Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Learning Objectives:
Understand the process of product design and
development
Understand the enterprise-wide view of
PPD(Product and Process Development) in the
context of different industry sectors
Develop an appreciation for different approaches to
PPD and different implementation methodologies
Develop an appreciation for collaborative models of
product innovation and commercialization
NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
– AN OVERVIEW
Market Segmentation
I) Consumer Mkt./Prescription Mkt.,
(patients - under diff therapeutic group)
(patient – end consumer – therapeutic
group, Drs. – Intermediate consumer-
Speciality, GPs)
2) Institutional Market (Hospitals)
3) Indl. Mkt. (Bulk drugs used in
formulations)
NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
– AN OVERVIEW
Therapeutic group
Antibiotics
Antacid preparations
Quinolones
Analgesics
Cardio vascular drugs
Cough & Cold preparations
Psychotropic & neurological drugs
Topical drugs
Vitamins
Anti-rheumatic, Non-steroidal
Anti-anemic preparations
NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
– AN OVERVIEW
Yes
Would it
No No No No No Should
help to Yes
we send
modify the
the idea
product or
back for
No marketing
product
program ?
develop
ment?
No No
1. IDEA GENERATION:
Search for New Ideas (Brain storming)
Marketing Plan : Top Managers define the product and
market scope and the NP Objectives
Develop Breakthrough products (Sildenafil-Pfizer,
Voveron Tab-NSAID-Ciba/Novartis-Aggressive scientific
promotion-British Med Journal/American journal)
Modifying existing products (Eg. Scored tablets)
Copying competitor’s products (Samsung)
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
1. IDEA GENERATION:
Ideas can come from
Customers
Scientists
Competitors
Employees
Channel members
Top management
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
1. IDEA GENERATION:
E.g. 3Ms Traditional soap pads vs Scotch-Brite Never
scratch soap pad – Sales exceeded by 25%
Alkem-Cepholosporin-Taxim – 1st to launch (30-40 Cr
brand)
Toyota employees submit 2 million ideas annually – 35
per employee – 85% are implemented.
Kodak give monetary, holiday, or recognition awards for
best ideas.
Source of ideas: Sales reps & intermediaries, Top
management, Market research firms, Indl. Consultants,
Indl. Publications/Journals, advertising agencies, patent
attorneys, Trade shows(CPHI India 1-3 Dec’10), etc.
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
1. IDEA GENERATION:
Some ways to get Great New-Product Ideas
i. Run Informal sessions where group of customers meet
with co. engineers and designers
ii. Allow time off for technical people to putter on their own
pet projects
iii. Make a customer brainstorming session
iv. Survey your customers – Know their likes and dislikes –
Ranbaxy-Revital(Vit+Ginseng)-now OTC-Advt.
v. Undertake camping out research with customers (done by
Hewlett Packard), SAMMY(S-Adenosyl Methionine
Tablets)-Cartilage Regenerator(ortho)-now also used in
Neuro.
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
1. IDEA GENERATION:
Some ways to get Great New-Product Ideas
vi. Set up a key word search that routinely scans trade
publications in multiple countries.
- Oxalgin Tabs (Oxaphinbutazone – NSAID banned –
replaced with new formula Diclo+Para, made use of
Brand equity. Further introduced Oxalgin Nano gel for
better absorption and penetration for faster relief
vi. Treat trade shows as intelligence missions
vii. Have your technical and marketing people visit your
supplier’s labs and spend time with their technical
people to find out what’s new
viii. Set up an idea vault – make it open and easily
accessed. Allow employees to review the ideas and add
constructively to them.
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
2. IDEA SCREENING
The Company shud motivate its employees to submit ideas to idea
Manager
Reviewed by Idea Committee
Should avoid two types of errors
1. A DROP ERROR
Eg SEARS dismissed the importance of discounting, Walmart and
Kmart did not.
Too many drop errors would mean the co’s standards are too
conservative
2. A GO ERROR – occurs when the co. permits poor ideas into
development and commercialisation
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
2. IDEA SCREENING
There are three types of product failures under GO ERROR:
1. Absolute product failure – loses money, its sales do not
cover variable costs
2. Partial product failure – loses money but its sales cover
all its variable costs and some of fixed costs
3. Relative product failure – yields a profit but less than
the target
The purpose of screening is to drop poor ideas as early as
possible
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
2. IDEA SCREENING
Estimation of products overall probability of success:
*The company then has to judge whether this probability is high enough to warrant
continued development.
