Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SELECTION OF BOILER
TYPE OF BOILER
Based on steam parameter- Subcritical/ Supercritacal Based on steam/ water circuit-Once throuh/ drum type Based on air/ flue gas path- Tower/Two Type of fuel- Coal fired/ oil fired
path/ T-type
Type of draft systemType of burner arrangement- Tangential/Front/ opposed Selection of Firing system- Type of mills Single reheat/ double reheat Type of water wall tube- Plain, rifled Type of tubing arrangement- Spiral/ straight
SUPER CRITICAL TECHNOLOGY Technology Advancement Thermal efficiency improvement Supercritical plant - world wide trend Availability Manufacturers Major differences wrt subcritical Environmental Aspects Advantages Trends in steam parameters TECHNO ECONOMIC STUDY
Base price estimate Efficiency gain Selection of parameters for study Techno economic evaluation - Alternatives & Factors Indeterminants Technology cost Conclusions
PART-I
SUPERCRITICAL TECHNOLOGY
50
40
IGHAT
PFBC
30
20
Pulverised Coal
10 First Station 0
1880
1900
1920
1940
1960
1970
1980
1990
2000
SUPCF: Sub Critical Pulverised Coal Fired PFBC: Pressurised Fluidised Bed Combustion IGCC: Integrated Gasification Combined Cycle IGHAT: Integrated Gasification Humid Air Turbine USPCF: Ultra Super Critical Pulverised Coal Fired IGMCFC: Integrated Gasification Molten Carbonate Fuel Cell AGMCFC: Advanced Gasification Molten Carbonate Fuel Cell
2020
Cycle thermal efficiency is improved by increasing the mean temperature of heat addition process. This temperature is increased because the boiler inlet pressure sets the saturation temperature in Rankine cycle.
Total fuel input Heat Rate =-----------------Electrical generation (KW) 860 = ------------------- Kcal/Kwh n
240 kg/cm2
Expansion Line
170 kg/cm2
Condensation
Enthalpy
%
0.41 Efficiency Increase 0.32 5660C/5930C 0.33 5660C/5660C 5380C/5660C 5380C/5380C 6000C/6000C
5660C/5660C
0.35
0.27
0.69
Base Efficiency 38.6%
169
246
310
Supercritical plants
1968
1971
1974
1977
1980
1983
1986
1989
1992
1995
1998
2001
2004
2007
2010
CALENDER YEAR
2013
Source ABB
50 1950s
Number of Units
1960s 1970s
100
150
200 1990s
250
1980s
Low availability in 1960s: Rapid unit size escalation Low fuel quality tolerance Inflexibility for cyclic loading
1993 82.0 89.8 1994 83.8 83.0 1995 83.7 84.7 1996 86.6 79.5 1997 88.5 90.3 1998 84.4 84.0
300-399 400-499 500-599 600-799 800+ 76.5 77.4 76.3 78.5 77.2 74.6 73.8 74.2 75.6
VGB
Year Subcritical Supercritical
JEPIC/FEPC Data- Supercritical units higher than subcritical units EPDC Experience- EPDC own plants do not show any difference. CIS CountriesRussian units have high availability.
TURBINE
GE,USA LMZ, RUSSIA WESTING HOUSE, USA TOSHIBA, JAPAN ABB, GERMANY HITACHI, JAPAN MHI, JAPAN ANSALDO, ITALY SIEMENS AG
Construction Spiral wound Smooth tubing Vertical Ribbed tubing Spiral wound Smooth tubing Vertical Ribbed tubing
Manufacturer Stien/EVT Stienmuller Deustche Babcock Under Indroduction CE, IHI, MHI ABB-CE MHI B&W, Foster Wheeler IHI, Hitachi Babcock Taganrog & Podolsk
Remarks Suitable for variable pressure operation Technology licenced by Siemens Suitable for sliding pressure operation Vertical tube design developed jointly by Sulzer/CE/MHI Used primary in USA and CIS countries
European Design
Sulzer
American Design
Boiler Type Furnace Water walls Tube material Tubing dia Circulation Pressure Parts
-Spiral bare tubing -Vertical bare/rifled tubing -Low alloy steel -31-38 mm -Forced once thru -Increase in thickness of tubing -Increase use of Stainless steel and P-91 material in SH/RH -Drain to condenser -Recirculation thru pump -Drain with regenerative heating Higher
Startup system
Start up rate
Critical Piping Main Steam piping Size Thickness Material HRH piping Size Thickness Material Feed piping
Supercritical Reduction in diameter due to lower specific volume Increase in thickness Change in material P-22/X-20 to P-91
No change in dia No change in thickness due to P41 material Change in material from P-22, X-20 to P-91 Increase in thickness
MATERIAL APPLICATION FOR HIGH STEAM TEMPERATURES COMPONENT BOILER SH HDR MS PIPE 538 C
2 1/4 Cr Mo 18 Cr steel 2 1/4 Cr Mo steel 9 Cr steel 2 1/4Cr M V steel 2 1/4 Cr Mo steel 18 Cr steel 12 Cr steel 12 Cr steel
566 C
9 Cr steel
593 C
12 Cr steel 20-25 Cr steel 9 Cr steel
2 1/4 Cr Mo steel
9 Cr steel
ENVIRONMENTAL ASPECTS
Reduction in CO2, SO2 and NOx between 1.79% to 4.24%
Reduction for 500 MW at 68.5% PLF per year is - CO2 78300 tons - SO2 365 tons - Nox 71 tons
SUBCRITICAL
SUPERCRITICAL
ULTRA SUPERCRITICAL
382-700/720
285-630/650 285-600-620
Mature Technology
1960s
Mature Technology
R&DAdvanced USC
1970s
1980s
1990s
2000s
2010s
Year
246-538/538
246-538/566
246-566/566
300-580/580
80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0
NO OF UNITS (%)
SELECTED PARAMETERS
MSP
MST RST
246 kg/cm2
5380C 5660C
MAIN CONCLUSION
Technology - Mature and establish Availability - Same as sub-critical Project Implementation- Essentially same as sub-critical O&M - By & large same as sub-critical Reduced Environmental Impact Most preferred parameters- 246 Kg/cm2-538oC/566oC Materials proven and already in use Technology cost for Indian OEM is not possible to assess.
Advatages
lower thermal stresses
Disadvantages No storage in the drum hence for any load change difficult to meet requirement immediately. Modified sliding pressure operation with active turbine valves .
Pressure(bar)
220 200 Constant pressure mode 180 160 140 30 50 70 Boiler Load (%) 90 110 Sliding pressure Modified Sloding pressure
BOILER DESIGN
The design of boiler requires proper selection from a number of major options. The most important of these options which have significant impact on the design are:
LOAD VS PRESSURE
300 250 200 150 100 50 0 0 20 40 60 LOAD 80 100 120
PRESSURE
Thermal behaviour of water walls The proportion of heat needed for evaporation and superheating changes with load. At low load the heat required for evaporation is high and superheat the steam is small. In subcritical the evaporation end point is fixed. In once through boiler, the evaporation end point is also changing within the waterwalls. So there is no division between superheater and evaporator.
3500
SH outlet WW outlet h
3000
Enthalpy (Kj/Kg)
2500
2000
1500
1000
26144
18256
15860
15 o
30 o
8000 50 o
ECONOMIZER
31186
22,753
ECONOMIZER
CL Top Nozzle
14,612
50
o
THANK YOU