Professional Documents
Culture Documents
THE INTERNATIONAL
ResouRce JouRnal
JULY 2012 Volume 4 Issue 7 www.irjonline.com
112
Seeds of distrust
Noordin Mengal is an activist in pursuit of independence for
Balochistan, a mineral rich province in southwestern Pakistan
bordering Iran and Afghanistan.
the Baloch in Iranian-occupied Balochistan, All state institutions, including the parlia-
- ment, judiciary and presidency, are subservient
ing direct air support to Pakistan in the military to the military. The incumbent so-called demo-
operation against the Balochs in 1970s, no cratically elected civilian government is an epito-
Pakistani saw it as foreign interference, but when me of politically impotent administrations that is
someone speaks out for the rights of the down- at the mercy of the Pakistani army. The military
trodden Baloch, Pakistan calls it interference in holds the levers of power and are the declared
its internal affairs. rulers of Pakistan since the country’s unfortu-
nate creation.
iRJ: The most recent Constitutional amend- Pakistan has occupied our land and has
ments in Pakistan have given the authority been systematically carrying out the social, politi-
over natural resource development to the pro- cal, cultural, physical and economic genocide
vincial governments, does this not give Balo- of the Baloch nation. Companies need to know
chistan enough control over which companies that any deal they make on Balochistan’s natural
it does business with? resources with this government is not meant to
last. Every successive government reverses the
MenGal: The Baloch remain disempowered and decisions of its predecessor, it’s a failed state
dispossessed. If we look at the human rights and many factors indicate that it clearly has no
situation, there is an oppressive military opera- future. The basic problem is that the future of the
tion ongoing and the powerless chief minister of Baloch people is not secure within Pakistan. No
Balochistan says he does not have the mandate to matter how good a deal might sound, we simply
change this and says that the Frontier Corps has won’t buy it anymore. We have constantly been
established a parallel government. Recently when deceived by the Pakistanis since the past 64
a senior provincial minister, Sadiq Umrani, held the years. We just want them to leave us alone.
FC responsible for disappearances and extrajudi- Companies that cut a deal with the central
cial killings, his younger brother was abducted to government over Balochistan’s resources need
silence him. If the provincial government cannot to realise that there are no guarantees to them
safeguard itself, what do they have authority over? for as long as there is no peace and stability. Any
116 ASIAp Seeds of distrust
attempt to indulge will be seen with strong nega- adopting the same illegal methods. There is an old
tivity by the population. They will also be seen as relationship there, Pakistan has been the concu-
exploiters adding to our miseries. Such compa- bine of China, that is how I would put it.
nies may get the deal on the condition that they
remain silent on the oppressive policies of the iRJ: Companies that develop natural resources
state against the Baloch, as have the Chinese. often bring much-needed development such as
Why do you think Pakistan is more pleased schools, hospitals and infrastructure, would Balo-
with China’s political establishment? Why is it
happier to let MCC [China Metallurgical Group Cor-
poration] work on the projects? If you look at Reko MenGal: We have heard the word “development”
Diq, Pakistan wouldn’t be in favour of the western- most of our lives. There is a difference between
based Tethyan Copper [Antofagasta and Barrick development and exploitation. When Pakistan
Gold joint venture], they would be more comfort- says it wants to bring development, what they
able with the Chinese because they are content really mean is they want to exploit. A prime exam-
with Pakistan carrying out atrocities against the -
Baloch as they themselves are the immoral mas- ated by a state-run company. Gas was discovered
ters of plundering and have no problem with others in 1952 and today there are only a couple of dis-
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 117
tricts in Balochistan that have access to gas. The frastructure, the state’s version of development
capital [of Balochistan], Quetta, received gas in is constructing massive military garrisons, para-
1986, 34 years after it was discovered, and that military bases, naval bases, air bases, several
too only after a military garrison was stationed hundred checkposts, illegal detention and inter-
- rogation facilities and nuclear testing sites in
ciary with all its major cities receiving household Balochistan with US and European taxpayers’
and commercial gasiby 1964. money and revenue generated from our land.
It is the Punjabi military that has been given Their other sham developments have been to
the most priority, Balochistan consumes 12 per construct roads for billions to inaccessible areas
cent of its own production though it is the largest and penetrate into our system to facilitate the mo-
province accounting for 47 percent of Pakistan’s bilisation and stationing of troops in order to forcibly
total land mass What did the Baloch people tap oil and gas and establish garrisons to further
gain from the gas? What have the people of the subjugate the Baloch and promote fundamental-
district that pumps gas to the whole of Pakistan ists and the construction of madrassahs, to counter
gained? They still burn wood. All the dividends the secular Baloch movement and build a breeding
from the sale of Baloch gas are usurped by Pun- ground and safe haven for radical mullahs.
jab. There is no shining precedent of the Baloch Another crime they committed in the name of
development was the nuclear tests conducted on
The military has already been working directly our land on 28 May 1998, which has caused count-
on the Chamalang coals mines, said to be one of less diseases among the inhabitants of Chaghai
due to the radiation. When my uncle’s government,
get a hold of Reko-Diq by backing D. Samar Mubara- which wasn’t even consulted, protested against the
kmand. In 2009, when the provincial secretary for tests on Baloch soil, his government was systemati-
mines and minerals opposed granting an exploration cally toppled on June 15 1998.
lease for the Chamalang mines to military, he was The time for reconciliation is over, now our
critically injured in an assassination attempt soon demands are for nothing short of independence.
We have absolutely no future in Pakistan.
Instead of schools, hospitals and basic in-
118 ASIAp Seeds of distrust
iRJ: Some would point to a lack of skilled labour drilling, would that give them an unquestionable
among the Baloch population to work on these right to explore North Sea oil or the Hibernia oil
projects as part of the problem, for example, the
deep sea port in Gwadar on the Arabian Sea, a The Baloch fear that the port will cause a
highly strategic asset and one that could boost
the economy of the region considerably. What encouraged by the government to migrate to
do you say to companies that require skills and Balochistan for employment and will be used to
expertise to handle mega-projects like this? create a demographic imbalance and convert
the Baloch into a minority in their own homeland,
MenGal: I would say hold your horses, the Baloch given the Baloch’s small population – less than
require more than skills and technical expertise, 10 million compared to Punjab’s 91 million.
they need empowerment and the freedom to China’s political establishment has collabo-
decide their fate. Just like other projects, outsid- rated with Pakistan’s government in the con-
ers have come, the staff and labour is from other
parts of Pakistan, locals are not allowed access to too have contributed to our plight and alienation.
schools and hospitals, which are reserved just for We would have welcomed the building of a port
employees, and no efforts have been made to set but China did not take the Baloch national in-
up training facilities, polytechnic institutes or vo- terest into consideration, they did not take the
cational centres so that locals attain the required
skills. Gwadar port was a project pushed for many announced and dealt with Punjab and its civil-
years by the Baloch but the project was taken military establishment directly.
over by the Pakistan establishment and then they Before Gwadar port’s construction, those
painted an absurd picture that Baloch nationalists people who had land [in the area] had their
oppose development. It is the Pakistani establish-
ment that is not only a threat to the Baloch national cheaply by force. However, most of the land was
identity but also an impediment to peace, stability, allotted to military generals who subsequently
security and “genuine” development in the region. sold them in the open market, to fellow Punjabis
If the French had better skills for deep sea and Muhajirs and earned billions.
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 119
must not collaborate with oppressive and corrupt situation. No one wants that.
regimes in carrying out crimes against humanity. Now, there is the Iran-Pakistan pipeline being
Multinational companies should not see our pre- constructed without the Baloch nation’s consent.
dicament as an opportunity to make a buck. They The Baloch will not sit as silent spectators as
can wait and we expect them to act more respon- they are trampled upon and there will undoubt-
sibly. We will be willing to talk to them when the edly be strong political resistance to allow it
situation is conducive for business. through our homeland.
