Professional Documents
Culture Documents
November 2010
Nauman Khan
nauman@investcapital.com 9221-111 111 097 (ext 8636)
InvestCap is the brokerage arm of: Invest Capital Investment Bank Ltd.
www.investcapital.com
COMPANY UPDATE
A Publication of InvestCap Research
November 2010
Contents
Attock Refinery Limited. - Ramping up to full throttle!
Investment Theme Refinery sector Pakistan Refinery sector Pakistans oil chain Recent Developments Attock Refinery Limited Potential Dampeners/Weaknesses Valuation Risk to valuation Financial Highlights
1 1 3 7 8 9 9 13 15 16
Prices are as of November 08, 2010 Date of completion: November 10, 2010
COMPANY UPDATE
A Publication of InvestCap Research
November 2010
Investment Theme
Company Description
Attock Refinery is a subsidiary of Attock Oil Company, UK, and is principally engaged in processing of crude oil, with having strategic investments in NRL and APL. The company has a paid-up capital of Rs852mn (USD9.88mn). `
We are initiating our coverage with a 'Buy' stance on Attock Refinery Limited (ATRL). We have employed Sum-of-Part (SoTP) method to value company's core-refinery operations along with its strategic investments particularly in National Refinery Limited (NRL) and Attock Petroleum Limited (APL). Through Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) methodology, using a CoE (Cost of Equity) or WACC (Weighted Average Cost of Capital) of 24.75% (due to debt-virgin balance sheet) and terminal growth rate of 3%, we have arrived at company's core-refinery operation value of Rs82/share. Furthermore, we have also assigned a value of Rs83/share to ATRL's investment portfolio, translating into our Jun-11 Target Price (TP) of Rs165/share. At current levels, the scrip offers an attractive upside of 37% from current levels, while trading at a P/BV (Book Value) and P/SPS (Sales Per Share) of 0.61x and 0.11x against its historic averages of 1.41x and 0.16x (FY06-10) respectively.
InvestCap Research
COMPANY UPDATE
A Publication of InvestCap Research
November 2010
Refinery sector
Substantial decline in crude oil demand on the back of worst economic periods observed since the Great Depression, congruent with the recent wave of new refinery capacity, led to depressed profitability of international refinery sector of late. Additional 7.3mn barrels per day (bpd) production of refining capacity is further expected to be added by the end of CY15. This additional capacity is accompanied with a changing refining configuration towards high yields middle and low distillate products, particularly in the Asiatic region. The paradigm is now shifting from hydroskimming to hydro-cracking technology. With early signs of economic recovery kicking-in, the said paradigm shift is expected to have a mark implication on the middle and low distillates crack spreads, as the same could stay lower compared to pre-recession levels. With this background in place, we now start our discussion on the global oil refining sector.
Evolution of refinery industry Oil chain Boom of auto industry Exploration and production Refineries Oil marketing companies World 1st crude oil refienry Final conusmer Basic distillation process Post war recovery and focus on environmental issues Catalytic Processes Thermal cracking
1856
Early 1900
2000's
Changing global economic dynamics have changed the oil market dynamics and subsequently, the global oil refining sector. Though the traditional economic power houses i.e. USA and Europe, still contribute 43% of the total world refining capacity, U C Plan the new capacities with advanced technology are taking their root in the emerging - economies.
-
- - - 800 800
Alongside movements in the international oil prices, factors that play an important role in the determination of spreads are Refinery outages Cycle of the crude oil i.e. driving season, winter season and two lag seasons Demand and supply scenario of the individual products, with respective to global economic environment and crude oil cycle Change in technology in the refinery operations towards minimizing yield of loss-making products (as evident by the sudden dip in crack spreads towards the end of CY08 as Reliance Industry came online)
140 -
InvestCap Research
Page 1 of 2
COMPANY UPDATE
A Publication of InvestCap Research
November 2010
BYCO
NRL
PRL
However, operational issues (particularly with regards to BYCO Petroleum Company) along side impact of exogenous factors in a highly regulated industry have forced the sector to operate at an average 75% (FY05-10) of its nameplate capacity. Moreover, with no substantial addition to country's refining capacity, depicted by the last 5-year CAGR (Compound Average Growth Rate) of mere 0.3%, the sector has only been able to fulfill on an average 64% of country's overall petroleum
(mn tons) 25 20 15 10 5 FY05A FY06A FY07A FY08A FY09A FY10E Consumption and throughput comparison Refining capacity Refining throughput Petroleum prod. consumption
InvestCap Research
COMPANY UPDATE
A Publication of InvestCap Research
November 2010
products demand with the last 5-year (FY05-10) CAGR at 5.9%. Therefore, the country is also a net importer of petroleum products with the pricing and operational dynamics of the international refineries having a significant impact on country's domestic oil refining industry.
