Please check, just in case

APA Tip of the Day: Past Tense

When you describe what an author wrote,
use past tense:
Sleeter (1986) argued that
When defining disability, Jones (1996)
stated that
Rosenblum and Travis (2006) defined

However!
Do not make all of the verbs in the sentence in
past tense:
Sleeter (1986) argued that learning
disabilities are socially constructed.
NOT
Sleeter (1986) argued that learning
disabilities were socially constructed. (Unless
past tense is meaningful in that context.)

Announcements
1. The first major assignment is not due until
March 9th. However, you are already working
on it via your readings reviews make sure
that you carefully review the Key Concept
paper assignment description ASAP, so that
you can gear your readings reviews toward
completion of that assignment.
2. Make an appointment to go over upcoming
assignments in advance.

Quick
questions or
quandaries?

Todays Topic:
Introducing theories
of language
development

Important dates in the history of

language development theory:
1957: Skinner publishes Verbal
behavior a behaviorist explanation for
language development
1959: Chomsky publishes a negative
review of Verbal behavior in
Language.
1965: Chomsky published Aspects of
the theory of syntax (a nativist
explanation of language development).

NOTE!
As of yet, there is no one theory
of language development which:
o Is universally accepted as the
explanation for first language
development, or
o Explains all aspects of language
development: syntax, morphology,
semantics, phonology, and
pragmatics.

Famous Behavior Theorists:

Pavlov
Watson
Skinner
Hewett
Lovaas

Classical Conditioning

What is learning?
According to behaviorists,
learning occurs as a
result of the consequences
of behavior.
Alberto & Troutman, 2003, p. 18

What is learning?
According to behaviorists,
learning occurs as a result
of the consequences of
behavior.
Alberto & Troutman, 2003, p. 18

The A, B, Cs of
behaviorism:
Antecendent
Behavior
Consequence

Operant Conditioning:

Good job!

positive reinforcement,
negative reinforcement, and
punishment
I will bring my homework to
school every day.
I will bring my homework to
school every day.

Two other mechanisms for

learning:
Shaping:
Reinforcement of subsequent
approximations of the target behavior.

Modeling:
Learning by watching and imitating.

Quick Write
What understandings about theories
of language development did you
take away from the de Valenzuela
and Niccolai (2004) reading?

Contrary evidence for a

behaviorist explanation of
language development:

He brunged his
lunch

Other contrary evidence

Young infants learn are born with the ability
to discriminate between a variety of sounds
that are not in their own language.
However, by 6-9 months, they lose the
ability to differentiate between similar
sounds that are not distinct phonemes in
their language (e.g. /l/ and /r/ for Japanese
speakers). But children at that age are not
yet using words.
How do they learn this without
behavioral reinforcement?

Hypothesis Testing
Formulaic speech (i.e. went)
Rule formation (i.e. ed)
Over-extension (i.e. goed)
Exceptional to the rule (i.e.
went)

Example of grammatical overextension and resistance to correction:

Child:

he falled down

Mom:

no Timmy, he fell down

Child:

yeah, he falled down

Browns First 14 Morphemes:

present progressive
-ing (without
auxiliary)
in
on
regular plural -s
irregular past
possessive -s
uncontractible
copula (to be as
main verb)

articles
regular past -ed
regular 3rd person -s
irregular 3rd person
uncontractible
auxiliary
contractible copula
contractible auxiliary

See http://firstyears.org/c1/u5/brown.htm for examples

Criticisms of a behavioral theory

of language development:

Overly simplistic explanation.

Overlooks learner contributions
Untestable.
Ignores un-reinforceable development
(e.g. phonological knowledge) and
unreinforced productions does not
explain the acquisition of underlying
rules.

Note:
These are criticisms of behaviorism
as a theory of language
development. It is not a criticism
of applied behavior analysis as a
method of teaching discrete
behaviors.

Misconception Alert!
observation & imitation

operant conditioning

Imitation Behaviorism
It seems quite beyond question that
children acquire a good deal of their
verbal and nonverbal behavior by
casual observation and imitation of
adults and other children [emphasis
added] (Chomsky, 1959, p. 42).

Chomsky's
explantion?

UG and LAD
Important components of nativist
theories of language acquisition are:
o Language acquisition device
o Universal grammar

The Nativist Explanation:

Children are born with a specific
innate ability to discover for
themselves the underlying rules of
a language system on the basis of
the samples of a natural language
they are exposed to.
(Lightbown & Spada, 2006, p. 15)

Nature AND Nurture

According to Chomsky (1959), the
characteristics of complex organisms
are in general a complicated product of
inborn structure, the genetically
determined course of maturation, and
past experience (p. 27).

Inborn structure????

It appears to be a fundamental fact about

human beings that our behavior and
behavioral capacities often surpass the
limitations of our individual reinforcement
histories. Our history of reinforcement often
is too impoverished to determine uniquely
what we do or how we do it. Much learning,
therefore, seems to require pre-existing or
innate representational structures or
principled constraints within which learning
occurs.
Graham, 2005, http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/behaviorism/

Chomskyan Nativism
The childs language grows in the mind as
the visual system develops the capacity for
binocular vision, or as the child undergoes
puberty at a certain stage of maturation.
Language acquisition is something that
happens to a child placed in a certain
environment, not something the child does.
(Chomsky, as cited in Cowie, 1999, p. 153)

Universal Grammar Definition

Innate linguistic knowledge which, it is
hypothesized, consists of a set of
principles common to all languages.
This term is associated with
Chomskys theory of language
acquisition.
(Lightbown & Spada, 2006, p. 205)

Small Group Activity:

Summarize the development of
early communication and language
development presented in Cattell
using big paper.

20 minutes!

Main Points:
1. Behaviorism is generally not accepted
as an adequate theoretical explanation
for the development of complex
cognitive systems, such as language.
2. The nativist explanation of language
development, as acquired not learned,
is diametrically opposed to behavioral
theories.

Main Points, cont.:

3. It is possible that different theoretical
explanations might account for the
development of different aspects of
language and/or communication.

Looking ahead
Social and interactionist
perspectives on language
development

Please take a
minute for the
minute paper.

And dont forget to turn

your phone back on.