120 SECTION p Seeds of distrust
a BRieF histoRy
1666 Mir Ahmed Khan of Kambarani tribe independence. Pakistan
start Ahmedzai dynasty recognises Kalat’s sovereignty and
1749-1794 Reign of Nasir Khan and region congratulates Baloch.
named Balochistan 1948 In opposition to decision of Balochi
1839 British incursion legislature, Pakistan forces Kalat
1854 Nasir Khan’s successors defeated to be ruled by an agent of the
by British and treaty formed with Pakistani state. Troops enter the
Khan of Kalat to defend territories capital and forcibly incorporate
from Central Asian or Iranian Balochistan into Pakistan. Balochi
invasions nationalist defence continues under
1860s -70s Growing British interest to pre- Abdul Karim Khan until 1950. He
empt potential advance of Russia. A spends 16 of his remaining 22 years
period known as the “Great Game”. in Pakistani prisons on charges of
1905 Demarcation of boundary between sedition
British India-Iran and British India- 1952 Pakistan’s first oil field discovered
Afghanistan effectively divides near Sui
Balochistan among three states – Balochistan Union States
British India, Iran and Afghanistan established
1934 Armed struggle for liberation and 1955 Princely states in Balochistan
unification of Balochistan begins (Kalat, Kharan, Las Bela, Makran)
under Magsi, head of Baloch abolished
national movement 1958 Second uprising and retaliatory
1947 Pakistan becomes heir to British military operation
rule, Kalat state [Princely state 1962 Third uprising and military
of Balochistan] proclaims operation, which ended when
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 121
Pakistan’s army took an oath on the 1993 - 1997 BHP negotiates Chaghai Hills
Quran not to harm rebels and their Exploration Joint Venture Agreement
90-year old leader while promising (CHEJVA) with Balochistan province
amnesty and to accept demands. and discovers significant copper-
Imprisonments and executions gold deposits near Reko Diq
followed. 1995 National Mineral Policy
1970 Within Pakistan, Balochistan Saindak copper-gold project trial
province established production begins with operations
1971 East Pakistan breaks away, handed over to Pakistani state-
Bangladesh created backed company Saindak Metals.
1972 First elections won by Nationalist Bureaucratic squabbling delays the
Party led by Sardar Attaulah project.
Mengal, first chief minister of 1998 Nuclear tests were carried out
Balochistan despite protests of ruling nationalist
1973 – 1977 Large scale Baloch rebellion led by party in bal headed by Akhtar
Marri and Mengal tribes suppressed Mengal leading to the dissolution
by Pakistani forces with the help of of the legislature in 18 days
the Shah of Iran 1999 General Pervez Musharraf takes
1978 General Zia ul Haq comes into power in bloodless coup
power through coup, withdraws 2000 Tethyan Copper Co. established after
troops from Balochistan and project taken over from BHP and
releases Baloch leaders of China approached by Musharraf to
Nationalist Party from prison. fund Gwadar deep water port
Baloch leaders Marri and Mengal Septuagenarian Baloch leader Nawab
go into self-imposed exile. Marri imprisoned, but released a year
and a half later
122 ASIAp Seeds of distrust
aFGhanistan:
Pawn or potential queen?
It took decades for an agreement to get reached on the Turkmenistan, Afghanistan,
Pakistan and India (TAPI) gas pipeline but commitment to bring the project to life
in the spirit of what is written on paper is going to be a tougher test yet.
Regional actors such as China, Iran, Russian and Pakistan may not see TAPI fitting
their strategy in the region and therefore may work to engineer its collapse against a
backdrop of geostrategic competition, writes Javed Noorani.
124
126 ASIA p Pawn or potential queen?
Caspian gas reserves to keep alternative energy exports - such as a deal to supply 30 billion cubic
sources. However, the Caspian region is still seen feet of gas to China, some to Iran and export to
Kazakhstan though Russia - Turkmenistan has
The four Caucasus and Central Asian states, committed itself to pipeline some gas to Euro-
namely Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, Turkmenistan pean Union too. Not surprisingly, the US and
and Uzbekistan, produced 4.7 trillion cubic feet European Union support Turkmenistan’s policy of
of gas, representing four per cent of the world’s multiple export routes.
total production in 2010. The Russian federation China, India, Pakistan and Iran are locked
possesses 24 per cent of the gas reserves and into energy competition due to their industrial
largely dominates the gas market in the Caspian needs. China and India have growing economies
region to maintain its hegemony and thus use it which make energy an important element of their
as a diplomatic tool. strategic imaginations. Pakistan’s energy needs
Despite over-committing itself to various gas are increasing by 10-12 per cent annually.
128 ASIA p Pawn or potential queen?
ReGional status
The regional aspiration of India and its
Pakistan has been eyeball to eyeball with energy needs magnify the importance
India over territorial disputes for six of sustained supply of gas for its large
stays armed to the teeth. recoverable gas and India offers the Turkmen
gas a sustainable market and an opportunity
d ReseRVes (2009)
Africa, Asia and Latin America, may not like its main
-
Source: BP Statistical Review
of World Energy 2010 cording to US self-interest. China may play to stop
India its rival from accessing gas through TAPI. It
will be able to buy extra gas from Turkmenistan to
address its energy insecurity cost-effectively and
supply some of it to its xingjaing province, with
some rebellious Muslim population thus stabilising
Russian
Federation the region through industrialisation and connect-
24%
ing it to the Silk Road. To this end, Kashgar, part
of xingjaing, is one of those areas where a Special
Economic Zone is being established.
Pakistan, in the light of its long term interest
and fear of dependence on Afghanistan, may opt
Iran
16% for the Iranian pipeline to have access to reliable
gas supply and earn some money in transit.
Besides this, the Iran-Pakistan gas pipeline
will give the two countries cover to suppress the
people of Balochistan, who have roots in and
pipelines. Sources in Afghanistan’s south have disputes with both countries. TAPI will collapse in
on numerous occasions reported that senior such a situation where all the major regional ac-
members of Sepah Passdaran (The Iranian Revo- tors excluding India team up together against it.
lutionary Guards) have visited some provinces Such an event will rob Afghanistan of the chance
along planned pipeline routes. There has been for the project to contribute to the country’s sta-
evidence of Iranian weapons seized by interna- bility through investment.
tional militaries based in Afghanistan, though it
- At stake
ed countries are ubiquitous. Afghan hydrocarbon experts from the 1980s
China, in its aggressive campaign to reach pointed out that Afghanistan’s northern geology
132 ASIA p Pawn or potential queen?
Turkmenistan. No doubt, the discovery of the by Canadian energy economist John Foster
gas in Afghan-Tajik Basin will rekindle hopes of writing in the Energy Security Journal.
stability and security once again. Some sources,
on condition of anonymity, said that the USGS Pawn’s promotion?
had estimated gas reserves in Afghanistan’s Pinning so much hope in TAPI without under-
north to be 25 trillion cubic feet. Moreover, the standing the regional giants which will at all costs
country may be home to reserves in Katawaz seek to secure their interest is a giant misstep
basin in the southeast. and a potential tragedy for Afghanistan. Though
With these kinds of deposits, Afghanistan -
can turn into a regional gas-bazaar and qualify to tries at the moment, the shifting geopolitics may
join the elite gas suppliers club. Chevron’s inter- take regional actors away from the project.
est in the Afghan-Tajik basin and China’s Nation- A more prudent path for Afghanistan would be
al Petroleum Company’s eye-catching contractual to explore its own gas to supply to its households
terms in favour of the Afghanistan government and industries and encourage indigenous invest-
for the Amu Darya oil deposits in the north of the ment. Gas can also be used for electricity genera-
country are clear signals that there is more to tion and presents tremendous export potential.
invest in a mere 87 million barrels of oil. Some Afghanistan than building its own mines and under-
sources say Tajikistan has already been using standing its neighbours’ strategies, which is critical
diplomatic channels to bid for Afghan gas. to avoid being trapped into their game plans.
Failure of TAPI will amount to US failure in
Afghanistan. One of the reasons for the US to
put boots on the ground was to ensure the TAPI
pipeline was made possible; US-based Unocal
was competing with Bridas, a Brazil-based oil
on
ad
loration’s
old mine
136 ASIA p Metals Exploration
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 137
“This project is on the cusp of being developed, there have been very few
new programmes that have actually been financed so we are a stand out
and we are going to kick that goal” – Ian Holzberger
Metals exploRation is going full steam ahead “Because we are using biological leaching the
into the construction phase of development, process becomes hydrometallurgical…lab work
suggests it will work for us to recover that moly, but
pushed until a full funding package is in place, because it is a novel process, we don’t want to com-
which Ian Holzberger, chairman and project direc- promise the main game, which is gold,” he says.
tor at Metals Exploration, expects to announce in Biox, the biological leaching process tech-
the coming weeks. nology that Metals Exploration will be using
“As soon as the drawdown is available on at its plant, is the intellectual property of a
subsidiary of South African miner Gold Fields
into full construction and the trigger on that is and is one of the many partners the company
really the construction of the processing plant, is working with as it upgrades basic infrastruc-
which is ready to go and we have already started tures in its operating region.
construction for the plant pad,” Holzberger says.
Feasibility and optimisation studies show an Improvement partners
average annual production of 96,700 ounces -
(oz) of gold over an initial mine life of 10.3 years provement in the local area, adds Holzberger.
at an average operating cost of $477/oz while “While there are roads and power already
the internal rate of return is expected to be 42 available, it needs to be upgraded and part of our
per cent at a $1,500/oz gold price. development plan is leveraging off that to improve
The area is also home to some 25 million it. This will cut our costs but also it will improve local
pounds (Mlb) of molybdenum, which Holzberger conditions so it is a double win for us,” he says.
explains could be a future credit story though the Although Leighton is the primary contractor on
company’s key focus is getting gold into produc- site tasked with building the processing plant, most
additional contractors are from the Philippines.
