Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Management
in Primary Health Care System
Pradana Soewondo
Diabetes and Lipid Center,
Department of Internal Medicine
Faculty of Medicine University of IndonesiaCipto Mangunkusumo National Referral Hospital
Jakarta, Indonesia
Agenda
Introduction
Results of IDMPS
Indonesia
Perkeni Guidelines and
Awareness Survey
Prolanis T2DM
Conclusion
of
Type 2 Diabetes in Indonesia
Known DM
Undiagnosed DM
Total DM
IGT
1,5 %
4,2 %
5,7 %
10,2 %
1. Indonesia
2. Thailand
3. The Philippine
4. Malaysia
5. Vietnam
6. Myanmar
7. Singapore
8. Cambodia
9. Lao Peoples
Democratic
Republic
10.Brunei
11.Timor Leste
2030
Number
Number
Country
(age 20
79)
6.963.50 1. Indonesia
0 2. Thailand
(age 20
79)
11.980.0
00
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
The Philippine
4.956.200
Malaysia
6.163.800
Vietnam
3.244.500
Myanmar
3.414.900
Singapore
1.754.900
Cambodia
742.000
Lao Peoples
724.200
Democratic
301.500
Republic
28.200 10.Brunai
53.500
16.300 11.Timor Leste
Atlas IDF,33.500
2010
3.538.000
3.398.200
1.846.000
1.646.600
921.800
436.600
354.000
143.300
IDMPS
Indonesia
715 DM patients
686 met inclusion/exclusion
criteria
12 T1DM and 674 T2DM
Location : 85% urban vs 15%
rural
Age : mean 55.16 (SD 10.20)
years
BMI
Sex : female
54.6% vs male
52.6
60
50 45.4%
34.3
40
30
18.5-25
25-30
30-35
>35
90
76.7
80
70
60
50
40
30
16.8
20
10
6.4
0.1
IDMPS Indonesia
40.6
HbA1c
Measurement
59.4
A1c Measurements
No A1cMeasurements
OGLD
HbA1c
OGLD Insulin
+
Group
Insulin
<7%
14.3
32.9
15.8
HbA1c
8.49
8.12
8.58
Mean (SD) (1.42) (2.12)
(2.61)
Diet +
Exerci Total
se
44.4
30.5
7.04
8.27
(1.18) (2.19)
IDMPS Indonesia
Comorbidities and
Complications Type 2
Variable
Hypertension
Yes with treatment
Yes but no treatment
No hypertension
Dislipidemia
Yes with treatment
Yes but no treatment
No dislipidemia
Late complication
At least one
No complication
Lifestyle
OGLD
Insulin +
Total
8 (38.1)
0
13 (61.9)
230 (44.2)
17 (3.3)
273 (52.5)
59 (45.4)
5 (3.8)
66 (50.8)
297 (44.3)
22 (3.3)
352 (52.5)
8 (40.0)
4 (20.0)
8 (40.0)
179 (42.6)
36 (8.6)
205 (48.8)
53 (50.0)
12 (11.3)
41 (38.7)
240 (44.0)
52 (9.5)
254 (46.5)
9 (69.2)
4 (30.8)
290 (70.6)
121 (29.4)
97 (85.8)
16 (14.2)
396 (73.7)
141 (26.3)
Diabetic Complications
60
Microangiopathy >>
Macroangiopathy
54
50
Re nopathy
Neuropathy
Proteinuria
40
30
Dialysis
33.4
Foot Ulcer
26.5
Amputa on
Angina
MCI
20
10.9
8.7
10
0.5
0
7.4
1.3
5.3
2.7
5.3
Heart Failure
Stroke
PAD
IDMPS Indonesia
Resource Use
Variable
Specialty
GPs/ internists
Endocrinologists
Follow up in the last 3
months
By GPs/ internists
Followed up
None
By endocrinologists
Followed up
None
Type 2
Lifestyle
OGLD
Insulin +
Total
13 (61.9)
8 (38.1)
387 (74.0)
136 (26.0)
71 (54.6)
59 (45.4)
471 (69.9)
203 (30.1)
1 (33.3)
2 (66.7)
105 (60.7)
68 (39.3)
23 (47.9)
25 (52.1)
129 (57.6)
95 (42.4)
13 (100.0)
0
332 (95.4)
16 (4.6)
96 (98.0)
2 (2.0)
446 (96.1)
18 (3.9)
Indirect Cost
Variable
Working productivity
Unemployed
Normal work
Sick leave
Unable to work
Hospitalized
Yes
No
Mean (SD)
Median
Type 2 DM
359 (53.3)
234 (34.8)
64 (9.5)
16 (2.4)
69 (15.8)
369 (84.2)
1.1 (0.5)
1.0
IDMPS Indonesia,2007
Education Session
Variable
Lifestyle
