job offer to work for a Commercial Fisherman in 2010.
Any eligible Claimant may receive compensation based upon one of the following three
categories (but no more than one of the three categories), provided the Claimant satisfies the
requirements outlined below.
I. INDIVIDUAL CLAIMANTS WITH TAX INFORMATION OR PAY PERIOD
EARNINGS DOCUMENTATION FOR 2009: Applies to Claimants providing Tax
Information Documents or Pay Period Earnings Documentation for the selected Base
Year(s). Requirements detailed in Section I must be fulfilled.
II. INDIVIDUAL CLAIMANTS WITHOUT TAX INFORMATION OR PAY PERIOD
EARNINGS DOCUMENTATION WHO SUBMIT A CLAIMANT SWORN WRITTEN
STATEMENT AND EMPLOYER SWORN WRITTEN STATEMENT TO
ESTABLISH EARNINGS: Applies to two types of Claimants: (i) those without
sufficient Tax Information Documents or Pay Period Earnings Documentation
regarding 2009 earnings, but who provide Sworn Written Statements (from both the
Claimant and the Claimants employer) presenting employment and compensation
information for 2009; and (ii) those with proof of an offer of employment in a Claiming
Job for 2010. Requirements detailed in Section II must be fulfilled.
III. INDIVIDUAL CLAIMANTS WITHOUT TAX INFORMATION OR PAY PERIOD
EARNINGS DOCUMENTATION WHO SUBMIT A CLAIMANT SWORN WRITTEN
STATEMENT, SPONSOR SWORN WRITTEN STATEMENT(S) AND ATTORNEY
SWORN WRITTEN STATEMENT (IF APPLICABLE) TO ESTABLISH EARNINGS:
Applies to Claimants without sufficient Tax Information Documents or Pay Period
Earnings Documentation and without an Employer Sworn Written Statement to
document earnings for 2009 but who provide at least three Sworn Written Statements
presenting employment and compensation information for 2009. Requirements detailed
in Section III must be fulfilled.
029219
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 76 of 96
66
Definitions
The following defined terms used in this Seafood Crew Compensation Plan shall have the
meanings set forth below and be presented in bold-faced type.
13
A. Actual Earnings: Claimants Income actually earned from the Claiming Job.
B. Base Year(s): A Claimant selected period, applicable to Category I only, used for
historical comparison and defined as one of the following options, provided that
once selected, the same Base Year(s) shall be used in this Seafood Crew
Compensation Plan for all purposes for which a Base Year(s) is required for that
Claimant. Provided further, a Claimant is restricted to the following three options
in choosing the Claimants Base Year(s).
2009; or
The average of 2008 and 2009; or
The average of 2007, 2008 and 2009.
C. Benchmark Period: For purposes of this Seafood Crew Compensation Plan,
the Benchmark Period for claimants in Category I is the period of April 20
through December 31 of the year or years selected from the Base Year(s), and the
Benchmark Period for claimants in Categories II and III is April 20, 2009
through December 31, 2009. The Benchmark Period is used to establish
baseline earnings to be used in calculating the Claimants lost earnings arising out
of the harvesting of seafood due to the Deepwater Horizon oil spill.
D. Category II Aggregate Compensation Amount: $80 million is the Aggregate
Compensation Amount for Category II claims.
E. Category III Aggregate Compensation Amount: $50 million is the Aggregate
Compensation Amount available to pay Category III claims.
F. Claiming Job(s): The job held by the Claimant that meets the definition of
Seafood First Mate, Seafood Second Mate, Seafood Boatswain or Seafood
Deckhand.
G. Claims Administrator: The Claims Administrator and related staff appointed
pursuant to the Deepwater Horizon Economic And Property Damages Settlement
Agreement.
H. Income: Gross earnings from the Claiming Job.
13
These definitions apply to the Seafood Crew Compensation Plan only and not to other aspects of the Seafood
Compensation Program generally.
029220
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 77 of 96
67
I. Pay Period Earnings Documentation: Documentation sufficient to establish a
Claimants earnings from employment and hours worked during the applicable
Benchmark Period. Documentation may include:
Paycheck stubs; and/or
Other employer records documenting actual amounts paid, if applicable;
and/or
Bank records showing income deposits and supporting documentation
indicating the source of those deposits; and/or
Receipts or records from check cashing or payday loan services and
supporting documentation indicating the source of those funds; and/or
Contracts for employment accompanied by documentation establishing that
wages or other amounts to be paid pursuant to the contract, if applicable, were
in fact paid; and/or
Pay period earnings detail submitted under oath and included in court filings
(for example, documentation provided in connection with divorce, child
support, or wage garnishment proceedings).
J. Tax Information Documents: Tax Returns or Forms W-2 and/or 1099s.
K. Tax Returns: Federal or state income tax returns, including any relevant
supporting schedules.
L. Sworn Claim Form: Each Claimant must complete and submit a Claim Form
which the Claimant shall verify under penalties of perjury. The Claim Form
shall direct the Claimant to provide information, including the Claimants chosen
Base Year(s) for Category I. The Claimant shall attach required documents
supporting the claim. All statements made in, and documents submitted with, the
Sworn Claim Form may be verified as judged necessary by the Claims
Administrator. The Claimant shall provide forms in which the Claimant shall
authorize the Claims Administrator to: (1) verify employment and obtain copies
of wage records, (2) obtain the relevant Tax Information Documents from the
Internal Revenue Service and/or Social Security Administration, and (3) confirm
any bank account information used in support of a claim, but the authorization for
bank records shall be limited to the Claimants chosen Base Year(s). The Claim
Form may be submitted in electronic fashion, including scanning of documents or
copies of verification from public databases providing the same information as
would be provided by the original document.
029221
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 78 of 96
68
I. CATEGORY I: INDIVIDUAL CLAIMANTS WITH TAX INFORMATION OR
PAY PERIOD EARNINGS DOCUMENTATION FOR 2009
Category I is open to all eligible Class Members claiming economic loss arising out of
the harvesting of Seafood where the Claimant was employed by a Commercial
Fisherman in 2009, worked or anticipated to work harvesting Seafood in 2010, and can
provide sufficient documentation as set forth below. Claimant must provide either:
(i) Claimants federal or state Tax Information Documents (Tax Returns or Forms
W-2 and/or 1099) for the selected Base Year(s) or (ii) Pay Period Earnings
Documentation sufficient to establish earnings from the Claiming Job for the selected
Base Year(s). The Claimants compensation shall be calculated as set forth in Section
I.D below and shall be based on the earnings from the Benchmark Period and the
applicable RTP.
A. Documentation Requirements
1. Documentation Establishing Employment Earnings: For each year
included in the selected Base Year(s), Individual Claimants must provide
at least one of the following Tax Information Documents:
Federal tax Form 1040 pages 1 and 2, all pages of Schedules C, E,
and F, and any supporting statements attached to the Form 1040
filing (including Form W-2s for joint returns); or
State tax return, including any supporting schedules or statements;
or
Forms W-2 documenting earnings from the Claiming Job; or
Forms 1099 documenting earnings from the Claiming Job.
AND/OR
For each year included in the selected Base Year(s), Pay-Period Earnings
Documentation sufficient to establish the source(s) and amounts of earnings,
which may include as follows:
Bank records showing income deposits and supporting
documentation indicating the source of those deposits; and/or
Documents from BP/GCCF/Transition Facility showing payment
and the Claimants BP/GCCF/Transition Facility Claim Number;
Receipts or records from check cashing services or payday loan
services and supporting documentation indicating the source of the
funds; and/or
029222
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 79 of 96
69
Other documents provided by an employer setting forth for such
other employment position(s): (i) required hours of work, (ii)
actual hours worked by Claimant, and (iii) compensation rate for
the Claiming Jobs.
2. Additional Claimant Documentation:
a. Claimant Employability Documentation: Consists of both:
i. A copy of a Social Security card, government-issued
identification (for example, a valid drivers license),
temporary worker visa, or green card that was valid as of
April 20, 2010 for the Claimant, or a print out from a public
database providing the same information as would be
provided by the original document;
AND
ii. Evidence the Claimant was at least 16 years of age as of
April 20, 2010. Acceptable evidence includes a copy of a
valid drivers license, a valid passport, a certified copy of
the Claimants birth certificate, or a print out from a public
database providing the same information as would be
provided by the original document.
b. Licensing Documentation: If Claimants employment requires a
government-issued license/permit, a copy of valid 2009 or 2010
licenses (even if it had expired), if appropriate, or a print out from
a public database providing the same information as would be
provided by the original document.
c. Work Availability: A statement and documentation sufficient to
establish that the Claimant was present and available to work in
close enough proximity to the location of employment to travel to
the job as frequently as required by the employer during the period
from April 21, 2010 through December 31, 2010.
i. Documentation that could demonstrate presence and
availability includes, but is not limited to, the following:
(A) Proof of home ownership and address; or
(B) A lease or rental agreement; or
(C) A sublease agreement; or
(D) Contemporaneous utility bills.
02922
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 80 of 96
70
ii. Documentation that could demonstrate location of
employment includes, but is not limited to, the following:
(A) Employers business name and address; or
(B) Jobsite location; or
(C) Docking and port information for a vessel.
3. Seafood Spill-Related Payments:
The Claimant shall provide a Sworn Written Statement attesting whether or not the
Claimant received any Seafood Spill-Related Payments. If the Claimant received
Seafood Spill-Related Payments, the Claimant shall provide documents sufficient to
establish the timing, amount and source of Seafood Spill-Related Payments, including
documents providing the claimants BP/GCCF/Transition Facility Claim Number, if
applicable, and any corresponding payments.
B. Causation Requirements
For Claimants who satisfy the Documentation Requirements, the DWH Spill shall be
presumed to be the cause of the Claimants lost earnings for a Claiming Job.
C. RTP
An RTP of 2.25 shall apply to all Claimants with claims that qualify for compensation
under Category I of this Seafood Crew Compensation Plan.
D. Compensation Calculation
The Claims Administrator shall use Tax Information Documents and/or Pay Period
Earnings Documentation and/or other supporting documentation provided by the
Claimant to calculate the Claimants lost earnings from the Claiming Job. The
Claimants lost earnings shall be calculated as 37% of the average Actual Earnings from
the Claiming Jobs held by the Claimant during the Benchmark Period. The Claimant
shall receive a lump-sum payment of this amount. Claimants who provide documents
sufficient to prove Work Availability as set forth in Section I.A.2.c above will also
receive the applicable RTP.
II. INDIVIDUAL CLAIMANTS WITHOUT TAX INFORMATION OR PAY
PERIOD EARNINGS DOCUMENTATION WHO SUBMIT A CLAIMANT
SWORN WRITTEN STATEMENT AND EMPLOYER SWORN WRITTEN
STATEMENT TO ESTABLISH EARNINGS
Category II is open to all eligible Class Members who anticipated working in the
Seafood Industry in 2010 and can provide sufficient documentation as set forth below,
through two alternative methods. First, any Claimant who does not have sufficient Tax
Information Documents or Pay Period Earnings Documentation for the Claiming
029224
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 81 of 96
71
Job evidencing the Claimants earnings during 2009 may instead establish lost earnings
and causation by submitting, in addition to a Sworn Claim Form, (a) a Claimant Sworn
Written Statement with specified contents (see below), (b) one or more Employer
Sworn Written Statement(s) providing information for 2009, and (c) any other specified
documentation (see below). If the Claimant submits an Employer Sworn Written
Statement from a parent, grandparent, child, grandchild, spouse, brother, sister, aunt,
uncle, niece, nephew, brother-in-law, sister-in-law, step-parent, step-brother, step-sister
or step-child of the Claimant, then the Claimant shall submit an additional Sponsor
Sworn Written Statement from a person not related to the Claimant. The Claimants
compensation shall be calculated as set forth in Section II.D below and shall be based on
the earnings from 2009 in the Benchmark Period and the applicable RTP.
In addition, Claimants who can establish that they were offered and accepted
employment in a Claiming Job prior to April 20, 2010 for the period of April 20, 2010
through December 31, 2010 and that the offer was withdrawn or rescinded in whole or
part after April 20, 2010 may establish lost earnings and causation by submitting, in
addition to a Sworn Claim Form, (a) a Claimant Sworn Written Statement with
specified contents (see below), (b) one or more Employer Sworn Written Statements(s)
providing information related to the job offer, and (c) any other specific documentation
(see below).
All Claimants who seek compensation under Category II shall submit the Sworn Claim
Form and all necessary documents in a final and complete form no later than the Bar
Date. Any claim that is not filed as of the Bar Date shall be rejected, and the Claimant
shall receive no compensation under this Settlement Agreement for the Claimants lost
earnings for the Claiming Job.
The Claims Administrator shall receive and process claims under Category II as
required to allow for Claimant and/or the Claims Administrator to supplement the claim
or acquire any additional necessary information or documentation. However, no
Category II claim shall be paid until after the Bar Date. After the Bar Date, the Claims
Administrator shall process as expeditiously as possible all timely submitted claims as
described in further detail in Section II.C below.
A. Documentation And Causation Requirements:
A Category II claimant must provide a Sworn Claim Form and the documents identified
below. The Claims Administrator shall review and assess the documentation provided
by the Claimant, including information from the Claimants employer(s), and any other
information deemed relevant by the Claims Administrator, for purposes of determining
whether the Claimant had earnings in 2009 from employment as a Seafood First Mate,
Seafood Second Mate, Seafood Boatswain or Seafood Deckhand or whether the
Claimant had a legitimate job offer that was rescinded or withdrawn in whole or in part
for employment as a Seafood First Mate, Seafood Second Mate, Seafood Boatswain
or Seafood Deckhand. The Claims Administrator shall rely on his assessment of the
credibility and reliability of the information submitted in determining if the causation
02922
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 82 of 96
72
requirement is satisfied and the amount of any lost earnings arising out of the harvesting
of Seafood due to the Deepwater Horizon oil spill.
1. Claimant Sworn Written Statement: The Claimant shall submit a
Claimant Sworn Written Statement which sets forth all of the following
information and shall attach any relevant documents in Claimants
possession:
a. The Claimants employment history with each employer,
including, for example, the nature of the work performed, number
of years worked, whether the employment is steady or seasonal,
year-round or intermittent, and the circumstances of the Claimants
departure and/or termination, if applicable. At a minimum, the
Claimant shall include for each of the Claimants employers in
2009, the business name, last known address and telephone
number.
b. The Claimants income from all sources in 2009, and any other
earnings history that the Claimant believes is relevant to support
the claim, including any support for the Claimants belief that
these actual earned amounts are accurate.
c. A statement attesting whether or not the Claimant received any
Seafood Spill-Related Payments. If the Claimant received Spill-
Related Payments, the Claimant shall provide documents sufficient
to establish the timing, amount and source of Seafood Spill-
Related Payments, including documents providing the claimants
BP/GCCF/Transition Facility Claim Number, if applicable, and
any corresponding payments.
d. Work Availability: A statement and documents sufficient to
establish that the Claimant was present and available to work in
close enough proximity to the anticipated location of employment
to travel to the job as frequently as required by the employer
during the period from April 21, 2010 through December 31, 2010.
i. To be potentially eligible for an RTP, the Claimant must
satisfy the above requirement for the period April 21, 2010
through December 31, 2010.
ii. Documentation that could demonstrate presence and
availability includes, but is not limited to, the following:
(A) A lease or rental agreement; or
(B) A sublease agreement; or
(C) Contemporaneous utility bills.
02922
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 83 of 96
73
iii. Documentation that could demonstrate location of
employment includes, but is not limited to, the following:
(A) Employers business name and address; or
(B) Jobsite location; or
(C) Docking and port information for a vessel.
e. If the Claimant is seeking compensation based on a job offer, the
Claimant shall provide proof of an offer of employment made and
accepted prior to April 20, 2010 for employment between April 21
and December 31, 2010. The proof must include information
sufficient to establish proposed start and end dates, wage rates and
projected hours, and withdrawal in whole or part of the offer
during the period April 21 through December 31, 2010.
2. Claimant Employability Documentation:
In order to prove employability, the Claimant should provide both:
a. A copy of a Social Security card, government-issued identification
(for example, a valid drivers license), temporary worker visa, or
green card that was valid as of April 20, 2010, or a print out from a
public database providing the same information as would be
provided by the original document.
AND
b. Evidence that the Claimant was at least 16 years of age as of April
20, 2010. Acceptable evidence includes a valid drivers license, a
valid passport, or a copy of the Claimants birth certificate, or a
print out from a public database providing the same information as
would be provided by the original document.
3. Licensing Documentation: If the Claimants employment in the
Claiming Job requires a government-issued license/permit, the Claimant
shall provide a copy of 2009 license(s) (even if it had expired), or a print
out from a public database providing the same information as would be
provided by the original document.
4. Employer Sworn Written Statement: The Claimant shall submit an
Employer Sworn Written Statement from at least one of the Claimants
employers for 2009, which sets forth the following information with any
relevant documents attached.
029227
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 84 of 96
74
a. Employer Information
i. Employers business name
ii. Address(es)
iii. Telephone number(s)
iv. Website(s), if available
v. A description of the nature of the business
vi. Compensation practices (for example, weekly or bi-weekly
pay periods), wage rates, and typical hours worked for
employees holding jobs comparable to the Claiming Job.
vii. The size and scale of the employers business, such as:
(A) Size of the vessel;
(B) Best estimate of the number of customers;
(C) Best estimate of the volume of product produced
(such as volume of seafood harvested);
(D) Best estimate of the number of full-time and part-
time employees; or,
(E) Financial information
viii. The number of Employer Sworn Written Statements
submitted on behalf of any Seafood Crew Compensation
Plan.
b. Employee Information
i. The Claimants employment history with employer,
including, for example, the nature of the work performed,
number of years worked, whether the employment is steady
or seasonal, year-round or intermittent, and the
circumstances of the Claimants departure and/or
termination, if applicable.
ii. The Claimants wage rate and total compensation for 2009.
If the employer cannot provide precise actual dates and
times, it shall be sufficient for the employer to provide
more general information satisfying this standard for
example, Claimant was employed for 30 days at a rate of
02922
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 85 of 96
75
$100 per day for 12 weeks during the months of June -
August 2009.
iii. If the employer (i) employed the Claimant and/or
(ii) offered the Claimant employment during the period
from April 20, 2010 to December 31, 2010, the employer
shall provide the following:
(A) How the employer (a) terminated the Claimants
employment, (b) reduced the Claimants hours of
work, (c) withdrew an offer of employment, (d) did
not extend an offer of seasonal (partial year)
employment to the Claimant, or (e) otherwise
reduced employees compensation due to or
resulting from the DWH Spill with sufficient detail
to permit the Claims Administrator to calculate
the Claimants lost hours of work and lost earnings
from such employment during such period.
(B) A specific explanation of how (i) the reduction of
Claimants hours of work, or (ii) the withdrawal of,
or (iii) the failure to extend, an offer of employment
was due to or resulting from the DWH Spill.
The number of Employer Sworn Written Statements submitted by an employer on
behalf of the Claimant and any other Claimants shall be monitored by the Claims
Administrator for reasonableness in light of the employers operations. For example, it
would be anticipated that a 45-foot boat would have approximately two full-time
equivalent employees, or that a 75-foot boat would have approximately three full-time
equivalent employees.
5. Sponsor Sworn Written Statement:
If the Claimant submits an Employer Sworn Written Statement from a parent,
grandparent, child, grandchild, spouse, brother, sister, aunt, uncle, niece, nephew,
brother-in-law, sister-in-law, step-parent, step-brother, step-sister or step-child of the
Claimant, the Claimant shall also submit a Sponsor Sworn Written Statement which
sets forth the following information with any relevant documents attached.
a. The sponsors name, address, daytime and evening telephone
numbers, Social Security number or government issued
identification number, and the length of time the sponsor has
resided at their current address.
b. A statement that a true and correct copy of one (or more) of the
following forms of valid identification of the sponsor is attached:
valid drivers license, Social Security card, valid U.S. Passport,
029229
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 86 of 96
76
Green Card, and attached copies, or verification from a public
database that the sponsor has one or more of the listed items.
c. The sponsors relationship to the Claimant, which must be other
than the parent, grandparent, child, grandchild, spouse, brother,
sister, aunt, uncle, niece, nephew, brother-in-law, sister-in-law,
step-parent, step-sister, step-brother or step-child of the Claimant
and the basis for the sponsors personal knowledge of the
Claimants employment.
14
d. A description of the Claimants employment prior to April 20,
2010, if relevant, the Claimants expected employment as a
Seafood First Mate, Seafood Second Mate, Seafood Boatswain,
or Seafood Deckhand thereafter, and the sponsors basis of
knowledge for these facts.
i. An explanation of how the reduction of Claimants hours of
work, termination of the Claimants employment, or
withdrawal of an offer of employment during the period
from April 21, 2010 through December 31, 2010, was due
to or resulting from the DWH Spill and the sponsors basis
of knowledge for these facts.
ii. A representation that the sponsor has not submitted a
Sponsor Sworn Written Statement for more than ten
other claimants.
iii. A representation that the sponsor understands and
acknowledges that the Claims Administrator will rely on
statements in the Sponsor Sworn Written Statement,
which acknowledgement the sponsor verifies under penalty
of perjury is true and correct.
iv. A representation that the sponsor understands that
fraudulent claims and statements will be prosecuted to the
full extent of the law.
B. Interviews
1. The Claims Administrator shall have the right to interview all Claimants,
employer(s) and sponsor(s) as the Claims Administrator deems
appropriate. For example, if an employer submits Employee Sworn
Statements on behalf of more employees than the Claims Administrator
determines could reasonably have been employed in the job by the
14
The standard to be applied is whether or not the Sponsors statement contains facts that would allow the
Sponsor to testify under the Federal Rules of Evidence as being within the Sponsors personal knowledge.
0292 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 87 of 96
77
employer, then the Claims Administrator may determine an interview of
the employer is appropriate. The Claims Administrator shall follow the
Interview Guidelines contained in Exhibit 83 of the Deepwater Horizon
Economic and Property Settlement Agreement (Addendum to Individuals
Framework - Interviews of Claimants Alleging Individual Economic Loss
and Other Individuals Providing Sworn Statements in Support of Such a
Claim).
C. RTP
An RTP of 2.25 shall apply only to Claimants with claims that qualify for compensation
under Category II of this Seafood Compensation Plan and who provide documents
sufficient to prove Work Availability as set forth in Section II.A.1.d above.
D. Description Of Compensation Calculation And Distribution Of Payments
The Claims Administrator shall determine the amount of Claimants lost earnings
relating to employment by a Commercial Fisherman due to or resulting from the
Deepwater Horizon oil spill based on the totality of the information provided by the
Claimant and the Claimants employer(s), including the Sworn Claim Form, the
Claimant Sworn Written Statement, the Employer Sworn Written Statement(s), and,
if applicable, the Sponsor Sworn Written Statement(s), and any other supporting
documentation provided by the Claimant. The Claims Administrator cannot rely solely
on the Claimant Sworn Written Statement for proof of lost earnings.
The Claims Administrator shall receive and process claims under Category II as
required to allow for Claimants and/or the Claims Administrator to supplement the
claim or acquire any additional necessary information or documentation. No Category II
claim shall be paid until after the Bar Date. After the Bar Date for Category II claims,
the Claims Administrator shall determine whether each Claimant who timely submitted
a Category II claim is eligible and qualified to receive compensation.
The Claims Administrator shall determine compensation for Category II Claimants as
follows. For claimants that establish a valid job offer, their lost potential earnings
relating to potential employment by a Commercial Fisherman due to or resulting from
the Deepwater Horizon oil spill shall be calculated as the wages that the Claims
Administrator establishes would have been earned from April 21, 2010 through
December 31, 2010. For example, if the Claimant validly established a qualifying job
offer for 40 hours per week that was revoked, the Claimant could establish lost earnings
of the hourly wage times 40 hours per week times 36 weeks.
For Category II claimants, the Claimants base compensation shall be calculated as:
(i) 37% of the Actual Earnings from the Claiming Jobs held by the Claimant during the
Benchmark Period; or, (ii) as 37% of the Claimants potential earnings for April 20,
2010 through December 31, 2010.
The Claimant shall receive a lump-sum payment equal to the Claimants base
compensation plus any applicable RTP.
0292 1
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 88 of 96
78
No Claimant in Category II shall receive more than $9,500 in base compensation before
application of the RTP. Further, if the total aggregate amount of Category II
compensation claims for all claimants who have timely submitted eligible and qualifying
Category II claims exceeds the Aggregate Compensation Amount for Category II,
then Category II claimants will be subject to a pro rata reduction in compensation. If the
Aggregate Compensation Amount for Category II is not exhausted, then any
remaining amount within the Aggregate Compensation Amount for Category II shall
be distributed as part of the balance described in the General Framework and Overview
of Seafood Compensation Program Distribution Section of the Seafood Compensation
Program.
There are no appeal process rights available under Category II of the Seafood Crew
Compensation Plan. The decision of the Claims Administrator is final and not
appealable.
III. CLAIMANTS WITHOUT TAX INFORMATION OR PAY PERIOD EARNINGS
DOCUMENTATION WHO SUBMIT A CLAIMANT SWORN WRITTEN
STATEMENT, SPONSOR SWORN WRITTEN STATEMENT(S) AND
ATTORNEY SWORN WRITTEN STATEMENT (IF APPLICABLE) TO
ESTABLISH EARNINGS
Any Claimant who does not have Tax Information Documents or Pay Period Earnings
Documentation for the Claiming Job evidencing the Claimants earnings during 2009
may instead establish lost earnings and causation, by submitting in addition to a Sworn
Claim Form: (a) a Claimant Sworn Written Statement with specified contents,
(b) one or more Sponsor Sworn Written Statement(s) and/or one or more Attorney
Sworn Written Statements(s), and (c) any other specified documentation. In addition,
the Claims Administrator may interview the Claimant and/or the sponsor(s) and/or the
attorney(s) if the Claims Administrator determines an interview is appropriate.
All Claimants who seek compensation under Category III shall submit the Sworn Claim
Form and all necessary documents in a final and complete form no later than the Bar
Date. Any claim that is not filed as of the Bar Date shall be rejected, and the Claimant
shall receive no compensation under this Settlement Agreement for the Claimants lost
earnings for the Claiming Job.
The Claims Administrator shall receive and process claims under Category III as
required to allow for Claimants and/or the Claims Administrator to supplement the
claim or acquire any additional necessary information or documentation. However, no
Category III claim shall be paid until after the Bar Date. After the Bar Date, the Claims
Administrator shall process as expeditiously as possible all timely submitted claims as
described in further detail in subsection C below.
There are no appeal process rights available under Category III of the Seafood Crew
Compensation Plan. The decision of the Claims Administrator is final and not
appealable.
0292 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 89 of 96
79
A. Documentation And Causation Requirements:
A Category III claimant must provide a Sworn Claim Form and all of the documents
identified below. The Claims Administrator shall review and assess the documentation
provided by the Claimant, including information from the Claimants sponsor(s) and/or
attorney(s), and any other information deemed relevant by the Claims Administrator,
for purposes of determining whether the Claimant had Actual Earnings in 2009 from
employment as a Seafood First Mate, Seafood Second Mate, Seafood Boatswain or
Seafood Deckhand. The Claims Administrator shall rely on his assessment of the
credibility and reliability of the information submitted in determining if the causation
requirement is satisfied and the amount of any lost earnings relating to employment by a
Commercial Fisherman due to or resulting from the Deepwater Horizon oil spill.
1. Claimant Sworn Written Statement: The Claimant shall submit a
Claimant Sworn Written Statement which sets forth all of the following
information and shall attach any relevant documents in Claimants
possession:
a. Information about each employer for whom a claimant worked at
any time in 2009 and/or 2010, including, for example, the nature of
the work performed, number of years worked, whether the
employment is steady or seasonal, year-round or intermittent, and
the circumstances of the Claimants departure and/or termination,
if applicable. At a minimum, the Claimant shall include the
following:
i. The business name, last known address, and telephone
number of each of Claimants employers for 2009 and/or
2010.
b. The Claimants actual earned income from all sources in 2009 and
2010, and any other earnings history that the Claimant believes is
relevant to support the claim, including any support for the
Claimants belief that these actual earned amounts are accurate.
c. An explanation of how the reduction of Claimants hours of work,
termination of the Claimants employment, and/or withdrawal of
an offer of employment related to the Claiming Job(s) for the
period from April 21 through December 31, 2010 was due to or
resulting from the DWH Spill.
d. The name, address and telephone number of any individual
submitting a Sponsor Sworn Written Statement and the
Claimants relationship to such sponsor and/or the name, address
and telephone number of an attorney submitting an Attorney
Sworn Written Statement.
0292
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 90 of 96
80
e. A Sworn Statement attesting whether or not the Claimant received
any Seafood Spill-Related Payments. If the Claimant received
Seafood Spill-Related Payments, the Claimant shall provide
documents sufficient to establish the timing, amount and source of
Seafood Spill-Related Payments, including documents providing
the claimants BP/GCCF/Transition Facility Claim Number, if
applicable, and any corresponding payments.
f. A statement and documents sufficient to establish that the
Claimant was present and available to work in close enough
proximity to the anticipated location of employment to travel to the
job as frequently as required by the employer during the period
from April 21, 2010 through December 31, 2010.
i. Documentation that could demonstrate presence and
availability includes, but is not limited to, the following:
(A) A lease or rental agreement; or
(B) A sublease agreement; or
(C) Contemporaneous utility bills.
ii. Documentation that could demonstrate the location of
employment or anticipated location of employment
includes, but is not limited to, the following:
(A) Employers business name and address; or
(B) Jobsite location; or
(C) Docking and port information for a vessel.
2. Claimant Employability Documentation:
Consists of both:
a. A copy of a Social Security card, government-issued identification
(for example, a valid drivers license), temporary worker visa, or
green card that was valid as of April 20, 2010, or a print out from a
public database providing the same information as would be
provided by the original document.
AND
b. Evidence that the Claimant was at least 16 years of age as of April
20, 2010. Acceptable evidence includes a valid drivers license, a
valid passport, or a copy of the Claimants birth certificate, or a
0292 4
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 91 of 96
81
print out from a public database providing the same information as
would be provided by the original document.
3. Licensing Documentation: If the Claimants employment in the
Claiming Job requires a government-issued license/permit, the Claimant
shall provide a copy of valid 2009 and/or 2010 licenses (even if it had
expired before that date), or a print out from a public database providing
the same information as would be provided by the original document.
4. Sponsor Sworn Written Statements and/or Attorney Sworn Written
Statement: In addition to the Claimant Sworn Statement, the Claimant
must submit two additional Sworn Written Statements. The Claimant
shall be required to submit an Attorney Sworn Written Statement if an
attorney:
a. submitted or pursued a claim on the Claimants behalf in the OPA
Process, or,
b. submitted or pursued a claim on the Claimants behalf in the
Transition Process, or,
c. submitted or pursued any claim on the Claimants behalf in the
Deepwater Horizon Economic Litigation, such as a Plaintiff
Profile Form or Short Form Joinder, or
d. represents the Claimant for any claims arising from, or related to,
the Deepwater Horizon Incident.
If the attorney for the Claimant has withdrawn his or her representation of
the Claimant, then the Claimant will not be required to submit an
Attorney Sworn Written Statement. In addition to the Attorney Sworn
Written Statement, the Claimant shall also submit a Sponsor Sworn
Written Statement. A sponsor who submits a Sponsor Sworn Written
Statement may not be the parent, grandparent, child, grandchild, spouse,
brother, sister, aunt, uncle, niece, nephew, brother-in-law, sister-in-law,
step-parent, step-brother, step-sister or step-child of the Claimant, unless
such sponsor employed the Claimant at some time during 2009 or 2010.
If the Claimant is not required to submit an Attorney Sworn Written
Statement as set forth above, the Claimant must submit either two
Sponsor Sworn Written Statements (at least one sponsor must be
unrelated to the Claimant) or a Sponsor Sworn Written Statement and
an Attorney Sworn Written Statement.
e. Sponsor Sworn Written Statement: a Sponsor Sworn Written
Statement must include the following information:
0292
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 92 of 96
82
i. The sponsors name, address, daytime and evening
telephone numbers, Social Security number or government
issued identification number, and the length of time the
sponsor has resided at their current address.
ii. A statement that a true and correct copy of one (or more) of
the following forms of valid identification of the sponsor is
attached: valid drivers license, Social Security card, valid
U.S. Passport, Green Card, and attached copies, or
verification from a public database that the sponsor has one
or more of the listed items.
iii. The sponsors relationship to the Claimant, which must be
other than the parent, grandparent, child, grandchild,
spouse, brother, sister, aunt, uncle, , niece, nephew,
brother-in-law, sister-in-law, step-parent, step-sister, step-
brother or step-child of the Claimant unless such person
was the Claimants employer in 2009 or 2010 and the basis
for the sponsors personal knowledge of the Claimants
employment.
15
iv. A description of the Claimants employment prior to
April 20, 2010, and, if relevant, the Claimants expected
employment as a Seafood First Mate, Seafood Second
Mate, Seafood Boatswain, or Seafood Deckhand
thereafter, and the sponsors basis of knowledge for these
facts.
v. An explanation of how the reduction of Claimants hours of
work, termination of the Claimants employment, or
withdrawal of an offer of employment during the period
from April 21, 2010 through December 31, 2010, was due
to or resulting from the DWH Spill and the sponsors basis
of knowledge for these facts.
vi. A representation that the sponsor has not submitted a
Sponsor Sworn Written Statement for more than ten
other claimants.
vii. A representation that the sponsor understands and
acknowledges that the Claims Administrator will rely on
statements in the Sponsor Sworn Written Statement,
which acknowledgement the sponsor verifies under penalty
of perjury is true and correct.
15
The standard to be applied is whether or not the Sponsors statement contains facts that would allow the
Sponsor to testify under the Federal Rules of Evidence as being within the Sponsors personal knowledge.
0292
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 93 of 96
83
viii. A representation that the sponsor understands that
fraudulent claims and statements will be prosecuted to the
full extent of the law.
f. Attorney Sworn Written Statement: an Attorney Sworn
Written Statement must include the following information:
i. The attorneys full name, office address, office telephone
number, and email address.
ii. The attorneys Bar Association membership number.
iii. The attorneys relationship to the Claimant, including a
description of when the attorney began representation of
the Claimant, and the scope of such representation.
iv. A representation that the attorney has made a reasonable
investigation of the Claimants Sworn Claim Form and
Claimant Sworn Written Statement and that the
attorneys findings are, to the best of the Attorneys
knowledge, reasonably consistent with the content of such
Claim Form and Claimant Sworn Written Statement.
Such investigation shall be made by the attorney or a
member of the attorneys staff. If a member of the
attorneys staff makes the investigation, the Attorney
Sworn Written Statement shall identify the staff member.
Furthermore, whether the attorney or a staff member makes
the investigation, the Attorney Sworn Written Statement
shall state with specificity what steps were taken in the
investigation in conducting the investigation.
v. A representation that the attorney understands and
acknowledges that the Claims Administrator will rely on
statements in the Attorney Sworn Written Statement, which
acknowledgement the attorney verifies under penalty of
perjury is true and correct.
B. Interviews
1. The Claims Administrator shall have the right to interview all Claimants
and related sponsor(s) and/or attorney(s) in this Category III if the Claims
Administrator determines an interview is appropriate.
16
The Claims
16
In addition, nothing in this Seafood Crew Compensation Program shall in any way limit the right and
obligation of the Claims Administrator to investigate fully all suspicions of fraudulent conduct by or on behalf
of any claimant, including but not limited to conducting any interviews and obtaining any documents the
Claims Administrator deems necessary.
0292 7
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 94 of 96
84
Administrator shall follow the Interview Guidelines contained in the
Deepwater Horizon Economic and Property Settlement Agreement.
C. Description Of Compensation Calculation And Distribution Of Payments
The Claims Administrator shall determine whether the Claimant is eligible and qualified to
receive compensation for a Category III claim based on the totality of the information provided
by the Claimant, the Claimants sponsor(s), and the Claimants attorney, including the Sworn
Claim Form, the Claimant Sworn Written Statement, the Claimant Employability
Documentation, the Licensing Documentation, the Sponsor Sworn Written Statement
and/or the Attorney Sworn Written Statement, any other supporting documentation provided
by the Claimant, and any additional interviews or information as deemed appropriate by the
Claims Administrator. The Claimant is eligible and qualified to receive compensation for a
Category III claim if the Claims Administrator determines, based upon this information, that
the Claimant had actual earnings from employment as a Seafood First Mate, Seafood Second
Mate, Seafood Boatswain, or Seafood Deckhand during the time period of January 1, 2009
through April 20, 2010.
The Claims Administrator shall receive and process claims under Category III as required to
allow for Claimants and/or the Claims Administrator to supplement the claim or acquire any
additional necessary information or documentation. No Category III claim shall be paid until
after the Bar Date. After the Bar Date for Category III claims, the Claims Administrator shall
determine whether each Claimant who timely submitted a Category III claim is eligible and
qualified to receive compensation. If the Claims Administrator determines that a Claimant is
eligible and qualified to receive compensation for a Category III claim, the Claimant shall
receive a lump-sum payment of $5,000. If the total aggregate amount of Category III
compensation claims for all claimants who have timely submitted eligible and qualifying
Category III claims exceeds the Aggregate Compensation Amount for Category III, then
Category III Claimants will be subject to a pro rata reduction in compensation. If the Aggregate
Compensation Amount for Category III is not exhausted, then any remaining amount within
the Aggregate Compensation Amount for Category III shall be distributed as part of the
balance described in the General Framework and Overview of Seafood Compensation Program
Distribution Section of the Seafood Compensation Program.
0292
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 95 of 96
85
SEAFOOD SPILL-PAYMENT REDUCTION PROCEDURES
If the Claims Administrator determines that the Claimant has received Seafood Spill-Related
Payments, the Claims Administrator shall offset any compensation under the Seafood
Compensation Program by the total of the Seafood Spill-Related Payment amount. If a Claimant
qualifies for compensation under multiple provisions of the Seafood Compensation Program, the
Seafood Spill-Related Payment is only applied once. For example, if a Claimant qualifies to
receive: (i) $275,563 under the Shrimp Reduced Expedited Compensation Program; (ii) $32,000
under the Blue Crab/Other Seafood Compensation Program; and (iii) received $25,000 in
Seafood Spill-Related Payments, his compensation under the Seafood Compensation Program
would be: $282,563 ($275,563 + $32,000 - $25,000).
0292 9
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-22 Filed 04/18/12 Page 96 of 96
11
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 34
Page 1 of 33
Compensation Framework for Coastal Real Property Claims
1. Eligibility Requirements
A. Eligible Claimants shall be comprised of claimants who do not fall within the
exclusions to the Economic Loss and Property Class Definition and who are
owners or lessees of Eligible Parcels satisfying the following criteria:
i. The claimant owned the Eligible Parcel during the time period April 20,
2010 to December 31, 2010; or
ii. The claimant was a lessee of the Eligible Parcel, and the lease provided
for possession of the Eligible Parcel for a period of 60 days or longer
during the time period April 20, 2010 to December 31, 2010 and the lease
was executed prior to April 20, 2010.
i. The Claims Administrator shall determine whether an Eligible
Claimant(s) is/are the owner(s) of an Eligible Parcel.
B. Coastal Real Property Claim Zone shall be defined as the blue shaded portions of
the Coastal Real Property Claim Zone Map attached as Appendix A. (See
Appendix B for a description of the criteria used to establish the Coastal Real
Property Claim Zone.)
C. Eligible Parcels shall be comprised of the following two categories:
i. Parcels located within the Coastal Real Property Claim Zone that have a
County Land Use Designation included on the list attached as Appendix
C. (A parcel is a specific tract of real property defined by a legal
description of boundaries used for taxing purposes.)
ii. Deeded Boat Slips located within the Coastal Real Property Claim
Zone. Deeded Boat Slips shall be defined as boat slips for which the
Eligible Claimant paid real property tax during the time period April 20,
2010 to December 31, 2010.
D. An Eligible Parcel shall be placed into one of four Compensation Categories
1
:
Compensation Category A1 shall consist of Eligible Parcels satisfying the
following two criteria: (i) the presence of oil was reported on the Eligible
Parcel by the Deepwater Horizon Unified Command Shoreline Cleanup
1
Grand Isle, Louisiana and Dauphin Island, Louisiana are included in the Coastal Real
Property Claim Zone and will be placed into a Compensation Category consistent with
Section 1. D.
027 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 34
Page 2 of 33
Assessment Teams (SCAT) or a Pre-Assessment conducted as part of Phase
1 of the Natural Resources Damages Assessment process (NRD Pre-
Assessment) and (ii) the Eligible Parcel includes, or is situated upon, a
shoreline for which no portion of the shoreline has a primary
Environmental Sensitivity Index (ESI) classification of 10A (salt and
brackish (coastal marshes)), 10B (freshwater marshes), 10C (freshwater
swamps) or 10D (scrub-shrub wetlands (includes mangroves)) as
determined by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration
(NOAA)
2
.
Compensation Category A2 shall consist of Eligible Parcels satisfying the
following two criteria: (i) the presence of oil was reported on the Eligible
Parcel by SCAT or an NRD Pre-Assessment and (ii) the Eligible Parcel
includes or is situated upon a shoreline for which some portion of the
shoreline has a primary ESI classification of 10A (salt and brackish (coastal
marshes)), 10B (freshwater marshes), 10C (freshwater swamps) or 10D
(scrub-shrub wetlands (includes mangroves)) as determined by the NOAA.
Compensation Category B1 shall consist of Eligible Parcels satisfying the
following two criteria: (i) no presence of oil was reported on the Eligible
Parcel by SCAT or an NRD Pre-Assessment and (ii) the Eligible Parcel
includes or is situated upon a shoreline for which no portion of the
shoreline has an ESI classification of 10A (salt and brackish (coastal
marshes)), 10B (freshwater marshes), 10C (freshwater swamps) or 10D
(scrub-shrub wetlands (includes mangroves)) as determined by the NOAA.
Compensation Category B2 shall consist of Eligible Parcels satisfying the
following two criteria: (i) no presence of oil was reported on the Eligible
Parcel by SCAT or an NRD Pre-Assessment and (ii) the Eligible Parcel
includes or is situated upon a shoreline for which some portion of the
shoreline has a primary ESI classification of 10A (salt and brackish (coastal
marshes)), 10B (freshwater marshes), 10C (freshwater swamps) or 10D
(scrub-shrub wetlands (includes mangroves)) as determined by the NOAA.
i. An Eligible Parcel shall be classified as having the presence of oil (a criteria
for Compensation Categories A1 and A2) when any SCAT zone within the
parcel has a maximum oiling classification other than no oil observed or (ii) an
NRD Pre-Assessment conducted within the parcel reported the presence of oil on
vegetation and/or sediment.
2
Environmental Sensitivity Index numbers used by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric
Administration can be found at the following website:
http://archive.orr.noaa.gov/gallery_gallery.php?RECORD_KEY%28gallery_index%29=joinphot
ogal_id,gallery_id,photo_id&joinphotogal_id(gallery_index)=86&gallery_id(gallery_index)=4&
photo_id(gallery_index)=35
027 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 34
Page 3 of 33
ii. An Eligible Parcel is determined to have no presence of oil (a criteria for
Compensation Categories B1 and B2) when (i) all SCAT zones within the
parcel have a maximum oiling classification of no oil observed or (ii) no NRD
Pre-Assessment conducted within the parcel reported the presence of oil on
vegetation or sediment.
iii. Administrators Database: The Claims administrator shall maintain a
Geographic Information Systems database (Administrators Database)
containing the results of SCAT, NRD Pre-Assessment, NOAA ESI shoreline
classifications, County Land Use Designations and the official parcel boundaries
for all real property within the Coastal Real Property Claim Zone. The Claims
Administrator shall determine the Compensation Category for each Eligible
Parcel based upon the information in the Administrators Database and
consistent with the criteria in this Section 1. D. Attached is a map classifying each
known Eligible Parcel into a Compensation Category by applying the
information in the Administrators Database as of the settlement date. This map
shall be referred to as the Eligible Parcel Compensation Category Map, and a
copy is attached as Appendix D. Administrators Database shall be periodically
updated through the duration and term of the Settlement Agreement.
Administrators Database is presumed to be the best available evidence,
however, that presumption may be rebutted as outlined in Sections E., F., G. and
H. below. The use of environmental data (including SCAT and NRDA data) as
part of this Compensation Framework shall not constitute an admission or judicial
determination related to the admissibility or interpretation of such data for any
other purpose, and, further, the use of such data shall have no effect on, and shall
be without prejudice to, the use, admissibility and interpretation of such data for
any other purpose, including any claims for natural resource damages.
E. A parcel not located within the Coastal Real Property Claim Zone may be added to
the Coastal Real Property Claim Zone by the Claims Administrator only if the
parcel is documented as oiled pursuant to SCAT or by an official assessment
conducted by Natural Resource Trustees in connection with the DWH Spill. No other
parcels outside the Coastal Real Property Claim Zone shall have the ability to
become an Eligible Parcel.
F. The Administrators Database contains the publicly available parcel boundary data
released by county tax assessors for real property in the Coastal Real Property
Claim Zone. In some instances, publicly available parcel boundary data may be
incomplete or out-of-date. Accordingly, real property located in Coastal Real
Property Claim Zone not identified as a parcel shall nonetheless be classified by the
Claims Administrator as an Eligible Parcel provided the claimant documents the
following:
i. Actual presence of the parcel in the Coastal Real Property Claim Zone.
Documentation of actual presence of parcel in the Coastal Real Property
Claim Zone must consist of an official document provided by the county
027 07
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 34
Page 4 of 33
tax assessor, Clerk of Court, Registrar of Lands or other governmental
lands office or agency such as a 2010 county tax notice or a professional
survey of the parcel.
G. The Administrators Database contains publicly available County Land Use
Designations for parcels within the Coastal Real Property Claim Zone. In some
instances, publicly available County Land Use Designations may be incomplete or
out-of-date. Accordingly, a parcel located within the Coastal Real Property Claim
Zone for which the County Land Use Designation in the Administrators Database
is not listed in Appendix C nonetheless shall be categorized as an Eligible Parcel if
the claimant provides documentation from the county tax assessor, Clerk of Court,
Registrar of Lands or other governmental lands office or agency sufficient to show
that the parcel does in fact have a County Land Use Designation listed in Appendix
C.