138 ASIA p Metals Exploration
METALS ExPLORATION BAGGED THREE OF THE MOST COVETED AWARDS IN THE MINING INDUSTRY INCLUDING 2011 PRESIDENTIAL MINE
GXD was established in the Philippines to provide services to the Construction, Geological,
Exploration and Mining industries. Since the conception of the company we have emphasized
delivering quality and reliable services and materials to the industry. All the products and
services that we provide have been the best available in the market and supplied directly to
our clients from the manufacturer with the necessary backup the industry demands.
Broker’s view
At its most recent AGM, the company lost one
of its non-executive directors, Jonathan Beard-
sworth, who did not stand for re-election. Though
this was unexpected, observers note that it may
not be too surprising since Beardsworth had a
to early development.
“Block 188 now looks much nearer to de-
velopment than we previously thought. Investor
attention had been on Ghana, where [Clontarf] is
-
cus is now on Peru. The securing of a JV or strate-
gic partner on either Block 188 or 183 could lead
AUGUST 2011 pThe African Business Journal 141
news in ReView
By the middle of 2013, the miner aims to said the offer had come “from one of the Russian
triple its current Pilbara production capacity of 55 state companies”, but would not specify whether it
million tonnes. was Rosneft or Gazprom.
The equal joint venture with Russian oli-
Bp consideRs oFFeR FoR Russian JV stake garch consortium Alfa Access Renova, led by
iRJ - June 1 - BP will be pursuing a potential sale of -
its shareholding in TNK-BP after receiving unso- tuated by Fridman’s recent resignation as chief
licited indications of interest. The company added executive of TNK-BP.
that there is no guarantee a transaction will take TNK-BP was formed in 2003 as the result of
place. the merger of the oil and gas assets of the two
The Financial Times said a sale could fetch up partners. It is vertically integrated with a diversi-
to $30 billion and cited an unnamed source who -
AUGUST 2011 pThe African Business Journal 143
sia and Ukraine and international interests in of the UK…Today’s deal between EnQuest and
Brazil, Venezuela and Vietnam. KUFPEC, bringing up to £300m of foreign invest-
ment into the North Sea, proves that the UK
kuwait to inVest $500M in uk noRth sea oil Field continental shelf remains an attractive prospect.
iRJ - May 30 - Enquest will farm out a 35 per The Government will continue working with the
- industry in the North Sea to get the most of what
opments to Kuwait Foreign Petroleum Explora- is a huge national asset.”
tion Company (KUFPEC) for a total investment of
$500 million in cash. anGloGold takes Full owneRship oF BRazilian
Mine FoR $220M
iRJ - May 29 - AngloGold Ashanti is set to acquire
UK North Sea. Alma was previously abandoned the remaining 50 per cent stake in Mineracao
because of high water content of output. First Serra Grande in Brazil from Kinross for $220 mil-
production is anticipated in the fourth quarter of lion. The transaction will be funded from existing
2013, with peak gross production of over 20,000 cash reserves and debt facilities.
To date, the Serra Grande mine has pro-
million barrels of oil. duced 3.4 million ounces (Moz) of gold. Last
According to the Financial Times, Amjad year, the mine produced 134,000 ounces of gold
Bseisu, chief executive of EnQuest, said the talks at a cash cost of $767 per ounce. Over the past
began last year with partners over investing in the four years, more than 1Moz of mineral resources
$1bn project but were held up until tax breaks have been added.
Commenting on the deal, chief secretary gives us greater exposure to Brazil, where we’ve
to the Treasury, Danny Alexander, said: “This is
good news for North East Scotland and the whole as well as our reserve and resource base,” Mark
144 SECTION p Title
news in ReView
Cutifani, AngloGold Ashanti’s chief executive, said.
“We see long-term, lower risk, potential from Serra
Grande, which is a key component of our strategy
to grow the contribution from the Americas.”
The operation comprises three under-
ground mines and one open pit mine as well
as a processing plant.
news in ReView
ing agreement, which is for seven years at a bor-
half of 2013. Glencore’s plans have led it to also rowing cost of 11 per cent, will be in place by the
acquire around $140 million of shareholder debts end of July 2012.
as part of the deal. “The mine plan shows a deeper level of min-
The announcement comes in the midst of the ing and longer development time – this is posi-
much anticipated $90 billion “GlenStrata merger tively offset by block cave economics with longer
of equals”. block cave life and higher grades providing for
According to the Financial Times commodities
note, long only funds have been spotted buy- adding that the technical mining and processing
plant have been subject to in-depth review by SRK
per cent on May 24 when some 36 per cent of Consulting.
shares come off lock-up. The implication is that Maiden run of mine production is expected at
index linked tracker funds will be buying the Swiss around 8 thousand carats (kcts) supplemented by
trader as it gains a greater weighting in the FTSE, tailings reprocessing that is expected to produce
putting the company in a good position to see the around 15kcts in 2012 and 30kcts in 2013. Lace
merger voted through. will reach full production by mid-2014 producing
300kcts from both tailing and run of mine produc-
idc Backs diaMondcoRp’s lace Mine with $33.6M tion, according to Northland Capital Partners.
loan DiamondCorp owns 74 per cent of the Lace
iRJ - May 21 - DiamondCorp has signed a term diamond mine with the remaining 26 per cent
sheet with South African state-backed Industrial held by the company’s Black Economic Empower-
Development Corporation (IDC) for a $33.6 mil- ment (BEE) partners.
lion loan to develop the Lace Mine in Free State DiamondCorp CEO, Paul Loudon said: “The
province. key driver for management in seeking funding for
-
AUGUST 2011 pThe African Business Journal 147
news in ReView
NSL expects to begin gradually ramping up
production and sales tonnages towards Phase
1’s target production capacity of 200,000 tonnes
per annum (t/y) in the third quarter.
The dry separation circuit is expected to un-
showed YPF’s production declining 60 per cent, about upstream discovery and development –
petroleum and gas reserves down to one third
of peak levels, imports up by 100 per cent from But the real shame was that the one thing that
the company should have had expertise in, the
down from their peak - nobody was very happy. downstream sector, was left neglected.
But the real damage came when it became Storage capacity, for example, was not prop-
widely known that Repsol intended to repatriate erly attended to which left supply vulnerable to
-
its stake. Until that moment, Repsol had time tions. Gas-oil during planting and harvest sea-
and dialogue with the government. sons became scarce causing inconveniences
In short, Repsol didn’t serve its customers to farmers. Tourist seasons and long weekends
properly. Which is why when Argentine president proved to be a challenge for car travellers in
Cristina Fernandez declared the government’s search of petrol. The manufacturing industry
intention to renationalise, no one shed a tear for consistently complained about the petroleum
the Spanish parent. If anything, there was some and gas industry due to its continued fuel short-
concern that the cure was no better than the ages. Moreover, households have priority for fuel
illness and may negatively impact foreign direct delivery during shortages, making matters worse
investment into the country. Though this seems for manufacturers.
unlikely as oil majors compete to pick up YPF Storage facilities should have included tank
operations and the Argentine government sends
clear signals that it is willing to talk. tank capacity at service stations. Doubling ca-
pacity at those points to account for two weeks
Expectations management of consumption would have mitigated the risks of
Was it possible for Repsol to better manage and frequent strike action by truckers.
hedge its risks? Yes. Marketing innovation was non-existent other
The company had plenty of chances and no re- than for petrol itself. Repsol was reluctant to create
strictions making its mistakes conspicuously worse. or participate in a possible futures market, a move
There was little evidence that Repsol cared that would have been welcomed by consumers and
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 153
reduced YPF’s exposure to commodity price risk. condition. It was absolutely dysfunctional.
On top of that, human resources were not A parallel can be drawn to a similar case of
valued nor were employees promoted properly. water distribution and sewage services run by
Segregation of YPF staff from Repsol was pain- Aguas Argentinas - a consortium led by Suez,
fully obvious, even as the parent needed the best Aguas de Barcelona, Vivendi and AWG Group
of local ingenuity to run its operations. That local - which lost its contracts for mismanagement
under similar circumstances.
helped Repsol’s endeavour in Alaska, among Still, it remains to be seen whether this
nationalisation leads to a decrease in foreign
The company’s interaction with local com-
munities, including provincial governments and
municipalities, was also defective. One wonders which provide satisfactory services, could ever be
what sort of rationale was behind expensive put in such odious position.
company initiatives such as promoting football
clubs when investment was better spent in com- westsideconsultants.coM
munities to boost jobs and fund schools and
hospitals.
Ripple effect?
Lack of allocated capital and sloppy manage-
ment for the biggest Argentine oil and gas com-
pany was bound to lead to problems. Risk man-
agement presupposes essentially two things: -
that there should be enough capital to foot the
bill for a viable functional project and that an-
other tranche of equity should be available for
possible volatility.
