Professional Documents
Culture Documents
12
DCF Valuation
What is it?
Shortcomings Inaccurate information (distant cash flows) is added to accurate information (near-term cash flows), which produces inaccurate information Leads to false sense of security
Example
Consider the Terminal Value in a DCF
Comprises the majority of the value in most valuations If we are wrong by 1% in either direction, range of TV
9%
3%
1/(9%-3%) = 16.6
A Better System
1) Asset Value- How much are the companys assets on
the books worth TODAY 2) Earnings Power Value- How much is the current earnings power worth (assuming zero growth) 3) DCF How much (if anything) is growth worth?
Asset Value
Any valuation start with a decision about the
In Terminal Decline?
Estimates the current earnings powerif it were to continue indefinitely into the future with zero growth.
Adjusted earnings include Rectifying accounting misrepresentations (one-time charges Resolving discrepancies between depreciation and amortization and actual amount of investment by the company Take into account the current position in the business cycle EPV has the advantage of being based entirely on currently
available information and is uncontaminated by more uncertain conjectures about the future
(Adjusted OCF/ Cost of capital) + Net Cash = Earnings Power Value / Shares outstanding
= EPV/share
competitive advantages
Realize not all growth is valuablefor companies w/o
competitive advantages, growth can actually DESTROY value By employing three-stage valuation, an investor has a far better idea of what he/she is betting on than an investor just starting with DCF
Nike, New Balance Over $1 B sales since 2005 Shape-Ups Boosted earnings 40% in 2010
Company too aggressive with growth plans (fad) Forced to liquidate inventory at huge write-downs Will likely have to pay large fine ($60 mm) for false
advertising claims to FTC Stock price fallen from high of $23 to low of $11 to current price of $14
1: Asset Value
Current Stock Price= ~$14
$18 TBV/share (28% upside) Excludes value of int. assets Need to further adjust for further inventory write-downs ($35 mm), $60 mm FTC liability Adjusted TBV= ~$16 (14% upside) NCAV: $9.25- 9.72/share (~30% downside) Most conservative estimate of Asset Value
could look like without the Shape-up revenue 2005 operating results, which are 30% lower than 2007
Value of Growth
Assumes 2007 starting point for FCF ($70.2 mm)
Average 5% growth next ten years, 2% TG 11% Discount Rate, constant margins
Valuation Summary
Asset Value: Low: $9.25 High: $16 EPV Low: $13.26 (5% DS) High: $17.47 (24% US) DCF Base: $21 EPV > Asset Value =
company has competitive adv. in marketplace My competitive analysis suggests SKX is likely to maintain market position (but not necc. Increase) Stock likely worth between EPV values
Summary
Relying on DCF alone is dangerous It lumps together estimates based on good information with those based on very uncertain assumptions producing poor information It relies on making accurate estimates of events that are far in the future The 3-Stage Valuation model I have proposed emphasizes
current information and a knowledge about fundament competitive conditions It depends on specific knowledge about particular industries and assets, and it places less faith in projections of rosy futures unless substantiated by current hard date This is the discipline of value investing in the Graham and Dodd Tradition