Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Perception and use of social media platforms among businesses and consumers in Northern Ireland, with a focus on Facebook and LinkedIn
Table of Contents Abstract.................................................................................................................................................3 Results..........................................................................................................................................3 Acknowledgements...............................................................................................................................4 Introduction...........................................................................................................................................5 Review of the Literature.......................................................................................................................6 1.1 Introduction to Chapter 1.......................................................................................................6 1.2 Emergence of Social Media .................................................................................................6 1.3 Evolution of the media landscape. 1.3.1 1st Revolution - Printing Press Type 1.3.2 2nd Revolution - Electrical Telegraph and Telephone 1.3.3 3rd Revolution - Recorded Media other than Print - Tape, Vinyl Record, Photo & Movie 1.3.4 4th Revolution - Broadcasted Media - T.V & Radio 1.3.5 5th Revolution - The Internet World Wide Web 1.4 Marketing Models 1.4.1 Introduction 1.4.2 21st Century Marketing Model Networking/Social Media 1.5 The Impact and Value of Social Media Expression 1.5.1 The wisdom of the former audience 1.5.2 20th Century Consumer Vs 21st Century Human 1.6 Business & Social Media Integration 1.6.1 Introduction to Enterprise 2.0 1.6.2 Social Media Platforms used for Business 1.6.3 Benefits of Social Media 1.6.4 Criticism of Business & Social Media Integration 2.0 Methodology................................................................................................................................16 2.1 Introduction 2.2 Method of Data Collection 2.2.1 Qualitative and Quantitative Research 2.3 Data Collection 2.3.1 Online Questionnaire 2.4 Code of Conduct, Pilot Testing & Software used 2.4.1 Consumer Questionnaire 2.4.2 Data Collection - Business Questionnaire 2.5 Time 2.6 Compare and Contrast 2.7 Time Constraints 2.8 Limitations in Data Sampling Conclusion 3.0 Data Analysis & Discussion........................................................................................................22 3.1 Introduction 3.2. Online behaviour of Northern Ireland Consumers. 3.3 Northern Ireland's Facebook Consumer Behaviour 3.4 Business Perception of Social Media 3.5 Business Awareness of Social Media 3.6 Facebook Northern Ireland Business Profile
1
3.7 LinkedIn Northern Ireland Business Profile 3.7.1 Understanding of the LinkedIn Platform 3.8 Utilization of LinkedIn Opportunities 3.8.1 Recruitment & Selection 3.8.2 Observing Competition 3.8.3 LinkedIn Answers 3.8.4 ROI of discussing expertise within LinkedIn. 3.8.5 Outsourcing 4.0 Recommendations & Conclusion.................................................................................................33 4.1.2 Recommendation 1 4.1.3 Recommendation 2 4.1.4 Recommendation 3 4.2 Conclusion and Further Implications of the Study Bibliography.......................................................................................................................................37 Appendices..........................................................................................................................................42 Table of Figures..................................................................................................................................50 Figure 1 - Influencing of Consumer Behavior Figure 2 - Reliability of Reviews Figure 3 - Sharing Online Reviews Figure 4 - Sharing Online Reviews Figure 5 - Sharing Facebook Links Figure 6 - Sharing Online Reviews Figure 7 - Purpose of Twitter for Business Figure 10 - Business Purpose of Facebook Figure 11 - Reasons for not having a Facebook Figure 12 - Perception of Linkedin Figure 13 - Linkedin Profile Figure 15 - Linkedin Answers Figure 16 - Linkedin New Business Figure 17 - Linkedin Networking Figure 18 - Linkedin Outsourcing
Abstract
Background This report is an investigation to create a better understanding of Social Media and highlight how it has been best used within Northern Ireland. The investigation will focus on the current perceptions and use of social media platforms by businesses in the the Northern Ireland Business Community.
Objectives of the research: Explanation of Social Media significance and benefits to business Create a general understanding of the behaviour of the Northern Ireland online consumer and Facebook User. Create a general understanding of the Northern Ireland Business Community's (NIBC) perception and understanding of Social Media, with a focus on Facebook & LinkedIn platforms.
Results
The data collected indicated that the Northern Ireland Business Environment (NIBE) do believe that social media will have a significant impact on future business models. However, there is a lack of understanding in the business benefits of social media integration into the business model. Random Comments, Facebooks conversation, NewsFeed were all highlighted for their ability to influence consumer buying behaviour. Data found that there was a competent awareness of LinkedIn, however there was a low utilization of its different platforms.
Conclusion and Recommendations While the research suggested a competent awareness of social media and its benefits, the author has made recommendations to increase NIBE utilization of social media platforms.
Keywords
3
Social media, Social Media Platform, Social Media Marketing, Marketing Communications, Behaviour, Integration, Facebook and LinkedIn, ROI, Northern Ireland Business Community and Northern Ireland Consumer.
Acknowledgements
Firstly I would like to thank my family who always have given me the strength in everything I do.
To my friends and teammates, thank you for all your encouragement and support throughout this project.
I would like to thank my mentors for the help and guidance they provided me with while completing this strategic and throughout all my studies, Thank you.
I would like to thank the Northern Ireland LinkedIn and Facebook community for their questionnaire participation and discussion on Social Media
I would like to thank Ari Herzog, whose blogging enthusiasm provided a stranger from Ireland valuable pointers to the great researchers in the field of Social Media .
I would like to thank the speakers at TED.com who always spark creativity in my thoughts.
