Professional Documents
Culture Documents
QUALITY
Definition : 1) Fitness for use or fitness for the purpose :- Juran 2) Conformation to the customers requirements :- Crosby 3) Total composite of characteristics of products & services, to meet the need and expectations of the customer. :- Feigenbum 4) Degree of excellence at an acceptance-price (for the customer) and degree of control of variability at an acceptable cost (for the producer). :- Bohr 5) Totality of features and characteristics of products or services that bear on its ability to satisfy the stated as well as implied needs of the users. :- ISO :840 6) Degree of capability of fulfillment of customers or consumers requirement by the inherent characteristics and features of the product. 7) Quality is the measure of the (i) products conformance (how close) to the specifications (requirement)/ expectation of the customer or (ii) conformance to the standards recommended by the designer / the customer, and (iii) the degree of its satisfactory performance to the end-user. Quality = Actual Conformance / Performance of the product Expectation or Satisfaction or Requirement of users
INTRODUCTION
Before implementation of the Quality Management concept, the manufacturing was primarily inspection-oriented (ie accept or reject).
HISTORY OF TQM : # The journey of Quality Management started in 1920s with its pioneer Quality Guru Walter Shewhart, known as the Father of Statistical Quality Control.
# The American Quality Gurus who developed the Quality Management Concept, in the 1950s are W Edwards Deming, Joseph Juran and Armand Feigenbum.
# The Japanese Quality Gurus who added values to and extended the American Quality Management ideas and models are Kaoru Ishikawa, Genichi Taguchi and Shigeo Shingo. # The 1970-80s Western Quality Gurus, Philip Crosby and Tom Peters, further extended the Quality Management concepts after the Japanese successes. TQM : Joseph Juran in his QUALITY TRIOLOGY, indicated the three universal sequences required for Quality management, as (i) Quality Planning, (ii) Quality Control and (iii) Quality Improvement. # TQM additionally needs all out awareness, commitment & involvement (management, workforce, suppliers, & customers and all departments), not only to meet but also to exceed the customer expectations, by quality sustainance & improvement, leading towards achieving business excellence.
JOURNEY OF TQM
Statistical Methods applied to Quality Control Increased emphasis on Process Improvement Japan emerges as the World Quality Leader
19401960s
1920s 1940s
1940s
WALTER SHEWHART : Father of Statistical Quality Control & the pioneer in modern Quality Approach EDWARD DEMING :14 Points TQM Program, Top Management Leadership, Deming Wheel (PDCA), Continuous Improvement
J. JURAN (Quality Triology & Quality Cost), & A. Feigenbum (Management Leadership & commitment, Employees Involvement) Kaoru Ishikawa (Quality Circle, Fish Bone Analysis) & Genichi Taguchi (Quality Loss-Function, Robust Design, Signal-Noise Ratio) Philip Crosby (Zero Defect, Quality is free), Shigeo Shingo (Poka Yoke) KANO (Customer-Voice), QFD, FMEA, FTA, Six -Sigma, LEAN concept, SERVQUAL,
1960s 1970s
1970 1980s
1980s to-date
Evolution of TQM
1) WALTER SHEWHART (1920s): an employee of Bell Telephone developed technical tools of Statistical Quality Control, which are foundation of modern Quality Management. He is called Father of Statistical Quality Control. He introduced the philosophy of Quality Assurance. EDWARD DEMING (1940s): being a disciple of Shewhart, he changed the focus of Quality Assurance from technical/statistical aspect to Managerial commitment, support and responsibility. He advocated continuous improvement of production process. Deming discouraged inspection only at final stage and recommended quality checking at every stage from the beginning (raw materials). He also recommended extensive Involvement of operators (who knows the machines, process and problems more deeply) in quality maintenance and improvement. He also prescribed the thorough Training of operators on Quality Control and Improvement Techniques and methods. Deming Wheel ie P-D-C-A Cycle is an important technique for solving quality problem and continuous quality improvement. Demings 14 Points Philosophy has major influence on modern TQM.