Diabetes education
Given
None
Mean (SD)
Median
8 (40.0)
12 (60.0)
6.8 (4.7)
3.0
Type 2
OGLD
168 (34.6)
317 (65.4)
4.1 (3.3)
3.0
Insulin +
Total
49 (41.2)
70 (58.8)
4.3 (3.9)
7.0
225 (36.1)
399 (63.9)
4.2 (3.5)
3.0
% Target Achievement
70
58
60
50
44
40
40
37.4
34.45
30
16
20
10
0
China
South Korea
Panama
Egypt
Indonesia DIabCare-Indonesia
Conclusion
DIABETES
Chronic condition with comorbidities and
complications
Huge resource use and significant cost
ACTION
early diagnosis
prompt treatment
effective metabolic control
screening for diabetic complications
The
Indonesian Society of
Endocrinologist's
Diabetes Mellitus
National Clinical
Practice Guidelines
DM
Lifestyle
Modification
Phase-I
Lifestyle
Modification
+
OAD Monotherapy
Phase-II
Lifestyle
Modification
+
2 OADs
Combination
Alternative :
Insulin not available
Patient preference
Glucose control not
optimal
Notes :
Fail : not achieving A1c target <7% after 2-3
months of treatment.
(A1c = average blood glucose conversion, ADA
2010)
Lifestyle
Modification
+
3 OADs
Combination
Phase-III
Lifestyle
Modification
+
2 OADs
Combination
+
Basal insulin
Intensive Insulin
HbA1c Level
7-8%
Lifestyle
Modification
Lifestyle
Modification
<7%
+
Monotherapy
Met, SU, AGI,
Glinid, TZD,
DPP-IV
8-9%
>9%
9-10%
>10%
Lifestyle
Modification
+
2 OADs
Combination
Met, SU, AGI,
Glinid, TZD,
DPP-IV
Notes :
Fail : not achieving A1c target <7% after 23 months of treatment.
(A1c = average blood glucose conversion,
ADA 2010)
Lifestyle
Modification
+
3 OADs
Combination
Met, SU, AGI,
Glinid, TZD,
DPP-IV
Lifestyle
Modification
+
2 OADs
Combination
Met, SU, AGI,
Glinid, TZD
+
Lifestyle
Modification
Basal Insulin
+
Intensive
Insulin
Characteristics
n (%)
Media
n
Minmax
Age (n=399)
15 years
0-45 years
Gender (n=399)
Male / Female
208 (53)
Private clinic
64 (16)
96 (22)
Private hospital
20 (5)
8 (2)
Academic hospital
6 (2)
119 (33)
127 (35)
Characteristics
Participation in DM training
(n=367)
Yes
Number of DM patients seen in
a week (n=343)
Proportion of DM patients
among all patients seen
(n=381)
<10%
10-30%
>30%
Awareness to DM consensus
(n=383)
Never know
Heard but never had
Had but never read
Read and implement
n (%)
Media
n
Minmax
1-120
234 (64)
243 (64)
117 (31)
21 (5)
43 (11)
138 (36)
78 (20)
124 (33)
Conclusion
Despite high awareness GPs may not adopt
*Diet initially then sulphonylureas, insulin and/or metformin if FPG >15 mmol/L
ADA clinical practice recommendations. UKPDS 34, n=1704
UKPDS 34. Lancet 1998:352:85465; Kahn et al (ADOPT). N Engl J Med 2006;355:242743
*Conventional treatment (
); diet initially then sulphonylureas, insulin and/or metformin if FPG >15 mmol/L
in developing countries
1. WHO. Compliance to long-term therapies: evidence for action. Geneva: WHO, 2003;
2. Haynes RB et al. The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2002, Issue 2.
barrier
Social and economic factors
Healthcare team/system
Condition-related factors
Therapy-related factors
Patient-related factors
WHO. Compliance to long-term therapies: evidence for action. Geneva: WHO, 2003.
self-management
More effective interventions are essential
WHO. Compliance to long-term therapies: evidence for action. Geneva: WHO, 2003.