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
2. IDEA SCREENING
Product-Idea Rating Device( To promote Systematic product-idea evaluation &
discussion) :
(Not for Management decision)
Relative Product Product
Weight Score Rating
Product Success Requirements (a) (b) (c= a x b)
Unique or superior product .40 .8 .32
High performance-to-cost-ratio .30 .6 .18
High marketing dollar support .20 .7 .14
Lack of strong competition .10 .5 .05
Total: 1.00 .69*
*Rating scale: .00-.30 poor; .31-.60 fair; .61-.80 good. Minimum acceptance rate: .61
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
5. BUSINESS ANALYSIS:
To evaluate the Proposal’s business attractiveness
Prepare Sales, Cost and Profit projections to determine whether
they satisfy company objectives
Estimating Total Sales:
a. It is a sum of Estimated first-time sales, Replacement sales and
Repeat Sales
b. Estimation will depend upon whether the product is
i. One-time purchase (e.g. a retirement home, engagement ring)
ii. Infrequent purchase (e.g. automobiles, indl. equipments)
iii. Frequent purchase (e.g. consumer & indl. Nondurables,
FMCG)
PRODUCT LIFE CYCLE
FOR THREE TYPE OF PRODUCTS
Repeat Purchase
sales
Sales
Sales
Sales
Replacement
sales
5. BUSINESS ANALYSIS:
Estimating Costs & Profits:
a. Costs are estimated by the R&D, Mfg. Mktg.
and Finance dept.
b. Next slide illustrates Projected sales revenue over the 5year
period. ( Behind this sales projection is a set of assumptions
about Mktg. Growth, Cos. Mkt. Share, and the factory-realised
price)
FIVE-YEAR PROJECTION OF SALES, COST AND PROFITS FOR
INSTANT BREAKFAST DRINK
9. Cumulative discounted cash flow -3500 -4613 -2922 -1405 1298 3644
(P B P)
Unit: $
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
5. BUSINESS ANALYSIS:
Estimating Costs & Profits:
c. Other financial measures to evaluate the merit of a new-product
proposal is the
- simplest Break-even analysis (estimates how many units need
to be sold to break even with the given price and cost structure)
and
- The most complex method of estimating profit is Risk analysis
(Optimistic, pessimistic and most likely)
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
6. PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT:
After the product concept passes thru business test, it moves to
R&D or engineering.
Involves large investments
At this stage the company determines whether the idea is
technically or commercially feasible
The target customer’s requirement is taken care of by QFD. –
Customers Attributes(CAs) are converted into list of
Engineering Attrubutes (EAs)
E.g. Proposed truck acceleration rate – Engineers convert into
required horsepower.
QFD is a communication point between Marketer, Engineers
and Mfg. People.
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
6. PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT:
Developing certain features takes time – Even a new taste formula.
E.g Maxwell House – consumers wanted “bold, vigorous, and deep
tasting coffee. The Lab took 4 months time to make the various blends
– turned out to be too expensive to produce – company compromised
on taste – eventually did not sell.
Lab scientists must not only design product’s functional characteristics
but also communicate psychological aspects thru physical cues.
E.g. case of Mouthwash– yellow color supports an “antiseptic”claim
(Listerine) – red color supports a refreshing claim(Lavoris) – green or
blue color supports “cool” claim (Scope)
E.g. Tamoxifen – failed contraceptive – new uses discovered -
successful in reducing risk of breast cancer by 50%.
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
6. PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT:
When prototypes are ready – must go thru rigorous Functional test and
Customer tests.
Alpha testing – Testing the product within the firm – in different
applications
Beta testing – Enlists set of customers to use and give feedback
on their experiences – Most useful where the potential customers
are heterogeneous.
Functional tests: E.g. Gillette – 200 volunteers from various
depts to work unshaven each day – enter small booths with a sink
and mirror – use razor, shaving cream or aftershave as per the
technicians instructions – fill questionnaires.
An employee quips “We bleed so you’ll get a good shave at
home”
In Pharma Industry: Stability studies are undertaken – can take
few months.
