Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Michael Koester Interoperability Test Director C2 Systems Branch/JITC (520) 538-4230 Michael.koester@disa.mil
C2 Lab Mission
Mission
Provide C2 interoperability testing & certification
Objectives:
Ensure accurate information exchange Verify interoperability Assist in problem resolution Develop rigorous and repeatable testing through configuration management and automated test tools
Why Interoperability?
Identifies
Inaccurate data Missing data Systems interoperability limitations Critical information lose
Leads to
Great user awareness of inaccuracies Less user confusion over inaccuracies
Verifies new fielded systems are interoperable Satisfies Joint Staff certification requirement
Test Process
Requirements
Net-Readiness KPP Joint Mission Threads Information Exchange Requirements
National IBS Tactical USMTF OTH-G Link 11 Link 16 VMF Systems GCCS-J GCCS-M TBMCS GCCS-A Etc. Sim
Execution
Test Environments
Sim
TIBS
TDDS ETMS SCTD
Lab Distributed
Actual Applications/Systems
Real Users
Evaluation
Accuracy
Certification Letter
Operational
Completeness
Usability
Timeliness
MS-B KDP-B
DAB/DSAB/ITAB REFINE ANALYSIS
MS-C KDP-C
DAB/DSAB/ITAB REFINE ANALYSIS
ICD
CDD
JROC
Test and Evaluation Master Plan (TEMP) J-6 Interoperability and Supportability Certification DOT&E Review
CPD
JROC
DISA (JITC) Interoperability Certification Testing IA Accreditation (DITSCAP) J-6 interoperability and Supportability Certification Service/Agency Operational Testing
IOC
JROC
Requirements -Review ICDs, ISPs, CDDs, CPDs, TEMPs -Ensure systems are measurable and testable -Need to start influencing this according to our metrics
Planning -Develop plans and metrics to answer I-KPP / NR-KPPs (IERS) -Identifying sites based on use of critical interfaces -Coordinate with other PMs/Services/test agencies
Test Conduct -Conduct technical / standards testing (lab / sim) -Conduct functional / end to end interoperability testing (operational / real users / sites)
Reporting -Produce assessment / certification letters / reports for Joint Staff, PMs, DOT&E, COCOMS
J6 Validation
C2 Complexities
Force Readiness Force Projection Force Projection Force Sustainment Force Sustainment
GCCS-J
SORTS Strategic SORTS Strategic Server Server
GCCS J Infrastructure GCCS-J Infrastructure COE Infrastructure COE Infrastructure Intelligence
JOPES JOPES Strategic Strategic Server Server GCSS (CC/JTF) GCSS (CC/JTF) Strategic Server Strategic Server
GCCS -J Infrastructure GCCS-J Infrastructure COE Infrastructure COE Infrastructure
JETJET RPI RQT RQT TLT TLT DVT DVT Sch TMT & Move JEPES RPI Scheduling & Movement JEPES TMT TMT
JOPES Infrastructure JOPES Infrastructure GCCS -J Infrastructure GCCS-J Infrastructure COE Infrastructure COE Infrastructure JFRG JFRG II II
Stand Stand alone alone JOPES JOPES client client
Force Employment
Integrated Integrated Imagery Imagery and and Intelligence Intelligence (I3) (I3)
ATO COP Weather COP Visualization Readiness Readiness Tools Interface Segments Weather Interface Dynamic Track COP Sync Assessment AssessmentCOP Sync Segments Group/Assoc Tools ATO Visualization Dynamic Track Group/Assoc System System COP Infrastructure
ACOA ACOA
JC2 COI
NCES
Force Protection
Situational Awareness
JITC
GCCS-A (JOPES) (USA) GCSS1, 2 (CC/JTF)
CSDS, CFDB, DMDC, Fed Links, FLIS, GDDS, GDSS GTN, JOPES, JTAV NGA, SORTS
As of 10/24/05
EPLRS (USA) GALE-LITE (DIA) GCCS-A (COP) (USA) GCCS-M (USN) ETMS ICC (NATO)
JOIIS (NATO/NC3A)
JSTARS (USAF) LATTEL (NORAD) FNMOC (NITES II) (USN) NGA NRTD (NSA) OMNITK (DISA) SBMCS (SPACECOM) TBMCS (USAF) TII
AMHS/DMS4 (DISA) NTP4 (USN) ASAS-RWS (I3) (USA) IOS (USMC) IPL (I3DB) (NGA) MIDB (I3DB) (DIA) PRISM UAV CGS
OTH-G
LINK 11A
LINK 11B
LINK 16
TDDS3
TIBS3
USMTF
JITC IOP Certified JITC IOP Assessment Not Certified or Not Tested
One-way Query
One-way Data
Two-way Data
* Interfaces based on the GCCS-J Test and Evaluation Master Plan, Block IV Annex, 1 December 2003 and other requirement sources 1 Force Readiness 2 Force Sustainment 3 Will become part of Integrated Broadcast Service 4 Cross Functional/Infrastructure * TBD Information unavailable in the GCCS-J V4.X, ICD
Evaluation Measures
Measure of Interoperability
Can GCCS-J effectively exchange information with X system?