H. An Eligible Parcel within the Coastal Real Property Claim Zone may be
reclassified by the Claims Administrator into a different Compensation Category if
one of the following conditions is satisfied:
i. An Eligible Parcel placed in Compensation Category B1 or
Compensation Category B2 pursuant to information in the
Administrators Database shall be reclassified by the Claims
Administrator into Compensation Category A1 or Compensation
Category A2 if the Eligible Claimant provides independent
documentation in the form of a government or academic report, not
commissioned by the Eligible Claimant or Eligible Claimants attorney
or agent, with said independent documentation establishing that the
Eligible Parcel contains the presence of oil released by the DWH Spill
even though no portion of the parcel is classified as oiled pursuant to
SCAT or NRD Pre-Assessment.
ii. An Eligible Parcel on a shoreline with a primary ESI classification of less
than 10 as determined by NOAA and classified into Compensation
Category A1 or Compensation Category B1 shall be reclassified into
Compensation Category A2 or Compensation Category B2 if the
Eligible Claimant provides documentation from NOAA showing that the
Eligible Parcel is on a shoreline with a primary ESI classification of 10A
(salt and brackish (coastal marshes)), 10B (freshwater marshes), 10C
(freshwater swamps) or 10D (scrub-shrub wetlands (includes mangroves)).
iii. The Claims Administrator shall undertake an investigation to determine
whether the information submitted pursuant to this Section satisfies the
criteria for reclassification set out H. i. and H. ii.
2. Compensation for Eligible Parcels
027 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 34
Page 5 of 33
A. An Eligible Claimant must submit a Claim Form
3
, all required supporting
documents and a Verification Statement to receive compensation for Eligible
Parcels. The Claim Form, Document Requirements and Verification Statement
are attached as Appendices E, F and G, respectively.
B. An Eligible Claimant who satisfies the eligibility requirements of Section 1 and
submits a Claim Form, all required supporting documents and a Verification
Statement, shall be entitled to receive the appropriate Coastal Real Property
compensation amount (Coastal Real Property Compensation Amount) for an
Eligible Parcel depending upon the criteria outlined in this section. The particular
Coastal Real Property Compensation Amount shall be calculated as follows using
a specified percentage of the 2010 Applicable Property Tax
4
for the Eligible
Parcel
5
:
i. For an Eligible Parcel in Compensation Category A1 the Coastal
Real Property compensation amount shall be 40% of the 2010
Applicable Property Tax.
ii. For an Eligible Parcel in Compensation Category A2, the
Coastal Real Property Compensation Amount shall be 45% of
the 2010 Applicable Property Tax.
iii. For an Eligible Parcel in Compensation Category B1, the
Coastal Real Property Compensation Amount shall be 30% of
the 2010 Applicable Property Tax.
iv. For an Eligible Parcel in Compensation Category B2, the
Coastal Real Property compensation amount shall be 35% of
the 2010 Applicable Property Tax.
C. For the Coastal Real Property Compensation Amount described in Section 2. B,
2010 Applicable Property Tax shall be defined as an Eligible Parcels 2010
County Appraised Value multiplied by 1.18% (Applicable Real Property Tax
Rate).
D. County Appraised Value shall mean the following for an Eligible Parcel
depending on the state it is located in:
Florida: For an Eligible Parcel located in the Florida counties of
Escambia, Okaloosa, Santa Rosa, Walton, Bay, Gulf, Franklin and
3
The Claim Administrator may prepare the final Claim Form consistent with Appendix E. In no
case shall the final Claim Form omit the substance of any question contained in Appendix E.
4
2010 Applicable Property Tax is defined in Section 2. C.
5
See Appendix H for example calculations of Coastal Real Property Compensation Amounts.
027 09
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 34
Page 6 of 33
Wakulla, County Appraised Value shall mean Just Value as determined
by the respective Florida County tax assessor.
Alabama: For an Eligible Parcel located in Baldwin County, Alabama,
County Appraised Value shall mean True Value as determined by the
Baldwin County tax assessor. For an Eligible Parcel located in Mobile
County, Alabama, County Appraised Value shall mean Market Value, as
determined by the Mobile County tax assessor.
Mississippi: For an Eligible Parcel located in Jackson County Mississippi,
County Appraised Value shall mean TOTALVAL as determined by
Jackson County tax assessor. For an Eligible Parcel located in Harrison
County, Mississippi, the County Appraised Value shall mean Total Value
as determined by the Harrison County tax assessor. For an Eligible Parcel
located in Hancock County, Mississippi the County Appraised Value
shall mean LRTOT as determined by the Hancock County tax assessor.
Louisiana: For an Eligible Parcel located in Grand Isle, Jefferson Parish,
Louisiana, County Appraised Value shall mean Fair Market Value as
determined by the Jefferson Parish tax assessor.
i. If the County Appraised Value is net of a Homestead Exemption, the
amount of such Homestead Exemption shall be added to the County
Appraised Value for purposes of calculating the Coastal Real Property
Compensation Amount.
E. An Eligible Parcel with a County Land Use Designation listed in Appendix I shall
be entitled to the greater of (i) calculation in 2. B. above or (ii) a minimum as detailed
below.
6
i. The minimum Coastal Real Property Compensation Amount shall be
as follows:
a. $1,000 for an Eligible Parcel in Compensation Category A1.
b. $1,100 for an Eligible Parcel in Compensation Category A2.
c. $800 for an Eligible Parcel in Compensation Category B1.
d. $800 for an Eligible Parcel in Compensation Category B2.
ii. An Eligible Parcel for which the County Land Use Designation in the
Administrators Database is not listed in Appendix H, shall nonetheless
6
See Appendix J for an example calculation of a minimum Coastal Real Property
Compensation Amount.
027 10
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 7 of 34
Page 7 of 33
be categorized as an Eligible Parcel for which the County Land Use
Designation is listed in Appendix H, if the claimant provides
documentation from the county tax assessor sufficient to show that the
parcel does in fact have a County Land Use Designation listed in
Appendix H.
F. The Coastal Real Property Compensation Amount shall be allocated as follows:
i. For an Eligible Parcel for which there is only one Eligible Claimant, the
Eligible Claimant shall receive the entire portion of the applicable
Coastal Real Property Compensation Amount.
ii. For an Eligible Parcel for which there are more than one Eligible
Claimants, the Coastal Real Property Compensation Amount shall be
allocated based on the period of legal possession of the particular Eligible
Parcel by each Eligible Claimant between April 20, 2010, and December
31, 2010. The allocation shall be determined by dividing the Coastal Real
Property Compensation Amount by 255 days and then multiplying the
product by the number of days each Eligible Claimant had legal
possession of the Eligible Parcel.
iii. The Claims Administrator shall determine whether an Eligible
Claimant(s) is the owner of an Eligible Parcel
G. An RTP of 2.5 shall be applied to the Coastal Real Property Compensation
Amount. For example, a hypothetical Coastal Real Property Compensation
Amount of $1,859 (refer to Appendix H), would receive an RTP equal to $4,648 for
a total Coastal Real Property Compensation Amount of $6,507 inclusive of RTP.
3. Physical Damage to Real or Personal Property
A. Physical Damage shall be defined as any physical damage that occurred to an
Eligible Claimants real or personal property located on an Eligible Parcel(s) in
connection with the DWH Spill or as a result of the response cleanup operations that
were consistent with the National Contingency Plan or specifically ordered by the
Federal On-Scene Coordinator or delegates thereof, with the exception of any damage
claimed for intrusion of oil, dispersant or other substances onto the Eligible
Claimants Eligible Parcel(s). Damages for claims of intrusion of oil, dispersants or
other substances on an Eligible Parcel are addressed in Section 2. B. above.
i. Examples of Physical Damage includes, for example, physical damage
that occurred to landscaping, a structure, appurtenances, a dock, a
building, a patio, or a deck furniture located on an Eligible Parcel caused
by a vehicle, machinery or equipment in use for DWH Spill response
cleanup operations.
027 11
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 8 of 34
Page 8 of 33
B. An Eligible Claimant must provide the Claims Administrator with satisfactory proof
of all of the following items below in order to qualify to receive compensation for
Physical Damage:
i. The claimant is an Eligible Claimant.
ii. The claimed Physical Damage occurred on an Eligible Parcel.
iii. The Physical Damage occurred between April 20, 2010 and the date the
Economic Injury and Property Claim Settlement Agreement is executed
by the parties.
iv. The condition of the real or personal property prior to the claimed physical
damage.
v. The Eligible Claimant owned the real or personal property for which
Physical Damage is claimed at the time the damage occurred. The
Claims Administrator shall determine whether an Eligible Claimant(s) is
the owner of the real or personal property for which Physical Damage is
claimed at the time the damage occurred.
vi. The Physical Damage was caused by DWH Spill response cleanup
operations.
vii. For an Eligible Claimant claiming to have incurred costs to repair or
replace the damaged property, evidence to establish that the costs were
incurred by the Eligible Claimant and that they were reasonable and
necessary.
viii. For an Eligible Claimant seeking compensation for costs not yet incurred
to repair or replace the damaged property, a cost estimate and proof the
costs are reasonable and necessary.
C. An Eligible Claimant must comply with the Claim Form, Document
Requirements and Verification Statement listed in Appendices E, F and G in order
to qualify to receive compensation for Physical Damage.
D. An Eligible Claimant who claims Physical Damage and satisfies Section 3. A, 3. B
and 3. C above shall receive the lesser of the reasonable and necessary costs to repair
or replace the damaged property.
027 12
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 9 of 34
Page 9 of 33
i. The Claims Administrator shall have the authority to verify the Eligible
Claimants estimate of repair and replacement costs, and to undertake an
investigation to determine the reasonableness of the costs to repair or
replace the damaged property, including obtaining an independent
estimate.
ii. In no event is an Eligible Claimant entitled to receive pursuant to this
Section 3 damages for intrusion of oil, dispersants or other substances onto
the Eligible Claimants Eligible Parcel(s). Compensation for claims of
intrusion of oil, dispersants or other substances on an Eligible Parcel are
addressed in Section 2. B above.
4. Federal and State Regulatory Requirements
A. Nothing in this Compensation Framework for Coastal Real Property Claims shall
alter, expand, or reduce BPs obligations for cleanup, removal, spill response and
remediation of real property under applicable federal, state, or local laws, regulations,
orders, or agreements. Eligible Claimant shall acknowledge that any right to require
any cleanup or remediation of the parcel shall not lie with the claimant, but solely
with governmental authorities, and that the need for any cleanup or remediation, and
the standards by which the need for or sufficiency of such remediation is decided,
shall be determined by governmental regulators of the executive department in
accordance with properly promulgated law, rules, regulations, orders or agreements.
Such governmental regulators alone shall make such determinations, and the Eligible
Claimant shall not employ regulatory proceedings as a means to seek the redress of
claims, which are extinguished pursuant to this Settlement Agreement. It is expressly
agreed that this acknowledgement of continued potential responsibility for
governmental compliance on the part of the BP (and all other parties released) shall
not grant the claimant any personal jurisdiction recourse with respect to the regulatory
obligations of the released parties. In the event proceedings, formal or informal, occur
before governmental authorities, the claimant agrees to cooperate fully with the
released parties in addressing questions or concerns presented by such proceedings;
the Eligible Claimant shall provide full and free access to the Eligible Parcel in
connection therewith, and shall further cooperate with the released parties in
undertaking and proposing by the released parties such remediation that the released
parties deem most appropriate, desirable, and/or cost-effective in meeting regulatory
requirements, irrespective of any personal claims, preferences, rights of use or similar
considerations of the Eligible Claimant, it being understood that such personal
claims and considerations fall within the scope of the claims released by the Eligible
Claimant.
027 1
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 10 of 34
Page 10 of 33
Compensation Framework for Coastal Real Property Claims
Appendix A
Coastal Real Property Claim Zone Map
The Coastal Real Property Claim Zone Map is found in a separate document.
027 14
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 11 of 34
Page 11 of 33
Compensation Framework for Coastal Real Property Claims
Appendix B
Criteria Used to Establish the Coastal Real Property Claim Zone
The following criteria were used to establish the Coastal Real Property Claim Zone.
1. Areas directly intersected by the portions of shoreline assessed by SCAT teams (SCAT
Line), regardless of whether or not the presence of oil was reported on that portion of
the SCAT Line are included in the Coastal Real Property Claim Zone, as depicted
below:
2. Areas not directly intersected by the SCAT Line but touching a portion of the coast on
which the SCAT line is located, regardless of whether or not the presence of oil was
reported on that portion of the SCAT Line, are included in the Coastal Real Property
Claim Zone, as depicted below:
027 1
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 12 of 34
Page 12 of 33
3. Where portions of the SCAT Line showing the presence of oil terminated short of certain
physical boundaries (such as waterways, bridges, or roads), parcels between the
termination of the SCAT line and the particular physical boundary were included in the
Coastal Real Property Claim Zone. An example is depicted below.
027 1
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 13 of 34
Page 13 of 33
Compensation Framework for Coastal Real Property Claims
Appendix C
County Land Use Designations Required for a Parcel to Qualify as an Eligible Parcel
ABRASIVE, ASBESTOS, AND MISCELLANEO
ACREAGE NOT AGRICULTURAL
AGRICULTURAL
AIRPORTS, BUS TERMINALS, MARINE TERMINALS, PIERS, MARINAS
AIRPORTS, TERMINALS, MARINAS
AMUSEMENT-OTHER
APARTMENT (LOW RISE SINGLE BLDG)
APARTMENTS, DUPLEX
AUTO SALES, REPAIR, RENTAL, ETC.
BANK/FINANCIAL INSTITUTION
BARS AND TAVERNS
BOAT DOCKS, MARINAS, AND CAMPING AREA
BOAT HOUSE
BOWLING ALLEYS/SKATING RINKS
BUSINESS SERVICES
CAMPS
CANNING AND PRESERVING OF FRUITS, V
CASINOS
CHURCHES
CLUBS, LODGES, UNION HALLS
CLUBS/LODGES/UNION HALLS, ETC.
COMMERCIAL
COMMERCIAL PARKING
COMMERICAL FORESTRY PRODUCTION
COMMON AREAS
COMMUNITY SHOPPING CENTERS
CONCRETE, GYPSUM, AND PLASTER PRODU
CONDOMINIA
CONDOMINIUM
CONDOMINIUM RES.(HIGH RISE)
CONDOMINIUM RES.(LOW RISE)
CONDOMINIUM, MASTER CARD
CROPLAND (GOOD A1)
CULTURAL/ENTERTAIN/REC.-OTHER
DUPLEX RESIDENCE
ENCLOSED THEATRES/AUDITORIUMS
FARMS(GENERAL)
FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
FISHING ACTIVITIES AND RELATED SERV
027 17
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 14 of 34
Page 14 of 33
FOOD AND KINDRED PRODUCTS - MANUFAC
GENERAL MERCHANDISE
GOLF COURSES, DRIVING RANGES
HARDWARE,PLUMBING,HEATING EQUIP,AND
HIWAY AND STREET RIGHT OF WAY
HOTELS, MOTELS
HOTELS/MOTELS
HOTELS-RESIDENTIAL
HOUSEHOLD UNITS. (VAC)
HUNTING AND FISHING CLUBS
ISLAND
LAKES AND PONDS
LEASEHOLD INTERESTS
MACHINERY,EQUIPMENT AND SUPPLIES-WH
MANUFACTURING HOMES
MARINAS
MARINE REPAIR DOCKS
MASTER CARD
MEATS AND FISH MARKETS-RETAIL
MINITURE GOLF
MISCELLANEOUS RESIDENTIAL
MIXED USE
MOBILE HOME PARKS
MOBILE HOME PARKS OR COURT
MOBILE HOMES
MOBILE HOMES (SINGLE TRAILER)
MOTELS
MOTELS, TOURIST COURTS, ETC.
MULTI-FAMILY
MULTI-FAMILY (10 UNITS OR MORE)
MULTI-FAMILY (UNDER 10 UNITS)
MULTI-FAMILY 1O UNITS OR MORE
MULTI-FAMILY LESS THAN 10 UNITS
MULTI-USE AND MILTI-STORY BUILDING
NIGHTCLUBS, LOUNGES, BARS
NON AGRICULTURAL ACREAGE
NURSING HOMES
OFFICE (LOW RISE)
OFFICE BUILDINGS
OFFICE BUILDINGS - MULTI STORY
OFFICE BUILDINGS - ONE STORY
OFFICES-GENERAL
ONE FAMILY UNIT
027 1
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 15 of 34
Page 15 of 33
OPEN STORAGE/JUNK YARDS, ETC.
ORPHANAGES
OTHER FABRICATED METAL PRODUCTS - M
OTHER FINANCE,INSURANCE AND REAL ES
OTHER FOOD AND KINDRED PRODUCTS - M
OTHER FOOD PROCESSING
OTHER FOOD RETAIL
OTHER FORESTRY ACTIVITIES AND RELAT
OTHER PUBLIC ASSEMBLY
OTHER RETAIL TRADE
PAINTS, VARNISHES, LACQUERS, ENAMEL
PARKING LOTS, MOBILE HOME PARKS
PARKS
PASTURELAND (GOOD B1)
PATIO HOME
POINT CADET DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION
PREFAB. METAL BUILDING (COMM.)
PREFAB. METAL BUILDING (FARM)
PROFESSIONAL SERVICE BUILDINGS
PROFESSIONAL SVCS. BUILDINGS
RECREATIONAL - CLASSIFIED USE
RECREATIONAL (LOW PARTITIONS)
RECREATIONAL ACTIVITIES
RELIGIOUS SERVICES
RENTAL-SERVICES
REPAIR SERVICE SHOPS
REPAIR SERVICES
REPAIR SHOPS (NOT AUTOMOTIVE)
RESIDENTIAL
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANTS
RESTAURANTS(ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES)-RE
RESTAURANTS(CARRY-OUT SERVICE)-RETA
RESTAURANTS(CURB SERVICE)-RETAIL
RESTAURANTS, CAFETERIAS
RESTAURANTS-GENERAL
RETAIL TRADE-AUTOMOTIVE, MARINE CRA
RIGHTS-OF-WAY/STREETS/DITCHES
RIVERS AND LAKES
RIVERS/LAKES/SUBMERGED LANDS
SERVICE STATIONS
SERVICE STATIONS-RETAIL
SERVICES-OTHER
027 19
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 16 of 34
Page 16 of 33
SEWAGE DISPOSAL, SOLID WASTE, BORROW PITS, DRAINAGE RESERVOIRS,
WASTE LAND, MARSH, SAND DUNES, SWAMPS
SEWAGE DISPOSAL/LANDFILLS/MARSH
SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE
SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL
STORE (RETAIL TRADE)
STORES, ONE STORY
TIMBER (AVG)
TIMBER (GOOD)
TIMBER (POOR)
TIMBERLAND
TIMBERLAND (FAIR)
TIMBERLAND (POOR)
TIME SHARING COMPLEX
TOURIST ATTRACTIONS
TOWNHOUSE
TOWNHOUSE - SINGLE FAMILY
TWO FAMILY UNITS
UNDEFINED (DOR USE ONLY)
UNDEVELOPED AND UNUSED LAND
UNDEVELOPED LAND & WATER AREAS
UNION,FRATERNAL,CIVIC SERVICE FACIL
UNKNOWN COMMERCIAL
UNKNOWN LANDUSE
VACANT COMMERCIAL
VACANT FLOOR AREA, COMMERCIAL
VACANT INDUSTRIAL
VACANT IZ LAND (PAVE RD)
VACANT LAND NOT SUITABLE FOR DEVELO
VACANT LAND SUITABLE FOR DEVELOPMEN
VACANT MULTIFAMILY RESIDENTIAL
VACANT RESIDENTIAL
VACANT RESIDENTIAL LOT
VACANT RESIDENTIAL SUBDIVISION
VACANT ST RURAL LAND (NO ROAD)
VACANT ST RURAL LAND (PAVE RD)
VACANT WATERFRONT
VACANT/UNDEVELOPED LAND
WAREHOUSE
WAREHOUSING AND STORAGE
WAREHOUSING, DISTRIBUTION TERMINALS, TRUCKING TERMINALS
WAREHOUSING/TRUCKING TERMINALS
WATERFRONT IMPROVED
027 20
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 17 of 34
Page 17 of 33
027 21
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 18 of 34
Page 18 of 33
Compensation Framework for Coastal Real Property Claims
Appendix D
Eligible Parcel Compensation Category Map
The Eligible Parcel Compensation Category Map is found in a separate document.
027 22
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 19 of 34
Page 19 of 33
Compensation Framework for Coastal Real Property Claims
Appendix E
Coastal Real Property Claim Form
1. Are you claiming you are entitled to compensation for one or more parcels you owned during
the time period April 20, 2010 to December 31, 2010 under the Compensation Framework
for Coastal Real Property Claims?
____ Yes ____ No
2. Are you claiming you are entitled to compensation for one or more parcels you leased during
the time period April 20, 2010 to December 31, 2010 under the Compensation Framework
for Coastal Real Property Claims?
____ Yes ____ No
3. If you answered yes to Question 1 or 2 above, are you also claiming you are entitled to
compensation for physical damage that occurred to your real or personal property located on
your parcel(s) in connection with the DWH Spill response clean-up operations during the
time period April 20, 2010 to December 31, 2010?
____ Yes ____ No
If you answered yes to any of the questions above, (i) answer the questions below, (ii) provide
the documentation required in the Document Requirements form (Appendix F), and (iii)
complete a Coastal Real Property Verification Statement (Appendix G).
4. What is the street address of the parcel(s)?
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
5. What is the tax assessment identification number of the parcel(s)?
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
027 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 20 of 34
Page 20 of 33
6. What is the parcel identification number of the parcel(s)?
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
7. If you owned the parcel(s) and leased it during the time period April 21, 2010 to
December 31, 2010, when did the lease begin?
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
8. If you owned the parcel(s) and leased it during the time period April 21, 2010 to
December 31, 2010, when did the lease end?
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
9. If you were a lessee of the parcel(s) and you leased it during some time period between
April 21, 2010 and December 31, 2010, when did the lease begin?
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
10. If you were a lessee of the parcel(s) and you leased it during some time period between
April 21, 2010 and December 31, 2010, when did the lease end?
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
You must only answer the following questions if you claim you are entitled to compensation for
physical damage that occurred to your real or personal property located on your parcel(s).
027 24
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 21 of 34
Page 21 of 33
11. Identify and describe the real or personal property that you claim was physically damaged in
connection with the DWH Spill response cleanup operations.
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
12. Describe the physical damage that you claim occurred to your real or personal property
located on your parcel(s) in connection with the DWH Spill response clean-up operations.
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
13. Where on your parcel was your real or personal property located when the damage occurred?
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
14. When did the physical damage to your real or personal property occur?
027 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 22 of 34
Page 22 of 33
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
15. Describe in detail what caused the physical damage to your real or personal property.
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
16. If you know, who caused the physical damage to your real or personal property?
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
17. If you know, were the DWH Spill response cleanup operations that you claim caused the
physical damage to your real or personal property consistent with the National Contingency
Plan or specifically ordered by the Federal On-Scene Coordinator or delegates thereof?
____ Yes ____ No _____ I Dont Know
18. Describe the condition of the real or personal property prior to the damage you claim
occurred.
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
19. Did you own the real or personal property that you claim was damaged at the time the
damage occurred?
____ Yes ___ No
027 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 23 of 34
Page 23 of 33
20. Have you already incurred the cost to repair or replace the real or personal property that you
claim was physically damaged?
____ Yes ___ No
21. If your answer to Question 20 is yes, please identify the following:
a. Was the damaged property repaired or replaced?
____________________________________________________________
b. If the damaged property was replaced, state the reasons that the property was replaced
instead of being repaired.
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
c. If the damaged property was replaced, state the name and address of the individual or
business from which the replacement was obtained and the cost you incurred to
replace the property.
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
d. If the damaged property was repaired, state the name and address and telephone
number of the individual or business that did the repairs, the cost you incurred to
repair the property, and identify the repairs that were done.
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
22. If the answer to Question 20 is no, please identify the following:
027 27
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 24 of 34
Page 24 of 33
a. State whether the damaged property can be repaired?
____ Yes ___ No
b. If the damaged property can be repaired, have you obtained a cost estimate to repair
the damaged property?
____ Yes ___ No
c. If you have obtained a cost estimate to repair the damaged property, state the name
address and phone number of the individual or entity that provided the cost estimate,
what repairs are being done and the amount of the cost estimate for the repairs.
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
d. If you claim that the damaged property cannot be repaired, explain the reasons for
your claim.
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
027 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 25 of 34
Page 25 of 33
Compensation Framework for Coastal Real Property Claims
Appendix F
Coastal Real Property Claim Form
Document Requirements
To receive compensation under the Compensation Framework for Coastal Real Property
Claims you must provide copies of the documents described below.
1. Owners of parcel(s) seeking compensation under the Compensation Framework for
Coastal Real Property Claims must provide the following:
a. Official copy of the deed for the parcel for which you are seeking compensation
showing that you are the owner of the parcel.
i. To the extent a state, county, municipality or other governmental agency
agrees to provide the Claims Administrator with access to an official database
sufficient for the Claims Administrator to confirm the claimant owned the
parcel for which they are seeking compensation, the Claims Administrator
need not require from the claimant an official copy of the deed or official copy
of the 2010 property tax assessment notice for the parcel for which they are
seeking compensation. Rather, the Claims Administrator is authorized to
accept from the claimant the street address and tax identification number or
parcel identification number for the parcel for which they are seeking
compensation as sufficient to satisfy this subpart, and the Claims
Administrator will use the database to confirm the claimants valid ownership
during the time period April 20, 2010 to December 31, 2010
b. Official copy of the 2010 property tax assessment notice for the parcel for which you
are seeking compensation.
7
i. To the extent a state, parish, municipality or other governmental agency
agrees to provide the Claims Administrator with access to an official database
sufficient for the Claims Administrator to confirm the claimant owned the
parcel for which they are seeking compensation, the Claims Administrator
need not require from the claimant an official copy of the deed or official copy
of the 2010 property tax assessment notice for the parcel for which they are
seeking compensation. Rather, the Claims Administrator is authorized to
accept from the claimant the street address and tax identification number or
parcel identification number for the parcel for which they are seeking
compensation as sufficient to satisfy this subpart, and the Claims
7
In some counties, issuance of 2010 tax assessment notices may occur prior to April 20, 2010
such that the correct owner of the eligible parcel may not be reflected, (for example if notices
were mailed January 2010 but ownership changed February 2010). In such a case, a claimant
may provide other documentation such as a copy of the real estate closing/settlement statement
from a sale, in order to prove ownership.
027 29
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 26 of 34
Page 26 of 33
Administrator will use the database to confirm the claimants valid ownership
during the time period April 20, 2010 to December 31, 2010
c. If you owned a parcel that you leased for a period of 60 days or longer during the
time period April 20, 2010 and December 31, 2010 and the lease was executed prior
to April 20, 2010, provide copies of the executed lease for any time period during
April 20, 2010 and December 31, 2010.
d. If you believe your parcel should be added to the Coastal Real Property Claim
Zone (see Section 1. E.), documentation showing a parcel contains the presence of oil
pursuant to SCAT or by an official assessment conducted by the Natural Resource
Trustees in connection with the DWH Spill.
e. If your parcel is not identified in the Coastal Real Property Claim Zone and should
be (see Section 1. F. i.), an official document provided by the county tax assessor,
Clerk of Court, Registrar of Lands or other governmental lands office or agency, or a
professional survey of the parcel showing actual presence of the parcel within the
Coastal Real Property Claim Zone.
f. If your parcel has a County Land Use Designation listed in Appendix C but that is not
reflected in the Administrators Database (see Section 1. G.), documentation for the
county tax assessor, Clerk of Court, Registrar of Lands or other governmental lands
office or agency sufficient to show that the parcel does in fact have a County Land
Use Designation listed in Appendix C.
g. If you believe your parcel should be reclassified from Compensation Category B1
or B2 to Compensation Category A1 or A2 (see Section 1. H. i.), independent
documentation in the form of a government or academic report, not commissioned by
the Eligible Claimant or the Eligible Claimants attorney or agent, with said
independent documentation establishing that the Eligible Parcel contains the
presence of oil released by the DWH Spill.
h. If you believe your parcel is on a shoreline with a primary ESI classification of 10A
(salt and brackish (coastal marshes)), 10B (freshwater marshes), 10C (freshwater
swamps) or 10D (scrub-shrub wetlands (includes mangroves)) as determined by the
NOAA, but that is not reflected in the Administrators Database (see Section 1. H.
ii.), documentation from NOAA showing that the Eligible Parcel is on a shoreline
with a primary ESI classification of 10A, 10B, 10C or 10D.
i. If you believe your parcels County Appraised Value is net of a Homestead
Exemption (See Section 2. D. i.), documentation showing the Eligible Parcels
County Appraised Value is net of a Homestead Exemption, and the amount of such
Homestead Exemption.
j. If your parcel has a County Land Use Designation listed in Appendix H but that is not
reflected in the Administrators Database (See Section 2. E. ii.), documentation
027 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 27 of 34
Page 27 of 33
from the county tax assessor, Clerk of Court, Registrar of Lands or other
governmental lands office or agency that the parcel does in fact have a County Land
Use Designation listed in Appendix H.
k. Completed Verification Statement.
2. Lessees of Parcel(s) seeking compensation under the Compensation Framework for
Coastal Real Property Claims must provide the following:
a. Executed lease agreement showing possession of the Eligible Parcel for a period of
60 days or longer during the time period April 20, 2010 and December 31, 2010 and
was executed prior to April 20, 2010.
b. Documents reflecting the lease payment(s) made for any time period during April 20,
2010 and December 31, 2010.
c. If you believe your parcel should be added to the Coastal Real Property Claim
Zone (see Section 1. E.), documentation showing a parcel contains the presence of oil
pursuant to SCAT or by an official assessment conducted by the Natural Resource
Trustees in connection with the DWH Spill.
d. If your parcel is not identified in the Coastal Real Property Claim Zone and should
be (see Section 1. F. i.), an official document provided by the county tax assessor,
Clerk of Court, Registrar of Lands or other governmental lands office or agency, or a
professional survey of the parcel showing actual presence of the parcel within the
Coastal Real Property Claim Zone.
e. If your parcel has a County Land Use Designation listed in Appendix C but that is not
reflected in the Administrators Database (see Section 1. G.), documentation for the
county tax assessor, Clerk of Court, Registrar of Lands or other governmental lands
office or agency sufficient to show that the parcel does in fact have a County Land
Use Designation listed in Appendix C.
f. If you believe your parcel should be reclassified from Compensation Category B1
or B2 to Compensation Category A1 or A2 (see Section 1. H. i.), independent
documentation in the form of a government or academic report, not commissioned by
the Eligible Claimant or the Eligible Claimants attorney or agent, with said
independent documentation establishing that the Eligible Parcel contains the
presence of oil released by the DWH Spill.
g. If you believe your parcel is on a shoreline with a primary ESI classification of 10A
(salt and brackish (coastal marshes)), 10B (freshwater marshes), 10C (freshwater
swamps) or 10D (scrub-shrub wetlands (includes mangroves)) as determined by the
NOAA, but that is not reflected in the Administrators Database (see Section 1. H.
ii.), documentation from NOAA showing that the Eligible Parcel is on a shoreline
with a primary ESI classification of 10A, 10B, 10C or 10D.
027 1
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 28 of 34
Page 28 of 33
h. If you believe your parcels County Appraised Value is net of a Homestead
Exemption (See Section 2. D. i.), documentation showing the Eligible Parcels
County Appraised Value is net of a Homestead Exemption, and the amount of such
Homestead Exemption.
i. If your parcel has a County Land Use Designation listed in Appendix H but that is not
reflected in the Administrators Database (See Section 2. E. ii.), documentation
from the county tax assessor, Clerk of Court, Registrar of Lands or other
governmental lands office or agency that the parcel does in fact have a County Land
Use Designation listed in Appendix H.
j. Completed Verification Statement.
3. Owners or Lessees of parcel(s) seeking compensation for physical damage to real or personal
property pursuant to Section 3. B. of the Compensation Framework for Coastal Real
Property Claims, must provide the Claims Administrator proof of the items below. Proof
may consist of documents, receipts, photographs, videotaped footage, a sworn statement
from the claimant and/or sworn statements from a witness(es).
a. The claimed physical damage to your real or personal property occurred on a parcel
listed in the Claim Form.
b. The physical damage occurred between April 20, 2010 and [date of settlement
agreement].
c. The condition of the real or personal property prior to the claimed physical damage.
d. You owned the real or personal property at the time the physical damage occurred.
e. The physical damage was caused by DWH Spill response cleanup operations.
f. If you claim to have incurred costs to repair or replace the damaged property,
evidence to establish that the costs were incurred by you and that they were
reasonable and necessary.
g. If you are seeking compensation for costs not yet incurred to repair or replace the
damaged property, a cost estimate and proof the costs are reasonable and necessary.
027 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 29 of 34
Page 29 of 33
Compensation Framework for Coastal Real Property Claims
Appendix G
Coastal Real Property Verification Statement
For parcel owners, please check the box that applies:
1. I owned and did not lease my parcel at any time during the period April 20, 2010
to December 31, 2010.
2. I owned and did lease my parcel for more than 60 days during the time period
April 20, 2010 to December 31, 2010.
For parcel owners, if you checked box #2, please provide the name(s) of the lessee(s) and time
period of the lease(s).
Name of Lessee Dates of Lease
1.
2.
3.
4.
For parcel lessees, please check the box if applicable:
1. I leased my parcel for more than 60 days during the time period April 20, 2010
to December 31, 2010.
027
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 30 of 34
Page 30 of 33
For parcel lessees, please provide the name of the owner of the parcel and time period of the
lease.
Name of Owner Dates of Lease
1
2
3
4
I declare and affirm under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States of America that
the foregoing are true and correct.
_______________________________________
Name
________________________________________
Signature
________________________________________
Date
027 4
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 31 of 34
Page 31 of 33
Compensation Framework for Coastal Real Property Claims
Appendix H
Calculation Examples for Coastal Real Property Compensation Amounts
8
8
The final compensation amount shown in this Appendix is exclusive of an RTP of 2.50.
A B C D E F
D = B * C F = D * E
Property
2010 County
Appraised
Value
Applicable
Real
Property Tax
Rate
2010
Applicable
Property
Taxes
Applicable
Percentage for
Compensation
Category A1
Coastal Real
Property
Compensation
Amount
Property A - ESI 2B $350,000 1.18% $4,130 40.0% $1,652
A B C D E F
D = B * C F = D * E
Property
2010 County
Appraised
Value
Applicable
Real
Property Tax
Rate
2010
Applicable
Property
Taxes
Applicable
Percentage for
Compensation
Category A2
Coastal Real
Property
Compensation
Amount
Property B - ESI 10B $350,000 1.18% $4,130 45.0% $1,859
A B C D E F
D = B * C F = D * E
Property
2010 County
Appraised
Value
Applicable
Real
Property Tax
Rate
2010
Applicable
Property
Taxes
Applicable
Percentage for
Compensation
Category B1
Coastal Real
Property
Compensation
Amount
Property C - ESI 6A $350,000 1.18% $4,130 30.0% $1,239
A B C D E F
D = B * C F = D * E
Property
2010 County
Appraised
Value
Applicable
Real
Property Tax
Rate
2010
Applicable
Property
Taxes
Applicable
Percentage for
Compensation
Category B1
Coastal Real
Property
Compensation
Amount
Property D - ESI 10D $350,000 1.18% $4,130 35.0% $1,446
Compensation Category A1
Compensation Category A2
Compensation Category B1
Compensation Category B2
027
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 32 of 34
Page 32 of 33
Compensation Framework for Coastal Real Property Claims
Appendix I
County Land Use Designations Eligible for Minimum Compensation
APARTMENT (LOW RISE SINGLE BLDG)
APARTMENTS, DUPLEX
COMMON AREAS
CONDOMINIA
CONDOMINIUM
CONDOMINIUM RES.(HIGH RISE)
CONDOMINIUM RES.(LOW RISE)
CONDOMINIUM, MASTER CARD
DUPLEX RESIDENCE
MANUFACTURING HOMES
MASTER CARD
MISCELLANEOUS RESIDENTIAL
MOBILE HOMES
MOBILE HOMES (SINGLE TRAILER)
MULTI-FAMILY
MULTI-FAMILY (UNDER 10 UNITS)
MULTI-FAMILY 1O UNITS OR MORE
MULTI-FAMILY LESS THAN 10 UNITS
ONE FAMILY UNIT
PATIO HOME
RESIDENTIAL
SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE
SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL
TOWNHOUSE
TOWNHOUSE - SINGLE FAMILY
TWO FAMILY UNITS
WATERFRONT IMPROVED
MULTI-FAMILY (10 UNITS OR MORE)
027
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 33 of 34
Page 33 of 33
Compensation Framework for Coastal Real Property Claims
Appendix J
Calculations Examples for Minimum Coastal Real Property Compensation Amounts
9
9
The final compensation amount shown in this Appendix is exclusive of an RTP of 2.50.
A B C D E F G H
D = B * C F = D * E
Property
2010 County
Appraised
Value
Applicable
Real
Property Tax
Rate
2010
Applicable
Property
Taxes
Applicable
Percentage for
Compensation
Category A1
Coastal Real
Property
Compensation
Amount
Minimum Coastal
Real Property
Compensation
Amount (A1)
Actual Coastal
Real Property
Compensation
Amount *
Property A - ESI 7 $180,000 1.18% $2,124 40.0% $850 $1,000 $1,000
* The higher between the Coastal Real Property Compensation Amount and the Minimum Coastal Real Property Compensation Amount (A1)
A B C D E F G H
D = B * C F = D * E
Property
2010 County
Appraised
Value
Applicable
Real
Property Tax
Rate
2010
Applicable
Property
Taxes
Applicable
Percentage for
Compensation
Category A2
Coastal Real
Property
Compensation
Amount
Minimum Coastal
Real Property
Compensation
Amount (A2)
Actual Coastal
Real Property
Compensation
Amount *
Property B - ESI 10A $180,000 1.18% $2,124 45.0% $956 $1,100 $1,100
* The higher between the Coastal Real Property Compensation Amount and the Minimum Coastal Real Property Compensation Amount (A2)
A B C D E F G H
D = B * C F = D * E
Property
2010 County
Appraised
Value
Applicable
Real
Property Tax
Rate
2010
Applicable
Property
Taxes
Applicable
Percentage for
Compensation
Category B1
Coastal Real
Property
Compensation
Amount
Minimum Coastal
Real Property
Compensation
Amount (B1)
Actual Coastal
Real Property
Compensation
Amount *
Property C - ESI 3B $180,000 1.18% $2,124 30.0% $637 $800 $800
* The higher between the Coastal Real Property Compensation Amount and the Minimum Coastal Real Property Compensation Amount (B1)
A B C D E F G H
D = B * C F = D * E
Property
2010 County
Appraised
Value
Applicable
Real
Property Tax
Rate
2010
Applicable
Property
Taxes
Applicable
Percentage for
Compensation
Category B1
Coastal Real
Property
Compensation
Amount
Minimum Coastal
Real Property
Compensation
Amount (B2)
Actual Coastal
Real Property
Compensation
Amount *
Property D - ESI 10C $180,000 1.18% $2,124 35.0% $743 $800 $800
* The higher between the Coastal Real Property Compensation Amount and the Minimum Coastal Real Property Compensation Amount (B2)
Compensation Category A2
Compensation Category A1
Compensation Category B2
Compensation Category B1
027 7
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-23 Filed 04/18/12 Page 34 of 34
11
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 69
Appendi xAt oCompensat i onFr amewor kf or
Coast al Real Pr oper t y Cl ai ms: Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai ms:
Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m ZoneM ap
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
1
025288
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 69
Loui si ana,M i ssi ssi ppi ,Al abama,Fl or i da
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
2
02528
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 69
HancockCount y,M S(Ent i r eCount y)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
3
0252 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 69
HancockCount y,M S(Det ai l edPor t i on1)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
4
0252
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 69
HancockCount y,M S(Det ai l edPor t i on2)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
5
0252 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 69
HancockCount y,M S(Det ai l edPor t i on3)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
6
0252
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 7 of 69
Har r i sonCount y,M S(Ent i r eCount y)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
7
0252
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 8 of 69
Har r i sonCount y,M S(Det ai l edPor t i on1)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
8
0252 5
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 9 of 69
Har r i sonCount y,M S(Det ai l edPor t i on2)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
9
0252
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 10 of 69
Har r i sonCount y,M S(Det ai l edPor t i on3)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
10
0252
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 11 of 69
Har r i sonCount y,M S(Det ai l edPor t i on4)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
11
0252 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 12 of 69
Har r i sonCount y,M S(Det ai l edPor t i on5)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
12
0252
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 13 of 69
JacksonCount y,M S(Ent i r eCount y)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
13
025 00
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 14 of 69
JacksonCount y,M S(Det ai l edPor t i on1)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
14
025 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 15 of 69
JacksonCount y,M S(Det ai l edPor t i on2)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
15
025 02
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 16 of 69
JacksonCount y,M S(Det ai l edPor t i on3)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
16
025 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 17 of 69
JacksonCount y,M S(Det ai l edPor t i on4)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
17
025 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 18 of 69
M obi l eCount y,AL(Ent i r eCount y)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
18
025 05
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 19 of 69
M obi l eCount y,AL(Det ai l edPor t i on1)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
19
025 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 20 of 69
M obi l eCount y,AL(Det ai l edPor t i on2)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
20
025 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 21 of 69
M obi l eCount y,AL(Det ai l edPor t i on3)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
21
025 08
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 22 of 69
M obi l eCount y,AL(Det ai l edPor t i on4)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
22
025 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 23 of 69
Bal dw i nCount y,AL(Ent i r eCount y)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
23
025 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 24 of 69
Bal dw i nCount y,AL(Det ai l edPor t i on1)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
24
025
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 25 of 69
Bal dw i nCount y,AL(Det ai l edPor t i on2)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
25
025 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 26 of 69
Escambi aCount y,FL(Ent i r eCount y)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
26
025
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 27 of 69
Escambi aCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on1)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
27
025
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 28 of 69
Escambi aCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on2)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
28
025 5
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 29 of 69
Sant aRosaCount y,FL(Ent i r eCount y)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
29
025
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 30 of 69
Sant aRosaCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on1)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
30
025
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 31 of 69
Sant aRosaCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on2)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
31
025 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 32 of 69
Okal oosaCount y,FL(Ent i r eCount y)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
32
025
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 33 of 69
Okal oosaCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on1)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
33
025 20
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 34 of 69
Okal oosaCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on2)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
34
025 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 35 of 69
Wal t onCount y,FL(Ent i r eCount y)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
35
025 22
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 36 of 69
Wal t onCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on1)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
36
025 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 37 of 69
Wal t onCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on2)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
37
025 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 38 of 69
Wal t onCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on3)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
38
025 25
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 39 of 69
Wal t onCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on4)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
39
025 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 40 of 69
Wal t onCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on5)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
40
025 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 41 of 69
BayCount y,FL(Ent i r eCount y)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
41
025 28
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 42 of 69
BayCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on1)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
42
025 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 43 of 69
BayCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on2)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
43
025 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 44 of 69
BayCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on3)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
44
025
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 45 of 69
BayCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on4)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
45
025 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 46 of 69
BayCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on5)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
46
025
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 47 of 69
BayCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on6)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
47
025
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 48 of 69
Gul f Count y,FL(Ent i r eCount y)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
48
025 5
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 49 of 69
Gul f Count y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on1)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
49
025
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 50 of 69
Gul f Count y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on2)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
50
025
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 51 of 69
Gul f Count y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on3)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
51
025 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 52 of 69
Gul f Count y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on4)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
52
025
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 53 of 69
Fr ankl i nCount y,FL(Ent i r eCount y)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
53
025 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 54 of 69
Fr ankl i nCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on1)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
54
025
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 55 of 69
Fr ankl i nCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on2)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
55
025 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 56 of 69
Fr ankl i nCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on3)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
56
025
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 57 of 69
Fr ankl i nCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on4)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
57
025
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 58 of 69
Fr ankl i nCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on5)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
58
025 5
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 59 of 69
Fr ankl i nCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on6)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
59
025
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 60 of 69
Fr ankl i nCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on7)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
60
025
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 61 of 69
Fr ankl i nCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on8)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
61
025 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 62 of 69
Fr ankl i nCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on9)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
62
025
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 63 of 69
Fr ankl i nCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on10)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
63
025 50
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 64 of 69
Fr ankl i nCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on11)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
64
025 5
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 65 of 69
Wakul l aCount y,FL(Ent i r eCount y)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
65
025 52
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 66 of 69
Wakul l aCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on1)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
66
025 5
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 67 of 69
Wakul l aCount y,FL(Det ai l edPor t i on2)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
67
025 5
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 68 of 69
Gr andIsl e,LA(Ent i r eIsl and)
Appendi xA:Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
68
025 55
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-24 Filed 04/18/12 Page 69 of 69
EXHIBIT 11C
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 144
D Appendi xDt oCompensat i onFr amewor kf or
Coast al Real Pr oper t yCl ai ms:
El i i bl C M El i gi bl ePar cel Compensat i onCat egor yM ap
1
025356
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 7 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 8 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 9 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 10 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 11 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 12 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 13 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 14 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 15 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 16 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 17 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 18 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 19 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 20 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 21 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 22 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 23 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 24 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 25 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 26 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 27 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 28 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 29 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 30 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 31 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 32 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 33 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 34 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 35 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 36 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 37 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 38 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 39 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 40 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 41 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 42 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 43 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 44 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 45 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 46 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 47 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 48 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 49 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 50 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 51 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 52 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 53 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 54 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 55 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 56 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 57 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 58 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 59 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 60 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 61 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 62 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 63 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 64 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 65 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 66 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 67 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 68 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 69 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 70 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 71 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 72 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 73 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 74 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 75 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 76 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 77 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 78 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 79 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 80 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 81 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 82 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 83 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 84 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 85 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 86 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 87 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 88 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 89 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 90 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 91 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 92 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 93 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 94 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 95 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 96 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 97 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 98 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 99 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 100 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 101 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 102 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 103 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 104 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 105 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 106 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 107 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 108 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 109 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 110 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 111 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 112 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 113 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 114 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 115 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 116 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 117 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 118 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 119 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 120 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 121 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 122 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 123 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 124 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 125 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 126 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 127 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 128 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 129 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 130 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 131 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 132 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 133 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 134 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 135 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 136 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 137 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 138 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 139 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 140 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 141 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 142 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 143 of 144
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-25 Filed 04/18/12 Page 144 of 144
2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 32
Page 1 of 31
Compensation Framework for Wetlands Real Property Claims
1. Eligibility Requirements
A. Eligible Claimants shall be comprised of claimants who do not fall within the
exclusions to the Economic Loss and Property Class Definition and who were
owners of Eligible Parcels during the time period April 20, 2010 to [the date of the
Settlement Agreement].
i. The Claims Administrator shall determine whether an Eligible Claimant(s) is the
owner of an Eligible Parcel.
B. Wetlands Real Property Claim Zone shall be defined as the blue shaded portions of
the Wetlands Real Property Compensation Zone Map attached as Appendix A. (See
Appendix B for a description of the criteria used to establish the Wetlands Real
Property Claim Zone).
