Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1_114Q07- 1 -
General
Switchgear
Medium Voltage
AGENDA
INTRODUCTION
CONSTRUCTIVE TYPES
Metal-Clad units
AIR INSULATED
SF6 INSULATED
Compartmented switchgear
AIR INSULATED
SF6 INSULATED
Cubicle switchgear
AIR INSULATED
SF6 INSULATED
TESTS
PERSONAL SAFETY
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 2 -
AGENDA
INTRODUCTION
CONSTRUCTIVE TYPES
Metal-Clad units
AIR INSULATED
SF6 INSULATED
Compartmented switchgear
AIR INSULATED
SF6 INSULATED
Cubicle switchgear
AIR INSULATED
SF6 INSULATED
TESTS
PERSONAL SAFETY
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 3 -
Introduction
Cable bridge
Protection Protection
Incoming/outgoing Switching General Measurement Transformer Transformer
feeder protection 1 2
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 14 -
TESTS
PERSONAL SAFETY
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 15 -
Constructive types
Considering the constructive type, and according to the
standard IEC 298, the prefabricated metal-enclosed
switchgear for alternate current, for indoor or outdoor
installations, are divided in three categories:
Metal-clad switchgear and controlgear
Compartmented switchgear and controlgear (with one or more
non-metallic partitions)
Cubicle switchgear and controlgear
They may have either SF6 or air as insulator, depending on
the electrical and business premises of the installation.
However, the current trend is to use SF6 due to its lesser
requirements regarding space and maintenance.
Besides, the growing demand in the market propitiates the
comparison between switchgear insulated with SF6 or with air,
which are traditionally cheaper.
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 16 -
Constructive types
Taking into account the type of automatic circuit breaker
involved, the quenching technologies employed might be SF6
or vacuum, and currently there are switchgear units that can
use either of them indistinctly.
If the switchgear unit is air-insulated, the automatic circuit
breaker can be truck-mounted (draw-out) or fixed-mounted.
However, nowadays the switchgear units are built only with
truck-mounted circuit breaker, since they offer numerous
advantages respect to the older units with fixed-mounted
circuit breaker:
The disconnectors are eliminated, since the top and bottom
contacts of the truck work as disconnectors; hence the truck is
disconnected when moved.
Good access makes maintenance easier.
The apparatus can be substituted easily in case of failure.
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 17 -
AGENDA
INTRODUCTION
CONSTRUCTIVE TYPES
Metal-Clad units
AIR INSULATED
SF6 INSULATED
Compartmented switchgear
AIR INSULATED
SF6 INSULATED
Cubicle switchgear
AIR INSULATED
SF6 INSULATED
TESTS
PERSONAL SAFETY
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 18 -
Metal-Clad units
According to the standard IEC 298, the metal-clad units are metal-
enclosed switchgear which components are situated inside separated
compartments.
These compartments have metallic walls with a given protection level,
which should be grounded.
The units have separated compartments for the following devices:
Each apparatus of the main connection
The devices connected to one of the sides of the apparatus of the main
connection (e.g.: feeder compartment)
The devices connected to the other side of the apparatus of the main
connection (e.g.: busbars compartment; when there is more than one
busbar set, each busbar set should be in a separate compartment)
The metal-clad units offer a higher security level, since they present a
metallic and grounded plug of fixed contacts. Then the total separation
of the units by exclusively metallic sides is assured.
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 19 -
Air insulated Metal-Clad units
The existing metal-clad with air insulation and truck-mounted circuit
breaker are characterized by their flexibility.
This flexibility allows complying with the demands of most of the
installations. They may include
automatic circuit breakers, either SF6 or vacuum (circuit breakers of
manufacturers other than the manufacturer of the unit may be used),
breakers with fuses, load breakers, disconnectors, earthing switches, etc.;
voltage and current transformers,
protections of different functions and characteristics;
and standardized components such as probe insulators, plates, buses, fuses,
standoff insulators, etc.
To simplify and reduce the maintenance and operation of the switchgear,
the manufacturers seek for a design that ensures the area of the
different compartments, which makes it easier to access to all of them.
The truck-mounted circuit breaker also contributes to this purpose.
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 20 -
Air insulated Metal-Clad units
TESTS
PERSONAL SAFETY
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 31 -
SF6 insulated Metal-Clad units
Using SF6 gas as the insulating material
provides the metal-clad units several
advantages, such as:
reduced required space for its installation,
high level of availability,
superior reliability,
utmost protection against undesired
contacts (thanks to the hermetic seal of
the enclosure),
isolates the energized parts from
atmospheric pollution, dust, insects, etc.
