400 views

Uploaded by bobmarley20161934

- STATE OF THE ART REPORT FOR THE ANALYSIS METHODS FOR UNREINFORCED MASONRY HERITAGE STRUCTURES AND MONUMENTS
- Shear Lag Final
- Untitled 1
- Carbody Flex
- Finite Element Analyses for Limit State Design of Concrete Structures
- design of Reinforce concrete Torsion in Beams Slides
- t6
- Evaluation of Engineering Stresses as the “Correct” Measure of “Physical” Stresses in Large Strain
- Combined Torsion and Bending in Reinforced and Pre Stressed Concrete Beams Using Simplified Method for Combined Stress-Resultants
- ACI Torsion
- Bou Aziz 2007
- Shear and Torsion in Concrete Structures
- Schmalberger-FinalReport
- relationship between shear stress and shear strain
- VEM_PT-12_en
- Cook R-L. Shear Banding in Time-Dependent Flows of Complex
- Flange Connection Type-P J1069 1051-1069(18Jul12)R01
- 978-1-58503-660-8-2
- An Improved Simulation Model of Shear Wall Structures
- Laboratory Exercises for Statics and Mechanics of Materials on a Shoestring

You are on page 1of 34

20 Fall, 2002

Unit 10

St. Venant Torsion Theory

Readings:

Rivello 8.1, 8.2, 8.4

T & G 101, 104, 105, 106

Paul A. Lagace, Ph.D.

Professor of Aeronautics & Astronautics

and Engineering Systems

Paul A. Lagace 2001

MIT - 16.20 Fall, 2002

III. Torsion

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 2

MIT - 16.20 Fall, 2002

We have looked at basic in-plane loading. Lets now consider

a second building block of types of loading: basic torsion.

There are 3 basic types of behavior depending on the type of

cross-section:

1. Solid cross-sections

classical solution technique

via stress functions

2. Open, thin-walled sections

Membrane Analogy

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 3

MIT - 16.20 Fall, 2002

3. Closed, thin-walled sections

Bredts Formula

In Unified you developed the basic equations based on some broad

assumptions. Lets

Be a bit more rigorous

Explore the limitations for the various approaches

Better understand how a structure resists torsion and

the resulting deformation

Learn how to model general structures by these three

basic approaches

Look first at

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 4

MIT - 16.20 Fall, 2002

Classical (St. Venants) Torsion Theory

Consider a long prismatic rod twisted by end torques:

T [in - lbs] [m - n]

Figure 10.1 Representation of general long prismatic rod

Length (l ) >> dimensions

in x and y directions

Do not consider how end torque is applied (St. Venants principle)

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 5

MIT - 16.20 Fall, 2002

Assume the following geometrical behavior:

a) Each cross-section (@ each z) rotates as a rigid body (No

distortion of cross-section shape in x, y)

b) Rate of twist, k = constant

c) Cross-sections are free to warp in the z-direction but the

This is the St. Venant Hypothesis

warping is the same for all cross-sections

warping = extensional deformation in the direction of the axis

about which the torque is applied

Given these assumptions, we see if we can satisfy the equations of

elasticity and B.C.s.

SEMI-INVERSE METHOD

Consider the deflections:

Assumptions imply that at any cross-section location z:

d

_

dz

,

z k z

(careful!

a constant

Rivello uses !)

rate of twist

(define as 0 @ z = 0)

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 6

Figure 10.2 Representation of deformation of cross-section due to

torsion

(for small )

undeformed position

This results in:

consider direction of + u

u (x, y, z) = r (-sin )

v (x, y, z) = r (cos )

w (x, y, z) = w (x, y)

independent of z!

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 7

MIT - 16.20 Fall, 2002

We can see that:

r y

2

x +

2

sin

y

r

x

cos

r

This gives:

u (x, y, z) = -y k z (10 - 1)

v (x, y, z) = x k z (10 - 2)

w (x, y, z) = w (x, y) (10 - 3)

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 8

MIT - 16.20 Fall, 2002

Next look at the Strain-Displacement equations:

u

0

xx

x

v

0

yy

y

w

0

zz

z

u

(consider: u exists, but

x

0

v exists, but

v

0

)

y

No extensional strains in torsion if cross-sections are free

to warp

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 9

MIT - 16.20 Fall, 2002

u v

+ z k + z k 0

xy

y x

cross - section does not change shape (as assumed!)

