Professional Documents
Culture Documents
W2-01/03/2014
LOGO
Presentation Agenda
Readings for Block 3: Reading 12: The Competitive advantage of nations Reading 13: National Policies and domestic politics Block 3: Unit 4 (sections 4.3 & 4.4)
W2-01/03/2014 2 Copyright Material Arab Open University Egypt Branch-B301B
LOGO
Reading 12
The Competitive Advantage of Nations
W2-01/03/2014
Porter argued that a nation can create new advanced factor endowments (talents) such as skilled labour, a strong technology and knowledge base, government support and culture. A nations competitiveness depends on the capacity of its industry to innovate and upgrade. Companies gain advantage against the worlds best competitors because of pressure and challenge. They benefit from having strong domestic rivals, aggressive home-base suppliers, and demanding local customers. According to Porter, a nation attains a competitive advantage if its firms are competitive. Firms become competitive through innovation. Innovation can include technical improvements to the product or to the production process. Porter used a diamond shaped diagram as the basis of a framework to illustrate the determinants of national advantage. This diamond represents the national plying field that countries establish for their industries. Copyright Material Arab Open W24 University Egypt Branch-B301B 01/03/201
Information plays a large role in the process of innovation and improvement information that either is not available to competitors or that they do not seek, it comes simple investment in R&D or market research, or from effort and from openness and from looking in the right place. The only way to sustain a competitive advantage is to upgrade it to move to more sophisticated types. (i.e. Japan cars). Two additional prerequisites for sustaining competitive advantage:
1. A company must adopt a global approach to strategy. It must sell its product worldwide, under its own brand name, through international marketing channels that it controls. This approach require the company to locate production or R&D facilities in other nations to take advantage of lower wage rates, to gain or improve market access, or to take advantage of foreign technology. 2. Creating more sustainable advantages often means that a company must make its existing advantage obsolete even while it is still an advantage.
5 Copyright Material Arab Open University Egypt Branch-B301B W2-01/03/2014
W2-01/03/2014
1. Factor Conditions
By factor condition: it is meant the nations position in terms of factors of production such skilled labour or infrastructure necessary to compete in a given industry. Most of the factors of production that are required in todays sophisticated and knowledge-intensive industries are created factors (such as skilled human resources or a scientific base). thus a nation does not inherit (get) but instead creates the most important factors of production. This is in contrast to the old doctrine (guideline) of factors of production labour, land, natural resources, capital, infrastructure. Even educated workface is not enough what matters most is specialized workface e.g. in chemical industries, optics.etc. Governments may have an important role in creating or supporting the creation of factors of production by funding training and support specialized scientific institutions.
8 Copyright Material Arab Open University Egypt Branch-B301B W2-01/03/2014
2. Demand Conditions
Porter argues that a sophisticated domestic market is an important element to producing competitiveness. Firms that face a sophisticated domestic market are likely to sell superior products because the market demands high quality and a close proximity to such consumers enables the firm to better understand the needs and desires of the customers. Nations gain competitive advantage in industries where the home demand gives their companies a cleared or earlier picture of emerging buyer needs, and where demanding buyers pressure companies to innovate faster and achieve more sophisticated competitive advantages than their foreign rivals. Demanding and sophisticated consumers in the home market can pressure companies to meet high standards and innovate faster than their foreign rivals. Government policy can aid this process by instituting and strict product safety and environmental standards
9 Copyright Material Arab Open University Egypt Branch-B301B W2-01/03/2014
11 W2-01/03/2014
Porter argues that the best management styles vary among industries. Some countries may be oriented toward a particular style of management. Those countries will tend to be more competitive in industries for which that style of management is suited. Individual motivation to work and expand skills is also important to competitive advantage. For example, Germany tends to have hierarchical management structures composed of managers with strong technical backgrounds and Italy has smaller, familyCopyright Material Arab Open W2-01/03/2014 run firms. 14 University Egypt Branch-B301B
B. Structure
C . Rivalry
Porter argues the presence of strong local rivals is a final, and powerful, stimulus to the creation and persistence of competitive advantage. Competition is particularly strong in Japan, where many companies compete strongly in most industries. Domestic rivalry, like any rivalry, creates pressure on companies to innovate and improve. Local rivals push each other to lower costs, improve quality and service, and create new products and processes, also will keep each other honest in obtaining government support Copyright Material Arab Open W2-01/03/2014 15
University Egypt Branch-B301B
16
1. The effect of one point depends on the others. For example, factor disadvantages will not lead firms to innovate unless there is sufficient rivalry. The diamond also is a self-reinforcing system. For example, a high level of rivalry often leads to the formation of unique specialized factors. At the broadest level, weaknesses in any one determinant will constrain an industrys potential for advancement and upgrading. But the points of the diamond are also self-reinforcing: they form a system. Two elements, domestic rivalry and geographic concentration, have especially great power to transform the diamond into a system domestic rivalry because it promotes improvement in all the other determinants, and geographic concentration because it elevates and magnifies the interaction of the four separate W2-01/03/2014 Copyright Material Arab Open influences. 17
University Egypt Branch-B301B
20
W2-01/03/2014
W2-01/03/2014
1. Create pressure for innovation: A company should expose themselves to challenges to have incentive to innovate and sell to customer with difficult needs or provide material from advanced suppliers. 2. Seek out the most capable competitors as motivators Company should be dynamic and meet new challenges by studying and respecting competitors and compete with them 3. Establish early-warning systems Company had to investigate new buyers, competitors and maintain relation with research centres 4. Improve the national diamond For international success firm had to improve their national position through forming clusters and deal with local buyers, suppliers to help them upgrade.