C. Eligible Parcels shall be defined as parcels located within the Wetlands Real
Property Claim Zone.
D. An Eligible Parcel shall be placed into one of two Compensation Categories:
Compensation Category A shall be defined as those Eligible Parcels that were
documented as containing the presence of oil by one or more of the following:
The published reports of the Deepwater Horizon Unified Command
Shoreline Cleanup Assessment Technique teams (SCAT).
The Pre-assessments conducted as part of Phase 1 of the Natural Resource
Damages Assessment process (NRD Pre-assessment).
The Rapid Assessments conducted as part of Phase 1 of the Natural
Resource Damages Assessment process (NRD Rapid Assessment).
The Coastal Wetland Vegetation Assessment conducted as part of the
Restoration Planning Phase of the Natural Resource Damages Assessment
process (NRD CWVA).
Compensation Category B shall be defined as those Eligible Parcels that were
never documented as containing the presence of oil by any of the following:
SCAT, NRD Pre-assessment, NRD Rapid Assessment, or NRD CWVA.
i. An Eligible Parcel shall be classified as having the presence of oil (criteria for
Compensation Category A) if the parcel meets any of the following conditions:
02 808
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 32
Page 2 of 31
a. Any SCAT Zone
1
within the parcel has a maximum oiling
classification other than no oil observed. A SCAT Zone is an area
within a SCAT Segment which has a boundary defined by the
condition of oil observed during a survey by SCAT assessment teams
in the Louisiana wetlands.
b. Any NRD Pre-assessment conducted within the parcel reported the
presence of oil on vegetation and/or sediment.
c. Any NRD Rapid Assessment conducted within the parcel reported an
Oil Thickness Code of anything other than NA or recorded a Depth
of Penetration greater than zero.
d. Any NRD CWVA conducted within the parcel reported a Vegetation
Oiling Extent Index of greater than zero or a Sediment Surface Oiling
Coverage of greater than zero.
ii. An Eligible Parcel shall be classified as never being documented as containing
the presence of oil (criteria for Compensation Category B) if the following
conditions are met for each assessment conducted within the Eligible Parcel:
a. No SCAT zone within the parcel has a maximum oiling classification
other than no oil observed.
b. No NRD Pre-assessment conducted within the parcel reported the
presence of oil on vegetation and/or sediment.
c. No NRD Rapid Assessment conducted within the parcel reported an
Oil Thickness Code other than NA and reported a Depth of
Penetration greater than zero.
d. No NRD CWVA conducted within the parcel reported a Vegetation
Oiling Extent Index greater than zero or a Sediment Surface Oiling
Coverage greater than zero.
1
For the purposes of calculating the Wetlands Real Property Compensation Amount, the Claims
Administrator will use the SCAT Zones defined by the Maximum Oiling Observed file
published on the Environmental Resource Management Application (ERMA) Gulf Response
website, which was developed jointly by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration
(NOAA) Office of Response and Restoration, the University of New Hampshire, and the U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency. The Maximum Oiling Observed file can be viewed and
downloaded on the ERMA Gulf Response website at http://gomex.erma.noaa.gov/. To access the
file, select SCAT and then select Maximum Oiling Observed.
02 80
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 32
Page 3 of 31
iii. Administrators Database: The Claims Administrator shall maintain a
Geographic Information Systems database (Administrators Database)
containing the results of SCAT, NRD Pre-assessment, NRD Rapid Assessment,
NRD CWVA, and the best available information on parcel boundaries for all real
property within the Wetlands Real Property Claim Zone. The Claims
Administrator shall apply the appropriate Compensation Category for each
Eligible Parcel based upon the information in the Administrators Database and
consistent with the criteria in Section 1. D. Attached as Appendix C is a map
classifying each known Eligible Parcel into a Compensation Category by
applying the information in the Administrators Database as of the settlement
date. This map shall be referred to as the Eligible Parcel Compensation
Category Map. The Administrators Database is presumed to be the best
available evidence, however, that presumption may be rebutted as outlined in
Sections E., F., G. and H. below. The use of environmental data (including SCAT
and NRDA data) as part of this Compensation Framework shall not constitute an
admission or judicial determination related to the admissibility or interpretation of
such data for any other purpose, and, further, the use of such data shall have no
effect on, and shall be without prejudice to, the use, admissibility and
interpretation of such data for any other purpose, including any claims for natural
resource damages.
E. A parcel not located within the Wetlands Real Property Claim Zone may be added to
the Wetlands Real Property Claim Zone by the Claims Administrator only if the
parcel is documented as containing the presence of oil pursuant to SCAT or an official
assessment conducted by the Natural Resource Trustees in connection with the DWH
Spill. Only parcels located in the following geographic area (Area of Potential
Eligibility) are eligible to provide such documentation:
i. As far west as the Louisiana/Texas state line
ii. As far east as the Louisiana/Mississippi state line
iii. As far south as the end of Louisiana state waters
iv. As far north as one half mile inland from the Wetlands Real Property Claim
Zone (refer to Appendix D for the Area of Potential Eligibility Map)
2
F. The Administrators Database contains the best available parcel boundary data for
real property in the Wetlands Real Property Claim Zone. In some instances, this data
may be incomplete or out of date. Accordingly, real property located in the Wetlands
Real Property Claim Zone not identified as a parcel shall nonetheless be classified by
2
This map shows the boundaries within which parcel owners are eligible to submit additional
documentation to become Eligible Parcels.
02 8 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 32
Page 4 of 31
the Claims Administrator as an Eligible Parcel provided the claimant documents the
following:
i. Actual presence of the parcel in the Wetlands Real Property Claim Zone.
Documentation of actual presence of a parcel in the Wetlands Real Property
Claim Zone must consist of an official document provided by the parish tax
assessor (such as a 2010 parish tax notice), Clerk of Court, Registrar of Lands, or
other governmental lands office or agency, or a professional survey of the parcel.
G. The Administrators Database contains the best available parcel boundary data for
real property in the Wetlands Real Property Claim Zone. In some instances, the
named owner(s) of a parcel may be inaccurate or out-of-date. Accordingly, a claimant
not listed in the Administrators Database will be treated as an Eligible Claimant if
the claimant provides the following to demonstrate Eligible Claimants ownership of
an Eligible Parcel:
i. An official copy of the deed for the Eligible Parcel.
AND
ii. The 2010 property tax assessment notice for the eligible parcel or an official
document from the Clerk of Court, Registrar of Lands or other governmental land
office or agency showing proving ownership of the Eligible Parcel during the
time period April 20, 2010 to [the date of the Settlement Agreement].
3
iii. To the extent a state, parish, municipality or other governmental agency agrees to
provide the Claims Administrator with access to an official database sufficient for
the Claims Administrator to confirm the claimant owned the parcel for which they
are seeking compensation, the Claims Administrator need not require from the
Eligible Claimant an official copy of the deed or official copy of the 2010
property tax assessment notice for the parcel for which they are seeking
compensation. Rather, the Claims Administrator is authorized to accept from the
claimant the street address and tax identification number or parcel identification
number for the Eligible Parcel for which they are seeking compensation as
sufficient to satisfy this subpart, and the Claims Administrator will use the
database to confirm the claimants valid ownership during the time period April
20, 2010 to [the date of the Settlement Agreement].
3
In some counties, issuance of 2010 tax assessment notices may occur prior to April 20, 2010
such that the correct owner of the eligible parcel may not be reflected, (for example if notices
were mailed January 2010 but ownership changed February 2010). In such a case, a claimant
may provide other documentation such as a copy of the real estate closing/settlement statement
from a sale, in order to prove ownership.
02 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 32
Page 5 of 31
H. An Eligible Parcel within the Wetlands Real Property Claim Zone may be
reclassified by the Claims Administrator into a different Compensation Category if
the following condition is satisfied:
i. An Eligible Parcel within the Wetlands Real Property Claim Zone shall be
reclassified by the Claims Administrator from Compensation Category B to
Compensation Category A if the Eligible Claimant provides independent
documentation in the form of a government or academic publication or map, not
commissioned by the Eligible Claimant or the Eligible Claimants attorney or
agent, with said independent documentation establishing that a portion of the
Eligible Parcel contained the presence of oil although no portion of the Eligible
Parcel is classified as containing the presence of oil pursuant to the published
reports of SCAT, NRD Pre-Assessment, NRD Rapid Assessment or NRD
CWVA.
ii. The Claims Administrator shall undertake an investigation to determine whether
the information submitted pursuant to this Section satisfies the criteria for
reclassification set out H. i. and H. ii.
2. Compensation for Wetlands Real Property
A. An Eligible Claimant must submit a Claim Form
4
, all required supporting documents
and a Verification Statement to receive compensation for an Eligible Parcel. The
Claim Form, Document Requirements and Verification Statement are attached as
Appendices E, F and G.
B. An Eligible Claimant who submits a Claim Form, all required supporting documents,
and a Verification Statement, shall be entitled to receive the appropriate Wetlands Real
Property Compensation amount (Wetlands Real Property Compensation Amount)
based upon the criteria outlined in this section.
C. The Wetlands Real Property Compensation Amount shall be calculated as explained
below. See Appendix H for an example calculation of Wetlands Real Property
Compensation Amount on a hypothetical parcel in Compensation Category A.
i. An Eligible Parcel in Compensation Category A shall be compensated for
an Oiled Primary Area, a Non-Oiled Primary Area, and a Buffer Area.
ii. An Eligible Parcel in Compensation Category B shall be compensated for a
Non-Oiled Primary Area only.
4
The Claims Administrator may prepare the final Claim Form consistent with Appendix E. In
no case shall the final Claim Form omit the substance of any question contained in Appendix E.
02 8 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 32
Page 6 of 31
iii. Oiled Primary Area shall be defined as an area 50 feet immediately inland
from the following:
a. The SCAT Zone(s) documented as containing the presence of oil within
an Eligible Parcel that is located on the portion of the shoreline assessed
by SCAT teams (SCAT Line).
b. The SCAT Zone nearest to the location of any NRD Pre-assessment,
NRD Rapid Assessment, or NRD CWVA which reported the presence of
oil within an Eligible Parcel if no SCAT Zone also within the parcel
reported the presence of oil.
iv. Buffer Area shall be defined as an area 30 feet immediately inland from the
entire length of the Oiled Primary Area.
v. Non-Oiled Primary Area shall be defined as an area 30 feet immediately
inland from SCAT Zone(s) documented as not containing the presence of oil
within an Eligible Parcel.
vi. Eligible Parcels in Compensation Category A shall be paid a Wetlands
Real Property Compensation Amount calculated as follows:
a. The Oiled Primary Area shall be compensated at $25,000 per acre
(Oiled Rate).
b. The Buffer Area shall be compensated at $10,000 per acre (Buffer
Rate).
c. The Non-Oiled Primary Area shall be compensated at $11,000 per acre
(Non-Oiled Rate).
vii. Eligible Parcels in Compensation Category B shall be paid a Wetlands
Real Property Compensation Amount calculated as follows:
a. The Non-Oiled Primary Area shall be compensated at $4,500 per acre
(Non-Oiled Rate B). See Appendix I for an example calculation of
Wetlands Real Property Compensation Amount on a hypothetical
parcel in Compensation Category B.
viii. Appendix J provides examples of the calculation of the Wetlands Real
Property Compensation Amount.
ix. Eligible Parcels shall be entitled to the minimum payments as outlined below.
Appendix K provides an example of the calculation for a minimum Wetlands
Real Property Compensation Amount.
02 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 7 of 32
Page 7 of 31
a.Parcels in Compensation Category A shall be compensated for a
minimum of one acre of Oiled Primary Area and a minimum of one
acre of Buffer Area, equal to a total of $35,000.
b. Parcels in Compensation Category B shall be entitled to
compensation for a minimum of one acre of Non-Oiled Primary
Area, equal to $4,500.
D. An RTP of 2.5 shall be applied to the Wetlands Real Property Compensation Amount.
For example, a hypothetical Wetlands Real Property Compensation Amount of
$38,788 (refer to Appendix K), would receive an RTP equal to $96,970 for a total
Wetlands Real Property Compensation Amount of $135,758 inclusive of RTP.
E. The Wetlands Real Property Compensation Amount shall be allocated as follows:
i. For an Eligible Parcel for which there is only one Eligible Claimant, the
Eligible Claimant shall receive the entire portion of the Wetlands Real
Property Compensation Amount.
ii. For an Eligible Parcel for which there is more than one Eligible Claimant, the
Wetlands Real Property Compensation Amount shall be allocated based on the
period of legal possession of the particular Eligible Parcel by each Eligible
Claimant between April 20, 2010, and [the date of the Settlement Agreement].
The allocation shall be determined by dividing the Wetlands Real Property
Compensation Amount by the number of days between April 20, 2010 and [the
date of the Settlement Agreement] and then multiplying the result by the number
of days each Eligible Claimant had legal possession of the Eligible Parcel.
iii. The Claims Administrator shall determine whether an Eligible Claimant(s) is the
owner of an Eligible Parcel
3. Physical Damage to Real or Personal Property
A. Physical Damage shall be defined as any physical damage that occurred to an Eligible
Claimants real or personal property located on an Eligible Parcel(s) in connection with
the DWH Spill response cleanup operations that were consistent with the National
Contingency Plan or specifically ordered by the Federal On-Scene Coordinator or
delegates thereof, with the exception of any damage claimed for intrusion of oil,
dispersant or other substances onto the Eligible Claimants Eligible Parcel(s). Damages
for claims of intrusion of oil, dispersants or other substances on an Eligible Parcel are
addressed in Section 2. B. above.
02 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 8 of 32
Page 8 of 31
i. Some examples of Physical Damage include but are not limited to Physical
Damage that occurred to a dock, a building, a structure, appurtenances, a patio, or
a deck located on an Eligible Parcel caused by a vehicle, machinery or equipment
in use for DWH Spill response cleanup operations.
B. An Eligible Claimant must provide the Claims Administrator with satisfactory proof of
all of the following items below in order to qualify to receive compensation for Physical
Damage:
i. The claimant is an Eligible Claimant.
ii. The claimed Physical Damage occurred on an Eligible Parcel.
iii. The Physical Damage occurred between April 20, 2010 and the date the
Economic Injury and Property Claim Settlement Agreement is executed by the
parties.
iv. The condition of the real or personal property prior to the claimed physical
damage.
v. The Eligible Claimant owned the real or personal property for which Physical
Damaged is claimed at the time the damage occurred. The Claims Administrator
shall determine whether an Eligible Claimant(s) is the owner of the personal
property.
vi. The Physical Damage was caused by DWH Spill response cleanup operations.
vii. For an Eligible Claimant claiming to have incurred costs to repair or replace the
damaged property, evidence to establish that the costs were incurred by the
Eligible Claimant and that they were reasonable and necessary.
viii. For an Eligible Claimant seeking compensation for costs not yet incurred to
repair or replace the damaged property, a cost estimate and proof the costs are
reasonable and necessary.
C. An Eligible Claimant must comply with the Claim Form, Document Requirements
and Verification Statement listed in Appendices E, F and G in order to qualify to
receive compensation for Physical Damage.
02 8 5
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 9 of 32
Page 9 of 31
D. An Eligible Claimant who claims Physical Damage and satisfies Section 3. A, 3. B and
3. C above shall receive the lesser of the reasonable and necessary costs to repair or
replace the damaged property.
i. The Claims Administrator shall have the authority to verify the Eligible
Claimants estimate of repair and replacement costs, and to undertake an
investigation to determine the reasonableness of the costs to repair or replace the
damaged property, including obtaining an independent estimate.
ii. In no event is an Eligible Claimant entitled to receive pursuant to this Section 3
damages for intrusion of oil, dispersants or other substances onto the Eligible
Claimants Eligible Parcel(s). Compensation for claims of intrusion of oil,
dispersants or other substances on an Eligible Parcel are addressed in Section 2.
B above.
4. Federal and State Regulatory Requirements
A. Nothing in this Compensation Framework for Coastal Real Property Claims shall
alter, expand, or reduce BPs obligations for cleanup, removal, spill response and
remediation of real property under applicable federal, state, or local laws, regulations,
orders, or agreements. Eligible Claimant shall acknowledge that any right to require any
cleanup or remediation of the parcel shall not lie with the claimant, but solely with
governmental authorities, and that the need for any cleanup or remediation, and the
standards by which the need for or sufficiency of such remediation is decided, shall be
determined by governmental regulators of the executive department in accordance with
properly promulgated law, rules, regulations, orders or agreements. Such governmental
regulators alone shall make such determinations, and the Eligible Claimant shall not
employ regulatory proceedings as a means to seek the redress of claims, which are
extinguished pursuant to this Settlement Agreement. It is expressly agreed that this
acknowledgement of continued potential responsibility for governmental compliance on
the part of the BP (and all other parties released) shall not grant the claimant any personal
jurisdiction recourse with respect to the regulatory obligations of the released parties. In
the event proceedings, formal or informal, occur before governmental authorities, the
claimant agrees to cooperate fully with the released parties in addressing questions or
concerns presented by such proceedings; the Eligible Claimant shall provide full and
free access to the Eligible Parcel in connection therewith, and shall further cooperate
with the released parties in undertaking and proposing by the released parties such
remediation that the released parties deem most appropriate, desirable, and/or cost-
effective in meeting regulatory requirements, irrespective of any personal claims,
02 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 10 of 32
Page 10 of 31
preferences, rights of use or similar considerations of the Eligible Claimant, it being
understood that such personal claims and considerations fall within the scope of the
claims released by the Eligible Claimant.
02 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 11 of 32
Page 11 of 31
Compensation Framework for Wetlands Real Property Claims
Appendix A
Wetlands Real Property Compensation Zone Map
The Wetlands Real Property Compensation Zone Map is found in a separate document.
02 8 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 12 of 32
Page 12 of 31
Compensation Framework for Wetlands Real Property Claims
Appendix B
Criteria Used to Establish the Wetlands Real Property Claim Zone
The following criteria were used to establish the Wetlands Real Property Claim Zone:
1. Areas directly intersected by the SCAT Line, regardless of whether or not the presence of oil
was reported on that portion of the SCAT Line, depicted below:
2. Parcels in which an NRD Pre-assessment, NRD Rapid Assessment, and/or NRD CWVA
reported the presence of oil, depicted below:
02 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 13 of 32
Page 13 of 31
3. Where there is a break in an otherwise continuous portion of a SCAT Line, BP and the PSC
jointly selected parcels that would have likely been intersected by the SCAT Line if it had
been continuous.
The zone geography is based on Tobin Digital Ownership maps published by P2 Energy
Solutions in Cameron, Calcasieu, Iberia, St. Mary, Iberia, Lafourche, Jefferson, Plaquemines,
and St. Bernard Parishes. In Terrebonne Parish, the zone geography is based on parcel
boundaries published by the Terrebonne Parish Tax Assessor.
02 820
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 14 of 32
Page 14 of 31
Compensation Framework for Wetlands Real Property Claims
Appendix C
Eligible Parcel Compensation Category Map
The Eligible Parcel Compensation Category Map is found in a separate document.
02 82
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 15 of 32
Page 15 of 31
Compensation Framework for Wetlands Real Property Claims
Appendix D
Area of Potential Eligibility Map
The Area of Potential Eligibility Map is located in a separate document.
02 822
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 16 of 32
Page 16 of 31
Compensation Framework for Wetlands Real Property Claims
Appendix E
Wetlands Real Property Claim Form
1. Are you claiming you are entitled to compensation for one or more parcels you owned during
the time period April 20, 2010 to [the date of the Settlement Agreement] under the
Compensation Framework for Wetlands Real Property Claims?
____ Yes ____ No
2. If you answered yes to Question 1, are you also claiming you are entitled to compensation for
physical damage that occurred to your real or personal property located on your parcel(s) in
connection with the DWH Spill response clean-up operations during the time period April
20, 2010 to [the date of the Settlement Agreement]?
____ Yes ____ No
If you answered yes to any of the questions above, (i) answer the questions below, (ii) provide
the documentation required in the Document Requirements form (Appendix F), and (iii)
complete a Wetlands Real Property Verification Statement (Appendix G).
3. What is the street address of the parcel(s)?
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
02 82
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 17 of 32
Page 17 of 31
4. What is the tax assessment identification number of the parcel(s)?
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
5. What is the parcel identification number of the parcel(s)?
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
You must only answer the following questions if you claim you are entitled to compensation for
physical damage that occurred to your real or personal property located on your parcel(s).
6. Identify and describe the real or personal property that you claim was physically damaged in
connection with the DWH Spill response cleanup operations.
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
02 82
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 18 of 32
Page 18 of 31
7. Describe the physical damage that you claim occurred to your real or personal property
located on your parcel(s) in connection with the DWH Spill response clean-up operations.
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
8. Where on your parcel was your real or personal property located when the damage occurred?
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
9. When did the physical damage to your real or personal property occur?
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
02 825
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 19 of 32
Page 19 of 31
10. Describe in detail what caused the physical damage to your real or personal property.
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
11. If you know, were the DWH Spill response cleanup operations that you claim caused the
physical damage to your real or personal property consistent with the National Contingency
Plan or specifically ordered by the Federal On-Scene Coordinator or delegates thereof?
____ Yes ____ No _____ I Dont Know
12. If you know, who caused the physical damage to your real or personal property?
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
13. Describe the condition of the real or personal property prior to the damage you claim
occurred.
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
02 82
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 20 of 32
Page 20 of 31
14. Did you own the real or personal property that you claim was damaged at the time the
damage occurred?
____ Yes ___ No
15. Have you already incurred the cost to repair or replace the real or personal property that you
claim was physically damaged?
____ Yes ___ No
16. If your answer to Question 15 is yes, please identify the following:
a. Was the damaged property repaired or replaced?
_____________________________________________________________________
b. If the damaged property was replaced, state the reasons that the property was replaced
instead of being repaired.
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
c. If the damaged property was replaced, state the name and address of the individual or
business from which the replacement was obtained and the cost you incurred to
replace the property.
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
02 82
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 21 of 32
Page 21 of 31
d. If the damaged property was repaired, state the name and address and telephone
number of the individual or business that did the repairs, the cost you incurred to
repair the property, and identify the repairs that were done.
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
17. If the answer to Question 15 is no, please identify the following:
a. State whether the damaged property can be repaired:
____ Yes ___ No
b. If the damaged property can be repaired, have you obtained a cost estimate to repair
the damaged property?
____ Yes ___ No
c. If you have obtained a cost estimate to repair the damaged property, state the name
address and phone number of the individual or entity that provided the cost estimate,
what repairs are being done and the amount of the cost estimate for the repairs.
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
02 828
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 22 of 32
Page 22 of 31
d. If you claim that the damaged property cannot be repaired, explain the reasons for
your claim.
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
02 82
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 23 of 32
Page 23 of 31
Compensation Framework for Wetlands Real Property Claims
Appendix F
Wetlands Real Property Claim Form
Document Requirements
To receive compensation under the Compensation Framework for Wetlands Real Property
Claims you must provide copies of the documents described below.
1. Owners of parcel(s) seeking compensation under the Compensation Framework for
Wetlands Real Property Claims must provide the following:
a. Official copy of the deed for the parcel for which you are seeking compensation.
i. To the extent a state, parish, municipality or other governmental agency
agrees to provide the Claims Administrator with access to an official database
sufficient for the Claims Administrator to confirm the claimant owned the
parcel for which they are seeking compensation, the Claims Administrator
need not require from the Eligible Claimant an official copy of the deed or
official copy of the 2010 property tax assessment notice for the parcel for
which they are seeking compensation. Rather, the Claims Administrator is
authorized to accept from the claimant the street address and tax identification
number or parcel identification number for the Eligible Parcel for which they
are seeking compensation as sufficient to satisfy this subpart, and the Claims
Administrator will use the database to confirm the claimants valid ownership
during the time period April 20, 2010 to [the date of the Settlement
Agreement].
b. Official copy of the 2010 property tax assessment notice.
5
i. To the extent a state, parish, municipality or other governmental agency
agrees to provide the Claims Administrator with access to an official database
sufficient for the Claims Administrator to confirm the claimant owned the
parcel for which they are seeking compensation, the Claims Administrator
need not require from the Eligible Claimant an official copy of the deed or
official copy of the 2010 property tax assessment notice for the parcel for
which they are seeking compensation. Rather, the Claims Administrator is
5
In some counties, issuance of 2010 tax assessment notices may occur prior to April 20, 2010
such that the correct owner of the eligible parcel may not be reflected, (for example if notices
were mailed January 2010 but ownership changed February 2010). In such a case, a claimant
may provide other documentation such as a copy of the real estate closing/settlement statement
from a sale, in order to prove ownership.
02 8 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 24 of 32
Page 24 of 31
authorized to accept from the claimant the street address and tax identification
number or parcel identification number for the Eligible Parcel for which they
are seeking compensation as sufficient to satisfy this subpart, and the Claims
Administrator will use the database to confirm the claimants valid ownership
during the time period April 20, 2010 to [the date of the Settlement
Agreement].
c. If you believe your parcel should be added to the Wetlands Real Property Claim
Zone (see Section 1. E.), documentation showing a parcel contains the presence of oil
pursuant to SCAT or by an official assessment conducted by the Natural Resource
Trustees in connection with the DWH Spill.
d. If your parcel is not identified in the Wetlands Real Property Claim Zone and
should be (see Section 1. F. i.), an official document provided by the county tax
assessor, Clerk of Court, Registrar of Lands or other governmental lands office or
agency, or a professional survey of the parcel showing actual presence of the parcel
within the Wetlands Real Property Claim Zone.
e. If you believe the Administrators Database does not list you as the owner of a
parcel in the Wetlands Real Property Claim Zone that you own (see Section 1. G. i.
- ii.), an official copy of the deed and the 2010 property tax assessment notice for the
parcel.
f. If you believe your parcel should be reclassified from Compensation Category B to
Compensation Category A (see Section 1. H. i.), independent documentation in the
form of a government or academic report, not commissioned by the Eligible
Claimant or the Eligible Claimants attorney or agent, with said independent
documentation establishing that the Eligible Parcel contains the presence of oil
released by the DWH Spill.
g. Completed Verification Statement.
2. Owners of parcel(s) seeking compensation for physical damage to real or personal property
pursuant to Section 3. B. of the Compensation Framework for Coastal Real Property
Claims, must provide the Claims Administrator proof of the items below. Proof may consist
of documents, receipts, photographs, videotaped footage, a sworn statement from the
claimant and sworn statements from a witness(es).
a. The claimed physical damage to your real or personal property occurred on a parcel
listed in the Claim Form.
b. The physical damage occurred between April 20, 2010 and [date of settlement
agreement].
02 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 25 of 32
Page 25 of 31
c. The condition of the real or personal property prior to the claimed physical damage.
d. You owned the real or personal property at the time the physical damage occurred.
e. The physical damage was caused by DWH Spill response cleanup operations.
f. If you claim to have incurred costs to repair or replace the damaged property,
evidence to establish that the costs were incurred by you and that they were
reasonable and necessary.
g. If you are seeking compensation for costs not yet incurred to repair or replace the
damaged property, a cost estimate and proof the costs are reasonable and necessary.
02 8 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 26 of 32
Page 26 of 31
Compensation Framework for Wetlands Real Property Claims
Appendix G
Wetlands Real Property Verification Statement
I, _________________________________, owned my parcel during the period April 20, 2010 to
[the date of the Settlement Agreement].
I declare and affirm under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States of America that
the foregoing is true and correct.
________________________________________
Signature
________________________________________
Date
02 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 27 of 32
Page 27 of 31
Compensation Framework for Wetlands Real Property Claims
Appendix H
Example of Wetlands Real Property Compensation Amount
6
on Hypothetical Parcel In
Compensation Category A
6
The final compensation amount shown in this Appendix is exclusive of an RTP of 2.50.
SCAT Line
D
e
p
t
h
(
f
t
)
30
50
80
0
100
Oiled Primary Area
50 ft depth from SCAT Line
Oiled Rate:
$25,000 / acre of Primary Area
Oiled Primary Area Buffer
30 ft depth inland of the entire
length of the Oiled Primary
Area
Buffer Rate:
$10,000 / acre of Primary Area
Non-Oiled Primary Area
30 ft depth from SCAT Line
Non-Oiled Rate:
$11,000 / acre of Primary Area
Parcel Boundary Oiled SCAT Zone Non-Oiled SCAT Zone
02 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 28 of 32
Page 28 of 31
Compensation Framework for Wetlands Real Property Claims
Appendix I
Example of Wetlands Real Property Compensation Amount
7
on Hypothetical Parcel in
Compensation Category B
SCAT Line
D
e
p
t
h
(
f
t
)
30
50
80
0
Non-Oiled Primary Area
30 ft depth from SCAT Line
Non-OiledRate:
$4,500 / acre of Primary Area
Parcel Boundary Non-Oiled SCAT Zone
7
The final compensation amount shown in this Appendix is exclusive of an RTP of 2.50.
02 8 5
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 29 of 32
Page 29 of 31
Compensation Framework for Wetlands Real Property Claims
Appendix J
Calculation Example of Wetlands Real Property Compensation Amount
8
Example 1 Compensation Category A: Parcels Documented as Oiled by SCAT
Key Field Formula Values
A Oiled SCAT Zone Length (ft) 1,500
B Oiled Primary Area Depth (Section 2. C. iii.) (ft) 50
C
Oiled Primary Area (ft
2
)
A x B 75,000
D Oiled Primary Area (acres)
C / 43,560 ft
2
1.72
E Oiled Rate (Section 2. C. vi. a.) $25,000
F Oiled Primary Area Compensation D x E $43,044
G Oiled Buffer Primary Area Depth (Section 2. C. iv.) (ft) 30
H
Oiled Buffer Primary Area (ft
2
)
A x G 45,000
I Oiled Buffer Primary Area (acres)
H / 43,560 ft
2
1.03
J Buffer Rate (Section 2. C. vi. b.) $10,000
K Oiled Buffer Primary Area Compensation I x J $10,331
L Non-Oiled SCAT Zone Length (ft) 1,800
M Non-Oiled Primary Area Depth (Section 2. C. v.) (ft) 30
N
Non-Oiled Primary Area (ft
2
)
L x M 54,000
O Non-Oiled Primary Area (acres)
N / 43,560 ft
2
1.24
P Non-Oiled Rate (Section 2. C. vi. c.) $11,000
Q Non-Oiled Primary Area Compensation O x P $13,636
R Wetlands Real Property Compensation Amount F+K+Q $67,011
8
The final compensation amount shown in this Appendix is exclusive of an RTP of 2.50.
02 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 30 of 32
Page 30 of 31
Compensation Framework for Wetlands Real Property Claims
Appendix J
Calculation Example of Wetlands Real Property Compensation Amount
9
Example 2 Compensation Category B: Parcels not Documented as Oiled by SCAT
9
The final compensation amount shown in this Appendix is exclusive of an RTP of 2.50.
Key Field Formula Values
A Oiled SCAT Zone Length (ft) -
B Oiled Primary Area Depth (Section 2. C. iii.) (ft) 50
C
Oiled Primary Area (ft
2
)
A x B -
D Oiled Primary Area (acres)
C / 43,560 ft
2
-
E Oiled Rate (Section 2. C. vi. a.) $25,000
F Oiled Primary Area Compensation D x E -
G Oiled Buffer Primary Area Depth (Section 2. C. iv.) (ft) 30
H
Oiled Buffer Primary Area (ft
2
)
A x G -
I Oiled Buffer Primary Area (acres)
H / 43,560 ft
2
-
J Buffer Rate (Section 2. C. vi. b.) $10,000
K Oiled Buffer Primary Area Compensation I x J -
L Non-Oiled SCAT Zone Length (ft) 2,000
M Non-Oiled Primary Area Depth (Section 2. C. v.) (ft) 30
N
Non-Oiled Primary Area (ft
2
)
L x M 60,000
O Non-Oiled Primary Area (acres)
N / 43,560 ft
2
1.38
P Non-Oiled Rate B (Section 2. C. vii. a.) $4,500
Q Non-Oiled Primary Area Compensation O x P $6,198
R Wetlands Real Property Compensation Amount F+K+Q $6,198
02 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 31 of 32
Page 31 of 31
Compensation Framework for Wetlands Real Property Claims
Appendix K
Calculation Example of Minimum Wetlands Real Property Compensation Amount
10
Compensation Category A: Parcels Documented as Oiled by SCAT
Key Field Formula Values
A Oiled SCAT Zone Length (ft) 450
B Oiled Primary Area Depth (Section 2. C. iii.) (ft) 50
C
Oiled Primary Area (ft
2
)
A x B 22,500
D Oiled Primary Area (acres)
C / 43,560 ft
2
0.52
E Minimum Oiled Primary Area (acres) - If Oiled Primary Area < 1 acre 1.00
F Oiled Rate (Section 2. C. vi. a.) $25,000
G Oiled Primary Area Compensation E x F $25,000
H Oiled Buffer Primary Area Depth (Section 2. C. iv.) (ft) 30
I
Oiled Buffer Primary Area (ft
2
)
A x H 13,500
J Oiled Buffer Primary Area (acres)
I / 43,560 ft
2
0.31
K Minimum Oiled Buffer Primary Area (acres) - If Oiled Primary Area < 1 acre 1.00
L Buffer Rate (Section 2. C. vi. b.) $10,000
M Oiled Buffer Primary Area Compensation K x L $10,000
N Non-Oiled SCAT Zone Length (ft) 500
O Non-Oiled Primary Area Depth (Section 2. C. v.) (ft) 30
P
Non-Oiled Primary Area (ft
2
)
N x O 15,000
Q Non-Oiled Primary Area (acres)
P / 43,560 ft
2
0.34
R Non-Oiled Rate (Section 2. C. vi. c.) $11,000
S Non-Oiled Primary Area Compensation Q x R $3,788
T Wetlands Real Property Compensation Amount G+M+S $38,788
10
The final compensation amount shown in this Appendix is exclusive of an RTP of 2.50.
02 8 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-26 Filed 04/18/12 Page 32 of 32
2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-27 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 13
Appendi xAt oCompensat i onFr amewor kf or
Wet l andsReal Pr oper t yCl ai ms:
Wet l andsReal Pr oper t yCl ai mZoneM ap
1
Appendi xA:Wet l andsReal Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
028028
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-27 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 13
Loui si ana(Ent i r eZone)
Not es:
1. Par cel boundar i esar ebasedonTobi ndi gi t al ow ner shi pmapspubl i shedbyP2Ener gySol ut i ons.
2. Pot ent i al cl ai mant scandet er mi new het her t hei r par cel i sel i gi bl ef or compensat i onunder t heCompensat i on
Framewor kf or Wet l andsReal Pr oper t yCl ai msbyent er i ngt hei r addr essor l ocat i onont heset t l ement websi t e.
2
Appendi xA:Wet l andsReal Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
02802
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-27 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 13
3
Loui si ana(Det ai l edPor t i on1)
Appendi xA:Wet l andsReal Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
0280 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-27 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 13
4
Loui si ana(Det ai l edPor t i on2)
Appendi xA:Wet l andsReal Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
0280
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-27 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 13
5
Loui si ana(Det ai l edPor t i on3)
Appendi xA:Wet l andsReal Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
0280 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-27 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 13
6
Loui si ana(Det ai l edPor t i on4)
Appendi xA:Wet l andsReal Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
0280
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-27 Filed 04/18/12 Page 7 of 13
7
Loui si ana(Det ai l edPor t i on5)
Appendi xA:Wet l andsReal Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
0280
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-27 Filed 04/18/12 Page 8 of 13
8
Loui si ana(Det ai l edPor t i on6)
Appendi xA:Wet l andsReal Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
0280 5
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-27 Filed 04/18/12 Page 9 of 13
9
Loui si ana(Det ai l edPor t i on7)
Appendi xA:Wet l andsReal Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
0280
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-27 Filed 04/18/12 Page 10 of 13
10
Loui si ana(Det ai l edPor t i on8)
Appendi xA:Wet l andsReal Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
0280
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-27 Filed 04/18/12 Page 11 of 13
11
Loui si ana(Det ai l edPor t i on9)
Appendi xA:Wet l andsReal Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
0280 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-27 Filed 04/18/12 Page 12 of 13
12
Loui si ana(Det ai l edPor t i on10)
Appendi xA:Wet l andsReal Pr oper t yCl ai m
ZoneM ap
0280
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-27 Filed 04/18/12 Page 13 of 13
2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-28 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 13
Appendi xCt oCompensat i onFr amewor kf or
Wet l andsReal Pr oper t yCl ai ms:
El i gi bl ePar cel Compensat i onCat egor yM ap
1
Appendi xC:El i gi bl ePar cel Compensat i on
Cat egor yM ap
0280 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-28 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 13
Loui si ana(Ent i r eZone)
ZoneA
ZoneB
Appendi xC:El i gi bl ePar cel Compensat i on
Cat egor yM ap
0280
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-28 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 13
3
Loui si ana(Det ai l edPor t i on1)
Appendi xC:El i gi bl ePar cel Compensat i on
Cat egor yM ap
ZoneA
ZoneB
0280 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-28 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 13
4
Loui si ana(Det ai l edPor t i on2)
Appendi xC:El i gi bl ePar cel Compensat i on
Cat egor yM ap
ZoneA
ZoneB
0280
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-28 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 13
5
Loui si ana(Det ai l edPor t i on3)
Appendi xC:El i gi bl ePar cel Compensat i on
Cat egor yM ap
ZoneA
ZoneB
0280
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-28 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 13
6
Loui si ana(Det ai l edPor t i on4)
Appendi xC:El i gi bl ePar cel Compensat i on
Cat egor yM ap
ZoneA
ZoneB
0280 5
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-28 Filed 04/18/12 Page 7 of 13
7
Loui si ana(Det ai l edPor t i on5)
Appendi xC:El i gi bl ePar cel Compensat i on
Cat egor yM ap
ZoneA
ZoneB
0280
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-28 Filed 04/18/12 Page 8 of 13
8
Loui si ana(Det ai l edPor t i on6)
Appendi xC:El i gi bl ePar cel Compensat i on
Cat egor yM ap
ZoneA
ZoneB
0280
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-28 Filed 04/18/12 Page 9 of 13
9
Loui si ana(Det ai l edPor t i on7)
Appendi xC:El i gi bl ePar cel Compensat i on
Cat egor yM ap
ZoneA
ZoneB
0280 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-28 Filed 04/18/12 Page 10 of 13
10
Loui si ana(Det ai l edPor t i on8)
Appendi xC:El i gi bl ePar cel Compensat i on
Cat egor yM ap
ZoneA
ZoneB
0280
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-28 Filed 04/18/12 Page 11 of 13
11
Loui si ana(Det ai l edPor t i on9)
Appendi xC:El i gi bl ePar cel Compensat i on
Cat egor yM ap
ZoneA
ZoneB
028050
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-28 Filed 04/18/12 Page 12 of 13
12
Loui si ana(Det ai l edPor t i on10)
Appendi xC:El i gi bl ePar cel Compensat i on
Cat egor yM ap
ZoneA
ZoneB
02805
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-28 Filed 04/18/12 Page 13 of 13
2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-29 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 13
Appendi xDt oCompensat i onFr amewor kf or
Wet l andsReal Pr oper t yCl ai ms:
Ar eaof Pot ent i al El i gi bi l i t yM ap
Appendi xD:Ar eaof Pot ent i al El i gi bi l i t y
M ap
1
028052
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-29 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 13
Loui si ana(Ent i r eZone)
Appendi xD:Ar eaof Pot ent i al El i gi bi l i t y
M ap
2
Loui si ana/ TexasBor der
Loui si ana/ M i ssi ssi ppi Bor der
Endof Loui si anaSt at eW at er s
mi l eInl andf r omZone
028053
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-29 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 13
Camer onPar i sh,LA
Appendi xD:Ar eaof Pot ent i al El i gi bi l i t y
M ap
3
028054
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-29 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 13
Ver mi l i onPar i sh,LA
Appendi xD:Ar eaof Pot ent i al El i gi bi l i t y
M ap
4
028055
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-29 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 13
Iber i aPar i sh,LA
Appendi xD:Ar eaof Pot ent i al El i gi bi l i t y
M ap
5
028056
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-29 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 13
St .M ar yPar i sh,LA
Appendi xD:Ar eaof Pot ent i al El i gi bi l i t y
M ap
6
028057
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-29 Filed 04/18/12 Page 7 of 13
Ter r ebonnePar i sh,LA
Appendi xD:Ar eaof Pot ent i al El i gi bi l i t y
M ap
7
028058
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-29 Filed 04/18/12 Page 8 of 13
Laf our chePar i sh,LA
Appendi xD:Ar eaof Pot ent i al El i gi bi l i t y
M ap
8
028059
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-29 Filed 04/18/12 Page 9 of 13
Jef f er sonPar i sh,LA
Appendi xD:Ar eaof Pot ent i al El i gi bi l i t y
M ap
9
028060
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-29 Filed 04/18/12 Page 10 of 13
Pl aquemi nesPar i sh,LA
Appendi xD:Ar eaof Pot ent i al El i gi bi l i t y
M ap
10
028061
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-29 Filed 04/18/12 Page 11 of 13
St .Ber nar dPar i sh,LA
Appendi xD:Ar eaof Pot ent i al El i gi bi l i t y
M ap
11
028062
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-29 Filed 04/18/12 Page 12 of 13
St .TammanyPar i shandOr l eansPar i sh,LA
Appendi xD:Ar eaof Pot ent i al El i gi bi l i t y
M ap
12
028063
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-29 Filed 04/18/12 Page 13 of 13
EXHIBIT 13A
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-30 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 11
1
Note: The most current definitions of the Economic Injury and Property Claim Settlement
Class Definition are included in the draft Economic Injury and Property Claim Settlement
Agreement forwarded by BP to the PSC on December 4, 2011 and in the class definition
document bates numbered 005125 to 5128 and dated December 20, 2011.
026375
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-30 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 11
2
Sales shall not include transfers from borrowers to lenders that take place as part of the
foreclosure process, such as deeds in lieu of foreclosure, foreclosure deeds, Sheriffs deeds.
026376
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-30 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 11
a. The sale price of the Residential Parcel shall be multiplied by the Real Property
Compensation Percentage of 12.5%. A detailed description for calculation of the
Real Property Sales Compensation Percentage is contained in Appendix C.
b. Any prior compensation to the claimant from the GCCF or BP for a claim related
to the sale of the Residential Parcel shall be deducted.
c. The Real Property Sales Compensation Amount shall be allocated among Eligible
Claimants according to their ownership interest.
Example
An Eligible Claimant who submits a claim form and supporting documentation for a sale of a
Residential Parcel with a sale price of $200,000, with no former co-owners, and no prior GCCF
or BP payment for the same property damage would receive compensation of $25,000.
Residential Parcel Sale Price x Real Property Sales Compensation Percentage =
Real Property Compensation Amount
$200,000 x 12.5% = $25,000
026377
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-30 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 11
Appendix A
Real Property Sales Compensation Map
The Real Property Sales Compensation Zone Map is found in a separate document.
026378
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-30 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 11
Appendix B
Real Property Sales Claim Form
1. Did you own a Residential Parcel within the Real Property Sales Compensation Zone identified on the
Real Property Sales Compensation Zone Map on April 20, 2010?
____ Yes ___ No
2. Did you execute a sales contract for the sale of that Residential Parcel?
____ Yes ___ No
3. Did you close on that sale of that Residential Parcel on or before December 31, 2010?
____ Yes ___ No
If you answered yes to all of the questions above, please (A) answer questions 4 through 10 below and (B)
provide copies of the documents required below.
If you answered no to any of the questions above, you are not eligible for compensation under the Real
Property Sales Compensation Framework portion of the Settlement Agreement and you should not
complete or submit this form.
4. What date did you execute your sales contract? _______________________________
5. If you executed your sales contract before April 21, 2010, was the contract price reduced at some point
before closing?
____ Yes ___ No
026379
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-30 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 11
6. If the contract price was reduced at some point before closing, why was the price reduced?
7. What is the street address of the Residential Parcel? ________________________________________
8. In what county is the Residential Parcel located? ___________________________________________
9. What is the parcel identification number for the Residential Parcel? ____________________________
10. What is the tax identification assessment number for the Residential Parcel? _____________________
026380
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-30 Filed 04/18/12 Page 7 of 11
Document Requirements
If you answered yes to questions 1 through 3 above, please provide copies of the following documents.
1. Official copy of the deed for the Residential Parcel sale that took place during the time period
April 21, 2010 to December 31, 2010.
2. Copy of the signed sales contract(s) for the sale that took place during the time period April 21,
2010 to December 31, 2010.
x If you answered yes to question number 5 above, provide a copy of both the sales
contract executed before April 21, 2010 and a copy of the sales contract executed on or
after April 21, 2010.
3. If you answered yes to question number 5 above, provide the supporting documentation to
demonstrate why the contract price was reduced. For example, provide the letter from the
purchaser or the purchasers real estate attorney requesting the reduction. If you have no
documentation, provide contact information for the purchaser.
4. Copy of the closing statement for the sale that took place during the time period April 21, 2010
to December 31, 2010.
026381
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-30 Filed 04/18/12 Page 8 of 11
Appendix C
Detailed Description
a) Real Property Sales Compensation Zone consists of Residential Parcels identified in Real
Property Compensation Map.
b) Real Property Sales Comparison Zone consists of improved residential parcels in the
counties in Real Property Compensation Map not in the Real Property Sales
Compensation Zone.
c) Sale Price is the actual sale price of the parcel.
d) Benchmark Price is an estimate of the value of the parcel at the time of sale based on the
2010 county appraised value. The formula is for the Benchmark Price is:
2010 County-Appraised Value
x Sales-Appraised Value Ratio (expressing the value as of 1/1/10)
x Change in HPI
3
for MSA
4
of parcel (expressing the value as of 3/31/10)
x Change in HPI for non-Gulf MSA (expressing the value at the date of sale)
= Benchmark Price
e) Sales to Appraised Value Ratio is calculated as follows. For each arms-length sale of
improved residential parcels in the region during 2009 the Sale Price is divided by the
2010 County Appraised value.
5
The Sales to Appraised Value Ratio is the average of
these values. A separate Sales-Appraised Value Ratio is calculated for condominiums
and single-family homes.
The formula for Sales to Appraised Value Ratio is as follows:
Sales Appiaiseu value Ratio
Where i represents each individual parcel in the region and n represents the total number
of parcels in the region.
f) Change in HPI for MSA of parcel is the percentage change from January 1, 2010 to
March 31, 2010 in the HPI for that MSA. See Table 1, Pre-Spill column.
3
House Price Index (HPI) is the index of price changes in each MSA, as compiled by the Federal Housing Finance
Agency.