2)
3)
JOSEPH JURAN (1950s) : Juran included Quality in the Strategic Planning process. Juran Triology is the three universal sequences or three phases of application of quality, which is suitable for any industry. Juran Triology includes (1) Quality Planning, (2) Quality Control and (3) Quality Improvement. Jurans COST OF QUALITY is an important concept for Quality decision. A. FEIGENBUM (1960s) : emphasized on Management Leadership & Commitment and introduced TQM as a total committed effort, company-wide from the management to employees throughout the organization, to improve quality continually. PHILIP CROSBY (1970s) : He emphasized on Cost of Poor Quality (like loss in cost of manpower, materials, machine-hour, loss of sales, cost of Customer dissatisfaction, etc). He advised for ZERO DEFECT production. He indicated Four Absolutes of Quality Management as, (1) Quality should be in conformance to requirements, (2) Prevention of non-conformance is Objective but not appraisal, (3) Performance Standard is Zero Defect, not that is close enough (4) Measurement of quality is through Cost of Non-conformance. He prescribed 14 point Prescription for Quality Improvement.
4)
5)
6)
K. ISHIKAWA (1970s) : He promoted QUALITY CIRCLE and FISHBONE DIAGRAM of Cause & Effect Analysis. His philosophy that a quality organization is needed to create a quality product or service has been accepted as the base of modern TQM. Genichi Taguchi (1980s) : He developed QUALITY LOSS FUNCTION concept which combines Cost, Target and Variation in performance Characteristics into one metric. Because Quality Loss Function is reactive, he developed Signal to Noise Ratio as a proactive equivalent. Robust Design of parameters & tolerance is the outcome of his philosophy.
7)
#
1) 2)
3)
4) 5) 6)
7)
8) 9) 10) 11) 12) 13)
#
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
#
1.
2.
3.
4.
5. 6.
7.
Suppliers or Vendor selection will be mainly based on their quality commitment and not based on the lowest price only. Constantly improve the quality system focusing on the (i) process and (ii) Operator. Workers Training is essential . The training should be focused on (i) Identification & Solving the quality problem, (ii) effective use of SQC techniques & other Quality Tools (iii) Continuous improvement. Instill Leadership among supervisors to guide and help operators to perform better.
8.
9. 10. 11.
Encourage employees involvement by (i) eliminating Fear of identifying quality problems , (ii) treating them with dignity and (iii) encouraging them to contribute ideas for improvement (ie innovation). Eliminate barriers between different departments and promote
cooperation & TEAM-APPROACH, for working together.
Target / focus on QUALITY and not on quantity (Eliminate numerical quota set for operators to meet at any cost without regard to quality). Eliminate slogans for quality target (ie urging upon workers for achieving higher quality-performance level) without providing specific processimprovement.
12.
13. 14.
Enhance workers PRIDE of WORKMANSHIP and SELF ESTEEM by recognizing & appreciating their participation & sincere efforts, so that workers can perform to their capabilities and considering himself as a family member of the organization having same mission. Vigorous quality-awareness Training & Education program at all levels throughout the organization. Develop & ensure Top Managements COMMITMENT to implement the above points.
#
1)
2)
3)
QUALITY IMPROVEMENT (i) Establish infrastructure needed to secure periodic quality improvement
(ii) Identify Quality-improvement PROJECTS (iii) Form Teams to implement improvement projects (iv) Provide resources, motivation and training to the team for quality improvement.
Quality variation
Quality Planning & Organizing
Quality Control Quality Improvement
Variation Limit
Chronic Waste
Time
Quality Improvement
QUALITY COST is the costs associated with providing quality of the product or
service ie cost incurred to ensure perfect / approved quality of product or service.
A.
1)
QUALITY COST
(i) Scrap (Rejections which are not re-workable or repairable) (ii) Re-doing/ Re-working on Rejections which are re-workable or repairable, Over-time for re-doing, Re-inspection & testing (iii) Re-ordering (iv) Servicing / Repairing at site when the product fails in operation, (v) Return and Replacement of defectives, (vi) Process Failure Analysis (causes of failure of the production process) (vii) Process-downtime (shutting down the production process (1) to prevent continuing generation of defects, and (2) to identify & locate the problem and its cause and to rectify, (viii) Price discount (in case of selling the defectives as Seconds) (ix) Penalty for late delivery
(x) Excessive Inventory
Hidden Costs (which are difficult to quantify), associated with non-conformance of product to customer requirements. It includes cost of (i) Complaint-handling,
(ii) Customer Dissatisfaction leading to loss of customers, (iii) Loss of goodwill / brand image, (iv) Loss of sales. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Q*
Optimum Qualitity
Quality
[Index shows the trend of quality improvement. Reduction of Quality Index shows the quality improvement.] ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
[ It shows the trend of Productivity improvement. QPR can be increased by (i) Quality improvement , and/or (ii) reducing of re-working cost, and/or (iii) by reducing the processing cost.]
