You are on page 1of 13

Ethnic Polarization In Pakistan Case Study Fall- 2011

We must learn to live together as brothers or perish together as fools


-Martin Luther King Jr
Group Leader Saniya Raza Tiwana 117 Group Members Fahd Hussain Khan 025 Fatima Ikram 030 01-11109101-11109101-111091-

Sana Abid Ansari 01-111091-115

Ethnic Polarization In Pakistan

TEACHERS REMARKS _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________ Signed By: _________________

Group Number Three, Saniya Raza Tiwana

Page 2

Ethnic Polarization In Pakistan Introduction A precise definition of ethnicity is not easy. People define it according to their own perceptions. Theoretically, it emerges that it is much more than racial, cultural, religious or even political phenomenon. At its core it is probably psychological, i.e., the perception what separates us from them. It is a shared sense of fear, vulnerability and shared aspirations by a persecuted people resulting in hatred and a craving for separation. The increasing incidence of ethnic conflicts and the much publicized consequences of these conflicts have made many researchers to revisit social sciences. It is a point of inference that ethnically diverse societies have a higher probability of political conflicts. According to Montalvo, the political instability caused by potential ethnic conflicts has a negative impact on investment and, indirectly, on growth. It is also a point of argument, according to some researchers that, where there is ethnic diversity it would generate a high level of corruption, which in turn, could deter investment in that country/or region. Additionally, in heterogeneous societies or strong tribal structure (with strong cultural and communal affinity) such as Balochistan and FATA, there is low level of propagation of technology and creativity due to inbuilt potential for partiality, favoritism and nepotism, which through social and political channel, affects the economy.

Background
When we look at the worlds lesser known conflicts, Pakistan cannot be neglected. There are many religious sects, tribes and cultural groups in Pakistan; some of which we hardly know, while others are on our fingertips because they make efforts to do so. Not denying the fact that lack of education, poverty, bigotry, feudalism, tribalism, ethnic polarization, discriminatory law and justice compounded with foreign interference, are elements which are tearing apart the Pakistani society. Since independence, these have steadily become violent because certain groups want to attain acceptance for their lawful or unlawful demands and failure of the successive Governments to enforce writ of the state or reconciliation. Conversely, high level of diversity can also be a potential for growth when handled by erudite and dedicated leadership.

Group Number Three, Saniya Raza Tiwana

Page 3

Ethnic Polarization In Pakistan

Following table and map define the statistics & ethnic groups location in Pakistan:
Major Ethnic Groups in Pakistan, 1973 (Wikipedia Map)

Population Percentage Punjabi Pashtun Sindhi Seraiki Muhajir Baloch Others 42.15% 17.42%, 14.1% 10.53%, 7.57%, 3.57% 4.66%

Current Ground Realities

Pakistan is a multi lingual, multi ethnic and multi cultural country with more than 60 languages spoke in it. Strangely enough, the struggle for Pakistan during British Rule transcended ethnic, lingual, cultural and regional differences. It was an expression of a deep Muslim consciousness which was both inspiring and invigorating. Unfortunately, post independence that expression could not be sustained. The independence movement in British India is an inspiration to the argument that there never was true unity among major ethnic groups; it was only a forced lumping together by the British rulers. So was division of East & West Pakistan. Post 1971 Pakistan has also witnessed Baloch insurgencies, Pashtun separatism, Sindhi regionalism etc. Today Pakistani society is extremely polarized along ethnic, geographic, economic, gender as well as religious lines which are preventing the social cohesion necessary for broad-based, inclusive growth. These secular movements pose serious risks to the Federation. These challenges are indeed
Group Number Three, Saniya Raza Tiwana Page 4

Ethnic Polarization In Pakistan mounting, at the same time; these very events offer an opportunity for seeking solutions remaining still in a multi-ethnic framework. Symptoms [2] On June 5, 2008, the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace hosted a discussion on Pakistans economic and social challenges and prospects. Jan Vandermoortele along with few others was the featured speakers. The discussion was opened with an overview of Pakistans lackluster performance in achieving human development goals. The country has made some limited progress on poverty and health indicators, its education sector remains well below those of countries at similar levels of existence. The reason ascribed was that the country spends only about 2.5% of GDP on health and education, whereas most countries that have prospered have spent on a sustained basis, at least 7% of their GDP. Extreme examples of ethnic violence are of Balochistan and KPK. Several events like the PIA Flight PK-544 hijack by the Baloch Students Organization (BSO), the abduction of John Solecki; head of UN High Commissioner for Refugees in Balochistan (UNHCR) in 2009, of Chinese engineers from the Gwadar port, of socio-political leaders and rich businessmen for ransom or for release of captured compatriots. Our focus in this study is on the ethnic polarization in Pakistan.

