Professional Documents
Culture Documents
.6 BN RECORD NET INCOME , PUTS UP PHP 4BN FOR PADCAL, BULAWAN , KALAYAAN AND SILANGAN EXPLORATION CAPEX
SAYS PX CHAIR MVP
2012
2012 Ju n 29 Vo l u me 1 No . 5
he Bellwether
Fortnightly on Market Action and Outlook
Dizon Copper-Silver Mine Inc.s Tailings Dam Project is Key to Share Price Run
Dizon Copper Silver Mines Inc. (DCSMI), together with Canada-based Capital Gold, will form a joint venture (JV) company to operate its Tailings Dam Project. DCSMI will own at least 20% of the JV company while the remaining stake will be allocated to the foreign partner and a technological partner. The project will require an estimated development cost of $70mn, which will be shouldered by both the foreign and technological partner. Essentially, Dizon will enjoy a free carry from these investors, giving Dizon at least a 20% share in the income. The tailings dam was where Benguet Corporation's previous gold mining operations' (that ceased in 1997) "waste" went. Its estimated resource/reserves is 100m tons of gold ore or 1m oz. of extractable gold. Gold grade is 0.30 grams per ton ore. There are also copper and pyrite in the dam, whose separation from the gold deposits will require a flotation and a leaching facility.
Market Stats
For the week ending June 29, 2012
Top Gainers Stock BEL TEL GLO MER FGEN PSEi Closing High Low Value T/O (in mn Php) Price 5.25 2,650.00 1,115.00 253.40 17.66 % w-o-w change 10.06% 5.92% 5.19% 5.15% 4.50% Value 5,246.41 5,285.84 5,144.91 30,554.70 736.35 % w-o-w Change 2.47% 2.50% 2.97% 32.33% 1,147.39% Stock AGI SMC AC BDO Top Losers Price 11.54 114.00 469.20 63.40 % w-o-w change -3.19% -1.38% -0.17% -0.16%
Continuation on Page 4
demand in the Luzon grid, higher energy acceptance rate of National Grid Corporation of the Philippines (NGCP) for the reserve power market and spot prices for full year 2013 earnings to reach Php2bn, we estimate FGEN's profit uptake from FG Hydro to be Php800mn or 40% of the abovementioned figure. FG Hydro has one of the brightest prospects among EDC's power plants given the ff:
3) Since FGEN also owns a direct 40% equity in FG Hydro and 29% of the latter indirectly through EDC, it will share in the robust operating prospects of the hydro plant. FG Hydro made Php1.1bn net profits in 1Q12, equal to the full year net profits in 2011 worth Php1.1bn. Assuming the favorable earnings results in 1Q12 is replicated in 2Q12 due to strong electricity
it has an ancillary contract with NGCP which accounted for Php600mn of the Php1.4bn operating revenues in 1Q12; strong WESM prices hitting a high of Php16/kwh in May; strong electricity consumption; and high dam water levels.
Page 2
(FGENcontinued from page 2) Half of FG Hydro's 130MW capacity is contracted with Nueva Ecija electric cooperatives while the rest is sold to the merchant and ancillary markets. FGEN owns 40% of the plant directly and another 29% indirectly by way of EDC's 60% stake in FG Hydro. FGEN owns 60% of EDC.
Execution on Bacman's rehabilitation, which EDC said 4) Improved effective cost of debt to 2.04% in 1Q12 will start commercial operations early next year. The from 2.30% or a 26 bps decline as the newly issued weather for FG Hydro whose dam water level is critical preferreds last July 2011 carrying a lower interest rate to power sales delivery. Buy. were used to retire the high cost 11.5% note of Unified We estimate FGEN's 2013 earnings to reach $149mn Holdings (UL). UL owns FGEN's subsidiary FGP Corp. or Php6.4bn based on the contribution of its significant
that runs the 500MW San Lorenzo natural gas plant. Applying the cost of debt improvement on FGEN's outstanding debt of $936mn, we estimate a minimum yearly interest savings of $2.4mn of Php105mn. Also FGEN intends to pay down more of the natural gas plants' debt after extinguishing total debts worth $213mn last year. FGEN's balance sheet leverage remained steady even with the abovementioned bond paydown as new long-term debt of $60mn was booked as of 1Q2012. Interest bearing debt-to-equity ratio stood at 0.64:1, same as in 1Q11.
subsidiaries: the wholly owned nat gas plants, 49%owned EDC and 69%-owned FG Hydro (direct and indirect ownership of 69%). On market cap of Php59bn, FGEN's PE based on 2013 earnings is 9.4x, a deep discount to market PE of 15x. Key risks are:
Stock Data Price (Php) Market Cap (Php Bn) Outstanding shares (Bn) Book Value/Share (Php) Price to Book (X) Recommendation
Source: Bloomberg
Electric Cooperative (ILECO 1) Build a 10MW hydro power plant in Cagayan de Oro costing $30mn, to operate in 4Q2013. Likely off-takers are Bukidnon Electric Cooperative or Cagayan Electric Power and Light Co., Inc.
