effectiveness of your brainstorming and follow up plans. Affinity Diagram (island chart) The Affinity Diagram, KJ Method, or Island Chart is named after Kawakita Jiro a Japanese anthropologist. Useful for gathering and arranging opinions, ideas, suggestions, etc., Organized into sub-groups based on a common relationship or theme. Helps refine brainstorming providing a path for further investigation and action. Affinity Diagrams Boost the Effectiveness of Brainstorming Separates the issue into independent causes and allows focused brainstorming on sub- topics. Facilitates more depth & breadth in brainstorming Prioritizes the causes according to group consensus Leads to a more thorough review and logic for actions Affinity Diagram Write down ideas Look for natural groupings and arrange similar ideas together Look for trends, themes and overlap Prioritize main topics Plan Actions that will address the highest priority islands Basic Steps to making an Affinity Diagram Brainstorm ideas writing each idea on an individual card. Place the cards face up on a table. Read each idea to the group. Arrange the ideas into common themes. Talk about and refine the groupings and look for inter-relationships. Give each island a title. I think we can improve by Write each idea on a card. Lay the cards out on a table. melt temp diameter of hole diameter of the stem differences between molds cool time plastic color type of plastic mold wear installation force time delay after mold back pressure smooth stem draft modifications order installed interference fit SPC dropped caster fell out 100% inspect missed inspection caster not missing reduce variation build error intention al flash short shot shrink feeder went empty Problem: What causes missing casters and what could be done to fix it? Begin to arrange cards into natural groups. melt temp diameter of hole diameter of the stem differences between molds cool time plastic color type of plastic mold wear installation force time delay after mold back pressure smooth stem draft modifications order installed interference fit SPC dropped caster fell out 100% inspect missed inspection caster not missing reduce variation build error intention al flash short shot shrink feeder went empty Problem: What causes missing casters and what could be done to fix it? Arrange Ideas into Sub-groups (distinguish between causes and solutions) Put similar ideas together Bucket SF Process Operator Automation Other Caster melt temp diameter of hole diameter too small differences between molds cool time plastic color type of plastic mold wear installation force time delay after mold back pressure smooth stem draft mold modifications order installed interference fit SPC dropped caster fell out 100% inspect missed inspection caster not missing reduce variation build error intentional flash short shot SPC intentional flash shrink feeder went empty
Differences in in Diameter What causes missing casters? After the ideas are arranged Look over the groupings for additional thoughts or insight about the problem. Write down any new ideas that come up and place them accordingly. Rank the ideas using nominal group technique to prioritize further work. That gives me another great idea! Rank The Ideas (Nominal Group Technique) Focus most of our attention investigating things that could cause a difference in diameter. Letter Cause Ellen Steve Jeff Julie Dave Terry Total Count Rank Top 3 A Plastic Color 0 0 20 B Hole Diameter 5 5 4 5 3 2 24 6 1 * C Build error 0 0 11 D Mold modifications 1 1 1 9 E Mold wear 1 2 2 1 6 4 5 F Shrink 1 1 1 8 G Draft 0 0 23 H Type of plastic 2 2 1 7 I Time Delay after mold 1 3 5 9 3 4 J Order installed 0 0 21 K Dropped caster 0 0 12 L Installation force 0 0 22 M Feeder went empty 0 0 13 N Smooth stem 3 2 5 2 6 O Stem Diameter too small 4 3 5 4 4 3 23 6 2 * P Melt temp 0 0 16 Q Cool time 1 1 1 10 R Back pressure 0 0 17 S Short shot 0 0 18 T Missed inspection 0 0 19 U Caster not missing 0 0 15 V Fell out 0 0 14 W Differences between molds 2 4 3 5 4 18 5 3 * Plan Further Work Refine ideas Develop investigation plan Gather data. Brainstorm for solutions Develop solutions that solve the broad categories. Be sure you have significant actions to address the highest priority areas.
What could we do to the design so that any differences in diameter wont be an issue?
Things to remember in using an Affinity diagram 1. Rapidly group ideas that seem to belong together. 2. Copy an idea into in more than one group if appropriate. 3. Look at small groups. Should they belong in a larger group? 4. Do large groups need to be broken down more? 5. Wait until most of the ideas have been sorted to decide on titles. Thank you!