4
Metropolitan Statistical Areas (MSAs) are geographical zones defined by the U.S. Office of Management and
Budget. If a sale occurred in a county without an MSA, the most similar surrounding MSA was used. Non-Gulf
MSAs are surrounding MSAs that are not on the Gulf coast.
5
Before a Sales to Appraised Value Ratio is determined, (1) 2009 Sales Prices are adjusted to account for the
change in real estate values between the sale of those parcels and January 1, 2010 (See Table 2); and (2) the top and
bottom 2.5% of parcels are excluded based on the ratio of 2009 sales prices to 2010 assessed values.
026382
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-30 Filed 04/18/12 Page 9 of 11
g) Change in HPI for the Non-Gulf MSA is the percentage change in the HPI for the Non-
Gulf MSA that is most similar to the parcels MSA between March 31, 2010 and the
quarter of the date of sale for the parcel. See Table 1, Post-Spill column.
h) Real Property Sales Compensation Zone Percentage is the weighted average percentage
difference between Sales Prices and Benchmark Prices for all Real Property Sales
Compensation Zone parcels sold in arms-length transactions during April 21, 2010
through December 31, 2010.
6
The formula for Real Property Sales Compensation Zone Percentage is as follows:
Real Piopeity Sales Compensation Zone Peicentage
Where i represents each individual parcel and n represents the total number of parcels.
i) Real Property Sales Comparison Zone Percentage is the weighted average percentage
difference between sales prices and Benchmark Prices for all improved residential parcels
sold in arms-length transactions in the region except Real Property Sales Compensation
Zone parcels during April 21, 2010 through December 31, 2010.
The formula for Real Property Sales Comparison Zone Percentage is as follows:
Real Piopeity Sales Compaiison Zone Peicentage
Where i represents each individual parcel and n represents the total number of parcels.
j) Real Property Sales Compensation Amount shall be defined as the Real Property Sales
Compensation Zone Percentage subtracted from the Real Property Sales Comparison
Zone Percentage plus the Real Property Sales Compensation Zone Adjustment
Percentage.
The formula for the Real Property Sales Compensation Amount is as follows:
Real Property Sales Comparison Zone Percentage
Real Property Sales Compensation Zone Percentage
+ Real Property Sales Compensation Zone Adjustment Percentage
= Real Property Sales Compensation Percentage
6
When calculating average differences between Sales Prices and Benchmark Prices, the top and bottom 2.5% of
parcels are excluded based on the ratio of 2010 sales prices to 2010 assessed values.
026383
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-30 Filed 04/18/12 Page 10 of 11
026384
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-30 Filed 04/18/12 Page 11 of 11
EXHIBIT 13B
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 69
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
1
026307
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 69
LA,M S,AL,FL
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
2
026308
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 69
HancockCount y,M S(1)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
3
026309
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 69
HancockCount y,M S(2)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
4
026310
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 69
HancockCount y,M S(3)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
5
026311
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 69
HancockCount y,M S(4)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
6
026312
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 7 of 69
Har r i sonCount y,M S(1)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
7
026313
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 8 of 69
Har r i sonCount y,M S(2)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
8
026314
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 9 of 69
Har r i sonCount y,M S(3)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
9
026315
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 10 of 69
Har r i sonCount y,M S(4)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
10
026316
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 11 of 69
Har r i sonCount y,M S(5)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
11
026317
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 12 of 69
Har r i sonCount y,M S(6)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
12
026318
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 13 of 69
JacksonCount y,M S(1)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
13
026319
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 14 of 69
JacksonCount y,M S(2)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
14
026320
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 15 of 69
JacksonCount y,M S(3)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
15
026321
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 16 of 69
JacksonCount y,M S(4)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
16
026322
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 17 of 69
JacksonCount y,M S(5)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
17
026323
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 18 of 69
M obi l eCount y,AL(1)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
18
026324
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 19 of 69
M obi l eCount y,AL(2)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
19
026325
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 20 of 69
M obi l eCount y,AL(3)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
20
026326
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 21 of 69
M obi l eCount y,AL(4)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
21
026327
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 22 of 69
M obi l eCount y,AL(5)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
22
026328
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 23 of 69
Bal dw i nCount y,AL(1)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
23
026329
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 24 of 69
Bal dw i nCount y,AL(2)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
24
026330
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 25 of 69
Bal dw i nCount y,AL(3)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
25
026331
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 26 of 69
Escambi aCount y,FL(1)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
26
026332
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 27 of 69
Escambi aCount y,FL(2)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
27
026333
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 28 of 69
Escambi aCount y,FL(3)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
28
026334
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 29 of 69
Sant aRosaCount y,FL(1)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
29
026335
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 30 of 69
Sant aRosaCount y,FL(2)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
30
026336
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 31 of 69
Sant aRosaCount y,FL(3)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
31
026337
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 32 of 69
Okal oosaCount y,FL(1)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
32
026338
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 33 of 69
Okal oosaCount y,FL(2)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
33
026339
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 34 of 69
Okal oosaCount y,FL(3)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
34
026340
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 35 of 69
Wal t onCount y,FL(1)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
35
026341
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 36 of 69
Wal t onCount y,FL(2)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
36
026342
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 37 of 69
Wal t onCount y,FL(3)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
37
026343
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 38 of 69
Wal t onCount y,FL(4)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
38
026344
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 39 of 69
Wal t onCount y,FL(5)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
39
026345
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 40 of 69
Wal t onCount y,FL(6)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
40
026346
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 41 of 69
BayCount y,FL(1)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
41
026347
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 42 of 69
BayCount y,FL(2)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
42
026348
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 43 of 69
BayCount y,FL(3)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
43
026349
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 44 of 69
BayCount y,FL(4)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
44
026350
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 45 of 69
BayCount y,FL(5)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
45
026351
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 46 of 69
BayCount y,FL(6)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
46
026352
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 47 of 69
BayCount y,FL(7)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
47
026353
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 48 of 69
Gul f Count y,FL(1)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
48
026354
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 49 of 69
Gul f Count y,FL(2)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
49
026355
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 50 of 69
Gul f Count y,FL(3)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
50
026356
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 51 of 69
Gul f Count y,FL(4)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
51
026357
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 52 of 69
Gul f Count y,FL(5)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
52
026358
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 53 of 69
Fr ankl i nCount y,FL(1)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
53
026359
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 54 of 69
Fr ankl i nCount y,FL(2)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
54
026360
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 55 of 69
Fr ankl i nCount y,FL(3)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
55
026361
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 56 of 69
Fr ankl i nCount y,FL(4)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
56
026362
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 57 of 69
Fr ankl i nCount y,FL(5)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
57
026363
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 58 of 69
Fr ankl i nCount y,FL(6)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
58
026364
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 59 of 69
Fr ankl i nCount y,FL(7)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
59
026365
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 60 of 69
Fr ankl i nCount y,FL(8)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
60
026366
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 61 of 69
Fr ankl i nCount y,FL(9)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
61
026367
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 62 of 69
Fr ankl i nCount y,FL(10)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
62
026368
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 63 of 69
Fr ankl i nCount y,FL(11)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
63
026369
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 64 of 69
Fr ankl i nCount y,FL(12)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
64
026370
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 65 of 69
Wakul l aCount y,FL(1)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
65
026371
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 66 of 69
Wakul l aCount y,FL(2)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
66
026372
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 67 of 69
Wakul l aCount y,FL(3)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
67
026373
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 68 of 69
Gr andIsl e,LA(1)
Appendi xA:Real Pr oper t ySal es
Compensat i onZoneM ap
68
026374
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-31 Filed 04/18/12 Page 69 of 69
EXHIBIT 14
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-32 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 14
Compensation Framework for Vessel Physical Damage Claims
1. Eligibility Requirements
A. Eligible Claimants shall be comprised of claimants who do not fall within the
exclusions to the Economic Loss and Property Class Definition and who were
owners of an Eligible Vessel(s) during the time period April 20, 2010 to December
31, 2011, except for the following:
i. Claimants who are owners of an Eligible Vessel(s) that have signed a
Receipt and Release Letter Agreement in connection with the BP program
to reimburse costs from damage to vessels involved in the Vessels of
Opportunity program.
ii. Claimants who sustained Physical Damage to an Eligible Vessel while
working for an Oil Spill Response Organization or an Oil Spill Removal
Organization (OSRO) in the DWH Spill response. However this
exclusion shall not apply to claimants who were participating in the
Vessels of Opportunity Program.
B. An Eligible Vessel shall be defined as a vessel, and/or vessel appurtenances, that
sustained Physical Damage.
C. Physical Damage shall be defined as physical damage that was sustained by an
Eligible Claimants Eligible Vessel due to or resulting from the DWH Spill or the
DWH Spill response cleanup operations, including the Vessels of Opportunity
Program, that were consistent with the National Contingency Plan or specifically
ordered by the Federal On-Scene Coordinator or delegates thereof. Physical Damage
shall also include the need for removal of equipment or rigging that was added to an
Eligible Claimants Eligible Vessel to conduct DWH Spill response cleanup
operations.
i. Some examples of Physical Damage include a bent propeller, dents or
scratches to a vessels hull, damage to a vessels engine from the intake of
MC252 oil, scratching or staining of a vessels paint or gelcoat from
coming into contact with MC252 oil and/or dispersants, damage to nets,
rakes, traps or other gear used in the harvesting of seafood, or the need for
decontamination of MC252 oil from a vessel.
D. Notwithstanding the above, Physical Damage shall not include the following types of
damage: i) damage caused by the negligence of an Eligible Claimant or an Eligible
Vessels captain or crew, ii) damage caused by an employee or agent of an OSRO;
iii) damage caused by an act of God, iv) damage caused by normal wear and tear, or
v) damage to a trailer or anything else used to transport an Eligible Vessel.
027893
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-32 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 14
i. Some examples of damage not included in the definition of Physical Damage
include, but are not limited to, the following: damage from running aground,
damage from contaminated fuel, damage from allision with a fixed object,
damage sustained while vessel operator was inebriated, damage caused by
violation of the United States Coast Guards Navigation Rules, damage from
lightning strikes, or damage caused by the unseaworthiness of the vessel.
E. Administrators Database: The Claims Administrator shall maintain a database
(Administrators Database) containing information on Eligible Claimants that
have signed a Receipt and Release Letter Agreement in connection with the BP
program to reimburse costs from damage to vessels involved in the Vessels of
Opportunity program. The Claims Administrator shall check the Administrators
Database to determine whether an Eligible Claimant has signed a Receipt and
Release Letter Agreement in connection with the BP program to reimburse costs
from damage to vessels involved in the Vessels of Opportunity program. The
Administrators Database is presumed to be satisfactory evidence of such a
release.
2. Compensation
A. An Eligible Claimant must provide the Claims Administrator with satisfactory proof
of all of the following items below in order to qualify to receive compensation for
Physical Damage.
i. The claimant is an Eligible Claimant.
ii. The claimed Physical Damage was sustained by an Eligible Claimants Eligible
Vessel.
iii. The Physical Damage occurred between April 20, 2010 and December 31, 2011.
iv. The Physical Damage was sustained due to or resulting from the DWH Spill or
the DWH Spill response cleanup operations, including the Vessels of Opportunity
Program, that were consistent with the National Contingency Plan or specifically
ordered by the Federal On-Scene Coordinator or delegates thereof. Satisfactory
proof shall include operations of the Vessels of Opportunity program or other
operations approved by BP or the Unified Command.
v. The condition of the Eligible Vessel prior to the claimed Physical Damage.
a) As part of the Vessels of Opportunity program, the condition of certain
vessels was inspected prior to beginning an operational mission. These
027894
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-32 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 14
inspections are reflected in documents referred to as the Jackson On-
Hire Surveys. The Claims Administrator shall be provided with
Jackson On-Hire Surveys for vessels involved in the Vessels of
Opportunity program.
vi. The Eligible Claimant owned the Eligible Vessel for which Physical Damaged
is claimed at the time the damage occurred.
vii. For an Eligible Claimant claiming to have incurred costs to repair or replace the
Eligible Vessel, evidence to establish that the costs were incurred by the Eligible
Claimant and that they were reasonable and necessary.
viii. For an Eligible Claimant seeking compensation for costs not yet incurred to
repair or replace the Eligible Vessel, a cost estimate and proof the costs are
reasonable and necessary.
B. An Eligible Claimant must comply with the Claim Form, Document
Requirements and Verification Statement listed in Appendices A, B and C in order
to qualify to receive Vessel Damage Compensation.
C. An Eligible Claimant who claims Physical Damage and satisfies Section 2. A, and
2. B above shall receive Vessel Damage Compensation. Vessel Damage
Compensation shall be the lesser of the reasonable and necessary costs to repair or
replace an Eligible Vessel. Vessel Damage Compensation shall only include the
cost to replace an Eligible Vessel if the Claims Administrator determines that the cost
to replace an Eligible Vessel is less than the cost to repair an Eligible Vessel.
i. The Claims Administrator shall have the authority to verify any of the criteria
contained in the Compensation Framework for Vessel Physical Damage Claim
including, the Eligible Claimants claimed repair and/or replacement costs, and
to undertake an investigation to determine the reasonableness of the costs to repair
and/or replace the Eligible Vessel, including obtaining an independent estimate.
D. In no case shall an RTP be applied to Vessel Damage Compensation.
027895
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-32 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 14
Compensation Framework for Vessel Physical Damage Claims
Appendix A
Vessel Physical Damage Claim Form
1. Are you claiming you are entitled to compensation for physical damage that occurred to your
vessel due to or resulting from the DWH Spill or the DWH Spill response cleanup
operations, including the Vessels of Opportunity Program, during the time period April 20,
2010 to December 31, 2011?
____ Yes ____ No
If you answered yes question 1 above, (i) answer the questions below, (ii) provide the
documentation required in the Document Requirements form (Appendix B), and (iii) complete
a Vessel Physical Damage Verification Statement (Appendix C).
2. What is the vessels registration number?
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
02789
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-32 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 14
3. If your vessel participated in the Vessels of Opportunity program, provide the contract
number of the Master Charter Vessel Agreement you executed.
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
4. Identify and describe the vessel that you claim sustained physical damage due to or resulting
from the DWH Spill or the DWH Spill response cleanup operations, including the i) make, ii)
model, iii) year, iv) length, v) capacity, vi) propulsion type, and vessel class (e.g., deck boat,
dinghy, multihull cruiser, etc.).
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
5. Describe the physical damage that you claim was sustained by your vessel due to or resulting
from the DWH Spill or the DWH Spill response cleanup operations.
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
6. Describe what activity your boat was performing at the time of the physical damage that you
027897
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-32 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 14
claim was sustained by your vessel.
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
7. Where was your vessel located when the physical damage occurred?
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
8. When did the physical damage to your vessel occur?
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
027898
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-32 Filed 04/18/12 Page 7 of 14
9. Describe in detail what caused the physical damage to your vessel.
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
10. If you know, did the physical damage that your vessel sustained result from the DWH Spill
or the DWH Spill response cleanup operations consistent with the National Contingency Plan
or specifically ordered by the Federal On-Scene Coordinator or delegates thereof?
____ Yes ____ No _____ I Dont Know
11. Was the damage to your vessel caused by any of the following: i) your fault, ii) the fault of
the vessels captain or crew, iii) an act of God, or iv) normal wear and tear.
____ Yes ___ No
12. Describe the condition of the vessel prior to the damage you claim occurred.
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
13. Did you own the vessel that you claim was damaged at the time the damage occurred?
____ Yes ___ No
027899
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-32 Filed 04/18/12 Page 8 of 14
14. Have you already incurred the cost to repair or replace the vessel that you claim was
physically damaged?
____ Yes ___ No
15. If your answer to Question 13 is yes, please identify the following:
a. Was the vessel repaired or replaced?
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
b. If the vessel was replaced, state the reasons, in precise detail, that the vessel was
replaced instead of being repaired.
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
c. If the vessel was replaced, state the name and address of the individual or business
from which the replacement vessel was obtained and the cost you incurred to replace
the vessel.
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
027900
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-32 Filed 04/18/12 Page 9 of 14
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
d. If the vessel was repaired, state the name and address and telephone number of the
individual or business that did the repairs, the cost you incurred to repair the vessel,
and identify the repairs that were done.
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
16. If the answer to Question 13 is no, identify the following:
a. State whether the vessel can be repaired:
____ Yes ___ No
b. Have you obtained a cost estimate to repair the vessel?
____ Yes ___ No
027901
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-32 Filed 04/18/12 Page 10 of 14
c. If you have obtained a cost estimate to repair the vessel, state the name address and
phone number of the individual or entity that provided the cost estimate, what repairs
are being done and the amount of the cost estimate for the repairs.
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
d. If you claim that the vessel cannot be repaired, explain in precise detail the reasons
for your claim.
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
17. Have you signed a Receipt and Release Letter Agreement in connection with the BP
program to reimburse costs from damage to vessels involved in the Vessels of
Opportunity program.
____ Yes ___ No
027902
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-32 Filed 04/18/12 Page 11 of 14
Compensation Framework for Vessel Physical Damage Claims
Appendix B
Vessel Physical Damage Claim Form
Document Requirements
To receive compensation under the Compensation Framework for Vessel Physical Damage
Claims you must provide copies of the documents described below.
1. Owners of vessels seeking compensation under the Compensation Framework for Vessel
Physical Damage Claims must provide each of the following:
a. A copy of the title for the vessel for which you are seeking compensation;
b. A copy of the registration for the vessel for which you are seeking compensation; and
c. Completed Verification Statement.
2. Owners of vessels seeking compensation under the Compensation Framework for Vessel
Physical Damage Claims must provide the Claims Administrator with proof of the items
below. Proof may consist of documents, receipts, invoices, estimates, photographs,
catalogues, advertisements, pricelists for vessels or vessel parts, videotaped footage, a sworn
statement from the claimant and/or sworn statements from a witness(es).
a. The claimed physical damage to your vessel was due to or resulting from the DWH
Spill or the DWH Spill response cleanup operations.
b. The claimed physical damage to your vessel was not caused by any of the following:
i) you, ii) the vessels captain or crew, iii) an act of God, or iv) normal wear and tear.
c. The physical damage occurred between April 20, 2010 and December 31, 2011.
d. The condition of the vessel prior to the claimed physical damage.
e. You owned the vessel at the time the physical damage occurred.
f. If you claim to have incurred costs to repair or replace the vessel, evidence to
establish the costs, that you incurred and that they were reasonable and necessary.
027903
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-32 Filed 04/18/12 Page 12 of 14
g. If you are seeking compensation for costs not yet incurred to repair or replace the
vessel, one or more cost estimates to repair or replace the vessel and proof that the
cost estimates are reasonable and necessary.
h. Signing the Verification Statement will qualify as support for subsections a, b, c, d
and e above.
027904
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-32 Filed 04/18/12 Page 13 of 14
Compensation Framework for Vessel Physical Damage Claims
Appendix C
Vessel Physical Damage Verification Statement
I, _________________________________, owned the vessel(s) for which I am submitting this
claim during the time period April 20, 2010 to December 31, 2011, and the physical damages for
which I seek compensation were due to or resulting from the DWH Spill or the DWH Spill
response cleanup operations.
I have not signed a Receipt and Release Letter Agreement in connection with the BP
program to reimburse costs from damage to vessels involved in the Vessels of Opportunity
program.
The physical damage that I claim was sustained to my vessel was not caused by any of
the following: i) my fault, ii) the fault of the vessels captain or crew, iii) an act of God, or iv)
normal wear and tear.
The physical damage that I claim was sustained to my vessel did not occur while working
for an Oil Spill Response Organization or an Oil Spill Removal Organization (OSRO) in the
DWH Spill response (However - You should check this box if your vessel damage occurred
while you were working in Vessels of Opportunity Program).
I declare and affirm under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States of America that
the foregoing is true and correct.
________________________________________
Signature
________________________________________
Date
027905
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-32 Filed 04/18/12 Page 14 of 14
EXHIBIT 15
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-33 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 5
RTP CHART
As set f or t h in t he Deepwat er Horizon Economi c and Pr oper t y Damages Set t lement
Agr eement , an RTP (r i sk t r ansf er pr emium) shal l mean t he amount pai d t o a Cl ai mant f or any and al l
al l eged damage, i ncl uding pot ent i al f ut ur e inj uri es, damages or l osses not cur r ent l y known, whi ch
may l at er mani f est t hemsel ves or devel op, ar i si ng out of , due t o, r esult i ng f r om, or r el at i ng i n any
way t o t he Deepwat er Hor i zon Inci dent , and any ot her t ype or cat egor y of damages cl aimed,
i ncl uding cl ai ms f or punit i ve damages. To t he ext ent t hat an RTP i s t o be paid t o a Cl ai mant , i t shal l
be a f act or whi ch i s mul t ipl i ed wi t h t hose Compensat i on Amount s whi ch t he Exhi bit s t o t his
Agr eement speci f y ar e el i gi bl e f or an RTP t o cal cul at e a sum whi ch i s added t o t he Compensat ion
Amount pai d t o t he Cl ai mant . The f ol l owi ng i s a summar y of t he appl i cabl e RTPs.
CLAIM TYPE RTP
Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms x Busi nesses sat i sf yi ng t he Tour i sm Def i nit i on and locat ed i n
Zone A -- RTP i s 2.50.
x Busi nesses sat i sf yi ng t he Tour i sm Def i nit i on and locat ed i n
Zone B -- RTP i s 2.00.
x Busi nesses sat i sf yi ng t he Tour i sm Def i nit i on and locat ed i n
Zone C -- RTP i s 2.00.
x Busi nesses sat i sf yi ng t he Tour i sm Def i nit i on and locat ed i n
Zone D -- RTP i s 1.25.
x Busi nesses sat i sf yi ng t he Char t er Fi shing Def ini t i on and locat ed
i n Zone A, Zone B or Zone C -- RTP i s 2.50.
x Busi nesses sat i sf yi ng t he Char t er Fi shing Def ini t i on and locat ed
i n Zone D -- RTP i s 1.25.
x Busi nesses sat i sf yi ng t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Pr ocessor Def i ni t i on
i n t he Seaf ood Di st r i but ion Chain Def ini t i ons who pr ocess
Shr i mp/ Cr ab/ Oyst er and ar e l ocat ed i n Zone A, Zone B, Zone C
or Zone D -- RTP i s 3.00.
x Busi nesses sat i sf yi ng t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Pr ocessor Def i ni t i on
i n t he Seaf ood Di st r i but ion Chain Def ini t i ons who pr ocess
Seaf ood ot her t han Shr imp/ Cr ab/ Oyst er and ar e l ocat ed i n
Zone A, Zone B, Zone C or Zone D -- RTP i s 2.25.
x Busi nesses sat i sf yi ng t he Landi ng Si t e or Commer ci al
Whol esal e or Ret ai l Dealer A Def i nit i ons i n t he Seaf ood
Di st r ibut i on Chai n Def i nit i ons and ar e l ocat ed i n Zone A, Zone
B, Zone C or Zone D -- RTP i s 2.25.
028739
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-33 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 5
- 2 -
CLAIM TYPE RTP
x Busi nesses sat i sf yi ng t he Commer ci al Whol esal e or Ret ai l
Deal er B, Secondar y Seaf ood Pr ocessor , Seaf ood Whol esal er or
Di st r ibut or , or Seaf ood Ret ai l er Def i nit i ons i n t he Seaf ood
Di st r ibut i on Chai n Def i nit i ons and ar e l ocat ed i n Zone A, Zone
B, Zone C or Zone D -- RTP i s 2.25.
x Non-Tour i sm and Non-Seaf ood Businesses l ocat ed i n Zone A --
RTP i s 1.50.
x Non-Tour i sm and Non-Seaf ood Businesses l ocat ed i n Zone B --
RTP i s 1.25.
x Non-Tour i sm and Non-Seaf ood Businesses l ocat ed i n Zone C --
RTP is 0.25.
x Non-Tour i sm and Non-Seaf ood Businesses l ocat ed i n Zone D --
RTP i s 0.25.
St ar t -up Busi ness Cl ai ms RTPs ar e t he same as f or Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms.
Fai l ed Busi ness Cl ai ms No RTP.
Fai l ed St ar t -up Busi ness Cl ai ms No RTP.
M ul t i -Faci l i t y Busi ness The RTP i s det er mined per Busi ness Economi c Loss Cl ai ms as
appl i ed t hrough t he Compensat i on f or M ult i -Faci l it y Busi nesses
f r amewor k.
Indi vi dual Economi c Loss Cl ai ms
Cat egor y I, II & III Cl ai mant s The pr esumpt i on i s t hat t he RTP shal l be det er mined by t he
i ndust r y of t he Individual s employer and t he Zone i n whi ch t he
Individual s employer is locat ed. However , a Cl aimant may
est abl i sh an alt er nat i ve Zone t o be used f or t he RTP by
demonst r at i ng t hat pr i mar y empl oyment act i vit i es and
r esponsibi l i t i es wer e per f or med in a l ocat i on di f f er ent f r om t he
empl oyer s business address and t he cl ai med DWH spi l l -r el at ed
economi c loss occur r ed in t hat l ocat ion.
x Empl oyed by business sat i sf ying t he Tour i sm Def ini t i on and
l ocat ed i n Zone A -- RTP is 2.50.
x Empl oyed by business sat i sf ying t he Tour i sm Def ini t i on and
l ocat ed i n Zone B -- RTP is 2.00.
028740
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-33 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 5
- 3 -
CLAIM TYPE RTP
x Empl oyed by business sat i sf ying t he Tour i sm Def ini t i on and
l ocat ed i n Zone C -- RTP is 2.00.
x Empl oyed by business sat i sf ying t he Tour i sm Def ini t i on and
l ocat ed i n Zone D -- RTP is 1.25.
x Empl oyed by business sat i sf ying t he Chart er Fi shing Def i ni t i on
and locat ed in Zone A, Zone B or Zone C -- RTP i s 2.50.
x Empl oyed by business sat i sf ying t he Chart er Fi shing Def i ni t i on
and locat ed in Zone D -- RTP i s 1.25.
x Empl oyed by business sat i sf yi ng t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Pr ocessor
Def ini t ion in t he Seaf ood Di st r ibut i on Chain Def init i ons who
pr ocesses Shr i mp/ Cr ab/ Oyst er and i s locat ed in Zone A, Zone
B, Zone C or Zone D -- RTP i s 3.00.
x Empl oyed by business sat i sf yi ng t he Pr i mar y Seaf ood Pr ocessor
Def ini t ion in t he Seaf ood Di st r ibut i on Chain Def init i ons who
pr ocesses Seaf ood ot her t han Shr i mp/ Cr ab/ Oyst er and i s
l ocat ed i n Zone A, Zone B, Zone C or Zone D -- RTP i s 2.25.
x Empl oyed by business sat i sf ying t he Landing Si t e or
Commer ci al Whol esal e or Ret ai l Dealer A Def i nit ions in t he
Seaf ood Di st r ibut i on Chai n Def ini t i ons and i s l ocat ed in Zone A,
Zone B, Zone C or Zone D -- RTP i s 2.25.
x Empl oyed by business sat i sf ying t he Commer ci al Whol esal e or
Ret ai l Deal er B, Secondar y Seaf ood Pr ocessor , Seaf ood
Whol esal er or Di st r i but or , or Seaf ood Ret ai l er Def i nit i ons i n
t he Seaf ood Di st r i but ion Chai n Def ini t ions and i s locat ed i n
Zone A, Zone B, Zone C or Zone D -- RTP i s 2.25.
x Empl oyed by Non-Tour i sm and Non-Seaf ood Business i n Zone
A -- RTP i s 1.50.
x Empl oyed by Non-Tour i sm and Non-Seaf ood Business i n Zone
B -- RTP i s 1.25.
x Empl oyed by Non-Tour i sm and Non-Seaf ood Business i n Zone
C -- RTP i s 0.25.
x Empl oyed by Non-Tour i sm and Non-Seaf ood Business i n Zone
D -- RTP i s 0.25.
028741
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-33 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 5
- 4 -
CLAIM TYPE RTP
Cat egor y IV Cl ai mant s Onl y Cl ai mant s who, in 2011, (1) cont inued t o be empl oyed i n a
posi t i on t he same as, or si mi l ar t o, t he Cl ai mi ng Job, and (2) st i l l
l i ved wi t hi n 60 mi l es of t hei r pl ace of empl oyment , r ecei ve an RTP
of 1.
Indi vi dual Per i odi c Vendor s RTP i s 1.
Fest i val Vendor s x For Fest i val Vendor wi t h document at i on est abl i shi ng l oss of
ear ni ngs f rom f est i val s -- RTP i s 1.
x For Fest i val Vendor wi t hout suf f i ci ent document at i on of
ear ni ngs f rom f est i val sales who rel i es on Fest i val Coor di nat or
Swor n St at ement s -- No RTP.
Seaf ood Pr ogr am Cl ai ms RTPs i n r espect of Seaf ood Pr ogr am Cl ai ms ar e set f ort h el sewher e
i n t he Set t l ement Agr eement .
Subsi st ence Cl ai ms RTP i s 2.25.
VoO Char t er Payment No RTP.
Vessel Physi cal Damage No RTP.
Coast al Real Pr oper t y Cl ai ms An RTP of 2.50 i s appl ied t o t he Coast al Real Pr oper t y
Compensat i on Amount . No RTP f or physi cal damage
compensat i on.
Wet l ands Real Pr oper t y Cl ai ms An RTP of 2.50 i s appl ied t o t he Wet l ands Real Pr oper t y
Compensat i on Amount . No RTP f or physi cal damage
compensat i on.
Real Pr oper t y Sal es No RTP.
028742
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-33 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 5
EXHIBIT 16
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-34 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 9
1
NAICScodesl i st edi n Oi l & GasIndust r yExcl usi ons (02669426703).
2
NAICSCodesl i st edi nSect i onsI& IIof Indust r yTypesSubj ect t oRevi ewbyCl ai msAdmi ni st r at or f or Pot ent i al M or at or i aLosses (026613026631).
3
NAICSCodesl i st edi n Economi cLossandPr oper t yCl assDef i ni t i onExcl usi ons (028759 - 028772).
026686
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-34 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 9
shal l cr eat ededi cat edt eamt oeval uat ebusi ness
economi cl osscl ai msf r om suchbusi nesses/
empl oyer s.
4
Seet heNAICSCodesl i st edi nSect i onIIof Indust r yTypesSubj ect t oRevi ewbyCl ai msAdmi ni st r at or f or Pot ent i al M or at or i aLosses (026613026631).
02668
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-34 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 9
Indi vi dual s/ Empl oyees Indi vi dual s/ Empl oyees Indi vi dual s/ Empl oyees
02668
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-34 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 9
0266
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-34 Filed 04/18/12 Page 9 of 9
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-35 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 11
Thi si ndust r ycompr i sesest abl i shment swi t hbul kl i qui dst or agef aci l i t i espr i mar i l yengagedi nt he
mer chant w hol esal edi st r i but i onof cr udepet r ol eumandpet r ol eumpr oduct s,i ncl udi ngl i quef i ed
pet r ol eumgas.
Bul kgasol i nest at i ons
Bul kst at i ons,pet r ol eum
Cr udeoi l t er mi nal s
Fuel oi l bul kst at i onsandt er mi nal s
Gasol i nebul kst at i onsandt er mi nal s
Li quef i edpet r ol eumgas(LPG)bul kst at i onsandt er mi nals
Lubr i cat i ngoi l sandgr easesbul kst at i onsandt er mi nal s
Oi l ,pet r ol eum,bul kst at i onsandt er mi nal s
Pet r ol eumandpet r ol eumpr oduct sbul kst at i onsandt er mi nal s
Pr opanebul kst at i onsandt er mi nal s
Ter mi nal s,pet r ol eum
424720Pet rol eumandPet rol eumProduct sM er chant Whol esal ers(except Bul kSt at i onsandTer mi nal s)
Thi si ndust r ycompr i sesest abl i shment spr i mar i l yengagedi nt hemer chant w hol esal edi st r i but i on
of pet r ol eumandpet r ol eumpr oduct s(except f r ombul kl i qui dst or agef aci l i t i es).
Cr udeoi l mer chant w hol esal er s(except bul kst at i ons,t er mi nal s)
Fuel oi l mer chant w hol esal er s(except bul kst at i ons,t er mi nal s)
Fuel oi l t r uckj obber s
Fuel i ngai r cr af t (except oncont r act basi s)
Gasol i nemer chant w hol esal er s(except bul kst at i ons,t er mi nal s)
Li quef i edpet r ol eumgas(LPG)mer chant w hol esal er s(except bul kst at i ons,t er mi nal s)
Lubr i cat i ngoi l sandgr easesmer chant w hol esal er s(except bul kst at i ons,t er mi nal s)
Oi l ,pet r ol eum,mer chant whol esal er s(except bul kst at i ons,t er mi nal s)
Pet r ol eumandpet r ol eumpr oduct smer chant w hol esal er s(except bul kst at i ons,
t er mi nal s)
486110Pi pel i neTr anspor t at i onof Cr udeOi l
Thi si ndust r ycompr i sesest abl i shment spr i mar i l yengagedi nt hepi pel i net r ansport at i onof cr ude
oi l .
Boost er pumpi ngst at i on,cr udeoi l t r anspor t at i on
Cr udeoi l pi pel i net r anspor t at i on
Pet r ol eumpi pel i nes,cr ude
Pi pel i net r anspor t at i on,cr udeoi l
486210Pi pel i neTr anspor t at i onof Nat ur al Gas
Thi si ndust r ycompr i sesest abl i shment spr i mar i l yengagedi nt hepi pel i net r anspor t at i onof nat ur al
gasf r ompr ocessi ngpl ant st ol ocal di st r i but i onsyst ems.
Boost er pumpi ngst at i on,nat ur al gast r anspor t at i on
Gas,nat ur al ,pi pel i neoper at i on
Nat ur al gaspi pel i net r anspor t at i on
Nat ur al gast r ansmi ssi on(i .e.,pr ocessi ngpl ant st ol ocal di st r i but i onsyst ems)
Pi pel i net r anspor t at i on,nat ur al gas
St or ageof nat ur al gas
Tr ansmi ssi onof nat ur al gasvi api pel i ne(i .e.,pr ocessi ngpl ant st ol ocal di st r i but i on
syst ems)
486910Pi pel i neTr anspor t at i onof Ref i nedPet r ol eumPr oduct s
026 02
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-35 Filed 04/18/12 Page 10 of 11
Thi si ndust r ycompr i sesest abl i shment spr i mar i l yengagedi nt hepi pel i net r anspor t at i onof r ef i ned
pet r ol eumpr oduct s.
Boost er pumpi ngst at i on,r ef i nedpet r ol eumpr oduct st r anspor t at i on
Gasol i nepi pel i net r anspor t at i on
Nat ur al gasl i qui dspi pel i net r anspor t at i on
Pet r ol eumpi pel i nes,r ef i ned
Pi pel i net r anspor t at i on,gasol i neandot her r ef i nedpet r ol eumpr oduct s
Ref i nedpet r ol eumpr oduct spi pel i net r anspor t at i on
486990Al l Ot her Pi pel i neTr anspor t at i on
Thi si ndust rycompr i sesest abl i shment spr i mar i l yengagedi nt hepi pel i net r anspor t at i onof
pr oduct sexcept cr udeoi l ,nat ur al gas,andr ef i nedpet r ol eumpr oduct s.
Boost er pumpi ngst at i on(except nat ur al gas,pet r ol eum)
Coal pi pel i net r anspor t at i on
Pi pel i net r anspor t at i on(except cr udeoi l ,nat ur al gas,r ef i nedpet r ol eumpr oduct s)
Sl ur r ypi pel i net r anspor t at i on
026 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-35 Filed 04/18/12 Page 11 of 11
8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-36 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 15
1
Economi c Loss and Pr opert y Cl ass Def i ni t i on Excl usi ons
(Gami ng, Banki ng, Insur ance, Funds, Def ense Cont r act or s, and Devel oper s)
Business Ent it ies wit hin t he NAICS Code descr ipt ions set f or t h i n Sect ions I-IV below, or wi t hi n t he
descr i pt i ons set f ort h below i n Sect i ons V (Def ense Cont r act or s) and VI (Developer s and Sel l er s of Real
Pr oper t y), and Nat ur al Per sons (Indi vi dual s) empl oyed by such busi ness ent i t ies, ar e excl uded f r om t he
cl ass t o t he ext ent and i n t he manner set f or t h i n t he Excl uded Indust r i es Char t [ 026686 - 026693] .
1
Wi t h r espect t o cl aims by any Busi ness Ent i t y or by a Nat ur al Person rel at ed t o hi s or her empl oyment by
a Busi ness Ent i t y, t he Cl ai ms Admi ni st r at or shal l det ermi ne t he appr opr i at e NAICS code f or t he Busi ness
Ent i t y based on hi s r eview of (a) t he NAICS code shown on a Business Ent it y claimant s 2010 t ax r et ur n,
(b) 2010 busi ness permi t s or l i cense(s), and/ or (c) ot her evidence of t he business s act ivit ies necessary
f or t he Cl aims Admi ni st r at or t o det ermi ne t he appropr i at e NAICS code.
For Def ense Cont r act or s and Real Est at e Devel oper s or Sel l er s, t he appl i cabi l i t y of t he excl usi on wi l l be
det ermined by t he Claims Administ r at or based upon his r eview of (a) t he claimant s 2010 t ax r et ur n,
(b) 2010 busi ness permi t s or l i cense(s), and/ or (c) ot her evidence of t he relevant business s or
individual s act ivit ies necessar y f or t he Claims Administ r at or t o det ermine whet her t he exclusion
applies.
I. Gami ng Indust r y
2
713210 - Casi nos (except Casi no Hot el s)
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n oper at i ng gambl i ng f aci l i t i es t hat
of f er t abl e wager i ng games al ong wi t h ot her gambl i ng act i vi t i es, such as slot machi nes and spor t s
bet t i ng. These est abl i shment s of t en pr ovi de f ood and bever age ser vi ces. Incl uded i n t hi s i n dust r y
ar e f l oat i ng casi nos (i .e., gambl i ng cr ui ses, r i ver boat casi nos).
Casi nos (except casi no hot el s)
Cr ui ses, gambl i ng
Fl oat i ng casi nos (i .e., gambl i ng cr ui ses, r i ver boat casi nos)
Gambl i ng cr ui ses
Ri ver boat casi nos
St and al one casi nos (except sl ot machi ne par l or s)
713290 - Ot her Gambl i ng Indust r i es
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n oper at i ng gambl i ng f aci l i t i es (except
casi nos or casi no hot el s) or pr ovi di ng gambl i ng ser vi ces.
Bi ngo hal l s
Bi ngo par l or s
Booki es
Bookmaker s
Car d r ooms (e.g., poker r ooms)
1
Busi ness Ent i t i es and Nat ur al Per sons (Indi vi dual s) al so may be subj ect t o ot her excl usi ons as set f or t h i n t he
Agr eement i n Pr i nci pl e Regar di ng Deepwat er Horizon Economi c and Pr oper t y Damages Set t l ement .
2
The f ol l owi ng busi ness t ypes wi l l not be excl uded: (1) bi ngo par l or s and (2) vi deo gami ng at t r uck st ops, bar s,
r est aur ant s, hot el s, r acet r acks, bi ngo par l or s, and of f -t r ack bet t i ng par l or s.
028
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-36 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 15
2
Coi n-oper at ed gambl i ng devi ce concessi on oper at or s (i .e., suppl yi ng and ser vi cing i n
ot her s' f aci l i t i es)
Gambl i ng cont r ol boar ds, oper at i ng gambl i ng act i vi t i es
Gambl i ng devi ce ar cades or par l or s, coi n-oper at ed
Gambl i ng devi ce concessi on oper at or s (i .e., suppl yi ng and ser vi ci ng i n ot her s'
f aci l i t i es), coi n-oper at ed
Lot t er y cont r ol boar ds (i .e., oper at i ng l ot t er i es)
Lot t er y cor por at i ons
Lot t er y t i cket sal es agent s (except r et ai l st or es)
Lot t er y t i cket vendor s (except r et ail st or es)
Of f -t r ack bet t i ng par l or s
Sl ot machi ne concessi on oper at or s (i .e., suppl yi ng and ser vi ci ng i n ot her s' f aci li t i es)
Sl ot machi ne par l or s
Vi deo gambl i ng devi ce concessi on oper at or s (i .e., suppl yi ng and ser vi ci ng i n ot her s'
f aci l i t i es)
Vi deo gami ng devi ce concessi on oper at or s (i .e., suppl yi ng and ser vi ci ng i n ot her s'
f aci l i t i es)
721120 - Casi no Hot el s
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n pr ovi di ng shor t -t er m l odgi ng i n hot el
f aci l i t i es wi t h a casi no on t he pr emi ses. The casi no on pr emi ses i ncl udes t abl e wager i ng games and
may i ncl ude ot her gambl i ng act i vi t i es, such as sl ot machi nes and spor t s bet t i ng. These
est abl i shment s gener al l y of f er a r ange of ser vi ces and ameni t i es, such as f ood and bever age
ser vi ces, ent er t ai nment , val et par ki ng, swi mmi ng pool s, and conf er ence and convent i on f aci l i t i es.
Casi no hot el s
Hot el s, casi no
Hot el s, r esor t , wi t h casi nos
Hot el s, seasonal , wi t h casi nos
Resor t hot el s wi t h casi nos
711212 - Racet r acks
Thi s U.S. i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar ily engaged in oper at ing r acet r acks. These
est abl i shment s may al so pr esent and / or pr omot e t he event s, such as aut o, dog, and hor se r aces,
hel d i n t hese f aci l i t i es.
Aut omobi l e r acet r acks
Dog r acet r acks
Dr ag st r i ps
Gr eyhound dog r acet r acks
Har ness r acet r acks
Hor se r acet r acks
Mot or cycl e r acet r acks
Racet r acks (e.g., aut omobi l e, dog, hor se)
Snowmobi l e r acet r acks
Speedways
St ock car r acet r acks
Thor oughbr ed r acet r acks
II. Banki ng Indust r y
3
3
The f ol l owi ng busi ness t ypes wi l l not be excl uded: st andal one ATM busi nesses, payday l oans or paycheck advan ce
busi nesses.
028 60
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-36 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 15
3
522110 - Commer ci al Banki ng
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n accept i ng demand and ot her deposi t s
and maki ng commer ci al , i ndust r i al , and consumer l oans. Commer ci al banks and br anches of
f or ei gn banks ar e i ncl uded i n t hi s i ndust r y.
Banks, commer ci al
Br anches of f or ei gn banks
Commer ci al banki ng
Commer ci al banks
Deposi t or y t r ust compani es
Nat i onal commer ci al banks
St at e commer ci al banks
522120 - Savi ngs Inst i t ut i ons
Thi s U.S. i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n accept i ng t i me deposi t s, maki ng
mor t gage and r eal est at e l oans, and i nvest i ng i n hi gh-gr ade secur i t i es. Savi ngs and l oan
associ at i ons and savi ngs banks ar e i ncl uded i n t hi s i ndust r y.
Associ at i ons, savi ngs and l oan
Banks, savi ngs
Feder al savi ngs and l oan associ at i ons (S&L)
Feder al savi ngs banks
Inst i t ut i ons, savi ngs
Mut ual savi ngs banks
Savi ngs and l oan associ at i ons (S&L)
Savi ngs banks
Savi ngs i nst i t ut i ons
St at e savi ngs and l oan associ at i ons
St at e savi ngs banks
522190 - Ot her Deposi t or y Cr edi t Int er medi at i on
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n accept i ng deposi t s and l endi ng f unds
(except commer ci al banki ng, savi ngs i nst i t ut i ons, and cr edi t uni ons). Est abl i shment s known as
i ndust r i al banks or Mor r i s Pl ans and pr i mar i l y engaged i n accept i ng deposi t s, and pr i vat e banks
(i .e., uni ncor por at ed banks) ar e i ncl uded i n t hi s i ndust r y.
Banks, i ndust r i al (i .e., known as), deposi t or y
Banks, pr i vat e (i .e., uni ncor por at ed)
Indust r i al banks (i .e., known as), deposi t or y
Mor r i s Pl ans (i .e., known as), deposi t or y
Pl ans, Mor r i s (i .e., known as), deposi t or y
Pr i vat e banks (i .e., uni ncor por at ed)
522210 - Cr edi t Car d Issui ng
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n pr ovi di ng cr edi t by i ssui ng cr edi t
car ds. Cr edi t car d i ssuance pr ovi des t he f unds r equi r ed t o pur chase goods and ser vi ces i n r et ur n
f or payment of t he f ull balance or payment s on an inst allment basis. Cr edit car d banks ar e
i ncl uded i n t hi s i ndust r y.
Banks, cr edi t car d
Char ge car d i ssui ng
Cr edi t car d banks
Cr edi t car d i ssui ng
Issui ng, cr edi t car d
522291 - Consumer Lendi ng
028 6
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-36 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 15
4
Thi s U.S. i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n maki ng unsecur ed cash l oans t o
consumer s.
Consumer f i nance compani es (i .e., unsecur ed cash l oans)
Consumer l endi ng
Fi nance compani es (i .e., unsecur ed cash l oans)
Loan compani es (i .e., consumer , per sonal , smal l , st udent )
Per sonal cr edi t i nst i t ut i ons (i .e., unsecur ed cash l oans)
Per sonal f i nance compani es (i .e., unsecur ed cash l oans)
Smal l l oan compani es (i .e., unsecur ed cash l oans)
St udent l oan compani es
522292 - Real Est at e Cr edi t
Thi s U.S. i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n l endi ng f unds wi t h r eal est at e as
col l at er al .
Const r uct i on l endi ng
Far m mor t gage l endi ng
Feder al Land Banks
Home equi t y cr edi t l endi ng
Loan cor r espondent s (i .e., l endi ng f unds wi t h r eal est at e as col l at er i al )
Mor t gage banki ng (i .e., nondeposi t or y mor t gage l endi ng)
Mor t gage compani es
Real est at e cr edi t l endi ng
Rever se mor t gage l endi ng
522293 - Int er nat i onal Tr ade Fi nanci ng
Thi s U.S. i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n pr ovi di ng one or mor e of t he
f ol l owi ng: (1) wor ki ng capi t al f unds t o U.S. expor t er s; (2) l endi ng f unds t o f or ei gn buyer s of U.S.
goods; and/ or (3) l endi ng f unds t o domest i c buyer s of i mpo r t ed goods.
Agenci es of f or ei gn banks (i .e., t r ade f i nanci ng)
Agr eement cor por at i ons (i .e., i nt er nat i onal t r ade f i nanci ng)
Banks, t r ade (i .e., i nt er nat i onal t r ade f i nanci ng)
Edge Act cor por at i ons (i .e., i nt er nat i onal t r ade f i nanci ng)
Expor t t r adi ng compani es (i .e., i nt er nat i onal t r ade f i nanci ng)
Expor t -Impor t banks
Int er nat i onal t r ade f i nanci ng
Tr ade banks (i .e., i nt er nat i onal t r ade f i nanci ng)
Tr ade f i nanci ng, i nt er nat i onal
522294 - Secondar y Mar ket Fi nanci ng
Thi s U.S. i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n buyi ng, pool i ng, and r epackagi ng
l oans f or sal e t o ot her s on t he secondar y mar ket .