Causes
a. Unpatriotic Leadership. The leaders for the independence movement had achieved their

aim in the later part of their lives and were not available to guide it through its formative years. Their inheritors were the big landlords and tribal bourgeois who were no visionaries like Muhammad Ali Jinnah, Liaqat Ali Khan etc. Due to their personal differences, greed and protectionist instincts did not permit stabilizing of state institution like legislative assembly, independent judiciary, executive and the taxation administrations. It took them six years to agree on their first Constitution and since then it has been abrogated, set aside or changed as many times. These interest groups and cartels control the state institutions as well as all the sources of wealth. The common people are beholden to them for their survival.

Group Number Three, Saniya Raza Tiwana

Page 5

Ethnic Polarization In Pakistan


b. Weak Education Base The successive conflict ridden leadership failed to conceive and

implement a national education policy fulfilling the aspirations envisaged for secession from India, which is, to surmount economic persecution under the dominant Hindu population. Thus, an educated leadership and workforce have not emerged who could resolve the issues, appropriately utilize the wealth of resources.
c. Regional and International Interests and Intervention. Pakistan is located at the

international cross-roads which makes it prone to regional & international rivalries. The fledgling state was constrained to join CENTO in sixties, a western alliance against its neighboring super power the USSR and paid a heavy price for it. In the eighties, again forced into active war for over a decade for stopping and breaking up of USSR, as a consequence it received millions of Afghan refugees, freedom fighters called Jihadist from all over the world, Kalashnikov bearing trained fighters who had married or settled their families here. After the war these Jihadist termed Taliban, had no jobs or sustenance, most had worked for international intelligence spy networks, and were available for any takers. They were clandestinely used against Pakistans interests to create disillusionment and further rift between ethnic groups. All these factors disrupted the national cohesion and weakened economy. The leadership which led to the breaking up of USSR, could have defended against such schemes, was conspired against and violently removed. Even then, the country was not left alone; political and military governments were installed and removed in quick succession to keep the country begging from IMF, World Bank and the so called Big Eight Countries to continue doing their bidding. These Powers have eyes on the natural and human resources in and around Pakistan thus they are a source of conflict.

d. Religious Factions. Pakistan was created on social and religious differences with Hindus

of Hindustan (India to the western countries) but, since inception it also failed to conceive and implement Islamic laws / constitution. Successive civil and military leadership did not emerge from the grass roots. They were sons and daughters of wealthy elite who were educated in the west, dreaded Islamic laws because they were imbued by western culture, which itself had degenerated into free for all society, do anything but dont be caught. Pakistan was forced into Wests war, who called it a holy war. Taking advantage of
Group Number Three, Saniya Raza Tiwana Page 6

Ethnic Polarization In Pakistan existing religious sects, funded these groups and devious individuals who recruited simple Muslims from all over the Islamic world in the name of Jihad. These little known so called Islamic groups fattened by foreign currencies and weapons have started wielding power and become a source of conflict too.
e. Weak Economy. Despite having vast natural resources in the form of rich mineral deposits,

rivers and network of irrigation canal system, vast expanses of arable land a conducive climate able to produce three crops per year, its economy has failed to develop given the above potentials. The reason for this failure squarely rests with leadership which successively emerged from particular factions or areas who failed a judicious distribution of national resources and wealth, thus the polarization.

