You are on page 1of 40

The effects of voltage

sags
For IEEE Hong Kong Section
May 31, 2002

by
Terry Chandler
Power Quality Inc/Power Quality Thailand LTD

May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org All rig 1
hts reserved
Sags or Dips?
A decrease in the nominal voltage
for a short duration.

May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 2
Standards regarding Sags

IEC 1000-4-1/11 Measurement of sags


IEEE 1159 Monitoring of Sags
IEEE P1346
ANSI C84.1
IEEE 1100

May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 3
IEEE SCC 22
Short duration variations
2.1 Instantaneous
2.1.2 Sag(Dip) 0.5 to 30 cycles 0.1 to 0.9
pu

sags (dips) have a magnitude and


duration
SCC is the standard coordination
committee of IEEE
May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 4
Accepted description

Sag is a IEEE term DIP is IEC term


Sag refers to % of decrease in Voltage
IE a 20% sag is a voltage decrease to 0.8 PU

DIP refers to % of voltage remaining


IE a dip to 80% is a decrease to 0.8 PU

Is the glass half full or half empty?


May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 5
Classifying Sags (Dips)

CBEMA

100%

May 2002 1 day


WWW.powerquality.org 6
Classifying sags (dips) II

ITIC (New
CBEMA)

acceptable
May 2002
unacceptable
WWW.powerquality.org 7
Cause of Voltage sags

Faults on the distribution system


User distribution system failure
User loads
Equipment malfunction

May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 8
Faults on the distribution
system

May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 9
User equipment that can
cause sags
Copiers and laser printers
Arc welders
Motor starting
Power saws

May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 10
Welder causes voltage sag

May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 11
Voltage sag from the
utility

May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 12
Semi 47 Voltage sag
standard
A new standard developed by the
SEMI organization members to
define the desired minimum
equipment sensitivity to voltage
sags
Similar to ITIC curve in the voltage
sag domain
May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 13
ITIC Semi 47

May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 14
ITIC
Semi 47
| 0.5 sec | 10 sec

20 ms

50 ms 0.2 0.5 second

May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 15
Load sensitivity to voltage
sags
Motors
Contactors that

Small 50% sag shuts down 600 hp load


May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 16
Sag indications without a
PQ meter
Lights blink
Motors slow down and return to
normal speed
Computers reboot unexpectedly
Automated equipment stops
unexpectedly
May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 17
Root cause of sensitivity
Electrical contactor on the input power

Equipment
disconnect

Automated
Equipment

May 2002 Ac relay


WWW.powerquality.org 18
Process sensor
With voltage sags sends shut down signal

Equipment
disconnect
Automated Equipment

DC relay process
May 2002 sensor
WWW.powerquality.org 19
Emergency shutdown
circuit
With voltage sag sends shutdown signal
Equipment
disconnect

Automated
Equipment

Ac relay
May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 20
DC buss sag
AC motor

AC to DC DC to AC
convertor invertor

DC buss
DC relay monitor Electronic
control

May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 21
Voltage imbalance sensor

AC motor

AC to DC DC to AC
convertor invertor

voltage
unbalance Electronic
DC relay relay control

May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 22
Improving voltage sag
immunity
Relay settings
DC relays
Switchmode power supply configuration
oversize power supply or capacitor
Dynamic sag corrector
Connect loads phase to phase

May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 23
Voltage sense relays

Upper and lower trip points


May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 24
Ride thru device

May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 25
Sag mitigation
technologies
UPS
Standby
line interactive
On-Line

Dynamic voltage restorer (DVR)


Voltage Regulator
Static transfer switch

May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 26
UPS Uninterruptible Power
Supplies
Battery
On-line
Standby

Flywheel
Super conductor
Super Capacitor
Fuel Cell

May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 27
On-line UPS
System
bypass

Bypass

Rectifier Inverter
input
harmonic Load
filter Charger

Battery
system
May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 28
Rotary UPS

May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 29
Example of rotary

May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 30
DVR
B ypass

T o S o u rc e T o P la n t

Is o la tio n Is o la tio n

D V R E le c tr o n ic s
S S S h o r tin g S w itc h In v e r te r s ,
F ilte r s , C o n tr o ls

C a p E n e rg y S to ra g e

May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 31
Flywheel ups

May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 32
Example of flywheel UPS

May 2002 Photo compliments of Beacon.com


WWW.powerquality.org 33
Standby UPS

Battery or Flywheel
More efficient than on -line
Output meets ITIC or Semi-47
standard

May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 34
Standby UPS
CB3
Bypass
Utility Critical
CB1 CB2
Input Input Output Load
Static Switch

up to (8) Power Modules


System
Control

Inverter
Battery Bridge
String Battery
Charger
Isolation
Main System Container Transformer
May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 35
Example of Standby UPS

May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 36
3 phase sag

May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 37
UPS output during sag

May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 38
Conclusions
Voltage sags are the #1 Power Quality
problem
The source can be from the utility or
from internal loads, wiring, problems
etc
Solutions can be very inexpensive or
very expensive
May 2002
Graph compliments of WWW.powerstandards.com
WWW.powerquality.org 39
The bottom line

Voltage sags are an economic or $$


problem
It requires detailed PQ data to
determine if the solution costs $100 or
$10,000,000.

May 2002
WWW.powerquality.org 40

You might also like