Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ETHICAL
GROUP
MORAL
SELF
Bioethics
Bioethics: A discipline dealing with the ethical implications of biological research and applications
1. Extrinsic objections
2. Extrinsic objections
B. Unsafe for environments superweeds
Herbicide resistance - canola gene flows into weedy relatives Bt toxin kills monarch butterfly larvae
Extrinsic objections
C. Unfair to small farmers Rich get richer, poor get poorer Vandana Shiva Monocultures of the Mind
she has established Navdanya, a movement for biodiversity conservation and farmers' rights
Does the business of biotechnology corrupt the purpose and integrity of the process of the science?
Or can business and scientific partnerships be beneficial for society?
Critics:
Focusing on profits contradicts the purpose of science - to enhance or improve the quality of life Biotechnology commodifies life and leads to reductionist science
Advocates:
The spiraling costs of R & D required to bring a product to market justifies the closer ties of science and business This relationship has been beneficial to society and has contributed to the public good
2. Intrinsic objections
GM foods are wrong no matter how great the benefits may be.
Intrinsic objections
GM foods are wrong because its wrong to:
1. Play God 2. Invent world changing technology 3. Cross species boundaries 4. Reproduce by nonsexual means 5. Disrupt integrity, beauty, balance of nature 6. Harm sentient beings
Intrinsic objections
Intrinsic objections
1. Dont play God
Counter-examples:
High tech medicine
Intrinsic objections
Intrinsic objections
2. No world-changing technology
Counter-example:
Agriculture
Intrinsic objections
Intrinsic objections
3. Dont cross species
Intrinsic objections
Intrinsic objections
4. Dont reproduce nonsexually
Intrinsic objections
Intrinsic objections
6. Dont harm sentient beings
Extrinsic objections
Unsafe for consumers? Food allergens, toxins Unsafe for environment?
Extrinsic objections
Extrinsic objections
Support: Regulatory oversight on case-by-case basis Do not support: a ban on all GM crops
Diets in developing countries Efficiency of food production Safety and purity of food Agricultural sustainability Diversity of agro-ecosystems
Enhanced nutrition
Insect resistance
Bt corn
Insect resistance from Bacillus thuringiensis Non-toxic to humans Target insect: corn borer 40% U.S. Corn crop Bt Potential to reduce insecticide use
Disease resistance
Potatoes Squash Tomatoes Corn Rice Canola Soybeans Grapes Cantaloupes Cucumbers
Monosodium glutamate
Used to make HFCS Gras status in 1995 10% U.S. corn crop processed into syrups
Does society have an ethical obligation to maximize consumer knowledge and choice?