You are on page 1of 64

Advanced Accounting

3rd Edition

Susan S. Hamlen
University at Buffalo, The State University of New York
Ronald J. Huefner
University at Buffalo, The State University of New York
James A. Largay III
Lehigh University

Cambridge Business Publishers


Chapter 1

Intercorporate Investments:
An Overview

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Motivations for Intercorporate Investments

As a temporary investment of excess cash or part of a


long-term risk-adjusted portfolio
Expectations of dividends and gains
As a strategic investment
Develop relationships with suppliers and customers
Gain access to new product or geographic markets
To facilitate activity along its supply chain

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Investments on the Balance Sheet

Coca-Cola Company reported the following investments


at December 31, 2013 and 2012 (in millions):

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Coca-Colas Investments

Marketable securities
Includes trading, available-for-sale, and held-to-maturity
investments
Equity method investments
Investments for which Coca-Cola exerts significant influence
over operations
Coca-Colas equity method investments
23% interest in Coca-Cola Hellenic
28% interest in Coca-Cola FEMSA
29% interest in Coca-Cola Amatil

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Coca-Colas Investments
continued

Joint ventures
Investments for which Coca-Cola and at least one other
company share ownership interest and jointly control a
separate entity
Controlling interest
Investments for which Coca-Cola has a controlling interest in
another company
2010 acquisition: Coca-Cola Enterprises (CCE)

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Types of Investments for
Reporting Purposes

Trading

Controlling Available-
interest for-sale

Derivatives Held-to-
(hedges) maturity

Equity
method

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Fair Value Option

ASC Topic 825 allows companies to elect the fair value


option for eligible intercorporate investments
Investments reported at fair value
Value changes reported as part of income
Option available only for noncontrolling investments

This chapter assumes the company


did not elect the fair value option.

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Learning Objective 1

Describe the reporting for


trading, available-for-sale,
and held-to-maturity
intercorporate investments.

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Examples of Marketable Debt
and Equity Investments

Debt Securities Equity Securities

Commercial
Common stock
paper

Corporate
Preferred stock
bonds

Redeemable Put and Call


preferred stock options

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Investments Under ASC Topic 320

Readily determinable market values


No significant influence over the investee
Three categories:

Trading Available-for-sale Held-to-maturity


investments investments investments

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Trading Investments

Debt or equity securities


Reported as current assets at fair value
Income statement reporting

Income Statement
Other income/losses:
Unrealized gains/losses on trading investments $ xx
Realized gains/losses on trading investments xx
Investment income xx

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Accounting for Trading Investments

Securities owned:

Total cost of trading investments = $800,000

To record purchase of trading investments costing $800,000


2015
Oct. 15 Investment in trading securities 800,000
Cash 800,000

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Accounting for Trading Investments
continued

To record the sale of trading security C for $214,000


2015
Dec. 5 Cash 214,000
Investment in trading securities 200,000
Gain on sale of trading securities (income) 14,000

To record the unrealized value change for securities A and B


Security Cost Year-End Value Unrealized Gain (Loss)
A $100,000 $125,000 $25,000 gain
B 500,000 485,000 $15,000 loss

2015
Dec. 31 Investment in trading securities 25,000
Unrealized gain on trading securities (income) 25,000
Dec. 31 Unrealized loss on trading securities (income) 15,000
Investment in trading securities 15,000
Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016
Accounting for Trading Investments
continued

To record the sale of trading securities A and B


Security Cost Year-End Value Date Sold Selling Price Realized Gain (Loss)
A $100,000 $125,000 1/15/16 $120,000 $(5,000)
B 500,000 485,000 1/15/16 496,000 $11,000.

Security A
2016
Jan 15 Cash 120,000
Loss on sale of trading securities (income) 5,000
Investment in trading securities 125,000
Security B
2016
Jan 15 Cash 496,000
Investment in trading securities 485,000
Gain on sale of trading securities (income) 11,000
Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016
Accounting for Trading Investments
continued

Gains and losses are reported in income as the value of


the securities changes
No impairment testing is necessary since all changes in
value flow through income
No difference in accounting between a normal decline in
value and a decline characterized as impairment.