Measures of Performance
Accuracy
Verify data sent or queried is the data received or displayed
Completeness
Verify all expected data received
Usability
Can the warfighter utilize the capability in an efficient manner to meet mission requirements
Test Events
GCCS-J v4.0 JOPES SSE OT&E, Jun 05 (GCCS-AF/DCAPES, GCCS-A) Integrated Broadcast System Test, (GCCS-J/M), Sep 04 JIT 04-06, Oct 04 (GCCS-J/M Link 11/16 receive) GCCS-M v4.0 TechEval, Sep/Oct 04 GCCS-J v4.0 Global SAT, Dec 04 GCCS-M v4.0 OT&E, Dec 04/Jan 05 CST Test, Mar 05 (GCCS-J, GCCS-M, GCCS-A, TBMCS) GCCS-AF/DCAPES DT&E, Mar 05 GCCS-J v4.0 JOPES SSE SAT, Apr 05 GCCS-J v4.0 Global OT&E, Apr 05 GCCS-M v4.0.1 Regression Test, Jun 05 GCCS-J v4.0 JOPES SSE OT&E Jun 05 GCCS-J v4.0.1 JOPES and Global Regression Test, Jul 05
Situational Awareness
Air Tracks ATO Targets Ground Units TBMs Maritime Tracks Overlays - Air Routes - Airspace Control - Weapons Range
ADSI MTDS Radiant Mercury JTT MATT
NGA Maps Targets - MIDB Xref - Imagery Xref NRTI Data Collection Mgmt 3D Sensor Coverage Terrain Masking Sensor Status
SIPRNET/GCCS LAN
OTH-G MDX CSTMDXNET
USMTF JVMF
MIDB
IPL
C/S/A Systems
Tactical Systems
Broadcasts
AUTODIN/ DMS
Intel Systems
Imagery Systems
METOC
Link11 Link16
1553
11 16 L 11 16 11 16 L 11 16
GCCS-J LEGEND: GCCS-J 4.0 CST 4.5.7.0 MTC 4.5.9.5 TADIL A/B 4.5.2.9 GCCS-J 3.6.6 CST 2.1.2.0 MTC 2.3.0.11 TADIL A/B 3.1.0.7
S 11
L 16
TAP S 11
TAP S 16
TAP S 11
TAP L 16
TCP/IP GCCS-M 4.0 COMMS1, NETRA20 GCCS-M 4.0 PC Client GCCSM0001 GCCS-M 3.x JOTS1, HP 9000 GCCS-J 3.6.6 POOH, ULTRA 2
CSTXAN2PIG PORT 9119
S L
GCCS-M LEGEND: GCCS-M 4.0 CST 4.5.7.0 MTC 4.5.9.5 TADIL A/B 4.5.2.9 GCCS-M 3.x CST 2.1.3.0 MTC 2.3.0.121 TADIL A/B 3.1.0.7
JOINT
SBMCS
TRANSCOM
GCCS-J V3.6.7 GCCS-J V4.0
ETMS
ARMY
NAVY
AIR FORCE
GCCS-A V3.2.5.1 P8
GCCS-M V3.1.2.5 P9
GCCS-M V4.0
TBMCS V1.1.1
TBMCS V1.1.3
JITC
GCCS-J
XANDER WILLOW KANGA DAWN TOP COP 280R Web Server 4.0 ANGEL 280R Infra Admin 4.0 SPIKE Ultra 2 TMS GCCS-J 3.6.7 9119 280R TMS GCCS-J 4.0 9125 V480 TMS GCCS-J 4.0 3.x 9119 4.0 9125 GCCS-A 3.2.5.1 P8 9119 C2PC PC Client V5.9.0.3P6 C2PC PC Client V6.1 GCCS-J 4.0 PC Client GILES
GCCS-A
GCCSA002
TIGGER A
ANYA
BUFFY B
Legend
9119 SAASVR F TBMCS 1.1.1 TBMCS 1.1.3 9119 UBMSTRB G A B C E Inject/Feed CST via SIPRNET C Link 11, Link 16, USMTF, OTH-G, TDDS, ETMS Link 11, Link 16, USMTF, TDDS, OTH-G, ETMS, SBMCS D Link 11, Link 16, USMTF, OTH-G, TDDS
9119 JOTS1
9125 COMMS1 D
TBMCS
GCCS-M
AFC2ISRC
Injects will occur one at a time A, B, C, etc. and verified at each participating system.