Introduction
Porter (2001) states that the internet tends to weaken industry profitability, without providing proprietary operational advantages, moreover, businesses should be see it as another interface of business. In hindsight, this description, by one of the leading voices of traditional marketing, highlights an unimpressive underestimation of the internets potential impact on business. Social Media provides businesses with online tools and platforms (e.g. Facebook and Linkedin etc...), which enables co-ordination of different groups with different capabilities to create dynamic business models. The potential benefits for business are beyond increases in sales and advertising. It needs to be understood that social media platforms (SMP) are revolutionary new components of the Marketing Mix (Porter, 1985) and Value Web (Lauden & Lauden, 2009), as it mirrors 'push marketing strategies' with 'pulling social technologies'. The research will aim to counter negative doubts on the business benefits of social media by traditionalist marketers, while attempting to gain a better understanding of Northern Ireland businesses and consumers perceptions and use of social media platforms.
Section 1: Emergence of Social Medias Significance Traditional marketings underestimation of the Internet impact on business. th Social Media is the 5 evolution of media. th st Marketing Models: 20 Century Vs 21 Century The Impact and Value of Social Media Expression th st Consumer Expression: 20 Century Consumer Vs 21 Century Human
Section 2: Business & Social Media Integration Introduction to Enterprise 2.0 Social Media Platforms used for Business Benefits of Social Media Criticism of Business & Social Media Integration
Research exhibits Appendix 1, which illustrates the scope of internets growth when Porter (2001) made his presumptions about the Internet being just an interface. Companies like Amazon and eBay survived the crash of the .com, while Wikipedia was about to defy all marketing forecasts in becoming the largest open source encyclopedia (Appendix 2). McAfee (2009) highlights there is a need to understand how a technology is created, to truly understand how it can be and will be consumed. Traditional marketers lack of technological expertise may be the reason why many failed to foresee 2001 as being the year Social Media evolved. In 2001, online tools were used by the masses to enable search, organisation and distribution of data across the internet. Search engines and email services had become 'technologically-boring' (Shirky, 2009) and permeated society to the point it would be difficult to imagine life without them. E-mail is an inflection technology; it has completely changed the nature of how businesses communicate and the culture that surrounds it. It has opened new doors for innovative technologies and new business models, and there are still tremendous opportunities for emerging technologies to further the electronic messaging platform.
(Raffel, R., cited by Charney et al, 2001)
Since 2001, social online platforms have emerged and have increasingly proliferate around the world. Blogs, Facebook Pages, Twitter followers, LinkedIn Profiles, Flickr streams and Digg rankings, have transformed online media consumption to a more 'Social' experience. Social Media Platforms (SMP) and tools enable consumers gather around, express, discuss and share views on content (Appendix 3). Porter's (2001) underestimation exemplifies marketing strategies misunderstanding of Social Media capabilities today. Boyd (2009) observes that current marketing strategies continue to fail, in attempts to 'push' Social Media platforms into traditional broadcasting channels. This is the equivalent of perceiving the main benefit of email was the ability to spam consumer inboxes with advertising in 1998.
7
He who first shortened the labor of copyists by device of movable types was disbanding hired armies, and cashiering most kings and senates, and creating a whole new democratic world: he had invented the art of printing.
(Carlyle, 1833)
The electromagnetic telegraph was the first long distance device for human-to-human transmission of coded text messages. The Telephone was the first device that allowed real time voice conversations from different geographical points across the globe. The scope of the telephone's impact was emphasized by Aronson (1971): it facilitated the efficient organisation and operation of large-scale, integrated mass production manufacturing enterprises... No previous mode of communica-
tion was able to combine the latter's speed with its simplicity and economy of operation' (Aronson, 1971, p. 155) 1.3.3 3rd Revolution - Recorded Media other than Print - Tape, Vinyl Record, Photo & Movie Recorded media provided the ability to encode information onto a physical object. Emphasis of its social impact is be expressed by Kealy (1979) who credited it to 'democratization' of music, by making it available to consumers irrelevant of skill, time, place, and social standing . 1.3.4 4th Revolution - Broadcasted Media - T.V & Radio The last media revolution came in the past 100 years as society gained the ability to harness the electromagnetic spectrum to enable sound and images sent through the air (Shirky, 2009). The medium of TV & Radio was to the printing press, what the telephone had been to the letter, it allowed immediacy and it enabled listeners to experience events as they happened (Lewis, 1992). 1.3.5 5th Revolution - The Internet World Wide Web Shirky (2009) points out a curious asymmetry in first four revolutions; the media capable of creating conversation (e.g. Telephone), is incapable of communicating to groups, while the media that is capable in communicating to groups is incapable of creating conversation (e.g. TV). Shirky (2009) further explains that the internet has enabled the Many:Many communication patterns and for the first time media is now capable of supporting these kinds of conversations. According to Liu & Shrum (2002) emergence of new media (Internet), brought new models of interactivity: user-to-user and userto-message. Shirky (2009) describes the Intenet as being the mode of carriage for all media' because all media is becoming digitised and migrates to the internet (e.g. Telephone Skype, TV Hulu). As every form of media is right next door to every other form this creates synergy and innovation resulting in them emergence of Social Media platforms have appeared. These have enabled groups to share, create and highlight content within their social networks (Appendix 7).
9
It's as if, when you bought a book, they threw in the printing press for free. It's like you had a phone that could turn into a radio if you pressed the right buttons.
(Shirky, 2009)
Social Media Platform growth into the mainstream, highlights Facebook's ambition to become part of the internet's core infrastructure akin search engine Google Kirkpatrick. Shirky (2009) describes this transformation of the Internet as a shift from being less just a source of information and more increasingly a site of co-ordination.