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Available-for-Sale Investments

Debt or equity securities


Balance sheet
Reported as current or noncurrent assets at fair value
Unrealized gains/losses reported in accumulated other
comprehensive income
Income statement reporting
Realized gains/losses on available-for-sale investments
Investment income
Other comprehensive income
Unrealized gains/losses on available-for-sale
investments
Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016
Journal Entries for
Available-for-Sale Investments

AFS investments:

Total cost of trading investments = $800,000

To record purchase of investments costing $800,000


2015
Oct. 15 Investment in AFS securities 800,000
Cash 800,000

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Journal Entries for
Available-for-Sale Investments
continued

To record the sale of AFS security C for $214,000


2015
Dec. 5 Cash 214,000
Investment in AFS securities 200,000
Gain on sale of AFS securities (income) 14,000

To record the unrealized value change for securities A and B


Security Cost Year-End Value Unrealized Gain (Loss)
A $100,000 $125,000 $25,000 gain
B 500,000 485,000 $15,000 loss

2015
Dec. 31 Investment in AFS securities 25,000
Unrealized gain on trading securities (OCI) 25,000
Dec. 31 Unrealized loss on AFS securities (OCI) 15,000
Investment in AFS securities 15,000
Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016
Journal Entries for
Available-for-Sale Investments
continued

2015 Year-End Date Selling Realized


Security Cost Value Sold Price Gain (Loss)
A $100,000 $125,000 1/15/16 $120,000 $2,000.
B 500,000 485,000 1/15/16 496,000 $(4,000)

To record the sale of AFS security A


2016
Jan 15 Cash 120,000
Reclassification of gain on AFS securities 25,000
Investment in AFS securities 125,000
Gain on sale (income) 20,000

To record the sale of AFS security B


2016
Jan 15 Cash 496,000
Loss on sale (income) 4,000
Investment in AFS securities 485,000
Reclassification of loss on AFS securities 15,000
Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016
Impairment Testing for AFS Securities

Required because impairment losses go through


income but normal declines are reported in OCI
Is the securitys fair value below its cost?
If so, is the decline other than temporary?
Common indicator: security will be sold before value can be
recovered

To record $15,000 decline in value of AFS security B at December 31, 2015


2015
Dec. 31 Impairment loss on security B (income) 15,000
Investment in AFS securities 15,000

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Impairment Testing of AFS Securities
continued

After recognition of impairment, Security Bs cost is


$485,000.
Subsequent value increases are not reported
Example of loss recognition when unrealized
gains/losses previously reported:
AFS security, book value $200,000, original cost $160,000,
fair value $90,000

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Impairment Testing of AFS Securities
continued

Fair value ($90,000) < cost ($160,000)


If the decline in value is other than temporary:
Record the decline in value of the AFS security from cost to
fair value as impairment loss, in income,
Reclassify the unrealized gain out of AOCI, and
Write the investment down from book value to fair value

Reclassification of gain on AFS securities (OCI) 40,000


Impairment loss on AFS securities (income) 70,000
Investment in AFS securities 110,000

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Held-to-Maturity Investments

Debt securities only


Reported at amortized cost
Discount or premium amortized over time
No gains or losses unless sold prior to maturity
Early sale requires extreme circumstances

Income Statement
Other income/losses:
Interest income $ xx

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Journal Entries for HTM Investments
Example

A company purchased a $1 million face value, 5% corporate bond


on January 1, 2015 for $965,349, yielding 6%. Interest is paid
annually on December 31. Maturity is December 31, 2018.

To record the purchase of HTM securities


2015
Jan. 1 Investment in HTM securities 965,349
Cash 965,349

To record the receipt of interest income for 2015


2015
Dec. 31 Cash $1,000,000 x 5% 50,000
Investment in HTM securities $57,921 $50,000 7,921
Interest income $965,349 x 6%
57,921

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Journal Entries for HTM Investments
Example
continued

$1 million, 5% face value corporate bond for $965,349, yielding 6%.


Carrying value at December 31, 2015: $965,349 + $7,921 = $973,270
To record the receipt of interest income for 2016
2016
$1,000,000 x 5%
Dec. 31 Cash 50,000
Investment in HTM securities $58,396 $50,000 8,396
Interest income $973,270 x 6% 58,396

Carrying value at December 31, 2016: $973,270 + $8,396 = $981,666


To record the receipt of interest income for 2017
2017
Dec. 31 Cash $1,000,000 x 5% 50,000
Investment in HTM securities $58,900 $50,000 8,900
Interest income $981,666 x 6%
58,900
Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016
Journal Entries for HTM Investments
Example
continued

$1 million, 5% face value corporate bond for $965,349, yielding 6%.


