Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sri:
Srimathe Ramanujaya Nama:
A thousand years back, when swami emperumAnAr was ruling the leelA
vibhuti, as the chief of our Sri Vaishnava SampradhAyam, there lived a
vidhwan called "yaJNyamUrthy". He was a great scholar in vEdAnta, and
a sanyAsi following the advaita sampradhAyam. He heard about swAmi
emperumAnArs vaiBhavam, and decided to have a debate with swAmi
(hereafter swAmi will always refer to swAmi emperumAnAr, in the rest
of the document) and defeat him. Having decided thus, he wrote lot of
shAstrAs, based on the doctrine of advaitha, and carried them all with
him, to Srirangam. On reaching Srirangam, he expressed his wish to
debate with swAmi, which was gladly accepted by swAmi too. Both of
them put forth their conditions as follows : yaJNyamUrthy promised that,
if defeated, he will carry the holy sandals of swAmi, change his name
to that of swAmi, and also become a Sri Vaishnava. SwAmi too
promised that, if defeated, swAmi will take up grantha sanyAsam.
With this the debate started and continued for 18 days. Till the end of the
16th day, neither of them could defeat the other. But on the 17th day, the
arguments and ideas of yaJNyamUrthy grew stronger and swAmi could
not think of anything else to refute it. That day yaJNyamUrthy returned
home in an ecstatic mood, while swAmi was greatly dejected at the turn
of events. He then offered prasadam to his thiruvArADhana perumAL,
pEraruLALan, and silently started pouring his heart out to him. "Starting
with AzhwArs, and carried on by Sri AlavandAr, should this great
sampradAyam come to an end with the birth of a person like me. If this
is what is your desire, be it so." Thinking thus, and with extreme grief,
swAmi went to bed without having any prasAdam.
That night pEraruLALan appeared in his dream and spoke thus : "Oh!
IlayAzhwAr, why do you worry? I have given you a siShyA who is
equivalent to you in all aspects. Use the arguments of your
paramAchAryAr, Sri AlavandArs? mAyAvAdha Khandanam, and
defeat him."
SwAmi woke up suddenly and realized that it was a dream and was
overjoyed. He happily completed his nithya karmAnuShTAnam, and
after worshipping his thiruvArADhana perumAL and went to the debate
hall with all the majestic look. YaJNyamUrthy, on seeing swAmi was
awe struck, by his majestic appearance and happiness in his face,
that he thought: "Is this the same emperumAnAr, who returned
dejected yesterday. Now that he is entering the debate hall with a
majestic look of an elephant." On seeing all these, yaJNyamUrthy,
being a JNyAni, understood the divine power of swAmi, and decided
that it is not possible for a normal being to return with such energy,
after being badly defeated the previous day, and fell at the feet of
swAmi, and conceded defeat. As per the promises, he then requested
swAmi to forgive him by placing swamis holy feet on his head. This
act of yaJNyamUrthy completely surprised swAmi, who asked him
if he is not willing to continue with the debate. For this
yaJNyamUrthy replied, "When periya perumAL showed himself to
you, there is no difference between periya perumAL and swAmi, and
he (yaJNyamUrthy) does not have any capacity to speak a word in
front of such a great AcharyA." On hearing this swAmi was extremely
pleased, but still to bring the debate to a formal conclusion, he
explained yaJNyamUrthy, the flaws in the mAyAvAdha siDhAntham.