You are on page 1of 15

Fachhochschule Dortmund

University of Applied Sciences

Data Privacy and Data Security as factors influencing the Mass Rollout of Smart Meters

- An International Comparison Formatvorlage des Untertitelmasters durch Klicken bearbeiten

Autor / FS Mobile Business - Mobile Systems / Wireless Technology 2006, Dortmund

Fachhochschule Dortmund
University of Applied Sciences

Agenda

The Topic at Hand Applied Method Results Conclusion/Prospect s Q&A

Markus Roth Data Privacy Mobile Systems / Autor / FS Mobile Business - and Data Security as Factors Influencing the Mass Rollout of Wireless Technology 2006, Dortmund Smart

21

Fachhochschule Dortmund
University of Applied Sciences

The Topic

Metering Today
Billing information p.a. Monthly partial payment based on estimation Limited flow of information

Future Metering
Smart Meter as part of the Smart Grid (enabler) Decentralized generation Future = data flood
Markus Roth Data Privacy Mobile Systems / Autor / FS Mobile Business - and Data Security as Factors Influencing the Mass Rollout of Wireless Technology 2006, Dortmund Smart 32

Fachhochschule Dortmund
University of Applied Sciences

The Topic

Regulatory Framework
2006/32/EC 2009/72/EC

96/92/EC

improved energy end- considered to more aimed to create an internal market for the use efficiency influential directive electricity sector important for metering demanding a further End users to choose is article 13: requiring opening of electrivity their ESC individual meters markets displaying time and non-discriminatory stipulating CBA to be amount of consumed network access energy; billing on basis carried out of actual consumption unbundling limited requirements

Markus Roth Data Privacy Mobile Systems / Autor / FS Mobile Business - and Data Security as Factors Influencing the Mass Rollout of Wireless Technology 2006, Dortmund Smart

43

Fachhochschule Dortmund
University of Applied Sciences

The Topic

Data
SMs are capable transmitting energy consumption data in real-time or on a 15-minute interval basis Data sets with high granularity make it possible to draw conclusions on lifestyles

Problems

More Information Cyber Attacks Targeted Home Invasion


Markus Roth Data Privacy Mobile Systems / Autor / FS Mobile Business - and Data Security as Factors Influencing the Mass Rollout of Wireless Technology 2006, Dortmund Smart 54

Fachhochschule Dortmund
University of Applied Sciences

The Topic

Markus Roth Data Privacy Mobile Systems / Autor / FS Mobile Business - and Data Security as Factors Influencing the Mass Rollout of Wireless Technology 2006, Dortmund Smart

65

Fachhochschule Dortmund
University of Applied Sciences

The Method

Secondary Data
Collected, assembled and interpreted Relatively cheap Results of earlier surveys can be compared to new findings

Criteria
Market Structure and Market Players Triggers, Goals and Strategic Milestones Technical Requirements Status Quo Legislation concerning Privacy

COMPARISON

Markus Roth Data Privacy Mobile Systems / Autor / FS Mobile Business - and Data Security as Factors Influencing the Mass Rollout of Wireless Technology 2006, Dortmund Smart

76

Fachhochschule Dortmund
University of Applied Sciences

Results

1998/2008 liberalization Federal Network Agency = regulator No mandated rollout but policy driven by customer demand (ESCs in charge) SM in new or refurbished buildings (beginning of 2010) Variable tariffs No minimum functional requirements No CBA (cost benefit analysis) yet ~ 48 Mio connections; x<3% fitted Federal DataAutor / FS Mobile Business - and Data Security as Protection Data Markus Roth Act; Privacy Mobile Systems / EnWG-E Factors Influencing the Mass Rollout of Wireless Technology 2006, Dortmund Smart

87

Fachhochschule Dortmund
University of Applied Sciences

Results

Liberalization in 2004 (reorganized in 2006) NMa = regulator Privacy = big issue


Legal framework for voluntary installation, providing end users 4 options

Minimum requirements by NTA8130 and DSMR DSOs in charge of rollout Pot. 7,9 Mio connections; ~4% installed DPA = framework for metering data
98

Markus Roth Data Privacy Mobile Systems / Autor / FS Mobile Business - and Data Security as Factors Influencing the Mass Rollout of Wireless Technology 2006, Dortmund Smart

Fachhochschule Dortmund
University of Applied Sciences

Results

Liberalization in 2000/2003 Ofgem = regulator Mandatory rollout for larger customers until 2014 Mandate in place for domestic rollout until 2020 No minimum requirements Rollout by ESCs Potential of ~29 Mio connections; ~3% are fitted DPA of 1998; framework to integrate PBD

Markus Roth Data Privacy Mobile Systems / Autor / FS Mobile Business - and Data Security as Factors Influencing the Mass Rollout of Wireless Technology 2006, Dortmund Smart

10 9

Fachhochschule Dortmund
University of Applied Sciences

Conclusion

Markus Roth Data Privacy Mobile Systems / Autor / FS Mobile Business - and Data Security as Factors Influencing the Mass Rollout of Wireless Technology 2006, Dortmund Smart

11 10

Fachhochschule Dortmund
University of Applied Sciences

Conclusion

Similarities in terms of functionalities, although only put down in the Netherlands Privacy issues are acknowledged in all three countries Lack of legislation concerning privacy and security can lead to low demand of new technology UK appears to be most willing to implement SM on a large scale

Markus Roth Data Privacy Mobile Systems / Autor / FS Mobile Business - and Data Security as Factors Influencing the Mass Rollout of Wireless Technology 2006, Dortmund Smart

12 11

Fachhochschule Dortmund
University of Applied Sciences

Prospects

Approach to implement systems that are able to cope with new migration solutions Privacy should be addressed right from the start Data Protection Issues minimized through Privacy by Design:

Proactive not Reactive; Preventive not Remedial Privacy as Default Privacy embedded into Design Full Functionality End-to-End Lifecycle Protection Visibility and Transparency Respect for User Privacy

Aliasing, de-personalizing, aggregation of load profiles etc. Trustful handling of meter data among ESCs

Markus Roth Data Privacy Mobile Systems / Autor / FS Mobile Business - and Data Security as Factors Influencing the Mass Rollout of Wireless Technology 2006, Dortmund Smart

13 12

Fachhochschule Dortmund
University of Applied Sciences

Formatvorlage des Untertitelmasters durch Klicken bearbeiten

Questions & Answers


Markus Roth Data Privacy Mobile Systems / Autor / FS Mobile Business - and Data Security as Factors Influencing the Mass Rollout of Wireless Technology 2006, Dortmund Smart 14 13

Fachhochschule Dortmund
University of Applied Sciences

Sources

Derived from the bibliography in the thesis


Slide 2: ([48.], p. 7) Slide 2: ([67.], p. 23) Slide 4: ([72.], p. 25) Slide 5: ([26.], p. 9) Slide 10: ([78.], p. 2)

Markus Roth Data Privacy Mobile Systems / Autor / FS Mobile Business - and Data Security as Factors Influencing the Mass Rollout of Wireless Technology 2006, Dortmund Smart

15 14

You might also like