This document compares the human resource practices of two fertilizer companies - Pakarab Fertilizers (owned by Fatima Group) and HFC Fertilizers (owned by Allahdin Group). It provides a detailed comparison of their approaches to HR planning, recruitment, training, performance management, compensation and benefits, career management, and unions. It then performs a SWOT analysis for each company's HR practices and provides recommendations. The key strengths of Pakarab include its formalized HR processes and motivated workforce, while incentives are limited. For HFC, management support and incentives are strengths, but HR practices need more formality and career management is lacking.
This document compares the human resource practices of two fertilizer companies - Pakarab Fertilizers (owned by Fatima Group) and HFC Fertilizers (owned by Allahdin Group). It provides a detailed comparison of their approaches to HR planning, recruitment, training, performance management, compensation and benefits, career management, and unions. It then performs a SWOT analysis for each company's HR practices and provides recommendations. The key strengths of Pakarab include its formalized HR processes and motivated workforce, while incentives are limited. For HFC, management support and incentives are strengths, but HR practices need more formality and career management is lacking.
This document compares the human resource practices of two fertilizer companies - Pakarab Fertilizers (owned by Fatima Group) and HFC Fertilizers (owned by Allahdin Group). It provides a detailed comparison of their approaches to HR planning, recruitment, training, performance management, compensation and benefits, career management, and unions. It then performs a SWOT analysis for each company's HR practices and provides recommendations. The key strengths of Pakarab include its formalized HR processes and motivated workforce, while incentives are limited. For HFC, management support and incentives are strengths, but HR practices need more formality and career management is lacking.
Fatima Group and Allahdin Group of Companies : FERTILIZERS SECTION Table Of Contents TOPICS Overview of the Organizations Nature of the Business and it Activities Business Volume Human resource process comparison in Two Organization SWOT Analysis of Human Resource process Recommendations Amir Jabbar BB-10-08 Overview of the Organization Brief History Nature of the Organization Business Volume Product Line Number of Employees Brief History Pakarab Fertilizers Established in 1973 Agreement signed PIDC and ADNOC Shares: 52% NFC 48% IPIC It was then acquired by Fatima Group and Arif Habib Group in 2005 HFC Fertilizers Established in 1968 by Lyallpur Chemicals & Fertilizers Pvt. Ltd. Purchased by AGC in 2006 Renovated to meet the global standards Now called as AL-HAMD Fertilizer Pvt. Ltd Pakarab HFC HR Department Nature of the Organization Pakarab Fertilizers include manufacturing of the plant nutrient, packaging, transportation, distribution and export Annual Production 90,000 tons Urea 450,000 of tons CAN 305,000 tons NP 847,000 tons of multi product HFC Fertilizers It is also a manufacturer of plant nutrients, packaging, And Transportation Producer of SSP (single super phosphate) Sulphuric Acid Zinc Sulphate bio gold bio fertilizer Business Volume Pakarab Fertilizers EPS: increasing positively Operating and Net profit increases HFC Fertilizers Almost a turnover of 1 billion Product Line Pakarab Urea
Calcium Ammonium Nitrate (CAN) Nitrophos (NP)
HFC Fertilizers SSP (single super phosphate) Sulphuric Acid Zinc Sulphate bio gold bio fertilizer Number of Employees Pakarab Fertilizers HFC Fertilizers
Senior Executive
Middle Managers
Junior Management Officers 20-80 Ratio WAQAR AKHTAR BB-10-02 COMPARISION OF HR PRACTICES: PAK ARAB FERTILIZER VS. HFC COMPARISION 1. HR planning and forecasting: PAK ARAB HFC A Proper HR Process Is Followed HOD Determines need and forecasts it Budget is assigned for yearly hiring Forecast is done on the basis of production to be done Long-term yearly plan exists Talent hunts are planned in institution like LUMS, IBA HR Processes Not Followed So Formally HOD determines need for hiring No yearly hiring program HR need forecast is done on the production basis Needs are determined on seasonal basis No talent hunt program PAK ARAB HFC Policy issues are formally addressed Proper test, interview and group discussion takes place Mostly ads are given, interview is taken for replacement decision, due process 1 st priority is internal source Meritocracy is valued Special preferences to institution like LUMS, IBA Policy issues not given much weight age except for legal requirements After application just interview is done Inside hiring for replacement decisions 1st priority is internal source of hiring Meritocracy is valued No institute based preferences COMPARISION 2. Employee recruitment and selection: PAK ARAB HFC Training for all level of employees Department head assesses need for training Training focused of all level equally Practical workshops, seminar for high level employees Clearance and budget is approved by CEO Training programs are highly formalized at all levels Training for all level of employees Department Head assesses need for training Training more focused on sales person seminars are conducted, farmer days are celebrated, field meeting are done, sales conferences Same is here. CEO give permission and budget COMPARISION 3. Training and development PAK ARAB HFC Performance standards are target based A formal appraisal form is forwarded Under performance doesnt lead to firing Incentive are not a very common practice no recognition or award