Carrying value at December 31, 2017: $981,666 + $8,900 = $990,566
To record the receipt of interest income for 2018
2018
$1,000,000 x 5%
Dec. 31 Cash 50,000
Investment in HTM securities $59,434 $50,000 9,434
Interest income $990,566 x 6% 59,434

Carrying value at December 31, 2018; $990,566 + $9,434 = $1,000,000


To record the receipt of face value bonds at maturity
2018
Dec. 31 Cash 1,000,000
Investment in HTM securities 1,000,000
Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016
Impairment Testing for HTM Investments

Required because normally HTM investments are


carried at amortized cost
Two criteria, same as for AFS securities
Fair value declines below amortized cost, and
Decline is judged to be other than temporary
If judged to be impaired:
Write down the security to fair value
Report the decline as an impairment loss on the income
statement
Ignore subsequent increases in fair value
Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016
Recording an Impairment Loss
Example

An investor owns an HTM security with a current amortized cost


of $981,666. At the end of 2016, the investor determines that it is
probable that all amounts due according to the contractual terms
of a debt security will not be collected. The current market value
is $200,000.

To record the impairment


2016
Dec. 31 Impairment loss on HTM securities (income) 781,666
Investment in HTM securities 781,666

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Proposed Reporting Changes
for Financial Instruments

Classification and measurement


Deliberations substantially completed, with a final standard
expected later in 2015
Key provisions
Marketable equity investments generally measured at fair value
through earnings (AFS classification eliminated)
No significant changes expected to classification and measurement
guidance for investments in loans and debt securities
For financial assets and liabilities measured at amortized cost, public
business entities required to present fair value information (either
parenthetically on face of balance sheet or in notes to the financial
statements)
Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016
Proposed Reporting Changes
for Financial Instruments
continued

Impairment
Deliberations continue on this issue
FASB has proposed a current expected credit loss (CECL)
model for financial assets measured at amortized cost
Requires recognition of an allowance for the full amount of
contractual cash flows not expected to be collected
FASB continues to refine the CECL approach

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Learning Objective 2

Explain the reporting for


equity method
intercorporate investments.

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Investments with Significant Influence

Two accounting options exist


Elect to use the ASC Topic 825 fair value option, or
Apply the equity method (ASC Topic 323)
Investor must exert significant influence over operating
and financing decisions of the investee

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


When is Significant Influence Present?

Representation on the investees board


Involvement in investee operating and financial policies
Significant transactions between investor and investee
Guideline: 20% to 50% ownership
BUT significant influence can exist with less than 20%
ownership

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Accounting Using the Equity Method

Investment performance reflects the investees


performance.
Equity Method Investment
Increases Cost of investment

Investor's share of investee's Investor's share of investee's


income and OCI gains losses and OCI losses
Decreases
Dividends declared
by investee
Ending balance

Investment changes in proportion to the investees


retained earnings and AOCI accounts.
Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016
Equity Method
Example
Suppose Coca-Cola acquires 30% of Rocky Mountain Bottlers stock
(300,000 shares) for $12 million. During the first year, the investee
reports net income of $2 million and declares and pays dividends of
$0.50/share.
To record the purchase of equity investment
Investment in Rocky Mountain Bottlers 12,000,000
Cash 12,000,000
To record dividends declared; $0.50 x 300,000
Dividends receivable 150,000
Investment in Rocky Mountain Bottlers 150,000
To record dividends paid
Cash 150,000
Dividends receivable 150,000
To accrue earnings of investee; 30% x $2,000,000 = $600,000
Investment in Rocky Mountain Bottlers 600,000
Equity in net income of Rocky Mountain Bottlers 600,000
Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016
Equity Method
Example
continued

Suppose Rocky Mountain Bottlers (the investee) reported $200,000


in unrealized gains on AFS securities, its only OCI item.

To record share of investees OCI (unrealized gains on AFS securities);


30% x $200,000 = $60,000
Investment in Rocky Mountain Bottlers 60,000
Unrealized gains on AFS investments (OCI) 60,000

Change in investees equity = $2,000,000 $500,000 + $200,000


= $1,700,000
Change in equity method investment = $600,000 $150,000 +
$60,000 = $510,000, or 30% of the change in the investees equity.
Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016
Equity Method
Example
continued

Coca-Cola (investor) acquired 30% of Rocky Mountain Bottlers


(investee) stock (300,000 shares) for $12 million. During the first
year, Rocky Mountain reported net income of $2 million, declared
and paid dividends of $0.50/share, and reported $200,000 in
unrealized gains on AFS securities.
Investment in Equity in Net Income of
Rocky Mountain Bottlers Rocky Mountain Bottlers
12,000,000 600,000
600,000 150,000
60,000
12,510,000 600,000

Balance Sheet as Income Statement


long-term asset
Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016
Equity in Net Income

Adjustments to reported net income may be required


If investment cost differs from investees book value:
Adjustment required: Amortize investment cost in excess of book
value acquired
If investor and investee transact business with each other:
Adjustment required: Remove intercompany profit that is not yet
earned

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Adjustments to Equity in Net Income

Adjustments should be made for depreciation and


amortization on revaluations of:
Tangible assets, and
Limited life intangible assets

EXCEPTIONS
No adjustments for goodwill impairment or
impairment of other indefinite life intangibles.