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
6. PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT:
E.g.s of Functional tests: Shaw (Carpet Mfg.) – Temps are
paid to walk for 8 hours a day on the carpet to and fro to
determine the time taken for wear and tear (20000 steps) of
the carpet over the years.
Customer tests: Can take a variety of forms – Samples to
use at home, In home placements are common viz. new
appliances etc.
Consumer preferences measured in several ways.
E.g A, B, C (3 cameras, 3 insurance plans or 3 Advt.s)
a) Rank order Method: To be ranked in order of preference
b) Paired comparison method: Presented with pairs eg. AB,
AC, and BC – he prefers A to B, A to C and B to C. to
conclude A > B > C. It is easy to state their preference
between two items – focussing on 2 items at a time
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
6. PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT:
E.g A, B, C (3 cameras, 3 insurance plans or 3 Advt.s)
c) Monadic-rating Method: To be rated on a 7-point scale.
1=Intense dislike
4=Indifference
7=Intense like
If A=6, B=5, C=3, then we can conclude the individual’s
preference order is A>B>C.
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
7. MARKET TESTING:
After satisfying functional and psychological performance – the product
is ready for Branding and Packaging.
It is put to a Market Test.
Market Test yields valuable information viz.
Information about buyers, dealers
Marketing program effectiveness
Market Potential
High-Investment, high risk products must be market tested. – Market
test cost is insignificant compared to the total project cost.
Products with novel features warrants more market testing. (e.g. first
fluoride toothpaste brand)
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
7. MARKET TESTING:
Procter & Gamble spent 2 years market testing its new no-
calorie fat substitute Olestra.- FDA approved the product –
however 2% experienced stomach problems (side effect)
Co. modified the product and successfully tested the product in
market
However, FDA still insisted that the label should bear the
following statement:
“Olestra may cause abdominal cramping and loose stools. ….”
Market testing may not happen if there is an urgency to launch
a highly successful product – for not to lose on on distribution
and market penetration.
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
7. MARKET TESTING:
Consumer-Goods Market Testing:
The Co. seeks to estimate 4 variables
i) trial,
ii) first repeat (many try but few re-buy it),
iii) adoption
iv) purchase frequency (permanently adopt the product
but low purchase frequency. Eg. Frozen foods)
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
7. MARKET TESTING:
Consumer-Goods Market Testing:
The major methods of consumer-goods market testing (least to
most costly -
i) Sales-Wave Research
- Consumers who initially try the product are re-offered the
product at slightly reduced price
- Re-offered as many as 3 – 4 times (sales waves)
- Co. notes down how many customers selected the co.’s
product again and their reported level of satisfaction.
- It can also include exposing consumers to one or more
advtg concepts – see the impact of that advt on repeat
purchase.
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
7. MARKET TESTING:
Consumer-Goods Market Testing:
ii. Simulated Test Marketing: (Imitate or pretend to feel)
- 30 – 40 qualified shoppers are questioned about brand
familiarity and preferences in specific product category.
- They are invited to a brief screening of both well-known
and new commercials.
- Consumers receive a small amount of money – invited
into a store to buy any items.
- Co. notes how many buy the new brands and competing
brands.
This measures the ad’s effectiveness vs the competing
ads in stimulating trial – Gives fairly accurate results.
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
7. MARKET TESTING:
Consumer-Goods Market Testing:
iii. Controlled Test Marketing:
- A panel of stores are identified to carry new products for
a fee.
- The Co. specifies the no. of stores and geographic
locations for test
- The research firm controls shelf position/displays and
POP promotions; and pricing.
- Sales is measured.
- It also evaluates the impact of local advt and promotions
during the test.
- However, this technique exposes the product and its
features to competitors’ scrutiny.
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
7. MARKET TESTING:
Consumer-Goods Market Testing:
iv. Test Markets:
- It is full-blown test market.
- Co. chooses a few representative cities
- The sales force tries to give a good shelf exposure
- The Co. puts a full advt and promotion campaign in these
markets
A full-scale test can be very costly depending upon the no.
of test cities, the test duration and amount of data required.