23 Copyright Material Arab Open University Egypt Branch-B301B W2-01/03/2014
Government policy can support each factor in this diamond; in factor conditions, supporting specialized scientific institutions. In demand condition, government policy can aid this process by instituting and enforcing strict product, safety and environmental standards. In related and supporting industries, government policy may support the formation of regional and national clusters by encouraging the creation of appropriate regional infrastructure. In firm's strategy, structure and rivalry, government policy can influence a firm's behaviour in this respect in various ways, such as through its taxation policies towards long-term investment and through the nature of its competition policies. Government policy needs to take account of how the four elements of the diamond interact with each other, and try to ensure that they reinforce and complement each other, to increase the capacity of a nation to innovate and Copyright Material Arab Open W2-01/03/2014 25 upgrade. University Egypt Branch-B301B
Government policy
W2-01/03/2014
26
28
W2-
W2-01/03/2014
29
Introduction
Formally, the interaction between domestic policy and international business runs in two directions. States erect policies that affect firms' ability to trade and invest across borders; and the actions of trading and investing firms affect the political climate of the states in which they do business. The relationship, of course, is interactive and changes over time: states influence firms, and firms influence states, and both operate simultaneously in a number of domestic and international arenas. This article concentrates on just one piece of this complex arrangement. Arguing that international business is essentially, incontrovertibly (unquestionably) political, it describes the range of state policies that can shape and constrain the behaviour of firms. Specifically, it examines five different kinds of domestic policy: trade policy, foreign direct investment, capital controls, regulation, and Copyright Material Arab Open University competition policy. W2-01/03/2014 30 Egypt Branch-B301B
W2-01/03/2014
31
1. Trade policy
Of all the rules impinge (impose) upon the conduct of international business , the rules of trade are perhaps the most obvious. Because trade so clearly crosses national borders and can effect a national economy so deeply, governments have nearly always tried to govern the trade economy and shape the performance. The government try to create rules that directly and indirectly affect the ability of firm to compete across borders .
W2-01/03/2014 Copyright Material Arab Open University Egypt Branch-B301B 32
At some level of abstraction , nearly any economic policy undertaken by the state can be seen as exerting an influence on trade. Any policy that effect relative costs ,or demand , or labour market can shift the international trading broad macro level is series of policies that target directly the conduct of trade . These policies used for different ends such as To enhance the competitive performance of national based firm. Competitive advantage is wholly tangential (vague) .
W2-01/03/2014 Copyright Material Arab Open University Egypt Branch-B301B 33
However, firms contemplating (anticipating) either a trading relationship or a foreign investment need to investigate the commercial impact of these trading rules. Three kinds of rules demand particular attention A. Export control B. Protectionism C. Strategic trade policy
W2-01/03/2014 Copyright Material Arab Open University Egypt Branch-B301B 34
A. Export controls
States have tried to limit , from time to time , the goods that producers can ship across their borders. These controls serve an economic object , insulating the domestic economy from the inflationary impact of excess foreign demand . Controls serve a distinctly political purpose , they are designed to prevent a rival state from gaining access to key resources and technology, or to punish a state for some perceived wrongdoing , in both of these instances , export controls are employed as "force short of war, a way for the state to enhance its geopolitical aims without having to risk military confrontation .
W2-01/03/2014 Copyright Material Arab Open University Egypt Branch-B301B 35
A. Export controls
Export controls fall into one of two related categories: a. A government will compose a list of strategic goods (computers , encryption codes) and matching list of countries to which the export of these goods is prohibited. b. Impose specific sanction or embargoes (bans) to protest the action of rival state, during the period of apartheid .
