Professional Documents
Culture Documents
of Rachel
Carson Before
ttre organi.zations
oD Reoraganization of Coun-ittee
on Goveitment
EM/IROIMEIMAIJ EAZINDS COIIIROI. OF PESTICIDES ArO qUIER CHEM.ICAL POTSONS ilune 4. 1963
Mr. with
Ctrairrian,
I appreeiate
ttre
op;rcrtunity of
to
discrrss hazards
morning
the problems
environnental
the najor
and erater of
supports anirnals
ttrouaands
and plants,
suPPorts ignore
rn the past
we lrave often
tLlae return
to bring
hazard is
ourselves. tmrEt
explore that
one tlrat
strongly session
be'made on it reason
on the shole
Contanination tlre physical and vegetationment rrithin many sorrrces: and hospitals.
of various ttrat
kinds
al1 soi1,
of air,
environment It
suplrorts
environ-
the bodies
radioactive faLlcnt
from nuclear
explosions,
d@estic
wastes
-Z-
from
ci.ties
and-towrrsa
cliemical'
wastes
from factories,
t
detergents
from homes anct industries. ttre history of mankind in relation for to the that
short-sighted of the
the soil,
forests,
naters
technica1
even a generation
irirpossible, but
to reverse rise
tlrese
the disturbing
talcen to exasrine. I have pointecl problen tetct, into these of pesticldes as part the of the out before, and I shall .repeat nofu, that in consubstanees tlre
understood
only
envirorulent.
In water trith
chemicals
substances. summations of
There effect.
understood
interactions for
understands, stored in
presdtrE
vrater,
the lining
more readily to
absorbs assess
pesticides, introduced
people irtto
too a.
ttrese
ctrenicaLs
are being as in
environment,
a laboratoty
o<1leri-'.
largely
to peseicides
am glad,
-J-
that
you'have
highly
problem. seems 'to me that the most siginificant knorrrledge that up of far some
within
the past year tras been the piling of, pesticide I should
chernicals,
J-ike to cite
spreading
on a small that
scale, it
vre accept
staternents
is not
the. deliberate
Yet studies
Division
serrre as public
water
supplies,
ttrese
reserroirs
and Concord
l4assactrusetts
of 96.7 p.p.m.
tr,ro places,
14 tfunes
the 1egal
DUf in diffi.cult
Although
tb jmagine
domestic \.rater supplies exarilPles of a different explanation. Wales Island and Wildlife fish in four Such, in for
easy or
example,
Alaska. biologists
have sampled resident island and have found DDT, There is The nearest no
systems on this
rnetabolites,
-4An even more lemote tras been yielding Service for several region, not data is far bel'ow the Arctic circle,
to the
Fistr
waterforl
remote
any hurnan .
No spraying several
known to have
hundred for
alone
by the
hate
States.
been
f,ound to
residues. lfhe most disturbing of al.I of jl such reports, fish fish tiat live off howeverr far at concerns. sea. coasts and Asia. floor of the of
of DDA in
the oit.
caught
both
Arnerica,
EuloPe, on the
species
concerned
,Pacific
rarely
fish'have
Dxl1t in this
gives
deeply reaclr
residues
rte are nqr discovering ansftrer ttris like to catrl question yorrr
complete to
attention
certain
do have
a bearing
are basicall.y
or d5.rectly. last the fact acreage year by the U.S. aerial, in Department of Agriqrltrrre about 22%
ttrat
comprises Studies
sprayed
by Professor confirrn
the
University
of Maine
(and whidr
less r'eleased
directly plane
approximately dis-
target,
crystals
are the
cqrq)onents every
--
the
contam-
or from his
planes
was known a decade ago ttrat far tion. as 15 or 20 rniles The drift of is facts little in
the lrerbicide
quantities is
insecticides properly
studied
I predict
we shall
discover
aPPears that
our
atmospheric
influence is convec-
or the uprrard
of air
Conceivably, materials
particles
an altitude play,
at which
came into
effecting
transport other
distances. of
materials.