1.4.2 20th Century Marketing Model Broadcasting Media The Broadcasting Media landscape was simple in conception to the degree that professionals provided content, services and products for amateurs. The 'Broadcasting' businesses strategy was often based on bundling information into a single message and sent out to all edges of the network (Shirky, 2009). Godin (2009) describes this as a massive spamming 'push' of mostly average ideas, in an attempt to hypnotise consumers into buying a service or product. Everyone tuned in via the same devices, at the same time, to hear the same message
(Boyd, 2009)
10
This methodology was socially accepted due to the limited communication channels and high costs only enabled a small proportion of businesses to use them. These traditional communication channels had low degrees of accuracy even in the later attempts of target marketing (Shachar & Anand ,1995). Godin (2009) sarcastically described broadcasting marketing model: Television. Advertising. Push push. Take a good idea and push it on the world. I have a better mousetrap. And if I can just get enough money to tell enough people, I'll sell enough. And you can build an entire industry on that. If necessary you can put babies in your ads. If necessary you can use babies to sell other stuff. And if babies don't work, you can use doctors.
1.4.2 21st Century Marketing Model Networking/Social Media In an era where media is global, social and ubiquitous (Shirky (2009), Social Media has not only allowed consumers to connect with each-other but also exposed some of the most niche silos of interest across the globe. This 'niche-fication' (Boyd 2009) of the global market creates valuable opportunities for all businesses (Godin, 2009). Content is no longer about destination, it is about connection.
(Shirky, 2009)
Peters (1998) and Normann and Ramirez 's(1994) prediction that the internet would transform the 'former audience's' (Gilmore, 2004) capabilities from being restrictively consuming to having the ability to co-produce are now apparent. As a result of this, consumer power has multiplied ten-fold, as Shirky (2009) describes the current consumer generation as having the largest expressive capability in human history.
11
1.5.1 The wisdom of the former audience Consumer ability to express and create content can be exemplified through the growth of public social platforms such as Wikipedia and Youtube. However, the value of social media-enabled expression extends beyond the mainstream and into civic niches, as seen with www.paitentslikeme.com (Appendix 8) and www.Ushahidi.com (Appendix 9). Shirky (2010) explains how the strategy behind these social platforms appreciate the concept that groups know mostly everything about a common interest, but no individual knows everything about the interest. Social media platforms take the tacit information available from the group/public, aggregate it, map it in a publicly consumable form. McAfee (2009) suggests through experience, that the 20th Century corporate reaction to the strategy of co-ordinating public groups to assemble pools of data, as 'pure madness'. He advocated that corporate management would base their evaluational of a group's integrity by the rule of thumb, 'the IQ of a group is half the average of its weakest members'. Business leaders' underestimation derives from an era where the common denominator between the majority of informal groups being their geographical location. Social Media tools eradicated the limitations of geographical location and enabled groups to virtually assemble around a common 'interest'. Wikipedia is a champion example of a social media tool that provides groups with a platform to gather around common interests. Data on Wikipedia is downloaded thousands of times, edited, and new information is added by unpaid and widely unknown collaborators (Leadbeater 2009). Despite success, open source platforms akin Wikipedia are often criticized for inaccuracy (Seigenthaler, 2005), which tends to illuminate minority of content. However, research has proved Wikipedia to be significantly accurate: We analyzed the evolution of content in English Wikipedia articles and showed that nonfeatured articles tend to have highquality content 74% of their lifetime and this is 86% for featured articles.
(Javanmardi et al, 2010)
Provision of social platforms with clear rules, has proven a successful method of harnessing the 'Wisdom of Crowds' (cited by Surowiecki 2005, Clay, 2009, McAfee 2009 and Kittur & Kraut, 2008) by yielding masses of quantitive data in aggregated manner that can be accepted as both accurate an of quality. Research has shown the 20th century business'
12
underestimation of a group's intelligent quotient (IQ) but what groups use Social Media has also illuminated a misinterpretation of the 20th century consumer's motives.
1.5.2 20th Century Consumer Vs 21st Century Human It was assumed by business that consumers were intrinsically motivated, rational and self maximizing, in order to survive in the competitive markets of the 20th century (Slater, 1997).
The media landscape in the 20th century was very good at helping people consume... what we're seeing is that people weren't couch potatoes because we liked to be, we were couch potatoes because that was the only opportunity given to us.
(Shirky, 2010)
Social Media platforms have enabled a shift in human behaviour in that there were always people who wanted to share their message and but there was no pulpit to stand on (Boyd, 2009). The growth of social media platforms akin Linux Operating Systems (Proffitt, 2008), OpenStreetMaps (Berners Lee, 2009) and Amazon book reviews, prove that consumers have intrinsic motivations that are non-financial. These platforms can incur positive as well as negative effects on a business, pending the culture that surrounds the social platform of expression. This is made possible by Social Media's collaboration with the 'Wisdom of Crowds' which illuminates a relatively untouched resource, which Shirky (2009) describes as the 'Cognitive Surplus'. The 'Cognitive Surplus' is estimated and described by Shirky (2009) as the 1 trillion hours of the 'former audiences' free time. Research exhibits a small percentage of this figure can create to radical open source projects and small valuable data-pools, which is something that would not be possible without Social Media Tools.
1.5.3 Conclusion
13
Section 1 of the literature review has highlighted the significance of Social Media's ability to unlock consumer expression and collaboration. Section 2 will exhibit the use, benefits and criticisms of Social Media integration into business.
