You are on page 1of 52

|  



   
 
    
  

    


    
  
? 
?
  
? 
? 


R   
 
Challenges in Clinical Health Services (HS 265)
ð       
         
         


 !   "   
    #   
  
 $ %       & 
' (     
) *  +   
  #  + 
—+    , 
,  ,  

-!.& /
!./
!. /
!. /
0!.&  /

1
( R*2

 3       4


 3   "    4
 5 "    4
 5       " 
 4

0
 
 $  
 ,     
 $ &
 4
  
' 6 "     
' %"  &   
     
 ,  7
 —    
   8 9  
ô
ð ð  R5$,


R5$,:
 $ "  &   ; 
  )       <
 &
         
       & 
     "  &  
   "     
 

÷ ÷÷
 

-
R5$, ,  
  R  5   $& 
, 
 6;R,,     
     
' $  #      
  
' R        "  & 
 $3      
       #     

 =##   )&# #  #$>ð#$+ %   


?   #  
CAHPS surveys ask about aspects of care
for which:

' $     "   


 
' $       &    
"   


—  8   
 CAHPS surveys are NOT satisfaction
surveys
' (    

 Focus is on experiences and behaviors


'    "     "  
"9 &      


,  7 
 ×nstrument
' ?&        
 Protocol
' ,         
           7 
 Analysis
' ,  7        
 Reporting
' ,           
   
 2  +
' R5$,>  " 

   & 
&     


esigned for all types of users
'           
 &  

 Spanish language versions


' &  
'      "  

?8 &   
 Cognitive testing
' , &   
' ( ,    ?

 Field testing
' ? &    " & 
          

1
—    
 Report information that patients and
purchasers say is important

 Cognitive testing of report formats and


language
'  8 7   "    "

0
 " 
 CAHPS grantees

 AHRQ and CMS Staff

 Westat Staff

 Stakeholders

ô
$ "—  
 Free!
' $ 
 , &  — @   )&
' R5$,(    
 5  A   0 
 ?
5     B )&


A    — & '  
 Review of the relevant literature

 ×dentification of:

' ( +  

' $ &   

' %     


-
C   
 ?&      

 ð   —  6 

 (  ?8 $  


>    ( 

 Cognitive ×nterviews with members of the target


population

'     


' ? , 
'   & "  
 

 =##     #   #)  & 


ð ( =(  
 •oals:

' Ã
 
       

!

' Ã
   
 
 " 
  



(  ð ( $
 Mixed mode
' R&     
'  )  
' —    
'  )  
' (   

 Telephone only
' R&     
' (    


R  ð ( > 
 Psychometric analysis to assess how well individual survey
items are performing

 Assess effectiveness of data collection modes and


equivalence of different modes

 Modeling of Unit Non-Response and Evaluation of Non-


Response Weights


( 
 The CAHPS instruments are designed
to accommodate items from existing
surveys.

 Testing of an integrated questionnaire


will allow facilities to track the trending
of data for quality improvement
purposes.

1
ëARð $  % 

 ë R5$, *%  & 

       & 


 &       & 
R5$,   
 
$  $   
&   &
 —   " +R5$, 
  
       &  
   
 ;  " &       
 (      
  
 $

 &  &   
 2— (?   
—   D;  

 $ 
' R   &
"   &  
' $  &  "   &   " 
     

 >   "       ) 


 & 
> &  D;  
 ð&   

 ð   
'  R 5 ,   
&)    

%
)   
  "       

  &  " "
     

 =##   )&# #  #%#$—C>E%E%0$  


D;   > 
6 "  

   
' >   
' C   
' R ô 

 %"  
' —   
' —  <   
—    $ 
   &doctor communication, office staff 
' >     &
8       
  4
 Yes, definitelyFYes, somewhatFNo

 A   access
'         
<        
         
)      4
 NeverFSometimesFUsuallyFAlways
>      

>     &

?8       


  4
A     4
 %&        " 
 +      "  4
, +     " 
   4
1,      4
0,     4
C ,    
 >     &  
 +    <
         
 " 4

>     &


 +    <
      
  4
R   ô  
    
3    <   
         
    )   
   4
3         +

     


        
    4
3    <  
         
    )   
 4
R    
       
 <      
      
    )  
    4

13       


    8    
      
 ô    
  4
%"   
ôë  "   
    " 
  "  "  
 "       
4

3    <


     4

' Yes, definitely; Yes, somewhat; No


; 4


R5$,R   
' % AR   > &       "  
5R5$, &    — — &--
1-
'  G6    + &       &    
"    8     5 , &—  "   
' @  $,   %    &           
   0 

