Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Inhibitors
John J. Cush, MD
Presbyterian Hospital of Dallas
GI Outcomes Trials: Design
VIGOR (n=8076) CLASS (n=7982)
Drug Rofecoxib 50 mg QD Celecoxib 400 mg BID
(2x max chronic dose) (2x max chronic dose)
Bombardier et al. N Engl J Med. 2000;343:1520-1528 Silverstein et al. JAMA. 2000; 284:1247-
NSAID Impact/Cost
13 million chronic users (70 million Rx/yr)
Dyspepsia 20% > Gastric ulcers 10%
Serious GI complications
1.3 % RA pts
0.73% OA pts
Hospitalization (UGI bleed) 103,000/year
5-10% mortality (est 16,500 deaths/year)
NSAID deaths 15th most common cause in USA
Cost > $2 billion/year
NSAID Concerns
13 million chronic Mortality for 7 Selected
users (U.S.) Disorders (1997)
Dyspepsia in 10-20%
Serious GI
complications in 1.3%
Fatalities in 5-10% of
these
Direct cost/year > $2
billion
~ 15th most common Wolfe, et al: NEJM 1999
cause of death (U.S.)
Mechanism of Action of NSAIDs
CO2H
Arachidonic acid
COX-1 Non-specific COX-2
“Constitutive” NSAIDs “Inducible”
COX-2 NSAIDs
GI Mucosa Platelet
Prostaglandins
Prostaglandins Thromboxane
Mediate pain,
GI mucosal
Hemostasis inflammation, and fever
Protection
Bakhle et al. Med Inflamm. 1996;5:305-323.
Vane et al. Inflamm Res. 1995;44:1-10.
GI Outcomes Trials: Design
VIGOR (n=8076) CLASS (n=7982)
Drug Rofecoxib 50 mg QD Celecoxib 400 mg BID
(2x max chronic dose) (2x max chronic dose)
Bombardier et al. N Engl J Med. 2000;343:1520-1528 Silverstein et al. JAMA. 2000; 284:1247-
CLASS Trial: Upper GI Complications
Alone and With Symptomatic Ulcers
= celecoxib
6
= NSAIDs (ibuprofen + 5
p = 0.02
diclofenac) 4
p = 0.09
49 / 1384
All Patients 3
20 / 1384
30 / 1441
Annualized Incidence %
2
1
11 / 1441
0
6
5 p = 0.02
4
p = 0.49
6 17 / 283
5 14/ 298
4 p = 0.92
Patients Taking Aspirin 3
6 / 283
2
6 / 298
1
0
Ulcer ComplicationsSymptomatic Ulcers and
Silverstein et al. JAMA 2000; 284:1247-1255 Ulcer Complications
Events Leading up to FDA Mtg
Results of VIGOR and CLASS
9/30/04 Merck voluntary w/d of Vioxx (based
on APPOVE trial)
Reanalyses of all COX2 data
12/9/04 FDA warning of CV events in Bextra
CABG trial
12/17/04 NCI stop APC trial (concerns over
celecoxib data)
12/20/04 NIH stops ADAPT trial (concerns
over naproxen)
FDA: COX-2 Safety
February 16-18, 2005
Arthritis Advisory Committee
Drug Safety and Risk Management
Other speakers, SGEs
8 rheums, 19 physicians, 8 statisticians, 1 ethicist,
patient and industry representatives
ISSUES:
1. Does the agent pose a risk for CV events?;
2. Does the risk versus benefit profile of the drug support its
marketing in the U.S.?
3. If continued marketing is supported, what actions are
recommended to ensure its safe use?
