Power Electronics Ned Mohan Slides Ch27

Snubber
Circuits
A.
Overview of Snubber Circuits
B.
Diode Snubbers
C.
Turn-off Snubbers
D.
Overvoltage Snubbers
E.
Turn-on Snubbers
F.
Thyristor Snubbers
AnoopMathew
HoDEEE
CopyrightbyJohnWiley&Sons2003
Forclarifications:anoopmathew@ieee.org
Snubbers1
OverviewofSnubberCircuitsforHardSwitchedConverters
Function:Protectsemiconductordevicesby:
Limitingdevicevoltagesduringturnofftransients
Limitingdevicecurrentsduringturnontransients
Limitingtherateofrise(di/dt)ofcurrentsthrough
thesemiconductordeviceatdeviceturnon
Limitingtherateofrise(dv/dt)ofvoltagesacross
thesemiconductordeviceatdeviceturnoff
Shapingtheswitchingtrajectoryofthedeviceasit
turnson/off
TypesofSnubberCircuits
1. UnpolarizedseriesRCsnubbers
Usedtoprotectdiodesandthyristors
2. PolarizedRCsnubbers
Usedasturnoffsnubberstoshapetheturnon
switchingtrajectoryofcontrolledswitches.
Usedasovervoltagesnubberstoclampvoltages
appliedtocontrolledswitchestosafevalues.
Limitdv/dtduringdeviceturnoff
3. PolarizedLRsnubbers
Usedasturnonsnubberstoshapetheturnoff
switchingtrajectoryofcontrolledswitches.
Limitdi/dtduringdeviceturnon
Snubbers2
NeedforDiodeSnubberCircuit
d i Df
+
Vd
-
Rs
Df
Io
Cs
i Df (t)
Io
d t
Vd
=
L
t
I rr
Sw
L = stray inductance
Sw closes at t = 0
Rs - Cs = snubber circuit
v (t)
Df
Diode voltage
without snubber
Vd
L
di L
d t
diL
Diode breakdown if V d + L
> BVBD
dt
Snubbers3
EquivalentCircuitsforDiodeSnubber
L
+
Vd
-
Diode
snap-of
cathode
Simplified snubber the capacitive snubber
Rs
anode
+
v
Cs
-
Vd
i Df
Rs = 0
Worst case assumptiondiode snaps of instantaneously

at end of diode recovery
v
d2vCs
= -v
Df
vCs
Vd
=
LCs
L Cs
Governing equation -
Boundary conditions - vCs(0 +) = 0 and iL(0 +) = Irr
dt2
Cs
Cs
Snubbers4
PerformanceofCapacitiveSnubber
vCs(t) = V d - V d cos(ot) + V d
o =
1
L Cs
Cbase
sin(ot)
Cs
V cs,max = V d
I 2
rr
Cbase = L
V d
Cbase
1 +
Cs
1 +
Cs,max
Vd
2
0
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.2
1.4
1.6
1.8
C base
Cs
Snubbers5
EffectofAddingSnubberResistance
SnubberEquivalentCircuit
L
i(t)
-
+
V
d
-
Rs
Df
+
(t)
Governing equation
Boundary conditions
Cs
i(0 +) = Irr and
d2 i
di
i
+ Rs
+
=0
2
dt
C
dt
s
V d -I rrRs
di(0 +)
=
dt
L
Diodevoltageasafunctionoftime
Vdf
et
Vd (t)=1 cos()sin(at+);Rs2Rb
Rs
1
(2x)
2
1
a=o 1(/o) ;=2L ;o=
;=tan
LCs
2
4x
L[Irr]2
Cs
Rs
Vd
=C ;x=R ;Rb= I ;Cb=
;=tan1(/a)
2
b
b
rr
Vd
Snubbers6
Performance of R-C
Snubber
3
At t = tm vDf(t) = Vmax
tan-1 (a/ )
-
tm =
+
0
a
a
V max
Vd
=1 +
Cs
Cbase
1+ -1 -x exp(-t m)
and
LsI rr2
Cbase =
V d2
x=
and
Rs
R s,opt
C s = C base
base
2
V max
V
d
1
Rbase
Vd
Rbase =
Irr
= 1.3
R sI rr
V
0
0
Rs
R base
Snubbers7
DiodeSnubberDesign
Wtot
2
L s I rr/2
WR
2
L s I rr/2
0
2
0
V max
0
0
Vd
0 0
0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0
for R = R
s
s,opt
0 0
R s,op
R base
0
0
C s / C base
Snubbers8
NeedforSnubberswithControlledSwitches
Switchcurrentandvoltagewaveforms
Stepdownconverter
L1
V
d
L2
i
L3
L di
dt
sw
Sw
Io
I rr
sw
L di
dt
Io
+
vsw
-
vsw
to t
Io
V
d
t
1
t
4
t5
t6
L1 , L 2 , L 3 = stray inductances
Switchingtrajectoryofswitch
L = L1 + L + L
2
3
idealized
switching
loci
i sw
t5
t6
t
turn-off
o
t
turn-on
Overcurrent at turn-on due to

