UNIT OPERATIONS (CHE 347/ 251)

LIQUID-LIQUID
EXTRACTION
SITI FATIMAH BINTI ABDUL HALIM
FACULTY OF CHEMICAL ENGINEERING
UiTM PULAU PINANG

12/1/2017 1
 LEARNING OUTCOME

The student should be able to:

Acquire fundamental concepts of liquid-liquid extraction.
State and explain the cases for using liquid-liquid extraction.
Sketch and label liquid-liquid extraction column as required based on the information
given
Discuss and differentiate the partially miscible and immiscible systems.
Identify and differentiate between extract and raffinate phases and between solute,
carrier and solvent.
Plot the right triangular diagram (solvent vs. solute and solute vs. solvent) for partially
miscible system.
Develop new tie lines using conjugate line method as well as by using equilibrium y-x
plot.
Calculate amount and compositions of extract and raffinate phases produced for
single stage extraction.
Determine for partially miscible and immiscible systems by graphical method for multi
stages counter current flow :
amount and compositions of extract and raffinate phase produced
no. of theoretical stages required percent of extraction

12/1/2017 2
12/1/2017 3
3.1 DEFINITION & APPLICATIONS

The transfer of solute-A of a liquid solution-B (diluent/carrier) by contact with another

insoluble liquid-C (solvent).

Transfer is based on the preferential solubility of solutes-A in the liquid-C (solvent).

.
Two streams result from this contact:
a) Extract is the solvent rich solution containing the desired extracted solute.
b) Raffinate is the residual feed solution containing little solute

12/1/2017 4
 Liquid-liquid Extraction Principle

C - solvent (blue)

A-solute (black)
B-liquid solution(red)

When Liquid-liquid extraction is carried out in a test tube or flask the two
immiscible phases are shaken together to allow molecules to partition
(dissolve) into the preferred solvent phase.

12/1/2017 5
DEFINITION & APPLICATIONS
Common production processes using LLE i.e:-

i. Food processing
ii. Pharmaceutical separation
iii. Oil purification
.

The difference between LLE and distillation process in the separation of liquid mixture:-

LLE depends on solubilities between the liquid components and produces new
solution which in turn has to be separated later, whereas;

Distillations depends on the differences in A/B / P of substances. It also

requires heat supply.

12/1/2017 6
 Table 3.1.1: Industrial Liquid Liquid Extraction (LLE) Processes

CHE 347/ 251: UNIT OPERATIONS

12/1/2017 (CHAPTER 3 ) 7
-
The advantages of LLE vs distillation process:-

a) Recovery of heat-sensitive materials, where low to moderate processing

temperatures are needed. Thermal decomposition might occur.

b) Separation of mixture which the components have close boiling point (vapor
pressure)

c) Separation of mixture which its relative volatility nearly to unity

d) Presence of azeotropic mixture/solution

e) If distillation utilizes excessive amount of steam generation cost

f) Solvent recovery easily maintained and energy saving can be realized.

12/1/2017 8
Work in a group

Which one is much

more better

LLE or DISTILLATION ?

12/1/2017 9
Solvent is the key point need to consider for optimized LLE separation. The criterias are as follows:

a) Distribution coefficient - the ratio (at equilibrium) of solutes concentration in extract and
raffinate phases. It gives a measure of the affinity of the solute for
the 2 phases.
b) Solubility - the solutes are soluble in solvent but insoluble (low solubility) in the
feed solution. For example, if there is significant solubility of
solvent in the raffinate stream, an additional separation is required
to recover the solvent.
c) Recoverability - necessary to recover the solvent for re-use purposes.
d) Density - A large difference in density between extract and raffinate phases
permits high capacities in equipment. This especially important for
extraction equipments that utilizing gravity for phase separation.
e) Chemical Reactivity - Chemically stable and inert towards other components of th
system & construction
f) Viscosity / P - Low & P for ease in handling & storage. E.g. high leads to
difficulties in pumping, dispersion & mass transfer rate.
g) Availability & cost.

-selectivity :
-interfacial tension: (sept 2014)
12/1/2017 10
Work in a group

Discuss what contribute to ideal

characteristics of solvent?