The following non-critical interfaces were not assessed for interoperability. AMHS, EPLRs, GALE-LITE, GDSS, GTN, ICC, JOIIS, JSTARS, LATTEL, OMNITK, SDDC-TEA and TIBS.
PACOM GCSS
MARFORLANT MAGTF II
Certification Status
SYSTEM GCCS-J 3.x GCCS-J 4.x GTN-21 GCCS-A B3 GCCS-A B4 COMPASS GCCS-M 3.x GCCS-M 4.x DCAPES 4.0.1.2 TBMCS 1.1.2 IOS V1 MEF IAS MAGTF II 6.3 CERTIFIED ORD/CDD/ CPD NO NO (1) 9 FEB 2001 NO 16 NOV 2000 NO 12 FEB 1999 12 FEB 1999 (4) 28 MAR 1996 (5) 9 JUL 2001 NO DRAFT NO CERTIFIED NRKPP/IERS NO NO (1) YES (2) NO YES (2) NO NO (3) YES (2)(1) NO (5) YES (2) NO NO NO INTEGRATED ARCH PRODUCTS NO NO (1) NO NO NO NO NO NO (1) NO NO NO NO NO TEST CERTIFICATION STATUS Specified Interface Ass Specified Interface Ass ? Specified Interface Ass Strategic Sp Int Ass Operational FY06 GCCS-J Sp Int Ass Specified Interface Ass Certified Specified Interface Ass Specified Interface NONE ? Specified Interface Ass
Status Reporting
Standards Conformance Certification System is certified for conformance to a standard System-level Interoperability Test Certification Full system certification. System meets all certified interoperability requirements (I-KPP) Specified Interfaces Certification System meets subset of the certified interoperability requirements Non-Certification System is fielded -- critical operational impacts expected Provides a warning to the Warfighter
Interoperability Assessment System is not ready for interoperability certification, but PM would like to determine how well certain interfaces interoperate System may lack Joint Staff certified requirements
Summary
Ensure systems are interoperable when fielded Ensure warfighters are aware of limitations and inaccuracies Identify interoperability requirements not specified in documents Help improve operating procedures
Contact Information
ADSI AMHS AMP BCAT/LOGCAT JSTARS CAMPS
POC:
JFRG II JFAST
BROADCAST FORMATS
Mr. Michael Koester TIBS IPL (I3) C2 Systems Branch/JITC TDDS ICC Comm (520) 538-4230 TC-AIMS II DSN 879-4230 GTN (SMINT) Michael.Koester@disa.mil GTN (C2INT) TBMCS koesterm@fhu.disa.smil.mil GTN SORTS
UAV GCS
LATTEL COMPASS MAGTF II DCAPES EPLRS MIDB (I3DB) NTP Time OMNITK NSOF FOCUS ETMS
Web URLs:
GDSS
SDDC-TEA SBMCS
FNMOC
MESSAGE FORMATS http://jitc.fhu.disa.mil/gccsiop GCCS-M GALE-LITE http://jitc.fhu.disa.mil/cop GCCS-A (JOPES) GCCS-A (COP) http://199.208.204.125/gccsiop/index.html
GCSS CC/JTF
DODD 5105.19
DISA shall ensure end-to-end interoperability.