Five refineries contribute 99% of country's total refining capacity. This proposition seems to be standing as an 'Oligopoly' from the naked eye. However, the sector fails to depict two essential characteristics of an Oligopoly 1) ability to set prices and 2) profit maximization conditions, arising out of its weak position with respect to competition dynamics. Firstly, the sector is highly regulated as ex-refinery prices of eight petroleum products are announced by the Oil & Gas Regulatory Authority (OGRA) on a monthly basis through Import Parity Price (IPP) Formula. Only one product is unregulated product i.e. Furnace Oil (FO), however, the domestic prices of this product also trails that of the international prices. Secondly, Pakistan is a net importer of crude oil. Therefore, the raw material pricing is also a function of international pricing. Weak bargaining position of the sector on either ends limits sectors ability to set prices and operate at its maximum capacity. Hence, it is a misconception that the sector is an 'Oligopoly' as it lacks pricing power which also keeps rivalry amongst the individual refineries at bay.
Plus
Back charges Import Equivalent Incidents Handling charges Warfage Conversion Deemed Duty Conversion From USD to PKR 7.5% on HSD prices From M. Ton to Litre
However, understanding the technological drawback faced by local refineries as compared to its international peers, the government embedded a 10% Deemed Custom Duty on HSD and 6% tariff each on Light Diesel Oil (LDO), Jet Propulsion (JP4) and Kerosene (KERO), thus creating a favorable environment for the industry. However, when crude oil prices rallied to their record highs, gov't withdrew tariff on LDO, JP-4 and KERO, while reducing 10% tariff to 7.5% on HSD. Therefore, keeping in view the technological perspective, the embedded deemed duty stands vital for sector's profitability. The graph above illustrates the same that the listed refineries' GRMs would be slashed by a massive ~99%, in case the deemed duty is completely abolished.
InvestCap Research
COMPANY UPDATE
A Publication of InvestCap Research
November 2010 (USD/bbl) 30 20 10 Nov-10 0 Oct-06 Mar-06 May-07 May-08 Oct-08 Sep-05 Jun-09 Jun-09 (10) (20) May-10 May-10 Nov-07 ATRL GRMs Comparisons Without With
(USD/bbl) 15 10 5 0
Oct-06
Mar-06
May-07
Dec-09
Feb-06
Feb-07
Jul-07
Sep-05
Jan-08
Jun-08
Sep-08
PARCO holds the biggest chunk, ATRL better off with utilization
With respect to market share, PARCO traditionally enjoys a lion share of above 41%. However, on account of the recent flood scenario, the biggest refinery had to close its operations for about a month whereby its market share dropped to 26% in 1QFY11. The lost ground was primarily picked up by NRL and ATRL increasing their market shares to 25% and 23% respectively, followed by PRL at 21%. BYCO, on the other hand, witnessed a plant closure in Jun-10 and as a result, its market share stood at a mere 2.5%. For the same period, capacity utilization of the individual refineries stood at 97% for ATRL and 86% for NRL followed by PRL with utilization level of 74%. Conversely, BYCO and PARCO's capacity utilizations stood at only 39% and 19% respectively.