Analysis
Whatever the causes of ethnic polarization the fact remains that it has become a serious threat to the integrity of the Pakistani nation. Ethnic prejudices are entrenched in our minds from the moment we are able to distinguish between right and wrong. No matter how much we may deny it, but when we look at a person we instantly notice his race and try to distinguish his origins. When we meet people one of the first thought that come to our minds is, Now where does this person come from?, or Oh! He / she must be Pathan, Punjabi, Muhajir or Taliban. We notice the color of that persons skin, decide on his ethnicity and instantly form judgments about him. These judgments barricade us from recognizing intellectual and professional capabilities, moral character and exploit such potential. This tendency of stereotyping and making generalizations is extremely prevalent in our society. This only leads to provincialism and ethnic disputes. In Karachi there has been widespread unrest and violence between the Pathans, Muhajirs and Sindhis. In Balochistan there is hatred against Punjabi civil military bureaucracy and agro-industrial settlers. The Baloch people feel that they have not been given fair share in their economic development and appropriate representation in the government. These divisions have caused much impediment politically and economically, and might even lead to further division of the country.

Group Number Three, Saniya Raza Tiwana

Page 7

Ethnic Polarization In Pakistan The violent unrest that has taken place in Karachi over the years is solely on the basis of economic disputes transiting into ethnic prejudices. At the time of the creation of Pakistan in 1947, a large number of migrants settled in the urban areas of Punjab and Sind, namely Karachi, Hyderabad and Sukkur. These migrants were called Muhajir or refugees. From the very start the Sindhi population did not accept the influx of the Muhajirs into their lands. The immigrants or Muhajirs belonged to urban, middle class families, were well educated and experienced in various occupations and they gave initial impetus to state organizations. On the other hand the Sindhi population was relatively uneducated and rural, struggling to survive under their own feudal system. They and their feudal lords resented the presence of a more educated community taking over their economic prospects. In the 1970s there was violent confrontation between the two communities, as unlike the rest of the country, the Sindhis were also unwilling to accept Urdu as the national / official language in their province. There was much bloodshed on both sides and no favorable conclusion could be reached. Karachi being a port city grew is an economic hub, thus a number of Pashtun and Punjabi people also came and settled there, taking over many jobs that would be available to Sindhis or Muhajirs. To protect themselves the Muhajir Qaumi Movement or MQM was created in 1986 by Altaf Hussain. They have since been involved in culpable activities. Whether the MQM has been of benefit to the people of Karachi is a matter of personal opinion. (Ahmer) However, the biggest example of ethnic prejudice in Pakistans history lies in the formation of Bangladesh, previously known as East Pakistan. East Pakistan too had a higher literacy rate and more population than West Pakistan. Their demand to make Bengali also a national language along with Urdu was ignored. Apart from this they were not given fair representation in the National Assembly and the government. There were financial and monetary disputes as well. Bengalis complained that most of the foreign exchange earned from their produce was not spent on them and was squandered in West Pakistan by the West Pakistan heavy leadership and bureaucracy. Taking advantage of that situation India mobilized the East Pakistani people financially and militarily and Bangladesh was created. (Ahmed) What we need to learn from all this is that we should look beyond racial and provincial boundaries and see what really binds us together as a nation. Ethnic prejudice has only lead to increased tensions and bloodshed of our own people. It is high time to look back on the Two Nation Theory and educate the people of Pakistan about the true essence of their identity. What matters is that we
Group Number Three, Saniya Raza Tiwana Page 8

Ethnic Polarization In Pakistan are all Pakistani and not Baloch, Sindhi, Urdu speaking, Punjabi or Pathan. It is our country that gives us our identity. Nobody outside Pakistan is going to ask us which province or state we belong to. The current situation in Pakistan cant take any more divisions or faults within itself. We shouldnt let anything; especially disputes within ourselves get in the way of our progress.