154 LATIN AMERICA p Leni Gas and Oil
n
m
ad
WORKOVER AT AYOLUENGO
156 LATIN AMERICA p Leni Gas and Oil
london-headquaRteRed leni Gas and Oil (LGO) international areas and on top of that, there is
- no obvious follow-on business,” says Ritson.
velops those reserves with new technologies and
investment. Its strategic assets are the Ayoluen- by interest from multiple bidders when the asset
went on sale. Ritson downplays the impact of
the country, and it has interests in the Caribbean the eurozone crisis in the company’s divestment
island nation of Trinidad. decision, saying that he has not seen interest
But the company’s asset base is about to for European primary production assets wane;
change, explains Neil Ritson, chief executive at though raising capital to develop them will likely
LGO, as it divests the Spanish assets to further
Out of the submitted proposals, one bid-
der was given exclusivity until the end of May to
Switching plays
First developed by Chevron in the 1960s, the lipped about any further details as discussions
are ongoing, but he does add that should talks
was acquired by LGO, a move that doubled pro- stall, other bidders are waiting on the sidelines.
duction which peaking at over 300 barrels of oil “We should conclude something in the third
quarter, but if the current market does not sup-
have over 100 million barrels (mmbbls) original port the kind of price we want then we will keep
oil in place. Unfortunately, the economics showed
that between 300 to 400 per cent increase was for us every month,” Ritson says.
necessary to create the necessary internal cash
Trinidad opportunity
The operational cost structure, explains Rit- So why sell now? In the continuing turbulence of
son, is not particularly favourable. capital markets – particularly for small caps with
“Equipment needs to be imported across high capital expenditure projects – LGO wants to
Europe, there is no indigenous service sector, take advantage of what the company’s manage-
while labour, equipment and transportation costs ment believes is an early mover advantage for the
are on the high end compared to the US or other redevelopment of the onshore Trinidad oil play.
158 LATIN AMERICA p Leni Gas and Oil
In November, the £10 million market cap of the capital markets altogether and this will
producer raised £1.5 million for working capi- mean using its asset base in order to pursue
tal purposes, which adds to a £5 million line of growth opportunities.
equity to draw down from as well as a revenue In 2008, LGO acquired a 50 per cent in-
base from an annual 65 thousand barrels of oil
(mbbls) across its operations. The company’s western Trinidad operated by local oil and gas
aim at this point, explains Ritson, is to stay out company, Primera. Current daily production for
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 159
non-coRe opeRations
Multiple leases in the shallow Gulf of supplier, but also buyer of product.
Mexico (7.25 per cent interest) -
Total 2010 production net to LGO’s interest -
was 6,617 barrels of oil and 37.8 million
ply at the moment and that is something the
standard cubic feet of gas (12,913 barrels of
government is keen to address, it is looking to
oil equivalent). Additional potential exists
at Eugene Island to recomplete existing attract inward investment from companies such
wells or to sidetrack wells to undepleted as ourselves to raise production levels. They
zones. LGO and its partners are actively are currently importing crude in order to meet
studying these options.
Ca
st
16
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 163
latin aMeRica
abral Resources
tRike when iRon is hot
62
Hot on the heels of signing agreements with the Bahia state government,
Cabral Resources has begun a maiden resource drilling programme at its
Brazilian magnetite tenements.
164 LATIN AMERICA p Cabral Resources
www.5aconsultoria.com.br
phone: 55-71-3033-8680 | contato@5aconsultoria.com.br CONSULTORES & ASSOCIADOS
Salvador/Bahia/Brazil
“In our region, we have subsistence farming network” for offtake agreements, joint venture
and we are very conscious of having a good rela- partners, infrastructure solutions, rolling stock
tionship with local landowners. We employ them in and locomotives and project funding alternatives.
That contact network is fomented by James
with communities in terms of having open ses- Li, who is employed by Cabral. A metallurgist by
sions and keeping regular dialogue. Locals under- background, Li has strong relationships with steel
stand the mining industry well, some operations in
the area have been running for 70 years…and as banks and other state-owned enterprises that can
we move to construction and operating phases we be tapped into towards developing the project.
will certainly look to training and technology for lo- China is not only a partner, but also a
cal talent in order to achieve our objectives as well target customer.
as those of the state government,” he says. “We will be looking to our Chinese friends for
In terms of overseas partners, Cabral has project partnerships and infrastructure solutions,
formed a “unique and established Chinese contact so it makes sense to look at offtake agreements
168 LATIN AMERICA p Cabral Resources
austRalian-lataM inVestMent in the spotliGht
for allocations signed.” cost for your clients. With high technical and management
capacity performed by qualified professionals, the Topographic
has an objective and bold view, always focused on customer
satisfaction.
170 Susta
news
Unprecedented levels of civil society -
representatives have flooded into Brazil for view of the progress the mining sector has made
Rio+20, the majority of which are from the since companies joined NGOs in calling for the
developing world for the first time. Mining, Minerals and Sustainable Development
(MMSD) initiative.
iRJ takes a look at global developments pushing “The 2002 MMSD report was a game-chang-
sustainability into the headlines. -
utives committed to act to maximise their sec-
Large miners lead way on sustainability tor’s contribution to sustainable development,
and they adopted the MMSD agenda as a robust
IRJ - June 8 - The world’s biggest mining companies and credible way to do this. Ten years on, how-
have made major improvements in environmental ever, the results are mixed and new challenges
policies though as a whole the industry continues have emerged.”
-
Buxton, author of a report from the International ments are reasserting control over their natural
Institute for Environment and Development. resources, they lack the capacity to ensure that
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 171
ainability
s in ReView
mining contributes to sustainable development. dumping toxic water in the rainforest.
Buxton’s report also states that the Interna-
tional Council on Mining and Metals – an umbrella indigenous groups in Ecuador and approximately
organisation of leading companies such as Rio 70 farmer communities who want Chevron to pay
Tinto and Anglo American - has succeeded in imple- the judgment imposed by an Ecuador trial court
menting many of MMSD’s recommendations for
industry. But complementary measures proposed Ecuador’s court of appeals in January. In total,
for governments, the small scale mining sector and the long-standing case spans 19 years.
communities have not matched this success. Canadian lawyer Alan Lenczner, who will be
representing the Amazon communities, said the
Ecuadorian coalition hits Chevron with
$18bn lawsuit in Canada Ontario is targeting Chevron and various subsidiar-
“I am honoured to have been asked by the company will vigorously defend against any
indigenous people of Ecuador to correct a histor- enforcement action.
ic injustice visited upon them by Chevron,” said “Chevron is defending itself against false al-
Lenczner, who visited Ecuador and reviewed the legations that it is responsible for alleged environ-
extensive trial and appellate records of the case, mental and social harms in the Oriente region of
which exceed 250,000 pages. Ecuador. Chevron never conducted oil production
“Chevron fought for nine years to move the operations in Ecuador, and its subsidiary Texaco
trial from the United States to Ecuador, and then Petroleum (TexPet) fully remediated its share of
had a full opportunity for eight years to defend environmental impacts arising from oil production
itself in Ecuador,” Lenczner added. “This is a le- operations, before leaving Ecuador in 1992,
gitimate judgment and I believe Canadian courts
will recognise it and enforce it as such.” all agencies of the Ecuadorian government
In response to the media reports, Chevron responsible for oversight, TexPet received a
said that the Ecuador judgment is a product complete release from Ecuador’s national,
of bribery, fraud, is illegitimate and that the provincial, and municipal governments that
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 173
extinguished all claims before Chevron ac- the bank’s annual meeting taking place in Lon-
don May 18 to 19 amid criticisms of its high level
evidence exonerates Chevron and proves that of fossil fuel investment.
The announcement outlines new funding
to human health or the environment,” the oil for projects worth up to €25 billion over the next
major said in a released statement. three years that reduce energy waste and green-
The Amazon Defense Coalition says that house gas emissions. The bank is aiming to pro-
Chevron is using the “fraud” charge as a ruse vide €4.5 to €6.5 billion out of its own coffers.
to try to block enforcement of the judgment The EBRD was founded in response to the col-
and to distract attention from the overwhelming lapse of the Berlin Wall and is owned by 63 coun-
evidence of its historic misconduct. The Ecua- tries as well as the European Union and the Euro-
dorian state-backed NGO noted that Chevron’s pean Investment Bank. It supports projects in 29
countries from Central Europe to Central Asia.
when compared to BP’s disaster in the Mexican And as government budgets get slashed
Gulf in 2010. BP estimated the accidental leak across Europe in the middle of ongoing currency
of 4.9 million barrels of crude oil would cost the
oil major $37.3 billion. By comparison, Chevron
intentionally dumped 16 billion gallons of toxic -
produced water in Ecuador containing far more tor has an important role to play.
crude oil that was spilled in the Gulf, as well as “A lot of the very capital intensive measures
heavy metals and other drilling chemicals, and on climate mitigation are being postponed be-
faces less than half of BP’s costs to clean it up. cause of constraints from governments…[previ-
ously] it was all about governments and public
EBRD launches next €25bn phase of sector well, you know what is happening to bud-
sustainable energy investment gets...so the emphasis that is given to the private
sector is very important,” he said.