12/1/2017 11
 PROCESS FLOW DIAGRAM LIQUID-LIQUID EXTRACTION

V1 Extract VN+1 Solvent

yA1 yAO
yB1 yBO
yC1 yCO

1 2 3 N

Lo Feed LN Raffinate
XAO XAN
XBO XBN
XCO XCN

V1 (ya1, yb1, yc1)

12/1/2017 12
 Principles of Liquid-Liquid Equilibrium

Extraction involves the use of systems composed of at least 3 substances, and

generally all 3 components appear at least to some extent in both phases. The
graphical way to represent concentrations in ternary (i.e. 3-components) systems
are right triangular diagram or equilateral-triangular diagram

0.9

0.8

0.7

0.6
xC,yC

0.5

0.4

0.3
M
0.2

0.1

0
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1
xA, yA

Right triangular diagram Equilateral triangular diagram

Coordinate point M (0.3,0.5,0.2) coordinate point M (0.4,0.3,0.3)
12/1/2017 13
3.1.2 DIFFERENT WAYS TO DRAW THE LLE PHASE DIAGRAMS
(a) Equilateral triangular diagram

One liquid phases

M (0.4, 0.3, 0.3)

Two liquid phases

(B)

12/1/2017 14
Figure 3.1.3 Ternary diagram of ethylene water-glycol-furfural (25C)
 (b) Right triangular diagram

CHE 347/ 251: UNIT OPERATIONS

12/1/2017 (CHAPTER 3 ) 15
 EQUILIBRIUM CURVE
Dot line Dash line ---
1 Raffinate layer Extract layer
(water layer) (isopropyl ether layer)
0.9
water layer Isopropyl ether layer

0.8 Acetic isopropyl Acetic isopropyl

acid water ether acid water ether
0.7 0 0.988 0.012 0 0.006 0.994
coordinate 0.0069 0.981 0.012 0.0018 0.005 0.993
0.6
(0.311,0.108,0.581)
0.0141 0.971 0.015 0.0037 0.007 0.989
xC,yC

0.5 coordinate 0.0289 0.955 0.016 0.0079 0.008 0.984

(0.362,0.151,0.487
0.0642 0.917 0.019 0.0193 0.01 0.971
0.4
0.133 0.844 0.023 0.0482 0.019 0.933
0.3
0.255 0.711 0.034 0.114 0.039 0.847

coordinate 0.367 0.589 0.044 0.216 0.069 0.715

0.2
(0.464,0.371,0.165) 0.443 0.451 0.106 0.311 0.108 0.581
0.1
coordinate
(0.443,0.451,0.106) 0.464 0.371 0.165 0.362 0.151 0.487

0
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1
xA, yA

12/1/2017 16
Tie line
A pair of extract and raffinate coordinate
1
water layer Isopropyl ether layer
0.9
Acetic isopropyl Acetic isopropyl
0.8
acid water ether acid water ether

0 0.988 0.012 0 0.006 0.994 0.7

0.0069 0.981 0.012 0.0018 0.005 0.993 0.6

xC,yC
0.0141 0.971 0.015 0.0037 0.007 0.989 0.5

0.0289 0.955 0.016 0.0079 0.008 0.984 0.4

0.0642 0.917 0.019 0.0193 0.01 0.971
0.3
0.133 0.844 0.023 0.0482 0.019 0.933
0.2
0.255 0.711 0.034 0.114 0.039 0.847
0.1
0.367 0.589 0.044 0.216 0.069 0.715
0
0.443 0.451 0.106 0.311 0.108 0.581 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1
xA, yA
0.464 0.371 0.165 0.362 0.151 0.487

12/1/2017 17
SINGLE STAGE OF LLE
- Solvent and feed streams are contacted each other in single stage producing the raffinate
and extract streams which are in equilibrium states.

- Feed stream normally consists of binary solution containing solute (A) dissolved in a
diluent/carrier (B).

- The extracting solvent (C) can be either pure solvent or may content low concentration of
solute (A) (recycle solvent).

- When feed mixed with solvent, an intermediate phase M momentarily forms as the light
liquid moves through heavily liquid in the form of bubbles. These bubbles provide a large
surface area for contact between the feed solution and the solvent that speed up the mass
transfer process

- In most single stage LLE, it is interested to determine the equilibrium composition and
mass flowrates of extract and raffinate by using ternary phase diagram and mass
balance principle.