Feder al Agr i cul t ur al Mor t gage Cor por at i on
Feder al Home Loan Mor t gage Cor por at i on (FHLMC)
Feder al Int er medi at e Cr edi t Bank
Feder al Nat i onal Mor t gage Associ at i on (FNMA)
FHLMC (Feder al Home Loan Mor t gage Cor por at i on)
Fi nanci ng, secondar y mar ket
FNMA (Feder al Nat i onal Mor t gage Associ at i on)
GNMA (Gover nment Nat i onal Mor t gage Associ at i on)
Gover nment Nat i onal Mor t gage Associ at i on (GNMA)
Gover nment -sponsor ed ent er pr i ses pr ovi di ng secondar y mar ket f i nanci ng
Real est at e mor t gage i nvest ment condui t s (REMICs) i ssui ng, pr i vat e
028 62
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-36 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 15
5
REMICs (r eal est at e mor t gage i nvest ment condui t s) i ssui ng, pr i vat e
Repackagi ng l oans f or sal e t o ot her s (i .e., pr i vat e condui t s)
Secondar y mar ket f i nanci ng (i .e., buyi ng, pool i ng, r epackaging l oans f or sal e t o
ot her s)
SLMA (St udent Loan Mar ket i ng Associ at i on)
St udent Loan Mar ket i ng Associ at i on (SLM A)
522298 - Al l Ot her Nondeposi t or y Cr edi t Int ermedi at i on [ Except Pawn Shops]
Thi s U.S. i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n pr ovi di ng nondeposi t or y cr edi t
(except cr edi t car d i ssui ng, sal es f i nanci ng, consumer l endi ng, r eal est at e cr edi t , i nt er nat i onal
t r ade f i nanci ng, and secondar y mar ket f i nanci ng). Exampl es of t ypes of l endi ng i n t hi s i ndust r y ar e:
shor t -t er m i nvent or y cr edi t , agr i cul t ur al l endi ng (except r eal est at e and sal es f i nanci ng) and
consumer cash l endi ng secur ed by per sonal pr oper t y.
Agr i cul t ur al cr edi t i nst i t ut i ons, maki ng l oans or ext endi ng cr edi t (except r eal est at e,
sal es f i nanci ng)
Agr i cul t ur al l endi ng (except r eal est at e, sal es f i nanci ng)
Banks, i ndust r i al (i .e., known as), nondeposi t or y
Commodi t y Cr edi t Cor por at i on
Edge Act cor por at i ons (except i nt er nat i onal t r ade f i nanci ng)
Fact or i ng account s r ecei vabl e
Feder al Home Loan Banks (FHLB)
Indust r i al banks (i .e., known as), nondeposi t or y
Indust r i al l oan compani es, nondeposi t or y
M or r i s Pl ans (i .e., known as), nondeposi t or y
Nat i onal Cr edi t Uni on Admi ni st r at i on (NCUA)
Pawnshops
Pl ans, M or r i s (i .e., known as), nondeposi t or y
Pur chasi ng of account s r ecei vabl e
Shor t -t er m i nvent or y cr edi t l endi ng
522310 - Mor t gage and Nonmor t gage Loan Br oker s
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n ar r angi ng l oans by br i ngi ng
bor r ower s and lender s t oget her on a commi ssion or f ee basi s.
Agenci es, l oan
Br oker ages, l oan
Br oker ages, mor t gage
Br oker s' of f i ces, l oan
Br oker s' of f i ces, mor t gage
Loan br oker ages
Loan br oker s' or agent s' of f i ces (i .e., i ndependent )
Mor t gage br oker ages
Mor t gage br oker s' or agent s' of f i ces (i .e., i ndependent )
522320 - Fi nanci al Tr ansact i ons Pr ocessi ng, Reser ve, and Cl ear i nghouse Act i vi t i es
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n pr ovi di ng one or mor e of t he
f ol l owi ng: (1) f i nanci al t r ansact i on pr ocessi ng (except cent r al bank); (2) r eser ve and l i qui di t y
ser vices (except cent r al bank); and/ or (3) check or ot her f i nanci al i nst r ument cl ear i nghouse
ser vices (except cent r al bank).
Aut omat ed cl ear i nghouses, bank or check (except cent r al bank)
Bank cl ear i nghouse associ at i ons
Check cl ear i ng ser vi ces (except cent r al banks)
Check cl ear i nghouse ser vices (except cent r al banks)
028 6
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-36 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 15
6
Check val i dat i on ser vi ces
Clear i nghouses, bank or check
Cr edi t car d pr ocessi ng ser vi ces
El ect r oni c f i nanci al payment ser vi ces
El ect r oni c f unds t r ansf er ser vi ces
Fi nanci al t r ansact i ons pr ocessi ng (except cent r al bank)
Pr ocessi ng f i nanci al t r ansact i ons
Reser ve and l i qui di t y ser vi ces (except cent r al bank)
U.S. Cent r al Cr edi t Uni on
522390 - Ot her Act i vi t i es Rel at ed t o Cr edi t Int er medi at i on
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n f aci l i t at i ng cr edi t i nt er medi at i on
(except mor t gage and l oan br oker age; and f i nanci al t r ansact i ons pr ocessi ng, r eser ve, and
cl ear i nghouse act i vi t i es).
Check cashi ng ser vi ces
Loan ser vi ci ng
Money or der i ssuance ser vi ces
Money t r ansmi ssi on ser vi ces
Tr avel er s' check i ssuance ser vi ces
523110 - Invest ment Banki ng and Secur i t i es Deal i ng
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n under wr i t i ng, or i gi nat i ng, and/ or
mai nt ai ni ng mar ket s f or i ssues of secur i t i es. Invest ment banker s act as pr i nci pal s (i .e., i nvest or s
who buy or sel l on t hei r own account ) i n f i r m commi t ment t r ansact i ons or act as agent s i n best
ef f or t and st andby commi t ment s. Thi s i ndust r y al so i ncl udes est abl i shment s act i ng as pr i nci pal s i n
buyi ng or sel l ing secur i t i es gener al l y on a spr ead basi s, such as secur i t i es deal er s or st ock opt i on
deal er s.
Banki ng, i nvest ment
Bond deal i ng (i .e., act i ng as a pr i nci pal i n deal i ng secur i t i es t o i nvest or s)
Commer ci al paper deal i ng (i .e., act i ng as a pr i nci pal i n deal i ng secur i t i es t o i nvest or s)
Invest ment banki ng
Maki ng mar ket s f or secur i t i es
Mar ket maki ng f or secur i t i es
Paper , deal i ng of commer ci al (i .e., act i ng as pr i nci pal i n deal i ng secur i t i es t o
i nvest or s)
Secur i t i es deal er s (i .e., act i ng as a pr i nci pal i n deal i ng secur i t i es t o i nvest or s)
Secur i t i es deal i ng (i .e., act i ng as a pr i nci pal i n deal i ng secur i t i es t o i nvest or s)
Secur i t i es di st r i but i ng (i .e., act i ng as a pr i nci pal i n deal i ng secur i t i es t o i nvest or s)
Secur i t i es f l oor t r ader s (i .e., act i ng as a pr i nci pal i n deal i ng secur i t i es t o i nvest or s)
Secur i t i es f l ot at i on compani es
Secur i t i es or i gi nat i ng (i .e., act i ng as a pr i nci pal i n deal i ng secur i t i es t o i nvest or s)
Secur i t i es t r adi ng (i .e., act i ng as a pr i nci pal i n deal i ng secur i t i es t o i nvest or s)
Secur i t i es under wr i t i ng
St ock opt i ons deal i ng (i .e., act i ng as a pr i nci pal i n deal i ng secur i t i es t o i nvest or s)
Tr adi ng secur i t i es (i .e., act i ng as a pr i nci pal i n deal i ng secur i t i es t o i nvest or s)
Under wr i t i ng secur i t i es
523120 - Secur i t i es Br oker age
028 6
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-36 Filed 04/18/12 Page 7 of 15
7
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n act i ng as agent s (i .e., br oker s)
bet ween buyer s and sel l er s i n buyi ng or sel l ing secur i t i es on a commi ssi on or t r ansact i on f ee basi s.
Bond br oker ages
Br oker ages, secur i t i es
Cer t i f i cat e of deposi t (CD) br oker s' of f i ces
Commer ci al not e br oker s' of f i ces
Mut ual f und agenci es (i .e., br oker ages)
Mut ual f und agent s' (i .e., br oker s' ) of f i ces
Secur i t i es br oker ages
Secur i t i es br oker s' of f i ces
Secur i t i es f l oor br oker s
St ock br oker ages
St ock br oker s' of f i ces
St ock opt i ons br oker ages
523130 - Commodi t y Cont r act s Deal i ng
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n act i ng as pr i nci pal s (i .e., i nvest or s
who buy or sel l f or t hei r own account ) i n buyi ng or sel l i ng spot or f ut ur es commodi t y cont r act s or
opt i ons, such as pr eci ous met al s, f or ei gn cur r ency, oi l , or agr i cul t ur al pr oduct s, gener al l y on a
spr ead basis.
Commodi t y cont r act t r adi ng compani es
Commodi t y cont r act s deal i ng (i .e., act i ng as a pr i nci pal i n deal i ng commodi t i es t o
i nvest or s)
Commodi t y cont r act s f l oor t r ader s (i .e., act i ng as a pr i nci pal i n deal i ng commodi t i es
t o i nvest or s)
Commodi t y cont r act s f l oor t r adi ng (i .e., act i ng as a pr i nci pal i n deal i ng commodi t i es
t o i nvest or s)
Commodi t y cont r act s opt i ons deal i ng (i .e., act i ng as a pr i nci pal i n deal i ng
commodi t i es t o i nvest or s)
Commodi t y cont r act s t r ader s (i .e., act i ng as a pr i nci pal i n deal i ng commodi t i es t o
i nvest or s)
For ei gn cur r ency exchange deal i ng (i .e., act i ng as a pr i nci pal i n deal i ng commodi t i es
t o i nvest or s)
For ei gn cur r ency exchange ser vi ces (i .e., sel l i ng t o t he publ i c)
Fut ur es commodi t y cont r act s deal i ng (i .e., act i ng as a pr i nci pal i n deal i ng
commodi t i es t o i nvest or s)
Tr adi ng compani es, commodi t y cont r act s
523140 - Commodi t y Cont r act s Br oker age
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n act i ng as agent s (i .e., br oker s) i n
buyi ng or sel l ing spot or f ut ur e commodi t y cont r act s or opt i ons on a commi ssi on or t r ansact i on
f ee basis.
Br oker ages, commodi t y cont r act s
Commodi t y cont r act s br oker ages
Commodi t y cont r act s br oker s' of f ices
Commodi t y cont r act s f l oor br oker s
Commodi t y cont r act s opt i ons br oker ages
Commodi t y f ut ur es br oker ages
Fi nanci al f ut ur es br oker ages
Fut ur es commodi t y cont r act s br oker ages
Fut ur es commodi t y cont r act s br oker s' of f i ces
028 6
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-36 Filed 04/18/12 Page 8 of 15
8
523210 - Secur i t i es and Commodi t y Exchanges
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n f ur ni shi ng physi cal or el ect r oni c
mar ket pl aces f or t he pur pose of f aci l i t at i ng t he buyi ng and sel l ing of st ocks, st ock opt i ons, bonds,
or commodi t y cont r act s.
Commodi t y cont r act s exchanges
Exchanges, commodi t y cont r act s
Exchanges, secur i t i es
Fut ur es commodi t y cont r act s exchanges
Secur i t i es exchanges
St ock exchanges
St ock or commodi t y opt i ons exchanges
523910 - Mi scel l aneous Int er medi at i on
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n act i ng as pr i nci pal s (except
i nvest ment banker s, secur i t i es deal er s, and commodit y cont r act s deal er s) i n buyi ng or sel l i ng of
f i nanci al cont r act s gener al l y on a spr ead basi s. Pr i nci pal s ar e i nvest or s t hat buy or sel l f or t hei r
own account .
Indi vi dual s i nvest i ng i n f i nanci al cont r act s on own account
Invest ment cl ubs
Mi ner al r oyal t i es or l eases deal i ng (i .e., act i ng as a pr i nci pal i n deal i ng r oyal t i es or
l eases t o i nvest or s)
Oi l r oyal t y deal i ng (i .e., act i ng as a pr i nci pal i n deal i ng r oyal t i es t o i nvest or s)
Tax l i ens deal i ng (i .e., act i ng as a pr i nci pal i n deal i ng t ax l i ens t o i nvest or s)
Vent ur e capi t al compani es
Vi at i cal set t l ement compani es
523920 - Por t f ol i o Management
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n managi ng t he por t f ol i o asset s (i .e.,
f unds) of ot her s on a f ee or commi ssi on basis. Est abl i shment s i n t hi s i ndust r y have t he aut hor i t y t o
make i nvest ment deci si ons, and t hey der i ve f ees based on t he size and/ or over al l per f or mance of
t he por t f ol i o.
Invest ment management
M anagi ng i nvest ment f unds
M anagi ng mut ual f unds
Managi ng per sonal i nvest ment t r ust s
Managi ng t r ust s
M ut ual f und managi ng
Pensi on f und managi ng
Per sonal i nvest ment s t r ust s, managi ng
Por t f ol i o f und managi ng
523930 - Invest ment Advi ce
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n pr ovi di ng cust omi zed i nvest ment
advi ce t o cl i ent s on a f ee basi s, but do not have t he aut hor i t y t o execut e t r ades. Pr i mar y act i vi t i es
per f or med by est abl i shment s i n t hi s i ndust r y ar e pr ovi di ng f i nanci al pl anni ng advi ce and
i nvest ment counsel i ng t o meet t he goal s and needs of speci f i c cl i ent s.
Cer t i f i ed f i nanci al pl anner s, cust omi zed, f ees pai d by cl i ent
Fi nanci al i nvest ment advi ce ser vi ces, cust omi zed, f ees pai d by cl i ent
Fi nanci al pl anni ng ser vi ces, cust omi zed, f ees pai d by cl i ent
Invest ment advi ce consul t i ng ser vi ces, cust omi zed, f ees pai d by cl i ent
Invest ment advi ce counsel i ng ser vi ces, cust omi zed, f ees pai d by cl i ent
Invest ment advi sor y ser vi ces, cust omi zed, f ees pai d by cl i ent
028 66
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-36 Filed 04/18/12 Page 9 of 15
9
523991 - Tr ust , Fi duci ar y, and Cust ody Act i vi t i es [ Except t o t he ext ent a Tr ust ee or Cust odi an of a
Tr ust whose benef i ci ar i es ar e one or mor e Nat ur al Per sons, or an execut or of an est at e of a Nat ur al
Per son, or a guar di an of a Nat ur al Per son asser t s ot her wi se per mi t t ed cl ai ms.]
Thi s U.S. i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n pr ovi di ng t r ust , f i duci ar y, and
cust ody ser vi ces t o ot her s, as i nst r uct ed, on a f ee or cont r act basi s, such as bank t r ust of f i ces and
escr ow agenci es (except r eal est at e).
Admi ni st r at or s of pr i vat e est at es
Bank t r ust of f i ces
Escr ow agenci es (except r eal est at e)
Fi duci ar y agenci es (except r eal est at e)
Per sonal i nvest ment s t r ust admi ni st r at i on
Secur i t i es cust odi ans
Tr ust admi ni st r at i on, per sonal i nvest ment
Tr ust compani es, nondeposi t or y
523999 - Mi scel l aneous Fi nanci al Invest ment Act i vi t i es
Thi s U.S. i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n act i ng as agent s and/ or br oker s
(except secur i t i es br oker ages and commodi t y cont r act s br oker ages) i n buyi ng or sel l i ng f i nanci al
cont r act s and t hose pr ovi di ng f i nanci al i nvest ment ser vices (except secur it i es and commodit y
exchanges; por t f ol i o management ; i nvest ment advi ce; and t r ust , f i duci ar y, and cust ody ser vi ces)
on a f ee or commi ssi on basi s.
Cl ear i nghouses, commodi t y exchange or secur i t i es exchange
Deposi t br oker s
Exchange clear i nghouses, commodi t i es or secur it i es
Gas l ease br oker s' of f i ces
Oi l l ease br oker s' of f i ces
Pr ot ect i ve commi t t ees, secur i t y hol der s
Quot at i on ser vi ces, secur i t i es
Quot at i on ser vi ces, st ock
Secur i t i es hol der s' pr ot ect i ve ser vi ces
Secur i t i es t r ansf er agenci es
St ock quot at i on ser vi ces
St ock t r ansf er agenci es
Tr ansf er agenci es, secur i t i es
III. Insur ance Indust r y
524113 - Di r ect Li f e Insur ance Car r i er s
Thi s U.S. i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n i ni t i al l y under wr i t i ng (i .e.,
assumi ng t he r i sk and assi gni ng pr emi ums) annui t i es and l i f e i nsur ance pol i ci es, di sabi l i t y i ncome
i nsur ance pol i ci es, and accident al deat h and di smember ment i nsur ance pol i ci es.
Acci dent al deat h and di smember ment i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Acci dent al deat h and di smember ment i nsur ance under wr i t i ng, di r ect
Annui t i es under wr i t i ng
Cooper at i ve l i f e i nsur ance or gani zat i ons
Cr edi t l i f e i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Di sabi l i t y i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Di sabi l i t y i nsur ance under wr i t i ng, di r ect
Fr at er nal l i f e i nsur ance or gani zat i ons
Insur ance car r i er s, di sabi l i t y, di r ect
Insur ance car r i er s, l i f e, di r ect
Insur ance under wr i t i ng, di sabi l i t y, di r ect
028 6
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-36 Filed 04/18/12 Page 10 of 15
10
Insur ance under wr i t i ng, l i f e, di r ect
Li f e i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Savi ngs bank l i f e i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
524114 - Di r ect Heal t h and Medi cal Insur ance Car r i er s
Thi s U.S. i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n i ni t i al l y under wr i t i ng (i .e.,
assumi ng t he r i sk and assi gni ng pr emi ums) heal t h and medi cal i nsur ance pol i ci es. Gr oup
hospi t al i zat i on pl ans and HMO est abl i shment s (except t hose pr ovi di ng heal t h car e ser vi ces) t hat
pr ovi de heal t h and medi cal i nsur ance pol i ci es wi t hout pr ovi di ng heal t h car e ser vi ces ar e i ncl uded
i n t hi s i ndust r y.
Dent al i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Gr oup hospi t al i zat i on pl ans wi t hout pr ovi di ng heal t h car e ser vi ces
Heal t h i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Hospi t al and medi cal ser vi ce pl ans, di r ect , wi t hout pr ovi di ng heal t h car e ser vi ces
Hospi t al i zat i on i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect , wi t hout pr ovi di ng heal t h car e ser vi ces
Insur ance car r i er s, heal t h, di r ect
Insur ance under wr i t i ng, heal t h and medi cal , di r ect
Medi cal i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Medi cal ser vi ce pl ans wi t hout pr ovi di ng heal t h car e ser vi ces
524126 - Di r ect Pr oper t y and Casual t y Insur ance Car r i er s
Thi s U.S. i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n i ni t i al l y under wr i t i ng (i .e.,
assumi ng t he r i sk and assi gni ng pr emi ums) i nsur ance pol i ci es t hat pr ot ect pol i cyhol der s agai nst
l osses t hat may occur as a r esul t of pr oper t y damage or l i abi l i t y.
Agr i cul t ur al (i .e., cr op, l i vest ock) i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Aut omobi l e i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Bondi ng, f i del i t y or sur et y i nsur ance, di r ect
Bur gl ar y and t hef t i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Casual t y i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Cr edi t and ot her f i nanci al r esponsi bi l i t y i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Cr op i nsur ance car r i er , di r ect
Fi del i t y i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Fi r e i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Homeowner s' i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Insur ance car r i er s, f i del i t y, di r ect
Insur ance car r i er s, pr oper t y and casual t y, di r ect
Insur ance car r i er s, sur et y, di r ect
Insur ance under wr i t i ng, pr oper t y and casual t y, di r ect
Li abi l i t y i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Mal pr act i ce i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Mar i ne i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Mor t gage guar ant y i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Pl at e gl ass i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Pr oper t y and casual t y i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Pr oper t y damage i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Sur et y i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Wor ker s' compensat i on i nsur ance under wr i t i ng
524127 - Di r ect Ti t l e Insur ance Car r i er s
Thi s U.S. i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n i ni t i al l y under wr i t i ng (i .e.,
assumi ng t he r i sk and assi gni ng pr emi ums) i nsur ance pol i ci es t o pr ot ect t he owner s of r eal est at e
or r eal est at e cr edi t or s agai nst l oss sust ai ned by r eason of any t i t l e def ect t o r eal pr oper t y.
028 68
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-36 Filed 04/18/12 Page 11 of 15
11
Guar ant eei ng t i t l es
Insur ance car r i er s, t i t l e, di r ect
Insur ance under wr i t i ng, t i t l e, di r ect
Real est at e t i t l e i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Ti t l e i nsur ance car r i er s, r eal est at e, di r ect
524128 - Ot her Di r ect Insur ance (except Li f e, Heal t h, and Medi cal ) Car r i er s
Thi s U.S. i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n i ni t i al l y under wr i t i ng (e.g.,
assumi ng t he r i sk, assi gni ng pr emi ums) i nsur ance pol i ci es (except l i f e, di sabi l i t y i ncome, acci dent al
deat h and di smember ment , heal t h and medi cal , pr oper t y and casual t y, and t i t l e i nsur ance
pol i ci es).
Bank deposi t i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Bur i al i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Cont act l ens i nsur ance, di r ect
Deposi t or shar e i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Funer al i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Homeowner s' war r ant y i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Pet heal t h i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
Pr oduct war r ant y i nsur ance car r i er s, di r ect
War r ant y i nsur ance car r i er s (e.g., appl i ance, aut omobi l e, homeowner s, pr oduct ),
di r ect
524130 - Rei nsur ance Car r i ers
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n assumi ng al l or par t of t he r i sk
associ at ed wi t h exi st i ng i nsur ance pol i ci es or i gi nal l y under wr i t t en by ot her i nsur ance car r i er s.
Acci dent al and heal t h r ei nsur ance car r i er s
Li f e r ei nsur ance car r i er s
Mar i ne r ei nsur ance car r i er s
Medi cal r ei nsur ance car r i er s
Pr oper t y and casual t y r ei nsur ance car r i er s
Rei nsur ance car r i er s
524210 - Insur ance Agenci es and Br oker ages
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n act i ng as agent s (i .e., br oker s) i n
sel l ing annui t i es and i nsur ance pol i ci es.
Agenci es, i nsur ance
Br oker ages, i nsur ance
Br oker s' of f i ces, i nsur ance
Insur ance agenci es
Insur ance br oker ages
Lif e insur ance agenci es
524291 - Cl ai ms Adj ust i ng
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n i nvest i gat i ng, appr ai si ng, and set t l i ng
i nsur ance cl ai ms.
Cause-of -l oss i nvest i gat or s, i nsur ance
Cl ai ms adj ust i ng, i nsur ance
Fi r e i nvest i gat or s
Insur ance cl ai ms adj ust i ng
Insur ance cl ai ms i nvest i gat i on ser vi ces
Insur ance set t l ement of f i ces
Loss cont r ol consul t ant s
524292 - Thi r d Par t y Admi ni st r at i on of Insur ance and Pensi on Funds
028 6
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-36 Filed 04/18/12 Page 12 of 15
12
Thi s U.S. i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n pr ovi di ng t hi r d par t y
admi ni st r at i on ser vi ces of i nsur ance and pensi on f unds, such as cl ai ms pr ocessi ng and ot her
admi ni st r at i ve ser vi ces t o i nsur ance car r i er s, empl oyee-benef i t pl ans, and sel f -i nsur ance f unds.
Clai ms pr ocessi ng ser vi ces, i nsur ance, t hi r d-par t y
Empl oyee benef i t pl ans, t hi r d-par t y admi ni st r at i ve pr ocessi ng ser vi ces
Insur ance cl ai ms pr ocessi ng ser vi ces, t hi r d par t y
Insur ance f und, t hi r d par t y admi ni st r at i ve ser vi ces (except cl ai ms adj ust i ng onl y)
Insur ance pl an admi ni st r at i ve ser vi ces (except cl ai ms adj ust i ng onl y), t hi r d-par t y
Pensi on f und, t hi r d par t y admi ni st r at i ve ser vi ces
524298 - Al l Ot her Insur ance Rel at ed Act i vi t i es
Thi s U.S. i ndust r y compr i ses est abl i shment s pr i mar i l y engaged i n pr ovi di ng i nsur ance ser vi ces on a
cont r act or f ee basi s (except i nsur ance agenci es and br oker ages, cl ai ms adj ust i ng, and t hi r d par t y
admi ni st r at i on). Insur ance advi sor y ser vi ces and i nsur ance r at emaki ng ser vi ces ar e i ncl uded i n t hi s
i ndust r y.
Act uar i al ser vi ces, i nsur ance
Insur ance act uar i al ser vi ces
Insur ance advi sor y ser vi ces
Insur ance cover age consul t i ng ser vi ces
Insur ance exchanges
Insur ance i nvest i gat i on ser vi ces (except cl ai ms i nvest i gat i on)
Insur ance l oss pr event i on ser vi ces
Insur ance pr ocessi ng, cont r act or f ee basi s
Insur ance r at e maki ng ser vi ces
Insur ance r epor t i ng ser vi ces
Insur ance under wr i t er s l abor at or i es and st andar ds ser vi ces
Medi cal cost eval uat i on ser vi ces
Rat e maki ng ser vi ces, i nsur ance
IV. Funds, Tr ust s, and Ot her Fi nanci al Vehi cl es
525110 - Pensi on Funds
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses l egal ent i t i es (i .e., f unds, pl ans, and/ or pr ogr ams) or gani zed t o pr ovi de
r et i r ement i ncome benef i t s excl usi vel y f or t he sponsor ' s empl oyees or member s.
Empl oyee benef i t pensi on pl ans
Funds, empl oyee benef i t pensi on
Funds, pensi on
Pensi on f unds
Pensi on pl ans (e.g., empl oyee benef i t , r et i r ement )
Pl ans, pensi on
Ret i r ement pensi on pl ans
Uni on pensi on f unds
525120 - Heal t h and Wel f ar e Funds
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses l egal ent i t i es (i .e., f unds, pl ans, and/ or pr ogr ams) or gani zed t o pr ovi de
medi cal , sur gi cal , hospi t al , vacat i on, t r ai ni ng, and ot her heal t h- and wel f ar e-r el at ed empl oyee
benef i t s excl usi vel y f or t he sponsor ' s empl oyees or member s.
Empl oyee benef i t pl ans (except pensi on)
Funds, heal t h and wel f ar e
Heal t h and wel f ar e f unds
Pl ans, heal t h and wel f ar e r el at ed empl oyee benef i t
Uni on heal t h and wel f ar e f unds
028 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-36 Filed 04/18/12 Page 13 of 15
13
525190 - Ot her Insur ance Funds
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses l egal ent i t i es (i .e., f unds (except pensi on, and heal t h- and wel f ar e-r el at ed
empl oyee benef i t f unds)) or gani zed t o pr ovi de i nsur ance excl usi vel y f or t he sponsor , f i r m, or i t s
empl oyees or member s. Sel f -i nsur ance f unds (except empl oyee benef i t f unds) and wor ker s'
compensat i on i nsur ance f unds ar e i ncl uded i n t hi s i ndust r y.
Compensat i on, wor ker s, i nsur ance f unds
Funds, sel f -i nsur ance (except empl oyee benef i t f unds)
Sel f -i nsur ance f unds (except empl oyee benef i t f unds)
Wor ker s' compensat i on i nsur ance f unds
525910 - Open-End Invest ment Funds
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses l egal ent i t i es (i .e., open-end i nvest ment f unds) or gani zed t o pool asset s
t hat consi st of secur i t i es or ot her f inancial inst r ument s. Shar es in t hese pool s ar e of f er ed t o t he
publ i c i n an i ni t i al of f er i ng wi t h addi t i onal shar es of f er ed cont i nuousl y and per pet ual l y and
r edeemed at a specif ic pr ice det er mined by t he net asset value.
Funds, mut ual , open-ended
Invest ment f unds, open-ended
M oney mar ket mut ual f unds, open-ended
M ut ual f unds, open-ended
525920 - Tr ust s, Est at es, and Agency Account s [ Except t o t he ext ent a Tr ust ee or Cust odi an of a Tr ust
whose benef i ci ar i es ar e one or mor e Nat ur al Per sons, or an execut or of an est at e of a Nat ur al Per son,
or a guar di an of a Nat ur al Per son asser t s ot her wi se per mi t t ed cl ai ms.]
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses l egal ent i t i es, t r ust s, est at es, or agency account s, admi ni st er ed on beh al f
of t he benef i ci ar i es under t he t er ms of a t r ust agr eement , wi l l , or agency agr eement .
Bankr upt cy est at es
Per sonal est at es (i .e., managi ng asset s)
Per sonal i nvest ment t r ust s
Per sonal t r ust s
Pr i vat e est at es (i .e., admi ni st er i ng on behal f of benef i ci ar i es)
Test ament ar y t r ust s
Tr ust s, est at es, and agency account s
525990 - Ot her Fi nanci al Vehi cl es
Thi s i ndust r y compr i ses l egal ent i t i es (i .e., f unds (except i nsur ance and empl oyee benef i t f unds;
open-end i nvest ment f unds; t r ust s, est at es, and agency account s)). Incl uded i n t hi s i ndust r y ar e
mor t gage Real Est at e Invest ment Tr ust s (REITs). Il l ust r at i ve Exampl es: Cl osed-end i nvest ment
f unds Speci al pur pose vehi cl es Col l at er al i zed Mor t gage Obl i gat i ons (CM Os) Uni t i nvest ment t r ust
f unds Face-amount cer t i f i cat e f unds Mor t gage r eal est at e i nvest ment t r ust s (REITs) Real Est at e
Mor t gage Invest ment Condui t s (REMICs).
Closed-end i nvest ment f unds
CMOs (col l at er al i zed mor t gage obl i gat i ons)
Col l at er al i zed mor t gage obl i gat i ons (CMOs)
Face-amount cer t i f i cat e f unds
Funds, mut ual , cl osed-end
Invest ment f unds, cl osed-end
M oney mar ket mut ual f unds, cl osed-end
Mor t gage r eal est at e i nvest ment t r ust s (REITs)
M ut ual f unds, cl osed-end
Pr of i t -shar i ng f unds
Real est at e mor t gage i nvest ment condui t s (REMICs)
REMICs (r eal est at e mor t gage i nvest ment condui t s)
028
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-36 Filed 04/18/12 Page 14 of 15
14
Speci al pur pose f i nanci al vehi cl es
Uni t i nvest ment t r ust f unds
V. Def ense Cont r act ors and Thei r Sub-Cont r act ors and Suppl i er s
Cl ai ms f rom busi nesses and t hei r employees f or whi ch at l east 50% of annual r evenue i s gener at ed f rom
cont r act s wi t h t he Uni t ed St at es Depart ment of Def ense wi l l be consi der ed def ense cont r act or s.
VI. Real Est at e Devel oper s or Sel l ers
See Agreement sect i ons 2.2.4.7 and 5.9.3.
028 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-36 Filed 04/18/12 Page 15 of 15
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-37 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 20
1/ 19
2/ 19
3/ 19
Thi si ndust r ycompr i sesest abl i shment spr i mar i l yengagedi nsi t epr epar at i onact i vi t i es,suchasexcavat i ngand
gr adi ng,demol i t i onof bui l di ngsandot her st r uct ur es,sept i csyst emi nst al l at i on,andhousemovi ng.Ear t hmovi ng
andl andcl ear i ngf or al l t ypesof si t es(e.g.,bui l di ng,nonbui l di ng,mi ni ng)i si ncl udedi nt hi si ndust r y.
Est abl i shment spr i mar i l yengagedi nconst r uct i onequi pment r ent al w i t hoper at or (except cr anes)ar eal so
i ncl uded.
Aer i al or pi cker t r uck,const r uct i on,r ent al w i t hoper at or
Backf i l l i ng,const r uct i on
Backhoer ent al w i t hoper at or
Bl ast hol edr i l l i ng(except mi ni ng)
Bl ast i ng,bui l di ngdemol i t i on
Bl ast i ng,const r uct i onsi t e
Bor i ng,f or bui l di ngconst r uct i on
Bui l di ngdemol i t i on
Bul l dozer r ent al w i t hoper at or
Cai sson(i .e.,dr i l l edbui l di ngf oundat i ons)const r uct i on
Cesspool const r uct i on
Concr et ebr eaki ngandcut t i ngf or demol i t i on
Const r uct i onequi pment (except cr ane)r ent al w i t hoper at or
X Cor edr i l l i ngandt est bor i ngf or const r uct i on
Cr aw l er t r act or r ent al w i t hoper at or
Cut t i ngnew r i ght sof w ay
Demol i t i oncont r act or
Demol i t i on,bui l di ngandst r uct ur e
Dew at er i ngcont r act or s
Di ggi ngf oundat i ons
Di r t movi ngf or const r uct i on
X Di smant l i ngengi neer i ngst r uct ur es(e.g.,oi l st or aget ank)
Dr ai nagesyst em(e.g.,cesspool ,sept i ct ank)i nst al l at i on
Dr i l l edpi er (i .e.,f or bui l di ngf oundat i ons)cont r act or s
Dr i l l edshaf t (i .e.,dr i l l edbui l di ngf oundat i ons)const r uct i on
Dr yw el l const r uct i on
Equi pment r ent al (except cr ane),const r uct i on,wi t hoper at or
Excavat i ng,ear t hmovi ngor l andcl ear i ng,mi ni ng(except over bur denr emoval at openpi t mi nesi t esor
quar r i es)
Excavat i ng,ear t hmovi ng,or l andcl ear i ngcont r act or s
Excavat i oncont r act or s
Foundat i ondi ggi ng(i .e.,excavat i on)
Foundat i ondr i l l i ngcont r act or s
Gr adi ngconst r uct i onsi t es
Gr aveexcavat i oncont r act or s
Gr oundt haw i ngf or const r uct i onsi t edi ggi ng
Housedemol i shi ng
Houser azi ng
Hydr odemol i t i on(i .e.,demol i t i onw i t hpr essur i zedw at er )cont r act or s
Landcl ear i ng
Landl evel i ngcont r act or s
Li nesl ashi ngor cut t i ng(except mai nt enance)
M achi ner y,const r uct i on(except cr anes),r ent al w i t hoper at or
X M i nesi t epr epar at i onandr el at edconst r uct i onact i vi t i es,const r uct i oncont r act or s
Pi l edr i vi ng,bui l di ngf oundat i on
Pi l i ng(i .e.,bor ed,cast i npl ace,dr i l l ed),bui l di ngf oundat i on,cont r act or s
0266
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-37 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 20
4/ 19
5/ 19
6/ 19
7/ 19
8/ 19
9/ 19
10/ 19
Thi sU.S.i ndust r ycompr i sesest abl i shment spr i mar i l yengagedi nmanuf act ur i nggener al pur posepumpsand
pumpi ngequi pment (except f l ui dpow er pumpsandmot or s),suchasr eci pr ocat i ngpumps,t ur bi nepumps,
cent r i f ugal pumps,r ot ar ypumps,di aphr agmpumps,domest i cw at er syst empumps,oi l w el l andoi l f i el dpumps
andsumppumps.
Cent r i f ugal pumpsmanuf act ur i ng
X Oi l w el l andoi l f i el dpumpsmanuf act ur i ng
X Pumps(except f l ui dpow er ),gener al pur pose,manuf act ur i ng
Pumpsf or r ai l r oadequi pment l ubr i cat i onsyst emsmanuf act ur i ng
X Pumps,i ndust r i al andcommer ci al t ype,gener al pur pose,manuf act ur i ng
X Pumps,oi l f i el dor w el l ,manuf act ur i ng
Pumps,sumpor w at er ,r esi dent i al t ype,manuf act ur i ng
Sumppumps,r esi dent i al t ype,manuf act ur i ng
336611Shi pBui ldi ngandRepai r i ng
Thi sU.S.i ndust r ycompr i sesest abl i shment spr i mar i l yengagedi noper at i ngashi pyar d.Shi pyar dsar ef i xedf aci l i t i es
w i t hdr ydocksandf abr i cat i onequi pment capabl eof bui l di ngashi p,def i nedasw at er cr af t t ypi cal l ysui t abl eor
i nt endedf or ot her t hanper sonal or r ecr eat i onal use.Act i vi t i esof shi pyar dsi ncl udet heconst r uct i onof shi ps,t hei r
r epai r ,conver si onandal t er at i on,t hepr oduct i onof pr ef abr i cat edshi pandbar gesect i ons,andspeci al i zedser vi ces,
suchasshi pscal i ng.
Bar gebui l di ng
Car goshi pbui l di ng
Cont ai ner shi pbui l di ng
Dr edgebui l di ng
X Dr i l l i ngandpr oduct i onpl at f or ms,f l oat i ng,oi l andgas,bui l di ng
Dr ydock,f l oat i ng,bui l di ng
Fer r yboat bui l di ng
Fi r eboat bui l di ng
Fi shi ngboat ,commer ci al ,bui l di ng
Hydr of oi l vessel bui l di ngandr epai r i ngi nshi pyar d
Naval shi pbui l di ng
X Oi l andgasof f shor ef l oat i ngpl at f or msmanuf act ur i ng
Passenger shi pbui l di ng
Pat r ol boat bui l di ng
Sai l i ngshi ps,commer ci al ,manuf act ur i ng
Shi pdi smant l i ngat shi pyar ds
Shi pr epai r donei nashi pyar d
Shi pscal i ngser vi cesdoneat ashi pyar d
Shi ps(i .e.,not sui t abl eor i nt endedf or per sonal use)manuf act ur i ng
Shi pyar d(i .e.,f aci l i t ycapabl eof bui l di ngshi ps)
Submar i nebui l di ng
Tow boat bui l di ngandr epai r i ng
Tugboat bui l di ng
Yacht sbui l t i nshi pyar ds
423830Indust r i al M achi neryandEqui pment M er chant Whol esal er s
Thi si ndust r ycompr i sesest abl i shment spr i mar i l yengagedi nt hemer chant w hol esal edi st r i but i onof speci al i zed
machi ner y,equi pment ,andr el at edpar t sgener al l yusedi nmanuf act ur i ng,oi l w el l ,andw ar ehousi ngact i vi t i es.
Baker ymachi ner yandequi pment mer chant w hol esal er s
Bever agebot t l i ngmachi ner ymer chant w hol esal er s
Bl ow er s,i ndust r i al ,mer chant w hol esal er s
Bot t l i ngmachi ner yandequi pment mer chant w hol esal er s
Cement maki ngmachi ner ymer chant w hol esal er s
026622
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-37 Filed 04/18/12 Page 11 of 20
11/ 19
12/ 19
X Ref i ner ymachi ner yandequi pment mer chant w hol esal er s
Saw mi l l machi ner y,equi pment ,andsuppl i esmer chant w hol esal er s
Sew i ngmachi nes,i ndust r i al ,mer chant w hol esal er s
Shoemanuf act ur i ngandr epai r i ngmachi ner ymer chant w hol esal er s
Smel t i ngmachi ner yandequi pment mer chant w hol esal er s
Speci al pur posei ndust r i al machi ner yandequi pment mer chant w hol esal er s
Spr aypai nt i ngequi pment ,i ndust r i al t ype,mer chant w hol esal er s
St acker s,i ndust r i al ,mer chant w hol esal er s
Test i ngandmeasur i ngequi pment ,el ect r i cal (except aut omot i ve),mer chant w hol esal er s
Text i l emachi ner yandequi pment mer chant w hol esal er s
Ti r er ecappi ngmachi ner ymer chant w hol esal er s
Tool s,machi ni st s' pr eci si on,mer chant w hol esal er s
Tr act or s,i ndust r i al ,mer chant w hol esal er s
Tr ai l er s,i ndust r i al ,mer chant w hol esal er s
Tr ucks,i ndust r i al ,mer chant w hol esal er s
Tur bi nes(except t r anspor t at i on)mer chant w hol esal er s
Tw i st dr i l l smer chant w hol esal er s
Val ves,hydr aul i candpneumat i c,mer chant w hol esal er s
W at er t r eat ment equi pment ,i ndust r i al ,mer chant w hol esal er s
W el di ngmachi ner yandequi pment mer chant w hol esal er s
W i nchesmer chant w hol esal er s
W oodw or ki ngmachi ner ymer chant w hol esal er s
424690Ot her Chemi cal andAl l i edPr oduct sM er chant Whol esal er s
Thi si ndust r ycompr i sesest abl i shment spr i mar i l yengagedi nt hemer chant w hol esal edi st r i but i onof chemi cal sand
al l i edpr oduct s(except agr i cul t ur al andmedi ci nal chemi cal s,pai nt sandvar ni shes,f i r ewor ks,andpl ast i csmat er i al s
andbasi cf or msandshapes).
Aci dsmer chant w hol esal er s
Adhesi vesandseal ant smer chant w hol esal er s
Al cohol ,i ndust r i al ,mer chant w hol esal er s
Al kal i esmer chant w hol esal er s
Ammoni a(except f er t i l i zer mat er i al )mer chant w hol esal er s
Ant i f r eezemer chant w hol esal er s
Ar omat i cchemi cal smer chant w hol esal er s
Aut omot i vechemi cal s(except l ubr i cat i nggr eases,l ubr i cat i onoi l s)mer chant w hol esal er s
Bl eachesmer chant w hol esal er s
Car bonbl ackmer chant w hol esal er s
Caul ki ngmat er i al smer chant w hol esal er s
Caust i csodamer chant w hol esal er s
X Chemi cal addi t i ves(e.g.,concr et e,f ood,f uel ,oi l )mer chant w hol esal er s
Chemi cal gasesmer chant w hol esal er s
Chemi cal s(except agr i cul t ur e)(e.g.,aut omot i ve,househol d,i ndust r i al ,phot ogr aphi c)mer chant
w hol esal er s
Cl eani ngcompoundsandpr epar at i onsmer chant w hol esal er s
Coal t ar pr oduct s,pr i mar yandi nt er medi at e,mer chant w hol esal er s
Compr essedgases(except LPgas)mer chant w hol esal er s
X Concr et eaddi t i vesmer chant w hol esal er s
Cycl i ccr udesandi nt er medi at esmer chant whol esal er s
Deodor ant s(except per sonal )mer chant w hol esal er s
Det er gent smer chant w hol esal er s
X Dr i l l i ngmudsmer chant w hol esal er s
02662
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-37 Filed 04/18/12 Page 13 of 20
13/ 19
14/ 19
Thi sU.S.i ndust r ycompr i sesest abl i shment spr i mar i l yengagedi npr ovi di ngai r t r anspor t at i onof passenger sor
passenger sandcar gowi t hnor egul ar r out esandr egul ar schedul es.
X Ai r passenger car r i er s,nonschedul ed
X Ai r t axi ser vi ces
X Ai r cr af t char t er ser vi ces,passenger
X Char t er ai r passenger ser vi ces
X Hel i copt er passenger car r i er s(except sceni c,si ght seei ng),nonschedul ed
X Nonschedul edai r passenger t r anspor t at i on
X Passenger ai r t r anspor t at i on,nonschedul ed
X Passenger car r i er s,ai r ,nonschedul ed
483113Coast al andGreat LakesFr ei ght Tr anspor t at i on
Thi sU.S.i ndust r ycompr i sesest abl i shment spr i mar i l yengagedi npr ovi di ngw at er t r anspor t at i onof car goi ncoast al
w at er s,ont heGr eat LakesSyst em,or deepseasbet w eenpor t sof t heUni t edSt at es,Puer t oRi co,andUni t ed
St at esi sl andpossessi onsor pr ot ect or at es.M ar i net r anspor t at i onest abl i shment susi ngt hef aci l i t i esof t heSt .
Law r enceSeaw ayAut hor i t yCommi ssi onar econsi der edt obeusi ngt heGr eat LakesW at er Tr anspor t at i onSyst em.
Est abl i shment spr i mar i l yengagedi npr ovi di ngcoast al and/ or Gr eat Lakesbar get r anspor t at i onser vi cesar e
i ncl udedi nt hi si ndust ry.
X Bar get r anspor t at i on,coast al or Gr eat Lakes(i ncl udi ngSt .Law r enceSeaway)
X Coast al f r ei ght t r anspor t at i ont oandf r omdomest i cpor t s
X Coast al shi ppi ngof f r ei ght t oandf r omdomest i cpor t s
X Deepseaf r ei ght t r anspor t at i ont oor f r omdomest i cpor t s(i ncl udi ngPuer t oRi co)
X Fr ei ght shi ppi ngont heGr eat Lakessyst em(i ncl udi ngSt .Law r enceSeaw ay)
X Fr ei ght t r anspor t at i on,deepsea,t oandf r omdomest i cpor t s
X Gr eat Lakesf r ei ght t r anspor t at i on(i ncl udi ngSt .Law r enceSeaw ay)
X Int er coast al f r ei ght t r anspor t at i ont oandf r omdomest i cpor t s
X Lakef r ei ght t r anspor t at i on,Gr eat Lakes(i ncl udi ngSt .Lawr enceSeaw ay)
X Shi pchar t er i ngw i t hcr ew ,coast al or Gr eat Lakesf r ei ght t ranspor t at i on(i ncl udi ngSt .Law r enceSeaw ay)
X Shi ppi ngf r ei ght t oandf r omdomest i cpor t s(i .e.,coast al ,deepsea(i ncl udi ngPuer t oRi co),Gr eat Lakes
syst em(i ncl udi ngSt .Law r enceSeaw ay))
532412Const r uct i on,M i ni ng,andFor est r yM achi ner yandEqui pment Rent al andLeasi ng
Thi sU.S.i ndust r ycompr i sesest abl i shment spr i mar i l yengagedi nr ent i ngor l easi ngheavyequi pment w i t hout
oper at or st hat maybeusedf or const r uct i on,mi ni ng,or f or est r y,suchasbul l dozer s,ear t hmovi ngequi pment ,w el l
dr i l l i ngmachi ner yandequi pment ,or cr anes.