IRJ - May 18 - The European Bank for Reconstruc- Since its inception, SEI has adopted a
tion and Development (EBRD) launched the next business model that drives investment at
phase of its Sustainable Energy Initiative (SEI) at commercially viable projects at market rates.
174 SUSTAINABILITY NEWS IN REVIEW
furnaces. It is expected to cut energy consump- of the bank’s shareholders dealing with large
tion 15 per cent by 2015. -
Carbon markets, on the other hand, have onstrate it is delivering maximum value,” he said.
dropped down the agenda.
“The market mechanism was supposed million and invested over €9 billion in 380 proj-
to send a carbon price signal, at this stage it ects of which 29 per cent were sustainable
is not…we obviously feel we need to try and energy initiatives.
continue supporting this approach because it
is an approach that does have a benefit, but
at this point we may be at the low end of the
cycle on it,” he said.
Speaking at the opening session of the board
-
ister, congratulated the EBRD on its work.
“The EBRD can help expand new markets
and leverage private investment and with many
176 US, CANADA AND AUSTRALIA METALS AND MINING p Riversdale Resources
176 RiVeRsda
Alaskan coal p
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 177
us, canada and austRalia Metals and MininG
ale ResouRces
play
178 US, CANADA AND AUSTRALIA METALS AND MINING p Riversdale Resources
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 179
Change to Affordable
On-site Data
Weatherford slimline logging services help you extract more value
from coal, minerals and unconventional hydrocarbon resources
Weatherford has a full suite of specialized tools and experienced logging personnel to acquire
high-quality logging data from small-diameter holes in subterranean mines and vertical to
high-angle boreholes.
Technologies
Applications
Borehole diameters
Drilling
Put our 30-plus years of mining experience and Tactical Technology™ to work for you. Contact
your Weatherford logging services representative or visit us at weatherford.com/slimline.
Openhole
Slimline
The change will do you good
Completion
Production
Intervention weatherford.com
182 US, CANADA AND AUSTRALIA METALS AND MINING p Riversdale Resources
the state and through Anchorage, the biggest city legislation in order to generate funds to support
in Alaska with a population of about 300,000 and mental health programmes.
connects with Chickaloon. Riversdale believes the Riversdale has a 10-year lease with exten-
Port Authority is targeting between 2 and 3 million sion by production and exclusive rights to coal
tonnes per year (Mt/y) of coal exports from existing in a US$3million deal. In addition, royalties are
infrastructure and rail and dock upgrades are being payable to AMHT with no additional state royal-
considered for the future. ties payable, though this does not reduce Rivers-
The Chickaloon region’s coal is bounded by dale’s requirements to comply with the Depart-
two river systems, the Chickaloon and King rivers, ment of Natural Resources or other regulations.
and the land is amenable to a number of open pit “The relationship with AMHT is a unique
and underground development. Riversdale has arrangement and from our perspective a very
acquired about 40.5km2 of land in the Matanuska satisfying one. Every dollar that we spend in
valley, leased from the Alaska Mental Health Trust acquiring the land lease and in paying royalties
(AMHT), which was awarded the land as part of
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 183
11401 Olive Lane, Anchorage, Alaska holes into sections right through that full thick-
907-522-4664 www.alaskaearthsciences.com
ness of the coal seams and understand exactly
how thick those seams are and how the quality
and Innovation in the Queensland Government’s varies between them,” Dann says.
Mining and Energy agency and, prior to that, was
the Latin America, Philippine and USA exploration Global and local partners
- As the company moves towards development,
ed – part of the former Hanson Plc group) . Dann explains that Riversdale is trying to com-
“There are a series of igneous intrusions in the bine teams of local Alaskan knowledge and expe-
area and that appears to be the primary reason rience with the more global technical capability
of groups it has worked with in the past.
we take some of the historical coking coal analyses Riversdale is working with Anchorage-based
Alaska Earth Sciences to tap into the group’s coal
for coking coal, we are very happy with those re- expertise and experience in community engage-
sults. It certainly gives us the indication and encour- ment. Overseeing the environmental programme is
agement that we have the potential for a very good
quality coking coal,” Dann says. has also contracted SRK Consulting for the water
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 185
New Millennium
1
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 187
us, canada and austRalia Metals and MininG
FRoM its BeGinninGs as a capital pool company capital costs. When the DSO project goes into
in 2003, New Millennium Iron has grown into an production by the end of the year, New Millen-
emerging producer controlling one of the largest iron nium will become an operating company with
ore resources in the world – the Millennium range,
a 210km long taconite belt in eastern Canada. In 2013, the company is targeting 2 million
The company’s direct shipping ore (DSO) tonnes (Mt) in production, ramping up to full
project in partnership with Indian steelmaking capacity of 4.2 million tonnes per year (Mt/y)
- in 2014. Tata Steel Europe, which has plants
cause of its smaller scale and relatively lower in the UK and Netherlands, has committed to
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 189
7JTJUPVSXFCTJUF
www.sauvageau.qc.ca
"VUPTt$BNJPOTt7ÏIJDVMFTTQÏDJBMJTÏT
$BSTt5SVDLTt4QFDJBMJ[FEWFIJDMFT
1.866.SAUVAGEAU.728.8243
Across Quebec, one near you
8FIBWFUIFSJHIUUSBOTQPSUTPMVUJPOGPSZPV
521 Côte Joyeuse, St-Raymond, Québec, Canada, G3L 4A9
www.sauvageau.qc.ca
BEI Professionals can provide services in the following areas: t1SFPQFSBUJPOBMUFTUJOH
DPNNJTTJPOJOHBOE4UBSUVQ
t1SPKFDU.BOBHFNFOUBOE$POUSPMT t1PTUPQFSBUJPOBMUSPVCMFTIPPUJOHBOEUSBJOJOHDBQBCJMJUJFT
t1SFGFBTJCJMJUZ
#BTJDBOE%FUBJMFE%FTJHOPGQJQFMJOFT t-BCPSBUPSZ5FTUJOH
t#BOLBCMF'FBTJCJMJUZ4UVEJFT t'JFME&OHJOFFSJOH4FSWJDFTGPS
t3PVUF*EFOUJmDBUJPO
1MBOOJOH P(SFFOmFMEQMBOOJOHBOEEFTJHO
t5SBEFPGG4UVEJFTBQQMZJOHBMUFSOBUJWFDPTUFGGFDUJWFNFUIPET P&YJTUJOHPQFSBUJPOT
t0QFSBUJOH.BOVBMT P$POTUSVDUJPO
P#SPXOmFMENPEJmDBUJPOTBOEJOTUBMMBUJPOT
#3"44&OHJOFFSJOH*OUFSOBUJPOBM]$BNJOP3BNPO
4VJUF
4BO3BNPO
$"
64"5'XXXCSBTTFOHJOFFSJOHDPN
Proudly
supplying NML
with our leading
pelletizing plant
technology.
which will last for upwards Minerals Canada (Tata Steel 80 per cent: New
world’s iron ore resources historic iron ore producing region of Northern
are being depleted at a Quebec and Labrador and had been previously op-
considerable rate” erational until the market lost its appetite for lower
quality ore being produced by the operation.
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 193
Dean Journeaux, chief executive of New Mil- meeting today’s market requirements for quali-
lennium, gets his share of questions on this point ty, and of course, the price of iron ore has gone
– what makes him think he can do better today? up quite a bit since 1982,” Journeaux says.
“The operator closed down the mine in
1982 because for one, the market was bad, C$300 million of the capital costs, with New Mil-
but also, the product was not treated, not up- lennium responsible for 20 per cent of the excess.
graded, running around 58 or 59 per cent iron.
We are upgrading the run of mine ore grade Human Resources
to a 64.5 per cent iron, in other words, we are The DSO project is just the beginning for the
194 US, CANADA AND AUSTRALIA METALS AND MINING p New Millennium Iron
Indian steelmaker in Canada, and it will be using develop either one or both properties, with New
the experience as a tester before considering Millennium free to decide what to do should Tata
not go ahead.
comes with estimated capital costs of between LabMag is located about 30km northwest
$4.4 and $5 billion dollars for each of the two of the town of Schefferville, Quebec. About
deposits targeted for development. 1,800 First Nations people live in the surround-
A $50 million feasibility study, expected to be ing area, a sizeable population that Journeaux
completed by the end of the year, is underway for says can go far in meeting the projects’ human
- resources needs in the future – the plant op-
Mag in Western Labrador. Tata has an option to erators, truck drivers, mechanics, electricians
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 195
Mineral Processing
HPGR, Crushing, Grinding, Classification, Flotation
Bench Scale and Pilot Scale facilities
Pyrometallurgy
Blast Furnace Pellet Production and Testing
Sinter Pot Simulator
Pot Grate Simulator
DRI Pellet Production and Testing
Midrex and HYL DRI Testing
Bench Scale and Pilot Scale Facilities
and other supervisory, management and ad- “I get asked if I am worried about the future
ministrative personnel who will be required to labour supply considering the global skills shortage
maintain operations. and I guess we are, but on the other hand, we have
On the DSO project, the JV, Tata Steel Miner- this tremendous asset in the surrounding communi-
ties and if we can encourage people through educa-
with First Nations groups. Apart from employ- tion and through other means, we hope it will bring
ment, the company is providing training and has them into the employment pool,” says Journeaux.
donated $50,000 to run a bursary programme For now, the company estimates that at least
at the region’s secondary schools. 1,000 people will be needed to operate each of
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 197
t e Sit es
Re m o
For more information on how Sodexo Remote Sites can provide a complete on-site service
solution for your remote site, contact Jerome Texier, Vice President Sodexo Remote Sites
at 514-866-7070 ext. 249 or email Jerome at Jerome.Texier@sodexo.com.
