Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Introduction
the predictions that China would become
the worlds largest economy in the very
near future has led to the growing
popularity of studies in comparative world
history, which seek to explain the Great
Divergence of economic wealth between
the West and the rest of the world after
about 1800
Great Divergence
theory of German
historians:
theory of of Asian
historians:
they provided evidence that demonstrates that the
standard of living in advanced parts of India and China
was about the same as in eighteenth century
northwestern Europe. They have also offered other
arguments in terms of resource endowments, the impact
of Western imperialism, and historical path dependency
in order to argue that the traditional rise of the West
explanation is wrong
Some of them:
Kenneth Pomeranz, Bin Wong, Prasannan
Parthasarati
Robert Allen:
studied the history of wages and prices in Beijing,
Canton, and Suzhou/Shanghai from the
eighteenth century to the twentieth, and
compared them with leading cities in Europe
Coclusion:
In the eighteenth century, the real income
of building workers in Asia was similar to
that of workers in the backward parts of
Europe but far behind that in the leading
economies in north-western Europe. Real
wages stagnated in China in the eighteenth
and early nineteenth centuries and rose
slowly in the late nineteenth and early
twentieth, with little cumulative change for
200 years. The income disparities of the
early twentieth century were due to long-run
stagnation in China combined with
industrialization in Japan and Europe.
anthropometric measures
literacy measure
level of urbanization measure
problematic issues
Gupta and Ma believe that institutions and
historical path-dependencies are crucial
components of the Great Divergence between
Asia and Europe. Asian institutions has been
relatively neglected in the study of the Great
Divergence.
conclusion:
the advanced parts of AsiaIndia
and Chinalooked more similar to
the backward parts of Europe than to
the advanced northwest during the
early modern period. The Great
Divergence was well underway in the
seventeenth century16 at a time
when the influence of the West was
still very modest in Asia