Bul l dozer r ent al or l easi ngw i t hout oper at or
Const r uct i onf or mr ent al
Const r uct i onmachi ner yandequi pment r ent al or l easi ngw i t hout oper at or
X Cr aner ent al or l easi ngw i t hout oper at or
Ear t hmovi ngequi pment r ent al or l easi ngw i t hout oper at or
For est r ymachi ner yandequi pment r ent al or l easi ng
Heavyconst r uct i onequi pment r ent al w i t hout oper at or
Loggi ngequi pment r ent al or l easi ngw i t hout oper at or
M i ni ngmachi ner yandequi pment r ent al or l easi ng
X Oi l f i el dmachi ner yandequi pment r ent al or l easi ng
X Oi l w el l dr i l l i ngmachi ner yandequi pment r ent al or l easi ng
W el di ngequi pment r ent al or l easi ng
X W el l dr i l l i ngmachi ner yandequi pment r ent al or l easi ng
541330Engi neer i ngSer vi ces
026626
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-37 Filed 04/18/12 Page 15 of 20
15/ 19
Thi si ndust r ycompr i sesest abl i shment spr i mar i l yengagedi nappl yi ngphysi cal l aw sandpr i nci pl esof engi neer i ngi n
t hedesi gn,devel opment ,andut i l i zat i onof machi nes,mat er i al s,i nst r ument s,st r uct ur es,pr ocesses,andsyst ems.
Theassi gnment sunder t akenbyt heseest abl i shment smayi nvol veanyof t hef ol l ow i ngact i vi t i es:pr ovi si onof
advi ce,pr epar at i onof f easi bi l i t yst udi es,pr epar at i onof pr el i mi nar yandf i nal pl ansanddesi gns,pr ovi si onof
t echni cal ser vi cesdur i ngt heconst r uct i onor i nst al l at i onphase,i nspect i onandeval uat i onof engi neer i ngpr oj ect s,
andr el at edser vi ces.
Acoust i cal engi neer i ngconsul t i ngser vi ces
Acoust i cal syst emengi neer i ngdesi gnser vi ces
Boat engi neer i ngdesi gnser vi ces
Chemi cal engi neer i ngser vi ces
Ci vi l engi neer i ngser vi ces
Combust i onengi neer i ngconsul t i ngser vi ces
Const r uct i onengi neer i ngser vi ces
Consul t i ngengi neer s' of f i ces
Consul t i ngengi neer s' pr i vat epr act i ces
El ect r i cal engi neer i ngser vi ces
Engi neer i ngconsul t i ngser vi ces
Engi neer i ngdesi gnser vi ces
Engi neer i ngser vi ces
Engi neer s' of f i ces
Engi neer s' pr i vat epr act i ces
X Envi r onment al engi neer i ngser vi ces
Er osi oncont r ol engi neer i ngser vi ces
X Geol ogi cal engi neer i ngser vi ces
X Geophysi cal engi neer i ngser vi ces
Heat i ngengi neer i ngconsul t i ngser vi ces
Indust r i al engi neer i ngser vi ces
Loggi ngengi neer i ngser vi ces
X M ar i neengi neer i ngser vi ces
M echani cal engi neer i ngser vi ces
X M i ni ngengi neer i ngser vi ces
X Pet r ol eumengi neer i ngser vi ces
Tr af f i cengi neer i ngconsul t i ngser vi ces
541360Geophysi cal Sur veyi ngandM appi ngSer vi ces
Thi si ndust r ycompr i sesest abl i shment spr i mar i l yengagedi ngat her i ng,i nt er pr et i ng,andmappi nggeophysi cal
dat a.Est abl i shment si nt hi si ndust r yof t enspeci al i zei nl ocat i ngandmeasur i ngt heext ent of subsur f acer esour ces,
suchasoi l ,gas,andmi ner al s,but t heymayal soconduct sur veysf or engi neer i ngpur poses.Est abl i shment si nt hi s
i ndust r yuseavar i et yof sur veyi ngt echni quesdependi ngont hepur poseof t hesur vey,i ncl udi ngmagnet i csur veys,
gr avi t ysur veys,sei smi csur veys,or el ect r i cal andel ect r omagnet i csur veys.
X Aer i al geophysi cal sur veyi ngser vi ces
X El ect r i cal geophysi cal sur veyi ngser vi ces
X El ect r omagnet i cgeophysi cal sur veyi ngser vi ces
X Geol ogi cal sur veyi ngser vi ces
X Geophysi cal mappi ngser vi ces
X Geophysi cal sur veyi ngser vi ces
X Gr avi t ygeophysi cal sur veyi ngser vi ces
X M agnet i cgeophysi cal sur veyi ngser vi ces
X M appi ngser vi ces,geophysi cal
X Radi oact i vegeophysi cal sur veyi ngser vi ces
X Remot esensi nggeophysi cal sur veyi ngser vi ces
02662
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-37 Filed 04/18/12 Page 16 of 20
16/ 19
17/ 19
II. Indust r yTypesSubj ect t oQuest i onRegar di ngSuppor t Ser vi cest oOi l &GasIndust r y
andPossi bl eRevi ewbyCl ai msAdmi ni st r at orf or Pot ent i al M or at or i aLosses
For busi nessest heCl ai msAdmi ni st r at or det er mi nesf al l w i t hi nt hef ol l ow i ngcodesanddescr i pt i ons
mar kedw i t han x, cl ai mant m ust subm i t asw or ncl ai mf or mansw er i ngt hi squest i on: In2009,di d
your busi nesspr ovi desi gni f i cant ser vi ces,goods,and/ or suppl i est obusi nessesi nt heof f shor eoi l & gas
i ndust r yi nt heGul f of M exi co? If t hecl ai mant r espondsaf f i r mat i vel y,i t scl ai m shal l ber out edbyt he
Cl ai msAdmi ni st r at or t oat eamdedi cat edt ot heeval uat i onof busi nesseconomi cl osscl ai msf or
pot ent i al mor at or i al osses.Cl ai mant shal l ber equi r edt opr ovi desuppl ement al i nf or mat i oni nor der f or
Cl ai msAdmi ni st r at or t oconduct t hi sr evi ew .
488310Port andHar borOper at i ons
Thi si ndust r ycompr i sesest abl i shment spr i mar i l yengagedi noper at i ngpor t s,har bor s(i ncl udi ngdocki ngandpi er
f aci l i t i es),or canal s.
X Canal mai nt enanceser vi ces(except dr edgi ng)
X Canal oper at i on
X Docki ngf aci l i t yoper at i ons
X Har bor mai nt enanceser vi ces(except dr edgi ng)
X Har bor oper at i on
X Li ght houseoper at i on
X M ai nt enanceser vi ces,w at er f r ont t er mi nal (except dr edgi ng)
X Por t f aci l i t yoper at i on
X Seaw ayoper at i on
X W at er f r ont t er mi nal oper at i on(e.g.,docks,pi er s,w har ves)
X W har f oper at i on
488320M ar i neCargoHandl i ng
Thi si ndust r ycompr i sesest abl i shment spr i mar i l yengagedi npr ovi di ngst evedor i ngandot her mar i necar go
handl i ngser vi ces(except w ar ehousi ng).
X Loadi ngandunl oadi ngser vi cesat por t sandhar bor s
X Longshor emenser vi ces
X M ar i necar gohandl i ngser vi ces
02662
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-37 Filed 04/18/12 Page 18 of 20
18/ 19
19/ 19
Thi si ndust r ycompr i sesest abl i shment spr i mar i l yengagedi npr ovi di ngdayt odaybusi nessandot her
or gani zat i onal suppor t ser vi ces(except of f i ceadmi ni st r at i veser vi ces,f aci l i t i essuppor t ser vi ces,empl oyment
ser vi ces,busi nesssuppor t ser vi ces,t r avel ar r angement andr eser vat i onser vi ces,secur i t yandi nvest i gat i on
ser vi ces,ser vi cest obui l di ngsandot her st r uct ur es,packagi ngandl abel i ngser vi ces,andconvent i onandt r ade
show or gani zi ngser vi ces).Il l ust r at i veExampl es:Bar t er i ngser vi cesFl aggi ng(i .e.,t r af f i ccont r ol )ser vi cesBot t l e
exchangesFl oat decor at i ngser vi cesCl ot hcut t i ng,bol t i ng,or w i ndi ngf or t het r adeInvent or yt aki ngser vi ces
Cont r act met er r eadi ngser vi cesLumber gr adi ngser vi cesDi vi ngser vi cesonacont r act or f eebasi s.
Auct i oneer s,i ndependent
Bar t er i ngser vi ces
Bot t l eexchanges
Cl ot hcut t i ng,bol t i ng,or w i ndi ngf or t het r ade
Coi npi ckupser vi ces,par ki ngmet er
Couponpr ocessi ngser vi ces
Couponr edempt i onser vi ces(i .e.,cl ear i nghouse)
X Di vi ngser vi cesonacont r act or f eebasi s
Document shr eddi ngser vi ces
El ect r i cal met er r eadi ngser vi ces,cont r act
Fi r ef i ght i ngser vi cesasacommer ci al act i vi t y
Fl aggi ng(i .e.,t r af f i ccont r ol )ser vi ces
Fl oat decor at i ngser vi ces
Gasmet er r eadi ngser vi ces,cont r act
Invent or ycomput i ngser vi ces
Invent or yt aki ngser vi ces
Li censei ssui ngser vi ces(except gover nment ),mot or vehi cl e
Locat i ngunder gr oundut i l i t yl i nespr i or t odi ggi ng
Lumber gr adi ngser vi ces
M et er r eadi ngser vi ces,cont r act
M ot or vehi cl el i censei ssui ngser vi ces,pr i vat ef r anchi se
Pr i nt i ngbr oker s
Pr i vat evol unt eer f i r ef i ght i ng
Tapesl i t t i ng(e.g.,cut t ingpl ast i cor l eat her i nt ow i dt hs)f or t het r ade
Text i l ecut t i ngser vi ces
Tr adi ngst amppr omot i onandsal et ost or es
Tr adi ngst ampr edempt i onser vi ces
722310FoodSer vi ceCont r act or s
Thi si ndust r ycompr i sesest abl i shment spr i mar i l yengagedi npr ovi di ngf oodser vi cesat i nst i t ut i onal ,gover nment al ,
commer ci al ,or i ndust r i al l ocat i onsof ot her sbasedoncont r act ual ar r angement sw i t ht heset ypeof or gani zat i ons
f or aspeci f i edper i odof t i me.Theest abl i shment sof t hi si ndust r ypr ovi def oodser vi cesf or t heconveni enceof t he
cont r act i ngor gani zat i onor t hecont r act i ngor gani zat i on' scust omer s.Thecont r act ual ar r angement of t hese
est abl i shment sw i t hcont r act i ngor gani zat i onsmayvar yf r omt ypeof f aci l i t yoper at ed(e.g.,caf et er i a,r est aur ant ,
f ast f oodeat i ngpl ace),r evenueshar i ng,cost st r uct ur e,t opr ovi di ngper sonnel .M anagement st af f i sal w ays
pr ovi dedbyt hef oodser vi cecont r act or s.
Ai r l i nef oodser vi cescont r act or s
Caf et er i af oodser vi cescont r act or s(e.g.,gover nment of f i cecaf et er i as,hospi t al caf et er i as,school
caf et er i as)
Foodconcessi oncont r act or s(e.g.,convent i onf aci l i t i es,ent er t ai nment f aci l i t i es,spor t i ngf aci l i t i es)
Foodser vi cecont r act or s,ai r l i ne
Foodser vi cecont r act or s,caf et er i a
Foodser vi cecont r act or s,concessi onoper at or (e.g.,convent i onf aci l i t i es,ent er t ai nment f aci l i t i es,spor t i ng
f aci l i t i es)
X Indust r i al cat er er s(i .e.,pr ovi di ngf oodser vi cesonacont r act ur al ar r angement (except si ngl eevent basi s))
0266
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-37 Filed 04/18/12 Page 20 of 20
20
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-38 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 6
Other Released Parties
Abdon Callais Offshore, Inc.
Admiral Robert J Papp Jr.
Admiral Thad Allen
Admiral Towing, LLC
Aerotek, Inc.
Airborne Support, Inc.
Airborne Support International, Inc.
Alford Safety Services Inc.
Alford Services Inc.
Ameri-Force, Inc.
Ameri-Force Craft Services, Inc.
American Pollution Control Corporation
Anadarko Petroleum Company
Anadarko Petroleum Corporation
Anadarko E&P Company LP
Apex Environmental Services, LLC
Art Catering, Inc.
Ashland Services, LLC
B&B Environmental Services, Inc.
Belle Chasse Marine Transportation, Inc.
BJ Services Company, USA
Blue Marlin Services of Acadiana, LLC
Bobby Lynn's Marina, Inc.
BP America Inc.
BP America Production Company
BP Company North America Inc.
BP Corporation North America Inc.
BP Energy Company
BP Exploration (Alaska) Inc.
BP Global Special Products (Americas) Inc.
BP Holdings North America Limited
BP Exploration & Production Inc.
BP p.l.c.
BP Products North America Inc.
BP International Ltd.
BP Corporation North America Inc. Savings Plan Investment Oversight Committee
Brett Cocales
Brian Morel
Cabildo Services, LLC
Cabildo Staffing, LLC
Cahaba Disaster Recovery LLC
Cal Dive International, Inc.
Cameron Corporation
Cameron International Corporation
Cameron International Corporation f/k/a Cooper Cameron Corporation
Cameron International Corporation d/b/a/ Cameron Systems Corporation
Center for Toxicology and Environmental Health L.L.C.
Chill Boats L.L.C.
Chouest Shorebase Services, LLC
Clean Harbors, Inc.
Clean Tank LLC
Clean Tank Inc.
Core Industries, Inc.
Core 4 Kebawk, LLC
0288
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-38 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 6
2
Crossmar, Inc.
Crowder/Gulf Joint Venture
Crowder Gulf Disaster Recovery
Danos and Curole Marine Contractors, LLC
Danos & Curole Staffing, L.L.C.
David Sims
Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill Trust
Diamond Offshore Company
DOF Subsea USA, Inc.
Don J. Vidrine
DRC Emergency Services, LLC
DRC Marine, LLC
DRC Recovery Services, LLC
Dril-Quip, Inc.
Dynamic Aviation Group, Inc.
Eastern Research Group, Inc.
Environmental Standards, Inc.
Environmental Safety & Health Consulting Services
Environmental Safety & Health Environmental Services
ES&H, Inc.
ESIS, Inc.
Exponent, Inc.
Faucheaux Brothers Airboat Services, Inc.
Global Diving & Salvage, Inc.
Global Employment Services, Inc.
Global Fabrication, LLC
Global Marine International, Inc.
Graham Gulf Inc.
Grand Isle Shipyard Inc.
Gregg Walz
Guilbeau Marine, Inc.
Guilbeau Boat Rentals, LLC
Gulfmark Offshore, Inc.
Gulf Offshore Logistics, LLC
Gulf Offshore Logistics International, LLC
Gulf Services Industrial, LLC
HEPACO, Inc.
Hilcorp Energy Company
Hyundai Heavy Industries Co. Ltd, Inc.
Hyundai Motor Company
I-Transit Response, L.L.C
International Air Response, Inc.
Island Ventures II, LLC
JMN Specialties, Inc.
JNB Operating LLC
John Guide
K & K Marine, LLC
LaBorde Marine Services, LLC
Lane Aviation
Lawson Environmental Service LLC
Lawson Environmental Service & Response Company
Lee Lambert
Lord Edmund John Browne
Lynden Air Cargo, LLC
Lynden, Inc.
Maco of Louisiana, LLC
0288 6
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-38 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 6
3
Maco Services, Inc.
Marine Spill Response Corporation
Mark Bly
Mark Hafle
M-I L.L.C.
M-I Drilling Fluids L.L.C.
M-I Swaco
Miller Environmental Group, Inc.
Mitchell Marine
Mitsui & Co. (USA), Inc.
Mitsui & Co. Ltd.
Mitsui Oil Exploration Co. Ltd.
ModuSpec USA, Inc.
Monica Ann LLC
Moran Environmental Recovery, LLC
MOEX Offshore 2007 LLC
MOEX USA Corporation
M/V Monica Ann
M/V Pat Tilman
M/V Damon B. Bankston
M/V Max Chouest
M/V Ocean Interventions
M/V C. Express
M/V Capt. David
M/V Joe Griffin
M/V Mr. Sidney
M/V Hilda Lab
M/V Premier Explorer
M/V Sailfish
M/V Seacor Washington
M/V Emerald Coast
M/V Admiral Lee
M/V Seacor Vanguard
M/V Whuppa Snappa
Nalco Energy Services, LP
Nalco Holding Company
Nalco Finance Holdings LLC
Nalco Finance Holdings Inc.
Nalco Holdings LLC
Nalco Company
National Response Corporation
Nature's Way Marine, LLC
Nautical Ventures, LLC
Nautical Solutions, LLC
OBriens Response Management, Inc.
Ocean Runner, Inc.
Ocean Therapy Solutions, LLC
Oceaneering International, Inc.
Odyssea Marine, Inc.
Offshore Cleaning Systems L.L.C.
Offshore Service Vessels, LLC
Offshore Inland Marine & Oilfield Services, Inc.
Oil Recovery Company, Inc. of Alabama
Oilfield Marine Contractors, LLC
Parsons Commercial Services Inc.
Parsons Services Company
0288
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-38 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 6
4
Parsons Facility Services Company
Parsons Corporation
Patriot Environmental Services Incorporated
Peneton Company
Perennial Contractors, LLC
Peneton Corporation
Production Services Network U.S., Inc.
Quality Container, Inc.
Quality Energy Services, Inc.
Ranger Offshore, Inc.
Reel Pipe, LLC
Resolve Marine Services, Inc.
Robert Kaluza
Ronald W. Sepulvado
Schlumberger, Ltd.
Seacor Holdings Inc.
Seacor Marine, LLC
Seacor Marine, Inc.
Seacor Marine International, Inc.
Seacor Offshore LLC
Seacor Worldwide, Inc.
Sealion Shipping LTD
Sea Support Services, L.L.C.
Sea Tow of South Miss, Inc.
Seafairer Boat, LLC
Shamrock Management LLC et al.
Shoreline Services, LLC
Siemens Financial, Inc.
Shoreline Construction, LLC
Smith Marine, Inc.
Southern Cat, Inc.
Southern Environmental of Louisiana, LLC
Stallion Offshore Quarters, Inc.
Subsea 7 LLC
Tamara's Group, LLC
Team Labor Force, LLC
Technical Marine Maintenance Services, L.L.C.
The Modern Group, Ltd.
The Modern Group GP-SUB, Inc.
The OBrien Group, LLC
The Response Group, Inc.
Tiburon Divers, Inc.
Tidewater, Inc.
Tidewater Marine LLC
Tiger Rentals, Ltd.
Tiger Safety, LLC
Toisa Limited
Total Safety U.S., Inc.
Twenty Grand Offshore, LLC
Twenty Grand Marine Service, LLC
Twenty Grand Offshore Inc.
USES/Construct Corps
United States Environmental Services, LLC
United States Maritime Services, Inc.
Viscardi Industrial Services, LLC
Weatherford International Ltd.
0288 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-38 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 6
5
Weatherford U.S. L.P.
Wood Group Production Services, Inc.
Worley Catastrophe Services, LLC
Worley Catastrophe Response, LLC
0288
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-38 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 6
2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-39 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 13
- 1 -
1. ASSIGNMENT AND PROTECTIONS.
1.1. The Parties have agreed to the terms of an assignment and certain protections for
Released Parties as set forth in this Attachment:
1.1.1. Satisfaction of Compensatory Damages. The Economic Class, Plaintiffs,
and all Economic Class Members agree and acknowledge that the
Settlement Payment(s), in addition to constituting consideration from the
Released Parties, also constitute full, complete, and total satisfaction of all
of their Compensatory Damages against the Transocean Parties and the
Halliburton Parties.
1.1.2. Protections for Released Parties. The Economic Class, Plaintiffs, and all
Economic Class Members promise, agree, acknowledge, represent, warrant,
and covenant as follows:
1.1.2.1. No Assignment of Economic Classs, Plaintiffs, or Economic Class
Members Claims or Reassignment of Assigned Claims. Neither the
Economic Class nor any Plaintiff or Economic Class Member shall assign
or reassign, or shall attempt to assign or reassign, to any person or entity
other than BP any rights or claims arising out of, due to, resulting from, or
relating in any way to, directly or indirectly, the Deepwater Horizon
Incident, including attempts to reassign the Assigned Claims. Any such
assignment or reassignment, or attempt to assign or reassign, to any person
or entity other than BP any rights or claims arising out of, due to, resulting
from, or relating in any way to, directly or indirectly, the Deepwater
Horizon Incident shall be void, invalid, and of no force and effect.
1.1.2.2. No Recovery of Additional Compensatory Damages. Neither the
Economic Class nor any Plaintiff or Economic Class Member shall accept
or attempt to recover, through insurance, reinsurance, indemnification,
contribution, subrogation, litigation, settlement, or otherwise, any
Compensatory Damages from the Transocean Parties and the Halliburton
028 8
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-39 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 13
2
Parties, except from Assigned Claims subject to the terms and conditions
of Section 1.1.2.4. Nothing in this Section 1.1.2.2 shall impair or impact
rights to pursue Transocean and Halliburton for exemplary and punitive
damages reserved by the Economic Class and Economic Class Members
in Sections 3.6, 3.7, 10.2, and 10.3 of the Agreement and claimed as either
individuals or members of the Economic Class.
1.1.2.3. Non-Execution and Non-Collection for Compensatory Damages. In
the event that the Economic Class or any of the Plaintiffs or Economic
Class Members is or becomes the beneficiary of any judgment, decision,
award, or settlement arising out of, due to, resulting from, or relating in
any way to, directly or indirectly, the Deepwater Horizon Incident, the
Economic Class and/or such Plaintiffs and/or Economic Class Members
shall not accept, execute on, attempt to collect, or otherwise seek recovery
of any Compensatory Damages from the Transocean Parties or from the
Halliburton Parties, except from Assigned Claims subject to the terms and
conditions of Section 1.1.2.4. Nothing in this Section 1.1.2.3 shall impair
or impact rights to pursue Transocean and Halliburton for exemplary and
punitive damages reserved by the Economic Class and Economic Class
Members in Sections 3.6, 3.7, 10.2, and 10.3 of the Agreement and
claimed as either individuals or members of the Economic Class.
1.1.2.4. Conditional Collection of Damages. In the event that the Economic
Class or any of the Plaintiffs and/or Economic Class Members is or
becomes the beneficiary of any judgment, decision, award, or settlement
arising out of, due to, resulting from, or relating in any way to, directly or
indirectly, the Deepwater Horizon Incident, including from Assigned
Claims and/or Expressly Reserved Claims, the Economic Class and/or
such Plaintiffs and/or Economic Class Members shall not accept, execute
on, attempt to collect, or otherwise seek recovery of any Damages, to the
extent that any Other Party is seeking or may seek to recover such
Damages from any Released Party, whether through indemnity,
028 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-39 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 13
3
contribution, subrogation, assignment, or any other theory of recovery, by
contract, pursuant to applicable law or regulation, or otherwise, directly or
indirectly. The Economic Class, Plaintiffs, and/or Economic Class
Members may, however, accept, execute on, attempt to collect, or
otherwise seek recovery of Damages if and when a court or tribunal of
competent jurisdiction has finally determined that Other Parties cannot
recover such Damages, whether through indemnity, contribution,
subrogation, assignment or any other theory of recovery, by contract,
pursuant to applicable law or regulation, or otherwise, directly or
indirectly, from any Released Party. For purposes of this Section 1.1.2.4,
finally determined shall mean the conclusion of any applicable appeals
or other rights to seek review by certiorari or otherwise, or the lapse of any
and all such rights, or the lapse of any and all applicable limitations or
repose periods.
1.1.2.5. Conditions on Future Settlements. The Economic Class, Plaintiffs,
and/or Economic Class Members may settle or compromise any rights,
demands, or claims with the Transocean Parties, the Halliburton Parties,
and/or any Other Parties arising out of, due to, resulting from, or relating
in any way to, directly or indirectly, the Deepwater Horizon Incident if but
only if the Transocean Parties, the Halliburton Parties, and/or such Other
Party, as the case may be, agrees as part of that settlement or compromise
to a full and final release of, dismissal of, and covenant not to sue for any
and all rights to recover, directly or indirectly, from the Released Parties
(whether through indemnity, contribution, subrogation, assignment or any
other theory of recovery, by contract, pursuant to applicable law or
regulation, or otherwise) for any Damages or other relief or consideration
provided under or relating to such settlement or compromise (whether the
settlement is of a class, of individual claims, or otherwise), including from
Expressly Reserved Claims, and further represents and warrants that it has
not assigned and will not assign any rights to recover for such Damages or
other relief or consideration (whether through indemnity, contribution,
028
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-39 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 13
4
subrogation, or otherwise). As part of this commitment and without
limitation, the Economic Class, Plaintiffs, and/or Economic Class
Members shall not settle or compromise with the Transocean Parties, the
Halliburton Parties, and/or any Other Parties on terms that might allow
any insurers, reinsurers, or indemnitors thereof to claim against any
Released Parties for indemnification, subrogation, contribution,
assignment or under any other theory of recovery. The Economic Class,
Plaintiffs, and Economic Class Members agree that, before any such
settlement or compromise is executed, BP shall have the right to approve
language in any such settlement or compromise memorializing the
representation and warranty set forth in this Section 1.1.2.5, which
approval shall not be unreasonably withheld.
1.1.2.6. Indemnity to Released Parties. Notwithstanding any provision in the
Agreement to the contrary, if any Other Party recovers or seeks to recover
from any Released Party (under any theory of recovery, including
indemnity, contribution, or subrogation, and including from Assigned
Claims and/or Expressly Reserved Claims) any Damages either (a) paid to
a particular Plaintiff or Economic Class Member for which a release was
given to BP through the Settlement or in an Individual Release, or (b) by,
through, under, or on account of such Plaintiff or Economic Class Member
for which a release was given to BP through the Settlement or in an
Individual Release; then that Plaintiff or Economic Class Member shall
indemnify (but not defend) the Released Parties, but only to the extent of
Settlement Payment(s) received by that particular Plaintiff or Economic
Class Member (by way of example, if a particular Plaintiff has received
$100.00 in Settlement Payment(s), its indemnity obligation would be
capped at this amount). This indemnity obligation owed by a Plaintiff or
Economic Class Member who has given a release to BP includes any and
all claims made or other actions taken by that Economic Class Member in
breach of Sections 1.1.2.1 through 1.1.2.5.
028 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-39 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 13
5
1.1.2.7. Notice Regarding Indemnity. Plaintiffs and Economic Class Members
expressly acknowledge that, to the fullest extent allowed by law, the
indemnity obligations contained in Section 1.1.2.6 apply to claims against
Released Parties predicated on negligence, gross negligence, willful
misconduct, strict liability, intentional torts, liability based on contractual
indemnity, and any and all other theories of liability, and any and all
awards of attorneys fees or other costs or expenses. The Plaintiffs and
Economic Class Members acknowledge that this indemnity is for conduct
occurring before the date of the Agreement and therefore is not affected by
public policies or other law prohibiting agreements to indemnify in
advance of certain conduct. THE PLAINTIFFS AND ECONOMIC
CLASS MEMBERS ACKNOWLEDGE THAT THIS SECTION
1.1.2.7 COMPLIES WITH ANY REQUIREMENT TO EXPRESSLY
STATE THAT LIABILITY FOR SUCH CLAIMS IS INDEMNIFIED
AND THAT THIS SECTION 1.1.2.7 IS CONSPICUOUS AND
AFFORDS FAIR AND ADEQUATE NOTICE.
1.1.2.8. No Set-off. Should the Economic Class, Plaintiffs, or the Economic Class
Members succeed in recovering monies from Transocean or Halliburton,
BP agrees that it would not be entitled to set-off such recovery against its
obligation to make Settlement Payment(s). Notwithstanding this Section
1.1.2.8, however, the Economic Class, Plaintiffs, and Economic Class
Members acknowledge and agree that this no set-off term does not
apply to any right BP may have pursuant to the Agreement to receive a
credit for monies received by Economic Class Members.
1.1.3. Assignment. To the fullest extent allowed by law and applicable contracts,
and subject to Sections 1.1.2, 1.1.4, and 1.1.5, upon Preliminary Approval,
and subject to occurrence of the Effective Date as a condition subsequent,
BP assigns to the Economic Class, only as a juridical entity and not to
Economic Class Members individually, the following claims and causes of
action against Transocean and Halliburton (but no other party) arising out
028993
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-39 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 13
6
of, due to, resulting from, or relating in any way to, directly or indirectly, to
the Deepwater Horizon Incident, on the terms and conditions set forth
herein:
1.1.3.1. All damages related to the repair, replacement, and/or re-drilling of the
MC-252 Well;
1.1.3.2. All economic damages for the loss of the MC-252 Well, including lost
profits, lost hydrocarbons, and diminution in value of the leasehold;
1.1.3.3. All costs that BP incurred to control the MC-252 Well and/or to respond
to, contain, and/or clean up the DWH Spill;
1.1.3.4. All rights to indemnity, contribution, or subrogation for claims paid by BP
and/or the GCCF on or before the entry of the Preliminary Approval
Order, subject, however, to (a) BPs retention of its right to pursue the
payments identified in Section 1.1.4.2, which are expressly retained, and
(b) BPs retention of its right to recover from Transocean and Halliburton
for the payments identified in Section 1.1.4.2;
1.1.3.5. All claims or causes of action to pursue reimbursement of Settlement
Payment(s) under theories of indemnification, contribution, subrogation,
or any other theory of recovery;
1.1.3.6. All punitive, exemplary, multiple, or non-compensatory damages;
1.1.3.7. All claims and causes of action to recover the damages, losses, costs, fees,
and amounts set forth in Sections 1.1.3.1-1.1.3.6, including BPs claims
for breach of contract, unseaworthiness, negligence, gross negligence,
willful misconduct, fraud, fraudulent concealment, and intentional torts
and including BPs claims in the BP Parties Counter-Complaint, Cross-
Complaint And Third Party Complaint Against Transocean And Claim In
Limitation, Docket No. 2074 in Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS, and BPs
Cross-Complaint And Third-Party Complaint Against Halliburton, Docket
02899
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-39 Filed 04/18/12 Page 7 of 13
7
No. 2082 in Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS.
1.1.3.8. BP agrees to cooperate, at its expense, in discovery with the Economic
Class in the prosecution of the Assigned Claims, through the provision of
evidence and witnesses, and the Economic Class agrees to exercise
reasonable restraint in their requests for assistance. The Economic Class
pledges to use its best efforts to avoid having to call BP employees as
witnesses in court for a trial or other proceedings pursuing Assigned
Claims.
1.1.4. All Defenses and Other Claims Retained. All of BPs claims not
expressly assigned by Section 1.1.3 are hereby retained.
1.1.4.1. Notwithstanding Section 1.1.3 and to avoid doubt, BP does not assign any
claim for indemnification or contribution or subrogation of amounts it
might pay for fines, penalties, or sanctions, including under the Clean
Water Act or other federal or state laws. Nothing in this provision shall be
construed to indicate that BP believes such claims are valid, and BP
reserves all legal arguments against such claims.
1.1.4.2. Notwithstanding Section 1.1.3 and to avoid doubt, BP does not assign, and
in fact retains, any claim for indemnification, contribution, subrogation, or
insurance coverage for amounts paid by the GCCF and/or BP on or before
the entry of the Preliminary Approval Order to settle or resolve any
personal injury, bodily injury, and/or wrongful death claims of the
employees of Transocean or Transoceans contractors who were on board
the Deepwater Horizon on April 20, 2010, whether brought by such
employees or their representatives, including for amounts the GCCF paid
for any Employee Settlement and to resolve Employee Claims as
defined and provided for in the Agreement Relating to Payment of
Transocean Employee Settlement Claims and as approved by Court order
entered on December 13, 2011 (Rec. Doc. 4893) (hereafter referred to as
Insurance Proceeds for Transocean Personnel). BP warrants that it has
02899
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-39 Filed 04/18/12 Page 8 of 13
8
not received any Insurance Proceeds for Transocean Personnel to date.
This retention is subject to the terms of Section 5.14 of the Agreement.
1.1.4.3. Notwithstanding Section 1.1.3 and to avoid doubt, the Economic Class,
Plaintiffs, and Economic Class Members acknowledge and agree that BP
retains its right to receive a credit for monies received by the Economic
Class, Plaintiffs, and/or Economic Class Members pursuant to the terms of
the Agreement.
1.1.4.4. Further, notwithstanding any other provision of the Agreement, BP hereby
retains all defenses, regardless of how designated, against all claims and
causes of action of the Transocean Parties and/or the Halliburton Parties
against any of the Released Parties, including all defenses against the
Transocean Parties and the Halliburton Parties claims for contractual
indemnification against BP, which shall include BPs rights to allege and
argue breach of contract, gross negligence, willful misconduct, fraud,
and/or intentional torts as defenses to contractual indemnification and to
seek or oppose reconsideration, appeal, or other review of any decisions
by courts or arbitrators regarding contractual indemnification between BP
and the Transocean Parties and/or the Halliburton Parties, including (a) the
Order and Reasons as to Transocean and BPs Cross-Motions for Partial
Summary Judgment Regarding Indemnity, Docket No. 5446 in Case 2:10-
md-02179-CJB-SS and (b) the Order and Reasons as to Halliburtons and
BPs Cross-Motions for Partial Summary Judgment Regarding Indemnity,
Docket No. 5493 in Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS.
1.1.4.5. Neither the provisions regarding Assigned Claims, nor any other provision
in the Agreement, shall limit BPs ability to take any action to defend
itself in any litigation or arbitration.
1.1.4.6. No Warranties for Assigned Claims. BP does not make, and expressly
disclaims, any representations or warranties regarding the Assigned
Claims, including but not limited to representations and warranties
02899
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-39 Filed 04/18/12 Page 9 of 13
9
regarding the validity, value, enforceability, defenses to, or assignability
of the Assigned Claims. The invalidity, illegality, or unenforceability of
the assignment of any or all Assigned Claims shall not operate to
invalidate the Agreement or the Individual Releases, and shall not affect
the validity or enforceability of any other provision, or portion thereof, of
the Agreement or the Individual Releases. Should the Effective Date
occur but part or all of the assignment be held invalid, BP acknowledges
and agrees that it will not seek to pursue such Assigned Claims that were
the subject of the invalidated assignment.
1.1.5. Retention of Assigned Claims. The occurrence of the Effective Date is a
condition subsequent of the assignment of the Assigned Claims. If the
Effective Date does not occur for any reason, the Assignment made in
Section 1.1.3 shall become null and void and the Assigned Claims shall be
retained by BP. If any of the Assigned Claims have been liquidated by the
Economic Class through judgment or settlement with Transocean and/or
Halliburton, such funds shall not be disbursed until the Effective Date has
occurred and no compromise, release, or other impairment of the Assigned
Claims shall become operative until the Effective Date. Any attempt to
release, compromise or otherwise impair the Assigned Claims shall not
become operative until the Effective Date, and any attempt to release,
compromise, or otherwise impair the Assigned Claims with an operative
date before the Effective Date shall be null and void.
2. DEFINITIONS.
2.1. The capitalized terms used in this Attachment shall have the same definitions as
in the Agreement unless defined in this Attachment. In the event of any conflict,
the definitions in this Attachment shall prevail over any definitions used in the
Agreement for purposes of applying the terms of this Attachment.
2.2. Agreement shall mean the Economic and Property Damages Settlement
Agreement, including all of its attachments and exhibits.
02899
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-39 Filed 04/18/12 Page 10 of 13
10
2.3. Assigned Claims shall mean the claims defined in Section 1.1.3, excluding the
Retained Claims defined in Section 1.1.4.
2.4. Compensatory Damages shall mean any and all forms of damages, known or
unknown, intended to or having the effect of satisfying, compensating, or
reimbursing the Economic Classs, Plaintiffs and /or Economic Class Members
claims for actual economic or pecuniary costs, expenses, damages, liability, or
other losses or injuries arising out of, due to, resulting from, or relating in any
way to, directly or indirectly, the Deepwater Horizon Incident, regardless of what
such damages are designated, called or labeled. Compensatory Damages do not
include and may not be interpreted to have any overlap with punitive, exemplary,
multiple, or non- compensatory damages. Bodily Injury Claims (including
wrongful death) are not included in Compensatory Damages. Claims of BP
shareholders in any derivative or direct action solely in their capacity as BP
shareholders are not included in Compensatory Damages. The Parties
acknowledge and agree that the term Compensatory Damages as defined and used
herein does not limit the amounts to be used for the calculation of punitive or
other non-compensatory damages in any current or future litigation pursued by
the Economic Class, Plaintiffs, and /or Economic Class Members. Nothing herein
shall be deemed to limit the right of an Economic Class Member to pursue against
BP Moratoria Losses or other claims expressly reserved under Section 3 of the
Agreement.
2.5. Damages shall mean all forms of damages defined as broadly as possible without
exception, including losses, costs, expenses, taxes, requests, royalties, rents, fees,
profits, profit shares, earning capacity, loss of subsistence, damages to real or
personal property, diminution in property value, punitive damages, exemplary
damages, multiple damages, non-compensatory damages, Compensatory
Damages, economic damages, injuries, liens, remedies, debts, claims, causes of
action, or liabilities.
028998
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-39 Filed 04/18/12 Page 11 of 13
11
2.6. Halliburton shall mean Halliburton Energy Services, Inc. and all and any of its
Affiliates, other than any Natural Person or Entity that is also an Affiliate of any
of the Released Parties as of April 16, 2012.
2.7. Halliburton Parties shall mean Halliburton (including all persons, entities,
subsidiaries, divisions and business units comprised thereby); each of
Halliburtons respective past, present and future directors, officers, employees,
general or limited partners, members, joint venturers, and shareholders, and their
past, present and future spouses, heirs, beneficiaries, estates, executors,
administrators, personal representatives, attorneys, agents, trustees, insurers,
reinsurers, predecessors, successors, indemnitees, assigns, Affiliates; any natural,
legal or juridical person or entity acting on behalf of or having liability in respect
of Halliburton, in their respective capacities as such; and the federal Oil Spill
Liability Trust Fund and any state or local fund, and each of their respective
Affiliates including their officers, directors, shareholders, employees, and agents.
2.8. Other Party shall mean every person, entity, or party other than the Released
Parties.
2.9. Retained Claims shall mean the claims retained by BP in Section 1.1.4.
2.10. Transocean shall mean Transocean Ltd., Transocean, Inc., Transocean Offshore
Deepwater Drilling Inc., Transocean Deepwater Inc., Transocean Holdings LLC,
and Triton Asset Leasing GmbH and all and any of their Affiliates, other than any
Natural Person or Entity that is also an Affiliate any of the Released Parties as of
April 16, 2012.
2.11. Transocean Parties shall mean Transocean (including all persons, entities,
subsidiaries, divisions and business units comprised thereby); each of
Transoceans respective past, present and future directors, officers, employees,
general or limited partners, members, joint venturers, and shareholders, and their
past, present and future spouses, heirs, beneficiaries, estates, executors,
administrators, personal representatives, attorneys, agents, trustees, insurers,
028999
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-39 Filed 04/18/12 Page 12 of 13
12
reinsurers, predecessors, successors, indemnitees, assigns, Affiliates; any natural,
legal or juridical person or entity acting on behalf of or having liability in respect
of Transocean, in their respective capacities as such; and the federal Oil Spill
Liability Trust Fund and any state or local fund, and each of their respective
Affiliates including their officers, directors, shareholders, employees, and agents.
029000
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-39 Filed 04/18/12 Page 13 of 13
22
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-40 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 2
M apof Gul f Coast Ar ea
02889
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-40 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 2
23
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-41 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 4
B C D
E
F
G
H
I J
K
Seei nset
onPage2
LEGEND
Speci f i edGul f W at er s
Boundar i esof Nat i onal Ter r i t or i al
W at er s
M apof Speci f i edGul f Wat er s
A
L
Wat er sNot Incl udedi nCl assDef i ni t i on:St at eW at er s
W i t hi n3M ar i neLeagues(9Naut i cal M i l es)of Coast sof
TexasCount i esNot Incl udedi nGul f Coast Ar ea
1
Seei nset
onPage3
Point Lat it ude Longit ude Point Lat it ude Longit ude
A 28. 206N 96. 318W G 25. 703N 91. 092W
B 25. 956N 97. 145W H 25. 669N 88. 385W
C 25. 971N 96. 980W I 24. 933N 87. 210W
D 25. 997N 93. 445W J 24. 941N 86. 938W
E 24. 734N 93. 664W K 25. 207N 86. 553W
F 25. 445N 91. 645W L 23. 925N 81. 216W
BOUNDARYPOINTSINGULFOFM EXICO
02889
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-41 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 4
LEGEND
Speci f i edGul f W at er s
Boundar i esof Nat i onal Ter r i t or i al
W at er s
Count yBoundar i es
BRAZORIACOUNTY
GALVESTONCOUNTY
A
B
C
D
M apof Speci f i edGul f Wat er s
Point Lat it ude Longit ude
A 29. 197N 95.057W
B 29. 086N 95.130W
C 29. 063N 95.092W
D 28. 986N 94.978W
BOUNDARYPOINTS
Wat er sNot Incl udedi nCl assDef i ni t i on:St at eW at er s
W i t hi n3M ar i neLeagues(9Naut i cal M i l es)of Coast sof
TexasCount i esNot Incl udedi nGul f Coast Ar ea
2
028892
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-41 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 4
LEGEND
Speci f i edGul f W at er s
Boundar i esof Nat i onal Ter r i t or i al
W at er s
Count yBoundar i es
Wat er sNot Incl udedi nCl assDef i ni t i on:St at eW at er s
W i t hi n3M ar i neLeagues(9Naut i cal M i l es)of Coast sof
TexasCount i esNot Incl udedi nGul f Coast Ar ea
M apof Speci f i edGul f Wat er s
3
A
B
C
D
E
M ONROECOUNTY
M IAM IDADE
COUNTY
Point Lat it ude Longit ude
A 25. 306N 80. 372W
B 25. 354N 80. 265W
C 25. 342N 80. 251W
D 25. 314N 80. 150W
E 25. 184N 79. 692W
BOUNDARYPOINTS
028893
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-41 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 4
2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-42 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 8
1
BP CORPORATION NORTH AMERICA INC. GUARANTEE
1. Guarantee of Obligations. For good and valuable consideration received, the receipt
and sufficiency of which are hereby acknowledged, BP Corporation North America Inc., a
corporation organized under the laws of Indiana (the First Guarantor), subject to the terms
and conditions herein, hereby absolutely, irrecoverably, and unconditionally guarantees the
Economic and Property Damages Settlement Class (the Beneficiary), by and through (i) the
Claims Administrator, or (ii) Stephen J. Herman and/or James Parkerson Roy, or their
successors, acting as Economic and Property Damages Class Settlement Counsel (Lead Class
Counsel), that BP Exploration and Production Inc. and BP America Production Company
(collectively, the Primary Obligors) will duly and punctually pay all of the Primary Obligors
payment obligations (the Obligations) under that certain Deepwater Horizon Economic and
Property Damages Settlement Agreement to be dated on or around April 18, 2012 (the
Agreement), as and when required in accordance with the terms thereof, in each case, without
regard to whether such obligation is direct or indirect, contingent or otherwise, now or hereafter
existing or owing, or incurred or payable before or after commencement of any proceedings by
or against the Primary Obligors under any applicable bankruptcy or insolvency law or similar
law or proceeding. This guarantee (the Guarantee) is given in accordance with Section 37 of
the Agreement. For purposes of this Guarantee, all capitalized terms not otherwise defined
herein shall have the meaning ascribed to such term in the Agreement.
2. Event of Default of Primary Obligors. The Primary Obligors shall be deemed in
default solely after the occurrence of all of the following events (Default):
(a) The Primary Obligors have failed to pay an Obligation within the period allowed
by the Agreement.
(b) The Claims Administrator or Lead Class Counsel issues a Demand (defined in
Clause 9(b)) to the Primary Obligors and the First Guarantor alleging that the Primary Obligors
have not paid their Obligations within the period allowed by the Agreement.
(c) The Primary Obligors do not cure the alleged breach within five (5) business days
after receipt of the Demand.
(d) The Claims Administrator or Lead Class Counsel shall concurrently notify the
Court (presiding judge or magistrate of the division of the District Court for the Eastern District
of Louisiana having oversight of the Agreement) of the alleged breach, and First Guarantor shall
not oppose expedited consultation and/or mediation of the dispute.
(e) The Court informally consults regarding and/or mediates the dispute.
(f) The Primary Obligors fail to take curative action within the greater of (i) two
business days after the conclusion of the consultation and/or mediation with the Court, or (ii) the
balance of the time period specified in Clause 2(c).
3. Obligation of First Guarantor. If and only if the Primary Obligors are in Default and
such Default has not been cured and is continuing, then First Guarantor must pay or procure the
0292
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-42 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 8
2
payment of the applicable overdue and unpaid Obligations of the Primary Obligors within the
greater of (i) 15 days from receipt of the Demand or (ii) five business days after the
determination of a Default as specified in Clauses 2(a) (f).
4. Joint and Several Obligation. The First Guarantors obligations under this Guarantee
are contingent upon the occurrence and continuation of a Default by the Primary Obligors. Upon
and after the occurrence, and during the continuance, of a Default, (a) this Guarantee shall be a
guarantee of payment, and not of collection, of the applicable overdue and unpaid Obligations;
(b) the First Guarantors obligations hereunder shall be on a joint and several basis with the
Primary Obligors to the same degree and extent as if the First Guarantor had been a co-principal
obligor of the applicable unpaid Obligations, and (c) a separate action or actions may be brought
and prosecuted against the First Guarantor to enforce this Guarantee, irrespective of whether any
action is brought upon the Primary Obligors or whether any Primary Obligor is joined in any
such action or actions.
5. Duration. The obligations of the First Guarantor set forth herein constitute the full
recourse obligations of the First Guarantor enforceable against it to the full extent of all its assets
and properties and shall remain in full force and effect until the earlier of (i) such time as all the
Obligations of the Primary Obligors under the Agreement have been performed in full and so
declared by Court order, or (ii) such time as the Agreement terminates or becomes null and void
for any of the reasons set out in Section 21 of the Agreement.
6. Waiver of Defenses. The obligations of the First Guarantor hereunder shall not be
subject to any counterclaim, setoff, deduction, diminution, abatement, stay, recoupment,
suspension, deferment, reduction or defense (other than full and strict payment or other
satisfaction of the Obligations) based upon any claim the First Guarantor may have against the
Beneficiary or any other obligor. Subject to Clause 5, the obligations of the First Guarantor
hereunder shall remain in full force and effect without regard to, and shall not be released,
discharged or reduced (except to the extent of any defenses to payment or performance to which
the Primary Obligors are entitled under the Agreement) for any reason, including (a) any
amendment or waiver of any term of the Agreement, whether or not the Beneficiary, Primary
Obligors, or the First Guarantor has notice or knowledge of any of the foregoing; or (b) any
bankruptcy, insolvency or similar proceeding with respect to the First Guarantor or Primary
Obligors or their respective properties, or any action taken by any trustee or receiver or by any
court in any such proceeding. The First Guarantor also waives any right to demand arbitration or
mediation, and any right to a jury trial. The obligations of the First Guarantor hereunder shall be
subject to, and the First Guarantor shall be entitled to assert, any counterclaim, setoff, deduction,
or defense that the Primary Obligors could assert against the Beneficiary under the Agreement.