diode reverse recovery
t3
V
Overvoltage at turn-off
due to stray inductance
vsw
Snubbers9
TurnoffSnubberforControlledSwitches
D
f
DF
Turn-off
snubber
Io
Ds
Rs
S
w
Io
Io- i
i sw
Cs
Df
V
Stepdownconverterwithturnoffsnubber
Cs
Cs
Equivalentcircuitduringswitchturn
off.
Simplifyingassumptions
1. Nostrayinductance.
sw
2. isw(t)=Io(1t/tfi)
3. isw(t)uneffectedbysnubbercircuit.
Snubbers10
TurnoffSnubberOperation
2
Io t
and v (t) =
Cs
2C t
s fi
Iot
Capacitor voltage and current for 0 < t < t fi iCs(t) =
t fi
Iot fi
For Cs = Cs1, vCs = Vd at t = tfi yielding Cs1 =
2V d
Circuit waveforms for varying values of Cs

i
sw
sw
sw
Io
i
Df
tf
Df
Df
t
tf
Cs
V
d
v
Cs
Cs
< Cs1
Cs = Cs1
Cs > C
s
1
Snubbers11
BenefitsofSnubberResistanceatSwitchTurnon
v sw
Io
Io
DsshortsoutRs
duringSwturnoff.
Rs
V
d
Sw
DuringSwturnon,
Dsreversebiasedand
CsdischargesthruRs.
Ds
Cs
Io
d
t ri
t ri + t rr
I rr
i sw
TurnonwithRs=0
v sw
i sw
discharge
of C s
t rr
t rr
EnergystoredonCsdissipated
inSw.
Vd
Io
Rs
I rr
TurnonwithRs>0
EnergystoredonCsdissipated
inRsratherthaninSw.
Voltagefalltimekeptquite
short.
ExtraenergydissipationinSw
becauseoflengthenedvoltage
falltime.
Snubbers12
EffectofTurnoffSnubberCapacitance
1
Energydissipation
W total / W base
W
0.8
WR = dissipation in
resistor
0.6
WT = dissipation in
switch Sw
W R / W base
0.4
W T / W base
W
0.2
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.2
Iot fi
Cs1 =
2V d
1.4
Cs / C s1
Wtotal = WR + WT
i sw
Io
Wbase = 0.5 V dIot fi

Cs < Cs1
RBSOA
Switchingtrajectory
Cs = Cs1
Cs > Cs1
V
v sw
Snubbers13
TurnoffSnubberDesignProcedure
SelectionofCs
Minimizeenergydissipation(WT)inBJTatturnon
MinimizeWR+WT
KeepswitchinglocuswithinRBSOA
ReasonablevalueisCs=Cs1
Snubberrecoverytime(BJTinonstate)
Capacitorvoltage=Vdexp(t/RsCs)
TimeforvCstodropto0.1Vdis2.3RsCs
SelectionofRs
BJTmustremainonforatimeof2.3RsCs
Vd
Limiticap(0+)= R <Irr
s
Vd
UsuallydesignerspecifiesIrr<0.2Ioso R =0.2Io
s
Snubbers14
OvervoltageSnubber
L
Io
ov
Vd
kV
d
s
w
Io
Sw
Dov
Cov
Step-down converter with