feed raffinate
% Removal=
= LoXAo-L1XA1 x100%
LoXAo
12/1/2017 18
 Figure 3.2.1.1 Single stage equilibrium LLE
(a) Schematic diagram of LLE (b) Ternary phase diagram
- The material balance for the diagrams boundary in Fig 3.2.1.1 can be written as:-
Overall mass balance : LO + V2 = L1 + V1 = M (3.1)
Mass balance on comp. A : LOxAO + V2yA2 = L1xA1 + V1yA1 = MxAM (3.2)
Mass balance on comp. C : LOxCO + V2yC2 = L1xC1 + V1yC1 = MxCM ...(3.3)
- The points Lo, V2 and M can be plotted as shown in Fig 3.2.1.1 (b).
- Then using trial and error method to find tie line which can be drawn through the point M, that locates the
compositions of L1 and V1
- The amounts of L1 and V1 can be determined by substitution into Eqs. (3.1) - (3.3)
12/1/2017 19
 EXERCISE 3.1
A single stage extraction is performed in which 400kg/h of a solution containing 40 wt% acetic acid in
water is contacted with 400kg/h of pure isopropyl ether. Determine:-

i. The compositions of raffinate and extract

ii. The flowrates of raffinate and extract
iii. The percentage of acetic acid removal in the system

CHE 347/ 251: UNIT OPERATIONS

12/1/2017 (CHAPTER 3 ) 20
 V2=400kg/h
Solution Exercise 3.1 yAo=0
yBo=0
V1 yCo=1

L1
Lo=400kg/h
xAo=0.4
xBo=0.6
xCo=0

1 Plot coordinate Lo and V2

2 Find M coordinate
3 Overall balance Lo + V2 = L1 + V1 = M
400 + 400 =M =800

balance on A Lo xAo+ V2yA2 = MXAM

(400x0.4) + (400x0) =800XAM
XAM = 0.2
balance on c Lo xco+ V2yc2 = MXcM
(400x0) + (400x1) =800XcM
XcM = 0.5

M coordinate (0.2,0.3,0.5), make sure this point align with Lo-V2 line 21
12/1/2017
 V2 (0,0,1) = (yA2, yA2 yC2)

Answer (A) V1 (yA1, yB1 yC1)

L1-V1 line is drawn through point M M(0.2,0.3,0.5) = (xAM, xCM xCM)

by trial and error
L1 (xA1, xB1 xC1)

V1 = (0.14,0.05,0.81) M
L1 = (0.29,0.68,0.03) L0(0.4,0.6,0) = (xA0, xB0, xC0)

Answer (B)

V1 = 480 kg/h
L1 = 320 kg/h

Answer (C)

% Removal=LoXAo-L1XA1 x100%=42%
LoXAo
12/1/2017 22
 3.2.2 MULTIPLE STAGES OF LLE

Figure 3.2.2.1 : Schematic

diagram of counter-current
multistages LLE

- The material balance for the diagrams boundary in Fig 3.2.2.1 can be written as:-
Overall mass balance : LO + VN+1 = LN + V1 = M (3.4)
Mass balance on comp. A : LOxAO + VN+1yAN+1 = LNxAN + V1yA1 = MxAM (3.5)
Mass balance on comp. C : LOxCO + VN+1yCN+1 = LNxCN + V1yC1 = MxCM ..(3.6)
- Determination of LN and V1 flowrates will be as follows (Fig. 3.2.2.2-a):-
i. Plot the ternary diagram of the system
ii. Calculate the M coordinate (xAM, xCM) by using eqs (3.2 & 3.3) & locate the M coordinate accordingly on
the ternary diagram
iii. Locate the coordinates of VN+1 (yAN+1, yCN+1); LO (xAO, yCO) & LN (xAN,xCN). Coordinates of VN+1 & LN
must lie on the phase envelope/ boundary. Normally xAN (composition of solute at raffinate) will be
given.
iv. Plot line from LN to M V1( yA1, yC1). V1 coordinate must lie on the phase boundary.
v. Finally calculate the LN and V1 flowrates value by substituting the respective value using eq.( 3.4 3.6)
CHE 347/ 251: UNIT OPERATIONS
12/1/2017 (CHAPTER 3 ) 23
- Determination of no of theoretical (graphical method) will be as follows (Fig. 3.2.2.2-b):-
i. Find reference coordinate. It is interception point between 2 operating lines:-
a) LO & V1 - Initial
b) LN & VN+1 - Final
ii. Start iteration from V1 to equilibrium diagram then back to ternary diagram to give L1 coordinate.
iii. Draw tie line from V1 to L1 1 stage
iv. Continue iteration from L1 to reference coordinate to give V2 2nd operating line
v. Continue the same procedure until the tie line intercept the final operating line.
vi. Finally, calculate the quantity of tie line in the diagram which represent the no of theoretical stages.