The figure shows the diagram of this
type of unit, with double bus, where the
blue-coloured areas are those filled with
ABB Power Technology
SF6
1_114Q07- 32 -
SF6 insulated Metal-Clad units
As well as with air insulated
metal-clad units, all SF6
insulated metal-clad units
from diverse manufacturers
are alike.
The most evident
differences are the
utilisation of vacuum or SF6
automatic circuit breaker
and the placement inside
the unit of the
compartments.
Figure shows a double-bus
units with vacuum circuit
breaker and the bus
ABB Power Technology
Access lid with bursting disk, with signal contact for fast opening
of the feeder circuit.
1_114Q07- 37 -
Low voltage central board
The low voltage frontal board is constituted by:
Two compartments to locate the auxiliary
low voltage devices, the terminals to
connect the auxiliary circuits (protection,
measurement and control), as well as
protection relays and measurement
equipment.
A first central compartment that includes
the electrical and manual drives of the
three-position disconnectors and the
interlocking systems (either mechanical or
electrical) to avoid incorrect switching, as
well as the one-line diagram of the main
circuit.
A second central compartment that
contains the automatic circuit breaker
drive.
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 38 -
Low voltage central board
TESTS
PERSONAL SAFETY
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 40 -
Compartmented switchgear
The compartmented
switchgear, according to the
IEC 298 standard, are units
with metallic enclosure which
elements are disposed inside
separated compartments like in
metal-clad switchgear, but
including one or several no-
metallic partitions with a
protection level adjusted to the
standard.
The compartmented
switchgear insulated by air
includes either a switch-
disconnector in SF6 with or
without fuses, or a vacuum
or SF6 fixed-mounted
automatic circuit breaker.
1. Tank
2. Enclosure
3. Driving axle
4. Fixed contact
5. Mobile contact
6. Gasket
When the unit uses a switch-disconnector as the switching device, this compartment
is limited by the epoxy resin casing enclosure, filled with SF6, that surrounds the three
rotary contacts that indicate one of the three positions of the disconnector, forming
an insulating shield between the bus compartment and the feeder compartment.
If the unit uses a vacuum or SF6 automatic circuit breaker, the epoxy resin casing
filled with SF6 will also have three rotary contacts, but with functions of disconnector
and of earthing switch
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 43 -
Feeder compartment
About 85% of the unit room is reserved for feeders connection,
allowing the use of either unipolar or tripolar cables with simple
terminals screwed on the casing bottom.
The room is also ample enough to include accessories, such as
surge arresters, current and voltage transformers, a second
earthing switch, etc.
If the unit is also used for protection, the fuses or the automatic
circuit breakers are also included in this compartment.
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 44 -
Feeder compartment
If the protected equipment is a transformer, the outgoing feeders to the transformer
are connected at the bottom of the inferior fuseholders, given that the unit uses a
switch-disconnector; or the outgoing feeders are connected to the unit connection
plates, given that the unit uses an automatic circuit breaker.
The compartment door has an inspection window and standard security interlocking.
Three individual plug plates located in the floor serve as ingoing feeders, which are
adequately fixed by supports.
The frontal plates and sockets of the unit can be removed to facilitate the cable
mounting.
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 45 -
Bus/ Drive/ Controlgear compartments
Bus Compartment
This compartment includes the buses, formed by three copper elements placed in parallel.
The buses are connected to the unit in the top of the casing. The buses are isolated by a thermo-retractile insulating case.
Drive Compartment
The drive compartment contains, depending of the type of switchgear, the drives that permits to operate the switch-disconnector, the automatic circuit
breaker and the earthing switch, as well as the corresponding signalling and a set of voltage indicator pilots.
It also allows easily installations of padlocks, interlocking locks and low voltage accessories (such as auxiliary contacts, coils and motorization).
Controlgear Compartment
In case of motorization of the breaker drive, this compartment includes a strip of low voltage terminals and fuses, and depending of the type of
switchgear, it can incorporate low voltage magneto-thermal breakers and relays.
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 46 -
AGENDA
INTRODUCTION
CONSTRUCTIVE TYPES
Metal-Clad units
AIR INSULATED
SF6 INSULATED
Compartmented switchgear
AIR INSULATED
SF6 INSULATED
Cubicle switchgear
AIR INSULATED
SF6 INSULATED
TESTS
PERSONAL SAFETY
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 47 -
SF6 insulated Compartmented switchgear
This type of SF6-insulated compartmented switchgear is used to make compact designs, in which three or four functions are found in the same
unit incorporated inside a single metal enclosure.