Recommendations
Implementing Democratic Practices. The simple people of Pakistan have paid a heavy price for delegating their rights to greedy individuals who had fed them with false hopes and promises. With the new found freedom of Press & IT they have been well exposed. It is time that the people choose well their leaders, make them accountable and demand their rights. Strengthening Institutions. Institutions are assessed on the basis of their response to the crises and providing relief to the population, more or less institutions in Pakistan (Executive, Judiciary, Education, Health, Power, Land Administration, Taxation, & Police) have not delivered. The ethnic polarization in Pakistan can be determined from the uneven distribution of developmental projects, infrastructure, institutions and poverty alleviation throughout the country, except Punjab which had a better deal by a fostering leadership which is the bone of resentment for other provinces specially Balochistan. These anomalies need to be addressed immediately. In the rural areas of the provinces, majority of the population live at below poverty level where are no decent hospitals that can provide them with reasonable health services. Diseases like Malaria and Tuberculosis are common, especially those living in thickly-populated slums. This is greatly due to their low standards of living and literacy. Every year Tuberculosis causes approximately 70,000 death out of 270,000 afflicted by the disease. According to World Health Organization, the country is 27th in the list of most affected states. (MacKenzie, 2011) Establish Rule of Law and Accountability. Economic experts point out that institutional proficiency depends to a large extent on the combination of the rule of law, accountability and democratic practices. Decades have passed, unfortunately for Pakistan, to be ruled by the gang of landowner wadaras (feudal), big industrialists and civil-military bureaucracy, taking turns, who have been making a show of holding accountable the outgoing regime but pardoning them later. This must end now.
Group Number Three, Saniya Raza Tiwana Page 9

Ethnic Polarization In Pakistan Judicious Distribution and Utilization of National Resources. Another big issue is the unfair representation of isolated ethnic groups on the national level. Some provinces end up getting a larger share of everything, be it water, power, employment and budget and get to enjoy the superior facilities that may not be found in other provinces. This has caused resentment and been taken advantage by the opportunists and external actors (to further their own vested interests) Justly elected representatives must ensure equal distribution of national resources its best utilization. An Empowered Regulatory Authority. According to a market analyst Yunus Kamran, the inability of the state to deliver basic public goods and appropriate regulatory framework and the accumulation of tax, trade, wage and bank arrears indicates weakening of institutions. The most important reason of this is the presence of corruption at the top level. According to the Annual Corruption Perception Index (CPI) 2001-2010, Pakistan is ranked at 143rd out of the 178 countries surveyed (Livingston, 2011). Finally there is a strong perception that there has been a systemic decline in the quality of tax administration and in the face of growing evasion and corruption; it is argued that the incidence of taxes has effectively declined- Chaudhary, 2010. An Indigenous Education and Religious Policy. These two need immediate reforms. Apart from few decent schools and colleges for the financially rich people in Pakistan, the general population has no option but to go to Urdu medium schools where, given the pitiable allocation of resources, the standards and amenities are contemptible. A big number of very poor family children are taken up by Religious Mudrissahs which are run by benevolent funding and which are preaching religion, morality or behavior in an irritatingly tedious or overbearing way repugnant to the mainstream Islam. In the absence of a national educational policy each educational or religious institute is having their own syllabi. Making things even worse are the strong political parties who for the lust of money keep opting for aid in the name of education but would make no such efforts to develop good educational institutions. In an article by Stuteville, 2010; as many as 30,000 ghost schools nonfunctioning schools, that exist only on paper. This has to stop. There is a dire need of formulating and implementing an indigenous national education and religious policy to bring out the best national talent. The education system should be such that it surpasses the international standards yet at the same time promotes knowledge regarding the true Islamic / world history culture, literature and art of Pakistan. What lies at the essence of such an educational system is that
Group Number Three, Saniya Raza Tiwana Page 10

Ethnic Polarization In Pakistan students would not only be focusing on reaching International standards but also having a firm grip on what they are and where they belong. Adding books written by authors of Pakistani origin as part of schools syllabus along with comprehending the geographic and cultural beauty of Pakistan. The aim should be to make the youth feel proud that they are a part of a nation whose ancestors include people like Sultan Fateh Ali Tipu, Mirza Ghalib, Sayyed Ahmad Khan, Allama Muhammad Iqbal, Muhammad Ali Jinnah etc rather than creating a sort of inferiority complex through dramatizing western heroes. The government of Pakistan should create as many educational platforms that would educated people regarding how they can practice their rights make them understand what is considered as their right and make them believe that the government will be there for their support. Once the students have a firm belief that they are no lesser a nation than any other on the face of this planet, they would do wonders for this country. A Proactive Agriculture Policy and Land Reforms. Adop[tion of wrong policies have lead the country to rely more on loans from IMF and World Bank for its very survival. What makes things even worse for Pakistan is the segment of the population who are feudal and landlords who just do not want their children as well as others to get educated. The feudal archetype in Pakistan consists of landlords with large joint families possessing hundreds or even thousands of acres of land (interior Punjab, KP and Sindh). They seldom make any direct contribution to agricultural production. Instead, all work is done by peasants or tenants who live at subsistence level. Pakistan suffers not only from decadent feudalism but also from the primitive tribal system. In order to improve institutions, new and fresh policies should be implemented throughout Pakistan. Thoroughly revising and making structural changes ensuring equal representation to each and every province. An indigenous Foreign Policy. Pakistan is in dire need of a foreign policy that would benefit the National Interest of the country itself rather than one that is customized and manufactured by super powers. Type-casting some minorities with menial sanitary work are belittling and extremely discriminatory. Therefore care must be taken that minorities dont get stereotyped and consequently oppressed by those in the majority.