(2009) highlights social medias ability to strengthen weak professional ties through such SMPs as LinkedIn. Stelzner (2010) confirms that 53.1% of professionals who invested a few months in social media, report gains of new partnerships and qualified leads. Vaynerchuck (2008) is justified by Stelzner (2010) in his explanation that 'sweat equity' (time & effort) is the only main cost during social media marketing campaigns. Vaynerchuck (2008) also believes it is a more effective way of spending resources than many traditional advertising method, citing 'Billboards' as a prime example of inflated spending. 1.6.4 Criticism of Business & Social Media Integration The number one criticism of Business & Social Media Integration efforts is the inability to sufficiently quantify opportunity cost with return on Investment (Stelzner, 2010, Vaynerhuk, 2008). As Social Media is a relatively new transformation there are few concrete benchmarks or procedures management recognise to equal certain success. Marketer's find it difficult to convince management about the ROI, as there is a lack of key metrics to measure benefits, such as customer satisfaction and brand loyalty (Stelzner, 2010). Many marketers recognise business & social media integration efforts as taking an enormous amount of time. Many cite absence of expertise as a key difficulty when planning campaigns. Social Media platforms expose businesses to public criticism, which can result in a negative impact for brand image.
15
2.0 Methodology
2.1 Introduction
The aim of this chapter is to discuss the empirical research that was used to gather the raw data needed to analyse, discuss and answer aims stated in the research objectives.
Ireland business environment. Therefore the author has believed that the best way of addressing this is to combine the social media tools that the internet has required to gather both qualitative and quantitative.
2.4.1 Consumer Questionnaire The author has decided to use Facebook as a data collection platform due to its superior size, activity and more importantly its 'Live Status Update' widget (Appendix 13). This widget is central to the design of Facebook (Kirkpatrick, 2010) and with every 'Wall Post' invitation, the widget automatically increases the populations awareness of the authors research. Due to a lack of quantitive research available on Northern Ireland Facebook activity the author had to collate his own calculation of the population size he was sampling from. As the total UK population is 61,792,000 (OFNS, 2010) and 1,780,000 (OFNS, 2010) of those people residing living in Northern Ireland (NI), this equates to 2.9% of the overall UK population residing in NI. Collating this percentage of the UK population with the total number of Facebook members in the UK, 28,003,500 (Gonzalez, 2010), would equate to a total population of 784,098 NI Facebook members (Appendix 23). The sample size of the survey totaled 95 people, 34 females (35.8%) and 61 males (64.2%). The mode age of participation ranged between 15 25 years old, this aggregated 73.7% of the total sample size, notably followed by '25 -35' (18.9%) and '35 44' (3.2%) respectively. The questionnaire was derived from the previous literature review, included 22 closed ended questions and took an average of 5 6 minutes to complete during pilot testing, which produced quantitive data. Closed questions allow the respondents to answer the same question so that answers can be meaningfully compared. It produces answers that are much easier to analyze (McCracken, 1988). The author introduced each request with an honest and articulated invitation explaining: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Reasons for research Number of questions to be asked. Types of answers requested. Estimated completion time based on pilot tests. Apologies for lack of custom invitations due to the quantitive nature of research.
Notable Comments: Participation was better than expected with 100 participants and 66 invites.
18
Honest and polite explanation of questionnaire led to participants forwarding question to their contacts (3rd party). Indirect use of Facebooks Newsfeed led to greater awareness of the research.
2.4.2 Data Collection - Business Questionnaire Research has shown more effective platforms, such as LinkedIn, Viadaeo or Xing , that can be used in order to target participants from the Northern Ireland Business community. The author has decided to use LinkedIn as the preferred sampling platform to gauge business participation, due to its higher adoption rate per capita in Northern Ireland in comparison with its rivals. The author utilized the online professional network LinkedIn, understanding the importance of a targeted audience (Garton, Haythornthwaite, & Wellman, 1999; Wellman, 1997), as well as time and opportunity cost of businesses participation within quantitive research. The author created a LinkedIn Profile explaining his current purpose of participation at LinkedIn (Appendix 14). This added clarity when requesting to join groups through an honest and articulated pitch to each group's Manager. The author requested to join 9 Linkedin groups formed by and for Northern Ireland Professionals and Business owners. One request was ignored (Queens Alumni Group) and eight were successful (Appendix 15). The 8 Northern Ireland based LinkedIn groups (Appendix 16, 17 & 18) had varying degrees of participation and accumulated to have a population potential of 3,045 professionals & business owners. The reason for an estimation in population is due to a number of professionals having affiliation with multiple groups. The sample size of the survey researched 38 professionals of varying degrees of experience amongst various industries in Northern Ireland. The questionnaire had an average completion time of 8 9 minutes during pilot tests, encompassing 21 close/scale-ended and 4 open-ended questions. Open questions allowed the respondents to express themselves in their own words and allow the author to identify complex motivational influences. Cohen at al (2000, P.255) identifies that the open ended question is a very attractive de19
vice for small scale research or for those sections of a questionnaire that invites an honest personal comment from the respondents. The research produced both quantitive and qualitative data, as well as engaging participants to further extend offers of their time to engage in future qualitative research (Appendix 22 - Most notably, Social Media Manager for the Belfast Telegraph, Barry Adams).
2.5 Time
Online surveys saved time by allowing the author to collect data while working on other tasks (Llieva, Baron, & Healey, 2002). After the initial invitation to participate by the author on LinkedIn discussion boards or Facebook Profile 'Walls', awareness grew and participation growth began to quicken and increase. SurveyMonkey allowed the author to collect data while engaging in blogs in order to collect more primary data and recommendations for areas of study (Appendix 20) (Andrews et al., 2003).
