Professional Documents
Culture Documents
APPEALS OF ZAMBOANGA
DEL SUR v. SAMAR MINING
COMPANY, INC. and
THE COURT OF TAX APPEAL.
G.R. No. L-28034. February 27, 1971
FACTS
Samar Mining Co (Samar)
42 km
gravelpit SamicoRoad
Pier in Pamintayan,
Zamboanga del Sur
FACTS
Samar Mining Co (Samar)
an assessment letter
from the Provincial
Assessor, charging
them P
1,117,900.00 as
real estate tax on
the taxable portion of
Samico Road.
BAA
onthe ground that the
roadwas notataxable
improvement
because it was
constructed
entirely on public land.
upheld the
assessment but
held it
unenforceable until
the lease contracts
were executed.
CTA
the road was constructed on public lands such that it is an integral part
of the lands and not an independent improvement thereon, and that
upon the termination of the lease the national government will acquire
ownership of the road, Samar should be exempted from paying
ISSUE
SAMAR
BAA
ARGUMENTS
DOCTRINES
Bislig Bay Lumber Co., Inc. v. Provincial Government of Surigao, 100 Phil.
303 It is well settled that a real tax, being a burden upon the capital, s
hould be paid by the owner of the land and not by a usufructuary (Merc
ado v. Rizal, 67 Phil., 608; Article 597, new Civil Code). Appellee is but
a partial usufructuary of the road in question."
Municipality of Cotabato, Et. Al. v. Santos, Et Al., 105 Phil. 963, this Co
urt ruled that the lessee who introduced improvements consisting of dik
es, gates and guard-houses on swamp lands leased to him by the Bure
au of Fisheries, in converting the swamps into fishponds, is exempt from
payment of realty taxes on those improvements.
RULING
NO.
RULING
QUESTIONS
1.Is Samico Road an improvement on the land?
Answer: YES
QUESTIONS
3. Why is the Bislig case applicable although the
road in that case was built on inalienable tim
berland?
Answer: The road in issue in the Bislig Bay case was exempted not because it
was constructed on inalienable public lands. What is emphasized in the lease is th
at the improvement is exempt from taxation because it is an integral part of the p
ublic land on which it is constructed and the improvement is the property of the g
overnment by right of accession. Under Section 3(a) of the Assessment Law (Com.
Act 470), all properties owned by the government, without any distinction, are ex
empt from taxation.