Refinery Shares in 1QFY11
PARCO ATRL PRL BOSI NRL Other
2% 23%
2% 27%
BYCO
PARCO
25%
Source: OCAC, InvestCap Research
InvestCap Research
NRL
PRL
21%
0%
May-08
Nov-07
Oct-08
Sep-05
COMPANY UPDATE
A Publication of InvestCap Research
November 2010
With uniform pricing structure for both product and raw material, the differentiating factor between the GRMs of various refineries is the product mix of individual refineries. Refineries with superior product mix i.e. having high yields of premium products (MOGAS and HSD) along with low yields of scrap pricing products (FO) will fare better as compared to their peers having an unfavorable product mix. For this purpose, we have developed 'Yield Efficiency Ratio' (YER) to gauge the relative efficiency of the individual refineries at domestic front. In simple terms, higher the ratio, the superior the product mix and therefore, superior GRMs of a particular refinery. USD/bbl PRODUCT MIX OF REFINERIES GRMs comparisons 25 NRL ATRL PRL BOSI PARCO ATRL BYCO NRL PARCO PRL Industry 20
MOGAS KERO/AF HSD FO Naphtha Non-energy Others YER Ratio 18% 16% 26% 24% 11% 5% 1% 1.85 7% 0% 6% 9% 19% 13% 30% 27% 11% 0% 0% 1.83 6% 14% 28% 39% 13% 0% 0% 0.86 12% 15 12% 10 30% 5 27% 0 8% (5) 5% 7% (10) 1.52
Aug-06
Dec-09
Feb-06
Feb-07
Jul-07
Sep-05
Jan-08
Jun-08
Sep-08
May-
0.898 1.76
(15) (20)
(USD/bbl)
Domestic GRMs
15 10
FY08
FY09
FY10
1QFY11
Kero
HSD
FO
Going forward, we believe that global economic recovery would improve petroleum product margins. However, the same are expected to remain below the levels of the pre-recessionary period on account of changing paradigm in international refinery operations. We expect domestic GRMs to recover at least to USD3-4/bbl in FY11 and beyond.
InvestCap Research
Nov-10
COMPANY UPDATE
A Publication of InvestCap Research
November 2010
Refinery 67% PARCO - 41% ATRL - 18% PRL - 17% NRL - 16% BYCO - 8%
Domestic 0.4%
Industry 5.2%
Agriculture 0.3%
Transport 47.7%
Power 43.3%
Others 3.0%
Demand
9.2 7.4
Supply
Others Power Transport Agriculture Industry Domestic 1.9 0.2 Kerosene MS 0.7 JP-1 HSD
Imports Refinery
0.07 LDO
InvestCap Research
COMPANY UPDATE
A Publication of InvestCap Research
November 2010
Recent Developments
Deregulation of pricing - oil chain integration to be leverage
A recent issue that is impacting, domestic refineries is the revision in IPP formula on the directive of the apex court of the country. In this regard, the proposal of deregulation of the petroleum product pricing has attained the central stage. In addition, the scheme also encompasses deregulation of the IFEM (Inland Freight Equalization Margin) that is applied after the ex-refinery prices to equalize freight charge across the country. As per our understanding, influence of the international refinery dynamics will restrict the benefits for the domestic refinery sector at the ex-refinery prices. Furthermore, the de-regulation of the IFEM will indirectly impact the refinery sector where the emerging benefit will be restricted to refineries that are part of integrated oil chains. Therefore, we deem the change in the pricing formula to have a favorable impact on refineries that can generate positive synergies on account of their group profiles. Attock Group, in this regards, is expected to benefit the most as the group is both backward and forward integrated (from Oil & Gas Exploration to Refining to Marketing & Distribution).
InvestCap Research
COMPANY UPDATE
A Publication of InvestCap Research
November 2010
Attock Group
Pharaon Investment
Pakistan Oilfields
With ATRL being in the central tier of the predominant pyramid holding patterns along side a vital link between the upstream and downstream oil sectors, the
InvestCap Research
COMPANY UPDATE
A Publication of InvestCap Research
November 2010
company reaps the maximum benefit arising from the synergies created by the group companies. At one end, the company forms a crucial link between POL (E&P) and APL (OMC), while holds its strategically diversified investments in NRL, APL, Attock Gen Limited and Attock Information Technology Services, on the other hand.
InvestCap Research
10
COMPANY UPDATE
A Publication of InvestCap Research
November 2010
approach and charged deferred tax assets to the P&L, resulting in increased effective tax rates to 42%, over and above corporate tax rate of 34%. Therefore, the reversal of the new tax at the same time would reset company's bottomline to its pre-tax imposition levels going forward where we expect company's 2QFY11 earnings to augment by an incremental impact of Rs2.07/share to Rs11.65/share.
11%
Further muscle to the bottomline also came from surge in company's other operating income (excluding dividend income from associates), massively up by 68% YoY. However, the only earning dampener was inflated effective tax rate at 42% over and above corporate tax rate of 34%. The surge in effective tax rate was on account of the change in the taxation regime leading to company opting to expense out its deferred tax asset.