20
21
22
to communicate their opinions on products and services (Boyd, 2009). These trends are echoed within the sample, as 74.4% (n = 64/86) of Northern Ireland consumers (NIC) believed 'random comments' were a reliable source of product research at some level (Figure 2).
23
Another interesting fact is that 27% (n = 24/88) of that group, shared a random consumer review with a friend(s) and later discovered 56.5% (n = 13/23) of that communication was done via 'Word of Mouth' (Figure 3 v Figure 4). This research exhibits similarities to Shirky's (2009) claims on the transformation of the media landscape, and more importantly accentuates the ability of a 'Random Comment' to transform into 'Word of Mouth' communication between friends.
24
Kirkpatrick (2009) states that Facebook's 'News Feed' is central to its structure, with the goal of being the centerpiece of user activity. Research found 33.7% (n = 31/92) of participants have voiced their opinions on product/service and consumer experience via the 'News Feed'. The reach and impact of each comment is difficult to quantify but it can be assumed to have a significant impact on NIFUs perceptions on product/services. To give an estimation of its scope, the user suggests Shirkys (2010) metaphorical calculation of potential impact, in that, the impact is the squared total of the sum of all the members connections. In combining this data with the assumption that social media has become daily routine for
many (Ivanauskas, 2009), as well as Kirkpatrick's (2009) insight into the future technological capabilities of Facebook, suggests that public 'Facebook' communication (e.g. Wall Posts, Status Update), could be described as 'Virtual Word of Mouth' .
25
Research found that only 13% (n = 5/38) of the NIBC agreed that 'mass online following was essential for a successful social media marketing campaign'. This conflicts with the author's assumptions based on the literature by Boyd (2009), who highlighted a lack of understanding and continuous attempts by current businesses to saturate social media channels with mass marketing broadcasting techniques.
26
Findings found a split in opinion which is related to literature claims that being on every platform does not necessarily equate to additional value (Vaynerchuk, 2008). Research found that 47.4% (n= 18/38) of business participants agreed, at varying levels, that they needed to be on as many social media sites as possible. This indicates a lack of clarity and planning by this segment of the NIBC, as literature has further highlighted the drawbacks of being on too many social media platforms. (Vaynerchuk, 2008)
ther analyfound, 50% 5/10) of that ment who not have a book page 'they did not derstand benefits of book from a ness stand(Figure
The social media thing is a bit of a quagmire for me at the moment as it is for a lot of businesses I'm sure... While technically, I fully understand the mechanics of twitter etc. I'm still struggling to see how the amount of work needed that will bring a significant enough return.
(Melia, 2010)
Literature has expressed the importance to businesses of engaging frequently with their community (Vaynerchuk, 2009). Research exhibits 82.3% of the NIBC who have a Facebook profile for business, claim to update/add content on their page '1-7 times per week' or more. Further research into NIBC Facebook 'Fan' engagement exhibits 52.9% (n = 9/17) of participants claim to engage with a 'Fan' after every profile question and 35.3% (n = 6/17) claim to engage with a 'Fan' after every profile comment. This indicates a positive correlation between the behaviour patterns of the NIBC and the the 'best practice' highlighted by the literature.
3.7.1 Understanding of the LinkedIn Platform Professional networking platforms such as LinkedIn claims to provide members with a network most conwill an in of their trusted tacts that give them advantage their career (Linkedin, 2010). Reenwere and ment ple had a LinkedIn Profile (Figure 13). Findings exhibited 86.1% (n=36) of participants perceive the main advantage of LinkedIn to be 'Professionals ability to network online, while 11.1% (n=4) more acutely understand the capability to '...gain advice from other professionals' (Figure 12). search found the tire sample aware of LinkedIn a 75% segof the sam-
29
This indicates a competent understanding by the NIBE of LinkedIn's purpose. The research highlights suggests an a standing in the ties by the NIBC a pattern that primitive understrength of weak (McAfee, 2010).
of LinkedIn ties
ment & Selec-
LinkedIn enables members to post and distribute job listings to find the best talent for their company (LinkedIn, 2010). Research found that 47.2% of the NIBE sample have used LinkedIn as a tool to recruit staff or potential staff, while only 2.8% didn't know this was a possibility. This research exhibits a competent use of this feature by the NIBE.
30
3.8.2 Observing Competition NIBC research has highlighted that 75.8% of the sample (n = 25/33) have used LinkedIn to monitor their competition. This highlights and emphasizes literature complaints of social/networking media's privacy issues for business. 3.8.3 LinkedIn Answers LinkedIn highlights its ability to provide members with access to new insights from discussions with likeminded professionals (LinkedIn, 2010). Research exhibits 55.6% of the NIBC sample had used 'LinkedIn Answers' to acquire knowledge in solving a business problem. Research has shown that 55.6% of the NIBC sample had used 'LinkedIn Answers' to help them acquire knowledge to solve a business problem, while 33.3% had not and a further 11.1% did not know this was possible (Figure 15).
This indicates the authors opinion that a small NIBC segment being unaware of LinkedIn Answers, but an overall under utilization of the pool of knowledge available to NIBC, especially considering the advantages exhibited in the literature (e.g. cost savings by avoiding consultation fees).