v w w

yz

z

+

y

k x +

y

(10 - 4)

w u w

zx

x

+

z

k y +

x

(10 - 5)

Now the Stress-Strain equations:

lets first do isotropic

1

xx

E

[

xx

(

yy

+

zz

)

]

0

yy

1

[

yy

(

xx

+

zz

)

]

0

E

1

zz

E

[

zz

(

xx

+

yy

)

]

0

xx

,

yy

,

zz

0

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 10

MIT - 16.20 Fall, 2002

(

2 1 + )

0 0

xy

E

xy xy

2 1 + )

yz

(

E

yz

(10 - 6)

1/ G

(

xz

2 1 + )

xz

(10 - 7)

E

only

xz

and

yz

stresses exist

Look at orthotropic case:

1

xx

E

11

[

xx

12

yy

13

zz

]

0

1

yy

E

22

[

yy

21

xx

23

zz

]

0

1

zz

E

33

[

zz

31

xx

32

yy

]

0

xx

,

yy

,

zz

0 still equal zero

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 11

MIT - 16.20 Fall, 2002

1

yz

G

23

yz

1

xz xz

G

13

Differences are in

yz

and

xz

here as there are two different

shear moduli (G

23

and G

13

) which enter in here.

for anisotropic material:

coefficients of mutual influence and Chentsov coefficients

foul everything up (no longer simple torsion theory). [cant

separate torsion from extension]

Back to general case

Look at the Equilibrium Equations:

xz

z

0

xz

xz

( , x y)

yz

z

0

yz

yz

( , x y)

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 12

MIT - 16.20 Fall, 2002

So,

xz

and

yz

are only functions of x and y

xz

+

yz

0 (10 - 8)

x y

We satisfy equation (10 - 8) by introducing a Torsion (Prandtl)

Stress Function (x, y) where:

y

xz

(10 - 9a)

x

yz

(10 - 9b)

Using these in equation (10 - 8) gives:

_

+

_

0

x y,

y

x

,

Automatically satisfies equilibrium (as a stress function is

supposed to do)

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 13

MIT - 16.20 Fall, 2002

Now consider the Boundary Conditions:

(a) Along the contour of the cross-section

Figure 10.3 Representation of stress state along edge of solid cross-

section under torsion

outer contour is stress-free

surface (away from load

introduction)

Figure 10.4 Close-up view of edge element from Figure 10.3

xz

(into page)

yz

(out of page)

x

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 14

MIT - 16.20 Fall, 2002

Using equilibrium:

F

z

0

(out of page is positive)

gives:

xz

dydz +

yz

dxdz 0

Using equation (10 - 9) results in

dy

,

_

+

_

dx 0

x

,

dy

,

_

+

dx

_

,

d

x

And this means:

d = 0

= constant

We take:

= 0 along contour (10 - 10)

Note: addition of an arbitrary constant does not affect

the stresses, so choose a convenient one (0!)

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 15

MIT - 16.20 Fall, 2002

Boundary condition (b) on edge z = l

Figure 10.5 Representation of stress state at top cross-section of rod

under torsion

Equilibrium tells us the force in each direction:

F

x

zx

dxdy

using equation (10 - 9):

y

R

dxdy

y

L

y

where y

R

and y

L

are the geometrical limits of the cross-

section in the y direction

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 16

MIT - 16.20 Fall, 2002

y

R

dx

[ ]

y

L

and since = 0 on contour

F

x

= 0

O.K. (since no force is applied in x-direction)

Similarly:

F

y

zy

dxdy 0

O.K.

Look at one more case via equilibrium:

Torque

[

x

zy

y

zx

]

dxdy

x

B

x

x

dxdy +

y

y

L

R

y

y

dydx

x

T

where x

T

and x

B

are geometrical limits of the cross-section

in the x-direction

Integrate each term by parts:

AdB AB BdA

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 17

MIT - 16.20 Fall, 2002

Set:

A x dA dx

dB dx B

x

and similarly for y

x

[ ]

x

B

dx

]

dy +

[ ]

y

y

R

dy

]

dx

x

T

y

L

= 0 = 0

since = 0 in contour since = 0 in contour

2 dxdy (10 - 11)

Up to this point, all the equations [with the slight difference in stress-strain

of equations (10 - 6) and (10 - 7)] are also valid for orthotropic materials.

