Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Presented by:
Michelle P. Ranges
Introduction to Gender, Sex,
and Sexuality
In 2009, the 18-year old South African athlete, Caster Semenya,
won the women’s 800-meter world championship in Track and Field. Her
time of 1:55:45, a surprising improvement from her 2008 time of
2:08:00, caused officials from the International Association of Athletics
Foundation (IAAF) to question whether her win was legitimate.
If this questioning were based on suspicion of steroid use, the case would
be no different from that of Roger Clemens or Mark McGuire, or even
Track and Field Olympic gold medal winner Marion Jones.
But the questioning and eventual testing were based on allegations
that Caster Semenya, no matter what gender identity she
possessed, was BIOLOGICALLY A MALE.
Introduction to Gender, Sex,
and Sexuality
In the 1996 Atlanta Olympics, eight female athletes with XY
chromosomes underwent testing and were ultimately confirmed as eligible
to compete as women (Maugh, 2009).
Ben A. Barres
DOES GENDER MATTER
Ben Barres
“Women are not advancing in Science
because of INNATE inability.”
IN CONTRAST WITH
‘Stephen Jay Gould Hypothesis’
available scientific data do not provide
credible support for the hypothesis
but instead support an alternative one:
that women are not advancing because of
discrimination.
DOES GENDER MATTER
Ben Barres
THE SUMS DON’T ADD UP!
The Article will argue on the following:
1.Larry Summers Hypothesis amounts to
nothing more than blaming the victim
2.why it is so harmful to women
3. what can and should be done to help
women advance in science.
DOES GENDER MATTER
Ben Barres
1. Larry Summers Hypothesis amounts to nothing more
than blaming the victim…
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
What is to be blamed?
1. The societal assumption that women are innately
less able than men.
A substantial degree of bias against women — more than is
sufficient to block women’s advancement in many
professions.
DOES GENDER MATTER
Ben Barres
1. Larry Summers Hypothesis amounts to nothing more
than blaming the victim…
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
What is to be blamed?
1. The societal assumption that women are innately
less able than men.
a. Studies reveal that in many selection processes, the
bar is unconsciously raised so high for women and
minority candidates that few emerge as winners. For
instance, one study found that women applying for a
research grant needed to be 2.5 times more
productive than men in order to be considered
equally competent (Fig. 2)12
DOES GENDER MATTER
Ben Barres
1. Larry Summers Hypothesis amounts to nothing more
than blaming the victim…
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
What is to be blamed?
a. Evolutionary Theory
b. social learning theory
c. cognitive development theory
d. gender schema theory
THEORIES ON GENDER ROLE DEVELOPMENTS
• Parenting is gendered.