Professional Documents
Culture Documents
HELD:
The court declared the resolution as null and void.
The comelec in the exercise of the power given to
them in determining the dates for pre-election should
not contradict any laws, which in this case is based on
Section 8 of RA 8189, that the prohibited period for
registration is only 120 days before the regular
election and 90 days for special election. The
COMELEC should respect and exercise its power
based on the substantive law.
RATIO:
Both provisions seem that they are contradicting each other but it is
still capable of being harmonized and reconciled.
Rudimentary is the principle in legal hermeneutics that changes
made by the legislature in the form of amendments to a statute
should be given effect, together with other parts of the amendment
act. It is not to be presumed that the legislature, in making such
changes, was indulging in mere semantic exercise. There must be
some purpose in making them, which should be ascertained and given
effect.
Corollarily, it is specious for herein petitioners to argue that
respondent COMELEC may validly and legally conduct a two-day
special registration, through the expedient of the letter of Section 28
of RA 8436. To this end, the provisions of Section 28, RA 8436 would
come into play in cases where the pre-election acts are susceptible of
performance within the available period prior to election day. In more
categorical language, Section 28 of R.A 8436 is, to our mind, anchored
on the sound premise that these certain "pre-election acts" are still
capable of being reasonably performed vis-a-vis the remaining period
before the date of election and the conduct of other related pre-
election activities required under the law.
TRANSFER R.A. 8189
Section 12. Change of Residence to Another City or
Municipality. Any registered voter who has
transferred residence to another city or municipality
may apply with the Election Officer of his new
residence for the transfer of his registration records.
The application for transfer of registration shall be
subject to the requirements of notice and hearing and
the approval of the Election Registration Board, in
accordance with this Act. Upon approval of the
application for transfer, and after notice of such
approval to the Election Officer of the former
residence of the voter, said Election Officer shall
transmit by registered mail the voters registration
record to the Election Officer of the voters new
residence.
TRANSFER R.A. 8189
Section 13. Change of Address in the Same City
or Municipality. Any voter who has changed his
address in the same city or municipality shall
immediately notify the Election Officer in
writing. If the change of address involves a
change in precinct, the Board shall transfer his
registration record to the precinct book of voters
of his new precinct and notify the voter of his new
precinct All changes of address shall be reported
to the office of the provincial election supervisor
and the Commission in Manila.
SEC. 12. PROCEDURE FOR FILING OF APPLICATION FOR TRANSFER
OF REGISTRATION RECORDS WITHIN THE SAME CITY AND
MUNICIPALITY DUE TO CHANGE OF ADDRESS COMELEC RESOLUTION NO. 9149
reason of marriage
court order or
ARTICLE XXII
ELECTION OFFENSES
Section 261. Prohibited Acts. - The following
shall be guilty of an election offense:
(y)(2) Any person who knowingly makes any
false or untruthful statement relative to any of
the data or information required in the
application for registration.
(5) Any person who, being a registered voter,
registers anew without filing an application for
cancellation of his previous registration.
ELECTION REGISTRATION BOARD
Composition:
Election Officer (Chairman)
Reason:
To preserve the integrity of the Election
Registration Board
NOTICE AND HEARING OF APPLICATIONS:
FOR REGISTRATION:
STEP 1: Approach the Election Assistant in-charge of
your barangay for interview and submission of
requirements.