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 18

MIT - 16.20 Fall, 2002

Summarizing

Long, prismatic bar under torsion

Rate of twist, k = constant

w

yz

= kx +

y

w

xz

= - ky +

x

y

xz

x

yz

Boundary conditions

= 0 on contour (free boundary)

2 dxdy

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 19

MIT - 16.20 Fall, 2002

Solution of Equations

(now lets go back to isotropic)

Place equations (10 - 4) and (10 - 5) into equations (10 - 6) and

(10 - 7) to get:

w_

yz

G

yz

G

k x +

y ,

(10 - 12)

xz

G

xz

G

k y +

w

_

(10 - 13)

x

,

We want to eliminate w. We do this via:

x

{Eq. (10 - 12)}

y

{Eq. (10 - 13)}

to get:

yz

xz

2

w

2

w

_

x

y

G k +

+ k

y x

,

x y

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 20

and using the definition of the stress function of equation (10 - 9) we

get:

2

2

x

2

+

y

2

2Gk (10 - 14)

Poissons Equation for

(Nonhomogeneous Laplace Equation)

Note for orthotropic material

We do not have a common shear modulus, so we would get:

+

( )

+

( )

2

2

2

2

2

x

k G

w

x y

G G

xz yz yz xz

We cannot eliminate w unless G

xz

and G

yz

are virtually the

same

+

y

G

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 21

MIT - 16.20 Fall, 2002

Overall solution procedure:

Solve Poisson equation (10 - 14) subject to the boundary

condition of = 0 on the contour

Get T - k relation from equation (10 - 11)

Get stresses (

xz

,

yz

) from equation (10 - 9)

Get w from equations (10 - 12) and (10 - 13)

Get u, v from equations (10 - 1) and (10 - 2)

Can also get

xz

,

yz

from equations (10 - 6) and (10 - 7)

This is St. Venant Theory of Torsion

Application to a Circular Rod

Figure 10.6 Representation of circular rod under torsion cross-section

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 22

MIT - 16.20 Fall, 2002

Let:

C

1

(x

2

+ y

2

R

2

)

This satisfies = 0 on contour since x

2

+ y

2

= R

2

on contour

This gives:

2

2

x

2

2C

1

y

2

2C

1

Place these into equation (10-14):

2C

1

+ 2C

1

2Gk

Gk

C

1

2

Note: (10-14) is satisfied exactly

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 23

MIT - 16.20 Fall, 2002

Thus:

Gk

(

x

2

+ y

2

R

2

)

2

Satisfies boundary conditions and partial

differential equation exactly

Now place this into equation (10-11):

2

dxdy

Figure 10.7 Representation of integration strip for circular cross-section

R +

Gk

- R -

R -

2

2

y

y

2

2

(

R

2

y

2

x

2

)

dxdy

-R

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 24

1

]

MIT - 16.20 Fall, 2002

+

Gk

R

R

(

R

2

y

2

)

x

x

3

3

1

]

1

y

y

2

2

R

R

2

2

dy

4

R

/

Gk

3

R

(

R

2

y

2

)

3 2

dy

+R

/

Gk

4 1

y

(

R

2

y

2

)

3 2

+

3

R

2

y R

2

y

2

+

3

R

4

sin

1

y

1

3 4

2 2 R

1

R

= 0 = 0

3

R

4

2

This finally results in

R

4

Gk

2

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 25

MIT - 16.20 Fall, 2002

Since k is the rate of twist:

k

d

, we can rewrite this as:

dz

d

dz GJ

where:

R

4

_

J = torsion constant

2

for a circle

,

= amount of twist

and:

GJ = torsional rigidity

Note similarity to:

d w

dx

M

EI

2

2

where:

(I) J - geometric part

(E) G - material part

EI = bending rigidity

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 26

To get the stresses, use equation (10 - 9):

Gkx x

yz

x J

xz

Gky

J

y

y

Figure 10.8 Representation of resultant shear stress,

res

, as defined

Define a resultant stress:

zx zy

2

+

2

J

x

2

+ y

2

= r

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 27

The final result is:

r

J

for a circle

Note: similarity to

x

Mz

_

,

always acts along the contour (shape)

resultant

Figure 10.9 Representation of shear resultant stress for circular

cross-section

Cross-Section

No shear

stress on

surface

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 28

Also note:

1. Contours of : close together near edge higher

Figure 10.10 Representation of contours of torsional shear function

2. Stress pattern () creates twisting

Figure 10.11 Representation of shear stresses acting perpendicular to

radial lines

magnitudes of

res

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 29

MIT - 16.20 Fall, 2002

To get the deflections, first find :

d

dz GJ

(pure rotation of cross-section)

integration yields:

z

+ C

1

GJ

Let C

1

= 0 by saying = 0 @ z = 0

Use equations (10 - 1) and (10 - 2) to get:

z

u yzk y

GJ

z

v xzk x

GJ

Go to equations (10 - 12) and (10 - 13) to find w(x, y):

Equation (10 - 12) gives:

w

yz

kx

y G

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 30

MIT - 16.20 Fall, 2002

using the result for

yz

:

w Gkx

kx 0

y G

integration of this says

w(x, y) = g

1

(x)

(not a function of y)

In a similar manner

Equation (10 -13) gives:

w

xz

+ ky

x G

Using

xz

= -Gky gives:

w

Gky

+ ky 0

x G

integration tells us that:

w(x, y) = g

2

(y) (not a function of x)

Using these two results we see that if w(x, y) is neither a function of

x nor y, then it must be a constant. Might as well take this as zero

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 31

MIT - 16.20 Fall, 2002

(other constants just show a rigid displacement in z which is

trivial)

w(x, y) = 0

No warping for circular cross-sections

(this is the only cross-section that has no

warping)

Other Cross-Sections

In other cross-sections, warping is the ability of the cross-section to

resist torsion by differential bending.

2 parts for torsional rigidity

Rotation

Warping

Ellipse

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 32

MIT - 16.20 Fall, 2002

x

2

y

2

_

C

1

a

2

+

b

2

1

,

Equilateral Triangle

C

1

x 3y +

2

_

3y a x +

1

a

_

a x +

2

_

3

,

3

,

3

,

Rectangle

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 33

MIT - 16.20 Fall, 2002

C

n

+ D

n

cosh

n y

_

cos

n x

n odd

b

,

a

Series: (the more terms you take, the better the

solution)

These all give solutions to

2

= 2GK subject to = 0 on the boundary. In

general, there will be warping

see Timoshenko for other relations (Ch. 11)

Note: there are also solutions via warping functions. This is a

displacement formulation

see Rivello 8.4

Next well look at an analogy used to solve the general

torsion problem

Paul A. Lagace 2001

Unit 10 - p. 34

- STATE OF THE ART REPORT FOR THE ANALYSIS METHODS FOR UNREINFORCED MASONRY HERITAGE STRUCTURES AND MONUMENTSUploaded byPauloAndresSepulveda
- Shear Lag FinalUploaded byPramin Pradeep
- Untitled 1Uploaded byAnonymous g3Mz9CygCR
- Carbody FlexUploaded byHemantha Kumar R
- Finite Element Analyses for Limit State Design of Concrete StructuresUploaded byMaurício Ferreira
- design of Reinforce concrete Torsion in Beams SlidesUploaded byMesfin Derbew
- t6Uploaded byapi-3733260
- Evaluation of Engineering Stresses as the “Correct” Measure of “Physical” Stresses in Large StrainUploaded byfat470
- Combined Torsion and Bending in Reinforced and Pre Stressed Concrete Beams Using Simplified Method for Combined Stress-ResultantsUploaded byMuhammad Saqib Abrar
- ACI TorsionUploaded byNeil Duldulao
- Bou Aziz 2007Uploaded byLuis Miguel Perez Pertuz
- Shear and Torsion in Concrete StructuresUploaded byRobert Vochescu
- Schmalberger-FinalReportUploaded byPetre Bogdan
- relationship between shear stress and shear strainUploaded bywindgust82
- VEM_PT-12_enUploaded bySandya Karanam
- Cook R-L. Shear Banding in Time-Dependent Flows of ComplexUploaded byniebelungen
- Flange Connection Type-P J1069 1051-1069(18Jul12)R01Uploaded bymohan chand mulpuri
- 978-1-58503-660-8-2Uploaded by23mh283991
- An Improved Simulation Model of Shear Wall StructuresUploaded bynvel0006
- Laboratory Exercises for Statics and Mechanics of Materials on a ShoestringUploaded bypauloamancioferro
- 3D Thin-Walled StructuresUploaded byDinh Cuong Tran
- AWS100 Ch08 ResultsUploaded byRebeca Garzon
- Poly_JccUploaded bySchmetterling Traurig
- Material PropertiesUploaded byArjed Ali Shaikh
- Creep Analysis of Thin Rotating Disc Under Plane Stress With No Edge LoadUploaded byManish Garg
- Slip Filed AnalysisUploaded bychintans_47
- large displacementUploaded byadamadamO
- Chapter 2Uploaded bydearsaswat
- 105108070Uploaded byRon Jacob
- Chapter 1_stress and StrainUploaded byMuhd Qayyum Mohd Fuad