' H  G     # =R   
     R5$, 62>"  + G?) =0
' % ?   —  #      <    
    5R5$, &    — — &--0

' ?6   >   +  5R5$,    
 " 4    —   — & -ô
-1
' A  3%?6          
       8            
    —   — & -1
ôô
' ?6  R9  "     8    
       =     5 , & 
—  00ô0
ô 
' ?6      &    &    

   8   "   7  5R5$, &     0-
0
0
' 2 + @  C     =(    &  
 &   5 , & —  00 -1ô
-0
' 5  R?6  $   &         
8       "        0- ô
ô-
1
R5$,R 
' , 5  $        8     & 
     
    +      ? G% $ 
ô 
ô
' A 5       )    6 I+,5 $R G
      ô 
 
' —) 75$  (     
"     & 
 &     8   =R    &  G% 0 
 
' %   $  > &      
"       
"    $   0 10
1ô0
' — 75$  C 7    +        
   8      5 , & — 00 
 
' 3  
C 2  R R5$, R       G
5   $ë  & ô
- 
' ,  ,AH  &+RH "+A2C<  RG5  R* $>
 +  "                 
     

 &    0-ô -
ô1
' A 5       )       6 I+,5 $5 
, &—  ð "0 "
' @  ,  (  &      &  "  +
       =ë    < 8           ) 
GR > R 0
1-
' ð "   $ "    =5   ) 

  
 4R  &    0-

' ?6  ?  &      8    R5$,
   &  5 , & —  00ô
ô 
' @  $,  ;    "+  "      
               0- 

1-
'  ,  $           
"    <       8   5   ð — & 10
ô1
'  GR  ?  &           &  
R5$,R  
' , >$   >   &    ) 45 
, &— 01 1
ô 
' % 7 G   ë"      &  ) 
   G5 ?- 
ô
' R ?@   R      %  <
  $  ,5 $=15   ð — &01
ô-
' > & ?   ?&        R5$, &  
 &   
     =A   )  & 
 " & 5 ?8   
-
' , GR   R           
, 
 +   =   $  ?  -1
1
0
' ð R   —     =2 +     
 G5   $ë  &   1
0-
' 3 
  —   , &           
R5$,   "5    01
 
' ;  >>   2  $+ 5  , &  R5$,
5  , &    0ô0
 
' — RR         8     &  
  "     R5$,   & 45 , & 
—  01

' ?6   5 8     8
     
     "      &         45 
, & —  01 11
0 
' 3 
  —   A          &  
        "5 5 , & —  01ôô
ô 
1
R5$,R - 
' H  &+R-ë      "    
&         ,   ô

' 2 & 23 —D  G*>   GA->   
   4(     )     
    5 (  ô
ô
'  (-     )   5   
ð — &  ô
-
'  2G  ?  " &       
  J      
   )  — , 
R $    
0
' @ 6  (  &       
 , 5 (     
' % ——  (      &  
 7  )      5 , &— 
0 

' C @? J"        
  R5$,2  +>  "  5      — & 
1 ô
 
' > "   R  5 $&  
, R5$,= &&  +   R G ; 
  00
0-
1
R5$,R ô

' > 9>     ë,R=  R  
 R  5 $ , & R5$, 
>      ? G$ "5  ô
ô
' R CR  $     > & 
 5  
 &  R  5 $ , & 
 5 , &—  0  0
1 
' 2   ô?&       
,  + J    5   ð — & 
ô
ô
' % (A  ô$      & &  &  
     R 
R    "  
>   1
- 
'   ô( R5$,5  , & = &  
     G G; $  , 1 ôô

' —",  ôð  &   "    
      5   ð — & 

0
R5$,R ô
' , ,  ô3   + "  
)     4 5 , &—  0
1
' % ?  ô          J
 & = & &  R5$,5  , &  &  
  5 , &— 0 --
ô
' ð +>>  ôC       & 

     G5   $ë  &  --

' , ,5  ô(    "  )  
7      R G     ô
-
' , >$  ô     
  = &         7 
    +    0111
0
' , GR  ô> &      &  
 R  5 $ R5$,G G; 
$  ,  1 1
0
' @   ôR9 $   R  
5 $ , R5$,, ?  ð  
5 $ $      0100
ô