Indirect Costs
Loss of productivity
Premature retirement
Premature mortality
Pain, anxiety and inconvenience
12/25/16
12
/2
5/
16
12
/2
5/
16
12/25 12/25/1
/16
6
12/2
5/16
12/2
5/16
12
/2
5/
16
12
/2
5/
16
12/2
5/16
Diabetesrelated
death
Myocardial
infarction
Microvascular
complications
10
14%*
20
30
40
50
Other drugs
18%
Ambulatory
Hospitalization
37%*
*p<0.0001
Dat
e
20%
55%
21%*
Antidiabetic drugs
43%*
Source: Revealing the cost of Type II diabetes in
Europe, B. Jnsson in Diabetologia (2002)
23
20
14
15
10
5
0
ASKES
126.104 pts
258.208 pts
384.312 pts
Million US$
Without Complications
Data
Total
With Complications
900
40
US$
ed
ma
Pri
ry
re
Ca
ru
St
ur
ct
l
Se
ed
Tertiary
Secondary
e
ar
fC
Se
c
da on
r
Ca y
re
s
Un
ur
ct
Rujukan Kewenangan
Primary Care
Tertiary Care
RS/PUSKESMAS
DAERAH
GATE KEEPER
INTERVENSI 3 :
Self Care
PRAKTEK SWASTA
PELAYANAN
PELAYANAN
TIDAK
TIDAK
OPTIMAL
OPTIMAL
RS/PUSKESMAS
DAERAH
PUSK
ESMA
S
RS
DAER
AH
PRAKTEK SWASTA
RS
DAER
AH
PUSAT RUJUKAN
PUSK
ESMA
S
DOKTER KELUARGA
38
NHS
England
28 %
INA CBGs
76 %
56 %
Kapitasi
Gate Keeper
15 %
BPJS Kesehatan
24 %
BASIC CONCEPT
Managed
Care
Referral system
Selected Provider (Credentialling)
Provider Payment System
Utilization Review
Preventive & Promotive
Drugs Formulary Fornas and Refer Back Program
Penjelasan Poin 2
Obat Penyakit
Kronis
e. Pelayanan obat mengacu kepada Formularium Nasional baik nama
generik, jenis, kekuatan maupun restriksinya. Brand obat dan
peresepan maksimal mengacu kepada DPHO PT. Askes (Persero) Tahun
2013
f. Dalam hal obat yang diresepkan tidak tercantum dalam Formularium
Nasional, maka biaya obat tersebut sudah termasuk dalam komponen
paket INA CBG
g. Obat yang diresepkan pada poin 5.d hanya untuk obat kronis. Apabila
pasien membutuhkan obat akut maka obat tersebut disediakan oleh
Rumah Sakit dan biaya sudah termasuk dalam komponen paket INA
CBG
h. Obat pada poin 5.d.ii. dibayar oleh BPJS Kesehatan mengacu pada ecatalogue obat Tahun 2014 ditambah dengan faktor pelayanan dan
embalage sesuai SE Menteri Kesehatan RI Nomor HK/31/Menkes/I/2014.
Sebelum adanya ketetapan e-catalogue obat Tahun 2014, maka harga
obat mengacu pada DPHO PT Askes (Persero) Tahun 2013 dan/atau ecatalogue obat Tahun 2013.
