Professional Documents
Culture Documents
THE COURTS
Learning Outcomes
14.1 Define judicial review, explain the circumstances under which it was established, and assess the significance of the authority it gave the courts. 14.2 Outline the organization of the U.S. court system and identify the principal functions of courts at each tier of the system.
Learning Outcomes
14.3 Describe the process by which cases are both accepted for review and decided by the U.S. Supreme Court and analyze the role played by judicial restraint and judicial activism in judicial decisions. 14.4 Explain how judges at different levels of the federal court system are nominated and confirmed to the federal bench.
Learning Outcomes
14.5 Examine the impact, influence and acceptance of decisions on issues of national importance by an institution unaccountable to the electorate. 14.6 Evaluate the decision-making authority of the federal judiciary within the context of both majoritarian and pluralist democracy.
10
11
12
13
Supreme Court strives to achieve just balance among values of freedom, order, and equality Values came into conflict in two controversial issues
Desecration of the flag School desegregation - Brown v. Board of Education
14
15
Rule of four
16
17
Duties:
Determining whether to appeal a lower courts decision Reviewing and modifying briefs for appeals Deciding whether or not to file amicus curiae briefs in any appellate court
18
Decision Making
Courts grant review
Attorneys submit written briefs Oral arguments, limited to 30 minutes per side Oral arguments released on website Justices meet in conference
19
Decision Making
Judicial Restraint and Judicial Activism
Judicial restraint
Defer to decisions of elected branches of government Elected representatives should make the laws
Judicial activism
Judges should not defer to the elected branches but should use their judicial power to promote the judges preferred social and political goals
20
21
Decision Making
Judgment and Argument
Judgment Votes remain tentative until Court issues an opinion announcing its judgment
Argument Concurrence Dissent
22
Decision Making
The Opinion
Chief justice or most senior justice in majority decides which justice writes majority opinion Draft opinion circulated among justices for criticisms and suggestions Public respect of court tested when court ventures into controversial areas
23
24
Judicial Recruitment
25
Judicial Recruitment
Senate Judiciary Committee reviews each judicial nominee and conducts a hearing
26
Judicial Recruitment
27
Judicial Recruitment
28
Judicial Recruitment
29
30
31
32
Majoritarian model
Courts adhere to letter of law and defer changes to elected representatives
Pluralist model
Courts are policymaking branch of government Class action suits
Rulings have broader impact than other types
State court rulings can be based on either federal law, state law, or both
33
Judges pay attention to views of other courts and not just those above them
34