The doctrine of cy-pres allows charitable trusts to fulfill the settlor's intent even if the original purpose for the trust becomes impossible, impracticable, or illegal to carry out. Under cy-pres, a court will authorize the trust funds to be used for an alternative charitable purpose that is as near as possible to the original intent. The document discusses the meaning and origins of cy-pres, its application in cases of initial or subsequent failure of a charitable trust, and examples of how Malaysian and English courts have historically applied cy-pres to redirect funds to similar charitable purposes.
The doctrine of cy-pres allows charitable trusts to fulfill the settlor's intent even if the original purpose for the trust becomes impossible, impracticable, or illegal to carry out. Under cy-pres, a court will authorize the trust funds to be used for an alternative charitable purpose that is as near as possible to the original intent. The document discusses the meaning and origins of cy-pres, its application in cases of initial or subsequent failure of a charitable trust, and examples of how Malaysian and English courts have historically applied cy-pres to redirect funds to similar charitable purposes.
The doctrine of cy-pres allows charitable trusts to fulfill the settlor's intent even if the original purpose for the trust becomes impossible, impracticable, or illegal to carry out. Under cy-pres, a court will authorize the trust funds to be used for an alternative charitable purpose that is as near as possible to the original intent. The document discusses the meaning and origins of cy-pres, its application in cases of initial or subsequent failure of a charitable trust, and examples of how Malaysian and English courts have historically applied cy-pres to redirect funds to similar charitable purposes.
Apply the doctrine of Cy-prs Solve and relate the doctrine of Cy-prs to the present circumstances
Dr. Zuraidah Ali 2
MEANING derived from Norman-French term :ici-pres which means near this aussi pres : as near as possible The courts are willing for the funds to be applied to other objects which are as near as possible to the settlors intention.
Dr. Zuraidah Ali 3
The Law In England there is an express provision on Cy-prs under the Charity Act 1993, ss13(1) & 13(2)
In Malaysia-there is no provision on Charity neither on Cy-prs
Dr. Zuraidah Ali 4
Depends very much of the width of the charitable intent Divided into two: 1) Initial Failure 2) Subsequent Failure /Supervening impossibility
Dr. Zuraidah Ali 5
Initial Failure Property is given to charity which ceases to exist at the date the gift takes effect. The charitable organisation existed at the when the gift was made but ceased on the date it is to be executed. Eg : A make a will to give RM1million to XXX charity in 1995 . A died in 2002. XXX charity ceased in 2000.
Dr. Zuraidah Ali 6
1)Width of charitable intent Where a charitable trust fails as being effective on the date of the gift, the gift will lapse of the property will apply cy pres Only if the court finds a wider intent, cy pres will be applicable.
Dr. Zuraidah Ali 7
RE RYMER [1984] 1 Ch 143 A legacy to the rector for the time being of ST Thomas Seminary for the education of the price for the diocese of Westminister. When the testator died the Seminary ceased to exist and students has been transferred to another seminary in Birmingham Held : Gift failed
Dr. Zuraidah Ali 8
Buckley J : The task of the court : to consider whether it was an essential part of the testators intention that his benefaction should be carried into effect in all respects in the particular manner indicated and no other OR Whether his true intention was to make a gift for charitable purposes without qualification
Dr. Zuraidah Ali 9
In only the latter case the court will, if it carry the testators true intention into effect in some way cy pres.. and in so doing the court is not departing from the testators intention but giving effect to his true paramount intention.
Dr. Zuraidah Ali 10
Where there was a gift for non-existent charity, it was easier to find the charitable intent in a case where the institution had never existed than it was in the case where the identifiable institution had ceased to exist
Dr. Zuraidah Ali 11
IN Re Lysaght [1966] Ch. 191 Ttrix gave fund to the RCS to found some medical studentships with some restriction. The RCS refused to accept the gift and such refusal will caused the gift to fail. Ct There was a paramount intention.
Dr. Zuraidah Ali 12
Re Valibhoy Charitable Trust [1975] 1 MLJ 187 The testator left 1/3 of his net estate on trust for education purposes to be performed in India. It was impracticable to administer the trusts for lack of funds and through uncoorperative attitude of the relevant authorities in Gujerat State. Held : The will indicated an intention Dr. Zuraidah Ali 13 b) Defunct or non existent charity 1) Re Harwood (1936) Ch 285 A testatrix died in 1934. Left 200 to the Wisbech Peace Society and 300 to the Peace Society in Belfast. Wisbech Society had existed prior to 1934 but ceased by the date to exist. No evidence that the Peace Society of Belfast had ever existed.
Dr. Zuraidah Ali 14
Re Satterwaithes Will Trust [1966] 1 WLR 277. The testatrix left all her estate in equal shares to nine named animal societies which she had selected randomly from a telephone directory. One of the societies was the London Animal Hospital which did not exist but a veterinary surgeon had once practised under this name. Held : Cy-pres could be applied.
Dr. Zuraidah Ali 15
c) Continuation of Charity in Another Form Re Faraker (1912) 2 CH 48 A gift to Mrs Bayleys Charity Rotherhithe. A number of local charities had been consolidated under a scheme by the Charity Commission in 1905 and funds were held in various trusts for the benefit of the poor in Rotherhithe. COA : the Bayly trusts had not been destroyed by the scheme and that the consolidated charities were entitled to the legacy. ```` Dr. Zuraidah Ali 16 Malaysian Cases TAI KIEN LUING V TYE POH SUN & ORS[1961] 1 MLJ 78 SIR HAN HOE LIM V LIM KIM SENG & ANOR [1956] 1 MLJ 142