DM, hipertensi,
jantung,asma,PPOK,epilepsi,skizofren,sirosi
s hepatis,stroke,SLE
Captiation
Primary Care
Provider
Referral
Hospital
Emergency
Claim Ina
CBG
BPJS Center
Drug Prescription
Apotek
BPJS
Branch Office
PT Askes
(Persero)
Referral
Comprehensive & Continued
control
Care
Mentor &
(Guidelines Evidence Based)
consultant for
- Referral to the advanced level GPs
- Health Education
- Health Status Monitoring
- Prescription chronic
drugs
Health status evaluation and
feedback
Health care cost
Workshop for family Physician (DM
Family Physician
Type2)
by endokrin specialist
Members
Chronic Disease
DM Tipe2
(individual
treatment)
DM Guidelines
MEDICAL PROFESIONAL ORGANIZATION
PERHIMPUNAN ENDOKRINOLOGI INDONESIA (PERKENI)
Primary Care
for Members Diagnosed DM Type 2
Members
Diagnosed
DM Type 2
Register to Primary
Care
Family Physician
Individual Physician
500 to 2.000 members
Group Physicians
with maximum 50 members
Clinics
diagnosed DM Type 2
7 PILAR PPDM 2
KONSU
L-TASI
MEDIS
REMINDE
R
KLUB
RISTI
PENYULU
HAN
OLAHRAGA
CLINICA
L
GUIDELI
NE
7
PILAR
PPDM
PEMANTAUAN STATUS
KESEHATAN
PELAYAN
AN OBAT
SCR
TEPAT &
CEPAT
HOME
VISIT
51
Target of Treatment
Risk CVD (-)
Blood Glucose
-
FPG (mg/dL)
< 100
< 100
< 140
< 140
< 7,0
< 7,0
A1C (%)
BMI (kg/m2)
Blood Pressure
18,5
- < 23
18,5
- < 23
< 130/80
< 130/80
Total Cholesterol(mg/dL)
<200
<200
Triglyceride (mg/dL)
<150
<150
>40/>50
>40/>50
< 100
< 70
Lipid
Periode
EKG
ECHO
Blood
Glucose
Test
1 per
Month
Sistole /
Diastole
1 per
Month
Body Mass
Index
1 per
Month
Albumin
HBA1C
1 per 6
Month
SGPT
Rontgen Thoraks
Funduscopy
ABI
Ureum
Creatinin
SGOT
Protein Kualitatif
Cholesterol Total
Choleterol LDL
Cholesterol HDL
Trigliserida
1 per
Year
URAIAN
BPJS KESEHATAN
1.
Landasan Hukum
Peraturan BPJS
2.
Pemberi Layanan
3.
Cakupan PRB
4.
5.
Sistem
pembiayaan Obat
PRB
6.
DM dan HT
Fee For Service langsung kepada
Apotek
Sediaan dan
Kekuatan
OPR
B
Keterangan:
Acarbose
Glibenklamid
Ta 2,5 , 5 mg
Glicazid
Tab MR 30 mg
Glikuidon
30 mg
Glimepirid
Tab 1, 2 ,3,4 mg
Glipizide
Tab 5, 10 mg
Metformin
Pio Glitazon
Tab 5 dan 10 mg
Antidiabetes
Oral
Antidiabetes parenteral
Sediaan dan
Kekuatan
OPRB
Keterangan:
Antihipertensi Oral
amlodipin
tab 5, 10 mg
atenolol
tab 50 , 100 mg
beraprost sodium
tab 20 mg
v
v
x
bisoprolol
tab 5 mg
diltiazem
doksazosin
hidroklortiazid
tab 25 mg
imidapril
tab 5 dan 10 mg
irbesartan
kaptopril
klonidin
Tab 0,15 mg
kandesartan
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
Antihipertensi
oral
klortalidon
lisinopril
metildopa
nifedipin
Sediaan dan
Kekuatan
tab 50 mg
Tab 5, 10 dan 20
mg
Tab 250 mg
kap 10 mg, tab
20 mg SR, tab 30
mg oros
perindoprilarginin tab 5 mg
propranolol
tab 10 mg
ramipril
OPRB
v
v
v
telmisartan
tab 40 ; 80 mg
valsartan
tab 80 ; 160 mg
verapamil
Keterangan:
Orphan Drugs
Lifestyle interventions
1 to 2%
Metformin
1 to 2%
Sulfonylureas
1 to 2%
Insulin
Glinides
1.5 to 3.5%
1 to 1.5%1
Thiazolidinediones
0.5 to 1.4%
-Glucosidase inhibitors
0.5 to 0.8%
GLP-1 agonist
0.5 to 1.0%
Pramlintide
0.5 to 1.0%
DPP-IV inhibitors
0.5 to 0.8%
1. Repaglinide is more effectie than nateglinide
Adapted from Nathan DM, et al. Diabetes Care
2009;32:193-203.
tab 50 mg
v
vitamin B kompleks
Tab
Tab 10 mg dan 25 mg
Reimbursment System
Primary Care
Specialist Care
Conclusion
Diabetic cost is increasing
High rate of undiagnosed diabetes
High rate of uncontrolled blood glucose
High rate of complications
Efficacy of treatment depends not only on
medication but also on patients
compliance and healthcare system
The need of health care restructurization to
fit the management of chronic diseases
Improving the quality of care may increase
the cost efectiveness of diabetes
management