Conclusion

Group Number Three, Saniya Raza Tiwana

Page 11

Ethnic Polarization In Pakistan


Pakistan is a state of over 180 million people with sixty percent in the age group of 35 years and below, who are imbued with nationalistic fervor, are hard working and God fearing. They are well aware of the prevailing regional and international geopolitics. If equal opportunities for all, best man for the job is adopted as the state policy it will mitigate the grouse among the people and the provinces. In the end a beautiful quote by Mr Mowahid Hussain;

Pakistan was never envisioned to be the play ground of plunderers, perverts and parasites, given the horrid results so far, is there any harm, for a change of flavor, to give recognition to honesty, hard work and merit? Surely, results cant be any worse ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

References
Montalvo, J.G , 2005. Ethnic Polarization. Ethnic Polarization, Potential Conflict, and Civil wars, [Online]. Vol. 95, No. 3, pp. 804-805. Available at: http://www.econ.upf.edu/~reynal/aer_final_conflict.pdf [Accessed 30 November 2011]

Group Number Three, Saniya Raza Tiwana

Page 12

Ethnic Polarization In Pakistan Jan Vandemoortele. 2008. Confronting Pakistan's Economic and Social Challenges. [ONLINE] Available at:http://carnegieendowment.org/2008/06/05/confronting-pakistan-s-economic-andsocial-challenges/90g. [Accessed 22 October 11] Wikimedia commons, (1973), Pakistan ethnic groups [ONLINE]. Available at:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Pakistan_ethnic_1973.jpg [Accessed 16 October 11]. Foreign Policy Centre. 2006. Balochis of Pakistan. at: http://fpc.org.uk/fsblob/817.pdf. [Accessed 17 October 11] [ONLINE] Available Available

Eriposte. 2010. Ethnic/Linguistic Demographics of Pakistan. [ONLINE] at:http://www.theleftcoaster.com/archives/015268.php. [Accessed 28 October 11]

The Breakup. In R. Z. Ahmed, Pakistan The Real Picture (pp. 270-292). Ferozsons (Pvt.) Ltd. Ahmer, M. (n.d.). Pakistan: The Sindhi-Mohajir Conflict. Retrieved December 1, 2011, from http://www.conflict-prevention.net/page.php?id=40&formid=73&action=show&surveyid=15. Ian. S Livingston and Michael OHanlon . 2011. Pakistan Index: Tracking Variables of Reconstruction & Security. [ONLINE] Available at:http://www.brookings.edu/~/media/Files/Programs/FP/pakistan%20index/index.pdf. [Accessed 07 November 11] Chaudhry, I.S, 2010. Determinants of Low Tax Revenue in Pakistan. Pakistan Journal of Social Sciences, Vol. 30, pp. 439-452 Mackenzie, J.S, 2011. Emerging Infectious Diseases. Responding to Emerging Infectious Diseases: reducing the risks through understanding the mechanisms of emergence, [Online]. Vol. 2, pp. 2-5. Available at: http://www.wpro.who.int/wpsar/archives/Archive-Vol2(1) 2011_Editorial_McKenzie.htm[Accessed 29 November 2011] Stuteville, S. ( May 2010). Global Post. [Accessed 29 November 2011]

Group Number Three, Saniya Raza Tiwana

Page 13

You might also like