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Inventory Sales
Between Investee and Investor

Downstream Sales
Investor sells inventory to investee
Upstream Sales
Investee sells inventory to investor

Both companies record sales Both companies report


as if selling to outside Results in gross margin as part
customers. of income.

If inventory not sold to Investor must remove


unrelated outside party at when calculating equity
year-end, gross margin is not in net income
yet earned. of investee.
Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016
Revaluations
Example
Suppose on January 1, 2016, Rocky Mountain Bottlers reports total
assets of $80 million and total liabilities of $50 million, for a net
book value of $30 million. Coca-Cola paid $12 million for 30% of
Rocky Mountains shares. Analysis indicates that Rocky Mountain
has unreported technology valued at $5 million and its plant and
equipment is undervalued by $1 million. Plant and equipment has a
remaining life of 10 years as of January 2, 2016 and uses straight-line
depreciation. The previously unreported technology is a limited life
intangible asset with a 5-year life.
Price paid $12,000,000
Share of Rocky Mountains net assets acquired:
Book value (30% x $30,000,000) $9,000,000
Revaluation of plant & equipment (30% x $1,000,000) 300,000
Unreported technology (30% x $5,000,000) 1,500,000 10,800,000
Additional investment cost (goodwill) $ 1,200,000
Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016
Unconfirmed Inventory Profits
Example

Suppose Rocky Mountain Bottlers sells canned beverages to Coca-


Cola upstream for $800,000 at a 20% markup on cost. Coca-Cola
holds $210,000 of this inventory at year-end. Coca-Cola sells
finished products to Rocky Mountain downstream for $500,000 at
a 25% markup on cost. Rocky Mountain holds $100,000 of this
inventory at year-end.
How much is unconfirmed profit?
Unconfirmed gross profit on $210,000 upstream sales:
$210,000 ($210,000 / 1.20) = $35,000
Unconfirmed gross profit on $100,000 downstream sales:
$100,000 ($100,000 / 1.25) = $20,000
Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016
Recognition of Adjusted Equity in Net
Income for 2016

Coca-Colas share of Rocky Mountains reported


2016 income (30% x $2,000,000) $600,000.
Adjustments for revaluation write-offs:
$300,000 / 10
Plant and equipment (30,000)
Previously unreported technology (300,000) $1,500,000 / 5
Adjustments for unconfirmed inventory profits:
Upstream sales (10,500) 30% x $35,000

Downstream sales (6,000) 30% x $20,000


Equity in net income of Rocky Mountain $253,500.

2016
Dec. 31 Investment in Rocky Mountain Bottlers 253,500
Equity in net income of Rocky Mountain Bottlers 253,500

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Impaired Technology
Equity Method Investments

Impairment testing required for equity method


investments (ASC Topic 323)
Criteria
Fair value of the investment declines below its carrying
value, and
The decline is other than temporary
Accounting requirements
Investment is written down and a loss is recognized on the
investors income statement
Subsequent increases are ignored

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Joint Ventures

An entity formed by a group of individuals or firms


that contributes resources and jointly shares in
managing and controlling the venture
Often established for a short-term, single business
transaction or activity
Enables expertise, special technology, capital, access to
markets to be combined

U.S. companies use the equity method


for joint ventures.

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Learning Objective 3

Describe the reporting


for controlling interests
in other companies.

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Controlling Investments

The investor has control over the operating and financial


decisions of the investee
Three forms
Merger, consolidation, or asset acquisition
Stock acquisition
Variable interest entity
Assets, liabilities, revenues, and expenses are combined
with those of the investor for financial statement
reporting

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Mergers, Consolidations,
and Asset Acquisitions

Investor directly acquires the assets and liabilities of


the investee
Assets and liabilities recorded directly on investors
balance sheet at fair value
Merger Consolidation
Occurs when the investor acquires Occurs when a new entity is
the investee and becomes the formed to acquire both the
remaining legal entity. investor and the investee.