InvestCap Research
11
COMPANY UPDATE
A Publication of InvestCap Research
November 2010
Understanding the changing trends in the international refining operation, ATRL has formulated a comprehensive plan that not only encompasses capacity by another 12,400bpd, but also aims at improving companies Mogas and HSD yields by an 0.3mn tons) and 0.6mn tons respectively. As per news reports the estimated cost of these projects is USD100mn. The brief of these projects are: FUTURE PLANS
Project Preflash Unit Isomerization Unit Diesel Hydro-Desulphurization Aim Crude processing capacity enhancement To increase the gasoline RON and reduce benzene and aromatics Diesel Hydro-Desulphurization (HSD) Unit, Capacity Benefit 12,500pbs 0.3mn tons 0.6mn tons
Due to tentative nature of these projects, we have not incorporated in the project in to our financial model for the company, however any positive development in this front will have a significantly positive impact on company's valuation.
InvestCap Research
12
COMPANY UPDATE
A Publication of InvestCap Research
November 2010
Valuation - BUY
WACC Risk Free Rate Risk Preimum Adjusted Beta Cost of Equity Cost of Debt WACC 14.25% 7.0% 1.50 24.75% 24.75%
We have employed Sum of the Parts (SOTP) Discounted Cash Flow model to value the company. Under this valuation scheme, we have projected cashflows for the next 5 years (FY10-15) incorporating a Cost of Equity of 24.75% (Weighted Average Cost of Capital also stands at 24.75% due to no debt on company's balance sheet). We have applied a terminal growth rate of 3%, while have scaled up the beta to 1.5x, to capture the volatility in the scrip. We have arrived at per share value from FCFE of Rs82 from company's core refinery operations. Furthermore, we have arrived at a value of Rs83/sh for company's investments, yielding a target value for the company of Rs165/share. We recommend a 'Buy' on the scrip, with our Jun-11 TP of Rs165/share FREE CASHFLOW PROJECTIONS
(Rs mn) EBIT Adjustments (+) Depreciation (-) Other Income Less Tax Change NWC Capex Free Cashflows Discounted Cashflows Terminal value Discounted Terminal value Firm value Less: Long term Debt Add: Cash balance Enterprise Value Investment (40% Discount) Total Value of Equity Equity Value per share
880 8,032 (354) 10,744 7,137 2,945 3,054 3,964 7,018 7,053 14,071 165
Sensitivity Analysis
WEIGHTED AVERAGE COST OF CAPITAL (WACC) TER. GROWTH RATE Rs/sh. 19.75% 1% 2% 3% 4% 5% 171 173 175 176 179 22.25% 167 168 169 170 172 24.75% 163 164 165 166 167 27.25% 160 160 161 162 163 29.75% 157 158 158 159 160
InvestCap Research
13
COMPANY UPDATE
A Publication of InvestCap Research
November 2010
3.5x
2.5x
1.5x
0.9x
0.3x
Jan-06
Jan-08
Sep-06
Sep-08
Jan-10
May-07
(Rs bn)
ATRL PS Bands
34
0.34x
29
24
May-09
Sep-10
0.25x 0.15x 0.1x 0.035x
19
14
Jan-06
Jan-08
Sep-06
Sep-08
Jan-10
May-07
InvestCap Research
14
May-09
Sep-10
-1
COMPANY UPDATE
A Publication of InvestCap Research
November 2010
Risk to valuations
With little maneuverability in companys plant set-up firmly placed in, the major risk to our earning arise from pricing scenarios. We have classified the major pricing risk that can have an adverse impact on companys valuation.
Currency risk
With both product and raw-material being priced in USD terms, it provides a natural hedge for the organization against the currency risk. However, any abrupt change in the PKR/USD parity (as in the case was in FY08), will adversely affect companys earning. However, this would be a short term phenomena, with companys cash rich balance sheet acting as its buffer.