The aim of sanction or export control is to force the target country to change Its behavior.
W2-01/03/2014 Copyright Material Arab Open University Egypt Branch-B301B 36
However these policies directly effect commercial conditions (the target state , the sending state , and the peripheral countries ). Strategic import are liable to disappear from the market , leaving importers and import-dependent firms at a loss, while massively unceasing demand for locally available substitutes Exporters from the sending states , meanwhile will face an immediate decline in sales and the potential loss of long term relationship. So firms needs to keep a careful watch on political events that could lead to sanctions or other export controls So firms also needs to be aware of the political forces and particular rules that drive sanction policies
W2-01/03/2014 Copyright Material Arab Open University Egypt Branch-B301B 37
A. Export controls
Protectionism policies are a common feature of the international economy . All states employ protectionism in one guise or another . All firms have felt its various effect. The challenge for mangers is to understand as precisely as possible where protectionism lies , and how best to avoid or exploit its rules . Sometimes protectionism is flagrant , in its oldest and most obvious forms , like tariffs ,quotas and other mechanical barriers to trade , because it want to protect its domestic producer from the strains of international competition. Or it wants to nurture and support domestic production , the state impose quantitative or price based restriction
B. Protectionism
W2-01/03/2014
Foreign firms hoping to sell into the protected market either to fit in under the requisite quota or see the tariff include in the cost of their product , both response damage the competitiveness of foreign firms relative to their domestically based competitions, a similar relationship holds for less direct forms of trade protection, under international pressure to reduce tariffs and eliminate quotas , many state resort to more discreet means. They offer research or export credit to their own firms or impose regulatory conditions that disadvantage foreign firms against their domestic rivals. Such as nontariff barriers are legion , and the subject of intense international acrimony.
W2-01/03/2014 Copyright Material Arab Open University Egypt Branch-B301B 39
B. Protectionism
40
These are rules that influence the condition under which firms can invest directly in the territory of foreign state. Historically , the rules and context of foreign investment have been driven by conflict, fearful of the economic and industrial power of foreign investor , many state in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries kept exceedingly tight reins over the companies that invested in there territory. Investment were negotiated on case by case basis and the state retained a unique ability to wrest further concessions from foreign investors once their capital hade been sunk into the country and their technologies rendered obsolete by the passage of time.
W2-01/03/2014 Copyright Material Arab Open University Egypt Branch-B301B 41
Recently , the hungry for the capital and technology of foreign firms , many state anxiously competing to attract investors, offering them financial incentive and the promise of preferential treatment, that does not means that foreign investment has lost its political under current , or domestic rules no longer affect the environment for investing firms , foreign investment remains inherently political , and rules can have a dramatic impact on the investing firms. Rules shape the investment climate in a number of ways a. First there were still customarily restrict (they can not enter some sectors) b. Even where investment in permitted , it may nevertheless be conditional on the participation of local joint venture partner , the import of certain technologies or a promise to manufacture for export
W2-01/03/2014 Copyright Material Arab Open University Egypt Branch-B301B 42
States can influence foreign investment through a. Limits on the employment of aliens and specific performance requirement b. Use the rules or FI to attract and advantage particular firms. So the firms must think strategically about how to avoid the limits imposed by domestic law as well as how to reap the benefits that the law particular circumstances are capable of providing . However the politics of FI can create a far more hostile environment and discouraging set of rules, under these circumstances , the investors only options were either to leave the market or fight their battles directly with those who made the rules .
W2-01/03/2014 Copyright Material Arab Open University Egypt Branch-B301B 43
In the past , most of the countries imposed some level of control over the export of capital , fearful of dis-equilibrating swings in short term capital movement , so they regulate how much capital investors could take aboard with them , and under circumstances . Essentially countries use capital control to buffering the domestic economy from free flowing forces of the international capital market ,developing countries find themselves caught between two opposing tensions. On one hand the globalization of capital flows reduce the efficacy of any unilateral rules on capital risk isolating any country that attempts to stem or control the flow . On the other hand , the sheer forces of the global market increase the financial vulnerability of developing states .
W2-01/03/2014 Copyright Material Arab Open University Egypt Branch-B301B 44
3. Capital control
3. Capital control
To blunt the impact of such external shocks , developing countries often maintain a series of control on capital and foreign exchange flow (IMF) for purchase of goods and services . While many of these controls are targeted most short term, or portfolio , flows, they have a strong peripheral impact on flows associated with trade and foreign investment , they also tend to fall most heavily on foreign firms , since government that grant licenses of foreign exchange typically distinguish between foreign and domestic applicant . So multinational firms need to include them as part of strategic landscape , and respond to them accordingly. For countries that are economically volatile , also they need to consider the possibility of dramatic policy shift.