overvoltage snubber comprised
of Dov, Cov, and Rov.
Overvoltage snubber limits
overvoltage (due to stray I
nductance) across Sw as it
turns of.
s
w
fi
Switch Sw waveforms without overvoltage snubber
t fi = switch current fall time ; kV d = overvoltage on Sw

diL
Io
kV d = L
= L
dt
t fi
L =
kV dt fi
Io
Snubbers15
OperationofOvervoltageSnubber
i
L
L
Dov on for 0 < t <
D ov
V
ov
t fi <<
+
ov
i
Cov
+
V
d
Dov,Covprovidealternatepath
forinductorcurrentasSwturns
off.
Switchcurrentcanfalltozero
muchfasterthanLscurrent.
Dfforcedtobeon
(approximatingashortckt)byIo
afterSwisoff.
Equivalent circuit while

inductor current decays to zero
+
C
ov
Cov
Equivalentcircuitafterturnoff
ofSw.
V
d
t
LC ov
with time constant R ov C

ov
V sw,max
s
w
(t) = Io cos[
L
i L(0 +) = Io
Discharge of C ov thru R ov
L
I
v Cov (0 +) = V d
i
Charge-up of C ov from L
i
LCov
L
L
LCov
Energy transfer from L to C ov

Cov ( V sw,max) 2
L(I o) 2
=
2
2
LC ov
4
Snubbers16
OvervoltageSnubberDesign
Cov =
L s Io2
(vsw,max) 2
Limit vsw,max to 0.1V d

kV d t fi
Using Ls =
Io
Cov =
kV dt fiIo2
Io(0.1V d) 2
in equation for Cov yields

=
100k t fi Io
Vd
t fiIo
Cov = 200 k Cs1 where Cs1 =

2V d
in turn-of snubber
which is used
Recovery time of Cov (2.3RovCov) must be less

than off-time duration, t of , of the switch Sw.
Rov
t of
2.3C ov
Snubbers17
TurnonSnubber
+
D
Ls
+
f
Snubber
circuit
Ls
D
Ls
D
V
Ls
Sw
Io
Stepdownconverter
withturnonsnubber
Ls
Ls
f
Sw
SnubberreducesVswatswitch
turnonduedropacross
inductorLs.
Willlimitrateofriseofswitch
currentifLsissufficiently
large.
i sw
With
snubber
Without
snubber
Ls
Switchingtrajectorywithandwithoutturnonsnubber.
di sw
dt
V
d
v
sw
Snubbers18
TurnonSnubberOperatingWaveforms
v
Small values of snubber inductance (L s < L s1 )

disw
controlled by switch Sw
dt
and drive circuit.
LsIo
vsw =
t ri
Io
s
w
Large values of snubber inductance (L s > L s1 )

disw
Vd
Io
limited by circuit to
<
dt
Ls
t ri
I rr
s
w
t ri
t rr
I rr
s
w
reduced
V
Io
V dt ri
Ls1 =
Io
Irr reduced when Ls > L s1 because Irr proportional to
i
disw
dt
s
w
t on
Ls Io
V
> tri
+ rr
t
Snubbers19
TurnonSnubberRecoveryatSwitchTurnoff
+
D
f
Io
I o RLs exp(-R Ls t/L s )
Io R
Ls
is
w
V
d
Ls
Ls
vs
w
Ls
Sw
Assumeswitchcurrentfalltime
tri=0.
Inductorcurrentmustdischarge
thruDLsRLsseriessegment.
V
d
Io
t rv
Switchwaveformsatturnoffwithturnonsnubberincircuit.
Overvoltagesmalleriftfismaller.
Timeof2.3Ls/RLsrequiredforinductorcurrenttodecayto0.1Io
Offtimeofswitchmustbe>2.3Ls/RLs
Snubbers20
TurnonSnubberDesignTradeoffs
Selection of inductor
LargerLsdecreasesenergydissipationinswitchatturnon
Wsw=WB(1+Irr/Io)2[1Ls/Ls1]
WB=VdIotfi/2andLs1=Vdtfi/Io
Ls>Ls1Wsw=0
LargerLsincreasesenergydissipationinRLs
WR=WBLs/Ls1
Ls>Ls1reducesmagnitudeofreverserecoverycurrentIrr
InductormustcarrycurrentIowhenswitchisonmakes
inductorexpensiveandhenceturnonsnubberseldomused
SelectionofresistorRLs
SmallervaluesofRLsreduceswitchovervoltageIoRLsat turnoff
Limitingovervoltageto0.1VdyieldsRLs=0.1Vd/Io
LargervaluesofRLsshortensminimumswitchofftimeof2.3Ls/RLs
Snubbers21
ThyristorSnubberCircuit
P
1
-
3phasethyristorcircuitwithsnubbers
van(t) = Vssin(t), vbn(t) = Vssin(t - 120),
vcn(t) = Vssin(t - 240)
an +
- v bn
B
-
v cn +
C
Cs
4
Phasetoneutralwaveforms
v an
Rs
v
bn
vLL (t) = 3 V ssin(t - 60)