31
3.8.4 ROI of discussing expertise within LinkedIn. Research has found that 66.7% of the NIBC had answered a LinkedIn question within their area of expertise, while over 30% had not, consequently 2.8% never knew this was a possibility and two participants conceded the question. Literature cites evidence of Vaynerchuk's (2008) description of Sweat Equity as the key catalyst in boosting business reputation, i.e.the process of becoming involved in the conversation. LinkedIn (2010) claims involvement in the conversation can lead to attainment of inside connections that can help land jobs and close deals. Research exhibits these potential opportunities to be true as 80% (n=20) (Figure 17) of the sample extended their professional network and 34.6% (n=9) (Figure 16) acquired new business as a result of providing a LinkedIn answer.
3.8.5 Outsourcing LinkedIn (2010) claims to provide a platform that enables the user to be found for business opportunities and find potential partners'. Liturgy has found examples of this in practice, as research has exhibited 39.4% of the sample (n = 13/33) have used LinkedIn to find vendors for outsourcing services (Figure 18).
32
dian6 or Scout Labs). SMM software tracks consumers who engage via social media platforms and collates data found via social bookmarks, comments, engagement, influence, friends, followers, downloads, favorites, views, votes and links. SMM software aggregates this data and presents it in a manner that gains insightful knowledge and thoughts regarding online consumer behaviour. Research further addresses that non-utilization of free online social tools, such as search.twitter.com, are at the detriment of the companys competitive advantage, due to the simplicity of their use and availability to competitors both locally and globally.
4.1.3 Recommendation 2 A competent proportion of the NIBC have integrated Facebook into their business model at some level for those that have not, this if often due to their lack of understanding of the business benefits. The majority of NIBC understood the potential business impact of Social Media and a significant number had integrated Facebook into their business model. A meaningful number of those who had not integrated Facebook into their business model justified their decision by stating a lack in understanding of business benefits rather that measurement of ROI. It is recommended that even minimum participation on Facebook can have business benefits, especially for SMEs. Campaigns are most effective when a customer base is passionate about about a companys product/service and research exhibits a Northern Ireland based company, Chain Reaction Cycles, as champion example of best practice that others should follow (Appendix 24 & 25). The author recommends that the strategic planning behind any Business Facebook should always start with building relationships with customers and not to increasing sales. This will plant the seeds of a culture with similar characteristics to the Facebook campaigns this study has exemplified and in the long term generate new channels of sales. plains: Good use of social media requires a solid understanding of your target market, and a keen awareness of a companys desired public image. You dont want a newspaper like the Belfast Telegraph to go all ganstah-speak on Facebook, just as you dont want Jay-Z to start talking in Oxford English
34
(Adams, 2010).
4.1.4 Recommendation 3
A competent presence and awareness of the advantages of LinkedIn but a glaring low utilisation of its range of capabilities There is a competent NIBE presence within the LinkedIn community and an adept awareness of it advantages to businesses. There are mundane and various levels of NIBE activity within LinkedIn, ranging from monitoring the competition, scouting for potential employee or outsourcing partners as well as problem solving and answering queries. There is also low utilization of LinkedIn platforms such as participation in answering LinkedIn questions, which have the potential to generate a ROI from extending professional networks and goodwill. Research recommends that NIBC engage more often in LinkedIn discussion as it has the potential to increase the size of their profession network and generate links with potential business and outsourcing partners. Increased participation could also have an added value to a a companys value chain, by reducing costs incurred by consultation fee and aid research and selection in finding top employees. In light of all these benefits, research recommends NIBE protect their top employees from being head hunted by companies who use LinkedIn as a scouting tool.
35
social media in Ireland, which could discover other behaviour of consumers and businesses in Northern Ireland. The main limitation of the research is considered to be the participation issues within the design of the questionnaire. The majority of questions were optional in order to increase participation but this resulted in a fluctuation in the number of participants that answered each question, which could have reduced the credibility of the overall research. Furthermore, a limitation of the research is considered to be the research setting itself, that is, Facebook and LinkedIn participation. As all consumer participants were gathered via Facebook, this may give a biased opinion of the online consumer and similarly with business profiling via LinkedIn participant. Finally, it was noticed that a heavy majority of participants were aged between 15 24 years old, which illuminated a disproportionate profile of the Northern Ireland consumer. These limitations highlighted the opportunity for the researcher to improve their primary research skills with an emphasis on planning and methodology. Using more suitable questionnaire techniques and collecting data from numerous online platforms beyond LinkedIn and Facebook would increase the credibility of primary data. The implications of this research should mostly concern marketing professionals in Northern Ireland as the data gathered provides interesting insights into perceptions, understanding of Social Media, by both business and consumers in Northern Ireland. Regardless, it gives the opportunity for academic researchers to verify the presented research and local businesses to gain a better understanding of Social Media.
36
Bibliography
Andrews, D., Nonnecke, B., & Preece, J. (2003). Electronic survey methodology: A case study in reaching hard-to-involve Internet users. International Journal of Human-Computer Interaction, 16(2), 185-210.
Aronson, Sidney (1971). 'The Sociology of the Telephone', International Journal of Comparative Sociology 12: 153-67.
Berners Lee, T. 2009. Tim Berners-Lee on the next Web. USA:TED2009. Available at http://www.ted.com/talks/tim_berners_lee_on_the_next_web.html [12th September 2010]
Boyd Lee, T. 2009. "Streams of Content, Limited Attention. Web 2.0 Expo NY: OReilly. Available at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DW3_JhQksv4l [6th September 2010]
Carlyle, T., 1833. Sartor Resartus: The Life and Opinions of Herr Teufelsdrockh
Charny B., Festa, P., Konrad, R., Lemos, R./Jenkins, J., 2001. How has email effected your life? (1st). CNET News: CNET. Available from: http://news.cnet.com/How-has-e-mailaffected-your-life/2100-1023_3-274215.html#ixzz0yyuCwS00[8thSeptember 2010].