FDA COX-2 Hearing
Limitations of available data
Most trials of short duration, using low dose
Most trials done with efficacy endpoints
Few designed with CVS safety endpoint
Most trials were active comparator and NOT
placebo controlled trials
Observational studies (presented) are for
generating signals and hypotheses
Safety signals drawn from other indications are
valid, but not conclusive unless repeated or of
sufficiently great magnitude
Table 1A. Placebo-controlled trials: Prospective CV Endpoint*
Populatio COX-2 dose/d
Trial N Control Results
n (Rx duration)
APPROV Polyp Rofecoxib 25 Cardiac evnt 31 v 12;
2586 Placebo
E** prevention mg (3 yr) HR 2.8 (CI, 1.4-5.4)
Valdecoxib 40
CV/thromboembolic
CABG- High risk mg
1671 Placebo 11 v 3;
II** CABG Parecoxib 40
RR 3.7 (CI, 1-13.5)
mg (10 d)
Parecoxib IV No increase in MI;
CABG-I 80mg Increased CVA in
462 CABG Placebo
(035)** Valdecoxib 80 parecoxib/ valdecoxib
mg (10 days) (2.9% v 0.7%)
Table 1B. Placebo-controlled trials: Sporadic, Observed CV Adverse Events
COX-2, dose/day
Trial N Population Control Results
(Rx duration)
Celecoxib 400
HR 400mg RR 3.0
mg
203 Polyp (0.3-28.6)
APC Celecoxib 800 Placebo
5 prevention 800 mg RR 6.1 (0.7-
mg
50.3)
(>2.8 yrs)
Alzheimer Alzheimer’s Celecoxib 400 MI 2 v 0;
425 Placebo
s-001 prevention mg (1 yr) CV deaths 2.4 v 1.4%
156 Polyp Celecoxib 400
Pre-SAP Placebo No CV increase
1 prevention mg
246 Alzheimer’s Celecoxib 400 Placebo
ADAPT+ No CV increase
3 prevention mg (~2 yrs) Naproxen
Alzheimer 209 Alzheimer’s Rofecoxib 25 mg
Placebo No CV increase
/MCI 1 prevention (1 yr)
197 Polyp
VICTOR$ Rofecoxib (3 yr) Placebo RR 3.14 (1-9.75)
6 PY prevention
Table 2A. Naproxen active comparator trials: Observed Adverse events
Trial N Populati COX-2,dose Compared Results
Rofecoxib MI: 20 v 4 @ 8mos
VIGOR 8076 RA Naproxen
50mg/10 mo RR 2.38 (1.39-4.0)
Metaan
Etoricoxib 3457 Etoricoxib Naproxen RR 1.70 (0.9-3.18)
alyses
TARGET Lumiracoxib
9471 OA Naproxen HR 1.77 (0.82-3.84)
(0117)** 400 mg 1 yr)
Table 2B. NSAID active comparator trials: Observed Adverse events
Celebrex800 Diclofenac
CLASS** 5968 OA, RA No CV increase
mg (9-5mos) Ibuprofen
Celebrex Naproxen
Success-1 13194 OA No CV increase
200, 400 mg Diclofenac
OA/GI Etoricoxib No CV increase
EDGE** 7111 Diclofenac
tolerab (9-16 mos) Small ↑ HTN
TARGET Lumiracoxib
8773 OA Ibuprofen No CV increase
(2332)** 400 mg/1 yr
Serious CV/T1 Events
Different Endpoints (VIGOR)
Vioxx 50 mg
64
Naproxen
45
32 35
19 18
Rofecoxib 25
Placebo
Vioxx – APPROVe: Effect of ASA on APTC *
APTC N Y t t N
CV Death N N t t t
NF MI N Y t t N
NF Stroke N N N N N
N= no signal. Y= Clear signal. t = Trend. AAC: February 8, 2001 FDA Arthritis Advisory Committee
meeting. RAe: Rheumatoid Arthritis efficacy supplement. SURs/AD: Safety Update Reports including
Alzheimer’s disease studies. Epi= epidemiologic studies. NF= non-fatal.
CLASS - APTC-like Events
CV death 11 5 5
MI 19 4 9
Stroke 4 6 6
Garcia-Rodriguez I
Ray I
Schlienger
Ray II
Mamdani
Kurth
Kimme
l
Garcia-Rodriguez II
Pooled NSAIDs
NSAIDs RR=1.04 [1.00-1.08
Garcia-Rodriguez I
Ray I
Solomon
Watson
Schlienger
Ray II
Mamdani
Kimmel
Garcia-Rodriguez I
Ray I
Solomon
Watson
Ray II
Kimmel
IBUPROFEN Garcia-Rodriguez II
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
Hazard Ratio for CV Death in Long-term NSAID Users Compared to Non-users
(with 95% Confidence Intervals)
On Safety…
“The desire for safety stands against every
great and noble enterprise”
- Tacitus