Example-1 on QPR
H S Motor Co. produces electric motors at a processing cost of $30 per unit and defective ones can be reworked at an average cost of $12 per unit. The Co. produces 100 motors/day out of which 80% are of good quality and 50% of the defective products can only be reworked to acceptable quality level. The Co. wants to improve the productivity and ask you to give your impression on the effect of following 4 different proposals on productivity improvement,
(i) Increase the production rate to 200 motors/day, (ii) Reduce the processing cost to $27 and reworking cost to $10, (iii) Increase the product yield of good quality to 95%, by process improvement, with increase in processing cost to $ 30.20 per unit, (iv) Increase the product yield of good quality to 85% by process improvement, along with reduction of reworking cost to $10 per unit.
80 + 0.5 x 20 = 0.0289 100x$30 + 10x$12 Proposal-1 : Increase the production rate increased to 200 motors/day, QPR1 = 160 + 0.5 x 40 = 0.0289 QPR1 = QPR0 200x$30 + 20x$12 Proposal-2 : Reduce the processing cost to $27 and reworking cost to $10, QPR2 = 80 + 0.5 x 20 = 0.03214 QPR2 > QPR0 100x$27 + 10x$10 Proposal-3 : Increase the product yield of good quality by quality improvement to 95%, with increase in processing cost to $ 30.20 per unit, QPR3 = 95+ 0.5 x 5 = 0.03197 QPR3 > QPR0 100x$30.20 + 2.5x$12 QPR3 < QPR2 Proposal-4 : Increase the product yield of good quality by quality improvement to 85%, along with reduction of the reworking cost to $10, QPR4 = 85+ 0.5 x 15 = 0.03008 QPR4 < QPR3 100x$30 + 7.5x$10 QPR2 > QPR3 > QPR4 >QPR1 & QPR0
QPR is maximum in Proposal-2 (by Reducing the processing cost to $27 and reworking cost to $10). So, proposal-2 may be adopted for Productivity improvement.
Example-2 on QPR
H S Motor Co. produces electric motors at a processing cost of $30 per unit and defective ones can be reworked at an average cost of $12 per unit. The Co. produces 100 motors/day out of which 75% good quality and 40% of the defectives can only be reworked to acceptable quality level. The Co. wants to improve the productivity and ask you to give your impression on the effect of following 4 different proposals on productivity improvement, (i) Increase the production rate by 50%, (ii) Reduce the processing cost to $28 and reworking cost to $10, (iii) Increase the product yield of good quality by quality improvement to 85%, (iv) Increase the product yield of good quality by quality improvement to 95%, with an increase of the processing cost to $30.50.
[Ans : QPR1 = QPR0 = 0.02724 , QPR2 = 0.02931 , QPR3 = 0.02962 , QPR4 = 0.03155 . QPR4> QPR3 > QPR2 >QPR1 & QPR0 ]
Committed and involved Management : to provide long term Leadership and organizational support Focus on Customer, both internal & external Effective Involvement & Participation of entire Workforce, Empowerment of participating workforce Quality Training for entire workforce
Quality Culture and Team Spirit among entire workforce in any department and among all departments Quality Management System (QMS) & Quality Assurance CONTINUOUS IMPROVEMENT of Business Process and Production Process Forming Quality Steering Committee / Quality Council , headed by CEO and members from different sections and the Quality Manager; and under Q Council, Quality Sub-Groups at different sections or branches, for TQM implementation operation in big industries. Continuous Self Performance Measurement and Benchmarking for the Process and performance Good communication both internal & external Collaborative relation with suppliers / vendors (Treating the SUPPLIER as PARTNER)
5.
6. 7. 8. 9.
BENEFITS of TQM
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. Improvement of Quality of products and services and its consistency Improvement of competitiveness Improved Delivery commitment Improved Customer-satisfaction Increase of Market Share Reduction of Scrap and cost of defectives Reduction in Inventory Increase of Productivity and Profitability Improved Team work and Team spirit Increase of Employees involvement and participation Improved Employees self-esteem & motivation Improved Communication both internal and external
INSPECTION
INSPECTION
Inspection may be (i) Pre-shipment (In-shop Final Inspection), (ii) Stage
Inspection, (iii) Third-Party Inspection by authorized & appointed Inspection Agency, (iv) Customs inspection (on Quality, Quantity and Price) (v) Inspection at receiving end ,for quality & quantity.