0
—R6>  K-1
 2GR6   ,?5 —>,$ð*ð  >
C   ,               
  1-,-

   @A,$ðð  >C,  GR?>2*
%   $  ?  =?   R5$,  
 &       1-,-
ô
 ð ðG%   $*6   ,       
    R5$, &       1-,0
0
 5 
@9 A>ð ðG2GR,  GR*,  ,ð
  (   &   &    &   R5$,  
 &       1-, 
 
 5 —>, GR3 D,AA " G,5 
@9 A
, ,ð* $>   $     
R5$,( , &         1-,
1 
 % G@   >?, ,5  & GA5?*@  ,
   + &      =5  
   &  R5$,     1-,1
0
 ,  GR, ,ð3 D,A@ +2A " G,5 
—>*5 
@9 A   ,       R5$,(
, &         "         1-,
- 
 3  22G*%  A  (   R5$,  & 
 ,      1-, 

0
—R6>   
    >5 7?A, 7 @% &  2G*5 —
>  R         R  
5 $ ,  (    -ô
ô
 ,   @   >??,$ðð  >C*5 —
>  >     )      
  4 5  , & —  1ô11
0-
 ?6, 7—R G, 7 @A*5 —>   

8 9   6  R5$,:2  +>   =R& 


   4 5 , & —  1ôôô
ô-1
 @ ,   @   >*$ ,  (  
 "      R5$,:> 5  &  ,  
 R=—R6>>—ë
11
R5—;
   %6  A,?, 7 @*5 —
>         R  5 
$ , R5$,:   &  $ R   1 

   A,?63 
  —, 7 @A*5 —
>   >   R5$,:   &    "   
=R   6  R5$,:2  +>    5 
, & —  1ôô
 -
   A,3  2*5 —>  —  "R5$,
     &  A *—R@ +  , & 
   5 , & —      1
 >5,,$ " 
6$5,
 15 &    01
—R6>   
 3 
  —  A,, 7 @?*5 —
>   —         <   
           5 , & —  1
ô-ô
ô0
 3 
  —3  2  A, >*5 —
>  
       &  =( R5$,
8    A *—R@ +  , &    
5 , & —     -ô
 >5,,$ " 6
$5,
 15 &   
 >  $3 G(  ?(5 —>
@   >?*ð  >C  R5$,   =(   
   G  R "       ô1
0
 ð  >C?6,$ð>  $@   >?*
5 —> R5$,     
  "    "         —   
— & ô1 
11
 ð  >C,$ð?6@   >?2GR*
5 —>  ? R5$,        
 "6 G    "    5 , & —  
1- ô
-.
 5 
@9 A>G L?ð, ð@ +2*2G
 3  &        M   
"    45   ð — &  0 -
1

00
—R6>   
 ,$ð +A5"" G, GR5 
@9 A
ð85>  $ëG>* $> ,   
           0 
1
 3  23 
  —> "*  A,
 A   ?= 5 +A   GRR
  =  
 1
 ?61  
8 9        
R5$,:ð

, &  & ð    , &  
1
0
 ?61 $"
      
   R5$,:ð

, &  &  ð    
, &  
-
 ?65 "   @? *, 
1 R  
8       
   ð
ð
, & R5$,: >—ë
1-
,
 5  & GA5 —>* $>1$ 
    R  5 $ , R5$,:
    &  5 , & —  1  ô
ô-
 5 —>@2G, 7 @A*5 @1
$     &   =R &   
>%   R5$, & 
 &  &  R  G  
  ;  ô 



—R6>   
   D%?6 " A6*A  (
1 ,            
R5$,:ð

, &  &  ð    , & 
1
 
   A,3 
  —?63  2*
5 —> 1 $     ,  
R  5 $ , & R5$, 5 G  
2  & ,  ô 11 
0
 3 
  —  A,?, 7 @  
%*5 —> 1 —  #       J
            5 , & 
—   1 1- 
 
 >  $?( *5 —>0 >   
  R5$,
"    "     
   5 , &  C  —   ô
1
ô
 @   >?,   *D    G 0 — 
"    ) =R     8 5 $  
$  ô 1 
1  
   A?2G— *5 —> 0 ( 
 "  R  5 $ , & 
R5$,$   $& C 7  ë ,  =R
       G  ; 
5     
-
0
—R6>   
 3 
  —?  A,, 7 @A
  %*5 —> 0 5       
            #   
G  %          1
0ô
   62G5  @R*5 —>> ô — & 
      &         
 J     5 , & —  &0 
   
 -
 > "5 —>*@ + $ô > &    &  
 R5$,:5  , &  5 , & —  &0
    -1
-
  D 5?65  @R@  ,>*5 —>
ô ?) &            R5$,:
5  , &  5 , & —  &0   
 