7. Waiver of Notice. Except as set forth in this Guarantee, the First Guarantor
unconditionally waives all notices which may be required by statute, rule of law or otherwise to
preserve any rights against the First Guarantor hereunder, including (a) notice of the acceptance
of this Guarantee by the Beneficiary or any assignee thereof, or the modification of the
Obligations or notice of any other matters relating thereto; (b) any presentment, demand, notice
of dishonor, protest or nonpayment of any damages or other amounts payable under the
Agreement; (c) any requirement for the enforcement, assertion or exercise of any right or remedy
under the Agreement; (d) any requirement of diligence; (e) if the Primary Obligors are in
0292 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-42 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 8
3
Default, the right to require the Beneficiary to proceed against the Primary Obligors or any other
person liable on the Obligations, and the Guarantor waives the right to have the property of the
Primary Obligors first applied to discharge the Obligations.
8. Subordination of Rights. The First Guarantor shall be subrogated to all rights of the
Beneficiary against the Primary Obligors in respect of any amounts paid by the First Guarantor
pursuant to the Guarantee, provided that the First Guarantor waives any rights it may acquire by
way of subrogation under this Guarantee, by any payment made hereunder or otherwise
(including, without limitation, any statutory rights of subrogation under Section 509 of the
Bankruptcy Code, 11 U.S.C. 509, or otherwise), reimbursement, exoneration, contribution,
indemnification, or any right to participate in any claim or remedy of the Beneficiary against the
Primary Obligors or any collateral which the Beneficiary now has or acquires, until all of the
Obligations shall have been irrevocably and indefeasibly paid to the Beneficiary in full. If (a)
the First Guarantor shall make payment to the Beneficiary of all or any part of the Obligations,
and (b) all the Obligations shall have been indefeasibly paid in full, then the Beneficiary shall, at
the First Guarantors request, execute and deliver to the First Guarantor appropriate documents
necessary to evidence the transfer by subrogation to the First Guarantor of any interest in the
Obligations resulting from such payment of the First Guarantor. Any sums received by the First
Guarantor in violation of the foregoing shall be held in trust for the Beneficiary and shall be
promptly paid over to the Claims Administrator or Lead Class Counsel on behalf of the
Beneficiary without any need for further action of any kind by the Beneficiary, to be credited and
applied against the Obligations.
9. Demands.
(a) This Guarantee may only be enforced by the Claims Administrator or Lead Class
Counsel on behalf of the Beneficiary and may not be enforced by any other Natural Person or
Entity, including, without limitation, any member of the Beneficiary.
(b) Any demand sent by the Claims Administrator or Lead Class Counsel to the First
Guarantor under this Guarantee shall be in writing and shall (i) state the reasons for making such
demand, and (ii) clearly identify the Obligations under the Agreement which the Primary
Obligors have failed to pay, and such notice shall be delivered or sent by email, facsimile, and
overnight mail to the First Guarantor at its address as provided under Clause 12(b) (Demand).
(c) All Demands to proceed under this Guarantee must be sent to the First Guarantor
by the Claims Administrator or Lead Class Counsel.
10. Representations and Warranties.
(a) The First Guarantor is a corporation duly formed and validly existing under the
laws of the State of Indiana.
(b) The First Guarantor has the power and authority to execute, deliver and perform
its obligations under this Guarantee and has taken all necessary action to authorize the execution,
delivery and performance of this Guarantee. No consent is required for the due execution,
delivery, and performance by the First Guarantor of this Guarantee, except those that have been
obtained and are in full force and effect.
0292 3
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-42 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 8
4
(c) The authorization, execution, delivery and performance of this Guarantee by the
First Guarantor will not result in any breach of or default under (or any condition which with the
giving of notice or lapse of time or both would constitute a breach or default under) (i) the
constituent documents of the First Guarantor, or (ii) any contract, indenture, mortgage, security
agreement or other document, instrument or agreement or any judgment, order or decree or law,
rule, or regulation to which the First Guarantor is a party or to which the First Guarantor or any
of its property is subject.
11. Sole Remedy. The First Guarantors obligations under this Guarantee are the sole and
exclusive remedy of the Beneficiary against the First Guarantor under the Agreement. The First
Guarantors entire obligation to the Beneficiary is the guarantee of the Obligations and the other
obligations expressly set forth in Clause 12 and the First Guarantor shall have no other
obligations of any kind to the Beneficiary. No person or entity, other than the Beneficiary acting
through the Claims Administrator or Lead Class Counsel, shall have any rights, remedies or
recourse to the First Guarantor under this Guarantee.
12. Miscellaneous.
(a) The First Guarantor shall not assign any of its rights or delegate any of its duties
under this Guarantee to any person or entity without the prior written consent of the
Beneficiaries. This Guarantee shall be binding upon First Guarantor, its successors, and assigns,
and shall inure to the benefit of Beneficiary, its successors, and assigns.
(b) Any notice to the First Guarantor pursuant to this Guarantee shall be sent by
electronic mail, facsimile, and overnight mail to the following individuals, who are authorized to
receive all notices, demands, suits to perform, and all other correspondence arising out of the
Guarantee:
John E. (Jack) Lynch Jr.
Deputy Group General Counsel
U.S. General Counsel
BP America Inc.
501 Westlake Park Boulevard
Houston, TX 77079
Fax: 713-375-2808
E-mail: John.Lynch@uk.bp.com
James J. Neath
Associate General Counsel
BP America Inc.
501 Westlake Park Boulevard
Houston, TX 77079
Fax: 281-366-5901
E-mail: James.Neath@bp.com
0292
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-42 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 8
5
Any notice to Beneficiary pursuant to this Guarantee shall be sent by electronic mail, facsimile,
and overnight mail to the following individuals in their capacity as Lead Class Counsel:
Stephen J. Herman
Herman Herman Katz & Cotlar LLP
820 OKeefe Avenue
New Orleans, LA 70113
Fax: 504-561-6024
E-mail: sherman@hhkc.com
James Parkerson Roy
Domengeaux Wright Roy & Edwards
LLC 556 Jefferson Street, Suite 500
Lafayette, LA 70501
Fax: 337-233-2796
E-Mail: jimr@wrightroy.com
Any notice to the Claims Administrator pursuant to this Guarantee shall be sent by electronic
mail, facsimile, and overnight mail to the following individual in his capacity as the Claims
Administrator:
Patrick Juneau
Juneau David, APLC
Post Office Drawer 51268
Lafayette, LA 70505-1268
Fax: 337-269-0061
E-mail: paj@juneaudavid.com
fgg@juneaudavid.com
Whenever any notice is sent related to this Guarantee, such notice shall be sent to all of the
addressees listed in this Clause 12(b).
(c) This Guarantee shall not be amended without the written consent of the First
Guarantor and the Beneficiaries.
(d) The provisions of this Guarantee shall be deemed severable, and if any one or
more provisions of this Guarantee shall be determined to be invalid or unenforceable, all other
provisions shall, nevertheless, remain in full force and effect.
(e) If the First Guarantor has performed under this Guarantee, then within 30 days of
a written demand, the First Guarantor shall pay all reasonably incurred and properly documented
out-of-pocket costs, fees, and/or expenses incurred by the Claims Administrator and/or Lead
Class Counsel, including fees and disbursements of counsel, in connection with the pursuit of
performance under this Guarantee.
(f) THIS GUARANTEE SHALL BE GOVERNED IN ALL RESPECTS,
INCLUDING AS TO VALIDITY, INTERPRETATION AND EFFECT, BY THE LAWS OF
THE STATE OF NEW YORK, WITHOUT GIVING EFFECT TO ITS PRINCIPLES OR
RULES OF CONFLICT OF LAWS, TO THE EXTENT SUCH PRINCIPLES OR RULES ARE
NOT MANDATORILY APPLICABLE BY STATUTE AND WOULD PERMIT OR REQUIRE
THE APPLICATION OF THE LAWS OF ANOTHER JURISDICTION.
0292
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-42 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 8
6
(g) Pursuant to the Courts continuing jurisdiction over the Agreement, the First
Guarantor, Beneficiary, Claims Administrator, and Lead Class Counsel agree that the United
States District Court for the Eastern District of Louisiana shall have exclusive jurisdiction and
venue to enforce, interpret, give effect to, or resolve any disputes, cases, or controversies
concerning this Guarantee. If MDL 2179 has not yet been terminated, any pleading filed on
behalf of any complainant party relating to the Guarantee shall be accompanied by a legal
request for such dispute, case, or controversy to be made part of MDL 2179. In all other respects
and purposes unrelated to matters involving the Guarantee or its enforcement, the First Guarantor
specifically reserves any and all defenses to the jurisdiction and venue of this Court. The
Beneficiary, Claims Administrator, and Lead Class Counsel agree that the First Guarantors
agreement in this Clause 12(g) does not constitute a waiver of jurisdictional defenses, consent to
jurisdiction, or an act supporting or sufficient to establish jurisdiction over the First Guarantor
for any matter besides disputes, cases, or controversies concerning this Guarantee.
0292
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-42 Filed 04/18/12 Page 7 of 8
0292
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-42 Filed 04/18/12 Page 8 of 8
2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-43 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 9
BP P.L.C. BACK-UP GUARANTEE
1. Recitals.
(a) Whereas, BP Corporation North America Inc., an Indiana corporation (the First
Guarantor), is providing a guarantee (the BPCNA Guarantee) in favor of the Economic and
Property Damages Settlement Class (the Beneficiary) in connection with that certain
Deepwater Horizon Economic and Property Damages Settlement Agreement to be dated on or
around April 18, 2012 (the Agreement), guaranteeing the payment obligations (the
Obligations) of BP Exploration and Production Inc. and BP America Production Company
(the Primary Obligors) under the Agreement.
(b) Whereas, the First Guarantor is a wholly-owned indirect subsidiary of BP p.l.c., a
company incorporated in England and Wales (the Second Guarantor), and the Second
Guarantor has agreed to provide this guarantee (the Guarantee) pursuant to Section 37 of the
Agreement.
(c) Now, therefore, for good and valuable consideration received, the receipt and
sufficiency of which are hereby acknowledged, the Second Guarantor agrees as follows:
2. Guarantee of Obligations. The Second Guarantor, subject to the terms and conditions
herein, including, without limitation, the occurrence and continuance of a BPCNA Default,
hereby absolutely, irrecoverably, and unconditionally guarantees the Beneficiary, by and through
(i) the Claims Administrator, or (ii) Stephen J. Herman and/or James Parkerson Roy, or their
successors, acting as Economic and Property Damages Class Settlement Counsel (Lead Class
Counsel), that the Primary Obligors (or, if applicable, the First Guarantor) will duly and
punctually pay all of the Primary Obligors Obligations under the Agreement, as and when
required in accordance with the terms thereof, in each case, without regard to whether such
obligation is direct or indirect, contingent or otherwise, now or hereafter existing or owing, or
incurred or payable before or after commencement of any proceedings by or against the Primary
Obligors under any applicable bankruptcy or insolvency law or similar law or proceeding. For
purposes of this Guarantee, all capitalized terms not otherwise defined herein shall have the
meaning ascribed to such term in the Agreement.
3. Event of Default of Primary Obligors and First Guarantor. The Primary Obligors
and the First Guarantor shall be deemed in default solely after the occurrence of all of the
following events (BPCNA Default):
(a) The Primary Obligors have failed to pay an Obligation within the period allowed
by the Agreement.
(b) The Claims Administrator or Lead Class Counsel issues a Demand (defined in
Clause 11(b)) to the Primary Obligors, the First Guarantor, and the Second Guarantor alleging
that the Primary Obligors have not paid their Obligations within the period allowed by the
Agreement.
02900
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-43 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 9
2
(c) The Primary Obligors do not cure the alleged breach within five (5) business days
after receipt of the Demand.
(d) The Claims Administrator or Lead Class Counsel shall concurrently notify the
Court (presiding judge or magistrate of the division of the District Court for the Eastern District
of Louisiana having oversight of the Agreement) of the alleged breach, and Second Guarantor
shall not oppose expedited consultation and/or mediation of the dispute.
(e) The Court informally consults regarding and/or mediates the dispute.
(f) The Primary Obligors fail to take curative action within the greater of (i) two
business days after the conclusion of the consultation and/or mediation with the Court, or (ii) the
balance of the time period specified in Clause 3(c).
(g) The occurrence and continuation of either: (i) a failure by First Guarantor to pay
the applicable Obligations or otherwise cure the Default (as defined in the BPCNA Guarantee) of
the Primary Obligors within the time specified in the BPCNA Guarantee, or (ii) a Net Worth
Event as defined hereinafter.
4. Obligation of Second Guarantor. If and only if a BPCNA Default has occurred and
such BPCNA Default has not been cured and is continuing, then Second Guarantor must pay or
procure the payment of the applicable overdue and unpaid Obligations of the Primary Obligors
within the greater of (i) 30 days from receipt of the Demand or (ii) 15 days after the
determination of a BPCNA Default as specified in Clauses 3(a) (g).
5. Net Worth Event. For purposes of this Guarantee, the terms set forth below have the
following meanings.
Consolidated Net Worth means Total Assets less Total Liabilities.
GAAP means, as at any date of determination, generally accepted accounting
principles in the United States.
Net Worth Event means the Consolidated Net Worth of the First Guarantor, as
demonstrated in the most recently produced audited, annual consolidated balance sheet
shall be less than ten billion ($10,000,000,000), pursuant to audited financials that First
Guarantor shall produce to Lead Class Counsel and the Claims Administrator at least
once a year, subject to a customary confidentiality agreement reasonably acceptable to
the First Guarantor and the Second Guarantor. If the annual audited financials required
hereunder (subject to the confidentiality agreement) are not produced on or before the
earlier of (a) 120 days after the end of First Guarantors fiscal year or (b) the date the
audited financials are provided to the First Guarantors creditors, a Net Worth Event will
immediately be deemed to have occurred without the need for further action of any kind;
provided, however, that the First Guarantors subsequent provision of the audited
financials to Lead Class Counsel and the Claims Administrator showing the Consolidated
Net Worth of the First Guarantor to be in excess of ten billion dollars ($10,000,000,000)
shall immediately cure the Net Worth Event.
029002
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-43 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 9
3
Total Assets means, as at any date of determination, all assets of the First Guarantor
and its subsidiaries on a consolidated basis in conformity with GAAP.
Total Liabilities means, as at any date of determination, all liabilities of the First
Guarantor and its subsidiaries on a consolidated basis in conformity with GAAP.
6. Joint and Several Obligation. The Second Guarantors obligations under this
Guarantee are contingent upon the occurrence and continuation of a BPCNA Default. Upon and
after the occurrence, and during the continuance, of a BPCNA Default, (a) this Guarantee shall
be a guarantee of payment, and not of collection, of the applicable overdue and unpaid
Obligations; (b) the Second Guarantors obligations hereunder shall be on a joint and several
basis with the Primary Obligors and the First Guarantor to the same degree and extent as if the
Second Guarantor had been a co-principal obligor of the applicable unpaid Obligations, and (c) a
separate action or actions may be brought and prosecuted against the Second Guarantor to
enforce this Guarantee, irrespective of whether any action is brought upon the Primary Obligors
or the First Guarantor or whether any Primary Obligor or First Guarantor is joined in any such
action or actions.
7. Duration. The obligations of the Second Guarantor set forth herein constitute the full
recourse obligations of the Second Guarantor enforceable against it to the full extent of all its
assets and properties and shall remain in full force and effect until the earlier of (i) such time as
all the Obligations of the Primary Obligors under the Agreement have been performed in full and
so declared by Court order, (ii) five years after the Effective Date, as defined in the Agreement,
or (iii) such time as the Agreement terminates or becomes null and void for any of the reasons set
out in Section 21 of the Agreement.
8. Waiver of Defenses. The obligations of the Second Guarantor hereunder shall not be
subject to any counterclaim, setoff, deduction, diminution, abatement, stay, recoupment,
suspension, deferment, reduction or defense (other than full and strict payment or other
satisfaction of the Obligations) based upon any claim the Second Guarantor may have against the
Beneficiary or any other obligor. Subject to Clause 7, the obligations of the Second Guarantor
hereunder shall remain in full force and effect without regard to, and shall not be released,
discharged or reduced (except to the extent of any defenses to payment or performance to which
the Primary Obligors are entitled under the Agreement) for any reason, including (a) any
amendment or waiver of any term of the Agreement, whether or not the Beneficiary, Primary
Obligors, or the Second Guarantor has notice or knowledge of any of the foregoing; or (b) any
bankruptcy, insolvency or similar proceeding with respect to the First Guarantor or Primary
Obligors or their respective properties, or any action taken by any trustee or receiver or by any
court in any such proceeding. The Second Guarantor also waives any right to demand arbitration
or mediation, and any right to a jury trial. The obligations of the Second Guarantor hereunder
shall be subject to, and the Second Guarantor shall be entitled to assert, any counterclaim, setoff,
deduction, or defense that the Primary Obligors could assert against the Beneficiary under the
Agreement.
9. Waiver of Notice. Except as set forth in this Guarantee, the Second Guarantor
unconditionally waives all notices which may be required by statute, rule of law or otherwise to
preserve any rights against the Second Guarantor hereunder, including (a) notice of the
acceptance of this Guarantee by the Beneficiary or any assignee thereof, or the modification of
029003
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-43 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 9
4
the Obligations or notice of any other matters relating thereto; (b) any presentment, demand,
notice of dishonor, protest or nonpayment of any damages or other amounts payable under the
Agreement; (c) any requirement for the enforcement, assertion or exercise of any right or remedy
under the Agreement; (d) any requirement of diligence; (e) if the Primary Obligors are in default,
the right to require the Beneficiary to proceed against the Primary Obligors or any other person
liable on the Obligations, and the Second Guarantor waives the right to have the property of the
Primary Obligors first applied to discharge the Obligations.
10. Subordination of Rights. The Second Guarantor shall be subrogated to all rights of the
Beneficiary against the Primary Obligors and the First Guarantor in respect of any amounts paid
by the Second Guarantor pursuant to the Guarantee, provided that the Second Guarantor waives
any rights it may acquire by way of subrogation under this Guarantee, by any payment made
hereunder or otherwise (including, without limitation, any statutory rights of subrogation under
Section 509 of the Bankruptcy Code, 11 U.S.C. 509, or otherwise), reimbursement,
exoneration, contribution, indemnification, or any right to participate in any claim or remedy of
the Beneficiary against the Primary Obligors or any collateral which the Beneficiary now has or
acquires, until all of the Obligations shall have been irrevocably and indefeasibly paid to the
Beneficiary in full. If (a) the Second Guarantor shall make payment to the Beneficiary of all or
any part of the Obligations, and (b) all the Obligations shall have been indefeasibly paid in full,
then the Beneficiary shall, at the Second Guarantors request, execute and deliver to the Second
Guarantor appropriate documents necessary to evidence the transfer by subrogation to the
Second Guarantor of any interest in the Obligations resulting from such payment of the Second
Guarantor. Any sums received by the Second Guarantor in violation of the foregoing shall be
held in trust for the Beneficiary and shall be promptly paid over to the Claims Administrator or
Lead Class Counsel on behalf of the Beneficiary without any need for further action of any kind
by the Beneficiary, to be credited and applied against the Obligations.
11. Demands.
(a) This Guarantee may only be enforced by the Claims Administrator or Lead Class
Counsel on behalf of the Beneficiary and may not be enforced by any other Natural Person or
Entity, including, without limitation, any member of the Beneficiary.
(b) Any demand sent by the Claims Administrator or Lead Class Counsel to the
Second Guarantor under this Guarantee shall be in writing and shall (i) state the reasons for
making such demand, and (ii) clearly identify the Obligations under the Agreement which the
Primary Obligors have failed to pay, and such notice shall be delivered or sent by email,
facsimile, and overnight mail to the Second Guarantor at its address as provided under Clause
14(b) (Demand).
(c) All Demands to proceed under this Guarantee must be sent to the Second
Guarantor by the Claims Administrator or Lead Class Counsel.
12. Representations and Warranties.
(a) The Second Guarantor is a company duly formed and validly existing under the
laws of England and Wales.
02900
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-43 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 9
5
(b) The Second Guarantor has the power and authority to execute, deliver and
perform its obligations under this Guarantee and has taken all necessary action to authorize the
execution, delivery and performance of this Guarantee. No consent is required for the due
execution, delivery, and performance by the Second Guarantor of this Guarantee, except those
that have been obtained and are in full force and effect.
(c) The authorization, execution, delivery and performance of this Guarantee by the
Second Guarantor will not result in any breach of or default under (or any condition which with
the giving of notice or lapse of time or both would constitute a breach or default under) (i) the
constituent documents of the Second Guarantor, or (ii) any contract, indenture, mortgage,
security agreement or other document, instrument or agreement or any judgment, order or decree
or law, rule, or regulation to which the Second Guarantor is a party or to which the Second
Guarantor or any of its property is subject.
13. Sole Remedy. The Second Guarantors obligations under this Guarantee are the sole and
exclusive remedy of the Beneficiary against the Second Guarantor under the Agreement. The
Second Guarantors entire obligation to the Beneficiary is the guarantee of the Obligations and
the other obligations expressly set forth in Clause 14 and the Second Guarantor shall have no
other obligations of any kind to the Beneficiary. No person or entity, other than the Beneficiary
acting through the Claims Administrator or Lead Class Counsel, shall have any rights, remedies
or recourse to the Second Guarantor under this Guarantee.
14. Miscellaneous.
(a) The Second Guarantor shall not assign any of its rights or delegate any of its
duties under this Guarantee to any person or entity without the prior written consent of the
Beneficiaries. This Guarantee shall be binding upon Second Guarantor, its successors, and
assigns, and shall inure to the benefit of Beneficiary, its successors, and assigns.
(b) Any notice to the Second Guarantor pursuant to this Guarantee shall be sent by
electronic mail, facsimile, and overnight mail to the following individuals, who are authorized to
receive all notices, demands, suits to perform, and all other correspondence arising out of the
Guarantee:
Rupert Bondy
Group General Counsel
BP p.l.c.
1 St James's Square
London SW1Y 4PD
United Kingdom
Fax: +44-20-7496-4242
E-mail: Rupert.Bondy@uk.bp.com
David Bucknall
Group Treasurer
BP p.l.c.
4th Floor
20 Canada Square
London E14 5NJ
United Kingdom
Fax: +44-20-7948-7783
E-mail: David.Bucknall@uk.bp.com
02900
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-43 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 9
6
John E. (Jack) Lynch Jr.
Deputy Group General Counsel
U.S. General Counsel
BP America Inc.
501 Westlake Park Boulevard
Houston, TX 77079
Fax: 713-375-2808
E-mail: John.Lynch@uk.bp.com
James J. Neath
Associate General Counsel
BP America Inc.
501 Westlake Park Boulevard
Houston, TX 77079
Fax: 281-366-5901
E-mail: James.Neath@bp.com
Any notice to Beneficiary pursuant to this Guarantee shall be sent by electronic mail, facsimile,
and overnight mail to the following individuals in their capacity as Lead Class Counsel:
Stephen J. Herman
Herman Herman Katz & Cotlar LLP
820 OKeefe Avenue
New Orleans, LA 70113
Fax: 504-561-6024
E-mail: sherman@hhkc.com
James Parkerson Roy
Domengeaux Wright Roy & Edwards
LLC 556 Jefferson Street, Suite 500
Lafayette, LA 70501
Fax: 337-233-2796
E-Mail: jimr@wrightroy.com
Any notice to the Claims Administrator pursuant to this Guarantee shall be sent by electronic
mail, facsimile, and overnight mail to the following individual in his capacity as the Claims
Administrator:
Patrick Juneau
Juneau David, APLC
Post Office Drawer 51268
Lafayette, LA 70505-1268
Fax: 337-269-0061
E-mail: paj@juneaudavid.com
fgg@juneaudavid.com
Whenever any notice is sent related to this Guarantee, such notice shall be sent to all of the
addressees listed in this Clause 14(b).
(c) This Guarantee shall not be amended without the written consent of the Second
Guarantor and the Beneficiaries.
(d) The provisions of this Guarantee shall be deemed severable, and if any one or
more provisions of this Guarantee shall be determined to be invalid or unenforceable, all other
provisions shall, nevertheless, remain in full force and effect.
029006
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-43 Filed 04/18/12 Page 7 of 9
7
(e) If the Second Guarantor has performed under this Guarantee, then within 30 days
of a written demand, the Second Guarantor shall pay all reasonably incurred and properly
documented out-of-pocket costs, fees, and/or expenses incurred by the Claims Administrator
and/or Lead Class Counsel, including fees and disbursements of counsel, in connection with the
pursuit of performance under this Guarantee.
(f) THIS GUARANTEE SHALL BE GOVERNED IN ALL RESPECTS,
INCLUDING AS TO VALIDITY, INTERPRETATION AND EFFECT, BY THE LAWS OF
THE STATE OF NEW YORK, WITHOUT GIVING EFFECT TO ITS PRINCIPLES OR
RULES OF CONFLICT OF LAWS, TO THE EXTENT SUCH PRINCIPLES OR RULES ARE
NOT MANDATORILY APPLICABLE BY STATUTE AND WOULD PERMIT OR REQUIRE
THE APPLICATION OF THE LAWS OF ANOTHER JURISDICTION.
(g) Pursuant to the Courts continuing jurisdiction over the Agreement, the Second
Guarantor, Beneficiary, Claims Administrator, and Lead Class Counsel agree that the United
States District Court for the Eastern District of Louisiana shall have exclusive jurisdiction and
venue to enforce, interpret, give effect to, or resolve any disputes, cases, or controversies
concerning this Guarantee. If MDL 2179 has not yet been terminated, any pleading filed on
behalf of any complainant party relating to the Guarantee shall be accompanied by a legal
request for such dispute, case, or controversy to be made part of MDL 2179. In all other respects
and purposes unrelated to matters involving the Guarantee or its enforcement, the Second
Guarantor specifically reserves any and all defenses to the jurisdiction and venue of this Court.
The Beneficiary, Claims Administrator, and Lead Class Counsel agree that the Second
Guarantors agreement in this Clause 14(g) does not constitute a waiver of jurisdictional
defenses, consent to jurisdiction, or an act supporting or sufficient to establish jurisdiction over
the Second Guarantor for any matter besides disputes, cases, or controversies concerning this
Guarantee.
02900
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-43 Filed 04/18/12 Page 8 of 9
02900
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-43 Filed 04/18/12 Page 9 of 9
2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-44 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 3
Procedures for Filing and Briefing of Appeals
1. The Claims Administrator shall designate an appeals coordinator (Appeals
Coordinator) to coordinate the appeals process set forth in Section 6 of the
Agreement.
2. Appeals shall be commenced by the appellant filing with the Appeals
Coordinator within the applicable time frames set forth in Section 6 of the
Agreement a Notice of Appeal stating the appellants election to appeal, the issues
being appealed and the relief requested. The Appeals Coordinator shall provide a
copy of the Notice of Appeal to the appellee. Such copy shall be provided by
electronic mail if the appellee has provided the Claims Administrator with an
electronic mail address or otherwise by U.S. Mail.
3. Upon receiving a Notice of Appeal, the Appeals Coordinator shall issue a
schedule to the appellant and the appellee, and shall provide the address and email
address at which to serve the parties to the appeal and Lead Class Counsel. The
schedule shall set forth specific due dates (month, day, and year) so that there is a
clear understanding of the following applicable deadlines:
A. For appeals to which the baseball process applies pursuant to
Section 6 of the Agreement, the appellant and appellee shall file their Initial
Proposal with the Appeals Coordinator, and serve the other party by electronic
mail and overnight delivery within 15 days of the date that the Appeals
Coordinator transmits the Notice of Appeal to the appellee via email and overnight
delivery. Any party may file a memorandum in support of its Initial Proposal
together with its Initial Proposal. By no later than 25 days of the date that the
Appeals Coordinator transmits the Notice of Appeal to the appellee, if the appeal
has not been settled by the appellant and appellee, the appellant and appellee shall
each file its Final Proposal and shall serve the other party by electronic mail,
overnight delivery, or U.S. Mail.
B. For appeals to which baseball does not apply pursuant to the
Agreement, the appellant shall file with the Appeals Coordinator, and serve the
appellee, an opening memorandum in support of its appeal explaining the basis for
its appeal within 10 days of the date that the Appeals Coordinator transmits the
Notice of Appeal to the appellee. The appellee may file an opposition
memorandum by no later than 25 days of the date that the Appeals Coordinator
transmits the Notice of Appeal to the appellee. The appellee shall file the
opposition memorandum on the appellant by electronic mail, overnight delivery, or
02 9
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-44 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 3
U.S. Mail. The appellant may file a reply brief by no later than 35 days after the
date that the Appeals Coordinator transmits the Notice of Appeal to the appellee.
The appellant shall file the reply memorandum on the appellee by electronic mail,
overnight delivery, or U.S. Mail.
4. The Appeals Coordinator may grant extensions to the above-mentioned
deadlines in the Appeals Coordinators discretion.
5. The Appeals Coordinator, upon concurrence of the Claims Administrator,
may amend and/or adopt procedures as necessary to implement Section 6 of the
Agreement after providing notice and a right to comment by the BP Parties and
Lead Class Counsel.
6. The Appeals Coordinator shall post on the Court Approved Settlement
Program web site and make available in hard copy a protocol summarizing these
procedures and mechanism for filing appeals and documents in connection
therewith (i.e., address for filing appeals and documents in connection therewith).
7. All decisions of Appeal Panelists shall be emailed to attorneys for the parties
and Lead Class Counsel. In addition, public versions shall be created with
personally identifying information redacted.
8. Pursuant to Section 6.6 of the Settlement Agreement, the Court maintains
the discretionary right to review any Appeal determination and upon reviewing
such determination, the Court shall treat the Appeal determination as if it were a
recommendation by a Magistrate Judge.
02 9 6
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-44 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 3
26
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-45 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 22
Important Information About the Attached Full and Final Release,
Settlement, and Covenant Not to Sue
All claimants have the right to consult with an attorney of their own choosing prior to
accepting any settlement payment or signing a release of legal rights. If you are represented by
an attorney in connection with your claim, confer with your attorney before signing this
document.
The attached Full and Final Release, Settlement, and Covenant Not to Sue (Individual Release)
is a binding legal document. By signing this document, you are forever waiving and releasing all
claims that you may have against BP or any other party in connection with the Deepwater
Horizon Incident (as defined in the Individual Release) except for Expressly Reserved Claims (as
defined in the Individual Release).
By signing the attached Individual Release, you are forever giving up and discharging any
rights that you may have for any costs, damages, causes of actions, claims, or other relief
related to or arising from the Deepwater Horizon Incident except for Expressly Reserved Claims
even if you are not currently aware of such costs or damages and even if such costs or
damages arise in the future (i.e., additional oil impacts) or do not manifest themselves until
the future.
By signing the attached Individual Release, you acknowledge that you have read and understand the
terms of the Individual Release, and that you execute the Individual Release voluntarily and without
being pressured or influenced by, and without relying upon, any statement or representation made by
any person acting on behalf of BP or any other released party.
The settlement payment you have been offered arises under the auspices of the federal District
Court in New Orleans presiding over the multidistrict litigation titled In re Oil Spill by the Oil Rig
Deepwater Horizon in the Gulf of Mexico, on April 20, 2010 (MDL No. 2179). A class action
settlement has been proposed in that case, but the Court has not yet given final approval of that
proposed settlement. If the Court does approve the proposed class action settlement, an appellate
court could reverse the approval. In addition, it is possible that the terms of the proposed
settlement may change in the futurefor better or for worseas a result of further legal
proceedings. However, if you sign this Individual Release, none of those uncertain future events
will affect you. By signing this Individual Release you are forever waiving and releasing all
claims that you may have against BP (except for Expressly Reserved Claims) in exchange
for the compensation being provided. In fact, even if the Court does not approve the proposed
class action settlement agreement or the approval is reversed by an appellate court, you shall
continue to be bound by this Individual Release.
For a Business Claimant, if the business is a sole proprietorship and you are the owner and you
are married, or if the business is jointly owned by you and your spouse, both you and your spouse
must sign the Individual Release. For an Individual Claimant, if you are married, both you and your
spouse must sign the Individual Release. You and your spouse should not sign the Individual
Release unless you both intend to release and give up all of your claims.
02926
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-45 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 22
2
By signing below, you acknowledge that you have read and understand the information above. You
elect to accept the payment as a final settlement of all claims against any party in connection with
the Deepwater Horizon Incident except for Expressly Reserved Claims. You consent to the use
and disclosure by the Claims Administrator and those assisting the Claims Administrator of any
information that the Claims Administrator believes necessary and/or helpful to process your claim
for compensation and payment and to any legitimate business purposes associated with administering
the settlement facility. Finally, you consent to the Claims Administrator providing documentation and
information to Lead Class Counsel, BP, and the Court as provided for in the Settlement Agreement.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
I/We acknowledge that I/we have read and understand the information above. I/We consent to
the claimants election to accept the payment as a final settlement of all claims of claimant against
any party in connection with the Deepwater Horizon Incident except for Expressly Reserved Claims.
Signature of Claimant Date
Signature of Claimants Spouse Date
029269
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-45 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 22
3
FULL AND FINAL RELEASE, SETTLEMENT, AND COVENANT NOT TO SUE
1. Definitions: For purposes of this Individual Release, the following definitions shall
apply, and in the case of defined nouns, the singular shall include the plural and vice versa:
(a) Affiliate means with respect to any Natural Person or Entity, any other
Natural Person or Entity that directly or indirectly, through one or more intermediaries, controls, or is
controlled by, or is under common control with, such Natural Person or Entity.
(b) Assigned Claims means the claims defined in Exhibit 21 to the Settlement
Agreement.
(c) Bodily Injury Claims means claims and damages, including lost wages, for or
resulting from personal injury, latent injury, future injury, progression of existing injury, damage, disease,
death, fear of disease or injury or death, mental or physical pain or suffering, or emotional or mental
harm, anguish or loss of enjoyment of life, including any claim for mental health injury, arising out of,
due to, resulting from, or relating in any way to, directly or indirectly, the Deepwater Horizon Incident.
(d) BP means BP Exploration & Production Inc., BP America Production
Company, BP America Inc., BP Company North America Inc., BP Corporation North America Inc., BP
Corporation North America Inc. Savings Plan Investment Oversight Committee, BP Energy Company,
BP Exploration (Alaska) Inc., BP Global Special Products (America) Inc., BP Holdings North America
Limited, BP p.l.c., BP Products North America Inc., and each of their respective direct or indirect parents,
subsidiaries and subsidiary undertakings (as those terms are defined in the U.K. Companies Act 2006),
Affiliates, divisions, and business units.
(e) Claim means any demand or request for compensation (other than Bodily
Injury Claims or Expressly Reserved Claims), together with any properly completed forms and
accompanying required documentation, submitted by a Claimant to the Settlement Program.
(f) Claimant means any Natural Person or Entity that submits a Claim to the
Settlement Program seeking compensation as a member of the Economic Class.
(g) Coastal Real Property means property in the Coastal Real Property Claim
Zone.
(h) Coastal Real Property Claim Framework means that process described in
the document captioned Coastal Real Property Claim Frameworks, attached as Exhibit 11A to the
Settlement Agreement.
(i) Coastal Real Property Claim Zone means the areas identified on the Coastal
Real Property Compensation Zone Map included with the Coastal Real Property Claim Framework.
(j) Coastal Real Property Damage means a loss to Real Property claimed to
have been suffered by a Coastal Real Property owner or lessee in the Coastal Real Property Claim
Zone allegedly arising out of, due to, resulting from, or relating in any way to, directly or indirectly, the
Deepwater Horizon Incident that is separate from Seafood Compensation Program, Economic
Damage, Real Property Sales Damage, Wetlands Real Property Damage, VoO Charter Payment,
Vessel Physical Damage and Subsistence Damage, and is more fully described in Exhibit 11A to the
Settlement Agreement.
0292 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-45 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 22
4
(k) Compensatory Damages means any and all forms of damages, known or
unknown, intended to or having the effect of satisfying, compensating, or reimbursing Claimants claims
for actual economic or pecuniary costs, expenses, damages, liability, or other losses or injuries arising out
of, due to, resulting from, or relating in any way to, directly or indirectly, the Deepwater Horizon
Incident, regardless of what such damages are designated, called or labeled. Compensatory Damages
do not include and may not be interpreted to have any overlap with punitive, exemplary, multiple, or non-
compensatory damages. Bodily Injury Claims (including wrongful death) are not included in
Compensatory Damages. Claims of BP shareholders in any derivative or direct action solely in their
capacity as BP shareholders are not included in Compensatory Damages. BP and Claimant
acknowledge and agree that the term Compensatory Damages as defined and used herein does not limit
the amounts to be used for the calculation of punitive or other non-compensatory damages in any current
or future litigation pursued by Claimant. Nothing herein shall be deemed to limit Claimants rights to
pursue Moratoria Losses or other claims expressly reserved against BP under Section 3 of the Settlement
Agreement.
(l) Damages means all forms of damages defined as broadly as possible without
exception, including losses, costs, expenses, taxes, requests, royalties, rents, fees, profits, profit shares,
earning capacity, loss of subsistence, damages to real or personal property, diminution in property value,
punitive damages, exemplary damages, multiple damages, non-compensatory damages, Compensatory
Damages, economic damages, injuries, liens, remedies, debts, claims, causes of action, or liabilities.
(m) Deepwater Horizon Economic Litigation means all Claims brought by
Claimant or any Economic Class Member for damage covered by the Seafood Compensation
Program, Coastal Real Property Damage, Economic Damage, Real Property Sales Damage,
Subsistence Damage, VoO Charter Payment, Vessel Physical Damage or Wetlands Real Property
Damage allegedly arising out of, due to, resulting from, or relating in any way to, directly or indirectly,
the Deepwater Horizon Incident, in the MDL Action.
(n) Deepwater Horizon Incident means the events, actions, inactions and
omissions leading up to and including (i) the blowout of the MC252 Well, (ii) the explosions and fire on
board the Deepwater Horizon on or about April 20, 2010, (iii) the sinking of the Deepwater Horizon on
or about April 22, 2010, (iv) the release of oil, other hydrocarbons and other substances from the MC252
Well and/or the Deepwater Horizon and its appurtenances, (v) the efforts to contain the MC252 Well, (vi)
Response Activities, including the VoO Program; (vii) the operation of the GCCF; and (viii) BP public
statements relating to all of the foregoing.
(o) DHOST means the Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill Trust, which is the
irrevocable common law trust established under Delaware law in accordance with the trust agreement
titled Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill Trust dated August 6, 2010, and entered into among BP Exploration
& Production Inc.; John S. Martin, Jr. and Kent D. Syverud, as individual trustees; and Citigroup Trust-
Delaware, N.A., as corporate trustee.
(p) Economic Class means the Economic and Property Damages Settlement
Class.
(q) Economic Damage means loss of profits, income, and/or earnings arising in
the Gulf Coast Areas or Specified Gulf Waters allegedly arising out of, due to, resulting from, or
relating in any way to, directly or indirectly, the Deepwater Horizon Incident; provided, however, that
Economic Damage does not include (1) loss of profits or earnings, or damages for injury relating to Real
Property or personal property that constitutes any part of the Seafood Compensation Program, Coastal
Real Property Damage, Real Property Sales Damage, Wetlands Real Property Damage, Vessel
0292
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-45 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 22
5
Physical Damage, or (2) VoO Charter Payment, or (3) damages for loss of Subsistence use of natural
resources, which constitutes Subsistence Damage.
(r) Entity means an organization or entity, other than a Governmental
Organization, operating or having operated for profit or not-for-profit, including a partnership, a
corporation, a limited liability company, an association, a joint stock company, a trust, a joint venture or
an unincorporated association of any kind or description.
(s) Expressly Reserved Claims means the following Claims that are not
recognized or released under this Individual Release, and are reserved to Claimant: (1) Bodily Injury
Claims; (2) claims of BP shareholders in any derivative or direct action solely in their capacity as BP
shareholders; (3) claims of Natural Persons and Entities for Moratoria Losses; (4) claims relating to
menhaden (or pogy) fishing, processing, selling, catching, or harvesting; and (5) claims for Economic
Damage suffered by Entities or employees (to the extent they allege Economic Damage based on their
employment by such an Entity during the Class Period) in the Banking, Gaming, Financial, Insurance,
Oil and Gas, Real Estate Development, and Defense Contractor Industries, and entities selling or
marketing BP-branded fuel, including jobbers and branded retailers, as defined in the Settlement
Agreement; and (6) claims for punitive or exemplary damages against Halliburton and Transocean
subject to the provisions of Section 11 of the Settlement Agreement; and (7) the rights of the Claimant
to recover additional benefits from the Economic Class secured by virtue of the efforts of the Economic
Class to pursue Assigned Claims, again subject to the provisions of Section 11 of the Settlement
Agreement.
(t) Finfish means fish other than shellfish and octopuses.
(u) Game includes nutria, mink, otters, raccoons, muskrats, alligators, and other
wildlife.
(v) GCCF means the Gulf Coast Claims Facility.
(w) Governmental Organization means: (a) the government of the United States
of America, (b) any state or local government, (c) any agency, branch, commission, department, or unit of
the government of the United States of America or of any state or local government, or (d) any Affiliate
of, or any business or organization of any type that is owned in whole or in part to the extent of at least
51% by the government of the United States of America or any state or local government, or any of their
agencies, branches, commissions, departments, or units.
(x) Gulf Coast Areas means the States of Louisiana, Mississippi, and Alabama;
the counties of Chambers, Galveston, Jefferson and Orange in the State of Texas; and the counties of Bay,
Calhoun, Charlotte, Citrus, Collier, Dixie, Escambia, Franklin, Gadsden, Gulf, Hernando, Hillsborough,
Holmes, Jackson, Jefferson, Lee, Leon, Levy, Liberty, Manatee, Monroe, Okaloosa, Pasco, Pinellas,
Santa Rosa, Sarasota, Taylor, Wakulla, Walton and Washington in the State of Florida, including all
adjacent Gulf waters, bays, estuaries, straits, and other tidal or brackish waters within the States of
Louisiana, Mississippi, Alabama or those described counties of Texas or Florida.
(y) Halliburton means Halliburton Energy Services, Inc. and all and any of its
Affiliates, other than any Natural Person or Entity that is also an Affiliate of any of the Released
Parties as of April 16, 2012.
(z) Halliburton Parties shall mean Halliburton (including all persons, entities,
subsidiaries, divisions and business units comprised thereby); each of Halliburtons respective past,
0292 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-45 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 22
6
present and future directors, officers, employees, general or limited partners, members, joint venturers,
and shareholders, and the past, present and future spouses, heirs, beneficiaries, estates, executors,
administrators, personal representatives, attorneys, agents, trustees, insurers, reinsurers, predecessors,
successors, indemnitees, assigns, Affiliates; any natural, legal or juridical person or entity acting on
behalf of or having liability in respect of Halliburton, in their respective capacities as such; and the
federal Oil Spill Liability Trust Fund and any state or local fund, and each of their respective Affiliates
including their officers, directors, shareholders, employees, and agents.
(aa) Incompetent Claimant means a Natural Person who lacks the capacity to
enter into a contract on his or her behalf at the time this Individual Release is executed, in accordance
with the state laws of that persons domicile as applied to adult capacity issues, whether through power of
attorney agency documents, guardianship, conservatorship, tutorship, or otherwise.
(bb) Individual Release means this Full and Final Release, Settlement, and
Covenant Not to Sue.
(cc) MC252 Well means the exploratory well named Macondo that was being
drilled by the Transocean Marianas and Deepwater Horizon rigs in Mississippi Canyon, Block 252 on the
outer continental shelf in the Gulf of Mexico, approximately 130 miles southeast of New Orleans,
Louisiana.
(dd) MDL Action means the federal multidistrict litigation pending before the
United States District Court for the Eastern District of Louisiana, titled, In re: Oil Spill by the Oil Rig
Deepwater Horizon in the Gulf of Mexico, on April 20, 2010 (MDL No. 2179).
(ee) Minor Claimant means a Natural Person whose age is below that of the
majority rule for the State in which the minor resides at the time this Individual Release is executed.
(ff) Moratoria Loss means any loss whatsoever caused by or resulting from
federal regulatory action or inaction directed at offshore oil industry activity including shallow water
and deepwater activity that occurred after May 28, 2010, including the federal moratoria on offshore
permitting and drilling activities imposed on May 28, 2010 and July 12, 2010 and new or revised safety
rules, regulations, inspections, or permitting practices.
(gg) Natural Person means a human being, and includes the estate of a human
being who died on or after April 20, 2010. For purposes of this Individual Release, a Natural Person
that is the estate of a human being who died on or after April 20, 2010, a Minor Claimant or
Incompetent Claimant, shall be deemed to act through his, her or its Representative.
(hh) OPA means the Oil Pollution Act of 1990, 33 U.S.C. 2701, et seq.
(ii) Other Party means every person, entity, or party other than the Released
Parties.
(jj) Other Released Parties means Released Parties other than BP.
(kk) Real Property means land, including improvements thereon, and property of
any nature appurtenant or affixed thereto.
(ll) Real Property Sales Compensation Zone shall be defined as Residential
Parcels identified in the Real Property Compensation Zone Map.
0292
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-45 Filed 04/18/12 Page 7 of 22
7
(mm) Real Property Compensation Zone Map means the map(s) attached as
Exhibit 13B to the Settlement Agreement.
(nn) Real Property Sales Damage means damages for realized damage on the sale
of Residential Parcels arising out of, due to, resulting from, or relating in any way to, directly or
indirectly, the Deepwater Horizon Incident.