Scientists
Institute
have studied
the betravior
--6nuclei, into the drawn frqn atrrosphere. -at least the surface These tiny as far transports spores, oceanic that of ttre ocean and lifted particJ.es are carried ,And we kn*r of high great that ll,ving -It
i
.d
as 4O0 rniles.
atmosphere
and insects
isiands
should
be tested
atrnosphere may be carrtring radioaetive such remote of debris, places of and that as those fallout. that
chemical the
particles
as ireli
pesticicte
i trave mentioned
factor the
may contribute
to
atlnospherie from
is
tendency
aerial. in tlre
sole
atmosphele.
studies
Public lished
of yeals over
fact
sprayed
pesticides.as
streams, transport
rte may bssurne, there the atmosphere. litt1e of transport example of charged arseoic healthon several on a broader from heavily ditions distances. dramati.c that t]rought
further
seems to have been given Yet, Agril, on a snall when health dust scale,
to
the possibility
of,f,icials fields,
airborne
insecticidle
closing
clogged reasonable in
especially insecticides
are right,
may carry
-t
long
but degree.
this
is
a phenomenon tlrat
iln
remain i.n
interesting occurs
in living
or indirectly. of miles,
Di.rect
transportation
wintering
gfrounds
treatment provinces.
areas
rnaritime
A }ess
exceedingly is ttrat in
method of
by living
organisms
which
to another as it goes.
a natural
irnpressive by
phenonenon.
At Big Bear Lalce, for hydroiarbon, it was found up this \f,as applied that the
e:<ample, toxaphene,
minute
organisms it
piclced
ctremical
to a level
73..[r.p.mcontaining ing
with
and a fish-eating
contain-
was appliedl
in these vraters.
3 p.p-m. the
convinced is
toxaphene did
control,
provide
- a.instructive The sane sort Clear I 1*", data on transfer of chemicals. tlrrougb out food in detail chains. at
I :/
California LiJte to add a vrord about There is nothing initial the concentrat.ion about or buildttri.s --
should
up of, the chemicals. especially Aquatic extract -trate about organisns minerals theur. the
surprising
concentration
the lrater
llarine
organisns of
in particular in rivers
ttre perceirtage
silica
diatons
withdlraw of coba1t
by lobsters
nollusks,
thesg
onl.y with
difficulty. ifr"t in
Oysters the
at a level should
1TOrOOOtirnes
surroundirrg
water.
to.find trating
marine
as DDT. exposed to
c.ontained for
132,.OOO parts
in to A
tissues. oysters --
forms of marine
current contains of
publication this
Service is of
statement: -re-cycling
the
a continuous
pesticidal welfare-
cornpounds until
threat
to man's own
it
inevli.ably of
spraying
pesticides reduced
be brought
under
strict
and -sh-otqld be
's
accomplish coulse,
objectives.
be opposed on the
-9grounds of econony and efficiency. the basic shall probleni of, environmental t6 count If we are ever t<i solve horrever, ate
contamination, costs
of what we
are doing,
The second conclusion and unremitting pesticides eliminate mendations strongly effort
seems apparent
ought
to be made to reduce
and ultfunately
the recomI
s Scien:e
Committee.
consur
reeommendation, spreading
the rapidly
contamination
other
to
on various -oroblem.
immensely
r hope this
the
citizen poisons
in his
by ottrer
persons.
as a biologist this is
strongly
that
or should that it
human righs.
I am afraid.
however,
or no existence in my files
to personal
loss of pets or valuable.horses poisons dents Iast their result. State frorn a neighborr
or other
domestic his
s spraying
invaded
property.
me that to
land but It is
for dairy
injury farmers
that
in New York
suffered
contamination
land by Federal-State
- 10.sprayirig milJ< later State for g11psy mottrs, w:itb the result tlrat their
._7
.inevitable
contained.
il-le$a1
residues
as unfit
Under suclr circtmstances, may recall ttre case'in inJunction the opinion of
States
of Appeals sought an
vrtrictr a graup
a
citizens spraying
to
prevent
they
repeated
could ruling
an injunction, like
I should
ttre
would
out
a district sprayi.ng
a clairn
aerial
any otlrer
program
which
and damage as widespread to travg caused, and safegiuards incidents nature assumiJrg, of here of the to 9f
as this
inquire
closely pro-
any proposed
cedures
seemingly
unnecessary
trave,shorrnr jrrterest.
such a progran
be required
citizens
whatever. by chance
days before
wotrk.
lfhey were
told. to tlle
by their courts of
attolrreys
was possible.'
ttrerefore, tftwarted
intent
ttre court
as indicated'
above is
sucb cases.