W2-01/03/2014 Copyright Material Arab Open University Egypt Branch-B301B 45
4. Regulations
They are direct instead to the domestic economy , and to the mass of policy objectives that economic activity both facilitates and demand . Because these policies vary so widely across national borders , however , they are inherently important to the conduct on international business. Government regulate in order to promote a public good or address a public bad, known more formally as positive and negative externalities . They regulate to improve economic efficiency by correcting naturally existing market imperfection, or by controlling egregious excesses that the market has produce They also regulate in order to guide market forces towards certain noneconomic , socially desirable (clean air, medical treatment price caps wage control)
W2-01/03/2014 Copyright Material Arab Open University Egypt Branch-B301B 46
4. Regulations
The rules and political of regulation affect foreign firms A. They establish which specific industries are subject to regulation , and thus which firms will need to participate in direct and on-going relationship with the state(pharmaceuticals , food processing , health care .) B. Even when firms move from one regulated market to another , the forms regulation can still be different .
W2-01/03/2014 Copyright Material Arab Open University Egypt Branch-B301B 47
These are rules that provide the basic guidelines for market activity, rules that are deeply embedded in the political culture of a country and thus tend to vary widely across national borders. Antitrust policy seeks to maintain the efficacies of competition by keeping capitalist firms from growing too large or working too closely with their would-be rivals, it also intend to prevent firms from exerting undue control over the market in which they operate , it target several kind of presumed anti-competitive behaviour : predatory prices , excessive market concentration and collusion. Like regulation , antitrust is a form of state directed almost entirely at the domestic market, state employ antitrust to gain what they believe to be a more efficient use of national recourses , higher level of domestic growth , greater stability in prices , output, or employment , or more equitable distribution of income
W2-01/03/2014 Copyright Material Arab Open University Egypt Branch-B301B 48
Sometimes government also just use antitrust as a means to limit the reach of firms they perceive as being too large or powerful. Antitrust affect the domestic environment of business , so it affect any foreign firm operating within the domestic market. Sometime , antitrust and competition policy can provide dramatic opportunity for competitive advantage
W2-01/03/2014 Copyright Material Arab Open University Egypt Branch-B301B 49
Domestic politics
The policies that effect international business are generated through some kind of rational process and by particular, often even predictable , If the firm want to understand the policies that are liable to effect their businesses , they need to consider as well the process by which these policies are established , they need , in other words to understand the domestic politic of the countries in which they trade or invest. So where do policies come from? And how are they created ?it depend in some countries rules emerge through rational and predictable process of rent seek. various interest group express their preferences to a political system which arbitrate their interest and rewards those with the most vote, the greatest clout, or staunchest coalition
W2-01/03/2014 Copyright Material Arab Open University Egypt Branch-B301B 50
Domestic politics
In other instances , rules spring much more directly from the will and power of the central leadership. In most countries , power is split among various groups and agencies and rules emerge from a continuous bargaining among them. The outcome of these struggle depend on the institutional structure of the various agencies and the relative weight of power distributed among them.
W2-01/03/2014 Copyright Material Arab Open University Egypt Branch-B301B 51
Domestic politics
This gape between politics and policy is subtle but important , all national policy, it seems safe to conclude, is the product of domestic politics , of the struggle for power and interest that define a national system and create its rules. Firms must consider the full range of political action that resides there: the political forces that give rise to actual policy, as well as the quieter dimmer , but no less powerful forces that shape unwritten rules of business.
W2-01/03/2014 Copyright Material Arab Open University Egypt Branch-B301B 52
A change in the rules of trade at the international level may thus necessitate a change in corporate strategy in a particular domestic market. A similar dynamic holds at the regional level , where rules promulgated by institutions such as EU, NAFTA. It is the dramatic growth of nongovernmental organization , transnational groups that form around a particular shared interest :in human rights or environmentalism.
W2-01/03/2014
54
Not that none of these accusations allege illegal conduct on the part of the corporate participants. And all of them focus on rules that apply primarily at the domestic level. Yet transnational groups are able, increasingly , to exert pressure on how these rules are created and enforced . Through a variety of tactics , they compel government to revisit their own policies and cede, perhaps, a portion of their own power.
W2-01/03/2014
55
W2-01/03/2014
59
W2-01/03/2014
60
Homework
Homework Block 3: activities 4.12, 4.13, 4.14, 4.15, 4.16, 4.17, 4.18, 4.19, 4.20, 4.21
W2-01/03/2014 61
Copyright Material Arab Open University Egypt Branch-B301B
LOGO