CJCSI 6212.01C
All IT and NSS must be evaluated and certified for Joint interoperability by DISA (JITC).
DOD 4630/5000
DODI 4630.8
Interoperability is the ability to provide and accept data, information, materiel, and services ... ...includes both the technical exchange of information and the end-to-end operational effectiveness of that exchange, as required for mission accomplishment. DOD 5000 series
CJCSI 3170.01D
All IT and NSS must be tested for interoperability before fielding ... and certified by DISA (JITC).
For IT systems, including NSS, ... JITC shall provide system interoperability test certification memoranda ... throughout the system life-cycle and regardless of ACAT.
JITC
GSORTS (CC/JTF) GTN 4.5.2 (CC/JTF) GTN (C2INT)
vTBD
As of 8/17/04
ASAS-RWS 2.5 (USA) COLISEUM vTBD (DIA) COP TSE 1.3.3.0 (TRANSCOM) GCCS-A * Block III (USA) GCCS-M 3.1.2.1P1 (USN) IBS vTBD
V1 (TCO), V2 (IAS) (USMC)
GTN (SMINT)
vTBD
JEPES 6.0.2.0 JFAST 8.0 (TRANSCOM) JFRG II 1.4.1.2 JOPES (CC/JTF) JTAV (CC/JTF) MAGTF II 6.3 (USMC) MAT 2.0 NIMA Airfields Data (CC/JTF) RUDRS 3.0 (USN) SORTS v7.3.0.0 (NMCC) DMS 3.0 JDIICS-D (DISA) JSCS (JCS) USMTF TIBS TDDS OTH-G LINK 16 LINK 11B LINK 11A TBMD vTBD (BMDO) TBMCS 1.1.2 (USAF)
IOS 3.6.0.0 *
GCCS 3.x
Force Projection Force Employment Situational Awareness Force Sustainment Force Readiness Force Protection Intelligence
JMS 3.0.2.0 (METOC) (USN) JOIIS 1.0.1.0 LATTEL 1.1.1.1 LOGFAC 3.3.1.0 (USAF) MIDB 2.0 (I3DB) (DIA) NRTD vTBD OmniTRAC 1.0.1.0 PLRS/EPLRS 9.4.3 SCTD 1.0.3.0 (SPACECOM) SOF IV vTBD (SOCOM) SWPS-SIOP (STRATCOM)
Based on GCCS 3.X RID and EPIP , 22 Dec 98; ICD, 31 May 01; and other requirement sources. For additional information go to: http://jitc.fhu.disa.mil/gccsiop/ * Full capability not assessed. Certification is limited to the items addressed in the certification letter.
Certification
Environments
1. Laboratory/HWIL Comprehensive data collection for multiple tests under controlled conditions. Can include realistic loads and Hardware In The Loop. Test asset availability provides a representative sample of joint service participation.