- reinforcement front pageUploaded bybobmarley20161934
- Map 1m Below Metro ManilaUploaded bybobmarley20161934
- crude oilUploaded bybobmarley20161934
- point 1Uploaded bybobmarley20161934
- Guide to Hot Weather Front Page OnlyUploaded bybobmarley20161934
- Water Cement RatioUploaded bybobmarley20161934
- Bar Lap Gap SpacingUploaded bybobmarley20161934
- Random CheckUploaded bybobmarley20161934
- Pulse Velocity Using Concrete PropertiesUploaded bybobmarley20161934
- reference for acicode.pdfUploaded bybobmarley20161934
- reference for acicode.pdfUploaded bybobmarley20161934
- reference for acicode.pdfUploaded bybobmarley20161934
- water cement ratio.pdfUploaded bybobmarley20161934
- Front Page Design and Control of MixUploaded bybobmarley20161934
- Slip Form Front Page OnlyUploaded bybobmarley20161934
- C25024 PropertiesUploaded bybobmarley20161934
- Front Page Only ACI 311Uploaded bybobmarley20161934
- blurUploaded bybobmarley20161934
- space gas 01Uploaded bybobmarley20161934
- Front FenceUploaded bybobmarley20161934
- C25024 properties.pdfUploaded bybobmarley20161934
- Sample CheckUploaded bybobmarley20161934
- Mechanical LoadingUploaded bybobmarley20161934
- Portal FrameUploaded bybobmarley20161934
- concrete duct bankUploaded bybobmarley20161934
- Corrosion-Understanding the Basics Front PageUploaded bybobmarley20161934
- ri value for moment frames.pdfUploaded bybobmarley20161934
- asdddd.pdfUploaded bybobmarley20161934
- STAAD Design ParametersUploaded bybobmarley20161934
- wind modelUploaded bybobmarley20161934

- des3326SRM_Manual_402B13.pdfUploaded by0x0000AF56
- Rubber balloon barrage project over the river TapiUploaded bynikunj64508
- testingUploaded byVinod Naraya
- Investigating Causal Relations Ny Econometric Models and Crosss-pectreal MethodsUploaded byFauzul Azhimah
- PlasmaPulsedPowerGeneration.pdfUploaded byClifford Stone
- What is TBFUploaded byAnudeep Bhattacharya
- Oracle Ref CursorUploaded byPraful Ingle
- The Double Egg Water VortexerUploaded by1neo28
- 44949665-Code-of-Ethics.docUploaded byManishaDhiman
- The Virginia Class Submarine ProgramUploaded bycjnjr1
- Shuttle TankersUploaded byAugusto Huanca
- Beginners Guide to CorrosionUploaded byعبدالناصر الزهراني
- tpu brosurUploaded byfadewae
- Use ADB Method to Install Apps or Move Installed Applications to SD Card on Your Android Phone _ UsmanAfzalUploaded byHemant Arora
- civil engg.pdfUploaded byankit kumar singh
- SRA GUIDEUploaded byRichard Salvato
- As 1012.14-1991 Methods of Testing Concrete Method for Securing and Testing Cores From Hardened Concrete ForUploaded bySAI Global - APAC
- ch 5 etbis.docxUploaded byBella
- Obsolescent and Obsolete Circuit Breakers SdUploaded byjavier1539
- AsphaltPaveMaint.pdfUploaded bySan Andrade
- Peracetic Acid SDSUploaded byEsteban Murillo
- 03.00.08.14. Menghitung Pressure Blower Silo.pdfUploaded byRachmat Cahaya Putra
- EFFECT_OF_CHOPPING_STEP_AND_DRYING_TECHN.pdfUploaded byYopiWindaSari
- Cardax Encoder III[1]Uploaded byVĩnh Hội Nguyễn
- Project Reference List - ReferenceUploaded byGohds
- Shared Pointers in C++Uploaded bySubrato Saha
- Eco Hopper GBUploaded byRudy de SpiderHerp
- Designing Stairs and Laying Out Stair StringersUploaded byJessicalba Lou
- 4b-AdvInterpUploaded byIgnacio Juarez
- PssUploaded bydavev2005