Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Section 9 to 13
Restitution of Conjugal
Rights u/s 9
Conjugal Right is a matrimonial right
which husband and wife have to each
others society, comfort and
affection;
This is the express condition of the
law that each party to the marriage
is to become life associate of the
other and enjoy the pleasures and
consortium of each other
Incidents of Sec 9
Where the wife or the husband as the case may be
Has withdrawn from the society of the other,
Without reasonable excuse,
The court is satisfied of the truth of the statements
made in the petition, and
There is no legal ground why the application should
not be granted
-u/s9(1) the husband or wife may get the decree of
restitution of conjugal rights
-the burden of proving the reasonable excuse shall be
on the person who has withdrawn from the society.
Grounds
1. u/s 10(1)(a) - Extra-marital voluntary sexual intercourse
where either party to marriage wilfully had sexual intercourse
with another person after marriage, the other party to marriage
could obtain the decree of judicial separation.
To decide cases one has to depend on ancillary facts which may
bea) Circumstantial evidence;
b) Birth of a child to the wife when there is no evidence of contact
with her;
c) Contracting of a venereal disease;
d) Admission on the part of the respondent in some other
proceedings or a clear confession by him/her;
e) Discovery of letters which might contain such contents which
suggest sexual relationship between the two.
Cruelty
The expression cruelty is not defined in the act
The judicial decisions have made it distinct that
cruelty in the legal sense not necessarily be
physical violence;
A course of conduct or treatment which tends to
undermine the health of the spouse/ affects the
reasonable happiness of the life and ill-treatment
both physical and mental would constitute cruelty;
There is mental as well physical cruelty;
Motive or intention to be cruel is not necessary if
conduct otherwise can be held to be cruel
Leprosy
Where the respondent is a victim of serious
leprosy in its incurable and virulent form, a
decree of divorce will be passed in favour
of petitioner;
Virulent means the disease is considered
to be extremely poisonous;
No person can be forced to undergo a
medical examination but if he or she
refuses to do so, it raises a presumption
against that person.
Venereal disease
Where the respondent has been suffering from
venereal disease in a communicable form, a
decree of divorce will be granted in favour of
petitioner;
The period of duration is dispensed with by
Marriage Laws (amendment) Act, 1976;
The section requires that the disease must be
in a communicable form;
Venereal diseases are only such diseases which
are communicated by sexual intercourse.
Presumptive death
Where there are reasonable grounds for supposing the
other party to marriage to be dead, the petitioner may
seek divorce on this ground.
This supposition could be drawn where the other party
has not been heard of as being alive for a period of 7
years or more by persons who would naturally have
heard of him/her had that party been alive.
On the court being satisfied that sufficient enquiries
have been made as to the existence of the respondent
and has no reason to think that he/she is alive, pass the
decree of divorce on this ground;
If the respondent returns the marriage will not get
restored.