InvestCap Research
15
COMPANY UPDATE
A Publication of InvestCap Research
November 2010
96,652 102,489 94,675 98,639 1,978 1,571 1,520 714 2,234 26.20 3,850 3,422 391 853 1,243 14.57
KEY RATIOS
FY08A Basic Share Information (Rs) Earning Per Share Book Value Per Share Free Cashflow per share Cash per share Business Performance Return on Capital Employed Return on Equity Return on Asset Gross Margin Operating margin EBITDA margins Net margins Earning Growth Operational Performance Gross Refinery Margins (USD/BBl) Plant Utlization Earnings Quality (x) Cash Realization Ratio Tax Rate Net debt-to Equity Ratio Interest Coverage Standard Valuations (x) Price to Earning Ratio Price to Sales per share Price to Book Value Free Cashflow Yield EV/EBITDA 5.04 0.13 1.03 0.92 3.11 13.01 0.17 1.09 (0.87) 5.27 56.00 0.08 0.58 (0.57) 56.49 4.59 0.11 0.71 0.12 4.77 8.25 0.10 0.69 (0.28) 3.48 7.92 0.09 0.67 0.25 3.77 7.25 0.08 0.65 0.01 3.33 6.70 0.08 0.63 0.17 2.66 27.95 136.22 130.11 221.79 23% 53% 12% 4% 4% 5% 7% 722% 9.29 104% 1.81 30% 1.68 3.32 11.90 141.45 (135.35) 79.70 14% 8% 2% 2% 2% 3% 1% -83% 1.82 89% (11.37) 62% 2.12 1.73 1.48 142.94 (47.59) 46.47 1% 1% 0% -1% -1% 0% 0% -88% 1.77 91% (32.11) -161% 3.48 0.41 26.20 169.13 14.52 73.16 12% 15% 3% 2% 2% 3% 2% 1668% 5.71 95% 0.55 34% 3.08 7.80 14.57 174.44 (33.99) 39.03 15% 8% 2% 4% 3% 4% 1% -44% 6.05 95% (2.33) 34% 3.38 10.41 15.18 179.39 29.60 65.16 12% 8% 2% 3% 3% 3% 1% 4% 6.41 95% 1.95 34% 3.54 8.58 16.58 184.71 1.72 65.38 12% 9% 2% 3% 3% 3% 1% 9% 6.41 95% 0.10 34% 3.63 9.38 17.95 190.65 20.83 84.17 14% 9% 2% 4% 4% 4% 1% 8% 6.41 95% 1.16 34% 3.61 11.25 FY09A FY10A FY11E FY12E FY13E FY14E FY15E
InvestCap Research
16
COMPANY UPDATE
A Publication of InvestCap Research
November 2010
RESEARCH Khurram Schehzad Farhan Bashir Khan Muniba Saeed Nauman Khan Mazhar A. Sabir Abdul Azeem Saeed Khalid Akhtar Nawaz Asim Abbas Economy, Strategy and Oil
(92-21) 111 111 097 Fertilizers, Cements, Construction and Telecom Banks, Power and Textiles E&P, Refineries and Chemicals Insurance and Mutual Funds Automobile, Gas Distribution, Textiles and Technicals Commodities, FMCGs and Paper & Board Database Incharge Research Distribution
EQUITY SALES DESK (92-21) 3520 8727, 3520 8735, 3520 8730-31 Shahrukh Naqvi Noureen Moin Khan Nabeel Jafar Irfan Ali Muhammad
MONEY MARKET DESK (92-21) 3520 8751, 3520 8757, 3520 8767 Naeem-ul-Hasan Aamir Saeed Khan Mobin Wahid Asif Hussain Nasir Suria Mehmood Qureshi
FOREIGN EXCHANGE DESK (92-21) 3520 8778-87 Imran Chohan Atif Ali Syed Atif Abbas Naqvi Syed Ali Yazdan Mohammad Waqas Mohammad Zain
COMMODITY SALES DESK (92-21) 3521 35226-28 Ali Kazmi Junaid Zakaria
InvestCap is the brokerage arm of: Invest Capital Investment Bank Ltd.
www.investcapital.com
Islamabad Office
301, Muhammad Gulistan Khan House 82E, Blue Area, Fazal-e-Haq Road, Islamabad Telephone Fax: + 92 (51) 282 5904 +92 (51) 227 5202
Peshawar Office
1st Floor, State Life Building 34 - The Mall, Peshawar Cantt. Telephone Fax +92 (91) 527 6025-28 +92 (91) 527 3683
Lahore Office
16A, Main Gulberg ,Near MCB Tower, Lahore Telephone Fax +92 (42) 3577 6701-08 +92 (42) 3577 6710
This report is for information purposes only and we are not soliciting any action based upon it. The material is based on information we believe to be reliable but we do not guarantee that it is accurate and complete. Invest Capital Investment Bank Ltd. will not be responsible for the consequence of reliance upon any opinion or statement herein or for any omission. This report or any part of it may not be reproduced or published without prior permission.