Chevalier & Mayzlin. (2004). Teffect of word of mouth on sales: online book reviews. 2(1). Availible from: http://www.atypon-link.com/AMA/doi/abs/10.1509/jmkr.43.3.345[7thSeptember 2010.
37
Foddy, W,1993. Constructing Questions for Interviews and Questionnaires: Theory in Practice in Social Research. UK. University of Cambridge
Garton, L., Haythornthwaite, C., & Wellman, B. (1999). Studying on-line social networks. In S. Jones (Ed.), Doing Internet Research: Critical Issues and Methods for Examining the Net(pp. 75-105). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Gilmore, D., 2004. We the Media - Grassroots Journalism by the People, for the People. (1st). USA:Creative Commons. from: http://www.authorama.com/we-the-media-8.html [8th September 2010].
Ivanauskas. (2000). The evaluation of social media effects on marketing communications: the UK consumers perspective. Available from: http://www.scribd.com/doc/12921323/Social-Media-in-the-UK-MA-Dissertation [9th September 2008]
Javanmardi, J., , T., Lopes, C. & Baldi, P.Measure of the Effectiveness of the Open Editing Model of Wikipedia. of California, Irvine, (7). Available from: http://www.icwsm.org/2010/papers/icwsm10dcw_3.pdf[8thSeptember 2010].
Kealy, E. R. (1979). 'From craft to art: the case of sound mixers and popular music'. Sociology of Work and Occupations, vol 6, Feb 1979.
38
Kittur, A., Chi, E., Suh, B. Crowdsourcing for Usability (2008): Using Micro-Task Markets for Rapid, Remote, and Low-Cost User Measurements. In Proc. CHI 2008, ACM Press.
Kittur, A., Kraut R.E., 2008. Harnessing the Wisdom of Crowds in Wikipedia: Quality Through Coordination. 2008, (8). Available from: http://portal.acm.org/citation.cfm? id=1460563.1460572 [8thSeptember 2010].
Kreis, S., (2004). The Printing Press. (2nd). The History Guide: Lectures on Modern Intellectual History. Available from: http://www.historyguide.org/intellect/press.html [ thSeptember 2010].
Laudon, K. & Laudon, J. (2010) Management Information Systems (11th ed.) Pearson.
Lewis, T., (1992). A Godlike Presence: The Impact of Radio on the 1920s and 1930s. Organisation of American Historians. Available at: http://www.oah.org/pubs/magazine/communication/lewis.html [Accessed: 8th September 2010].
Liu, Y. and Shrum, L.J. (2002), What is interactivity and is it always such a good thing? Implications of definition, person, and situation for the influence of interactivity on Advertising effectiveness, Available from:htt p:// w w w .yupingliu.com/L iu_Shr um_Interacti vit y.pdf [9th September 2008]
39
Llieva, J., Baron, S., & Healey, N. M. (2002). Online surveys in marketing research: Pros and cons. International Journal of Market Research, 44(3), 361-367.
McAfee, A. P., 2009. Mechanisms to Let Structure Emerge. In: Harvard Business Press, 1st . Enterprise 2.0: New collaborative tools for your organisation's toughest challenges. Boston, MS: Harvard Business School Publishing..
McLuhan, Marshall 1962, The Gutenberg Galaxy: The Making of Typographic Man (1st ed.), University of Toronto Press, ISBN 978-0802060419.
Normann, R. and Ramirez, R. (1994), Designing Interactive Strategy: From Value Chain to Wiley & Sons.Value Constellation, John Wiley & Sons.
OFNS, 2010. Internet Access 2010. Office for National Statistics: Statistical Bulletin. Available at http://www.statistics.gov.uk/pdfdir/iahi0810.pdf [7th September 2010].
Peters, L. 1998, The new interactive media: one-to-one, but who to whom?, Marketing Intelligence & Planning, Vol. 16/1, pp 2230.
Porter, M.E., 1985. Competitive Advantage, Free Press, New York, 1985.
Porter , M. E. 2001. Strategy and the internet. Harvard Business Review (March): 2. from: http://hvass.nu/s2/artikler/teori/Misc/porter.pdf[8thSeptember 2010].
Proffit, B. 2005. Killing With Kindness. Linux Today. May 30, 2008, 22:30. http://www.linuxtoday.com/news_story.php3?ltsn=2008-05-30-020-26-OP-MS-NV
40
Qualman, E., 2009. Socialnomics: How Social Media Transforms the Way We Live and Do. New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons.
Selgenthaler Sr, J., 2005. A false Wikipedia 'biography'(1st). Editorial/Opinion: USA Today. Available from:http://www.usatoday.com/news/opinion/editorials/2005-11-29-wikipediaedit_x.htm[8thSeptember 2010].
Shachar, T., Anand, B. 1995. Effectiveness and Targeting of Television Advertising. Journal of Economics & Management Strategy, Volume 7, Number 3, Fall 1998, 363 - 396. Available at http://www.people.hbs.edu/banand/effectiveness.pdf[12thSeptember 2010].
Shirky, J., (2008). Here comes everybody: the power of organizing without organisations(1st). USA: Penguin Press Inc.
Shirky, J., (2010). Cognitive Surplus: Creativity and Generosity in a Connected Age (1st). USA: Penguin Press Inc.
