Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Questions
How is it possible to understand such a requirement
for compliance once the origin and character of these
values are put into question?
What are the sources of societal values? Should they
be only secular?
Given that political autonomy is a core liberal principle
how can one take account of individuals distinct
values in multicultural societies?
Pragmatism
Ernst Tugendhat
Compromise of interests X moral
consensus
Fails to justify the superiority of reflexive
modes of justification for collective action
Classical Liberalism
Rawls Original Position X Perspective of
real-life argumentation
Contextualism
Ethnocentrism X Expansion of
interpretive horizons
Why Translation?
Alasdair MacIntyre
() every tradition is embodied in some particular
set of utterances and actions and thereby in all the
particularities of some specific language and culture
(Whose Justice, Which Rationality?, 1998: 371)
Learn as a second language
Conclusion
Legitimacy :
-Dialogical evaluation of validity claims
(reason and tradition)
Rethinking the postmetaphysical
foundations of democracy
Common values Engagement and
challenge for a moral consensus