The switchgear and the buses are enclosed in a single hermetic tank, filled with SF 6.
This monobloc set, with integral insulation, constitutes the medium voltage component of a transformation centre medium/low voltage, or a
distribution centre in medium voltage.
Thus, this type of unit posses all needed functions for network operation, as well as the transformers connection, protection and feeding.
These units include, inside a single metallic enclosure:
Feeder function: with a switch-disconnector to switch the incoming/outgoing feeder of the transformation centre,
The protection function: with circuit breaker and fuses combined,
Earthing switch: with making capacity (40 kA) in all functions.
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 48 -
SF6 insulated Compartmented switchgear
The following figure presents the transversal view of an SF 6-
insulated compartmented compact switchgear of 24 kV (the
blue-coloured area is SF6) with two feeder functions and one
protection function, where the below-described
compartments can be recognized
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 49 -
SF6 insulated Compartmented switchgear
The metallic tank is made of
stainless steel and everlastingly
sealed.
It contains the active parts of the
switchgear.
It is totally hermetic and filled with
SF6 at a relatively low pressure (0.2
or 0.3 bars according the voltage
level).
In the bottom of the tank there is a
security bursting disk located
outside the personnel access.
In case of arc inside the tank, this
disk would drop, due to the
ABB Power Technology
TESTS
PERSONAL SAFETY
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 57 -
Cubicle switchgear
The cubicle switchgear is, according to the IEC 298
standard, metal-enclosed switchgear different from the
metal-clad and the compartmented switchgears.
The difference may reside in the following particularities:
Less compartments than in metal-clad or compartmented
switchgear.
Partitions with a protection level lower than those specified
by the standard.
No inner partitions.
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 58 -
Cubicle switchgear
Such as with the other kinds of
switchgear, there are cubicle switchgear
insulated by air or SF6.
Likewise, vacuum or SF6 circuit breakers
can be used in cubicle switchgear, as well
as three-position switch-disconnectors.
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 59 -
Cubicle switchgear
Fig. shows the diverse variations of cubicles units with draw-
out truck and air insulation.
There are units with no inner compartment with or without frontal
door and units with inner compartment with or without frontal
door.
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 60 -
Air insulated Cubicle switchgear
This type of unit may use either a circuit breaker or a switch-
disconnector.
In case of circuit breaker, this may be of removable (draw-out)
chassis or truck.
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 61 -
Air insulated Cubicle switchgear
Similarly, this type of units may have an inner compartmentalization
similar to those in metal-clad and compartmented switchgear, where the
following compartments can also be discriminated: circuit breaker, fuses,
cables, drive, control and low voltage.
There are also, however, units which present a partial
compartmentalization for buses, drive and control
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 62 -
AGENDA
INTRODUCTION
CONSTRUCTIVE TYPES
Metal-Clad units
AIR INSULATED
SF6 INSULATED
Compartmented switchgear
AIR INSULATED
SF6 INSULATED
Cubicle switchgear
AIR INSULATED
SF6 INSULATED
TESTS
PERSONAL SAFETY
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 63 -
SF6 insulated Cubicle switchgear
This type of switchgear uses a vacuum or SF6 automatic circuit
breaker fixed-mounted. It is partially compartmentalized, with a
common compartment for the active elements of the unit (breaker and
buses), filled with SF6, like in the compact compartmentalized units
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 64 -
AGENDA
INTRODUCTION
CONSTRUCTIVE TYPES
Metal-Clad units
AIR INSULATED
SF6 INSULATED
Compartmented switchgear
AIR INSULATED
SF6 INSULATED
Cubicle switchgear
AIR INSULATED
SF6 INSULATED
TESTS
PERSONAL SAFETY
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 65 -
Type test for medium voltage switchgear
In the IEC 298 standard, it is also indicated that the medium voltage installations should be built in such a manner that they fulfil the
requirements stated in the corresponding standard regarding their
insulation capability,
protection against accidental contacts,
current capacity,
making capacity and
mechanical function.
This fulfilment can be demonstrated by running tests on a prototype of medium voltage switchgear.
Apart from this, each switchgear unit is subjected to the routine tests in the factory before its delivery.
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 66 -
Type test for medium voltage switchgear
The insulation level of a medium voltage installation built in metallic sheets should be
chosen considering the requirements of the distribution network.
Regarding the rated impulse withstand voltage, the different stresses requirements will
allow to decide between the list 1 or the list 2.