 1
 ?6? R  G5 "   @*5 
—>ô $         R5$,:
5  , &  5 , & —  &0   

 
 ?6ð  >5 "   @*5 —>ô >
     R5$,      4 R6 
G          01 -
11

0-
—R6>   
 5  @R2GR5 —>ô    
        8     &     
     ?&    5 $  1--
1 
 5  R  G2  ,*5 —>ô R   
) &    ,  ?&  R5$,:5  
, &  )      5 , & —  &0
    0
  
 @  ,CJ  G5 —>  —RH  &+R5  
@R* $>ô       R5$,:
5  , & 5 , & —  0ô-
--
 A & —?ð ðGG*2GRô — & 
   &   R5$,:5  , & 5 , & 
—  &0   1-
ô
 CJ  RGH  &+R?6H "+A* $>
ô  
8 9   R5$,:5  , & 5 
, & —  &0    
 
 CJ  RGH  &+R5 —>5  @R@  ,*
 $>ô ?8       R5$,: 
 &           " 
 & 5 , & —  &0   -
ô

0
—R6>   
 , A5 —>H  &+R* $
> ô $     %
A &  
R  5 $ , %
R5$,    
  01ô1

   A,?63 
  —*5 —
>  (        J 8   
"           —   
— & 1 
 
 ?6H  &+R* $>  R  
         4 5 
, &  C  —     ô1
ô
 ð 6  33 
  —%   7
$—*5 —>    )  
  "    "R R   3 
          G  R 5 
ô--
- 
 6
 7 ;(  G,+>53  23 

  —5  *5 — C"     


   ;   =C"  $  J
$  &  (   ð 
 —  ,$ 9 ——RR(  A,*5 —
> R  
 &        
&     "    
)   &   2  & —  0  ô

0
—R6>   
 5 —>2G2Aë, 7 @A  GG
               
 
      J    J       
  00  , 1,
, 
 >  @@   >?3  23 
  —%  —
5 —>-> &   , 
      R5$,
G G  ;  $  ,  11
 
 ?62 + @@   >?5 "   @*2  
, - $"
     &   
        —   — & 0ô=
 0
 , G2   G 7 2  ,@  , 6
2G  6, + +?*A >- (  &  
 R5$,     65R5$, GR,
$ 1

 —  ,$7G*5 —>-(   "   
 &         ; A 
—        
1 
 ,   >?6, —*@   >?>  
        =    "  4
- 5   ð — &  1=0-
ô
 (  +,@   >??65 A D 5 *;  >>
- ë       R5$,  5 
  ð — &   1 -
1

ô
—R6>   
 3 
  —ð 6%   7$*5 —> 
A          &          "
5 5  , & —  01ôô
ô 
 ?62 + @@5 "   @*5 —>
 5 8     8
       
   "      &    "     45 
, & —  01 11
0 
   >ð*?6 $     
  &  "     5 , & —  01  ô

 
 3 
  —?6C  R, @*5 —>
 , &           R5$,   "
5     01
 
 ;  >?65 —>@ >*ð  > 2  
" =      8      &  
R5$,:   &     0ô0
 
 ð 6  33 
  —%   7$—*5 
—>  —     =2 + 3      
G  5    $ ë  &   1
0-
  D 5?6@   >?*(  +,, ë  
+  7         ð  
-
 
 — RR$ +55 —> ? *>  —R   
    8     &    "    
R5$,:5   & 45 , & —  01 

ô
—R6>   
  ,?6 $>@   >?2@R, 7 @
A5  R*5 —>$      
    "           8   5   
ð — & 10
ô1
 ?65 & R@   >?5 "   @*5 —>
R9  "     8       
   =     5 , &— 00ô0
ô 
 ?6H  &+R% ?A  35 "  @
2 + @*% A?  &      8 
   R5$,   &  5 , &— 00ô
ô 
 %   $  > &      
"     
  "    $   0 10
1ô0
 3  
C 2  R R5$, R    
  G5   $ë  & ô
- 
 ?6  R9  "     8    
       =     5 , & 
—  00ô0
ô 
 ?6      &    &  
 
   8   "   7  5R5$, & 
    0- 0
0
 2 + @  C     =(    &  
 &   5 , & —  00 -1ô
-0
 5  R?6  $   &       
  8       "        0- ô
ô-
 ?6   >   +  5R5$,  
  " 4    —   — & -ô
-1
 % ?   —  #      <  
      5R5$, &    — — &--0

 A  3%?6        
         8        ô
        —   — & -1
ôô