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
7. MARKET TESTING:
Consumer-Goods Market Testing:
iv. Test Markets:
The Management faces several questions:
1. How many test cities? 2 – 6 cities
2. Which cities ? ..Metros + other cities
3. Length of test ? ..few months – a year
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
7. MARKET TESTING:
Consumer-Goods Market Testing:
iv. Test Markets:
The Management faces several questions:
4. What Information?
- Warehouse shipment data – will show gross inventory
buying
- Store audits – will show retail weekly sales and competitor’s
mkt share
- Consumer panels – will indicate the Brands bought, loyalty
and switching rates.
- Buyer surveys – will yield consumer attitude, usage and
satisfaction
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
7. MARKET TESTING:
Consumer-Goods Market Testing:
iv. Test Markets:
The Management faces several questions:
5. What action to take?
- If test market shows High trial & repurchase rates: Launch
nationally
- High trial rate and low repurchase rate: Customers are not
satisfied; product shud be redesigned for dropped.
- Low trial rate and high repurchase rate: Product is
satisfying but more people have to try it. Means more advt and
sales promotion.
- Trial and Repurchase both low: Product should be
abandoned.
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
7. MARKET TESTING:
Business-Goods Market Testing:
Expensive Indl. Goods and new technologies
normally undergo alpha testing (within the co.) and
beta-testing (with outside customers).
The test can influence product design, pricing, etc.
The next common method is introducing the new
products at trade shows – draws large no. of buyers
– they view many products in a few concentrated
days.
Can observe how much interest buyers show in new
products, its features, etc and how much express
purchase intentions or place orders.
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
7. MARKET TESTING:
Business-Goods Market Testing:
Disadvantage of Tradeshows is, they reveal the
product to competitors – hence the vendor should be
ready to launch the product soon after the trade
show.
New Indl. Products can be tested in distributor and
dealer display rooms possibly standing next to the
competition products.
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
8. COMMERCIALISATION:
If Co. goes for commercialization, it will face the largest costs to
date
The Co. can manufacture the product in-house or outsource(LL
or 3rd party Mfg.)
Marketing is one of the major costs apart from others. – Mktg.
Expenses roughly around 57% of sales (New food products)
during the first year.
“Size does matter” – Eg. Sony Pictures. – “Godzilla” - Spent
huge amount – movie was a big flop. – After initial screening by
top brass spent even more money on marketing. – Big success.
“Me-too Market” – Muscle Power (Finance) works to sustain in
the highly competitive market.
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
8. COMMERCIALISATION:
WHEN (Timing):
Market entry timing is essential.
The Company faces 3 choices while facing competition:
1. First entry: “First mover advantage” – locking up key
distributors and customers – gaining leadership.
But if hurriedly launched without thoroughly debugging –
can spoil reputation.
2. Parallel entry: Coinciding the launch with the competition –
Market may pay more attention – two co.s are advtg. NP.
3. Late entry: Firm might delay the launch – Competitor wud
have borne the cost of educating the market – may reveal
faults which late entrant can avoid.
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
8. COMMERCIALISATION:
WHERE (Geographic Strategy):
1. Single Locality
2. A Region
3. Several Regions
4. National Market
5. International Market
- Co. size is important factor in selection of above. Small
co.s select Cities one at a time. Large companies select
one whole region at a time.
Coca-Cola’s Citra (caffeine-free) was introduced in about
half of US.
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
8. COMMERCIALISATION:
TO WHOM (Target-Market Prospects):
- Initial Distribution & Promotion to the best prospect groups
- The Prime prospects could be reached at low cost:
a) The Early adopters
b) Heavy users,
c) Opinion leaders
- The aim is to generate strong sales / motivate the sales force / attract
future prospects.
- Who really buys the product and why ?
- e.g Microwave oven sales grew when Microwave Oven Popcorn was
developed. –
- e.g. Households > purchase of PCs when CD-ROM multimedia
feature was introduced.
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
8. COMMERCIALISATION:
HOW (Introductory Market Strategy):
- Co. must develop an Action Plan for introducing the product
into the markets.
- To co-ordinate the many activities make use of Network
planning techniques viz. CPS (Critical Path Scheduling)
It is an estimate of how much time each activity takes to
complete the entire project.
If the Launch must be completed earlier – search for ways to
reduce time along the critical path
THE NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
2 ½%
Innovators