Asset Acquisition
Occurs when an investor acquires
a subset of the investees assets.
Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016
Merger
Example

Coca-Cola acquires all of Rocky Mountain Bottlers assets and


liabilities in a merger by paying $40 million in cash on Jan. 2, 2016.
Fair values are: Current assets, $20 million; plant and equipment,
$61 million; current liabilities, $15 million; and long-term liabilities,
$35 million. Coca-Cola identified and valued Rocky Mountains
previously unreported intangibles asset, technology, at $5 million.
Price paid $40,000,000
Fair value of identifiable net assets acquired:
Current assets $20,000,000.
Plant and equipment 61,000,000.
Technology 5,000,000.
Current liabilities (15,000,000)
Long-term debt (35,000,000) 36,000,000
Goodwill $ 4,000,000

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Merger
Example
continued

To record the acquisition of Rocky Mountain Bottlers

Current assets 20,000,000


Plant and equipment 61,000,000
Technology 5,000,000
Goodwill 4,000,000
Current liabilities 15,000,000
Long-term debt 35,000,000
Cash 40,000,000

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Stock Acquisitions

Occurs when an investor obtains control over another


company by investing in its voting stock
Investee remains a separate legal entity
The separate
financial records
are consolidated
at the end of
PARENT each reporting
The investor SUBSIDIARY period.
The acquired company
(investee)
Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016
Stock Acquisition
Example

Assume Coca-Cola acquires and holds all of the voting stock of


Rocky Mountain Bottlers, paying the former stockholders of Rocky
Mountain $40 million cash.

Investment in Rocky Mountain Bottlers 40,000,000


Cash 40,000,000

This is the entry Coca-Cola makes on its own books,


but its annual report shows Coca-Cola and
Rocky Mountains combined accounts as if Coca-Cola
recorded the acquisition as a merger.

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Variable Interest Entities (VIEs)

Investee is a separate legal entity controlled by another


company
Control occurs through legal relationships rather than
stock ownership
Entity is considered to be a VIE if:
The entity must obtain guarantees from other parties in
order to obtain financing, or
The equity holders do not have the usual rights and
responsibilities of equity ownership, such as voting and
residual return rights
Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016
Issue of Control with VIEs

Consequences of control
Must have the power to direct the VIEs activities
Must absorb the majority of the VIEs risks and rewards
Reporting is the same as for stock investments

Voting rights are not an indicator


of controlling a VIE.

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


Learning Objective 4

Discuss International Financial


Reporting Standards (IFRS)
for intercorporate investments.

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


IFRS for Marketable Debt and Equity
Investments

Currently accounted for the same as U.S. GAAP (IAS 39)


IFRS 9 (effective 2018):
Default: FV-NI
Option for equity investments not held for trading: FV-OCI,
never reclassified to income
Option for debt securities held for principal and interest
payments (i.e., no intent to sell): amortized cost

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


IFRS for Marketable Debt and Equity
Investments
continued

Impairment losses
IAS 39 focuses on observance of specific loss events
related to a decline in value, such as
Decline in credit rating, or
Investee misses scheduled debt payments
IFRS 9 introduces the expected credit losses (ECL) model
Focuses on more timely recognition of losses
Entities must account for ECL from when financial instruments are
first recognized
Amount of ECL recognized is updated at each reporting date to
reflect changes in credit risk of financial instruments

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


IFRS for Significant Influence Investments

Investee is defined as an associate


Principles-oriented view to significant influence
Representation on the investees board
Participation in policy-making process
Material transactions between the investor and the investee
Interchange of managerial personnel
Provision of essential technical information

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


IFRS for Significant Influence Investments
continued

Equity method required


Similar to U.S. GAAP procedures
Impairment testing
Compare the investment carrying value with the higher of its
market value or value-in-use
Value-in-use is the present value of the investments future
expected cash flows

Possible differences in impairment loss recognition


between IFRS and U.S. GAAP.

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


IFRS and Joint Ventures

IFRS 11
Two kinds of joint arrangements:
Joint operations (rights to entitys assets and liabilities)
Joint ventures (rights to entitys returns and disposal value)
Joint ventures are most common
Reported using the equity method

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


IFRS and Controlling Investments

IFRS 10: When should an entity be consolidated?


Control occurs when investor has all of the following:
Power to direct the activities that significantly affect the
investees returns
Exposure to variable returns from investee
Ability to use power to affect the amount of investors
returns

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


IFRS and Controlling Investments
continued

IFRS 10 applies to all control relationships


Investments in stock of a company
Control achieved through contractual relationships
Variable interest entities

Should an entity controlled through a financial


relationship be consolidated?
Possible differences between IFRS and U.S. GAAP.

Cambridge Business Publishers, 2016


For additional practice materials,
please visit

www.cambridgepub.com/
student-materials/21

Practice Quizzes
Quiz Solutions
Excel Spreadsheets

You might also like