Clarifications OREs Php470mn paid to related parties were Earnings ORE mines pre-operating costs incurred from 2Q2012 earnings likely to be higher than 2007 to 2010. These advances are likely to be Php167mn, the level of 1Q12. paid in stock and not in cash and the cash outORE has slumped to Php5.00/share on what the mar- Dividends likely in 2013 which will clearly put it flow wont repeat. ket perceives to be inconsistencies between shipment in the radar screen of more investors. Nickel ore average selling prices dipped from volume, selling prices and earnings. Slowly, ORE $32/ton in 2Q2011 to P13 per ton in 1Q2012 on share prices are recovering, rising to Php5.42/share Plans low-grade shipments. yesterday, in line with sector sentiment improving over Building a $10mn nickel ore beneficiation plant the "rumored" minimal changes in Malacanang's draft to be operational by 2013. mining policy to come out officially very soon. At the Acquiring a Palawan-based nickel mine bigger annualized 1Q2012 earnings which is a rough estithan its 2,100 ha. MPSA. mate of the full year operations of its two mines in Exploring a Mindanao gold mine, 4000 hectares. Palawan and assuming shipments of low-grade ore for Shipping a minimum of 3.5mn tons of ore in the entire year, which ORE management confirmed to FY2012 and 4mn tons in FY2013. be the operating cycle and strategy for 2012, PE is Expansion of port facilities costing P250mn to These are limonite (the top soil) with > 30% iron 12x. ORE's PE is below the market PE, but half-way double capacity from 5 to 10 vessels/mo. content selling at $25 to $28 per ton, the level at its peers' PE range: Marcventure's 5x and Nickel Expand monthly shipment from 400k tons in which Marcventures sells. Asia's 14x.Unless the LME nickel spot improves sub2012 to 700k tons in 2013. stantially, back above $20k, ORE is not shipping out Conclude a power supply agreement for its its high grade nickel ore. 18MW $60mn Aklan hydro power plant with Iloilo
Page 3
(Dizon Tailings Dam Project...continued from page Cash cost per oz is estimated at $400, lower as the 1) gold deposits are already on the surface requiring no mining cost, which is about $850/oz. for a typical mining The consortium of foreign investors are after a copper operation. off-take (for Hyudai) and gold (for Capital Gold), whose sales the latter is sharing with Dizon. Dizon, being the We obtained 20% of the tailings dam project NPV tailings dam claim owner, is also entitled to 80% of the worth Php4.5bn which is the value of Dizon's project 2.5% royalties computed on the gross profit margin. stake and add the DCF of Dizon's earnings from project royalties, being the claim owner, worth Php510mn. We estimate the net present value of the tailings pro- Thus our estimate of Dizon's equity value (excluding ject to be Php23bn based on a six year mine life. Out- other planned acquisitions) is Php5bn or Php64.35/ put (gold ore extraction) is planned to be ramped up share. from initially 20k daily tonnage in year one or 2014 to 100k tons as early as the second year or 2015. That Key risk is execution. translates to a recovery of 85% of the 1m oz of gold reserves or 170k oz of shipment per year at $1,500/oz. Recommending a trading buy on Dizon.
Stock Data Price (Php) Market Cap (Php Bn) Outstanding shares (Mn) Book Value/Share (Php) Price to Book (X) Recommendation
Source: Bloomberg
Page 4
Given the earnings drop this year for PX's bread and butter gold mining operations, we are recommending a switch to PXP. PXP has been generating market excitement in terms of the prospective resource estimates, contingent reserves of the natural gas find on par with Malampaya as well as its varied fuel resource portfolio of coal (with an off-take agreement with Iligan Cement), petroleum expansion through Galoc phase 2 and Pitkin's oil exploration in Peru and Vietnam and most recently an announced expansion into renewable energy, i.e. geothermal.
Page 5
Stock Data Price (Php) Market Cap (Php Bn) Outstanding shares (Mn) Book Value/Share (Php) Price to Book (X) Recommendation 218.20 77.73 356.30 46.42 4.70 BUY
the weakness of coal prices abroad. The sales volume mix is expected to turn 80% in favor of local versus exports amid the China slowdown, which previously accounted for a third of the 30% share of exports to Semirara's total coal sales of 6.5m-7.0m tons yearly. Calaca's two plants running will increase coal demand from Semirara to 2m tons as each 300MW unit will require about 1 million tons each year of coal. Semirara's domestic coal selling price is holding at Php3,000/ton, lower than the previous high of Php3,300/ton early in the year and in late in 2011. However, coal exports have softened to slightly below Php3,000/ton. Domestic demand for coal is expected to pick up with about 900MW coal-fired plants rising in the Mindanao grid in the medium-term, the one by Abotiz Power "Davao Coal" and three units of 200MW each by Conal in Zamboanga province. All these plants will use circulating fluidized-bed combustion technology that require low grade coal. At an assumed shipment of 7m this year, we expect the mining bottom line to be Php5.3bn. Add the Php2.25bn from Calaca, our consolidated bottom line projection is Php7.6bn for a PE of 10x. Buy.
Page 6