Mobile County's dangerous dog law ruled unconstitutional | al.

com

http://blog.al.com/live/2010/09/mobile_countys_dangerous_dog...

Sign in | Register for free

Site Search

Search Local Business Listings

Brought to you by:

Search for keywords, people, locations, obituaries, Web ID and more...

Home

News

Weather

Sports

Entertainment

Travel

Interact

Jobs

Autos

Real Estate

Rentals

Classified Ads

Shop

Top Stories

Toys for Tots has gifts for 6,000 in N. Alabama

Judge refuses to throw out Nodine charges

Facebook founder Time's 'Person of Year'

1 of 5

12/16/10 5:54 AM

Mobile County's dangerous dog law ruled unconstitutional | al.com

http://blog.al.com/live/2010/09/mobile_countys_dangerous_dog...

Home > Breaking News from the Press-Register

Sponsored By:

Mobile County's dangerous dog law ruled unconstitutional

Published: Thursday, September 30, 2010, 7:48 PM Updated: Thursday, September 30, 2010, 7:49 PM

Mark R. Kent, Press-Register

Follow

Share this story

Story tools

MOBILE, Ala. -- A law designed to protect residents of rural Mobile County against dangerous dogs was ruled unconstitutional earlier this week in Mobile County District Court. The Tuesday ruling in District Judge George Hardestys courtroom resulted in two dogs being returned to a Semmes man after they were quarantined in March following an attack on his neighbors 3-year-old daughter.

More Breaking News from the Press-Register Most Comments

Most Recent

Breaking News from the PressRegister stories with the most comments in the last 7 days.

52 42

Stephen Nodine trial reveals long and public affair Judge in Stephen Nodine trial refuses to throw out murder, stalking, ethics charges 2 men testify that they also dated shooting victim Angel Downs Nodine's attorney challenges investigator in Angel Downs death over observations of bruising Stephen Nodine murder trial: Testimony describes stormy, violent relationship with Angel Downs

Chad Fincher

10
Share

40
Be the first of your friends to like this.

Like 6 Comments

35

Brian Overstreet, attorney for the dogs owner, James White, said the ruling came during a civil hearing to have the dogs declared dangerous so they could be euthanized. He said the laws constitutionality was challenged on several points, including that it does not cover all parts of the county in the same manner. Overstreet said Hardesty did not state exactly what prompted him to strike the law down. The ruling drew concern from Joshua Shelton, a neighbor of Whites on Stone Road. Shelton said his daughter, Madison, was hospitalized March 10 after being attacked in her front yard by Whites two dogs, Sailor and Captain, and an Australian cattle dog, commonly called a blue heeler. White told the court that he did not own the blue heeler, which was also quarantined but not released from the Mobile County Animal Shelter after the ruling, according to Assistant District Attorney John Piazza. White was told by Hardesty to keep the released dogs secured or face a contempt citation, Piazza said. Shelton said he and a number of neighbors have expressed fears about the dogs. The deputies took about 20 statements from neighbors complaining about these dogs, he said. Shelton said a civil suit against White, seeking damages for his daughters injuries, is pending. Attempts to reach White were unsuccessful. Meanwhile, both Overstreet and District Attorney John Tyson said it will be up to State Rep. Chad Fincher, R-Semmes, who sponsored the overturned law, to introduce a new version that will stand up to legal challenge. Fincher said he will reintroduce the law in the next legislative session. One of my first priorities is to have the act amended with the language changed.

31

Most Active Users

What's this?

2 of 5

12/16/10 5:54 AM

Mobile County's dangerous dog law ruled unconstitutional | al.com

http://blog.al.com/live/2010/09/mobile_countys_dangerous_dog...

Users with the most al.com comments in the last 7 days

251 201 190 165 162

ALLTIGER85

ahsaaref- Here Come the Tigers AU6

trubluau71

songstress

3 of 5

12/16/10 5:54 AM

Mobile County's dangerous dog law ruled unconstitutional | al.com

http://blog.al.com/live/2010/09/mobile_countys_dangerous_dog...

Users We Love

Beer snob? Check out What's Brewing

Dan Murphy is the author of al.com's new beer blog, What's Brewing.
More Users We Love

Connect with al.com

What's this?

All Facebook & Twitter accounts

Recommendations
Auburn's Gus Malzahn turns down Vanderbilt 1,757 people shared this. Video: Here's Cam Newton doing the Top 10 list on the Late Show with David Letterman 970 people shared this. http://www.al.com/sports/index.ssf /2010/12 /oregons_uniform_for_bcs_champi.html 776 people shared this. SWAC invites Tennessee State to join 319 people shared this.

Facebook social plugin

From Our Advertisers Share your story and read others HERE Free Financial Counseling Come work for Brookwood Medical! Advertise With Us

Popular Tags

What's this?

Alabama Baldwin County Bob Riley BP crime Deepwater Horizon Fairhope forecast Gulf of Mexico oil spill Gulf of Mexico oil spill 2010 Gulf Shores Mobile mobile Mobile County Mobile police murder oil spill Orange Beach Prichard rain
robbery shooting southwest alabama

weather Weather

4 of 5

12/16/10 5:54 AM

Mobile County's dangerous dog law ruled unconstitutional | al.com

http://blog.al.com/live/2010/09/mobile_countys_dangerous_dog...

Site Search

Search Local Business Listings

Site Map | Advertise | Contact us Make us your home page

Search by keyword, town name, Web ID and more...

Home | News | Weather | Sports | Entertainment | Travel | Interact | Jobs | Autos | Real Estate | Rentals | Classified Ads | Shop | Place an Ad
Your Photos Your Videos Blogs Forums Travel Music Post a Job Post a free classified ad Sell your car Sell/Rent your Home Apartments & Rentals Claim your Business Listing for Free Alabama Business News US & World News Obits / Death Notices Weddings & Celebrations Lifestyle News Good Deals & Frugal Living Subscribe to our content (RSS) Newsletters | Text alerts Follow @aldotcom on Twitter Friend al.com on Facebook al.com mobile site

Special home delivery offers!

The Birmingham News | The Huntsville Times | Mobile Press-Register

2010 Alabama Live LLC. All Rights Reserved. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement. Please read our Privacy Policy. Community Rules apply to all content you upload or otherwise submit to this site. Contact interactivity management.

5 of 5

12/16/10 5:54 AM