TYPES of INSPECTION
1. Stage Inspection : during Procurement, Manufacturing/
Operational process and Assembly, before Pre-shipment (final) inspection on output products, by manufacturers inspection team and/or Buyers representatives.
2.
3.
4.
5.
QUALITY-INSPECTION
(A) INSPECTION METHODS :
comparison) (mainly Measurement, testing &
(1) Visual (colour, shape, finish, damage, etc) (2) Touching (mainly for finish, fitting, texture, etc) (3) Smelling (odour or correct smell like coconut oil, chemicals, talcum powder, perfume, some of food staff, etc), where ever applicable (4) Measurement [size/dimensions, tolerances, capacity (by volume or weight), weight, density, viscosity, voltage, current, electrical resistance, electrical power, speed, pH, etc] (5) Gauging (Go & Not-go, match or no-match type) (6) Testing in Laboratories (strength, hardness, efficiency, performance, micro cracks or internal cracks (X-ray testing / Radiography) , pressure rating, temperature rating, etc) (7) Comparison of measured data (i) with quality data of standard sample or (ii) data prescribed in relevant Standard or (iii) specified data
(B) SAMPLING :
Picking up an adequate number (Sample Size) of items (from an big lot of the same item, offered for Inspection), which truly represent the entire population of the offered/ referred lot, with the purpose of Inspection and Testing, with the OBJECTIVE to considerably reduce the (i) Insp. Time, (ii) Insp. Cost, (iii) Insp. effort, (iv) Insp. Fatigue, (v) Insp. Manpower, (vi) Damage of products (in case of destructive testing), for inspection.
The true Sample must be the real representatives of the whole population.
For inspection, Acceptance Sampling is the process of inspecting / evaluating a portion of the products in a lot called Sample, for the purpose of accepting the complete lot as conforming, or rejecting the complete lot as Non-conforming to the quality specification.
(i)
1)
SAMPLING METHODS :
Simple Random Sampling : All the items of the sample are
arbitrarily (at random) selected from any where of the entire lot. Each item of the population has equal probability to be selected & inspected.
2)
3)
Systematic Sampling :
When the lot size of the product is very big and the lot is presented in many groups like stacks, piles, bins, chambers, etc., Systematic Sampling may be suitably adopted. In this method, adequate no. of sample-items are systematically selected from the systematically selected piles or stacks or bins, etc of the lot, at regular predetermined interval to meet the Sample Size (depending on the size of the lot). [example : 3rd, 13th, 23rd, 33 rd, ..items from 1st stack; 7th, 17th, 27th, 37th, items from 2nd stack, and so on] or K number of items randomly from each of the 2nd , 5th, 8th, 11th, 14th , . stack)
4)
Cluster Sampling :
When the lot contains a (i) good number of clusters or packs, (ii) each of small no. of items. First random sampling is done on the packs/clusters in the lot and then all the items of the selected sample-packs (which constitute Sample Size) are inspected.
5)
Two-stage Sampling :
When a huge lot size, containing a good number of packs or sub-lots, each pack/sub-lot containing a good number of items, Two-stage Sampling may be adopted. In this method, at the first stage, selection of packs is done randomly or systematically from the good number of packs in the lot, and then at the second stage, selection of items is again done randomly or systematically from the each of the selected sample-pack.
(ii)
SAMPLE SIZE :
The Sample Size is the minimum statistically adequate number of sample-items to be selected from the whole lot / population, by any sampling method, for the purpose of quality Inspection of the offered lot. Sample Size depends on, (i) Variation in observations (measurements Xi) in the population (ii) Status of existence of items (Mixed / Focused / Stratified / Clustered or Continuous / Categorical) (ii) Confidence Level / Significance Level (Z is dependent on Conf. L) (iv) Precision Interval (h is dependent on Precision Interval)
N sample
= Z2 . [ N Xi 2 - ( Xi)2 ] h2 ( Xi)2
where, Z = Standard Normal Statistics at given CONFIDENCE LEVEL (90% to 98%) which indicates probability of getting correct representative result.