Performance standards are target based Appraisal form is not a common practice Consistent under performance leads to firing Incentive exist but dominantly for sale person Employee or sales person of the year award exists. COMPARISION 4. Performance management: PAK ARAB HFC Pay structure: 90% basic + 10 % health allowance Yearly increment is done 2 bonuses per year and a graduate is paid at every year end Cars are given to managers Pay structure: 45% basic salary + 27.5% house rent + 27.5% utility bills Yearly increment is done No bonuses of graduate No such package like a car COMPARISION 5. Employee compensation and benefits: PAK ARAB HFC A job rotation policy exists to give the employee exposure, somehow career management exists Career management practices do not exist COMPARISION 6. Organizational career management
COMPARISION 7. Job changes within organization PAK ARAB HFC A promotion policy exists thorough which employee is promoted after every 3 to 5 years Transfers are need based and exist Firing is very rare, so is demotion. But promotion is stopped as an alternative for demotion 1 month notice for resignation for permanent employees Employee retire at the age of 60 No promotion policy exists but employee are promoted on performance basis Geographical transfers are not a common practice Demotion dont exist, it just goes to firing 1 month notice for resignation of permanent employee No fixed retirement age COMPARISION 8. Unions and management
PAK ARAB HFC Unions exist but do not have much bargaining power Unions do not exist
Naveed Ahmad BB-10-75 SWOT ANALYSIS AND RECOMMENDATIONS STRENGTH: Entrepreneurial leadership exists in Pak ARAB Facilities for workers (house, medical center, school, management etc.) Best Management team for fertilizers firm in Pakistan Full formalized HR processes exist Experienced workforce exists and employees are highly motivated Career management is done to some degree Frequent training for all level of employees Managements attitude towards employees is very positive
SWOT ANALYSIS PAK ARAB (FATIMA GROUP) WEAKNESS: Incentives are very less, the only incentive is yearly salary increase Equal treatment for all the employees even some of them are performing better Working hour are two much, employees get tired
SWOT ANALYSIS PAK ARAB (FATIMA GROUP) OPPORTUNITIES: HR needs will increase as the demand for fertilizer increases New HR practices can be employed to make man force more effective. The gas line project is an opportunity of expansion for the company in near future
SWOT ANALYSIS PAK ARAB (FATIMA GROUP) THREATS: High competition means high turnover of employees In order to retain employee organization will have to reduce some profit and give employees more compensation The shortage of gas is creating inconsistencies in the production making the need for employee inconsistent Global crisis which leads to low incentives for employees Increased labor regulation laws can be threatening
SWOT ANALYSIS PAK ARAB (FATIMA GROUP) SWOT ANALYSIS HFC (Allahdin Group of Companies) STRENGTHS: Management is supportive towards the HR practices Clean environment for employees where they work Healthy environment for manual workers Incentives exist and lead to higher motivation of employees Training and development process is formalized Sales force is highly active achieving targets because they are properly trained WEAKNESS: Employees are not very specialized in HFC HR practices exist to a certain level but there is a lack of a formal HR system A formal appraisal system does not exist Career management practices are absent Seasonal nature of business makes turnover high because of which motivated employee do not exist Fewer seats for permanent jobs are there, mostly there are employees on daily basis and contract basis
SWOT ANALYSIS HFC (Allahdin Group of Companies) OPPORTUNITIES: Growing need for fertilizers leads to increase in employee demand and an opportunity to develop a good formalized workforce Entering in other cities means people across the country can join and a more diverse workforce will be part of the company
SWOT ANALYSIS HFC (Allahdin Group of Companies) THREATS: Increasing demands of employees will give them more bargaining power Increased competition means more incentive to motivate employee properly Legal restriction regarding labor may increase in future
SWOT ANALYSIS HFC (Allahdin Group of Companies) They need to maintain existing HR practices and look for new developments in HR. They need to change their perception of employee from worker to a partner. They should expand their HR department and try to develop a system in which they can accommodate diverse workforce. Due to increasing need for efficiency Pak Arab needs to run regular training program for employees so that they remain aware of state of art technology. RECOMMENDATIONS PAK ARAB (FATIMA GROUP) The HR process should be made more formal. Training and development should expand beyond the sales department to all other departments A proper appraisal method should be established. Bonuses and other incentive should be given to employees as well. Over all the company should fine tune its HR processes and make them formal, standardized. RECOMMENDATIONS HFC (Allahdin group of companies) CONCLUSION