(oo) Released Claims means all claims arising out of, due to, resulting from, or
relating in any way to, directly or indirectly, the Deepwater Horizon Incident, including any and all
actions, claims, costs, expenses, taxes, rents, fees, profit shares, liens, remedies, debts, demands,
liabilities, obligations, or promises of any kind or nature whatsoever, in both law or in equity, past or
present, whether known or unknown, including claims for any and all Unknown Claims or damages,
future injuries, damages or losses not currently known, but which may later develop, provided they arise
out of, are due to, result from, or relate in any way to, directly or indirectly, the Deepwater Horizon
Incident, and regardless of the legal or equitable theory, arising under any source of law whether
international, federal, state, or local, and regardless of whether pursuant to statutory law, codal law,
adjudication, quasi-adjudication, regulation, or ordinance, including common law, maritime or admiralty,
statutory and non-statutory attorneys fees, breach of contract, breach of any covenant of good faith
and/or fair dealing, fraud, misrepresentation, fraudulent concealment, deception, consumer fraud,
antitrust, defamation, tortious interference with contract or business expectations, loss of business
expectations or opportunities, loss of employment or earning capacity, diminution of property value,
violation of the federal Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act or any similar state law,
violations of any consumer protection act, punitive damages, exemplary damages, multiple damages, non-
compensatory damages, Compensatory Damages, pain and suffering, interest, injunctive relief,
declaratory judgment, costs, deceptive practices, unfair business practices, regulation, strict liability,
negligence, gross negligence, willful misconduct, nuisance, trespass, fraudulent concealment, statutory
violations, including OPA or other statutory claims, unfair business practices, breach of fiduciary duty,
and all other theories whether existing now or arising in the future, arising out of, due to, resulting from,
or relating in any way to, directly or indirectly, the Deepwater Horizon Incident. Released Claims
shall not include Expressly Reserved Claims.
(pp) Released Parties, for purposes of the Released Claims, means (i) BP
(including all persons, entities, subsidiaries, divisions and business units comprised thereby), together
with (ii) DHOST; (iii) the persons, entities, divisions, and business units listed on Attachment A; (iv)
each of BPs and the Other Released Parties respective past, present and future directors, officers,
employees, general or limited partners, members, joint venturers, and shareholders, and their past, present
and future spouses, heirs, beneficiaries, estates, executors, administrators, personal representatives,
attorneys, agents, trustees, insurers, reinsurers, predecessors, successors, indemnitees, assigns; (v) any
natural, legal or juridical person or Entity acting on behalf of or having liability in respect of BP or the
Other Released Parties, in their respective capacities as such; and (vi) the federal Oil Spill Liability
Trust Fund and any state or local fund, and, as to i-vi above, each of their respective Affiliates including
their Affiliates officers, directors, shareholders, employees, and agents. Released Parties will also
include any vessels owned or chartered by any Released Party (except for the Deepwater Horizon itself).
Notwithstanding anything herein to the contrary, in no event shall any of the following be deemed to be a
Released Party: Transocean or Halliburton. Claimant specifically reserves its rights for punitive and
exemplary damages against Transocean and Halliburton subject to the provisions of Paragraph 11 of the
Settlement Agreement. Furthermore, nothing herein shall impair the rights of the Claimant to recover
additional benefits from the Economic Class secured by virtue of the efforts of the Economic Class to
pursue Assigned Claims, again subject to the provisions of Paragraph 11 of the Settlement Agreement.
0292
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-45 Filed 04/18/12 Page 8 of 22
8
(qq) Residential Parcels means those parcels within the Real Property Sales
Compensation Zone for which the county where the parcel is located has designated the parcel as a
residential classification.
(rr) Response Activities means the clean up, remediation efforts, and all other
responsive actions (including the use and handling of dispersants) relating to the releases of oil, other
hydrocarbons and other pollutants from the MC252 Well and/or the Deepwater Horizon and its
appurtenances and the Deepwater Horizon Incident.
(ss) Seafood means fish and shellfish, including shrimp, oysters, crab, and Finfish,
caught in the Specified Gulf Waters. Seafood shall exclude menhaden.
(tt) Seafood Compensation Program means the program defined in Section 5.2
of the Settlement Agreement.
(uu) Settlement Agreement means the Economic and Property Damages
Settlement Agreement.
(vv) Settlement Program means the Deepwater Horizon Court Supervised
Settlement Program created pursuant to the Settlement Agreement.
(ww) Specified Gulf Waters means the U.S. waters of the Gulf of Mexico and all
adjacent bays, estuaries, straits, and other tidal or brackish waters within the Gulf Coast Areas, as
specifically shown and described in Exhibit 23 to the Settlement Agreement.
(xx) Subsistence means fishing or hunting to harvest, catch, barter, consume or
trade Gulf of Mexico natural resources (including Seafood and Game), in a traditional or customary
manner, to sustain basic personal or family dietary, economic security, shelter, tool, or clothing needs.
(yy) Subsistence Damage means a loss of value of Subsistence use of natural
resources alleged to arise out of, result from or relate in any way to, directly or indirectly, the Deepwater
Horizon Incident.
(zz) Transocean means Transocean Ltd., Transocean, Inc., Transocean Offshore
Deepwater Drilling Inc., Transocean Deepwater Inc., Transocean Holdings LLC, and Triton Asset
Leasing GmbH and all and any of their Affiliates, other than any Natural Person or Entity that is also an
Affiliate of any of the Released Parties.
(aaa) Transocean Parties means Transocean (including all persons, entities,
subsidiaries, divisions and business units comprised thereby); each of Transoceans respective past,
present and future directors, officers, employees, general or limited partners, members, joint venturers,
and shareholders, and the past, present and future spouses, heirs, beneficiaries, estates, executors,
administrators, personal representatives, attorneys, agents, trustees, insurers, reinsurers, predecessors,
successors, indemnitees, assigns, Affiliates; any natural, legal or juridical person or entity acting on
behalf of or having liability in respect of Transocean, in their respective capacities as such; and the
federal Oil Spill Liability Trust Fund and any state or local fund, and each of their respective Affiliates
including their officers, directors, shareholders, employees, and agents.
(bbb) Unknown Claims and damages or not currently known claims and damages
(whether or not capitalized) means all past, present, and future claims and damages arising out of facts,
including new facts or facts found hereafter to be other than or different from the facts now believed
0292
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-45 Filed 04/18/12 Page 9 of 22
9
to be true, arising out of, due to, resulting from, or relating in any way to, directly or indirectly, the
Deepwater Horizon Incident covered by this Individual Release that Claimant does not, in whole
or in part, know or suspect to exist and which, if known by them, might have affected their decision to
provide such Individual Release, including all claims arising out of new facts or facts found hereafter to
be other than or different from the facts now believed to be true.
(ccc) Vessel Physical Damage means physical damage that was sustained by an
eligible Claimants eligible vessel due to or resulting from the Deepwater Horizon Incident or the
Deepwater Horizon Incident response cleanup operations, including the VoO Program, that were
consistent with the National Contingency Plan or specifically ordered by the Federal On-Scene
Coordinator or delegates thereof.
(ddd) VoO Charter Payment means a loss alleged by a VoO Charter Payment
Claimant for any payment or compensation related to participation in the VoO Program that satisfies the
requirements set forth in Section 5.5 of the Settlement Agreement.
(eee) VoO Charter Payment Claimant means an Economic Class Member
claiming to have suffered a VoO Charter Payment loss.
(fff) VoO Master Vessel Charter Agreement means the standard agreements
utilized by BP and its agents or subcontractors to charter the vessels available for work or service in
connection with the VoO Program.
(ggg) VoO Program means the program through which vessel owners performed
work for BP or BPs authorized agents pursuant to the terms of the VoO Master Vessel Charter
Agreement.
(hhh) Wetlands Real Property Claim Framework means the rules described in the
document captioned Wetlands Real Property Claim Frameworks, attached the Settlement Agreement as
Exhibits 12A-12B.
(iii) Wetlands Real Property Claimant means an Economic Class Member
claiming to have suffered Wetlands Real Property Damage.
(jjj) Wetlands Real Property Damage means a loss alleged by a Wetlands Real
Property Claimant that satisfies the requirements set forth in the Wetlands Real Property Claim
Framework.
2. Release. In consideration of payment in the amount of [insert $$], previous payments
for Claims referenced and released herein, and the right to receive additional Settlement Payment(s) for
any additional Claims, if any, pursuant to the terms of Section 4.4.8 of the Settlement Agreement, which
Claimant accepts as sufficient and adequate consideration for any and all Released Claims, Claimant,
on behalf of Claimant and Claimants heirs, beneficiaries, estates, executors, administrators, personal
representatives, agents, trustees, insurers, reinsurers, subsidiaries, corporate parents, predecessors,
successors, indemnitors, subrogees, assigns, and any natural, legal or juridical person or entity entitled to
assert any claim on behalf of or in respect of any Claimant, hereby releases and forever discharges with
prejudice, and covenants not to sue, the Released Parties for any and all Released Claims; provided
however that this Individual Release does not apply to, and the term Released Claims does not include,
Expressly Reserved Claims. In the event a Released Party is sold or otherwise transferred to or
purchases or otherwise acquires, or enters into a partnership or joint venture with, a Natural Person or
Entity that is not otherwise a Released Party immediately prior to giving effect to such transaction, then
0292 6
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-45 Filed 04/18/12 Page 10 of 22
10
the non-Released Party shall as a result of such transaction obtain a benefit under this Individual
Release only with respect to any liability of the Released Party that it, or any such partnership or joint
venture, has acquired or assumed or otherwise become liable for, and not in its own right.
3. Release Is Comprehensive. Claimant agrees and acknowledges that the consideration
granted in Paragraph 2 above constitutes full, complete, and total satisfaction of all of the Released
Claims against the Released Parties. In addition, Claimant agrees and acknowledges that the
consideration granted in Paragraph 2 above also constitutes full, complete, and total satisfaction of all of
Claimants Compensatory Damage Claims against the Transocean Parties and the Halliburton
Parties.
4. Non-General Release. Claimant expressly waives and releases with prejudice, and
shall be deemed to have waived and released with prejudice, any and all rights that it may have under any
law, codal law, statute, regulation, adjudication, quasi-adjudication, decision, administrative decision, or
common law principle that would otherwise limit the effect of the Individual Release to those claims or
matters actually known or suspected to exist at the time of execution of the Individual Release.
California law is not applicable to this Individual Release, but purely for illustrative purposes the
Released Claims include, but are not limited to the release of claims provided for in Section 1542 of the
California Civil Code, which provides as follows: A general release does not extend to claims which the
creditor does not know or suspect to exist in his or her favor at the time of executing the release, which if
known by him or her must have materially affected his or her settlement with the debtor.
5. Contribution, Subrogation, Indemnity. This Individual Release is not intended to
prevent BP from exercising its rights of contribution, subrogation, or indemnity under OPA or any other
law, including its rights of assignment regarding Assigned Claims as set forth in Exhibit 21 to the
Settlement Agreement. BP is hereby subrogated to any and all rights that the Economic Class
Members, or any of them, may have had or have arising out of, due to, resulting from, or relating in any
way to, directly or indirectly, the Deepwater Horizon Incident under OPA. All such rights of BP to
contribution, indemnity, and subrogation, and BPs subrogation to the rights of Economic Class
Members, are subject to the provisions regarding Assigned Claims in Exhibit 21 to the Settlement
Agreement.
6. Consideration. Claimant agrees that this Individual Release is entered into in
consideration of the agreements, promises, and mutual covenants set forth in this Individual Release and
for such other good and valuable consideration the receipt and sufficiency of which are hereby
acknowledged.
7. No Further Action. Claimant agrees not to file federal or state judicial or
administrative proceedings concerning cleanup, removal, spill response or remediation of Coastal Real
Property Damages and Wetlands Real Property Damages, or the underlying Real Property, as a
means to seek the redress of Released Claims.
8. Dismissal of All Claims.
(a) In consideration of the benefits provided under this Individual Release, all
Released Claims by or on behalf of Claimant against any and all Released Parties shall be
dismissed with prejudice in any lawsuit in which the Claimant is a party.
(b) This Individual Release shall be the exclusive remedy for any and all Released
Claims by or on behalf of Claimant against any and all Released Parties, and Claimant shall
0292
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-45 Filed 04/18/12 Page 11 of 22
11
not recover, directly or indirectly, any sums from any Released Parties for any Released Claims
other than those received for the Released Claims under the terms of this Individual Release.
(c) Claimant agrees that Claimant, and all other Natural Persons and Entities
claiming by, through, or on behalf of Claimant will be forever barred and enjoined from
commencing, filing, initiating, instituting, prosecuting, maintaining, or consenting to any judicial,
arbitral, or regulatory action against the Released Parties with respect to the Released Claims.
(d) If Claimant commences, files, initiates, or institutes any new action or other
proceeding for any Released Claims against the Released Parties in any federal or state court,
arbitration tribunal, or administrative or other forum, such action or other proceeding shall be
dismissed with prejudice and at Claimants cost; provided, however, before any costs may be
assessed, counsel for such Claimant, or, if not represented, such Claimant shall be given
reasonable notice and an opportunity voluntarily to dismiss such new action or proceeding with
prejudice. Furthermore, if Claimant brings any legal action before any Court, arbitration panel,
regulatory agency, or other tribunal to enforce its rights under this Individual Release, such
Released Party shall be entitled to recover any and all related costs and expenses (including
attorneys fees) from any Claimant in violation or breach of its obligations under this Individual
Release.
9. No Admission of Liability or Wrongdoing by BP. The Paragraph 2 payment to
Claimant is made without any admission of liability or wrongdoing by BP or any other Released Party
and is made purely by way of compromise and settlement.
10. Claimant Warranty. Claimant represents and warrants that Claimant or Claimants
undersigned representative in the case of a business entity has authority to execute this Individual
Release on behalf of Claimant.
11. Additional Protections for Released Parties. Claimant promises, agrees,
acknowledges, represents, warrants, and covenants as follows:
(a) No Assignment of Claims. Claimant shall not assign or reassign, or attempt to
assign or reassign, to any person or entity other than BP any rights or claims arising out of, due
to, resulting from, or relating in any way to, directly or indirectly, the Deepwater Horizon
Incident. Any such assignment or reassignment, or attempt to assign or reassign, to any Natural
Person or Entity other than BP any rights or claims arising out of, due to, resulting from, or
relating in any way to, directly or indirectly, the Deepwater Horizon Incident shall be void,
invalid, and of no force and effect.
(b) No Recovery of Additional Compensatory Damages. Claimant shall not
accept or attempt to recover, through insurance, reinsurance, indemnification, contribution,
subrogation, litigation, settlement, or otherwise, any Compensatory Damages from the
Transocean Parties and/or the Halliburton Parties. Nothing in this Paragraph 11(b) shall
impair or impact Claimants rights to pursue Transocean and Halliburton for exemplary and
punitive damages individually or through the Economic Class.
(c) Non-Execution and Non-Collection for Compensatory Damages. In the event
that Claimant is or becomes the beneficiary of any judgment, decision, award, or settlement
arising out of, due to, resulting from, or relating in any way to, directly or indirectly, the
Deepwater Horizon Incident, Claimant shall not accept, execute on, attempt to collect, or
otherwise seek recovery of any Compensatory Damages from the Transocean Parties and/or
0292
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-45 Filed 04/18/12 Page 12 of 22
12
the Halliburton Parties. Nothing in this Paragraph 11(c) shall impair or impact Claimants
rights to pursue Transocean and Halliburton for exemplary and punitive damages individually
or through the Economic Class.
(d) Conditional Collection of Damages. In the event that Claimant is or becomes
the beneficiary of any judgment, decision, award, or settlement arising out of, due to, resulting
from, or relating in any way to, directly or indirectly, the Deepwater Horizon Incident,
including from Assigned Claims and/or Expressly Reserved Claims, Claimant shall not accept,
execute on, attempt to collect, or otherwise seek recovery of any Damages, to the extent that any
Other Party is seeking or may seek to recover such Damages from any Released Party, whether
through indemnity, contribution, subrogation, assignment, or any other theory of recovery, by
contract, pursuant to applicable law or regulation, or otherwise, directly or indirectly. Claimant
may, however, accept, execute on, attempt to collect, or otherwise seek recovery of Damages if
and when a court or tribunal of competent jurisdiction has finally determined that Other Parties
cannot recover such Damages, whether through indemnity, contribution, subrogation, assignment
or any other theory of recovery, by contract, pursuant to applicable law or regulation, or
otherwise, directly or indirectly, from any Released Party. For purposes of this Paragraph 11(d),
finally determined shall mean the conclusion of any applicable appeals or other rights to seek
review by certiorari or otherwise, or the lapse of any and all such rights, or the lapse of any and
all applicable limitations or repose periods.
(e) Conditions on Future Settlements. Claimant may settle or compromise any
rights, demands, or claims with the Transocean Parties, the Halliburton Parties, and/or any
Other Parties arising out of, due to, resulting from, or relating in any way to, directly or
indirectly, the Deepwater Horizon Incident if but only if the Transocean Parties, the
Halliburton Parties, and/or such Other Party, as the case may be, agrees as part of that
settlement or compromise to a full and final release of, dismissal of, and covenant not to sue for
any and all rights to recover, directly or indirectly, from the Released Parties (whether through
indemnity, contribution, subrogation, assignment or any other theory of recovery, by contract,
pursuant to applicable law or regulation, or otherwise) for any Damages or other relief or
consideration provided under or relating to such settlement or compromise (whether the
settlement is of a class, of individual claims, or otherwise), including from Expressly Reserved
Claims, and further represents and warrants that it has not assigned and will not assign any rights
to recover for such Damages or other relief or consideration (whether through indemnity,
contribution, subrogation, or otherwise). As part of this commitment and without limitation,
Claimant shall not to settle or compromise with the Transocean Parties, the Halliburton
Parties, and/or any Other Parties on terms that might allow any insurers, reinsurers, or
indemnitors thereof to claim against any Released Parties for indemnification, subrogation,
contribution, assignment or under any other theory of recovery. Claimant agrees that, before any
such settlement or compromise is executed, BP shall have the right to approve language in any
such settlement or compromise memorializing the representation and warranty set forth in this
Paragraph 11(e), which approval shall not be unreasonably withheld.
(f) Indemnity to Released Parties. Notwithstanding any provision in this
Individual Release to the contrary, if any Other Party recovers or seeks to recover from any
Released Party (under any theory of recovery, including indemnity, contribution, or subrogation,
and including from Assigned Claims and/or Expressly Reserved Claims) any Damages either
(a) paid to Claimant, or (b) by, through, under, or on account of Claimant; then Claimant shall
indemnify (not defend) the Released Parties, but only to the extent of the consideration received
in Paragraph 2 above (by way of example, if Claimant has received $100.00 pursuant to
Paragraph 2 above, its indemnity obligation would be capped at this amount). This indemnity
0292 9
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-45 Filed 04/18/12 Page 13 of 22
13
obligation owed by Claimant includes any and all claims made or other actions taken by that
Claimant taken in breach of this Individual Release.
(g) Notice Regarding Indemnity. Claimant expressly acknowledges that, to the
fullest extent allowed by law, the indemnity obligations contained in Paragraph 11(f) above apply
to claims against Released Parties predicated on negligence, gross negligence, willful
misconduct, strict liability, intentional torts, liability based on contractual indemnity, and any and
all other theories of liability, and any and all awards of attorneys fees or other costs or expenses.
Claimant acknowledges that this indemnity is for conduct occurring before the date of this
Individual Release and therefore is not affected by public policies or other law prohibiting
agreements to indemnify in advance of certain conduct. CLAIMANT ACKNOWLEDGES
THAT THIS PARAGRAPH 11(g) COMPLIES WITH ANY REQUIREMENT TO
EXPRESSLY STATE THAT LIABILITY FOR SUCH CLAIMS IS INDEMNIFIED AND
THAT THIS PARAGRAPH 11(g) IS CONSPICUOUS AND AFFORDS FAIR AND
ADEQUATE NOTICE.
12. Claimant Signature Requirements. Claimant must personally sign the Individual
Release, rather than through an attorney or otherwise. An electronic signature is insufficient. In addition
to signing and accepting the overall Individual Release immediately below, Claimant agrees to
separately sign and vouch for the accuracy of the certifications contained in Attachment B.
13. Spouses Signature. If the Claimant has a living spouse, the Claimants spouse must
also personally sign below. An electronic signature is insufficient. The Claimant and his or her spouse
should not sign the Individual Release unless they both intend to release all Released Claims.
14. Choice of Law. Notwithstanding the law applicable to the underlying claims, which is a
disputed issue not resolved by this Individual Release, this Individual Release and all questions with
respect to the construction and enforcement thereof and the rights and liabilities hereto shall be
interpreted in accord with General Maritime Law, as well as in a manner intended to comply with OPA.
15. Superseding Nature of Agreement. This Individual Release constitutes the final,
complete, and exclusive agreement and understanding between BP and Claimant and supersedes any and
all other agreements, written or oral, between BP and Claimant with respect to such subject matter of this
Individual Release in settlement of Claims arising out of or related to the Deepwater Horizon Incident.
16. Continuing Effectiveness of Agreement. This Individual Release shall remain
effective regardless of any appeals or court decisions relating in any way to the liability of the Released
Parties in any current or future litigation. This Individual Release shall also remain effective
regardless of whether the Settlement Agreement resolving the Claims of the Economic Class is
approved.
17. Choice of Federal Forum and Waiver of State Forums. Any and all disputes, cases, or
controversies concerning this Individual Release, including without limitation disputes concerning the
interpretation or enforceability of this Individual Release, shall be filed only in the United States District
Court for the Eastern District of Louisiana, accompanied by a legal request made on behalf of any
complainant party (whether one of the Released Parties or the Claimant) for such dispute to be made
part of the MDL Action if the MDL Action has not yet been terminated. No actions to enforce this
Individual Release shall be filed in any state court, arbitration tribunal, or administrative agency and
Claimant represents and warrants that it shall not file such an action in any state court, arbitration
tribunal, or administrative agency. Claimant agrees not to contest the existence of federal jurisdiction in
the MDL Action or the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Louisiana .
0292 0
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-45 Filed 04/18/12 Page 14 of 22
14
18. Reservation of Rights. Notwithstanding the above and foregoing Individual Release,
Claimant hereby reserves: (i) the right to additional settlement payments for any additional Claims, if
any, pursuant to the terms of Section 4.4.8 of the Settlement Agreement; (ii) any and all rights or claims
to which Claimant may be entitled for additional distributions from and funds held in reserve or trust
(including, but not limited to, the Seafood Compensation Program, Assigned Claims and/or
Transocean Personnel Insurance Proceeds) according to the terms of the Settlement Agreement; and (iii)
Expressly Reserved Claims.
19. Claimants Responsibility for Attorneys Fees. To the extent that Claimant has
retained or engaged a private attorney to represent him or her or it in connection with the Deepwater
Horizon Incident, Claimant acknowledges and agrees that he or she or it, and not the BP Parties, is
solely responsible for any attorneys fees or costs owed to such attorney by the Claimant.
Claimants Name Claimants Signature & Date
Title, if Business Entity Claimant
Claimants Spouses Name Claimants Spouses Signature, Date
if applicable
0292
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-45 Filed 04/18/12 Page 15 of 22
15
Attachment A Listing Released Parties
Abdon Callais Offshore, Inc.
Admiral Robert J Papp Jr.
Admiral Thad Allen
Admiral Towing, LLC
Aerotek, Inc.
Airborne Support, Inc.
Airborne Support International, Inc.
Alford Safety Services Inc.
Alford Services Inc.
Ameri-Force, Inc.
Ameri-Force Craft Services, Inc.
American Pollution Control Corporation
Anadarko Petroleum Company
Anadarko Petroleum Corporation
Anadarko E&P Company LP
Apex Environmental Services, LLC
Art Catering, Inc.
Ashland Services, LLC
B&B Environmental Services, Inc.
Belle Chasse Marine Transportation, Inc.
BJ Services Company, USA
Blue Marlin Services of Acadiana, LLC
Bobby Lynn's Marina, Inc.
BP America Inc.
BP America Production Company
BP Company North America Inc.
BP Corporation North America Inc.
BP Energy Company
BP Exploration (Alaska) Inc.
BP Global Special Products (Americas) Inc.
BP Holdings North America Limited
BP Exploration & Production Inc.
BP p.l.c.
BP Products North America Inc.
BP International Ltd.
BP Corporation North America Inc. Savings Plan Investment Oversight Committee
Brett Cocales
Brian Morel
Cabildo Services, LLC
Cabildo Staffing, LLC
Cahaba Disaster Recovery LLC
Cal Dive International, Inc.
Cameron Corporation
Cameron International Corporation
Cameron International Corporation f/k/a Cooper Cameron Corporation
Cameron International Corporation d/b/a/ Cameron Systems Corporation
Center for Toxicology and Environmental Health L.L.C.
Chill Boats L.L.C.
Chouest Shorebase Services, LLC
Clean Harbors, Inc.
Clean Tank LLC
Clean Tank Inc.
Core Industries, Inc.
Core 4 Kebawk, LLC
0292 2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-45 Filed 04/18/12 Page 16 of 22
16
Crossmar, Inc.
Crowder/Gulf Joint Venture
Crowder Gulf Disaster Recovery
Danos and Curole Marine Contractors, LLC
Danos & Curole Staffing, L.L.C.
David Sims
Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill Trust
Diamond Offshore Company
DOF Subsea USA, Inc.
Don J. Vidrine
DRC Emergency Services, LLC
DRC Marine, LLC
DRC Recovery Services, LLC
Dril-Quip, Inc.
Dynamic Aviation Group, Inc.
Eastern Research Group, Inc.
Environmental Standards, Inc.
Environmental Safety & Health Consulting Services
Environmental Safety & Health Environmental Services
ES&H, Inc.
ESIS, Inc.
Exponent, Inc.
Faucheaux Brothers Airboat Services, Inc.
Global Diving & Salvage, Inc.
Global Employment Services, Inc.
Global Fabrication, LLC
Global Marine International, Inc.
Graham Gulf Inc.
Grand Isle Shipyard Inc.
Gregg Walz
Guilbeau Marine, Inc.
Guilbeau Boat Rentals, LLC
Gulfmark Offshore, Inc.
Gulf Offshore Logistics, LLC
Gulf Offshore Logistics International, LLC
Gulf Services Industrial, LLC
HEPACO, Inc.
Hilcorp Energy Company
Hyundai Heavy Industries Co. Ltd, Inc.
Hyundai Motor Company
I-Transit Response, L.L.C
International Air Response, Inc.
Island Ventures II, LLC
JMN Specialties, Inc.
JNB Operating LLC
John Guide
K & K Marine, LLC
LaBorde Marine Services, LLC
Lane Aviation
Lawson Environmental Service LLC
Lawson Environmental Service & Response Company
Lee Lambert
Lord Edmund John Browne
Lynden Air Cargo, LLC
Lynden, Inc.
Maco of Louisiana, LLC
0292
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-45 Filed 04/18/12 Page 17 of 22
17
Maco Services, Inc.
Marine Spill Response Corporation
Mark Bly
Mark Hafle
M-I L.L.C.
M-I Drilling Fluids L.L.C.
M-I Swaco
Miller Environmental Group, Inc.
Mitchell Marine
Mitsui & Co. (USA), Inc.
Mitsui & Co. Ltd.
Mitsui Oil Exploration Co. Ltd.
ModuSpec USA, Inc.
Monica Ann LLC
Moran Environmental Recovery, LLC
MOEX Offshore 2007 LLC
MOEX USA Corporation
M/V Monica Ann
M/V Pat Tilman
M/V Damon B. Bankston
M/V Max Chouest
M/V Ocean Interventions
M/V C. Express
M/V Capt. David
M/V Joe Griffin
M/V Mr. Sidney
M/V Hilda Lab
M/V Premier Explorer
M/V Sailfish
M/V Seacor Washington
M/V Emerald Coast
M/V Admiral Lee
M/V Seacor Vanguard
M/V Whuppa Snappa
Nalco Energy Services, LP
Nalco Holding Company
Nalco Finance Holdings LLC
Nalco Finance Holdings Inc.
Nalco Holdings LLC
Nalco Company
National Response Corporation
Nature's Way Marine, LLC
Nautical Ventures, LLC
Nautical Solutions, LLC
OBriens Response Management, Inc.
Ocean Runner, Inc.
Ocean Therapy Solutions, LLC
Oceaneering International, Inc.
Odyssea Marine, Inc.
Offshore Cleaning Systems L.L.C.
Offshore Service Vessels, LLC
Offshore Inland Marine & Oilfield Services, Inc.
Oil Recovery Company, Inc. of Alabama
Oilfield Marine Contractors, LLC
Parsons Commercial Services Inc.
Parsons Services Company
0292
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-45 Filed 04/18/12 Page 18 of 22
18
Parsons Facility Services Company
Parsons Corporation
Patriot Environmental Services Incorporated
Peneton Company
Perennial Contractors, LLC
Peneton Corporation
Production Services Network U.S., Inc.
Quality Container, Inc.
Quality Energy Services, Inc.
Ranger Offshore, Inc.
Reel Pipe, LLC
Resolve Marine Services, Inc.
Robert Kaluza
Ronald W. Sepulvado
Schlumberger, Ltd.
Seacor Holdings Inc.
Seacor Marine, LLC
Seacor Marine, Inc.
Seacor Marine International, Inc.
Seacor Offshore LLC
Seacor Worldwide, Inc.
Sealion Shipping LTD
Sea Support Services, L.L.C.
Sea Tow of South Miss, Inc.
Seafairer Boat, LLC
Shamrock Management LLC et al.
Shoreline Services, LLC
Siemens Financial, Inc.
Shoreline Construction, LLC
Smith Marine, Inc.
Southern Cat, Inc.
Southern Environmental of Louisiana, LLC
Stallion Offshore Quarters, Inc.
Subsea 7 LLC
Tamara's Group, LLC
Team Labor Force, LLC
Technical Marine Maintenance Services, L.L.C.
The Modern Group, Ltd.
The Modern Group GP-SUB, Inc.
The OBrien Group, LLC
The Response Group, Inc.
Tiburon Divers, Inc.
Tidewater, Inc.
Tidewater Marine LLC
Tiger Rentals, Ltd.
Tiger Safety, LLC
Toisa Limited
Total Safety U.S., Inc.
Twenty Grand Offshore, LLC
Twenty Grand Marine Service, LLC
Twenty Grand Offshore Inc.
USES/Construct Corps
United States Environmental Services, LLC
United States Maritime Services, Inc.
Viscardi Industrial Services, LLC
Weatherford International Ltd.
0292
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-45 Filed 04/18/12 Page 19 of 22
19
Weatherford U.S. L.P.
Wood Group Production Services, Inc.
Worley Catastrophe Services, LLC
Worley Catastrophe Response, LLC
0292 6
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-45 Filed 04/18/12 Page 20 of 22
20
Attachment B Certification
Claimant hereby signs to attest to and vouch for the accuracy of the certification below:
For all types of claims:
I certify that I understand and acknowledge that, (subject to my right to additional Settlement
Payments, if any, pursuant to Section 4.4.8 of the Settlement Agreement), I am forever giving up
with prejudice and discharging, without any right of legal recourse whatsoever, any and all rights
I have or may have to the Released Claims against the Released Parties. I acknowledge that by
having executed the Individual Release and signing below neither I nor the entity I represent
has been pressured or influenced by, or is relying on any statement or representation made by
any person acting on behalf of BP or any other Released Party. I certify that I understand that I
have the right to consult with an attorney of my choosing before signing this Individual Release.
PLUS ONE OF THE ADDITIONAL CERTIFICATIONS FOLLOWING (AS
APPLICABLE):
For business or property claims:
I certify that either:
(1) I have not made an insurance claim or received any insurance proceeds for any business or
property Claim arising out of, due to, resulting from, or relating in any way to, directly or
indirectly, the Deepwater Horizon Incident; OR
(2) If I have made or do make an insurance claim and/or receive or have received insurance
proceeds for any business or property claim arising out of, due to, resulting from, or relating in
any way to, directly or indirectly the Deepwater Horizon Incident, I will indemnify BP for any
liability it incurs for a subrogation claim made against BP arising out of:
(a) such insurance proceeds, provided that the subrogation claim is brought by an entity
seeking payment of insurance proceeds to me for any business or property claim arising
out of, due to, resulting from, or relating in any way to, directly or indirectly, the
Deepwater Horizon Incident; and
(b) the amount that I indemnify BP shall not exceed the amount of insurance proceeds
that I received for the business or property claim at issue.
CLAIMANT ACKNOWLEDGES THAT THIS CERTIFICATION COMPLIES WITH
ANY REQUIREMENT TO EXPRESSLY STATE THAT LIABILITY FOR SUCH
CLAIMS IS INDEMNIFIED AND THAT THIS CERTIFICATION IS CONSPICUOUS
AND AFFORDS FAIR AND ADEQUATE NOTICE.
0292
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-45 Filed 04/18/12 Page 21 of 22
21
For individual claims:
I certify that either:
(1) I have not made a claim for unemployment insurance benefits arising out of, due to, resulting
from, or relating in any way to, directly or indirectly, the Deepwater Horizon Incident; OR
(2) If I have made or do make a claim for unemployment insurance benefits arising out of, due
to, resulting from, or relating in any way to, directly or indirectly, the Deepwater Horizon
Incident, I will indemnify BP for any liability and defense costs it incurs for a subrogation
Claim made against BP arising out of such insurance proceeds provided that the subrogation
Claim is brought by an entity seeking payment of insurance proceeds to me for any business or
property Claim arising out, due to, resulting from, or relating in any way to, directly or
indirectly, the Deepwater Horizon Incident; and the amount that I indemnify BP shall not
exceed the amount of insurance proceeds that I received for the unemployment insurance
benefits Claim at issue.
CLAIMANT ACKNOWLEDGES THAT THIS CERTIFICATION COMPLIES WITH
ANY REQUIREMENT TO EXPRESSLY STATE THAT LIABILITY FOR SUCH
CLAIMS IS INDEMNIFIED AND THAT THIS CERTIFICATION IS CONSPICUOUS
AND AFFORDS FAIR AND ADEQUATE NOTICE.
Claimants Name Claimants Signature, Title if Date
Business Claimant
Claimants Spouses Name Claimants Spouses Signature, Date
if applicable
0292
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-45 Filed 04/18/12 Page 22 of 22
2
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-46 Filed 04/18/12 Page 1 of 10
EXHIBIT 27 TO
DEEPWATER HORIZON ECONOMIC AND PROPERTY DAMAGES
SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT DATED APRIL 18, 2012
and
EXHIBIT 19 TO
DEEPWATER HORIZON MEDICAL BENEFITS CLASS SETTLEMENT
AGREEMENT DATED APRIL 18, 2012
1. Interim Class Counsel under the Economic Agreement and the Medical
Settlement Agreement and BPs Counsel commenced negotiations on common benefit and/or
Rule 23(h) attorneys fees and costs on April 17, 2012, only after such Interim Class Counsel and
BPs Counsel reached agreement on all of the material terms of the Economic Agreement and
the Medical Settlement Agreement and delivered that information to the Court.
2. Subject to the provisions, conditions, and understandings set forth below, the BP
Parties agree not to contest a joint request by Economic Class Counsel and Medical Benefits
Class Counsel (collectively, the Class Counsel) for, nor oppose an award by the Court for, a
maximum award of $600,000,000 (Six hundred million US Dollars), as a payment of all
common benefit and/or Rule 23(h) attorneys fees, costs and expenses incurred at any time,
whether before or after the date hereof, for the common benefit of members of the Economic
Class and the Medical Class. If the Court awards less than the amount set out in this paragraph
2, the BP Parties shall be liable only for the lesser amount awarded by the Court. In no event
shall the BP Parties be liable for any amount of common benefit and/or Rule 23(h) attorneys
fees, costs and/or expenses in excess of the amount agreed upon in this paragraph 2. The
common benefit and/or Rule 23(h) attorneys fees, costs and expenses awarded by the Court,
subject to the limitations in the preceding sentence, shall be collectively referred to as the
Common Benefit Fee and Costs Award.
0292 9
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-46 Filed 04/18/12 Page 2 of 10
2
3. The Common Benefit Fee and Costs Award shall cover any and all common
benefit and/or Rule 23(h) attorneys fees, costs and expenses that may be claimed against BP or
any of the Released Parties by or on behalf of the Economic Class or the Medical Class, or any
member thereof, or their current or former counsel, including attorneys fees and costs pursuant
to Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(h), Pretrial Order No. 9, and the Courts Order and Reasons As To The
Motion To Establish Account And Reserve For Litigation Expenses, Rec. Doc. 5022, and
amendments thereto, including Rec. Doc. 5064 and 5274 (collectively, the Holdback Order).
4. The BP Parties shall make payments into the qualified settlement fund to be
established pursuant to Section 5.16 of the Economic Agreement and Section XXII.S of the
Medical Settlement Agreement (the Common Benefit Fee and Costs Fund) as follows:
a. The BP Parties shall make a non-refundable payment of $75 million (Seventy-
five million US Dollars) (the Initial Payment) into the Common Benefit Fee
and Costs Fund on the first date on which all of the following have occurred:
(i) 30 days have elapsed after the Court has granted preliminary approval of
the Economic Agreement, and (ii) the Court has entered an Order modifying
the Holdback Order to provide that it shall not apply to any Settlement
Payments or Other Economic Benefits paid pursuant to the Economic
Agreement or any Medical Settlement Payments or Other Medical Benefits
pursuant to the Medical Settlement Agreement. Subject to the conditions in
the preceding sentence, the Initial Payment from the Common Benefit Fee and
Costs Fund shall be paid to Class Counsel pursuant to an order of the Court.
b. From and after the date of the Initial Payment, through the earlier of the
Effective Date under the Economic Agreement or the termination of the
029290
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-46 Filed 04/18/12 Page 3 of 10
3
Economic Agreement, within 15 days after the end of each calendar quarter,
the BP Parties shall irrevocably pay into the Common Benefit Fee and Costs
Fund an amount equal to 6 % (six percent) of (i) the aggregate Settlement
Payments paid under the Economic Agreement in respect of Claimants that
have executed an Individual Release (or in the case of payments pursuant to
the Transition Process, to Economic Class Members that execute a full
release), together with (ii) the amount of Other Economic Benefits paid, in
each case under the Economic Agreement during such calendar quarter (or, in
the case of the first such payment, during the period from April 18, 2012 to
the end of such calendar quarter, or during the period from and after February
26, 2012 pursuant to the Transition Process).
c. From and after the date of the Initial Payment, through the earlier of the
Effective Date under the Medical Settlement Agreement or the termination of
the Medical Settlement Agreement, within 15 days after the end of each
calendar quarter, the BP Parties shall irrevocably pay into the Common
Benefit Fee and Costs Fund an amount equal to 6 % (six percent) of the
aggregate Other Medical Benefits paid under the Medical Settlement
Agreement during such calendar quarter (or, in the case of the first such
payment, during the period from April 18, 2012 to the end of such calendar
quarter). If the Effective Date under the Medical Settlement Agreement
occurs, the BP Parties shall irrevocably pay into the Common Benefit Fee and
Costs Fund an amount equal to 6% (six percent) of the aggregate Medical
02929
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-46 Filed 04/18/12 Page 4 of 10
4
Settlement Payments paid under the Medical Settlement Agreement as and
when such Medical Settlement Payments are made.
d. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary herein, (i) the BP Parties shall be
entitled to credit the Initial Payment against the first $75 million of payments
required under paragraphs 4b and 4c, and (ii) in no event shall the total
amounts paid into the Common Benefit Fee and Costs Fund (including the
Initial Payment and any additional amounts paid pursuant to paragraphs 4b
and 4c) exceed $480,000,000 (Four hundred eighty million US Dollars) in the
aggregate, unless and until the Effective Date under the Economic Agreement
occurs (except as expressly set forth in paragraph 4g below with respect to
certain Settlement Payments made from and after the termination of the
Economic Agreement).
e. If the Effective Date under the Economic Agreement occurs, the BP Parties
will irrevocably pay the remaining balance of the Common Benefit Fee and
Costs Award into the Common Benefit Fee and Costs Fund on the first date
(the Final Fee and Costs Payment Date) on which both of the following
have occurred: (i) 30 days have elapsed after the Effective Date under the
Economic Agreement, and (ii) the Court has entered an order approving the
Common Benefit Fee and Costs Award.
f. If the Medical Settlement Agreement is terminated prior to the occurrence of
the Effective Date under the Medical Settlement Agreement, the BP Parties
shall not be required to make any further payments whatsoever pursuant to
paragraph 4c into the Common Benefit Fee and Costs Fund.
029292
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-46 Filed 04/18/12 Page 5 of 10
5
g. If the Economic Agreement is terminated prior to the occurrence of the
Effective Date under the Economic Agreement, the BP Parties shall not be
required to make any further payments whatsoever into the Common Benefit
Fee and Costs Fund (other than payments pursuant to paragraph 4c in respect
of the Medical Settlement Agreement) from and after the date of termination;
provided that to the extent the BP Parties make Settlement Payments to
Economic Class Members that filed Claims prior to the termination of the
Economic Agreement, then within 15 days after the end of each calendar
quarter thereafter, the BP Parties shall pay into the Common Benefit Fee and
Costs Fund an amount equal to 6% (six percent) of the aggregate Settlement
Payments paid under the Economic Agreement during such calendar quarter
(less any payments made prior to the termination of the Economic
Agreement); and provided further that, notwithstanding anything to the
contrary herein in paragraph 4b or 4c or otherwise, in no event shall the total
amounts paid into the Common Benefit Fee and Costs Fund at any time
(including the Initial Payment, any additional amounts paid pursuant to
paragraphs 4b and 4c, and any amounts paid pursuant to this paragraph 4g)
exceed the amount of the Common Benefit Fee and Cost Award, in the
aggregate.
5. Prior to the Final Fee and Costs Payment Date, no amounts shall be paid by or out
of the Common Benefit Fee and Costs Fund, other than (i) the Initial Payment, or (ii) from and
after the occurrence of the Effective Date under the Medical Settlement Agreement, any
payments to the Common Benefit Fee and Costs Fund that are or were made under paragraph 4c
02929
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-46 Filed 04/18/12 Page 6 of 10
6
above in respect of the Medical Settlement Agreement. If the Economic Agreement is
terminated prior to the occurrence of the Effective Date, Economic Class Counsel may petition
the Court for an order approving disbursement of amounts in the Common Benefit Fee and Cost
Fund (and the BP Parties will not oppose any such petition). To the extent the Court enters an
order approving disbursement of any or all amounts in the Common Benefit Fee and Cost Fund,
such amounts in the Common Benefit Fee and Cost fund shall be paid to Class Counsel pursuant
to the order of the Court. If Economic Class Counsel has not filed such a petition within 120
days after termination of the Economic Agreement, or if the Court denies such petition in whole
or in part, or if the Court grants an order for disbursement of less than all amounts in the
Common Benefit Fee and Cost Fund, then all remaining amounts in the Common Benefit Fee
and Cost Fund shall promptly be repaid to the BP Parties.
6. The BP Parties, the Plaintiffs under the Economic Agreement (on behalf of
themselves and the Economic Class Members), and the Medical Benefits Class Representatives
under the Medical Settlement Agreement (on behalf of themselves and the members of the
Medical Class) hereby stipulate and agree as follows:
a. All payments into the Common Benefit Fee and Costs Fund are common
benefit and/or Rule 23(h) fees, costs and expenses within the meaning of
applicable law, including Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(h), Pretrial Order No. 9, and the
Holdback Order;
b. Upon the full payment of the Common Benefit Fee and Costs Award, BP and
the Released Parties shall be immediately and fully discharged from any and
all further liability or obligation whatsoever with respect to any and all
common benefit and/or Rule 23(h) attorneys fees, costs and expenses
02929
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-46 Filed 04/18/12 Page 7 of 10
7
incurred by or on behalf of the Economic Class or the Medical Class, or any
member thereof, in respect of, or relating in any way to, directly or indirectly,
any and all Released Claims under the Economic Agreement, Released
Claims under the Medical Settlement Agreement, the Action under the
Economic Agreement, or the Medical Action.
c. Other than (i) the payments by the BP Parties of the Common Benefit Fee and
Cost Award into the Common Benefit Fee and Cost Fund, and (ii) payments
by the Common Benefit Fee and Costs Fund to Class Counsel pursuant to any
order of the Court, neither BP nor any of the Released Parties, nor the Claims
Administrator, the Claims Administration Staff, nor the Common Benefit Fee
and Costs Fund shall have any liability whatsoever in respect of or for any
attorneys fees, costs or expenses incurred by or on behalf of the Economic
Class or the Medical Class, or any member thereof, or any of their current or
former counsel in respect of the Released Claims under the Economic
Agreement, the Released Claims under the Medical Settlement Agreement,
the Action or the Medical Action, or by any other entity or person, including
Halliburton or Transocean, in respect of any Released Claims or Assigned
Claims under the Economic Agreement, Released Claims under the Medical
Settlement Agreement or in any way relating to the Action or the Medical
Action.
d. The BP Parties and Class Counsel agree to request, and will not contest or
oppose, that the order approving the Common Benefit Fee and Costs Award
will include the language set forth in this paragraph 6.
02929
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-46 Filed 04/18/12 Page 8 of 10
8
7. Neither BP nor any of the Released Parties shall have any responsibility,
obligation or liability of any kind whatsoever with respect to how the Common Benefit Fee and
Costs Award is allocated and distributed among any counsel for the Economic Class or the
Medical Class, or any member thereof, which allocation and distribution is the sole province of
Class Counsel to recommend, and the Court to decide.
8. The Claims Administrator and the Claims Administration Staff shall be directed
that, where a Claimant is represented by counsel, any Settlement Payment (a) shall be by check
made payable to both the Claimant and his, her or its designated counsel (Designated
Counsel), and (b) shall be made only after the receipt of a written acknowledgment by the
Claimant and the Designated Counsel that funds received fully and finally satisfy any and all
fees and costs in respect to representation of the Claimant by any counsel (including but not
limited to any asserted by lien or privilege) in connection with the Claim and rights of such
counsel to them.
9. Economic Agreement means the Deepwater Horizon Economic and Property
Damages Settlement Agreement Dated April 18, 2012. Capitalized terms used but not otherwise
defined herein have the meanings set forth in the Economic Agreement.
10. Medical Action means Plaisance, et al., individually and on behalf of the
putative Medical Benefits Settlement Class v. BP Exploration & Production Inc., et al.
11. Medical Settlement Agreement means the Deepwater Horizon Medical Benefits
Class Action Settlement Agreement dated April 18, 2012.
12. Medical Settlement Payments means payments of compensation for Specified
Physical Conditions (as defined in the Medical Settlement Agreement) and payments in respect
029296
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-46 Filed 04/18/12 Page 9 of 10
9
of visits of the Periodic Medical Consultation Program (as defined in the Medical Settlement
Agreement).
13. Other Economic Benefits means payments under the Economic Agreement with
respect to the Gulf Tourism and Seafood Promotional Fund and the Supplemental Information
Program Fund.
14. Other Medical Benefits means payments under the Medical Settlement
Agreement for the Gulf Region Health Outreach Program (as defined in the Medical Settlement
Agreement).
15. Other Settlement Benefits means, collectively, Other Economic Benefits and
Other Medical Benefits.
02929
Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 6276-46 Filed 04/18/12 Page 10 of 10