_11 As a rnini.rmun protection, adequate spraying hearing gest citizen neighbor's advance notice ntp"r"*", of alI allbefore I
sq. that
any spraying
f,urttrer
be established
so that
inconvenienced
I hope this
Conunittee wilL
give
its in
of medicar
research felt
individual important
ercceptions, environmental
informed rt
on this
hazard.
science
c-onfi.rm this
by saying,
of pesticides,
a complete
sponsored poisoning,
especially illness-
rather today,
of the field at a
given
ttre shole
reduced.
is happening into
are being
i.ntroduced
the environ-
the person
r r.prnember several
cases in
lindane,
heard
and did
- L2 -.
not knosr the approprl.ate American cides tion }ledical treatilent. l:ad a6out a special ten years ago t.he on pestiinforma-
Association to time
conmittee
whidr
from'tine
publ.ished
authoritative
several
functioningr
Arnerican cians
Medica]- Association
unbiased trade
from one of
the pesticide
organizations. I should like to eurphasize, however, and of interesti.ng that the many individual need for letters first I research receive
tr*rysicians in this
fiel.d.
In what l.beJ.ieve
recog-
society
approved.a
dlirecting
effects
a cop:f of this
resolution
at ttris
RESOLUIION
lgrlcTlrs
I$IERSAS the total consequences to rnan and his renewable and often resources from the present widespread substances of toxic unrestrained dissernination int,o the-environment are only vagruely known and some effects cannot yet even be surcmised; and of pesticides, WHEREAS the indirect and untovrard effects chemicals and kindred insecticides, rodenti.cides difficult to trace are f,requently long delayed' in air, and apparent safe miniroal acqumulations can in soil, rtater, tLberr. food and al.l tissues and levels; tirne accrue to ?ra.rmful or even lethal effect latent often have a profound WHEREASttrese toxicants for intended on flora and fauna not originally and or eradicatioo; suppression WIIEREAS these to:(icants are anong the most PoteDt ever' sul>' evaluated known and such new incornpletely andl stances are being developed annually;
-13
WIIEREASthese letlral agents can be purchased by anyone, to guard anlnrhere without adequate controls against their rnisuse; NCfl TEEREFORE, BE Il RESOLVED'that the Board of trustees of the Illinois state Medical Society go on record that eforts balances by to manipulate ecologic governmental private and indivlndustry agencies, iduals ttrrough the use of toxicants. and radiation needs urgent and conscientious study for the development of wise and ef-fective and controls; BE rT t"URIllER RESOLVED that in the opinion of the Eoard of Trustees of the l11inois State l,ledical Society the present state of knor,vledge dictates a policy of caution, of judgernent and inguiry, maturity statesmanship; and BE IT FURTHERRESOL\'ED ttrat ttre Director of the lllinois Departnent of Public Eealth through tbe Btrreau of, Bazardous Substances and Poison Control be requested to undertalce a study of al.l toxicants, . current and sold or used in lllinois, and'future distribution. for appropriate PrePare a report (Approved by Board of Tnrstees of the ll].inois Society on l[arch 17, L963 in Ctricagoi ll].inois.) 3. the least state should see legislation, State Medical
also
like the
to
possibly at
at
level,
restricting capabte
sale
to'those
following
directions.
and applied
shoclcing that these chernicals : by illiterate and even by raentally rmrch more stringent least are not about restrictions on
persons. of drugs --
We place which at
sprayed
from porerful
machines!
_soneone
wrote
me recently fron
hepatitis
a spray he had been'using, that the nan could buy the had to
nade hin
but
of Agricultrrre otrt
The deficiencf of
in ttre leport
the Presidentts
comnittee.
strrrays,
logieal
necessary should
Edueation the
and Welfare of
participate used.
registration
ctrenicals-,so
and recreational
resourcesin the
The Departinent
Interior of
registration
upon your
two more recotnmendations. our of it troubles chemical is quite are unnecessarily corDpounds in use lmpossible on the physical their ttrat facts for
chemicals
conclusion by the
great
proJ.iferatiin within to
dictated
than
by actual will
need.
see thl
be approved do
method will
6. to will research
fn
conclusion,
.I
Eive
full
support
of pest
in wtrich
chemicals
be rninimized
some of
that groups
adapted
Therefore, varied,
since
control
one super-vreapon
"l
_15_ all our problens, adJusted but to for its a g?eat tast. diversity of alrnarents, this eactr
Ao accour;rlish but
end rgguires to be
persisteace,
and itedicatiq$,
ttre rerrards
are great.
//////
./