198 US, CANADA AND AUSTRALIA METALS AND MINING p New Millennium Iron
“I get asked if I am wo
labour supply conside
shortage and I guess w
hand, we have this tre
surrounding commun
Taconite technology
LabMag is owned 80 per cent by New Millennium
and 20 per cent by Naskapi Nation of Kawawa-
chikamach through an initial investment, one of
via 600km ferroduct to Port of Sept-Iles. average grade of 30.3 per cent Fe
1,437Mt of inferred resources at an
average grade of 30.9 per cent Fe
Lavalin as the study manager for the feasibility
study and has also contracted specialist German dso pRoJect contains:
- 64.1Mt of proven and probable mineral
tung as its primary metallurgical process consul- reserves at an average grade of 58.8
per cent Fe
tant while Midland Research Centre, in Minnesota,
21.0Mt of measured and indicated
provides crushing, blending and characterisation
mineral resources at an average grade
work of samples. of 59.2 per cent Fe
Journeaux explains that the process to 10.3Mt of inferred resources at an
mine and process Taconite was developed in average grade of 58.3 per cent Fe
Between 25 and 30 million tonnes
Minnesota because the US state is home to
of historical resources that are not
the massive Mesabi iron range. Aside from
currently in compliance with NI 43-101
200 US, CANADA AND AUSTRALIA METALS AND MINING p New Millennium Iron
MAC 50-12
5001, Trans-Canada Highway Toll free: 800.363.6785
Pointe-Claire, Québec, www.hewitt.ca
Canada, H9R 1B8 mining.cat.com
Midland Research Centre, other Minnesota- with 360,000 to 400,000 tonnes of capacity.
based specialists have been brought on board. This last February, those development plans
Barr Engineering will be doing work on the received a boost when the Government of
concentrator and the company uses the Univer-
sity of Minnesota Coleraine Minerals Research million, or 25 per cent of the project costs,
laboratory facility. towards construction.
As with the DSO project, Tata Steel Europe “[The deep water dock] is under detailed
is expected to be a major offtake customer planning right now…we need those larger ves-
for the Taconite project as well, taking at least sels to lower freight costs so this is an impor-
half of the product. The rest will be left for the tant factor in our development plan,” he says.
open market.
For that product to reach Asian markets, how- Strategic board
ever, the Port of Sept Iles will need an upgrade In furthering that development plan towards
for a deep water dock capable of handling ships production, New Millennium’s board represents
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 201
INNU MUNICIPAL
a broad range of backgrounds with experience
in mining, accounting, business and marketing,
geology, strategy and most recently, commanding
the Canadian Armed Forces.
General (Ret.) Rick Hillier, former Chief of the
Defence Staff, the highest rank of the Canadian
Forces, joined New Millennium’s board in 2011.
If that seems surprising, consider this, what iron
ore project couldn’t use a leader with a steady
resolve who doesn’t waver under pressure?
“He’s managed large groups of people and
facilities, the logistics side, but a good part of
the decision was that he is a Newfoundlander.
-
ness sense, experience and who understands
202 US, CANADA AND AUSTRALIA METALS AND MINING p New Millennium Iron
“New Millennium is a
company on the TSX
have these very large
it becoming another
which had eight or s
at one time in differe
www.nMliRon.coM
Forg
FoR
204
us, canada and austRalia Metals and MininG
ge Resources
RGinG ahead
4
With much of the pre-development legwork already completed
at its recently acquired flagship Balla Balla project in Western
Australia, Forge Resources has begun marketing a magnetite iron
ore product as the company seeks to secure project financing.
206 US, CANADA AND AUSTRALIA METALS AND MINING p Forge Resources
Balla Balla is a large-scale, JORC compliant tonnes per year (Mt/y) of shipping capacity at
titanium-vanadium-magnetite resource close to the Port Hedland.
James explains that Forge bought the Balla
granted mining tenements. Major approvals such as Balla project from Atlas Iron for A$39.5 million,
environment, native title, water access and condi- which was over $100 million less than Atlas Iron
paid approximately 18 month prior to acquire
feasibility study (DFS) was completed in early 2010. Aurox Resources, which then owned the project.
Atlas kept the 10Mt/y Port Hedland capacity for
robust as a magnetite only project. However what its own DSO hematite iron ore operations.
is attractive about Balla Balla is the additional “Without the Port Hedland capacity we knew
vanadium and titanium contained within the an alternative transport route would be required
resource, which we view as an embedded option to get to export. We were already looking at
for the company,” says Matthew James, manag- trans-shipping as an option, which we think is
ing director of Forge. feasible particularly as a trans-shipment opera-
Initially, the vanadium which is contained tor is already in northern Western Australia. In
within the magnetite concentrate that will be sold places like South America and Indonesia there
to steel mills, most likely in China, will act as a is quite a bit of this being done, where the mate-
free credit for those mills that have the technol- rial is barged from the coast to a ship anchored
ogy to separate the vanadium, he explains. offshore” says James.
“This vanadium credit allows steel mills to lower A back up plan includes negotiating capacity
their net cost of production. In addition we will be at Anketell Port since the Balla Balla project is
getting a titanium revenue stream from an ilmenite situated just 100km east of the area and Forge
by-product produced alongside the magnetite. In has been short-listed for consideration, but the
the longer term we aim to extract the full value of company’s main focus is on trans-shipment.
both the titanium and the vanadium,” says James. “Our primary plan is the trans-shipment op-
The Firm encompasses: We provide high level services in the following areas:
t5IJSUZTJYZFBSTFYQFSJFODFJOUIFNJOFSBMT t1SPKFDU.BOBHFNFOUoTNBMMUPNVMUJTDBMFQSPKFDUT
FYQMPSBUJPOJOEVTUSZ t*OEFQFOEFOUUFDIOJDBMSFWJFXTBOESFQPSUTGPS*10T
ti$PNQFUFOUQFSTPOwo+03$$PEF t*10MJTUJOHQSPDFTT
t&YFDVUJWFSPMFTJO"49MJTUFEDPNQBOJFT t1SPQFSUZSFWJFXBOETFMFDUJPO
t.VMUJDPNNPEJUZFYQPTVSF t(SBTTSPPUTFYQMPSBUJPOUISPVHIUPQSFNJOFEFWFMPQNFOU
t$PVOUSZFYQFSJFODFJODMVEFT"VTUSBMJB
1BQVB/FX t1SFDJPVTBOECBTFNFUBMT
(VJOFB
4PMPNPO*TMBOET
/FX;FBMBOEBOE64 "MBTLB
t*OEVTUSJBMNJOFSBMT
BOENPSFSFDFOUMZ$FOUSBM"TJBBOEOPSUIFSO&VSPQF t+PJOU7FOUVSFBHSFFNFOUT
t5FOFNFOU.BOBHFNFOU
t(PWFSONFOUMJBJTPO
t&OWJSPONFOUBMJNQBDUBOEQMBOOJOHQSPDFTTFT
6OJU
4PNFSTFU"WFOVF/BSFMMBO/48"VTUSBMJB
5FMF]'BY]FYQMPSFS!IBSWFTUFYQMPSBUJPODPNBV]XXXIBSWFTUFYQMPSBUJPODPNBV
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 209
CSM
QA
HH if req
Ink/s CMYK
James himself is an alumnus of Lynas as is 45 per cent Fe content, 0.62 per cent vanadium
Forge’s non-executive director, Harold Wang, an oxide and 13.8 per cent titanium oxide.
experienced resources expert who has worked There are historical offtake agreements
across China’s ferrous and non-ferrous sector as equating to 10Mt/y with two Chinese steel mills
well as in Australia. Prior to Lynas, James worked with which Forge has started initial discussions
at McKinsey & Company and Deutsche Bank, in a bid to revive the contracts.
both in London. -
ect, a company-making asset and in a relative-
ly short time-frame can be put into production
be a three-year schedule starting with 6Mt/y pro- -
duction and ramping up to 10Mt/y a year later. pany,” he adds.