Surowiecki, J., (2004). The Wisdom of Crowds: Why the Many Are Smarter Than the Few and How Collective Wisdom Shapes Business, Economies, Societies and Nations (1st). New York: Little Brown.
Vaynerchuk, J., (2008). Crush It!: Why Now is the Time to Cash in on Your Passion (1st). New York: Barnes & Noble.
41
Appendices
Appendix 1 - Timeline of Internet Growth
Source - http://www.migueltodaro.com/img_2/internet_timeline.jpg
42
Source: http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/cf/EnglishWikipediaArticleCountGraph_linear.pn g
Source - http://files.brandflakesforbreakfast.com/uploaded_images/mattmcd-social-media-diagram764149.jpg
PatientsLikeMe is a social networking health site that enables its members to share treatment and symptom information in order to track and to learn from real-world outcomes. PatientsLikeMe currently has communities for amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), multiple sclerosis (MS), Parkinson's disease, fibromyalgia, HIV, chronic fatigue syndrome, and mood disorders, as well as the rare conditions progressive supranuclear palsy, multiple system atrophy, and Devic's disease (neuromyelitis optica). Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PatientsLikeMe
43
Appendix 9 Civic Niche - www.ushahidi.com Ushahidi uses the concept of crowdsourcing for social activism and public accountability, serving as an initial model for what has been coined as 'activist mapping' - the combination of social activism, citizen journalism and geospatial information. Ushahidi provides a mechanism for local observers to submit reports using their mobile phones or the internet, while simultaneously creating a temporal and geospatial archive of events.
Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ushahidi
Appendix 13 Facebook News Feed Source: http://www.facebook.com/ Appendix 14 LinkedIn Profile Source: http://www.linkedin.com/profile/view?id=84115884
Source: http://www.linkedin.com/profile/view?id=84115884
44
Notable Comments: vided some insightful qualitative feedback. 2. Belfast Business People 190 Members
Notable Comments: Manager of the group was very eager to aid research. After an initial low participation activity, Rush (2010) sent out a 2nd request to group members which seen an increase in questionnaire completion.
3.
Notable Comments: Manager of the group was eager to aid research but recently had launched a discussion (inc. questionnaire) on 'Cloud Software and Services sector in Ireland'. The administrator did not want to spam members with online questionnaire requests. The proposed rescheduled date was beyond the research period and therefore could not take place during this research. 4. Ireland Business Consultancy Network - 279 Members
Notable Comments: Manager of the group encouraged discussion within the group. 5. Northern Ireland Business - 348 Members
Notable Comments: Manager of the group encouraged discussion within the group. Several group members made InMail contact with author wishing to discuss their views on Social Media and Business. 6. Northwest Connects - 110 Members
Notable Comments - Manager of the group encouraged discussion within the group. 7. UK & Eire Business Network Group - 396 Members
Notable Comments Manager of the group encouraged discussion within the group. Several group members made InMail contact with author wishing to discuss their views on Social Media and Business. 8. University of Ulster Alumni Group 45
1,132 Members Notable Comments Manager of the group encouraged discussion within the group. Several group members made InMail contact with author, wishing to further discuss their views on Social Media and Business.
Source: http://www.linkedin.com/groupAnswers?viewQuestionAndAnswers=&discussionID=28437922&gid=2792811&commentID=22510485&trk=view_disc
Appendix 18 LinkedIn - Example of enthusiasm and generosity by Belfast Business People Group Manager - Justin Rush
Appendix 19 LinedIn - Example of demand to participate beyond research closing date Appendix 20 - Example of Primary Research through 3rd Party Blogs
Source: http://ariwriter.com/who-are-the-best-social-media-researchers/ Appendix 22 - Example of extended offers of qualitative research from the Social Media Manager for the Belfast Telegraph - Barry Adams.
46
As there are no government surveys aggregating Northern Ireland's online participation, this study attempts to profile the countries Facebook population and demographics. This will be attempted through aggregating Gonzalez (2010) UK statistics (Appendix?) with Northern Ireland 2.8%* of UK total population.
UK Total Facebook Population Online Population % Percentage of Global Facebook Audience Gender Male Female Age <=13 14-17 18-24 25-34 35-44 45-54 55-64 65+ UK% 48.2% 51.8% UK% 1.1% 12.0% 25.4% 26.7% 17.7% 10.0% 4.7% 2.3% 28,003,500 64.9% 5.43%
UK Total 13,093,120 14,069,780 UK Total 319,300 3,359,960 7,104,100 7,466,160 4,965,140 2,810,540 1,323,300 655,020
Northern Ireland* 366,607 393,954 Northern Ireland* 8,940 94,079 198,915 209,052 139,024 78,695 37,052 18,341
47
Appendix 24 - Chain Reaction Cycles - NIBE Champion in Social Media Facebook Platform - High levels of community following, engagement and contribution with Chain Reaction communication.
Source: http://www.facebook.com/#!/ChainReactionCycles?v=info&ref=ts/
48
Appendix 25 - Chain Reaction Cycles - NIBE Champion in Social Media Facebook Platform - High levels of eyeballs (i.e following) and consistent tweeting patterns engage strong attention to the channel.
Source: http://twitter.com/chain__reaction
49
Table of Figures
Figure 1 - Influencing of Consumer Behavior
- ReliaRe-
50
51
52
Figure SharOnRe-
6ing line
views
53
54
Fig-
ure 10 - Business Purpose of Facebook Figure Reafor havFace11 sons not ing a book
55
Fig12
ure -
Perception of Linkedin
56
57
Figure
16 -
58
Figure
17 -
Linkedin Networking
59
60