When selecting between both lists, account must be taken of the risk of lightning or
switching overvoltages, the method of neutral-point earthing and, if present, the nature of
the overvoltage protection.
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 67 -
Type test for medium voltage switchgear
The switchgear indicated in the list 1 will be appropriated to:
Industrial installation networks not connected to overhead lines:
in case that the neutral-point of the winding is grounded through direct connection or through a few ohms;
in case of a compensation of the earthing system and for special networks with overvoltage protection.
Networks and industrial installations connected merely through transformers with overhead lines and in which the capacitance to earth of the cables (connected
to the low voltage terminals) is of at least 0.05 F in each conductor.
In case of an insufficient earthing capacity, additional capacitances might be included between the medium voltage installations and the transformers, as close
as possible to the transformers terminals.
Then, the following cases are established:
neutral-point of the winding grounded through direct connection or through low resistance;
compensation of the earthing system with overvoltage protection.
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 68 -
Type test for medium voltage switchgear
Networks and industrial installations connected directly to an overhead line:
neutral-point of the winding grounded through low resistance connection and with
overvoltage protection,
compensation of the earthing system with overvoltage protection.
In any other case, or if it is required a high security level in service 1, then
it would be needed to install a switchgear as that specified in the list 2 .
Rated voltage Rated lightning withstand voltage (peak value) Rated power-frequency withstand
voltage
Um effective value
effective value
List 1 against through the sepa- List 2 against through the sepa- against through the separation
ground ration section ground ration section ground section
kV kV kV kV kV kV kV
3,6 20 23 40 46 10 12
7,2 40 46 60 70 20 23
12 60 70 75 85 28 32
17,5 75 85 95 110 38 45
ABB Power Technology
TESTS
PERSONAL SAFETY
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 70 -
Personal safety
According to the recommendations of the IEC 298 standard, the medium voltage installations must be designed and built to provide personnel with the best possible
protection in the case of an arc fault.
With this recommendation, switchgear installations can be subjected to an internal arc test under uniform conditions, and evaluated.
The effects of the arc fault on the switchgear installation depend on the intensity of the arc, its duration and the enclosed volume.
The criteria for the test are as follows:
1. None of the properly closed or locked doors comes open
2. No parts are ejected (pressure-relief flaps, windows, etc.)
3. No holes are caused in the enclosure by burning, splintering or tearing due to the action of the arc
4. Vertically arranged cotton gauze indicators are not ignited by the emission of hot gases
5. Horizontally arranged cotton gauze indicators are not ignited
6. No earth connections are rendered ineffective
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 71 -
Personal safety
Arc faults can arise because of overvoltages, faulty insulation, malfunctioning drives or incorrect operation.
The arc has a temperature of nearly 4.000 K at its root points, and about 15.000 K at its core.
When it strikes, the arc heats the surrounding air explosively, due to its very high temperature.
In an enclosed space (the bay or an oil chamber), this produces a rise in pressure.
This pressure rise would reach the mechanical limit of the enclosure if switchgear cubicles were not
provided with pressure-relief flaps.
These open after some 5-8 ms, and the overpressure is gradually reduced.
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 72 -
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 73 -
Personal safety
Personal safety
It must be assumed that the arc will burn for at least 70 ms before it is interrupted, but may be 1s to 1.5s,
depending on the networks relay settings.
During this time, the enclosure is subjected not only to pressure, but also to heat.
The heat of the arc can melt steel sheet.
Switchgear cubicles thus have double walls at critical points, with an air gap inbetween, so that the arc is
restricted to its point of origin.
Other measures are taken (e.g. labyrinths between cubicle interior and front door) to ensure that the hot gases
are cooled so as not to endanger personnel.
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 74 -
Personal safety
Pressure resistance (criteria according to standard, t = 0.1s) is demonstrated by optical
means.
High-speed cameras running at 800 frames per second are able to show clearly the
standard complying.
The thermal effects (criteria according to standard, t = 1.0s) are shown by easily
flammable pieces of cotton gauze, which during the test should not be ignited by the hot
gases.
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 75 -
Personal safety
Depending on the nature of the installation, these indicators (e.g. cretonne) are arranged
vertically in front of the cubicle at a distance of 30 cm or 10 cm.
In these tests special attention must also be paid to the height of the ceiling above the
apparatus; if the ceiling is low the rebounding gases can constitute a hazard.
Proof is provided by horizontal indicators placed 2.0 m above floor level.
Personal safety can be improved by deflection blades attached to the top of the cubicles.
ABB Power Technology
1_114Q07- 76 -