Live
Interoperability Tests
Laboratory
Note: MIL-STDs provide a necessary building block for ensuring interoperability, but are not sufficient to ensure that systems are interoperable in a joint environment. Building Block Approach
2. Live Exercise/OT Event Tests ability to effectively exchange information with joint participants in an exercise or test environment with conditions as realistic as possible. Ensures end-to-end interoperability (after component integration) to assure total system interoperability effectiveness
Test Venues
Joint Interoperability Test Service Testing OT&E
GLOBAL
IBS 27-29 Sept 04
12 29 Oct 04
NCTSI
Service GCCS Variants DT/OT
18 26 Apr 05
At COCOMs Operationally Realistic Environment
ADSI/Link 11/16
CST Event 14 18 Mar 05 Distributed event w/services GCCS-J, GCCS-A, GCCS-M, TBMCS 4.0.1 Regression Test 5 8 July 05 @ JITC 11-15 July @ DISA
Lab/Technical
TDDS/TAB37
18 22 July @ PACOM
DCAPES DT Monitor progress / track problem reports JOPES SS SIT 14 18 Mar 05 Monitor progress / track problem reports JOPES SS SAT 4 8 Apr 05 FORSCOM, TRANSCOM, ACC, MARFORLANT Lab and Operationally Realistic Environment
JOPES SSE
GCCS-A DT Monitor progress / track problem reports JOPES SS Technical Test 28 Mar 1 Apr 2005 Monitor progress / track problem reports
JOPES SS OT&E
9 May 20 May 05 TRANSCOM, FORSCOM, MARFORLANT, ACC Operationally Realistic Environment
ADSI*
AMHS EPLRS ETMS* GALE-LITE GCCS-A* GCCS-M* GDSS
JITC
N/A N/A JITC/TRANS N/A JITC JITC N/A
JIT/CST
N/A N/A CST/OT N/A CST CST N/A
GTN
ICC JOIIS JOPES/SORTS
N/A
N/A N/A CENTCOM
N/A
N/A N/A OT Site
TBMCS*
TDDS* TIBS UAV GCS* Events
Langley
JITC/CENT JITC/CENT SOCOM
CST
IBS/CST/OT CST/OT OT
Interface
Interfaces with an * are critical. GCSS is not listed in current TEMP Annex. Italics Can data be collected during OT or CST event?
GCSS* (CFDB, FLIS, GTN, JTAV, NGA, GDSS, DMDC, GDS, JOPES, SORTS)
PACOM
OT
Not assessed Met Met Not Met Met Met Met Met Met Met Met Met Met Met Met Met
Not assessed Met Met Not Met Met Met Met Met Met Met Met Met Met Met Met Met
Not assessed Met Met Met Met Not Met Met Not Met Not Met Met Met Not Met Met Not assessed Met Met N/A Not Met Met Met Met Met Not assessed Met Met Not assessed N/A Met N/A Met N/A Met N/A Met N/A Met
C4I COMPLEXITIES
STAR Office SENSOR REP TRS TAB 37 TAC ELINT
JOINT
Readiness
Force Planning
Situational Awareness
I3
AIR FORCE
TBMCS DCAPES AOC WS GCSS-AF
NAVY
AHORE
AFLOAT TAC-MOBILE GCSS-N
MARINE CORPS
IOS/TCO
IOS/IAS MAGTF II GCSS-MC
ARMY
MCS
GCSS-A
Future C2
Users
National Military Command System
Intel
Sensors
Logistics Finance
DOD & nonDOD Agencies IC Components HLS/HLD Components Combatant Commands Service Headquarters JTF Components
C2
Weapon Systems
Personnel
Etc.
J C 2
ESM
Unit Level Commanders Multinational Components
Mediation
Messaging
Collaboration
User Asst
Discovery
Security/IA
Storage
App
Other Assets
ADSI Link11 Link16 M&S Link16 OTH-G TDDS TIBS Link11 USMTF
GCCS I3
Capability IPL MIDB
COP Suite
Multiple TDBMs COP Clients C2PCs
GCCS Suite
Deliberate and Crisis Action Planning (JOPES) Situational Awareness (COP) Office Automation
Other Locations
COCOMs Services Agencies
Systems
e.g., GCCS-A GCCS-M IOS (TCO/IAS)
JDEP CS3