Mineral reserve estimates shows proven and
probable reserves of 229 million tonnes (Mt) with FoRGeResouRces.coM.au
212 US, CANADA AND AUSTRALIA METALS AND MINING p Navarre Minerals
Navarre Minerals
GoinG BiG FoR G
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 213
us, canada and austRalia Metals and MininG
212
Gold
Australian-based explorer Navarre Minerals has achieved early
exploration success at its Tandarra Gold Prospect situated just
40km from the historic Bendigo Goldfield in Victoria.
214 US, CANADA AND AUSTRALIA METALS AND MINING p Navarre Minerals
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 215
Bendigo, which has a history of mining among city sitting over top of our project so open pit min-
its population of about 100,000 people. ing is an option,” McDermott says.
“There is access to water, people, power Aside from Tandarra and Kingston, Navarre
which passes through the western side of our is also exploring for base metals at its Black
tenement, there is a highway that goes straight Range property, which is a copper-zinc-gold 100
past and a daily train service out of Melbourne… per cent owned prospect with similar geology to
we are well situated. And we don’t have a town or Tasmania’s Mount Read Volcanics – host to large
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 219
220 Th
rev
pro
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 221
special suppleMent
In contrast to the oil and gas sector, the cies - particularly in the base metals sector both
mining sector in Australia is showing in Western Australia and Queensland and in the
conflicting signs, writes Jody Elliott, steel industry in New South Wales.
director at The Resource Channel Data coming from the exploration sector also
paints a mixed picture. Whilst Australian Bureau
at least ten major LNG/CSG projects are now -
under construction in Australia and generating ploration expenditure for 2011, closer analysis
shows that expenditure in the iron ore sector
mining industry is slightly different. rose 32.9 per cent while exploration for Nickel
Weaker commodity prices, the high Aus- and Cobalt fell 33 per cent.
tralian dollar and higher input prices, including
labour costs, appear to be having a negative In the Bureau of Resources and Energy Econom-
impact in parts of the industry and a level of cau- ics’ latest release dated March 2012 they predict;
tion is evident throughout. Australia’s resources and energy com-
National economic indicators outside the re- modity export earnings are forecast to
sources sector remain sluggish and there is still grow over the medium term to reach a
a great deal of uncertainty on the international record A$225 billion dollars in 2016-17
front especially in Europe. This is having some Despite projections of lower commodity pric-
- es over the medium term this is to be offset
ment freezes, project delays and even redundan- by substantially greater export volumes
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 223
Between now and 2016-17 export vol- on major projects mainly in Western Australia
umes are forecast to increase for iron ore and Queensland that are either underway or
(62 per cent), metallurgical coal (47 per showing strong progress towards this goal. This
cent), thermal coal (65 per cent), copper list is not in any way exhaustive, particularly
ores and concentrate (77 per cent) and when you consider there are 456 projects in the
alumina (29 per cent). Australian resource sector in the construction
pipeline with 272 of those already committed
According to the Bureau’s Professor Grafton, and/or under construction. These range from
the increase in Australia’s export volumes for major expansions like BHP Billiton’s Iron Ore to
westeRn austRalia
westeRn austRalia
Roy hill iRon oRe pRoJect low phosphorous ore bodies in Australia outside
the control of the majors and is located 105km
operators: Hancock Prospecting north-east of Newman in the Pilbara region of
Location: Chichester Ranges Western Australia.
Timeframe: Construction between mid-2011 –
The project will consist of:
planned for 2014 Mining operation for 55Mt/y hematite
Cost: Reported to be approx. A$7 billion iron ore;
Employment: During construction, the workforce Crushing, screening and processing lump
will peak at 3,500 people (with a total of 10,000 ex-
pected over the life of construction) and it will have Stockpiling and train loading;
an operational manning of over 1,600 personnel. A 370km standard gauge, single line,
Status: The Roy Hill project will be a world-class dedicated heavy-haul railway from the
iron ore mine. The deposit is the last of the large mine site to Port Hedland;
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 227
westeRn austRalia
operators:
Location: 85km south of Karratha
Timeframe: First production expected in late
2012 with a 25-year mine life
Cost: US$30 billion
Employment: More than 4,000 construction jobs
and 600 operational jobs. With commissioning
-
erational recruitment efforts.
Status: In the mine-pit, individual load tests have liner and cranes. Second magnetic separation pip-
ing and electrical installation is complete. The main
1 conveyor belt has been installed. The power e-house is ready to be energised; water cooling and
distribution system is ready to be energised. The air compressor systems have been installed and
major components of the second crusher have pump station installation is underway.
also been installed. At the power station, gas turbines 3 and 4 have
missioning. Main substation electrical testing has At the desalination plant, pressure testing and
been completed and is ready to be energised. bubble tests have been completed on the east
Major port assets including four barges, two tugs train and endurance testing has been completed
on all three intake pumps. Loop checking is
their kind in WA waters) have arrived. ongoing. Mechanical, electrical and instrumenta-
In the port area, piping and electrical installation tion installation in the west train is progressing
has been completed for building 1 of the dewa- and mechanical installation for the west train
tering plant and individual equipment testing is pre-treatment is nearing completion.
underway. Conveyor structure and mechanical Civil work has been completed for all workshops
installation has been completed at the stockyard in the mining infrastructure area and steel struc-
and belt installation is progressing. Hydro tests ture erection is underway.
have been carried out on the concentrate thick-
eners and power distribution systems have been
installed throughout the area.
230 The Resource Channel
westeRn austRalia
southeRn seawateR
desalination plant staGe 2 become fully operational ahead of schedule in
-
operators: Southern Seawater Alliance (SSWA) sioning. The SSWA is led by Spanish companies,
Location: Binningup, south of Perth Tecnicas Reunidas and Valoriza Agua. Its part-
Timeframe: 18 month construction, expected to ners are construction company, AJ Lucas and
be commissioned by 2014 engineering consultancy Worley Parsons. Tecni-
Cost: A$955 million cas Reunidas and Valoriza Agua have extensive
Employment: 600 jobs during construction, local major desalination experience and are interna-
workforce only (no camp facilities) tional multidiscipline construction companies.
Status: A Spanish-led consortium, Southern Sea- These two companies will operate and maintain
water Alliance (SSWA) will build a second desali- the full plant, which will be owned by the Water
nation plant with 100 gigalitre per year (GL/year) Corporation, for 25 years.
maximum capacity plant for the Water Corpora- SSWA plant support:
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 231
westeRn austRalia
Bhp Billiton, iRon oRe expan- associated with its expansion projects. The
sion pRoJects project, which is expected to be reviewed for full
approval in the fourth quarter of calendar year
operators: BHP Billiton 2012, has an embedded option to expand by a
Location: Pilbara further 100 Mt per year. The funds approved
Timeframe: Construction has commenced, will enable the company to progress feasibility
studies and the procurement of long lead time
Cost: Reported to be approx. A$7 billion items. It will also allow for dredging to begin,
Employment: Exact numbers unknown, but is in subject to the necessary regulatory approvals. In
the thousands for construction and operational. parallel with this work, engineering studies are
Status: BHP produces most of its iron ore underway to match mine and rail expansions to
through seven mines at three big mining hubs in the expanded port capacity.
the central and east Pilbara known as MAC, New-
man and Yandi. To expand to 220 Mt it will build -
another, Jimblebar, and to move to 350 Mt it will ment would include the proposed construction
open up four more mines: Jinidi, Marillana 1 and of a 4km jetty, a four-berth wharf, 32 kilometres
2 and Southern Flank. Since our last update, of dredged departure channel and
BHP Billiton has also bought out the equipment landside infrastructure, including stockyards and
and operators of its contractor, HWE and moved a rail spur.
to an owner-operator model.
Bhp Billiton iRon oRe expan- the structural, mechanical, piping and
Joint venture partners, RCR Tomlinson to 300t - from Port Hedland to the Yandi
and Laing O’Rourke; will design and mine site, located 140km northwest of
Australia and SKM will develop and works for BHP Billiton Iron Ore’s
deliver iron ore projects to meet the Yarnima Combined Cycle Power Station
global market demand forecast for BHP in Newman, Western Australia. The
August 2011 the contract for pre- and associated equipment. Due for
westeRn austRalia
oakaJee poRt and Rail One village will be located at the port site and the
others along the rail line. The portside construction
operators: OPR was established in September village will comprise 1,100 rooms. The rail villages
2007 to pursue a joint venture between Murchi- will vary in size from 150 to 760 rooms. All villages
son Metals and Mitsubishi Development, each of will be managed by the successful contractors in
which has a 50 per cent stake in OPR.Murchison accordance with strategies determined by OPR.
Metals. The project is now owned 100 per cent The total number of accommodation rooms will be
by Mitsubishi. determined bearing in mind project management
Location: Mid west region of Western Australia manning, workforce rosters and visitor contingen-
Timeframe: The project timetable from construc- cies.