Maximum rms line-to-line voltage V LL =
3
V
2 s
v LL = v
v
bn v an = ba
t1
Snubbers22
EquivalentCircuitforSCRSnubberCalculations
Assumptions
Trigger angle = 90 so that vLL (t) = maximum = 2 V LL
EquivalentcircuitafterT1reverserecovery
Reverse recovery time t rr <<period of ac waveform so that
vLL (t) equals a constant value of vba(t 1 ) =
2 V LL
Worst case stray inductance L gives rise to reactance equal

to or less than 5% of line impedance.
Line impedance =
Vs
2V LL
V LL
V ( t )
1
ba
-
2Ia1
6Ia1
3Ia1
where Ia1 = rms value of fundamental component of the
line current.
V LL
L = 0.05
3Ia1
2 L
P
T1 after
recovery
T 3 (on)
Cs
i
A
T1
Rs
Snubbers23
ComponentValuesforThyristorSnubber
Use same design as for diode snubber but adapt the formulas to the
thyristor circuit notation
Snubber capacit or Cs = Cbase = L
I 2
rr
V d
From snubber equivalent circuit 2 L
Irr =
diL
t rr
dt
2V LL
2V LL
t rr =
2L
diL
dt
0.05 V LL
t rr = 25 Ia1t rr
3I a1
Vd =
Cs = Cbase =
Vd
Snubber resistance Rs = 1.3 Rbase = 1.3
Irr
2 V LL
2 V LL
Rs
0.05 V LL
3I a1
= 1.3
25 I
a1t rr
2V LL
2V LL
25Ia1t rr
2
=
8.7 Ia1t rr
V LL
0.07 V LL
Ia1t rr
Energy dissipat ed per cycle in snubber resistance = WR
WR =
L Irr2
2
CsV d2
2
= 18 Ia1 V LL (t rr) 2
Snubbers24

Power Electronics Ned Mohan Slides Ch27

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Power Electronics Ned Mohan Slides Ch27

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Snubber

Overview of Snubber Circuits

Simplified snubber the capacitive snubber

Worst case assumptiondiode snaps of instantaneously

Boundary conditions - vCs(0 +) = 0 and iL(0 +) = Irr

i(0 +) = Irr and

Overcurrent at turn-on due to

Circuit waveforms for varying values of Cs

Wbase = 0.5 V dIot fi

Step-down converter with

Switch Sw waveforms without overvoltage snubber

t fi = switch current fall time ; kV d = overvoltage on Sw

Dov on for 0 < t <

Equivalent circuit while

with time constant R ov C

Energy transfer from L to C ov

Limit vsw,max to 0.1V d

in equation for Cov yields

Cov = 200 k Cs1 where Cs1 =

Recovery time of Cov (2.3RovCov) must be less

Small values of snubber inductance (L s < L s1 )

Large values of snubber inductance (L s > L s1 )

Irr reduced when Ls > L s1 because Irr proportional to

I o RLs exp(-R Ls t/L s )

vLL (t) = 3 V ssin(t - 60)

Worst case stray inductance L gives rise to reactance equal

Snubber capacit or Cs = Cbase = L

From snubber equivalent circuit 2 L

Energy dissipat ed per cycle in snubber resistance = WR

You might also like