CHE 347/ 251: UNIT OPERATIONS

12/1/2017 (CHAPTER 3 ) 24
 EXERCISE 3.2
An aqueous feed of 200 kg/h containing 40 wt % acetic acid is being extracted by pure isopropyl ether
at the rate of 600 kg/h in a countercurrent multistage system. The exit acid concentration in the
aqueous phase is to contain 10 wt % acetic acid. The equilibrium data is provided in the appendix.
Determine:
i. Schematic diagram of the system
ii. Construct the ternary phase diagram and equilibrium diagram for acetic acid (A)-water(B)-
isopropyl ether(C) system by using the given equilibrium data.
iii. The compositions of the extract and raffinate. (V1 (0.1,0.03, 0.87), Ln(0.1, 0.88, 0.02)

iv. The amounts of the extract and raffinate (V1: 663.63 kg/h, Ln:136.36 kg/h)

v. Percentage of the acetic acid is being removed from the system 82.9% .
vi. The number of theoretical stages (2.2-2.56)

M (0.1, 0.15, 0.75)

CHE 347/ 251: UNIT OPERATIONS

12/1/2017 (CHAPTER 3 ) 25
 V1 VN+1
Lo 1 N
LN

1. Plot the ternary diagram of the system

2. Locate the coordinates of LO, VN+1, & LN (must lie on the equilibrium curve).

3. Calculate the M coordinate (xAM, xCM)

4. Plot line from LN to M V1 is located at the intersection of line LN-M with the
phase boundary

5. Line LoV1 and LNVN+1 are drawn and the intersection is the operating line

6. From V1 find the L1 ( using 45 line or tie line)

7. Line L1 is next drawn locating V2

8. From V2 find the L2 ( using 45 line or tie line)

9. Line L2 is next drawn locating V3

10. Stop when you get L is over the LN

12/1/2017 26
 C V1 VN+1
1. Plot the ternary diagram of the system Lo 1 N
Vn+1 LN
2. Locate the coordinates of LO, VN+1, &
LN (must lie on the equilibrium curve). V2

V1
3. Plot line from Lo to VN+1
4. Calculate the M coordinate (xAM, xCM), m
where M point located at line Lo VN+1

5. Plot line from LN to M V1 is located

at the intersection of line LN-M with the
phase boundary L2
B L1 A
6. Line LoV1 and LNVN+1 are drawn and LN Lo
the intersection is the operating line
7. From V1 find the L1 ( using 45 line or
tie line)

8. Line L1 is next drawn locating V2

9. From V2 find the L2 ( using 45 line or tie
line)

10. Line L2 is next drawn locating V3

11. Stop when you get L is over the LN

12/1/2017 27
 3.3 LLE FOR IMMISCIBLE SOLVENT

Figure 3.3.1 : Schematic diagram of counter-current multistages LLE

for immiscible liquid

- For the immiscible LLE, the material balance for the diagrams boundary in Fig 3.3 can be written as:-

xAO yAN+1 xAN yA1

L 1 - xAO + V 1-y = L 1 - x + V 1- y (3.4)
AN+1 AN A1

OPERATING LINE
Where;
L = kg inert B/ h
V = kg inert C/ h
CHE 347/ 251: UNIT OPERATIONS
12/1/2017 (CHAPTER 3 ) 28
 - No. of theoretical stages are determine through the graphical method ( Fig. 3.3.2) from:-
i. Equilibrium line
ii. Operating line

yA1

yAN+1

xAN xo
Figure 3.3.2 : Graphical method for immiscible LLE
- Refer to example 12.7- 3 (P796) for further understanding.

CHE 347/ 251: UNIT OPERATIONS

12/1/2017 (CHAPTER 3 ) 29
 3.4 LIQUID-LIQUID EXTRACTION (LLE) EQUIPMENT
- 2 main classes of LLE equipment:-
a) Vessels in which mechanical agitation is provided for mixing
b) Vessels in which the mixing is done by the flow of the fluid themselves
- Both classes can be operated in batch or continuous.

Figure 3.4.1 (a) Compartmented mixing Figure 3.4.1(b) Horizontal gravity-settling vessel.
vessel with variable-speed turbine agitators CHE 347/ 251: UNIT OPERATIONS
12/1/2017 (CHAPTER 3 ) 30
(a) Scheibel column-first design (b) Scheibel column-second design

(c) Scheibel column-third design

(d) Oldshue-Rushton (Mixco) column (e) Rotating-disk-contactor (RDC)

Figure 3.4.2 Commercial extractors with mechanical assisted agitation

12/1/2017 31
CHE 347/ 251: UNIT OPERATIONS
(CHAPTER 3 )
Table 3.4.1: Advantages and Disadvantages of Different LLE Equipments

CHE 347/ 251: UNIT OPERATIONS

12/1/2017 (CHAPTER 3 ) 32