Once the port and rail are operational, the villages
ship, takes the project out to 2014. will be decommissioned.
Cost: A$3 billion + Status: Oakajee Port and Rail (OPR) will deliver a
Employment: OPR expects to employ about 250 rail and port network business to transport iron
personnel, who will live in the region. ore from Western Australia’s mid-west region to
During construction, OPR expects the number of customers across the globe.
port and rail construction workers to reach a peak
of around 2600, comprising approximately 900 Back in 2009, OPR and the Western Australian
port area workers and just over 1,700 rail work- State Government signed an exclusive State
ers, 19 - 24 months into the construction period of Development Agreement for the development of
three years. the multi-billion dollar deepwater port at Oaka-
All construction workers will be employed by the jee, 25 km north of Geraldton and integrated rail
successful construction contractors. They will be network to service iron ore miners and other port
accommodated in single rooms with private ensuite users in the mid-west region.
facilities in up to seven construction villages.
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 235
Project planning, evaluation, engineering and design as the optimal solution to meet the gov-
regulatory approvals are well advanced. Indepen- ernment’s scoping requirements.
236 The Resource Channel
westeRn austRalia
kaRaRa iRon oRe pRoJect by 3km long and has been so far been drilled
to a depth of 300m. Karara’s open pit will be
operators: Gindalbie Metals and AnSteel (one of similar in size to the Kalgoorlie super pit once
China’s leading steel and iron ore companies) complete with a processing plant for opera-
Location: The operations, located 225km inland tions and maintainability.
from Geraldton in the mid-west region is the re- Dry stacked tailings - only one in Australia
sult of an A$2.57 billion project which has been to use this world leading technology. The
in development since early 2009 and is currently -
cant investment in water recycling capacity
Timeframe: Approaching commissioning, due at Karara, allowing the project to reduce its
September 2012 water consumption by about one-third.
Employment: Karara Mining will require a perma-
nent workforce of approximately 600 on a long- Commitment to training and education including
term basis once in full production. our University Scholarship Programme which is
Status: Karara Mining is fast approaching com- open to students in site local communities who
missioning in September this year for our 8Mt/y -
magnetite operations and already underway with al level in a mining company.
feasibility for 16Mt/y expansion.
kaRaRa iRon oRe pRoJect driven by oil and gas processing and
Downer EDI; awarded the mining set to rise by 17.1 per cent this year and
operation contract in February 15.4 in the next, while the total value of
at approximately $570 million over rise by 6.1 per cent and then 7.2.
six years, the contract is on the However, this growth could be offset
provision of drill and blast, and load Around 70 per cent of businesses
westeRn austRalia
FMG expansion pRoJect The port was designed with expansion in mind, to
allow construction to take place without interfer-
operators: Fortescue Metals ing with daily operations
Location: Pilbara
Cost: $360 million Development highlights:
Timeframe: 18 months, operational by mid-013
Employment: Unknown, but expected to be in Fortescue is undergoing a transformative
excess of 600 expansion from a 55Mt/y operation to a
Status: The existing integrated mine, rail and 155Mt/y powerhouse by June 2013.
port supply chain was constructed in less than The 155Mt/y expansion involves additional
two years and Fortescue’s board has recently infrastructure at Herb Elliott Port, 120km of
approved an US$8.4 billion expansion to their mainline rail duplication, a new 130km rail
Pilbara operations. Expansions plans are on spur from Solomon to the mainline, a 60Mt/y
schedule for completion in mid-2013. mine at Solomon and Chichester Hub de-
operations: velopment to take its combined production
located approximately 260km from Port Hedland. capacity to 90Mt/y (plus 5Mt/y from a 50/50
Christmas Creek is 50km to the east of Cloud- BC Iron Joint Venture).
break The Solomon Project is 120km to the west
Cloudbreak is a 40Mt/y mining operation, Christ- of the Chichester Hub, more than 3,000Mt
mas Creek is currently operating at approximate- have been discovered here and early ore is
ly 18Mt/y. expected later this year, with full production
The 40t axle load railway is the heaviest haul in on target for July 2013.
the world with up to seven trains a day transport Solomon is the largest iron ore start-up in
iron ore from the mines to Herb Elliott Port in Australia, showcasing innovation to execute in
Port Hedland record time and at a lower capital cost/tonne
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 239
queensland
alpha coal & keVin’s coRneR long-standing interest in the development of the
pRoJects Galilee Basin, with the parent company having
held coal exploration permits and investigated
operators: Hancock Prospecting the Alpha region since the 1970s.
Location: Galilee Basin
Timeframe: The Test Pit for Alpha Coal has been Kevin’s Corner Coal Project is adjacent to Han-
completed and construction is due to commence cock’s Alpha Coal Project and both Projects will
utilise the proposed multi-user rail and port facili-
Cost: A$7.5 billion ties. This is designed so that at a future point, it
Employment: 2,500 construction jobs and 1,600 will have the potential to transport, load and ship
permanent jobs capacity greater than the combined production
Status: Hancock Coal (HCPL), a wholly owned level of both the Kevin’s Corner and Alpha Coal
subsidiary of Hancock Prospecting, has as its Projects.
centrepiece, the development of an extensive Similarly to the Alpha Coal Project, the Kevin’s
thermal coal deposit in Queensland’s Galilee Corner deposit also lies within the late Permian
Basin, about 400km inland from the coast. The Colinlea and Bandanna Formations consisting
project will include the construction of approxi- of four main thermal coal seams suitable for the
mately 495km of rail, port facilities, mine infra- global export market. The coal seams dip gently
structure, process plant and workforce village. from east to west varying in thickness from 5 to
Adjacent to Alpha Coal, the Kevin’s Corner Proj- 8m, enabling high production open-cut mining
ect is a recognised thermal coal deposit within and underground longwall mining.
the Galilee Basin. This deposit contains very Exploration to date has concentrated on the coal
large resources of thermal coal in a premium reserves with the best export marketability, with
location of the Basin. Hancock Galilee (HGPL), the resources to be further upgraded following
a subsidiary of Hancock Prospecting, has a additional drilling to the west. With the comple-
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 241
queensland
IRJ - May 21 – Prime minister Julia Gillard Japan, bringing social and economic
has officially opened an A$34 billion development to the Northern Territory and
northern Australian port city Darwin. millions of Japanese homes and businesses.
Japanese oil and gas company Inpex, strengthen the ties between Australia
and many valuable contracts to the place as an emerging hub of oil and gas
queensland
coal handling and preparation plant. efficiency, power supply flexibility, ore
blending and freight optimisation.
queensland
queensland
wandoan coal pRoJect and the Queensland Minerals and Energy Academy
will provide A$720,000 over three years for fund-
operators: The project is being delivered by ing, equipment, curricula enrichment and school
xstrata Coal Queensland and funded through a industry liaison to Wandoan State School, and
joint venture between xstrata Coal Queensland Taroom State School and Miles High School.
(75 per cent ownership), ICRA (Itochu) (12.5 Status: Awaiting state and federal government
per cent ownership) and Sumisho Coal Australia approvals. The Wandoan Coal Project has been
(12.5 per cent ownership). established to investigate the possibility of open-
Location: Wandoan (immediately west of the ing an open-cut thermal coal mine immediately
township) west of the Wandoan township. The mine would
Timeframe: Two to three year construction pe- include an open-cut coal mine, a coal handling
riod and preparation plant and support facilities.
Employment: 1,300 jobs required to build the With an expected life of more than 30 years, the
mine infrastructure which will generate up to 210 mine would produce thermal coal which would be
further jobs in the local region each year. Once the crushed, sized and washed before being trans-
mine is operational, 754 permanent jobs and 90 ported by rail to port facilities on the Queensland
contractor maintenance jobs will also be created on coast and exported around the world, or used
- here in Australia. It is anticipated that about 30
fect that will generate 150 to 200 permanent jobs million run-of-mine tonnes (t) of coal would be
in the local region. A number of entry level jobs mined at Wandoan each year. As at May 2012,
for school-leavers, including apprenticeships and
traineeships will be created among the long term from the Queensland Government to allow them
jobs on the mine site once the mine is operational. to proceed with the development of the proposed
The xstrata QMEA Education Partnership between mine. After the Mining Lease and Environ-
xstrata Coal, Queensland Department of Education mental Authority are granted by the Queensland
JULY 2012 pThe International Resource Journal 249
minister Martin Ferguson is putting plant, 105km railway link from Pimba to the
There is speculation that rising costs in year (Mt/y) to 72Mt/y; copper concentrate
the country and a less certain environment production from 600,000tpy to 2.4Mt/y;
for uranium and copper demand could uranium oxide from 4,500tpy to 19,000tpy;
cause BHP to defer the A$20 billion dollar gold bullion from 100,000oz to 800,000; and
investment it is considering for the next silver from 800,000oz to 2.9 million.
queensland